Board: Milton Board Of Assessors

Date: 2025-11-06


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:15–00:18)

I believe the video's going.

Speaker 2 (00:20–01:18)

I don't know if it's starting to go. All right, let's call the meeting to order at 6.08 PM. Do we need to move the meeting minutes from October 20th as a chance to review them? Yeah, let's play a couple of questions.

I asked Charlie and Jason and yes, he had the wrong German time. Yeah, initially, extra hour and an extra hour. So I had a motion to accept the 20 minutes. I think I'm unanimous.

Speaker 1 (01:18–01:30)

I'm sorry. We're trying to fix something. I know. We're trying to fix something.

Speaker 2 (01:31–07:03)

That was funny. That was funny, Chad. Yeah. All right.

So, Chad, do you want to run us through the text classification slides? Yeah. So, basically, what we're really doing here, thank you, You know, we have to do the typical thing that we've been doing for years, which is take a look at the tax classification that's going to basically be on the third page. And obviously, we have the override.

And, you know, if you were interested in kind of what the override is doing. I did put like the levy limiting here and all that too. So everything that you see includes the, it's 8,800,000 and there's another 700,000 in addition to that. So that's just the way it was voted on and gone.

So what you're really seeing up here are the adjustments that we needed to make. So in this case here, you'll see in the past, down in the history of the tax rates, we've been at 149, 156, 156, 155. And we came in where the highest that we can shift is a 15. So that would be the first column, which would then be a 0.97714.

the most we can do for the residential side and then I gave you two other options and then there's the single tax rate you could see that the um you know there'd be a difference in that commercial if we did a single tax rate. It seems to me that the best option would be option one, just because that's going to give the most relief to the residential side without really beating up the commercials. But that would be the best we can do for adjustments on the residential side. What changes for the residential three options they'll see at the same rate is mostly rounding so.

you know, so you'd have an 11, nine, you'd have a, you know, like 11.99 or whatever, but the spreadsheets kind of rounded down. So it's minimally, minimally different. Yeah. And if you look at the factor, it's basically put nine, seven, seven, one, seven, two, and seven, three.

I will be honest. I didn't really spread it out and give you large chunks of different ones because, you know, I think the way the budget's going to work in town, um, you know, the, they'd like to get the, the 15.9771, and that would still be fair to the commercials, because commercials didn't go up as much as the residentials did. And so if their tax rate goes up a bit more, it'll kind of even things out. In the sense that residential property values went up and commercial didn't.

Yeah, commercial went up about 4%. Residentials went up about 5%. Okay. Yeah, so, I mean, it would depend even on a case like that.

But the average tax change is 11.9% for a single family home and 10.6% for average commercial. Yes, if you think of option one. Yeah, so that's sort of keeping it. slightly even in a sense, because it's not like it's a big difference.

I feel like this is the tightest all these options have been in several years. Right. Typically, there's quite a gap in all three of them. Yeah.

And most of the time, You can see when we go to like 1.56, there's two options is either 1.5 or 1.75. And it has to do with how the values relate to each other. We often have the 1.75 adjustment, but we don't use it that way. We use it like we'll do 1.56 or 1.52 or 1.55.

But this year came out to a 1.5 is the most we can adjust. And it's also the lowest we could do for the residential factor. So why is it? Why was it the lowest you can do?

So the Department of Revenue has kind of a site that we put all the information into. And, you know, again, it's just doing the relationships between all of the values and saying, you know, is it going to be fair to allow you to adjust it 1.75 1.5. Yeah, it's a lot of state oversight but it keeps it tight. Okay, I just wanted to make sure.

I want to make it uniform too for all the other municipalities. Yeah, I mean if you have the 1.75 and you decided to use it, you know, it would be a big adjustment but it wouldn't be fair, right?

Speaker 3 (07:03–07:03)

Right.

Speaker 2 (07:26–10:21)

Yeah. So, um, if you see right here, this is where the, uh, fiscal 26 new values are. Um, and then just above there would be the, uh, old value. So, you know, we pretty much went from, um, you know, a million 28, four 87 to a million 81, one 91 for the rent.

Yeah. And the average difference. So, um, they went up about 5% and then commercials, um, it looks like 3.3%. Um, and, uh, that's really the difference where if you chose option one, it's kind of even pull up like 35 to 40.

Yeah. Residential of 50. So right. That's a lot more residential properties.

Yeah. And last year, uh, I think we were two, residential went up only about 2%, but most of the time it was because the sales were getting improved and sold. So that kind of didn't allow everyone to raise up with the boats or with the tide. Do you want me to tack on any of the other pieces in here?

By the other, the residential exemption and the small… Or even just any of these other pieces with the off questions and… Here it's about the average single family tax bill right after that. So 18 instead of 26, it's…

It's about 11.9%. tax bill increase. So it's actually on the second to last paragraph on the page right here. Um, so basically, you know, that's two things.

That would be the tax rate change and the revaluation change. So, you know, if you think of a tax rate, it went up about 7% revaluing up about 5%. So that's where you get to 11.9% of the residential. And, um, you know, the way to keep it down somewhat is to go with the option one.

And then, you know, again, you'll see that the residential, excuse me, the commercial in 1694 to 1813. And so again, that's about a 10.6% increase. So that's both the increase of the tax rate, but also the revaluation as well. So the increase in the average single county tax bill

Speaker 3 (10:22–10:35)

is the greatest one-year increase in the last nine years. Oh, absolutely. It's going up by over $1,300. And you say 700 is related to the override on the dollar.

Speaker 2 (10:35–11:25)

It's just broken up into two parts. So if you went to the levy limit, which is like, let me think here. So you see the maximum levy right here. And then the maximum levy, you'll see a fiscal override, $8,800,000.

But then I guess even the way it was worded during the vote, there was also another $700,000 that was put into the stabilization fund. So it's still, you know, 9.5 billion, but it's just broken up into two areas. Okay. Yeah.

Speaker 3 (11:29–11:40)

All right. Substantially seconding the number of elderly in the community and retirees. Yeah.

Speaker 2 (11:40–12:18)

Challenging on a fixed income. They are going to start trying to work on some of that, and same with veterans as well. I think we talked about the ARO Act last year, with the override didn't get through, but then also doing something for the elderly as well, so. Well, they did do that means-based.

Yes. They did pass it to me, so they've done something already. They expand on it. I think they just have to vote it in.

you know, get it moving, so. Yeah, you've got his top meetings. Yeah, that's not me.

Speaker 1 (12:23–12:27)

Yeah, there's the chart. Yeah, so you tell me. Yeah, okay.

Speaker 2 (12:44–14:27)

Brian, you would ask about the tax rate. I did put a piece in about shifting the tax rate, but it's about three pages long. Yeah, but the only… You're shifting the tax rate?

Just even the way we do it. So why do you get the 1.5 versus the 1.75? What's… What does this tell us?

Tax levies percent of budget compared to peer communities were the highest in terms of 85%. Yeah. So that really just means the levy itself. So other people might raise money.

So we typically have the amount that needs to be raised. Then we have the amount that's raised by the town, you know, just for all the fees that get charged, et cetera, et cetera. And then the rest is just 11, you know, make up for, you know, we have to obviously find the a hundred percent in that case. Does that mean we have lower fees than other communities?

If we're at possibly, you know, with less commercial and things like that, that can make a difference as well. Yeah. So these are ones where I basically have to go into the ELS database and pull that information out. Um, you know, uh, I don't think it really reflects anything on Milton and just that, um, you know, the tax levy itself, it's almost like people pay, one way or another, whether it's fines and things like that.

Not a lot.

Speaker 1 (14:27–14:43)

Yeah, that's fine.

Speaker 2 (14:44–19:22)

So yeah, maybe we can take a look at it and see what, what we wanted. Cause this, this package all goes to the Slack community. Yeah, exactly. And then you do see like a residential versus commercial industrial right after that.

And obviously Milton's down at the 4.1 and not really close to anyone else in there. So, and those are the people that do pay the fees and things like that, you know, depending on what they're doing. Yeah, I think that's our, all we do is assess it. I keep that because that's, you know, it's useful to our members.

Yeah, because it's just a description of the residential exemptions and how it actually isn't all that terrific. You know, if you say we're going to exempt everyone that's a homeowner, It only really means that people below the average amount get a break. And it doesn't have anything to do with what people need or anything like that. And the ones that are above it wouldn't get the exemption.

I think we're in line with a lot of others. There's not a lot. Does Boston do one? Yeah, they do.

So typically, Boston, Cambridge, I didn't have it listed here. Yeah, and I'm not saying, I think you're missing a couple though. I think in all sorts. I did look it up the other day, and it was less than there were.

But it's mostly places that people come in and rent. They want to then say, OK, well, let's give people that own in and live there. Or second houses. Yeah, exactly.

So pay a card or whatever, same type of thing. But I just looked it up the other day, and there were less, for whatever reason. Because you have more influence. Yes.

I mean, I feel the same. people started making their primary residence on the Cape or in Eggertown or whatever. So that might be like, hmm. Yeah.

Well, there's the whole thing now, too, about Vrbo and all that. They can rent their house out and how often do they do it and all that. But I think those all voted positively. They didn't want to hold back on any of that.

I think Rhode Island is perhaps the opposite of that. If you own a second home, they're charging you higher tax, even though you don't use any of the services on it. Most of us don't use the schools or anything like that. Their tax rate is different if it's a second property.

Wow. I actually did a bunch of towns down in Rhode Island over 30, 40 years or whatever it's been now. Yeah. So you're not using the schools.

Yeah. Yeah, and they said it's really gonna affect people that have high-end homes like Like it's like a Taylor Swift or the people that can afford to pay. Yeah There's an heir of the Budweiser that's down in Westerly that has a big house And I think I think Bill and Hillary Clinton have a house in Westerly Yeah, they're all they're all second or third homes. They're gonna have to pay more taxes the way they designed this law They have some nice places that, you know, like Narragansett, again, there's a, you know, nice areas.

You know, beaches and everything else. They're just people thinking of the cave instead of… But it's the rest of what you do here, they're kind of penalizing the people for having that second home, which doesn't really make a lot of sense. Right, right.

See, I've seen it's a cash balance. Yeah, especially if there's a lot of big houses in Newport. Right. Right.

Yeah. The company I worked for a vision of all those places.

Speaker 3 (19:42–19:44)

Now, did our overlay change?

Speaker 2 (19:44–22:06)

I looked at that earlier today, and we talked a little bit about the new value, but as I see it was 2.4 million. Yes, so there was no money taken. We didn't give back this year. Yeah.

And so there's an increase in that. Yeah, but there is an amount in the overlay that goes I think it was like 300,000 or something like that. Yeah. And that's also kind of an adjustment number because 395 actually, it's the third to the last page.

There's a separate sheet in the email. Yeah. It's right here. $395, $226.55.

But there's also the overlay transferred to overweight surplus after July 1st, and that's a zero. So it was Hayden's got some talent. So our overlay balance was $2.4. But we don't know what our liability against that is.

Yeah, it's on number 11. It's still Unquity and Winter Valley are the only ones so far that are still out there. Yeah, they're asking for the written minutes and all that kind of stuff. There's a potential expectation that they'll still push for it.

But that number is just 292,315. So we'll see what we see once the tax bills go out and people get them around January. So that could be potentially something that could be released if that goes in our favor, which it should. Right.

what's a little more clear on that this year. I think we haven't been in the past. Yeah. But, but the way it puts it, then with all that extra stuff that was hanging around here, that just was ridiculous.

Right. All the, the years that weren't, uh, that weren't, yeah.

Speaker 3 (22:06–22:19)

They couldn't, I think when we met with Joanna, the software had changed and they couldn't track any of that stuff back in, right. That was on the books of 2008, 2009. It was, But you know, they had no idea what it was.

Speaker 2 (22:19–23:22)

So it's like, what are we hanging on to? That's when we got rid of all that stuff. And they just upgraded software this year. And we obviously upgraded camera as well this year.

So, you know, a lot of new software. You know, I, I worked from Patriot for six years, so I was comfortable with the software. So I think we've got a better grasp on it now that we did all those conflicting numbers. Yeah.

Right. You do have this, some date, the date is November of 2026. Oh, is that the year it is? Yeah.

Yeah, it's, we're in fiscal 26. Yeah. And I've been doing that. I kind of tried to rush this since we had a meeting.

Yeah, I know. Your recommendation now is FY26, so. Okay.

Speaker 1 (23:22–23:42)

That's a little bit more. All right, so we've learned.

Speaker 2 (23:42–25:16)

Yeah, I'm good. Motion to approve the tax rate for fiscal year 26. Do we need to call that as a 1.5? I think you have to do what he's got on that.

Yeah, I think the other place. That's what we're looking for. So the board of trusts recommends the following, FY26, the title bill will adopt a minimal residential factor of 0.9771, not adopt a residential exemption and not adopt a small commercial exemption. Yeah.

I can get a second. Second. All in favor? Aye.

Aye. Did you make a motion? You can second. I did kind of put Bob up there, yeah.

Oh, yeah, he made a motion to go second. Yes, he is. And when do you want to get this back into the What I typically do is give it to Nick and then Nick gets it to them. Yeah, yeah, but when are you going to get it to Nick?

He didn't ask yet and I would think I've got at least another week or so. All right, let's sit down and go over and look at some of these. What's useful.

Speaker 3 (25:16–25:21)

I think some of the stuff is just, you know. It's like a graph.

Speaker 2 (25:22–27:42)

Yeah, I just think, I mean, we carry a lot of stuff over and sometimes Somebody else might have thought it was good to explain it, and we now look at it seven or eight years later. That might have extended. There's that page. Yeah, that page.

It probably takes a while to just look it all up because you got to go into the DLS and then you got the tables. Is this one here? Tax Limit is the budget? Yeah.

Yeah. I did make a few notes on that. Yeah. I just think, let's just, you know, just give them, you know, concise information so they can follow along.

Yeah. Yeah. you've got three new members on the board, so. Yes, right, so there's a massive city.

Yeah. So that's really all I had for you. I did just put in an item discussion on anything else you might want to talk about. Did you hear anything back concerning the So yes, I spoke to the DOR, Jim Crowley, who said the DOR doesn't want it.

So what one did not involve, they never requested it. But you said that there was a 20-year exemption on residential. But it wasn't a DOR, it was the division. MWAO is the one that sent it out.

Yeah, but at the recommendation of who? It was the division of small. It might have been division of local services. Local services, right.

That's who did it. So it wasn't a DOR. So this kind of symbolism, yeah. But I'm going to call the head of NAAO just to find out why they're even asking for it.

Yeah. Because that doesn't sound like it's anything they have to do. Yeah. Yeah.

Because what I think it does is it opens a can of worms. Again, if you don't own them. Yeah. I think KPMG filed like, you know, 351 abatement requests, but then they took them back when they realized what happened.

That's probably what they're trying to avoid. And I did ask, so after we had a meeting last time, I did ask Mr. Ben was on the board and sandwich about it.

Speaker 3 (27:43–27:56)

And he said the same thing we all said. It was the first they'd heard of it. He didn't know why they were doing it because they weren't taxed anyways. And the same, he also said that like we did, he didn't know of any municipality that taxed them, right?

Speaker 2 (27:56–28:24)

So there was none of them, but he knew on the cake that did it. So I don't quite know exactly as it seems like. Yeah, yeah. But I know the woman that's head of NAAO, so I'll just give her a call and ask why they're even doing it.

Yeah, I don't think it's any way to deal with it. Maybe they needed something to do it.

Speaker 3 (28:24–28:27)

Because again, in 20 years, they're not going to be worth it anyways.

Speaker 2 (28:27–30:39)

Yeah, they'll never make it. If you put them on five years ago, they're not worth anything now. There's a lot of new stuff out there. Exactly, right.

I mean, eventually they're going to be so small and it'll be in the shingles at some point. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Right.

It'd be in the shingles. So, okay. Any closing remarks, Sean? Outside of the fact that, you know, obviously values look like they're going to continue to increase.

We are in a, interesting spot with our tax rates because it's really the result of, um, uh, not really the revaluation, but the override. Um, otherwise we probably would have tried to get back into our old habit of going up three, 4% or something on the tax rate. Um, so we'll be dealing with that and I'm sure people will be a little more interested in their values. Yeah.

Yeah. Um, Yeah, I think I was asking Curtis how, in building permits, how they looked versus last year, the amount of building permits. Did he tell you how he felt? He felt pretty good about it.

I think this past year, though, was higher than we expected. Because I think the town probably estimated about a million dollars in their budget, and it was a good amount more. I think the ice house being finished and literally coming in right at the end of the year and putting in their condo docks, that was a pretty large influx right there. We'll have more about it.

I think if interest rates continue to go down, we've had two decreases already moving into next year, you might still do well with work. We'll probably have more people renovating, doing additions, things like that, because the average rates will be a little bit lower, and they'll be able to afford a little bit more.

Speaker 3 (30:39–31:06)

I've seen an uptick on my end, even just on the residential side. Yeah, commercial too, actually. We're pretty busy, but the residential is going up quite a bit. There's a lot of uncertainty with AI taking people's jobs.

Companies having record earnings and laying people off, so it's making its way through the general economy. But it really is, if you look at it, like I've tried it a couple of times before, because we just did it in the system.

Speaker 2 (31:07–31:20)

And it really is, unless you, it all depends on what's put into it. It's going to be like a very precise problem. It's going to be a lot of data to put into it, because if not, you don't, it just kind of spits out what you put into it.

Speaker 3 (31:20–31:32)

You know, I've tried it a couple of times with some specific stuff and it's been good, but other times I've been kind of vague and it just kind of spits out what I put in. And people will get better at it. And definitely.

Speaker 2 (31:35–31:57)

It's still does have its source. It's not thinking about these answers on its own, you know. That's it for me, though. So.

And the motion to adjourn? Motion to adjourn. All in favor, say aye.

Speaker 1 (31:58–32:06)

Unanimous. in our N640.