Board: Planning Board
Date: 2025-04-10
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:46–01:03)
Good evening and welcome to the 35th meeting of fiscal year 2025 for the Milton Planning Board. At this time, I would like to now call the meeting to order and begin by introducing the members and our staff. We can start with Cheryl, if you'd like to start. Sure, Cheryl Tagayas, secretary.
Sean.
Speaker 2 (01:04–01:04)
Sean Fahey, member.
Speaker 1 (01:05–01:06)
Maggie Ophiel, member.
Speaker 2 (01:06–01:07)
Jim Davis, member.
Speaker 1 (01:07–01:14)
And Meredith Hall, serving as chair. For our staff this evening, we have Cheyenne.
Speaker 3 (01:14–01:17)
Diane Frazier, Assistant Director of Planning.
Speaker 1 (01:17–02:22)
Great, and I don't think Julia is on yet. I'm here. Oh, Julia is here. All right, Julia, if you'd like to introduce yourself, sorry.
Julia Getman-Clerk. Terrific, thank you. Now for the administrative items. We don't have any minutes to approve this evening, so we can move on to the discussion of our next meeting dates.
We have a community forum scheduled for April 17th, which is going to be on MBTA zoning, and it will be at the Council of Aging at 7 p.m. And then our next regularly scheduled meeting is April 24th. So those will be the next dates. We can now open up for citizen speak.
If there is anyone online or the public who would like to speak, please raise your hand. I'm not seeing anyone in the public in person. But if there is anyone who would like to speak on anything that is not on the agenda, please raise your hand.
Speaker 3 (02:23–02:26)
We have two hands. So the first is going to be Anthony Larkin.
Speaker 1 (02:28–02:32)
Welcome, Anthony. You can state your name and address for the record, please.
Speaker 4 (02:33–06:39)
Sure, thank you very much. Hi, my name is Anthony Larkin. I live at 1061 Brush Hill Road with my wife and daughter. We're neighbors to Mr.
Erkovic and Ms. Leo and also Mr. Kamek who spoke during the meeting earlier this week. I first want to say I just have a huge appreciation for the planning board and its members.
I think you have an incredibly difficult task at hand and I thank you for all the time and effort that's gone into the planning so far. I think there's zero chance you're going to be able to make everybody happy. regarding the MBTA Communities Act and compliance, but I think the best possible outcome is one that brings common sense and protects our community over the long term. I'm speaking up tonight to bring some additional perspective to the planning board to further help with the analysis, particularly around the proposed Reedville Station sub-district.
So I have a couple points to share one being that do the deposit river and the surrounding wetlands, the actual walkability and access to transit and amenities from that proposed reveal substation or sub district doesn't, in my opinion, meet the proximity requirements. even though it's technically within the half-mile radius as the crow flies. And outlining the requirements, the pedestrian route, if you map it out, is almost a full mile and takes almost 20 minutes to walk because you have to go out and around the Neponset River and the wetlands. And that crosses major boulevards and multiple busy intersections.
And in my opinion, against the spirit and intention of the MBTA Communities Act, which is to build contiguous communities in proximity to transit stations. And Zoe, who I think has been doing a great job from Utah, used a similar argument to remove a lower parcel from the Bluehill outstation sub-district proposal, citing that it's not contiguous with the others and it has multiple crossings over busy intersections. I think the same is true for the entire proposed Reedville station sub-district, and the same logic should be applied and excluded from the proposal entirely. Now, the other thing that's important when you look at this area, the maps that you've been using in the decks and the graphics are difficult to see the actual topography of the land.
But if you look at it in a satellite view in the map, and if you actually come walk the area, you'll see how densely wooded those lots are and how much the wetlands are bordering those lots. There are many adjacent to the Raposo River, and any development there would have a negative environmental impact. The wetlands also restricts access to the parcels. So not only the southernmost parcel that was recommended for removal, which is actually my home, also the second southernmost parcel has a very securitous driveway that runs all the way up to the bottom of Big Blue.
And there's a guardrail that runs all the way along there because it's a very steep embankment down to the wetlands. It's making access to that parcel, one, either having to destroy the wetlands or somehow gain access, which would be difficult. So then if you exclude that parcel as well, you're looking at only six smaller parcels. And if you use the logic that Mistugius Togay has raised on single family areas to use a lower density approach, not radically transform such neighborhoods.
If you even took those single family partials and made them into two or three family parcels, you're looking at a maximum of 18 units in that area, which hardly makes a dent in the overall target and doesn't seem worth changing the face of the neighborhood. So lastly, I'll just say I'm in support of working towards compliance, but I think it's important that we avoid the practice of spot zoning in order to get there. This is more than just a mathematical exercise getting numbers to work with our fit. This type of development and zoning needs to be done responsibly.
Multifamily zoning should be focused on extending or increasing density in areas where multifamily zoning already exists. or adjacent to commercial districts and directly adjacent to transit. We should not be spot zoning high density housing into green space, adjacent to protected wetlands and transforming neighborhoods into mini cities where it's not reasonable in proximity to transit, especially if it's heavily wooded and teeming with wildlife. So thank you for listening tonight.
Speaker 1 (06:40–06:46)
Great comments. Thank you. And next, Cheyenne.
Speaker 3 (06:47–06:52)
I don't see any hands up. There were hands, but are longer. Okay.
Speaker 1 (06:53–06:53)
And we will.
Speaker 3 (06:55–06:58)
Bernadette raised her hand. Yeah. Okay.
Speaker 5 (06:59–07:01)
Bernadette. Hi.
Speaker 6 (07:03–08:28)
Hi there. Welcome. Thank you. Sorry about that.
I lowered my hand. I live at 117 Walcott Road, but for the paper street, I have bought St. Pius directly. St.
Pius Church. I agree 100% with what the earlier person said just now. This is just more human encroachment on the beautiful natural habitats that we have here. It's the reason I moved here 20 years ago.
I'm originally from Dorchester Lower Mills. I'm all for you know, complying and I understand the need for housing, but I agree that it should be in, you know, compatible with in areas where there is that already that type of housing. We have one family homes here and that particularly the field next to St. Pius Church is teeming with wildlife and it's something that we enjoy.
And I don't think that that type of development would be appropriate here. And again, also, I walked it out myself. It's a mile to the station from here. That's all.
I just wanted to say that. And thanks for working with us on that. We appreciate it.
Speaker 5 (08:29–08:30)
Thank you.
Speaker 7 (08:32–08:34)
Okay.
Speaker 5 (08:34–08:36)
All right. Did we hear Bernadette's last name?
Speaker 7 (08:36–08:37)
No.
Speaker 5 (08:37–08:39)
Bernadette, what is your last name for the record, please?
Speaker 6 (08:40–08:45)
Kenny. Kenny. K-E-N-N-Y. Great.
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (08:48–09:06)
Perfect. Okay. Thank you. Yes.
Thank you so much. Great. So if there's no one else, that will conclude our citizen speak, and there will be opportunity to speak later on other agenda items. Cheyenne, we can now go to you for your staff update.
Speaker 3 (09:08–09:22)
Sure. So my only update was that we are having the community forum next week at the Council on Aging. It'll be both hybrid, so Zoom and in person for those who can't make it in person, and it'll be at 7 p.m. That's my only update.
Speaker 1 (09:24–09:32)
Great, perfect, thank you. And now, do we have anyone online from 10 Bassett Street?
Speaker 3 (09:35–09:36)
Not that I can see.
Speaker 1 (09:37–09:51)
Okay. So, and I can read from the email or, Cheyenne, if you wanna actually tee this one up and just explain the email that you received from 10 Bassett Street, and then I can read the email.
Speaker 3 (09:53–10:23)
Sure. So we received an email, I believe it was earlier this week, Saturday, maybe, from the 10 Bass Street attorney, and they were just basically withdrawing their application without prejudice so that they can be able to come back once they get a little more information for the board and I'm sure for because they've been between our two boards. So they are currently withdrawn. So there is no active application with us at the time.
Speaker 4 (10:24–10:25)
Okay.
Speaker 1 (10:25–11:21)
We technically, we continued it to the public hearing at 7.05. So actually, we still have the public hearing piece is open on our end. So tonight, I think we have to vote to accept their withdrawal and close the public hearing. Yeah.
So I'll just read you the email that was sent. Chairperson Hall, my clients, Michael Mignosa and Mark Mignosa have requested that the pending application for modification of a prior site plan review presently scheduled for a hearing before the town of Milton Planning Board on April 10th, 2025 at 7 p.m. will be withdrawn without prejudice at the time of the upcoming hearing. Respectfully, I would ask that you as a chairperson request that the planning board take a vote to allow my clients to withdraw their pending application without prejudice.
So sign Michael Modestino, attorney.
Speaker 8 (11:22–11:28)
So with that- When we make the motion, do we need to make a motion to close the public hearing as well?
Speaker 1 (11:28–11:36)
We'll do that after. We'll do that separate. So we're going to first a motion to accept the withdrawal without prejudice.
Speaker 8 (11:35–11:40)
I make a motion to accept the withdrawal of 10 Bassett Street site plan modification without prejudice.
Speaker 1 (11:42–11:54)
Second. Is there a second? Second. Great.
All right. All in favor? Aye. Great.
Now I would take a motion to close the public hearing for 10 Bassett Street. So moved. Second.
Speaker 9 (11:55–11:55)
Second.
Speaker 1 (11:55–12:30)
All in favor? Aye. Thank you. Did we do that right, Dad?
Just making sure. Okay. No. Okay, so perfect.
So now, now, let's see, just double checking here. We are, We are now welcoming Attorney Corcoran representing 111 Highland Street. Modification of special permit. Great, welcome.
Speaker 10 (12:30–12:38)
Thank you. Good evening and you know it's been almost a year since I've been here.
Speaker 2 (12:38–12:38)
Is that a record?
Speaker 7 (12:39–12:42)
I think it is.
Speaker 10 (12:43–16:24)
The last night I was here was the night that you voted to approve the special permit, April 29 of last year. And we're back because a whole lot has happened in the interim, all of which has arrived at all objections to the plans that were submitted have been put addressed, dismissed, whatever. And I'll go through quickly the litany of that. But if you recall, the special permit itself contemplated an amendment to the final plan set based on the fact that we were under appeal of the order of conditions issued by the Conservation Commission in October of 23.
We had been appealed by one group of neighbors to the DEP. We were appealed by a second group of neighbors Superior court matter was stayed really pending the DEP review of the stormwater and related issues. And the plans, the final plans that had been approved by the board relative to the layout of the project, the building, the reduction and reduce the scale of the building. by a few thousand feet.
We reduced parking area in the back. We had moved what I call the noisemakers, the dumpster, the transformer from the front of the building to the rear of the building. All those had been done in the process of closing out the special permit, but we still had to go back. We had to follow through with that under the DEP appeal process.
DEP issued a superseding order of conditions in November of 24, so we were under appeal with DEP for about a year and certainly seven or eight months post the closing of the special permit. The special permit understood that that process was going and provided for a means of modifying the special permit when the DEP processes were complete. In the meantime, we were also, as you know, under appeal with Karen Bacardi and Gene Irwin, a third set of appellants to the Superior Court on the special permit that was granted. And we're gearing up recently for pretty significant discovery leading to trial.
And we arrived in March at a settlement. with them, and the result of which is that their appeal was dismissed. And the day after, the Superior Court action pending on the order of conditions was dismissed. So as of March 18th, there are no appeals pending.
There is nothing hanging over the project. So Paul Avery is with me on Zoom. He can walk through quickly the minor modifications to the plan set so that you can see the changes that were made in accordance with DEP's process. And then I would ask the board to adopt the modification, essentially changing Exhibit A, which lists all of the plans with a new Exhibit A that exists that lists now the final plan set.
Speaker 1 (16:26–16:30)
Okay. Yep, that would be great if we can introduce Paul to walk us through those changes.
Speaker 10 (16:31–16:56)
And in the interim, while he's, we did go before the Conservation Commission in January to have them review the plan changes that were approved by DEP and they made a specific finding in accordance with the town's bylaw that the changes represent an insignificant change in the original proposal and will cause no significant difference in the impact of the activity on the interest identified in the town's wetland bylaw.
Speaker 1 (16:59–17:01)
Okay, Paul.
Speaker 11 (17:01–17:31)
Hi, so I prepared and I trust you received a letter dated March 31st, which summarizes all the changes that occurred to the plans as we went through and concluded the appeal process for the superseding order of conditions with the. I can walk through those, and if you'd like me to show you what these items are on the plans, if you… That would be great, yeah. Yeah, if I can get screen sharing capability here somehow.
Speaker 3 (17:34–17:34)
Yes, I made it.
Speaker 11 (17:36–17:37)
I need to be promoted or something.
Speaker 3 (17:45–17:49)
It doesn't let me promote on here, but I can pull up the letters myself.
Speaker 11 (17:49–18:02)
I'm not looking for the letter sharing. So the letter is the letter, and I don't think we need to read the letter. I can summarize the points. What I was going to do was just walk through the plans.
So I don't have the capability of screen sharing here to do that.
Speaker 3 (18:04–18:08)
I have it on multiple participants can share. Can you try it again for me?
Speaker 11 (18:09–18:31)
I'm just not seeing, I can raise my hand, I can transcript and show captions. Those are my only options, I don't see any other menu items available to me. Okay. I can promote Mr.
Avery.
Speaker 10 (18:31–18:32)
He's still on attendance.
Speaker 1 (18:33–18:37)
You know what, we can promote you as a panelist and then you should be able to have the capability to share.
Speaker 3 (18:38–18:39)
Does it work now?
Speaker 10 (18:56–18:56)
Here we go.
Speaker 1 (19:07–19:08)
Great. Here you go, Paul.
Speaker 11 (19:21–19:24)
Can you hear me?
Speaker 1 (19:24–19:25)
Yes, now we can hear you.
Speaker 11 (19:26–19:28)
Can you see the screen? Can you see the screen? Yes.
Speaker 1 (19:28–19:29)
Great. Yes. Okay. Great.
Speaker 11 (19:30–22:19)
All right. So, I'll walk through. Sorry for the technical challenges here. The 1st item is just that the infiltration detention basin system was revised to provide maintenance access, increased setbacks.
from the wetland resource areas and other technical comments. So, zooming in on this, you can see this, I think. Here's the basin. At first glance, it looks the same.
It's in the same place. It does the same thing. It functions all the same way. It was just fine-tuned a bit to provide, you know, access and things like that, which were comments that we received from the DEP.
There's no more water going to it. Basically, the end result of the runoff calculations are all the same. The other item that came up is Wetlands Area Replication 2. Wetlands Replication Area 2 was located back here near this crossing over this Western Intermittent Stream.
The DEP requested that we move it up to this area here, so we did that. That area, it's not shown on this, is generally the area occupied by the existing barn on the 107 Highland Street. We didn't change the grading in here. All we did was basically we have a different area here that is designated for wetlands restoration where we're gonna specifically come in and follow the restoration protocol.
So we just, same thing, we just moved it to a different place. No changes in the grading, anything else. The stormwater all pretty much works the same. There was also quite a bit of housekeeping that we did with the DEP, just in terms of the accounting on some of the impacts.
As Pam Merrill went to write up the superseding order, she had to quantify everything. And we went back and forth and just clarified. We established some areas of temporary impacts, which are shown here in sort of that tan color. And there's the quantifications of, you know, BVW, temporary disturbance, you know, temporary disturbance, bank alteration, replication.
So there was none of this represented any change in the design at all. It was just how we went through and just fine-tuned, you know, categorizing the different areas of permanent and temporary impacts. For example, this area right here, number three, was counted as an area of temporary impact. The only thing we're doing there is mitigating invasive species.
So, things like that. So, it's just going through and quantifying in these tables over here, you know, what the impacts were. In most cases, actually, when we did all this, the numbers actually went down in terms of the accounting. Regardless of that, there was no change in the scope of work actually physically increasing impacts at all.
So, that's shown on drawings C302 and C303.
Speaker 10 (22:20–22:31)
We also hope it's like Pam Merrill is the wetland scientist at the EP who was responsible for saying that she issued the superseding order.
Speaker 11 (22:33–22:49)
Okay. Um, there were also jumping back to water quality swales that were added, uh, to outfall one, which is the one along Highland street. And the other one is the one, you know, down here near where the service area plan hasn't.
Speaker 10 (22:50–22:51)
Oh, there it is.
Speaker 11 (22:53–23:10)
Okay. Can you see it? Yep. Okay.
So outfall one, did you see outfall one up by Highland street? No. Outfall one appeared by Highland Street. Is my internet not working well?
Speaker 10 (23:11–23:13)
Just a little delay. Everything's just delayed.
Speaker 8 (23:21–23:24)
Yeah, I got an outfall one up in the upper right corner.
Speaker 1 (23:24–23:26)
Mm-hmm, outfall one. Yes, we see that.
Speaker 8 (23:26–23:27)
Got it.
Speaker 11 (23:28–24:00)
Right here, okay. So we just did some grading in here and created this, and this is, it's just polishing, water quality polishing, that's all it is. You know, provide further treatment to the runoff before it goes into the wetlands area beyond. So this was the one area here along Highland Street, and then the other one, is this refreshed, is down here?
Not yet. Near the service area? Is that refreshed? We're still on outfall one.
Speaker 9 (24:05–24:05)
It just moved.
Speaker 10 (24:07–24:08)
Here we go.
Speaker 9 (24:08–24:08)
There we go.
Speaker 10 (24:11–24:14)
Outfall two was by the loading dock.
Speaker 11 (24:14–24:26)
Yep, that's it. Okay, and all this stayed out of the non-disturbance zones and all that. We were able to put these polishing features in there to improve the water quality.
Speaker 10 (24:26–24:36)
And Paul, that outfall too is in the area where the dumpster and the transformer was formerly located.
Speaker 11 (24:37–24:54)
Yeah, pretty much spot on. I mean, I think if you overlay this, that's exactly what you'd see. Okay? Because we were able to make room there.
As a result of doing that, we were able to make room to put this in there. Okay? Any questions on that one?
Speaker 1 (24:56–24:58)
No. No.
Speaker 11 (24:58–26:45)
All right. So, I don't know if it's slow on the uptake here. I don't think it's particularly critical, but on sheets L-104 and L-105, there are, Procedures that were there unique to several of the specific. invasive species control areas and exactly what procedures were going to be used in those areas.
So if my screen is refreshed, you can see an example of one of those. This happens to be area one. And we went through and just worked out exactly what procedures we were going to use based on, you know, the nature of the invasive species that were in there, but also proximity to other activities. So in some cases, rather than than you know, go cutting and putting down herbicides and things like that.
Pam Merrill at the DEP said, look, you're in there doing work anyway, why don't you just reach over the backhoe and scoop them up? And it was like, okay, so that's what we did. So it just, the, you know, the procedures that we're using to do invasive species mitigation were just fine tuned a bit. Lastly, some of the limits of work in various places just got revised as, you know, we moved things around a little bit in terms of where we were doing work and where we weren't, but that's it.
Again, as Ned summarized, if you look at the project itself, in terms of the building or the grading of the site or the traffic circulation or any of those things, nothing changed. So it's just some of the little bit of the stormwater management things and how we accounted for the impacts. That's it.
Speaker 12 (26:47–27:15)
Any comments from the board or questions? Yeah, can I just ask a question on the third paragraph of that invasive plant species control measure? It says, that the invasive species and replication work shall be monitored annually for two years or until they are deemed to be successfully established with native plant species. Who is going to deem it to be successful?
Speaker 11 (27:17–27:26)
That's a good question. I would presume that that would probably be done in coordination with the Conservation Commission. Ned, what's your interpretation on that?
Speaker 10 (27:26–28:16)
Yeah, I agree. And it would be, we'd have to establish that it has been done in order to get a certificate of compliance from the CONCOM when the project is finished. they have a general rule that requires a two-year post to establish that 75% of species are surviving. And in this case, it's a more detailed requirement that you have to go beyond if it deals with the invasive species removal.
So we wouldn't be, there would be an item that we would have to establish in order to get the certificate of compliance. And our wetlands folks or our engineer would have to certify that with their stamp.
Speaker 1 (28:16–28:23)
So to me, these seem like they're all improvements to the project, especially the water quality, additional purification.
Speaker 8 (28:26–28:43)
I just have a quick question on the wetlands restoration. It looks like most of it is done in the back. Is there any of that brought to the front at all where it would remove or affect the plantings that are causing, that are creating a sort of a buffer to that long causeway? Or is it all in the back?
Speaker 11 (28:44–29:08)
Yeah, there were some minor adjustments to the planting plan, you know, in this area here. But again, there were some of just right, the only There were no plannings proposed where we're doing the wetlands restoration area here at all. And then just a little bit of adjustment of some of the trees to make room for the water quality swale that goes in there.
Speaker 8 (29:09–29:15)
So when you say adjustment, did you remove any or just kind of move them around to the same count? Okay, that's fine. Yeah.
Speaker 13 (29:17–29:18)
All right. Okay, I'm good.
Speaker 4 (29:18–29:19)
Okay.
Speaker 14 (29:20–29:26)
Right, so what does our motion need to be?
Speaker 10 (29:26–29:37)
Motion would be to approve the amendment to the special permit adopting the final plan set as Exhibit A. Can I ask a question just before we get to that?
Speaker 2 (29:38–29:57)
So Ned, just in terms of the whole project, Would you mind just updating, not only us, but anybody listening tonight on where the project's at, what other approvals are necessary, and what the path forward might be? Because I think if we don't ask you to do that, we may not get that information. Would you mind helping us all out?
Speaker 10 (29:57–34:04)
Sure, happy to. So the big news for the project is that all of the appeals have been dismissed. or successfully prosecuted. There were three.
There was the neighborhood appeal of the order of conditions. Superseding order was issued by DEP. There was the appeal to superior court under the town's wetland bylaw that was dismissed on March 18th. And there was the appeal of the planning board special permit that was dismissed on March 17th.
So those are all done, complete. We're now, the next major step in our side will be to take the conceptual plans, not conceptual, but the plans of the building and the project and develop construction documents. and then submit for two things. One would be a demolition permit for the remaining house and the barn and the shed.
And then a building permit to do the building and a permit with the town for the site work. There's also the permit to open the street to put in the sewer. Our best, my best guess at this point, and given the fluctuation and what's happening in the economy and interest rates and whatnot, is that, you know, that process will take six months. Let's say, you know, in the fall, they might be ready to start clearing and grubbing.
but they may wait till the spring. It just will depend on the weather and when and what's the best time to do the site work. But I would imagine that a year from now, they'll be in pretty full bore. There is a meeting taking place early next week between our landscape architect and Karen Bacardi's landscape architect to look at refining planting plans on her property, within the four corners of this property, but one of the pieces of the agreement with her in the resolution was that we would get together and cooperate in revisions to that planting plan.
To the extent that we can, the work on her property will commence roughly at the same time as we start work on the property, so she gets the benefit of the additional screening associated with those plantings. So the next steps are sort of apply for building permit, demolition permit, um, other permits with the town to get going with the work. And that's six to nine to 12 months. I don't see anything.
I don't think you'll see anything happening between now and the fall is there's too much architectural detail, engineering detail, too much of that stuff to do before. You know, the town wouldn't be in a position to approve much of anything. I mean, they could, they presumably could go in and start clearing trees. That would be the earliest.
But they're basically, the schedule, as I remember, is to work your way into the site and then work your way out. So that initial phase of work is really gonna be about the crossing the first wetland. building all that in so they can get inside of that with heavy equipment and then start up, you know, go, and then the next crossing to the rear parking area because that'll be an important area for construction lay down for heavy equipment. And then, you know, up into the hill where the building is located.
So, and then ultimately work your way out. probably assume two years construction once it gets going, give or take.
Speaker 2 (34:04–34:25)
So it's reasonable that it probably doesn't start for a year and maybe the only reason it might start sooner than that is if they found that working through the winter is advantageous just because the conditions are more tighter, you know, frozen. Exactly. That's helpful too. Okay.
And that would be that
Speaker 10 (34:26–34:40)
Presumably, that will be all about entering and getting the first two cross, the two crossings set so that you can do, you know, the building work would be, you know, sometime after that. OK, great.
Speaker 2 (34:40–34:41)
Thanks for that.
Speaker 12 (34:42–35:10)
So there will not be too much clearing of land too much in advance of when the project starts because there, you know, we've seen projects you know, where they go in and clear the land and then for some reason their financing falls through or there's a delay in their contractor and then you're looking at trees that are, you know, just cut halfway. So we don't want to be looking at that.
Speaker 10 (35:10–35:24)
This will be a very tightly financed project and it will all, once they start, they will go. And they'll go and there'll be a very tight schedule as to how they do it.
Speaker 9 (35:28–35:29)
Any other questions?
Speaker 10 (35:29–35:49)
So I have a, I provided a draft of an amendment that I think is ready for signature if the board's ready to, with a motion to approve and you can sign tonight or. Great.
Speaker 8 (35:49–35:52)
Did you email us that? I emailed it, it's part of the package.
Speaker 14 (35:53–36:10)
So, if you're ready, Meredith, I'll make a motion to amend the special permit and site plan approval for the special care memory care residence development at 107, 111, 107-111-0 Highland Street. Is there a second?
Speaker 2 (36:10–36:11)
I'll second.
Speaker 14 (36:11–36:13)
All in favor? Aye.
Speaker 1 (36:13–36:14)
Aye. Aye.
Speaker 4 (36:16–36:16)
Aye.
Speaker 1 (36:18–36:18)
All right.
Speaker 8 (36:19–36:19)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (36:19–36:23)
Thank you very much. Do you want to sign it? Yeah, I do.
Speaker 8 (36:23–36:25)
Yeah, sign it right now.
Speaker 1 (36:25–36:35)
If you want to pass it down and we can have it signed. And we'll get it to Cheyenne and file it, get it filed. That's great. Thank you, Ned.
Speaker 10 (36:36–36:38)
Nice job, Ned. Thank you. Thanks, Ned.
Speaker 1 (36:38–36:39)
Thank you very much.
Speaker 10 (36:39–36:42)
And I'll actually see you in two weeks, I think.
Speaker 14 (36:42–36:54)
Yes, on the 24th. Ned, you have a misspelling on Cheryl. I didn't notice it on here, but can I just correct it on here?
Speaker 10 (36:54–37:05)
Yes, you please do. I apologize. I apologize. Thank you.
Thank you. All right. Thanks, Ned. Take care.
Great.
Speaker 1 (37:06–37:11)
And I will date it.
Speaker 12 (37:15–37:19)
So did you sign it because you were there? I didn't sign the original.
Speaker 7 (37:20–37:23)
Okay. Great. Thank you. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (37:24–37:55)
Okay. All right. While we're signing that, we can now move to our discussion of MBTA communities. And Cheyenne, if you would like to, I know we just got a late update from Uteal.
if you could pull that up and we could sort of walk through that together, starting with, actually, if you want to pull up first the hypothetical statute plan.
Speaker 14 (37:57–38:01)
So that's not in what was submitted just today, then.
Speaker 1 (38:01–38:11)
Oh, you know what? Yeah, I just was going to review it for folks to see. Can you pull up that from our last meeting?
Speaker 3 (38:11–38:12)
The presentation, yeah.
Speaker 1 (38:12–38:23)
And we can just let people know this is what will be presented if they can't make it next Thursday as part of the presentation.
Speaker 3 (38:33–38:37)
Okay, so here's the one from Monday.
Speaker 5 (38:51–38:51)
Great.
Speaker 1 (38:54–39:44)
And we can move to sort of the areas that we were looking at within the half mile of the commuter stations, commuter lines. These were three, a scenario that we had evaluated And there was some question which I think we, Util wanted to know about the parcels that we wanted included or excluded on this. I don't know if anyone had any further thoughts on this. I don't think we have to decide tonight, but we had talked about whether to include the lower, the Yoga Studio parcel on that corner, that intersection, if we wanted to keep that in.
Speaker 14 (39:46–40:19)
So we're, Was it the intention to show options 1, 2, and 3 on this? Because options 2 and 3 are short the zone capacity. So I'm just wondering whether the focus for next week should be the option 1, because it does. It meets the capacity as calculated by the method that was used to calculate.
Okay? So. So this is option one on here.
Speaker 1 (40:19–40:20)
I think we would. Yeah.
Speaker 14 (40:20–40:32)
So I'm just. So that we don't confuse folks. Right. I think it's best not to.
include the ones that don't meet in all three categories. Because we're going to raise so many options, it's going to be too confusing.
Speaker 1 (40:33–40:37)
And what you're referring to is the 15 units per acre, a minimum. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 14 (40:37–40:53)
So that's just for the public. I think it was the 563. There's a question about how that number is calculated that we can get to. But even so, there are two of these options that don't meet that, right?
So my suggestion is not to show those next week. Right.
Speaker 1 (40:56–41:00)
So she has removing those two lower parcels. And there was good, there was rationale for.
Speaker 14 (41:00–41:53)
And, you know, I think the question on the Blue Hill Ave, one, I think that some raised this on Monday. I think we should just leave that as an open question for next week. Because that's part of the public forum that we want. Yeah, I mean, Fairmont makes more sense to remove, I think.
And the Readville, again, I think that could be open for discussion as well. But there's, especially given what we heard tonight, I mean, Fairmount, those two parcels, especially. And then, you know, there's the overall question in any case, but as far as just the question from you, Till, about which parcels to remove.
Speaker 1 (41:55–42:01)
So I would agree that option one would be what we would want to present.
Speaker 9 (42:01–42:05)
Would you see two and three real quick? This is a statutory plan.
Speaker 1 (42:05–42:12)
Statutory plan, yes. And option two were… Jim, can you see how many units that says on there?
Speaker 14 (42:12–42:14)
It says 470 on option two.
Speaker 8 (42:15–42:17)
So that was… Yeah, 15.3 density.
Speaker 14 (42:18–42:26)
Yeah. And what it does, though, is it puts that 20 units an acre also for the Blue Hill. Right.
Speaker 1 (42:27–42:29)
Which is higher than the 15. Yeah.
Speaker 14 (42:31–43:31)
So there's still option one has 20 there as well, which is something to highlight, I think. But, you know, just in terms of Consideration consideration that as I said that our meeting on Monday at some of the Blue Hill have. was included in the rapid transit from 2023. However, it was in different, three different sub-districts that had three different dimensional characteristics and requirements, and now they're all lumped together.
So, you know, it's something just to continue to point out and be mindful of. Option three, Jim has 259. Yes. Even less.
Yep. Okay.
Speaker 1 (43:36–43:50)
Any other further comments on this one? And I thought what we'd do, we would go through everything and then have the public, any questions that the public might have, and obviously our own comments as well.
Speaker 14 (43:53–44:08)
Yeah. No, I don't know if at this point we wanted to talk about the two emails that we received in terms of how we calculate this or we just want to keep going through the… So I almost… I suggest we keep going through that.
Speaker 1 (44:08–45:28)
I think we should keep going through it, but we can come back to this because I did have a question that we did get a response from you, Teal, saying that the numbers wouldn't change based on that definition. So I think we should… I think we should talk about that so that the people who said they wasn't… Maybe let's talk about that now then.
That's fine, that piece. Okay. One piece at one time or another doesn't matter to me. Exactly.
So we received a couple of emails. Cheyenne, if you wanna, you don't have to pull up the emails, but I'll, the concern, the question was around the definition. And I know we have one speaker who's gonna address it. And we can ask if Tom Doherty is, or Eric Holkinson is on, they were the two that had brought this up.
It's like Tom Doherty has his hand up. Yes. Tom, if you would like to speak on this. Welcome.
You can introduce yourself. Great. Welcome.
Speaker 15 (45:30–45:32)
Tom Doherty here, can you hear me?
Speaker 1 (45:32–45:33)
Yes, now we can hear you.
Speaker 15 (45:34–47:56)
Can you see me? Welcome, yes, we can see you in here. I could maybe deal with that first, right? As I pointed out, the statute plan as presented by UTL had incorrectly omitted the statute's definition of multifamily housing.
And so that needed to be redone, and I can just give it to you briefly. UTL's cover page in its hypothetical statute plan for Milton states, quote, definition of multifamily, and then it says, since this term was further defined in the guidelines as three plus units, but was not defined as such in the statute, we are assuming that two units on a lot would account in this hypothetical scenario, close quote. Actually, the way it works is that statute, Chapter 40, its definitions are in, you have to go back to Section 1A, and there's a whole list of definitions, and I'm not criticizing them, but that's just the way that statute and other statutes, but not all, work. When you go back to the definitions in the statute, it's there.
and when they are assuming that two units on a lot would count in this hypothetical scenario, that's incorrect. The words of the statute, it defines with a specific definition of multi-family housing in Massachusetts General Laws 40A, Section 1A, the definition section. quote, a building with three or more residential dwelling units or two or more buildings on the same lot with one or more residential dwelling unit in each building. That's the definition, and that applies to chapter, you know, 48 section 3A, part of that same statute here.
That's how the definitions work. And as we'll come back to incidentally, That was enacted on January 14, 2021, in the Economic Development Bond Bill, which was the same day that the statute section 3A that we're talking so much about elsewhere was enacted, and that becomes important later. But in any event, I think UTL would then go back and check to see what the difference of that assumption makes. And as I understand it, they have said that it didn't make a significant difference.
I'll stop there.
Speaker 1 (47:57–48:06)
Great, thank you. So we'll get clarification and maybe they can answer that question at the forum on Thursday when they go through that.
Speaker 14 (48:06–49:01)
Yeah, I think some of the, maybe the confusion lies in the compliance model, the way it does the calculation and the way they have to, kind of define their own way of doing the calculation here because there's no compliance model that contemplates this way of doing it. So in other words, like the compliance model would kick out ineligible sites, sites that wouldn't contribute to the district where there's nothing here to kick those sites out. But certainly the definition correction should be made. But I can understand why it doesn't necessarily, they reply that it doesn't make a difference because the compliance model isn't kicking anything out, since they're not running it through that model.
Speaker 1 (49:01–49:08)
They're not running it through. But I would think that that would have to revert them back to the statute. But Tom, do you want to comment on that?
Speaker 15 (49:08–49:23)
Yeah, I think both of those are correct. I mean, I think that it refers it back to the statute, but then also the model itself, it didn't make a significant difference. But they can address that themselves.
Speaker 1 (49:23–49:38)
Okay. So we'll put a pin in that. All right, Tom, thank you. I know we'll have you back to speak.
a little bit later as we run through this. So if there was anything else you wanted to add to that or?
Speaker 15 (49:38–49:57)
No, no, I think that's good. Okay, great. And I think they came up with 779, you know, total unit capacity with the requisite density of 15 units plus. So that is what it is.
Speaker 1 (50:00–50:55)
That was okay. Great. Thank you very much. All right.
Cheyenne, if you could go back and we can move to the adjacent, hypothetical adjacent community commuter. No, they made some adjustments. They did make some adjustments. So can you pull up the most recent?
They said just before our meeting. Okay. So, and do you have the memo? I don't know if you can go through what those changes are, Cheyenne.
Or is that hard to do with sharing the screen?
Speaker 3 (50:56–50:57)
I'll have to stop sharing the screen.
Speaker 1 (50:58–50:59)
Okay.
Speaker 3 (50:59–51:03)
Or I can try and pull it up on my phone.
Speaker 14 (51:04–51:09)
Well, I think we can just read through it, right? Do you have it? Yeah, I do, I can pull it up.
Speaker 1 (51:09–52:17)
All right, so let's use the most recent one. Okay, this was the email we received just a few minutes before our meeting tonight. And it was from JT. Cheyenne, please consult this attached deck instead.
Very minor correction to the annotations on slide two. Not all changes were highlighted with the orange outline. First, adjacent community scenario slide two aligned Blue Hills Parkway minimum lot size with Elliott Street Corridor Tier 1, 7,000 square foot minimum, and increased the paper mill as needed to hit compliance target. Cells outlined in orange reflect these changes to unit capacity for those districts, as well as the necessary changes to input parameters to achieve those numbers.
Two, rapid transit community scenario 4B. Before we go there, I'm sorry.
Speaker 14 (52:18–52:40)
So can we talk about this one first? Yes, first. Yeah. So what we had before for the paper mill was 109.
So this one upped by 20, which is I think what we were talking about, right? I think we said JT had advised we could go to 12 during that back and forth.
Speaker 2 (52:41–52:43)
by 30? It says 139 now, right?
Speaker 14 (52:44–52:45)
Oh, sorry. Yeah.
Speaker 2 (52:45–52:46)
Okay.
Speaker 14 (52:47–53:10)
I can't do math apparently. So 30 is more though than what we had, definitely more than what you talked about with the 12, right? But that also dropped the parkway from 235 that was here to 187.
Speaker 7 (53:10–53:11)
Yeah.
Speaker 14 (53:11–53:14)
Which feels better to me. Right.
Speaker 1 (53:14–53:16)
Going to that 7,000 minimum.
Speaker 14 (53:17–53:37)
I guess the question is, this has 711 Randolph at 97, whether we should take some from paper mill and put it to 711. But otherwise I think,
Speaker 1 (53:38–53:40)
Yeah, that might be a better, yeah.
Speaker 14 (53:40–54:14)
The question is whether the compliance model would say one of these flashing lights that you're trying to put too much on one site, you know how it has that in it, like you put these parameters in and it actually won't work. But if it says 40% and one parking space per unit, which is what they have here now, it's probably how it didn't get that flashing red light is that they made it that one parking space that we discussed. So I think I'm fine with this going to the forum with these adjustments.
Speaker 2 (54:14–54:16)
I agree. I would be too.
Speaker 12 (54:17–54:22)
Yeah, I don't have a problem with being 139, especially Granite Ave North is 171. Yeah. Okay.
Speaker 14 (54:27–54:37)
All right. And then we were not going to do… Numbers on Elliot Street are really low. This one, right?
Right.
Speaker 1 (54:37–54:38)
Okay.
Speaker 14 (54:40–54:45)
It just didn't… It was… Okay. I just wanted to be sure.
We're not going to show that.
Speaker 1 (54:46–54:58)
All right, so Cheyenne, if you want to pull up the map of the adjacent community just to show where those districts are for people in map form.
Speaker 14 (54:59–55:00)
Did they have that in the deck?
Speaker 1 (55:01–55:10)
Yeah, they did. It was on a different attachment. Yeah, let me go to the deck and find it. It was within the email.
Speaker 3 (55:17–55:24)
I think the map was in the one from Monday. I don't see a new map on this one. Or I think he sent it. Let me see.
Speaker 2 (55:27–55:29)
It's not in today's email, Cheyenne.
Speaker 3 (55:30–55:33)
Yeah, I think it was from Monday. Let's see.
Speaker 1 (55:37–55:48)
Oh, I have it when I pull it up. I have it in mind, but in the last, yeah.
Speaker 8 (55:48–55:51)
Is that for rapid transit or is that for adjacent?
Speaker 1 (55:55–56:04)
Let me double check. Oh, I'm sorry, it was the rapid transit, it wasn't the adjacent, sorry. So that was funny.
Speaker 14 (56:04–56:07)
I don't even think we had it in Monday. So we had this map, but.
Speaker 1 (56:07–56:24)
Yeah, she didn't really, we haven't gotten the full map. So we will be presenting that. They had it in a prior one. Yeah.
It was from a prior one, but it didn't include the reduction on Elliott Street. So, all right. Apologies, we don't have that map for tonight, but we will have it.
Speaker 12 (56:25–56:26)
So we should make note to request it.
Speaker 1 (56:27–56:27)
Yeah.
Speaker 3 (56:29–56:30)
Map for adjacent.
Speaker 1 (56:30–56:32)
Yeah, if you could request that. Yeah.
Speaker 14 (56:33–56:38)
And including that kind of enlargement of the Elliott Street corridor map.
Speaker 1 (56:39–56:51)
Yeah, and it would be great to have these just posted, too, for the public so they can review it in advance. Because sometimes at public forums it's hard. It's easier to prepare your comments if you have it in advance, so.
Speaker 8 (56:51–56:54)
Did you say enlargement of the evidence recorder?
Speaker 14 (56:54–57:06)
Yeah, because if you did the full map, it would be something like this, right? This isn't the right map, but it was the… And then they have this slide. This is the Monday.
Oh, including that enlargement on this. I'm sorry. I got you. Right.
Speaker 8 (57:06–57:07)
Yeah. I'm tracking.
Speaker 14 (57:07–57:08)
Yep.
Speaker 8 (57:08–57:08)
Yeah.
Speaker 14 (57:08–57:11)
Okay. Because it's different than… I got you.
Speaker 8 (57:11–57:17)
No, I totally understand. You lost me in enlargement. Meaning we enlarged the zone. Right, right.
Speaker 1 (57:18–58:42)
Okay, so now let me then move on. Is there anything else on the adjacent before we? I can be reading the comments. Let's see.
From JT. On the rapid transit, he states, rapid transit community scenario 4B.1, slide 11. We asked them to remove St. Pius, which was reduced by 30 units, reduce the Randolph access to a total of 80 units, including the 40B portion.
So down, let's see, she has it down 40 units, and add 20 units to Milton Station East, adding 12 to the paper mill, adding 15 to 711 Randolph, and adding 23 to Granite Ave North. Cells highlighted in yellow reflect these changes to unit capacity for these districts, as well as the necessary changes to input parameters to achieve those numbers. So I thought we asked to go lower on the access, Randolph access. So I'm sorry, let's run through this again.
Speaker 14 (58:42–58:45)
So Granite Ave North went up.
Speaker 2 (58:46–58:46)
Up 23.
Speaker 14 (58:46–01:00:43)
23, which is what we talked about, right? Yep. Milton Station, I just wanted to let you all know, I tried to determine if I was remembering correctly before. Extra space storage.
is about 142,000 square feet exclusive of wetlands. And if under that zone, PUD zoning, if you got the bonuses, you could get at maximum one unit per 1000 square feet. So that's 142 zoned capacity for extra space storage. 88 Wharf, while it has 73 units, using that same zoning and, you know, doing it the same way, it would allow for 110 units because, you know, 88 Wharf is very large units.
So, you know, you could have more units in the same square footage basically. And then there was a proposal that the owner of 30 to 40 Adams Street had presented in 2021 for 45 units. I didn't have the exact land area there. So you add those up, it's about 300 units.
And then the Webb Mill building at 24,000, that site, That would be 24. So it's about 325 units roughly under the current zoning. And what we had total for that district was 325 in the MBTA zoning. So if we bump a little bit, like we talked about for extra space in 88 Wharf and that 30 to 40 Adams, we would be just bumping up above what the zoning would currently allow.
By my rough estimation. So we'll see what Util comes back with, but I just wanted to share that.
Speaker 8 (01:00:43–01:00:48)
That's great. Thank you. And what is 30 to 40 Adams? I'm sorry.
Is that the big brick building?
Speaker 14 (01:00:48–01:00:56)
It's the citizens building and then air rights over the T parking lot.
Speaker 2 (01:00:56–01:00:59)
Right where the stair was? Remember where the stair?
Speaker 8 (01:00:59–01:01:03)
Oh, the stair, okay, I'm thinking of the citizens kiosk, yes, the citizens, yeah.
Speaker 14 (01:01:03–01:01:03)
Across the street, yeah.
Speaker 8 (01:01:03–01:01:08)
Gotcha, yeah. And air rights over the T. That's interesting.
Speaker 2 (01:01:08–01:01:10)
Really, I think it's over the, isn't it?
Speaker 14 (01:01:10–01:01:14)
It's over the parking lot. The T's parking lot. Oh, okay. Oh, the T parking lot.
Speaker 1 (01:01:16–01:01:25)
So I just wanted to throw that out. Which would be interesting to see, not for tonight's analysis, but our overlay zoning. the difference between the PUD and our overlay zoning.
Speaker 14 (01:01:25–01:01:36)
So the PUD allowed more than the overlay zoning, which is what I was remembering from before. I remember that pretty clearly that the PUD did allow more.
Speaker 1 (01:01:36–01:01:38)
But that's only at extra space storage.
Speaker 14 (01:01:38–01:01:39)
Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (01:01:40–01:02:03)
So if we look at, I think that slide up there. My question is the other pieces of the Milton station are not in that PUD, but yet we want to make it so if possible, we get credit through the MBTA, but we want them to use the overlay zoning.
Speaker 14 (01:02:03–01:02:22)
Yeah, the only one that's in the overlay zoning of those, there's only three. If we pull the web mill and put that into the bridge, I think it was called, right? The bridge is Milton Hill House. Yeah.
So we put it in there or we put it in west, I think is what actually Zoe thought to put it in west because it would be contiguous there.
Speaker 1 (01:02:22–01:02:30)
So if we pull the web… Both the web and the Milton Hill House? Milton Hill's already separate. Yeah, separate.
That's bridge.
Speaker 14 (01:02:31–01:03:27)
Yeah, but there were two options of where to put the web mill, either in the bridge or in west, and Zoe suggested west. So now what we're left with… I would feel more comfortable with that. Yeah, so then what we're left with in east is extra space storage that's parcel at 30 to 40 Adams and 88 Wharf.
So now we're talking about adding how many they have here adding, going to 325 from 325, so adding 20 units. And we've taken a site away from it that had 25 units. So it's kind of like adding 45 units to those three. But that, to me, still makes sense.
It's not a huge increase over what the zoning allows. Okay.
Speaker 1 (01:03:28–01:03:37)
So I think that one's good too. So should that be a request? We asked Cheyenne to ask UTL to change that map and maybe they have.
Speaker 14 (01:03:37–01:03:50)
We did ask them to do it, so we'll see whether, let's see if it says it here on this map too. Add 20 to Milton Station East. It didn't mention that change. Yeah, so I think we need to make sure the map change gets made.
Speaker 1 (01:03:51–01:04:11)
So can that be another request? The map for the adjacent and moving the Webb Mill building into the west. Into the west, right. Milton Station West.
And great. And now if you could pull that map up. Do you want to run through these first though?
Speaker 14 (01:04:11–01:04:19)
Yeah, sure. The rest of them? Yeah. OK, so then we went on the paper mill.
Speaker 1 (01:04:22–01:04:34)
We added 12 to the paper mill. We added 15 to 711 Randolph Ave. So that puts it up to 130.
Speaker 13 (01:04:35–01:04:43)
Which is the same as the statutory plan, right, that we just looked at? I'm sorry, the adjacent that we just looked at. So both of those are the same, right?
Speaker 1 (01:04:43–01:05:01)
And adding 23 to Granite Ave North. Which is what we talked about. And reducing… And so where does that put us here?
And reducing the Randolph access by 40. 40. Can you scroll just a little?
Speaker 8 (01:05:01–01:05:05)
All right. And 40 of those 80 are already approved.
Speaker 14 (01:05:05–01:05:14)
Correct, yeah. So we reduced by 125 total. I'm trying to understand that. Oh no, by zero?
Speaker 8 (01:05:14–01:05:26)
I'm not quite getting all my… It's 125 less than 2023, the select board's plan. Delta from target is zero, so it's the same.
Speaker 1 (01:05:28–01:05:28)
Yep.
Speaker 8 (01:05:29–01:05:30)
Exactly 2461.
Speaker 14 (01:05:30–01:05:32)
Yeah, it came out.
Speaker 8 (01:05:32–01:05:34)
Yeah, it's great.
Speaker 14 (01:05:35–01:05:43)
So which slide are you on, Zoe? Cheyenne, sorry, I'm sorry about that.
Speaker 3 (01:05:43–01:05:44)
I'm on slide 11.
Speaker 14 (01:05:44–01:06:13)
It's slide 11. 4B.1. Delta from 2023 is 125. Okay.
That's what I couldn't see that before. So if we go back to slide 10 is what you were referring to, Jim. Is that what you were looking at when you said that we were on 2, 4, 6, 1?
Speaker 8 (01:06:13–01:06:21)
No, I was on 11. Okay. I was just talking about the paper mill and 711 Randolph were the same as the 10% plan, so we should be okay with them.
Speaker 14 (01:06:22–01:07:03)
Because I thought that by adding some to our mandatory mixed use, but we, I guess because we took some out. Well, I guess I'm trying to understand the model density went from 18.33 to 18.15. But the, and the model, and the total zone capacity is the same. So I guess that has to do with that mandatory mixed use that Zoe was referring to on Monday.
Speaker 1 (01:07:05–01:07:29)
Yeah, let me see if that's mentioned. Yeah. That would be, I think, something really helpful for Zoe to explain at the forum, the mandatory mixed use and what going to a 25% plan, how we have to pick, we can't keep all of our, guarantee that all of our commercial will be kept.
Speaker 14 (01:07:30–01:07:49)
And that's one of the reasons that I supported removing East Milton Square because we couldn't do mandatory mixed use there because it makes sense for other reasons. We're already zoning at multifamily, so capture those units. We don't want to miss out on, or we don't want to lose commercial space as a result.
Speaker 1 (01:07:50–01:07:56)
I mean, our business districts are small. Anyway, all of them, we want to hopefully protect.
Speaker 12 (01:07:57–01:08:02)
We want to protect all of our small businesses. Yeah. No matter where you are.
Speaker 14 (01:08:03–01:08:10)
So I think this is a good place for this to go get public feedback.
Speaker 1 (01:08:10–01:08:30)
Yeah, I do too. I do too. Okay. And Tom, I know you would like to now speak because, yeah, we have some other comments that came in.
And I'll give you the floor, Tom, if you want to go ahead with your comments on.
Speaker 15 (01:08:30–01:17:09)
Yeah. I think this is important to reiterate and stress now. Yeah. Adjacent community plan elements could be used under the statute as it applies to Milton in addition to the statutory plan zoning that we talked about before, but cannot be used in substitute for it with that statutory plan.
And I mean, that's fundamental. And we've been trying to make this point. And I did in the email that I had sent. And last week, we talked about the two elements.
So let me just go through it. Milton cannot adopt a multifamily zoning plan that does not implement the exact words of Chapter 48, Section 3A. That's the governing statute. So let's focus on the statute, given that importance of that aspect that I just mentioned, because that's what's legally required to be focused upon first.
by the law, what the statute requires by its own words, quote, if applicable, close quote, is required. And as we'll see, the statute's specific wording is indisputably, indisputably applicable to Milton. So here we go. The statute's application is extremely clear, right?
As we know, Milton has 37 and a half acres of developable land located not more than 0.5 miles from three commuter rail stations. Chapter 40A, section 3A requires that Milton must adopt an ordinance or bylaw for, quote, at least one district of reasonable size, which size, quote, if applicable, and it is applicable to Milton, must have a minimum gross density of 15 units per acre and be located not more than 0.5 miles from a commuter rail station, if applicable, which indisputably is applicable to Milton, And so Milton must do so under Section 3A for the statute, which is the governing law. I'll get to the regulation in 30 seconds. But let's just look for a second, as I mentioned earlier, Chapter 40A, Section 5.
Now, remember, Section 40A, Section 1A had definitions. We then went to and talked about the definition as it related to the fact that there is, the guideline doesn't allow you to do the two units. So we'll go back to that. I'm sorry, the two family.
I won't go back to that. But what the statute section 5 is, it was enacted the same day as this statute, section 3A, because they're the same sections of the same statute. And that matters, because 40A section 5 is a section of the statute concerning how town select boards or town meetings vote, by majority vote or by 2 thirds vote for multifamily zoning. for, quote, eligible locations.
So there's a special section, section 5, that talks about eligible locations. That's going to be, that's important. Why? It provides for majority vote for multifamily zoning, that section of, quote, and I'll go slow, areas that are near rapid transit stations.
Yes, therefore Milton could and should be considered as a municipality, quote, near a rapid transit location for voting purposes. But even if that reference for voting purposes to rapid transit stations in Section 5 definitions includes, by inference, subway stations, even if in HLC's own published statements they include high-speed rail lines, That is not what Section 3A requires. That's about voting. What Section 3A requires is what I've stated before.
And it's what Milton must do in any case. It must submit its required zoning plan for majority vote. by the town select board or by town meeting that in any case complies with Section 3A. And I won't go back to it, but it's, you know, one and a half acres within I'm sorry, it's 0.5 acres within, you know, that half mile, therefore, of developable land within a half mile of the commuter rail station, which we have.
And then it's, you know, it's at least 15 multi-family zoning units per acre. So specifically, Section 3A, the legislature that same day mandated a narrower and very specific must-do requirement for a town, quote, if applicable, which it is, which is what I am going to repeat. As applicable, Milton must adopt This by majority vote, yes. Adopt a zoning plan to comply with 3A and that math that I've talked about, those words in math, a minimum gross density of 15 units per acre and be located not more than 0.5 miles.
from the commuter rail station, period, full stop. Milton could do more, but it must have such a vote on such a plan. That's my reading of chapter 40 in its entirety, including section 1, section 3, section 40. I'm sorry, section 1, section 3A, section 5 of chapter 48.
Now, incidentally, HLC itself has promulgated, but totally ignores in its assertion that Milton must comply with a rapid transit community 25% multifamily units capacity zoning plan. It ignores its own regulation, 72.081C, that itself states explicitly, quote, a rapid transit community with transit station areas around a subway station. Let's assume even the cases were that Milton had that rapid transit station area around a subway station in one part of town. Even assume that.
And then they go on. And a transit station around a commuter rail station in another part of town may locate its multi-family zoning district in either or both the station areas. Therefore, even if Milton did have a subway station within 0.5 miles, of a subway station, which it does not. Milton could choose to locate as its multifamily zoning district within those parts of Milton located not more than 0.5 miles of commuter rail stations.
And in any event, Milton must do so because it has no subway station, no ferry terminal, no bus station within 0.5 miles. But it does have a commuter rail station located within 0.5 miles. You apply that math in the statute, 0.5 miles, and the number of 15 units per acre, and you end up with the applicable and mandated zoning plan. So I just say that, I'll say it once, because there's this There's been a recitation at various meetings at the town, and God bless the residents who sort of say, look, you know, they prefer, you know, accessory dwelling, or they prefer the the so-called rapid transit, 25%, and the regulations are the law.
I'm sorry, if the regulations don't comply with the statute, they don't apply. That part of the regulations cannot legally apply. And in any event, what you've got is an overriding concentrated specifically applicable core element of a plan that must be voted upon, must be developed and voted upon at the moment that UTL has 779 units and where and whether that's the exact and relevant amount. That's for you and them.
I'm just trying to say the notion that somehow adjacent community could be somehow a substitute for the core requisite statutory plan is incorrect. We'll stop there.
Speaker 1 (01:17:12–01:17:13)
Great. Thank you, Tom.
Speaker 15 (01:17:13–01:17:14)
OK.
Speaker 1 (01:17:16–01:17:18)
Any comments?
Speaker 2 (01:17:18–01:17:29)
Well, I just want to ask a question because I think as Tom describes it, the way we're titling what we've talked about here earlier is not titled correctly, right?
Speaker 1 (01:17:30–01:17:37)
And the way we're defining things.
Speaker 14 (01:17:37–01:18:59)
Well, I appreciate your continued commentary, Mr. Daugherty. I really have a difficult time thinking that we would have to apply what we don't think makes sense to us from a planning perspective of having 15 to 20 units an acre on some of these single family parcels that are a small fraction of which are captured in the half mile of the commuter rail station, when we think that we have a much better planning rationale for an adjacent community that has a different map configuration. And it does capture parts of the Blue Hill Ave.
commuter rail station, which makes a lot of sense because it's not only close to the commuter rail station, it's close to the trolley in Mattapan Square and walkable to amenities and open space, I mean, including the Nuponset Trail. So there's, I think, a lot of good reason that the adjacent community, which captures that station area, makes sense. The other thing I wanted to just point out, we received a couple of emails from Eric. Can I ask you a question?
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (01:18:59–01:19:28)
In regards to what you just said. It could be considered a commuter rail zone plan. You can put as many into that as you want to. You don't have to call it an adjacent.
Why not call it what it meets by definition? And if there is a preference for it to have more zone units in it, that's okay. You can exceed.
Speaker 14 (01:19:29–01:20:09)
I guess if that's the case, that what we have is adjacent community can fit both. then that's okay. It's terminology, but if we're going back to an adjacent or what was called statutory in UTILS plans that puts 15 to 20 units on single family lots, that's not consistent with what we've been talking about for two years and I'm not comfortable with that. So that's the difference I'm trying to distinguish because what we've been looking at as adjacent community, again, looks at Unquity House separately, it looks at the single family separately, it captures larger sites.
Speaker 2 (01:20:09–01:20:45)
So that's my concern. As a member of the planning board, if I have a significant regret for what's been happening over the last year and a half, we never had a real thorough examination of 3A. I mean a real thorough examination of it because the statute is a law. It's taken us, I don't even know how long this has been going on, but were it not for Mr.
Daugherty providing the kind of analysis that he has of the specific language, the specific words, the specific phrases,
Speaker 1 (01:20:45–01:20:46)
statutory construction.
Speaker 2 (01:20:46–01:22:23)
Right, exactly. We, you know, this is really where we should have started a long time ago. Instead of, you know, instead of conclusions that were made very early and all of a sudden we were going in a very different direction. But, you know, I don't think anybody is going to dispute the statute has requirements that we have is indisputable.
We cannot, you know, the debate about regulations and statute is one thing, but the statute is the law. And, you know, to me, it makes 100% sense that what's being described by Mr. Daugherty, we are compelled, we don't have a choice. That's not a debatable point.
The statute requires us to zone because of our proximity to the commuter rail stations. We have no choice. That is not something that we should ever pursue as a town, whether we are or we're not. We definitively are.
So my opinion is, that that has to be, we have no choice, that has to be a zoning plan that we create. If we happen to add to it and create more units because we prefer to do that as a town, so be it, but we can't be less than that. If we want to make sure that we're not in violation of law, we should comply with the statute.
Speaker 14 (01:22:23–01:22:50)
So coming back to the statute, the statute doesn't have something called developable area. It has no definition of the area to include. So we should be including roadways and everything except for wetlands because that's what the statute says. So these calculations are based on developable area.
So it's going to be more than 563 if we do it by the statute.
Speaker 8 (01:22:50–01:23:05)
Well, I would assume the statute would follow regular zoning where you can't build on a road and you can't build on a park. You can't make that assumption, though, because you have to… Well, I think you can in this case because I couldn't go pull a permit to build on the road in front of 3405 Center Street.
Speaker 2 (01:23:05–01:23:15)
I guess what's interesting is… It's the way the destiny is calculated. It could be, but we have you, Teal, who has been working on this throughout the state and they're not calculating roadways in public ways.
Speaker 14 (01:23:15–01:23:22)
That's because people are mixing the statute and the compliance model and the regulations.
Speaker 2 (01:23:23–01:23:25)
So what is your interest? Tell me what your interest is.
Speaker 14 (01:23:25–01:24:39)
My interest is if the idea that people have is that there should be something that's strictly statute, then you can't mix statute and regulations because developable area is something that comes out of the regulations, it doesn't come out of the statute. Reasonable size, as we all know, is not defined in the statute and we know that the statute says that EOHLC is empowered to determine compliance. So we will not know whether anything is compliant with the statute if we don't know what reasonable size is and we have no way, and if we say that HLC is not empowered to determine compliance. We are left deciding what we think is compliance based on our interpretation of the language in there, what reasonable means.
And so I just want to be clear about that because when we say, well, we have to comply with the statute, we don't really know what that means. We don't really know what reasonable size is. The statute doesn't tell us to take the area within a half a mile of a transit station, whether it's commuter or in any other mode, and multiply it times 15. I've said that before because that would, if we did that and we were determined to be rapid transit, we would have a far higher number than 2,461.
Speaker 8 (01:24:39–01:24:48)
Yeah, it says just pick a district of reasonable size, which has to be 15 units per acre. So we could choose what reasonable sizes. We could just say the young playhouse is it.
Speaker 14 (01:24:48–01:24:53)
And then HLC will still decide whether it meets the requirements or not, right?
Speaker 8 (01:24:53–01:24:57)
It's not us to decide. It is, because we're complying with the law. The statute is the law.
Speaker 16 (01:24:57–01:25:00)
So that's where this is going. We won't be the final arbitrator for that.
Speaker 8 (01:25:00–01:25:01)
Tom, let's see what Tom has to say.
Speaker 4 (01:25:02–01:25:02)
Sorry.
Speaker 15 (01:25:02–01:26:20)
Can I just say, look, there are situations, for example, and I sent it in my memo. Let me give you something in contrast. Section 72051A3, that's part of the regulations, okay? Quote, in all cases, at least half of the multi-family zoning district areas must be continuous lots of land.
That's an example of a regulation for which the statute gives HLC discretion to add a requirement that the statute does not interdict. Okay, and then with respect to those pieces of the statute I talked about, those are mandated. With respect to, therefore, what is a, you know, developable, what is developable acreage? You know, obviously both the HLC and the extent and history of the town's own zoning.
you know, gives some discretion with respect to working that out. But the core mandate here of the units within 15 units an acre within a half mile from the community rail station, because it is applicable, that's mandated. Whereas the notion about contiguous lots of land, that's discretionary within HLC.
Speaker 14 (01:26:21–01:27:22)
I think, as I was saying, we're not going to know whether HLC is going to accept whether it's 563 zone capacity, whether it's 5 acres or 20 acres or 70 acres or 100 acres. And so we're not going to know what's going to be deemed compliant. So we need to use, I think, some planning judgment about what we think is the right area to zone and at what level of density. That's what we've been talking about all along, what level of density makes sense in the areas that are being contemplated.
So I personally would like to get Town Council's opinion about this. And I still think it's important to go forward with the three kind of scenarios that you two has helped us get to as of tonight for next week. And then we can, once we get input from the community, we get input from Town Council, we can have further discussion about what's the best path.
Speaker 15 (01:27:22–01:27:31)
I certainly agree with that, all of that. And I do think that the core requisite elements will be very determinative of whatever the outcome is.
Speaker 12 (01:27:34–01:28:31)
And I think if you go back, I think, to the original intent of 3A, that they voted on it, our legislators voted on it. from a good planning perspective. Because every town is so different from each other that actually a good planning initiative is a half a mile from a subway commuter rail. So built into the statute, I think, is actually good planning.
It was the guidelines that were poor planning. And so I think if we just really do look at the exact words of the statute as our North Star, so to speak, it will result in a good plan.
Speaker 14 (01:28:32–01:30:19)
I think though that if we, again, I still stand with what I think we should do for next steps, but it makes sense. in what we're calling the adjacent community and even in the much higher rapid transit is trying to put. zones in places that are good planning, that are convenient to transit. Convenient to the bike trail is good for some people too, you know, that want to commute by bike and bike close to amenities as well.
I mean, that's the idea behind it. And the reason that my understanding is that the legislature empowered EOHLC was to develop guidelines so that you wouldn't have a one-size-fits-all that you might find in a strict interpretation of the statute. So, 15 units an acre, you know, for some places might be completely appropriate and you just put it everywhere, but that they gave flexibility to have it be as an average is to allow you to tailor it to places that you can have more or less that makes sense, which is something that we've been trying to take advantage of quite a bit. And also to have it be that you don't have to have all of it in half a mile when your transit is along your edge of your town, right?
And in this case, the commuter rail is the same as a trolley that way. Everything is on the edge of the town. So being able to you know, have other places that we think make more sense based on a lot of science or what else is near there, I think also is a good flexibility that's built into the guidelines. And that's why I think that the guidelines provide us more flexibility than the statute does itself.
Speaker 12 (01:30:20–01:30:54)
And I agree, like as a town, there are other places in town that make sense from a planning perspective. But that's different than the MBTA 3A. So if you just follow the statute, MBTA 3A, it doesn't say average of 15 units per acre. So I think we're trying to do too much with the MBTA zoning.
Speaker 14 (01:30:54–01:31:51)
But if you think about the way it was, maybe it was contemplated. And if you say, okay, the red line goes through Quincy and they have whatever existing fabric around those red line stations, that's a lot different than the fabric we have around ours. So what, I don't know what was in the legislators' minds and how they came up with 15 units and acres being the right thing. I wish that they would justify how they arrived at that density because I'm not sure that it's a planning What's the planning logic?
And maybe there is a planning logic for that, that that's what triggers you to allow mixed use, for example, because that triggers enough people to be able to support a local restaurant or cafe. But it's not something which has given us any flexibility. That's one of the things that I think has been a little bit of a struggle. But the things that are in the guideline do give flexibility or in the regulation.
And I think we've studied those quite a bit to see.
Speaker 2 (01:31:51–01:34:40)
It's most likely that what we're facing in Milton was never contemplated. Never. The idea that the idea that the classification was arrived at and the notion that our transit is on the boundary of our town with the city of Boston, you know, and then we have this notion that, well, 50% of it doesn't have to be within a half mile in a town that's as densely built out as Milton has created so many problems for Milton. If we had simply been recognized as a community that was disadvantaged by the location of the transit and we were given the expectation to accomplish 50% because we can't go the half mile on the other side of transit, this probably would have been resolved a long time ago.
But this idea that we're wandering around Milton, how many different neighbors have we heard over the last year and a half talk about how they felt about this being applied to their neighborhood today. We just heard from several neighbors that are not happy with what we've talked about within the commuter rail area. We've heard plenty from the folks in East Milton. We've heard plenty from the folks on Grand Avenue.
We've heard plenty from the folks on Elliott Street. This is… It was never contemplated. I don't believe Milton was ever contemplated by anybody that worked on this.
And no one ever really imagined how difficult it would be to accomplish this in Milton. Milton is probably the most unique community within all of the 177 communities that are challenged with trying to achieve this. So I don't believe there was ever adequate contemplation of what's happening right here in this town. So, you know, look at what we're trying to do.
I agree with what you said, Cheryl. The spirit of this, and I think I've said this numerous times, the spirit of building housing, long before 3A was even a law, this goes back years and years and years ago, the idea was to build housing where there is rail transport. That's a notion that is decades old. That made all the sense in the world.
I remember building a project 20 years ago on a rail line. You know, that makes great sense. What you said earlier about building in an area where there is transportation, where there also is amenities that people can walk to, yes, a bike trail, perfect. All of that's great.
We're forcing something into Milton, forcing it into neighborhoods to reach a calculation that was never really imagined of what they were gonna ask Milton to do, so.
Speaker 14 (01:34:42–01:35:07)
But I even think the 15 units an acre applied to an area which has, you know, 1920s era built out character, and it was built with the transportation in mind, that area. And so, I don't think very many other communities have had a situation where they're rezoning single family parcels for it.
Speaker 2 (01:35:07–01:35:28)
And Cheryl, it also works, I think, in communities that are, you know, well outside of where we are in proximity to the city of Boston. You move yourself out into some of these communities, there's a lot more open land. There's a lot of land that's available, you know, near rail that you can put 15 units per acre on. And it's not going to create the scenarios that we're developing here.
Speaker 14 (01:35:28–01:36:20)
But I do think, you know, granted I have North. unclery house, extra space storage. We've identified places where we can, and that is within a half a mile of a trolley station. By doing those and then still having the only street quarter at a lower density, I think is the best approach to meeting what is required of this law.
And whether it's the letter of the law or the spirit of law, we can debate, I guess. But the approach that I think we've taken to it, which the guidelines have allowed us to do, is what allows us to even get close to having something that works for Milton. I really don't think the 15 units an acre blanket across whatever's there is a good approach. I don't like it.
That's why I like the guidelines better or the regulations better because they give us more flexibility.
Speaker 1 (01:36:20–01:37:40)
Great. So thank you, Tom. I appreciate your being here. We're going to, you know, we will be presenting all three of these and be able to sort of hear from the residents, hear from the community.
I think we should share Tom's memo with town council because I think what Tom is, what he's saying is, Guidelines can't be in conflict with the statute. And that's what we have. We have regulations that are using the term rapid transit again and again when there's no mention of rapid transit anywhere in the statute. So there's things that, yes, HLC was asked to promulgate these guidelines.
the guidelines or the regulations for the statute, but they can't expand on what the statute is. They can define within the parameters of that statute. So I think that's where I'm struggling and I have a finding conflict that it can't be more than what is in there. And what Tom was demonstrating was Section 5, Section 1A, I believe, does use the term rapid transit and does use eligible parcels, but that's not in 3A.
Speaker 14 (01:37:41–01:38:05)
I guess I really see that as sort of a legal issue. Yeah. So I think from our point of view, we're trying to address the three scenarios that we have felt like we're trying to do, that we're prepared with three scenarios, depending on the legal advice that the town gets. because I don't feel like it's our role to make a decision about that.
It's really the select board's role.
Speaker 1 (01:38:06–01:38:19)
And Thursday will really be to hear from the residents on, we're trying to find the best scenarios and have something that's statute compliant, but looking at the best alternatives.
Speaker 2 (01:38:19–01:38:35)
Part of our responsibility though, I believe, is the Select Board has identified that they feel 10% is fair for Milton, right? That's what the Select Board has said. So when they say that, I feel our obligation is to get as close to that as we possibly can.
Speaker 14 (01:38:35–01:39:54)
Well, we have, I think we have, as we said, we have statutory, which I don't like that, for reasons I've already said. I think we have a reasonable adjacent community, 10%, and we have a reasonable rapid transit community that people can see how this would work and how it's different than what they saw in 2023. And if the select board, I mean, really town, We have until July 13th to adopt zoning, right? We know that the final regs, the emergency regs have 90 day life.
We expect the final regs right next week. So we'll probably have them before the forum. And then the question is if those regs say as the emergency regs say that we're a rapid transit classification, then the decision needs to be made what's presented to the town meeting to approve in June, right? If there's some other legal thought about it, that's really coming from the select board because we don't have any authority to make any kind of legal challenge or recommendation.
So I think our best bet is to have options available.
Speaker 2 (01:39:53–01:41:02)
I don't want you to misunderstand me. I am 100% in favor of putting everything out in the public forum. If you think I'm opposed to that, that's the wrong interpretation of my point of view. I want to put it all out there.
And I look forward to the residents having an opportunity to see everything that we've created, all the plans. I'm not suggesting we only put one plan out there, not at all. I want them to see the 25% plan. I want them to see the, and I'm gonna try to start referring to it as the commuter rail station plan, right?
Because again, if we're going to follow a statute, follow the law, we should probably use the correct title. So I want them to see all of it and give them a chance to, you know, you make some valid points about some of these areas that I think are really appropriate development. And even if we weren't forced into it, it might be a good idea to do some of the zoning anyway, right? For some of these areas, when you talk about Milton Station East, there's some really nice development opportunities over there.
We probably should be talking about it, even if we weren't forced into it. So I want to talk about all of it. This has gone on for so long, we've got to get this thing to the end.
Speaker 12 (01:41:04–01:41:51)
And the other thing that I'm hoping, if we're going to be reaching out to town council, I would also like to know if HLC has done their small business impact analysis. So that is one of the requirements of the Administrative Procedures Act. And I haven't seen that. I've been sort of following that closely, and I haven't, seen that they have done a small business impact analysis.
I'm not sure if you know if they have or not. And will that analysis be released prior to the final regulations? I would think that they would be, as that is a mandatory step.
Speaker 14 (01:41:51–01:41:53)
Maybe that's something Cheyenne or Nick can ask about.
Speaker 12 (01:41:53–01:41:54)
Cheyenne, can you note that?
Speaker 1 (01:41:54–01:41:58)
Yeah, if the small business impact analysis
Speaker 12 (01:41:58–01:42:51)
And the other thing from a policy perspective is our, about the unfunded mandate. You know, so who, again, if we're going to stay in our lane, the policy is maybe from the select board is looking to get a determination from a court because my understanding is since the auditor has already acknowledged that it is an unfunded mandate, now it's up to every town to petition the court to get that determination officially. So my question is when is the town of Milton going to pursue that policy?
Speaker 14 (01:42:53–01:43:02)
Most of our work was funded by grant money though. most of UTILS work and RKG work.
Speaker 12 (01:43:02–01:43:10)
But the unfunded mandate is not just about doing the work, the study, it's really the future impact.
Speaker 14 (01:43:12–01:43:17)
There's, well, all right. That's correct. So that's just a question.
Speaker 12 (01:43:17–01:43:18)
Those are my questions.
Speaker 8 (01:43:18–01:43:28)
We should actually pursue that. I mean, do we suggest to the select board that they pursue the unfunded mandate? I mean, the way I understand it, it's a one-page petition.
Speaker 12 (01:43:28–01:43:54)
It's like I know when they discussed it. Yeah, do like I know in the past, I think we didn't we write a letter or suggest to the select board that we encourage them to seek reclassification. So would we as a planning board do a similar letter to the select men saying we would like them to pursue the unfunded mandate? through the courts.
Speaker 14 (01:43:55–01:44:17)
You know, I did share, maybe a month ago, an email, or by email, grants that were awarded to towns, basically infrastructure, you know, that would be applied towards those who are compliant with 3A. So, I don't know where that interface is with that.
Speaker 8 (01:44:17–01:44:19)
I don't think that justifies the unfunded mandate.
Speaker 5 (01:44:20–01:44:22)
It's worth talking to Nick about that.
Speaker 8 (01:44:22–01:44:29)
I think it is, yeah. I think we should eventually take a vote and pursue it, or not, or take a vote to not pursue it.
Speaker 1 (01:44:29–01:44:32)
I think the select board would have to take that vote, but we can talk to them in a related way.
Speaker 8 (01:44:32–01:44:34)
We can show our support for something like that.
Speaker 1 (01:44:34–01:44:36)
Interested in finding out where they're standing on this.
Speaker 12 (01:44:36–01:45:00)
Yeah, my understanding is it doesn't necessarily have to be just, the selectmen who do that, it could actually be 10 residents of a town could actually do that as well. I think it's a stronger argument if it comes from our select board, but I don't think that that's the only option.
Speaker 1 (01:45:01–01:45:04)
Well, thank you. I feel like this was productive. Did anyone have anything else?
Speaker 14 (01:45:04–01:45:54)
So, I just wanted to say to your point earlier, Meredith, about getting material posted. If Cheyenne could ask you to when they think they would have a package ready, and it, I know we don't have another meeting before then, but it would be nice maybe to have a look at it before it gets posted just in case we have any questions, we can channel them through Cheyenne. And they should have plenty of time since they were able to get this information. And maybe hope to have it posted by Monday or Tuesday maybe at the latest.
But if we could get a quick look at it just to make sure it's what we understand it to be, like if a slide we think is missing or something like that, we can make sure it gets included. So Cheyenne, is that something that you can check in with UTIL about?
Speaker 3 (01:45:55–01:46:02)
Yes, I won't be back in the office till Monday, so I'll just, I'll have Julia do it tomorrow. Ask him for the packet and we'll get it.
Speaker 1 (01:46:02–01:46:19)
Okay. Okay. And Cheyenne, we're also going to need to file this amendment to the special permit. Will Julia be able to, Julia, will you be able to do that tomorrow?
I'll leave it on your desk. Sure. Bring it down to Sue, and I did date it, so.
Speaker 5 (01:46:19–01:46:19)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (01:46:20–01:46:21)
We were all together tonight.
Speaker 2 (01:46:22–01:47:01)
Can we talk for a few minutes before we close just about how we're going to, how this is going to be conducted at the Council on Aging? I mean, we all know it's, some of this is hard to follow. You know, the maps are hard to read. People can't discern where is the street that I live on, right?
I mean, so how, you know, maybe in advance of that, we don't have to get into the details of it today, but I think this is something that's gonna be really important. It's how this is all communicated. I know Util's gonna lead the way, but the visuals are really important. I'm not sure if we're gonna be adequately able to do that.
I don't know.
Speaker 14 (01:47:01–01:47:12)
I think that the large screen at the Council on Aging is a lot bigger than this, which is beneficial. I think that Zoe's very skilled at presenting complex information.
Speaker 2 (01:47:13–01:47:23)
I'm not worried about her. I'm more worried about the technology, the clarity of the screen, whether people can actually read it. You know, that's not that crisp, that screen. So, we may just be a bit limited in that way.
Speaker 14 (01:47:23–01:47:33)
Maybe we could ask if handouts… That's what I was going to say. I mean, I have… But I don't think they have to be 11 by 17.
I think they could be an 8.5 by 11.
Speaker 2 (01:47:33–01:48:00)
It might be a little bit… It might be helpful for people if we had, you know, some posted, you know, large… You happen to print everything, which is great. You've an advantage because I know you've got all the equipment to print whatever you want, whatever size.
You got all that going. I get it. But it might be helpful if we have some printed so people could actually see them either on easels or posted on the wall. But there's a ton here for people to digest.
Speaker 14 (01:48:01–01:48:09)
Well, maybe even just three maps. Sure. At least 30 by 42 inch size.
Speaker 2 (01:48:09–01:48:25)
Yeah, typical drawing size that we typically see. I think we should put a little bit of thought into that so we don't have people frustrated at the end of it like I couldn't understand and I was sitting in the back and the screen was a long way. You know what I mean. We don't have too many chances to do this right.
Speaker 12 (01:48:26–01:48:54)
And not to put more work on our town staff, but when maps are created, they actually are able to do an Excel spreadsheet of each property by the property ID. So I know Alan Bishop in the GIS department, he has provided a list of the actual addresses. So I don't know if he has the ability to have that ready for the forum.
Speaker 1 (01:48:55–01:49:03)
We certainly can request it, because I think it's, yeah, it's built into the… I hate to ask this of the chair, but I'll ask it.
Speaker 2 (01:49:03–01:49:11)
It may be worth like a dry run between you, Cheyenne, and Zoe next week before the meeting, just to discuss how we're gonna have this all prepared.
Speaker 1 (01:49:12–01:49:34)
And have the presentation sent to us all, so we can sort of review it to see if there's anything. I know Tom has a couple of things that he was saying, you know, it should be added or, you know, certain little changes in the presentation itself. But if we have it all sent to all of us, if there's anything you can send it, comments to Cheyenne.
Speaker 14 (01:49:35–01:50:00)
So I think you shared Tom's email with you too. I also think that there's information in Mr. Hokanson's email that could be shared with you too as well. So just so that Those are the most detailed comments that we have received.
So rather than just having one person share with you, I'll have the other person share with you as well.
Speaker 2 (01:50:00–01:50:01)
Yeah, Eric should be sent along too.
Speaker 14 (01:50:01–01:50:05)
Yeah. Okay. So if Cheyenne can do that as well.
Speaker 12 (01:50:07–01:50:17)
Now, would Town Council have an opportunity to send his comments to UTL as well? Because a lot of this, I mean, it's all legal.
Speaker 14 (01:50:17–01:50:35)
Yeah, so that's why I'm a little concerned about instructing UTL to change their comments and not having us sort of have a a chance to see it, to have it, and if I see it. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3 (01:50:36–01:51:03)
So I have a quick note. Our next meeting, or at least Nick and I's next meeting with UTL is until next Wednesday. And I think when I was talking to Nick earlier, we were kind of wondering, like, if everything would be wrapped up today so that they can start working on things. So if we, I think if we start adding more and more comments, at the beginning of next week, it's not really going to give them much time to reproduce and then send out and do a dry run all before Thursday night.
Speaker 1 (01:51:03–01:51:12)
So I think if we said… I don't think there's many changes. It was just… Cheyenne, if you read what just there were a few things maybe adding the definition.
Speaker 14 (01:51:13–01:51:20)
I think the definition of three-family was the only thing that… Was a definition. That should be a change in their materials.
Speaker 1 (01:51:20–01:51:32)
And also eligible parcels. I think there was a comment that eligible parcels was not included in the statute. It was in one in five, section one of five, but eligible parcels is referred to.
Speaker 8 (01:51:34–01:51:51)
So that's a town council question, you know, to… So Eric Holkinson specifically in his letter says, I respect the request that neither this email nor my previous ones are used to justify further revisions or anything of the sort. So I think we might wanna not forward his email to anyone.
Speaker 14 (01:51:52–01:52:16)
All right. Well, then it just becomes a question of, you know, we're instructing you to change some things about what they put in as their interpretations and doing their work. And I'm just. Well, we can just ask.
I guess maybe raise the question for them, but I don't think we should instruct them to change what they think is proper.
Speaker 1 (01:52:17–01:52:23)
And if it's in the presentation for Thursday, certainly we could change it before we submit anything to HLC.
Speaker 12 (01:52:24–01:52:34)
Now, does UTL, maybe we should have asked this a year and a half ago before we ordered them the contract, but do they have an attorney that reviews all of this in their firm?
Speaker 14 (01:52:37–01:52:49)
I don't know if they do or not, but I know they've been working with HLC now for probably two or three years. At HLC, they're not attorneys. They have attorneys within HLC.
Speaker 12 (01:52:53–01:53:01)
And they're not looking out for the best interest of the town of Milton. They're looking out for the best interest from the state.
Speaker 1 (01:53:01–01:53:04)
Yeah, well, they don't represent Milton. That's correct. We have town council for that.
Speaker 12 (01:53:04–01:53:05)
Right. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (01:53:05–01:53:12)
So we'll have town council review it before any changes are made. So, yeah, I guess that's that's what you're saying.
Speaker 14 (01:53:12–01:53:23)
Yeah. Before we ask you to make changes, let's have town council address it. Tom's comments. And good catch, Jim, on what he said.
Speaker 8 (01:53:23–01:53:30)
Yeah, start reading the end of the email. Yeah. Anyway, it's all good. Yeah.
Anytime. Just save me. I'm here. I'm here for you guys.
Speaker 7 (01:53:30–01:53:34)
All right, great. Yeah, yeah. One last question. I'll follow up.
Speaker 2 (01:53:34–01:53:43)
Yeah, okay. Can we just quickly talk about May? May's a busy month. We have town meeting and I just, can we just talk quickly about what our meetings are?
Speaker 1 (01:53:43–01:53:55)
Yes, that reminds me, I do have two, Two questions, Cheyenne had said because of town meeting, do we want to move our regular scheduled meeting to the following week?
Speaker 2 (01:53:55–01:53:58)
Right, I think Cheyenne was suggesting go from the 8th to the 15th, is that?
Speaker 1 (01:53:58–01:54:04)
Yeah, and I think Cheryl responded, we just don't know where. where we're gonna be at that point.
Speaker 14 (01:54:04–01:54:11)
Yeah, I was just concerned that we need adequate time for submitting articles.
Speaker 1 (01:54:13–01:54:40)
But I know you wanna get your scheduled, so. So we'll have our meeting, our next meeting will be on the 17th for the forum and then the 24th. And then our regularly scheduled meeting would be the 8th, but we will have had town meeting 5, 6, 7, the previous days. So.
Speaker 14 (01:54:42–01:54:54)
So do you know when we have to have the public hearing for articles for a June 16th town meeting, and when do we have to have final language submitted?
Speaker 5 (01:54:54–01:54:55)
Cheyenne, do you have that date?
Speaker 1 (01:54:57–01:55:06)
I know it's on our timeline in Zoe's earlier presentation, I believe. Yeah, but do you recall what that date is?
Speaker 3 (01:55:08–01:55:22)
We made like a personal one. I think we were going to do around the 22nd. And then we're going to get everything ran at all times by early May. So the 22nd would be our public hearing date.
Speaker 14 (01:55:24–01:55:38)
But the language needs, I thought it's like a month before town meeting that it goes to the printer. So I thought the warrant is finalized. on the 16th and then we're having the public hearing after the warrant is finalized?
Speaker 1 (01:55:38–01:55:47)
We can do that. Tim would always say you can have it up to the week before, but obviously it makes sense. I prefer to have it earlier.
Speaker 14 (01:55:47–01:56:15)
So my concern would be then to go from the April 24th and then not have a meeting until the time that it has to be finalized. Because you're talking about having a meeting when? So we could- Because the 16th is a Friday. The 16th is what we were talking about.
So it's Friday the 16th, or the 16th of May is a Friday. So we would just have, that would be the last meeting or the last discussion before it has to be sent to print.
Speaker 2 (01:56:19–01:56:31)
So does this, are we really trying to decide if we can manage one on the 8th? Is that really what's coming down to? We have town meeting the 5th, 6th, and possibly the 7th.
Speaker 14 (01:56:32–01:56:40)
Yeah, I think it's just whether, realistically, what it's going to take to get to this end line here.
Speaker 2 (01:56:40–01:56:42)
That's the challenge, right? Four nights in a row.
Speaker 14 (01:56:42–01:56:42)
Right.
Speaker 12 (01:56:44–01:56:47)
Well, the bigger challenge is we have an election in between.
Speaker 14 (01:56:49–01:56:54)
We could also schedule a meeting for May 1st. Meaning I might not be here. Or myself.
Speaker 12 (01:56:54–01:56:55)
Then I don't have to.
Speaker 2 (01:56:56–01:56:57)
I'm not worried about it anymore.
Speaker 12 (01:56:57–01:57:00)
So I don't know if it's too premature to be talking about the… It probably is.
Speaker 2 (01:57:01–01:57:01)
That's right.
Speaker 14 (01:57:02–01:57:03)
What about May 1st?
Speaker 12 (01:57:04–01:57:07)
And then the bigger… May 1st is what happens.
Speaker 14 (01:57:07–01:57:10)
May 1st and then May 15th. That makes sense.
Speaker 2 (01:57:10–01:57:22)
That almost… I know. I will probably be… I'll be late on May 1st.
I have a board meeting that I have to be at. So I could be here, but I probably couldn't get it till eight o'clock.
Speaker 14 (01:57:25–01:57:47)
Okay. Well, it just, I think we could put it in the pencil that in just, I do think given where we are, that would give three meetings between the public forum and the final language. Yeah.
Speaker 2 (01:57:50–01:57:56)
If the board was able to move to Wednesday the 30th, I could be here on time.
Speaker 5 (01:57:58–01:58:02)
April 30th, I could do that. I can do the 30th.
Speaker 14 (01:58:05–01:58:06)
How about Cheyenne?
Speaker 1 (01:58:06–01:58:08)
Cheyenne, would that be good for you?
Speaker 3 (01:58:10–01:58:15)
Yeah, I'll be around the 30th, but not time needed just so everybody knows.
Speaker 14 (01:58:17–01:58:26)
And what about the, so then we would go to the 15th? Yeah. May 15th?
Speaker 1 (01:58:26–01:58:32)
Maybe we tentatively schedule the 8th if we just need to meet quickly on something.
Speaker 14 (01:58:32–01:58:41)
But I don't. So you want to put a April 24th, April 30th, May 8th. And May 15th.
Speaker 1 (01:58:43–01:58:49)
And we'll just put those in as placeholders, but hopefully we won't need all of those.
Speaker 14 (01:58:49–01:58:56)
So Julia or Cheyenne, can you send out calendar invites as holds for those for us, please?
Speaker 1 (01:58:56–01:59:49)
And one other, just last thing I meant to mention is Tom Caldwell is trying to get things lined up for the Junetown meeting and get his comments done as quickly as possible and has invited us to come for just a Q&A with the Warrant Committee on the East Milton overlay zoning. And I told him that next week is a really busy week for the planning board with with the forum and other obligations. So wondering if the following week, let's see where I was. Quick question, did you say May 13th or 15th?
15th. Okay, thanks. Because you all have Monday the candidate forum and then there's Thursday.
Speaker 13 (01:59:49–01:59:50)
Oh, I can't make the 15th.
Speaker 1 (01:59:51–01:59:52)
Oh, you can't make the 15th?
Speaker 13 (01:59:52–01:59:54)
No, my daughter's graduating.
Speaker 1 (01:59:54–01:59:55)
That's a good excuse.
Speaker 13 (01:59:56–01:59:57)
That's a hell of an excuse.
Speaker 1 (01:59:57–02:00:08)
So she's getting her undergrad on Thursday and her graduate on Friday. Would you want to move? Oh, that's awesome. Would you want to move to the 14th?
We have May 14th.
Speaker 14 (02:00:08–02:00:11)
I have another meeting that night.
Speaker 8 (02:00:11–02:00:17)
You guys can meet without me. It's not the end of the world if I miss one. Seems like we're pretty crunched for time.
Speaker 14 (02:00:18–02:00:23)
That should be pretty close to finalizing too, so.
Speaker 8 (02:00:24–02:00:26)
I won't take it personally if you guys need it.
Speaker 1 (02:00:26–02:00:32)
Okay. All right, then we'll keep the 15th for now, but if we need to adjust that.
Speaker 2 (02:00:34–02:00:43)
Did you say the 14th would work for you if we move to the 14th? I could do the 14th. Yeah, I think Cheryl can't do the 14th. Oh, you can't do the 14th.
Okay. Thank you, though.
Speaker 14 (02:00:43–02:00:44)
Unless I try and move another meeting.
Speaker 2 (02:00:46–02:00:51)
So, I'm sorry to move all over the place, but could we all get together for the 13th?
Speaker 14 (02:00:52–02:00:56)
It would just be a couple of days in between. I could do that. Would that be all right, though?
Speaker 2 (02:00:56–02:00:58)
Oh, you mean the 13th and the 15th?
Speaker 14 (02:00:58–02:01:02)
No, the 8th is a Thursday, and it's just a couple of days.
Speaker 2 (02:01:02–02:01:17)
I guess our alternative is to meet on the 14th, and you're not present, or meet on the 15th, and Jim's not present. But if all of us could be present for the 13th? I could do that. Cool.
Thank you. I mean, there's adequate space to sleep. I suppose we could move in up here too, right?
Speaker 1 (02:01:17–02:01:17)
A little bunk room.
Speaker 2 (02:01:17–02:01:21)
I heard the food's good. Okay.
Speaker 1 (02:01:21–02:01:34)
So, Julia and Cheyenne, we then will have our meeting on the 24th of April, the meeting on the 30th of April, and then May 8th and then May 13th.
Speaker 14 (02:01:34–02:01:42)
And then is the 22nd still the public hearing? May 22nd? And that we would, yeah.
Speaker 1 (02:01:42–02:01:48)
Didn't you say May 1st, we have a meeting too? We moved that to the 30th, April 30th.
Speaker 14 (02:01:49–02:01:53)
So can you just review those dates again for anybody who might be interested?
Speaker 1 (02:01:53–02:02:05)
Yes, so 4-24, 4-30, May 5-8, 5-13, and then a public hearing on 5-22.
Speaker 14 (02:02:07–02:02:10)
And the public hearing is just on the MBTA community center, right? Correct.
Speaker 1 (02:02:12–02:02:17)
Well, actually, we need to do our other articles.
Speaker 3 (02:02:17–02:02:26)
Because we're going to have 20 seconds going to be Lex Lane, East Milton Square and OK, we'll do all three.
Speaker 1 (02:02:27–02:02:28)
OK, that's good.
Speaker 12 (02:02:29–02:02:31)
OK, then enough time for all three.
Speaker 14 (02:02:35–02:02:38)
We've had a lot of process on the East Mountain Square, right? Yes.
Speaker 2 (02:02:39–02:02:42)
So what are we fitting in on the 22nd East Mountain Square and what else?
Speaker 1 (02:02:42–02:03:25)
The floodplain. The floodplain, which is, yeah. Okay. All right, and then, sorry, just to go back again.
So for the Warrant Committee, again, this would be open to all, whoever could make it. They just, Tom Caldwell just asked that we could give him a date. So next week, I told him it probably wouldn't be good, but the week of the 21st, 22nd, we've got our meeting on the 24th. Would Monday the 21st?
Speaker 7 (02:03:26–02:03:27)
What am I doing?
Speaker 1 (02:03:28–02:03:33)
Work for people? Whoever wants to go to the Warren committee.
Speaker 2 (02:03:34–02:03:35)
What time would that be?
Speaker 1 (02:03:35–02:03:37)
7 p.m.?
Speaker 2 (02:03:37–02:03:38)
I can't.
Speaker 1 (02:03:39–02:03:45)
That's it, don't worry about it, yeah. Mondays, I know, are tough. Or Tuesday. I mean, if you want to go.
Speaker 2 (02:03:45–02:03:49)
It's not about that. I have a campaign. For my campaign, it's Steel and Rye.
Speaker 1 (02:03:50–02:03:50)
Oh, that's, I'm sorry.
Speaker 2 (02:03:50–02:03:51)
You're welcome to come.
Speaker 1 (02:03:51–02:03:53)
I'm sorry, that's, yeah, of course.
Speaker 2 (02:03:53–02:03:55)
I assume you're gonna be there now.
Speaker 1 (02:03:55–02:04:02)
Yeah, I know, that's. Plug it. Yeah, no, that's. So let's do the 22nd, then.
The 22nd?
Speaker 12 (02:04:03–02:04:09)
Oh, 22nd is Earth Day, and that's my daughter's 24th birthday.
Speaker 14 (02:04:10–02:04:21)
Oh. I can't do the 23rd, and we have a meeting on the 25th. So I guess, Meredith, you can, this is for the East Milton.
Speaker 1 (02:04:21–02:04:32)
This is for East Milton overlay, just to give them sort of a run through. And did we already talk with them about that? I did. I went and just sort of gave them an overview.
This was, I think they're taking a deeper dive in because they were so deep in everything else.
Speaker 4 (02:04:33–02:04:33)
Okay.
Speaker 12 (02:04:34–02:04:38)
Of all the days, maybe the 22nd or it could be later.
Speaker 1 (02:04:42–02:04:44)
Yeah.
Speaker 8 (02:04:44–02:04:45)
22nd would be better for me.
Speaker 1 (02:04:47–02:05:31)
Let's do this 22nd and Maggie, if you can't make it, don't worry. What time is that at? That's at 7 p.m. But again, I know these are a lot of meetings, but I'll tell him at least, and we'll post that as a public meeting for April 22nd.
More committee, okay. So I think that's, Cheyenne, did you have anything else? No, I did not have anything else. So we can let Milton Access TV go home early tonight.
Anything else?
Speaker 8 (02:05:31–02:05:32)
We're just filled up.
Speaker 1 (02:05:32–02:05:39)
If there's anything else from the letters? No, not for me. No. Okay.
Okay, great. So I would entertain a motion to adjourn.
Speaker 8 (02:05:40–02:05:41)
I'll make a motion to adjourn.
Speaker 1 (02:05:42–02:05:45)
Is there a second? I will second. All in favor?
Speaker 5 (02:05:45–02:05:45)
Aye.
Speaker 17 (02:05:46–02:05:47)
Good night.