Board: Fire Station Building Committee Atherton Street Subcommittee

Date: 2026-01-20


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:22–00:23)

Brian, can you hear me?

Speaker 2 (00:26–01:11)

Sorry, I have the matrix printouts here. I'll put them up on the screen. I also have. The objectives that was generated, I think, by you literally and with chief to to kind of make sure that we all have on the wrong the same page as to what the apparatuses and what the needs are.

And then that kind of translates into our matrix here, fleshing out multiple different options and ultimately boiling it down as to what our strategy is going to be in May for town meeting. Ultimately, I think we want to use this time to go through these packets. I can share the screen as well. We can make any edits on the fly as we see here and then ultimately come to the larger body of a committee so that we can try to make a decision on what we're going to be doing.

Speaker 3 (01:11–05:46)

Brian, if I could, I apologize. I know I'm late and it's not typical, but a quick update going into this. I think it's important, especially with so many members of the community here with us. I told the committee that I would go out of my way to try to get together with Jay Fungling.

I see Jay's on the meeting. I was able to do that. I had a long conversation with him. And frankly, it was, for me, it was an excellent conversation because it reminded me we've all been doing it so long that we sort of assume things that aren't necessarily what everyone knows.

And Jay pointed out that certainly he's the chair of the Warren Committee. He's concerned about making sure the warrant is indicated. He had two main questions, two main needs, which I told him I would formally get back to him. I wanted approval of the committee, the poll committee.

But his two main needs were, why do we need to work on Atherton Street at all? Do we really need to update the Atherton Street fire station? Fair question. Second question, do we need to do now or can we wait 10 years?

Well, that'll be a question. So, you know, this committee has a long history. We were gonna do all three. We explained a lot to the community, but before we do any community, I think we have to re-educate everybody as to what we're doing.

Okay, so that's just the general info for the Warren Committee. And by the way, Part of that discussion, the committee worked hard when we were originally formed. First, answering the question and doing a deep dive, a lot of work. Does the town of Milton need three fire stations or can we deal with two?

When we were started, the objective was to investigate rebuilding all three fire stations. That was our charge. But we saw the wisdom in saying, look, we're going to have to really defend to the community that we need three stations versus two. And we had to convince ourselves.

So we did an analysis. Frankly, working with the former vice chair, Derek Clark, he found a program and we did an analysis and said, ignore who owns what properties in the town of Milton. and pick two best places for a fire station, right? Anywhere on the map.

The national standards for fire stations, and I do think, I'm sorry to take some time here, but I do think it's kind of important. The national standard for fire response by any fire station is to get 90% of your covered area within four minutes or four minutes or less. So we did a program on our own and came up with two spots. Ironically, the two spots are different.

One was close to the locations. One was close to where the current Athens Street is, ironically. The other spot was close to, oh my God, it's a piece of property that's owned by the cemetery trustees. It's right by the- Pon Pon.

Pon Pon, thank you. So we said, okay, we did an analysis in it. It was close as to whether it could really keep 90% of the calls within the 4 minutes. So, we decided we take it 1 step further would find out if there's a professional organization that does this kind of analysis.

We did, we engage them. They did it and the answer was. Simply, no, the 2 stations would not meet the standards. In fact, we fed them.

We had both five and 10 years with the actual fireballs, and we gave that tool, and there was. It was a couple of hundred of calls that Milton had to respond to that were within the timeframes for the three stations that now would not be. So we as a committee decided we did need three stations. I got to tell you, and the chief said this recently, which I think is a wide opinion, the way traffic is around the town of Milton, I'm glad we do have three.

I can't imagine, for example,

Speaker 4 (05:54–06:00)

OK, so let's cut to the chase.

Speaker 3 (06:00–06:03)

We're going to yeah, we're going to we're going to tell them we're going to thank you.

Speaker 4 (06:04–06:06)

I'm six.

Speaker 3 (06:07–06:35)

Yeah, I can come up with, uh, I do want to say about this support. I'm relieved that the options that we have are six options here that there's not a dramatic. Difference in the cost. And so that we, as a committee and the community will focus on what's the best solution, not look for the cheapest option.

Okay. And we have some flexibility there. So anyway, uh, let's do it. Go ahead.

Jump into the options, Brian. Yeah, sure.

Speaker 2 (06:38–07:49)

So, like I said, we, we tried to parse things out as we stood here, what we wanted to have is the driving force was the objectives list that was also sent around in those packets, which is kind of an updated programming to ensure that anything that was going to be designed is actually satisfying the needs of the department. I think the 1st question that we need to get out in the open for this for this forum in this committee is agreeance on option 1 and option 2 option. 1 is the current design as it stands right now. Leaving the 2 existing bays in the existing structure.

And 1 new additional bay built onto the side of it. That would mean that there would be 1 new apparatus bay to existing. According to the objectives and apparatus lists that we have here. I have that currently as this does not satisfy the programming and the operations of the department.

So option one. And chief, maybe if you could give me an assist here with the way that that breaks down with the objectives list and the bays that that would produce to be having one new apparatus and two existing, why that would not work for how you see the operations right now.

Speaker 5 (07:49–09:19)

So it's challenging just with the existing bays. they are not adequate. Right now the base, the doors are 10 by 10, but if you look at the top, it goes down to 98 and the fire trucks are 95. And then with a 10 foot width, the trucks are 96.

So it gives you two inches on each side, four inches on each side, and then two or three inches. When we had the firefighter at Daniel Thomas' funeral, Stoughton, was covered in the town, and they had to take equipment off the top of their truck to fit inside the bay. Those bays don't fit modern fire apparatus. Looking forward, where do we see ourselves with equipment now and in the future?

There's some things, the fire service has changed. We're not still the fire service from 1950s or 1901. The fire trucks are big, they're heavy. A lot of equipment.

We're asked to do a lot more than we ever have. We're not a fire department anymore. We're an all hazards rescue department. So the equipment that we have, the trucks carry all the equipment.

So that's why the size is there. We carry 750 gallons of water on each of the trucks. So we have some water to stop that fire attack right off the bat before anybody else could get there or the other apparatus get there.

Speaker 3 (09:19–09:21)

It's safe to say that as we pursue

Speaker 5 (09:25–10:10)

So we have a couple on order and they're the exact same size. The make and model that we have up there now, which we also have down at Engine 2, are the exact same size. The current Engine 1 that's out there right now does not fit at Engine 2's quarters and does not fit at Engine 4's quarters. So there's only one firehouse that it can fit.

It's here. our backup fire truck. When something goes up for maintenance, something breaks or whatever, or if we're tied up and we need another fire truck, that's the one that we're going to keep. So the only place to keep it, so it only goes here.

And it just doesn't fit in the park.

Speaker 4 (10:10–10:11)

Can it go to East Milton?

Speaker 5 (10:11–11:44)

The new firehouse, it will. The current firehouse, no, it will not. Right, so those both those doors are 10 by 10, and the new firehouse here is 14 by 14 and the new firehouse is 14 by 14. So, I think, Paul, you know the height on that?

That's like 10-something, right? Yes, it's 10-3. So it just doesn't fit. And then you're looking for the future.

Where are we going? What are some of the equipment that we need? One of the things that I've identified is when we've had these large scale wildfires, one of the things we don't have is water. We have a brush truck that carries 200 gallons of water in it.

Driving a mile and a half into the Blue Hills and putting 200 gallons of water on it, 10, 15 acre fire is nothing and we have to rely on mutual aid partners. We rely on, I think when we had the fire last November, we had 30 different departments there, but a lot of them were, we had Dover, we had Norfolk, we had Foxboro, we had Canton, we had Raynham, all of those large off-road tankers that carry 1,000, 2,000 gallons of water off-road into the woods. So we relied heavily on those. So looking into the future, you know, the immediate need right now, the immediate need is space for our fire apparatus that we have.

And then something that is needed right now is that off-road tankering.

Speaker 3 (11:44–12:08)

And that's something I'm looking at, like maybe grants to try and… And just for everybody, you know, we don't have these opportunities to build new stations or rehab stations that often. And so if we already know in the foreseeable future that we have needs, we certainly should be able to make sure that we're building buildings that can accommodate it. We did that here and we're doing that in East Milton.

Speaker 5 (12:10–12:18)

Yeah, it's a challenge. Where do we see ourselves? Where are we going? Where are we now?

Where are we going? And that's something that's hard to do.

Speaker 2 (12:19–12:43)

So that addresses our option number one here. Option number two is the same thing with yet another bay added on in a new design, scabbed onto the side of our existing structure. Based on the document that we have there and what chief had seen and potential future use of where the apparatus was going to go, that still was going to leave you short with what you believe was going to be needed.

Speaker 5 (12:43–14:11)

Best case scenario, yes, three modern bays would actually do wonders for us. But looking at two modern bays. At a minimum. Yeah, that would be, yeah.

I just don't see us. Billy, you know, and the fire trucks are here, they're here for 20 years, we've been heating for 20 years. So we have three fire engines right now, engine one, engine two, and engine four. We also have a ladder truck, actually we have four engines.

So engine three is a spare. So when something goes out of town for mutual aid or gets tied up someplace, we have the ability to put engine three in service instantly, it's ready to go, or if something breaks. So we have that. That is a 1999.

The next newest piece, or the next oldest, I should say, is Engine 1, which is a 2005. So Engine 1 is going to be replaced in probably about six months. So talking with the mechanic, he would like to keep two spared. One of the things that is a challenge for him is that when he takes a piece out of service, And these are big trucks, so they take a week, two weeks when they're out of service.

A lot of truckers came back, and it was gone for almost three weeks, a month, just with engine issues. They're out, they're hard, and they're out for a long time.

Speaker 4 (14:11–14:13)

They take them off-site? I'm just curious.

Speaker 5 (14:13–15:53)

Depends on what it is. A lot of truckers having motor problems. So they actually had to go offsite because it doesn't fit in any of the base, uh, down at central maintenance where he does a lot of the work. So it went out for the engine problems.

They had to replace a, uh, a fuel pump and some electrical wiring for it, because that is also a 2006, I believe. And so it needed some work. And then while it was there, I had to do a full break job. Uh, so they did all the breaks on it because it was actually inside the bed and the guy that, that mechanic shop could, could accommodate, um, auto mechanic.

So when the things, when the fire trucks go out, they go out hard and they go out. So, and they're constantly requiring maintenance and testing. So the ladders have to be tested. The pump has to be tested.

Everything has to, has to be tested to make sure that it's still compliant with the NFPA to make sure that we're doing the maintenance on it. So when it goes out, it goes out hard for a while. So he requested to keep two spares. So when you look at the, at the, at how we're doing, um, why do we need that second bay is you look here.

here is full. We're also getting a new ladder truck. That ladder truck should be in before less than a year from now. So we're going to keep the ladder, the current ladder one.

It's in great shape. Again, it did have to go up, but we just put a lot of money into it. So the idea is to maintain that, and that'll go into the far bay. And nobody has ladders.

I asked around everywhere. I was on text with Quincy, Braintree, Weymouth, all the fire chiefs. Everyone's asking for a lot of trucks. And we have a ladder.

And we have a ladder. Nobody has a ladder truck. So keeping that spare ladder truck is really important.

Speaker 3 (15:53–16:17)

And again, with so many people in the community, one thing that took me a while on the committee to learn, if we have multiple cars at home and one needs service, even if it goes out for a week or two, we have options like rent a car. only rent a fire truck. So Milton department does what a lot of other fire departments do. They keep older engines just in case they have to put them in service in an emergency.

Speaker 5 (16:17–16:37)

Yeah and it has to go into service immediately. It's always ready to go. Our engine three is sitting over there and it's ready to go. So if something died right now it would be.

So the mechanic has to keep two and we have two new engines on order. Should be by the end of the year we should have two new engines and a new ladder. So those The spares or the backups are what we need room for.

Speaker 4 (16:37–16:43)

How much space do they have over there that they can work on a vehicle, an engine at once?

Speaker 5 (16:43–16:47)

At Central Main? I think there's four bays.

Speaker 4 (16:47–16:49)

Could you store one down there?

Speaker 5 (16:49–17:34)

No, they're constantly working on, they've got every, they are the fleet mechanics for everything. For everything in town. Yeah. So all their trucks have to go inside.

Then if they're working on crews, they work on plows. You look at cemetery vehicles, you look at everything. They are the mechanics for every fleet. Milton fleet is tremendous.

And the other part of it too, is if we have to get into something right off the bat, if we have to go to central maintenance 15, 20 minutes behind. Yeah, so we keep it here. And that's the idea is to keep it in the firehouse. So we're ready for it.

And then nobody else can can touch it. There's, you know, there's a lot of expensive equipment on so we'd like to keep it locked up. We know all the equipment is

Speaker 2 (17:35–17:48)

And so just to be clear on option number two, where I have it as no doesn't satisfy the document is it that's driven because it would not allow for that added spare that you're talking about or for any, any future future expansion that you have.

Speaker 3 (17:48–18:22)

Okay. Right. I think also be helpful. with us today is to explain, there's a tremendous amount of interest in the community, I believe, in the committee of maintaining a historic building in the Atherton Street Station.

I believe, just going to throw it out there, that we will certainly I think we'll end up using some, if not all, of what we intended with Appleton Street. But there's a tremendous interest in that. So as you explain these options, would you mention this is a rehab or not?

Speaker 2 (18:22–21:39)

Yeah, go ahead. I'm sorry for not being clear. Options one through four are going to be salvaging the existing structure and repurposing it with a renovation for fire operations. With each of those options comes either additional construction onto the side of the building to accommodate the apparatus.

One bay, two bays, three bays with the renovation of the existing firehouse as it's seen now. To go into option 3, the green column, that is the current design that we have now with three new bays. constructed onto the side of the building. I have talked with Jeff who's online from context who believes that could have some constraints as for the size of the property and how those would be aligned.

That will need to be looked at. We find that that would satisfy the operations as Chief just alluded to with the amount of storage that he would need. But as you can see, options 1, 2, and 3 are really just an exercise of adding more bays on to each column. So option 1 would have one new bay, option 2 would have two new bays, option 3 would have three new bays on there.

Option number four in the purple. That is something we wanted to explore. The committee voted to have the structural engineer of record to come out and do some more deeper investigation about the actual. the quality of the building now and to do a little more deep dive with some destructive testing and to look at the structure holistically.

It was deemed that there would be some substantial seismic and steel and reinforcement that would need to be done not only with the slab, but with the foundations. Also thinking about the challenges that we have with the existing bays with the height and the width. that there would be some significant amount of demolition on the second floor in order to accommodate these new heights. So we wanted to put that in as an option in order to get two functioning bays in the existing structure and have still the single bay constructed onto the side of it to have three functional bays.

We have determined that that will increase not only the construction costs, it will have a significant cost with the design as well that we'll need to kind of revisit for all the structural advancements that would be needed on that. Option number five, we have five and five B, and I'll explain that as I think there's a little bit of variance to each of these. Option five would be to construct a new facility out behind the old facility, separate structure, ultimately designing more along the lines of thinking of the East Milton Firehouse that we're building right now, constructed with three bays, with a new administration wing, and leaving the existing structure as is with no renovations. Option 5B, we wanted to put some placeholders.

Speaker 3 (21:39–21:45)

Again, just for clarity. With no renovations and also meaning not using the existing base?

Speaker 2 (21:45–23:35)

Correct. Not using the structure itself, not touching it. Option 5B, we wanted to give a bit of a variant with that. which could be doing that new construction, new facility out in the back of the property, but also renovating the existing structure.

I think there would be some deeper consideration and discussion amongst the committee about whether or not if the structure was renovated, could it still house some fire programming if there's a separate structure that holds the apparatus that are out in the rear of the property. There would need to be phasing with that type of project. We would be able to avoid temporary facilities as long as you were able to continue working there for that 18 months. But this would come with added cost for construction, not only for the renovation, but for a whole new facility out in the rear of the property.

Option number six, which we wanted to kind of give you the full breadth of what the options were here, but option six would be to demolish the existing building and build a new facility in the exact location, therefore being able to dispatch out onto Blue Hill Ave at that location. We know that that would cost, there would be significant costs with temporary operations, there would be demolition, there would also be site Site work in order to manipulate the site in order to get the the deliverables that we would need for their construction. We did find using as many placeholders as possible that that would be ultimately the most expensive option, just based upon any type of abatement that would need to be done, the demolition, as well as the length of construction as there would be a different phase that we need to take.

Speaker 3 (23:35–24:26)

It seems to me the biggest difference between these last two options, is that the end product, where the fire engines be coming out essentially at the same location they do today. So the question I think for the committee to consider, is that important enough? In other words, coming out, actually, we would, if option five says the engines would be coming out on Athens Street, correct? Not the, yeah.

And so the question before, I think that we all need to understand, especially community, is that a problem? I've thought, and I don't know, I looked at the chief, I've thought that it isn't necessarily any problem. We've made up the design entry into the roadway.

Speaker 5 (24:26–24:48)

I don't know if it's a problem or not. I think it's something that is, you know, every problem is adaptable and you can overcome it. You know, is it a challenge just to come out and have to take away if you're left out? You know, depends on inclement weather.

Yeah, maybe that could be an issue, but I think for the most part, it wouldn't be that much of a challenge.

Speaker 3 (24:48–25:09)

The hill there. I recall we first started with chief grant chief grant made a big deal of if we were going to exit out. which is the other side, that has a steeper hill. I've sort of looked at them both, and that was his concern.

I'm not sure if it's as big a deal.

Speaker 4 (25:09–25:28)

I think Atherton was, and it was during snow. It's because the trucks would slip. If I remember it correctly, we can go back and check. That was why we didn't have the trucks coming off the back, and that's why we're just coming out to Blue Hills.

Speaker 5 (25:32–25:57)

Yeah, I think that that's, you know, the what if, what if, what if it's hard to, you know, obviously advances in snow removal have changed in the last 10 years and pre-treating and everything else. Pulling out anywhere is, you know, you look at pulling out into a lunar lab, that's a challenge too, with people driving by at 40 miles an hour, it's always a challenge no matter where you pull out, so.

Speaker 3 (25:58–26:12)

And again, many in the not-too-distant future, but I purposely went and checked, standing, if we exited from the back on either side and the hill was greater on Bradley Road than it was at Athens, just something else.

Speaker 4 (26:13–26:24)

But I don't think it's really us going out there arm-waving. I think it's just doing a test. You can figure out what angle the truck can go up, but it's math.

Speaker 5 (26:24–26:32)

I mean, one of our most experienced drivers is in the room. I don't want to throw him under the bus, but, you know. Would that be a problem?

Speaker 4 (26:32–26:38)

Well, I found a little hill and it gets salted and sanded like crazy. It's probably one of the first ones that does.

Speaker 3 (26:40–26:45)

Right. You're sort of pointing to Paul. Paul, what do you think?

Speaker 6 (26:45–27:15)

Well, there is, I mean, it turns out from when we used to, we still do, but I'm Batman now, but when you're coming back from Curry College and if you're out of light and get a cast in front of you and you're starting out to go come back in to Athens Street for the playoffs to back in, you'll do, you will, and then throw a snowstorm that hasn't plowed or possibly not even treated to dirt, but you're going to get that anyway. small incline up there.

Speaker 7 (27:15–27:16)

Would you get stuck?

Speaker 6 (27:16–27:23)

Yeah, with all that weight, even though you got all that weight of water in it, yeah, you'll spin the tires. The chains help, too. They really do.

Speaker 2 (27:27–28:18)

So I think moving into all of these options, obviously, there's a cost associated with all of them, and there's variables that go with each of these options that we've tried to flesh out with them. I could run through them quickly. Temporary operations is a big variable and a big unknown at this point. If the chief and staff need to relocate, an apparatus needs to be relocated, that can add up very quickly.

For some municipalities that don't have any resources and they don't have any land, they don't have any leaseable space for garage space, you can look at 1.5 plus million dollars for a year to 18 months of replicating a fire station in order to build where you're going to be. Those temporary options do come into play when we have any type of renovation where the chief is going to be impacted that needs to be moved out of that location.

Speaker 5 (28:18–28:26)

We talk about temporary housing. It's not a week or two, it's 18 months, two years.

Speaker 3 (28:28–28:48)

If we're talking about renovating the existing station, at the station. Is it within the realm of possibilities to have some sort of a hut that would protect the engine and a trailer or temporary housing?

Speaker 5 (28:48–29:02)

A lot of places will put a trailer to operate out of and then a Quonset hut. If you look at the city of If you haven't followed that, they were rehabbing their headquarters and they brought these.

Speaker 2 (29:02–29:03)

Some high-end ones, right?

Speaker 5 (29:03–29:25)

High-end ones. And you're talking, these things got shipped in and it actually won an award for the design and everything else. And it's tremendous. The building is amazing.

And they said that it would be for sale pretty soon because they've been there for about a year and a half now. So it's just one of those. There you go. But I'm not sure what the price tag on that would be.

Speaker 2 (29:25–29:33)

I think I saw the original. I think I saw the original price and it was 20 million. Outrageous. Yeah.

Speaker 5 (29:33–29:34)

They were shipped in from Canada.

Speaker 2 (29:34–29:35)

Correct.

Speaker 5 (29:35–29:38)

And they're nice. They're beautiful. And yeah.

Speaker 2 (29:38–29:53)

So obviously that's one of the variables we need to get over. If there's any thoughts of potential neighboring businesses or things that could help and offset those, obviously we would explore that throughout the design period in order to try to mitigate costs on it.

Speaker 3 (29:53–30:19)

I mean, eight years ago, we would kick around the table that perhaps we could rent some space off of Curry College. Folks buy and we're happy. But presumably, the million and a half dollar estimate of the cost might be reduced a bit if we were able to get kangaroos. Well, I don't know.

No, I know. I know. It's just an option. I guess if we get that, we should look at that option.

They're not going to go cheap.

Speaker 2 (30:19–30:23)

I know the designer. I can at least give him a call and ask him what the deal is with that.

Speaker 8 (30:23–34:30)

So a little bit of context. This has been a 10-year planning process. And I think that over that period of time, a lot has changed. Originally, the plan was to, because we wanted to get funding or make a request for funding all at once, we decided to try to design all three fire station designs all at once.

COVID came, raised some costs. Now we have, thanks to the chief, a much more B-R-Y-A-N. That's the fourth. Right.

That raising the floor gives us more height, but there's nothing we can do about the width. So we still have the nine foot, six inch truck with two inches of clearance on each side. Probably not acceptable, I don't think, if you're doing a new design for the future. So what I think Option 5B, I'm going to weigh in, what option 5B gives us is the best in both worlds.

That is a new East Milton design on the Atherton Suite 5. Three full-size bays in a new structure. Probably avoids any temporary operations costs, which is about $1.5 million. saves us the cost of raising the floor of the existing structure, which I'm in favor of retaining, because I think if you look at the reason we went through this exercise, if you look at all the programming needs, we have enough requirements to satisfy both the three bays in the new design and the two additional bays.

to have the opportunity to design all three fire stations in town at the same time. Second, and most importantly, perhaps, I think that we need to make sure that if you look at the objectives, we meet the chief's objectives of creating an all hazards department, fire, accidents, rescues, and that we do that in a way. What he's trying to do is make sure that wherever you are in town, The response time is as low as it can possibly be, and retaining the equipment that we as taxpayers have paid for with our capital and tax dollars, and making sure that we maximize the use of that equipment for as long as we can. So with what we have, equipment wise, space needs wise, and what we have coming, not in 2040.

But in 2026, we have a new ladder truck coming and a new engine coming. And over time, I expect that there will be some other equipment placements. This is the option, I think, for a relatively smaller difference in cost. Gets us the best of both worlds.

Speaker 3 (34:31–35:03)

If I could add, Leroy, there's been articles lately this per se, we're talking about, there's been quite an increase in forest buffers. We saw it last November here up in the Blue Hills, and we've got a lot of forest within the boundaries of the town of Milton. So it seems to me reasonable that the chief is going to make a case for this larger capacity water thing. So that's another thing that would probably, is in a reasonable future to set out a plan for us.

Speaker 4 (35:04–35:15)

Can I ask a question, Brian? When you say the estimated total project budget is 18.6, does that include the renovation of Atherton?

Speaker 2 (35:15–35:50)

That's what I did. So my assumption for that number is that I took, what I did is I took the cost of what it would take to construct three apparatus bays with some administration piece of it to it, similar to what we have at East Milton with an added bay on top of that. Then I took the square footage of the existing structure as it sits right now, and I took that off of our drawings and our programming of what the existing and I put a square footage number to it. So whether it's $600 a square foot for rental costs, as I saw it, that's what led to the sum of 18.6.

18.6.

Speaker 4 (35:51–35:59)

And the other numbers, 1 through 4, do not include the goal of a million dollars for the CPC funding?

Speaker 2 (35:59–36:10)

Nope, so that would be located, none of those numbers reflect the goal. Okay. What those are reflected on is the budget sheets that I have later on. He is not.

Speaker 4 (36:10–37:10)

So last time we met, I don't know when that was, Nick said And I don't have this I can't call him exactly that would be in his words, the most difficult option to get through town meeting, because it's an empty building with no use. Right, we had let me finish it away, but it's not an empty little will get program wise it is. So we have the building second floor here now. We can't use it because it doesn't have an elevator.

So I'm just saying what he said, right? From his point of view, it's the hardest thing to sell. He said, we're better off tearing it down and just building new. He said that.

So I just want to make a point of that because he's not on here. But one thing I want to say, I want to question, and I don't know, Chief, if you've looked at this, what's the operational budget when we do all this? When we have three spares, when we have all this new equipment, has that been analyzed?

Speaker 5 (37:10–37:20)

Operational budget? Yeah. They're really not going to change. Our budget is 95% salaries.

So just the maintenance.

Speaker 4 (37:20–37:24)

But is that, are you forecasting that?

Speaker 5 (37:25–38:30)

I'm just going on. We are not planning on adding any extra firefighters. We're not. So it would just be maintaining the extra spare engine, the extra spare ladder truck, and that would be it.

And that, I think- And that's minimal cost. And that's minimal cost. For the benefits that we have, that would give us as a fire department, I think it's definitely worth it. And just, you know, having the conversations with the mechanic, the pressure that he finds when something is, you know, changing tires and taking an engine out of service, he feels that pressure.

especially during the middle of a snowstorm. Now he has to weigh, do I get the plow on the road or do I get the fire truck on the road? So that's why he's requested to keep the space. And so he's willing to do that and, you know, help us in that to make sure that we have an adequately equipped fire department.

And again, we don't have, there's no plans right now Have I requested extra firefighters? Absolutely. But this has nothing to do with this. The extra firefighter will go on the ladder trusses.

Speaker 3 (38:30–38:57)

That's a question, by the way, that's come up to me personally and I think to the committee about East Milford. So the design is pretty clear up front. We've got a big poster and we're building a two bay station. So people are asking, oh, two staff fire engines out of that station?

And the answer is no. I mean, there's a two-bay station currently in East Milton, and it's only one active fire engine.

Speaker 2 (38:58–39:31)

So, Ellen to add to your comment a little, and maybe it's more of a another variant of 5 on here. I don't know if this is something to be done on arrival with staff, but if the existing structure is renovated. But not just empty, but actually used for some fire programming, whether that's the upstairs where currently there's sleeping quarters that's currently on the plans right now. with a separate structure that's out back that's more or less for apparatus and maybe decon and things like that.

I don't know if that would even, having two… It's hard to connect them.

Speaker 4 (39:32–39:32)

Correct.

Speaker 2 (39:33–39:33)

Correct.

Speaker 4 (39:34–40:45)

So I, I, my feeling is, I'm, you know, I trust you to, you know, what you're doing in terms of the spare. It sounds like we're designing like when you design a synagogue for high holidays, right? So you have a parking lot humongous. No one can really afford to do that.

So there's a compromise. So if we were going down the compromise road, I would support option two, but I hear what you're saying about the whole sphere. And I think we, I know we can make option two fit on that site without affecting MDOT, because we looked at that briefly. Option three, I think we could as well.

And it would still serve the purpose of providing you with enough new bays that you need. And it would be restoring Atherton to be part of the fabric of the station and pulling out onto Blue Hill Ave. It's keeping more on course than also at the same time you know, providing you with the space you need for the spare apparatus.

Speaker 3 (40:45–40:51)

So, Helen, just to understand, if you had a preference of two of these, it's two and three.

Speaker 4 (40:51–40:51)

Yes. Yeah.

Speaker 3 (40:51–40:52)

OK.

Speaker 4 (40:52–40:55)

But three is more hitting the chief's program.

Speaker 3 (40:56–41:00)

So because of that, you're OK supporting that option.

Speaker 4 (41:00–41:06)

Yeah. If that's what the group, we really wanted to provide that spare, you know,

Speaker 3 (41:07–41:45)

I should note, and again, I don't have a history of coming in 15 to 20 minutes late to the meeting. It's 5.30 now. I know. I mean, 6.30.

Hello. I'm happy, if the committee's happy, to continue the discussion. We all have a commitment at 7.00. I'm going to, if you hold that thought for a second, because I'd like the opportunity to see if the residents that have come here have some questions or thoughts.

And it's certainly Jay funneling with the WARA committee. So is the committee okay continuing? Is that all right, Brian?

Speaker 9 (41:45–41:47)

Brian, can I ask you a question?

Speaker 3 (41:47–41:51)

Yes. Is that Jane?

Speaker 9 (41:52–42:47)

Yeah, let me just try. I can't get you on the Zoom. As I look at all these things, the thing that concerns me the most is not spending money and renovate the existing station for the living quarters in case we have an earthquake. I mean, if you're building a brand new school, it's going to have to meet the seismic code.

You build a new house, it's going to have to meet a code. I think Leroy's suggestion of building a brand new station down below that meets all the codes. I mean, the last thing you want is a hurricane, an earthquake, And the fire guys can't get out of the fire station. And that foundation was built in 1902.

And I don't have any faith. I know the special engineer thinks he can work, but I'm not as confident as he is.

Speaker 4 (42:49–43:08)

Well, that's a good point to remind the group. He did go back out there and do what we asked him. He opened up areas they dug. And this is why we did it.

Yes. He did a test at the foundation and he was good with his original conclusion. So it's not it's like, you know, the foundation isn't falling apart underneath this.

Speaker 3 (43:09–43:11)

Correct. Yes.

Speaker 9 (43:12–43:30)

Well, I look at I think one of those plans talks about not upgrading the structure for the living quarters of the fight apartment. The money we're going to spend, I can't see why we wouldn't spend a little more on the living quarters.

Speaker 3 (43:30–43:32)

Gene, context at the table. They'd like to weigh in on this.

Speaker 10 (43:33–44:36)

Jeff can supersede me if you want. Basically, the current design in Franklin from Rome has an existing building renovation that does not exceed 51 percent, therefore, who do not need to upgrade the existing building structure to be as robust as you would if you were building all brand new under the category level four. So what Jean is saying is that the existing building, the Atherton structure, and we have to be conscious of this during design, if it would remain not exceeding that 51%, to Jean's point, it's just less hard So it's completely warranted comment. I'm just kind of explaining, but that's what that means.

The existing building 1901 doesn't have the structural capacity that you would build a modern fire station with. If you were to choose to renovate that existing building beyond 51%, the code would require you to harden the structure, which would basically be gutting that building to add a structural scale consistent to it to accommodate that.

Speaker 8 (44:42–44:54)

What Sean just said, it does not have the structural capacity that you would require if you were building a new fire station.

Speaker 4 (44:54–44:55)

That's true of a lot of buildings in the world.

Speaker 3 (44:55–44:57)

I just want to make sure everyone heard that.

Speaker 4 (44:57–44:59)

Yeah, that's done all day long.

Speaker 3 (45:00–45:12)

With the committee's agreement, I'd like to open up for some of the folks that are here. Oh, yes, we have the two addresses, by the way, the chair of our historic commission.

Speaker 7 (45:12–46:06)

I'll be real quick. Steve O'Donnell, historical commission and chair of the historical commission, also a member of the community preservation committee. As you might guess, I'm advocating for the preservation and reuse of the Avenue Street station. You all know the history of it, I don't have to go through that.

You're also all too young to remember the old town hall, which was demolished about 70 years ago. Take the credit. We still are costed by people. How could the town let that happen?

How could they do that? Well, the 1950s, yeah, mow it down and build something else. And that's what we have.

Speaker 3 (46:06–46:09)

Especially building such an ugly replacement.

Speaker 7 (46:14–47:42)

You said it. I didn't. And what people don't realize is that the old town hall stood in front of the present one. It could have been left there with an addition.

It wasn't. It was a mistake to tear it down. We're discussing preservation and reuse of heritage. Is that a mistake that's going to resonate for the next 70 years?

The commission is interested in preserving buildings. We're also interested in producing a preserving historic character of the town. New Hazardous Waste Station contributes to that historic character, particularly of that upper Blue Hill Avenue and Camden Avenue end of town, much the same way as the Town Hall contributed to Central Milton. There is money available and would be money available from CPC.

Rob can address that better than I. But I remember when this whole fire station situation was being addressed, this committee and Brian in particular was adamant about doing all three stations at the same time. Don't pick one side of town against another. Get it all out there, tell people what we're going to do, what we vote on, what town we appropriate.

Speaker 3 (47:43–47:57)

And Steve, just for clarity, it's also because our project manager and our architect look, if you put all three together, you're going to get better prices because it's a bigger, longer project.

Speaker 7 (47:57–49:55)

Well, what I think could well happen if the decision was made to demolish the station and build new, everybody voted for something. New station that we're in, new station in East Milton, a renovated station with the addition. Changing it in the middle of the game is that almost like bait and switch. We voted to do something.

Now we know There's been inflation. We know that. But there's also been inflation in what we're producing as well. East Milton is larger than what was proposed.

Avedon is being proposed to be larger than was originally sold. So I think we want to see a point of switch, like, now how much more money do we have to pay for what? The historic character of the town is, I'm looking at these numbers here and yeah, there's a big difference between the option one and option four or option five. The difference between a couple of them, a million dollars.

A million dollars, well, an extra day costs a half a million, so what's a million? I don't see any reason why, with the information that's been provided tonight, and for the hours and months and years that this committee has been working on this, why the station can't be preserved and reused. I would also agree, leaving a building empty or renovating it, and well, we can probably find something to do with it. try to sell that to John Lee.

Speaker 3 (49:57–50:32)

So Steve, just so I understand, some of it at least could be reused for the fire department. You're not advocating it's going to just be that building, but if we can save that thing, and by the way, it is a very historic building, and I don't think we could travel anywhere in the state, and I don't know how far I'll define use building a hundred years old with hand-fitted stones all around all the walls. I mean it's it's it does stand out.

Speaker 7 (50:32–50:45)

Yeah I mean you you've got four or four and a half options using the building. I'm speaking simply speaking to preserving and reusing the building as opposed to something else.

Speaker 3 (50:46–50:48)

You clearly don't want demolition.

Speaker 11 (50:49–54:00)

Thank you. Go ahead. I sit on the Community Preservation Committee with Steve. I'm also a town meeting member of Precinct 10.

I live around the corner for those of you who know me. This building's special. So for me, I'm also a professional architectural partner downtown. use there if you're going to look for extra money.

I will say that we do theaters. We specialize in theater. So we just had a great opening this weekend at the Zykerion in New Bedford. That project started off at $16 million.

That was in 2000, the year of the pandemic. It finished with a $32 million budget. It didn't get there without the use of public funding, but it opened its doors this weekend. And it's an amazing project.

But I'm going to be here as an advocate in keeping this building. Wilton's history is so strong. no here and demolishing the building, a huge mistake. To Steve's point, where the town hall, that's a whole thing that has sailed.

I think you're sitting in a great example with the central firehouse here in an old building. That's a great reuse. That probably is one of our favorite meeting rooms now is in the old building. So that's one piece of this.

The other part that I just want to come here and say you know, the CPA was passed with the notion that it's going to be used for this, for this, for the Atherton Fire Station. And, you know, I just got an email back today from Ellen, and I, now that we're catching up on this, just, I want the committee to understand that the CPA has been existing for four years. Just a couple of weeks ago, I passed our first, we passed, The first bonding CPA funded project, which has to go to town meeting, you need to keep those vote for the work part project and that was $750,000 project, just so you're aware of that over the time that's going to take our committee has about a million dollars. And so that, if it gets approved at town meeting, that will be about a $70,000 or $80,000 hit on our budget.

So that kind of gives you an idea that what I would like to say is that our committees need to talk, right, and the CPA was funded with this in mind. So a million dollars doesn't surprise me. I think you get a lot of support from the CPC. to even go higher.

Go back and look at what can be funded and look at where that can go. Even $2 million would only be $160 or $1,000 a year ahead.

Speaker 3 (54:00–54:23)

Just for clarity, one of the key points you are making there is the first three years of CPA expenditures were all using that year's money, if you're not playing three points, you're now at a point, and I know other preservation committees have done it. You're able to now put the project out for several years and dedicating a certain amount of funding per year, correct?

Speaker 11 (54:23–55:36)

Per year, yeah, and it's committed, so it's not like we're going out for new funding. It does need to get two-thirds vote passed at town meeting, but, you know, I think there's a lot of history here. You know, to say that it wouldn't be a bait and switch because the CPA was the whole thing, you know, A big portion of it was good was to put it towards this fire station. So I think there needs to be a little bit more detail within have people from this committee with the CPC It's a good time to do that, by the way, as well, because we're going to be working in a couple of months.

There's going to be that eligibility period to go figure out where that funding is and look at the detailed construction piece of this to figure out where that budget could be taken out for the long term. And I do think there would be some support there for it. And I think I would like to see, personally, to see that gap to go over that million or more, because I think it's fundamental. And so I think there needs to be a little bit more deeper dive into that and I figure out where you can close that budget gap.

I guess I have one question for you as a committee is, I know the town meeting had voted for these three projects. Where do we sit with like leftover funds? How much more? Yeah, that's a great question.

Speaker 3 (55:37–57:45)

And we have the chair. Oh, he's leaving. But I've already explained this to him. He said, spend whatever we need.

Yeah, so basically, this is worth the explanation. All the select chair, Tom Hurley, thank you, had a brilliant idea. He saw that the town was still paying money for the rebuild of the six schools and the rebuild of the Milton Library. And he said, look, we know we have to build, do something with the fire stations.

At the time, he also thought that there might be a case for doing some more building down at the DBW yard. So he drafted a proposal that is the only one still in the state that had to go through town meeting, get their approval, the TAO get their approval, and the state legislatures approval. And it's a special purpose stabilization fund. People in Milton typically refer to it as the Hurley Amendment.

They looked at the declining debt and said, OK, what could this afford for new construction? And the analysis was based on the current interest rates with the declining debt. And so we went in and We said, oh, and they said they calculated about $50 million worth of expense. So we did our analysis for the three stations, looked at putting all the ones, get the best cost, yada, yada.

And we came up with, I think it was $34.5 million. And said, all right, that's what we need. We're not going to ask for more than we need. And that's when we went to the town, to the town meeting of the town.

And so then COVID hit. And so the question is, here's the best way to articulate it. If we complete the East Milton Station, will there be funds left over to attack Athens Street? And the answer is basically no.

There might, it certainly would be, if I were to say, less than a million.

Speaker 11 (57:45–57:50)

Correct that's what we're so we got to get we got two for the price of three whatever when we're looking.

Speaker 3 (57:50–59:02)

Yeah. Yeah. And Rob, you're in the business and you. Except except there's 1P point that's not clear.

It's because of the interest rate more than anything else. So the interest rate that that was available when they did. the library in the six schools was significantly less than the interest rate right after COVID. And a matter of fact, I've had some conversations, Nick is sitting there.

Nick, if I say anything that you think is inaccurate, please correct me. But I did say to Jay Fundling, I wanted to sit down with the town accountant who, coincidentally, we used her a lot in the early days of that Early amendment funding formula, and she's pretty good at that. So I'm going to sit down. Jay wants to bring a couple of members.

I want to tell the committee. He wants to be a couple of members from the warrant committee. Right. To that discussion, but bottom line is.

There's not enough money there because of the interest rates to fund Atherton Street. We don't know how much, but it's practically nothing. Is that a fair statement?

Speaker 12 (59:02–59:38)

Right now, based on modeling of the final issuances for all of the work, done to date and he's been completing these built-in in terms of what the fund can support. It's about $200,000 a year in debt service per year. And a $15 million project might cost, though, belong to $1.2, $2.5 million in debt service. So of the $1.25 million the town would need, there's only about $200,000 to $250,000 available with future funding.

So we will be able to offset some of that cost, but the fund can't support the entire debt service.

Speaker 3 (59:42–01:00:01)

our community preservation people. If we were to get funds, the earlier we can get funds from a source, like the Community Preservation Act Committee, the better that is. If we can delay going to that formula for a year, it improves things somewhat. I don't know if it's huge, Nick, I'm looking to you, but no.

Speaker 11 (01:00:02–01:00:05)

It's not going to be huge on 2021.

Speaker 3 (01:00:06–01:00:20)

But it'll be, you know, So the calcs that were done originally said $50 million, and those calculations just don't substantiate what today's interest rates environment has supported.

Speaker 11 (01:00:20–01:00:32)

Do we have any clue? Even with these numbers, if it's 14 to 18 or whatever it is, you've got to have some ballpark of what it would be, right? In terms of additional? Your debt service, whatever.

Speaker 12 (01:00:32–01:00:52)

A $15 million project is probably about a million and a quarter. each year, of which we have 200,000 granted, the taxpayer will be asked in that scenario to pay another $1 million over and top of what was already expected. So that's the incremental increase that taxpayers will feel. That's about a 1% increase on the average tax.

Speaker 3 (01:00:52–01:01:43)

And by the way, when we went to the community, we had such a strong sales pitch. And I'm not afraid to say, I said at the time, be able to say, hey, you know what? We're going to build three fire stations, and we're not going to increase your taxes. Which was true because the taxes were frozen with the early amendment.

And the taxes did not go up. Obviously, we don't have that option anymore. And so we've got to present and articulate a proposal that's going to make the most sense to the town. And both town, well, both the Walmart community town meeting and town residents will agree to support.

What's your time frame? Is that this spring? Are you looking next spring? Without a manager sitting in the room, he would love us to have a number to come to the Springtown meeting.

Is that correct, Nick?

Speaker 12 (01:01:44–01:02:12)

So I think we're looking at a two-step process where Springtown meeting this year to request funding for wrapping up the design of the community recommendation. And then following subsequently either to the fall town meeting, fall ballot question vote, spring of the following year for the same process, the ballot question vote and how we vote. Both will be required in the full project. Thank you.

Speaker 3 (01:02:12–01:03:05)

And so Ron, you're right, I would like to visit the community preservation committee soon. I had told my committee members here I was going to try to reach Tom between our last meeting and now I haven't been able to sit down with him. I haven't, but yeah, I'd like to do that sooner. Absolutely, yeah.

I had all the members here, absolutely. So the But getting back to William, we have to kind of get a sense of what is it we're doing. So I've already heard from two of the members of the Atherton Street subcommittee. One member said, look, I prefer option two or three.

And one member said, just option six. Is that correct? Five B. I'm sorry, five.

Five B. Five B, OK.

Speaker 4 (01:03:05–01:03:19)

I was quoting you before, maybe poorly. So I'm going to ask you, your comment on 5B, I just want to be clear if I was mis-ordering things, is that you're concerned that we would have an empty building with no use?

Speaker 12 (01:03:20–01:04:07)

I think that's partially due to a misunderstanding, but I think my concern would be It doesn't sound like there's a clear game plan for what the rest of the building will be used for. It sounds like perhaps the two bays would be available for storage, but what is the game plan for the rest of the building? And we'd be facing all the same problems we have with the building next door, where we have usable space on an upper floor that can't be open to the public without the elevator. So it just presents those challenges.

We have a great meeting room being used. Now, school committees have been there all the time. A lot of boards can be used as a meeting room. Tennessee PC's been going, so it's getting used there.

It's like a dry code still haven't been Fix renovated, but to use with that problem repeat itself here as well. But it's kind of a concern that I, I had it now.

Speaker 3 (01:04:07–01:04:43)

And for everyone that select bullet at the time. That we were building this station. Uh, asked us if we could take some of the fire station funds. To build that conference room with the 1st floor of the building that would.

Vacating only because since we had a contractor on site and doing the work, they could do it significantly cheaper than the town would have to pay in the future to have that rehab. And so we did do that. We didn't take on the cost of the elevator, which would certainly help the second floor. But just the pitch.

I keep thinking of it as an I.O.U.

Speaker 12 (01:04:43–01:05:07)

from the top. perspective then and now it's doing the fire station component of the projects is great and it's much needed but to leave kind of half complete projects because it poses future challenges and future problems and then a bunch of crunch, those are hard ones to kind of go with.

Speaker 3 (01:05:07–01:05:24)

No, that makes sense. And actually, you know, there's certainly in the community, there's a lot of discussion and a lot of comments about what's going to happen to the old East Milton station. Oh, yeah. You know, so Yeah, as you can see.

Okay, other members in the community? I see we have our newest select board member, John.

Speaker 13 (01:05:27–01:06:11)

I'm not up to date on all this stuff, and I'm sorry. That's okay. We were on the committee when we voted to move this forward to the town meeting, and all we had to do was look at the picture behind us. It was horse and wagon pulling the fire trucks out of the…

So the town got their money's worth out of all these stations, and the fire department deserves launch stations that have all those things that find out what happens to them with the exhaust and everything else. And just one question, over eight months ago I'm reading that the city of Quincy got regularly funded for the future central fire station. Did we ever put in for those type of funds?

Speaker 3 (01:06:11–01:06:14)

We, the committee, did not. $25 million. Yeah.

Speaker 4 (01:06:15–01:06:17)

I don't think they were available when we were doing this.

Speaker 3 (01:06:17–01:06:23)

They weren't when we first started. I don't know what the- It's no fault of this committee.

Speaker 13 (01:06:23–01:06:34)

It's just that they just bothered me. Then Mariano gave me $25 million. The parking grant had a statement. Seems like we're always behind the eight ball on this grant.

Speaker 4 (01:06:34–01:06:43)

I honestly don't think they were available, Brian, because we looked. I don't know if you guys were here then, but we looked at all the grants. I think now the state is starting to do that.

Speaker 5 (01:06:44–01:07:30)

No, but the state is trying to push a public safety building authority. They should. They've been trying to do it in the FCA and the Fire Chiefs Association of Massachusetts. It's been one of their biggest pushes over the last, since I've been chief, it's one of those things.

And Senator Timothy was huge for it, and he sponsored the bill. Unfortunately, he stepped down, but other senators and other reps have picked up that fight. I don't know. I know that they've met with everybody.

And I was actually on the stairs of the statehouse. And we ran into the governor. And we brought that up again. And it's been a conversation.

But it just hasn't passed the goal. I know. I'm curious as to what grant they got. It was federal funding.

Speaker 3 (01:07:30–01:07:31)

I don't know.

Speaker 13 (01:07:31–01:07:32)

No, I'm just asking.

Speaker 3 (01:07:33–01:07:36)

I'm not sure. But they, you know, I know John's a good point. I'm glad you asked.

Speaker 13 (01:07:36–01:07:55)

I'll let you know. I appreciate everything for me going and I'm not up to. I'm so high gear here, but I also want to know how come the smoke is taking so long. It's like watching paint dry.

The other day, I'm down there salt in the parking lot. There's two guys up on a lift.

Speaker 3 (01:07:55–01:08:16)

That project, once the ground broke and we started on that, it's had a few setbacks. A lot of it had to do with, believe it or not, that the island in front of it, I know we have some of that. That's my new. No, but it was, it got a lot more.

Making any changes out to the road got pushed behind. Unbelievable.

Speaker 13 (01:08:16–01:08:18)

Say that again? Building right out here.

Speaker 3 (01:08:18–01:08:18)

Yeah.

Speaker 13 (01:08:18–01:08:19)

There's the headquarters.

Speaker 3 (01:08:19–01:08:20)

Yep.

Speaker 13 (01:08:20–01:08:22)

You know, they moved, they made progress.

Speaker 3 (01:08:22–01:08:33)

Yeah, when we broke ground, we expected that building to be done around November of next year. We still do. Yeah, happy to say too.

Speaker 2 (01:08:33–01:08:38)

I agree with your concerns. Something we bring up on a weekly basis.

Speaker 13 (01:08:38–01:08:41)

Is that true? Do they work? Excellent. Oh, good points.

Speaker 2 (01:08:41–01:09:20)

Yeah. Monday, you will see a large delivery what we call panels, their structural insulated paneling. That's going to be going on. The very little work that you're seeing here all needs to be done in order for these panels to go up.

So you'll see a lot of the blocking and what that's going on into the, into the webs of the steel beams as well as the waterproofing and dam proofing that's been going around the perimeter of the foundations. There'll be a large delivery on Monday, and you'll start actually seeing a shell of this building going up. And once that shell goes up, temporary heat will go on, we'll get the slab on grade done, and then you'll see a lot of activity going in as all the trades will start filling up the guts of the building. But point well taken, understood where we're at right now.

Speaker 13 (01:09:20–01:09:25)

We're still on schedule for early winter next year.

Speaker 3 (01:09:26–01:09:26)

Yes.

Speaker 13 (01:09:26–01:09:50)

That's awesome. And I agree with Mr. O'Donnell, I'd hate to see that building I understand what the chief is saying, but plus they had an override to keep Engine 4 open, so the worm committee man trying to hick around if he needed it, that was voted to keep that fire station open. I don't think anybody can close that.

Just a little history, right?

Speaker 3 (01:09:50–01:09:59)

Yeah. I'm escaping the name of the gentleman that used to… Chris Stingis. Chris Stingis, who ran a personal campaign.

He ran it to reopen.

Speaker 13 (01:10:00–01:10:18)

And only in equipment, there's nothing better than having garage space. You know, it's great. I'm standing behind the chief's opinion, Mr. O'Donnell's, and hopefully move this forward for all the taxpayers involved.

Speaker 3 (01:10:18–01:11:00)

All right, great. Anyone else that wanted to address us? So folks, we're way beyond what we were going to be. A lot of that's my fault.

The full committee is supposed to start now, right? And I think the full committee probably expected that we were gonna have a recommendation of sorts from these. I would rather just, if the subcommittee agrees, to basically extend this conversation and move forward with some of the recommendations and see what the full committee would support. The subcommittee, is there anyone on the subcommittee that has a problem with that approach?

I don't know.

Speaker 4 (01:11:00–01:11:08)

So we would not talk about East Miltonwood. continue this discussion and settle this and then talk. Yes. That's makes more sense.

Speaker 3 (01:11:08–01:11:14)

Okay, great. Brian, you're okay with that. All right. So is it the same dialing for good question.

Speaker 11 (01:11:14–01:11:17)

I don't think so.

Speaker 3 (01:11:18–01:11:30)

I didn't contain a motion that we adjourn the applicant subcommittee. Everyone's in the room.