Board: Planning Board

Date: 2025-07-10


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:22–00:38)

Good evening, and welcome to the 51st meeting of fiscal year 2025 for the Milton Planning Board. At this time, I'd like to now call the meeting to order and begin with our administrative items. First, we have approval of minutes.

Speaker 2 (00:39–00:40)

Did you want to do the introduction?

Speaker 1 (00:40–00:45)

We should do introductions first. Yes. Yes. Cheryl, if you'd like to introduce yourself.

Speaker 2 (00:45–00:46)

Sure. Cheryl Tagayas, secretary.

Speaker 3 (00:48–00:49)

Sean Fahey, member.

Speaker 4 (00:49–00:50)

Meg Yofield, member.

Speaker 3 (00:51–00:52)

Jim Davis, member.

Speaker 4 (00:52–00:54)

and Meredith Hall serving as chair.

Speaker 1 (00:54–01:02)

And tonight with us, we have on Zoom, Cheyenne, our staff.

Speaker 5 (01:03–01:04)

You're on mute, yeah.

Speaker 6 (01:09–01:14)

There, now we can hear you.

Speaker 1 (01:15–02:16)

Great. And Julia Getman is with us. She just had to step out for a moment. So we'll welcome her back in just a moment.

And then we can now, now we can look at the approval of our minutes. And we have five sets of minutes that Cheryl has done a great job. editing and going through, they are from the dates of May 8th, May 13th, May 21st, May 22nd, and June 12th. Has everyone had a chance to review those?

I did have just two small things that I noticed on just the June 12th. Under MBTA community zoning, under Tom Doherty of 247 Adams Street, the third row, third line down, right to choose, there's an extra letter there, R adjacent.

Speaker 2 (02:17–02:20)

What page was that, Meredith? The first page. First page, okay.

Speaker 1 (02:21–02:36)

Yeah, it's the second paragraph, the third line. Choose, and there's just a letter R. We can tell Julia.

Speaker 4 (02:38–02:40)

Did you see that? No.

Speaker 2 (02:40–02:45)

So, right to choose. After choose?

Speaker 7 (02:45–02:48)

Yeah, I downloaded what Cheryl sent today. There's no R.

Speaker 1 (02:48–02:51)

Okay, you don't have it in yours. Okay, so maybe that was corrected.

Speaker 2 (02:51–02:54)

Oh, I see, yeah, I see where it is. Okay.

Speaker 1 (02:54–03:01)

And then on page two, requirement is T, there's a letter T set by the law. Do you not see that?

Speaker 2 (03:01–03:03)

Okay, I'm sorry, can you do that one again?

Speaker 1 (03:03–03:13)

Sorry, on page two of June 12th? Yes. The first line, density requirement is, I show a letter T set by the law.

Speaker 2 (03:15–03:21)

Yeah, oh, I see it, yeah, okay. I'm correcting it in the online version too.

Speaker 1 (03:22–03:34)

It's just an extra letter and then just a few lines down the fourth sentence process all zoning is amended and there's just two periods.

Speaker 4 (03:38–03:39)

Good eyes.

Speaker 8 (03:39–03:41)

Very good. Impressive.

Speaker 1 (03:42–03:53)

And yeah, but everything else I thought looked great. After amended. After amended. Yeah.

It's an extra period before Mr. Fahey.

Speaker 2 (03:54–03:59)

Oh, I see. Yeah. OK. When you do these track changes, you lose some of those.

Speaker 1 (03:59–04:07)

Right. Right. And those are just tiny little things. But OK.

So with that, and I'll give this to.

Speaker 2 (04:07–04:22)

I already corrected them in the. file that's in the folder, so she should have access to those. She'll have the correct. Perfect.

When she had them printed out, but that's it's just the 12th, right?

Speaker 1 (04:22–04:36)

And it's just the 12th that it was amended. Everything else is perfect. So I would entertain a motion to approve the minutes and with the two small amendments to June 12th.

Speaker 9 (04:37–04:46)

I'll make a motion to approve the minutes from May 8th, May 13th, May 21st, May 22nd, June 12th with the two small changes made to the June 12th minutes.

Speaker 1 (04:47–04:49)

Second. All in favor?

Speaker 9 (04:50–04:50)

Aye.

Speaker 1 (04:51–05:16)

Thank you all. And thank you Cheryl again for getting those. pulled together. So now we are moving to the next meeting dates.

We have our next schedule, regularly scheduled meeting will be on the 24th of July. Hard to believe that's going so quickly. And then we have August 14.

Speaker 10 (05:17–05:17)

So

Speaker 2 (05:18–05:22)

The warrant articles are due before the 14th, right?

Speaker 1 (05:23–06:02)

Yeah, a draft of the warrant articles, yes. So, you know, depending on how much we could get done, we could look at adding, moving our meeting that would have been on the 14th to the first week on the 7th in August. I don't know if that's possible. I think that's on the way.

Would that make sense if we need to do any cleanup again? Well, OK, and again, we'll do what we can, you know, in this. This is such a short window of time before the fall town meeting. So and we'll all talk to the board committee.

I just think we want to be mindful not to send anything over too late to them.

Speaker 2 (06:02–06:29)

I think the select board is going to be Less forgiving, if you will, and they want to hold to the time frames a bit more so to not back up the Warrant Committee. So since they have to go to the Select Board, and I think the Select Board meets They'll meet on the 5th or the… No, they'll meet on the 12th.

Speaker 1 (06:29–06:31)

On the 12th? Typically, yeah.

Speaker 2 (06:31–06:37)

But when was it that we got an email from Cheyenne, right, with the date that the warrant was going to close?

Speaker 5 (06:37–06:44)

Cheyenne, could you maybe just review those dates again when the warrant closes? Yes.

Speaker 2 (06:44–06:46)

Thank you.

Speaker 9 (06:47–06:48)

July 1st.

Speaker 2 (06:51–06:53)

That's when she sent the email, July 1st?

Speaker 9 (06:53–06:58)

Yeah, it's July 1st email. STM timeline. Of course, it's not opening. Why is it not opening?

Oh, I'm not online.

Speaker 6 (07:07–07:20)

Yeah, so what we're going to post is August 8th. But for Google articles, August 12th. And then I need to approve the warrant by the 7th of October.

Speaker 1 (07:22–08:11)

Okay. So then is that okay if we then we would have a little break in between if we move our meeting to the 7th rather than the 14th. Okay. All right.

So our next meeting. Is that good for Cheyenne? Is that good for you? Okay.

Oh, I'm sorry Cheyenne. I know we're going to be celebrating you on the 24th. So it will be the 24th and And the 7th will be the next meeting dates. All right.

Great. And so, Cheyenne, do you have any updates for us from planning staff?

Speaker 6 (08:12–08:34)

Since our last meeting, we did receive the application and narrative from the fire station building committee. They will be coming on the 24th as it's a public hearing, a joint meeting with the tree warden, as well as a resident over at 179 Highland. So both applications have been sent out for review for the next meeting.

Speaker 5 (08:34–08:36)

Okay, great.

Speaker 1 (08:36–09:06)

And then Cheyenne, the only other thing that you might want to mention is the email that Nick sent out today regarding wanting the planning board's thoughts on the mapping for the liquor license. It's not on our agenda, but I think people can give feedback to you directly if they want to take a look at that. Yeah, do you want to pull the map up?

Speaker 7 (09:13–09:26)

Just quickly, while she does that, back to the fire station. That's a public hearing. So has that neighborhood been made aware? Are they in talks with the neighbors?

I wonder.

Speaker 11 (09:26–09:31)

There is a legal ad sent out to the neighbors, like in a butters notice.

Speaker 7 (09:32–09:33)

Oh, OK.

Speaker 9 (09:33–09:34)

Yeah. This is about moving the island?

Speaker 1 (09:35–09:50)

Yeah. Yeah. Taking that down. And I know, yeah, both are going to the historic commission that Tuesday before, so they'll have their comments prepared to give to us as well.

Speaker 9 (09:50–09:53)

Isn't removing the island kind of a must-have because of safety?

Speaker 1 (09:54–10:09)

Yeah, it's a fire act. Yeah, it's going to be fine, but it's just sort of a procedure that even the town goes through if they're removing a tree, you know, on a scenic roadway. All right, so that's the map that was sent out.

Speaker 5 (10:09–10:18)

Did everybody get that? Yeah. And Cheyenne, do you want to just explain that real quickly for the public who may want to weigh in as well?

Speaker 6 (10:20–10:50)

So at our last town meeting, there was an opportunity for adding more liquor licenses. And our desire is so it could be expansive of the entire town, so zone-specific. But now we kind of have to make it a little more zone-specific. So our town administrator, Nick Milano, went through our map and kind of identified zones that he thinks would benefit from these liquor licenses.

So that's kind of where we're at in the process. We just got that email today. his proposition of zones.

Speaker 7 (10:50–10:55)

OK, great. Thank you.

Speaker 4 (10:55–11:03)

So we're not we don't want our comments right now. Well, we can if it's part of her update, we could if you want to.

Speaker 7 (11:06–12:38)

So my concern is adding. To. two locations on Route 28 in light of the horrible accident that happened last week with three fatalities. I've been sounding the alarm about how dangerous Route 28 is and adding more density to Route 28.

and it's only going to get worse in the future. And it's not just this section of Route 28, which is, it's bad. I mean, I hear sirens every day. But it's also, you have to remember, Route 28 goes all the way around to the other side of the town, which I think on Nick's map also has, you know, another potential site.

So I'm just cautious in raising concern about adding more traffic at this point in time on Route 28 until a complete study has been done on this section, on the whole section of Route 28, in fact.

Speaker 2 (12:40–14:04)

It was a devastating accident. I don't recall that, you know, the fact that this would be liquor licenses for anywhere in town, because it seems to me that they normally would want to be associated with business uses. So that's just my overall general comment. And then my second comment would be Curry College.

I don't know what the thought is there, but There are underage students, I imagine. And so historically, I think, generally, I'm not saying Curry College in particular, but alcohol in colleges and college students can be a safety concern too, to your point. So I guess I would like to understand why Curry College was selected. And it seems to me the places that we said that are in the MBTA community zoning that allow business, which may not have it now, those would be good places because there could be businesses coming in there.

So that's my general thought.

Speaker 7 (14:04–14:55)

Yeah. And the other thought I had was why are we looking at actual districts in town. Should we or could we be looking at industries and commercial uses to be able to expand offering? I don't know if it's just a liquor license isn't just a bar, it also could be a package store, a liquor store.

So would we be able, would current businesses be able to apply for a liquor license? And then that way you're allowing an existing, pre-existing, non-conforming sometimes to be able to expand their offerings.

Speaker 2 (14:57–15:51)

Well, there are businesses on Randolph Ave, right? And that's probably why it was selected. And Wollaston Golf Course has a liquor license, or Wollaston Golf Club. And you know, whether it's something like a Newcomb Farms would benefit from being able, like the plate used to have a brunch and serve mimosas or whatever.

Right. So I guess that's another factor in terms of Randolph Ave, Maggie. But I, I, I do take your point. I think the I might have a little different idea about the speed being really a safety issue.

And usually when you have more people, you're going to have, it's going to cut down the speed because you're going to have more comings and goings. But I get the overall point about safety.

Speaker 7 (15:51–16:18)

Well, I mean, there's a high traffic count on Route 28 now. I went online to look at their report. And I don't know the exact number, I've forgotten, but it's like 300,000 cars a day or something on Route 28. It's an incredible amount.

So to your point, the more traffic, the slower the speed, that doesn't seem to be a correlation currently on Route 28.

Speaker 2 (16:19–16:28)

Then maybe it can take the lane diet that MassDOT had proposed and get bike lanes and sidewalks, which would improve it that fast.

Speaker 7 (16:28–16:59)

So that's where I would support if there's an actual change in the design of Route 28. I'm putting in turning lanes, fixing the lights. The lights don't always trigger. Even when I'm coming out of Hillside Street, sometimes it wasn't reading my car, so then I would have to go through the red light at Hillside to go on to Route 28 because it was never turning green for me.

So I would think that some things would have to happen.

Speaker 2 (16:59–17:46)

It seems to me that if they took away their prioritization of getting cars through Milton, then you would have more places to cross. If you think about the neighborhood that's where Sassaman and et cetera is, they're isolated, unless they're in the car. And they're still kind of dicey coming out of there in the car, right? But you can't really do a bicycle or pedestrian-oriented kind of access there even if it's nearby because of the challenges crossing.

I mean, I think Reid still has the same kinds of issues in terms of being able to cross. So one of the things I think that was identified in that bike pedestrian master plan is just… And the kicker is at the top of Sassamato Trailheads that you could actually go and hike or bike and it's just you can't get to them.

Speaker 9 (17:47–17:52)

Yeah. I mean, it was dangerous as hell 20 years ago when I lived on Sassamato trying to turn out and now it's just got worse.

Speaker 10 (17:53–17:53)

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (17:54–18:14)

So, I mean, I would love for us, not on our agenda, but to send a, you know, a support to the select board in terms of advocating for those kinds of changes and on Randolph Ave. We should put that on the agenda.

Speaker 9 (18:16–18:33)

But I would like to see this somehow opened up to the nonconforming uses in town. I don't know how we would do that because there's so many little pockets. But I mean, not to signal you off, but if you wanted to sell gift baskets with a bottle of wine, you can't do it. And you're missing an opportunity.

So like, how would we absorb those?

Speaker 2 (18:33–18:56)

I think that's Maggie's point about the use versus the geography. But I think they have to tie, they've been told they have to tie it to the geography. And I think I'm getting a sense that what he selected was trying to give that opportunity. So maybe that question could go back is can it get tied to uses as well as maps, which I think is what you're both saying.

Speaker 12 (18:56–18:58)

Good call, I missed it.

Speaker 1 (18:59–19:24)

So Cheyenne, if you could convey that information or thoughts to Nick. I know the select board is going to be meeting on this on the 22nd before we meet. So that would be great. And anyone else who has any comments, please feel free to send it to Cheyenne and she can Send it over.

Sean, did you have anything you wanted to add to that?

Speaker 3 (19:24–19:38)

No, not really. I was, you know, I was hopeful to have more of an explanation from Nick as to why he chose what he chose, but some of it is just, some of it, I guess, is just pretty logical. But, no, I don't really have a lot of comments on it. Okay.

Speaker 1 (19:41–19:58)

Okay, great. So, Cheyenne, was there anything else, anything else that you wanted to update on for staff update? Okay, great. So at this time, we can now move to a citizen speak.

If there's anyone here in the public who would like to join us, welcome.

Speaker 10 (20:00–30:44)

Good evening. Good evening, everyone. Is this close enough? Yes.

One additional point, welcome to Cheyenne, though I can't see her, and you might want to double check. A recent review of some of the requirements is when you are having a meeting, everyone has to be seen visibly on Zoom. So double check into that, just passing that along, along with the other reason that I'm here tonight. Right, thank you so much, especially for Cheyenne.

Diane DiTullio Agostino, town meeting member since 1983 and a former Warrant Committee member for years and a former Selectman for years. Currently, or possibly, we're still waiting for reappointments, although they weren't done legally last year by the town bylaws. And that's really why I'm here at Your Citizen Speak. I have grave concerns about way too many legal, you know, technicalities being ignored.

But I'm Chair of Conservation and Commission, so Cheyenne, I look forward to meeting you in person someday. You received, each of the members, along with the select board, along with the clerk, as soon as it was brought to my attention, received copies of the concern that the Article 5 and 6 were not properly or legally disposed of at town meeting. And I'm just going to give a little bit of background as to, you know, I've never been a lawyer. However, all of these years studying the law for the town of Milton has really led me to this situation tonight.

I sat along with Maggie, who was a co-signer of a Citizen's Article. And several of you, actually, all of you is still the same elected officials on some of the very topics. that I've now pinpointed we have not abided by state and local laws. And the reason that our citizens article to finally put Pope's Pond under the care, custody and control of the Conservation Commission per the 1963, I believe, article that passed in town meeting was because as the Warrant Committee sat here, The vote was 50-50, tied vote.

Sounds kind of familiar to the land swap vote, you know, by one vote. And the chair of the Conservation Commission was here. He came to the table, informed the Warrant Committee, any day now, the land court was going to approve moving the Pope's Pond under the care, custody and control of what the land swap requested, which was to split it between the Park Department for that 5.5 acres or something and the conservation. Now you're sitting here saying, Diane, why are you explaining this to us?

Because here we are over 24 months later in the land court is not and most likely never will be able to legally do that because state lawyers informed Maggie and myself your 1963 motion article that passed. must allow it to go to the Conservation Commission for their care custody control. And then when you listen and start digging into these things, it even gets more concerning as to who is overseeing that we're following the law. Because you'll recall, I stood at town meeting and questioned adding $250,000 to go to, in the warrant it says, Peverly Park.

Well, Peverly Park, we can't just give a quarter of a million dollars to a park. I called the Department of Revenue, legal department, they confirmed to me. Well, town council would know that appropriations can only be made to the entity that has the care, custody and control of the land. And yet, we went through town meeting, I think it's over 300,000 now.

So what I'm bringing before you, the issues on article five and six, has individuals who took the oath of office to uphold federal, state and local laws, is that at town meeting, the, I'll read this too, the, town moderator and according to the bylaws, the moderator. We only have one moderator at a time in the town of Melton. Because the moderator wisely decided to recuse herself, there was the need for town meeting to have a motion made of a nomination and then for a vote to be taken. After that vote was taken is when the individual who received the most votes would be sworn into office.

to be the temporary moderator. At that point, and only at that point, would they have the authority to oversee and moderate Article 5 and 6. Those are the two articles that come under your jurisdiction and that you're responsible for. So, the moderator.

when I emailed to request when the individual was sworn in, because if you'll recall, on the second night, other people had questioned the temporary moderator, and he commented he was sworn in. Lawyers that I spoke to explained, after your vote, after time of the vote, is when you should have, you know, that's when the swearing in could have happened right on stage, as other towns might do. So it sounds like a small technicality, except there were other issues. You'll recall on article 6, and I can always, I might not have given you each of these serious concerns of legality that, so I also spoke to and provided information to the Attorney General's Municipal Law Unit.

because they did, after a review a few years ago of the electronic voting devices and the way those were put into, they agreed the town violated the law. The certification document that goes with the submission of the article does not fully explain why the town violated the law. that whether or not the law was upheld at town meeting. It's looked at by the town of Milton has what we saw this, we heard this.

That doesn't mean it was legal. And to think about where this could end up years from now. So article six, the citizens article did not have the map date on the certification form to the attorney general municipal law unit. The map dates very important to make sure At town meeting, I brought this up to the temporary moderator, and yet when he brought it up to town meeting, I do not recall, and I have to review the tape, and it's important that you do, this was a citizen's article.

Citizen's articles, you can't just say, oh, we're gonna change this. Like if you wanted article five to be amended, you would say, yes, we accept a friendly motion, and you don't have to vote. But with the citizens article, it would have had to have been, you know, there were at least 10 that are in the book, but there are many other signers on that article. So just all of a sudden inserting a map date is very questionable, as well as the fact that there was a large amendment to the what was in the warrant with the streets actually identified.

So if the map was not in the warrant, the exact date, to let the citizens who might be concerned know, and I know former Selectman Roxanne Mostow spoke to this, that people are asking her, wait a minute, my street all of a sudden is mentioned. And I really, I don't want to take too much of your time, but we could end up putting the town in such a legal bind if Article 5 and Article 6 are not properly, the word is disposed of. And thankfully, or not thankfully, the actual moderator, the moderator did go back to the podium and state, don't leave yet, I need to take control back. So town meeting was legally dissolved.

So you can't just say, oh, it wasn't legally dissolved. We have to reopen. It was not even properly adjourned. It was fully dissolved.

So the question with someone overseeing the debate, overseeing the votes, not having been sworn in after an election. It's almost like me saying I'm going to run for the planning board next year, but I'm going to go upstairs and get sworn in now. It's just not something that you can do. And there's been no response.

A lot of lawyers that I have talked to, well, what are they coming back to you with, has an answer. I don't see how they can. I also, over a month ago, asked for the moderators, not the moderators, town councils, Arizona Mission proof. When I was a seated selectman, I requested that because we had a lot of contracts, there were questions on the contracts.

I wasn't even given it as a seated selectman. So that should be a matter of public information because we've also heard about Tom Dargity. Oh, he might not have had errors in a mission, which that was all just hearsay. When I am telling you I've requested an under public records, I have not received it to even find out, okay, all these questions at town meeting, when we have town council being paid to sit there, to make sure that you all make legal choices and that we as town meeting members, passed things legally, just the same way with the Lamb Woods, or the Land Swap article, and the Pope's Pawn article, and the other big thing that I learned, and it's right in the state law.

The deed for Lamb Woods was 100% in perpetuity because it was conservation land. It says it right under Mass General Law 184, Section 31, whether or not stated in any deed. that raises serious questions as to what Town Council presented to us, and that only won by one vote. So I am really imploring you, you know, you can call and ask me any of the details.

But it's very important that your Article 5 and Article 6 every step of the way because I probably didn't mention all the questionable steps.

Speaker 1 (30:45–30:49)

All right. Thank you very much. Thank you for bringing this attention.

Speaker 10 (30:50–30:50)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (30:51–32:07)

Okay. Great. Thank you. Okay.

Um, anyone on zoom Cheyenne, are you seeing any hands up who would like to speak? Okay, great. Thank you then we can move on to our next item on the agenda and that will be to discuss the articles for fall town meeting. I know we We had organized a list of things that we were gonna think about and sort of prioritize.

I had sent out, asked Cheyenne to send out a draft of sort of a template that I thought we could work through in thinking about a signed review. I thought that would be one. I don't know if people have had a chance to look at, Cheyenne had also sent a few of the Airbnbs. I know that was a concern or anything else.

that folks want to discuss, but I thought if we could at least try to get one thing accomplished, you know, for a small town meeting, it would be nice to check off another box. So is that okay if we walk sort of through this and discuss?

Speaker 2 (32:08–33:52)

One thing that was on, it might be on the list, but From 2019, and I'm trying to think of things that are kind of low-hanging fruit. 2019, there was an… Actually, I'm not sure when it was first adopted, but the traffic impact mitigation, you know, which triggers a contribution to the fund. There was a miss in there where the business districts were left out of having to…

be subject to it. And the board at the time brought an amendment and it got sent back for further study. And it's not been studied since. But it's a missed opportunity.

I think we asked for it for maybe 440 Granite Ave when it wasn't being triggered. So I just thought that that was one. It's like, If this project is going to contribute to traffic and parking issues, then they would have to make a contribution into a fund that is for that particular neighborhood. Well, the fund is one for the town, but its distribution out would have to go towards the neighborhood impacted by the project which made the contribution.

So I can get that out, but I just want for our next meeting, but I just wanted to raise that since we didn't talk about it before. I think that would be great. And the work's been done in the past, I think. I don't recall what the concerns were at the time.

I'd have to go back and look. But if you're interested, I will do that for the next meeting. That seems like a simple.

Speaker 7 (33:53–33:58)

Yeah, especially if most of the work has been done on it, then I would think that'd be easy enough.

Speaker 2 (33:59–34:04)

It's one of those that was sent back for further study, so we just have to look at what the concerns were.

Speaker 9 (34:06–34:08)

All right. And that was an amendment to the traffic and bylaw?

Speaker 2 (34:09–34:47)

I'm sorry, parking and traffic bylaw? It was the traffic impact mitigation. I can look up which section of the code it is at some point, but it was… Article 4 in 2019 it looks like on my list, which is the list that Josh Eckertley put together.

Was that on your list too, Julia? I didn't have a printout, a print of everything that's on your list. And then as far as signage,

Speaker 1 (34:48–34:54)

Is this fine? Do you want Cheyenne to pull up the list that we talked about? Because Sean wasn't here, so that might be just helpful for Sean.

Speaker 8 (34:54–34:55)

Yeah, I wasn't either.

Speaker 1 (34:55–35:03)

Yeah. And Jim, I'm sorry. Yeah, we had a small group and we were out by 8.15, so. We missed a good meeting.

That was a good one.

Speaker 12 (35:03–35:04)

I'll try to say less, though.

Speaker 1 (35:04–35:08)

We're out by 8.10. Cheyenne, if you wouldn't mind pulling up those lists.

Speaker 12 (35:08–35:09)

Me too.

Speaker 6 (35:11–35:26)

That Julie had put up. Yeah, I mean, it's just like a general list. Yeah. or it can be Julia's, yeah, either one.

Speaker 2 (35:26–36:36)

So while she's doing that, this that Josh had put together in May of 23, identified things that had been discussed but hadn't made it to any formal language for submission. But something that I have, I dug back out from my list here and from 2018, Maggie, it's aligning nursery and farm language with state language. And Marion McKettrick had supplied some language for that. I don't, I don't know if that's something for the fall because of the limited time.

But I would like for us not just to decide about the fall now, but to decide about the spring because we'll be here before we know it. And we'll have a lot more time. And the things that might be easy to the things that might take a little more time or public input. But we want to I just think we should prioritize which things that we think we can do now and what we can do in the spring.

Can you increase the size of that?

Speaker 5 (36:38–36:50)

Yeah, that would be… Right, exactly. Yeah, just for general…

Speaker 2 (36:52–38:06)

Yeah, so what else while she's doing that? The small cell wireless I think was something that… 5G. Yeah, the 5G.

And that's something I think that is already pulled together. And the cut and fill, which we've talked about. And I had done some work with Tim and Denny Swenson on that before, and it got paired back to what that tree bylaw was, but it does… It was something that Joe Prondack was involved with and I have notes from those discussions with him.

I think it's important like we're going to lack a little bit of institutional knowledge in the building department but I think it's important to get their feedback because they're the ones who have to you know, look at applications and decide what conforms and doesn't conform, and then also the ZBA, because they're also the ones that… They get the complaints. Well, they look at the complaints, but they also have to make the variances and the special permits and so forth. So I think it'd be important to ask them if there's things that they think are low-hanging fruit that we should address.

Speaker 7 (38:07–39:56)

Well, one thing on the cut and fill, I appeared before the planning board, you know, when I believe it was Cheryl and Rich and Kathleen and Denny. And the cut and fill bylaw covers a lot of seemingly dissimilar topics. You would think that, in my mind, cut and fill was literally you're going in and cutting land away and then bringing land in for projects. But one of the last paragraphs on the cut and fill references nurseries having the ability to bring in clean earthen materials.

and for everyday use. And I requested, I think it was like back in 2020 maybe, that that really was a very, oh, I think Meredith, you were on it too at that point. I provided language, it really should be taken out of the cut and fill because it has nothing to do with cutting and filling. And so if we're looking at the cut and fill, then I think we have to look at the whole thing, and we might have to parse it out and put it under the correct heading in our zoning.

So again, our shade tree should not be in cut and fill. That should be a different article. So I think that cut and fill is just kind of very unwieldy. It needs to be addressed.

Speaker 2 (39:57–40:01)

And I don't think that's something that can be done for fall. I don't think it's something that can be done in one meeting.

Speaker 1 (40:02–40:06)

There is a new building commissioner who will be coming on board, so it would be nice to include.

Speaker 2 (40:08–42:13)

And I had done, I had taken a look at what some other communities have for this topic and There's a model land clearing, grading, and protection of specimen trees bylaw that the Cape Cod Commission has. It's a model bylaw. So Cape Towns can adopt from that model bylaw the way I understand it. That would be interesting.

Yeah. And then there are a couple other communities that had some. The trigger, one of the things that I was really surprised about was there was no permit required unless it was something like 7,500 cubic yards, which is a lot. And so like, you know the property out on the very end of Canton Avenue right before it makes that right turn to connect with Blue Hill Ave?

There's, a couple of fences and shrubs, et cetera, that's all fill. And I remember calling Joe Prondack about it and asking him for the plans, the site plans that showed all the fill. And he didn't, he only had plans for like the structure there. And I said, well, did you make a determination that this didn't require a permit for the fill?

and he had made that determination. But if the bylaw isn't that explicit, then it's an interpretation of the building commissioner. So on the scenic road, to me, you're putting in that kind of fill with fencing, you're changing the character of the scenic road, right? And So whether cut and fill addresses scenic road differently or proximity to a property line, that's kind of like a retaining wall to me when the way they did that.

And so it's the same.

Speaker 13 (42:13–42:20)

It's a retaining wall. It's multiple. It's four by two concrete blocks you'd see on the side of a highway. I can't believe they did that on a scenic road.

Speaker 2 (42:21–42:22)

And with no permit triggered.

Speaker 7 (42:23–43:58)

So I thought the cut and fill was 1,000 cubic yards, that it triggered if you were bringing in over 1,000 cubic yards, you need a special permit. And that happens a lot, especially on scenic roads and in historic neighborhoods, because we're all on septic. So it happens a lot in my neighborhood. a property sold behind the nursery.

They had to go through the ZBA to bring in over 1,000 cubic yards to do a raised septic system. It just has to get done. But my concern was at the time that this race septic system was literally feet from my property line. And we had just spent a lot of money on a new drainage system.

And my concern was if the ZBA approved this raised septic system, how would it impact any properties downstream? And that's a concern. And they granted it, and a beautiful house was built. But they have a racist system that affects abutting properties.

Speaker 2 (43:58–44:51)

I have to go back. I'm not finding it right now. But in one of my notes, I just quickly understand that you may want to move on to other things. Well, a couple of the things is that Joe Prondek had said at the time that that bylaw, our cut and fill, is rarely used once or twice a year, he had said, and it doesn't take into account the size of a lot.

So if you had a two acre, three acre, four acre versus a quarter acre, the trigger is still the cubic yards. So obviously that's a lot different for a small lot than it is for a large lot. And there was nothing that was requiring anything about a balance of cut and fill or net figures or anything. You know, I think, again, I can dig through my notes again and kind of put a summary together from where we got with it before.

Speaker 1 (44:51–45:11)

And we also talked about doing like a subcommittee on this, because I think this will take some coordination. This will be something that's super important, but something that will need input from ZBA, from what we've seen here on the planning board and what a building commissioner would have to add.

Speaker 2 (45:12–45:38)

And then probably the DPW because of stormwater regs. Right. Which brings me also to the stormwater regs because a lot of, you remember Wolcott Woods, a lot of that earth was disturbed up front in order to put in the stormwater retention structures. So you're having to do a lot of cut to put in the structures underneath, which impacts trees too, which we've seen in other projects.

Speaker 1 (45:38–45:52)

Would you and Maggie like to be a subcommittee? I know, Sean, you had said at one point, because you have expertise also from a construction standpoint, but maybe you two take the lead?

Speaker 3 (45:52–45:55)

I'd be happy to participate too.

Speaker 1 (45:55–45:59)

Or do you want to? I mean, we can only have two.

Speaker 7 (45:59–46:06)

No, my input is focused on one of the last paragraphs in it. So Sean, maybe, yeah, Cheryl.

Speaker 3 (46:07–46:09)

We're shooting for the spring for this?

Speaker 2 (46:09–46:11)

This would be for spring.

Speaker 3 (46:11–46:12)

Okay, yeah.

Speaker 2 (46:12–46:17)

And I would think that the articles will probably be due in, what, February for spring?

Speaker 3 (46:17–46:20)

Yeah. Yeah. It's time for that, yeah.

Speaker 7 (46:20–46:45)

And the other thing is it's hard to measure. I believe it's a thousand cubic yards. and it's usually 50 yards around a trailer. So it's the oversight of it that can be challenging, counting all the trailers and counting 1,000 cubic yards to ensure that it's not in excess of.

Speaker 1 (46:45–46:46)

So enforcement?

Speaker 3 (46:46–47:19)

Yeah. Yeah, that pot is a challenge because I mean, a site could be a balanced site, but that doesn't mean that you won't have an export and an import, and you will still end up with a balanced site. You may have organic material on the site that can't be utilized. It gets a bit complicated.

I don't even know how we enforce it, but for some reason I feel like it's 800 yards, not 1,000, but I can't remember. But I'd be happy to work on it with Cheryl.

Speaker 2 (47:21–48:19)

I'm thinking, you know, the whole reason to address it is because of the site planning and the projects that we review. Such as the memory care and we've got the subdivision on Pleasant. You know, I think some of the daycare facilities with the large stormwater retention necessitating site planning around these things, you know, so I do think having a. The impact on the trees as well, because, you know, people, I don't know, you probably have heard, too, but the 40B on Brush Hill Road, where they just came in and cut all the way into that hill.

And, you know, a lot of people don't like, at least so far, the way that's looking. So, yeah.

Speaker 1 (48:20–49:00)

That was, yeah, I think that's, that would be great. So that is one that we've earmarked that we definitely would like to. I know the bed, the, I'm sorry, Airbnb short term. And Cheyenne, I know you had sent out a couple of those.

But I would like to look at those a little more closely and see if there's something that we could have a template for. that we could do. I don't know if we could get it done by fall, but it's important, I think with the ADUs, that when those start to go into effect, that we have something.

Speaker 2 (49:04–49:08)

Was there something that's been worked on before? We have not.

Speaker 1 (49:08–49:19)

Okay, so with… It was from other towns, what Cheyenne sent out. I see, okay. So we might need to recirculate those.

Speaker 11 (49:20–49:26)

Didn't Brian first do an article three years ago for Airbnbs?

Speaker 2 (49:26–49:32)

That's what I was asking, but I don't recall. I'd have to go back and look through our records.

Speaker 11 (49:34–49:36)

Yeah. I didn't see.

Speaker 2 (49:36–49:38)

You saw one? OK.

Speaker 1 (49:40–49:46)

Because there is something that the building department refers to, but I didn't think it was a separate Airbnb.

Speaker 11 (49:47–49:48)

I'll have to read it, I just saw the title.

Speaker 1 (49:49–50:00)

Yeah, we can ask Walter White, maybe check out, because there was a complaint in East Milton Square that one was being used for an Airbnb.

Speaker 11 (50:00–50:06)

Well, Jay came to the office just tonight and told me that you guys were considering this and that they're absolutely not allowed.

Speaker 1 (50:07–50:25)

So maybe there is something that did go through town meeting. Okay, so we should find out about that. Good, and I'll talk to Jay. Jay would know.

Okay, and then the other things on the list.

Speaker 7 (50:26–50:31)

Those are housing production plan. How long would it take to do a housing production plan?

Speaker 2 (50:32–50:42)

I understand that the select board is taking the lead on that. Because I think I watched a part of a meeting where they were discussing it.

Speaker 6 (50:42–50:54)

Is that right, Cheyenne? I did not hear us when they were saying these last time I left off, we were still getting our consulting quotes.

Speaker 4 (50:54–51:00)

Okay, maybe I misunderstood them. Were you able to reach out to the person who did ours the last time?

Speaker 6 (51:02–51:11)

Yes, we did. Last time, the last update was from our last meeting, and she said that she was interested, so it was fine.

Speaker 1 (51:11–51:14)

Okay, so that is in the work, that's moving along.

Speaker 2 (51:14–51:19)

So these were where we were talking about use of funds. Yeah, this was a funds use.

Speaker 1 (51:19–51:33)

Yeah, this was a little different, but yeah, these aren't the zoning articles that we, oh, we signed review bylaw, we did have that. I think these were general things that we were talking about.

Speaker 2 (51:33–51:47)

The recodification would be a zoning change, but again, that's not something I think that could get done for September. I would love to see that get done for the spring. Yeah.

Speaker 1 (51:49–51:57)

What's number seven? Rules and regs. We were talking about reviewing those.

Speaker 3 (51:57–51:58)

Okay.

Speaker 2 (51:58–53:11)

I think that's a spring. Well, that doesn't have to go to town meeting so that's just our own work. Some of that though is I think with coordination with DPW because we have this in the rules and regs we have this road section. And we've granted waivers for this many times because this is a 50-foot right-of-way and requires sidewalks on both sides.

It hasn't been really updated or looked at in a long time and it requires granite curb and we've often done Cape Cod berm and other wavers. And so this is a marked up from August of 2019. It has long been on people's radar. But this is not just a planning board thing.

I mean, this is a DPW engineering item. And just like the stormwater regs,

Speaker 7 (53:12–53:23)

So should we prioritize what we think we can get done for fall? That's what I'm trying to do. So I think Airbnb is huge.

Speaker 1 (53:24–53:26)

And if we have something, we may already have something.

Speaker 7 (53:26–53:28)

And Sign Review is the sign by law.

Speaker 9 (53:28–53:29)

Those two are the biggest.

Speaker 7 (53:29–53:40)

They're big. The 5G thing, which as I said before, I didn't really know what that was, but you say that's practically done anyway.

Speaker 1 (53:40–54:08)

Cheryl, do you want to mention what you drew to my attention, that there's a public hearing on July 30th? you yeah it's on the this is this is why I'm worried about signage it's like and this would be a special permit it's going to the ZBA on this but I think residents need to know because all of a sudden they say how did this something get approved and this is this is something that's being proposed and part of

Speaker 2 (54:10–54:34)

Yeah, I don't know what we can do about things like this where it's operating under a variant that was granted in 1962. But 480 Adams Street, which is where in that mess, I don't call it a mess, but between the roadways and the highway, that commercial building that's actually in the residential district, we talked about that with the Milton overlay.

Speaker 12 (54:34–54:35)

Where Squanton hits Adams?

Speaker 2 (54:36–55:17)

Yeah. That building. The U.S. Trust.

I mean, Rockland Trust. Yes. So there's a proposal for 16 feet by 16 and a half feet illuminated channel letter sign to be installed facing the highway for the applicant is the Russian School of Mathematics. And I called Kathleen to ask if she was aware of this.

She's not on the panel, but she did look it up. And so there is a filing that if we wanted to look up and look at it. But there's no mock-up.

Speaker 6 (55:17–55:18)

I do remember them.

Speaker 2 (55:19–55:19)

Sorry?

Speaker 6 (55:21–55:26)

It came before this interview today, like a month ago.

Speaker 10 (55:26–55:26)

OK.

Speaker 6 (55:27–55:31)

saying to get them where they are now.

Speaker 7 (55:31–55:53)

Okay. So we have a meeting on July 24th. Could we put on our agenda a discussion about that? And then we could send the ZBA our thoughts and let them know that we are in the process of reviewing our sign and it might be too premature for them to be granting anything at this point in time.

Speaker 1 (55:53–56:05)

Well, certainly we're illuminated signs are are becoming an issue, so externally illuminated, I should say, not externally.

Speaker 2 (56:06–58:00)

And so one of the things about the signs, I agree with you, but I do think we still can do a traffic impact mitigation for the fall. Yeah, I do too. But the signs, when I called Tim today, I wanted to ask him what he recalled about what he had put together 10 years ago. And he said that the, The business district signage was updated, or amended rather, in 2017, but it didn't fully encompass some things.

Like it did not ban billboards in neon, and it did not address signs in the residential districts, which this one that we just spoke about is one of those. But you can think about their nursery or, Eagle Farm or Thomas or Newcomb. I mean, a lot of businesses actually on Randolph-Ave. But in other places, too, the 7-Elevens, they were all…

Residential. There's no… They end up having to go with… There's no zoning that addresses them.

So I think that we would want to tie, at a minimum, tie it to the same thing that the businesses are… Right, and it does break that down. And then the other thing Tim said is that the handbook needs to have a better connection to the zoning because when someone's making a decision about approving these signs, you have to have something that's defendable, according, Tim said, like town councils that can't defend, you know, there's not enough here to defend. So that's another factor to think about, like.

can't deny a sign based on what's in the current kind of.

Speaker 1 (58:00–58:04)

And you can't and that's what that's that's the problem is it has to be.

Speaker 2 (58:04–58:17)

And then this is what someone Julia called me when she couldn't reach you. I said this would be a good thing for everyone to have because this is what's in the zoning the handbook and then Tim's. Yeah. So I know you would ask her for this.

Speaker 7 (58:17–58:18)

Yeah. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (58:18–58:19)

Yeah.

Speaker 7 (58:20–58:28)

So from a process it's We've identified how many, five or six that we want by fall?

Speaker 2 (58:28–58:30)

No, I think two by fall.

Speaker 7 (58:30–58:42)

Two by fall. And then, so should we assign it to, that's what I was trying to think, should we assign to your point of subcommittees? Subcommittees on these.

Speaker 10 (58:43–58:43)

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (58:44–59:09)

So that's my point, too, about thinking about spring is it's going to take a lot longer. So we shouldn't wait two months to decide who's going to work on them because it'll creep up fast. And if it takes coordination with other boards and committees and staff, it takes time to get those meetings scheduled. I think we should try and say these are our goals for the spring, too, and who's going to work on them.

Right. Because otherwise, I think it'll be hard to meet our deadline.

Speaker 3 (59:09–59:13)

So what are we saying for the fall? What to sign by law?

Speaker 2 (59:14–59:30)

I think if the sign can address both business and residential or if it needs to be two separate, I think traffic impact mitigation. This does expanding it to make sure it covers. But just all the districts, I think it was an oversight in terms of the language before.

Speaker 1 (59:33–59:52)

So I think this what Tim drafted does address both residential and business. So when we go when we get to that, but but I think those two would be good. And then the cut and fill for spring. The recodification, if we can do that for spring.

Speaker 2 (59:53–01:00:01)

I think the nursery farm. Nursery Farm for spring? Since it's been on the list since 2018.

Speaker 7 (01:00:01–01:00:15)

And that's mostly, I mean, that's fairly easy than Nursery Farm because it's just getting State law. State law. It's not necessarily changing anything. It's just becoming current.

Yeah.

Speaker 3 (01:00:24–01:00:26)

Where's Airbnb?

Speaker 1 (01:00:26–01:00:35)

I think that's… And we'll double check to see what we already have. I'll talk to Jay and find out what he's referring to as saying you can't do an Airbnb.

Speaker 7 (01:00:35–01:00:39)

Because if he's saying it's not allowed, that's the official stance.

Speaker 1 (01:00:40–01:00:42)

Then maybe we don't need to create it.

Speaker 7 (01:00:42–01:00:43)

Then it's not a priority.

Speaker 10 (01:00:49–01:00:49)

Yeah.

Speaker 8 (01:00:49–01:00:54)

Okay. So fall is sign review and cut and fill and recodification.

Speaker 7 (01:00:55–01:00:58)

The spring is cut and fill and reconification.

Speaker 2 (01:00:59–01:01:31)

I had in my notes that we talked about scenic road updates. I don't remember exactly what we were thinking though. I think if you had we had a situation or two where applicants didn't know that they had to file for approvals and they removed. trees and stonewall sections in the public way, on public right of way, right?

Speaker 14 (01:01:34–01:01:34)

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (01:01:34–01:01:41)

So I know folks want to try and remember what the other thoughts about that were. Yeah. Do outreach on that.

Speaker 7 (01:01:45–01:01:53)

And is the shade tree advisory committee, are they working on a tree bylaw? I feel like they've been working on one.

Speaker 1 (01:01:53–01:02:20)

I think they may have. Would you follow up with them on that? That would be great. And we can find out from the tree warden when he's here on the 24th.

I think that's a good

Speaker 2 (01:02:21–01:02:44)

We talked about nonconforming businesses. I don't know if that's something we can tackle before the spring or not, but. Yeah, that was mentioned. I think there's some interest in business tax revenue, so that could be tied together.

Speaker 1 (01:02:49–01:02:51)

I think we should certainly keep it on.

Speaker 2 (01:03:08–01:03:13)

So for signs, Meredith, you're interested in signs, right?

Speaker 1 (01:03:13–01:03:38)

Yes. And I'd love to go through this tonight to just if we could just quickly, because we only have this meeting in the 24th, really, and then if we're going to do it. And again, I don't want to feel rushed for people, but I think what was put together is just some little things we could change.

Speaker 2 (01:03:40–01:03:48)

Do we know that some of the parts of this may have already been incorporated in 2017?

Speaker 1 (01:03:48–01:04:06)

This would be just replacing it all, so it would be inclusive of, and I'll cross-reference, I'll take that on to look at that to see what was included in this so I can mark it as what was updated.

Speaker 7 (01:04:07–01:04:19)

So when a business goes to apply for a sign, this is the packet they get. Is this correct? This is what they get in the checklist that they follow.

Speaker 1 (01:04:21–01:04:35)

Yeah. So this breaks out also, it's almost like our site plan review, but for signs, it gives a more complete, this is what you need to bring, these are all the tools. So Cheyenne, if you wanna pull up on the screen,

Speaker 2 (01:04:36–01:04:56)

So, Meredith, just quickly, if you look at page 5, the bottom, it says that this is replacing basically the business. It doesn't, this doesn't mention, it's mentioning only business district, right?

Speaker 1 (01:04:57–01:04:58)

It does reference.

Speaker 2 (01:05:00–01:05:02)

Signs and.

Speaker 1 (01:05:07–01:05:25)

Yeah, the following addition, with the following addition, because it does reference presidential. We want to make sure that when we go through it,

Speaker 2 (01:05:26–01:06:36)

So I was looking at this one. This is the front. Which is the one that August 3rd, 2015. It addresses.

And one of the things Tim said when he did this was he had looked at signed bylaws in Lexington and Wellesley and other communities. So I guess what we would need to do, Meredith, is to find all of the references to signage, I guess. Yeah. Because it's in the, like definitions would be a different part where you're, it says, so here he's saying you're amending the definition section, which is part of the overall bylaw in the front.

And then this goes down further into signs and billboards and business district, right? Right. Where's signs and billboards now? You found that.

Speaker 1 (01:06:37–01:06:40)

Julia here this one this chapter 113.

Speaker 2 (01:06:40–01:06:44)

Okay, one. Yeah. Yeah, that's do you have an extra one of these?

Speaker 1 (01:06:45–01:06:52)

Yes, we want it. We would want to make sure it's all included. I'll take it. I'll give it back to you.

One sec.

Speaker 2 (01:06:52–01:07:01)

Yeah, no problem.

Speaker 15 (01:07:01–01:07:05)

And then accessory residence. Yep. Okay.

Speaker 1 (01:07:08–01:11:37)

So yes, so I thought just for tonight that we wouldn't spend time on the definitions, because we can read those on our own. But they're very specific. I think they're good as they relate to the changes that would be, or updates that would be made. So starting with like the five, intent and purpose, I thought that intent and purpose looked good, pertinent to other laws, the purpose, interpretation and conflict clause, severability clause.

We can go through that on our own and maybe have comments on that. getting into the applicability, and then the existing signs. So really, starting on page 7, I thought we could cruise through this, try to cruise through this quickly. And the way Tim had written this to break down, there's three types of existing signs.

Existing signs are those defined as erected before, be our fall town meeting, and are classified into four separate categories. These are conforming signs which comply with all provisions of this bylaw in its most recent amendment form to prohibited signs as specified in section that needs to be filled in. non-conforming signs which do not comply with one or more provisions of the SPY Law in its form prior to the October and for us 2025 town meeting, but which are not described as prohibited signs in subsection 8. And then non-conforming protected signs, which fully complied with this bylaw prior to the amendments approved by the October 2015 meeting.

Removal of existing signs. So I was mistaken when I said this is not retroactive, because I wanted to make sure that any sign that currently exists is grandfathered and does not need to be… We wouldn't be asking anybody to take any signs down. But these are when the removal of existing signs.

When nonconforming signs which are enlarged, reworded, redesigned, replaced, or altered in any way, including repainting in a different color or re-lettering, shall comply immediately with all provisions of this bylaw and provided further that any such sign has deteriorated to such an extent that the cost of restoration would exceed 35% of the replacement value in time. So that seemed all fine. The building commissioner, this talks about the building commissioner as the authority. shall order the removal of any signs erected or maintained in violation of this bylaw.

Fourteen days' notice in writing shall be given to the owner of such sign or the building structure or premises on which the sign is located to remove the sign or to bring it in compliance with the bylaw. Abandonment or failure to maintain a sign, that seems pretty straightforward. Then sign permits, the sign permit required. All persons desiring to erect, install, place, construct, alter, move, or maintain a sign shall apply to the building commissioner for a permit.

Exempt signs are excluded from this requirement. So this is what I thought was really good, is the application submittal and content. So it makes it really clear if somebody is wanting to put up a sign, what types, what you need. And if you listen to the sign review committee, John Zagwitz does a a wonderful job of just walking through everything that's needed when it's applied.

If there's things that are missing, like such as the material or the color of the signs, the type of illumination is required to be noted, number type, size, height of sign, size of lettering. That's all things that are asked for. And those seem very straightforward and pretty much what we do right now. for all signs, a copy of a letter from the chairman of the Sign Review Committee indicating the recommendation of the Sign Review Committee.

Speaker 2 (01:11:37–01:12:18)

Can we back up? Yes, absolutely. Non-conforming signs and non-conforming protected signs on page seven. And going back to the definitions, I don't see those being, I suppose, non-conforming straightforward enough, but protected, like, is not defined.

So, like, what's… Yeah, that they would be protected. Like, is it free speech protection type signs? Like, but it's not…

Define. Protect, yes. So I think we would need to know what that is.

Speaker 15 (01:12:20–01:12:26)

Okay, good. All right.

Speaker 2 (01:12:28–01:12:36)

And all these dates would just need to be the new date. Right. And then I guess

Speaker 9 (01:12:36–01:12:51)

Isn't that the definition right there, non-conforming protected signs, like number four? I take that as signs which fully comply with the bylaws prior to the amendments approved by October 15, right? So there's no need to change those signs, we're just sort of adopting them?

Speaker 14 (01:12:51–01:12:52)

Yeah.

Speaker 9 (01:12:52–01:12:57)

So wouldn't that be the definition? I mean, I don't look for more clarity than that.

Speaker 1 (01:12:57–01:12:58)

What page are you looking on, sorry?

Speaker 9 (01:12:58–01:13:16)

Page seven, existing signs, number four. I mean, it seems like one through four are all- Fully complied with this bylaw. Definitions, right? Like a conforming sign is, it doesn't say a sign which, but it should say conforming signs are signs which comply with all provisions of this bylaw in its most recently amended form.

I guess to me that makes sense.

Speaker 11 (01:13:17–01:13:17)

Okay.

Speaker 9 (01:13:17–01:13:36)

All four of those kind of make sense if you just put the word, after number two, prohibited signs. are signs as specified in section, it just seems like it's missing one little phrase. Mike? Right in the number three.

Speaker 2 (01:13:37–01:14:04)

You're thinking more. Well, I'm looking at conforming sign, and it says it complies with all the provisions of the bylaw. And then I look at non-conforming, and it says it fully complies with the bylaw. But there's no amendments that have been I guess I'm not quite understanding.

I think that's the idea.

Speaker 9 (01:14:04–01:14:13)

If there's a sign that kind of meets the criteria. before October 15th, it's non-conforming protected. So there's no need to change it. That's the way I take that.

Speaker 2 (01:14:13–01:14:35)

But is it protected to, is protected mean that if they want to change it in the future, they get to keep it what they had before? Like if I look down to the existing sign, it says removal of existing signs, but it also says enlarged, reworded, redesigned, or altered. So that's not really replacing. So when they, like if you,

Speaker 9 (01:14:36–01:14:42)

non-conforming signs which are enlarged, rewarded, or altered.

Speaker 2 (01:14:42–01:14:53)

So is it protected? If it's before. If you're replacing, if you're re-awarding it, or if you're going to redesign it. No, that's more than 35%.

Speaker 3 (01:14:53–01:15:10)

Isn't that the reference to that Section 8, you know, when you turn to it, there's a category of signs that are called exempt signs. Are exempt signs and protected signs referring to the same type of sign?

Speaker 2 (01:15:11–01:15:12)

Which page are you looking at, Sean?

Speaker 1 (01:15:12–01:15:23)

Exempt signs are a type of sign? And prohibitive.

Speaker 3 (01:15:23–01:15:32)

The following signs shall be allowed by right without the necessity of a sign permit. Is that a non-conforming protected sign?

Speaker 7 (01:15:37–01:15:43)

Exempted signs are different than prohibited signs. If you turn the page.

Speaker 1 (01:15:46–01:15:48)

Yeah, you could.

Speaker 3 (01:15:48–01:15:52)

Right. So there's a category that defines prohibited signs.

Speaker 9 (01:15:55–01:16:00)

I take the exempted signs to be like a handicapped bathroom sign or exit sign.

Speaker 1 (01:16:00–01:16:02)

Or street, it gets into the detail.

Speaker 3 (01:16:02–01:16:05)

Yeah. Description of what an exempt sign is.

Speaker 16 (01:16:05–01:16:06)

Oh, you're right.

Speaker 3 (01:16:06–01:16:08)

It goes all the way to page 15. Wow.

Speaker 2 (01:16:09–01:16:30)

holiday decorations. And some of this came about due to, there was, the reason some of this didn't get changed back then is there was a case before the Supreme Court about what's protected under free speech. That's kind of what I was thinking when I said what does protected mean, and maybe this is where it defines it.

Speaker 3 (01:16:30–01:16:38)

So what is the history of this? This is noted as proposed zoning back in October 2015, 10 years ago.

Speaker 1 (01:16:38–01:16:44)

Did it not get… It never… Tim left. That's when he left.

Speaker 3 (01:16:44–01:16:48)

But there was a 20… 2015, that's 10 years ago. Tim wasn't…

Speaker 7 (01:16:48–01:16:49)

No, he was assistant planner.

Speaker 2 (01:16:49–01:17:54)

He was assistant town planner. But what happened was this case. And so there was, when Alex White said he was still on the board, that there was this sense that there was only so much you could do with changing the signage requirements until that case was decided. And that's why there was a limited amendment that went forward in 2017.

And then I think there was, it never, once that case was decided, it never got revisited and never got moved forward with the change in personnel. But that's why it didn't happen at this 2015. Oh, that makes, yeah. But, I think that there is a certain class of signs that are considered protected, but not this type that we're trying to regulate here.

And I think that's where a town council or someone should take a look at this and make sure that it's consistent with that law.

Speaker 7 (01:17:55–01:18:13)

And can the, so protected, the way that I look at it as a protected sign is the free speech sign. And can those protected signs be limited in size? Do we have the ability to do that?

Speaker 2 (01:18:14–01:18:44)

I know that businesses aren't, business signs advertising a commercial use are not considered protected, right? But as far as the size, there was like this, I don't remember now, Maggie, but there was, it was surprising that really there was, you could put something up like in your yard that was, you know, pretty visible and, you know, like decrying some whatever issue that the person was concerned about and that's considered protected. but it's not advertising business.

Speaker 7 (01:18:44–01:19:03)

Yeah. Right. So, you know, I'm not saying we, I think I believe in free speech. And so, um, my questions are just, is it the size of the sign related to like the size of the building or the size of the lot?

Speaker 1 (01:19:04–01:19:04)

So it describes it.

Speaker 7 (01:19:04–01:19:12)

So I think it's a protected use. A protected sign. There's a limit to the size. There's a limit to the size.

Speaker 1 (01:19:12–01:19:54)

Yeah. And I had interpreted protected as to be, it's protected, meaning that you can maintain that sign. because it was approved. It's protected if it was before October, 2025, we'll say.

But if you go and change it, that nonconforming, it's sort of like if you take a house that is a nonconforming resident, single family home, and you tear that down, or a garage, now you have to follow the current zoning that may not have been in place when that house was built.

Speaker 7 (01:19:55–01:20:12)

So I always go back to mine. I've taken down a sign because it was in disrepair. I've also had a sign hit on Route 28, and I haven't replaced that yet. So now Emma and those were grandfathered in.

Speaker 15 (01:20:13–01:20:16)

Were those special permit, were those special permit those signs?

Speaker 7 (01:20:17–01:20:35)

No, no, because the selectmen at the time could give, they do the, well, they sign permits. And so we got to sign out on Route 28 through that simple process, you know, forever ago.

Speaker 14 (01:20:35–01:20:36)

Right.

Speaker 7 (01:20:36–01:20:36)

50 years ago.

Speaker 1 (01:20:37–01:20:37)

Right.

Speaker 7 (01:20:38–01:20:41)

And it gets hit by the plow, so it's just replacing.

Speaker 1 (01:20:41–01:20:52)

Yeah, exactly. So that would, you would probably, you know, go before the Sign Review Committee, who would… I don't know if I… I think you would if it's…

Or maybe you wouldn't have to.

Speaker 9 (01:20:52–01:21:00)

If you voluntarily take it down and don't put it back up, and then you want to put it back up in a certain amount of time, I think you'd have to go before the Sign Review Committee.

Speaker 1 (01:21:00–01:21:01)

And that seems like that would be protected.

Speaker 9 (01:21:02–01:21:06)

But I'm… I don't know.

Speaker 1 (01:21:08–01:21:21)

If you take it down and put it back up, it might. I know, like St. Michael's Church just went, they're gonna put up a new sign and change the color, and they just went through the sign review committee, everything, you know.

Speaker 7 (01:21:22–01:21:28)

That's surprising, really, because I would think that they're a Dover, they're protecting the Dover.

Speaker 5 (01:21:28–01:21:33)

I know, I was, but they did go before the sign review committee.

Speaker 1 (01:21:33–01:21:36)

So those are all, yeah, we'll have to define, I guess, what protected is.

Speaker 7 (01:21:36–01:21:38)

What protected is and what exempt is.

Speaker 2 (01:21:40–01:21:45)

Yeah. It's not clear to me yet, but I need to continue looking at it.

Speaker 1 (01:21:45–01:22:14)

Yeah. And that's why this is to sort of filter out some of those things that we want to identify. With removing of his existing signs. And then, OK.

So the application and submittal and content, I think that's really helpful to applicants. Again, like our site plan approval, the following attachments, necessary copies should be… So one of the things… Yeah.

Speaker 2 (01:22:17–01:22:52)

Sorry, I just wanted to… Is this bringing back memories of looking at this years ago? This is… I don't know if my brain works that well anymore for 10 years, but yes.

Does this, did this require some kind of visualization on the building and put the sign on the building? It says color photographs of the property, but now it's pretty common with technology that's available to do a simulation of the signage on the building. And they've been doing, I've noticed that. I think that should be a requirement if it's not.

That's good, because I,

Speaker 1 (01:22:55–01:23:11)

I've been noticing the applicants are doing that, so it might be… Apparently they haven't for that big one on… Yeah, that is, yeah. Size, dimensional, drawing, lettering, words.

So how would you word that?

Speaker 2 (01:23:12–01:23:59)

I'll come up with something. Color photographs of the property under… Yeah, somewhere under there I would say some kind of a visualization or mock-up. That would be under four, maybe, added to that.

Yeah, I would add a separate line there. Visualization. Which would show the sign in three dimensionally on a photograph or a rendering. to scale or something like that, so it's not just a hand scribble.

Speaker 14 (01:24:05–01:24:13)

Okay, we'll work on that.

Speaker 1 (01:24:14–01:24:21)

Okay. Let's see.

Speaker 2 (01:24:22–01:24:35)

So, can we just go through that list again? So, the purpose, the dimensions. Did they give, there was not a, we haven't gotten to a size limit yet, right? That's coming?

Yeah, that's coming. Okay.

Speaker 1 (01:24:35–01:25:02)

But the, I did think as under sex appropriate fees as set from time to time by the Board of Selectmen, I feel like that should be the building commissioner because they typically set, The fees, because they're applying, the following attachments and necessary copies, as required by the building commissioner, shall be submitted. That's a question for the select board.

Speaker 2 (01:25:02–01:25:04)

Maybe Nick. I don't know.

Speaker 1 (01:25:04–01:25:12)

Because I don't think they, when they apply, I don't know who gets those fees currently. So I can ask John, too.

Speaker 14 (01:25:13–01:25:18)

The building department.

Speaker 1 (01:25:26–01:25:38)

And then the town shall process sign permit applications within 30 days. A receipt of complete and accurate application by the building commissioner.

Speaker 2 (01:25:38–01:25:49)

I'll color photographs. That should be and there should be renderings for new construction because this is assuming the signs are all on existing buildings.

Speaker 1 (01:25:54–01:25:59)

Isn't that in three such drawings shall be to a legible architect scale?

Speaker 2 (01:25:59–01:26:17)

I'm thinking that that's like elevations. OK. So. Photograph of the facade.

I'm thinking three-dimensional, not two-dimensional.

Speaker 1 (01:26:18–01:26:21)

Right, three-dimensional rendering on the building, visualized on the building?

Speaker 2 (01:26:21–01:26:32)

Yeah, because I'm kind of thinking the way I read those above, I read those as two-dimensional, because when you say to an architect's scale, normally you're talking about a two-dimensional drawing.

Speaker 14 (01:26:35–01:26:35)

Right.

Speaker 2 (01:26:37–01:26:40)

So I just think it's good to be explicit that we also require three-dimensional.

Speaker 15 (01:26:40–01:26:44)

That's a good point, because the depth and width

Speaker 1 (01:26:51–01:26:53)

Anything else from that?

Speaker 2 (01:26:54–01:27:07)

And again, this is… So now the way it works is if the building commissioner rejects a signed application, it goes to either the Board of Appeal or Select Board? Do we know?

Speaker 1 (01:27:13–01:27:20)

I think the building commissioner refers it to the signed review committee. Okay.

Speaker 7 (01:27:21–01:27:27)

So the selectmen only have review over list signs? Is that their purview? An appeal.

Speaker 1 (01:27:27–01:28:09)

Actually, so if they get denied at the sign review committee, which for example, the digital billboard for the fitness center, which started off as the sleepies mattress sign on the expressway, that was granted by the select board. They went and appealed it. They were denied. And now that applicant comes back every year and the sign review committee denies them every year.

So they just haven't changed it. It's like caught in this cycle, but they're grandfathered in. They would be able to keep that sign.

Speaker 7 (01:28:09–01:28:18)

Not that I want to take on more work, but do you think the select board's the appropriate board to hear these?

Speaker 1 (01:28:18–01:28:31)

Well, that's what I'm going to get to. I was thinking the ZBA might be the better path forward for appeal. You'd have to have a public hearing.

Speaker 7 (01:28:32–01:28:46)

I mean, it could come back to us, but… The selectmen normally don't have public hearings. So I would think that the neighbors would want to say… Usually the appeal would go to the Board of Appeals.

Speaker 1 (01:28:46–01:28:55)

That's what I was thinking. So I would think that's where it would go. That's what I was going to recommend when we get to that point on the authority.

Speaker 2 (01:28:55–01:30:16)

As far as the design, if there's a project that's subject to our review, like commercial buildings over 600 square feet or these others, we do provide some feedback on signage, but they still have to go through their signage review package. Do we, when those come in, though, like, is there anything about those kind of signs like for the memory care facility contemplated in here? Do we know? Meredith?

It talks about types of signs. If we go back for a moment to, well, maybe it's going to go, going forward, there'll be types of signs, but there was for types of signs, submission requirements are different for standing signs versus… you know, an awning or a wall mount sign. I think it does get into that a little bit.

It talks about protruding signs or different… But I'm thinking those, I forget what they're called now, but the kind like at the memory care facility where it's out in the landscape. Right. There's a term for that kind of sign that I'm just not remembering.

But does that, do you remember if that's in here? Because… It talks about setback.

Speaker 1 (01:30:17–01:30:21)

It talks about size. I think when we get, yeah.

Speaker 10 (01:30:22–01:30:22)

Okay.

Speaker 1 (01:30:23–01:30:26)

So, time limit. Yes.

Speaker 6 (01:30:28–01:30:28)

Oh.

Speaker 4 (01:30:33–01:30:36)

Yes, Kathleen. Yeah. Welcome, Kathleen. Yes.

Speaker 17 (01:30:40–01:30:40)

Hi.

Speaker 18 (01:30:40–01:31:14)

I just jumped on the same thing. I just wanted to say that the current process is that if you get denied by the building commissioner, it goes to the Board of Appeals, not to the select board. not to the assigned committee. As I said, it's an appeal of a denial of a building permit.

So that's the process for it. There's no jurisdiction of the planning board for the denial. I mean, any denial of a building permit for anything goes to the board of appeals, not the planning board.

Speaker 1 (01:31:15–01:31:44)

Right, no, I think what's happened, it goes to the sign review committee, and then if they deny a sign, that has been going to the select board, but if it's a special permit, such as the one that's being proposed on the 30th, it's under a special permit because it's a business in a residential district, so the business itself is under a special permit.

Speaker 18 (01:31:45–01:32:27)

I don't think that's how it's coming to us, but. You know, I said, because there's already there's already signs on that building. Yeah, we did we did hear the 1 for the heart dental. That was 1 that that I was that I sat on.

Rockland Trust, I think they just switched out the writing from Blue Hill Bank or whatever that was before. So I don't think that went anywhere. But this is a new sign on the north side of the building. So they applied for a building permit.

They applied to install it. And that was denied. And they were told they had to come to us. So that's how that process happened.

Speaker 6 (01:32:28–01:32:29)

Yeah.

Speaker 18 (01:32:29–01:32:33)

I don't know if it's under the signs at all or the select board.

Speaker 6 (01:32:35–01:33:28)

Yeah, there have been- So it came before the sign review committee. Okay. And originally, the whole thing had started a couple years back with the Heart Dental, and I guess they had got rejected, had to go to the select board, got it appealed, and then accepted. And so we had actually been working with the building owners because they're now letting other residents put up signs.

But because there was this initial agreement where there can only be one sign, we had them actually come to a sign review meeting with the Russian School of Mathematics applicants to kind of appeal their sign review decision. So where we had left it was that the entire building owner was supposed to get that denial before CBA and kind of open it up so that we could get the Russian School to get their sign up there. So the Russian School itself was approved, but we need to deny it to open it up to get them on there.

Speaker 18 (01:33:30–01:33:57)

But I just wanted to sort of go to Maggie's comment about the fact that, you know, we have a process and you can't, we can't delay things because the planning board might want to reduce, might want to revise the sign committee. When we have boards of appeals have specific timeframes by which they have to make their decisions, hold their hearings, make decisions. And so we can't, you know, postpone that while you folks work on a, on a new sign bylaw.

Speaker 1 (01:33:58–01:34:17)

No, that's wouldn't be the case that, you know, we're that that all is going forward and the and the signed review committee is not being changed at all. Although in this, I think it says there's four members and I believe there's five, which Tim or planning staff sits in on so that it doesn't affect wouldn't change that at all.

Speaker 2 (01:34:18–01:35:14)

Yeah. According to section 275-3.33. Business district uses. actually four, it says appeal to select board, an applicant, planning board, sign review committee, or person aggrieved by a permit issued by the building commissioner or denial of a permit may appeal to the select board in the same manner as an appeal from an enforcement order of the building commissioner may be taken to the board of appeals.

The select board shall establish specific procedures for such appeals. In the event of an appeal, the building commissioner, after consultation with the signed review committee, may authorize temporary advertising signs during continuance of an appeal. So that's in the existing zoning.

Speaker 1 (01:35:17–01:35:22)

And I think it should go to the ZBA. I don't necessarily feel like the planning board needs to hear that.

Speaker 2 (01:35:23–01:35:28)

But this language will be replaced by what we're reviewing right now tonight, right? So.

Speaker 18 (01:35:31–01:35:54)

Yeah, I don't see how you folks have jurisdictions over time. That's all I'm trying to say. So, I mean, a project that you've already got before you for building and that sort of thing, you know, yes, you're sort of doing a brand new building. You would be controlling the some part of the signs, but I don't think that you've got jurisdiction over.

you know, this type of situation.

Speaker 7 (01:35:55–01:35:57)

I don't think we have it over in appeal.

Speaker 2 (01:35:57–01:36:11)

No, that's not what my point was. So we were just actually, I think, Kathleen, thinking about whether this makes sense for it to be appealed to the Select Board rather than the Board of Appeal on a sign.

Speaker 18 (01:36:13–01:36:23)

I don't know how the select board has the ability to seek relief from a zoning bylaw. I mean, I don't know how the select board can do that.

Speaker 2 (01:36:23–01:36:26)

All right, so you agree that it should go to the Board of Appeal.

Speaker 18 (01:36:27–01:36:31)

Yeah, because in the bylaw right now, it's an accessory use. Right, okay.

Speaker 1 (01:36:32–01:36:38)

So we do agree on that. With you on that, okay. Thank you, Kathleen.

Speaker 5 (01:36:38–01:36:42)

That's all right. Thank you very much because that's helpful.

Speaker 1 (01:36:42–01:36:47)

It is helpful. OK. All right.

Speaker 2 (01:36:49–01:37:06)

So we were application. So I was looking at design review and it says all signs requiring a signed permit or a special permit under the provisions of the section shall require the review of the sign review committee. So do you recall seeing where it says the sign permits required?

Speaker 1 (01:37:08–01:37:18)

There is language, yes. And there's authority for the permit. Yeah. So that's so application rejection.

Speaker 7 (01:37:19–01:37:19)

What page do you want now?

Speaker 1 (01:37:20–01:37:54)

10. So F permit revocation. So that's the building commissioner there. Expiration date.

Penalties, this is where I also thought this should be the building department. Fines that establish, I don't know that the Board of Selectmen want to establish fines. It seems like that's more in the building department.

Speaker 7 (01:37:56–01:39:34)

Shouldn't there be a predetermined chart of fines? Because I had a situation. How does the building department? I was not happy with the way that my fine was determined by the building inspector.

After we got our special permit, we were in the process of installing our drainage system. And we were fined by the building inspector because we started our machine 15 minutes before. That fine was $1,000. I got fined for a failure to notify.

That was fined by $1,000. And I had a fine of a truck being on the property, which was a fine of $1,000. The original fine was $5,000 per offense. I had to hire a lawyer.

The lawyer had to talk to town council, and we negotiated it down to $1,000 per offense. And so, there should be consistency and there should be a chart. Like a schedule of fines. Like a schedule of fines.

Yeah. So, I think that has to… We should find out more.

Speaker 1 (01:39:35–01:41:23)

So, but I do think, I don't, I don't think necessarily the select, the select board, you know, want to take that. on but we can talk to the building department to see if that would make sense. All signs requiring a signed permit or special permit under the provisions, so signed permit under the provisions of this section shall require the review of the Sign Review Committee. So the Sign Review Committee shall be appointed by the Board of Selectmen, that's how we do it now, on an annual basis.

The committee will have, this has four members, one of whom is the Director of Planning and Community Development. and others whom are residents or owners of businesses within the town. At least one member shall be an architect, urban designer, or planner, which is the case on that board. The member shall choose the chairman annually.

The committee shall act as an advisory board according to the requirements of the section. So this all seems, this process, Section C, is consistent with how they're operating at this point. So I don't think there was nothing there that needed to be changed. Criteria for review.

These are all, again, I think what is currently how it's operating with the Sign Review Committee's review and advisory. Recommendation of proposed signs shall be based on the following. The listing of those, number two, the signed handbook to be updated from time to time by the Board of Selectmen. So that's…

Why would they be the ones updating it?

Speaker 2 (01:41:24–01:41:46)

That's what I… That was one of the… And before you get to that on number C3, I'm wondering Who is the advisory recommendation to? Is it to the select board?

Is it to the building commissioner? It says it's advisory. So the building commissioner is granting the permit, right?

Speaker 1 (01:41:47–01:42:02)

So I do think that is a difference in here that we would want to correct. I don't think they make an advisory. And Cheyenne, you might want to add to this. They make the decision, I believe.

Or are they making a recommendation to the building inspector?

Speaker 6 (01:42:03–01:42:21)

Great, okay.

Speaker 2 (01:42:22–01:42:52)

So the guidebook should be updated by the assigned review committee at least as a recommendation. And maybe it seems to me personally I think like. where these go on buildings and so forth is sort of tied to design guidelines like we have in our business districts, not just sort of, but is. So it seems like any update to this should be consistent with those design guidelines in Milton Village and East Milton Square.

Speaker 19 (01:42:52–01:42:53)

Maybe that we should be.

Speaker 2 (01:42:54–01:43:48)

Well, they can make the recommendation, but we should review it. I just think we should have a review in it because of the design guidelines. Right. And we also want to make sure it's tied to the zoning.

Right. So it needs to. So because it needs to be tied to the zoning, you know, maybe it's the the sign review committee in conjunction with the planning board or advisory to the planning board. It's just, again, I'm not sure where the board of selectmen role in here makes the most sense, because they're not really reviewing.

That's what I had either occasions for projects in these districts, maybe the planning board and the sign review committee. Because once… And all these references to the Board of Selectmen should be changed to Select Board anyway. Yeah.

I'm just reading from them, but it really should change.

Speaker 1 (01:43:49–01:44:36)

So considerations of how proposed signs related context of the facade of the building, buildings in the immediate vicinity to the sign, the basic pattern of the street front to which the sign is oriented, the sign brightness, style, height, and colors, and other pertinent structures and elements in the immediate vicinity. It goes on to to say actually a lot of this is in our site plan review process too. Reflect the character of the building to which is it attached or associated with which is also sort of in the handbook. Displaying graphic symbols which are legible to both vehicle operators and pedestrians so all of that.

And the recommendation, the sign review committee's advisory recommendation shall take one of the following forms.

Speaker 2 (01:44:37–01:44:57)

So I think here we could add that it needs to somehow consider the design guidelines when located within districts that have design guidelines. Because it might not be in their handbook, but it's in our design guidelines. That's true.

Speaker 7 (01:44:57–01:45:02)

Do we need this if we have design guidelines? Can we try to simplify the process?

Speaker 2 (01:45:02–01:45:50)

No, because there's so many signs that are in places that don't have guidelines. That's why I think we say in… Or just copy the language to make it consistent. Or say refer to…

Yeah, I would say where it says here on page 11 that The consideration of how the proposed sign relates to and the first… I mean, we could put the first bullet point is design guidelines for those signs located within overlay districts for which there exist design guidelines or something like that.

Speaker 3 (01:45:52–01:46:01)

Are we saying that in any district where there are design guidelines, the design guidelines, if there are a conflict, supersede?

Speaker 2 (01:46:02–01:46:13)

I'm just saying that they should consider them here. I think we could leave it to the review of the signed review committee, honestly. But because there are only guidelines there.

Speaker 3 (01:46:13–01:46:22)

If you're an applicant and there's a conflict, which is which is the governing document.

Speaker 1 (01:46:28–01:46:53)

Yeah, I think I think this governs. I think the sign review governs. This will be ours or this will be a bylaw. This will be.

But it's this gives them the authority to consider that as part of their overall consideration, because I think there's different things that they consider when they're looking at the signage, you know, challenges that an owner or store owner might have on what type of sign.

Speaker 2 (01:46:54–01:47:33)

So Cheryl, can you say that again? Well, I was just thinking it's a consideration of how the proposed sign relates to requirements or maybe it's not requirements. I'm trying to think of the right word, but let me just use requirements for the moment. Requirements contain within design guidelines at locations for which they exist or something like that.

I mean, it can be improved, but I'm trying to… All right, let's think about that language. So it needs to consider those design guidelines.

Speaker 16 (01:47:34–01:47:36)

Like principles instead of requirements?

Speaker 2 (01:47:38–01:47:52)

Do you remember how they're phrased in the design guidelines? Just say how it relates to the design guidelines. Criteria or how it relates to the design guidelines. Criteria for design guidelines.

Criteria, okay.

Speaker 15 (01:47:55–01:48:03)

Criteria for design guidelines within districts.

Speaker 7 (01:48:07–01:48:17)

provided that are… As an applicant, this is kind of… 22 pages, right? Yeah.

Plus a handbook. Right, right.

Speaker 9 (01:48:17–01:48:21)

The handbook's actually helpful. I like it. Yeah. It's a lot here for a sign.

Speaker 7 (01:48:21–01:48:25)

It's a lot for just a regular person like myself.

Speaker 2 (01:48:25–01:49:31)

Yeah, but this, if you look, if you read this, anything in our current zoning is, even for professionals, is difficult. I stopped into the building department last week to talk to them about something and I said, you know, we'd like to, the board's talking about codification and they said how much they would support that. I said it's confusing and they said you don't need to tell us basically. And they get calls from architects all the time who are used to reading these things, zoning and trying to design towards it.

And ours is so confusing that professionals who deal with this every day are having to look for the interpretation of the local official because that's who gets to make the decision. But it should be better than that. Meredith, I think just put something in like we talked about and we can think about fine-tuning of that language, right? Okay, all right.

Speaker 1 (01:49:33–01:50:52)

So recommendations, so this is just the process, the different forms, the recommendation that the Sign Review Committee will make, and then the appeal and special permits, right of appeal, any applicant for a sign permit, any person who has been ordered by the building commissioner to incur expense in connection, and any person dissatisfied with any refusal, order, or decision of the building inspector, and this is what's happened, I think what this says, may appeal to the Board of Selectmen. So we're changing ZBA. within 20 days from the date of which refusal, order or decision after notice given to the public and abutting property owners and or residents, the ZBA should hold a public hearing. Applying the standards in subsection 6D, the board shall affirm, annul, or modify such refusal.

The action of the building commissioner may be annulled or modified only by a maturity of decision of the and I would put in ZBA board again. The action of the commissioner is modified or annulled. If the action is annulled, the building commissioner shall issue sign permit in order in accordance with the decision of the board. So.

Speaker 2 (01:50:54–01:51:01)

So then again, the next one, the special permit granting authority should be ZBA. ZBA, yeah.

Speaker 1 (01:51:02–01:54:28)

shall serve as the special permit granting authority for all special permits and signs and shall consider requests for special permits in accordance with the section, section, da, da, da, da. Okay. Circumstances in which a special permit may be sought. Special permits may be considered and issued for any request for relief of the requirements of this section.

However, special permits may not be issued to allow those signs indicated in Section A. And those are the prohibited signs. I would change, again, any permit ZBA, all the select board ZBA language here. And then under required findings, I just changed that language also to ZBA.

So there is a design review. Design review prior to granting of a special permit by the ZBA, the signed review committee shall submit an advisory recommendation on the special permit to the board, and that would be to the ZBA. Such recommendation shall address compliance of the sign with subsection 6E. An unfavorable report of the Sign Review Committee shall indicate which of the findings were not met and shall state what modifications to the sign or signs could be made to render a favorable report.

Failure of the Sign Review Committee to make such a report within 30 days from the date of the submission of the application materials to the Sign Review Committee shall be deemed by the ZBA to constitute a favorable report. Okay. So now, this is the exempt signs. So these seemed pretty straightforward.

Except for on the language, under 8, that would be signs located on property owned by the town Oh, I guess that should stay the board of selectment, the select board? Probably. But we should, all of these change to select board. And great.

signs sanctioned by the Town of Milton Historical Commission, which display historic information about the building's property not exceeding. Those are just the historic plaques. Those are The historical commission doesn't have any jurisdiction over any, we don't have local historic districts, so the commission does not have any say on those. So these are all the exempt.

Then you get down to the prohibited signs.

Speaker 2 (01:54:28–01:54:43)

It's under 10 there. Signed within the town's right of way should be the select board also. So they have board of selectmen in here, but I think that should stay. Select board, right?

What number was that? I'm sorry. 10 on page 15.

Speaker 1 (01:54:43–01:54:48)

Yeah, but that should be select board. And right below it too.

Speaker 15 (01:54:50–01:54:51)

Select board.

Speaker 1 (01:55:05–01:55:28)

All right, so one, so two, I wasn't sure what Tim meant by this. Any new or existing sign not erected pursuant to and in accordance with the requirements of this bylaw, period. Any new existing…

Speaker 2 (01:55:29–01:55:33)

You can't erect a sign on your own.

Speaker 1 (01:55:34–01:55:40)

That's why I read that. Okay. And then it says see blank for guidance on non-conforming signs.

Speaker 2 (01:55:41–01:56:13)

So that would be section… It goes back to… We had something in here for non-conforming signs, right? But…

We'll have to look at that section. So it seems to me they're prohibited as new signs, but there are the ones that were predating this bylaw, right? Mm-hmm. So it would be section 4.

Speaker 9 (01:56:13–01:56:16)

1, 2, 3, and 4.

Speaker 1 (01:56:16–01:56:19)

4A, just existing.

Speaker 9 (01:56:19–01:56:20)

4A, I'm sorry, yeah.

Speaker 1 (01:56:20–01:57:15)

C4A. Signs which incorporate any manner of flashing, moving, or intermittent lighting, excluding public service signs showing Time and temperature, these include promotional beacons, laser lights, or images. Wind signs, including banners, pennants, spinners, streamers, and other wind actuated components. Mechanically activated signs, other than rotating barber poles, which I don't think we have any more of those.

Sadly. I know. I love them. I know.

Any sign which advertises or calls attention to any products, businesses, or activities which are no longer sold.

Speaker 2 (01:57:15–01:57:18)

That's just a typo there, which are not longer sold?

Speaker 1 (01:57:19–02:01:00)

Yes, that's what I was like with that. No longer sold or carried on at any particular premises. It should be premise, not premises if it's particular, right? at any particular premise.

Yeah. No such sign shall remain in place or vacated or vacated premises for more than or maybe it is premises. I have to double check that now. I'm questioning myself.

Vacated premises for more than 90 days from the date of the vacancy commenced. Portable signs except for sidewalk signs as defined in section, to look at that, where that was, of this bylaw, not permanently affixed, anchored or secured to the ground or structure on the lot it occupies. signs advertising businesses services or activities located at different premises from at different premises from the premises on which the sign is located except street banners permitted by the Board of Selectmen which would be approved that is that type of banner I'm thinking of all the veterans banners that are up right now. So I think that is a select board.

So that should just be changed to select board. as defined in Section 8A, window signs which cover more than 25% of the window or which obstruct the middle third of the window or door such that eye-level view through the window is blocked, signs erected so as to obstruct any door, window, or fire escape on a building, signs constructed, erected, or maintained on the roof of a building or which extend above the roof plate line, Signs in the right-of-way other than those belonging to a government, public service agency, or railroad. Signs which are pasted, attached, mounted, or located on a tree, utility pole, fence, or structures such as an overpass, add, bridges, or other similar structure. Signs posted or attached to other signs are prohibited unless such subsidiary portions are an integral part of the total sign design.

Signs not in good repair, in violation codes, or containing or exhibiting broken panels, visible rust, visible rot, damage, support structures, or missing letters. This is where the height comes in. Maggie, you were asking about this, the measurement of the sign area. That's included in here, measurement of sign height, ground signs, building signs.

location, structure, and design standards. So this is what your ground signs, I don't know if this would be what you were referring to, unless more restrictive setback is specified, otherwise in the section all ground signs, whether permanent or temporary, shall be set back at least 15 feet from the nearest property line, whether or not said line abuts a public or private streetway. Which one, where are you waiting from? Sorry, I'm on 10 now?

On which page, though? On 17.

Speaker 2 (02:01:00–02:01:11)

So where's the square footage calculation? It says the measurement. So that's actually, yeah.

Speaker 1 (02:01:11–02:01:17)

OK. There is coming a. OK. It comes a little bit later.

Speaker 7 (02:01:17–02:01:25)

Can we put it here? Yes. So that we don't have to be flipping back and forth. That's my biggest pet peeve on these documents.

Speaker 1 (02:01:25–02:01:58)

I just would like. Well, that's one thing, because he has Tim did prohibited illumination in an illumination section, but it's not in the prohibited section. So that should be moved. All right.

Well, let's just keep going, I guess. Yeah. And then we'll. Yeah.

Because I think there will be some things to move. So measurement, sign area, structure, generally structure, ground signs, setback, corner clearance, right away.

Speaker 2 (02:01:58–02:02:15)

Sorry, I'm back on the setback on the ground signs. Yeah. 15 feet. Is that what we've approved in some of our memory care and daycare facilities?

Have they been 15 feet back?

Speaker 9 (02:02:17–02:02:19)

I never paid attention to it, to be honest with you.

Speaker 2 (02:02:19–02:02:30)

Just thinking we should look at it just to see if that's the right number. We should, yeah. Or they're going to be looking at some variances or appeals.

Speaker 1 (02:02:31–02:02:45)

Yeah, because there could be things like I'm thinking about when the hospice was installed. I don't think that's 15. Maybe it is, but I don't know if that's 15 feet. Maybe roughly.

Speaker 9 (02:02:46–02:02:55)

Memory kind of couldn't go back any further because of the wetlands, I think. That was right on the curb cut almost.

Speaker 2 (02:02:55–02:03:04)

I think we should take a look at what those couple that we've approved that haven't filed for their signage yet, probably. And if this would impact them.

Speaker 1 (02:03:08–02:03:22)

Yeah, good. Corner clearance right away, no sign or part thereof. Compliance with building code maintenance installation.

Speaker 2 (02:03:25–02:04:31)

Well, the installation, none painted or posted directly on the exterior wall. You know, there's historically the signs were painted on to the sides of walls and you still see them as a historic feature in some buildings. So, I guess I wonder if that's a good requirement. I think where we see them in our business districts.

Like if you think about Abbey Park as the mural on the side that's painted directly onto the, you know, that's considered a sign or art or something else. But what if they wanted to put Abbey Park as a, there on that as part of that? There is a certain style. Yeah.

I know what you're talking about. Yeah. It makes sense. Some of the old mill buildings.

And whether that would make sense in Milton village, for example. Um,

Speaker 16 (02:04:38–02:04:42)

Actually, was, too, Elliot going to put a mural behind where the parking was?

Speaker 14 (02:04:42–02:04:43)

Mm-hmm.

Speaker 16 (02:04:43–02:04:44)

Wasn't that part of his rendering?

Speaker 1 (02:04:44–02:04:45)

I think they are, yeah.

Speaker 9 (02:04:45–02:04:48)

Which I'm OK with, but to your point.

Speaker 1 (02:04:49–02:05:03)

Is that considered a sign, though? I don't know. That's more of a, I would say, like artwork. And I think of Abbey Park as being artwork, but what if they wanted to paint Abbey Park in a certain style?

Speaker 9 (02:05:03–02:05:06)

It would be a shame to send the message that we don't want that.

Speaker 1 (02:05:07–02:05:12)

Yeah, I don't think that would be considered a sign, though. OK.

Speaker 2 (02:05:12–02:05:33)

Well, I think it'd be worth going back to look what you like you suggested, Jim, at what was proposed for 2 Elliott, because I can see like the Webb Mill building when if they did the brewpub that they're talking about doing something on the side of one of those buildings and having it be considered signage and it would be appropriate there. Yeah.

Speaker 7 (02:05:34–02:05:53)

Especially if it's not facing the street, what does it matter? It just says on any wall. But if it's a wall on an alleyway, what would be the harm in that?

Speaker 2 (02:05:54–02:05:57)

In many historic brick buildings, you'll find old faded ones.

Speaker 8 (02:05:59–02:06:00)

The coolest.

Speaker 1 (02:06:01–02:06:07)

So maybe we take out that first line and just have all signs must be painted, posted, or otherwise securely attached.

Speaker 10 (02:06:11–02:06:11)

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (02:06:11–02:06:52)

But then you're, all signs must be painted. To an intermediary sort of movable surface is what you're saying. I think you could say sign, I don't think you can take it out entirely without revising the second sentence, but what you could say is, without express approval or something, because you'd want it to be reviewed for the circumstances. So you're calling attention to it may or may not be approved.

I don't know if that's the right language, but.

Speaker 9 (02:06:55–02:06:56)

I like where you're going with it, though.

Speaker 1 (02:06:57–02:07:20)

Or signs… Say that again, because you could say signs may be painted… Signs shall be painted unless approved… I said without express approval, which…

Without express approval, yeah. By the Sign Review Committee.

Speaker 3 (02:07:28–02:07:47)

Yeah, I think what Tim was writing is to protect against, you know, a rash of painted or applied signs, you know. There are some locations where it is probably really attractive and nice to have, but there's more locations that you don't want that.

Speaker 2 (02:07:50–02:07:52)

Well, do you think this covers the protection of it, I think?

Speaker 3 (02:07:52–02:07:57)

Yeah, I'm not sure. I just feel like we should definitely protect against that, you know.

Speaker 2 (02:07:57–02:08:18)

Yeah, I think I kind of think of as part of the overall design package, you know, so it needs to be looked at in the context of what's being proposed. So like what's appropriate, let's say, for the two Elliott would be different than what would be appropriate for, let's just say, the Masonic building, for example, or for something on High Street, you know, it's like,

Speaker 7 (02:08:20–02:08:31)

Would that painting have to go to the Historical Society? They could just paint on any old outside old building and ruin.

Speaker 1 (02:08:32–02:08:38)

We don't have a jurisdiction. Yeah, we wouldn't. It's not a local historic district, so we don't have.

Speaker 9 (02:08:40–02:08:52)

I don't think I've ever seen a mural, excuse me, on anything other than an old brick building. I've never seen it on clapboards or shingle or anything. It's just fitting to something old, like to Eliot.

Speaker 3 (02:08:54–02:08:58)

We don't have that many buildings that it would be fitting for. We have some.

Speaker 1 (02:09:03–02:09:06)

Okay, I like what Cheryl added to that.

Speaker 2 (02:09:07–02:09:25)

And I think what you could do is you can have their handbook be more explicit about it, like where it's appropriate, what type of application. Because I just looked through it now, I don't see it addressed in there right now.

Speaker 1 (02:09:27–02:10:03)

Okay, so 19, and we can just try to move through this quickly because I don't want to keep us too late. We have a couple of other things. And if we want to break at any time, tell me. But the illumination permitted externally illuminated signs.

Signs may be externally illuminated by white, steady, stationary light. shielded and directed downward solely at the sign. Reverse lit signs. Signs may be reverse lit, illuminated by white light only.

And I'm trying to think of what that looks like, Cheryl.

Speaker 2 (02:10:03–02:10:23)

What comes to mind when you… Reverse lit would be something where it's like lit from behind. So let's just say like letters were cut out and you had like a white acrylic behind it and then there's light within it. or channel letter, which has an acrylic and then the lights behind it.

That's the way I understand. Is that the hospice?

Speaker 7 (02:10:24–02:10:25)

Hospice have that?

Speaker 2 (02:10:25–02:10:28)

I'm not sure. I'd have to go take a look.

Speaker 1 (02:10:29–02:11:18)

Yeah, I'd be just love to see an example. Then prohibited the following types of illumination shall be prohibited, except as may be permitted by the issuance of a special permit. So this is saying internally illuminated signs. So this is what's in conflict.

This is some, because it's all, what it says earlier is a special permit can be given except for what is prohibited. So maybe we need to take out this prohibited section here and just… I'd put these in a special permit category.

Speaker 2 (02:11:19–02:11:24)

Not a prohibited, but a special permit, right?

Speaker 1 (02:11:24–02:11:58)

I think we want these in the prohibited section because then the special permit section refers to except for the prohibited. You can't, the special permit, there's a list of things that they can't give permits to, just about everything they can. And except for the, in that prohibited section, that's what's referred to.

Speaker 2 (02:12:00–02:12:19)

So… I guess I don't understand why certain signs might be allowed by special permit. And that's what this says. But prohibited and special permits seem like different terms to me.

Prohibited would mean to me, you don't get a special permit.

Speaker 1 (02:12:20–02:12:29)

Nobody gets it. That's what we want. That's what we want. Because that's what we're getting right now, and we don't have anything that protects us.

Speaker 2 (02:12:29–02:12:36)

Eternally illuminated signs, though, in my mind, aren't necessarily all bad for all circumstances.

Speaker 1 (02:12:36–02:12:51)

I think we need to look at what some of these are. So like Santander, we're starting to see them, like in people, the Santander sign, which these Milton Square residents really don't like.

Speaker 7 (02:12:52–02:13:06)

I guess I'd have to see what is so bad, why is a reverse lit sign permitted, but an internally eliminated sign is not?

Speaker 2 (02:13:06–02:14:01)

A lot of, well, if you look at a lot of this, this whole thing is set up for like East Milton Square, but it's not like contemplating the kinds of signs that you see in other places, like what about the gas stations? What about the, you know, like the memory care? It's like, If I look through this guidebook, there's nothing about ground mounted signs or something where you're having to mount it not on the building face, but it does have this rock, but you know, I think it needs to think a little bit more comprehensively about all the types of signs that there are. Right.

And not just the ones that are mounted to historic, you know, frames.

Speaker 1 (02:14:01–02:15:52)

So I think what happens is, so Wellesley, for example, does not allow any illuminated signs. I was listening and it goes through their planning board and they had a gas station. Somebody was asking for a new sign and they did not even allow uplit light. They had to have down lit lights, but no illuminated signs.

And it changes the look. of a town when you start seeing internally illuminated signs all over. It just, it's a very different look when you drive through. And that's why you drive through like Andover Center and you see the Santander Bank with gooseneck lighting.

And now Milton, we have this huge, big, internally illuminated plastic sign. And it's a difference of a look. And it's being sensitive, I think, to the historic character of the town, if we can. not have those.

What just is, it was very controversial, was one of the gas station signs that on the Bassett Street side, that gas station did the pricing in the electronic, and it's on here. And now the new gas station on across the street is now they just requested one and they've been granted approval for, and they're going to be going up. They're going to put a new sign up and they're putting these, um, it's the led price signs. So they're the really bright price signs.

And it's, you know, when one, when one sign it's like, okay, is that so bad? It's when you start seeing all of a sudden, and once you, you know, are allowing them, you're going to have others and say, well, this is fine.

Speaker 7 (02:15:52–02:16:05)

I know, because as a business owner, you get a little annoyed. Because the sign review can't- When you see that other people are allowed to do things and there's no enforcement, and it really is very annoying.

Speaker 1 (02:16:05–02:16:45)

So the sign review committee is put in a difficult position where they've now been recently approving more internally lit signs. it changes the look of a business district to do that. And so that's why internally illuminated open face channel letters, signs fabricated with letters, numbers, designs, or images consisting of an exposed or visible light source emitted from the face of a sign, including but not limited to incandescent and fluorescent bulbs, LED price signs, LED and digital displays, and neon tubes.

Speaker 2 (02:16:45–02:17:29)

Once we get public with this, we're going to need some photographs of the kinds of signs we're talking about here. And I think we should have those sooner rather than later. So if people can get out and take a look at these things, if anybody can photograph them at night. Because this is a whole class of sign, and maybe some of them make more sense, like a large sign on a gas station, you don't want a certain type, but on a different kind of building, or even on the ground mounted sign, it might be okay to have the type.

I mean, this is prohibiting a whole class of sign, and I just think we wanna make sure we understand what we're doing here.

Speaker 7 (02:17:29–02:17:41)

And is it by height? Because… No. So the gas stations, they're being…

Are they asking for, you know, a 40-foot… Well, you'll see.

Speaker 1 (02:17:41–02:17:47)

We will get to that. There is a height limit on when we get into the business uses.

Speaker 7 (02:17:48–02:18:27)

Because again, maybe I'm dating myself, but I love like an old gas station sign lit up. You know, just like my favorite sign in the whole of Milton is the Pepsi sign. I love it when they light it up in the fall. and that's how I illuminate.

So if it's an old school style, then I like a vintage style, to your point, because it is a historic railway village or a Milton village. So if the sign is of a certain vintage, then I think that should be okay.

Speaker 1 (02:18:27–02:18:29)

Yeah, perhaps. Like the Walter Baker chocolate.

Speaker 7 (02:18:29–02:18:31)

Yes, I love that. That's iconic.

Speaker 2 (02:18:31–02:18:45)

Yeah, that's right across the river. So that's mounted on top of the building, which we're not allowing. Yeah, but that's in Dorchester, too. Yeah.

Oh, but I love that. I mean, you look at the extra space storage sign, right?

Speaker 1 (02:18:46–02:18:50)

That's a pretty big. That was the first internal. That was the first one that went that way.

Speaker 2 (02:18:50–02:18:51)

And it's big.

Speaker 1 (02:18:51–02:18:55)

And it's huge. And that got approved, yeah.

Speaker 2 (02:18:56–02:19:10)

So I think we need to do a survey of samples of different contexts, because you can't write it for one district only. So we have to think it through.

Speaker 1 (02:19:10–02:19:11)

We have to use examples.

Speaker 3 (02:19:11–02:19:55)

I have a memory of a project some years ago that we built in Connecticut. And it was a signed bylaw that was preventing my client from putting the sign up that they wanted. And I'm not, it's just something for consideration. What the client did, because we had the front of the building was entire glass, they hung a sign inside the building, which, was not considered signage.

Speaker 1 (02:19:55–02:19:57)

Do you know what I mean?

Speaker 3 (02:19:57–02:20:18)

Then just bring it up not only because we want to be careful that we don't allow a loophole for that to happen. The effect was just the same. Do you know what I mean? As if it was on the glass on the outside, but it was suspended on the inside and the authority having jurisdiction had no ability to say no.

Speaker 2 (02:20:19–02:20:54)

I don't know if this addresses it, but some bylaws have a primary sign that can be a certain size. You know how we looked at that? Goddard School had their primary sign and then they wanted these other things. So you can make the primary sign allowed to be, you know, one size and then you can maybe allow secondary signs to be another so that you can prioritize so that you don't get the situation where you get signs slapped on all the facades if it's, you know, visible to the public.

I think that's- Is that coming?

Speaker 1 (02:20:54–02:20:55)

That's coming too. Okay.

Speaker 2 (02:20:55–02:21:13)

But, and we can, you know, So I do think whatever this reverse lit, if that's a definition, needs to come somewhere. And they internally illuminate it. And I do think we should think about some of these with respect to size.

Speaker 1 (02:21:17–02:22:08)

And I'll look through to see if they have this. Okay, so we'll just skim through these. Then time, unless a business establishes open to the public, no sign shall be illuminated between the hours of 11 p.m. and 6 a.m., and that's usually what is required by the sign review committee.

Intensity exterior illumination of signs shall be shaded, shielded, or directed that they shall not reflect or shine on or into a neighboring premises or into any public street. The intensity of such light shall be deemed acceptable if it does not exceed a factor of three above the ambient light intensity at any point on the ground when measured with an incident an incident light meter and the following procedure.

Speaker 7 (02:22:08–02:22:11)

So as an applicant, how would you know what that is?

Speaker 4 (02:22:15–02:22:21)

So typically, does the town have a light meter?

Speaker 2 (02:22:23–02:22:29)

Well, if you're normally your sign fabricator can probably provide that information.

Speaker 3 (02:22:31–02:22:35)

The the electrical inspector probably has a light meter.

Speaker 14 (02:22:35–02:22:42)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (02:22:42–02:23:30)

So then it goes into, so that was business districts. Then it goes into the residential districts because we were going to cross over this. A sign of not more than two square feet in an area displaying the street number, the name of the occupant, the property, and the historical references, if any, without need for a permit under this bylaw. a sign pertaining to the lease or sale of a lot or building without the need for a permit under this bylaw provided that such signs do not exceed a total area of nine square feet nor more than one and a half feet in any dimension until at such time as all lots, apartments, condominiums, or houses have been rented or sold.

Speaker 2 (02:23:32–02:23:41)

That's an obscure bylaw. The… Sorry, sorry, go ahead. I think I jumped ahead.

Speaker 1 (02:23:42–02:24:32)

That's all right. One contractor's sign not exceeding 12 feet or more in area, otherwise provided maintained on the property while construction is in progress and containing information relevant to the project. Such sign shall not require a permit under this bylaw and shall be removed within three business days after completion of construction. one sign identifying each public entrance to a subdivision or multifamily development such as apartments, condominiums, or townhouses of not more than nine square feet in area, not more than three and a half feet in any dimension.

In addition, each family unit may carry a single sign of not more than one square foot without time limit.

Speaker 2 (02:24:32–02:24:59)

So one thing I would say here is we've got child care facility, memory care facility, hospice, hospital, businesses, and we haven't covered them at all. And they, we should. Yeah. In the residential districts?

Yes. Yeah. Right. I don't know what the zoning is for Milton Hospital, but, hmm?

Speaker 9 (02:25:00–02:25:04)

It's residential. I didn't get where you were going, but now I get it. I'm sorry. It's like, I understand now.

Speaker 2 (02:25:04–02:26:18)

I get it. Yeah. I just didn't hear you. Sorry.

Because we've had projects that we've reviewed where we've seen these signs, right? So and again, I don't know how big those signs were that we approved anymore, but we should look. Nine square feet. And three and a half feet in any direction are bigger than that.

I can tell you that. Yeah. There's definitely bigger than that on the memory care. How would you categorize those?

I would just commercial uses because they are commercial uses in a residential. Yeah. Well. I think we've got the multifamily already covered, right, with number four.

So then I think number five, which Tim said that needs to be is not just nonconforming business, though. I would call it commercial uses. and non-conforming. I mean, you could take it a step further and say even protected uses, because like a house of worship is protected, the daycares are protected.

Speaker 1 (02:26:20–02:26:29)

And they have signs. Well, that's in here too. Tim covered everything. We'll get religious and educational nonprofit institutions.

Speaker 2 (02:26:30–02:26:43)

So that could be, yeah. So then the only thing maybe is it's the memory care is not protected. The hospice is not protected. So then I guess the businesses and commercial uses is probably fine.

Speaker 1 (02:26:42–02:26:47)

And we would need to determine what that would be with those.

Speaker 2 (02:26:47–02:26:56)

I think a business should get to have the comparable to the business district.

Speaker 9 (02:26:57–02:26:58)

I agree.

Speaker 2 (02:26:58–02:27:01)

So there's a way to write that here.

Speaker 1 (02:27:02–02:27:13)

We could because that's going to come next, the business district, and that's where the specific detail signs, the measurements are included here.

Speaker 2 (02:27:14–02:27:19)

We can, once we read through this, see if there's anything that we think is not appropriate, but otherwise I think it should be the same.

Speaker 15 (02:27:20–02:27:38)

So commercial uses and non-conforming protected in residential zones are subject to business district requirements.

Speaker 1 (02:27:49–02:30:11)

All right, so business districts, and we're almost there, total sign area, unless otherwise here and afterward provided the total area of all signs erected on a lot shall not exceed one and a half square feet in area for each horizontal linear foot of the building face parallel to or substantially parallel to street line. However, if the primary façade is on a parking area, then said façade shall be used to determine the amount of allowable signage. Principal signs, no more than two principal signs shall be allowed for each business establishment. A principal sign may be a flat wall sign, a projecting sign, or a freestanding sign.

The total area of all flat wall signs shall not exceed 50 square feet on any one wall of the business establishment. Flat wall signs shall not project more than 12 inches from the facade of the wall. Subject to the approval of the building inspector, a flat wall sign may be located anywhere on a wall of a building provided that it does not conceal any part of a window and that its length does not exceed seven-eighths of the facade of the business establishment. A projecting sign shall not extend beyond the curb line or more than 50 inches, exclusive of any supporting structure from the building.

A projecting sign shall not be less than 10 feet from the ground level at the base of the building over a vehicular way, 10 feet over a sidewalk or a lesser distance, so long as public safety is not endangered, nor more than 20 feet from the ground level to the top of the sign. allowable area of a projecting sign will be computed as one half square foot for each horizontal linear foot of the facade of the establishment on which it hangs. Such signs shall not extend above the building, nor be more than 12 feet in area. So freestanding signs shall not exceed 50 square feet of an area when the…

So 12 square feet is like two feet by six feet.

Speaker 2 (02:30:12–02:30:42)

That would be like a tiny sign on a big building. So again, it's like… Yeah, which way? More than…

So it's like a projecting sign out, but… I mean, I don't know, if you think about like the, you want signs on a building that are sort of proportionate to the scale of the building. So like if you have a big, massive brick building and you have this little sign on it, it's not gonna look right.

Speaker 1 (02:30:43–02:31:11)

We think of the towns that, I think of the projecting signs, which again, I use Andover Center, but they do have, they're not huge, but they're very charming. It adds charm to it, the way, just the way they are applied to the building. I think it's in our design guidelines that we actually do like those signs, but you don't want it to be a massive if it's an extended sign. That would be,

Speaker 9 (02:31:12–02:31:15)

I'm trying to picture a projected sign.

Speaker 2 (02:31:15–02:31:20)

I don't… Just like a blade sign that comes out from the… Like the cue up in Marblehead?

Speaker 3 (02:31:20–02:31:23)

Like when you walk around the Marblehead? Face the building and the sign goes this way.

Speaker 9 (02:31:23–02:31:24)

Oh, I'm sorry.

Speaker 3 (02:31:24–02:31:25)

Yes. Gotcha.

Speaker 1 (02:31:26–02:31:29)

So we should do a mock-up of some example, you know, different signs.

Speaker 7 (02:31:30–02:32:04)

So my only concern when you put in language that says for the non-conforming commercial uses shall be subject to the business requirements. What if the businesses aren't, the interior of a business isn't seen from the street? Because I think, Shelly, you used something, a phrase that's visible to the public. If it's not, what happens if it's not visible to the public?

Speaker 3 (02:32:11–02:32:13)

Meaning it's inside the building?

Speaker 7 (02:32:13–02:32:26)

No, it's still outside the building, but there's enough space around the building and away from the street. So any passerbyers on the streets can't actually see your outside signs.

Speaker 2 (02:32:26–02:33:12)

So this is my point about how some of this is really thought of as like East Milton Square and not like all kinds of signs. So it's almost like some of these requirements should be specified that way. So four signs on buildings in, you know, the business districts. Because if you think about to Granite Ave, a sign that's 12 square feet is going to be like a little dot on that building versus where Fitness Unlimited is.

And we're trying to apply the same dimensional standard for that range of scales.

Speaker 7 (02:33:13–02:33:47)

And I was thinking even memory care. So yes, we should have it for a certain sign size along Highland Street. But within the property of the memory care, they may want to have some signs directing, you know, deliveries out back and nobody from the public will be able to see it. It won't interfere with the public view.

So would they have to come and get permission for all their interior signs? Directional signs are exempt.

Speaker 9 (02:33:47–02:33:50)

It covers directories in here. I remember looking for that.

Speaker 7 (02:33:50–02:33:58)

Are exempt. They're exempt, okay. Yeah. If they are not viewed from the public.

Speaker 15 (02:33:59–02:34:00)

No, I think they're just exempt.

Speaker 9 (02:34:02–02:34:04)

The next page, 21.

Speaker 4 (02:34:06–02:34:11)

Tim is everything in here, I'm telling you. He was very thorough.

Speaker 3 (02:34:11–02:34:45)

Yeah, I didn't read it either. He was very thorough. Well, when you get over to, then this, I know there's a typo in here, but I think he's thinking about in the business district. So if you go to, he's probably thinking about what you were thinking, Cheryl.

Go to 21. Okay. And now he's talking about freestanding signs, but A freestanding sign shall not exceed 50 square feet of area when the establishment fronts on Route 2. So, I don't know, maybe this came from some language in another town, right?

Speaker 1 (02:34:45–02:34:48)

But… So for us it would be like Granite Ave.

Speaker 3 (02:34:49–02:35:02)

Maybe. Yeah. I'm thinking that he was thinking of scale, you know, which is what Cheryl was talking about. or more than 25 square feet of area when they're establishing funds on a street other than Route 2.

Speaker 2 (02:35:02–02:35:02)

Exactly.

Speaker 3 (02:35:02–02:35:05)

That's where you were going with.

Speaker 2 (02:35:05–02:35:06)

That's where I was going, yeah.

Speaker 3 (02:35:06–02:35:15)

So he was thinking of creating language that allowed scale to be used.

Speaker 2 (02:35:15–02:35:27)

So I think you could apply that to We could think about whether that should apply to these other signs as well. But I wouldn't, I'd like to kind of think about these scales.

Speaker 14 (02:35:27–02:35:28)

Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2 (02:35:28–02:35:35)

I think that's, that's good, yeah.

Speaker 20 (02:35:35–02:35:47)

It's just finding the right language to describe that so it's appropriate, you know.

Speaker 10 (02:35:47–02:35:47)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (02:35:49–02:40:19)

All right, so secondary signs, this discusses that if a business establishment consists of more than one building or if a building has secondary frontage on a street or parking area, a secondary sign may be affixed to one wall of each building. or to the second side, secondary signs shall not exceed one square foot for each horizontal linear foot of secondary frontage on a street or parking lot, and said area shall be limited to 50% of the area allowed for the primary sign. Directories where there are three or more businesses on a lot or there are businesses without an entrance on the street frontage, a directory may be permitted for the purpose of traffic direction and control. The size of the directory shall not exceed nine square feet plus one and one-half square feet per business establishment.

Such a directory shall be included in the calculation of a total permitted sign area for the lot. awning, retractable fabric, fabric awnings projecting from the wall of the building for the purpose of shielding the doorway or windows from the elements may include signage on the valance. Such signage shall not be included in the calculation of the total permitted sign area for the lot, provided that no lettering or symbol is greater than six inches in height. No awning may extend within two feet of a curb line.

Temporary sale signs in a business district. Temporary signs advertising specials or promotions or sale of merchandise may be attached to or located only within the interior of a window or door and shall not require a permit under this bylaw or considered in calculating the total permitted sign area for the lot. Such signs must be registered with the building commissioner prior to their installation. Each business establishment shall be limited to display such signs for a period of not exceeding 30 days.

with no more than three such 30-day periods permitted calendar year. 30-day periods may be utilized consecutively. Signs painted on windows in a business district, script describing a product or theme, and not including the name of the business. Such signage shall not require a permit under this bylaw or be included in the calculation of the total permitted sign area for the lot, provided that no lettering or symbol is greater than six inches.

in height. Sidewalk signs, one A-frame sandwich board per business premises shall be permitted, including with the public right-of-way sidewalk only. In addition to the other signs permitted under the Section 8, under the section, under signs under Section 8, such signs shall not require a permit under this bylaw subject to the following conditions. The sign shall only be displayed in front of businesses adjacent to the buildings, not only along the curb.

The sign shall be displayed only during the months of May through October. The sign shall not exceed 24 inches in width and 40 in height. The sign shall not be made entirely of plastic, nor shall it be primarily devoted to a single product. The sign shall advertise the businesses and the goods and services.

available on the premises. The sign shall not protrude on the sidewalk in such a way as to obstruct pedestrian traffic or reduce the open sidewalk width to less than four feet. The sign shall be free of sharp corners, protrusions, and devices which could inadvertently cause injury. The sign must be constructed with a crossbar brace for stability.

The sign must have sufficient strength to stand by itself. In response to specific safety concerns, the police department may prohibit sidewalk displays in designated areas during holiday parades or other specified times or days when sidewalk congestion is excessive. The sign may be displayed only during business hours and must be removed from the sidewalk thereafter. The building commissioner shall issue a sticker permit on an annual basis, which shall be attached to the interior of the sidewalk sign.

Speaker 7 (02:40:19–02:40:25)

Wait, so is this saying that all A-frames need to actually get a permit?

Speaker 1 (02:40:26–02:40:35)

So this sounds like something that they would leave out if it's left out. for months at a time.

Speaker 7 (02:40:36–02:40:37)

Sticker permit.

Speaker 1 (02:40:39–02:41:05)

I don't know. I don't know if we do that, if we do anything like that currently. We don't see many sidewalk signs here. I mean, occasionally I see Abbey Park and Navarra doing them.

I do one.

Speaker 9 (02:41:07–02:41:12)

Yeah, I did one when I owned Ben's and I put it down on rent. I feel like, yeah. Never got permission for it.

Speaker 4 (02:41:12–02:41:14)

Did you leave it out? Was it out there?

Speaker 9 (02:41:14–02:41:17)

I took it in every night. I left it out all day and then took it in every night.

Speaker 4 (02:41:17–02:41:22)

They left mine out all night, seasonally. Why don't we ask about that? Why don't we find out?

Speaker 7 (02:41:22–02:41:28)

Because that might be something that we might not… Like 7-Eleven does it.

Speaker 15 (02:41:29–02:41:29)

Do they?

Speaker 7 (02:41:29–02:41:31)

Yeah, down on Randolph Ave.

Speaker 15 (02:41:35–02:41:37)

So let's put a question mark on that.

Speaker 7 (02:41:37–02:41:41)

That's one of those ones that I get upset about, because there's inconsistency.

Speaker 15 (02:41:42–02:41:45)

Yeah, that's, let's find out.

Speaker 2 (02:41:45–02:41:50)

Yeah, the reverse lit is actually on the definitions, just in case anybody wants to read it.

Speaker 1 (02:41:50–02:42:15)

Okay. Yeah, we'll go there. Liability insurance shall be carried in evidence of some Same, maybe requested the building commissioner said insurance must cover personal injuries or property damage, which may occur in such areas. I don't know how folks feel about this.

I think most businesses carry liability insurance.

Speaker 7 (02:42:15–02:42:24)

So I don't know that we… On signs, they want insurance on… I think that's in case somebody trips over it or… or distance specifically to A-frame signs.

Speaker 9 (02:42:24–02:42:31)

Yeah, if you're blocking the sidewalk and somebody falls into the street and gets hit by a car. That's where I think they're going with that.

Speaker 1 (02:42:38–02:45:05)

I guess we can just leave it in and see if… Yeah, I don't see a problem with that, honestly. Most people probably have that. So last page, religious and educational nonprofit institutions.

One sign, including bulletin or announcement board, identification sign, or entrance marker is allowed for the principal entrance to the premises of a church, synagogue, or other religious institutions or school, museum, library, or other not-for-profit organizations not exceeding 12 square feet in an area. One additional sign not exceeding 12 square feet in an area is also allowed if the establishment has frontage on a second public way. Up to nine additional square feet of signage is also allowed to provide information to the users on the site, provided that no single sign exceeds three square feet. Restaurants, in addition to other sign permits permitted by this bylaw, restaurants and other food service establishments may post an actual menu on the building where the premises are located near the main entrance of the door of the establishment without obtaining a permit under this bylaw.

I crossed off bed and breakfast because we don't currently allow them. Um, he probably just put it in as a placeholder. If we did, um, gasoline service stations, one identification sign not to exceed, and this is, you were talking about height, uh, Maggie, uh, not to exceed 12 square feet in an area. Oh, this is not, sorry.

That's the size product identifications. Signs for gasoline services stations may be maintained provided the total of said signs does not exceed nine square feet in area with no single sign to exceed three square feet in area. and then directional state traffic safety. Signs indicated entrance, exit, parking, or similar traffic directional information shall not exceed three square feet in area per sign provided these signs are erected on the lot pursuant to a town or state regulation.

They shall not be counted in the maximum sign number and sign area requirement for the lot. Signs indicated parking for specific businesses shall be limited to one sign per five spaces.

Speaker 2 (02:45:06–02:45:19)

So one thing I would say is I didn't notice an explicit prohibition of billboards. which that's the one thing that I thought might be implicit, but it's not explicit.

Speaker 1 (02:45:19–02:45:33)

Right. So chapter one, well, that's what I was surprised because Tim said this will cover, but like when he was sending it to me, he said, we don't have a way of protecting us on billboards, but

Speaker 2 (02:45:34–02:45:52)

But it might be implicit because you're not allowing a rooftop mount or a size of a billboard, but… Yeah, but would it hurt to just put a closet? I just wouldn't. I think so, too.

I think so, too. To be extremely explicit about it.

Speaker 9 (02:45:53–02:45:53)

Good catch.

Speaker 1 (02:45:54–02:46:00)

Yeah. So I would add, would we want to put that under prohibited?

Speaker 20 (02:46:00–02:46:01)

I think so.

Speaker 1 (02:46:01–02:46:05)

I think so. Just put a simple, it's just, I don't think it needs to be lengthy.

Speaker 2 (02:46:07–02:46:51)

And then that idea about the height of a sign. So if we're thinking about the gas stations again, like I don't think any of the gas stations meet the requirements that are in here. If you think about how much signage there is. So the question then becomes, you know, how is this derived and does it reflect the kind of signage that's used in gas stations today?

I don't know how different it is from 10 years ago, but it does seem like you wouldn't want to put something in here that has no bearing on any gas station kind of signage anywhere.

Speaker 7 (02:46:52–02:46:58)

Why would a gas station need a lit sign if we're saying it has to be shut off at all?

Speaker 2 (02:47:02–02:47:06)

When do the gas stations close in East Milton?

Speaker 1 (02:47:06–02:47:08)

And I don't think they shut off those pricing signs.

Speaker 9 (02:47:09–02:47:18)

Those are up and… Well, I'm thinking the winter when it gets dark at four. They need… I mean, all businesses need lit signs.

Speaker 14 (02:47:19–02:47:19)

Yeah.

Speaker 3 (02:47:22–02:47:26)

It was eight o'clock or nine o'clock. I don't think they were open past that.

Speaker 7 (02:47:27–02:47:32)

So should it be tied in with their hours of operation and not just a straight 11 o'clock?

Speaker 9 (02:47:35–02:47:36)

I think it is. It doesn't say.

Speaker 2 (02:47:37–02:47:38)

No, it said 11.

Speaker 9 (02:47:38–02:47:40)

It said 11 to 6.

Speaker 1 (02:47:42–02:47:52)

Did it say or their hours? Unless they're open later, like Abby Navarro could have their lights on later because they're open later, but… Maybe it did.

Speaker 11 (02:47:52–02:47:52)

Let's see.

Speaker 7 (02:47:55–02:48:03)

Because with the school on 138, didn't we say they had to shut their lights off and close the business?

Speaker 2 (02:48:04–02:48:06)

An hour after, I think it was.

Speaker 7 (02:48:06–02:48:09)

Yeah. It was on a timer.

Speaker 1 (02:48:10–02:48:24)

Yeah. And that's what I think the sign review committee has been doing, is saying hours of operation or your lights should be turned off at that time. I don't know.

Speaker 9 (02:48:24–02:48:30)

Yeah, you're right, 11 to 6. Unless the business establishment is open to the public, no sign shall be eliminated between the hours of 11 and 6.

Speaker 7 (02:48:30–02:48:35)

11 to 6, unless they're open later.

Speaker 9 (02:48:36–02:48:41)

It doesn't say that. Oh, I guess that's implied, huh?

Speaker 7 (02:48:41–02:48:55)

What page are you on? I'm on page 19. Oh, yeah, right here. Unless the business is open to the public.

Speaker 9 (02:48:55–02:48:55)

So I guess that's true.

Speaker 7 (02:48:55–02:49:04)

If they're open at 12, they can have their sign up. Yeah. What's the molten gas?

Speaker 9 (02:49:22–02:49:23)

So if a gas station goes to self-serve.

Speaker 7 (02:49:23–02:49:24)

They go to 11.

Speaker 9 (02:49:24–02:49:25)

They do.

Speaker 7 (02:49:26–02:49:27)

Milton fuel, 11.

Speaker 15 (02:49:32–02:49:39)

This one? 6. They open at 6. So that's this time, yeah.

Speaker 14 (02:49:39–02:49:41)

They're the reason why this is written like this. That's funny.

Speaker 1 (02:49:41–02:49:41)

Yeah.

Speaker 14 (02:49:41–02:49:43)

Oh, yeah.

Speaker 10 (02:49:45–02:49:45)

OK.

Speaker 1 (02:49:47–02:49:56)

Well, I think this is I think everyone can look this over on their own, you know, and think about things that the billboards. Absolutely. We want to.

Speaker 2 (02:49:56–02:50:03)

Can this be sent to the sign review committee for their feedback before our next meeting, if possible? Yeah.

Speaker 7 (02:50:04–02:50:08)

Well, the Shell gas station says it's open 24 hours.

Speaker 9 (02:50:09–02:50:24)

So that was my thing. If they're going to self-serve, I think they can stay open. I don't know if the town allows it, but the state allows them to stay open 24 hours now because they're self-serve and no one has to pump your gas. So could they keep their lights on all night?

Speaker 2 (02:50:26–02:50:34)

Well, would that mean like the citizens kiosk down in Milton Village can have lights on all night because you can go drive up to the ATM?

Speaker 9 (02:50:36–02:50:41)

Actually, if I was a Citizens Bank customer, I would want a light there, right?

Speaker 7 (02:50:41–02:50:55)

You'd want a light, yeah. For safety, yeah. And are all these lights dark sky compliant? These gas station lights?

Speaker 14 (02:50:55–02:50:57)

I don't think so. I don't think so.

Speaker 7 (02:50:59–02:51:05)

So that's a bit unfair to everyone else has to be dark sky compliant, but they don't have to be. But that's why it would be great.

Speaker 1 (02:51:05–02:52:53)

So they are grandfathered in. So there's nothing we can do about it now. But going forward, we would be able to not have LED pricing lights on those if we can, if we can do this in a way that's that prohibits these. under that section eight.

All right. So yeah, let's, I'll send this over to John and cause he's been through this from the beginning. It was actually, I, I had tried to get a design review committee established in Milton years ago when they, when, and John was on the, um, It was a central lab revitalization group. And we couldn't get that passed, but the select board did establish the assigned review committee.

And I had said, John, would you be the chair of it? So he's been there from the very beginning to see all of these different things. Because this booklet has also changed because there were things that came out of the booklet because they weren't in the bylaws. So it was like, they've not been able to match up.

So this used to prohibit neon signs, the booklet used to prohibit neon signs, but it wasn't really, it wasn't in our bylaws. So, and it was, I think under Flynn, he suggested not putting in our bylaws. He made it like more guidelines that could be changed or altered without going to town meeting, I think was his goal that you could change and update things. And then it got, you know, then people could appeal it and say it's not in the bylaws and the select board had to approve it, so.

Speaker 2 (02:52:54–02:53:00)

Right, that's what I understood, too. Yeah. I didn't realize he'd been there since day one, though. Yeah, he was the first.

Speaker 7 (02:53:01–02:53:05)

I mean, it was kind of common sense, I would think, that we don't want, like, lift.

Speaker 1 (02:53:06–02:53:52)

And he's always denied it. They always deny, they've always denied the neon signs, but yeah. So I'll send this over. and take a look and we'll think about billboards.

And then we have one, just two last things on the agenda. There is a new, and Cheyenne, we haven't put you to sleep with us going through this. Do you want to talk about what the finance subcommittee, a little bit about that role? and the select board will be making appointments and they have added the planning board as a representative position.

Speaker 5 (02:53:55–02:54:04)

Sorry, now we can hear you. Yeah. Yes, now we can hear you.

Speaker 6 (02:54:04–02:54:58)

Oh great. So that everybody could see it. Yeah, I only just heard about the committee like this morning or yesterday, so I don't have too much insight knowledge, but yeah, it's going to be like a subcommittee. And I think there's going to be one planning board.

Let me share my screen. Here we go. So it's going to have similar to other committees, kind of like a large group of other people just to give their other insights. So we're going to have two select board, two people from school committee, board committee, and then just one member of the planning board, which we're going to use tonight because we can get that tackled.

And I'll zoom in for you.

Speaker 2 (02:54:59–02:55:47)

Thank you. My understanding from watching some of their meetings is that they wanted to do basically coordinated financial planning to understand what the needs would be so that there's not a surprise sort of over budget. Like I don't know exactly how you want to describe like this past year, unexpected kind of expenditures beyond what the budget was. And partly also to think about like the revenue side and new growth as part of revenue, and that's tied to land use and tied to zoning, which is my understanding why a planning board is included in it.

Speaker 1 (02:55:50–02:55:59)

Great. I know Jim is on the capital committee. We were just talking.

Speaker 2 (02:55:59–02:56:00)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (02:56:00–02:56:25)

We were going to assign you to this subcommittee. So we were just talking about, we were just sort of going over this subcommittee. Yeah. So is there any interest?

I know everybody's busy with other lives and serving on different committees. Does anyone have interest in being on this, or has interest in not being on this committee?

Speaker 9 (02:56:25–02:56:37)

I have interest in not, unless nobody else wants to do it, then I will do it, to be perfectly honest. But it sounds interesting. I'm not that great with numbers, but I could figure it out.

Speaker 1 (02:56:38–02:56:39)

And you're on the capital committee.

Speaker 3 (02:56:40–02:56:40)

I am.

Speaker 1 (02:56:40–02:56:41)

So that's good.

Speaker 3 (02:56:42–02:57:10)

I definitely have interest in this, but this isn't the time for me to get myself involved in something else. Right now, I'm struggling trying to meet all of my life expectations. If it was a different time and circumstances were different, I'd volunteer because I do have an interest in the financial aspects of the town. Not the right time for me.

I'm sorry for that.

Speaker 7 (02:57:13–02:58:13)

So I know I'm on the climate action. So that's the only, not the only, but the only committee I'm on. And I'm not sure what the lifespan of that is, because it's the Climate Action Planning Committee. And, you know, they've done a great job.

Unfortunately, they've met many times when we meet. So I've missed a couple like tonight. So I guess the question I have would be, how often are they meeting? What time are they meeting?

Is there flexibility in days? And I don't know if they've gotten that far and maybe they have to meet to figure all that out. Right.

Speaker 3 (02:58:14–02:58:15)

I think it's once a month, isn't it?

Speaker 7 (02:58:15–02:58:17)

I think the charge is once a month.

Speaker 3 (02:58:17–02:58:18)

That's what I read, yeah.

Speaker 7 (02:58:19–02:59:14)

So once a month isn't overly, it doesn't have a lot of commitment hours there, I don't think, but sometimes you know how committees go. Then they start meeting more than once a month where they meet at like six o'clock, like the Climate Action Committee meets at six o'clock. And that's a challenge sometimes for me to get to at six o'clock. So those are just my questions and I don't.

You know, I'm around town, obviously, every day. I don't travel too far outside of town. So I'm interested in it. I'm just a little bit nervous about overextending myself, if, depending on.

I wonder if we could have, yeah, sorry.

Speaker 4 (02:59:14–02:59:14)

Yeah, no.

Speaker 1 (02:59:14–02:59:54)

I was gonna say, I'm not interested in it right now. It's not, it wouldn't be, something where I feel like I want to take on one more committee, although Town Farm is wrapped up, which Cheryl and I both served on. But I'm wondering if it has to be just one representative. I guess it probably should, or if we could have two people.

And if you were interested also, and we had somebody to attend to report back to the planning, you know, the planning board, what development projects we're working on maybe, or, you know, and bring feedback back to our committee.

Speaker 7 (02:59:54–03:00:18)

And that's the question is how much extra work is it? Is it just… And you're on a lot of committees too. Yeah, sitting around talking about things or do I actually have to go and how much work do you actually have to do outside of the committee?

Are you just reviewing? And I know it's a new one and so they probably don't even know yet. Um…

Speaker 2 (03:00:19–03:01:49)

I think some of this discussion came about, as I said before, about a lot of residents had concerns or questions about how budgets came together and how there could be surprises and so forth. And then I know some of the new select board members were, and maybe old ones too, are interested in more forecasting. And that requires all participation from town side, from school side, et cetera. And then, you know, some have said that, you know, we really need to look at our commercial tax revenue.

Right. And so I think that's where the Previously, there had been a committee that was select board and school committee and town staff. And so I think this new constitution sort of bringing in a few others is kind of to address that sort of larger, bigger picture. So in terms of the effort, I think it's probably kind of big picture discussion.

Like if someone said, well, can we begin to think about new revenue, like more commercial revenue, then you have to start talking about, well, can we get more out of the existing business districts than we're getting now? What kind of revenue are we getting there? How feasible is it to get business revenue? People…

What's the demand for office?

Speaker 1 (03:01:49–03:02:00)

What's the demand for medical office, et cetera, right? Because it's been challenging to get commercial. It took the Hendry site a long time. they ended up with a nail salon, you know, and it was like, everyone said anything but a nail salon.

Speaker 7 (03:02:00–03:04:38)

I know, I mean, it's tough running a brick and mortar. I mean, I know all the challenges, you know, I know them all. And residential, I mean, that's been very, you know, that's actually… Like the average household, mine included, you know, you get five, six boxes a day.

from Amazon or from wherever. I mean, it's really challenging. It's easier to run a service business than actually a retail business. And so when people start talking about, oh, why don't we have this type of business or that type of business?

Well, you need to find an owner who actually wants to take on operating a retail business because it is so challenging. And even if you look at the Chamber of Commerce, the makeup of the Chamber of Commerce, there are very few retail brick and mortar business owners. There's a lot of realtors. It's all service service.

You have, you know, mortgage providers, all part of the chamber. So that's why I'm interested in trying to have a more robust Retail. And there used to be, when people say, oh, Milton never allowed or never allowed commercial. When I was growing up, we had a lot more commercial.

And so I do take a little bit of offense to that, that oh, Milton is so closed-minded. But we had all of our little neighborhood stores and little pharmacies, all of our little corners. And it's been sad to go, but that wasn't, Milton wasn't, That wasn't Milton's fault. That was the change of people not wanting to run their own brick and mortar.

It's a lot. It's a lot. So I'd like to see the resurrection of more neighborhood, small businesses. But then you run into neighbor problems.

And the taxes as a commercial business is great. And you have to be able to work a lot of hours, sometimes outside of our business hours, if you have a bit of an unconventional business, so.

Speaker 4 (03:04:38–03:04:40)

So you would be interested.

Speaker 7 (03:04:40–03:04:44)

Yeah, so I would be interested, but I also don't want to like be a disappointment either.

Speaker 2 (03:04:46–03:05:05)

Well, you know, the Master Plan Implementation Committee is set to sunset in October, after 10 years. And there will be a recommendation to update the Master Plan that comes from that.

Speaker 1 (03:05:06–03:05:09)

And that's been a huge time commitment for you. You've committed a lot of time.

Speaker 2 (03:05:09–03:05:58)

Yeah, because I've chaired it. It's, you know, as you know from chairing, it does take time to make sure that every prepared for all the meetings, et cetera. And I'm our representative to the Community Preservation Committee. I have an interest in it.

I do have a tendency to overcommit, so I am worried about over committing as well. So, you know, Maggie, if you want to give it a start, I don't know. And if you find like that the hours or the that aren't convenient, or if you feel like there's other it's not the kind of input that you thought it's going to be, you know, maybe we could revisit it. Absolutely.

Speaker 1 (03:05:58–03:06:05)

Yeah, I think that because it is so new, we don't really quite know, but at least we would have somebody there at the start.

Speaker 7 (03:06:05–03:06:58)

And that's what I thought at the beginning when I heard the Selectmen talking about this. I thought it was more about, you know, the school budget is the biggest budget of the town. And for whatever reason, their finance subcommittees were not meeting. And so, at first, I didn't really understand the need.

I'm not one to be adding more committees to the town. I'd rather see maybe the merging of committees and we have town staff, I believe our town administrator, he should be doing a five year forecasting plan and and then bringing it to the Selectman to review it. So I kind of thought that that was his job description.

Speaker 2 (03:06:58–03:08:33)

So I would think, Maggie, you keep it to what the planning board can contribute to the discussion. And to me, it's sort of it's the land use things. And you, as a business owner, have a different perspective about that. But, you know, if you you.

you could ask the assessing department or finance office to provide what's the tax revenue generated from Milton Village, from Extra Space Storage, from East Milton Square, Milton Marketplace, and say, okay, you know, we know it's a small percentage. When we did the overlay in Milton Village, we said if that, at full build-out, we had MAPC do the build-out analysis, at full build-out, 2019 dollars, it would be half a million dollars in new revenue. So whatever that would be today. We know from 440 Grand Avenue, they're projecting, I think 250,000 a year.

The same thing memory care, I think they were projecting that amount. So you could just say like, for example, a 440 Granite Ave would bring in X, right? A Memory Care would bring in X. What kind of revenue are we trying to hit with new development?

And what does that look like on the ground? I think that's the kind of way the planning board can contribute to that conversation. Not schools, not town side, budgeting, but on the revenue side, on the new growth side.

Speaker 7 (03:08:34–03:09:01)

It is interesting when you talk about new growth, and I've spoken to the assessor about it, they're always focused on new growth. And I said, yeah, new growth is for that first year, but then they never look at the expense side of it. So they never forecast the expense of the new growth. And to me, that's always interesting.

And he's like, yeah, we don't look at that. We just are always looking for new growth.

Speaker 2 (03:09:02–03:09:42)

Well, if you think about the building department, new growth includes when you do an addition on your house or you renovate your house and the assessed value goes up, the tax revenue goes up, right? And there's a lot of that in Milton, right? There's a lot of, I'm sure, Jim, you've seen it, where a lot of small homes are being added on to. A lot right now are happening.

And what will ADU bring in for revenue? I think that's a good question. What will MBTA communities, you know, like the economic analysis, can there be a new economic analysis done? Those are the things I think that the planning board rep can bring to the discussion.

Speaker 1 (03:09:44–03:09:51)

Yeah. Good. All right. So is there a nomination to appoint Maggie to the finance subcommittee?

Speaker 2 (03:09:52–03:09:58)

I'll nominate Maggie to be the Planning Board's representative to the Finance Committee.

Speaker 3 (03:09:58–03:10:00)

I'll second the nomination.

Speaker 2 (03:10:00–03:10:01)

All in favor?

Speaker 4 (03:10:01–03:10:05)

Wait, does she accept it? Oh yeah, so you accept it? Yes. Conditionally.

Speaker 12 (03:10:07–03:10:16)

Don't be afraid to drive the time to the meeting. Just tell them, look, I want to meet in the mornings if you possibly can. Capital meets at 730 by Zoom. No one has a problem with that.

Speaker 2 (03:10:16–03:10:25)

And also, if you want my feedback or input, sometimes I'm happy to either participate or have a call with you about it. All in favor?

Speaker 1 (03:10:25–03:11:21)

Aye. Aye. Great, and then just there's one last thing on our agenda, and I don't want to spend too much time, but Diane did come and has been quite concerned that the zoning articles were not properly disposed of. And I have not talked to Nick, you know, to see what, I know she sent the select board a letter.

She came to us because she didn't hear back from the select board. So I think it makes sense to talk to Nick and find out if there's anything that's gonna be happening on, you know, with the state or any issues that the state has with the articles or the process. And I think he's probably had a conversation with Sue Galvin and probably town council.

Speaker 7 (03:11:22–03:13:37)

I mean, I sympathize with Diane and all residents for that matter, that if they ask questions and they don't get responses and you have to kind of bounce around trying to find somebody who will provide the answer for you. So I do sympathize. But I also understand that people are really busy too. And sometimes there can be a delay in getting a response.

But I do think she has brought up some valid points, not just on this particular issue, but that's why I know we're here, but it's just seems. To me, I've been frustrated not being able to get answers to questions or saying, oh, if you want those questions, you have to pay $13,000 to get the answers. So I'm sympathetic to her. So I don't know if we can ask just town council to give us an answer, give us a written answer.

To her questions, just so we have done our duty, which the resident has asked us for answers and some of the answers we just, I'm not comfortable answering. I mean, I did watch part of the town meeting again this afternoon and she is right that the moderator or new moderator said, I will step aside and collect my things as the temporary monitor gets sworn in, end quote. But I didn't see him and I don't recall him actually getting sworn in. And so to her point, do you normally get sworn in for a position before you get elected?

So maybe there's a very like reasonable response legally and maybe just town council needs to provide that to us so then we can say we listened and responded.

Speaker 2 (03:13:41–03:14:25)

Any other thoughts? I understand also about people not knowing in some cases where to go with an issue that they have that would like to get an answer on. But this clearly doesn't fall in our. jurisdiction.

That's what I, that was my comment. It falls under the clerk or the moderator or the select board. We don't have the authority. We have no authority and I really don't feel like we can put ourselves in a position of stepping in where we don't have authority because someone's not getting an answer from someone else.

I think it's important for us to stay in our lane.

Speaker 1 (03:14:26–03:14:39)

I wish you had gone to the select board and made the statement. I sort of thought after she sent us the email that she would be doing that. So I don't know where that is.

Speaker 3 (03:14:39–03:16:03)

Well, I think she's here because one of the articles she's referring to was an article that came from the planning board. I think it's obvious the reason she came here because our article was impacted by what she sees as a procedural violation. So she wants to know how do you feel about that, that your article, how do you feel about a procedural violation involved in the erotical. I think it's logical that she came here.

My opinion, since we're sharing opinions. I do agree the town should respond to the resident's concern. And there's a process that exists for a reason, there's a procedure that exists for a reason. Did we violate the procedure?

Are we in violation of process? And somebody should, this isn't hard, this is all recorded. I think the town should respond to the resident and say either yes or no. that there's a violation of procedure.

That's not complicated. And if the resident has called to attention of the town that a violation has occurred, I think the town's responsible for answering it, no matter what the subject is. I don't think it changes the vote at all, but you have to put that aside. This is a question of not of the vote.

It's a question of following process, following procedure, and did we follow it properly or did we not as a town?

Speaker 2 (03:16:04–03:16:06)

But still, it's not our jurisdiction.

Speaker 3 (03:16:06–03:16:53)

I'm not saying it is. I'm just offering my opinion. Why did she come here? Because it's an article that came from the planning board that was affected by the procedural violation that she sees.

So I'm not saying I'm telling anybody to do anything. I'm just, you know, Diane… I give Diane credit. She puts her heart and her soul into the town.

There probably aren't a lot of residents that commit as much time and as much energy as she does to the town. So she deserves to be, she deserves, every resident deserves fair and equal consideration. She's brought something forth that's legitimate. Everybody that seems to, you know, have listened to her or heard her, no one's arguing that she has an illegitimate claim.

The town should answer it.

Speaker 7 (03:16:56–03:17:49)

And back to process, I mean, I have a question about the process on citizens petitions because I've been through it. And when I went through it, I was told that I wasn't able to change or amend my citizens petition because I had so many signers on the citizens petition. So all those signers would have to agree to an amendment. So this is just a general question.

I don't need an answer now, but this is a question that maybe Peter Mello needs to respond to is, you know, when it's a citizen's petition, it's put forward by a hundred people. Do all a hundred people have to agree to that amendment?

Speaker 2 (03:17:49–03:18:23)

So I asked a question about, and I don't know who gave you the guidance before, but I asked it on this because I was curious about that because I think you may have mentioned it before. And what I was told was once it's put forward, then it can be amended like any other article once it's there. So just like we can put somebody, any town meeting member can make an amendment to a planning board article or anybody's submitted article. So that's what I was told by town council.

Speaker 12 (03:18:23–03:18:27)

But in that case, as the planning board, we would have to agree to the amendment, right?

Speaker 2 (03:18:28–03:18:39)

If we said no, we're not gonna accept it as a friendly amendment, town meeting could still vote for it anyway. So they could amend something that we've submitted. Oh, really? Yeah.

The town meeting can do that.

Speaker 7 (03:18:40–03:18:44)

Yeah. And so, yeah. And so then that's all the town council has to do.

Speaker 2 (03:18:45–03:18:57)

Yeah. I mean, I was having a different question and I said, by the way, now that I've got you on the phone, can I ask you about something else? But I wanted to take advantage of having him, but. So he so he can easily do that.

Speaker 7 (03:18:59–03:19:03)

You know, he can easily respond to that question in writing.

Speaker 9 (03:19:04–03:19:06)

So should we ask him to? Is that where you're going?

Speaker 7 (03:19:06–03:19:39)

Well, to everyone's point, it's out of our jurisdiction, except for it is zoning. I think it would be better if another board or another staff member responds to her out of respect. But if she doesn't get an answer, then I think we should respond. But I don't know how much time Yeah, we should wait for that.

Speaker 2 (03:19:41–03:19:47)

Well, I don't know exactly who she's reached out to, other than she said that she in what she was sent to us, that she had reached out to the select board.

Speaker 9 (03:19:48–03:19:50)

I thought she reached out to the state in her email.

Speaker 2 (03:19:50–03:20:13)

But whether she's reached out to the clerk, the moderator, the town council, I mean, the town administrator, chair of the select board, I don't know. But those all seem like more relative more ones who have jurisdiction than we do.

Speaker 3 (03:20:14–03:20:47)

Yeah, we certainly don't have jurisdiction. It's not like we could call Peter Mello and say, we want a written opinion from you, Peter Mello. But as a board, and since the resident came before us, I think it's fair to say that we could recommend that the resident get an answer from the town administrator, you know, as to her question. And I don't think there's anything wrong with saying that, right?

She came before us, it was on our agenda. There's nothing wrong with us saying that we recommend that the town administrator answer the question that the resident has asked.

Speaker 2 (03:20:48–03:20:57)

I don't see us taking a position like that and making that kind of being a conduit for something that's out of our jurisdiction.

Speaker 1 (03:20:57–03:21:39)

I don't think I'll talk to Nick and just see if I can gather more information because just as maybe Meredith could, maybe there's a process that they are doing that and taking some steps that we just don't know about. So I don't want to assume anything. So. But I do appreciate her coming and trying to keep us accountable for what's in our bylaws.

So I think it's important. So with that, that is the end of our meeting. So I would, unless there's anything else, entertain a motion. We will sign that before we leave.

But I would entertain a motion to adjourn. So moved. Is there a second? All in favor?

Speaker 17 (03:21:39–03:21:41)

Aye. Good night, all. Thank you. Good night.