Board: Warrant Committee
Date: 2025-01-23
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:56–03:45)
Good evening. Welcome to the Warren Committee. It's Thursday, January 23rd, 2025. Thanks for everyone for being here.
So just for a little bit of just introductions, as some of you, as all members of the committee know, but also probably a little scheduling shift to some personal issues. So tonight we have members of the School Committee, We have members of the school committee here. We have Dr. Burrows, our superintendent.
We have consolidated facilities director. In addition to Arrow to discuss the school building project. So we're gonna be addressing, we've addressed two of, there are three school articles. On the special time meeting warrant, we've already gone over two.
There's a new article concerning construction renovation at our Cunningham School to the third and fourth floors. This is a new article that we've just received from the select board the other day. So we're going to address that, but members of the committee, if there are other questions that came up regarding the school building committee membership or the school building association money warrants, please feel free to ask any questions to those. I would like, I would trust that after presentation, we'll have a discussion.
And as we indicated yesterday, I'd like to have a vote on these articles this evening. After that, there's more. Town Council, Mr. Mello, Attorney Mello is present, along with Town Administrator Nick Milano, who will be on Zoom.
Mr. Mello is here in person. He couldn't come yesterday, but he'll be addressing one of our liquor bylaws, which is the consumption of intoxicating beverages on town property. So we'll do that after schools.
And I hope and I believe based upon our conversations yesterday, we will vote on that article this evening also. So that really leaves our planning board articles. Some of you may have heard there may be some citizens petitions we may have to address. Those will be addressed after.
the deadline for comment submission. So as we said before, we'll be doing those comments and meeting throughout the month of February to prepare those comments and deliver them to town meeting. So with all that being said, I'd like to invite the members of, let's try that. Can we call a roll, Karen?
Speaker 2 (03:45–04:05)
We can. We have Tom Caldwell, Steve Rimes, Lori Connelly, Liz Dillon, Jay Funlan. On Zoom is Allison Gagnon. Peter Moll is here.
Julie Maxwell is here. On Zoom we have Brian McGuire, Aman Nagasi, and Judy Steele. So you have a quorum.
Speaker 1 (04:05–04:22)
Okay, thank you. I'd ask the members from school committee, superintendent, consolidated facilities to step forward in any order that you wish is appropriate. We only have two seats up there.
Speaker 3 (04:30–06:27)
Hi, everybody. Lizzie Carroll, chair of the school committee. Thank you very much for having us back to discuss this article. We're really very appreciative that the Select Board, well first the Capital Planning Improvement Committee, obviously Lori represents you all on that, as I do the School Committee.
We had a good discussion over a couple of meetings there, which led to this sort of recent development of the opportunity to bring this article forward for the February Special Tag Meeting. So we're very glad we can sort of present it, answer any questions. I am happy to have Anna Marghese here as the chair of the Facilities Advisory Committee. She was also a member of that advisory committee last year.
And so she will be well positioned to sort of share from the school committee lens the work that we have done. And of course, Dr. Rose, thank you for being here. He was supposed to be at Annie Jr.
at Pierce right now, but this was very important. I got to sing earlier. Very important that you could be here. And of course, our team that can speak to the details of the project as well.
I actually, of the five of us, am the least expert on the ins and outs of this actual requested proposal. So I'm happy to be here with this outstanding team. I don't know, Peter, Anna, what would you like to add before we kind of dive into some of the details of the project and then watch these members out?
Speaker 4 (06:29–07:36)
I mean, I guess I could just say that, echo what Lizzie shared, that we're really excited to be in front of you right now talking about this. We've been working on this issue of short-term space needs. Our highest density is in Cottingham and Calicut. We've been looking at this space for quite a long time, both, I think, in two respects.
One, the open space on the fourth floor, which we desperately need, and looking at the third floor and the library and the dysfunction of that space currently. So this is really important to us. We really appreciate it. We know it's challenging because we're coming in, you know, in terms of capital planning and over two years.
that initial estimate of $2 million was, as you know, we all know by now, was not nearly close enough to what the project would cost. So kind of a two-phase ask to the town, and I just appreciate being here to talk more about it, answer questions, and go from there.
Speaker 1 (07:37–07:38)
Thank you, Dr. Bartz.
Speaker 3 (07:40–08:03)
She's done a tremendous job leading, provisioning, and sort of moving forward with this project and Mark Loring working with you last year. And, you know, we definitely wouldn't be here without you, you know, really keeping urgency behind the need. So is there anything you want to say just sort of?
Speaker 5 (08:03–11:24)
I'm really grateful to be here. And I appreciate you guys kind of, you know, expediting the process. Lori, thank you so much for was we voted on this out of facilities back in October, I think, and it has taken a long time, right? And we started looking at the space in September of 2023 when we first, that was the chart for facilities that year was let's look at address short-term space.
We have a long-term space, Plan that's moving forward but we wanted to do something immediate in addition to just cutting up spaces in our buildings and we did just to provide some background facilities advisory committee went toward all six schools and went through a kind of. went with an open mind to see what can be done there. And a lot of the space has already been used, as you've known. Closets have been converted to offices.
And as we walked through the space, it was really interesting to see how much there was need, how important the need for additional space was. And then we requested, Dr. Reddin to show us the fourth floor, and when we went up there, it was like, wow, this is sitting here above us, collecting dust, basically. I mean, it was like tall ceilings, lots of windows, and just a lot of dust, and a lot of storage.
But it was great, it was well lit, and as I'm walking through the lower floors of Cunningham and Collie Pike, you see you know, service providers in closets, you know, with no windows and like a desktop. And so it was just like, gosh, what can we do? And the way we looked at it was it was great. Our facilities committee is made up of lots of different people with lots of different backgrounds, architects, so on and so forth.
So we just started kind of envisioning the potential. And going up there, it was really nice to see. Everybody just went like, whoa, this space is here. So what can we do?
And at the time, we were so eager to get costs, estimates, and so on and so forth, but without doing, obviously, a full, an inspection or anything like that. So the initial estimate, obviously, was done just to kind of, here's a rough cost, just as a starting point, and we appreciate you know, all your help last year with that. And of course, we're back because we had to do the next phase of it. And as we kind of delved into the project, we talked about more in that detail.
So that's, and so anyway, I'm kind of rambling. It's my first time talking at Warrant. But I just want to say I really appreciate you guys taking the time and having us back here again. And we want to work with you and be able to answer your questions and hopefully get to a good spot.
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (11:24–11:32)
And I'd just like to say that this is the place to ramble. Warrant Committee. So you found a nice home.
Speaker 6 (11:32–11:35)
You found a nice home.
Speaker 1 (11:36–11:41)
We've got a lot more than three minutes here. Thank you very much, I appreciate it, and thanks for your work.
Speaker 3 (11:45–12:18)
Anyone? Yeah. So, Tom, you've spent some time over the past couple of weeks helping us walk through, like, from your, you know, what is this project in terms of, this overview is helpful, and we should also, I didn't actually get to that. our architect.
Thank you for taking the time to join us. You might have good insights on how the project has evolved. So yeah.
Speaker 7 (12:19–13:05)
Yeah, I can talk to the basics. If we want real details, Shonali is the expert here. So they put together the plan for us. I've been working with this.
I just come on Consolidated in April. So kind of picked this ball up running. We've gone through walking through the buildings, finding out what we can do, talking with Arrow Street, and understanding what is realistic rather than the guesswork that was unfortunately done in the past. So now I think we're doing well with good numbers and good timing on how we can do it, when we can do it.
So we have a plan. It's just a matter of putting that plan in place.
Speaker 4 (13:09–13:23)
Do you want to maybe talk about just kind of overall design and what came up as you dug into your fourth floor for considerations around why we ended up where we did in terms of design?
Speaker 8 (13:23–14:10)
Sure. So Air Street was hired last summer to take a look at the Caldecott Cunningham spaces on the fourth floor and the third floor and convert the library from the library, move it to the fourth floor, and then convert the third floor to classrooms, and to figure out how many classrooms you could fit in that space, and if there are any additional spaces that we could configure, and then figure out how to move the library from Not, I wouldn't say it was significantly larger, but from a larger space to a smaller space and make it more efficient, but still provide some of the back health services that were in the third floor and maintain those services on the fourth floor. So we started with an existing conditions report. We walked the fourth floor, which is was the biggest concern.
Speaker 4 (14:11–15:22)
And one thing just to add in terms of the library space. It's used because there isn't a lot of gathering space between Cunningham and Collicutt. There's often, you know, people, both principals are kind of rushing to get to one of the spaces because they can't bring their staff together. So the library does serve a purpose beyond just being a library of one of the few large gathering places for staff.
So that is something that as we're looking at this that maybe hasn't I don't think it's been talked about much, but that is a critical factor of what the fourth floor will become as it's going to become a space that for countless meetings, whether I'm meeting with the community, but all of the things that we do to engage the community and then also internally. staff meetings, all those kinds of things, that space will be available for that too, which is a very different space than, for those of you who have been to the cafeteria, it's just a very, very different than a library space. So that is going to be, that fourth floor will be kind of a hub. So I just wanted to mention that as you're talking about it.
Speaker 8 (15:22–20:16)
I mean, I will also say that the fourth floor is a naturally very interesting, beautiful space. There isn't much that we have to do in terms of finishes to make it look great. But what we do have to do, and this came out of the existing conditions report, is when we walked the spaces, very quickly we realized that the fourth floor is not conditioned. And so we were there in July, August of last year, and it was unbearable.
And the heat, we know, continues on into the beginning of the semester and to the end. So that was a big concern for our engineers to understand how condition that space. We also had to look at the accessibility issues. Luckily, the fourth floor does have an elevator that will meet.
We'll have to get a variance, but it will meet the code. And we do have to do a little bit of work at the ceiling to complete some clearances. But elevator, that was a great saving. We were very excited.
That was a huge win for us having access to that. The other major challenge that we had to figure out was by code because it is a library for children. you have to have toilet rooms on the same level as children. So if the fourth floor were to become a teacher's adult-only space, you could go one level down or one level up by code to access toilet rooms.
And then we would have them on the third floor. But because it's children, code requires that you have to have toilet rooms. So we had to add two, one accessible and one a slightly smaller size. Luckily, we found a corner of the library that already had plumbing, so we don't have to reroute plumbing.
But we did have to move walls and secure the floors, ceilings, lighting, all of those things, and obviously new fixtures and tile them. So those are the two things that on the fourth floor were the really expensive driving costs. The HVA system, we found areas on the lower roof that we don't have to do additional structural work so that it's fully supported. have clear runs of all the duct works onto the fourth floor.
On the third floor, really it was just walls. Walls, flooring, paint, lighting. You do have to reroute a few pieces of ductwork because of where the new wall locations are. And we also have to change the sprinkler head.
So the sprinkler pipes stay in the same location, but we have to relocate sprinkler heads to get the correct amount of coverage across all of those spaces. So we had to convert from a dry sprinkler to a wet sprinkler system because the wet sprinkler has a quicker reaction. And so because, again, it's children, we went on the recommendation of GGD and best practices. So we were able to get four classrooms, six So we're taking 10 seats for teachers or admin or however you want to allocate the office space.
And we're also able to create a breakout space for kids to be pulled out of the classroom if they need some one-on-one instruction. So four classrooms is a fairly substantial number. They're very basic classrooms. We're not putting in any millwork.
There's no plumbing. It is just basic. We have accounted for power and areas where you need to have whiteboards and cameras and projectors, but we're not supplying that equipment. And we're not providing furniture either that will come either reused from other spaces.
For the library furniture, we are reusing the existing reception circulation desk, but we are recovering it. There are dents and scratches in the current desk, but we are using the exact same framework, the exact same desk, same millwork, and just replacing it to upgrade it. That's really the big description of the work that we're doing. When I talk about it, it sounds substantial, but we've kept it as simple as we can, and being really cognizant of the financial constraints, but also providing of size classrooms for the students to use to alleviate some of the pain pressures for kind of getting qualified.
Speaker 1 (20:16–20:28)
Is there anything else that any member of the panel would like to add just about the project before we open it up for questions? Anything you think that we should know?
Speaker 7 (20:29–20:30)
No, I got nothing.
Speaker 3 (20:30–21:30)
The only thing I would add is just around Grateful to be talking about this now, as opposed to prior for the Maytown meeting is really just to allow the project to begin this summer. It needs to occur during based over summer months. Maybe if there are questions to that, but that was the reason why we were so, you know. really in October, when we voted this out of the school committee, we were hoping for this opportunity to consider it in the winter, fall winter time meeting.
In order to not wait, because if you waited until May, we would then go out in mid. And at that point, you would really lose the opportunity to even begin it over the summer of this year, which really adds another year before students can begin using the space. So that's just you know, another reason why we were why we're appreciating the opportunity to have this come before the town in February instead of waiting.
Speaker 5 (21:31–22:35)
And we really want to maximize the summer while the kids are not in the buildings to do as much of the work as possible. And we've obviously phased it out where the third floor would the lead time for purchasing some of those oversized equipment that eats up a lot of the budget has long lead times. So we wanted to kind of accommodate for that as well and still keep the project moving. And I also want to just say that the third, the reason we kind of, we started out on the fourth floor and then we moved down to the third floor and that was you know, based on conversations with the building leaders who were in the buildings and kind of understanding what was most pressing for them and what are the spaces that they actually needed in the, in the buildings to help kind of alleviate the city's needs there.
So all of this was with their input, so to provide the maximum amount of space for them and their needs.
Speaker 1 (22:37–23:11)
Thank you. I'll open it up to questions, and I'd like to start. Maybe to Aristry and everyone here, the renovations, I know there was a walkthrough by the Massachusetts Building Committee. Did they make any recommendations as to the space issues?
Do they have any fee like what you're doing on Arrow Street, I guess, is were you working with the Massachusetts School Building Authority or did they make recommendations? We want to see X, Y and Z or anything like that.
Speaker 4 (23:12–23:30)
No, their their focus was just looking at the condition of overcrowding and and then assessing kind of our need relative to other school districts. So, yeah, they didn't give us anything. There was not an overlap period. Yeah.
Yeah, OK. There were two separate. Yeah, two separate.
Speaker 1 (23:30–23:44)
Yeah, I just want to make that clear. These are just two separate things. And I guess one more, and I'm sure members will have anything. What's the biggest ticket item of this project?
Like if there was, it might be hard, but like.
Speaker 8 (23:44–24:07)
No, it's your mechanical units. Yeah, mechanical units. OK. Your mechanical units are, I think, I can actually get you the exact percentage because I brought the estimate.
But it's a matter of. That would be great. I can get your percentage. Absolutely.
But it is the big handful unit is what is driving the cost.
Speaker 1 (24:07–24:33)
Well, yeah. And just take your time to look. And a question came up just the other day, which is about the cost. So I'm just trying to flag that just for the committee.
Oh, no, no. And I assume this is like heating, ventilation, and like conditioning, anything else, if you can mention that, that's included in the mechanical cost would be great.
Speaker 5 (25:00–25:24)
And just to clarify, because we went into the third floor, the scope also doubled, you know, since we were here last time. Of course. So that's part of the cost increase for them.
Speaker 1 (25:24–25:37)
Just the one. While we're waiting, I remember Jay or Steve, anybody? Remember the Milton Arts Center on the fourth floor? Do you remember that?
There used to be an art museum up on the fourth floor.
Speaker 9 (25:38–25:45)
And it was also the cafeteria when I was in junior high school, I think. People told me that.
Speaker 6 (25:45–25:48)
How was the pizza?
Speaker 9 (25:48–25:52)
People said, oh my gosh, I used to have a lot of pizza.
Speaker 4 (25:53–26:15)
Total history. I don't know why, I haven't heard why it was abandoned so to speak. Why it was just kind of at some point someone decided we're going to move everything out of there and just kind of leave it.
Speaker 1 (26:16–26:27)
It seems like when you look from the outside, it looks like a beautiful space with those windows. Don't make buildings like that.
Speaker 4 (26:28–27:16)
Well, that was one of the things as we were looking at adding classroom space was due to the design of those windows, you couldn't really put a drop ceiling in to create classroom space. That was the main driver, was the design of that space up there. Because the initial thought was putting classrooms up there and basically cutting that space up into four or five classrooms or whatever we can get out of it. And then as we looked at it, we realized the cost would be significantly more to try to do that work up there.
It would be easier to have it be a library space, which kind of was designed as like a large open space. So that was kind of the genesis of that shift in the design.
Speaker 1 (27:16–27:18)
I appreciate that. Thank you.
Speaker 8 (27:19–27:36)
So just material costs, not including any of the overages that our estimator included, any of the escalations or any of those contingency fees which are added on top of the materials cost, it's just under a million dollars just for your HVAC material.
Speaker 1 (27:47–27:56)
I guess just to follow up, is there any other, other than that you could just mention to the committee in terms of costs, percentages, or anything?
Speaker 8 (27:56–29:55)
So you're looking at roughly another… So your MEP systems are, that's what's driving your cost. We have about $160,000 total in interior finishes. That's your drywall, your carpet, your paint, but we're also talking about two floors.
So, and a little bit of tile in the toilet room. So that number is not surprising considering the amount of square feet. very basic finishes. We haven't done anything fancy.
So that's really where you're going to see the bulk of your costs. There is costs for demolition and some abatement up in the fourth floor. We have to remove the flooring. Again, that's where you're going to see the bulk of your costs.
So you're looking at point of view, you're looking at almost 60%. I'm not considering what you're getting, right? Like, currently, you have all of this, what I consider the fourth floor, a beautiful space, it has beautiful skylight, it's currently unusable. So you're converting unused square footage into usable square footage, which you're gaining substantial amount.
That to me is probably right in line with what you need to do to convert an attic space. Yeah, so if you don't do the work, you can't use the space, so that's part of the issue.
Speaker 1 (29:56–30:05)
And I'll stop, I feel like I'm monopolizing this, just for the facts, just for the record. What's the square footage on each floor that's gonna be renovated?
Speaker 8 (30:06–30:15)
I don't remember off the top of my head.
Speaker 1 (30:15–30:16)
I appreciate it.
Speaker 8 (30:16–30:30)
56, yep. That sounds about right, it's just under 6,000 square feet Correct, that sounds about right.
Speaker 10 (30:30–30:33)
Total, 3,000 each?
Speaker 7 (30:33–30:33)
11,650.
Speaker 9 (30:33–30:34)
I'm sorry?
Speaker 7 (30:34–30:38)
11,650. 11,650.
Speaker 1 (30:43–30:48)
And my last question right now is the abatement, is there asbestos up there? Is there something?
Speaker 8 (30:48–31:41)
So what we've called for in the specs is for the contractor to come and do additional testing and to, what we're suspecting is that it's in the floor. We have a report from the town that says that it's cleared of asbestos, but there's glue that's been exposed. And so we will have, once the bids go out and we talk to a contractor, we need to understand, can they cover over it and seal it, or do they have to do an abatement, so that there is some money carried in the estimate. We just don't know which is the more economical path slash correct path.
in terms of what the conditions are, and we would need somebody, we would need the contractor to advise us on that direction. We can only allow for it to happen in the drawings and the specifications.
Speaker 1 (31:41–31:46)
But you've provided for that, if an official abatement, if they had to come and beg the place.
Speaker 8 (31:46–32:07)
They have to come and do the report and let us know, and then we can make some decisions from there. If it needs to be a fully abated space, we don't have enough money in there. But based on the report that we received from Milton, where our understanding is it does not need to be fully abated. So based on the existing information, that's where we're at.
Speaker 7 (32:07–32:26)
It was done in the past. We have that report. There's one section of tile floor that was the cafeteria years ago. And that's the issue.
We just got to make sure. areas will take care of, according to the report.
Speaker 1 (32:26–32:30)
I don't have any other questions, members. So, Julia?
Speaker 11 (32:31–32:46)
So I will ask the obvious question that I presume has been answered many times, but I have not seen the answer. Why was the space not considered previously when looking at solutions for the space issues that our schools face?
Speaker 4 (32:52–34:00)
I think there was a lot of talk about the issues, but not enough moving towards action. This is kind of what I think probably was happening, and maybe holding out for, let's not do this partial piece, let's try to fix everything at once. So I know, was it two years ago, the font font was looked at maybe around this time. I think maybe those kinds of solutions were a focus of what's trying to find the solution, so to speak.
And so there was not as much energy put into this issue, which I think is, as I shared previously, is both a short-term remedy for lots of things that are challenging and kind of give a caw-caw, and it's a long-term investment regardless of what happens with a new school, that space is going to be used in perpetuity as long as that building is there.
Speaker 11 (34:02–34:12)
And what was the fourth floor originally? Like, why is there an empty fourth floor in the first place? What was it built to be?
Speaker 7 (34:12–34:39)
Just history-wise, when they redid the buildings, it was just never planned. It was storage, and that was it. That's why the sprinkler systems and dry because it was just going to be storage or just an attic. So they never really planned, back when they redid the schools, probably back in 2000, that, you know, that was 20, 40 years ago, probably didn't see the need.
Speaker 11 (34:39–34:47)
Yeah, okay. And then… I just do want one that kind of adds a little extra person. Can you just grab a mic for the people online?
Thanks.
Speaker 5 (34:47–36:48)
That was really loud. And I don't really know, all I've heard, like when I came onto the committee, it's like, you know, like, hey, we can't put kids up there. Like, there were lots of conversations, lots of things that were said. And then I think last year, our first year, Mark and I, on facilities, we were like, all right, let's really focus on short term space, you know.
And the best way to go about doing that is to walk around with the whole committee and just kind of brainstorm ideas. And I don't know if that was necessarily done. I may have done like, you know, in pockets and conversations, but really what we needed to do was just look at it as a clean slate. And we looked at, you know, different ideas at different schools, right?
Like if it ever comes to a point where we need to do something somewhere else, like we have a great committee with lots of creative people, a lot of creative thinking. And I think we're always coming up with solutions. But then when we looked at this particular one, something that looked like a non-viable option all of a sudden was like, well, maybe let's see where this can go. And it just opened a lot of possibilities for us, just seeing the big windows.
And we talked about getting a longer ladder, for instance, or fire safety and so on and so forth. A lot of brainstorming went into this to kind of say, okay, let's look at it. And then when Shonali came on board and said, hey, it is a viable space, we'll put in the work. And that was huge to hear because until then, like, There was a lot of like, oh, I don't know if we can put kids up there.
I don't know if we can use it. It's been kind of unused. And there has been a lot of history, right? Like, it was once a cafeteria.
It was once an art room. And you hear a lot of things, but I don't really know how much it was really pursued. But this time, we were like, all right, let's figure this one out.
Speaker 8 (36:48–37:18)
I just want to say one thing. To whoever came up with the idea of moving the library from the third floor to the fourth floor is what really unlock the potential for the fourth floor because you can't put classrooms up there. It doesn't meet the requirements for classrooms. So whoever came up with that thought and then came to us to ask us to design the library on the fourth floor, they're the ones who unlocked that potential and created a viable option.
So it does take time to get to that solution.
Speaker 5 (37:20–37:33)
I can't take credit for that either, but I think, again, it's just a group of really passionate people who were like, let's figure this out, and that's where it came out.
Speaker 3 (37:33–38:32)
Last thing to just add that we haven't mentioned yet, but it's the subtext, is that over these years, literally every other square foot of the building has been completely cannibalized. As Anna was mentioning, anybody who walks the buildings sees that. And it's having very negative consequences on teaching and learning. So I think it was just that hitting a breaking point where the principals just were like, there is not one more thing we can actually do.
It took a few years of every summer facilities going in and cutting up the third floor library converting the closets, that all was happening over time. And then last year, when we got the energy of a couple new school committee members that were very singularly focused on short-term solutions, I think it just kind of like… It's a town call.
Speaker 7 (38:32–38:32)
I got it.
Speaker 3 (38:32–38:40)
Oh, of course. It just shifted a gear into a new level of urgency around the project.
Speaker 11 (38:41–38:50)
And then how will this affect the new school building plans, or will it?
Speaker 4 (38:52–40:27)
It's a net gain of one to two classrooms total, because right now we have two classrooms in the workforce space. One is a makeshift space we created this year. Another one is an old computer lab that's in a weird shape for a classroom. So it's not going to have a significant impact on the number of classrooms we need that have gone into all the research on the new school building and overcrowding.
It does help. We were scrambling this year because we had an additional kindergarten class that we had to fit into the library where there wasn't space, so we had to quickly get some sheetrock up and essentially take a corner of the library to house that additional classroom that we had to add. So it does give us some flex in the next couple years as we're like, depending on what happens with our K numbers, whether they continue to stay high or not, but we would be able to add an additional classroom there where we really are literally out of options in all our elementaries in terms of an additional classroom space. And of course, we've lost a lot of our art rooms and music rooms, and those kinds of things are mostly traveling in our schools.
Speaker 5 (40:28–42:09)
I would like to say having set through all of our elementary site council presentations, our principals come in and they start off with the space needs before they get into anything else. So, you know, you just know it's really tight for them. And so it's, I feel like as a school committee member sitting at the table listening to them, I feel like we have to do something quickly that's gonna give them a little bit more than just, you know, let's find this corner and put up a wall, you know? So it's just, and again, the way it is done in the plans, the way Shonali and her team have designed it, it's done very thoughtfully so that, you know, when the new school gets built and so on and so forth, this is not like, a wasted space that's never going to be used.
So it's done thoughtfully. The way the library is designed, it will continue to be used forever. So it's an investment that you make. And it's not like, hey, we're going to spend this money now, and it's just going to sit there and collect dust, just like the current attic.
And that's not the case. And that's why we wanted in the design going in from that space and use it instead of just focusing on the fourth floor and turning it into something and then still having kind of a you know a space on the third floor where you have all these things happening in different corners and it's very distracting so it's just it's done thoughtfully that works with the rest of the building and there is a really nice flow to it so also a lot of thought
Speaker 11 (42:13–42:16)
I have more, but I'll give other people a chance.
Speaker 1 (42:16–42:20)
Julia followed my lead, bad example. Liz has a question.
Speaker 12 (42:20–43:40)
I have four questions. Four questions. They're very short. I'll just say all four of them and then I can remind you.
So I'm looking at a picture of this fourth floor space in the Milton Times from December 12th of 2023. Looks beautiful. Lots of windows. I agree.
The fourth floor. It does look, I mean, it's hard to tell, but it does look smaller than the current library, which is sort of what you said. So I was curious about how this will affect the library. You said it will be more efficient, substantively a lot of it's going to be the same, some of the back of the house is going to be moved.
I was just curious what exactly that meant. So that's one. Then the classrooms on the third floor, would those be for both the Collicott and Cunningham schools and the offices? And then I was interested in comparing the cost to, we've had a lot of discussions about like modular or trailer or whatever you want to call it, modular classroom.
So I was just interested in the cost of this versus the cost of that. And then I'm just interested in a monetary sort of an overall monetary breakdown about how we came to, I mean, you explained a lot of what costs money and I really appreciate that Shanali, but like sort of what is the $3.5 million broken up? That's all.
Speaker 4 (43:40–44:53)
So in terms of the space and the difference in size, there's a net gain because right now, I don't know when the library was just a library and hadn't been taken over, but it's kind of like a usable space, I think it's, you know, and if you go up there, you do kind of like experience, it's got a pretty nice breadth, that space. As I think about our other, and I don't have the numbers of the other libraries throughout the district, but it will be definitely comparable in size to our other libraries. Like I'm thinking of a Tucker, I'm thinking of Glover, it's actually bigger probably. So I think the space, I haven't heard from anyone who said this feels like work.
It's getting smaller and I think it's gonna feel adequate in terms of the size. Your second question was around classrooms.
Speaker 12 (44:54–44:56)
Whether they would be for both Collicott and Cunningham.
Speaker 4 (44:56–45:16)
Yeah, so they are right now. So we do have a flex where we'll have sometimes a collie cut class on the Cunningham side and a Cunningham class on the collie cut side. And it's not like West Side Story.
Speaker 12 (45:16–45:25)
You can't tell when you go from one to the other, honestly. You don't notice when you cross over the invisible barrier between them.
Speaker 4 (45:25–45:39)
The only complication is sometimes the announcements If you're on one side or the other, you get the Collingham announcement or the Cunningham announcement. So that is slight confusion for some people, but we've kind of managed for that.
Speaker 5 (45:39–46:36)
And that was one of the draws to the space for me, is that the high ceiling, obviously, so it feels big. And the windows really just open up the space. And the way the alcoves are set up is great for reading notes and so on and so forth. So it just felt like a library.
The other thing, too, is having both schools have access to it, which is another thing, too. So it's like when we talk about modulars and where we would find space to put it, because then you're taking away from playground spaces or space for kids or green space, and space around those two schools is pretty tight. So I think just looking at this from, like, a usability that's not going to inconvenience just the current setup. It just adds to or enhances the current experience because of this drop.
Speaker 12 (46:36–46:39)
The pricing of the modulars versus the cost of this.
Speaker 7 (46:41–47:51)
Yeah, there is an older study. anything, but the hurdle with putting modulas at Cunningham College is there is no space. There's just no extra space there to put them. And that's probably the biggest need right now.
And we have the space that just makes the most sense to utilize that particular space. And it's a permanent investment. permanent type building modular, similar to the new animal shelter, then the short term ones are only going to get 10 years out of them at best. And I think the cost would be greater than what it's going to cost to take care of this.
Speaker 12 (47:55–48:02)
No. The last one was if you could give a general price breakdown about the 3.5 million.
Speaker 8 (48:04–53:01)
I can just sort of list out some of the components of what, how all the components that got to the 3.5. So you understand sort of all the pieces of it. So for Floor 3, and also I just want to say that we had to do the estimating and broken down for the floors because of the phasing. It just makes it understandable because there's different costs associated with the different structures.
So Floor 3, obviously there's no foundation work, there's no steel, there's no columns, none of that kind of work. But you start with the interior construction. which is the partitions, the interior doors, and there's a little bit of specialty, what they're calling specialty work, but that's a lot of the framing that goes around the doors and stuff like that. So the naming's a little deceiving.
There's no work on staircases, but there is interior finishes, such as wall finishes, floor finishes, and ceiling finishes. Also, understand on the third floor, There are temporary classrooms, and there's also a giant soffit in the library that's kind of like this curved thing over the circulation desk. And the ceiling has to get reconfigured for the walls. The partitions have to go up above the ceilings for sound, so it doesn't get transmitted between the classrooms.
It makes the classrooms better. So there is ceiling work that needs to be done. And then obviously there is some HVAC work with the rerouting of the ducts and then the sprinkler heads having to change because the ceiling height changes. There's electrical work, lighting, some communications and security connections to your existing systems.
And then there is the selective demolition and there is there is money being held for some abatement on the third floor as well as the fourth floor. We don't expect it, but we're holding money. We would rather run a little conservative in that particular regard. For the fourth floor, for the exterior, the equipment on the fourth floor needs to get ducted out to the exterior.
There is an existing window slash grill that's hidden. You can't see it in the main volume room. It's in one of the side rooms. So we are removing that and ducting it and sealing it.
I was very lucky that it existed so we didn't have to cut into the exterior wall. But you do have a little bit of money there. There's a little bit of money in roofing to reflash where some of the exterior equipment is sitting on the lower roofs where it has to penetrate down. So we need to reflash and re-secure the roofs so there's no leakage.
So a little bit of money there. Interior construction, again, partitions, interior doors, specialty millwork. That specialty millwork also includes the refacing of the circulation desk. There is a little bit of work on the stairs on either side that's coming into the library.
Currently, the flooring that covers the stairs does not run continuous up to the library level. And that becomes a tripping hazard, particularly for little kids. So we are calling for new material, new flooring, new painting in those stairwells. So obviously, it's safe and continuous.
We're also carrying some specialty paint to make the stairs fun and exciting for kids to want to go to the library. There is some work on the elevator for cleaning the finishes on the interior. but also it's, again, that ceiling clearance. Right now, there's a diagonal ceiling.
We're not exactly clear how or why it came about that way, but there's a diagonal piece of ceiling that blocks the corner of the door when the elevator opens. So we're removing that and elevating the ceiling at that point so that the door is completely clear. It's a code requirement. You have to do it.
There is plumbing work, obviously, because there's toilets up there. HVAC, fire protection, electrical work with some lighting. Again, with the fixed furnishing, there's some cost associated with the circulation desk. And then the abatement.
and there'll be minimal demolition with some of the existing doors and walls. And those are all the components that equal the cost of the project. I don't know if that really answers your question.
Speaker 7 (53:01–53:07)
Isn't it IT? Didn't we have to do some IT work up on the floor? Because we don't have anything up there now.
Speaker 8 (53:07–53:12)
So there's that also, and then the communications. Yeah, the communications and security systems.
Speaker 1 (53:15–53:18)
We have Allison. And then Steve.
Speaker 2 (53:31–53:33)
Allison, do you have a question?
Speaker 13 (53:34–55:05)
Oh, sorry, yeah. So I want to thank everyone for their work in this project. I think it's long overdue. So just like I had thought that we couldn't do it, that was always the rumor in the school system for the years that I have been a part of this, is that it wasn't ever a possibility.
So, you know, I think that this is a wise investment for everyone for the future and the taxpayers of this town. So and I and I also wanted to, you know, really just stress the importance because, you know, that the new members who came on who had the energy to do it, you know, that's a little disappointing to hear because, you know, short term's been going on since 2019. So, you know, my question is, have we toured the other schools to this level to see if there's other options as to create more short term space? You know, when I looked at that 2019 study, there was additional opportunities off of the wings at Glover, that was also said that the second floor was not buildable.
So I'm just curious if this rumor wasn't true, if there was other options at other schools that were possibilities. Thank you. And if they've also toured the other schools to this level. Thank you.
Speaker 7 (55:08–55:32)
As far as I know, this was the one with the empty space. and then we'll talk in modules again.
Speaker 13 (55:33–56:03)
So have we, not to follow up on that, have we looked at spaces for modulars or additional opportunities to build off like the wing? When I looked at the plans, there's opportunities to build on the left side of Glover and the right side. So I appreciate touring the schools for open space, but have we looked at spaces for permanent modulars or additional opportunities to build classrooms? Thank you.
Speaker 7 (56:22–56:24)
wants to see it. It's an old.
Speaker 13 (56:29–57:03)
There's a representative, that would be great if you shared it. And then who is the facilities now the focus for short-term space? Because additionally, you know, back in when the school building committee was created, they were put together to work on short-term and long-term. So it's just, so it's facilities, the people that we would want to meet with for modulars in the future and for any other additional opportunities?
Speaker 7 (57:04–57:16)
I haven't been directly tasked with that, but I'm sure between the Facilities Advisory Committee and the Consolidated Facilities Department, we could certainly look at options.
Speaker 13 (57:20–57:21)
Awesome, thanks.
Speaker 10 (57:24–58:24)
Steve. Oh, thank you. Oh, thanks for all your hard work. This is really awesome and really exciting.
Couple things, couple comments, I think. Well, first of all, I think. I think the investment in one of our key assets is a great thing for the town. You know, when you look at Cunningham and Collicott, it's got an amazing presence on the street.
The proximity to Cunningham Park, it's beautiful. Green Space, the team that helped to develop that was groundswell parents getting together to make that happen. Folks like Christine Morrow and Anna and others too. It's amazing, right?
And I love that. So the questions I have too, and I kind of pulled your numbers apart a little bit on that too. So you gave some numbers of mechanicals of $1 million or 28%. And then kind of reversing Jeanette.
So I'm interested about that, but I guess trying to track this. So you're going to put, you said six offices up there, is that correct?
Speaker 8 (58:25–58:29)
So on the third floor, There are six offices.
Speaker 10 (58:29–58:35)
Six. And they are they permanent offices or are they people? Is it like a hotel space where someone drops in for a meeting?
Speaker 8 (58:35–58:41)
That's an operations issue, not an architectural one. So they have to refer to the superintendent.
Speaker 4 (58:41–59:56)
Yeah, we have we have so many people buying for that space right now. You know, we were talking about this. There's a shared space, a breakout space. That's more like that hotel space you're talking about right in the middle on the third floor.
I think the other office spaces probably will be occupied by different people. Right now we started, if you look at the design of our office spaces, they're designed for one person. We have three people in them. There are challenges right now in terms of privacy and making confidential phone calls and things like that.
So I think we would be, when this space is available, we have a lot of people ready to move. So we'll have a conversation to say like, you know, based on, you know, and of course this is a phased project too. So we can look at like in year one, like this will be a way, I think we'll probably have a transitional approach to the space in year one. And then once the project is completed, then we would, you know, we would kind of learn from year one in using that third floor space and then also looking at the additional space on the fourth floor.
What is the office? I know we have community schools, right?
Speaker 8 (59:56–01:00:07)
Community schools up there. There's an IT office. And then the librarian will get their office back because they apparently got kicked out of their office. Oh, jeez.
So they are gaining some space back.
Speaker 10 (01:00:08–01:00:56)
That's good. That's good. I also, I personally, I like the timing of you presenting this, because I think if you're presenting this in May, it's a crowded room with a lot of competing interest on this. And I think getting this through now is smart.
I love this project personally. I think it's awesome. Both my kids went through Colicad, so I'm a little biased. I think it's awesome.
You know, one of the things I would and I heard you early and I know it's a new team now. I heard that action was a little slower with the previous team. Perhaps I think I heard that a little bit or slower to react. I like that you're proactive in doing it.
So I like your approach. And if we could keep working together like this, I think it's what we need. There's a lot of good ideas. You folks have great ideas.
So let's work together to figure that out. So more of a comment than a question. Sorry.
Speaker 1 (01:00:57–01:00:57)
Nice work.
Speaker 10 (01:00:58–01:01:01)
Yes. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (01:01:01–01:01:09)
Looking around, okay, Julia? Yeah, Jay, would you like, Julia, would you defer? Yeah, Jay.
Speaker 14 (01:01:09–01:01:35)
Okay, sure. I'll ask a few, and maybe keep a few in reserve. One thing, so unlike my colleague here, I don't know these two schools at all. So quick question, I assume the answer is yes.
I mean, right now the library is in between the two schools, in my imagination, and the library is going to be more on the Cunningham side, so can you speak to will it still be accessible to Collicott, is that a really dumb question?
Speaker 4 (01:01:36–01:02:09)
That was a good question. Yeah, I mean it's still accessible, it's essentially if you're looking at the building like this, and third floor is here, right now the library is, I'm not sure it's exactly in the middle, it feels to me like it's a little bit over towards Collicott, so now it's shifting from here, it's going up to the fourth floor and moving over here, so it's just really just from Collicott it's going through the current library space and then there's the stairs are right there up to the fourth floor.
Speaker 14 (01:02:09–01:02:14)
So I'm a Collicott student, it's library time, my teacher leads me where?
Speaker 4 (01:02:17–01:02:37)
Well a student could still, I mean students are Students aren't running around Collicott without a teacher. A teacher would walk with the students to the space. Okay, I'll take your word for it.
Speaker 14 (01:02:38–01:02:48)
Another question. You addressed this a little bit. Why can't we put classes on the fourth floor? Or why would that be cost ineffective?
Speaker 8 (01:02:48–01:05:43)
Sorry, if you want to put classrooms on the fourth floor, one, the dimensions of that space are not the greatest for classrooms. I did not bring a plan of the fourth floor, so I apologize. But if you all look at the existing photos, I know somebody has it on their screen. there are all these little bays off of the fourth floor.
These sort of dormer, small, they're only- Almost like reading nooks. Yeah, like reading nooks. And they're roughly three and a half to four feet wide. You can't even fit, like we couldn't even fit furniture in there.
There's just not enough clearance. That's eating up a huge bulk of that square footage. And so it doesn't, to have, a dimension of a classroom that works really well for the educational goals of Milton, the depth of that space. There wouldn't be enough space for a corridor to reach from one side, so there's stairs flanking the space.
There wouldn't be enough space for a corridor to get from that stair around to the other stair. So that's issue one, the whole egress issue. And you wouldn't be able to fit four classrooms up there. So that's layout one.
Second thing is when you have, let's say hypothetically that we could get four classrooms up there, the number of toilet rooms that you would need to support that number of students would increase substantially, and you would also then have to put separate at least one, maybe one toilet, if I remember my math correctly, that's a toilet room that's dedicated to adults. So there's those issues, and those are the big ones, but egress, toilet rooms, We have talked to the code consultant about the elevator. And when we were initially designing and looking at the spaces and we did some test fits for the classrooms, he hadn't quite finished his study on whether or not the elevator would need to be replaced. But we never really got that far to get to a conclusion.
But in my mind, if we were to put classrooms up there, we would have to revisit the elevator issue because it is not wheelchair accessible, really. It's accessible. It complies to a certain level. But now if you start talking about students that are using those spaces every day for a full day, it's not wheelchair accessible.
And I think that's going to become an issue. So that means you're going to have trouble mixing your student populations up on that level. It doesn't provide the best educational experience, whether it's viable by code or not, which I don't have the answer at the moment. So those were the issues that we encountered dimensionally.
It's just not pretty.
Speaker 14 (01:05:43–01:06:10)
So I'll ask the slightly unpolite question. Why did we think this would cost $2 million a year ago or whatever? If we were to put classrooms on the fourth floor, it sounds like it would be maybe even more than $5.5 million. So how did it grow from, one reason it grew is because we're putting classes here, we're putting classes here in a library here, but why do we think it was two million and why were we wrong?
Speaker 7 (01:06:12–01:06:48)
Well I think part of the issue was it was an older estimate that was, so we worked with Arrow Street and come up with a feasibility study that gave us real numbers. Unfortunately the number that was come up before went basically off square footage, And again, it was an estimate provided years ago to, and I think they just ran with it, unfortunately. I wasn't involved in that, but that's the gist of what I'm getting. So now we have real numbers, a real feasibility study.
There was a communication with ERA.
Speaker 4 (01:06:48–01:07:27)
Yeah. And I think they obviously didn't do a deep dive the way, I mean, design the space, right? I think they looked at the space and they said, okay, based on current pricing and square footage, so like you said, based on square footage, this is what, you know, here's the ballpark. But it was very, you know, a very basic number and it was, as you know, as we dug into the space, we realized, okay, like, this is a totally different project than what we had initially conceived.
Speaker 7 (01:07:29–01:07:30)
thinking four, four.
Speaker 14 (01:07:30–01:07:31)
Correct.
Speaker 7 (01:07:31–01:07:34)
Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 14 (01:07:35–01:07:35)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (01:07:36–01:07:43)
I could ask a couple more questions or I could let someone… Well, let me go back to Julie had a question and then go back to you, Jay.
Speaker 11 (01:07:43–01:07:57)
So if we are or if you are able to take advantage of this summer for beginning the building, what is the overall timeline for finishing? Will they only be working in summers or…
Speaker 8 (01:07:59–01:09:09)
I'm happy to answer. So the way we designed the drawing sets and the phasing of the project is that third floor would happen this summer, and that the fourth floor would happen next summer. However, between this summer and next summer, work will be done behind the scenes in terms of, you had mentioned the long lead times on the equipment. We would have to first this year to get it in time for next year.
So we would not be able to reverse the phasing and do fourth floor this year and third floor next year. And the reason we did it has the least amount of impact on students. It doesn't take the school offline in any way. There will be no commingling of workers and children the day the kids leave the school, the contractor moves in, hopefully a week before the students come back.
The contractors will leave and the students come in and then it'll happen again next summer so that they can make as much noise as they need to. They don't have to worry about security access and all those kinds of things.
Speaker 11 (01:09:10–01:09:12)
So what happens to the library in that year?
Speaker 8 (01:09:15–01:09:48)
Oh, right, so this summer when the library comes up. Yeah. So we talked about a couple of different solutions. One was the corridor in the design of the classroom is quite wide.
You're going to have kids running around, so that could be a temporary solution. We could use one of the classrooms as a solution. haven't really come to a full conclusion, but we've thrown out a couple of options. But again, I think that's really up to the principals and superintendents to decide how they want to utilize the space temporarily.
Speaker 4 (01:09:48–01:10:37)
I think our initial thinking is utilizing one of these classroom spaces and then spilling out from there. I know in a lot of the work we did in designing last year on the new school design, a lot of schools are moving to kind of an open library or like a dispersed library throughout the building with little kind of like spots where kids can interact so it's not all in one place, which I thought was kind of interesting. So I think there are a lot of options that we'll look at to make sure that that learning doesn't stop for a year, but it continues. And obviously it won't take the place of having you know, a fully fleshed out library.
Speaker 11 (01:10:37–01:10:54)
OK, so two summers to complete the project in full. OK. And then knowing that town meeting last year passed the specialized stretch code, is this going to have like the heat pumps and solar panels or how?
Speaker 8 (01:10:54–01:11:04)
We're not subject to the specialized stretch code because of the type of renovation that it is. It's an interior fit out. We're not touching the exterior envelope.
Speaker 11 (01:11:09–01:11:13)
So what will the heating and the HVAC system run off of?
Speaker 8 (01:11:14–01:11:57)
So we're going to have condensing units on the low roof, air handling units, two condensing units, two air handling units, I believe. I didn't give you the specifics. But they are energy efficient. And if you were to renovate the exterior, we would have to confirm with UGB that they would meet the new requirements.
But because we're not touching the on-road, we don't have to do any of that energy modeling or any of that other specialty work that you're talking about with the stretch code. But all the units meet code.
Speaker 11 (01:11:59–01:12:13)
So has there been any analysis done for over time what this will cost in the short run versus if what you did invest in the heat pumps and solar panels and things like that?
Speaker 8 (01:12:15–01:12:17)
Oh, we haven't done any of that kind of analysis.
Speaker 14 (01:12:20–01:12:20)
Thank you.
Speaker 13 (01:12:22–01:12:22)
OK.
Speaker 14 (01:12:23–01:12:33)
Going on a similar theme, I'm wondering why we're cooling this space. Do we cool the other elementary schools?
Speaker 4 (01:12:36–01:12:43)
We do cool, and you can find state board where specifically, but we do cool certain specific spaces.
Speaker 7 (01:12:43–01:12:56)
Do you cool in auditoriums? We are cooling the high school library. Yeah, the library.
Speaker 14 (01:12:57–01:12:59)
So why are we cooling the space?
Speaker 7 (01:13:00–01:13:15)
The top, excuse me, the attic. Yes. I think because of where it's situated and what we found when we had the walkthrough is extremely warm up there. So I think to condition that space, it's almost necessary.
Speaker 14 (01:13:18–01:13:23)
Did we look at the option of not and put a dollar number on not air conditioning?
Speaker 8 (01:13:25–01:13:39)
It's GGD, who's a mechanical engineer, is recommending. I'm sorry, I can't. GGD, who's our mechanical engineer, made the recommendation that it needs to be cooled for personal comfort. But it's not an occupiable space with the level of heat that gets trapped up there.
Speaker 14 (01:13:40–01:13:43)
Is the floor below it? So is it because it's the fourth floor?
Speaker 8 (01:13:43–01:13:44)
It's because it's the fourth floor.
Speaker 7 (01:13:51–01:13:59)
You can't even believe yourself. feet off the floor. Yeah, you can't reach it.
Speaker 10 (01:13:59–01:14:30)
Just to make a comment on that. I mean, realistically, if you've ever gone in a house in an attic in the summertime, it's hot as bananas. It's hot. These are kids going up there.
I mean, this is a worthwhile investment to keep them cool and focused, because let's face it, in the springtime, I can't speak for everybody else, but for me, when it started getting hot, it was hard to pay attention. And if it's 1,000 degrees in the room, how are you gonna block it in and focus? It's a no-brainer cool space. I mean, it's fun.
Speaker 13 (01:14:30–01:14:52)
Especially if you're putting it to the studs. I mean, everybody who does a renovation on their home isn't like, they put an HVAC in. Like, are you going to build the new school and just open up the windows? No, you're going to put a central air in there, a cooling system.
So any time you do a renovation, you add what would make the environment more comfortable.
Speaker 14 (01:14:54–01:15:01)
I definitely appreciate hearing that from my colleagues. I feel like we have to ask the hard questions. This is a question I can imagine coming up on town meeting floor.
Speaker 8 (01:15:01–01:15:51)
Sure. I also want to say, when we say cooling, we're not talking about turning the temperatures down to like 60 degrees, and it's a nice, frosty, like you experience. This is for air circulation. This is for comfort, which is a different level of experience.
This is not. It is not your traditional air conditioning experience. This is purely for comfort. And I'd just like to reiterate about how hot it was.
We were there for an hour. I personally was ready to pass out. It was hot, hot up there. And if you're going to have teachers using that space in the summer for project planning and for other events, I know that the students hosted during the summer, that space would not be viable.
Speaker 14 (01:15:53–01:16:01)
Still on the HPAC, I work for Eversource, so I know mass save is a big thing with us. Have you looked at mass save rebates? Is that part of the budget?
Speaker 8 (01:16:03–01:16:28)
You know, we did not look at mass save rebates for this, but it was part of one of the questions that we'd be sending to the bidders to see if they could help have that conversation, the scale and the scope of this project. We were unsure of the rebates at the time. It would be working with the subcontractors more specifically for guidance on that particular one.
Speaker 14 (01:16:30–01:16:30)
Okay.
Speaker 1 (01:16:31–01:16:36)
I have a… Can I go next? Sure, sure, sure. Ron.
Ron has a question.
Speaker 15 (01:16:38–01:17:10)
Hi, thanks for the presentation and the information. I don't know much about library design, but I assume there have been a lot of advances in how modern libraries are built today. And I would think a lot more technology and a lot more technical capabilities for students to learn Will this library be provisioned like the current library, or are we going to try and make it more moderate? And is that kind of cost baked into this development budget?
Thank you.
Speaker 8 (01:17:13–01:17:53)
Well, we're going to tie into the existing billing system. So if you want access to the internet and all the things, that's going to be fully available. I know, I'm pretty sure that there's an existing Wi-Fi system that we'd have to talk the subcontractor would talk and tie into all that system. But the kind of technology that you're talking about, particularly for the elementary school level, will come from the hardware, like the laptops, the devices.
So yes, all of the space will be cabled, and you'll have access to it. But I think the level for the elementary schools will really depend on what kind of devices are provided to them for their use.
Speaker 1 (01:18:01–01:18:03)
Oh, Brian just raised his hand. Brian.
Speaker 16 (01:18:06–01:18:15)
Hey, guys. I'm from Belize. Thank you. They're complaining about the cold here because it's 73 degrees out.
Speaker 1 (01:18:16–01:18:19)
So thanks, Brian. Appreciate it.
Speaker 6 (01:18:19–01:18:23)
He's in Belize. Cooling, right?
Speaker 16 (01:18:24–01:20:13)
Yeah, talk about cooling. Anyways, I want to say I did get a tour from principals, and I really appreciate it. And they were great at highlighting the issues. And both my kids did go to collar cots, so a lot of fond memories of that.
I have a couple of comments. One is on the bid process. I think we should just, I mentioned this last night, but if you look at the average cost of building an office space in Boston. It's about in the mid $300 range, like 350.
And this is coming in at about $500 a square foot, which is adding like another million dollars to the project. And I think we should be really make sure that we're aggressive with the bid and make sure that we go out to every possible person we can. And I know it was an open bid process, but a lot of contractors in the business need to be notified about the bids. That's one comment.
I do agree with Allison. We need to revive the modular study and take a look at that and see, look at adding on that. We should probably look at the second floor of Glover too. I know that was mentioned six years ago on that study.
And maybe we should revisit that. And the last question I have is when you read, or the comment I have is, When I took the tour on that day, it was a very cold day. And most of the windows on the second floor, I think it was, were open. And the comment was that the heating system's not that great.
So if we were rehabbing this, and so money's going out the window, we should use this as an opportunity to fix the HVAC in the entire building, I'd say. That's it.
Speaker 1 (01:20:14–01:20:26)
Thank you, Brian. Would anybody be able to speak maybe to the air conditioning or just the air issues at the school?
Speaker 7 (01:20:27–01:20:56)
I mean, if you want to get into the building management system, we have a system and it controls the temperatures throughout the building. I can't speak for a teacher that feels hot or cold and decides to open a window. We can't police that every minute of the day. Brian did bring that up when I talked to Holly.
got anything back yet, but they certainly shouldn't be opening windows in the winter. I can assure you of that.
Speaker 1 (01:20:57–01:21:01)
In your estimation, is the system working well? Is it working?
Speaker 7 (01:21:01–01:21:42)
Yeah, I mean, we monitor it, there's nothing. The problem is, people don't understand, is you bring a certain temperature, it's cold outside, you're bringing air in, and you're circulating it and heating it so it's not just pulling cold air. So when it's really cold out, it's going to blow warmer air than maybe somebody thinks it should be. And it's the same in the spring and the fall when it's that, am I wearing a sweatshirt today or not?
It's that fine line, the system is doing its job. So I don't see any major faults in the system.
Speaker 1 (01:21:42–01:21:43)
Jay.
Speaker 14 (01:21:44–01:22:16)
You spoke earlier about, so there's a question of, will this change our need for a new school? And I believe your answer was no. I guess my question as a follow-up to that is, you had the MSBA tour Cunningham and Collicott. And now we're building something to improve the situation at Cunningham and Collicott.
Will they feel like it's a bait and switch? Will this endanger our MSBA? It just sets off my spider sense.
Speaker 4 (01:22:17–01:22:54)
No, I don't think it'll have any impact on that if they review the spaces that I believe, as we were walking around, we told them we were working on a project to utilize these spaces. But yeah, I don't think there's any kind of impact on MSBA. I mean, we're in the MSBA program now. moving towards module one on May 1st, so I feel, I don't think it's gonna have any bearing on, it will help, it's still very overcrowded.
Speaker 1 (01:22:57–01:22:58)
Lori?
Speaker 9 (01:22:59–01:26:07)
Oh, so I will back up. We, as Lizzie mentioned, I'm on the capital committee and we had talked about this a couple of times and then we were talking about the MSBA one and a half million for the feasibility study. And I had asked why that was happening in February, why not in May? And I think we've all talked about that here with Nick.
And it's just trying to get things off of May, get it done. It's not necessary. But we're not going to spend that money until we're in the program. MSBA has their program.
And we're thrilled to be in it, because we'll have a reimbursement. But as Allison mentioned, for those of us that have been here, we've been talking about there's a space problem for three years. And we're talking about, we're going to do this, we're going to do that. But it's all long term.
And I know personally, I've asked every year, what are we doing about the short term? And we weren't doing anything. I mean, we're talking about it, but we weren't getting there. But now that we got it, these guys, Mark and Anna on the facilities, did this, the fourth floor, and made that happen.
And then when we were at Capitol, we were talking about this was go to May, but we wouldn't start it this summer. I'm like, oh my gosh. It just really begs to be done. We have to do it.
It's a building we have. As Nick said, it's a 30-year investment. We'll pay for it over 30 years. It might be $400,000, but we're improving the space.
We're getting them space in a year. They need space. They needed space. We've heard it for years.
needs to happen. So I'm all in. Everything you've said, thank you so much for your help. Thank you so much for your work.
Thank you for going on the tours. I did go tour the space as part of the Capitol. I said I'd like to see the space. I went to see it.
And yeah, I mean, in the Holly and John did do a full tour, which I really just wanted to see the third floor. I don't need to see anything else. I believe it's crowded. I just want to go upstairs.
Okay, we'll start on the basement. So great, you know, great tour. They were very gracious, very expeditious too. I felt, you know, felt bad being, taking them away from their day job, but it's just, Incredible.
And the number was calculated based on last year, the 2 million. This is the square footage on the fourth floor. This is the average rate. This is the 2 million.
It was done to get a number, to get appropriated, to move forward with it. Now we've had it. We've talked to Arrow Street, got the work done, got a detailed analysis, priced it out. They've made some adjustments.
You guys have done a great job. Please, I beg you, let's vote to approve this.
Speaker 10 (01:26:12–01:26:17)
That's the most I've ever heard her speak in the morning.
Speaker 9 (01:26:18–01:26:23)
You're my fiscal North Star.
Speaker 1 (01:26:25–01:26:52)
You know, Lori, I appreciate all your work on capital here, the committee and everything else you do and keeping me informed of what's going on on the schools. And I know all members of the subcommittee working with the schools in this project. Thank you. So thank you.
Does anybody have any questions or comments they'd like to share with our great panel here? Who? Oh, Ron.
Speaker 15 (01:26:55–01:27:35)
Yeah, thank you. I think I've heard multiple comments that we haven't done anything in the past three or four years. And while maybe that's true in terms of capital expenditure, I think that maybe doesn't appreciate all the struggles that the administration and faculty have made to find space with the limited resources that we have. So I would just say maybe we haven't found a plan to go build or develop space in the short term, but I do think This committee and the employees of this town and the schools have done a lot to find space for these kids.
I'll just make that comment. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (01:27:36–01:27:38)
Ron, thank you. Lori, follow up?
Speaker 9 (01:27:38–01:28:17)
Yes. And Ron, I did not mean it that way. I'm looking for a substantial. They're tweaking little spaces.
One closet, oh, we better take this closet back. Put the copiers in the vestibule, in the entryway of the school. They're doing that, but I mean, this is substantial. I think this is a substantial investment, it's a build, and it's gonna give them much more space that, you know, cannibalizing the existing building is, they've been doing that.
It's not been a big spend. It's been a little bit of a spend, but it's not, this is big.
Speaker 3 (01:28:18–01:28:58)
Let's do it. Can I just say one quick thing? Yep, agreed. Thank you.
Because really, Laurie, just to appreciate you having sat with you, seeing your diligence and you do pay close attention and, you know, thinking really in that reality of our limited resources and whatever you all decide as a committee, you know, I just want to say I really appreciate your support of this project and your your ability to sort of articulate the way you just did. What we have been trying to say, but I think you've had a powerful voice on it, and we just want to thank you for that.
Speaker 14 (01:28:58–01:29:12)
Okay. Mr. Chair, I know we often have our guests, we talk to our guests, then they leave, then we talk amongst ourselves, then we vote. I'm wondering if right now, especially after my colleague's passionate speech, if we're just ready to vote, right?
Speaker 1 (01:29:14–01:29:22)
Am I getting the sense from the committee that we'd like to maybe waive discussion and vote?
Speaker 11 (01:29:22–01:30:26)
Laurie, discuss. I just wanted to make a comment because you said comments were OK. Please. I agree.
I absolutely, absolutely want this to happen. My concern in hearing that the sort of energy efficient heat pumps and solar panels and things like that haven't even been considered is concerning to me given the vote at town meeting last year for the specialized stretch code and how even given the two thirds threshold, it was easily reached. To me, that was kind of a mandate from town meeting that that's really important to them. And because this isn't simply a temporary solution, but is going to be used forever, I just have, I'm concerned that that could trip things up at town meeting for this project.
So, more of a statement. I'm not sure that there's anything we as a committee can do about that right now, but just wanted to name that.
Speaker 7 (01:30:27–01:30:53)
I'm sorry. I just wanted to mention that there are solar panels on top of the college on the school. Existing. It's actually one of the few that we own in town.
We don't have an agreement where we, you know, a paid agreement. So we own those. Full disclosure, there's an issue with the inverter and we're working on it right now.
Speaker 11 (01:30:53–01:30:56)
Are those going to be used as part of this new construction though?
Speaker 7 (01:30:56–01:31:05)
No, it's more to offset the energy use in the building as a whole. So everything's going to be tied together.
Speaker 11 (01:31:11–01:31:15)
But there's no net new solar?
Speaker 7 (01:31:15–01:31:18)
Yeah, there's no room left on the roof.
Speaker 11 (01:31:18–01:31:20)
OK, that's helpful to know.
Speaker 9 (01:31:21–01:31:24)
I was going to say, there's solar panels.
Speaker 1 (01:31:24–01:31:29)
Does anybody have any further comments?
Speaker 9 (01:31:30–01:31:37)
Well, and I think to your point, I suppose it's certainly worth investigating the heat pumps and the energy efficiency.
Speaker 8 (01:31:44–01:34:22)
that are going in meet code. They meet the code. What we don't have to do is energy modeling or any of that sort of advanced energy modeling that's required by stretch code because we are not touching the exterior of the building. So this is an interior fit-out project.
It is not a full building renovation. That is a different type of project and a different scope. We meet code. I just want to make that clear that we are not cutting any corners.
We put the best, most energy efficient system in that can fit in a space that is very limited. I can get you specific details on the exact type of system. I don't have that handy at the moment. I didn't think to look it up before.
I didn't think I was going to get questions on condensers. If you're handling units today, I thought it was going to be more square footage. So I apologize. And just to speak to solar panels as well, just for an FYI, architects don't do solar panel work.
We will provide a stub up to the roof and then we will vendor it out because it would be incredibly expensive to hire us. But your roof that is over the library would not be viable. experience of working with the vendors. And I'm speaking to you as somebody who works at an architecture firm that is incredibly sustainably formed.
We have been named one of the most sustainable design architecture firms in the state several years running. So I'm not trying to dismiss your thoughts or ideas, because I think they're incredible. And I really appreciate that you're But I am also trying to be mindful of a budget and a limitation. When we walked into this project, we were told $2 million all in.
And we as a team struggled to get you there, to get between the feasibility and the CDs, we were able to cut just under 20% of the cost. That is unheard of to see that significant this team really pulled it together. So I would love to be able to give you all of the bells and whistles, but we need to strike a balance.
Speaker 11 (01:34:24–01:34:26)
Thank you for the information. It's helpful.
Speaker 1 (01:34:28–01:34:47)
Okay. Well, thank you very much. I think we're all set with questions and comments. I really appreciate your time.
and all the effort and energy you put into this project. And I'd like to thank the committee, too, for your questions and diligence. Thank you. So I think we're going to take a vote.
Speaker 9 (01:34:47–01:34:49)
So I'd like to make a motion.
Speaker 1 (01:34:50–01:34:50)
OK.
Speaker 9 (01:34:51–01:34:54)
I'd like Lori to make a motion. OK.
Speaker 1 (01:34:54–01:35:42)
I'm going to second it. So just for the record and for our wonderful clerk, we'll start. So we'll start off with what we've been talking about right here, right now, recently. So that'd be the Cunningham Project, a numbered article in our draft warrant.
that states to see at the time we'll vote to appropriate, borrow, transfer from available funds and amount of money for the purposes of a renovation project on the third and fourth floors of the Cunningham School of 44 Edge Hill Road, Milton Mass, 02186, and to act on anything relating thereto, submitted by the school committee. I have a motion to take a vote from Lori, second from Peter. Karen, can you call the roll?
Speaker 13 (01:35:44–01:35:44)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:35:47–01:35:47)
Tom.
Speaker 1 (01:35:47–01:35:48)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:35:48–01:35:49)
Steve.
Speaker 1 (01:35:49–01:35:49)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:35:50–01:35:58)
Laurie. Yes. Liz. Yes.
Jay. Yes. Allison. Yes.
Julia.
Speaker 16 (01:35:58–01:35:59)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:35:59–01:36:00)
Peter.
Speaker 16 (01:36:00–01:36:01)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:36:01–01:36:01)
Brian.
Speaker 16 (01:36:02–01:36:03)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:36:04–01:36:04)
Aman.
Speaker 16 (01:36:05–01:36:05)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:36:06–01:36:14)
Ron. Yes. Judy. Yes.
Motion carries.
Speaker 1 (01:36:14–01:36:15)
Unanimous, thank you.
Speaker 2 (01:36:15–01:36:25)
I think Nick Milano has his hand up. Does Nick have his hand up? Nick has his hand up. Mr.
Milano.
Speaker 17 (01:36:27–01:36:56)
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sorry to intervene. I would just note for the committee that that draft motion is subject to approval by Bar Council.
So just as long as the committee is comfortable with it, we'll, with this vote, work with Bar Council to finalize that recommendation with their sign off. So it might look, the verbiage might be slightly different with the attorney's final review. Just want to make sure that's okay with the chair.
Speaker 1 (01:36:57–01:36:58)
That's fine.
Speaker 2 (01:36:58–01:36:59)
Subject to final.
Speaker 1 (01:36:59–01:37:23)
Subject to final. Yes, that's fine, Mr. Milano. Okay, thank you.
I appreciate that. Thank you for pointing that out. Members of the committee, if anything comes up regarding the language or the verbiage, we will revisit this and I will inform everybody promptly upon hearing from the town administrator. So I don't see any issues, however, at this time.
I'd like to move on to the next article.
Speaker 9 (01:37:23–01:37:23)
Thank you very much. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (01:37:24–01:37:25)
Thank you very much.
Speaker 14 (01:37:25–01:37:27)
Thank you. Thank you for being here.
Speaker 1 (01:37:31–01:37:32)
We're going to vote on everything.
Speaker 12 (01:37:32–01:37:47)
No, we talked about it already. Nobody asked any questions. He asked if anybody had any questions about anything and everybody didn't say yes. They were here before.
And everyone's comfortable with the committee, right?
Speaker 2 (01:37:47–01:37:50)
Yeah, I'm comfortable with it. I'm ready.
Speaker 1 (01:37:50–01:38:35)
We're going to go to Oh, we were going to see if the, this is to amend article six. We're unnumbered. Yeah, it's an unnumbered article to see if the town will vote to amend article six of the 2019 February special town meeting by adding positions to the school building committee established by said article six. This is what we discussed.
This was brought forward, submitted by the school committee. And you had indicated that Mr. O'Rourke is on.
Speaker 2 (01:38:35–01:38:39)
He's here. I don't know if he has anything to say.
Speaker 1 (01:38:39–01:39:31)
OK. Mr. O'Rourke, I appreciate you very much being on Zoom for us tonight. Does anybody right now Have any questions for Mr.
O'Rourke regarding the amendment of article six and adding the positions to the school building committee, including the superintendent of schools, town administrator, director of consolidated facilities, MCPPO certification appointed by the school committee, a member with MCPPO certification, the school principal, a school principal appointed by the school committee, and a local budget official. appointed by Mr. Milano, the town administrator. Does anybody have any questions for Mr.
O'Rourke as it pertains to this unnumbered article? No. Mr. O'Rourke, is there anything that you'd like to add or say to the committee?
We were planning on taking a vote on this.
Speaker 18 (01:39:32–01:39:50)
Yeah, sorry, Mr. Chair. Oh, no, no, no. I was joining mainly just as a spectator, and I got asked to be a panelist twice, so I didn't know I was going to be speaking.
I'll happily be a fly on the wall tonight, so I'm not here to speak on anything.
Speaker 1 (01:39:50–01:40:22)
Thank you. Mr. O'Rourke, I see you, you're here all the time. I always want to give you a chance to speak if you do.
And thank you for your work on all this also. So I'm going to, I'd ask, I think from the committee, we'll put this out unnumbered article to the vote to amend article six of the February special town meeting of 2019. Karen, can you call the roll? I need a motion.
Oh yeah, sorry, I need a motion. I'm getting too ahead of myself. Does anybody have a motion as to the unnumbered article concerning the amendment of article six to add positions to the school building committee?
Speaker 12 (01:40:23–01:40:23)
Yeah, I move.
Speaker 1 (01:40:23–01:40:31)
Liz Dillon moves. Do I have a second? Julia Maxwell second. We're gonna move to a vote.
Karen? Thank you.
Speaker 2 (01:40:33–01:40:41)
Tom? Yes. Steve? Yes.
Lori? Yes. Liz? Yes.
Jane?
Speaker 14 (01:40:41–01:40:41)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:40:42–01:40:55)
Allison? Allison? Come back. Julia?
Speaker 11 (01:40:55–01:40:55)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:40:56–01:40:56)
Peter?
Speaker 11 (01:40:57–01:40:58)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:40:58–01:40:58)
Brian?
Speaker 11 (01:40:59–01:40:59)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:41:00–01:41:01)
Aman?
Speaker 16 (01:41:02–01:41:02)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:41:03–01:41:18)
Ron? Yes. Judy? Yes.
And we'll try for Allison again. Yes. And yes for Allison.
Speaker 1 (01:41:18–01:42:16)
Okay, unanimous, second in a row. Okay, there's one final school article. I am asking the committee to vote. I think we're here with this, and this is concerning the MSBA.
So, just very briefly, this is an unnumbered article in our draft warrant to see if the town will vote to appropriate, borrow, or transfer from available funds an amount of money to be expended under the direction of the School Building Committee for a feasibility study of an elementary or middle school project for Cunningham School 44 Edge Hill Road, Milton, Mass., for which feasibility study the town might be eligible from a grant from the Massachusetts School Building Authority. So that is the article submitted by the school committee. Do I see, do I have any motion? Lori, do I have a second as to this article?
Speaker 6 (01:42:17–01:42:19)
Yeah, I'll second.
Speaker 1 (01:42:19–01:42:28)
Okay, Ms. Dillon, second. Okay, so I move forward to a vote. Karen, can you call the roll as to this article?
Speaker 2 (01:42:31–01:42:31)
Tom.
Speaker 1 (01:42:32–01:42:32)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:42:33–01:42:33)
Steve?
Speaker 14 (01:42:33–01:42:34)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:42:34–01:42:38)
Lori? Yes. Liz? Yes.
Jay?
Speaker 14 (01:42:38–01:42:38)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:42:39–01:42:45)
Allison? Yes. Julia?
Speaker 8 (01:42:45–01:42:46)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:42:46–01:42:47)
Peter?
Speaker 8 (01:42:47–01:42:48)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:42:48–01:42:48)
Brian?
Speaker 8 (01:42:49–01:42:49)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (01:42:50–01:43:01)
Imam? Yes. Ron? Yes.
Judy? Yes. Motion carries.
Speaker 1 (01:43:01–01:44:18)
Thank you all, all three unanimous for the schools. Thank you all for your work on this, and especially your diligence tonight, I appreciate it. Okay, we're moving on. We have Town Council Attorney Mello present.
I don't know if we have Mr. Milano still on Zoom, but Town Council, I'd invite you to step to the table. We have been eagerly anticipating your coming here to address authorizing the consumption of intoxicating beverages on town property, it previously being forbidden. And we are asking, this article asks us to now to allow that.
And I had a couple of members, and I appreciate that, forwarding me some questions. Mr. Mello that we just had, and they're really focused about risk to the town and liability, you know, as we discussed. And so I think I'd allow you if you want, if you want to make any type of statement just in terms of what you've done and what you've looked at in terms of this article.
Speaker 19 (01:44:19–01:48:08)
Thanks again for being here. probably a lot of the concerns could be addressed in a brief, concise summary. It's a good question, an important question. There are obviously risks associated with allowing alcohol to be consumed or served on town property.
There are ways for the town to minimize the risk and to protect itself from risks associated with those activities. I think most importantly, the town would want to secure from organizations that want to host events that feature alcohol, certain contractual concessions, like most prominent among them in my mind would be insurance protections that, for example, this is something we work closely with the town's insurers or insurance agents to confirm, but we would require that they have appropriate coverage that means the town is an additional insurer party. And we obviously want to work with the insurers to identify not only the appropriate forms of coverage but also the best optimal limits. And we'd also want to include provisions that require a defense indemnity in the event any claims arise against the town.
In other words, that the organization would be required to defend and indemnify the town from any claims. We want to have provisions that require that anyone serving alcohol is appropriately certified, TIP certified, for example, or otherwise appropriately licensed. And I think We should take some solace, if that's the right word, in the fact that the town's probably protected in most cases from extreme exposure by virtue of the TOR Claims Act. Because as a practical matter, most legal claims that would arise typically from events involving alcohol would be negligence-based or tort-based claims with respect to which the town would be protected by the liability cap that is provided under the Tort Claims Act of $100,000.
a combination of the insurance protections that we would secure from any organizations that would host events, other contractual requirements that would promise indemnity and waive liability or claims against the town, and, you know, measures that would best facilitate smooth operations and hopefully prevent situations from arising, like ensuring that any staff serving alcohol is appropriately certified and trained, could protect the town from, as a practical matter, from claims and liability. So, happy to answer any questions, but I think that generally summarizes it. You want good solid insurance protection, the right coverage, the right amount. You want good contractual protections that would entitle the town to indemnity and defense.
You would want to make sure that staff is appropriately trained. And that's about it in a nutshell.
Speaker 1 (01:48:09–01:49:00)
I'd like to start out, so, Mr. Mello, Attorney Mello, how would that like, you know, just kind of a hypothetical. Somebody wants to rent out the library, you know, get some type of fundraiser, debt together. They'd like to serve liquor.
So whomever approaches the Slack board and says this is what we'd like to do. So what would the response be from a town council? What would this process look like? So the Slack board might say, that's great.
We'd love to have you do this event at the library. We'll give you a one day license to serve. So how would that application look? What things as town council would you require?
You've got into it. What I'm saying is like, how would you execute that? How would the process go?
Speaker 19 (01:49:00–01:51:32)
Yeah, so the bylaw would require advance approval of the select board, and also in addition to the select board, any board or department with control of the subject town property. It would always require the select board's approval, but with respect to property that's managed or overseen by a different board, it would also require the separate approval of the board. So we would require as a condition of any approval that, which would need to occur in advance of the event, that they agree to contractual terms. And I haven't, you know, we have plenty of forms that we could use.
I haven't had occasion yet to, you know, prepare the form or the template we probably would require. And I think depending on the event or the circumstance, won't necessarily always be verbatim from one contract to the next. There may be unique circumstances that warrant different provisions in different contracts, but we would follow a general template that would include the language that I described. And again, among the most prominent important provisions in any of those agreements would be really tight insurance requirements that we would formulate after conferring with the town's insurer.
And again, we would want to make sure that we enumerate any policy, any rider that would typically be required with respect to these types of events. and make sure that the town's named as an additional insured, make sure that we obtain insurance certificates from the hosts, and even require that we obtain copies of the policies themselves to confirm. The certificate's just a one-page document that just identifies the coverages and the amounts and whether the town's an additional insured in the terms of the coverage, in terms of the duration. But we, I think, would also include language that requires the to actually provide a copy of the policies in question so that we can be assuaged before any approval is granted that we're sufficiently protected.
Speaker 1 (01:51:33–01:51:39)
Okay, and just to follow up with that, would you be working with the town administrator to be putting that together?
Speaker 19 (01:51:39–01:51:40)
Oh yeah, absolutely.
Speaker 1 (01:51:40–01:52:05)
Okay, and then I assume going back to the select board and telling them we've completed the process, everything's okay. Like, so I just wanna know, like, if you were one of these people, or just for town meeting, like, you know, the select board is approached, you work with the town administrator to get all the necessary insurance, riders, the documents, make sure everything's fine, like, what happens after that?
Speaker 19 (01:52:06–01:52:37)
Yeah, and I guess I, some of the particulars, I guess, are subject to, you know, I'd wanna have a discussion with Nick and others about, how they prefer to handle all of the exact steps and sequencing. But what I would envision is that before any vote is taken, we would have an executed copy of the agreement from the other side. And that upon the select board's approval, it would be signed by the appropriate town signatory.
Speaker 1 (01:52:38–01:52:44)
And that would probably be the select board and the chair of the committee, library trustees or whatever.
Speaker 19 (01:52:44–01:53:29)
Right. Yeah. the chair of the select board or the, you know, the select board, I think, would take the vote to authorize and perhaps authorize a designee town administrator or, you know, or the select board chair. However, that can be handled, you know, that it's subject to preference and logistical convenience and all that.
But no, the bottom line is, I think that we would require that any agreement be executed by the other side in advance of any vote. And certainly any vote would be required before any event occurred.
Speaker 1 (01:53:32–01:53:42)
Does anybody, any other member of the committee have any questions for Attorney Mello regarding this article? Jay.
Speaker 14 (01:53:43–01:54:07)
This is very nitpicky. a residential house, I believe, owned by the cemetery, leased out to people who live there, and that's their home. Are we just saying, see no evil, hear no evil? Or would the select board and the cemetery trustees say, you can drink in your own house?
It's a silly question, but it's also a real question.
Speaker 19 (01:54:07–01:54:56)
Yeah, no, absolutely. I think that's, I guess the way this proposed article reads to me is that it would require advance approval on a kind of an instance by instance basis. I guess there could be, it's conceivable, there could be situations in which, provided we have the appropriate contractual protection secured, an approval could authorize multiple instances or multiple events? I don't know, I guess it's a good question, Jay, and I think it's worth, I'm glad you raised it, because I think it's worth vetting and thinking more.
Speaker 14 (01:54:56–01:55:00)
Yeah, I'm not talking about them having a party at their house, I'm talking about them drinking a beer in the evening.
Speaker 19 (01:55:01–01:56:51)
Yeah, yeah, and I think, you know, I guess my initial thought is that the authorization takes whatever form the vote takes. I mean, the select board has final say in what it wants to approve and on what terms and how that will look. I guess what I was saying is I envision as a practical matter that if most times the way this would work is if the organization wanted to host an event on town property that featured alcohol, they would come to the select board on an event-by-event basis. That's kind of a unique scenario and I think requires some thought, but the bottom line is that any any use, any consumption or service would require advance approval by the select board.
Now, what form does that authorization take? Ultimately, it would be in the select board's discretion, but it's worth thinking about. You wouldn't want to, I think it's an excellent point, you wouldn't want to frame an authorization in kind of an open-ended fashion that could be construed to authorize service or consumption beyond what the board intends, you know, some sort of carte blanche, you know, right to use alcohol on a particular property, we would want to avoid that. So it's, I think in addition to all these protections, we want to make sure that any authorizing vote is framed and tailored appropriately.
Speaker 14 (01:56:52–01:57:03)
Is this something we'd want to hammer out before the February town meeting, or is it something we'll figure out with the select board after that?
Speaker 19 (01:57:03–01:57:14)
I think it could be. It's something that the board should be mindful of and aware of.
Speaker 1 (01:57:19–01:57:37)
But is there something… Yeah, I was just gonna make a comment to Jay and then Attorney Mello. I think, and maybe Liz can chime in. I think we could distinguish those situations in terms of the intent of the article.
We're talking about social host liability. and thing like Dram Shop. Yeah.
Speaker 12 (01:57:37–01:57:38)
I love a good Dram Shop.
Speaker 1 (01:57:38–01:58:06)
Yeah. So like, Jay, I appreciate it because that's like, that is a good nitpicking question. And that's something I would see on the floor. But I, Cherry Miller, if I'm off base on this, like, you know, they're renting a home private for purposes of private residence.
So I'd like to see, look at the lease. I think, I think it's not the same situation that they are, that they know the intention of the article. I could be wrong, but that would be like my, on my feed answer.
Speaker 14 (01:58:07–01:58:16)
I get that I caught you off guard. I'm just wondering, do we have to do something before town meeting four weeks from now, or is this somebody else's job?
Speaker 19 (01:58:16–01:59:00)
I think that the article is framed broadly enough to confer a lot of latitude upon the select board to decide these types of questions. I think that's probably the most appropriate way to frame it. I guess the short answer is I think the way the article is currently framed gives the board the authority to decide, again, on what terms it will allow alcohol to be consumed on any town property, including the property you described, which I think is the right way to frame it.
Speaker 1 (01:59:02–01:59:02)
Liz.
Speaker 12 (01:59:02–01:59:06)
I don't know why you brought me into that hole for Jay and maybe Liz.
Speaker 1 (01:59:06–01:59:08)
I thought you were looking at me.
Speaker 12 (01:59:08–01:59:10)
I was looking at you for a different reason.
Speaker 1 (01:59:11–01:59:13)
Do you have anything you'd like to say? Yes.
Speaker 12 (01:59:13–01:59:18)
I did not raise my hand to excoriate. I raised my hand to ask a question.
Speaker 1 (01:59:18–01:59:20)
I thought, you know, I was getting the feel.
Speaker 12 (01:59:22–01:59:55)
Mr. Milano had mentioned the last time he was here that the town was going to be working with their insurer who had made certain recommendations. And I just want a clarification. You have listed the things that I would tell.
I would tell my workplace to do in this scenario. So I feel good about that, but I just wanted to make sure that all of the insurer's recommendations have been implemented.
Speaker 19 (01:59:57–02:02:29)
It would be implemented. Yeah. It's hard to capture it in the article, but rest assured that the contractual protections that we would secure from organizations would include language that I think is pretty copious. The table lays out all the insurance requirements.
And I'm thinking, as I'm saying this, of language we include in templates with contractors. And it enumerates all the different types of coverage, CGL, commercial general liability, professional liability, Umbrella, workers' comp, has a standalone paragraph that requires that the municipality be additionally insured. It has language that requires that if the insurance coverage is terminated, that we receive advance notice. It's pretty carefully delineated and with something like this, I think you want to get really granular and not just identify policies, but riders and frame it so as to maximize the protections of the town.
And that's, as a practical matter, that's something that we really need to work with the insurance agent to craft because they're intimately familiar with the types of covers that are available on the market. and the appropriate amounts that we want. Sometimes you run into issues when you're dealing with organizations, particularly organizations without a lot of resources, dealing with insurance requirements because they can be, in some cases, cost prohibitive, and requiring a $10 million umbrella policy as opposed to a $5 million umbrella policy can, With some parties, they don't blink an eye. With others, that's really meaningful, and that'll drive up their premiums in a cost-prohibitive way.
So you want to make sure that you have the appropriate coverage. And that's something we would work closely with the town's insurance agent. That's an exercise we would work closely with the insurance agent in undertaking.
Speaker 6 (02:02:32–02:02:34)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (02:02:34–02:02:42)
Anybody online? You want to have any other questions for Tony Mello, our town council?
Speaker 9 (02:02:44–02:02:49)
No, I liked everything you had to say. OK, be comfortable.
Speaker 1 (02:02:50–02:02:58)
this. Okay. Attorney Mello, I appreciate you coming back. And thank you very much for waiting around.
Speaker 19 (02:02:58–02:03:01)
No problem at all.
Speaker 14 (02:03:01–02:03:01)
Good to see you.
Speaker 1 (02:03:02–02:03:04)
Good to see you, sir. I'm sure we'll be speaking again.
Speaker 6 (02:03:04–02:03:06)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (02:03:10–02:03:20)
I guess now we can have a discussion. If we'd like. Anybody would like to maybe speak to anything?
Speaker 12 (02:03:20–02:03:21)
I'm going to comment.
Speaker 1 (02:03:21–02:03:22)
Sure. Brief.
Speaker 12 (02:03:24–02:03:49)
Please. I was very heartened by Mr. Milano's statements yesterday about the fact that these would all be at open Slack board meetings and people would have a chance to weigh in in the neighborhood. And that made me feel a lot better about some of my questions.
And I knew that Attorney Mello would have good answers about the liability, but it was nice to hear about that too. So I appreciated that from both of them.
Speaker 1 (02:03:50–02:03:55)
Thank you, Liz. Anyone else have any comments just as to the?
Speaker 9 (02:03:55–02:03:57)
Yeah. Oh, I'm sorry.
Speaker 1 (02:03:57–02:03:59)
Oh, no. Go right ahead.
Speaker 9 (02:03:59–02:04:19)
I was just going to say, I feel like his point on the provisions of defense and indemnity, I didn't even think about that before. But that made me feel better. Because the indemnification wore off the hook. he hit on every single thing.
Speaker 12 (02:04:19–02:04:43)
So you're thinking to yourself, yes, yes, yes. So that made me feel, I would not expect any less, but still, that made me feel very comfortable. And it's true that the insurer would be able to help, because they'll say, this is what you need in order for us to insure this. And if you don't have that, then we won't.
And then, of course, you wouldn't do it. So that's good.
Speaker 1 (02:04:45–02:05:26)
I'll bring this up and I'll bring it up just because it's come up in past town meetings from a long, long time ago. Any policy considerations for drinking on town property? Anybody have any concerns about that generally? I know historically, Milton's been a dry town for a while, a long time.
I remember when Abbey Park and those liquor licenses were coming out. It's a lot of conversation at town meeting about the expansion of consumption of liquor in the town. So I just didn't know. I just want to raise it.
It's come up before historically. So I don't know if there was any member of the committee that has anything to say about that. And I just feel like I got to bring it up.
Speaker 20 (02:05:26–02:05:30)
I'd like to welcome Milton out of prohibition.
Speaker 1 (02:05:31–02:05:50)
Well, Peter, I thought I was gonna, you know, get some, you know, that Cary Nation tea total. But no, I just think it's a valid thing. I just, I just didn't know if anybody had any issues wanting to speak to Liz.
Speaker 12 (02:05:50–02:06:35)
Well, the thing that also makes me feel better about it when I was talking now, when Attorney Mello was answering my question, is it's true that because they're going to require insurance of a certain level, you're not going to have a group of like three friends forming a fake society in order to do it and drink, let's go drink on the deck. That can't happen because you're not going to spend that much money. And if you want to and you want to be insured to that level, go ahead. Because then the town is protected and the people of Milton are protected, fine.
I think that it's, you know, I was worried before about it being a slippery slope, but I was really glad to have Attorney Mello come in because I don't think that that's really possible with the insurance that we're talking about. So that was helpful.
Speaker 1 (02:06:36–02:06:38)
Okay. Any other comments?
Speaker 20 (02:06:38–02:07:34)
The only comment I guess is, you know, if you're sponsoring something, it's going to cost you something. And where does the money come from? So if you're the library, for example, and you're the friends of the library outside, they can understand that. if they want to pony up and have a fundraiser if they're paying for it.
But I don't think we want departments going along, you know, having their own parties on the town's property, given the cost for insurance, etc. If they want to pay for it, I suppose they could. I see this more as a… That's why I asked the question yesterday about Are we selling it or are we distributing it?
If you're selling it and you can make enough money to pay for the event, then it makes sense. And I guess we don't really care who steps up to sponsor it and to make it work. Jack?
Speaker 14 (02:07:35–02:08:37)
Yeah, you made me think that we're the pre-time meeting. As much as we can, should hash out all the issues that are going to come up in time meeting and pre-solve them. This is a town meeting that, in the very recent past, voted not to allow marijuana dispensaries in town, and that was, as far as I can tell, entirely a moral slash health decision. It certainly was not an economic decision.
It's also a town where the primary form of entertainment among high schoolers seems to be drinking in the woods, and that's a problem in town, and a problem that we haven't solved. So I can see objections coming up on the floor of town meeting. I'm not sure if I could say exactly what those objections would be, except for sort of a moral, what sort of example are we setting? And do we feel like we've just, I don't know what our answer would be.
What would our answer be?
Speaker 1 (02:08:39–02:08:41)
Liz, do you have any ideas?
Speaker 14 (02:08:41–02:08:42)
Put your head down.
Speaker 1 (02:08:43–02:08:44)
I'm gonna write it down.
Speaker 12 (02:08:46–02:10:20)
I feel better about the drinking in public because we're having tip-certified bartenders to make sure that people are not getting over-served and that people are of age so that we're not serving minors on town property, which would be very bad. And so I feel that we're not, hopefully, not going to have people drinking to excess. I feel better about my traffic concerns because first of all, people would have an ability to go to the select board and say that they have concerns. Second of all, I think the select board would take that into consideration and also I think the idea would be that it would only be limited to a few times per area per year, like the two on the deck that we talked about.
I don't have a feeling that drinking is morally bad, so I can't speak to those people, but I think that a lot of it is being, I think it's a good compromise between those two positions because I think that the risk is really being dialed back as much as possible. I mean, I don't feel a need to drink like in public property, but, you know, I take… Who made that point? Brian made that point about…
Somebody made the point about bringing together community and camaraderie, and I think that that's true. And if more people attend these events, that's wonderful. Bring community together. I don't have a problem with that.
Speaker 1 (02:10:21–02:10:59)
Yeah, I agree with that. I think that's a very positive thing. I think bringing people to town together, I think over centuries, right, people have gone together to raise a glass. All in moderation, of course, but I think it is a good thing, and to Liz's point, that the protections are in place.
I think it's a benefit, and I think, based upon my observation of many of these get-togethers, that people are responsible, and that's a good thing, and I think it will only benefit the town as long as we can safeguard and we continue to be responsible.
Speaker 20 (02:11:00–02:11:02)
I think it really does well. I'm sorry.
Speaker 2 (02:11:02–02:11:05)
No, no, go ahead. Go ahead.
Speaker 20 (02:11:05–02:11:06)
I'm going to remember to raise my hand.
Speaker 2 (02:11:06–02:11:07)
Go ahead.
Speaker 12 (02:11:07–02:11:07)
No.
Speaker 20 (02:11:07–02:11:52)
Peter. I probably won't. But I'm going to try to remember. I think the select board, basically, the answer to your question, you know, if there's moral outrage or issues, it's going to fall on the select board to basically weigh in on that.
And even in town meeting, if there's suddenly a wave against this at town meeting, I'd be surprised, but if that happens, then… It still falls on the town meeting members and the select board to basically monitor this. Don't want to be the guardians of people's morals around alcohol. If it happens, we'll deal with it down the road.
Speaker 1 (02:11:54–02:11:58)
Anybody online?
Speaker 12 (02:11:58–02:12:45)
It's my hand. Yeah, of course. Oh, it's OK. I also think that by allowing it, legislating it, you keep it from happening in secret, so people might over-consume and then go to the Halloween event.
I don't know. People might drink at home and then go to the tree lighting. Here, if you're having alcohol served, you might wait until you get there, and then you have a TIFF certified bartender. So I think that maybe there's something to that as well.
And having additional police presence, having additional protections, having the opportunity for neighbors to speak about it, I think that brings a lot of openness about what might be going on anyway. So I think that that's welcome.
Speaker 1 (02:12:47–02:14:10)
Okay, well I appreciate it. Do I, is there a, so this is an unnumbered article to see if the town will vote to amend chapter 105, alcoholic beverages of the general bylaws by striking section 105-1. Consumption on town property prohibited. Consumption on leased premises and replacing it with the following.
And there's a series of language. In 105-1, consumption on town property and leased premises, sections A and B. B, not only, section A authorizes drinking, sale, or possession of alcoholic beverages on town property. And section B, for the record, is concerning a fine.
I do not think this fine will be an issue in this town meeting. Correct. So that's section B, and it authorizes the town clerk. So I'm not going to read the whole section, but we've all seen this in their draft article.
It's essentially going from prohibiting to authorizing. That's what it is. So do I hear a motion as to this article? Julia Maxwell, do I have a second to Julia's motion?
Second. Steve Rhines, second the motion. Karen, can you call the roll?
Speaker 2 (02:14:14–02:14:15)
Tom?
Speaker 1 (02:14:15–02:14:15)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (02:14:16–02:14:21)
Steve? Yes. Lori? Yes.
Liz? Yes. Jay?
Speaker 14 (02:14:21–02:14:22)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (02:14:23–02:14:36)
Allison? Yes. Allison? Yes.
We'll come back. Julia? Yes. Peter?
Speaker 20 (02:14:36–02:14:37)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (02:14:37–02:14:37)
Brian?
Speaker 20 (02:14:38–02:14:39)
Yes.
Speaker 2 (02:14:45–02:14:45)
Brian?
Speaker 16 (02:14:47–02:14:50)
Sorry, yes. Yes.
Speaker 2 (02:14:52–02:15:03)
Aman? Yes. Ron? Yes.
Judy? Yes. We'll try Allison again. Allison.
Speaker 21 (02:15:03–02:15:04)
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (02:15:04–02:15:07)
There you are. Okay. Motion carries.
Speaker 1 (02:15:07–02:15:21)
Okay. Thank you very much, everybody. Good time. So I just got some housekeeping things.
Can I go first? What do you wanna say, Liz?
Speaker 12 (02:15:22–02:15:24)
Remember yesterday we wanted to vote on that?
Speaker 1 (02:15:25–02:17:17)
Yes, and that's what I'm gonna talk about. No, it's okay, I appreciate it. I may have forgotten, I forget to call attendance, so who knows? So I made an attempt to amend the agenda, it was denied.
respectfully by a town clerk, no big deal. Karen and I, Karen worked with town clerk to get that done. So I'm thinking it's a very easy comment and I think I feel as if though the committee is in agreement as to this housekeeping article. But what I think we'll do with this is we'll just hold back on this.
for the presentation of the other planning board articles, and we'll do them all en masse. And I'm saying this now because I posted for Monday. I don't see really a true need for a Monday meeting at this point. We can all come in to vote on that one article, and I would prefer not to do that.
I would prefer that the committee members work on the comments, because I'd like to assign some comments. And I think that maybe we don't need that meeting on Monday to vote in that one article. And we could just kinda group it all in February. I think that might be a better use of our time.
And I don't wanna get you guys worn out before February starts, because we're gonna be in here a lot, I believe, with the planning board and any other article that may come down the pike. I mean, I could see potentially four or three new articles, which is really going to be a busy month. So that's kind of what I foresee. I think it's a better idea.
Speaker 11 (02:17:18–02:17:19)
So sorry, what's the one article?
Speaker 1 (02:17:20–02:17:23)
It's the Brook Road overlay.
Speaker 11 (02:17:23–02:17:23)
Oh, okay.
Speaker 1 (02:17:24–02:19:32)
So I sense that we're all like, you know, we got to see that through, but I don't see a pressing need to come in for that one thing. I'd like to assign some comments now to people. And this is a little different than what we've done in prior years. Individuals have done comments.
But I'd just like everyone to get some experience writing these. As you can see from our draft, the town provides a tremendous amount of background information in the draft that you should use. And but just those comments with our conversations here, as I said, the vote, I think the first thing that we put forward is this is why we voted. This is the committee, this is what we said.
I think it is important to add some different opinions in the comments, just to share our discussion and what it entailed. I think for some of the articles, it might be good to give a little history. Like we have the fire station, maybe talk a little bit. But what really I think you should do, and what I did in my first year when I was asked to write a couple of these, I just went back to the old comments.
And you'll see all different styles. You'll see some that read like a story. You'll see others that are just like raw dally, just like this is what it is. We need not be verbose with these.
I think these are, you know, well, there's some differences, I think, of opinion we may have had on very small. I think we've all been unanimous on these. So I think, you know, this has been a good process for us. So I just ask you to just go back and read the old comments.
And I think they'll just show you and, you know, what the different styles are. You can tell different people wrote them. I can't anyway. Lori did a comment about a public way.
Lori, was that last year? I think it was. It was up.
Speaker 2 (02:19:33–02:19:33)
By the animal shelter.
Speaker 1 (02:19:34–02:20:27)
By the animal shelter. And I'm not armed with that information. That was a great comment. It was like two tight paragraphs of public way information and why we should do it and what we discussed.
It was just a really good comment. There are some comments, if I look in the past, some of the other things like Lamb Woods and some of the other things we've done which have attracted a lot of attention, no should be long, right? There's a lot to talk about. Some of these, not so much.
And I think they're representative in some of our previous warrants. I really like, but I think it's important as you draft these that you do mention some of the alternatives that were discussed, whether or not they were approved, No, yes, but I think they should be just put in there to discuss. Now I'm going to assign these. I don't want anybody to feel slighted.
Speaker 14 (02:20:28–02:20:59)
Can I ask? Sure. Can I ask about the tone? So we said like talk about alternatives.
I want to know your opinion. I think it we made a decision, and we want to say why we made that decision. Correct. So for example, if we're talking about some of the amendments that did not pass last night, I would not suggest anyone say, here are the things timing to do, if you mentioned it all say, we thought about this, but we decided not to.
And here's why we decided to keep it like this. And here's why I back up the decision we made. Yes. And not say, Oh, you could do this, you could do that.
Speaker 1 (02:21:00–02:22:04)
Yes, I agree. That's important. That's something I was told a long time ago. You need to give the message, this is what we voted and this is why we said it.
I think in the past, and I don't wanna speak to anyone more in committee, but I think sometimes there were some comments that confused town meeting. Right, Jay? Like, what did you guys vote on? Like, it sounds like you got one side and the other side, right?
So, I mean, that's what I made the comment, the winners write the history, right? I mean, you need to write it, this is what we voted, this is why, but I do think it is helpful to talk about the discussion. Jay's amendments from the other night, things that Julia's mentioned about the stretch code and its applicability to the project, why it's a good idea, why it wasn't done, because X, Y, and Z. So these things are helpful.
And I think it really shows what we talked about in putting things in that we actually talked about and not pulling things out of straight air. So I think watching the meeting, that's really all I have to say. Julia.
Speaker 11 (02:22:05–02:22:15)
So you're going to assign people or groups to draft the comments, and then what? So I draft my comment, then what?
Speaker 1 (02:22:15–02:22:17)
Then it comes to Steve.
Speaker 11 (02:22:18–02:22:18)
OK.
Speaker 1 (02:22:18–02:22:26)
And then Steve and I look them over. We try to make them look nice and clean, clean them up, grammar, and then we would submit them.
Speaker 11 (02:22:27–02:22:34)
So the rest of the committee doesn't get a chance to see the comments that everyone drafted?
Speaker 1 (02:22:34–02:22:57)
I can circulate the draft comments for everybody. I think given our deadlines, I don't think we really have an opportunity to kind of like go over them and redline them and start to talk about them. But I will certainly circulate the comments. So I used to wait for the warrant to come and be like, oh, wow, you know, I will share them with you.
Speaker 11 (02:22:57–02:23:18)
Yeah, that would be great. There were just a few things that made it in last year that if I had seen that ahead of time, I would have been like, whoa. And it'd be nice to have the opportunity to get on board with what's being written. But like you said, not to go in and nitpick everything, but more just to make sure that we're all in agreement with the way the discussion was represented.
Speaker 1 (02:23:18–02:23:37)
Yeah, and I think that's the importance. Julie, I appreciate that. And that's the importance of going back and just watching the meeting. Yeah.
Okay. And it really can fast for you know, when there was nonsense in way with a substantive conversation, and put those items in and a telltale meeting about the work we've done. Right showing up here. I think it's important.
Speaker 11 (02:23:37–02:23:38)
There's no nonsense that goes on here.
Speaker 1 (02:23:41–02:24:39)
So that's really what I have to say. Don't be offended if I'm not assigning you a comment. We're going to have like 70 of them at the annual town meeting. So there's going to be plenty to go around.
So this is kind of what I see this. And I'm sorry if you don't want to write one. So peg access, the fire station money, the $60,000. Ron, can you write that for us, please?
Ron, thank you. And there's some good language in there. If you want to talk about fire department history, you can go for it. But I would appreciate you doing that one.
The senior tax. Judy, you by far have done the most work on this and are the most knowledgeable. I'd ask that you write that comment for us.
Speaker 21 (02:24:41–02:24:44)
I accept as long as I have another committee member with me.
Speaker 1 (02:24:46–02:25:32)
Okay, I'll get back to you. Our liquor license issues. Liz, would you like to tackle those? Both the authorization to consume and the five new.
Those are kind of like one. On the school articles, I kind of would like to lean on my subcommittee on this. I'd ask Lori, can you take the lead? On the three comments?
Yeah. I'd ask that if there are subcommittee members who'd like to chime in and message Lori about their ideas or things that they would like to see in the comments, please do. Jay, I may ask you to do the lead pipe one.
Speaker 14 (02:25:33–02:25:33)
Yes, sir.
Speaker 1 (02:25:39–02:25:49)
And I think that's all. If anybody has any, so I need to get these to Mr. Moana by Tuesday.
Speaker 8 (02:25:49–02:25:53)
You forgot to say lead with that.
Speaker 1 (02:25:54–02:26:57)
I didn't want to leave it at that because I knew nobody. So like, I know I've done these before. I'm going to take over. I have to write some other stuff for the moderator and everything.
So I have my own project that I have to do. And I have to go on TV with him. So if you have any questions about these, I know you probably won't because you'll look at the, call me. give me a buzzer over the weekend.
I'm like, I'll be around all weekend, Saturday, Sunday, whenever I can meet you somewhere we can talk on the phone, we can zoom. I don't know if I'm going to give you like the all the answers. But you know, if you have questions about like, how do I start this? No, I'll be happy to help.
And if you're up in the air about anything or something, call one of your colleagues. Call me, maybe I can point you in the right direction to somebody, but I don't think these are so hyper and complex that any of you here will have any problems doing this. And I'm really looking forward to seeing what you write.
Speaker 2 (02:26:58–02:27:00)
Judy has her hand up.
Speaker 1 (02:27:00–02:27:02)
Judy? Oh, you need a friend.
Speaker 21 (02:27:05–02:27:31)
So you just mentioned that anyone writing a comment could call a colleague reassurance or help in a way. That would not be out of meeting law because just conversing about a comment and it's one-on-one.
Speaker 1 (02:27:31–02:27:31)
Yes.
Speaker 21 (02:27:32–02:27:45)
I just want to make that point for the public, those watching at home. I may send you a little note, is that okay?
Speaker 1 (02:27:46–02:28:06)
Sure. Thank you. Would anybody like to give assistance to Judy on the circuit breaker? I'm happy to be a friend on the phone.
So Judy, why don't you include Steve and I in the correspondence? Okay. Just about the comment and we can help you out.
Speaker 11 (02:28:07–02:28:08)
All right, thanks a lot.
Speaker 1 (02:28:09–02:28:10)
Thank you, Judy. Julia?
Speaker 11 (02:28:10–02:28:27)
I was also just going to volunteer myself. I'm a pretty decent writer and I'm very anal about grammar and things like that. So if anyone wants a once over or is stuck, I'm happy to help. Over the weekend, I can't guarantee a time of availability just with my three and six year old.
Speaker 21 (02:28:27–02:28:29)
Pick me first. Pick me first.
Speaker 11 (02:28:29–02:28:34)
OK. Send it on over, but Friday and Monday, I have time to review.
Speaker 1 (02:28:34–02:28:44)
Julia, I really appreciate that. I'm sure you're probably better at grammar than me. I really enjoy grammar.
Speaker 11 (02:28:44–02:28:50)
I work really well with something to work off of. So if you have a draft, I'm happy to then go off of that.
Speaker 1 (02:28:50–02:28:53)
Love a good semicolon.
Speaker 11 (02:28:53–02:28:54)
Oxford comma forever.
Speaker 1 (02:28:56–02:28:58)
Yes.
Speaker 12 (02:28:58–02:29:01)
If you need to send them on Tuesday, when do you want them by?
Speaker 1 (02:29:01–02:29:10)
I would ask, just set, okay, you want deadlines? Monday at noon. Yeah, I would say Monday at noon by the latest.
Speaker 11 (02:29:10–02:29:12)
So that you can circulate to all of us.
Speaker 1 (02:29:12–02:29:31)
Yeah, like I might have to circulate them. But like if I circulate them and someone goes to Julia with some like grammar questions, like you're not going to get the Julia version. You're gonna get the raw version or the Tom and Steve cleaned up, you know what I mean? I'm trying to get them out as I get them to everybody.
So, yeah, it's a lot. So.
Speaker 11 (02:29:32–02:29:39)
Well, and I feel like it's a speak now or forever hold, but like when you send it out, we all have to look. And if you miss the chance to look, then that's on you.
Speaker 1 (02:29:39–02:30:25)
Yeah. And like, I'm gonna be, you know, I don't know what it will be like. I mean, town meetings vary. You know, if we miss something and I get called up, you know, I'll mention it.
Or if I'm asked about it and I get a, you know, I'll tell them. But, you know, that's why I said just watch the meetings, stick to the meeting, stick to the comments, stick to the discussion, and there won't be a problem. Okay. I'm gonna, I'm on the point of probably cancel this Monday meeting.
Okay, but just keep an eye, I know you will, keep an eye out in your email. And if anything, again, anything comes up, even outside of the comments, please feel free to give me a buzz. Jay.
Speaker 14 (02:30:25–02:30:26)
Different topic?
Speaker 1 (02:30:26–02:30:27)
Different topic.
Speaker 14 (02:30:28–02:30:50)
We've still got a lot of work to do for the February town meeting. Yes. But can we, should we start, should we be working on the May town meeting, working on our subcommittee work? Yes.
I do well with deadlines. If you tell me to, you know, Should we start doing internal presentations of, oh, I looked at the X budget and here's what's going on with it?
Speaker 1 (02:30:50–02:31:09)
Yeah, we do. I'm, I gotta tell you, I'm very nervous about the planning board stuff. Okay. And I'm nervous about any potential, any other bylaw that might come down.
And I'm also concerned about any citizen matters that might come down. I don't want to overextend us in the month of February.
Speaker 14 (02:31:09–02:31:12)
I really, Jay, I really want to overextend this in the month of March.
Speaker 1 (02:31:12–02:33:10)
True. But I think we need to zero, like our next thing is the special. So, I mean, we could meet five days a week. Cause I'm really anticipating probably up to maybe nine to 12 meetings in the month of February.
to tackle, to get the necessary people in here, the additional questions. I don't know, I'm just like, this is gonna be a very, I think these are gonna be some hot issues for town meeting. I will give a lot of thought to this, Jay, and I'll think, and I will actually, I think it's good, Steve, to talk about giving you guys some certainty in terms of scheduling out through May, so you can plan with your families, and other things and just so you have a general idea of what we're gonna do. And I'm cognizant of that.
I don't wanna, I feel bad dropping things on people at the last moment, but Jay, it's not lost in me because I'm constantly thinking about the annual and the work we're gonna have to do. So, Julia mentioned that, I think Julia mentioned like, you should kind of have like a little nice little break. There's no more breaks. So I think after we finish, unfortunately, on the 24th, 25th, 26th, we're gonna be right back here that first week of March.
We're gonna be dealing with the presentations by the different subcommittees, talking to the Warren Committee, and then having the people in, going through their budgets with them, and then maybe override. So. You know, there's a lot, this is quite the year to be a first year. Learn a lot.
So I think we're gonna have an O-rate. So that's a big deal. Tom? Yes, Judy.
Speaker 21 (02:33:10–02:33:38)
I have a clarification question. Sure. So if we're getting our comments ready and it's going to print, but we still have the planning board, the warrant would be reopened for that and our comments would have to go via a green sheet at the town meeting?
Speaker 1 (02:33:38–02:33:39)
Yes, that's true, Judy.
Speaker 13 (02:33:40–02:33:40)
Okay.
Speaker 1 (02:33:41–02:33:50)
And I've talked to Mr. Milano about that and we're in agreement. It happens from time to time. I don't remember it the last time, but we will be green sheeting these comments.
Speaker 21 (02:33:51–02:34:10)
And also, it would seem to me that the actual articles might not make the print. Excuse me, how would that work? The article itself and the comments now all go into a green sheet?
Speaker 1 (02:34:10–02:34:24)
It has to be posted to the town. The town needs notice for these articles. So I wouldn't be surprised, Judy, if they pop up on the 29th and they're in the printed warrant.
Speaker 11 (02:34:24–02:34:26)
Is that the last day for articles?
Speaker 1 (02:34:26–02:35:01)
That's like the last day. That's like the secret, secret. And I've already, so I've dropped that. So Judy, it's a great point.
I don't know where they're at. They might, and he was here, they might be with town council now. I know there was some conversation, just making sure the language is good, but I wouldn't be surprised if those pop in because of the notice issue to the town. So we can do our comments on the green sheet, which is a, no, it's not helpful for town meeting, unfortunately.
I didn't like getting the comments the night out.
Speaker 21 (02:35:01–02:36:03)
I had an idea that popped into my head, and I may have mentioned it, but I'll ask it again. Say the article itself goes into the warrant. We haven't even, you know, done our work on it, and our comments are going to be on a green sheet. Would it be wise to have the warrant go to print with these not fully processed articles have just a little blurb that would say the comments, however you want to word it, the comments will be on a green sheet.
Please check for the comments when you arrive at town meeting. And that way, perhaps, when a town meeting member receives the award in the mail, they're not perplexed as to why there's no comments as what they usually see?
Speaker 1 (02:36:04–02:36:47)
Yeah, Judy, we will put a placeholder in there indicating to the citizens of the town, the circumstances surrounding the comment, why it's not in print. So that'll be noted for every member of the town to see in the warrant. So they'll obviously, the select board is the one who authorizes these. So they saw a need, to open the warrant and bring these forward.
And that's their purview. So, you know, obviously that'll be reflected in the placeholder, but we'll just say like, stand by. Comments, comment coming.
Speaker 21 (02:36:47–02:36:49)
Comments coming.
Speaker 1 (02:36:49–02:37:32)
And I think hopefully, you know, people watch us in February and they listen to our discussions on them. And I probably give them a good idea of where we stand on them, the planning board's work, what they've done. So everyone, I think comments by noon Monday at the latest as if you finish one on Saturday, send it over. It gives me more time to look at it, gives me time to circulate it, and if it needs the Julia scrub, then it can get that.
So, noon Monday. Do I hear a motion? Motion to adjourn?
Speaker 9 (02:37:32–02:37:34)
Second.
Speaker 22 (02:37:35–02:37:38)
Peter, we are adjourned. Thank you, everybody.