Board: Planning Board
Date: 2025-04-30
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:50–01:35)
So good evening, everyone. Welcome to the 39th meeting of fiscal year 2025 for the Milton Planning Board. I would like to now call the meeting to order. We can begin with the introduction of the board, welcoming back our candidates.
And I do wanna just say, I think congratulations to Maggie and Sean, but congratulations to all candidates in this election. We all know how much work it is to run for a town position and just wanna say congratulations and what a great job I think all the candidates did. So with that, we can begin by introducing Jim.
Speaker 2 (01:36–01:37)
Jim Davis, member.
Speaker 1 (01:38–01:38)
Sean.
Speaker 2 (01:38–01:39)
Sean Fahey, member.
Speaker 1 (01:40–01:53)
Cheryl. Cheryl Tagayas, secretary. Maggie. Maggie Oakfield, member.
and myself serving as chair. We have with us tonight, Cheyenne, if you'd like to introduce our staff.
Speaker 3 (01:54–01:55)
Cheyenne Frazier.
Speaker 4 (01:56–01:59)
Yeah, Cheyenne Frazier, Assistant Director of Planning.
Speaker 1 (02:00–02:44)
Great, welcome. And thank you all. The next is the approval of minutes. I still have not had a chance to look over that last, that came in just before our last meeting.
And we will need to also schedule an executive session for the other meeting minutes that were taken with the joint session with the select board and the planning board. So I think for tonight, if I could have a motion to defer the approval of minutes. OK, thank you. And is there a second second?
OK, roll call, since we're on Zoom, Jim.
Speaker 5 (02:44–02:44)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (02:45–02:45)
Sean.
Speaker 5 (02:45–02:46)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (02:47–03:34)
Cheryl. Yes. Maggie. Yes.
And myself. Yes. Great. Thank you.
And now we can move to our citizen speak. Tonight we may have a lot of people who would like to speak. I just would ask that if you did send a letter, that we just know, please know that we have read your letters and you don't need to speak again. We will be discussing those tonight.
But if there is anyone, we're fully remote. If you would like to speak, we would like to give you three minutes to speak and just be mindful of others who are also wanting to speak this evening. So with that, if we're seeing, I think there was one hand up earlier.
Speaker 4 (03:34–03:45)
Yes. So far we have four hands. So the first person is going to be Karen Friedman. Great.
Welcome, Karen. Can you unmute yourself? Can you hear me?
Speaker 6 (03:45–07:00)
Yes, we can. Welcome. I thank you so much. And congratulations to all of you that were running.
And I appreciate to start with that. You are submitting a plan that is hopefully more in line with what the state is looking for. I live on a side street off of Elliott Street on Norway Road, and I'm a town meeting member in Precinct 2, so the area that is very much affected by the new plan and the old plan. I've supported the MBTA Communities Act Once I understood it and help my neighbors and other constituents to understand it for the most part, ultimately be in favor of it, despite it potentially having a significant impact on our neighborhoods right from the start.
Our area is adjacent to the trolley line and it has always been slated as one of the areas that we're going to have the zoning aspect to it. I. sympathized with East Milton in understanding the burden that they were feeling and in general supported a revision to the plan given their concerns. But it appears, unfortunately, that you as the planning board have fallen a little bit on deaf ears in understanding what the burden to a few congested areas means and are just altering the location of that burden without altering the burden itself.
I'm sure that East Milton is very happy right now that almost all of the zoning that they were slated to have was taken away for the MBTA changes. Our neighborhoods had a lot of it right off the bat, but now it has practically all of it between the Elliott Street Corridor and Blue Hills Parkway, areas that abut this same area. Many of my neighbors and I accept the need for the additional housing, absolutely, and different types of housing, absolutely. But we urge you to use what you hopefully learned from the original neighborhood that felt so burdened and to be more equitable in assigning the zoning changes to more areas that are available and appropriate, not just ours.
We understand that there may need to be some additions to it, although, again, it was quite considerable to begin with in our area. And we accept that maybe there should be a little bit more in this area, since this is where the trolley is and we benefit from that, and it's not that far from the commuter rail as well. But there are other areas on your map that would be appropriate. And we heard I heard you and I'm speaking for many years that they do this, that you consider that.
Speaker 1 (07:00–07:07)
Great. Thank you so much, Karen. And what number you said, Norway Road, just Norway Road.
Speaker 4 (07:10–07:22)
Great, next, yep. Next is Regina. Great, welcome Regina. Can you hear me all right?
Yes, welcome.
Speaker 7 (07:23–09:02)
My name is Regina Campbell Malone. I'm a town meeting member from precinct one. I live at 177 Truro Lane. I first wanna congratulate you on working so hard to put forth a compliant plan and for considering lots of different and incredibly creative options.
I'd like to especially thank the Chair and Mr. Behe for thinking creatively about reducing the lot sizes in an effort to solve the planning issue and I hope that others share my understanding and my My really, really valid hope that you will research all of the sub districts once again in town to see which of all of the subject sub districts would allow the town to gain the most units without hurting the density numbers, instead of just focusing on reducing the parcel size. for three-family housing in that Blue Hills triad. I think if we're going to make some really big changes like that, going down below 5,000 and, sorry, going down from 6,000 to 5,000 and even considering 4,500 square feet, that we should look at all neighborhoods and all sub-districts with that in mind before we decide on the Blue Hills Triad as that for that option.
Thank you very much.
Speaker 4 (09:06–09:11)
Okay is Christine. Christine Hodlin, welcome.
Speaker 8 (09:18–12:24)
Can you hear me? Yes, welcome, Christine. Thank you very much. I appreciate being able to speak.
And I appreciate all the work that has gone into this. Seems like you've been working on the new plans for almost a year and a half. And I was hoping that we could have a couple or at least another public forum open to be able to discuss a final plan. But it seems at this point that you don't really have a final plan yet and are still working on it.
And I appreciate if you try to make some changes to that based on our input. I live at 112 Maple Street. I am partially on the Elliott Street corridor. My house doesn't appear to be hit my lot, but other houses on my street are.
I'm still a supporter of the MBTA zoning that's compliant with the state law. And I listened to the meeting last week and have a few comments based on that. I am opposed to making the Elliott Street corridor even more dense than it was before and also reducing the lot size. And again, I think the precinct two area was very accepting of the first plan that came out, which had a lot of the density added, but I don't think it's fair that you dump all of it or so much of it in this one particular area of town when there are other options.
I am also opposed to creating another district, as you suggested, or as Zoe had mentioned, possibly along the Blue Hill Parkway, where there are two thirds of the houses are single family, one third are two families, and only one house is three families. and why would you look to turn that into a very dense neighborhood with possibly many more three families. I'm very familiar with that area. I own a house over there.
My children live over there and there is not a lot of open space. There's not a lot of parking and it's already very dense. I also would hope that since many of you are not Are not in favor of being a rapid transit community that why you wouldn't consider is always suggestion to try to create other districts near the commuter rails, which she had suggested at least 1 last week. And I think there may have been another 1.
And I guess I just want to say, it's just frustrating that you've been working on this for a year and a half and. we're still a month away from a town meeting where we're supposed to vote on this. The last public forum was provided with a very short notice during school vacation week and during holy week and you held it on Maundy Thursday that week. I don't think that was fair enough to give many of the residents in town the opportunity to look at what you were proposing and be able to comment.
So I hope that you'll continue to look at the options that Zoe and you have all come up with so that we can have a plan that has been vetted through everyone, which is the Select Board, the Warrant Committee, and the public prior to town meeting. So thank you very much.
Speaker 1 (12:25–12:31)
Thank you, Christine. Looks like Anthony next has his hand up.
Speaker 9 (12:31–12:35)
Yes. Can you hear me?
Speaker 1 (12:36–12:37)
Yes, welcome.
Speaker 9 (12:38–13:33)
Hi, my name is Anthony Nottolo. I'm in 4A, I live on Kalar Avenue. I watched last week's planning board meeting, and I was shocked by the suggestion that one neighborhood, the Elliott Street Corridor, required a 6,000 square foot lot to build a triplex, but the Blue Hill Parkway neighborhood is being considered to lower the minimum floor as low as 4,500 square feet for a triplex. When Cheryl brought up, and rightfully so, that the Blue Hill Parkway area is socioeconomically and racially diverse, Maggie Willfield said that it was why she was pushing to rezone that area because it's a quote-unquote opportunity.
I'm appalled to hear that a planning board member suggests that one neighborhood, which happens to be predominantly white, inherently needs more outdoor space than any other neighborhood, which so happens to be majority-minority. If the minimum square feet to build a triplex is 6,000 feet in one area, it should be the minimum everywhere. That's all.
Speaker 1 (13:33–13:52)
Thank you very much. Um, Robert Lynch. Uh, Robert, if you could unmute yourself.
Speaker 10 (13:55–15:46)
Yes. Thank you. Great. Welcome.
Robert Lynch, one of six Decker street town meeting member precinct one. This board's discussion a few days ago around potential zoning changes for the Blue Hills Parkway corridor has surfaced with concerning timing. The fact that this topic gained significant traction just days before an election with public comments scheduled for the day after an election makes me question whether the community will really have a chance for thoughtful input. It also concerns me that this potential changes appear to have been considered before with your own expert at that time.
And again, now advising against them. The concept of significantly reducing the minimum square footage for lots only in the Blue Hills Parkway corridor and nowhere else is deeply problematic. If this were to become a formal proposal, it would represent a significant and seemingly unjustified deviation from established owning practices across the town, as well as contradicting the concerns that were repeatedly raised by your own expert during your discussions a few days ago. I disagree with any implication that residents in this part of town are somehow accustomed to or accepting of smaller lots and less green space.
Green space is vital for everyone, and zoning should not disproportionately reduce green space in any single neighborhood. Furthermore, I disagree with the assumption that allowing larger structures on smaller lots will create an economic benefit for the area. While a single lot or developer might see increased economic value, if an out-of-scope development diminishes the value of neighboring lots, can we really say that's a net economic benefit? So as you move forward, the fundamental question remains, why would you entertain a zoning proposal that contradicts your own experts advice with previously and currently and establishes such an unequal standard within our community?
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (15:47–15:51)
Thank you very much. And next we have Ada Rosemary.
Speaker 11 (15:57–17:34)
Good evening. Can you hear me. Yes, good evening, Ada Rosemary and 32 Columbine Road town meeting member precinct to. I join my neighbors in being supportive of a compliant plan with the MBTA communities and I'm glad to see that that you are considering this.
I'm disappointed to have to speak at a citizen speak at the 11th hour on this very important topic. I think the community process for input on on the planning board's plans has been lacking. I share my neighbor's concerns about the density in the current plan for the Elliott Street corridor and I hope that you will continue your efforts to find other districts around town to reduce the density in our area. And I agree with our neighbors in the Blue Hill um, Blue Hills have triplet triplex area, um, about not reducing the lot size and in that district as well, that that that just is not fair.
Um, two of you and congratulations for being reelected. Two of you just took your oath of office this evening to fairly and equitably execute the laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. And I implore you now to do your job that you just took an oath to do. Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 (17:34–17:39)
Thank you very much. And next we have Scott McKay. Welcome, Scott.
Speaker 12 (17:41–17:44)
Good evening. I'm sure you can hear me.
Speaker 1 (17:44–17:45)
Yes, we can hear you.
Speaker 12 (17:45–20:01)
That's what everyone says to make sure that you can hear. Thanks for letting me speak tonight. I know that I did submit a letter, but I like to talk. So thanks for having me.
I've worked with most of you guys before on different different projects around town and I come to you tonight as a resident in the Precinct 2 neighborhood. I live on 21 Columbine Road and I was until yesterday a town meeting member for nine years in our precinct. So I think I have a pretty good pulse on the feel of what our neighbors are thinking and what they're sharing amongst each other. And a lot of what has already been said tonight, I echo.
I just want you to, at some point, when you're looking at the map of the proposed zoning, that's for the 25% compliant plan now, there's the band of, you know, development that potentially could happen in the Elliott Street neighborhood and also Blue Hills Parkway. And then zoning out or zooming out, there's only two or three other locations in town that are having some of these units allocated to. As of right now, 77% of the units are on Elliott Street and Blue Hill Parkway. where the initial plan had only 56% in our neighborhood and Blue Hill Parkway.
I think that's consistent with what the state asked us to provide 50% of the units within a half mile radius around public transit. And I would think that spreading the units out in a more equitable fashion to show some color in some of our other neighborhoods would be appropriate. I just want to remind you that this isn't just a math problem. These are people's homes that we're talking about, and there are personalities and people behind that.
And I appreciate that you keep that in mind as you go further with your deliberations. Thanks for letting me speak.
Speaker 1 (20:02–20:09)
Thank you, Scott. And next we have Matthew. Matthew.
Speaker 13 (20:10–21:20)
Matt Zoller, Elliott Street resident, and I appreciate you all taking the time to hear everybody this evening. So I was always for MBTA zoning and remain that way. I am myself an affordable housing developer and I'm in favor of density in the appropriate locations for the appropriate reasons. I was for the previous plan.
I thought it was well thought through and equitable. And I think things have taken a turn now for the present plan. And I think the burden is largely placed on the Elliott Street Corridor now where it should be at the 50% or more or so that it originally had been where that's what complies with the law on a rapid transit corridor. Like my neighbors have said, Scott, Karen, Christine, I think you should look at other areas in the community to place some additional density and not burden the Elliott Street Corridor with all the density.
Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 (21:20–21:23)
Thank you, Matt. Next, we have Annie.
Speaker 14 (21:27–23:08)
Hi, yes, Annie Bush. I am Karen's neighbor at 8 Norway Road, and I just want to echo the comments that my neighbors have already made here. I support the MBTA Communities Act. I voted in favor of it in the last election.
Um, and I believe that Milton is in fact a rapid transit area. Um, but I do have some reservations about, uh, the plan that has been proposed. Um, the LA corridor is already quite dense. Um, I think.
Leaving aside the issues we have with traffic and people blowing through stop signs as it is, there's also probably going to be quite a parking issue, um, on such a narrow street, um, with so many houses already very densely packed together. I implore you to please consider, you know, thinking about where else in the town we can put some of this additional capacity so that it's more fair and equitable. And I would implore you to allow more community input. The only reason I know about this meeting in particular is from some of my concerned neighbors who brought this to our attention.
This is my first time ever coming to a meeting like this and speaking in this way. And I have to say, I'm really disappointed to have to come in this capacity to voice my opinion in this way. I really just wish that the communication was better and that we were thinking about all members of the community when we're making decisions like this. Thank you very much for allowing me to speak.
Speaker 1 (23:09–23:14)
Thank you, Annie. I appreciate you coming forward and speaking. Next, we have Alexander.
Speaker 15 (23:14–23:18)
Can you see me?
Speaker 1 (23:19–23:19)
Yes.
Speaker 15 (23:20–25:12)
Yeah, hi, I'm Alex Lang. I live on 27 Essex Road. As another P1 resident, I guess I was also really disturbed or surprised by last week's meeting, where a lot of the discussion was around lowering certain standards for, or whichever way you look at it, increasing standards for P1 at this Blue Hill Parkway triplex or triplex area. I live in the highlighted area.
to make that different than other districts in town, I think, is worrisome. It doesn't make a ton of sense for me. But what I mostly was concerned with that this came up sort of at the last minute, it seemed. It seemed like you guys were sort of tracking towards your three options, one of them the 25% compliant plan.
And it seemed like you guys were mostly in agreement and then sort of a couple members throughout some sort of last minute changes, you know, reducing on Randolph Ave and maybe increasing in P1. And that was sort of unfortunate because I think it needs, at that point, would need more citizen input. And we're clearly out of time. It's my understanding that, right, in order to get things ready for the June town meeting, we would have to submit something in the next couple of weeks.
And so there's clearly no time to get further input. So I just wanted to echo some of the other people in residence and speak up for this part of town. I'm generally, of course, in favor of this law. I think we need to come into compliance.
We've had a lot of time as a town and you as a board to come up with options. And I would echo some of the other callers who mentioned that it's a bit unfortunate that we are here at this last last at the 11th hour to still discuss these sort of major swings in your approach to this. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (25:13–25:18)
Great. Thank you so much. We now have Ian Boyd. Ian?
Speaker 16 (25:21–25:22)
Good evening. Thank you. Can you hear me?
Speaker 1 (25:22–25:23)
Yes.
Speaker 16 (25:24–26:44)
Thank you very much for your time. I'd like to commend the group for continuing to work on an issue which is causing great acrimony across the Commonwealth and within Milton. And I know these are a lot of hotbed issues, and it is affecting people. I want to echo one of the previous speakers by saying, this is affecting people's homes and their neighborhoods.
And so I think that brings up both emotions, which are hard to navigate. Now with that said, a term that has been brought up quite a few times here is equity and I do think the plan as it stands now does fly in the face of equity across Milton, it does put a burden on the Elliott Street corridor and the Blue Hills Parkway area. excessively. I live in the area affected.
I supported the original plan and I voted in opposition of the referendum. I understand that we should and I accept that we should increase density in Milton. I do think that it's unfortunate that this plan does seem to put that burden on a greater number of people in a smaller area and increasing density in already dense areas does just that. It affects more citizens disproportionately across Milton, and I do think that the board, and I do plead to the board, to look for alternatives to help spread this burden across more people in Milton so that the impact is not so acute.
Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 (26:44–27:01)
Okay, we have time for one more speaker. Lindsey Sands was next. And if we only have Eve, I'll let Eve speak too, but we will need to move on after that. So Lindsay, please welcome.
Speaker 17 (27:02–28:38)
Hi, can you hear me? Yes, welcome. Hi, Lindsay Sands. I live at 6 Waldo Road Precinct 2.
I've previously come before the board. I actually disagree with the classification, although I am Generally in favor of the law, I am on the Elliott Corridor. I opposed zoning this area previously. I oppose now that you've doubled the units in this area.
But the thing I'm curious about, and I haven't heard any discussion about it, although I admit I'm a bit behind the eight ball on this issue recently. Central Avenue seems so perfect for this zoning. opportunity. I forget where I've said it, but you know, a new $3.2 million house went up on a lot that could have easily been perfect for the intent of this law.
Those lots are big, the street is wide. I also have some concern, again, the traffic in the parking, not to reiterate what other people said, but, you know, we already have overflow parking on my street on Waldo Road for people on Elliott, just when their kids are home from school, or, you know, they have one or two guests, there's a lot of single lane driveways. I have a concern that the parking's gonna overflow to the commercial district down by El Barrio and turn away some of the traffic that those restaurants get and hurt the commercial business that we have there. So I know you guys have an enormous challenge in front of you.
I think this should be spread out more like others have stated. There's the Milton Academy area, there's Central Avenue, there's other areas. Obviously some on Elliott Corridor makes sense, just not the number that's currently proposed. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (28:38–28:43)
Great, thank you. And last, we have Eve. Welcome.
Speaker 18 (28:45–29:52)
Oh, that's how that works. Hi. Can you hear me? Yes, welcome.
Hi. So I've never actually spoken to one of these. And full disclosure, I don't live in the affected area, but I thought I had an interesting perspective to share, if that's OK. I live on Randolph Ave, which is currently seeing development, and I am in support of having more affordable housing, even though I see firsthand, I mean, there's going to be a very large apartment building right across from me.
There's going to be another one going in right around the corner. I get it. We need more affordable housing. It needs to go in somewhere.
But I want to echo the concern about equity to put more, to be building more on what we would call West Milton or whatever, is definitely an unfair equitable burden because it is very clear as someone who's just started to get to know this community, I've been here about five or six years, that there is much more density on that side of town and the other side of town. Like I'm on the dividing line, Randolph Ave, from Randolph Ave to East Milton, ought to have much more capacity for sort of coming in compliance with the law. So it really does come down to equity. That was, I think, my point.
Speaker 1 (29:53–30:33)
Okay, thank you. Okay, so with that, that will conclude our citizen speak for tonight. And thank you all for your comments and for folks who have written letters to the board. So at this time, our next item on our agenda is item number four, the reorganization of the board.
So this basically we would need to appoint a new chair and secretary. Any?
Speaker 2 (30:34–30:36)
So I'd like to nominate Meredith Hall for chair.
Speaker 19 (30:36–30:42)
I second that.
Speaker 1 (30:45–30:46)
Any discussion on that?
Speaker 20 (30:48–31:44)
I'd like to express a concern about having the chair be held by the same person, which would be now for four years. I've expressed in prior years that this position has rotated amongst board members. And while there's the role of facilitating the meetings and setting the agendas, There's also opportunities afforded to the chair and recently we have meetings with housing and livable communities about compliance with the MBTA Communities Act and You know that our current chair has expressed an interest in plans that aren't compliant. And so I just want to express my concern about continuing to have the same person in the chair's position.
Speaker 1 (31:47–32:05)
I appreciate that. We have emotion. I would be willing to accept that nomination. And I'm grateful for the nomination and and Caroline, I hear what you're saying and I, I appreciate your thoughts too on this.
Speaker 2 (32:07–32:20)
Sorry, Madam Chair, I nominated marriage because right now we're very busy. We have a lot going on around our time crunch. It seems like every single month we're under a new time crunch. Time crunch at every town meeting.
Speaker 20 (32:23–32:27)
Jim, I'm quite familiar with that. I'm answering. Today is the beginning.
Speaker 2 (32:27–32:29)
I think I was still talking.
Speaker 20 (32:29–32:30)
I thought you were done.
Speaker 2 (32:32–32:44)
I just don't see the need to mix it up or change anything right now. I think the board is working just fine as it is, and I think Meredith does a great job. So that's it, now I'm done.
Speaker 20 (32:48–33:35)
One thing I would like to say, as I said in prior years when this topic has come up, how the meetings are managed and how much is on the agenda, how late the meetings run, how much community engagement and the community engagement plan that I suggested for MBTA communities for this entire past year. it hasn't been followed through on. Last year, I made some suggestions about how we can run our meetings more efficiently and get our work done in a way that serves our constituents better. I continue to hope that that's going to happen because obviously, you all have major choices known.
Speaker 1 (33:38–33:45)
OK, so we'll need a roll call vote since we're on Zoom. We can start with Maggie. Yes. Jim.
Speaker 2 (33:46–33:46)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (33:47–33:47)
Sean.
Speaker 2 (33:49–33:55)
Muted, Sean. Yes.
Speaker 1 (33:57–34:17)
Cheryl. Same. And myself, yes, I accept. Okay, so now role of secretary.
Cheryl, you've been doing a great job with the minutes. I don't know if that's something you would like to continue to do or that's open for discussion as well.
Speaker 19 (34:20–34:28)
I do agree that Cheryl is doing a great job. So I would nominate Cheryl to stay as secretary if she would like to.
Speaker 2 (34:30–34:32)
I'll second that motion if you'd like to.
Speaker 20 (34:33–34:35)
I would accept the nomination then.
Speaker 1 (34:37–34:43)
Great. All right. Any other comments? If not, we can go to roll call.
Speaker 5 (34:45–34:46)
Can I make one comment?
Speaker 1 (34:47–34:48)
Maggie? Sorry, John?
Speaker 5 (34:48–35:19)
I just want to make one comment. I think both roles are a significant burden. And my only comment is that I appreciate the work that both of you do. I honestly know that it takes a lot of work, and I know Sheryl puts in a ton of work.
I know you do as well, Meredith, and I sincerely appreciate it. I don't have enough time to do either of the roles, and I appreciate the fact that you two are willing to do them.
Speaker 1 (35:22–35:33)
Thank you, Sean. I think everybody does a great deal of work, but I appreciate those comments. So we'll do a roll call again for this. Maggie.
Yes. Jim.
Speaker 2 (35:34–35:34)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (35:35–35:35)
Sean.
Speaker 2 (35:35–35:37)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (35:37–36:33)
Cheryl. Yes. And myself. Yes.
Okay, great. So now we can move to the discussion of our town meeting articles. I don't know if there was anything, I don't have anything for the, oh, you know what? I didn't discuss the next meeting date, so I'll just do that at this time as well.
Next week, we have our town meeting. So our, our next meeting will be prior to town meeting Monday at 630, where we will have time to touch base on where we are with the MBTA zoning, as well as anything that comes up with our ADU. or our site plan articles, but those are ready to go. They're printed in the warrant for anyone to read, and they're ready to be discussed when they come up at town meeting.
Speaker 5 (36:34–36:34)
Did you say 6.30?
Speaker 1 (36:34–36:46)
6.30. We're going to meet a little bit earlier than we normally do. Okay. Just to give us time, if there's anything we need to discuss for MBTA prior to that.
Speaker 5 (36:46–36:47)
Okay.
Speaker 1 (36:47–36:49)
If you can make that, I know sometimes- Yeah, no, I'll be there, sure.
Speaker 5 (36:50–36:50)
I'll be there.
Speaker 1 (36:55–37:04)
Okay. Anything else on those articles? If not, we can now move to the discussion of MBTA zoning and.
Speaker 21 (37:04–37:10)
Oh yeah. Tuesday we'll meet at 630 also. And then if time meeting goes to Wednesday, we'll meet at 630 also.
Speaker 1 (37:11–37:18)
Yes, we have scheduled. I think I'll have to. Cheyenne, do you know if we posted Wednesday for 630 also?
Speaker 3 (37:18–37:29)
We've only posted Monday so far. So, I was under the impression, only Monday we were going to be at 630 and then the other two days with me.
Speaker 1 (37:29–37:49)
Yeah, also, yeah we also discussed having a meeting on the eighth, just so we can. sort of, again, just MBTA only on that agenda, on the 8th, if folks are still good, whoever can make it on that. I just think it's important. And Zoe said that they would try to hold that date for us.
Speaker 5 (37:50–37:52)
And we'll be in person for that meeting?
Speaker 1 (37:53–37:54)
And that would be in person.
Speaker 5 (37:55–37:55)
Okay.
Speaker 2 (37:55–37:57)
I'll be a little late for that one.
Speaker 1 (37:57–37:58)
Yeah.
Speaker 9 (37:58–37:58)
Okay.
Speaker 1 (38:00–38:11)
We're hybrid for those who can't make it in person. So those would be the next meeting dates. So now moving to the discussion, we can welcome- Can I ask one more question?
Speaker 5 (38:11–38:17)
Sure. Just for the following week, we have our meeting on Tuesday the 13th?
Speaker 1 (38:17–38:18)
Correct.
Speaker 5 (38:18–38:20)
Okay. All right. And that's our only meeting that week?
Speaker 1 (38:21–38:22)
Yes.
Speaker 5 (38:22–38:25)
Okay. This time. Okay. All right.
Great. Thank you for that.
Speaker 1 (38:26–38:38)
Yes. That's great. And that will be focused, we'll be hearing back from two Elliott at that meeting. They'll be coming back for their continued public hearing and then MBTA.
Speaker 5 (38:38–38:43)
Okay, now following meeting from that one is the 22nd of May?
Speaker 1 (38:43–38:43)
Yes.
Speaker 5 (38:44–38:45)
Okay, all right.
Speaker 1 (38:45–38:46)
That would be our regular scheduled date.
Speaker 5 (38:46–38:48)
Okay, all right, great. Yep, thanks for all of that.
Speaker 1 (38:49–39:01)
Sure, okay. Okay, all right. So we can welcome Zoe and the, I'm not sure who else she was gonna have with her this evening.
Speaker 4 (39:03–39:03)
Matthew.
Speaker 1 (39:04–39:07)
Matthew's here. Okay, great. Welcome Zoe and Matthew.
Speaker 22 (39:09–39:10)
Hello again.
Speaker 23 (39:11–39:21)
We'll kind of be tag teaming the presentation tonight. So I'll kick us off and then Matthew will pick up and sort of go through some of the closer studies that we did of the Blue Hills fabric. Great.
Speaker 22 (39:22–39:23)
Excuse me.
Speaker 23 (39:23–54:24)
So I will go ahead and share screen for those that may be joining. for the first time. My name is Zoe Mueller. I've been the project manager supporting the MBTA communities analysis to support the planning board.
I'm a senior planner and associate principal with UTIL, and I'm joined by Matthew Littell, who's principal for UTIL and an architect by training. So we kind of tag team the different aspects of the project. So with that, today we thought we would just give, as always, a quick refresher on timeline and then go through some of the refinements and sort of alternatives discussed at our meeting last week for the rapid transit community plan. Then also kind of confirm that we're, you know, that where we left off with the planning board's adjacent community plan.
is still good as is, and then go through kind of next steps to make sure that we're moving things in the sort of sequence we need to to get to the deadlines we have. We sit here, the sort of the sense of urgency is because we need to kind of get to that final warrant by the 16th and in the intervening time, have to write the zoning and also do some coordination with the state to make sure that we're all buttoned up on multiple fronts. So that's kind of the big picture push that we're part of right now. And for the rapid transit pieces, I just kind of have this as kind of our anchor as a reminder to the standards or the targets that we're planning to for each of these.
This is just to kind of refresh. Last meeting we showed this, which is what we had shown at the public forum. And then we also want to share with the planning board a suggested adjustment to this that brings Elliott Street Corridor Tier 1 and the Blue Hills Parkway Corridor into alignment again for the FAR and lot size standards. So that was kind of a baseline starting at the last meeting.
And then we presented an alternative that Cheryl had originally prompted around, you know, potential ways to bring the unit count down on Elliott Street corridor sort of along the lines of what a lot of the public comment noted just before this. And that led to a discussion that sort of expanded like what are all the swaps that we might consider to accomplish that goal. What we're looking at is removing what we're using as a shorthand either Elliott East or Elliott West, you'll see what those geographies mean in just a second. So looking at removing one or the other of those and then swapping in one of three alternatives, either Blue Hills East, Blue Hills West, which again I'll show you the geographies in just a moment, or the Fairmount Station District, which is the one that Cheryl had originally raised to us as an alternative, which is close to the commuter rail stop.
So with that, I think I skipped one. Okay, so this is when I talk about Elliott West and Elliott East, this is what I'm referring to. So Elliott East is the sort of section that's south of Elliott Street. sort of beyond that one parcel depth that lines Elliott Street.
So it's that first geography and then the second geography that we refer to as Elliott West for now is I think what some call the Columbines, it's sort of the area that's slightly larger lot, single family homes along Cliff Road and Norway Road, and then retaining the Capeham Street fronting parcels. So just so everybody's kind of oriented to what our like nomenclature shorthand is for today. So what we've done is we've looked at existing unit densities on these parcels. This is using the state level data.
So there's maybe some small discrepancies, but the overall patterning is correct. And then also looked at lot size, just so you can see the patterns. And you can also compare kind of across the districts and understand how this all lines up, because for both Elliott Street Corridor and the Blue Hills area, there's a lot of important relationships that are embedded in the parcel size patterns and the existing unit density mix. What I'll help you read through this, the all column here is showing you the statistics in terms of single-family parcels, two-family parcels, and three-family parcels for the entirety of the Elliott Street Corridor as depicted in our work to date.
And then the West and East columns show the sub areas of the the sort of two areas that we're considering for swapping out. So you can see that the west area is entirely single-family, whereas the east area is more split with about 72% single-family, 26% two-family, sorry, 72% single-family, 26% two-family, and just 2% three-family. So when you look at that kind of comparing to the LA Street Quarter overall, West is sort of skewed more towards single family East is skewed more towards two family relative to the overall profile of Elliott Street. Moving from there to parcel size.
This is sort of part of our discussion in the meeting last time about the sort of parcel pattern differences between Elliott Street and the Blue Hills area. You'll see that here, very few parcels are under 5,000 square feet in the Elliott Street corridor geography. So looking at, again, same sort of structure here. So all the entirety of the Elliott Street corridor versus that East sub area and West sub area.
If you look at the Elliott Street corridor as a whole, you can see that essentially 10% of all parcels are below that 5000 mark. Whereas for East, we have just 4% that are below that and West, none are below that. So it's a sort of a different profile. And then you can see the sort of ramp up here in terms of parcel size thresholds.
Just as a reminder, right now for Elliott Street, we've set the tier one is a 6,000 square foot minimum. That's come down from the 7,500 that was proposed for the 2023 article. And then tier two is at the 10,000 square feet. Tier 3 is at 15,000.
And tiers 2 and 3 allow 4 units under the current rules, they allowed 3 units under the 2023 rules. So then coming over to just kind of look at this in a slightly different way so not spatially but instead like statistically looking at like what is the spread of parcels. This can just give you a sense of kind of at each of these for each of these buckets. How many parcels are in that bucket.
So this is a little bit complex to read. We can come back to it if there's something that we really want to drill into that is related to this, but to just to give you broad brushes of how to read this chart. The color tones that you're seeing are for the entirety of the Elliott Street corridor as currently drawn. You can see that there's a sort of a jump in parcel size, you know, here that are number of parcels that sort of really the majority of parcels are in that 7,500 to 10,000.
range, that's this color bar, and then slightly less in each of the sort of tiers below that. And then there's still a significant number that are kind of in that. slightly larger bucket here the 10,000 to 15,000 and then the 15,000 plus. So, the second thing I want to call attention to in terms of how to read this is we're also showing the relative reductions that you would see based on removing either the Elliott West geography.
also known as the combines and the Elliott East geography that's the part that's just south of Elliott Street. So this is kind of just gives you a sense of the parcel patterns of Elliott Street corridor and how that relates to the rules that we have applied to it currently. So with that, I'll go to the Blue Hills area and give you a sense of the same kind of analysis for that setting. So this one is looking at the existing units per parcel.
If you kind of can recall from the Elliott Street corridor, that was sort of a two thirds, one third split, two thirds, single family, like one third, two family. This is, Actually wait, I think I'm getting that a little bit wrong let me make sure I'm quoting that right. 80% single family 17% to family. And then when we go to Blue Hills, and look at the sort of profile overall.
We have 62% single family, 20% two family, and then kind of odds and ends in other categories. This is across the, sorry, I'm reading this a little wrong. This category here, current, this is, instead of comparing to the all, that is specifically the Blue Hills corridor. So that's the district that we have had in our map for quite some time including 2023.
That's the geography that you see outlined in pink here that lines the Blue Hills Parkway itself and includes those parcels at front on the parkway predominantly. So they have a slightly different pattern from the parcels that then sort of continue into the neighborhood on either side of it. So for that the current Blue Hills Parkway corridor you can see that that has a split of 62% single family, 20% two family, a couple in three and four family, and then significant non-residential uses currently. That's like institutional uses, religious, et cetera.
When we look at the West geography, so that's the sort of triangle of parcels to the West of the Blue Hills Parkway. That is 40% single-family, 48% two-family. So this is to my comments in the previous meeting, that this is really a more dominant two-family parcel fabric. So that's part of why you see different patterns.
And then three-family, 4%, so quite small, a single six-family, and 7% non-residential, so still some presence of other use types. And then for the east geography which just sort of talks in to the south and east of the current Blue Hills Parkway corridor geography here. that is 34% single-family, 61% two-family. So again, heavily two-family.
And then just a handful of non-residential uses in the mix. So what this is really kind of the story here is that both West and East have significant two-family presence in them already, but hardly any three-family. So it's an important distinction. We'll get to it in terms of like the bulk of the building, but if you think about like use density in terms of like the number of people that are there, the number of units, the number of households, it would be a significant change from that perspective, but maybe not from a bulk and sort of urban design perspective, which Matthew will get into in a little bit.
In terms of parcel size, this is another important distinction between the Elliott and Blue Hills area. So the, if you recall in Elliott, there were negligible sort of a total of 10% of all the parcels were below 5,000. If you look at even within the Blue Hills Parkway Corridor District that we have right now, again, as a reminder, that's this current column, a total of 22 percent are below that 5,000 number. If we look at the two areas that we're considering for the Blue Hills additional districts, 63 percent of the East District, is below 5000 square feet.
And then on the west, you can sort of doing the kind of quick addition there, that would be the 54% are under 5,000. So this is the real reason why in our earlier, like our 2023 analysis, why we ultimately moved away from using the Blue Hills Parkway District is because if you set that 5,000 square foot minimum lot size or even 6,000 or at the time 7,500, Just from a parcel size perspective alone you've knocked out the majority of parcels in this district and therefore it wasn't getting to the density numbers that we needed, so I had shared that in the previous meeting and the planning board expressed interest in seeing some analysis around the 4500. square foot threshold as a potential way to zone for in greater alignment with the existing parcel fabric of this area. So we've done that in our analysis today and we'll show you what we've come up with, but this can help you kind of just understand why this is really a different zoning question or zoning sort of pattern that needs to contend with both in terms of the existing uses and in terms of the parcel fabric.
So thanks for bearing with me on, on that. This is sort of a similar, excuse me, um, analysis of parcel size, um, sort of just in a, you know, going from the spatial perspective to more of like a statistical perspective of seeing that distribution. Um, and this just kind of summarizes out kind of in broad numbers so that if we need to kind of come back to it, it's all in one place. I won't go through this in detail.
It's the same information, just shown in a different way. Um, So with that, I'm going to have, maybe before I pass off to Matthew to run through the test fits, are there any questions on that, like existing use and parcel size analysis?
Speaker 5 (54:24–54:36)
I have a question, Zoe, if I may. Back on the triplex, what was the number of parcels? I have Elliott Street as 268. I think I missed the total number of parcels on the triplex.
Speaker 23 (54:37–54:52)
Let's see, I can do kind of a quick tally here. I believe it was, I think it's 61 in the West. I'm getting a little bit.
Speaker 5 (54:52–54:59)
Let me do some quick additions. 75, right? 30, 36, 66, 69, 70, 75.
Speaker 23 (55:00–55:07)
Yeah, so we have 75 in West, and I think that means we have 61 in East, because that's a number that's stuck in my head. So it must have come from somewhere.
Speaker 5 (55:08–55:13)
Yeah, that's it. 61. Okay. All right.
Great. Thank you.
Speaker 23 (55:18–55:22)
And then for Elliott, it's many more than that.
Speaker 5 (55:22–55:34)
Yeah, I got Elliott. I had 268 on Elliott. The 268 is for single family, so it would be… So it's 268 plus 58 plus 8, okay.
Speaker 23 (55:34–55:35)
Yeah, so 334.
Speaker 5 (55:36–55:37)
Okay, great. Thank you.
Speaker 23 (55:43–55:46)
Any other questions on this piece of the analysis before we go to Irma?
Speaker 5 (55:46–55:57)
I'm going to come. I'll come back because it's something I do want to talk about. But let me do a little bit of work here and so not to delay. And if Matthew's taking over, I'll be ready when at a later point.
Speaker 22 (55:58–56:06)
OK, sounds good. Anybody else have any questions on this? All right, Matthew, the floor is yours.
Speaker 24 (56:07–01:03:07)
Yeah, so relative to the 4500 limit, we did some conceptual planning to understand the feasibility of that and what the consequences would be. relative to open space and setbacks and so forth. You might recall we did this analysis for both 5,000 and 6,000 square foot parcels on Elliott Street, which is what is shown here, to demonstrate that there's a pattern that could be maintained within these dimensional parameters. I think the one thing to understand is that when we're looking at the feasibility of a three-family building, a three-unit building, vis-a-vis the regulations, and we limit ourselves to two and a half stories.
It's sort of, if you do the math at a thousand square feet a unit, you come up with a 1200 square foot footprint is what's sort of minimum required. And so, as you might remember, we've been calibrating the FAR and other things to sort of align with that. If you go to the next slide, Zoe. So the punchline is that a 4,500 square foot parcel will work in terms of the building size.
What is notable, obviously, because the building size remains constant, because we need to allow for parking, ideally behind the building, What we get to is an open space number that is quite low. So in the low 30s in this case, and this is fairly idealized and you'll see from this arrangement that's showing a fairly typical and pattern consistent setback. both on the front and sides that, you know, while that there is a 33% number, it's not really usable. I don't see a rear yard here or other kinds of usable open space.
But again, if we had to conform to the rules, it would fit. We looked at this in some other ways. If you go to the next slide, I wouldn't really recommend from a sort of urbanism good urbanism standpoint that we promote parking in a front lot but we were curious to to see how much open space that driveway to the to the rear was taking up. So again there are trade-offs here again this is a don't try this at home moment, but we wanted to see how the parking in the driveway affected the open space.
And as you can see, we're getting to 50%. Next slide. We looked at a slightly different shaped parcel, one that might be a little bit wider and less deep. This also works.
We're getting a little bit more open space in this case, but it's not inconsistent with some of the lots that are in the district. Next slide. And then again, look at this, what we would get from open space if we put the parking in the front. But again, I don't think that's consistent with the patterns that you see in that neighborhood.
If you go to the next slide, I was curious to see what the patterns really are existing, and we found a couple of, based on some of the analysis of various parcel sizes, a couple of examples that were sort of real-life examples of those sort of tests that we did. This is a series of two-family dwellings on Laurel Road. These all have almost exactly 4500 square foot parcels. And, you know, by my reckoning, the best I could with Google Earth and measuring footprints and so forth.
Approximately 300 gross square feet in the building, which is to say that dimensionally in terms of the building mass that these could accommodate three units as defined by the regs and how the model works. It's not to say that It's not insignificant. The change of use between two-family and three-family has other consequences. You know, there are more cars.
It's also important to note that in real-world scenarios, you see very little open space and greenery in this scenario. A lot of side lots have been paved over to accommodate multiple cars. Next slide. And this is another example on Collar Avenue, which is sort of just around the corner.
Very similar, same lot sizes, more or less the same building sizes. Again, meeting that sort of minimum threshold that we've been looking at to at least fit 3,000 square foot units. You'll see in this case that in some instances that there is more greenery. I'll also note that a lot of these buildings have garages in the rear that sort of might eat into usable open space in a rear yard.
And then we looked at Elliott Street as a kind of comparison. These are a little series of fairly typical Dwellings on 6000 square foot parcels. The buildings are approximately 3000 square feet. So when we look at the metric of where we have it right now.
This is the physical density that is represented in the numbers that we're carrying right now for Elliott Street. Again, very different use. I think these are probably single family, but it's important to have a visual that the physical density could carry and maintain the sort of physical pattern of the buildings on the street.
Speaker 22 (01:03:15–01:03:23)
I can pick up here. So I think with that, that kind of concludes the analysis that we did for both the Elliott Street and Blue Hills area.
Speaker 23 (01:03:23–01:08:30)
to inform kind of the development of zoning parameters for each. We had also just because we're going to be mentioning this as we go through the compliance numbers. This is the Fairmount Station District that was raised and discussed at the last meeting. You'll see it come up in some of the compliance scenarios that we've run tonight.
So you can see that it's basically the yellow highlighted parcels here and then the red arc that you're seeing is the half mile from the commuter rail stop. So you can kind of see that it's it's part in part out for that. And then we also wanted to bring back to this group, the 501 Randolph Ave parcel that came up in discussion at the last meeting. As discussed, this is owned by Milton Academy.
As the regulations were originally drafted, it would have been categorically excluded because of that institutional use. As was raised at the previous meeting, one of the few substantive changes that was included in the revised regulations that were published recently was the red lining that you see here at the bottom of this screenshot of the regulations. which provided some level of discretion for the state to make an exception to the general rule that institutional land would be excluded if and only if there was an indication that it was no longer going to be used for educational or institutional uses. And just as a sort of an anecdote, We are also working with the town of Hamilton.
This was an issue that the town of Hamilton raised to the state based on a specific condition in their community. And that is, we presume the sort of part of what has triggered the state to recognize that they should have a similar level of discretion to recognize specific circumstances in which institutional land is in the process of transitioning. into privately available land. And so in that case, it was just like help anchor this and make it more intuitive.
The Gordon Conwell Theological Seminary is a residential campus institutional campus that sits within the town of Hamilton. They have for a long time had student housing on campus. They are in the process of transitioning that student housing to be market available housing, not associated with the institution any longer. And that's an example of the kind of situation that the state might admit as a reason to accept the otherwise excluded land as developable.
So that's kind of what they're going for. So with that in mind, that sort of context, and based on sort of further follow-ups with Milton Academy, we would advise the planning board to not consider this further because we do not think that the state would accept it as a valid district because there isn't an indication that Milton Academy is interested in transitioning this away from their own ownership into private ownership. So that's kind of the conclusion of the analysis. And then we were going to go into showing the difference compliance scenarios and based on the sort of urban form analysis that Matthew kind of walked through and the parcel size analysis that we did of the Blue Hills area, this is the model inputs that we have used for the compliance runs that we're showing you today.
So it is broadly speaking, based on the parameters that we have had for the Blue Hills Parkway corridor. But we have made three modifications, the ones that are highlighted in red to reflect what would be necessary to have the level of physical density on those parcels that's necessary to get to three units. So that would mean the FAR would need to go up to that 0.67. That's coming from those sort of aerial views that Matthew walked us through.
The minimum lot size at 4,500, that's coming from the parcel size analysis from our prior work saying that if we set it at 5,000, that alone is enough to make this district have so many ineligible parcels that it's no longer contributing positively to the overall compliance picture for the town. And the 30% open space is a recognition of the site planning challenges of accommodating parking in the rear, that that would be necessary for some of these parcels to be able to achieve three units with three parking spaces that are not in front of the building. So those are the parameters that we've included. As we go through these, if there's a particular scenario that you want us to sort of refine and bring back to you at the next meeting, we're happy to revisit some of those.
But for the sake of efficiency, we just held that constant across all of the different versions that we're showing you. Okay, any questions before we dive into the compliance runs?
Speaker 2 (01:08:33–01:08:42)
I'm sorry, Sean, go ahead. No, no, no, please, Jim, you go first. I have a quickie. It's just so when you say you held a constant, that means everything we're looking at is going to be 30 units per acre as well?
Speaker 23 (01:08:43–01:09:00)
So all of the instances where the Blue Hills East or West districts are included in a compliance run, they'll be included with those parameters. So in other words, we didn't like in one compliance run use 30 units per acre for Blue Hills and another one use 29, et cetera.
Speaker 2 (01:09:01–01:09:02)
Okay, thank you.
Speaker 24 (01:09:03–01:09:28)
I'll add that 30, you know, if you sort of do the math, 4,500 square feet is approximately a tenth of an acre. To get to three units, you know, that's 30 units per acre. And the .67 times 4,500 gives you 3,000 square feet, which is, again, also the sort of minimum that the model will count for three units.
Speaker 5 (01:09:33–01:09:44)
Okay. Matthew, I just have I have a few questions and so if you don't mind, I feel like if I ask them now it might seem more orderly than to go back later if that's OK.
Speaker 22 (01:09:49–01:09:50)
Yes, go for it.
Speaker 5 (01:09:50–01:11:27)
Okay, all right, good. So I'm just trying to extract some data here from your data, or I'm creating some data. If we go over to Elliott Street, can you go back over to Elliott Street? And I'm going back to the 334 parcels.
Okay, excellent. And so we have, 334 parcels. And then if you go to your sheet that indicated the size of the parcels and the percentage of, there we go, great. So let's see, in the 7,500 to the 10,000 square foot category, we have a total of 22% that are that size parcel.
So just scratching some math out here, that means the 73 parcels, that would be 22% of, it's actually 22% of 334. So that means the 73, that is 7,500 square foot or greater, on the 10,000 square feet, 18%, so 18% of 334 is 60. So we have 133 that are either greater than 7,500 square feet or greater than 10,000 square feet, right? And Check me on number of units that can be built on 10,000 square feet and number of units on 7,500 square feet.
Speaker 23 (01:11:28–01:12:02)
So these would be sort of to cross-reference these with our tiers. So what you see in yellow here, the 15,000 plus, that would be four units under our current rule, that's tier three. The 10,000 to 15,000, that would also be four units, that's tier two. And then these three categories, the 6,000 to 6,250, 6,250 to 7,500, and 7,500 to 10,000, those would collectively constitute our current tier one, which allows for three units.
Speaker 5 (01:12:02–01:12:20)
I'm going to have to do a little bit of math here because I'm a little high on this. Do you want to bear with me for a second? I'll make my way through this. It'll take me one minute to do a little bit of math.
Speaker 20 (01:12:20–01:12:31)
Sean, are you trying to get at the zone capacity of the three Elliott Street corridors? tiers? I've calculated that as 813.
Speaker 5 (01:12:31–01:12:54)
No, I think I'm going a different direction than that. Bear with me for one minute, Cheryl. So 73 parcels could have potentially three units, 60 parcels could have four units per, right? Is that right, Zoe?
The 10,000.
Speaker 23 (01:12:54–01:13:29)
Let's do it quick. So it'd be the, if you take the, the four units are allowed on, let's see, 18% plus 8%. So 26% times 334. So there's 86, or 87 parcels that can accommodate four units, I think, if I'm doing my math correctly.
Speaker 5 (01:13:30–01:13:36)
So taking this- Let me check you on that. I had it at 18% of 334.
Speaker 23 (01:13:36–01:13:55)
That's for the 10,000 to 15,000, and then also for the 15,000 or more, you'd also be allowed four units on those. So if you add those two together, You have 26% of all the parcels are 10,000 square feet or above. And all of those parcels would be allowed four units.
Speaker 5 (01:13:56–01:13:59)
OK, so what did you have for total number of parcels that could have four units on?
Speaker 23 (01:14:00–01:14:02)
So I have 87 by that quick math.
Speaker 5 (01:14:02–01:14:06)
87, OK. And how many did you have that could have three?
Speaker 25 (01:14:08–01:14:11)
Wasn't that 73?
Speaker 23 (01:14:15–01:14:33)
So that'd be 46% times the 334. So that's 153, 154 per round could accommodate three units.
Speaker 5 (01:14:35–01:14:39)
154. Okay.
Speaker 23 (01:14:40–01:15:16)
So, and that's really, this is in terms of the changes that were made from 2023 to now, that's really what you're seeing there is, you know, for in 2023, right, we were cutting it off at the 7,500. So it was just the 22% of parcels could accommodate three units. And then we were also only allowing three units on the upper tiers. So the other, the two ways we've added units is we've allowed one more unit each on the ones that are 10,000 and above and then we've gained 14% of parcels that were previously excluded that now each are allowed three units.
Speaker 5 (01:15:17–01:16:47)
Okay, so stick with me for a minute, I'm gonna, I'm going to focus on 7500 and up. Okay, so I'm going to have a lower number here I'm going to, so I believe that is 73 parcels. that are in the 7,500 category. That's the 7,500 to 10,000.
And let's put aside the smaller parcels that can also have three. So here's what I'm looking at, Zoe. I'm looking at the most likely redeveloped parcels are the larger parcels. I'm just focusing on that area for a moment.
So if the 7,500 square foot to 10,000, I think that's 73 parcels. And that's 73 parcels times three units per parcel could generate 219 parcels. And if we take the 87 that you mentioned, which is in the category of 10,000 to 15,000 and also the 15,000 plus, that's 87 parcels times four, that equals 348 parcels, 348 could be developed. So if we take 348, Um, plus two 19 that's 567.
Right. Um, new residential units just in that area, uh, could be created and.
Speaker 23 (01:16:49–01:17:09)
That's where the net new comes in, right? Where this is a little bit more complicated than that, right? But I think I see what you're getting at. It's just like overall impact.
But I think it would, in order to really say like how many new units is that, we'd have to look at it in relationship to this other map, which is, you know, right now what's on it.
Speaker 5 (01:17:09–01:17:50)
Let me finish on what I'm saying here. So the math that I come up with then 567 units result from redeveloping the 7,500 plus the 7,500 to 10,000 square foot lots plus the 10,000 to 15,000 square foot plus the 15. So we have a total of 567 new residential units. That means that the net new of that is 407.
So that would be 407 net new units.
Speaker 23 (01:17:51–01:17:57)
Comparing to the assumption that it's one family currently?
Speaker 5 (01:17:57–01:17:58)
Exactly. I am.
Speaker 20 (01:17:58–01:18:52)
Sean, I did a calculation based on the actual split of singles and two families and based on parcel data that we have. And it was for the Elliott Street Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3. So the zone capacity, not reducing it yet from what Zoe is talking about tonight, in those three tiers is 813. The existing units in that area are 289 for a net new of 302.
I'm sorry, a net new and 23 of 302 Now 524. So an increase of 222 units of net new.
Speaker 5 (01:18:52–01:20:06)
Yeah, I guess what I'm looking at is the net new and my logic and the reason I wanted to focus on the lot sizes that are 7,500 foot or greater, I think they're the most likely to be redeveloped, most likely. Let's assume that the smaller lot sizes, economically, it's hard to redevelop them. You either have a restriction on the geography, but the bigger ones are much more likely. So if my math was right, and I'm not questioning, Cheryl, what you put together, but just my quick math here means 407, and this is only on the large parcels, 407 net new, which also means 407 more cars.
If we just say one vehicle, per residence, we have 407 more cars in that neighborhood. And I'm also curious to know what is the anticipated bedroom count that we might have if it's a 7,500 or a 10,000 square foot or a 15,000 square foot lot redeveloped? What would the bedroom counts be in those residences?
Speaker 23 (01:20:08–01:21:03)
That's something we can't predict. I mean, I think this was the subject of the RKG study to evaluate likely redevelopment and impacts on town services and occupation, et cetera. But I think there is no doubt that we're talking about an increase in density here. We're talking about an increase in the number of people.
And so that carries with it increases in use. traffic is part of that, parking is part of that. But I'm wondering if there's, you know, Sean, if there's like kind of a, if you're trying to get to, you know, I think this is this, this concept applies in all of the districts, right? This sort of issue of the, you know, what's the impact of that added density?
Is there a particular, are you suggesting that we change the rules?
Speaker 5 (01:21:04–01:21:30)
No, I'm not suggesting anything at the moment. I'm just trying to use a small area to try to, you know, develop an understanding of impact. That's it. You know, and it seemed really simple to just take this area and the large size only and not even consider the small size.
And like I said earlier, I think the larger size lots are more developable because they're gonna be less restrictive in terms of these.
Speaker 23 (01:21:31–01:22:36)
Yeah. Sort of in the spirit of what I think you're trying to get at and using Cheryl's analysis that based on the current geography. So if we were to focus, if we were to assume that parcels that are below 7,500 are unlikely to be developed under our current rules, if I'm doing my math correctly, that means that sort of, The parcels under 7,500, but above the threshold at which we're allowing three units, I would account for about 243 units. So if Cheryl's math was that the current rules allow for a net new of 524, then you could imagine that you take 243 of those out.
So if you're assuming that parcels under 7,500 are not being developed, so that means you take the 524 minus 243, that's a net new of 281 under that set of assumptions.
Speaker 5 (01:22:36–01:22:51)
Yeah, I'm not you know what I probably have to probably have to look at that a little bit more. I do we know on these parcels the large parcels. If those parcels have single family to family or three family homes on the large parcels.
Speaker 23 (01:22:52–01:23:12)
So we do know that but that's like that I think that's what Cheryl had, we have not done that granular analysis for Elliot in the current incarnation, we could do it and it's something that we've agreed that we will be willing to do once we get to a single sort of scenario that we're pursuing, but we don't have those numbers run now.
Speaker 5 (01:23:12–01:25:43)
Yeah. So the reason I'm drilling into this for myself is, I think we had, if my counts correct, we had 14 people that spoke tonight. During citizen speak, many of them have issues with the density in the Elliott Street neighborhood. There's also a considerable number of them that are in favor of 25%.
And I don't know, and maybe they do, maybe they've done these calculations themselves. I don't know that they recognize the kind of density that this is. And the reason I wanted to try to extrapolate what I'm doing here is so our audience tonight could imagine that if my math is right, I have 407 new units. And that's again, only on the large size.
That's again, assuming that all the large lots are single family right now, and they would go to either three or four. And that's 400 cars, and it's 400, you know, there's a density and the proponents of this should be able to understand the kind of density that this is bringing. And, you know, I know that each of the neighborhoods are unique, but the problem is the same, the density driven into any neighborhood is going to be pretty pretty intense. So, you know, it's the granularity and I understand your interest in trying to get to one plan and then developing the granularity.
But I almost feel like it might be too late developing the granularity at that point, because the granularity should be considered as we're trying to get to a plan. Do you follow what I'm saying? For people that are saying, oh, I think this is great. I think we should do it.
Elliott Street's too dense. I'm not sure. I mean, what is dense? It's relative, right?
density is not dense to another person, but if in fact all of those parcels got redeveloped, including the smaller ones, we're probably in a category of somewhere between 500 and 1,000 cars that would be added. to the LA street area. This is assuming every resident has one car. That's really what we're talking about.
I think it's an incredible amount of density that I'd want everybody to understand what we're talking about. So the granularity later might be too late for people to be able at that point to say, geez, I was supporting something I didn't quite understand the impact of. Now, I guess I understand the impact of it and I like it a lot less. It's for that reason that I'm trying to do this.
Speaker 20 (01:25:44–01:28:26)
I did that granular analysis last spring, and I shared it with this board last spring. We talked about it last summer when UTIL started working on these potential revisions. It's one of the reasons why I suggested we needed to have public forums long ago. And so you all have the data.
There's one parcel. in when the boundaries that we have had, that is 25,000 square feet. There are five parcels that are between 20 and 25,000. There are four parcels between 17, five and 20.
There's seven between 15, five and 17, five. There's 21 between 12, five and 15, five. And there's 39 between 10,000 and 12, five. There are 65 parcels between 7,500 and 10,000.
Between 7,500 and 6,000, there are 64 parcels. The net new that was discussed in 2023, we discovered was inaccurate because it used residency as a way of calculating it. When you look at the granular parcel by parcel data, I calculated that the net new in the 2023 article is actually 302. And so then if you look at what's proposed in this and what we've been looking at since last summer, we went from a zone capacity in the tiers one through three of 480 to a zone capacity of 813 for a change of 333 units.
The existing units that were in 2023 in that area were 178. And the existing units that are in it today, by adding more parcels and by allowing more units on the larger parcels, there's now 289 existing units for a net new of 524. And we've had most of that data for some time. I would actually like to see the rest of this presentation so that we can see where we are and see what other revisions we may seek to ask of you till before our deadline is up.
Speaker 5 (01:28:27–01:28:41)
Well, we're going to see it. It's only 730, right? Is that all? So no, it's 830.
I apologize. But we have plenty of time, Cheryl. We're going to get to it. And I appreciate your consideration allowing me the time to have these questions while the data is on screen.
Speaker 24 (01:28:43–01:29:45)
I might add just one quick before we move on. Sean, you asked about bedroom counts. I just want to point out that we've calibrated the FAR so that it keeps going down as you move up in tiers. It's at 0.4 for a 10,000 square foot lot.
That equates to four 1,000 square foot units gross. In this market, it's probably unlikely to be a full two bedrooms, definitely not a three. It's more likely to be a kind of, you know, one bedroom plus. So if that's any help, I can't, we can't predict what the market really, really wants, but based on the size limitations, you're unlikely certainly at the lower end of those tiers to get, certainly get three bedroom units.
Speaker 5 (01:29:45–01:31:37)
Yeah, Matthew, I appreciate that. That is helpful. You know, what I have said for a long time, the impact in terms of, and there is a real impact here for the potential for an increasing number of school age students in town. It's not as a result of four units being built on a 10,000 square foot lot.
Where it is a very likely result is the empty nester moving into one of those units. selling their home that's a three or four bedroom house. And that's where the school age children impact will happen. So I really appreciate that.
So you're saying that if a 10,000 square foot lot is developed and we hold the 0.4 for the FAR, we probably have four units of a thousand square foot each and most likely one and a half bedrooms per unit, right? So thanks, that's really helpful. And hopefully the impact that I'm the impact that I'm identifying is not families being able to move into these units, it's people like maybe myself, you know, selling my four-bedroom home and moving into one of those units and a family is the argument of this. You know, I have said and I know RKG, you know, did their analysis last year, I didn't agree with 275 students being the impact if we build 2,461 units.
That I'll never agree with. And what they had told us at that time was they did no calculation for what I'm describing as the empty nester transition. So yeah, I have a concern for, you know, with the impact and our capacity to be able to manage what we have when that happens. And that's the most likely result.
Speaker 23 (01:31:38–01:32:49)
I think that's a it's a good pattern to note it's certainly part of I think what the end goal is of this is making housing options available that enable people to move to housing that matches their needs and that includes people who needed a family size unit at one point in time and no longer need it. I will just also point out that. Most of those family sized units that maybe now have empty nesters did once have a family of more people that included children that went to Milton schools. And that's means that at some point those Milton schools were accommodating.
that number of children. So I think it's, it is a good point. It's also a generational turnover that happens naturally in every community. My parents started their family in a home that had a, you know, an elderly woman that was there that once had a family in that home before her.
So there's a generational swing to these things that I think this is at a, we're at a generational turning point as a region about that kind of housing stock, and to some extent that will happen, regardless of whether new units are made available.
Speaker 5 (01:32:49–01:33:48)
Yeah, no, I, and I understand it Zoe, and you know you probably aware that the discussion in town right now is building a new school. So we don't have enough capacity. So the reality of it is as residents, we have to realize that if what I described actually occurs, which I think is very likely to occur, all we'll do is create more stress. And in a conversation, we'll begin at some point in time down the road about building another school.
So it's just a point. It's just it's it's something that people should be aware of. should be aware of. And the reason I bring it up is there's not a lot of discussion about it.
RKG didn't want to talk about the number of kids that would become school age children if the empty nested transition occurred. And I don't think that's fair to the residents of the town. I think they should all understand it. Thanks for giving me the time here to walk through this.
Speaker 22 (01:33:49–01:34:04)
Of course, any other questions on the analysis before we dive into the compliance scenarios? All right, let me just jump to the first one.
Speaker 23 (01:34:04–01:40:08)
So just as a reminder, we're looking at essentially six combinations. um, a set of three where we, we remove, um, you know, Elliott East and swap in respectively Blue Hills East, Blue Hills West, or Fairmount Station District. And then similarly for removing, um, Elliott West and swapping in those same three districts. Um, for the sake of, um, you'll, you'll see these in sequence, um, sort of, I'll do my best to kind of present them as they come so you're really clear to, to you what is happening in each scenario.
And in all scenarios, we're using these parameters for the Blue Hills districts that are being added. And we're using for the Fairmount Station District, when it is added, we are using the same rules as are currently being applied in the Elliott Street corridor. So this is the first one. This is what we showed at the prior planning board meeting that takes the Elliott East, so that's the part that's south of Elliott Street, kind of in the middle of the Elliott Street corridor as we've been seeing it.
and swaps in for that the Fairmount Station District with the same rule sets as Elliott Street Corridor. So you can see at the bottom here, we're in the clear on all the compliance targets. We have a little bit of room to maneuver. We could potentially look at, for instance, bringing down Randolph-Avon Access Road by some units to line that up.
The next one we ran is, again, looking at swapping in Fairmount Station District, but instead of removing the Elliott East area, we're instead removing the Elliott West area. So that's the larger lot single-family Columbines area. So you can see here some changes to the numbers in the Elliott Street corridor that reflect that modification and then the same numbers for the Fairmount Station District. This one's also compliant across the board, has a little bit less room to maneuver, but still has some room to maneuver, just slightly different sort of profile.
Next one takes the Blue Hills East area and swaps it in for the Elliott East, which has been removed. In this one, again, we are compliant. We're pretty close on unit numbers, so not a ton of room to maneuver, but density is up well above 15, which is something that we haven't seen in many of our scenarios. So that also indicates that maybe there's some room to maneuver in a couple areas to kind of bring this into greater alignment with those targets.
I realized I neglected to mention up here I have for each of them I'm showing the delta in the Elliott street corridor as a whole since these are listed out by tier so it can be difficult to understand what's the the overall impact of that those so when we do when we move the remove the Elliott east the delta is 123 units and when we remove Elliott West the Delta is 154 units reduction in Elliott. So this one is now showing you still swapping in the Blue Hills East geography, um, and now removing Elliott West. Um, this one actually drops below, um, apologies, sort of color-coded that cell differently. This drops just below the compliance target, um, in terms of unit numbers, but is comfortably above in terms of density.
Um, so that's, um, you know, a bit asymmetrical. So maybe there's some correctional, um, you know, parameters we could tweak to get to what we need there, but, um, just want to call attention to that. And then here for, we're now swapping in Blue Hills West, instead of Blue Hills East. So that's the sort of triangle that's just sort of swings like a pie slice to the west of the Blue Hills Parkway corridor.
And we are removing Elliott East in this scenario. This one brings us well above the compliance target in terms of unit capacity as well as density. So again, a little bit of room to maneuver potentially. And then we have our last option, which again, swaps in Blue Hills West, but this time removes Elliott West.
And this one, you can see we have a bit of a margin on the unit capacity and also density is significantly above the 15. So broadly speaking, and I'll just, I'm gonna correct this now. So it's the visual is clear. This is not compliant on this cell.
So basically five of these six options are compliant. and have a little bit of room to maneuver in one way or another. The only one that is not is the removal of Elliott West and the swapping in of Blue Hills East under these rules. So I think the The goal here should be to both discuss the global decision of whether Blue Hills and Elliott Street geographies should be swapped, and same thing for the Fairmount Station District, speaking in broader terms about what some of the public comment addressed in terms of the distribution of units across town.
And then as we get through that to then speak more specifically about like which of these six the planning board would like us to refine as we're kind of moving forward, if there's any specific tweaks that you'd like us to address to kind of fine tune these options. So I will pause there and I'm happy to jump back to any of the ones that you want to look at a little bit further. And similarly, we can toggle back to some of the analysis as relevant.
Speaker 20 (01:40:14–01:40:20)
I think you're muted, Cheryl. Thanks, Zoe. Can you go back to the Fairmount Station one?
Speaker 23 (01:40:23–01:40:28)
We have the two ones, so this one swaps in for East and this one swaps it in for West.
Speaker 20 (01:40:29–01:40:58)
And if we went back to three units per parcel across the entire Elliott Street corridor. How many years would that take out? Would that take out about 87 units?
Speaker 23 (01:41:02–01:41:22)
So right now we're getting 248 units in tiers two and three, which are allowing four units. So if we multiply that times three quarters, we get 186.
Speaker 1 (01:41:23–01:41:25)
That was a question I had also.
Speaker 23 (01:41:25–01:41:38)
Delta would be. So that's a Delta of 62 units.
Speaker 20 (01:41:40–01:42:05)
So if we took those 62 units and we added those to Randolph Avenue and access, that would put that at a unit capacity of 162. And what would that make the units per acre on that one.
Speaker 23 (01:42:05–01:42:10)
If we added 62 units to the Randolph-Avon access road.
Speaker 26 (01:42:11–01:42:11)
Correct.
Speaker 23 (01:42:17–01:42:36)
That would be 164 units on Randolph-Avon access road and dividing that by 6.1. That would be a 26.9 density, 26.9 units per acre.
Speaker 20 (01:42:37–01:43:39)
Right, so that's still quite a bit less than Granite Ave North at 51 units an acre, Milton Station East, which is basically extra space storage and 88 Wharf, and Milton Station West, which is 131 Elliot and 36 Central, and where Steel and Rye is, and Milton Station Bridge, which is where Milton Hill House is, it's still like half the density of those areas. I think if we can take those 62 units out of the Elliott Street, Tier 2 and Tier 3, and put them into the Randolph Ave and do the Fairmount station. If we can get Fairmount to 200, we can address some of the spreading this a little further across town that we don't get when we're doing it, adding on to the sides of the Blue Hills Parkway sub-district.
Speaker 2 (01:43:41–01:43:56)
Yeah, I think it's tough to compare 711 Randolph Ave and Randolph Ave Access Road to Granite Ave North and Milton Station East West and the bridge. I mean, those are way more commercial type parcels as opposed to Randolph Ave and Access Road.
Speaker 20 (01:43:57–01:44:04)
Jim, Milton Station Bridge, though, is multifamily buildings that have single families next to them, so.
Speaker 2 (01:44:05–01:44:07)
They're very commercial. The point is they're very commercial.
Speaker 20 (01:44:07–01:44:11)
Elliott Street's residential in that part of Elliott Street.
Speaker 2 (01:44:11–01:44:15)
Boy, you interrupted me. I was just talking about Granite Ave North, Milton Station, East Western Bridge.
Speaker 20 (01:44:16–01:44:38)
No, Jim, you keep telling me I'm interrupting you. You're interrupting me. We're on Zoom. We're trying to have an interactive discussion here without raising our hands.
So we're going to either raise our hands and only speak when our hands are raised, or we're going to have some acknowledgment that we might not see when one another has finished speaking, OK? So I'd appreciate it if you would just continue asking me to stop interrupting you.
Speaker 1 (01:44:41–01:47:11)
So I will say I like the idea of taking the tier two and tier three down to three units instead of four and taking some of that pressure off. I see the combination, which seems to me to make sense, is to take the Elliott Street West, removing that, and adding the Blue Hill West combination, because those are leaving in areas that are currently have the most two families currently. And I think we have to remember, because I'm very sensitive to this too, and I think looking at what Matthew showed, Those are very large structures that are on very tight lots. So this is not changing anything that's not currently in existing condition.
But what we have to also factor in is that with our ADU bylaws, I hope people remember that two families already by right can have an ADU. So they can be a three-family right now without us doing anything. So those conditions are, there will be some conditions that may change there. The other thing I might say is with a larger structure, I think we're less likely on a smaller, some of the tighter lots, we're much more likely to see new construction and demolition of those structures.
The cost to tear a building down, if you have a two-family in it, the cost to tear a two-family down and build a three-family, Cheryl, you know does not make sense. It triggers, you know, if you're taking down an entire building, stretch codes, so everything needs to be energy efficient and materials and meet strict building codes. I think it's much more likely that you'll see a unit added, if at all, within the structure that currently exists. And I think that type of housing is needed.
And I think there's a value to that. So I like the idea of taking the west out. And I know the Fairmount, I don't see the advantage of of that neighborhood.
Speaker 20 (01:47:13–01:50:21)
But it's within a half a mile of a commuter rail station. It's to the letter of the law, as you all have talked about at many meetings. And so it's walkable to the commuter rail station, which everybody has said is a more reliable line than the Mattapan trolley is. And I still think that You know, there were a number of people who spoke about concerns of adding more density in the Blue Hills Parkway, Brush Hill Road triangle that we were looking at, and the impact on open space on the small, narrow streets and on parking situations where we have a little more room, where we have transit that's walkable.
I don't see why Fairmount Station, uh, shouldn't be included. It is, uh, it is very much the same kind of. Built environment as the history corridor, and it allows us to remove. some of that zone capacity in the Elliott Street corridor to an area that doesn't exacerbate the problems on Elliott Street.
And so I think the parkway doesn't have the same impact. And I think Randolph Ave is a four lane road. We've discussed this numerous times. Everyone in the planning board, we talked about the other properties on Randolph Ave.
We had a scorecard for districts last summer. We spent many, many meetings discussing. We have not run these analyses back through that scorecard, but we gave Randolph-Ave a pretty good rating because it had reasonable access for those who are driving. It has a bus line, and many say, yes, it's not very walkable.
But there are many parts of Milton that we have said, well, East Milton Square is walkable, right? In my view, East Milton Square, one of the disadvantages of these regulations, and it's something I wanted to ask Zoe about, is we are limited to the number of units that we can have in a mandatory mixed use zone to 25%. We said East Milton Square and the Milton Village combined our business districts, we can't make all of it mandatory mixed use because it exceeds what the state's allowing us to do. But when we're taking at the same time a mixed use overlay in East Milton Square that allows for multifamily housing.
I would like to ask Zoe if she thinks that the state, HLC, would make some kind of exception on this similar to the way they're making an exception to the district size for Granite Ave North and for the paper mill. Do you think there's any chance that they would allow for us to have a larger number of mandatory mixed use units?
Speaker 23 (01:50:23–01:51:16)
We haven't yet had a community ask for that from the state so I don't have a good sort of sense of their level of how receptive they are to that idea I do think that, you know, as we've discussed several times, I think Milton's the relationship of Milton's transit access to your parcel fabric. is unique and poses really specific challenges that we have collectively been revolving around for, you know, several years now, and is at the core of the Elliott Street corridor conversation. So, I mean, I think it's certainly something we can extend as a, you know, a specific request to the state to understand how receptive they are to that, but I don't think I have enough of an indication to give you a a sense just from our experience thus far. And can you remind me.
Speaker 1 (01:51:16–01:52:24)
Can I just say one thing I just, I didn't, I went we were talking about taking the 62 units off. I hadn't really, I don't have a strong opinion on where those go so I wasn't referring to putting those anywhere specifically I'm not. You know, I'm opening up open to looking at Randolph Ave, but I'm also thinking, you know, could we also, you know, look at putting it on maybe another area, the paper mill site? Could we bump that up?
I don't I don't know. Grenada North. I don't know what that would do. But so I wasn't saying exactly where I thought those 62 units.
I thought it was a good idea to reduce The Elliott Street corridor tier two and tier three down to three units, but I think when swapping out the, the another part of the Elliott Street I think the West makes sense, because the east has. more two families, there's virtually no two families on the larger parcels. And I think the larger parcels are more likely on Elliott Street in the Elliott West to be the potential for demolition and redevelopment there.
Speaker 20 (01:52:24–01:54:42)
I disagree that larger parcels are going to lead to more demolition because you can easily do an addition that can accommodate an additional unit on a two family or an additional two units. One of the advantages of the four units is that, and we limited it to, I think what we talked about before was it would be required that it would be two units in two buildings. And so that you could meet the requirement of a multifamily and not have four units in one building. And it would be a typology that already exists in the LA street corridor.
Because we have 2 families on 5000 square foot lots on the street quarter combined. Those 2 lots are 10,000 square feet with 4 units, 2 units in each building, but to what residents said in about 2 dozen emails. and many residents tonight, another dozen, they want to see a more equitable distribution of the zone capacity. We have to get back to talking about another parcel, another zone in another location, or we are not considering the three dozen comments letters that we received that said be more equitable.
And that's why I would like us to go back. We already are zoning from multifamily in East Milton Square. Why? If we can get the mandatory mixed use accepted for that, we are then basically taking the total amount of multifamily that we're allowing zoning for and reducing it some because we're incorporating the East Milton overlay into it.
Jim has said, why aren't we doing in Milton Village? We have a mixed-use overlay there. Why don't we get credit for those units? But that's in the same location.
The same logic applies to East Milton Square, except that it's in a different location and you can walk to amenities. That's more walkable than people said than Randolph-Avis. I'd like to go back to considering that, but I don't mind. going back and taking some of that density out of the street corridor, adding a station, adding a district at Fairmont station, and putting some additional on Randolph Ave or in East Milton Square's overlay area.
Speaker 1 (01:54:43–01:55:44)
So I just want to add on because I am open to and we're, you know, we're limited on time. But one of the things that Cheyenne and Zoe, I would be interested in going back is to look at, you know, to Cheryl's point, looking at some exceptions that we could actually use and count the ice house. If it's a it's a lower than a five acre parcel, it's about 2.2 acres, but that's mixed use multifamily housing. Would we be able to.
you know, what would be the appropriate way to request from HLC that that would be able to, we would be able to count units there. And also I think because of the being amenity rich, the Falcone property, that it's a smaller size parcel, but yet that is a tremendous amount of housing that will be, you know, partially affordable.
Speaker 20 (01:55:44–01:55:46)
Which Falcone property is that?
Speaker 1 (01:55:47–01:55:52)
So the new on Bassett Street, the new project that is the 40B project.
Speaker 20 (01:55:52–01:55:55)
Right, so that would be the overlay in East Milton Square.
Speaker 1 (01:55:56–01:56:24)
Well, no, I wouldn't do the I wouldn't do the entire overlay. It would be that specific parcel that I would I would if the board would agree, I think we should request getting credit for those multifamily housing and for the ice house. And that would simply be asking for an exception to the lot size because of our because of our limited land area that we have. So that would help us tremendously.
Speaker 23 (01:56:25–01:57:31)
I'm going to jump in real quick, and then I'll pass on. I know, Maggie, you're waiting to talk. I just want to make clear that the indications we've received from the state about their ability to make an exception to the five-acre rule have all been related to physically infrastructurally isolated parcels. So I am very doubtful that they will be interested in making exceptions to that five acre minimum for parcels that are embedded in the neighborhood fabric.
And the reason is because that the origin of that five acre minimum is really intended to prevent spot zoning, which is David Ensign, PB – He, Him, His): Very much what we're talking about zoning a single parcel, that is, you know multifamily use. David Ensign, PB – He, Him, His. : and not making it part of a larger zone is. is very much in the spirit of what they were trying to avoid with that regulation to begin with.
So I think we can absolutely ask, and we're happy to extend that to them, but I just want to make sure that you have a sense of how likely it is. I think it's relatively unlikely.
Speaker 1 (01:57:31–01:57:59)
Well, that would be very helpful, because then we could really take it off some of the areas that are dense, and I'm very sensitive to that. But if they currently can already be a three-family, and we have two families, I know other communities, when we were first watching, they utilized their two and three families existing because that was typical of what already was the character of that location.
Speaker 5 (01:57:59–02:00:07)
I think this is just the, maybe I've lost count, the 100th, maybe 150th, workaround that we continue to try to talk about, right? It's just, it's one thing after another. Let's add 62 units over to Randolph Ave. Let's try to figure out how to get the property behind Abbey Park, you know, included.
Let's include the ice house. This is why 25% is not reasonably applicable to Milton or any other town that has the restrictive nature of Milton. But, you know, Matthew said at the public forum, We have 14 districts. I think that Matthew said that there was not one town that he has worked with or UTL has worked with that has 14 districts.
What we really should do to achieve equitable for people is pursue something that gives us relief from 25%. That's what we should do. And everybody could have some relief in all of the neighborhoods, but this is nothing other than trying another workaround and another workaround and another workaround Move it here, move it there. If anybody's watched these meetings and I've heard enough criticism of the planning board and what we haven't accomplished in a year and a half, it's because 25% is not a reasonable, applicable zoning plan for a town like this.
It just isn't. It just isn't. And, you know, here we are trying to appease the folks over in Elliott Street, and I get it. I think I'd be asking for it if I lived in Elliott Street, too.
But, you know, moving 62 units, and I'm not saying I'm with, I'm for it or against the chair over to Randolph-Fab, but moving 60 units to Randolph-Fab is just another, it's another workaround. You know, Meredith's idea of trying to get them to accept the project needs to be another workaround, right? The most appropriate thing to do is ask for relief. And we'll probably, if we ask for relief and explain how restrictive this is for us, we'd probably have something that we would actually be able to put the town meeting and town meeting would accept.
That's enormously frustrating.
Speaker 19 (02:00:08–02:04:19)
It is enormously frustrating, and we have received a lot of emails the past few days, and I thank everyone for them. And a lot of them have been directed at my comments. And I apologize to anybody if I've offended anybody or taken advantage of anybody's situation. But I'm willing to, you know, walk the talk.
And, you know, my family has five acres. And I'd be willing to zone my families for five acres to reap an opportunity. I've talked about opportunities for our residents and I firmly believe that. And as Sean mentioned, land values are only increasing.
So if you guys wanna look at taking pressure off Elliott Street, I really would be willing to have you look at my family's property. And my neighbors might not like that, but I'd be willing to do it. And I firmly believe in open space. And anybody who knows me, I've advocated for open space my whole entire professional career.
I believe in green corners. I advocate for conservation land. I advocate for organic gardening and organic practices. And I do, I'm sorry if I've offended anybody, and I want everybody to have trees and open spaces.
I don't, I don't want, I want natural parks for our kids to grow up on. Um, so that's 1 point if you're looking for 5 acres, I'm look down at hillside street as 11 email suggested that you do. And then secondly, I wouldn't mind looking back at Randolph have. I look to see on this your unit capacity for the Randolph-Ebb Access Road, it's up to 102.
I've talked about it extensively. There's already 40 units on one acre already going there. I was comfortable doing another 40, so there'd be a total of 80. It's disappointing to still see this 102 is still sitting there.
Especially when there's going to be another development going on at the 711 store. And probably across the street on the other intersection. So there's a lot of development going on Randall fast. However.
If you don't mind going back to the map of the Randolph-Ave access road, and maybe we need to extend or expand the district from not just the horse farm, but also to the other houses that will complete the square of that Randolph-Ave. And again, I talk about resident opportunity, a firm believer in giving our residents. An opportunity to to take advantage of the increase in value of their homes and not. Letting it go to some big outside developer.
But could we look at, you know, the squaring off from the access road to square it off to, you know, the the house, you know, heading north? And what would that do? What would what would that do? I wonder.
You mean this one here, Maggie? Yeah, and continue going up to here. Yeah, so it'd be 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 houses.
Speaker 23 (02:04:19–02:04:23)
Got it. So basically carrying these lines forward to come out to Randolph.
Speaker 19 (02:04:23–02:04:47)
And again, I haven't talked to any of these neighbors except for one. He was willing to include his house in it because he believes that he would increase his value of his property and he's planning for his future with his children and his retirement. I haven't talked to anybody else, but I don't know if that would do anything.
Speaker 2 (02:04:49–02:04:54)
Well, you might as well include the parcel south of the proposed 40B along the access road.
Speaker 19 (02:04:55–02:04:57)
Yeah. Okay. Yeah, you could do that. Yes.
Speaker 2 (02:05:00–02:06:41)
I guess if you make it bigger, I wouldn't mind more units here, but I kinda like what you're, I mean, I agree with you where we sort of stopped at 80 and then we got to 100 somehow. And now we're just throwing more units on here to take them from somewhere else. And I guess if we're all airing our grievances, I would not put anything in East Milton Square. I mean, my feeling is that East Milton Square is getting theirs already with 100 or whatever, 97 Falcone units and then, 440 granite, and then, you know, our overlay zoning still hasn't even kicked in over there yet, so who knows what that's gonna bring.
And you can't walk to the T from East Milton Square. I mean, the spirit of this law is to walk to the T, not use a car. East Milton Square is a destination where you drive to it. And I would go back to the village, you know, I would put, I know you guys don't agree with it, but, you know, Milton Village, exactly what Cheryl said, I would bring the Hunnaman building, the bank down there, the post office, all the way up to the Verizon building.
I would include all those parcels, because those are great buildings that could use a little redevelopment. And those would bring a lot of units. And you can walk to the T, and it's already in a business district. And we can make it the mandatory mixed use.
I mean, that's where I would look. instead of trying to put units here, there, and everywhere. Because we've been doing that for the last couple of iterations, and we're maxed out at the paper mill. And I kind of thought we were maxed out here on this Randolph-Ath parcel.
We're maxed out at 711. You can't throw a couple more units on top, so.
Speaker 23 (02:06:43–02:06:50)
Jim, if I'm getting it right, can you describe to me the parcels in Milton Village that you thought we should expand to?
Speaker 20 (02:06:50–02:07:09)
Before you do that, before you go off this map, though, can I just add something else here? There's that parcel to the northeast that's landlocked. This one? Right.
And I know you, I think, explained that you didn't include it because of the access.
Speaker 23 (02:07:09–02:07:38)
Yeah, I think there's a, Nick had done some research on this for us from the town's perspective. I believe there is an access easement in place that provides access to these three parcels, but that same easement is not in place currently to extend to this parcel. There's a chance it could be extended, but that's the rationale for leaving it off because we thought it might be questioned by the state whether it has legitimate public access.
Speaker 20 (02:07:38–02:07:46)
And does it, who owns the easement? Is that a paper street and then the town grants the easement or is that a private property owner?
Speaker 23 (02:07:47–02:07:49)
I don't recall.
Speaker 20 (02:07:50–02:07:54)
Because if it's a town, it would be easy enough to grant the permission, right?
Speaker 23 (02:07:54–02:08:12)
Yeah, I think from, yeah, I'm not sure, but I think I think Nix had advised us based on the status of the current easement. So I think if he felt it was easy to extend on the timeline that we have, he would have indicated that.
Speaker 19 (02:08:13–02:08:47)
And just to go back, sorry, about my suggestion on increasing density here. I'm not really suggesting, you know, I would like to keep it like the three units per lot, if that's possible. I don't want to extend it out to be like another 15 units per lot. It would just be three units per each of these existing house lots.
Yeah, I understand.
Speaker 23 (02:08:48–02:09:25)
And just as a quick note, and then I think, Jim, let's get back to your idea. When we ran the compliance numbers here, we left that 102 in for the Randolph-Abenaxis Road because we weren't sure what numbers we were going to get. Almost all of them came in with some margin. So if we do choose to pursue one of those, I think they all have room to see a reduction or a correction back down close to that 80 number.
We just didn't have time to do it for today. So that wasn't like a intentional slight. Okay, Jim, can you kind of direct me on this, the parcels you were thinking about?
Speaker 2 (02:09:25–02:09:42)
Yeah, where it says the word Milton in red, the T station. If you go south of that, you see a bunch of trees and then right to the left building right there, this one parcel heading south on Adams Street. There's like a little old hat shop and a little
Speaker 22 (02:09:43–02:09:44)
Like down here.
Speaker 2 (02:09:44–02:09:50)
Right there. And then that building just to the south of that also is the Verizon building, which is a huge builder.
Speaker 20 (02:09:52–02:10:05)
Got it. But Jim, you're not suggesting that that would be added to Milton station West at a 6 story height, right? No, I'm East rather.
Speaker 2 (02:10:05–02:10:07)
No, not at a 6 story height.
Speaker 19 (02:10:07–02:10:13)
4.5 feel better. That's too tall.
Speaker 20 (02:10:14–02:10:24)
4.5 is? The zoning allows four stories under the overlay if the bonus is granted.
Speaker 19 (02:10:25–02:10:30)
Yeah, but only do it like two and a half stories and then keep the bonus in.
Speaker 20 (02:10:30–02:10:38)
No, it still allows three stories and then the bonus. Two and a half is less than what the overlay zoning allows.
Speaker 19 (02:10:38–02:10:40)
Yeah, but what's the underlying zoning?
Speaker 20 (02:10:41–02:10:42)
The underlying is business.
Speaker 19 (02:10:42–02:10:47)
This business allows 40, 40 feet, 45, 45 feet.
Speaker 1 (02:10:48–02:10:50)
So, the other would have to be a lower height.
Speaker 19 (02:10:50–02:11:02)
Then it would have to be keep it as the keep it as 45. and then if there's. They then should get a bonus if they do while affordables or something.
Speaker 20 (02:11:03–02:11:15)
But you can't. We haven't done the bonus in any of this, although I think some towns have, Zoe, if that's right. Yeah, that's right. They have a baseline zoning and then a bonus.
We haven't done the bonus anywhere.
Speaker 2 (02:11:15–02:11:18)
So let's start here.
Speaker 1 (02:11:20–02:11:30)
Well, no, I think we don't want to see these buildings torn. I mean, Swift Hat Shop will be torn down and rebuilt, but the Verizon building has a large lot that there could be an incentive to tear that down.
Speaker 2 (02:11:31–02:11:35)
Yeah, but it's- And we don't want that. The Verizon building, it's not that nice of a building.
Speaker 1 (02:11:37–02:11:39)
I mean the building is very attractive.
Speaker 5 (02:11:39–02:12:10)
Yeah. You know, it's a, you know, it strikes me as being a little. odd to be concerned about adding one story more down here in this area that already has multi-story buildings after we just heard Maggie talk about putting a hundred units, you know, where their nursery is. I mean, you know, I mean, my God, if we can put a hundred units up on Hillside with their nursery is we can add a story, you know, in the village.
Speaker 20 (02:12:13–02:12:15)
Sean, are you talking about making a four story?
Speaker 1 (02:12:16–02:12:41)
Yeah. Yeah. Which is what, that's the incentive, that's the bonus, Cheryl, right? On the overlay zoning?
Yes. So basically it would negate our overlay zoning that we worked really hard on down here. Because it would be much easier just to do it and bypass.
Speaker 5 (02:12:41–02:12:54)
I want to come back to the- If that's, I'm sorry to interrupt. I did interrupt and I apologize. If that's disturbing, call the governor. We're doing all kinds of crazy things.
None of it makes sense.
Speaker 20 (02:12:55–02:15:52)
I just want to go back to the East Milton Square for a minute, because it doesn't have these type of buildings right there. And we didn't do a build-out analysis, or we didn't have a consultant do a build-out analysis of what the zoning would yield in the mixed-use overlay. But we know 440 Granite Ave. is 20 some units, I forgot how many, 20 exactly, and 90 some at the 40B.
And so we know we have over 110 units there that are already being built that we should get credit for. And that more than offsets the 62 that we were talking about. And it cuts into some of the other that we were, 120 some that we were talking about. And if one of those, there are some buildings there that if they got redeveloped and had commercial first floor and residential above, That's exactly what our overlay zoning is allowing.
So, Jim, I understand that you're concerned that they already are getting it, but nothing about the zoning will change that they're already getting those buildings. And we're putting the overlay out there for TAMI to approve. We already are saying that we think it's a good option to have this overlay that allows a ground floor commercial and upper floor residential. If we made it at, just like we did in 2023, we made it less attractive than the overlay zoning, then the overlay zoning will be what developers use, but yet we still get credit for the zone capacity.
So it makes so much sense in that regard. You're getting credit for something that you're already planning. It's just like getting credit for the 4DB and the other approved project. And the only reason I have been concerned about it is because of the mandatory mixed use because I don't think any of us want to see business loss in that area.
And that's where I think it could be really important to get relief on that, which I think we have a good argument for because the places that make most sense for us to have districts are where we are. That's the only places that we have business districts. And so I think that's a really strong argument. This, I agree with Meredith, a balance between wanting to preserve these buildings and that's why I'd rather see Adam Street also has its own traffic challenges, and this intersection of Valiant and Adams does too.
I just want to say that people have talked about concerns about traffic, and all of the places under consideration, they all have traffic challenges. I just want to be clear about that.
Speaker 19 (02:15:52–02:15:54)
The whole town has a traffic.
Speaker 27 (02:15:54–02:15:54)
Yeah.
Speaker 19 (02:15:55–02:18:43)
Well, side street has a traffic problem. Everyone comes up from Rhode Island. Every single street is impacted. So, we all sympathize with traffic when my guys come home at the end of the day, they have to be.
They have to leave their job sites at three o'clock to come up Randolph have or come through the Blue Hills come down 138 every single neighborhood it's just awful. And so one of my frustrations if to Charles to your point about losing the business. It was just really interesting. One of the briefs, the amicus briefs that was submitted was that the HLC didn't do a small business impact analysis.
And as you know, we just, you know, received their small business impact analysis. And what was it? It was like two sheets of paper with checkboxes, no impact, no impact, no impact, no impact. That was the whole impact, small impact business analysis.
And I did speak about it when they had the hearing on the small business impact. I requested that they call me as a small business and as my husband's a small business, and nobody called me. Nobody called my husband. I hate to say, but I just don't think that they care about small businesses.
So we can look for some relief, but I don't have a whole lot of hope that they care, to be honest with you, because this is not about protecting small businesses. It's just a housing, a total housing initiative. And it's just a shame. And just the other thing I forgot to mention when Sean was talking about looking for relief, You know, there's this whole unfunded mandate process that's in play, and we're still waiting to hear from Plymouth Superior Court.
And as you know, five or six different towns are seeking an exemption from the mandate until this mandate is funded. And I would hate to see that we pass zoning Prior to getting that determination because if we pass zoning, and then it is determined and the court allows towns to seek an exemption from the mandate or from the zoning. We were stuck with it and we get no funding. So I'm really, I know, again, we're criticized for wasting town's resources, but I think it would be a really big mistake for us to not take advantage or be patient to hear the results of that court case.
Speaker 2 (02:18:44–02:18:52)
Yeah, the problem is, Maggie, I think that's on the select board to pursue that. And there's a new select board now.
Speaker 19 (02:18:53–02:19:10)
So I'm hoping, just from listening, I'm hoping from listening that they wanna work with other boards and work with the state. So I'm optimistic, it's a new day and I'm optimistic.
Speaker 2 (02:19:11–02:20:02)
Yeah, no, I hear your hope, but I mean, that's just missed opportunity as far as financial concerns. I mean, the amount of money that could be included in this if it is an unfunded mandate is huge. But anyway, getting back to East Milton Square, I mean, if it's this section or East Milton Square, I would much rather do this area. I just don't want to incentivize any more big projects in East Milton Square until that area feels the impact of 440 and of the Falcone project.
And I think here with J.D. Wild's project that we saw last week, and the potential for this area, I think it would be good to incentivize at least the buildings that we have circled, if not more, for redevelopment.
Speaker 5 (02:20:03–02:21:44)
You know, as we talk about, you know, again, I'm going to describe them as workarounds right because it's just where we're kind of where it's like a circular formula on an Excel spreadsheet. That's what it feels like it. We want to give consideration to all the residents, right, and to all parts of town. That's the fairest thing to do for everybody.
And also consider the things that, you know, both Cheryl and Maris were talking about regarding the village. You know, we created an overlay plan there. We'd like to be able to maintain the overlay plan and not put it at risk. But, you know, what the residents want is compliance, right?
I think we all want compliance. But, you know, it's my opinion, we should submit something that gives relief as the residents are requesting relief in all the areas that they're looking for relief. That number won't be a 25%, but see compliance that is responsive, you know, to what the residents concerns are. What's wrong with that?
I know it's not a 25% plan, but how do you ignore everybody's concerns? I'll finish, I promise, I'll finish. How do you ignore the concerns of the folks that are talking about the triplex, Elliott Street, the Randolph Abb discussion that we've had down here in the village, East Milton Square. You can't be responsive to everybody and put something together that is considerate of everybody and still hit a 25% number.
It's not going to happen.
Speaker 20 (02:21:46–02:22:18)
I was just going to comment that we have no indication and we've received no indication has been confirmed by the town administrator that HLC will accept anything but a 25 percent rapid transit compliant plan. I have a concern about passing zoning that is short of that. and we have the zoning on the books and then we still get sued by the state for a lack of compliance come July or August.
Speaker 5 (02:22:19–02:24:14)
And I'm not suggesting that that happens. I'm suggesting we put something together very quickly and we submit it and let HLC comment on it. And if we're not willing to do that, Um, I think we're, we're ignoring, um, at least, uh, uh, an attempt to, uh, find a plan that HLC would consider compliant and also, um, considerate of the residents and all the concerns that we've had. I'm not sure.
Well, I'm not, I'm not in favor of, I'm in favor of passing something at town meeting that will be accepted by HLC. So I, I, uh, but. You can't honor the wishes of everyone and achieve 25%. You just can't.
I'll finish in a moment. yet really wants to consider the negative aspects of this kind of density. I'd love to have people consider if you added 1,500 units, 1,500 more cars in Milton to a town that can't handle the cars that we already have. Nobody wants to talk about the likely capital cost that we will face if we have increases that require us to increase our facilities in town.
All of that is, this idea that the property tax value is going to overcome all of that, I think it's a fallacy. I don't believe it to be true at all. So, you know, how do we create belief and how do we manage the future of Milton? We do it by submitting something that is not as overwhelming as 25%.
And let me finish and ask HLC for consideration for what our issues are.
Speaker 20 (02:24:15–02:24:27)
And then if HLC comes back to us within two weeks and says, we don't accept this, we need a backup 25% plan. We can have that. We keep spinning our wheels on how to get there.
Speaker 5 (02:24:27–02:24:44)
Cheryl, we can have that. Cheryl, I'm not saying not to have one, but I'm saying that I think the responsible thing to do, given all the restrictive nature that we keep talking about over and over and over again, is to ask for something that would be acceptable that allows us some relief.
Speaker 20 (02:24:44–02:26:51)
So, Sean, if I can finish now to a compliant plan, we've heard from many residents and we've heard it for the last 2 years is. take advantage of HLC's guidelines, which allow 50% of the zone capacity to be outside of the Elliott Street corridor. We have opportunities. Members of this board have rejected certain locations for their own reasons.
We have not taken those options out to the public short of one forum and I have suggested we needed a public engagement plan for a year. We haven't done it. And I feel like this has been a real. flawed process as a result of that, because we are five people that continue to talk about these different locations and not getting feedback until the last hour from the public.
And I take that criticism that they have all stated tonight and other times to heart. And so how are we going to have a compliant plan? You said we're going to have one. How are we going to have it?
It's April 30th. We have July 13th. We have town meeting June 16th. And we're still talking about various alternatives tonight.
And we're not even agreeing that we should do an expansion of districts that spreads the zone capacity about. And so we have looked at other districts. We looked at St. Pius.
We looked at 333 Brush Hill Road. We looked at 1200 Brush Hill Road. you know, maybe one of those districts has to come back and that's the way that we get the more equitable distribution across the town. But we need to make that decision rather than talking about whether the HLC is going to agree to something.
We've got a 10% option, which Zoe mentioned at the outset of this discussion, that So if that's what you want to submit, we still need to decide on what this is going to look like. And when are we going to do it?
Speaker 5 (02:26:51–02:27:32)
Cheryl, I'm not saying that we shouldn't continue to try to figure out a 25% plan. What I am saying is we should submit a 10% plan or a 10% plus plan if there's other components we can add to the 10% that might work for Milton. But we can't stop working on 25%. But this idea of making it equitable Everyone knows that the original intention of this was to be within a half mile of transit, either side.
And this idea of moving it around Milton is only because the trolley is on the Boston-Milton border.
Speaker 20 (02:27:32–02:27:52)
We talked about the Fairmont line. There's three stations that are within a half a mile. Blue Hill Ave is one. We already have a district on Blue Hills Parkway.
St. Pius is near Reedville. It's just outside of the half mile. And the area we talked about for Fairmont is within a half mile.
Those should be included.
Speaker 5 (02:27:53–02:29:05)
Yeah, well, a resident asked in an email to all of us why the planning board was opposed to St. Pius. And that particular resident asked me specifically to explain why I am opposed to St. Pius.
And I'll answer the question for the resident and for anybody that's interested in hearing. I am opposed to zoning any religious, um, uh, or religious oriented, uh, property, because I find no matter what the, um, no matter what the, uh, nature of the religious property is, I find that to be something that is a component within our community that I'd like to maintain. And if we zone over St. Pius, I think it's a much greater likelihood that the archdiocese might consider selling St.
Pius, which might be great for for zoning and building housing, but I don't know that it's great for people that love St. Pius and enjoy having St. Pius as the church that they go to. And I feel that way for every religious institution, no matter what religion it is.
Speaker 20 (02:29:06–02:29:30)
So there's three churches in the Blue Hills Parkway subdistrict. I've mentioned that several times. And I don't believe the Catholic Church is going to make a decision about closing St. Pius based on whether multifamily zoning is put in place on a piece of property.
They're gonna have other reasons to make decisions about whether they close the church and sell property. And so- They're actively doing it right now.
Speaker 5 (02:29:31–02:29:34)
They're actively assessing churches to close.
Speaker 20 (02:29:35–02:29:39)
Exactly, but they're not basing it on whether there's underlying zoning is what the underlying zoning is.
Speaker 5 (02:29:40–02:29:43)
Do you not think they would consider that?
Speaker 20 (02:29:43–02:29:45)
Not a decision about closing it, no.
Speaker 5 (02:29:45–02:29:47)
It increases the value of the property.
Speaker 20 (02:29:48–02:29:56)
So somebody could buy that property and do a 40B, right? Correct. What's going to be the next use that's likely to go on that property if it sells?
Speaker 5 (02:29:58–02:29:59)
I don't know, Cheryl. I don't know.
Speaker 20 (02:29:59–02:30:06)
It's not going to be a single family house. Not as long as we're in a deficit on our subsidized housing inventory.
Speaker 1 (02:30:07–02:31:48)
OK. So I did want to point out one thing, because Zoe touched on the Milton Academy site. Nick Milano did reach out to Milton Academy, and they do intend to maintain that confirmed for their institutional use. So that would not be permitted as a site to use, just for future.
And I did want to just some of the emails mentioned that there was nothing that everything was being removed in our 2023 plan from East Milton Square. I just want to remind people that there are 200 units that the granite of the granite. to Granite, which is the Granite Ave North site, is still included, 200 units there, and that we are no longer allowed to utilize or zone on the Granite Ave South site. So just wanted to add that.
for those who didn't know that, that since the DOT is not actively looking to dispense of that property, that was the reason for that. So I would be open to, at this point, open to finding out if HLC would consider allowing a mixed use commercial in East Milton Square. for, you know, if that is the case to do something with a, you know, a less desirable incentive than what our overlay zoning would be. But it would have to be much less desirable because we want to encourage that overlay zoning to be utilized.
Speaker 20 (02:31:48–02:32:00)
So, Meredith, are you supporting the idea of asking for HLC to allow more mandatory mixtures than the 25% that they allow that we're utilizing?
Speaker 1 (02:32:01–02:32:27)
Yes. And I would be open if the rest of the board feels like they want to look at these Adams Street parcels, what that would get for us. And I'm assuming that we would be able to maintain the business on the first floor in these as well. But if that extends outside, because if it's more than 25%, I would not recommend these sites.
Speaker 20 (02:32:28–02:32:42)
And then I want to bring up one of the speakers mentioned Central Ave. Brian Furze, former plan board member, had sent us a suggested map that looked at extending a district down Central Ave.
Speaker 1 (02:32:43–02:32:48)
And I wanted to pull that up, but I didn't know. I wanted Zoe to finish, and then we could maybe do that.
Speaker 20 (02:32:49–02:32:54)
Could we? But I'd like for Zoe to take a look at that with us as well.
Speaker 1 (02:32:55–02:32:56)
Yes, I agree.
Speaker 20 (02:32:56–02:32:57)
I agree.
Speaker 1 (02:32:59–02:33:10)
If this is a good place to look at that, that would be fine. I sent it to everybody again, just so they could take a look. It's going to be Cheyenne to pull that up.
Speaker 23 (02:33:10–02:33:37)
We're kind of at the conclusion of our presentation. The only thing that we had left was, and I'll sort of go to that now. I'll mention one thing about the MMU, and then I'll go to the last slide that is just kind of codifying our next steps, like decisions we should try and make tonight. I haven't pinned down the exact number, but right now in our, I'll go back to see if I can get to the right one here.
Speaker 22 (02:33:37–02:33:46)
So for this, I'll clear my annotations here.
Speaker 23 (02:33:47–02:35:15)
So if we look at this example here, you can see here that when you're talking about mandatory mixed-use districts, it's a little bit convoluted how it gets enforced. But essentially, the simplest way I can say it is that 75% of your compliance target, your unit compliance target, needs to come from 3A alone, 3A districts alone. That means anything in excess of that 75% can come from mandatory mixed use districts. So right now, you're hitting 80%.
So there is, it's not enough for like all of East Milton Square. It's not enough for like, it may not be enough for the couple parcels, but you do still have some margin to increase the zone capacity in your mandatory mixed use districts by adding area or changing parameters. I can get you like what that exact number is, but I did just want to mention that before we completely move on. But there's a little bit of margin there.
And I think we can certainly share the the question back to you, HLC, to say, like, these are all the issues we've been encountering in Milton. This is why it's so difficult. Is there any relief you can provide to sort of allow more to come from mandatory mixed use and give them some some reasons? So I'm happy to do that, which kind of brings us to…
Wait, before you leave that screen, sorry, going back to the paper mill.
Speaker 19 (02:35:17–02:36:08)
So if you look at six stories and the unit capacity is 156 and the open space is 40%. So and if you look up at Granite Ave North, the unit capacity is 194. So why don't we increase the unit capacity of the paper mill site To equal what granted out north is possibly even exceed it. And again, I like open space.
But in this location, would we ever consider reducing the minimum open space here? Because it is along the tracks, it's along the Hyde Park border. It's a separate entity. So I don't know if that is something we would want to consider.
Speaker 1 (02:36:12–02:36:13)
I would if it's possible.
Speaker 2 (02:36:15–02:36:18)
Yeah, because that site is by open space. I would too.
Speaker 20 (02:36:18–02:36:44)
I mean, you could apply that to Granite Ave North as well. Because it's got the park across the street. It's got the Neponset trail. The same, I mean, that's the logic.
If you drop them both to 30%, I mean, I just wanted to clear the compliance model. puts this at 20%, right? Which 20% is really well usable open space.
Speaker 23 (02:36:44–02:37:07)
So the compliance model, by default, sort of assumes 20% open space. But we have, in all cases, explicitly put in a parameter that escalates that to the numbers that you're seeing here. So when we run the compliance model for these, it is reflecting an expectation that this percentage is being set aside. But you're right, Cheryl, that as a baseline, it assumes 20%.
Speaker 20 (02:37:07–02:37:41)
And I guess if you apply the same let's say if you have a logic Maggie where. If you're looking at the LA Street Corridor, the open space is tied to a particular development there. You have to get further away to find a playground or a park or something like that, whereas these have open space. That's why they're unique sites, is they have the open space around them.
It does seem like the usable open space, if you change at the paper mill, you would change it at Granite Ave North for the same reasons.
Speaker 19 (02:37:43–02:38:01)
And I know we can't dictate trees, but more trees will help reduce like the heat island effects. So, you know, landscaping is vitally important when you have less open space, you just don't want a lawn. You actually want trees and native plants, other things.
Speaker 1 (02:38:04–02:38:11)
So I guess we could look at the unit capacity that Granite Ave North could get if we reduce that to 30% would be.
Speaker 23 (02:38:12–02:38:30)
Dina Nugent, PB – she-her, HIP, she-hers is everyone comfortable with that we make a change, maybe to both Granite Ave and Paper Mill to reflect that 30% expectation based on both of them being proximate to larger open space and see what what benefit we get from that in terms of unit capacity.
Speaker 19 (02:38:31–02:38:48)
Yeah, and back to the paper mill site that site isn't that that set below grade. And again, should we, I know everyone likes consistency, but is that a site that could actually handle another floor or two?
Speaker 23 (02:38:50–02:39:23)
I think the biggest constraint there is really the access. I think that's probably the viability concern. I think if we go really far in excess of what realistically the site access can handle, it's essentially a one lane access into the site. that might invite increased scrutiny about the viability of the site as a whole, but I think it's certainly a unique site and it will require creative problem solving no matter what.
Speaker 19 (02:39:24–02:39:32)
I would think the viability though would increase with the more units that are there that would benefit anybody who's coming in to develop it.
Speaker 23 (02:39:33–02:39:48)
Yeah, I think you're absolutely right. And there's kind of like Matthew may be able to speak to this better than I can, but there's probably a tipping point where it's sort of like up until that, you know, there's like a certain number of units that's maybe just infeasible in a general sense.
Speaker 19 (02:39:48–02:39:55)
But we're not saying that they have to do it. We're just giving them the opportunity to do it.
Speaker 1 (02:39:55–02:40:04)
I do feel like we don't have anything larger than six stories in Milton, and I just don't want to set that precedent for other developers.
Speaker 20 (02:40:04–02:40:37)
I'm just going to add as an architect, once you get to high-rise, which seven stories would put you at, put you in a totally different construction type and a cost structure. And typically, just that one story is not going to be enough to warrant that additional cost. So they usually go higher than seven. I mean, it's possible to to do things without some of that, but six stories tends to be a reason why that's the cap in a lot of places.
Speaker 1 (02:40:38–02:40:48)
So I think six stories for Granite Ave North and Paper Mill site, but with a 30% open space requirement, maybe we could take a look at and see what that produces.
Speaker 22 (02:40:52–02:41:00)
That's good. So I will, I'll jump us to the end. So I'm going to kind of blow through these slides again to get to our last slide.
Speaker 23 (02:41:04–02:42:17)
I just had for reference the adjacent community plan slides. These are unchanged from last time, but I wanted to have them here to just confirm, and we can come back to this, that this is, if there's any revisions that are still needed to this. So I'm going to jump to this last slide, which basically just summarizes the decisions that I'm hoping we can get to tonight. I recognize there's a lot of new ideas that were shared today or kind of returning to ideas that we've explored previously to sort of see what they can do given the feedback that you've received.
But I think what we have essentially from now until the 8th to conduct some level of additional revision for you all and also some level of coordination with the state. And then as we move to the 16th, which is when we're trying to get that warrant finalized, we also need to have the zoning itself drafted. So these are kind of the decisions that are required in order to, um, address the state coordination issue, make sure we're getting revisions back to you, um, in time for you to see and discuss them again and make sure that you have zoning this drafted, um, in time for, for town meeting deadline.
Speaker 5 (02:42:17–02:42:40)
Zoe, could you go back one slide just for a moment? Uh, we moved so quickly past that. I just want to, yep. So, um, The changes we just talked about for Granite Ave North and the paper mill site.
I think we should apply it to this as well. Would everybody agree?
Speaker 1 (02:42:42–02:42:57)
And Cheyenne, did Zoe get the message about doing just the few slides just to show the community what an adjacent community plan would look like versus what the 25% plan looks like?
Speaker 3 (02:42:58–02:43:00)
That was your email the other day, right?
Speaker 1 (02:43:01–02:43:02)
Right, yeah.
Speaker 3 (02:43:02–02:43:16)
Yeah, we talked about it a little bit this morning. You I'm sorry. We had talked about the email that you sent a little bit this morning quickly in our meeting, but those slides didn't get made.
Speaker 23 (02:43:18–02:43:36)
Were you sorry, I'm I'm. Been a long day, but refresh my so so we have this map, which is not a perfect map of it, right? But it's it's essentially you know these are the districts that are considered here and that were you looking for just like a town wide map that shows it with the outlying districts?
Speaker 1 (02:43:36–02:44:03)
Correct. Just a fresh, new, clean map. Because rather than what the circle is saying, remove, remove, remove, it would just be what actually we would be mapping out, including the reduction. Because I think it's really important for Elliott Street Corridor to also see a clean map with that reduction.
It was a very specific email with six things that I had requested just to be able to demonstrate for tonight.
Speaker 5 (02:44:03–02:44:11)
I agree that's an important document to have. Could you flip back to that previous model?
Speaker 23 (02:44:11–02:44:12)
The table?
Speaker 5 (02:44:12–02:44:48)
Yeah, the table, thanks. This actually provides the relief that the Elliott Street folks are asking for. Um, you know, we're down to three as a maximum, you know, per lot. And, uh, this substantially creates relief over there for, for those that, that are interested in that substantially.
And, and if we can increase, uh, what we could accomplish at Granite Ave North and, um, the paper mill, um, you know, we, you know, that'd be okay. We should strive to improve this if we can.
Speaker 20 (02:44:48–02:44:56)
So we should then up 711 Randolph Ave above 97 then, because 90 is what the approved 40B is.
Speaker 5 (02:44:56–02:45:10)
Well, let me say this, Cheryl. I think Granite Ave North and the paper mill site is less impactful to any of the neighbors. And for that reason, I think increase those as much as we can.
Speaker 20 (02:45:14–02:45:50)
I think we're going to get If we do these changes, then we delay when something's sent to HLC and we can get a response. If we send this for review, as a 10% plan, send it tomorrow, at least we get some feedback on it. And these things, the modifications wouldn't significantly change it. We don't have another meeting until Monday.
630, which is just an hour before town meeting. So I'm just concerned how much further out this gets.
Speaker 23 (02:45:51–02:46:56)
before we get feedback. I think it's important that this week we're able to share. If we want state input, we need to share it this week because they have been very accommodating in making time to meet with us. But you have to recognize that they're working with many communities and it does require a level of depth for them to review and be able to give us feedback that is directional in terms of what they will and will not accept.
So we need to give them some time to review. So I think we can accommodate some of these, like, especially if it's just like changing parameters in different districts, that's absolutely something we can do quickly and get it out to EOHLC. If it's like drawing new districts, looking at different permutations and combinations, that's something that's not really feasible in the time that we have. For the adjacent like let's say, just for now focusing on the adjacent community right this one's close from the conversations we've had so far if it's just a matter of changing parameters I think we can get that done and get it over to you at Chelsea.
Speaker 5 (02:46:57–02:47:12)
This week, I think, so if that's the case I think it demonstrates, you know, it demonstrates a stronger effort. If you can modify Granite Ave and the paper mill site and still submit it this week, I think we should do that, right? You're saying that you could make those changes. Am I right, Sophie?
Speaker 23 (02:47:12–02:47:27)
Yeah. I think that's realistic for the adjacent community. I think basically where I'm drawing the line is if we're looking at multiple new combinations of districts, drawing those, populating those, that's something that's not really attainable for us to get through this week and get out to UHLC.
Speaker 5 (02:47:28–02:47:29)
And I wasn't talking about that.
Speaker 23 (02:47:29–02:47:36)
I mean, this is this is doable. The changes you just talked about, that's very doable. We can get that done this week, get it out to the state.
Speaker 20 (02:47:36–02:47:37)
Okay.
Speaker 23 (02:47:37–02:47:37)
All right.
Speaker 20 (02:47:37–02:48:01)
So then I would like to have some agreement on what they're going to look at, and then I'd like to understand how soon they can look at it. So we just talked about changing the paper mill in Granite Ave to reduce the open space. We talked about adding some zone capacity and some boundary at Randolph Ave. Should we go back and talk about that and make sure that we're in agreement on those?
Speaker 19 (02:48:01–02:48:04)
Yeah, but I don't know if that applies to this.
Speaker 20 (02:48:05–02:48:19)
No, it's not this one. I think what I'm suggesting, Maggie, is that we just all agree to what we're going to do with this, right? They're going to make those changes for Granite Ave North. and the paper mill, and then they're gonna send it to HLC.
Speaker 19 (02:48:20–02:48:36)
I mean, they can, right, so that's. Do we need to sort of take a little informal vote? So that's, so from a process standpoint, we agree to that, and then it's gonna get submitted by the end of this week. So we're correct, are we all in agreement to that?
Speaker 1 (02:48:37–02:48:53)
Yes, but there needs to be changes to the slides that I had emailed Cheyenne just to make it a map. We need the map. We need it to be clear. And I'm a little disappointed that Cheyenne, what is the status of that?
Was that not conveyed?
Speaker 3 (02:48:53–02:49:08)
No, we did. We did talk about it this morning, but when Nick and I discussed your email the other day, we were waiting on some other things like to meet with Util and sit down and talk about the stuff that you had sent over. I believe it was only.
Speaker 1 (02:49:08–02:49:13)
Yeah, it's basically what Util has done. It just is correcting things that are.
Speaker 20 (02:49:14–02:49:32)
So I guess what I would suggest then is that the board authorize Meredith to review the final map and summary with Cheyenne and Zoe before it's submitted at the end of the week.
Speaker 5 (02:49:33–02:49:35)
I agree. I agree. I support that.
Speaker 19 (02:49:36–02:49:38)
Yeah, I'm good with that.
Speaker 2 (02:49:38–02:49:45)
Okay. Can I just ask a quick question? So Zoe, how does this get submitted? Do you just email it to sort of a contact you have over there or?
Speaker 23 (02:49:45–02:50:20)
So there's a formal submission and review process that is the state's preferred method of reviewing all of this that requires having zoning written. We will not have zoning written. So we will be submitting it through a more informal channel by a direct email to their staff and request special consideration for them to review it even though it is incomplete. And they have generally been very responsive to those requests thus far.
So I'm optimistic that they will review it and give it the same care that they've given the other reviews that they've done more informally for us in the intervening time.
Speaker 20 (02:50:20–02:50:38)
So I would like to also ask that if there's agreement that we ask them to consider an increase in the mandatory mixed-use units that we're allowed to do in Philadelphia-Snowden Square. It would be good to get that feedback as well.
Speaker 2 (02:50:43–02:50:44)
Go ahead.
Speaker 1 (02:50:44–02:51:01)
I just was going to say, and just inquire about the ice house property on Blue Hills Parkway and the 40 B project in East Milton Square. If there would be any consideration for this plan is it not for this plan just
Speaker 23 (02:51:02–02:51:46)
Yeah, so that would be for the rapid. These are like, I think there's the, we just discussed the two parameter changes to Granite Ave and Paper Mill to the 30% open space and any associated in unit increases with that as well as updating to show a single unified map. Those two things would be submitted as a way of conveying what the adjacent community plan would be. And then separately, we'd have a couple of questions or sort of requests of UHLC related to the rapid transit 25% plan to hopefully help resolve remaining questions that are preventing us from getting to resolution on that.
Speaker 2 (02:51:48–02:51:59)
So when you submit this, Zoe, the person you're submitting it to, do they have the capacity or the authority to say, okay, I'll accept a 10% plan as opposed to 25? How's that gonna work?
Speaker 23 (02:51:59–02:52:33)
They wouldn't at the staff level, they would have to run it up their chain of command to, that's a level, there's a certain level of review that they can give us a direct answer that's within their authority. Things like this that would require exceptions from the regulations are things that they would have to move through their chain of command to get, be able to get us clarity. So that's why the time it's time sensitive, right? Cause you have to think about, they're going to have to have multiple conversations internally to be able to resolve that because we're asking for a special consideration beyond the regulations that they've been empowered to enforce.
Speaker 5 (02:52:35–02:52:46)
Okay. All right. To answer your question, I, we will get an answer. and it won't be one tier within EOHLC, it'll be several tiers that'll be looking at it.
Speaker 23 (02:52:48–02:52:52)
Yeah, I suspect these requests may have to go all the way up to the top of their chain of command.
Speaker 5 (02:52:52–02:53:12)
It may. The meeting that has been talked about, which I was present for, they wanted us to submit something that we could achieve. And this is likely achievable and recognizes the considerations that all of the neighbors are asking for. So we should submit it.
Speaker 2 (02:53:14–02:53:16)
Agreed. Agreed. Just wondering. Okay, that's good.
Speaker 23 (02:53:16–02:53:29)
Are there any questions other than the MMU increase and the Ice House and East Milton Square 40B sites that you would like us to pass along to them for consideration?
Speaker 20 (02:53:31–02:53:43)
That's it. I would like to have you continue to work on a 25% compliant plan so that if the 10% is not acceptable, that we have it ready.
Speaker 25 (02:53:46–02:53:46)
Yeah.
Speaker 20 (02:53:46–02:54:10)
So we talked about the next steps for that being paper mill and Granite Ave having 30% open space. We talked about Randolph Ave having increased zone capacity plus increased land area, but not at the same density. That's right, but yeah.
Speaker 23 (02:54:10–02:54:31)
And then can you just just to pause on that for a second? I think Maggie, you made a good point of wanting to have a rule set that distinguishes between the smaller parcels that are facing Randolph and the others. Do you have a rule set in mind that you think would be a good match for those parcels that are fronting Randolph?
Speaker 19 (02:54:32–02:54:43)
No, unfortunately I didn't have time to do a complete rule set. My basic thing was just three units.
Speaker 23 (02:54:43–02:55:00)
Yeah, that's plenty. That's enough. We can figure out what the parcel size threshold is to distinguish between the larger lot ones and the ones that fall below that threshold in front, Randolph, so that those are having a three unit
Speaker 20 (02:55:02–02:55:30)
So Zoe, I'd also like for you to have another conversation with Nick Milano or Cheyenne about that parcel that's landlocked in the back. So that if that's possible to add that. Even if it means that the only way it can be used if there's some common ownership in the future.
Speaker 19 (02:55:32–02:56:02)
Sorry, and I know you don't want to look at new. You don't want to look at new parcels, but with. The, the same pious church being up for discussion. And we possibly not wanting to zone any religious institution at this point.
In front of St. Pius is a development called Woodmere, and it's all one level. Would we ever consider zoning that to allow for another level?
Speaker 2 (02:56:06–02:56:14)
Yeah, I drove through there and I thought that had some potential. What's the Anchorage? Oh, man, I had it written down somewhere.
Speaker 20 (02:56:14–02:56:40)
I don't know. You know that St. Pius has a vacant parcel that is not being used at all, which is next to Woodmere. So I don't know what the acreage of that separate parcel is, if you didn't want to include the church with its parking area.
And Woodmere is where there used to be owned by the church, you know, that was sold. So it's not unreasonable to think that they would sell the vacant parcel in between.
Speaker 5 (02:56:40–02:56:46)
So Cheryl, as you look at the church, it's to the right of the paved surface.
Speaker 20 (02:56:46–02:56:52)
Yes, so Zoe, I don't know if you have the map from before when we look at this. Yeah, let me see if I can pull it in.
Speaker 1 (02:56:53–02:57:06)
And I do believe that Woodmere is 12 acres from what I recall, but I would be concerned that that, even if it's another story, it would drag our density down because of the number of units there.
Speaker 2 (02:57:09–02:57:11)
What's the address?
Speaker 1 (02:57:12–02:57:15)
Unless we upped the zoning, yes.
Speaker 2 (02:57:15–02:57:15)
We zoned it.
Speaker 1 (02:57:20–02:57:21)
That would be an option.
Speaker 19 (02:57:37–02:57:42)
Woodmere currently has 36 units, but I'm not sure of the acreage.
Speaker 1 (02:57:46–02:57:47)
Let's take a look at that.
Speaker 23 (02:57:49–02:58:03)
This is the St. Pius site, and apologies, this doesn't have the parcel boundaries on it or surrounding it, so it's a little hard to use for the purpose I think you're probably imagining it for.
Speaker 20 (02:58:05–02:58:09)
Yeah, unfortunately, it seems to be all one parcel and not two.
Speaker 2 (02:58:12–02:58:19)
And if it's all one parcel, don't they hit us hard with a spot zoning restriction? Bring up a red flag.
Speaker 23 (02:58:20–02:58:56)
Yeah, I think that's just like generally there's I think the way that they tried to prevent that in the way the regulations are drafted is through the five acre minimum. And then beyond that there's like, you know, just generally there's you know anytime you zone a single parcel. It invites a legal challenge. And so, you look for ways that you can.
reinforce a planning rationale that goes beyond ownership or land use to articulate a reason why that parcel is zoned on its own rather than being part of a larger district.
Speaker 20 (02:58:57–02:59:22)
I'm looking at the town's GIS mapping and it shows the parcel adjacent to the church property being owned by work housing corporations. Does anybody know what that's used for? It would be right here. It looks like there's a parking lot there, so I'm not sure that that's a residential use.
Speaker 26 (02:59:27–02:59:31)
I guess it's zoned residential, but I don't know if the use is residential.
Speaker 23 (02:59:32–02:59:38)
It's not uncommon for residential districts to allow for institutional uses and other. Right.
Speaker 20 (02:59:39–02:59:45)
So what I'm suggesting is if that could possibly be included if it's spot zoning with a question.
Speaker 26 (02:59:47–02:59:52)
It would be this parcel here. It's kind of a narrowish parcel like that.
Speaker 20 (02:59:53–03:00:01)
And its acreage is 1.11 acres.
Speaker 23 (03:00:04–03:00:10)
Is it kind of right here? Is that what you're talking about?
Speaker 20 (03:00:10–03:00:13)
Yes, right here. It's like this shape in here.
Speaker 5 (03:00:14–03:00:16)
Your mouse is not showing on our screenshot.
Speaker 20 (03:00:16–03:00:27)
Oh, I'm sorry. So if you can draw a line at the edge of that long driveway next to the building. And it's like in here.
Speaker 23 (03:00:27–03:00:28)
There's like a small parcel that's right there.
Speaker 20 (03:00:28–03:00:43)
Yeah, there's a small parcel right there, yeah. But then it's the one that's to the right of that here. Exactly all the way back right.
Speaker 2 (03:00:43–03:00:49)
So you're saying assemble that with the vacant lot but not the church or the parking lot to create a parcel?
Speaker 20 (03:00:50–03:00:59)
Yes except that the the church is not a two parcel so I think you would have to include the whole parcel but
Speaker 2 (03:00:59–03:01:01)
No, that was the issue. Yeah, that was.
Speaker 23 (03:01:01–03:01:10)
Yeah, that's in both your in your parcel data as in the town's GIS, as well as the parcel data we have from the state. This is shown as a single parcel.
Speaker 20 (03:01:13–03:01:15)
But the church could subdivide it.
Speaker 23 (03:01:16–03:01:19)
Yeah, but for the purposes of the zoning, it would need to be.
Speaker 20 (03:01:19–03:01:21)
It would have to be across.
Speaker 26 (03:01:26–03:01:28)
And that's 6.2 acres, right?
Speaker 23 (03:01:31–03:01:34)
the combination of those. 8.5.
Speaker 2 (03:01:35–03:01:36)
St. Pius and Woodmere.
Speaker 23 (03:01:50–03:02:10)
So there's, we discussed Woodmere. I don't think we caught to a conclusion on that. And then St. Pius, in combination with these two parcels?
Is there, can we have a broader indication from the board as to whether those are things that you want us to pursue?
Speaker 19 (03:02:10–03:02:27)
Yeah, so I think Woodmere is like nine acres, Meredith. 9.3, 9.34. It says it's 373,745 square feet.
Speaker 5 (03:02:30–03:02:39)
So, Zoe, can you, on the screen, can you just show us where the Woodmere parcel is? Can you draw us a line?
Speaker 23 (03:02:40–03:02:44)
It's between Cushing and Dana. Is it? Yeah. Okay.
It's this one. Okay.
Speaker 5 (03:02:45–03:02:49)
Oh, okay. I see it now. Okay. Yeah.
I'm sorry. I didn't know.
Speaker 22 (03:02:49–03:02:55)
I can pull this over in a second so people can see it. One sec.
Speaker 20 (03:02:58–03:03:16)
That's condominium, right? Yeah. For that to be redeveloped, it would require the condominium owners all to agree, which is the same thing we talked about at 131 Elliott. Excuse me.
That's it.
Speaker 26 (03:03:17–03:03:22)
This is the wood mirror. It's fairly new. We could look at that.
Speaker 5 (03:03:23–03:03:25)
That's seven acres? Is that what it was?
Speaker 26 (03:03:25–03:03:31)
Nine. Nine. Nine and a half. But it is a single parcel, right?
Speaker 23 (03:03:32–03:04:04)
It is, yeah. So it would carry the same, you know, I think for all of the single parcel districts we have looked at, they will all have the same question. We will, I think, need to think through what criteria makes it valid to single out that parcel. relative to the parcels that abuts as a district unto itself from a bigger picture planning logic and not just from an ownership or use perspective.
Speaker 2 (03:04:07–03:04:21)
Well, across the street is all Curry College. So I guess the only opportunity would be this houses to the north and south, right? So you're saying justify not including those houses to the EOHLC.
Speaker 23 (03:04:21–03:04:43)
Right, exactly. So if you think about, I think there's a very clear reason why it's not the same as an institutional use across the street. But why is it inherently different from the parcels that are on either side of it that are residential? That's basically the big picture legal argument that needs to be made anytime you're zoning a single parcel.
Speaker 2 (03:04:49–03:04:51)
Have you made that argument before, I hope?
Speaker 23 (03:04:53–03:05:57)
We have, we generally advise to avoid it wherever possible and in most of our, I'm trying to think back to all of our other other MBTA communities zoning efforts and I think in, in all of them we've been able to um, avoid single parcel zoning. Um, as we've talked about, Milton has a lot of characteristics that have driven us to consider more single parcels. Um, it's part of the fabric of your, you know, the parcel, the way parcels are divided up in your community. Um, so it's not surprising that we've encountered this issue multiple times, but it is not one that we have carried through, um, in many other cases, other than like the Granite Ave and Paper Mill are cases where there's an obvious argument for why these are standalone parcels, right?
There's a clear infrastructural logic for why it's inappropriate to combine those with other parcels and treat them as the same. So that's easier.
Speaker 20 (03:05:58–03:06:10)
Sorry. Good. Just thinking about the churches on Blue Hills Parkway, what's the zone density allowed for those churches?
Speaker 23 (03:06:12–03:06:21)
They're all at 30 units per acre per the rule set for the Blue Hills Parkway corridor as a whole.
Speaker 20 (03:06:24–03:06:47)
How many acres was St. Pius again? Six point something? 6.11, I think I said.
If you did, or six point something and the lot next door at 1.11, If you combine those two, you would be at, what was it? Seven point, Jim, you had it at eight?
Speaker 2 (03:06:48–03:06:49)
No, that was one year.
Speaker 20 (03:06:50–03:06:51)
Okay, sorry.
Speaker 23 (03:06:52–03:06:59)
I'm just going back to some of our prior slide decks. We had seen Pius at 6.3 acres in our prior analysis.
Speaker 20 (03:06:59–03:07:28)
If we had 6.3 and we did the parcel next door for not doing spot zoning, we'd be at 7.4. And if we use the same 30 units an acre that we're using at the other churches, that would get us 222 upzone capacity.
Speaker 2 (03:07:31–03:07:36)
I bet you if the Catholic Church sees that, they'll sell it. That's a lot of units.
Speaker 20 (03:07:37–03:07:54)
So, If this were dropped to 15 units an acre, you'd be at 111, right? How many units is Woodmere?
Speaker 2 (03:07:54–03:07:57)
30 something, 38.
Speaker 20 (03:07:57–03:07:58)
38?
Speaker 19 (03:07:58–03:08:00)
No, Woodmere is 36.
Speaker 20 (03:08:00–03:08:04)
36. On how many acres?
Speaker 19 (03:08:05–03:08:05)
Nine.
Speaker 2 (03:08:09–03:08:11)
That's nine acres. That seems small for nine.
Speaker 19 (03:08:11–03:08:16)
I think that's according to their permit. Yeah.
Speaker 23 (03:08:17–03:08:42)
So that would be a very low. I think that would carry the same issue we ran into with the brush site where it's so that's at like a 3.8, 3.9 units per acre. If we were to zone it for what it is today, right, if we were to zone it for 36 units, even if you were to double that, you would be at, you know, still under 10 units per acre.
Speaker 20 (03:08:42–03:08:51)
So, Zoe, do you think we would have to do, if we did St. Pius, we would have to do it at 15 units an acre to make it contribute and not cause other troubles?
Speaker 23 (03:08:52–03:09:34)
Yeah, I would, I would recommend at this point, I mean, Elliott Street corridor itself as a whole, is one of the lower density district so if part of our goal is to replace Elliott Street corridor area, you know it's okay if it's sort of in that like 10 11 units per acre, maybe. But it's like, that's like on the edge and it will, it'll be very sensitive to like the acreage of each thing, because it's a weighted average essentially across all the districts so it, that's not a guarantee but I think. 15 is safer, you might be able to bring it like into the low teens, but I wouldn't bring in new districts that are below 10.
Speaker 20 (03:09:34–03:10:11)
Right. So if you did 11 units, that would be 81. You're looking at a range of 81 to 111. 111 at 15 units and 81 at 11 units.
So. Maybe I'd suggest that we put back in the St. Pius with the adjacent parcel at the 11 units an acre, which would be 81 units.
Speaker 19 (03:10:12–03:10:14)
That seems a lot there.
Speaker 1 (03:10:17–03:10:30)
Yeah, I feel like that's just Because everything else is just single family. Can we go back to that map? Yeah.
Speaker 2 (03:10:30–03:10:33)
It's just impacting another area.
Speaker 20 (03:10:33–03:11:09)
But that's the idea, Jim. The idea that we've heard from so many people is to have some districts spread out in different places. I know some people don't like the idea, but the residents who are most impacted prefer that approach. They want to see some of this spread into different areas.
This is also not too far outside of the half mile. We heard about the walkability, but when we're looking at what the statute says, You know, this is one that's not too far outside the half mile, so.
Speaker 5 (03:11:09–03:11:16)
Well, if we could achieve acceptance of the adjacent community, we wouldn't have to do unusual things like this.
Speaker 20 (03:11:17–03:11:24)
Right. No, I understood. Understood, Sean. But this is trying to get at, if they don't accept it, we have to have an alternative plan, right?
Speaker 5 (03:11:25–03:11:27)
A number of alternatives to create another plan.
Speaker 2 (03:11:29–03:11:57)
So if we're talking about going into this area and starting something new, and I know you're going to kill me, but I still keep looking at the existing 40 Bs. And just like you talked about East Milton Square, and I know this board doesn't want to look at 648 Canton Ave. I'd much rather see something there where the impact is already being felt than to go here or to go to Fairmount.
Speaker 20 (03:11:58–03:12:58)
You know, Jim, I am going to have to, you know, excuse myself again if we're going to talk about can't now, but what I will want to come back to just on this is there were there were those of you on the board here who were. saying we should do a statute compliant plan. The statute compliant plan was looking at these commuter rail stations, and it would have had a district in this area, and a district at Fairmont, and a district at Blue Hill Ave. And we pulled away from that because we didn't like the idea of 15 units an acre just as a calculation, a math solution.
And so we're all back to now looking at what exists in the vicinity of these places. If Woodmere is OK here, except for it's the challenge of the density, what's the problem with this location of the same price? And we even had a resident who lives near here say, why did you remove it?
Speaker 19 (03:12:59–03:13:35)
Just as a reminder, because I'm a huge proponent of a statute plan, to accurately reflect the statute, it says a district of reasonable size. It does not actually put a square footage size on it. We have a statute compliant plan by just at the Mattapan station. So we don't really need to expand a statute compliant plan to impact more neighborhoods unnecessarily.
Speaker 20 (03:13:36–03:13:40)
I have a large concern. Sorry, go ahead, Jim.
Speaker 2 (03:13:40–03:13:56)
The difference between this and Woodmere is Woodmere is already built. There's already an impact there. And to Sean's point, this is a church. And if we start making it a very, very valuable piece of property, when the Catholic Church re-evaluates, they probably will sell it.
Speaker 20 (03:13:56–03:15:34)
When the Catholic Church sells it, they're going to look for the. the highest value that they can get. And I'm going to tell you that the highest value is not going to be single family residential. I think it will be a 40B.
I think we're better off zoning for it so that we are at a level that somebody would see it as an alternative to a 40B. Everybody talks about the 40Bs, you know, and we have them in part because we don't have our 10% affordability because we've not zoned to allow multifamily and included inclusionary zoning. And therefore, the only way we're getting affordable units is through the 40B process, except for the handful that come through some other projects, which is a drop in the bucket. We all said before that we'd like to see more than 10% affordable units come out of this MBTA community zoning.
In fact, we want to jump it up to 15. And we also said at a recent meeting that we're not going to get many units if we have a lot of these where it's just three units allowed or four units allowed or small projects allowed. In a zone where we can zone for 80, we're going to get at 15 percent, we're going to start to get some affordable units in a way that's more controlled by us, then if it's a 40 B and we're getting 25% of them affordable we're going to have to have a lot more of them in order to get that 40 B, we probably it's it's, I mean it'll contribute to discussion for all about planning with means but we probably should go back and reassess where we're at.
Speaker 5 (03:15:34–03:16:04)
with the 40B units with our, where we're at in terms of reaching the threshold, because there was, I think it's 740 units that through those 40B projects, some of which are, you know, under construction and in some that are still either in the permitting stage or being, going through a legal process, but I think it'd be really good for us to go back. And it's a long time since we looked at where we're at and what's it may be merit if that's something you could.
Speaker 1 (03:16:04–03:16:34)
Well, that's on the list. I just was going to say the housing production plan. Cheyenne has spoken about that, that it's expired. She's looking at a consultant.
And Cheyenne, just while we're just to mention, the person who did the previous, the two previous housing production plans, should probably be considered in doing the new one because she's worked on this before. And I don't know if you and Nick have that name, but I can provide that to you.
Speaker 3 (03:16:35–03:16:43)
I remember getting a note after the forum from Kathleen. She told me about the woman who did it prior. So we're going to.
Speaker 1 (03:16:43–03:16:51)
Good. OK. She's still in business, but that would be probably who we should look at on the 40.
Speaker 20 (03:16:51–03:17:24)
I just want to add. Given that the housing production plan is expired, we no longer have temporary safe harbor opportunity. So, there is a greater likelihood that we're going to see more 40 B applications because we're shy. Of our 10%, and we don't have safe harbor until we get a new.
housing production plan that's approved by HLC. And that housing production plan will have to have sites identified where we think affordable housing or housing can go.
Speaker 5 (03:17:25–03:17:31)
Cheryl, how far are we away from safe harbor now? How many units?
Speaker 3 (03:17:31–03:17:35)
Cheyenne, do you have that number? No, but I can get it tomorrow.
Speaker 5 (03:17:36–03:17:38)
That'd be great. Thank you.
Speaker 23 (03:17:40–03:18:05)
I think if I'm correct, what Cheryl is also referring to is there's more than one way to have safe harbor. The one that people talk about most is the percentage of subsidized housing inventory, but there are also other temporary forms of safe harbor that are associated with the pace of housing production plans or the pace of housing production and progress towards that target.
Speaker 19 (03:18:05–03:18:14)
Yeah, because it wasn't at a percentage of our overall land mass and then we look at it at 1 point and we didn't need it. But perhaps now we do need it because.
Speaker 20 (03:18:14–03:18:47)
We have more, no, it's been looked at. I think what's always referring to is you have safe Harbor once you hit 10%. But you can also have temporary safe Harbor. if you have an approved housing production plan and you're making progress on the development of those units.
And so if a 40B is approved, I think we said it was previously that if you did 48 units a year, then you would have temporary safe harbor. I don't, I'm just, that's from memory. So I'm not sure that's the right number, but let's just say that's a number like that.
Speaker 2 (03:18:48–03:18:56)
But the way I understand that is you would actually have to identify the parcels and then those specific parcels would have to be developed.
Speaker 20 (03:18:56–03:19:18)
They don't have to be developed though because they haven't identified the potential of them, Jim. But for example, we had a housing production plan that was approved. It was in place for five years and housing wasn't developed on. They have to have some opportunity.
It's not like HLC will accept it if there's no opportunity for development at all.
Speaker 5 (03:19:19–03:19:38)
Can I interrupt and make a suggestion to the board? It's 1020. Can we turn ourselves back to the matters that will allow us to get to the completion of the meeting with Zoe and Matthew? Yes.
Not that that topic isn't a good topic, but just in the interest of the time of night,
Speaker 1 (03:19:40–03:19:53)
So, well, how does the board feel on the St. Pius site? Do we want this to be evaluated? You know, obviously it would have a lower priority than the others, but, or do we not want that to be considered?
Speaker 5 (03:19:54–03:20:20)
You know, I think, again, I have to go back and listen and consider what Maggie said about, you know, her own property. And I don't own St. Pius, I'm just expressing consideration for people that attend Mass there. I think we should look at it, but I'm not, by any means, by looking at it, am I committing to saying that I would support including it, but I think we should look at it.
Speaker 20 (03:20:22–03:20:23)
All right.
Speaker 19 (03:20:23–03:20:26)
But at a low density, like at a low density.
Speaker 20 (03:20:26–03:20:30)
Well, at 11, Maggie, that's the only density that makes sense according to Zoe.
Speaker 19 (03:20:32–03:20:33)
11?
Speaker 20 (03:20:33–03:20:34)
It's an acre.
Speaker 19 (03:20:36–03:20:38)
Yeah, and it's, what did we say it is? How many acres?
Speaker 20 (03:20:39–03:20:49)
We said that it would be the property next door too, so not just St. Pius, right? So including both parcels, it would be a zone capacity of 81.
Speaker 19 (03:20:49–03:20:52)
That's a lot.
Speaker 20 (03:20:55–03:21:02)
Well, we have, we have to look at the spreading it out in my view.
Speaker 23 (03:21:04–03:21:27)
So I think maybe should try and get us unstuck on this I think my guess is that the 11 is kind of that tipping point, but is there a number that. I think we tested this in some of our prior, I think we got to a number for several districts, but St. Pius had been eliminated already when we got to those target numbers. Is there a number that, yeah, good.
Speaker 20 (03:21:28–03:22:02)
We got to five units an acre at 30 units. And I think that it was eliminated because it wasn't contributing and the density was too low. So, I think that's why if there's something between 5 and 11, that doesn't cause a problem and it causes the benefit or it allows the benefit of, you know, relocation of some of the zone capacity, whatever the right number is. If you want to calculate that for us, if you think it's 11, I'm fine.
with having that through the study and seeing what that does.
Speaker 23 (03:22:02–03:22:34)
So I think let's plan to, we'll come back to you with an answer on that, knowing that the board is not in agreement on the level of density that you're comfortable with here and that this is really an exercise in determining if this has a role to play in this version. I think, are we in agreement about not moving forward with Woodmere because the density would not, the density that you're comfortable with there would be quite low.
Speaker 20 (03:22:34–03:23:00)
The one thing I would just say to the other board members is just like 131 Elliott, when you have this many condominium owners, they would all have to agree to this new zoning. It's unlikely that that would happen. because then what you'd be looking at is everyone having to agree that they're all going to have the rights to reconstruct each structure. I just don't see it as it very likely, just like we talked about 131 earlier.
Speaker 19 (03:23:00–03:23:25)
And that's just another discussion point is when we're talking about a rapid transit and we're talking about 2,600 units, is it okay And is it beneficial to the town not to have every single unit built? But we get credit for it.
Speaker 20 (03:23:25–03:23:30)
Well, that's what we've been saying is the way forward on the 25%, right? It's trying to do that as much as possible.
Speaker 19 (03:23:30–03:23:31)
I think we should look at it.
Speaker 2 (03:23:31–03:23:35)
Yeah, by that rationale, we should do Windermere instead of St. Pius. Correct.
Speaker 19 (03:23:36–03:23:39)
That's why I think we should do Woodmere for that purpose.
Speaker 2 (03:23:41–03:23:41)
Absolutely.
Speaker 23 (03:23:42–03:26:09)
Okay, so we'll look at those two at similar density levels, both trying to say, I think, To see if it's possible to go below like 10 units per acre on those and not trip the overall density wire. Understanding that if we cannot do that, they may not be districts that the board wants to include. The other thing I wanted to return to was what Jim had raised earlier and also the. The East Milton Square conversation just in light of the fact that we, I do, I've done some quick math I'm not sure this is right I need to do it with a fresh mind in the morning but I think that you have about 120 units that you could.
Locate as part of a mandatory mixed use district and still stay within the limits of what the state requires. So, in other words, like, if, if the state does not provide you with special consideration and relief from that requirement, you still have a little bit of room. I think that that number is maybe a better fit for the couple of parcels that Jim had described than trying to make it fit in the East Milton Square geography, which is a larger geography. You could do like a donut hole kind of situation with the East Milton Square where you reserve the highest priority commercial parcels and take them out of an overlay and just zone a smaller sort of ring around them.
But when we last left off with East Milton Square, we had that plugged in at, let me pull that up. If I can find the latest one here. I think we had it at like around 200, yeah, it was 286 units was when we left off at East Milton Square. And that was starting to get relatively low density.
So all that is to say, If you had 124 units to put into a mandatory mixed use district, is there a place that stands out to you that you think is worth exploring for us to come back to you with on the 8th? And is it the Milton Village parcels that Jim had identified, or are there other ways that you think it would be worth expanding that within the town?
Speaker 2 (03:26:14–03:26:16)
I mean, if you're asking me, I'm all for the village.
Speaker 1 (03:26:21–03:26:26)
If you can keep the heights low so you don't have demolition down there.
Speaker 20 (03:26:26–03:26:32)
Right. As long as we don't incentivize the demolition of the buildings, which is what we were trying to do with the overlay.
Speaker 23 (03:26:33–03:26:39)
I'm fine with that. 3.5 story, is that enough, do you think? Or is that still?
Speaker 20 (03:26:41–03:26:48)
Yeah, I think that would work.
Speaker 23 (03:26:49–03:27:07)
Okay. Are there any other for the Milton village parcels that we discussed for Jim suggestion, is there any other. Let me, let me back up to was central have that we didn't talk about that.
Speaker 1 (03:27:07–03:27:10)
Yeah, there's one area that we wanted to pull up.
Speaker 23 (03:27:10–03:27:51)
Yeah okay we'll go to that in just one second. I just want to kind of make sure that I'm thinking through this right. So for the Milton station I think we would generally cue off of the kinds of densities that we're showing for the other Milton station districts but restrict the height more. Are there in terms of like FAR and units per acre is there a specific target that you want us to bring that down to?
for this potential expansion to the parcels along Adams. So like 40 units per acre.
Speaker 20 (03:27:57–03:28:21)
I think we should look at it and then we, I wouldn't, I can look at the zoning that we had before also the existing building sizes. So, if you cut off of the existing building sizes, and you said what you'd like to do is be able to renovate those. And let's say it's a 40,000 square foot building, then 1000 square foot unit, you'd like, get 40 units there. I'm just throwing that out if we just use those buildings.
Speaker 1 (03:28:22–03:28:32)
Sizes as our parameter, there's there's 3 distinctly different size buildings. Yeah. You'll see when you take a look. Yeah.
Okay.
Speaker 19 (03:28:32–03:28:41)
Is there like, at the extra space. Building in the surrounding buildings, what's the percentage of open space there? Is that.
Speaker 23 (03:28:42–03:28:49)
I plugged those in for our rules at 40%, but I'm not sure how that lines up with the level of open space that's there currently.
Speaker 2 (03:28:50–03:28:58)
So the whole war for his open space. I mean, if those parcels had less, the residents there would have plenty of access to some really nice open space.
Speaker 20 (03:28:58–03:29:06)
Agreed. The building, the Masonic building on Adam street there doesn't have any open space, but it has the park right behind it.
Speaker 2 (03:29:06–03:29:07)
Exactly what I'm saying.
Speaker 20 (03:29:07–03:29:10)
Yeah, agreed. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (03:29:11–03:29:16)
Okay, are we good on that? Yeah, it's 1030. We do have a couple of other things we still have to get to.
Speaker 23 (03:29:16–03:29:22)
Yeah, but the only other thing was the Central Ave. I think you had mentioned that you wanted to talk about.
Speaker 1 (03:29:22–03:29:31)
Yeah. Cheyenne, can you pull that email up that we had sent out yesterday morning to everybody?
Speaker 3 (03:29:31–03:29:34)
The one regarding the plan?
Speaker 1 (03:29:34–03:30:10)
Yes, that would be great. We can just take a look at that. So you can see that with the 10,000 square foot lot, 12 and a half and the 15, he was suggesting bumping those.
Speaker 23 (03:30:12–03:30:25)
Yeah, basically scaling with each increase of 2,500 square feet of a lot, you'd gain a unit essentially that you would, you could build. Right.
Speaker 1 (03:30:25–03:30:28)
And then he included a map below that.
Speaker 23 (03:30:29–03:33:11)
Yeah, and I think the map in a lot of ways, we did, we did review this so that we would be prepared to discuss with you all. The, I think that if you kind of think through the, like the, the geography that he, he's shared in this sketch, it sort of corresponds, not perfectly, but closely with the scenario we're showing where we remove what we referred to as Elliot West. And we add Blue Hills West. Right.
The main place where his map diverges from that scenario, there's two places is that there's a little cut out sort of between the Cape and stop and the Valley Road stop. There's like a little cut out there. And then there's an expansion into the along Central Ave in that area. And I think The reason we have previously excluded that portion of Central Ave is because of the large lots.
They reach a scale that really doesn't line up with our rules and starts to really drag down density because they're quite large and so having four units on them negatively impacts your density numbers. obviously with the rule set that Brian is describing, those would be able to accommodate, I'm not remembering exactly what the lot sizes, I think they're above like 20,000. I think they would be allowed many more units, like six, eight, 10 units per parcel. So I think that's the big, under our current rule sets, You would only be able to develop four units on those and it would not make sense from a density standpoint, you're not getting enough benefit for it to be worth extending the district to include that.
But if you are zoning them for greater density, in other words, if you created like a tier four of the Elliott Street corridor rules. Lauren Silberman, ACBP, she or hers? I think it would only be worth exploring this if the board is willing to
Speaker 19 (03:33:11–03:33:24)
No, I'm not. What if we reduced the boundary to just those properties in blue, not the one in the greenish?
Speaker 23 (03:33:26–03:35:16)
Yeah, so I think there's probably some small differences. Our current geography does capture some of those. We could go further along both Central Ave and School Street to capture some additional lots that are kind of that like mid small size, and similarly we could extend along Maple Street in a similar with a similar intent. I think we had previously shied away from some of those areas because it does contain more of those and particularly along Maple Street.
There are many very small parcels and so similarly when we include a lot of small parcels it does start to drag down your density numbers because those are unbuildable under the rules. So That's kind of the parcel size push-pull that's happening in this area because there's a lot of range in parcel sizes. So I think with the rules that we have now, which are allowing development on some of the smaller parcels, it means that Elliott Street as a whole is not as much of a drag on your density because we've modified the rules so that more lots are contributing to that density. I think we could look at changing the boundary in this area to capture more of, as Maggie put it, the blue parcels in this diagram.
But I think per the kind of reactions when I asked earlier, it sounds like it would not be worth looking at the parcels that are shown in the kind of like gold color here, because unless the planning board is willing to look at six, eight, 10 units, they're just not a good match for the rules we have.
Speaker 19 (03:35:17–03:35:23)
And so do you think it would be okay to do three units in the blue section.
Speaker 23 (03:35:24–03:35:40)
Yeah, I think that's how they would interact with our I don't know for sure without looking at the each individual person but my guess is that those would fall in our first tier, maybe our second tier. So probably they would mostly be three unit per lot rules.
Speaker 1 (03:35:42–03:36:10)
And I think what he has here is very similar to where we've sort of come out in our 25% plan. I think there's, except excluding those large parcels, which that we did not support. And I think that's why, yeah, we didn't go further with that. But then we start just, Maggie, then we start adding more to that Elliott Street corridor, which we've been working to take some of those units off.
You know, it's sort of,
Speaker 23 (03:36:10–03:36:34)
Yeah, that's what I was going to raise is I think it's kind of a tension, right? I think there's like, there's a valid argument for why those parcels can and should be included. And if overall, we're trying to find ways to spread units away from this area, adding more area to the district is going to mean more units.
Speaker 19 (03:36:35–03:36:41)
I mean, the one thing about Central Ave, though, it's a wider, it's a wider road.
Speaker 23 (03:36:41–03:36:49)
Yeah, and it's very close to the Central Ave stop and to the amenities that are, you know, the commercial amenities that are around that stop.
Speaker 20 (03:36:50–03:36:52)
I'd rather see it there than the, sorry, Zoe.
Speaker 19 (03:36:53–03:36:55)
No, go ahead. Yeah, I was going to say.
Speaker 20 (03:36:55–03:37:05)
I would rather see it there than adding some of that at the parkway, which is already denser. Yeah, because I do think this is better convenience for walking even.
Speaker 23 (03:37:05–03:37:39)
And you do have amenities there, you can get right to the T. Okay, so do we have some level of consensus that we should look at expanding the Elliott Street corridor to focus on the blue parcels as shown in the diagram here that extend along Central Ave. And I think School Street would also be included in that.
Speaker 2 (03:37:41–03:37:51)
So you're picking up about 15 parcels, kind of like from Grigs Lane East back towards Central, just the blue.
Speaker 23 (03:37:52–03:38:21)
Yeah, that's a good idea. You can kind of see the half mile radius. It's actually less than half mile. It's like a 1,000, I think.
So I'm trying to remember when we did this diagram. I think it's like a 1,000 foot linear feet from the station. So that's sort of roughly corresponding to where I think we would be drawing the line for the blue parcel, where it transitions from blue parcels to the gold colored parcels.
Speaker 19 (03:38:21–03:38:26)
And the same rule set would apply as does on like Elliot Street.
Speaker 20 (03:38:27–03:38:33)
That's what I would think. Yes, I think so, too. Just remind me, though, the blue is 7500 square feet in this one.
Speaker 23 (03:38:35–03:40:15)
Let me see if I can remember when this. We put together these diagrams, I think it was early on in 2025. Okay, yeah, so I think if I'm remembering this correctly, it depends a little bit on which my other screen so I can see both of them at the same time. Lauren Silberman, ACAB, she or hers?
Okay, I think this is showing the 5000 square foot threshold based on the pattern. So I think in this, I think the underlay of the diagram that Brian has used for this idea is a diagram that shows the pink parcels are under 5000 square feet. The gold parcels are over 20,000 square feet, and the blue parcels are in between 5,000 and 20,000. Basically, the blue parcels are the parcels that are a fit for tiers one, two, and three of the Elliott Street Corridor, but it includes all three of those tiers.
It collapses them into one. I'm good with that.
Speaker 2 (03:40:17–03:40:20)
So it starts at 6,000, not five, right? Cause that's our parameter.
Speaker 23 (03:40:20–03:40:39)
Yeah. So there would be some, you know, with our diagram or sorry, with our rules. Now there would be more pink parcels. In other words, like there, this is showing the pink parcels that are excluded based on a 5,000 threshold, but there are more parcels that would be excluded because we've set the floor at 6,000.
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (03:40:41–03:41:37)
Run it and find out the board. I'm sorry, Meredith, the board, I know this goes against what we just talked about in the Mattapan area, but Hawthorne and Briarfield, and maybe even Fairfax, this is kind of going up north. You're just drawing a straight line up almost to the parkway. There's a lot of gray area there.
Do you think that would be worth looking at? Or is that just expanding an area that we don't want to expand? You guys, do you know what I'm trying to say? So up by, so I guess I'm taking the conversation somewhere else from central up to Mattapan Square or Mattapan Station, Briarfield and Hawthorne Roads.
Same thing, I'm seeing a lot of gray area. Are we calling it blue or gray? Or we could just expand the boundary a little bit and probably pick up a lot of developable area. Does that make any sense at all or no?
Speaker 1 (03:41:42–03:41:51)
Is it needed? I don't know. Yeah, I'm not sure that we need it. All right.
Maybe start with this and if we need to expand it, but we don't want to end up with too many units.
Speaker 2 (03:41:52–03:41:53)
Right. OK.
Speaker 1 (03:41:55–03:42:00)
OK. All right, Zoe, thank you so much. We really appreciate this.
Speaker 22 (03:42:01–03:42:02)
Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker 1 (03:42:02–03:42:12)
OK, and I'll follow up with Cheyenne tomorrow and get those six slides for the adjacent plan that we can get sent to HLC.
Speaker 20 (03:42:12–03:42:21)
So, when do you think you'll be able to have this? Would it be for a meeting on Thursday? Next Thursday, the 8th?
Speaker 23 (03:42:22–03:42:51)
Yeah, so I think that's that's the next meeting that we're planning to join you for as the 8th, starting at 7. and those changes that we've all discussed, I think are possible for us to prepare for us to review together on the 8th. and we'll plan to prepare the adjacent community changes that we've discussed, as well as the handful of questions for HLC this week to share with Meredith and with the intention of sharing with HLC by the end of this week.
Speaker 20 (03:42:52–03:42:54)
Great, thank you.
Speaker 23 (03:42:55–03:44:43)
Yeah, and then the other thing I just want to return to quickly. First, I just want to acknowledge that Cheyenne did share the email with us, but we were honestly we were working right up until like 10 minutes before this meeting, so something just didn't get. We didn't get to, but we we will continue to move through those requests and we do. We are aware of them.
Thank you, that's great. I'm realizing I'm not sharing screen anymore. pull up the just like next step summary here to just make sure that we're resolving all the things that we need to keep things moving. So I think we've got We've got clarity on the revisions are making to the adjacent so we can share that with HLC.
We have clarity on the revisions, we should work on for rapid to share with you on the eighth but as I understand it right now that's not something that we're sharing with HLC yet where we would wait until the eighth, which means that they're. there's a risk that we won't hear back from HLC about the rapid scenario in the time that we have remaining. So just I'll name that and we'll try and include as many questions as we can that are related to the rapid transit so we have clarity on those key issues even if we don't have a full review of the rapid from the state. And that addresses number two and three.
And then for four, because we're limited on time, it'd be great if you can give the town staff some clarity on whether they're authorized to start preparing a zoning article for one or more of these and how you want them to move forward in the time that we have between now and the 16th.
Speaker 20 (03:44:45–03:45:49)
The one thing we've talked about Zoe is if our site plan approval by law passes town meeting next week. that we would pull out the site plan approval component of the zoning that we have in the 2023. And then Nick and Cheyenne shared a draft where they started to highlight things that we're going to need to revise that was using the 2023 as the basis. I do think a lot of it's going to depend on how many districts we have because we're going to have to include new districts, take some districts out and include new ones.
I did spend some time in 2023 providing comments in red line or in track changes mode to staff when they were working on it before. So I'm happy to do that again to help facilitate getting it done.
Speaker 24 (03:45:51–03:45:59)
Cheryl, you suggested that your site plan approval processes have been changed since then. Are you suggesting that they're not?
Speaker 20 (03:46:01–03:46:25)
We have a bylaw that's going to encompass site plan approval for other other requirements in our zoning, but it would also, we would refer to that if it passes this next week, we would refer back to that article in the MBTA community zoning for the process for site plan approval.
Speaker 24 (03:46:26–03:46:26)
Okay.
Speaker 1 (03:46:31–03:46:33)
A little more comprehensive, yeah.
Speaker 20 (03:46:33–03:46:38)
And it's based on what was in the 2023 MBTA zoning. Oh, good.
Speaker 24 (03:46:38–03:46:39)
Okay.
Speaker 20 (03:46:39–03:46:39)
Yeah.
Speaker 23 (03:46:41–03:47:01)
Okay, so is it just sorry one but a finer point on the zoning issue. So right now like we're actively discussing two different paths right we're discussing the adjacent community path and the rapid path, and those would carry different zoning rules. Do you want town staff to be drafting both of those one of those.
Speaker 19 (03:47:04–03:47:26)
Well, I would think they would do the adjacent community plan first. You know, and I mean, I'm a type of person who likes to complete a project. So it's, you know, I think we're pretty certain on the adjacent community. So why not focus just on that and get that complete?
Speaker 23 (03:47:30–03:48:20)
Okay. So kind of deal with it sequentially, address the adjacent community one. And then, um, I think there's a chance that we will That the town staff may need to start preparing the rapid one. If we have not yet heard back from the state about whether they will accept adjacent and there's a chance that the rapid will be moving forward.
Just because of the time crunch so I think that's that we don't need to be involved in figuring that out but I just want to flag it because there's a. The decision making sequence and the time we have remaining is not going to perfectly align. So we'll all do our best, and I'll leave that second question to the board. And I think with that, I'll stop sharing.
I think we can potentially leave you there. I know you mentioned you have some other agenda items, and I'm sure you're eager to get out.
Speaker 1 (03:48:21–03:48:26)
I just wrote two quick things, so. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Matthew.
Speaker 5 (03:48:26–03:48:28)
Thanks, Zoe. Thanks so much, Matthew.
Speaker 1 (03:48:29–03:48:30)
That's all. Good night. So long.
Speaker 5 (03:48:30–03:48:31)
Good night.
Speaker 1 (03:48:34–03:49:07)
Okay, great. So real quickly, because we don't, I don't think we need to go through all of this, but I just wanted the planning board to know Cheyenne and Nick have been working on a presentation for ADU and site plan articles to present in town meeting. I know Cheyenne, you said it might not be completed for tonight, but I thought maybe, and since it's so late, Once those are complete, Cheyenne, if you could send those out to the board members, just to see if there's any comments or anything that we would wanna add to that presentation.
Speaker 3 (03:49:08–03:49:21)
So we did finish it. It's in the OneDrive folder for tonight, but we can send it as late. We can still just take comments up until like Friday so that we can get it over to the Warrant Committee for Monday or whenever they get to us.
Speaker 1 (03:49:22–03:49:32)
Let's do that. So yeah. Let's do that. So everybody can look at it with fresh eyes.
Terrific. So Cheyenne will look for that in your email. She'll be circulating that.
Speaker 19 (03:49:32–03:49:37)
And then who will be presenting at a town meeting, Meredith? Will Cheyenne be presenting?
Speaker 1 (03:49:38–03:49:56)
I think depending on when it goes, Cheyenne's going to be away next week. So she won't be. So it would so I would be presenting it unless the board has a preference to have Nick present it. But it seemed like since it's coming from us, I should probably be the one.
Speaker 19 (03:49:56–03:49:58)
It's just I don't.
Speaker 1 (03:50:00–03:50:02)
Right, Cheyenne, you're gone Monday.
Speaker 3 (03:50:03–03:50:14)
I'm going to be gone early Monday, like during the workday. I'm going to try and get back for town meeting night, but the daytime I'm going to be out.
Speaker 19 (03:50:14–03:50:17)
It's just in the past. I thought Tim presented. He did.
Speaker 1 (03:50:17–03:50:37)
Yeah. So you think it'll be there Monday night, Cheyenne? Yeah. Tuesday night, will you be there?
Yeah. So I would be happy for Cheyenne to present it as well. So I thought you weren't going to be there. That's why I was just saying.
Speaker 3 (03:50:39–03:50:41)
No, no, I switched my trip a little later.
Speaker 19 (03:50:43–03:50:47)
OK. Well, you guys can discuss that offline.
Speaker 1 (03:50:47–03:52:25)
Yeah, we'll talk about that. We can talk about that tomorrow, which Cheyenne would be great doing that. Um, okay, so we'll talk about that. And then just the last thing that we, I just need to vote on.
So, Jim and I went to the to the warrant committee with our, our overlay zoning for East Milton Square, which they really everybody seemed to embrace and is. really supportive of. And they just had one very small thing that they asked that we add that was on Cheyenne, can you do you mind pulling up the overlay zoning language for East Milton overlay? Yep.
So it's on page two, B, letter D. Thank you a little bit bigger, please. Thank you. Great.
So where it says ground floor uses. In the second line where they said at least, well, at least 50% of the usable ground floor area of the building must be designed for, and they wanted the word shall be occupied. So the two words shall and be before occupied.
Speaker 3 (03:52:28–03:52:32)
I'm just doing it like this because I have to get the word document from Josh.
Speaker 1 (03:52:32–03:52:38)
It must be designed for. and shall be occupied by non-residential.
Speaker 20 (03:52:38–03:52:58)
So do we have a definition of usable ground floor here? Because we know parking is a non-residential use and it's commercial use, but I don't think we want parking as our 50%. I don't remember if we have that definition.
Speaker 22 (03:53:02–03:53:03)
For ground floor use.
Speaker 1 (03:53:20–03:53:23)
I thought we did describe the ground floor.
Speaker 20 (03:53:24–03:53:33)
Yeah, I just haven't looked at it more recently. And that just caught my eye as we were looking at that amendment's design standards.
Speaker 1 (03:53:37–03:53:41)
We have ground story height. Ground story, let me see.
Speaker 19 (03:53:42–03:53:44)
Maybe under parking.
Speaker 20 (03:53:44–03:53:45)
Maybe it's under parking, yeah.
Speaker 1 (03:53:57–03:53:58)
This one parking space.
Speaker 19 (03:54:20–03:54:23)
Is it like a simple sentences parking.
Speaker 5 (03:54:25–03:54:39)
This is a section we passed by earlier that I thought it said active ground floor. What was that? It might be early in the document, Cheyenne. Keep going up.
I think it said that.
Speaker 26 (03:54:39–03:54:47)
Right there. Active ground. That's not it.
Speaker 3 (03:54:57–03:55:01)
So eventually we'd like a definition for the ground floor is what Cheryl's looking for.
Speaker 20 (03:55:05–03:55:13)
Yeah, I don't mind going back and looking through it just to check. And if it's not there, I can email something. Does that sound good?
Speaker 5 (03:55:13–03:55:20)
That sounds great. The language change that they wanted, the language that they want to add, seems fine.
Speaker 1 (03:55:21–03:55:30)
It does to me, too. Yeah. So if I could. I have a motion to approve that language change.
Speaker 2 (03:55:34–03:55:41)
I have a motion to approve the language change on page 2, section D, adding the term shall be.
Speaker 1 (03:55:42–03:56:04)
Is there a second? Second. OK, roll call. Jim?
Yes. Cheryl? Yes. Maggie?
Yes. Sean? Yes. And myself, yes.
OK, great. And then Cheryl, yes, if you want to just look at, we can add that and approve that on Monday.
Speaker 20 (03:56:04–03:56:06)
Yeah, I'll take a look tomorrow.
Speaker 1 (03:56:07–03:56:32)
Okay. Great, but everything else was good. The only thing, Cheyenne, they, for some reason, the Warrant Committee had a slightly previous version, which had some typos in it, which our version had been corrected. So once we make these improvements, we'll send, or these changes, we can just send this as the fresh final document, so.
Speaker 3 (03:56:32–03:56:33)
All right.
Speaker 1 (03:56:33–03:57:01)
I think they pulled it off the website, and I think they just pulled off a previous, Well, previous draft, so. Okay, so that was just, that was the last item that I had. And so if there's not anything else, yep, that was the last item. I motion to adjourn.
Speaker 2 (03:57:02–03:57:03)
Second.
Speaker 1 (03:57:04–03:57:13)
Second. Okay, you a second. I made the motion. I made that motion.
Yes. So roll call Cheryl. Yes. Sean.
Speaker 5 (03:57:14–03:57:15)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (03:57:15–03:57:17)
Maggie. Yes. Jim.
Speaker 5 (03:57:17–03:57:18)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (03:57:18–03:57:19)
And myself. Yes.
Speaker 28 (03:57:20–03:57:21)
Good night. Good night.