Board: Planning Board
Date: 2026-05-14
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:22–00:37)
Good evening and welcome to the 20th meeting of fiscal year 2026. At this time, I would like to now call the meeting to order and begin by introducing the members of the planning board and our staff. Would you like to begin?
Speaker 2 (00:37–00:42)
Sure. Cheryl Tagayas, secretary. Sean Fahey, member. Hale Munger, member.
Speaker 1 (00:42–00:51)
And Meredith Hall, serving as chair. And tonight on Zoom, we also have Maggie. on mute.
Speaker 3 (00:51–00:56)
You're on mute, Maggie.
Speaker 1 (00:56–01:05)
Sorry, Maggie, old field member. Right. And tonight with us also on Zoom, we have our planning director, Liz, if you'd like to introduce yourself.
Speaker 4 (01:07–01:08)
Planning director. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (01:09–02:58)
Thank you. All right. So now we can move to our administrative items. First, we have our meeting minutes.
We have We had four sets of minutes from our last meeting that we had deferred, and we have meeting minutes from March 12th and 26th. I have not had a chance to look at the 12th and the 26th. Sean, I know you're set with those. Cheryl and Maggie, were you able to review the, it would be October 9th, October 23rd, the October 27th and November 13th.
So if we'd like to go through those, starting with October 9th, I had just a few minor things. On the first page, under public comment, third, the fourth line down, it says he addeds. It just needs the S removed. Okay, this would be he added to, and page three, second paragraph, first sentence, it was the same thing.
I think there must have been something with the typewriter. Actually, the last line in the first paragraph also, then reached, the S needs to be crossed off that. Mr. Geis mentioned in the next line that S also needed to be removed.
And then in the fourth paragraph on the fourth line, she added, it needs to be added. That was just wrong.
Speaker 2 (02:58–03:11)
It was sticking. It was sticking. You're good at catching these. And sometimes I think when you're trying to show that it's crossed out on what you're adding, it gets lost in there.
Right, exactly.
Speaker 1 (03:11–05:49)
And then And then, okay, under Milton Village, Local Historic District Discussion, Mr. Loeffler, it's actually L-A-W-F-L-E-R, Mr. Loeffler, and then it's also down under where it begins, Ms. Oldfield says, Mr.
Wild, the second line, Loeffler, spelled incorrectly. It's L-A-W-F-L-E-R. And that's all I had on those. Did anybody else have anything on October 9th?
Okay. So maybe, I don't know if we want to do these individually or all together. Okay, we'll keep going. So then October 23rd under staff update, Ms.
Manning asks, there's an S again, that friendly S. And in the following sentence, Ms. DeGias suggested that needs to lose the S. First sentence, first line in the next paragraph, Ms.
Manning discussed that needs to lose the S. And then the first sentence in the last paragraph, Ms. DeGias explained that needs to lose the S. Then on the very last paragraph of the second page, Mr.
Geis explained that the MPIC recommends the formation. I'm sorry. It's actually the second sentence where it says, she said there is a lot of content. It just says a lot content.
So I think it needs an of in between lot and content. There was… This is, there were two paragraphs. I actually, I know, I understand you were trying to cross it out, but I thought it might be important to include on the first paragraph of the third page.
Speaker 2 (05:49–05:59)
It's possible for Liz or… Yeah, to bring it up. The typos I don't think I need to see, but if you want to bring a paragraph back, I'd like to see it.
Speaker 4 (05:59–06:07)
There were two on this, which I just thought were important. What would you like me to do, pull up the page?
Speaker 1 (06:07–06:16)
Can you pull up the minutes from the third page of October 3rd? Okay.
Speaker 3 (06:28–06:29)
October 23rd?
Speaker 5 (06:30–06:30)
Yes.
Speaker 3 (06:48–06:54)
Yeah. Okay.
Speaker 4 (06:56–06:58)
How's that, good? And then page three?
Speaker 1 (06:58–07:40)
And then page three, please. And then it's the top, the very first paragraph. Right here? Yes.
And again, I thank Cheryl for going through this and taking a lot of this content out. This is the first paragraph. Mr. Fahy says he wants to collaboratively create an article that they can say the planning board unanimously supports and does not want to rush creation of a committee that serves an important process.
Ms. Hall said the planning board has a responsibility to extend the implementation timeframe. She says she didn't realize that last year when the MPIC was being extended, that it should have been something that the planning board had voted on.
Speaker 6 (07:41–07:51)
I thought there was some duplication. So can you just scroll back? Yeah, if there is. It's almost quite recognized.
Speaker 2 (07:57–08:05)
There's where it says to work collaboratively to create an article together. So I thought it was covered there. But if you don't think it's covered there.
Speaker 1 (08:05–08:06)
Where are you?
Speaker 2 (08:06–08:08)
I'm sorry. The paragraph that begins with Mr. Fahey.
Speaker 1 (08:12–08:14)
The second one on the second page?
Speaker 6 (08:16–08:25)
Sorry, I'm just looking on the screen. So I'm not sure which page that is. It looks like second page. Yeah, page two.
So where it says Mr. Fahey recognizes
Speaker 3 (08:27–08:40)
that is important committee that the select board initially proposed this committee. And it says the process was rushed.
Speaker 1 (08:40–08:44)
I thought that was kind of repetitive. So that's fine.
Speaker 6 (08:44–08:45)
I'm fine with that.
Speaker 1 (08:45–09:19)
OK, I just wanted to make sure we had noted that the planning board thought we would have had input. on that and then the next which was sort of similar and again this it may be another one of those maybe it might have been yeah I don't think I was trying to take out content no right one two three on the fourth page the third paragraph if you pull that up Miss Hall said she wants to make sure that communication is coming is coming through.
Speaker 6 (09:19–09:25)
I wasn't sure what that first sentence meant. I know. I know that doesn't really make sense.
Speaker 1 (09:25–11:40)
It doesn't make sense to me. To the planning board and collaborate with consultant. And. Yeah, that one, I don't know why that that I'm fine with.
So sorry. And then just the last paragraph of that where it says Ms. Manning provides It should be provided. Provided.
Yeah, I had a D there, so provided. And then that was it for that one. And jump in, anyone? In the 27th, I don't think I didn't have anything on that.
That was all fine. And then on November 13th, Under future meeting dates, Ms. Hull said the planning board will, it either needs to be, will not be meeting the week of or will not meet. And you added, oh, you did take that off.
So will not meet, nevermind. I didn't see that was stopped. And then the second page, She is interested, the second line, she's interested in connecting them about, connecting with them about the 40B projects. And it should have a, I think, two better understand.
So a two after and. And two better understand. He's on the same page, the second to the last paragraph. It starts with Ms.
Oldfield, the third line down, document from MAPC of the same. I think you just said of same. Okay. So of the same.
Sound better? And then the last paragraph, first line after discussed has an S, and then the second line after November 10th, she suggested that needs to lose that S.
Speaker 6 (11:43–11:49)
So every time it changed from present tense to past tense, the S didn't get eliminated.
Speaker 1 (11:50–12:55)
And then introduction of Michael White, the second line, where it says on the second line, and he has been, I think you took out been trying to, but I think the been needs to stay in. He had been working to understand. So keeping that in. And then that might have been.
All right, on that last page under fiscal year 27, planning board budget, the second paragraph down from that, there's just a, it says Ms. Hall on the second line, Ms. Hall said, I think noted maybe that KP law would sound better. And then the last sentence on that page, Ms.
Speaker 2 (12:55–13:11)
Hall seconded that just needs to lose the S. Since I think these are mostly clerical, Liz, do you think that you can pick these, Univanti can pick these up without a name for us to resubmit them? Yeah. Okay.
Speaker 4 (13:11–13:18)
One of us is going to have to listen to the recording anyway, so we'll get them that way.
Speaker 1 (13:18–13:44)
Yeah, little, I mean, little minor things, but. Okay, with that, if I could have a motion to approve the meeting minutes for October 9th, October 23rd, October 27th, and November 13th? As amended and corrected. Amended and corrected, okay.
Is there a second? Second. We have to do a roll call because Maggie's online. So Maggie?
Speaker 3 (13:45–13:47)
Yes. Cheryl? Yes.
Speaker 1 (13:48–14:13)
Yes. And myself, yes. Sorry, Hal. You're going to be caught up really soon.
So that was, sorry to go through, but we have just a lot of house cleaning today, housekeeping. Got to get it done. It is. It is.
So then our future meeting dates, we currently have scheduled our June 11th and June 25th.
Speaker 6 (14:14–14:16)
We have the 28th as well, right?
Speaker 1 (14:19–14:26)
I mean, oh, I'm sorry, we have May 28th. Yes, May, I was jumping to June already. And May 28th is our next, our last meeting in May.
Speaker 6 (14:26–14:28)
Can you repeat the June dates again?
Speaker 1 (14:28–14:36)
June 11th and the 25th of June. 28th. And then staff update, Liz.
Speaker 4 (14:39–19:27)
Great, thank you so much. Apologies for not being there in person for your first meeting. Member Munger. It's just been a long week.
So I kind of took advantage, especially with the rainy night. So and typically what I what Avanti and I have tried to do I think it's a good idea to have a written report every two weeks. I think one of the goals of HAL is to create a written report at least once a month for the board for this agenda topic. So that you'll see at the meeting on the 28th.
I initially had high hopes to be able to have a written report every two weeks, but I got realistic real quick. and just sort of, you know, kind of get together on priorities and timelines and what have you. So just very quickly, the work with the MPO on the Vision Zero project at Granite Avenue in East Guantanamo, West Guantanamo rather, which I've updated folks in the past on, there's going to be a meeting next week on that project. They're trying to figure out the day right now.
more than happy to bring anybody up to speed on that project with more detail. If they're interested, you can reach out to me separately. Don't have a ton of information on this, but there is a housing works grants being put together for the stretch between Guile Road and Reedsdale at Canton to do some infrastructure upgrade there. So that I believe is going in.
I think that's kind of coming under the auspices of the engineering office and the DPW. Very busy with two signs already under the new bylaw for the Gardner School and for two Elliott. I had a great conversation today with the admin in the zoning office, Bill Donley, in terms of, you know, how can we sync these things up? How can we make sure that once they're done with the sign review committee that, you know, it doesn't sort of start all over again at day one for these applicants?
So we had some really good conversations about that and had a bit of a back and forth with Kathleen O'Donnell as well, put her in the loop with all of the documentation, which can get confusing. I need to be careful, I can't be duplicating the zoning boards process and I don't want to be duplicating their submittals or what have you, I don't want to create confusion. But with this being brand new, I really wanted to make sure that they had everything that I had as quickly as possible. Those are getting teed up, Fingers crossed for a zoning board hearing as potentially as early as June 18.
So that's pretty much as quick as you probably could go. And so you've got that library letter. It was really just a very quick reflection of the conversation that took place at the board's meeting probably six weeks ago now. Took me a bit to put it together.
So that's in your folder. If you have any questions about that, feel free to ask me. Some good progress on the housing production plan as well. I'll just kind of put in a plug.
I know that's a later topic, but I'll put in a plug that it'll be easier for me if the two planning board reps are planning board members. I'm just throwing that out there. And so I know you guys want to have that conversation about that, about your, whether it's a member of the board, or if it's designee, I've got the contract. I worked with Nick on the contract for the zoning recodification.
He's going to be able to get that money encumbered and had a quick chat today. I can't even believe it. I literally have not caught my breath for Monday night. And he was like, yeah, if you guys are going to do anything for the fall, we're going to need it in the next six to eight weeks.
So my thought on that was, if there is something that the board really wants to go with quickly, if we've got KP under contract soon, then perhaps that could be folded into that scope. I don't know. I don't want to get ahead of anything, but that's just a thought. And then the last thing is the EFA process that MAPC took care of, that they worked on for us in the fall.
I've been kind of playing phone tag with them to figure out where that approval is. So more to come on that. So that's pretty much it, guys.
Speaker 1 (19:29–19:50)
That's great. And I just want to say, Liz, great job at town meeting. You really, I thought, did a wonderful job with the presentation. And having questions fired from members, we were very well prepared and handled everything very well.
So any questions for Liz on anything?
Speaker 7 (19:50–20:07)
No, I just want to make one comment. I think she provided the most abbreviated response at a town meeting to any question that's ever been asked. And I hope we all could follow the model that you have set forth. Great.
Speaker 4 (20:09–20:17)
I was just talking to someone about that today. I said, I've got to find out who that was because I feel like I need to apologize because I am never that abrupt, ever.
Speaker 7 (20:17–20:24)
I think your answer was accurate. That's all that matters.
Speaker 1 (20:24–20:26)
Anyhow, and I think the members appreciated the property.
Speaker 7 (20:27–21:08)
So yeah, great job. Yeah, for a long article that you know that the it's it's like everything else probably true for all of our work, you know what you and I'll do and what Meredith does and what Maggie and I do. Preparation is really key to everything. And your presentation was so well prepared with what was up on the screen for people to read.
And it uncomplicated what could have been very complicated. If we didn't have that up on the screen and you hadn't created the flowcharts, Liz, it would have been very difficult for the members to understand, you know, how do you go about, you know, getting a sign permit. You made it simple. So to you and Avanti and everybody involved in the preparation side of it, great job.
Speaker 8 (21:09–21:23)
And even the images at the end, I thought were good. Yeah. 100% help. Yeah.
Excellent. I had a question. Liz, what was that last topic you covered with, I didn't pick that up. That was that.
Speaker 4 (21:24–21:29)
Catch me guys if I've got this wrong economic feasibility analysis. Okay.
Speaker 8 (21:30–21:34)
Okay. That's right. Okay. All right.
I didn't I didn't catch the acronym. Okay. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (21:39–21:59)
And we're just waiting on a letter from them with their supporting. And is that, Liz, did they, do they communicate directly with HLC, or is that for up to us to close that loop with them and send issue that letter.
Speaker 4 (22:01–22:15)
That's, that's what I'm trying to, that's what I'm trying to understand with Adam Pletz who is the, the housing manager at MAPC. Okay, so I, we were. I called him, he called me back, we just haven't connected. So hopefully have at least an update.
Speaker 1 (22:15–22:37)
And they've done it for other communities, so they'll be very familiar with the process. So that's great. Okay. Good.
Okay, anything? You're good on that report, Liz? That's the staff update? Yep.
All right. So next we have public comment.
Speaker 7 (22:37–23:03)
Can I jump in before public comment because I'm just noting the upcoming dates 528 and 611 and I'll be away for both of those. So I am going to walk the Camino and I'll be gone from 526 to 614. So I won't be present for those two meetings. Okay.
That's impressive. Yes. Okay.
Speaker 3 (23:03–23:04)
Yeah. All right.
Speaker 7 (23:04–23:44)
been. Um anyhow, you know why I'm doing it. But um uh the the only comment I had on the meeting minutes, the two that were in the folder for today and and you know, when you get around to looking at them, it's real simple but there's a comment that I that uh is attributed to me in in regard to the um to the MPEC and and it it reads that, you know, That doesn't reflect what I said. I know it's an advisory committee.
It's not a thought. I mean, that was an article we passed in town meeting. So I know it's an advisory committee. That's the only thing I'd like that to be corrected for the record.
Speaker 6 (23:44–23:52)
Do you think it's a priority to understanding it or something?
Speaker 7 (23:53–23:57)
It's not a thought. It was a statement, really, more than anything else.
Speaker 6 (23:57–23:59)
They did that, so yeah.
Speaker 7 (23:59–24:15)
Yeah, that'd be great. That was it. Other than that, those two, when you get around to it. That's on the 12th or the 26th.
I can't remember. I can't remember which one it was. But anyhow, other than that, I didn't have any other comment on those minutes, and I don't want to slow down the process of getting them out, so.
Speaker 1 (24:15–24:34)
That's great. All right. So now, if there is anyone, we don't have anyone here to speak, but I don't know if anyone wants to speak who's online. If there's any comments or questions, you can raise your hand.
Speaker 3 (24:40–24:41)
I'm not seeing any.
Speaker 4 (24:44–24:46)
Can you guys see the participants? There's no attendees.
Speaker 1 (24:46–24:48)
Yeah. OK.
Speaker 9 (24:49–24:49)
OK.
Speaker 1 (24:51–25:38)
So with that, next item on the agenda is our annual committee appointments, which typically, many of the appointments that our committee, we sit on various committees, we probably are aware. They tend to be one year appointments, but some people are either on, they're assigned to a committee right now, So the question is, do people want to stay on that committee or, you know, or do they want to do something different? So that's the time that we'll talk about that. Currently, Cheryl sits on the CPC.
She's as our representative. Are you on affordable housing? Is there an affordable housing?
Speaker 2 (25:39–25:41)
No. OK, so.
Speaker 1 (25:42–25:53)
Right now, it's just the CPC, just the CPC, which I think that's and part of, I think, What's good is there's certain cycles of timing of things.
Speaker 2 (25:54–26:32)
So for the CPC, in the event that someone else wanted to do it, the applications are due at the end of the month. So they haven't been reviewed yet. So it's actually, it would be in October. it would be an okay time to change if somebody else really wanted to do it.
I don't mind, you know, rotation of committees, but I'm happy to continue with it. It's interesting and it's actually interesting to hear all of the projects that come in. But if it is a good time to do it, this is it, right, in terms of the timing.
Speaker 1 (26:32–27:43)
I've been on the Open Space and Recreation Committee. We are hopefully wrapping this up. We're in a final phase. This has been going on for four years.
So I'm happy to stay on because I think what we're doing right now is so important because it is cleaning up all the maps of our town, because even the Conservation Commission does not know what is necessarily what is conservation, what is in conservation, what is what is protected conservation in perpetuity. We're looking at what is DCR land, and there's confusion on some of the DCR parcels so I'm We've been working to reach out to DCR to try to get a whole list. We also dissolved our, our land trust Milton Milton had a land trust that was dissolved. Some of those parcels went to the wild lands organization, and then some went to the com com.
So, I'm trying to get a colored map. People from the parks department can say, gosh, could we put a playground somewhere? And they'll know what's town-owned, what's not in conservation, and just make it really transparent and user-friendly.
Speaker 8 (27:43–27:45)
I see it over the finish line.
Speaker 1 (27:45–27:50)
So I would like to see it over the finish line. But if somebody wants to step in, I'm, again, I'm happy to.
Speaker 2 (27:50–28:01)
That's like what I said with the MPIC in the last year or two. So it makes sense in this case, I think, for continuity. Just like I made the case for continuity in the past.
Speaker 1 (28:02–29:10)
Yeah. And then we had, so Jim Davis had been serving on the capital committee. So that we do need to put somebody onto that committee. That's actually a committee that meets before, you know, it meets early.
So it's before people's, you know, have to get to work. It's really interesting I first said that was the first committee I served on. And it was really interesting because you see, and they're now doing like a five year projection of capital needs in the town. So it might be the fire department and, you know, if they need another ladder truck it could be DPW it could be Council on aging.
It could be the schools, but the schools are, you know, capital projects. So it's really interesting because there's money that gets funded in the end, it's voted on by that committee so it's a, it's very interesting to sort of be an advocate in planning funds. We've always said that's something that's important and sometimes we feel like we don't get funded for the studies that we need to do.
Speaker 7 (29:11–29:14)
What's the frequency of that? Is that monthly?
Speaker 1 (29:15–29:41)
What's good about that is right now, it's a monthly meeting typically. As you get closer to to the budget cycle and to certain deadlines. They meet more frequently. So that does seem to pick up at budget time.
But it's really just a monthly. And Richard Wells was chairing it for years. I don't know who.
Speaker 9 (29:42–29:42)
Is Megan?
Speaker 1 (29:42–30:15)
Maybe Megan's going to chair it now? Or I forget who they said was going to step in. It's a lot of work just sort of tracking where we are, you know, and it's trying to, you know, fund some of these really important things. And some things just keep getting deferred year after year.
And then some years we have, you know, whether it's more free cash or, you know, it's able to be funded where money put towards that. So that's available. Sean, you were taking a little break.
Speaker 7 (30:15–30:44)
So you are- There's two that I was considering volunteering for. One is to fill gyms. The other is that the housing production committee. Those are two that I would volunteer for.
And, but I mean this is a discussion amongst all of us to make sure that we, you know, fill all there's a lot of roles. It's not like there's a shortage because you were on to last year I think Maggie's on to last year.
Speaker 2 (30:46–31:16)
I was on an ad hoc for a bit to the town farm, you know, that wasn't that you were for the planning board there, but there's been times where the master plan implementation committee also have a seat on different committees. So there were times, you know, when I had another one picked up. So, um, but so one feels like I was on it for the historical commission and you were on it for planning, maybe that was something like that. But, uh, I'm, I'm happy to do, um, another one, but you know, I also, it's up for discussion for anyone.
Speaker 1 (31:17–31:22)
And then Maggie, do you want to talk about the committees you've been serving on and just talk a little bit about what those.
Speaker 9 (31:23–34:08)
So I am on the Climate Action Planning Committee. And it's been a few years now. And we are getting close to finalizing our plan. We sort of got derailed a little bit, in my opinion, trying to fund grants and whatnot.
But we are making some progress on it. And we've had a lot of turnover. on the committee and also the committee has expanded in its membership, which has caused some problems getting a quorum at times. And, um, so it hasn't quite progressed as quickly as I thought it was going to progress.
So I would stay on that committee and I'm hopeful that at some point we will finish the climate action plan. and then it would be brought forward to town meeting to be adopted. And then, you know, then I'm not sure what the long range plan is for this committee. I think once it's adopted, then I would think that perhaps the committee would cease to exist.
So I would like to say on that in the Milton Budget Coordination Committee, as far as being the representative from the planning board, there has not been a lot of input at this point in time for a planning board representative. The charge was to review the fiscal budget every year and to have better communication primarily for the school committee and the select board. And again, we got off topic a little bit because we just started talking about the FY27 budget and we haven't really made any financial policy decisions at this point in time. But as a planning board rep, there's not a lot to do that this committee is not.
There's not a lot of heavy lifting on this committee for a planning board member. But I have found it interesting I've learned a lot about the budgets and, um, you know, and I like having interaction with a broad range of committees and town staff. So I would be willing to sit on that one too. Um, but as I said, it's not a lot of heavy lifting.
So if I'm needed on another committee, I could do that too. So.
Speaker 1 (34:12–34:14)
Okay. And how, anything that,
Speaker 8 (34:15–34:38)
Yeah, I looked into it a little bit and clicked on the links that Liz provided. The CPC would be something that I'd be interested in. And then the budget coordination, if Maggie would like to step down for that, that'd be something. And then the master plan committee.
Those are the three that were top of my list, if people want to discuss that. But those were my interests late.
Speaker 2 (34:41–35:02)
So, I'd be interested also in the housing production plan. The housing production plan? That's, yeah. Yeah, but if, so if Sean you're interested in that, I think Liz had two seats from the planning board, or two people from the planning board.
So, how were you, you were interested, what's your top one?
Speaker 8 (35:03–35:06)
Probably the CPC, the Community Preservation Committee.
Speaker 2 (35:06–35:12)
All right, okay. Do you want a second one, or do you think you want to start with one?
Speaker 8 (35:12–35:13)
Let's go.
Speaker 2 (35:15–36:00)
Because I would be coming off of that then, which I'm fine with. I'm fine to come off of that and have you replace me. So that leaves, and I'm happy, Sean, that you're interested in the capital committee. I was thinking to myself that would be a good one for you if you were interested in it.
So I'm glad to hear you're interested in that. You know, I think for the master plan committee itself, you know, obviously I've been on the MPIC for, I was on the MPIC for a long time and felt as if it's time for some new folks. But on the other hand too, I've had some people reach out to me and say that, you know, they wanted to talk to me about the report. And so.
Speaker 1 (36:01–37:10)
So we're not, we're not yet doing the master We'll hopefully be able to do that on the 28th. Oh, OK. Because we don't have, we need to distribute who all the applicants are for that. We need one person from us?
So one person from us, and then two other people from the pool of applicants that we can pick from. And I had talked to Liz. Liz was going to, our Liz, was going to talk to Liz Dillon check in with her to see where she was I think she wanted to interview some people, maybe find out, I don't know who she's selecting, and we'll see what what candidates are left and available. So just tonight I think just the housing production plan is, is the other one that to talk about.
And I agree with Liz that I think it is good to have, I think, two planning board members. Because I think that's what the select board was also wanting to do, to have two of their own, their two members, and then the Affordable Housing Trust.
Speaker 4 (37:10–37:12)
So I guess if Cheryl's interested.
Speaker 1 (37:12–37:13)
Sorry.
Speaker 4 (37:14–37:32)
Oh, I apologize if I made Meredith. Yeah. It's pretty expedited. So you folks have already seen the scope and you've already have a lot of familiarity.
So I just think it's much more efficient. Right.
Speaker 1 (37:32–37:34)
For the housing production. Oh, good.
Speaker 7 (37:34–37:42)
We like efficiency. Yeah, if it's two members, I'd be happy to be one of them. And it sounds like you'd be happy to be one as well.
Speaker 1 (37:45–37:49)
And then Maggie, you would stay on your two.
Speaker 9 (37:50–38:32)
Yeah, I would stay on mine if that's good. I'd really be on anything, so I'm fine where I am now. I know Hal expressed interest in the Budget Coordination Committee. If I drop that, then I would be interested in the Housing Production Plan.
committee, but as Liz said, that's a short, shorter commitment, I think. Isn't that the housing production committee is just trying to get the plan in place and that is pretty much in place because it's replicating pretty much what's already been done.
Speaker 1 (38:33–38:42)
It's working with the same consultant, but Liz, do you wanna speak to this? It's really updating a lot of what's happening.
Speaker 4 (38:42–39:36)
I guess the charge as it's laid out is to facilitate the creation of a town's housing production planning coordination with the town's consultant and to monitor the implementation of the housing production plan upon completion and approval by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. So I guess the monitoring the implementation part is something that can be We'll be discussed during the development of a plan. I mean, it's typically an implementation component to a plan. So, so it could, it could be something that does extend beyond the.
Beyond this, the timeframe that's in the consultants contract, which, and the reason why I'm saying expedited is she initially said 6 months. We're already almost 2 months into that. So we had a conversation last week and I said, is that still realistic? And she said, yes, but we really need to, yeah, we need to get moving.
So the intent is to have this thing wrapped up by mid-fall.
Speaker 2 (39:37–40:19)
So the last plan had a number of recommendations that the planning board was assigned as a lead party on. And so if that happens again in this plan, there should be recommend or follow-ups steps that the planning board will need to take. So having discussion about those and how we wanna go about those. I think after the consultant is done and the plan's adopted.
Last time around the select board and the planning board both adopted the plan and And it was a very robust plan.
Speaker 1 (40:19–40:25)
I mean, it was very good. And we've done a lot. I mean, I think our consultant was like, wow, you guys have been busy.
Speaker 2 (40:27–40:39)
Yeah, I'm sure there's some things that were kind of put upon us, like ADU was on that target list for a couple of generations of housing production plans, but the state went ahead.
Speaker 9 (40:40–41:42)
The other thing I'd like to advocate for is a reduction in committees. I mean, I've said this multiple times, you know, these past few years, the town has like 90 committees and we never, we always seem to be adding committees without ever getting rid of committees. And as I've said before, sometimes I do feel like these appointed committees can, kind of be a workaround to the elected committees. So I would like to see, and maybe it's not for discussion tonight, but there really should be some setting of these committees.
So we fulfill our charge, we do it, and then it's over. And then it comes down to town staff sort of to monitor things. I just think 90 committees is a lot for, um, for the town, especially when we have a strong town administrator.
Speaker 8 (41:43–41:46)
Will the open space sunset?
Speaker 1 (41:46–42:08)
That will sunset. That will be, yeah. It has to be, and then, you know, for a certain period of time, it'll be good, but it's similar to the housing production plan where you have to, in order to get state grants, you have to, you know, just update it. And so we're like in that updating stage, but it will.
So that will, once this finishes, that will sunset.
Speaker 8 (42:08–42:12)
And then the climate action planning committee would sunset as well. We're down to 88 Maggie.
Speaker 9 (42:12–42:36)
Yeah. Yeah, I think it's the plan should be created. And then I don't know what the next steps are. I don't know if it's going to be like MPIC and then you have to follow it all.
I'm not really sure we haven't. We haven't gotten to the plan yet, so we haven't even considered next steps yet.
Speaker 2 (42:36–44:11)
I guess it depends if there's really a simple follow-up entity, like if there's a staff person who that's their responsibility. The master plan itself had so many different responsible parties that I think that's why the implementation committee was recommended back when. But, you know, like this on a climate action plan, you know, maybe that falls under the town administrator or the DPW or the planning department or something. Just like the traffic mitigation committee did excellent work and issued a report.
And one of their high level suggestions was to make sure that there was a responsible party. And they suggested the town administrator be the responsible party. And so, you know, in that scenario, that was an advisory to the select board. So the select board could decide that that was a priority that they wanted the talent administrator to take on.
So I think it kind of depends on the charge of the committee, who formed the committee, what they want to do with the work of that committee. One of the things I think about the committee, I think about Even that one, Maggie, is you get some expertise from folks in town who don't necessarily want to run for office, but offer their expertise on a committee level, which same happened on that traffic mitigation committee. There were some really qualified people. So I think we do benefit from those committees who offer residents an opportunity to share their expertise.
Speaker 9 (44:13–44:53)
Oh, I agree. I mean, there's really great members on it. So I'm not trying to take away or diminish their credentials or the value that they add. It just is, I don't know, sometimes I feel like especially when a committee gets to be 15 people or 11 people, we can kind of get in our own way sometimes.
And as I said, there's turnover because they're really pointed for one year and you don't get a lot done in one year when you really need just once a month. And then sometimes you can't meet because you don't have a quorum.
Speaker 2 (44:54–45:47)
Yeah. Sometimes it's helpful if you have a large committee to have subcommittees so that the subcommittees can meet and report back to the larger. You know, the planning board, early on in my tenure, had some subcommittees where two people would work on a zoning article together and then bring it back to the whole board. And I was looking back for something and I was like, wow, we had six zoning articles we were discussing at the same time.
People were working on them, bringing them back, and we decided which ones might move forward to town meeting. So, I mean, that's another thing. If we don't have as much committee work that we're doing and we want to tackle some zoning work then we don't have a huge planning department staff wise. So it doesn't have to be writing the zoning itself, but to set out what would be the goals and then get help with the technical language.
But in any case.
Speaker 1 (45:47–46:23)
And we have posted for an administrative assistant in the planning department. So a part time 20 hours a week, if anyone is interested, Nick has posted that and Liz would love to have somebody come in and help her and help with the minutes. It's really, it would take a tremendous amount of work off of them. So I support all of the committee assignments that we've discussed in people's interest.
Speaker 2 (46:23–46:54)
So should I make a motion for the board to Appoint Hal to the Community Preservation Committee. Maggie to the Climate Action Planning Committee and the Budget Coordination Committee. Sean to the Capital Improvement Planning Committee. Meredith to the Open Space and Recreation Planning Committee.
Myself and Sean to the Housing Production Plan Advisory Committee. I would second.
Speaker 1 (46:54–46:57)
Okay. Any discussion?
Speaker 8 (46:57–47:02)
And then we'll discuss the master plan committee once we get the other information.
Speaker 1 (47:02–47:20)
Yes. And so hopefully, it would be nice to have that for our next on the 28th. So Liz is going to follow up with Liz Dillon on that. And then we can get those distributed for the applicants.
So with that, we'll do a roll call. Maggie? Yes. Al?
Speaker 8 (47:20–47:20)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (47:21–48:47)
Sean? Yes. Cheryl? Yes.
And myself, yes. Great. Thank you. for that.
And then the next item, and it was interesting when I was looking at the fall minutes, we discussed some of our goal setting and where we were and if we could get the sign bylaw approved, what would be the next things that we had been looking at. And I thought it was great because Cheryl put a list together of some things we haven't even talked about. So we can look at some of the things we have, and I think realistically, and now hearing what Liz said, what do we really think we could have an article pulled together for our next town meeting in the fall? And typically, we try to do zoning in the fall because you don't have so much budget stuff in the spring, so fall is the better time.
Looking at this, I mean, I think Liz, do you have a sense, or maybe we could get a sense from Carol, from KP Law, if she thinks it might be doable to get the first phase of the recodification, we did vote for the first three phases of the first level recodification.
Speaker 2 (48:48–49:07)
If she thinks, like the first level, in my recollection from the audit that was done previously, is really just a cleanup and organizational improvements. And it's not really content substantive. And if we could get that to fall town meeting, I think that would be great.
Speaker 4 (49:08–50:51)
I also just want to- Can I just interject here? Yes. I'm not sure that's the approach. I think the approach is sort of like an initial audit which is more to do with talking to people like the Chair of the Board of Appeals, the Building Commissioner, some of the local land use attorneys, almost trying to get a better handle on what's not working.
There's no way I see that. Yeah. It could be that the result of that audit does bring forward maybe some of that low-hanging fruit. Um, but bear in mind, it does need to be advertised by like, I mean, Nick was basically telling me today he, he wants ideally something's getting advertised in like July.
So, so I'm, so I'm that's, that's eight weeks. So, um, I'm just trying to, I'm just trying to wrap my head around that. And I'm almost thinking that if you guys have a single topic that Carolyn could kind of pull off the shelf. Right.
Cut and fill has been something. Cut and fill could be something where if you guys are looking for a similar approach, like with the sign bylaw, where no baloney, like here's the process, here's the definitions, this is what you have to do, these are the plans that are required, like whatever. I know nothing about your cut and fill. I heard today from Nick that it's like a paragraph.
Speaker 2 (50:51–52:31)
I don't know if that's true at all. That's not true. I just want to come back quickly. We can talk about cut and fill.
I was looking at my notes from five years ago on it. But if the intent is to talk to those other folks, I don't see that happening by the fall. And I just want to say, I think we should also plan for not just the fall, in the spring, but a year from the fall, from next fall, 20, because it's going to take that amount of time to work on larger things that I think we should work on. And I just, some of what I put on this list is based on, you know, when you're running for reelection, you're talking to a lot of people, a lot more people than you are on average.
And so there's definitely things people are interested in talking to having the board think about. And so some of it's planning and some of it's longer term. It won't be something that's, even if it does lead to zoning, it won't be immediate, right? It's going to take time.
So I think we need to think about short-term, medium-term, long-term. What are we going to work on? And it will fall across different time periods of our tenures, but I think We need to start thinking that way, because otherwise we're just going to keep getting the low-hanging fruit stuff. We don't end up getting sort of the larger things.
And we have an opportunity now, since we're past the ADUs and past the MBTA communities for the most part, that we can tackle a few things. And Cut and Fill is one of them, but there's a few others.
Speaker 1 (52:32–52:49)
You said on there was Airbnbs, and we had talked about that. You know, what I heard from Nick, and maybe I'm wrong and Liz, if you were part of this conversation more deeply is the building department said, well, they're not allowed.
Speaker 4 (52:50–52:58)
We don't allow it, but it's the same issue that you had with the sign by law. So it's like, it's silent.
Speaker 1 (52:59–53:00)
It's silent, exactly.
Speaker 4 (53:01–53:13)
It doesn't expressly prohibit. So there have been instances where, you know, you can have up to three unrelated persons in the same home, right, as boarders. Like that's just allowed.
Speaker 1 (53:13–53:18)
No less than 30 days. And there's a 30 day minimum for rental.
Speaker 4 (53:19–53:21)
I don't know. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (53:21–53:25)
That's what the building department was saying. Well, they're not allowed because you're not allowed to
Speaker 4 (53:27–53:41)
Rent a property for less than 30 days, but you can, but you can rent a room in your house. You can rent a room in your house to a border. For up to 3 unrelated people can be in a single family home. You can have 2 borders.
That's just that's just the law.
Speaker 1 (53:41–53:55)
So, so it's so I do, I think we should have it says, so I'm not I'm not I'm advocating that we should and I'm not sure why the building department. Yeah. So questioning it, but I think that might be a good one.
Speaker 2 (53:55–53:58)
Do you mind if we can actually run through the list? Sure, yeah. And then we can.
Speaker 10 (53:59–54:00)
Let's go top to bottom.
Speaker 2 (54:00–55:24)
Yeah, I just think it's, and I can explain why I put them on the list. And you know, some of them, like you've already identified that you're interested in, but so the codification we were just talking about. So I do think it would be helpful to understand from Carolyn, what kind of timeframe she thinks we're thinking about? It seems to me at the earliest would be the spring, and it could even be over a year, right?
Depending upon how many changes this is. So I'm just gonna say here, maybe spring of 27, question mark, okay? I just like it would be helpful if we that's something we know right the the next one I had review the Milton Village mixed-use overlay with landowners and perhaps with the economic feasibility consultant because we haven't we adopted it in 2020 and we haven't had any applications come in and I just like to understand if there's anything in the zoning that's an obstacle you know to having an application come in because And if there's not, then it's just because people haven't seen it as an opportunity they want to take advantage of. But, you know, when we spent so much time thinking that there was opportunity there for mixed use and to kind of revitalize.
Speaker 1 (55:24–57:01)
So I I would put that lower on a priority. First of all, it was COVID in 2020, so nothing really happened. You know, not not a lot was happening anyway. But what we what we've seen is we've seen the acquisition of property.
So we've seen a developer come in and acquire now five different separate buildings in that. And then, so we now have the Bank of America, which started that that ended up being the first project because of what what the developer has to go through with the DEP and more complications with the state on the muscle and flow building. He had also, the Fuji building has been acquired. And I'll just finish, I'm sorry.
And the other thing that we have also just finished is the MBTA zoning. So we've done two layers of zoning and the MBTA zoning, the ink just dried on that. We still have to come back to town meeting and sort of update our affordable units. I feel like of all the things we could do, that was an extensive, how many years did that even take to do that with the Milton Village District?
I think it just seems like there's things that we would like to get to, and we're seeing things happen. It might not be as fast as people think, like why isn't anything happening down there? There's also a possible proposal for extra space storage is possibly considering coming back with some sort of project down there. I feel like things are happening down there.
Speaker 2 (57:01–57:17)
And I, you know, one thing I say is like, you know, some of those properties have changed hands and one land owner owns quite a few of them. Right. And I think it would be interesting because he's talked about the mixed use as the use is what he wants to do with the building.
Speaker 6 (57:17–57:17)
Right.
Speaker 2 (57:17–58:12)
But we already know that one of them, he can't meet the parking requirements and maybe the other either. So is it. What's going to happen then? Can he come in under that or is he going to have to go to the Board of Appeals first because he can't meet the parking?
I just think we should be ahead of it instead of waiting until an application comes in. Maybe it's just a conversation that Liz can have with the property owners as he's contemplating what he's going to do with those properties. The other thing is the majority of the Milton Village is not in the MBTA communities. Remember, it's just the extra space storage, the web mill, and 88 Wharf.
And the rest of it's not. Milton Hill House? That is, but that's not in this overlay. Milton Hill House is not in the overlay.
I thought you meant in the MBTA.
Speaker 7 (58:12–58:52)
Can I suggest maybe an adjustment to the approach to this list? Can we work through it and just define What's on this list that absolutely should be accomplished in this year? You know, the things that are maybe low-hanging fruit or musts, you know, really, really important. Can we just do that?
And then go back and look at the balance and discuss how we can accomplish the balance and maybe what- I think that's a good idea. Would that be all right? Because there's a lot here and some of these are probably not complicated and we should just acknowledge it's going to be part of our work for this year. And we'll at least put them in a bucket of we're definitely going to get that done.
Speaker 8 (58:52–59:21)
All right, so. Can I just ask just a question of how the board operates before we move on? Does the board ever have, so Cheryl, you wrote, you know, have a reviewing with landowners. Does the board ever pull in business owners or landowners and have discussions about how they're seeing in the real world the zoning that we're writing and implementing, how that is actually affecting them?
Like, do we ever have like a workshop or a working session with them or is that something that's not
Speaker 1 (59:22–59:59)
We haven't done it on the sign review. Liz attended a Chamber of Commerce meeting. So I think Liz is trying, you know, opening dialogue with the Chamber of Commerce to hear certain things we've heard from them on. We had, we actually, this particular developer came before the planning board with a pre-application, sort of a conceptual plan.
which was really helpful because he wanted to know before he went down, you know, and maybe, you know, started really moving forward, that it was something that we would embrace.
Speaker 7 (01:00:00–01:00:24)
I think in, you know, the time that in my four years, I guess at HAL, it probably happens most often as part of a, of a process where an applicant's before us. We don't really have like an open forum and invite some of the active people in town to come in and tell us what challenges them. We don't really do that. I don't remember doing that at all.
Speaker 2 (01:00:24–01:01:24)
You know, when we did the Milton Village overlay, the MPIC, you know, started that process and we made an effort to meet with every property owner in the district because it's not a big district. And so, and that's how I found out that J.D. bought the Milton and he had just become the owner when we were doing that. But the East Milton, you know, there's more owners.
And I don't think I mean, certainly they were reached out to as a group, but not necessarily individually. And I think when we're working One of the things I think on my list is the non-conforming businesses. I think those property owners we should speak to. What do they see as being challenging?
Even Mr. Mignosa from the Fruit Center, what was challenging about getting their… Because I think that should inform our priorities too. What's an obstacle to business owners?
Speaker 7 (01:01:24–01:02:11)
I agree with you. And in a meeting not too long ago, I guess I'll call it recent, we were talking about an economic feasibility study. And my point of view was the existing business owners can tell us what works and what doesn't work, what restricts them and what could help them grow. learning that would help us better understand how to create more opportunity, you know, in town.
So I think how we can construct that, I'm not sure, but I think there would be a lot of valuable information that the planning board could gain from that. So, but it hasn't, it hasn't happened. It's not like how we haven't really had a forum and said, you know, where, where we want to hear from business owners, please come in and join us.
Speaker 2 (01:02:11–01:02:19)
Probably since the first, the master plan was done. You know, there was an outreach to all different groups, healthcare, you know, all sorts, but not since then, I think.
Speaker 7 (01:02:19–01:02:26)
How many years is that? It's been a while. Really, in that time, some of the business owners are the same, but some of the business owners are different.
Speaker 2 (01:02:26–01:06:37)
If you think about it, the health care environment has changed a lot with the hospital. Let me just give you my thoughts. Meredith, if I just tell you what the thoughts were, we can come back and talk about the merits or the priorities. So the MBTA affordability, I just Because I know that we had submitted for the 15%.
Like right now our zoning has like, you know, a caveat. It's not, it says, you know, it's 10% if HLC doesn't approve 15. You know, so I just feel like we should clean it up. But if we have time, I mean, if HLC has gotten back to us that that's acceptable.
So that's simple, I think. And then the, The condo conversion has come up because again, you know, properties to convert, we have a provision in our bylaw that allows the conversion of a large home of, I think, on 10 acres or more. And if we think about like the Burr Estate is one that I think is maybe what that was written for. But we've had some 40Bs that have been historic homes that are large, but there aren't 10 acres.
And so there's other properties for sale that are beautiful historic homes that are not 10 acres also. And so this was looked at a few years ago. And so there is work on it. I have in my records that I was beginning to look at again.
At a minimum, I think we could think about the acreage that the 10 acres, and that's just a flat out thing. What if it were in a Residence A, a Residence B, a Residence C, the acreage could be different, the size of the home, because you remember we had, Meredith, I think you'll recall the historical commission came in with, I have somewhere in here, a list of how many properties there are, like just like two acres even. And there's a lot of homes that are large and historic, like this was this list that they had provided us and two acre lots with residents. Six to seven thousand and more was like 31 houses.
And one to two acre lots, there's 20 that are in the six to seven thousand square foot range. You know, so There are buyers certainly for large homes, but would it make sense to think about that? Because it could help meet some of the housing affordability challenges without having to have even new construction, right? Because it could just be within an existing home.
So that's what that is. Then the short-term rentals, is something that's come up because people are experiencing them in their neighborhoods. Years ago, there was also a bed and breakfast. One of the things about both of those is, you know, there could be some, by regulating them, that things are happening already.
Once you regulate them, then you can enforce them. And you can have a registry requirement that they have to be licensed, I think it is, and they pay a fee. And so, As I said, we can come back to the merits of each of these. The Brook Road overlay, when that was first drafted, those buildings have been vacant now for a very long time.
There was an overlay that allowed for multifamily there, but it required a larger lot than what's available there. And so I just feel like there's a lot of people who don't like that there are like vacant properties there. And it just feels like we should understand if there's something we can do you know, in the zoning to help facilitate that.
Speaker 1 (01:06:38–01:07:09)
And there is a potential. Liz, I don't know if you've heard anything back, but there was sort of a somebody who wanted to meet a developer who wanted to do townhomes there under MBTA zoning. But I don't know, they were way off on their numbers, like they were way over on how many units they could put on the site. And so they were going to go back and run their numbers and take a look.
But I don't know if there's been a follow up, but there may be something happening there under MTA.
Speaker 4 (01:07:10–01:07:11)
Was that the one next to the food mart?
Speaker 1 (01:07:11–01:07:12)
Yeah.
Speaker 4 (01:07:13–01:07:19)
Oh, yeah. Yeah. No, I haven't heard anything. I mean, I think it's just the numbers just didn't work.
Speaker 8 (01:07:22–01:07:24)
We'll come back to it.
Speaker 2 (01:07:24–01:09:04)
Sorry, I'll make a note. So I mentioned address pre-existing non-conforming businesses. We're all pretty familiar with that. We can come back.
Site plan review for town-owned projects is something we've talked about, whether it's a fire station, a school, library parking, or what have you. So we can begin. Cut and fill, I was reading, again, through my notes. I had some notes with a couple of discussions with Joe Pranda.
So I'd like to go back and look at that. I also, there's a model bylaw from Cape Cod that addresses the topic. And I think one of the reasons that we're all interested in it is some of the things that come before us for site plan review, especially have had so much topographic change and retaining walls. that if we can get something in our bylaws to have it be more sensitive to the site.
So I'm still. interested in that and have some done some legwork in the past on it. And then the underlying business district zoning requirements, such as parking, right? Because we talked about that a little bit with the fire station in Smilton.
So that's why I put that on here. And if there's again, maybe this is where talking to the businesses to like, I can't do this because of the zoning. So I think we could learn from that planning. So this is like longer term, right?
So it's sort of a community process.
Speaker 9 (01:09:04–01:11:27)
Can I just hop in for the zoning thing before we move on? Sure. Could we look at an FAR zoning? Because Cheryl, you've said many times in the past that if you look at the Pine Gardens development, the houses are so big on Pleasant Street compared to the surrounding neighborhood that perhaps if we had a FAR limit or bylaw, then those houses would be more in scale.
So could we ever look at an FAR bylaw? Because I've been thinking about this for quite a number of years, that if you look at our ZBA, if you ever follow our ZBA hearings, it's run of the mill to you know, for them to approve a variance. And all of a sudden our little starter homes, say on Gulliver Road or Elm Street, they were our starter homes. And now all of a sudden they go to the ZBA and they get a variance and the three bedroom, one and a half baths are now four bedrooms, two and a half baths.
And our starter homes are also the same as our downsizing homes. So we have kind of done ourself in by allowing and giving these variances for these houses to become larger on these smaller lots. And now we've done away with our starter homes, we've done away with our downsizing homes, and now all of our more affordable housing are now not available because the housing, the square footage of the house has increased so much. I think perhaps looking at our FARs could be important.
Open space around each house is really important. We spent a lot of time on that on MBTA zoning. And I just think that having outdoor space available for homeowners and children to play is just great for mental health issues. So I think we should look at FARs.
Speaker 2 (01:11:30–01:13:10)
Okay. And one of the other, that would be like a change in the dimensional standards. So it's not like a new zoning, it's just a change to the dimensional standards within the districts we have. You know, remember when we were talking about ADU and how the We said we should look at our accessory structure setbacks and heights.
So that, I didn't put that on here, but when you're talking about FAR, it made me think of that. We should look at that too, because the ADU bylaw allows for the ADU to take, pick and choose between accessory structure and main structure. And in some of the districts, the accessory structure is very close, pretty close to the property line, but then you can also do the two and a half story, 35 feet. So you could be putting a pretty, you know, tall, big, a tall structure is not that big, I guess.
It depends. I mean, if you did a 450 square foot footprint, It got to 900 on two floors, and then you did a pitched roof, and you could do it pretty close to the property, and if everybody did that. So, I'm not saying we need, what we need to change, I just think we thought that's something we should look at. So, I'm gonna just put the- Dimensional standards.
Dimensional standards for accessory structures. Just so- With the FAR, yeah. And with FAR and open space, so it's- That did come up a lot. During our MBTA.
Speaker 7 (01:13:10–01:13:25)
Yeah. Can we go backwards, Cheryl? I just want to go back to, I want to understand, what is it? And maybe I didn't listen.
Excuse me. Maybe I didn't listen well. Add short-term rentals. What is it?
Speaker 2 (01:13:25–01:13:53)
We don't have a bylaw that addresses short-term rentals at all. That provides it or prevents it? Either one. It regulates it.
It doesn't regulate it. It's silent on it, in a sense. Like Liz said, you can have unrelated people living in your home, and they can be what's called boarders, right, Liz? I think that's the language.
So that means a boarder can be paying.
Speaker 1 (01:13:53–01:14:15)
And I'd be interested to see what other towns have been doing with this. And that's where I think Carol Murray and KP Law, she'll know of some really good Airbnb Yeah, I did locate a couple of things too. Most people don't want to allow them. Less than 30 days.
Yeah, but it's not regulated.
Speaker 8 (01:14:15–01:14:19)
They don't allow them, but they know that they're happening.
Speaker 2 (01:14:19–01:14:32)
Lexington has one. And I started reading one in Great Barrington that looked interesting. The Cape, of course, has them because they have a lot of rentals.
Speaker 7 (01:14:32–01:14:59)
But that's what it is. Isn't the zoning itself language that defines that it's not, you know, if we have single family zoning, that in itself would suggest that, you know, an Airbnb is not It's not a legal use.
Speaker 2 (01:15:01–01:15:04)
Well, maybe you can comment on that part.
Speaker 4 (01:15:05–01:15:57)
Well, and I think, too, because you have, you know, you've got pre-existing non-conforming, you know, multifamilies and apartments. And, you know, if you don't have a way of regulating how those get rented. Right. So there's that.
there's the border. I mean, you can have two people in your home, and you can rent them bedrooms, and they use the same bathroom, and they use the same kitchen, and that's just, it's allowed. So those are the two probably most problematic instances. Somebody would probably fall back on the argument that they're a border, and or they have a preexisting non-conforming multi, and they're maxing out how much income they can get for it.
Speaker 2 (01:15:57–01:16:53)
So some people have found that there are Airbnbs in their neighborhoods and there's no regulation really around it. So like you can put a regulation in that says that it can't be used for events, for example, like Airbnb I think as a company says that, but there's things in the couple that I've looked at. But I think it was raised with me during the campaign season that there were people who were interested in seeing us look into this. And I think if we did a process, maybe they would come to the board and tell us their experiences and what they're interested in.
Speaker 10 (01:16:54–01:16:58)
It came up several times in East Milton, in my area, just at the doors.
Speaker 1 (01:16:58–01:17:00)
I was surprised. And it came up in Precinct 2.
Speaker 10 (01:17:01–01:17:01)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (01:17:01–01:17:06)
Because I think there were buses dropping. There was one residence where bus loads of people were being dropped off.
Speaker 8 (01:17:06–01:17:15)
And this woman said that she contacted the town several times. And the town basically says that we can't do anything about it. There's no regulation on it.
Speaker 2 (01:17:15–01:17:21)
So that's where this is coming from. It's coming from people who are experiencing some things.
Speaker 1 (01:17:21–01:17:29)
I think that should be moved. And it seems like we should be able to have something that's pretty boilerplate that Carolyn can work from.
Speaker 7 (01:17:30–01:17:40)
So from your experience during the campaign, you're hearing people that see this as problematic and are looking for a regulation to prevent it.
Speaker 2 (01:17:41–01:17:52)
To regulate it, at least. To regulate, not necessarily prevent. You know, what people said was, I'd like regulation. So if we could call someone, if they're not following the regulation, then they can be enforced.
Speaker 7 (01:17:52–01:19:20)
Yeah. Well, you know, when I take a step back from and just think about where we're at as a town and the pace that we're changing. It's overwhelming. I'm not opposed to having this on an agenda for the year.
But we're watching multi-unit residential go up faster than probably anybody ever imagined. And we have yet to absorb what that impact will be on the community. We have the ADU, which now we're receiving applications. And I just feel for the town, we just need to be as, you know, cautious with what we do, because we're the pace is, is really overwhelming and I think most people in town, have no idea of what it's going to be like, and how quickly it's going to get there so you know, I'm not.
you know, regulations, sure, but I'm not a, I won't be a proponent when that discussion comes up of, you know, making this a, you know, a regulation that makes it, you know, possible to add Airbnb and show a term rental.
Speaker 8 (01:19:20–01:19:41)
No, that's not what I heard on the doors. I heard more the town setting boundaries and expectations for these things that are, we already know are happening, to be able to earn a fee on them, to be able to have someone that lives next door to be able to go to the town and point to saying, you know, this is the rules and the regulations of the town and how to, you know, they're not abiding by them. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (01:19:41–01:19:46)
You know, or, or something that prohibits them or the prohibits. Yeah.
Speaker 7 (01:19:46–01:20:10)
And I think for all the folks that, but you know, when I've, this is, this is going to sound like I'm repeating what I've said in previous years, if you moved into Milton because you wanted to live in a, you know, single family, um, residential neighborhood, I feel we, we owe those people as much protection as we possibly can. And having an Airbnb next to you is not.
Speaker 2 (01:20:11–01:20:13)
Well, that's why they phrase it as a problem.
Speaker 7 (01:20:13–01:20:56)
So, you know, again, I'm probably I'm probably already, you know, I'm probably already, you know, presenting my point of view on it, I feel it's important to protect desire not to have that. So that's my concern. Generally, you know, we have no idea if you could try to forecast what it's going to be like when the East Milton project is done and 440 Granite Ave is done and Randolph Ave is done and, you know, both sides of Randolph Ave are done. We're not that far away.
You know, these guys are moving at, you know, the pace that they're on is really, really fast. A year from now, a lot of these projects are going to be complete.
Speaker 9 (01:20:57–01:21:34)
Oh, sorry, Liz, can I just ask a clarifying question? When I know that our bylaw is about you can't have more than three unrelated people as boarders. So my interpretation, if you have a boarder, that means you as a person, you're living in the house and you're having boarders. So you are present in the house with two other people, you know, renting a room.
An Airbnb doesn't mean that the property owner is in the house at the same time.
Speaker 2 (01:21:34–01:21:36)
You can't really say that, I think.
Speaker 9 (01:21:37–01:21:42)
They can. They could be there. They could be there, but that doesn't mean they are there.
Speaker 4 (01:21:43–01:22:22)
I think early on, I mean, I had colleagues that were doing this, you know, 15 years ago, right? Because they had a two bedroom apartment over in South Boston. So, I think I think early on that was probably a much more standard model, but I think the economics are that. Investors, you know, have discovered that they can, if they're allowed to do it, there's a lot of money to be made.
But there's also, but there's also the other side of it too, which is that these are, there's regular folks that want to try to figure out ways to stay in their homes. So there's more than one side to the story.
Speaker 2 (01:22:23–01:25:53)
I'm pretty sure that you can regulate it such that it requires the homeowner to be living there and not renting it out and not be a corporate owner. So I think it's worth exploring because it could be that it is helpful to someone who's looking to be able to stay in their home, as you say, Liz. And, you know, it could be helpful for someone who's doing a renovation of a place and they need to be out for a short period or just something And they are happening. So that's the issue, they are happening.
So I think it's, whether we have something for the fall or not, I don't know, but I do think that that is something where we should start a public process and get some examples from other communities. And if Carolyn has some, Great, I've got a couple that I started to look at. Great, that's good. All right, move to planning.
Yeah, so we've heard a lot about West part of Milton, you know, not having a lot of planning effort. And there were the two visioning processes that happened that it would be nice to have some follow-up, you know, on those visioning sessions. there has been interest in amenities and in community gathering places that came out of that visioning, but we can look at those. MAPC did the visioning.
One was for 7 Brush Hill Road. I understand that DCR is now moving forward with that program, which is I don't know if that's a reversible decision or not, but it would be worth finding out. And then the other was Pagoda Circle. Yeah, but they're both, and then, you know, now there's the, there's some CPC funded projects like Peverly Park and the path around the pond and hopefully some kind of commercial business that's, you know, retail type facing will go into the Ice House.
But I just think that, I don't have anything in particular for a next step with it, but I just think a planning process there. The map boundaries of the business districts is just another thing to help think about what to make it easier for businesses so that if they don't have to always go to a special permit process, if they could be incorporated instead of residential district into the business district. So that's kind of, again, kind of a planning effort There's been a lot of talk because of the override and budget problems of whether we can get more commercial tax revenue. And so I do think it's something that the planning board should discuss from whether that tax revenue comes just purely from business or some mixed use or something else.
I do think that there's been, there was definitely a lot of talk about that. I thought it was good.
Speaker 1 (01:25:53–01:27:14)
I just, as a note that, because I think first of all, we all know like office space is, is not in demand right now. There's a, there's an abundance and there's, you know, for rent signs all over Milton, you know, lease or lease in commercial businesses, retail, you know, I think having amenities, you know, sort of to what you're, we've unfortunately seen every time we've had new retail space open up, we end up with a nail salon. So I think finding, you know, what are the amenities that we would like? You know, how do we implement them?
But I think the idea, which is important, and I know Sean has said this a number of times, but, and it was good to hear Jay Fundling in his study, analyze the, you know, the retail, the commercial property benefits. And then he said, it's never going to be a silver bullet for our budgeting purposes. So I think that people feel like it is somehow a silver bullet, that it's going to bring all of this cash flow in. I think we will, you know, we've talked about 88 Wharf is one of our, you know, highest revenue So, I think residential, we're going to see some really positive impact from residential projects.
Speaker 2 (01:27:15–01:27:56)
I had somebody say to me, knocking on the door, an indoor sports facility, because they have to take their kids to far off places, because there's just not enough places. So I think we maybe need to think beyond some of the traditional things that people think of with the commercial use maybe. I don't know. We need the economics study, obviously, I think, to help us with that.
But I do think we owe it to residents and taxpayers who've asked about it to take a look at it and see what it shows. Yeah.
Speaker 9 (01:27:56–01:29:54)
But as we know, and we've talked about it at the Budget Committee, and Sean brought it up, $3 million is generated by our commercial tax base. We bring in $4 million in personal property tax. And of that $4 million, 96% of that $4 million is attributed to our poles and our wires and our infrastructure. You know, I don't want to mislead people about what commercial is going to bring to the town.
Sean has stated it way more eloquently than I ever could in previous meetings. We've discussed it at the budget committee meeting. It's really, we would need 14 fruit centers, which would have $40 million worth of property value, and it would only generate $2 million property tax. So, um, I think we're covering this by doing this economic development, um, um, initiative, but I just want residents to know that the only additional income that, um, businesses bring in is restaurants contribute a meals tax and that's it.
Businesses do not contribute part of their profit to the town of Milton. I feel like I've heard that a couple of times. Businesses do not contribute a percentage of their profits to the town. The only thing the town gets is the property tax and then the revenue from the meals tax.
So I just, I hear all the time, we need more commercial, we need more commercial. I'm a huge advocate of small independent businesses, and I think it would make our everyday life better. But I don't think it's gonna solve our, our budget issues. So I just want to make that clear.
Speaker 8 (01:29:55–01:30:23)
And just to add my two cents, I know that you guys have discussed this a lot and I don't want to rehash everything, but I agree with Maggie in that maybe it's not a silver bullet, but the amount of people that talk to us about wanting to grab a cup of coffee after they drop their kids off at Tucker or having some sort of community space over there is really something that struck me. And I understand that we're not going to build 14 fruit centers, but maybe we could build one or two more coffee shops. Not just to improve people's quality of life.
Speaker 2 (01:30:23–01:31:11)
You know how it is when you see something posted, well maybe you don't if you don't look into Facebook very often, but how many times people say, oh, a Trader Joe's, a Trader Joe's, a Trader Joe's. But you know, there's a lot of dollars that Milton residents spend in other communities, in adjacent communities. So if we can somehow keep some of that, and you know, I'm talking about local businesses too. I'm not talking about like national kinds and big box kinds of things.
Because it's about people want community. They need a place for social interaction. Teens need that. Seniors need it.
Families need it. And we don't have a lot of it. And so if there's a way to get more, that gives us a little bit more commercial tax revenue. But really, it's about the amenities, I think, that come with it.
Speaker 1 (01:31:11–01:31:11)
I agree.
Speaker 2 (01:31:13–01:32:12)
So on the next one, the two families zoning. You know, there's a lot of people who just have concerns about the affordability challenges. And we have like almost 600 two-family units, but we don't allow them anymore. You know, after zoning was passed, I think in the 20s and 30s, they're not allowed anymore.
So is that, and we know that MBTA communities didn't consider two families multifamily, which is, I thought, a big mistake. But we don't know how things are gonna come in with the MBTA communities, how much it's gonna be to Shawn's point. But I thought we should just look at where we have the two families. Does it make sense to think about allowing some more of them?
I'm not saying like everywhere, but is it a way to help get some,
Speaker 1 (01:32:13–01:32:41)
Additional housing that's at a different price point more of a middle income price point No, I just said what are the other things is looking at what's coming in right now is Michael white is being overwhelmed with ADU applications right now and there is a you know coming up to speed process on this But he could almost have another full-time building department staff person
Speaker 2 (01:32:41–01:32:57)
I was wondering why he would, in the budget, he had raising the hours of the inspectors instead of having a plan reviewer. I mean, if he's doing all the plan review, you know, he needs someone to do plan review.
Speaker 1 (01:32:57–01:33:52)
He needs both, and I think they're down two people right now in the planning, in the building department, planning also, in the building department, and, you know, if we don't want to see a lot of turnover with our department, you know, people running these departments, we can't overburden them and we have to be conscious. And I think maybe, and I, cause I see what your point, we do have a lot of the two families, but maybe we need to just see how the ADUs are coming in. I'm sure there's like an, like a big rush to put them in because it just passed and they'll probably likely taper off after a little while. But, I feel like with the ADUs, we might wanna not rush to start, you know, doing two family and with MBTA until, to your point, until we sort of see the impacts of.
Speaker 7 (01:33:52–01:34:21)
What Michael's experiencing is consistent with what I said earlier. You know, the pace is, we've probably gone from, you know, 25 miles an hour to 60 miles per hour, and he'll never be able to keep up with it. I mean, that's on top of, That's on top of the work that he has just in terms of projects that are under construction, whether it's residential renovations, additions, new construction. He's completely overmatched, in my opinion.
Speaker 2 (01:34:22–01:34:48)
Well, I mean, I don't know how the procurement works in terms of if it's only annual for being able to add staffing. You know, the department's bringing in revenue. It's going to be bringing in additional tax revenue. Those applications pay for the people who are doing the reviews and the inspections.
It really shouldn't take too much to get it adequately staffed. That's in my opinion.
Speaker 7 (01:34:48–01:35:32)
My point earlier isn't about a math equation. It's not about making sure we're taking in enough revenue and permitting to offset the cost in the building department. My point earlier is about what pace should a town move in terms of its involvement. Do you know what I mean?
So I'm not, I'm never going to say, hey, as long as we're bringing enough in permitting, we can hire two more people to staff Michael's department. We should just keep on going. That's not what I'm saying. That's actually exactly opposite to what I'm saying.
I'm saying that it's changing so fast and before we, recognize the change that we've made in the last two or three years and absorbed it, where, you know, we got to be careful. We'll continue a pace of change in the town that we'll never be able to keep up with, ever.
Speaker 2 (01:35:32–01:35:44)
So, now that… A lot of the pace is due to people doing additions to their homes, and you can't tell one property owner that they can't do their addition because you don't have staff in the department. That's not what I'm talking about.
Speaker 7 (01:35:44–01:36:26)
I'm talking about… It's not… I'm not talking about that at all. You know, I'm talking about you know, creating more and more and more opportunities to drive more and more housing, you know what I mean, it's just we just have to be careful.
And I don't think my point of view is not just a point of view. You know, I also have plenty of people that I listened to that I talked to that I hear from, you know, I didn't have the opportunity to be running for election and listening to people that are, you know, considering the candidates, but, but we're all in the community. And there are a lot of people that you know, express their points of view too. So it's, there might be some that are proponents for just having the gas pedal down on housing.
There's a lot of people that aren't.
Speaker 2 (01:36:26–01:36:37)
That's why I have it under planning here and not under zoning. I'm not proposing anything for the short term. I said at the beginning of this, short term, medium term, long term, anything that's under planning is long term.
Speaker 7 (01:36:37–01:37:15)
Yeah, no, I get it. But there's, you know, there's a series of things here that are, you know, if the outcome imagine what some of the outcomes might be, it is just more residential units you know I mean if we get into a conversation about large homes, and I don't disagree with you show there are some large homes that there probably aren't, you know, many buyers for what is a six 7000 square And I'm just, what I'm recognizing is the list is pretty substantial in terms of the impact to create more housing. I'm just saying that we have to be careful. We just can't keep going, given what we've already done.
MBT housing, ADU, and the multi-unit residentials.
Speaker 8 (01:37:16–01:37:42)
So putting that aside, just if you can, how do we, as a planning board, advocate for the building department to have proper staffing? Is there something that we can do? Not to facilitate more, but to help him out so that he and the other people in the department can do their job as it is right now. Is there something that we as the five and Liz and Avanti can advocate for that?
Or is that not something that we can necessarily do?
Speaker 1 (01:37:42–01:38:25)
I think maybe communicating it with the select board and the town administrator. We have a strong town administrator who's, you know, and it's the same in the planning department. being careful because we're looking at the things that we do, but then the planning staff is overseeing all these permits that have already been issued and approved, all the 840B projects, but then there's the memory care, which people, things that are in the pipeline currently, which Liz is having to make sure that everything that we approved and site plan review and, in our permitting that the Goddard School.
Speaker 9 (01:38:27–01:40:40)
So my concern is if you just look at the signed bylaw request of Michael White. He requested a simple amendment to give himself additional time to review. And I was a little frustrated that his boss, the Strongtown administrator, did not take a more vocal support of his request. As an employer, if I have an employee come to me and say, I need this tool to do my job better, then I would go and I would do everything possible to give my employees the proper tools.
Because if they do their job better, then the customers are happier and everything's more efficient. So I was a little frustrated with that. We have an employee who said what he needed. He specifically said what he needed.
And unfortunately, the Warrant Committee didn't heed his concern. So I do think it It falls on Nick Milano to, um, to advocate for his employees. You know, if you look back through the, our budget cycle at the end of last year, we had $4.5 million certified free cash. And, you know, um, you know, a significant amount of that money, um, didn't go to the town departments, like at town hall, it went to the school side and, I was a little frustrated with that because we heard from the police and fire of their needs.
So I agree, Hal, that we should be helping our building department and our planning department because that's who we interact with. But it's really hard for us to do that because we're not really their bosses.
Speaker 1 (01:40:42–01:40:45)
But I will say the work on recodification will greatly also help.
Speaker 2 (01:40:45–01:43:06)
Absolutely. I was going to say, There's so much time in understanding our zoning bylaw. You know, Joe Prondack, the commissioner that was here for, what, 12 or 14 years, when he went to another community, he said, oh my God, what a difference. My job is so much easier.
That's why I've been, every year we've had an opportunity to ask for the funds for this. I've suggested it because it will save staff time and therefore town money to get it done. And, you know, when you're thinking about like even the 40B developers who have high paid attorneys, full consultant teams, they still had mistakes in their list of violations because of our zoning bylaws. And so getting that fix is going to make a difference.
And there's also, well, something on my list moving down, further state legislation, but now we have a lot of pre-existing non-conforming that ends up going to the Zoning Board of Appeal. And if these items that are in the budget bill that's being discussed now, it'll make some of that unnecessary if you're not making your non-conformity worse. Like right now, if you have a house that's non-conforming, anything you do, Just get scrutinized because it's already existing non-conforming. Anyway, there's just things like that that would make it easier for the building department.
So can I just finish the last thing on these things? The 40-yard zoning is just something that had been talked about at one time because it allows you some funding from the state. I'm just going to leave it at that. And then rules and regs.
We had talked about scenic roads, right? And we haven't had an application come in on that more recently, but we've had some frustrations with that in the past. And that's something that's just within the planning board, right? We don't, or is that actually have to go to the town meeting?
Speaker 1 (01:43:07–01:43:48)
No, it's just it's planning, but we usually go on. It's also the historical commission. um, is, is way it weighs in on it. And then it sort of, we, the planning board sort of listens to the recommendation of the historical commission, um, traditionally, and then they come back and then they make their decision.
But it's very, um, it's one of those that's very vague and, and what we can defend. you know, when somebody comes in, an applicant, you know, certain things are very clear as far as, you know, a driveway, how many feet of stone wall can you take down by right? But when it gets into trees and other things.
Speaker 8 (01:43:49–01:44:00)
Is this meant to designate more roads as scenic roads or the rules and regulations within designating a scenic road?
Speaker 2 (01:44:00–01:44:27)
My feeling was the rules within it, not adding to it, but I would agree. We've just had some issues come up. It's very general. Yeah, sort of.
Things have happened. People didn't know that they needed to come for a permit for a scenic road, which basically, if there's trees that are in the public way and stone walls that you're going to change those, then it needs a permit.
Speaker 1 (01:44:27–01:44:54)
And like fines, if they do remove things, I don't think there's It's always sort of negotiated like on Hillside Street, there was a developer came in and just, it was actually being sold it wasn't even the developer, it was, I think, that they just clear cut like a one day this whole, this whole lot was was all trees and the town on trees. And, you know, it ended up being a mitigation of having to come back and replant native plantings and.
Speaker 2 (01:44:54–01:45:10)
But then there's a question of, well, who's responsible to, let's say, water the trees to make sure they survive? And what if they don't survive? And there's just some questions that have come up, right? But I think we could make it better.
Speaker 1 (01:45:10–01:45:18)
Because I think we adopted the boilerplate from the state and then never put in rules and regs. So it would be there again.
Speaker 2 (01:45:18–01:45:45)
Good to see what other communities have done. And then I just put pending state legislation and ballot questions as something for us to be aware of and to think. Site plan review is one that's moving its way through the legislature. And I haven't compared what it says to what ours is, but at some point we should, especially if it passes and see if we're going to need to.
Speaker 9 (01:45:45–01:45:48)
Aren't they trying to do away with site plan review?
Speaker 2 (01:45:48–01:46:11)
No, they're trying to, they're trying to just make it be consistent because there's no, it's not like the zoning bylaw or the zoning by just enabling whatever the law, the overriding law is that allows zoning. There's no such overriding law that allows site plan review. So each town can write their own except for MBTA.
Speaker 9 (01:46:11–01:46:24)
And that's, I mean, and that's sort of been my problem with this administration. They're trying to take away local control. And this is one of the ways they're doing it, unfortunately. So I'm not a fan of what they're doing.
Speaker 2 (01:46:24–01:47:25)
I think, Maggie, they're trying to make it more consistent. From what I read, it's pretty consistent with what we have. Like, I don't think we'll have to change ours much. But I do think it'll, you know, maybe Carolyn at KP Lock can take a look at it if it looks like it might pass.
I mentioned there are a couple of items, housing related items or zoning related items in the budget bill. It has mostly to do with the ZBA, but I can share those. I think Liz, you have those too. You could share out with folks just to be aware of them.
And then there's a ballot question that's called legalized starter homes, which would make the minimum lot size 5,000 square feet. We have a lot of homes on 5,000 square feet in our residency districts already, but they're not, That's not the minimum lot size anymore. It's 7,500 for us. So we'll have to follow that.
So that's it.
Speaker 1 (01:47:25–01:47:58)
Yeah, I sent Wells and Driscoll some of the zoning, because it's like MBTA on steroids. Which one? I don't remember. There was two.
And they weren't even aware of them, because they were still in the subcommittee. So I don't know how they've. but it was like five, it was like five units, you know, on a, like a small parcel would allow up to five units or something. It was, it was definitely a multifamily housing.
Speaker 7 (01:47:58–01:48:47)
I don't, I don't know the language, but you could be describing what Cheryl had written as legalized. I think that is. It's a valid question to have a statewide zoning that lot size can be 5,000 square feet. Just imagine how that would change so many communities in Massachusetts.
I'm not familiar with the language.
Speaker 2 (01:48:47–01:49:39)
The ballot, yeah, it's actually pretty, I looked it up because the petition is this. That's it, that's how long it is. So it's, and it says no zoning ordinance or bylaw shall prohibit unreasonably restrict or require special permit or other discretionary zoning approval for the use of land or structures for a single family residence in a zoning district that allows residential uses provided that the single family residence is fully contained within a lot measuring equal to or greater than 5,000 square feet in area and with equal to or greater than 50 feet of frontage. What they said they're trying to do is basically allow starter homes again.
And the cost of the land is the thing that's driving the cost of starter homes to be too expensive. That's the ballot question.
Speaker 7 (01:49:39–01:49:43)
I think what they say and what their intention is is very different.
Speaker 2 (01:49:44–01:49:53)
Well, so if you just Google, you know, starter legalizing starter homes, ballot question, you can find this. I did it today.
Speaker 9 (01:49:53–01:50:04)
But what's the frontage in our I'm not sure what your frontage is, but you know, in a one acre single way, it's 150 foot frontage.
Speaker 2 (01:50:06–01:50:12)
I think in a C, it's probably 75. Because if you're talking about, yeah.
Speaker 9 (01:50:13–01:50:27)
So you're saying like in my neighborhood, Cheryl, you're showing yours, like I have an acre. So all of a sudden I could as a right subdivide my property and build more housing.
Speaker 2 (01:50:27–01:50:41)
Three homes. I don't know if that's what it's saying. Well, I don't hear anything about frontage, just the lot size, right? It's 5,000.
No, it does say 50 feet of frontage. 50 feet of frontage. Which has access to public.
Speaker 4 (01:50:41–01:50:46)
If you had 100 feet of frontage, then you'd have two lots.
Speaker 2 (01:50:46–01:50:51)
But it also has to have access to public sewer, so is Hillside public sewer or septic?
Speaker 9 (01:50:51–01:51:12)
Yeah, not the whole thing. Like plenty of other neighborhoods who people have spent a considerable amount of money on homes, especially recently, and they, you know, got into, you know, the idea of a single family neighborhood and now all of a sudden, that could totally change overnight.
Speaker 8 (01:51:13–01:51:15)
My lot frontage is 50 feet so.
Speaker 2 (01:51:16–01:51:44)
There's a lot of homes in Milton, a few that are non-conforming. East Milton, yeah. And not just East Milton, a lot of precinct 1 and 10 and 2. But it's consistent.
But it's in a whole area that's consistent. Yeah. So anyway, I just mentioned those as things for us to be aware of, not necessarily for us to do anything about, because it may require us to do something later.
Speaker 7 (01:51:44–01:52:50)
I guess as I think through what we could do that's most beneficial to the town, anything that makes other departments' jobs easier should be the highest priority we have. You know, anything like codification, absolutely. Like you talk about Michael White's job gets improved now. We're as far as we can go there.
Now it's up to KP Law to see how quickly, you know, Carolyn can get through that. But I think if there are opportunities for us to improve, know the improve you know any department's ability to execute their work we should that should be a that should be a priority for us I'm not sure if we're gonna find that but you know when we think about you know some of the some of the problems that we run into because maybe it's cut and filled isn't isn't well enough to find you know what I mean for whether it's a developer or somebody in town, but anything like that, I think should be should be high on our list, just to just to, you know, help anybody that we can possibly help.
Speaker 1 (01:52:50–01:52:52)
And we also talked about.
Speaker 9 (01:52:52–01:53:02)
Before we go, just I wanted to follow up on Cheryl's legislation. Cheryl, do you know who's sponsoring that? Is it all like developers are sponsoring that bill?
Speaker 2 (01:53:03–01:53:05)
I don't, the ballot question, I don't know.
Speaker 9 (01:53:05–01:53:06)
Or the ballot initiative?
Speaker 2 (01:53:06–01:53:19)
Yeah, who's sponsoring it? I don't know. I think it's like a number of different entities, but I'm not sure who it is. It doesn't say.
Speaker 9 (01:53:19–01:53:31)
I mean, there are people who signed it, but. That would be concerning, yeah. And it'd be concerning to see if those same people have contributed to Mari Healy's One Commonwealth Fund, you know.
Speaker 2 (01:53:32–01:53:39)
Well, I'm not. I'm not aware of who it is, so.
Speaker 8 (01:53:41–01:53:42)
Could I, so sorry.
Speaker 2 (01:53:43–01:53:43)
No, go ahead.
Speaker 8 (01:53:44–01:54:28)
So, Sean, to your point, and again, I apologize if I'm not advocating this, I'm just asking the question. The recodification. It's going to take a year, perhaps. But we all agree that if we were to get that, once we get that done, it's going to improve the situation here in town for the town itself, for the staff, for the people that want to live here and work here and open businesses.
Is it a money issue that can't be done faster? I'm not saying we have magical money to create, but if we were to be able to provide more money towards that from the board, from the town, would it go faster? I mean, I would think, yes, but not necessarily.
Speaker 7 (01:54:28–01:54:34)
I don't think at this point the funds have been allocated. Now it's in KP Law's hands to just execute as fast as she can.
Speaker 2 (01:54:35–01:55:04)
The question is, depending upon how much input they want to get from attorneys and, you know, There's been a handful of attorneys who've done the bulk of the work in my tenure on the board. And so they have a lot of experience with the issues that they've come across. If it's just those couple of people, I really think it would be helpful if Liz, you can ask Carolyn to give us a realistic timeframe at our next meeting.
Speaker 4 (01:55:05–01:56:34)
I think, yeah, and I think too, and this kind of came up when we were discussing the scope that they provided. I think it, I think it's in, it's, it's probably in the folder. Have you had a chance to look at the scope? How that they provide her strong recommendations was that a like, a repeal and replace.
process is very, very difficult. It's a really high bar. So that would be basically like take the existing zoning and drop it, drop it right on and take this whole new thing and sort of just repeal and replace, right? So her intent from her experience is that it's better to chunk it over like three town meetings.
So that was why I was kind of in my head thinking maybe there's a way we could somehow get some of this sort of like initial piece done in the fall. But I really, with all the other stuff that's on the plate, like the housing production plan, the economic development plan, the open space and migration plan, the climate action plan, which if that funding comes through, is going to be getting kicked off pretty soon, well, will be getting kicked off in the next couple of months, essentially. That Cheryl's probably much more realistic that it would probably be more like the spring, 2070 even for that first of the three town meetings. So that was just some of the feedback we were getting from Carolyn based on her experience with this stuff.
Speaker 2 (01:56:35–01:57:29)
So one of my experiences, Liz, is that we did just a renumbering of the zoning bylaw when we did the first round of codification and that generated discussion at town meeting. I really feel like the next generation of town meeting should just be like that, cleaning the whole thing up and not like a lot of changes because I feel as if that's going to be a lot for one vote. So, you know, cleanup can be explained as not changing the way or what people can do. Maybe it's changing the way a little bit, but not what people can do and where.
And then you can get to the things that the attorneys want to see done differently or that the commissioner wants to see done differently. after you've got the thing cleaned up?
Speaker 4 (01:57:33–01:57:51)
Yeah, I honestly, can you guys be quiet? I honestly. We can Liz, we will be quiet. I honestly don't know how much sort of like internal inconsistency there is in the documents.
Speaker 2 (01:57:52–01:59:02)
So just for example, there's no dimensional Table, so you read one place? I got a little search and jump around to find What my minimum lot size is what my setbacks are and someplace it might contradict it somewhere down the road here and The other thing that would take some cleanup would be the definition of height is different in different sections So I mean, yeah, that is like craziness in zoning I there's no like place that we're parking is like a table. I mean, if you were used to working with zoning codes like I am, you see this zoning code and you think like, how is it that this exists? Because it's just not user friendly.
That's just the first level is making it user friendly. So like there was an unofficial one pager that put the setbacks on it. just for the building department to use at one time. So they wouldn't have to go through 10 pages each time just to find out what the setbacks and the coverage and the heights were.
Speaker 9 (01:59:02–01:59:18)
I would think that if you put the narrative language from our zoning bylaw into AI and say, please convert this to a table or a chart, it could easily do that, couldn't it?
Speaker 6 (01:59:20–01:59:24)
I'd say it would take a lot of review to see if that's accurate.
Speaker 4 (01:59:25–02:00:38)
It would take a lot of review. And the height that's in section A pertains to very specific circumstances and very specific people that have very specific property rights. And the height that's in section whatever, same thing. And then the height that is in section whatever.
So that's where I hate cliches, but the devil's in the details. And that's where it gets hard, because then it becomes a substantive discussion. It doesn't become a clerical, a Scribner's. It's not, that's not what it is.
It's no, in this section of the bylaw, we're not pointing back to a, you know, to a definition that, you know, applies to the bylaw in its totality. We're talking about heights in this particular, you know, Oberle district, and that's it. So, so then the people in the overlay district are like, wait a second, we thought we could go higher. And, and, you know, do you want to make the rest of the town higher?
So that's, so that's where that stuff gets really hard. And then it becomes, it becomes substantive, fortunately, because it's, that's how, that's how the town wrote their bylaw. They wrote their bylaw, like, like circumstance by circumstance.
Speaker 2 (02:00:39–02:01:44)
So normally you'd find a use table and in the use table, you would find which districts you're allowed to do what? So if single family, and you'd have an X in each of the districts listed there. And then you'd have another use, and then it would check which districts. Now you go in there and you look, ah, I'm allowed this here, but maybe somewhere else in there it tells me I'm allowed it, there's an overlay that covers it somewhere else.
I mean, we did, until recently, we didn't even have, we still don't have all the overlays in the zoning map. I mean, if you're a property owner, I've had several people reach out to me and say, You know, can I do this with my property or where do I find out if I can do this with my property? And you realize that it's not like the easiest thing to answer. Say, okay, well, there's this GIS map and then you go to the GIS map and then you click on it and you're not, well, anyway, it will make a big time saver if people can find the information themselves.
You know, searchable format, Now it's searchable, but it's still difficult.
Speaker 7 (02:01:45–02:02:50)
So I have a suggestion on this. Liz and to our board, could we ask Carolyn to return back to meet with us just to have a discussion about how to expedite codification and to give Hal a chance to ask whatever questions he has of Carolyn. You both are architects. You guys spent time in code.
I'm a builder. you design it per code, I get to build it per design. So I don't have to spend the time in code evaluating the way you guys do. So you know how problematic it is to work with ours.
I don't have the pain every single day that you guys do. But I think in the interest of expediting, whatever it is we can expedite, whether it's chunking it out, as Carolyn has said, or whatever other process we discuss with Carolyn. I think it'd be great for her to come back in now that we have allocated funds, and just talk through one more time what her process is, what her timeline is, and let's make sure we all agree with the direction that she's going to go. Right.
Speaker 4 (02:02:50–02:02:54)
Yeah, I think that's an excellent idea. I'll definitely have Carolyn come in.
Speaker 7 (02:02:54–02:02:58)
Or we could give Carolyn another 30 minutes to criticize it as it is, because I'm
Speaker 1 (02:03:04–02:04:36)
So the things that this was a great, great list to go through, it's 10 after nine. And, you know, I'd like to sort of narrow it down to things that we think we want to like short term, because I think a lot of these are good also to be looking at for long term. The other things that I'll just add, we had talked about the town has not done a preservation plan in years. I think it would be nice to to be able to have a consultant, you know, to work on that and maybe jointly with the Historical Commission.
You know, it's a lot of the information we already have a lot of the properties that have been surveyed. But there's without any effort on preservation, whether it's open space, whether it's historic buildings. it's always fallen at the bottom of the list for the town to not really, and we live in a, you know, an incredibly wonderful town. And, you know, we talk about the physical character of the town.
And, you know, part of that is what the preservation plan does, incorporating, you know, cultural landscape reports, architectural, you know, historic homes. It's an inventory of what we have. And then, so what are we gonna, you know, Are there any actions that we're taking to do that? So that's something I would like to see.
I know other people have mentioned that to me, and it's been years since we've done one.
Speaker 2 (02:04:36–02:04:46)
Is it having one make grants available to us, or does it serve as a guide for the historical commission?
Speaker 1 (02:04:47–02:04:56)
I have to look at what to do, actually. Liz, do you? Would you know the answer to that? I have examples that I brought in.
Speaker 4 (02:04:57–02:05:48)
I would say that the CPC is probably where I would go first for something like this. The housing production plan informs their work under affordable housing. The open space and recreation plan informs their work. This recreation master plan informs their work.
My suggestion is that Historic preservation is one of the pillars, one of the three pillars. That's a possibility, maybe if there's some other town funding to get matched or something. Mass Historic does have very limited funding for historic structure inventory reports that I've worked with in the past, but there's not a lot of money out there for historic preservation. The main pot these days is CPC.
Speaker 2 (02:05:49–02:06:22)
But if once it's adopted, is there some financial opportunity once it's adopted? I'm just wondering what do we do with it once we have it? Is it used by the Historical Commission in making their decisions? Is it something which allows us to apply for municipal, you know, there's grants available to I think municipalities through the Mass Historic Commission, do you have to have one of these plans?
I don't really know. So I'm asking, that's what I'm asking.
Speaker 4 (02:06:23–02:06:53)
I think it's the same. I think it's the same answer, Cheryl. I don't think there's a lot of money out there for historic preservation. I think you have to get really creative.
There's definitely, there's tax credits. You know, there are, there are, you know, national register, you know, listings, state register listings. There's, you know, there are certain things that can get teed up based on doing some of this work, doing some of this like foundational work. It really depends on the town's priorities.
Speaker 1 (02:06:55–02:07:50)
And it may be helpful to inform CPC, you know, when the CPC makes decisions, what are the, you know, what are the priorities? What are the things that have been at risk? The CPC's funding the Yacht Club, which was, you know, our old jail and That's being, restoration work is being finally happening on that very slowly, but it's happening. They're getting ready to do the windows, the CPC, they've done the roof.
So that's something, but something to sort of guide and say, okay, these would be a priority. We had put on fire station, you know, previously it was, you know, the historical commission has said, we want, you know, we really these fire stations and we could use CPC funding to do them. And that's, you know, Atherton Street would be the next one. So it would be that type of municipal projects or assets the town has that I think it might guide that.
Speaker 8 (02:07:50–02:07:55)
Miss Historical will provide matching funds for a plan.
Speaker 1 (02:07:56–02:08:13)
Oh, OK. That's that's good to know. So maybe that could be something that the planning board applies to CPC for, you know, for a grant for for a consultant to maybe work on this. Not looking to put more work for our board.
Speaker 7 (02:08:13–02:09:47)
Just a thought I have in terms of what would our residents expect of us? Not every resident, but probably some residents and if any folks that are listening tonight and they hear some of the things that we're talking about, envisioning, I guess, aspirationally the list, but I'm sure there are plenty of residents that might be thinking, what's the impact of the change that's ongoing right now? before we make more changes, do we even recognize what is the impact of where this ain't built? And I think we have a responsibility to understand that and be able to respond to a resident that yes, we do understand what the impact is and we have capacity as a town to absorb more.
Do you know what I mean? We had a calculation that Liz gave to us recently of what's under construction, Liz, on the on the projects. I'm not asking you, but I know you gave it to us recently. There's a tremendous amount under construction.
Eventually, those are going to be occupied units. You know, I think, did you say that Michael White has 20 ADU applications? Maybe it wasn't you, maybe Liz said that. But, you know, we have this surge, you know, and I feel we're responsible to the residents to understand, you know, what's the impact of the change that's ongoing before we, you know, create even more impact within the town.
So, I don't know how we do that, you know, but I'm sure it's, there's a lot of, there's a lot of thought involved in that, but.
Speaker 1 (02:09:47–02:09:48)
Traffic analysis.
Speaker 7 (02:09:49–02:10:38)
You know, the impact is probably to every service we have in town. You know, we were talking about this back when the MBTA communities discussion took place, and, you know, but I'm considering, you know, the impact of all the multi-unit, and most of them 40Bs, and large 40Bs. I'm not sure there's ever been an analysis by the town of what the impact is of those. There isn't one that I'm aware of.
but you know, I, before, I'm sorry, Maggie, but before we face the criticism of residents in town that are hearing us talk about creating more opportunity for more residential, I would want to be able to be prepared as a board to say, yeah, well, we've been informed of what the changes are that have taken place and we understand them.
Speaker 1 (02:10:39–02:10:57)
Do you know what I mean? And that's actually, that's going to be one of the discussions that I wanted to bring up with our final agenda item and talking about the $450,000 grant. And part of that, and I'm not jumping to it, but I just was going to tie this in.
Speaker 9 (02:10:57–02:12:59)
Just talking about impacts before we get too far. So I was wondering, and I asked, and after town meeting, I did send Nick Mulato an email wondering if we can do assess impact fees So if you read in the paper recently, you know, the town of Braintree, they they're proposing a 700 unit project. And in return, the town of Braintree had a developer agreement and and to assess and to mitigate some of the impacts on their on the town. And as part of that agreement, the developer committed to paying substantial mitigation funding and public benefits, which included funding for public safety, a new patrol vehicle, more than $320,000 in support of the police department over time, traffic monitoring technology and cameras, contribution for schools and public amenities, including recreational access, parking and riverfront improvements.
Like, and I, and I think I reached out to Liz about this too, like how do we, as a town, um, get these developers to pay, um, and impact fees, you know, and then a town meeting the other night, we heard chief King talk about the drain on Milton hospital, the drain on his staff at the policeman. on because he has to send them up to the hospital for a lot of issues up there and it's draining our resources. So how do we get these developers to pay impact fees and who would negotiate these developer agreements at the start of any type of project?
Speaker 1 (02:13:03–02:13:12)
You know, Liz, I don't know if you want to comment on that in your experience. And I don't know how they, as a town, how they negotiated that themselves.
Speaker 4 (02:13:13–02:15:27)
But it would be interesting. I would probably need to, I know Maggie, when you reached out about that, I had said that my former colleague in Braintree probably wrote the zoning for that. I know she wrote the zoning for the project that's going by the old Armstrong. PB, Lisa Smith-Miyazaki, she was involved in both.
And she is also the chair of the zoning board in Watertown. or written into the zoning itself. I don't know the answer to that. I do know from a legal standpoint that there has to be a nexus between the project and the fee.
It can't just be some random item. If the developer doesn't mind and they do it of their own volition, then it probably could go through. But if it's challenged, it has to be a nexus. So I don't know.
I mean, the town has adopted inclusionary zoning for pretty much all of its multifamily development overlays, right? So there's decisions that are made about sort of like what do you want developers to provide, right? So there's that as well. You have to be able to justify what you're asking them to do.
So I don't know if it's something it's something I can definitely take a harder look at. And. Or maybe it's projects like the town's priorities, those are probably not 40 B's that you're referencing in Braintree, which I would think has neither. Neither are 40 B's.
Correct. Yes. Neither of those projects are 40 B's. Correct.
Speaker 6 (02:15:28–02:15:28)
Yeah.
Speaker 4 (02:15:28–02:15:58)
You really don't have any you have no ability to to impose additional fees. In fact, that letter that you saw that we put together for 648 Canton, you know, shows you the extent to which, you know, an applicant can come in and sort of get through that permitting process and sort of defer, you know, a significant amount of process, right? So, yeah, I don't know.
Speaker 2 (02:15:58–02:17:02)
Definitely something to look at. That scale of development, if the infrastructure can't support it, the town is not obligated to put in the infrastructure improvements for it. So part of it might be that the developer is required to pay for it because they wouldn't be able to do the project otherwise. And call it the impact fee, but it's really just a cost of doing their project.
It's a cost of business. I know Boston does impact. Fees and and other things as part of their large project review. It's baked into their their whole system and it's all based on scale the project and the location and the impacts in that particular location and You know, it's very neighborhood specific.
So Every that kind of is consistent with what you're saying Liz in terms of Having to be very much tied to the impact that the project has. It just can't be something broad.
Speaker 9 (02:17:04–02:17:10)
Police and medical are part of our infrastructure, and I feel like that gets overlooked.
Speaker 2 (02:17:10–02:17:19)
Yeah, I don't think that the law allows that to be something you can- Physical. Yeah. It's like roads, it's like water, it's like sewer.
Speaker 7 (02:17:19–02:18:45)
There's a gap, Maggie, as you see it and probably as a lot of people see it. If anything was evident in town meeting, it was Chief King and Chief Grant, how stretched they are trying to meet standard service requirements for the town. And I mean, it was really difficult as a town meeting member to sit and listen, you know, to what really appeared to me to be They're doing everything they can with really limited resources. And back to the point I was making earlier, they have yet to assume the responsibility of all this new development.
Their job just gets harder. Now all of a sudden you open up all these new buildings and it's not common for Milton to have 90 unit residential projects. We have yet to challenge our fire department or our police department with that kind of a demand. They don't have enough resources, it feels to me, the way they would like to for Milton as it is right now, and they have yet to experience Milton as what it's gonna be like in a year.
And when I think about creating a greater burden on police and fire or on DPW, I feel we have a responsibility to understand the impact of what's happening in Milton right now before we create more of a burden you know, on the top.
Speaker 2 (02:18:45–02:18:55)
I'm sure we could get stats on how often they're called to Fuller Village, or how often they're called to Unquity House, or Winter Valley, because those are all over 90 units.
Speaker 1 (02:18:55–02:18:58)
And Atherton gets more calls, you know.
Speaker 2 (02:18:58–02:20:49)
And the elderly get more medical calls, because, obviously, they have potential health issues. I'm sure they have the stats on that, so we would know, or we'd be able to ask, you know, on those. And those are the things I can think of off the top of my head. And there might be something else, which is at that level.
I'd like to suggest that we say for the fall that we could do the simple thing of the MBTA community 15% requirement. Does that make sense to everyone? All right. like to start a conversation on the short-term rentals.
I'm not saying where, you know, it might fall, but I think the conversation should start. And I'd also like to start a conversation or what would be involved with planning for the west part of Milton. And I recognize it's a long-term kind of thing. Which might actually come out of the housing production.
Or the economic development. Economic development plan. But I just think if we state it and we start to think about it, we don't have to start it immediately because there's other things that are going to, economic development plan is underway and the housing production plan is getting going. But I do think it would be beneficial for us to make a commitment to it.
about what we would want to do, what it might entail, and scenic roads. So those are my, everybody else can throw in theirs, but I mean, that's my suggestions for a focus start.
Speaker 9 (02:20:50–02:21:19)
So I would like to address non-conforming businesses. I feel like that would be somewhat easy to do. because all the non-conforming businesses have been around for decades and decades. And so we just have to make them not be by special permit.
And also I would like to do the FAR with dimensional standards and open space.
Speaker 2 (02:21:20–02:21:28)
So are you suggesting a zoning change in the fall for the pre-existing non-conforming Maggie or for the spring maybe?
Speaker 9 (02:21:29–02:22:09)
You know, as soon as it's ready, I don't want to kick the can too far down the road. I mean, I think, um, that I think addressing our preexisting businesses should take priority over, um, new businesses in town and looking, even though I do support looking at, um, opportunities in the West part of Milton and I've already you know, come up with three different locations where I think it would work. I think we owe our existing businesses the respect to codify their business before we take on new businesses.
Speaker 8 (02:22:10–02:22:17)
So Cheryl, you referenced earlier state legislation that could be pending about pre-existing non-conforming.
Speaker 2 (02:22:17–02:23:04)
I'm pretty sure it's residential. I'm pretty sure it's not business. And I support Addressing pre-existing non-conforming businesses. I just don't know that we could do it justice by the in eight weeks we have before For the fall and it's partly because I think if all it is is to say You're gonna change the map so that it's a business.
It's allowed business use or You know what I mean? I think we have to kind of hammer out what what the changes would be to address it and I don't I And I think we need to talk to some attorneys who have represented the businesses as well as the business owners themselves to kind of decide what we need to do, what we should do. But I think we can start working on it, Maggie, to your point.
Speaker 1 (02:23:04–02:23:12)
I think we could start looking at what maybe other communities have also done with that.
Speaker 2 (02:23:13–02:23:24)
And as far as the FAR and dimensional standards, I agree with that. It's possible that that could be for the fall.
Speaker 7 (02:23:26–02:23:36)
When we say for the fall, are we saying prior to fall town meeting, or are we saying in the season of the fall?
Speaker 1 (02:23:36–02:23:39)
I'm talking about for fall town meeting, which means a July 9th.
Speaker 7 (02:23:41–02:23:58)
So that means… Eight weeks. Yeah, eight weeks. Which is for us, four meetings.
That's what I was just thinking. So the FAR… I'm a little concerned that we don't have enough time to do all that.
Speaker 2 (02:23:59–02:25:54)
That would be the only one really for the fall because the MBTA ones are pretty straightforward. Just you strike some language that you don't need anymore once HLC accepts the 15%. That's just a cleanup. But I think on the FAR, we could target it.
And if we don't feel like we can, and the dimensional standards, if we don't feel like it's ready, we just don't do it. But at least we can, Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-Karen Hollweg, OSBT-K For us, it's review. I don't think FAR, I've looked at FAR for various zoning, like MBTA, for example, in particular. What I think we would want to do with that is kind of codify what is kind of our standard, what you find most places.
And just make sure you don't make it too strict that, you know, so that takes a little analysis, you know, in terms of what we've got. So try and pick some, each of the residential districts and say, do some analysis in each one. And maybe Hal and I can split it up and do some of that analysis, you know, take some what looks like a housing pattern in a residency, residence B, A, double A. Because we did do a lot of that with MBTA.
Yeah. Exactly.
Speaker 1 (02:25:54–02:25:56)
That's how we ended up with the FAA. Probably had a lot of that.
Speaker 2 (02:25:56–02:26:51)
Well, I did a lot of it in the Elliott Street Corridor and the Blue Hills Parkway. I didn't do it in the residences that weren't part of the MBTA zoning. But obviously, Lot coverage is another one that plays into big. And so like right now, you see all this stuff about lot coverage in our zoning, and then it says, except for single-family residential.
So that's how you get that, those houses on Pine Grove, whatever that street is off of Pleasant, which look like, you know, there's a bit, it's too much house on the size of the lot it is. So it's a combination of the FAR and the setbacks and the lot coverage. I think it's worth trying to look at too.
Speaker 9 (02:26:51–02:27:10)
And can't we even just put a placeholder in? I know like every other board puts placeholders in, even when their zoning isn't, or their warrant articles aren't ready. Couldn't we just put a placeholder in? And then if it's not ready, we just pull it.
Speaker 4 (02:27:11–02:27:57)
I think, Carolyn, you can definitely do that, Maggie, but even in my short time here, the level of consultation that was required on something like an FAR, like Cheryl said, the MBTA thing is clerical, but the FAR, if it starts to impact people's abilities to do certain things, Um, this just has to be a lot of consultation. So it's just, just, just being, just being realistic about, about, you know, how fully baked something needs to be pretty, pretty early on to have a good chance of passing.
Speaker 9 (02:27:58–02:28:28)
Yeah. Cause that's what I hear from people, you know, when a new house goes up and they're like, Oh my God, how did that go up? It's so out of place, you know, it just doesn't fit in. Um, you know, so, um, In adding on to houses and tearing down houses and putting new ones up, that's happening all the time.
So I think that's why it's a priority because all these houses aren't just fitting into the neighborhoods that the neighborhoods were designed for.
Speaker 2 (02:28:29–02:28:47)
One thing you have to be careful about is taking away too much of the their rights. And I think a lot of reasons people are adding on is they there's no a starter home become turning it into their next home because they have nowhere to go for the next home.
Speaker 9 (02:28:48–02:29:59)
That perpetuates that perpetuates the problem. That's what I was saying before. Like we are exasperating a problem because we are taking a starter home and making it, you know, a bigger home. And then there's no starter homes on the market.
You know, I've lived in five different houses, you know, and I went from smaller, went from an apartment on Blue Hill Parkway, you know, to a smaller house, to a bigger house, and now I'm downsized, now that I'm, you know, almost an empty nester. So, like, and I wouldn't be able to do that if all of a sudden the houses, like, are all And as I said, on Gulliver and Elm and Mathos Street, if you drive down Mathos Street, those houses are huge and they're built all the way to the property lines and they're going for like $2 million. And that neighborhood was a starter neighborhood. So we're taking our starter homes off of the market.
And so we're kind of, you know, we're sabotaging ourselves.
Speaker 8 (02:29:59–02:30:05)
Sounds like you're going to sign the legalized starter homes petition after this, Maggie.
Speaker 9 (02:30:07–02:30:10)
In certain neighborhoods.
Speaker 2 (02:30:10–02:30:57)
Well, I do think some of this will be coming as part of the discussion or should be in the housing production plan. Yeah. My thought was not to adjust the FAR so people couldn't do additions. It was really more to kind of think about how to just not have the most egregious Maggie.
So maybe we're in a little different place on how far to go with that. But I think the first thing is to understand what our built environment looks like and what the FAR is. That's what I did for MBTA communities. That's how we set those FARs.
And then look at what kind of adjustments, incremental adjustments might be made there.
Speaker 1 (02:30:58–02:31:06)
And if we get the housing production plan, the economic development plan done, and this list, you know, that we've started with.
Speaker 2 (02:31:06–02:31:16)
Those plans should feed into what we do next. I mean, we should, from those, we should have some marching orders. Looking at the west, on the west side.
Speaker 7 (02:31:16–02:31:55)
So. And all these are great ideas, but I will not ignore what I said earlier, that we need an analysis of the impact of the development that's ongoing and that's permitting. These are all great initiatives, but we can't, you know, I've said this repeatedly for years now, change really should be done in balance. If we don't do it in balance, we're going to create problems that we can't solve.
And we certainly don't have the funds, you know, to respond to our departments the way that we would like to be able to. It's just, it's not fair to the departments to create more burden. You know, again.
Speaker 2 (02:31:55–02:32:11)
So Sean, we talked about a clerical fix on the MBTA hearings. We talked about FAR lot coverage and dimensional standards. And we talked about initiating discussions for planning in West Milton. I don't see any of that.
Adding any burden to any anyone.
Speaker 7 (02:32:11–02:32:29)
No, I'm not. I'm not arguing with any of that, you know, but I just I'm reiterating what I had said earlier. I'm not I'm not trying to stop any of those things. We should do all of those.
We should do them quickly. We should do them fast and get them done. I just want to reiterate what I said earlier. You know, I think it's really important for the town and I think it's something we owe to the residents.
Speaker 2 (02:32:30–02:33:09)
I just want to be clear for anybody who's watching that we're actually not. Suggesting doing anything that's going to expand things at the moment, we're talking about addressing some fixes, which is the FAR and the dimensional standards and the reclassification and the pre-existing non-conforming businesses, I also think is something we've heard a lot of problems about over a long period of time, my entire tenure on the board. Initiating a conversation about short-term rentals is coming from residents. And I think we, and so is the planning for West Milton.
So I feel as if we should start those conversations.
Speaker 7 (02:33:10–02:33:38)
Sure. And for the folks that were listening earlier that heard amend condominium conversion section of the zoning, when we were talking about, you were articulating how many homes are six or 7,000 square feet. I think people that were listening then said, that sounds like more housing. So again, what you said, yeah, I just think we have to be able to recognize what it is we're asking our departments to digest before we suggest plans to create more burden for them.
Speaker 2 (02:33:38–02:34:28)
One of the things about the condo conversion is as an alternative to 40B. Now, some people say, well, we're getting close to our SHI requirements, but we know that two of the largest 40Bs in Milton are historic homes either being torn down or altered significantly because there was no alternative for them to do a condo conversion because their lot sizes were smaller than 10,000 square feet. I don't think they would have done a condo conversion, though. I don't think those developers were looking to do a condo conversion.
Maybe somebody else would have bought it, though, who would have. Are you referring to the Can-Nav? No. To the 582 Blue Hill Lab.
582 Blue Hill Lab, especially, because it's 11,000 square foot house on, what, five acres? So it's just also, there's no protection.
Speaker 1 (02:34:28–02:34:48)
Somebody can apply under the ZVA. They can go to the ZVA and apply if you have a large property and you want to subdivide into condos. There was an application a few years back that came in. Somebody wanted to take a large home, divide it into three condos, but the abutting neighbors said, were really upset about it and didn't want it.
And so the ZVA denied it.
Speaker 2 (02:34:48–02:35:24)
Well, let's just go back to when it was written. It was the Burr Estate. And so the Burr Estate was turned into condos, multiple buildings on a parcel, and a large historic home converted into condos. And we have more than one of those, I think.
So it's been utilized well. and it allows an opportunity to preserve. So I do think it's worth talking to the historical commission because they came to speak to the planning board before and saw it as an opportunity to help preserve large homes.
Speaker 1 (02:35:24–02:36:20)
So yeah, no, I respect all this list. I hear what you're saying, Sean. So just so you know, the chair of the select board reached out and was interested in wanting to know if the planning board would like to attend one of their meetings in June, which are on the Tuesdays typically before our meetings. I think this was a really good, robust discussion that we put our goals.
And I just wanted to discuss with the planning board if we would like to go and discuss this. I think the select board was thinking, are there things that we could align on that we would like to work on together? you know, certainly expressed interest in the housing production plan. Excuse me, the economic development plan.
And there will be, you know, they will have representation on the housing production plan. So, yeah.
Speaker 7 (02:36:20–02:36:24)
I would ask that if you would allow me to get back from my.
Speaker 1 (02:36:24–02:36:33)
Oh, yeah. So June, that would be the June 24th? Yes, so they actually meet on the 23rd, I think. The 23rd, OK.
Speaker 8 (02:36:34–02:36:37)
You said you were gone for the 11th and the 25th meeting. So are you back?
Speaker 2 (02:36:37–02:36:44)
Will you be back for that? It's the 28th and 11th, I think. 28th, 11th, 28th. Sorry, I wrote that down wrong.
All right, so June 23rd for the- 23rd.
Speaker 1 (02:36:44–02:37:10)
And basically just to recap this, what we're working on, I think it would be an opportunity for us to talk about the fact that we've already initiated our, we've engaged with MAPC and we have a certain scope of work that we had talked about expanding a little bit Do we know where that stands? Liz, do we know where funding to continue the economic development plan is?
Speaker 4 (02:37:13–02:37:28)
I'd have to go back and look at what was in the budget, but I believe there was either a $25,000 or a $30,000 allocation, and it was going to be split between the two boards so that each board sort of had an equal share.
Speaker 2 (02:37:29–02:38:13)
Because I was looking at the minutes, a request for us to accept $25,000 in free cash to go towards the economic development plan, which we accepted, right? Yeah. I just would like an update on like, what's the scope? Do we have an opportunity to have them come in and discuss the scope with us?
You know, should we discuss the scope jointly with the select board on the 23rd? Should MAPC be there for that discussion? I just feel like everything just takes so long to kind of like get ironed out. And it is something that I think if all the parties are together and we can hammer it out, we can at least get them going.
Speaker 9 (02:38:16–02:38:50)
I don't know if the APC should be at that first initial meeting. I would think that we would have to meet And didn't we get $25,000? And did they get $25,000? So it's a $50,000 contract, which was less than where the full scope was going to be covered.
I thought that's how we left it. We weren't sure. How much of the scope would be covered by the funds that we had?
Speaker 4 (02:38:51–02:39:29)
Yeah, and whether or not you folks want to use some of your FY 27 planning study money to enhance the, you know, some of the scope, potentially, I don't know. But I don't believe anything has been settled beyond the last, you know, round of conversations, which was that, you know, each of the boards was going to, was going to have a share in the funding and the scope was to be finalized. And so maybe the 23rd is the perfect time to have that conversation. I think everyone has.
Speaker 9 (02:39:29–02:39:37)
So we wouldn't finalize our scope, and they finalize their scope, and then we come together, because we have two different pots of funding.
Speaker 1 (02:39:38–02:39:53)
We've sent them what the original scope was. So it would be nice. Because I think Cheryl said, let's stay with that framework of what that scope was, what MAPC was working from, and then tweak from that.
Speaker 2 (02:39:54–02:40:48)
I mean, I remember, Maggie, at the time, we talked about, gee, maybe it'd be nice if they could take on the analysis of the pre-existing non-conforming areas and West Milton and possibly even what's going on Milton Village like or East Milton Square We have vacancies in those storefronts or we have vacant buildings, you know That though we thought might have to be sort of a round two, but it would be Useful to understand how much it would cost for round two You know, there's a lot of lost I think it's lost cost when you have something that languishes for a year and you have to kind of get the team back together and, you know, almost like start it again and pick up the pieces.
Speaker 9 (02:40:48–02:40:50)
I was just questioning the process.
Speaker 2 (02:40:50–02:40:50)
Yeah.
Speaker 9 (02:40:51–02:41:05)
Because at a joint meeting, the planning board is going to have our own discussion and the select board is going to have their own discussion. So I don't know if the planning board needs to do any more refinement of our previous discussion.
Speaker 2 (02:41:06–02:41:10)
I think there needs to be more collaborative than just two boards kind of doing their own thing.
Speaker 1 (02:41:10–02:42:23)
And maybe it's a question Liz can talk to Nick about, how we move this forward. And sort of we would like to work with our scope, or maybe some things we don't need necessarily in that. depending on our funds and what we can afford to do. Maybe we put this on the agenda for our next meeting.
I know, Sean, you're not going to be here, but at least maybe we could get some feedback on where we are with our consultant. And we could just have it on as just a brief discussion on that prior to the 23rd. Good, okay, so this was really a good discussion, thank you all. And we have one last final item, which that is, and Liz, if you wanna maybe just touch on this, what you know about it, the MassWorks grant for East Milton, sort of an overview.
I did get to, I don't know if everyone had a chance to read through that, but. Wait, was something added here?
Speaker 4 (02:42:24–02:44:13)
There was a. Okay. I just sort of threw this together quickly. Oh, thank you.
Yeah. The main thing that Nick wanted you folks to know was that public. the way it's laid out in scope, it's sort of buried kind of in like item number six. But in terms of the timeline, the listening session takes place in month zero to two, and then the public session, a second public session takes place somewhere between months four and six.
So I don't know what day zero is. I didn't get a chance to get to that. I don't know if that's tomorrow or if it's September 1st. I honestly don't know.
My sense is it's probably sometime in the next month or so. that they're going to, because I know they're getting close to getting a contract finalized. And so it'll be, you know, it'll move along. So I think the thing is just to be, you know, just to be paying attention to, you know, the levers where the public input and the boards input can be, you know, It will be taken.
And yeah, and there's a lot of detail in the scope. I mean, it's about six or seven pages long. I didn't get into a lot of that because it's pretty standard in terms of the assessment and the engineering. And I think you probably all know, too, that it's from the Quincy line.
over by the, what's that restaurant over there? Brick and beam. Brick and beam, thank you. Basically from brick and beam to the corner of Granite and then the two branches of Mechanic and Franklin.
Speaker 8 (02:44:14–02:44:27)
It seems to extend 100 feet beyond Mechanic. I believe I saw that in here. It goes pretty far down into East Milton Square, Good.
Speaker 4 (02:44:29–02:44:32)
Yeah, yes, yes, yes, I think, yeah.
Speaker 1 (02:44:32–02:45:46)
Okay, sorry. I just was gonna say I think I think this is, I think this is great. My only concern is a large significant part of this analysis is on the traffic. And with, with the balcony building.
it appears to be that the Falcone building won't even be completed when this is this timeline is completed. So I would think that, you know, and I'm not sure how that would work to really be able to understand the impacts already. We've seen the food centers saying they're going to start towing. They're worrying about the apartment residents parking.
over at the food centers parking. We don't know what on-street parking, we don't allow on-street parking. We don't know the traffic flows, sort of the impacts of 90 units is gonna be on that corner and intersection. So I guess that would be a question for the consultants on how that's gonna be managed and how that can be predicted if they're, intending to predict those impacts?
Speaker 8 (02:45:46–02:46:03)
Yeah, that is a great question, Meredith. But I do know from professional experience that they can model that, right? They do, okay. They can increase upon the size of the units and the number of people they anticipate moving in there.
They can model that forward, which would, I would hope, be included in this.
Speaker 1 (02:46:04–02:46:07)
Yeah. Because I know that's going to be a concern on some of the butters.
Speaker 8 (02:46:07–02:46:28)
Yeah, totally. But the scope of this with the sidewalks improvements along Mechanic and Franklin, I mean, that part of town needs it a lot. And I, you know, I'm not sure a lot of my neighbors necessarily know about this, but I would anticipate them, once I get into it and get some more information, they'd be welcoming to this, I would think.
Speaker 2 (02:46:29–02:46:33)
So the first public outreach is task five, is that right?
Speaker 8 (02:46:34–02:46:34)
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (02:46:35–02:46:41)
And it seems like it should be, That's after final design. So it seems like there should be a public outreach.
Speaker 8 (02:46:41–02:46:52)
Well, when you look at this, the listening session, I was wondering if that's with town, right? Conduct coordination meetings with town during project development phase. I don't know if that's.
Speaker 4 (02:46:52–02:47:03)
I think there's, yeah, I think there's, I'd have to go back and look at it, but I'm pretty sure that there's a public session, a public listening session. TAB, Mark McIntyre ): There is.
Speaker 8 (02:47:03–02:47:16)
TAB, Mark McIntyre ): Two outreach meetings, including one early stage public listening session. TAB, Mark McIntyre ): During project development, so I think, to your point it's the earlier that can happen, I think, is better for the neighbors.
Speaker 4 (02:47:17–02:47:45)
TAB, Tila Duhaime): yeah and I just want to make sure you folks are you folks are aware, because like I said if if day one is like you know June 15. TAB, Tila Duhaime): Then, this is literally happening before the summer's over so. that's the type of stuff that's important because it's gonna move fast. And you know, those questions getting on the record, you know, kind of as early as possible, you know, then the consultants can look at the questions.
Speaker 2 (02:47:45–02:48:41)
Yeah, I think that given summer, and a lot of people are busy in a way in the summer, even if the DPW did it, an info session, which says, here's what we've got a consultant, a grant and a consultant on board to do and have a map and kind of show people and say, we're going to have our first listening session, you know, in whatever it is. But just that, because like people saw it in the paper and they didn't know what it was, just like out of the blue. And I think there's just been so much interest in East Milton Square in the development and in the impacts of the development and other things that it shouldn't be after the project starts that they first have an opportunity to even learn about the details of it.
Speaker 7 (02:48:41–02:49:22)
I think the way that TEC wrote their proposal they are not doing anything with the public until they get passed because they have it as task five. Right. And they write this in a sequence Survey and base mapping, that's task one. Task two is project development.
Task three is preliminary 50% design. Task four is final design. And then they have public outreach and coordination. I think that's to discuss the project after it's designed in whatever coordination they feel.
And then they're into permitting. So they don't have anything. And reading through their proposal, they're leaving it to the town to do that, to do whatever public outreach.
Speaker 4 (02:49:23–02:49:44)
I think I don't I don't I don't think so. I don't think so, Sean. I think I think it's just the way they sort of I think it's just the way they laid it out. Really?
They're definitely on the book to do that listening session early on and to do the public session before. When I read. I didn't see it either.
Speaker 7 (02:49:44–02:49:49)
So when I read through the scope of services, it doesn't say anything about the listening session. So just go.
Speaker 8 (02:49:49–02:50:22)
So public outreach facilitate two public outreach meetings, including one early stage public listening session during project developments. And then if you flip back, project developments is task two. So hopefully page five, task five, it says town coordination meetings and then public outreach. So we should confirm, Liz should confirm, we should advocate for that.
The way that I'm reading this is the early stage during the project development is task two, when they're doing the conceptual design. So, yeah.
Speaker 7 (02:50:22–02:50:41)
So I guess- It is weird that it's all the way in five. Yeah, task five is meetings, public outreach and coordination, and they have a value assigned to it of $35,000. So they have some time allocated to it. It's just as Hal said, but anyhow, it wasn't clear in the previous, but anyhow, that's good.
Speaker 8 (02:50:42–02:50:53)
And it definitely was not clear in the article in the Times that, like, that seemed scary to me when reading it, that it was already to a point, but… Yeah, it should be covered.
Speaker 2 (02:50:53–02:51:08)
I think the sooner that meeting gets kind of scheduled and what the expectations are, and if it can be before end of school, or when school releases, because that's when a lot of people vacation and other things, right?
Speaker 7 (02:51:10–02:51:27)
Yeah. So when, when you read that description of the work, it says a hundred feet west of Franklin street. So that's going, that's going back towards the, towards the highway, a hundred feet towards the highway. And then all the way to the Quincy line.
Speaker 8 (02:51:27–02:52:00)
And it says even an additional 25 feet beyond that as well, just for like the proven pavement. So when I did, It looks like it's going all the way to the median there, the little island that's there. 125 feet is almost to that point. And then also it's down Franklin and down Mechanic.
It's on Mechanic all the way to Granite, and it's down Franklin all the way to Bassett, I think. Those sidewalks were terrible. That would be great improvement.
Speaker 2 (02:52:00–02:52:10)
Oh, and the roads, mechanicism. Yeah. The parking on the sidewalk, because there's no curb. No.
On mechanic, anyway. No. Not much needed.
Speaker 1 (02:52:11–02:52:20)
OK. Well, this was good. So I just wanted to put this on so we could understand it. So when we're asked about it, we could understand it.
Speaker 2 (02:52:20–02:52:52)
I did want to also point out here, it does say conduct coordination meetings Historic Commission and other relevant stakeholders as it relates to the Railway Village Historic Village. Railway Village Historic Village, but I think I meant districts. Two meetings with the Historic Commission, one virtual and one in person, one presentation to the select board. It's just kind of the way it's worth some of this information as it's It's not intuitive, but.
Speaker 7 (02:52:52–02:52:58)
Liz, do you know if there are any utility relocations involved in what they're proposing?
Speaker 3 (02:53:02–02:53:04)
You have a question for me? Yeah.
Speaker 4 (02:53:07–02:53:15)
This would be great to hear though. This is literally the first I've looked at this project was just to kind of give you guys a sense of the schedule.
Speaker 8 (02:53:15–02:53:19)
Okay, great. I feel like they buried some of the utilities at 440.
Speaker 1 (02:53:19–02:53:23)
They did. We had requested that.
Speaker 7 (02:53:23–02:53:59)
I'm not even thinking that they would be proud of it, but I'm just thinking about the period of design and then the period of construction. This is a long way away, I think. It just takes time to plan these projects. The start date on this project could be a year to two years away, I think.
you know, get involved in permitting and all the issues and if there are utilities involved. Funding is important, right? It's even more important, right? Yeah, the funding, yeah.
Okay, great. Thanks for putting it out there to us, Liz.
Speaker 1 (02:54:01–02:54:11)
All right. So, that is the last item on our agenda. And so, we wish you the best of luck in your
Speaker 7 (02:54:11–02:54:12)
You think I need luck?
Speaker 8 (02:54:13–02:54:14)
Do you have to be silent on it?
Speaker 7 (02:54:14–02:54:24)
That's what I was thinking about. You know, it's, uh, to be honest with you, I think, um, it's, there's plenty of people that, you know, spend some periods of time in silence.
Speaker 3 (02:54:26–02:54:28)
Okay.
Speaker 7 (02:54:29–02:55:04)
Yeah. No, you don't have to. I have, um, a priest, um, friends with who's walked a portion of this three times and no, uh, yeah. But, um, No, it's not.
It's not necessary. I think it's impossible. My daughter did it last year, and she came from Porto, so she was 170 miles. I'm coming from France, and 483 miles, and we won't be able to, we don't have enough time.
I can't spend a month in France, but we'll be somewhere around 200 miles. I'm sure some of it will be silent.
Speaker 1 (02:55:06–02:55:29)
All right, so thank you all. Liz, did you have anything else? Otherwise, I would entertain a motion to adjourn. No.
So moved. Second. All in favor. Roll call.
Oops. Sorry. Maggie? Yes.
Hal? Yes. John? Yes.
Cheryl? Yes. And myself, yes. Good night.
Good night. Thank you.
Speaker 3 (02:55:29–02:55:32)
Good night, everyone. Good night.