Board: Climate Action Planning Committee
Date: 2025-02-20
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:50–01:25)
All right, it's 6.05 PM, so I will call the February meeting of the Climate Action Planning Committee to order. Welcome, everybody, and thank you for being here. You can begin with public comment. And seeing no members of the public, we can move on from that to item three on the agenda, which is the voting to approve our meeting minutes from the January meeting.
Did anybody have a chance to review those?
Speaker 2 (01:26–01:28)
I reviewed them, they look good to me.
Speaker 3 (01:29–01:32)
Okay. Mr. Chairman, I'll move their adoption.
Speaker 1 (01:33–04:01)
Okay, can I get a second? Ron, Israel seconds. All in favor, say aye. Aye.
All opposed, say nay. That is unanimous. Okay, our voting business is done. So I didn't hear any specific plans from anyone on working group updates, but we have plenty of time for folks to share what they've been up to over the last month.
I personally have put most of my bandwidth into trying to combine the draft topic chapters that we have into a single draft climate action plan document. And that's involved some alignment of formatting, which I think is more than, it's a communication challenge, not just a formatting challenge. And so I'm happy to take these in either order. If there are folks who want to do working group updates first, say so.
My big goal for tonight is to have a conversation about how we get from where we are now to a draft climate action plan that we can use as a focal point for engagement. engaging the public, engaging the select board and town staff. There is a lot going on in town that is not climate action planning, but decisions getting made that will impact our resources for this work for years to come. And it feels urgent to be part of the conversation, but right now, I don't feel like I know how to do that or have the resources in hand to engage effectively.
So that's what I would like to discuss. Yes.
Speaker 4 (04:01–04:09)
Can you say a little bit more about the larger picture within which we're situated within the town?
Speaker 1 (04:11–07:26)
I don't feel… I guess I'll do my best. And I'm sure many of you are as familiar or more familiar with the situation than I am. We, let's see, everybody's familiar with the MBTA Communities Act and the controversy surrounding that.
We, I think most recently are back out of compliance after the select board and planning board decided not to submit an action plan by the deadline on February 15th. So that puts us sort of back in non-compliance status and at a disadvantage for all state grants, forgetting the adjective, competitive state grants or discretionary state grants. Additionally, the town has a structural deficit in the budget. a big focus on the schools.
And any attempt to explain it will will immediately code partisan for somebody. But my understanding is that there's been quite a bit of inflation. The proposition two and a half prevents towns from raising property taxes by more than two and a half percent without an override vote by the public, that in an era of 4% to 5% inflation, that means that you'll eventually need override votes to keep up with rising costs. And COVID relief money and other sort of emergency funds from the state have made it possible to avoid pursuing an override for several years when it's been sort of clear that we were going to have a problem eventually.
And so that's all coming to a head now. And opinions vary with great intensity on the right course of action. So The dollar value of the override that gets approved or not will determine whether the town can have level funding or needs to make cuts, or whether it gives itself enough headroom to not just continue with level service, but add investments in areas that have been under-invested in. Hopefully that's accurate enough, not too controversial, a summary of the situation.
Speaker 4 (07:26–07:28)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (07:28–08:12)
And of course, it's a false choice between investing in new areas. You could also find cuts that everyone could agree on. I am not afraid to say that I would hope to see us in a funding situation where investments in climate action can be made. That's not too partisan for the chair of the Climate Action Planning Committee, I hope.
Right. And so our tool for engaging that conversation would be our Climate Action Plan, or summaries thereof, and our engagement with elected officials and town staff in this process.
Speaker 2 (08:13–08:22)
Do you know when the two grants that would help us when those will be announced.
Speaker 1 (08:22–09:53)
I don't know. We do have a topic six to give you an update on that. My update is no update. I haven't heard a thing.
I don't know when I'm going to hear anything. Great update, Alex. OK. So the draft Climate Action Plan document that I put together so far is linked in the agenda.
Let me throw it up on the screen. And I'd like to thank Ron. Ron did a lot of drafting as well. I'm not showing the draft he sent me, but his work influenced me quite a bit.
And I hope you'll share your perspectives that you shared with me with the group. Give me a second to find it. All right, can folks see the draft on the screen?
Speaker 5 (09:53–09:54)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (09:56–11:01)
OK. So this is a suggestion I took from Ron. It begins with a letter to the select board. I think that's indicative of where we are.
The select board is sort of the executive oversight for town staff. And they're also the entity that created this committee, and we advise the select board. So I think we're reaching the point where we need their sort of active engagement to, as I put it here, refine the plan, align resources, staffing, and priorities to set it in motion. Acknowledging that there's a lot of things that feel much more urgent than this on their plate at the moment, but they also, these decisions they're making now impinge on this plan and kind of have long-term consequences for our ability to do this work.
So now's the time.
Speaker 6 (11:01–11:16)
Alex, I was just going to ask if you've been in touch with anyone there about what we're doing and the timing or what would really be helpful for them or whatever decision making they need?
Speaker 1 (11:21–12:37)
That's a great thing to discuss. So I went before them in September with an update. I have been informally in touch with individuals on the select board. Since then, mostly trying to sort out who could help me with really tactical stuff, setting up the Zooms for the meeting and posting the minutes after Jack left.
I would not say that I've done any sort of bigger picture engagement with the select board over the last few months. So I'm looking for guidance and thought partnership from all of you on how best to do it. I think the tools at our disposal are letters, phone calls, showing up at public comments at various committee meetings, or requesting to be a formal agenda item on a meeting. All these things are possible, but you have to know what you want to say and what you're asking for.
Speaker 6 (12:38–13:07)
I was just thinking that if we knew what kind of questions that they want to have answers to, we can bake that into what we're writing here. So it'll be immediately of value to them. Maybe this already is just looking for a particular, just want to plan. But if they have data that they need to help inform budget decisions or allocations, maybe knowing that ahead of time.
Speaker 1 (13:08–13:46)
Yeah, yes. So we'll get, we should dig into that. I think it's in Ron's draft, he sort of threw out a number in terms of budget allocation. It would be great to, nothing focuses the attention like a dollar number.
I didn't, I feel like we might need to do some work to ground that. in something, but yeah, we'll come back to that. Just, yes.
Speaker 3 (13:46–14:38)
Can I add that we probably have to make this a two-way street situation for the benefit of the select board in the town so that it's not solely a matter of the questions they will ask about something the individual members very probably have had or will have very little time to study and learn about. So that the other side of the street is where we educate them and bring them offers on an ongoing basis so that we keep climate planning for the town of Milton on their radar and on the town's agenda.
Speaker 1 (14:42–14:42)
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (14:45–15:16)
I have a thought, a strategy. Yes. Because it's going to be, even if we try to make it short, it's not going to be a quick read probably. And what if each subgroup attends one of their meetings and presents what we're suggesting?
So may I know, because they meet weekly, every other week?
Speaker 1 (15:16–15:17)
Every other week.
Speaker 2 (15:18–15:30)
So that might be too slow on our end, but also it might, we could break it up into digestible chunks for them.
Speaker 3 (15:31–15:56)
I think that's an excellent idea, having sat in one of those chairs for three years and chaired the board. Too much is not going to be effective. Disaggregating the plan and bringing it to them on a piece-by-piece basis on a regularly scheduled format would probably be very helpful to them. Yeah, I agree.
Speaker 4 (15:56–17:56)
Ron? So I think that a number of things we need to do. Number one is we need to get the working group reports kind of finished and in a similar format with three-year action steps and other things. And once we do that, then we should be able to complete a rough draft of the plan.
But then, I think we need to create an awareness building on a document which takes the main asks, the main issues that are addressed in each of the working group reports and elevates them, makes them interesting, says why they're important, It may be just a page that says, this is our thing. This is what we want to do. This is what we think the town needs us to do. And for more details, you can see our report.
And then third thing I would suggest is that maybe even before presenting or submitting to the select board that we have some sort of public meeting that we host for members of the public, the select board, whosoever, and where we present or preview our plan.
Speaker 2 (18:02–18:03)
How do we get people to come?
Speaker 4 (18:04–18:32)
Well, we do it. I think if we use the Melbourne Times, social media, I mean, even if we get 10 people to show up, that's good. And maybe it could also be online. But at least the exercise of doing it will create a greater awareness that there's something out there that needs attention.
Speaker 2 (18:34–18:40)
Sustainable Milton Green Fair. When is that?
Speaker 1 (18:42–18:49)
Yes. Do something for that for sure. I see Kyle's hand up then Eric.
Speaker 7 (18:51–19:35)
Yeah, and I think on that, anything we did that'd be public facing, we could do it in a context where it's recorded, and then we can keep sharing it with anyone who can't be there. But originally, I was going to say, back to the idea of presenting to the select board, I think in keeping with what we've been talking about in terms of prioritizing which elements of the plan are the most contextually relevant, we can maybe think about condensing like some of the mitigation elements into just a couple of presentations or something like that to help maybe feel like the time buy-in for them makes sense.
Speaker 8 (19:40–19:40)
And Eric?
Speaker 5 (19:41–21:20)
Uh, two things. Um, first the, the staged, you know, um, presentations, uh, I think that that has the capability to be one, keep people's attention better. And so I agree with that. The other is it helps us build.
So if we take some of the areas that might be, um, less contentious or easier to get buy-in for and they go first. So that one, we kind of see what the mood is. Two, we get some early good feedback and then it preps people kind of for the next stage. And then, so we're not walking in with, some people will see doom and gloom and dollar amounts and all this other stuff.
So if we ease into this a little bit, It helps us also prepare for the next meetings and knowing what the groundwork will be. I do have, and then switching to the comment of kind of having events and building support ahead of time, just because this is first time in a group like this, does doing events and trying to gather support for a committee outcome ahead of time, is that seen as, a positive when we come into a meeting or does it look like we were trying to, you know, gather groups, you know, potentially salt, you know, kind of cause ahead of time contention or anything like that. I just, I don't know what's what's best at something like this.
Speaker 1 (21:21–22:35)
I think that depends a lot on context and tone. Um. You know, I think when we bring a draft to the select board and town staff members, it should be in the spirit of. We expect to learn something about what's.
Feasible. Uh, what you know? Or how to get it done or what? You know what to call it?
We should. We should show up expecting to learn something. Um and I think that. Um.
productive conversations. Not that we think that this is the final word and we're trying to mobilize a mob to ram it through, right? Yeah, I'm concerned with that type of visual. I don't think we're in much danger of mobilizing the mob.
Present cons to that. Stephen, you had your hand up.
Speaker 6 (22:36–24:00)
Yeah, just quickly, just to add on to what Kyle and Eric said, and I completely agree with both of them and to what you just said, that context is really key. People, especially given your opening, Alex, people are going to see dollar signs attached to anything. And now that we're sort of at the wrong end of state grants. So, I think providing, we have to think about what the narrative is that we want to have that strings through whatever presentations we have and provide the context in which, you know, that's relevant to that narrative.
So, a little bit of a communications plan. I mean, part of it's lining up what do you say first, which of these you put first, but I think it's also what is the theme and what is the running narrative. So, you know, maybe we want to talk about protecting the Blue Hills from fire and drought, because that's going to immediately be relevant to people who want to go there or their property and sort of work out what, you know, what are we really trying to do? We're trying to protect Milton and we're trying to make this the best place to live.
And so whatever those messages are, I think the plan is part of that, but then we got to extract what are those those key messages we want people to resonate with. And then we're telling our stories through these different presentations.
Speaker 1 (24:02–24:59)
I will say that our core charge is around emissions mitigation. What is the roadmap to net zero by 2050 in alignment with the state law to that effect? And so I don't want to be The topics that sort of dominate mobility and buildings are 98% of that. Those are not necessarily the easiest topics to talk about, but I don't think that we should take the easy way out on it.
If we can get more buy-in and engagement, but also including the risk topics, that's great, but I don't think we should table the sort of leading emissions areas.
Speaker 4 (25:01–26:09)
Ron, you want to say something? Yeah. I think there's some danger in fragmenting the presentation, group by group, because It first of all fragments it, it makes it go on and on and on. And an alternative to that, as I tried to suggest earlier, would be to try to condense maybe just the three or four mitigation working groups, building and energy, transportation, forests, I think there was one other.
in like a single, very short one or two page document that highlights what it is, how we're gonna affect the town and have a more generalized discussion in which people can express greater or lesser interest in different parts of it.
Speaker 1 (26:11–30:01)
That does make sense to me. I mean, there's a very natural split between mitigation and adaptation. I'm not using those words in the section headings for this document because I like I've been around this for a while and I still those those words don't like I know that they're what policy nerds in this area say so we want to be consistent with that terminology but like mitigation doesn't map onto emission reduction for me. I call it emission reduction and adapting to climate risks, but those are the same areas.
Those are two easily separated topics. In terms of how the format helps us focus a narrative, I put an executive summary at the beginning of the document. This is where I think we want to put those messages that we, you know, 98% of people who look at this document are not going to get past page five, right? So like every everything that we want people thinking about and engaging with who are not sort of deeply partnering with us should be in here.
And there's a certain amount of like, context setting that feels unavoidable. But I think the area Um. And Ron has been kind of pushing on this. Over many months, right?
Saying, like, what are the 2 year outcomes? Right? We do have to have everything leading up to 2050 in the plan. Um.
But what are what are we going to be doing next month next week? And the kind of 2 year timescale I think is is, um. good for giving an idea of like where are we starting, especially in the current funding environment, right? And knowing that there's some things in this plan like retrofitting every municipal building with clean energy systems where we have no idea what that's going to cost by the time that we do it.
And figuring that, doing that capital planning associated with that and the technical planning of systems repair and when is end of life for which system and which building like that's that's kind of the the workload for the next couple years. So just to just to finish my ramble here like I have put in two year. priority actions for the buildings and energy chapter in here, because I wrote that chapter and I know what they should be. I took a stab at doing it for forest and watershed conservation, but this section should have that key proposals list, I think, for every working group.
And so far, I focused on emission reduction, those four topics, because I do think that's our core charge. And I would feel comfortable going to them with a draft that only had that. But I, and I don't have the bandwidth to do the adaptation chapters as well. This, this took a lot of time.
But I invite the folks, you know, there's been a lot of great work done on the adaptation topics, and I'd love to see those included at the same time if possible. So if you guys can, can do that, I'd love to see it. Okay, that's enough talking. Were you going to say something?
Speaker 2 (30:03–30:56)
Another idea for outreach, and I think it was a comment I saw that sparked this idea from either you or Eric, and it's this idea of like, you know, what do we want the future to look like? And kind of starting with that story of, you know, 10, 20 years from now, what, you know, what do you want it to look like in Milton? And that could be a source of getting feedback and be like, we took a stab at it. We did some work.
Here are some ideas we have. What do you think of these ideas? What are your ideas? What are you willing to do to get to this future?
And a future which, you know, like maybe we don't need all the mitigation. Yeah, mitigation.
Speaker 1 (30:56–30:57)
Adaptation.
Speaker 2 (30:57–31:22)
Adaptation. I'm with you on that. if the emissions come in line, if they are reduced. And so it's getting people to, yeah, I want that future.
And then we say, OK. We got to sell them on the future that they want. And then this is how we get there.
Speaker 1 (31:22–31:29)
I will say a lot of the climate action plans I've looked at had that section toward the beginning.
Speaker 2 (31:29–31:29)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (31:30–31:45)
To me, it feels like I want that in there, but I don't want it in the first five pages and they're usually on page one or two. And it just feels like a missed opportunity to kind of get people focused on what are you really suggesting right now.
Speaker 2 (31:46–31:50)
Maybe it's not in the plan, but maybe it's how we structure like an open house event.
Speaker 1 (31:54–32:52)
Yeah, as far as like a sort of broadly open discussion with the public, I was hoping to have consulting support by the time we do that, because I feel like there's a, you know, format and sort of facilitation approach that folks like that know how to do that. Yeah, it would be so easy for those conversations, those public events to be not very productive. I'd love to have support. Like in the near term, I'd rather target mapping stakeholders and partners and sort of having targeted conversations with people who might either have some expertise or be in a position to strenuously object or strenuously support and then have more kind of…
So you would, like if we're putting things in an order, right?
Speaker 2 (32:53–32:57)
stakeholder buy-in before general community outreach.
Speaker 1 (32:57–33:55)
If I just am honest about what I'm sort of enthusiastic to do next, I'd rather have like smaller conversations with people who can help or whose feedback is really important or support is really important to have. I am not at all minimizing the need to raise and maintain awareness, but also it's really challenging. We had a couple rounds of trying to do awareness campaigns from Sustainable Milton over the last couple of years, and it is hard. The attention economy is cutthroat.
There's a bunch of people who actually know how to do marketing out there. trying to focus people's attention on stuff that's happening right now. And this is challenging.
Speaker 2 (33:55–34:03)
Sure. And I'm just brainstorming here. Yeah, of course. I'm not proposing we do one thing over another.
Speaker 4 (34:03–34:23)
I just think that before going to the select board, short of having a mob attack, we create some sort of little buzz that we're doing something, something's going on, so we have some ideas and people to pay attention to.
Speaker 1 (34:23–35:57)
I mean, having an overview report of the presentation I did for them in September was specific enough that there were some reactions to it. And people reached out with interest. I mean, people watched select board meetings. And that content, like once you put together kind of an overview, you can do it again and again.
You mentioned the Sustainable Milton Green Fair is coming up. So like having some kind of overview of like here, I'm more vibing with what you said, like cover the four emission reduction areas. You know, if we completed It's still going to be a list of like 30 things, um, but maybe we can make it shorter. Um, but they're pretty specific at this point, you know, there might be two things in there that people that resonate with people positively or negatively and generate some discussion and that'd be great.
Um, and then it's, you know, it could be one time at the select board. Um, you know, one time that. during the Green Fair one time at the library, recorded and put it online for people to watch asynchronously and you could reach a lot of people that way. Arthur.
Speaker 3 (35:59–36:18)
Thanks, Alex. I just wanted to suggest that we might look at what some other communities have done who might be a little further down the road than we are so that we can build upon their best practices that may save us a lot of time and possibly pain.
Speaker 1 (36:22–36:24)
Anybody willing to do that research?
Speaker 9 (36:24–36:25)
I'll take a look at that.
Speaker 1 (36:26–36:26)
OK.
Speaker 2 (36:27–36:39)
I know Canton had an open house for their climate plan. I'm not sure where in the process.
Speaker 1 (36:39–36:45)
I can introduce you to the chair of their climate planning committee. in Canton.
Speaker 2 (36:45–36:49)
Okay, yeah, that'd be great.
Speaker 4 (36:49–36:56)
My brother works on the climate committee on the vineyard. And they've been at it for a while.
Speaker 1 (36:56–37:23)
I will say most of our counterparts have a consulting support to do that part of it. And that's why I'd love to find the money for that. But Matt, you have something to say? You're still muted.
Speaker 10 (37:23–38:05)
I apologize. Yeah, nothing on the outreach yet. And I'm sorry to be so pedantic. It sounds like you have a format, Alex, on this report.
that you and Ron are advocating for. And I'd sure like to know what the expectations are so that we can start to consolidate, summarize, reformat our current drafts. I don't feel like we've finished that discussion yet. I know this is all important, but like, look, if we've got to get a plan done first as the first kind of milestone, I'd sure like to know what the expectations are.
Speaker 1 (38:05–38:13)
Yeah, I don't think it's pedantic at all, because I think the formatting sort of follows the communication challenge.
Speaker 10 (38:13–39:02)
And by the way, I'm for creating the full plan, whether it's adaptation or, sorry, mitigation adaptation, I always get my terms wrong. But at any rate, part one and part two, We're in part two. I would still go ahead and complete the plan in its entirety, even if it is summarized into half a page, because we need to focus on part one. But I think having the full plan, given that most of us have spent time developing the full plan, I think would be fine.
I'm speaking for maybe a small, small group of folks. But in any case, I would be up for completing the entire plan once we agree the format, and then summarizing however you think is best delivered.
Speaker 1 (39:02–43:00)
Yeah, I agree with that. Why don't I take a few minutes to walk through this whole document and sort of describe what's there, the formatting choices I made, how that relates to what I'm trying to do. And then we can, this is not set in stone, right? So we can discuss.
So it begins with the executive summary, like I said, There's some inevitable context setting. What are the goals of this plan? What's the state level context? What role do we think the town has to play in that?
But I think the core of this is key actions over the next two years. And those are the things you want the decision makers and key partners to focus on and respond to. What do you want them to do in the next two years? And if those aren't the right things, then they need to come out of conversation with you.
So how we get there is really like providing context on the state's roadmap. And some of the sort of necessary outcomes. it listed in some real buzz, both positive and negative, when I put them in front of the select board and that audience in September. The role of the town sort of speaks a bit to strategy in terms of, you know, most of the emissions are from private residential sources.
So town's gonna take a, the way I'm putting it, like a supportive and encouraging role rather than a coercive role, because I think people will be worried about that. Leading by example in municipal operations has more leverage than the sort of percentage of the GHG inventory might suggest. So even though it's 2% of total town emissions, like seeing electric school buses and heat pump renovations in school buildings, would have outsized impact on people's private choices. Resilience and preparedness is also an area where the town can do a lot.
So key actions in the next two years, I think an expectation here is that each of the working groups needs to populate this section with their short list of things. What do you want to emphasize now and get people focused on and make them concrete and actionable. There can be more, you know, and I think in like bullet list format, cause this has to be short, short, short, right? Sure.
Yeah, that feels fair. I do have it's, I do have it kind of, and this makes it longer, but, but kind of broken apart by, who the audience is, like town staff, municipal facilities, but also for residents, right? So there is this divide between private action and town action. So we need to speak to residents, but if we were all doing our part to execute this plan that's coming together, what does that mean for your house and the buildings that you're responsible for or that you live in?
Speaker 2 (43:01–43:33)
Um, so just so I understand you, um, so actions the next two years you have for town staff and elected leaders and then buildings and energy. So there would be a transportation setting, uh, heading in bold with one to three things. I want, we want the town to do, and then repeat that for the other. sections in that teal color.
Speaker 1 (43:33–43:46)
And unfortunately, if we do both mitigation and adaptation in here, there's going to be 12 bold headings with three. I mean, it's going to get long. Yeah.
Speaker 4 (43:47–44:05)
I don't know how to… Are you saying that there's two-year action plan steps, each of the target audiences gets a set of those for each working group? Is that what you're saying?
Speaker 1 (44:06–44:09)
That's what I was doing. It is a lot.
Speaker 4 (44:09–44:28)
Yeah, I hear you. I would suggest that there just be two to three two-year action steps per group, period, regardless of trying to subdivide it. Because it does get pretty complicated.
Speaker 1 (44:29–44:45)
And maybe there could be one list for residents, sort of separate. As an individual, what are the key things I would need to do in the next two to 25 years?
Speaker 4 (44:45–45:21)
Yeah, I think that the key idea, at least my thought behind the two-year action steps, is that those are steps that are needed to begin to operationalize what's in each working group's plan. So for some working groups, maybe those steps relate directly to town members. For other working groups, maybe they relate to town government. I mean, I don't know.
I don't think.
Speaker 1 (45:22–46:01)
I do think that if I'm not part of town government in any way, but I'm interested in this issue and I Go find the plan. There should be a succinct list of like these are the eight things that private persons in Milton ought to be doing. Because there's no success for this plan without widespread collective action. private individuals who have no obligation whatsoever to do anything that the town tells them to, except in states where there's like taxes or bylaws involved.
Speaker 4 (46:01–46:37)
Yeah, but maybe we're not even gonna get to that place in the first year or two, like maybe, I'm just making this up, maybe an initial step would be to do an assessment of the town's population regarding the modes of transportation they use to get to and from school. And that's a kind of consultant task that involves asking people but not asking them to do something.
Speaker 1 (46:37–47:18)
I think we know what the behavior changes required are. What we don't know is how to make those feasible for everybody feasible and desirable for everybody. And so the I would prefer to put that list out there, knowing that it's not like one of those things is get rid of your natural gas, heat, or oil, heat, and install heat pumps like that's not actionable for a lot of people. It's not affordable.
It's scary, and people are not going to do it just because we wrote it down a plan. But like, it should be there to get the conversation started.
Speaker 2 (47:21–47:34)
Would this be like, since it's a draft, maybe we follow this template, we get all of it in there, we see how long it is, and then we prune it.
Speaker 1 (47:34–48:19)
Well, I think I take the feedback that having 1.3.1, 1.3.2, 1.3.3, each one having 12 subheadings, I'm willing to abandon that right now. Sort of three key actions aimed at the sort of town mobilizing against the plan. I will separate out the stuff for residents. And that doesn't need to be broken down by working group.
I think that there is a… I have a list of sort of eight things across all areas that I've had up on the Sustainable Milton website for several years, and I'm happy to write that into a short section.
Speaker 2 (48:19–48:28)
Right, yeah, like a resident might not care which working group that suggestion came from. They might just be like, oh, that's it.
Speaker 1 (48:28–48:55)
So I'm happy to take that part, and I will consolidate these bits. And I think the ask of you all is to get those top three mobilization steps written down in this section. Can we set a timeline for that? Because that's really, I think that's the key thing that we need in order to start engaging.
Speaker 2 (48:56–49:03)
Next month? Or about a week before the next meeting, so three weeks.
Speaker 1 (49:05–54:52)
So before we settle that, let me finish showing what's here, right? Sure. Introduction, this is still a little loose. This is sort of more quantitative detail from the state's roadmap plan.
I haven't really written this section, honestly. There was a bunch of extra stuff in here. Ron didn't like it. I took it out.
Unneeded. But I do think, like, I think at some point we need to sort of frame for people what this plan is and what it isn't, to try to avoid what feels to me like pointless controversy. People can be forgiven for feeling like there's sort of a lot of coercive policymaking on this topic, and they're tired of being told what to do. And there will be things in the plan that will clearly be expensive, but we have no idea how expensive.
We are not asking people to commit sight unseen to huge expenses, right? And so like having something in here that kind of sets those expectations for like, this is laying out what needs to happen so that we can figure out whether or not it's possible or how to do it, right? You can't work through those challenges without sort of knowing what's on the list. So this is not a pre-commitment to expensive stuff, it's a roadmap.
Then section three is the mitigation topics, sort of the meat of the plan for transportation, buildings, waste, and Conservation. Conservation is sort of a weird hybrid topic because it has a lot of adaptation dimensions, but it's also, it's the net and net zero, so it has this big, it has a bigger emissions dimension than even waste, according to our greenhouse gas inventory. So within each of these sections, there's this kind of an intro paragraph of context where you talk about you know, what's the portion of Milton's emissions? What are the sort of key elements of the Commonwealth's roadmap in this area?
Then a table of goals. And so this is where I'm not trying not to get into the how, but just like what's gonna happen, right? What are the quantitative outcomes that we'll see on what timelines and what are the metrics we'd use to track it. And then strategies and recommended actions under that.
And so I think there should be some more freedom in the format. And these, it's still pretty light in terms of context setting and explanation right now, but I think that's appropriate for a draft. And so I have, for buildings, transportation, conservation, and waste. I have taken your draft chapters and kind of put them into this format to the best of my abilities.
You know, I know we've been talking a lot about goals versus strategies versus actions. There were many instances where I thought some of your goals were strategies and some of your actions were strategies, you know, so I have, recategorize those in the way that made sense to me. And I offer this back for your, these are your sections, right? So I'm just trying to communicate to you what I think makes sense to me.
And hopefully you can sort of engage on these chapters until they make sense to you. And then, so getting into adaptation, I haven't done that. I think that the structure I used for the mitigation sections is not an obvious fit for adaptation, in particular, that goals and metrics table. Maybe that becomes like a key risks list or something.
But going back to Matt's I would love to see all this in the first draft as well. You guys have done a ton of work, a ton of good work. But I am saying that I don't personally have the bandwidth to do that. So I would love to see some folks who've been doing all that good work kind of step up to integrate your drafts into this document.
in a way that feels cohesive on the same timeline that we're sort of getting a draft ready to share with the select board. All right, that's what I have to say. Lisa.
Speaker 2 (54:53–56:28)
Two things. I think at the minimum, we want the decision makers to consider the plan, our recommendations in their decision-making, right? So if down the road, a new building's built, things are retrofitted, like this is, we're asking the government, you know, the town to make this part of their decision-making process. It may not always go that way, but, you know, they should understand that, you know, we're gonna, If you don't pay now, you're going to pay later some way, right?
And having that be part of the conversation. And then second, unrelated, as I look at the adapting to risk, if we're trying to make this scene more concise, could we combine drought or heat waves, drought and wildfire? Because they're all kind of like symptoms of the same thing. and intense storms and flooding, and then energy security.
So like kind of three, like lack of water, too much water, and then the separate category of energy. I don't know if having less headings makes it actually shorter, but I'm just throwing that out there.
Speaker 1 (56:32–57:51)
I think that's, I'll leave that for the folks who've written that content, whether it's easy to consolidate or not. There are certainly recommendations in those drafts that are more overarching, right? I can't remember who's, I think it was the HeatWave chapter that says, hey, the town needs to have a stronger ability to reach residents with urgent messages. And like more sort of widespread understanding of how to use that capability.
Maybe that's not something that should be buried down in heat waves, but kind of pulled up at a sort of… So another thing I've struggled with is there's sort of like governance and resourcing recommendations things like hiring an energy manager or sustainability director to kind of steward this work. That doesn't naturally fit within one topic. Maybe we need a section for stuff like that.
Speaker 11 (57:51–57:54)
Yeah.
Speaker 10 (57:54–58:12)
Alex, wouldn't that come up into this master list that's going to sit at the beginning, which is the top two or three recommendations from each. And that is on our list is resident alerts. And so look, if you see that three times, then you know that that's going to get brought up too.
Speaker 1 (58:14–58:25)
Yeah. So I think when we restructure that section, we'll have a kind of overarching governance. I know part of what's stopping me is I just don't have the right word for what to call that.
Speaker 8 (58:26–58:34)
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
Speaker 2 (58:35–58:38)
Well, like foundation goals.
Speaker 1 (58:38–58:54)
Yeah. Foundation setting. I don't know. Wordsmithing is hard in the evening.
But how are folks feeling kind of high level about this?
Speaker 10 (58:58–59:09)
We got it. We got a format. I think at least for our groups that, you know, that was the hope is that we would at least land on a format and we can get to work.
Speaker 8 (59:09–59:23)
Oh, I see some chat. What's going on in the chat?
Speaker 1 (59:24–01:00:25)
Yeah. So I think just in terms of, um, action steps. We were talking about filling out the two-year priorities. We gotta agree to a timeline for that.
Sooner is better, I think. A full month from now, Milton election fever will be in full swing, if it isn't already. Yeah. And then who from the kind of adaptation side wants to lead the charge on integrating drafts into this format?
Then I'll let you think about that.
Speaker 2 (01:00:25–01:00:29)
Yeah. Who touched their nose last?
Speaker 8 (01:00:40–01:00:42)
I'm going to look at my calendar.
Speaker 1 (01:01:05–01:01:23)
The third Thursday of March is the 20th. This would March 6th be feasible for folks to kind of extract their two-year actions?
Speaker 9 (01:01:26–01:01:29)
I think the waste group could come up with those.
Speaker 1 (01:01:30–01:01:39)
I would think that you guys have already done a lot of this thinking and writing. It's really like, okay, I've got a bunch of stuff. What are my top three?
Speaker 9 (01:01:39–01:01:47)
I think that'd be pretty easy. contact Arthur. We may have a meeting, but I think that would be pretty easy to come up with that.
Speaker 1 (01:01:54–01:02:00)
I'm going to assume silence is acquiescence to the March 6th timeline.
Speaker 10 (01:02:01–01:02:02)
No problem.
Speaker 1 (01:02:03–01:03:52)
Okay, nice. And then so imagining that that was done, going back to how to get the conversation going. I think we heard two different proposals. One was sort of breaking our plan into topics and sort of going back to the select board repeatedly with an overview of each topic versus Um.
Uh sort of overview of all the key recommendations across Mitigation. All at once. I kind of favor that. Um.
Not trying to do mitigation and adaptation at the same time, because that's sprawling. Maybe trying to get up trying to get into the select once we've got these sort of key things. And hopefully, I think once we see them written down, then it's, you know, okay, we'll go and show them to them. What are we asking for?
In a perfect world, I'd love to have a budget allocation that I'm asking for and to be able to defend it. I think you threw a number out. I didn't feel like I could defend that in a million years. I don't know how to get there, honestly.
Speaker 4 (01:03:52–01:04:00)
Yeah, I don't know whether funding for our work that we should expect it is going to come from the town.
Speaker 1 (01:04:01–01:04:14)
Yeah, it doesn't have to. Yeah. We've been pursuing grant funding for consulting support and for staff. And, you know, are we going to get it?
Speaker 4 (01:04:15–01:04:29)
Reactively, we could at some point proactively seek funds for what we're proposing to do from interested sources.
Speaker 1 (01:04:29–01:05:44)
You know, and some of it is stuff that's going to happen anyway. And like you said before, Lisa, we're requesting that they take this into account and what they're doing already. So like an example is when we met with the consolidated facilities director and the superintendent about the energy manager grant, it came out that the rooftop units on Collicott and Cunningham are 20 years old and they're not actively failing, but that's end of life for HVAC equipment. You know, our professional facilities manager knows that it's time to look into how long they've got left, like what state are they in and what's it going to cost to replace them, right?
So next year, he's going to do that study one way or another. And he was already looking for funding to bring in a consultant to help with that. If we got the energy manager grant, that would be great because that energy manager could do that. Right?
We would like to have, you know, options that are aligned with this climate roadmap considered.
Speaker 4 (01:05:45–01:05:50)
Can we list that as one of the two-year action steps? Mm-hmm. Yeah, that would be great.
Speaker 1 (01:05:50–01:06:24)
I mean, I think what I have now is, like, capital planning for all municipal facilities. That's a little broader and vaguer than that. Oh, bye, Eric. Thanks.
Anyway, wow, so it is 7-10. I got the sense that there are no working group updates, but if I'm wrong, let's pause to
Speaker 10 (01:06:26–01:06:39)
All right, Alex, we sent you some updates. This would have been late January, early February from meetings with Karen Lothrop from DCR and with Chief Madden from Milton Fire.
Speaker 1 (01:06:41–01:06:51)
Yeah, why don't you speak to those for a few minutes? Because I've been focused on the mitigation side, so I didn't really dig into them. And anyway, I think the group would definitely be interested in hearing about that.
Speaker 10 (01:06:52–01:10:41)
Okay. Um, yeah, quickly. So presented the plan to them again, Karen law, herp is the fire warden for DCR for our region. And then, uh, everybody knows chief Madden from, from Milton fire, uh, showing the plan, um, very aligned overall with the plan.
Um, and in fact, several of the recommendations from the plan. So we're, we're working a little bit in a vacuum that with them, before we really got into the plan and then brought them the plan to help validate. A lot of the recommendations in the plan were started already at some level. So as an example, we said, we're probably going to need some new equipment.
And Chief Madden said, look, the new truck should be delivered in two weeks. As an example, I'm over-dramatizing a bit. But so many of the elements of the plan were already in there own planning, and we're a work in progress, so that was good. So we updated our draft plan to reflect those items that are already on the go.
And then I would say kind of the holy grail within wildfires is this idea of a community wildfire protection plan. They've done these all over the Commonwealth, We looked at the plans from the Vineyard and also from Cape Ann. And so Karen provided some resources on how we might move that forward to engage with some consultants, look at some potential grant funding as well. So we did a little research on whether Milton is even in scope in terms of grants.
Turns out we are. We are in terms of risk. not in terms of, and these are federal grants, not state grants. So we're in scope for grants based on our risk category, albeit not based on our economics.
They prioritize high risk and low income, and we're high risk, high income. But okay, we're still in scope. And then Karen came back just in the last maybe two weeks and said, look, not only are you in scope, but we actually might have funds at the DCR level where we could partner with you. Now I've followed up twice with Karen on that subject and she's gone dark.
And it could be because she's busy or because she's also catching wind of the topic that we talked about at the beginning of the meeting. In other words, Milton is kind of on the naughty list. and they're going to use their funds for other towns. Don't know.
But they do have funds at a DCR level to do things like community wildfire protection plans. Just don't know whether we're going to be in that scope in terms of where they might partner up. But OK, we have a federal grant roadmap if we want to apply for grants. And, you know, and then we have a resource of consultants locally that did a couple of plans already, uh, that we could reach out to, to, to get an idea of funding and an idea of how long these things would take and, and how much they would cost.
So yeah. And now, okay, we're, I think we've got a format and, and I think we can move from where we are today to a few priorities for the next 24 months. And. and, you know, summarizing some of the content that we've already built.
Speaker 1 (01:10:44–01:11:44)
Sounds good. I do want to say, you know, when we're sort of pulling out those priority action steps for the next two years into the executive summary, totally acknowledging that in many cases we have more planning and research we need to do to really focus in on what needs to happen. I'd really like to avoid any to your action steps that involve creating more plans. I don't want to deliver a plan to plan.
So to the extent that we can identify sort of tangible stuff like by this firefighting equipment, Even if we're not certain that that's the most important thing right now, and we can caveat, but I'd like to keep it tangible at that level. Steve?
Speaker 6 (01:11:44–01:12:29)
Yeah, just to the point that I think you raised at the beginning of this last conversation, I would not rely on any federal grants at this point. There is, based on executive orders, all the grant programs that I'm aware of are being reviewed. A number of them are being rescinded or paused. So as we're planning sort of the next couple of years out, I think that we should really think about state, local, nonprofit support more than access to federal grant funds.
especially in this area.
Speaker 2 (01:12:37–01:13:06)
Related to that, you guys might remember that we used the National Renewable Energy Lab under DOE, and we had an expert match, and we'd been working with this woman there for months, and the plan was She helped us with, it was just about to be published, and now she has no idea when it can be published. We have access to the draft.
Speaker 1 (01:13:07–01:13:09)
Do we? I don't think she ever sent it to us.
Speaker 2 (01:13:09–01:13:10)
She hasn't sent it.
Speaker 1 (01:13:10–01:13:21)
Even in the last administration, they were kind of very formal about delivering the documentation of their recommendations. And so we don't have it.
Speaker 2 (01:13:22–01:13:24)
We have the previous drafts, though.
Speaker 1 (01:13:24–01:13:34)
Do we? I thought we saw it on a screen share. Anyway, if we do have a draft, I think we were explicitly told not to.
Speaker 2 (01:13:34–01:13:36)
Well, it was for internal use.
Speaker 1 (01:13:36–01:13:37)
Yeah, circulated publicly.
Speaker 2 (01:13:39–01:13:57)
But I could imagine there being cuts and layoffs to the Natural Renewable Energy Lab, which is unfortunate. I did check LinkedIn, and she seems to still be employed.
Speaker 1 (01:13:59–01:14:04)
Any other comments?
Speaker 10 (01:14:04–01:14:48)
Just one other thing that's kind of for Ron. And on these plots, Ron, that you want to do to get the tree stock, some estimation of a base on a tree stock. The Friends of the Blue Hills and the DCR are working on some test and control plots, principally around the wildfires. So you could imagine a couple of plots in the wildfires, which, you know, in the wildfire zones, which might not really help what you're trying to get at, but the control plots might.
So I'm going to plug you in with Jen Klein, our executive director, and see if maybe what's happening there might also help out what you've got in your plan.
Speaker 4 (01:14:49–01:14:56)
You know, could you also include Fiona? Is she on this? Cool, so she's not at the attorney level.
Speaker 8 (01:14:56–01:14:57)
Oh, there she is.
Speaker 12 (01:14:57–01:15:04)
Hi, I'm here. Yes, I've been lurking. I'm afraid I'm solo parenting tonight, so I've been mostly off video. But I am here.
Speaker 10 (01:15:05–01:15:11)
Yeah, could you include her, Matt? You bet. Yeah, I'll send an email tomorrow with all of you guys on copy.
Speaker 8 (01:15:12–01:15:15)
OK.
Speaker 1 (01:15:25–01:15:33)
Okay, well, is there anything else that folks would like to discuss before we call it an evening?
Speaker 2 (01:15:37–01:16:05)
Let's keep fighting the good fight here. It's discouraging. I've attended, I was at a renewable energy conference in Boston last week, and I attended a webinar for women in renewable energy today related to, you know, changes in our administration and it's a lot. Being with you all gives me hope.
Speaker 1 (01:16:08–01:19:27)
This project was always going to be a non-linear path. I think even under really favorable policy environment, this is not a straightforward undertaking and one with a very high probability of failure within its own terms. And I think it's important to keep in mind that the best available science says net zero by 2050 will sort of minimize the the risks of really serious consequences of climate change. Net zero by 2060 is also a lot better than doing nothing.
Net zero by 2070 is a lot better than doing nothing. And a lot can happen in a decade, let alone two or three decades. And so maintaining a hopeful, hope and optimism are not exactly the same things. I'm inspired by Paul Farmer.
I don't know if you guys read that book, Mountains Upon Mountains, but his quote about fighting the long defeat, that there's a lot of meaning and value in showing up to do the work, even if it kind of looks like you're losing locally. And in the very long run, losing can turn into victory. So I think we just have to keep working at it and make progress where we can as the environment changes. And honestly, as somebody who is really in favor of moving as fast as we can on this stuff, I definitely felt like there was overreach and excessively coercive policy making happening in the Biden administration.
We're having a very strong reaction to that, I think an overreaction. But this is an opportunity to focus on non-coercive encouragement type activities. There are still a lot of people in town who are interested in installing heat pumps or getting an EV. And we can do a lot to help them do that and also make sure that they have good outcomes so that when the public mood and policy environment changes again, we're in a different and hopefully better place.
And so far. I hope you all have a good month and don't be a stranger. I love hearing from you. even if I don't respond, but I do try to respond.
So with that, I will entertain motions to adjourn.
Speaker 2 (01:19:28–01:19:29)
I'll move to adjourn.
Speaker 1 (01:19:29–01:19:37)
Lisa moves to adjourn. Any seconds? Second. Ron seconds.
All in favor? Aye. All right. Good night, everybody.
Speaker 8 (01:19:37–01:19:38)
See you next month.