Board: Milton Conservation Commission

Date: 2024-05-21


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:51–01:31)

All right, good. Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the May 21st, 2024 meeting of the Milton Conservation Commission. Commission members are appointed by the select board to implement the rules and regulations of the State Wetlands Protection Act and the Milton Town Bylaw governing the wetlands. As a matter of formality, we have actually two rules.

One is that we invite everyone to speak. and be heard, ask questions, make comments, but we do ask that you identify yourself for the record. It is an open meeting, and we do try to abide by the record-keeping component of that. The second matter of formality is that we introduce ourselves.

My name is John Kiernan, and just to speed it up, let me go across the top. Philip?

Speaker 2 (01:31–01:34)

Hi. Philip Driscoll, Conservation Clerk.

Speaker 1 (01:35–01:35)

Steve?

Speaker 3 (01:36–01:38)

Steve Ibis, Conservation Agent.

Speaker 4 (01:39–01:42)

Hans? Hans Van Lingen, Commission Member.

Speaker 5 (01:43–01:44)

Tom?

Speaker 1 (01:48–01:55)

Can't hear you, Tom Palmer. Tom Palmer, commission member. There you are. Thank you.

Wendy?

Speaker 6 (01:56–01:59)

Good evening. I'm Wendy Garpo, one of the commissioners.

Speaker 1 (01:59–02:02)

Arthur? Arthur Doyle, commission member.

Speaker 7 (02:04–02:08)

Ingrid? Ingrid Beatty, commission member.

Speaker 1 (02:08–02:23)

Don't see Todd, but we have our quorum, so we're ready to go. First on the agenda is Town of Milton, the animal shelter project. These are revised plans, and I think, Tim, you're on. There you are.

Speaker 8 (02:24–02:41)

Hi, everybody. Thanks for having me. turn my light on it suddenly got pretty dark in here. So appreciate you having me.

My name is Tim Zerwinski. I'm the director of planning and community development for the town of Milton. John, should I just kind of go into it?

Speaker 1 (02:42–02:50)

Yeah, absolutely. This is just for the public's benefit. This is an order of conditions that we approved back in 2018 initially.

Speaker 8 (02:50–05:54)

Yeah, 2018 and then extended in 2021. So just to situate everyone, the town is planning on building a new animal shelter on a piece of town-owned land off of the former dump access road. As Chair Kiernan mentioned, this project got an order of conditions from the Conservation Commission in 2018, subsequently extended in 2021. The project has been a kind of a long time coming, but we are finally in a position to be commencing construction.

The site's been cleared. We are in the process of evaluating the amount of ledge that we're gonna need to excavate. We have a new foundation plan. We're hoping to be able to pin the foundation to the bedrock rather than excavate all the ledge and put a slab on grade, which is our plan.

But the reason we're here today is there are two, what I would consider to be good changes to the project since 2018. Part of the reason why this project has been so long coming is construction costs have escalated, you know, way beyond our original estimates. We've changed to a new construction method. We're doing modular construction.

And as a consequence, the footprint of the building has been reduced in size. and the size of our parking lot has been reduced. We used to have two kind of entrances to the parking lot. Now we've got one.

So I submitted a letter to the commission, I believe a few weeks ago, May 9th. So maybe less than two weeks ago with the stats. So an overall reduction in the building footprint from 7,200 square feet to 3,800 square feet. and the elimination of the second parking lot entrance and some walkways on the site plan, resulting in a reduction of the pavement from 8,600 square feet to 8,400 square feet, and a reduction in permanent buffer zone alteration of plus or minus, give or take a few square feet, 700 square feet.

My original letter had raised the possibility of a change to- Thanks very much, Sean. a potential change to our stormwater drainage plan. We have opted to not change that drainage plan. So the drainage plan that we're going with is the same one that was subject to the original order of conditions from 2018.

So I'm happy to answer any questions. I don't have our engineer with us tonight, but I think all the changes that we're presenting are net reductions in impervious surface, which I think is always a goal of whatever we do. So hopefully this meets with everyone's thumbs up. So I'm happy to answer any questions.

Speaker 1 (05:55–07:47)

No, that's great. That's good news from a procedural perspective. I think that we need to consider whether or not these are minor revisions, because if they are and we vote them as such, we can then take a vote as to whether or not to accept them and amend the original order of conditions. If they were deemed to be major revisions, then the town would be forced to file a new notice of intent.

But these appear to be both minor and beneficial to the Conservation Commission and our charter to protect the resource. A reduction both in the impervious surface of the parking lot and a significant reduction in the footprint of the building both seem to be beneficial to the environment and the resources that we protect. There was an issue initially in the change in the drainage plan because we are concerned with the sort of the confluence of three projects going in the same area, the animal shelter 728, which is actually. I think it's seven, it's 14 on our agenda and it's coming up tonight.

Or maybe just the access road component of it is coming up. And then across the street at 711 Randolph Avenue, we've got a 40B project going there. And all of the drainage, they all come together from the three projects at the intersection of the access road and Randolph Avenue, where they all daylight at that area and then stream flows south actually towards It's actually toward Wollaston and then it goes underneath Randolph Avenue and goes over to the other side. And a lot of it ends up in Russell Pond.

So that was going to be a significant concern for us, but you have opted not to make changes to drainage, correct?

Speaker 8 (07:49–07:49)

That's correct.

Speaker 1 (07:50–07:56)

All right. Any questions, comments? I know, Tom Palmer, you went up there and you've walked the area.

Speaker 9 (07:57–08:06)

Yeah, I did look at it. I do have a question on what is a drainage exactly? Does it simply vent out on the access road?

Speaker 8 (08:08–09:24)

So I can bring up, if I'm allowed to share my screen, I can bring up the site plan showing what was approved back in 2018 and compare it to the current site plan. There shouldn't be changes to that. So let me just Share my screen real quick No, this is sorry, this is what I want. Oh My goodness So this is the plan that was approved in 2018.

So this is the one showing the larger building, the two entrances, but it shows the original drainage plan that was approved or subject to the order of conditions from 2018. So there's a catch basin. here at the corner of the parking lot that drains out to this swale over here and then down the access road. So what's shown on this plan is the current contemplated drainage system.

Speaker 9 (09:26–09:38)

I see. I guess my question would be, I see where the water goes, but I wonder if Is it a mitigation for increase impervious or not?

Speaker 1 (09:40–09:42)

I'm sorry, increase or decrease?

Speaker 9 (09:43–10:27)

Well, increase on the original PRAM, because there's a parking lot and a building. Although we know the parking lot is being reduced by to the extent of one driveway, the rest of it and the building are still there. So they all drain to this point. Is that right?

Correct. Yeah. Generally when you add impervious surface you have to, where it leaves a lot, you have to show that it's not coming off any quicker than before you began. So usually you do that, right, by putting in a basin or something.

I guess you could say that.

Speaker 1 (10:27–10:38)

You're 100% correct, Tom, but that's what was done in 2018 when we approved the original plan.

Speaker 9 (10:39–11:51)

Yeah, I guess it's got our imprimatur. I'm kind of pleased that, for instance, that it doesn't go directly to the road, because I think that road doesn't have any drainage except country drainage all the way down, right? There are no catch basins or anything. And what's happening now on the entire road is a lot of water and material comes down from quarry hills and the sand piles and goes down toward the 40B that's coming in.

And that also has drainage, but That one is downstream from a big existing problem, I think. And I think this plan doesn't worsen that problem any, but it doesn't have to worry about it either, because it's sort of at the top of the hill. So I guess I was just curious. I'm OK with this plan.

It seems to address the drainage issue by not sending it right onto the road. Yeah, I'm ready to approve.

Speaker 3 (11:54–12:12)

And just for everybody's benefit, there's another drainage to the east side of the parking lot. I see a small triangle over there. Tim, if you want to bring the hand over to that area.

Speaker 8 (12:14–12:15)

What are we looking at?

Speaker 3 (12:16–12:51)

We're looking at the small triangle. is an outfall right up almost have it let's go up up up a little further and to the east right there right there to the east and we looked at that uh when we were out there with you tom i mean tim okay and the land to the east of that falls away So it just goes overland and has fun in amongst the rocks and the ledge in that area.

Speaker 9 (12:53–13:07)

I gotcha. One more question. The sewer goes out of the back of the building to the north toward Kathleen Drive. Does that sewer line already exist or does it have to be put in?

Speaker 8 (13:07–13:13)

That sewer line does not yet exist. That will have to be constructed as part of the project.

Speaker 9 (13:13–13:56)

I gotcha. Well, I won't show you the pictures, but as you say, it's all ledge and boulders. And it's a good question about whether you can put anything out there without a lot of, I wouldn't call it excavation. I call it blasting.

I think there's rocks plainly visible and the rocks are big and they're sitting on ledge. That's what the site is now. So yeah, it's going to be, uh, It's sort of challenging, I think, to fit a building on there, so it's sitting tight and sturdy. I don't know.

That's not my expertise.

Speaker 10 (13:58–14:08)

Mr. Chairman, if I may? Yes, sir. I would offer a motion to the effect that the proposed changes are not substantive or substantial.

Speaker 1 (14:10–14:17)

That's a great motion, but could we hold it and just ask any more comments or questions from commissioners?

Speaker 4 (14:18–14:34)

Yeah, I had just a few questions. What's the actual square footage of the parking area, original versus updated design?

Speaker 8 (14:38–14:56)

I don't have the, I have a sort of a cumulative figure for the parking lot and the on-site walkways, and that's 8,600 square feet original, and it's 8,400 square feet under the current contemplated plan.

Speaker 4 (14:58–15:16)

Okay, and so under the original plan there is, I think we were talking about this before, there's a catch basin down in the corner, the bottom I would say the southern corner of the parking lot and it looks like in the updated plan has that been relocated.

Speaker 8 (15:19–15:37)

That is not relocated. It's in the same location. We haven't made any change to that aspect of the plan. So that drainage is the same as what was subject to the original order of conditions.

Speaker 4 (15:39–15:46)

So the version of the plan that we got in our packets isn't all that clear. Can you bring that back up on the screen?

Speaker 8 (15:54–16:41)

So, so this this right here is is the original again which shows the larger building, and the to the two lane kind of entrance exit of the parking lot. And then the next plan shows. the reduced building, the reduced parking lot. This one does not show the original drainage plan.

It shows a proposed drainage plan that we were contemplating. So what you're really kind of looking at is the combination of these two plans. So this is the building footprint and the hardscape. And then on the previous sheet is the catch basins in the same location.

The drain pipe is in the same location. The water quality swells in the same location.

Speaker 4 (16:42–17:08)

And the culvert, is there still a culvert on the other side? Has that been eliminated? I don't see it. I'm looking at the bottom.

I'm looking at the notes on the bottom right. on the right side of the list of notes says flare to end outlet, 12 inch flare to end outlet.

Speaker 8 (17:09–17:38)

Yeah, so we just got updated plans today that kind of combine all these. So I can put these up if you want to look at these right now. So this is, again, that combination of the reduced building footprint the reduced parking lot and the original drainage where that catch base is in the same location.

Speaker 4 (17:39–17:41)

Yeah, this is much more helpful.

Speaker 8 (17:41–17:49)

Sorry. Yeah, I wanted to get as much as I could in front of you all. We literally just got these plans this afternoon.

Speaker 1 (17:52–18:38)

All right, thank you. Tim, can I ask you, it's kind of, I don't mean to send you a curve ball, but it relates to another project on our list tonight. Number 14 is notice of intent access road, Town of Milton Quarry Hills. And that's part of the project, the 728 Randolph Avenue.

And as I understand the ZBA's approval of the project required that the applicant repaves and rehabilitate the access road beyond the egress point for that project and it heads towards the animal shelter. And do you know how far that extension of the road goes? What I'm asking is, does it go all the way up to the egress to the animal shelter?

Speaker 8 (18:38–19:08)

No, so that project is responsible for improving the access road from the entrance at Randolph Ave up to its own driveway, which is effectively the sort of the, I don't know if it's the planned northernmost point of that project. So I don't know what the distance between, so there will be some distance of unimproved access road between our site and their site.

Speaker 1 (19:11–19:37)

Wow, OK. I misunderstood that. I thought that they had to go beyond their point of access and head up closer to the animal shelter. So is the condition of the road going to change at all?

That is, between the rehabilitated road for 728 Randolph Avenue and the animal shelter.

Speaker 8 (19:37–20:07)

in the near future. We obviously understand that this project is going to put not a significant amount of traffic on the access road, but more traffic than exists today. And so we don't have a plan yet, but we understand that that's going to have to be something that the town is going to be responsible for in the future of kind of continuing those improvements up the access road. But it's not a part of this project right now.

Speaker 9 (20:10–20:37)

I just measured that distance. I measured the distance you talked about, namely from the new 40B to the edge of the shelter lot, along the access road that's 408 feet. That's how much road is not scheduled to be worked on. And I agree with you, that's a big deal because of what comes down that road now.

Speaker 1 (20:40–21:04)

Well, it's really beyond the purview of this project, but I'm… confused because I thought there was some kind of a deal that the town received in exchange for the permit, not our permit, but rather the ZBA's permit of the 40B as part of the comprehensive permit. I thought they were extending their rehabilitation beyond their point of access, but apparently I'm wrong.

Speaker 9 (21:05–21:30)

That would be, yeah, that would be, I think, make a big difference on the project because as it is now, the unimproved portion, sends a lot of water and sediment right out where that driveway is going to be. So they might build a new development and find on day one they're getting flooding of material into their driveway whenever it rains.

Speaker 10 (21:31–21:48)

John, my recollection is that the question was indeed asked during a site walk at that location, but that the answer was there was no plan to do so. that that would, at some point in time, fall to the DPW.

Speaker 1 (21:49–21:54)

The sidewalk for which one? For 728 Randolph or for the animal shelter?

Speaker 10 (21:54–22:09)

At the end of the 728 going to the end of the driveway for the animal shelter. That would be something that would later on be the responsibility, as Tim was saying, of the town.

Speaker 1 (22:09–22:13)

All right. Understood. Any other questions from commissioners?

Speaker 4 (22:13–22:32)

Yeah, John, if you don't mind, I have one more question. Are any of these projects dependent on each other? So if the access road doesn't get improved, is that going to prevent either of these other two projects from occurring?

Speaker 8 (22:34–23:57)

No, the animal shelter project predates the 728 Randolph 40B by several years. And again, it's not a part of the project, but the town has kind of always understood that improvements to the access road are eventually going to be necessary. It's something we'll have to work out in a capital budget in the future, but we get it. And I think it is a, John, I appreciate if there was confusion.

It is a major win for the town. I know there's a 40B project, but the improvements that they are making to the access road are unequivocally going to create a better condition for both that project and the access road generally. So that was a part of a negotiation around the approval at 40B and the easement that was necessary to get onto the access road to make it, frankly, a much better project than what was originally proposed. But no, if this project doesn't happen, which I hope it does, and we're full speed ahead on it, doesn't affect the 40B.

If the 40B doesn't happen, we're effectively still in the same state as the project was when it received its original order of conditions back in 2018, except a slightly smaller building footprint and a slightly smaller parking lot.

Speaker 1 (24:00–24:15)

Understood. Any members of the public of others I can't see everybody. So if anybody raised their hand, I can't see them. Can anybody?

I don't see any hands. So I think, Arthur, now your motion would be appropriate.

Speaker 10 (24:17–24:26)

It would require a second. The motion was that this would not be considered a substantive change. Right. That these are minor revisions.

Speaker 1 (24:27–24:50)

Correct. Is there a second to that motion? Second. Thanks, Wendy.

Any discussion among commission members? Hearing none, seeing none, we'll call a roll call vote. Hans, I'm just looking at doing this by list here. Hans, how do you vote?

Yes. Tom Palmer? Yes. Ingrid?

Speaker 11 (24:51–24:51)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (24:52–24:52)

Wendy?

Speaker 11 (24:53–24:53)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (24:54–25:31)

Arthur? Yes. And I, John Keenan, vote yes as well. So that's unanimous.

And now we go to whether or not there should be a second motion now to revise the order of conditions to reflect these minor revisions. Arthur, do you want to address that? I shall move, Mr. Chairman.

Is there a second for that? I second. All right, Wendy came in first, so she gets a second. Any discussion among commission members?

Speaker 4 (25:32–25:34)

Yeah, can we make it conditional on receiving the updated plans?

Speaker 1 (25:38–25:43)

Oh, absolutely, but I thought we had. Philip, do you not have these?

Speaker 2 (25:44–25:46)

Not the ones from today, no.

Speaker 8 (25:46–25:58)

Yeah, we just got them this afternoon. So first thing in the morning when I get back to my desk, I'll send the updated site plans to Philip for you all to take a look at.

Speaker 10 (25:58–26:01)

All right, thank you. I'll accept that friendly amendment from Hans.

Speaker 1 (26:02–26:16)

Thank you. Yeah, good catch, Hans. Thank you very much. Any discussion?

We're going to go through it again. Hans, how do you vote? Yes. Tom Palmer?

Yes. Ingrid?

Speaker 7 (26:17–26:17)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (26:17–26:18)

Wendy?

Speaker 7 (26:18–26:19)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (26:19–26:30)

Arthur? Yes. And I, John Kiernan, vote yes as well. Thank you.

That's unanimous. Tim, you're all set to get the plans to us and we'll prepare the revised order of conditions.

Speaker 8 (26:30–26:44)

Wonderful. Thank you very much for this. And everybody, thank you very much for the work that you do. This is an often thankless job, but I am thanking you.

Keep up the good work and enjoy the rest of your meeting. Thank you very much, Tim.

Speaker 12 (26:44–26:44)

Thank you, Tim.

Speaker 1 (26:46–27:00)

All right, next on the agenda is extension permit of order of conditions at 131 Elliott. And I saw Steve Connolly somewhere. There you are. Hello.

Yes. Can you hear? Yes. Yes, Steve, we can.

Go ahead.

Speaker 13 (27:00–27:39)

Yes. Steve Connolly, manager of 131 LA Street LLC. And as you stated, Mr. Chairman, we're looking for a one year extension for our order of conditions.

And currently, there's actually five trees to be planted in different locations around the town. And currently, The DPW chair along with I believe the park manager are looking into locations that would be appropriate. And once things are determined and we get the okay, we'll plant those trees and then we'll come in for a meeting for compliance.

Speaker 1 (27:42–28:34)

All right, I actually had a conversation with Chase Berkeley about this and the location for the trees. And they're large enough in terms of caliber that they need to be carefully placed and cared for. So some time and effort will go into locating the best place for them and making sure they're done appropriately. So I thank you, Steve, for reaching out for them and to them for responding so quickly.

Okay. Are there any questions on the one-year extension from commission members? On the one-year extension, Mr. Chairman?

All right. Are there any questions or comments from a bunch of members of the public for us? Hearing none and seeing none. Arthur, your motion, sir?

Is to move for the one-year extension. All right. Is there a second to that motion?

Speaker 4 (28:35–28:36)

I'll second it.

Speaker 1 (28:36–28:54)

Thanks, Hans. Any discussion among commission members? Seeing none, hearing none. Hans, how do you vote?

Yes. Tom Farmer? Yes. Ingrid?

Ingrid, you're on mute.

Speaker 11 (28:57–28:59)

Yes. Sorry about that.

Speaker 1 (28:59–29:00)

Thank you. Wendy?

Speaker 11 (29:01–29:01)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (29:02–29:25)

Arthur? Yes. And I, John Kiernan, vote yes as well. So that's unanimous.

Steve, you're all set. We look forward to those tree plantings. Thank you. Great.

Thank you. Good night. Good night. Next on the agenda is number three on the list, a request for a certificate of compliance at 1 Penningham Lane.

Do we have a presenter tonight?

Speaker 14 (29:26–29:53)

Hi. Yeah, this is Colin Egan. We're the new owners at 1 Cunningham. I don't have much in the way of presentation, but we're requesting a certificate of compliance.

I think a little over 10 years ago, there was an order of conditions submitted. We had an appliance at Valley who did the initial plan come into an as-built conditions. We submitted that as long as the plans that they went through.

Speaker 1 (29:55–30:55)

Yeah. So there were some deviations. We've got the report from Steve DeRoach and James Napstedt. So there were some deviations.

I'm looking at the letter dated April 12th, 2024. So the basketball court was 47 by 30 rather than the approved 44 by 30. The location of the basketball court was shifted from the north 16 feet from the proposed location. This increased the street setback of 13.6 to 23.

And it's reflected on the plan. And then the third deviation was the existing wood deck was modified to accommodate the new basketball court. And the stairway was relocated from the southwest side of the deck to the north side of the deck. Steve, have you had an opportunity to see this?

Speaker 3 (30:55–31:11)

Yes, sir. I have. I have seen it. All right.

Looks great. The entire area looks very good. Surface is stable so much as it can be. There's a lot of roots at the surface toward the stream, which is to the north.

Speaker 1 (31:13–32:00)

All right, and the Conservation Commission was involved years ago. I'm not talking 2014, Colin. I'm talking about probably 1994 or so. Because there was concern that the second lot could be preserved, the empty lot where the stream comes in.

And that was pretty important to us. And I had asked Steve when he went out to look at it, just to make sure that the court did not encroach upon that. I think it's lot 15. Let me take a look at the map here.

And who is the owner of that second lot? Well, originally it was the same owner. I don't know who sold what to whom, because it's been 25 years or so. We don't own the second lot.

You do or you don't?

Speaker 14 (32:00–32:01)

We do not.

Speaker 9 (32:02–32:14)

Thank you. I know on the town website, it says the prior owner of your house owns it. A guy named Corcoran, I think. Who knows?

Speaker 3 (32:14–32:16)

Not any longer, I don't believe, Tom.

Speaker 9 (32:17–32:30)

Yeah. Well, good. I'm glad it's town ownership, I think. Why shouldn't it be town ownership if it's not going to be developed?

It does have a stream going through it. I guess that's Cunningham Brook.

Speaker 1 (32:32–33:34)

I think so. And there were, you know, back in the mid-90s, there were some serious flooding concerns in that area. So we were very sensitive to that lot 15. And when I saw the letter, I was concerned with that.

But now that I see the plan itself, the existing conditions that's been submitted by Colin, everything looks good to me, even with the deviations. And Steve, you're eye upon it. Are there any questions? Any commission members?

I thought somebody had asked a question. I started to. Hearing none, are there any butters? And the letter would suggest that I think there's enough data there that it conforms to our substantial compliance with the original order of conditions from 2014.

So is there a motion to issue the certificate of compliance? So moved. Thanks, Tom. Is there a second?

Speaker 11 (33:38–33:39)

Second.

Speaker 1 (33:40–33:54)

Thank you, Ingrid, for the second. Any discussion among commission members? Hearing none, Hans, how do you vote? Yes.

Tom Palmer? Yes. Ingrid?

Speaker 11 (33:55–33:55)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (33:56–33:57)

Wendy?

Speaker 11 (33:57–33:58)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (33:58–34:06)

Arthur? Yes. And I, John Kiernan, vote yes as well. So you've got your certificate of compliance, Colin.

Thank you very much for your patience and courtesy tonight.

Speaker 14 (34:07–34:07)

Thank you.

Speaker 1 (34:08–34:25)

All right. Good evening. Next on the agenda is number four, notice of intent at 440 Harlan Street. George, are you presenting on this?

Speaker 15 (34:26–35:11)

Yes, Mr. Chairman. Would you like to bring me to proceed? Yeah, yes, please.

Thank you. For the record, my name's George Collins. I'm a registered professional engineer. I'm representing Dr.

Scott Lutch at 440 Harlan Street. We've applied for a notice of intent associated with the upgrade of a residential septic system. This project has been issued DEP file number 46- I'm sorry, yeah, 46-644. Would you, if you'd like, I could share my screen, Mr.

Chairman.

Speaker 1 (35:11–35:13)

Oh, that'd be great if you could do that.

Speaker 15 (35:13–36:00)

Thanks. And a note, a quick note, this plan as well as the next application have been approved, were approved by the Board of Health last night. They did condition the approval on receiving conservation approval. So I was just going to zoom out here.

So basically, we have Harlan Street on the right-hand side, on the east to east side of the property. George? I'm sorry. George?

Speaker 1 (36:00–36:05)

We can't see anything. Oh, jeez. I can't either.

Speaker 3 (36:05–36:15)

It says he has started screen sharing on my screen, but I don't see anything, George.

Speaker 15 (36:17–36:44)

Okay, let's see here. I was all excited getting out of myself. Let's see here. New share.

Just try a new share. It says my sharing is paused. I'm going to start fresh.

Speaker 1 (36:44–36:49)

Steve, is there anything you can do to make him a co-host? I may be able to get at it. Yes.

Speaker 3 (36:49–36:54)

Well, no, I can make him a co-host, of course. And we can try that. Yeah.

Speaker 15 (36:55–36:59)

A participant has enabled closed captioning. Who can see the screen script?

Speaker 3 (37:02–37:05)

Let's take a look and see if I can nail it in making him a co-host.

Speaker 15 (37:05–37:07)

OK, wait a second. I just hit Resume Share.

Speaker 3 (37:10–37:28)

OK. And then I may have them available. Let me try. I want to try something different here.

OK, I'll let you go first, George.

Speaker 15 (37:29–37:34)

OK, I apologize. I thought I had my act together, but apparently I did not.

Speaker 5 (37:43–37:43)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (37:43–38:02)

Hey, Philip, are you able to contact Sean from Milton? Oh, here it is. Thank you.

Speaker 15 (38:02–38:14)

Okay. I apologize, this is not a colored version. I'm gonna see if I can open up the colored version, I apologize.

Speaker 3 (38:17–38:32)

John, I talked to Sean tonight myself. Okay. I should also say that I inspected every single one of the flags, the wetland flags that is out there right now. And they all look good to me.

Speaker 9 (38:34–38:50)

Could I add that I looked at the plans on paper They're really well-drawn plans, I would say. At least looking at them, they're very specific and detailed, and they're not messy either.

Speaker 15 (38:54–38:58)

Can anybody see my screen? I apologize. I'm trying desperately here.

Speaker 3 (38:59–39:01)

Oh, no. We can see it. Oh, you can.

Speaker 1 (39:01–39:03)

We could see it with the red lines. You had it.

Speaker 3 (39:04–39:08)

Yeah, we just saw it, George. Oops.

Speaker 1 (39:08–39:08)

Oh my gosh.

Speaker 3 (39:11–39:12)

It's OK. Take your time.

Speaker 9 (39:17–39:23)

The soil data is on the plan. It's very interesting. OK.

Speaker 5 (39:23–39:25)

I apologize. Where are we here?

Speaker 15 (39:25–42:38)

OK. I'm going to do this one more time. I was still OK. Here we go.

Share. There we go. Yeah, we can see it. I don't know.

I can't. Oh, here we go. Get rid of that thing. Okay.

Okay, so again, I apologize. I can go back to my little narrative, if that works with you. It does. So basically, so again, so we have Harlan Street to the east.

This dark black line is the property line. The green line is the delineated bordering vegetated wetland. It was delineated by Brooke Monroe. Got the 25-foot buffer line in black.

orange line is the 50 foot buffer, the magenta line is the 100 foot buffer, and then this red dash line is the Erosion control. We've specked out a straw waddle for that. So the entire leaching field and the new septic tank and pump chamber are completely outside of jurisdiction. The couple of things that will be occurring within jurisdiction is this existing septic tank will be decommissioned.

So they're just going to pump that and fill it with flowable fill right in location. And then you have the driveway here. This is all an existing lawn area. There's no vegetation removal.

This is an existing lawn area. It's going to be reestablished as long when we're done. And then I have a lot of my standard language on the wetland notes. Sedimentation control to be installed before work starts.

Contractor responsible for implementing all Conservation Commission and Board of Health Directors. The site is not located in an ACEC. Contractor to sweep the street at the end of each workday. DEP file number to be posted.

Copy of registry recorded odor. Conditions must be at the site. name, contact numbers for the contractor to be submitted to conservation, contractor to monitor and modify sedimentation control, the applicant is not seeking the approval of the wetland line, and then equipment storage and refueling to occur outside of the 50-foot buffer. You know, in all reality, my intent would be if any of the equipment I know we try to shoot for the 100-foot buffer, but that would put us up into the neighbor's yard or into this vegetation.

So if we were to do any type of equipment storage, it would be right here in this lawn area. I have a dewatering pit proposed, 8-inch straw waddle for erosion control. I'd be more than happy to answer any questions that the commission may have.

Speaker 16 (42:40–42:41)

I have a question.

Speaker 9 (42:43–43:12)

Sure. Yeah, I'm reading, under upgrade approval requests, you are asking for a variance from the requirement for a vertical separation from, I guess, the distribution lines to the high groundwater. Normally, four feet is required, and you're getting, or you ask for three feet. The question is, Is that something the board has approved as well?

Speaker 15 (43:12–43:21)

Yes, yep. I went to that meeting last night personally and this application and the next application were both approved pending conservation approval.

Speaker 9 (43:22–43:24)

Why did you want that variance?

Speaker 15 (43:25–44:47)

If you look under here, local upgrade approval request one will improve surface water impacts So that we do have a surface water does drain in this direction and basically instead of having like a big speed bump and water having more of a shallow concentrated upland flow of water being concentrated left and right. It's going to go more straight across in a sheet flow like it is already. And then there is a cosmetic component. The system's about one foot out of the ground the way it's proposed if we did not seek that local upgrade approval request.

It would be about two feet out of the ground and at that point it would be more difficult to landscape, it would be more of an eyesore. And again the property is not in a water protection district we're out of the hundred foot buffer zone. And, you know, the property is serviced by public water supply by a water line, so there's no wells. For example, the next application, they do have an on-site well, and because of that, I did not request a water table separation reduction because of the fact that there was an on-site drinking water supply.

Speaker 1 (44:52–45:44)

All right, well, George, I can say that our custom and practice has been that we always approve the line. But I'm impressed by two things, or three things. One is that the applicant's not seeking approval of the wetland delineation line. Two, both Tom has indicated that the data appears to be correct, and Steve has seen the line.

And what's most important to me is you're outside of the jurisdiction. So that would cause me to suggest that we may perhaps need not go out and look at that line. However, I lost you where you want to store the equipment, because we're pretty strict in terms of requiring equipment be stored outside of our jurisdictional line, including the buffer zone. I mean, did you find an area that's outside the 100 feet?

Speaker 15 (45:45–47:03)

Yeah, there is. Yeah. So I mean, there is an area in here. Because the only thing that might be there overnight would be an excavator.

And it's not a large excavator. It's like a medium sized excavator. They could probably store that right up in this area here. And they could also store it right up.

And actually, what it is, is there's a tree line here. So this is wooded. See this little gray line? That's an indication of…

So it's just the only place I can see that's out of a hundred. You know what? Actually, there's also a spot right here. Where are we here?

There is a spot right here that's this whole area right in here is outside of the 100-foot buffer zone. So I do think there is, we do have some options to keep it out of the 100. I just figured ask for the 50, you know, state the 50. just because I thought it was a little more of a realistic expectation, but I would be more than happy to.

Yeah, so like I said, this whole area here with the stockpile area, this whole area here is all outside of the 100. It's all an existing lawn area, so I do think we could definitely meet that condition. We'll just have to make sure the contractor is aware of that.

Speaker 1 (47:04–47:12)

Right, and we have sometimes had difficulties with contractors, but I thought that you were the contractor in addition to that.

Speaker 15 (47:12–47:15)

I'm not. I do exclusively engineering and inspections.

Speaker 1 (47:16–47:41)

All right, well, how about having a, A, keep the amount of 100 feet. We'll put it on you to ensure that they're aware of this and they comply with it. And we should have some kind of a spill control kit. Hans, those, I think, are something you're familiar with.

And they're pretty simple and it's not an expense item. It's just a device they have in there.

Speaker 15 (47:42–48:15)

And I do know the contractor that's doing the work. He's put in probably 40 of my systems over the years. So he and I do have a very good relationship. He's a very good communicator and you tell him what you want and he gives it to you.

So that's the big problem. Sometimes at this point, we don't know who the contractor is. But in this case, we do, and I can personally and professionally vouch for him. His name is Ed Hart from Ed Hart Title 5 Services.

Speaker 9 (48:17–48:27)

Thank you. One more question. The old system was sort of behind the house. Did it fail a test?

Why is it being upgraded?

Speaker 15 (48:27–48:53)

Yes. The house is, I believe, if it's not on the market, they're getting ready to put it on the market. So, you know, they are trying to capitalize on, you know, like a lot of people, they meet with me and they don't realize that it's actually a 90 day process to include appeal periods. So you go in there and they think they're okay when you meet with an engineer in April, and then you realize, you know, you're struggling to get something done in June.

So, um,

Speaker 9 (48:53–48:56)

Would the old system fail, do you think? I mean, what was the issue?

Speaker 15 (48:57–49:27)

Yes, yes. The distribution box is flooded. Ed Hart, actually the contractor that's doing the work, they actually ran a camera up the line. And it's a very strange setup.

The tank goes out here, and then it goes around the back of the house, actually uphill. which is just the craziest thing. We usually put septic systems downhill, just so you're not burying them deep in the ground. And the system was like six, seven feet in the ground.

So very you would never build it this way today.

Speaker 16 (49:28–49:28)

Really?

Speaker 15 (49:31–49:49)

But yeah, just a very, yeah. So the answer to your question is yes, the system is in failure. This distribution box and these lines are flooded. They're not experiencing any backups in the house, but the actual distribution box is the key inspection point with a Title V inspection, and that was flooded, which is a failure parameter.

Speaker 16 (49:51–49:51)

Thank you.

Speaker 1 (49:54–50:19)

You're welcome. And I would invite comments from commission members, because I usually try to be consistent and uniform in everything that we do. And I said something that's a little bit out of the ordinary, and that is that we may not need to do a site visit on this one to confirm the line. But I wanted to, and I explained why, but I want to know if others agree or disagree with that.

Speaker 9 (50:22–50:25)

Didn't you say that Steve looked at it?

Speaker 1 (50:25–51:09)

I did. But our custom and practice is that the commission approves the delineation. And what I see is I'm impressed because in foot in the number 10 of the note says that the applicant is not seeking the approval of the wetland line. So it's not officially the line.

So therefore, I defaulted to YARP seeing the plans and saying that they were complete with soil analysis and Steve's eyeballing and direct observation of the flags. And because they're not seeking a confirmation of the delineation, I was comfortable relying upon you and Steve. But I didn't want to speak for the commission because it is our practice to look at the line ourselves. So I invite comments from the other commission members.

Speaker 15 (51:10–51:36)

And Mr. Chairman, if I may, I don't know if any of you know Brooke Monroe, but she's been doing this for 45 years. And I've been working with her for about over 30 years. So when I met her 30 years ago, she had already been doing this for 15 years.

So I don't know if you know her personally or professionally, but she knows what she's doing. And so just food for thought.

Speaker 3 (51:37–51:40)

And she used to work for DEP Northeast Region.

Speaker 15 (51:41–51:47)

And she's also the conservation agent for the town of Carver right now. Right.

Speaker 1 (51:48–51:54)

So I, you know, I'm not suggesting otherwise, I'm just no, no, I just I didn't know if he knew her.

Speaker 15 (51:55–51:58)

So I just figured I would throw that out there.

Speaker 1 (51:59–52:22)

And I appreciate that. But I'm usually the guy that's talking about uniformity and, you know, a consistent application of our custom and practice. And here I am diverting from it myself. So I didn't know how Wendy or Arthur felt about that.

And I'm certainly available for a site walk if anybody thinks we should do one.

Speaker 10 (52:22–52:34)

Mr. Chairman, I would just observe that the thoroughness of what we've been presented with and studied here this evening, the fact that Steve's been there, is fine with me. I don't see the need for a site walk.

Speaker 1 (52:35–52:38)

Okay. Hans, Wendy, Ingrid?

Speaker 6 (52:40–52:41)

I agree with Arthur.

Speaker 4 (52:42–52:52)

Yeah, I just, I did have one question. You had mentioned providing a detail for dewatering. And do you anticipate significant dewatering?

Speaker 15 (52:54–54:16)

No, we do not. The soils were wet. You know, when we do the deep observation holes, we go down like 10 feet. But I believe I can actually look at on the plan, you know, we had.

Let's see. So that's a dewatering pit detail. Yeah, so we So the water table is at 56 inches and we're stripping down to 60 inches. So we're barely going to be going into the water table.

And honestly, when we did this last month, it was a lot wetter. six weeks ago than it is now. We observed some weeping in the sea horizon. I do over 200 of these septics a year.

I did 205 last year. Since then, I'm out in the field. I do three to five of these a week. This time of the year, as soon as the As soon as the trees bud, the water table drops pretty rapidly.

So the answer to your question is I'm anticipating little or no dewatering. If we were doing this in February, I think dewatering would come into play, but I don't think any dewatering will even be required if it's done in the next four months until fall.

Speaker 4 (54:17–54:20)

Okay. Just based on the information provided in your response, I'm good with it.

Speaker 1 (54:23–54:27)

All right, did I leave anybody out? I agree.

Speaker 17 (54:27–54:28)

Yeah, I agree.

Speaker 1 (54:29–55:12)

All right. All right, so are there any other questions or comments? This is a notice of intent. Are there others or members of the public that have a comment or would like to ask a question?

I can't see the whole screen of people, but does anybody see a hand up? I do not. All right, then. Seeing none, and with no further discussion among commission members, is there a motion to approve a notice of intent for 440 Harlem Street based upon the plans that have been submitted by Mr.

Collins? So moved. Thanks, Tom. Is there a second?

Speaker 6 (55:15–55:15)

I second, John.

Speaker 1 (55:15–55:49)

All right, thanks, Wendy. And this would be with our usual conditions, special conditions. And George, for your benefit, that's my reference to our usual ones, storing equipment outside of the… 100 foot buffer zone outside of our jurisdiction.

And in this case, I think we talked about having an extra condition there that they, because they're so close to the line in terms of storage, that there should be a spill control kit to protect the equipment by the contractor.

Speaker 15 (55:50–55:57)

Yeah, I'll actually send them an email. I'll send him an email tonight. And then also be in the written condition, presumably.

Speaker 1 (55:58–56:15)

All right, any other special conditions from commission members? Hearing none, that's the motion. Is there any discussion? Hearing and seeing no discussion, Hans, how do you vote?

Oh, yes. Tom? Yes. Ingrid?

Speaker 5 (56:16–56:17)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (56:18–56:18)

Wendy?

Speaker 5 (56:19–56:19)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (56:19–56:29)

Arthur? Yes. And I, John Kiernan, vote aye and yes as well. Thank you.

That's unanimous. You've got your order of conditions.

Speaker 15 (56:30–56:42)

All right, great. Thank you. And just out of curiosity, what would be the potential date of issuance of that, just so I can do my backwards planning for the 10-day appeal period, business day?

Speaker 1 (56:43–57:01)

Philip can probably get it done, what's today, Tuesday. The trick is not getting it typed up, the trick is getting it signed. So if we can get there, I'm going to be around Milton, so I could actually sign it tomorrow. But to be honest with you, it takes the better part of a week to get it signed.

Speaker 15 (57:01–57:08)

Okay, perfect. So in about three weeks with the appeal period, we should possibly be able to start work. Okay, perfect.

Speaker 2 (57:08–57:13)

I actually have tomorrow off, so I won't be honest, but I'll start on Thursday.

Speaker 1 (57:13–57:27)

Thank you, Philip. All right. All right. Thank you very much.

Mr. Collins, next on the agenda is number five. That's 1362 Canton Avenue.

Speaker 15 (57:27–58:30)

Again, For the record, George Collins from Collins Civil Engineering Group, representing Catherine and Fernando Pérez, 1362 Canton Ave, for the upgrade of a septic system. This has been issued DEP file number 46-645. If you'd like, I could share my screen. Let's see here, where are we?

Okay, this is actually a two-sheet plan. Can you folks see that plan? Yes.

Speaker 18 (58:32–58:32)

Okay.

Speaker 15 (58:32–01:06:49)

So, you're probably going to want to do a site walk on this one. I've been there. I know what you're talking about. I've counted about 3,700 septic systems in 22 years, and this is up there as far as complexity.

It's not even complexity. It's just a lot of obstacles. So basically, again, this is an existing single-family home. This is a driveway here that leads down to Canton Avenue.

If I were to guess, like four or five homes that are serviced by that driveway, just one of those classic driveways that service multiple lots on Canton Ave. So this is on the south side of Canton Ave. And this solid dark line around the perimeter, that is the property line. Offsite, actually I guess it clips the easterly corner of the property.

This is a potential vernal pool. Brooke Monroe again did the delineation. And then you have this bordering vegetated wetland line here, another bordering vegetated wetland line here. and another bordering vegetative wetland line here.

I believe that they're all hydraulically connected, you know, ultimately to the potential vernal pool. I'm going to zoom in a little bit here. So So, and then like I said, this has an existing drinking water well, so we kind of, you know, we did not do that water table separation reduction on this one. And then just as a point of interest that this also got approved last night from the Board of Health pending conservation approval.

So, like the other plan, you have the bordering vegetation, bordering vegetated wetland in green, the black, line here is your 25-foot no-touch line. The orange line is your 50-foot buffer. And then your magenta is your 100-foot buffer. So the existing leaching field is right in here.

It's within 25 feet of the bordering vegetated wetland. It's this rectangular area here. Also, the existing tank is right here. So and then I don't know if anybody's been out there, but there's a lot of ledge at this property.

So basically, we did did do some probing around. We did some test holes and what we figured the best thing to do is to the existing package. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.

But the proposed tanks where the existing tanks are. We have a septic tank and pump chamber here. There's also another tank here, an existing tank. We went to a septic tank and pump chamber there.

And again, I've never done this again, 3,700 of these. I've never done this before, but we have just the way the site is laid out with ledge outcropping, driveway crossing, and just the way everything worked out. What I ended up doing is, To combine these two systems, I'm running a two-inch force main from a septic tank pump chamber combination over to this pump chamber, and then this pump chamber services this septic tank. And then that ultimately will pump up to the leaching field.

So again, I've never done this before, but it's all very, very simple technology. Again, this has been approved. This is reviewed by an outside professional engineer, Paul Rybuck. I believe I forget his last name Braga, he reviewed it for the Board of Health.

It's unusual, but it's all pretty simple time-tested technology. One thing to be aware of is that Title V requirement. Septic tanks is 25 feet off a wetland, which we do meet those requirements. Obviously, in a perfect world, if we didn't have this line coming out here, this line goes under a concrete slab, so we don't have any ability to manipulate it.

In fact, only this part of the house has a full basement. The whole rest of this is a slab. So it's just our plumbing options are pretty much zero. We have a pipe coming out here, we have a pipe coming out here, and we have to just deal with it to the best of our ability.

So one note, if you look here, proposed two-inch diameter force main C, note 28 and 29. I'm not sure if that's on the sheet or not. So note 28 and 29. provide proper cover and back pitch for force main location of the line to be adjusted in the field as needed and shown on the as-built drawing.

And then rear force main to be installed by hand within the 25-foot no-touch buffer. So the force main only needs to be like, you only need about nine inches of soil coverage over a force main. What it does is the force main pumps up to the septic, in this case it pumps up to another septic tank, and then it completely drains back to, so this pump chamber will kick on every couple of days, pump up to this other pump chamber, and then it completely drains back into that pump chamber. So unlike, water lines, because this drains dry, you don't have to worry about you don't have to have four or five feet of cover over it.

So, so within in this little short strip here, we are actually in the 25 foot buffer zone. My expectation is for the contractor to do that all by hand. You can hand dig that. And then just, you can almost lay the pipe.

You can dig like a one foot deep hole, a trench, put the force main in it, cover it with soil. And then again, just make sure that you have proper drain back. So I just figured that would be a little bit of a safer provision. And then the fact of the matter, if you go out there, there's really no room.

to get heavy equipment out here, because this drops off. You can see these topography lines. In this very short distance, it drops like six, seven feet. So I figured that would be the most critical part of the project, is putting in these tanks, putting in that force, because they're all less than 50 feet from the wetland.

I do have erosion controls, straw wattle proposed, that's in red. And then like I said, the actual leaching field where all the digging is going to be done, the leaching field itself is 127 feet from the wetland. We have erosion control running all the way up alongside of that. We have 19 feet to the lot line, code is 10 feet.

So we have extra, we actually have a little bit of extra setback. And then one thing that's not shown on this, there's like a storage barn here, that next door. So it's not like we have a residential house next door, like a storage barn there. You'll see that when we go out and do the site visit.

So anyways, I'd be more than happy to answer any questions commission may have.

Speaker 9 (01:06:50–01:07:30)

I have another question. Go ahead, John. Yeah, I'm looking at the second page of the plan where you have the soil data that you got on April 2nd, and it was a witness by Joyce Krzypulski of Milton Board of Health, representing the town. And in your diagrams, you have the top 20 inches You call it fill slash A.

It was curious to me that you would say that that area had been filled at some point. Do you think that's the case? I mean, you say it could be fill or A layer.

Speaker 15 (01:07:31–01:08:02)

Yeah, what it is is basically from a Title V application, the A horizon always gets removed. So from a practical standpoint, and to keep it simple, what it is, is this probably like this probably like 14 inches of fill, and then you have like maybe a six inch A horizon. I lump those together because in no set of circumstances do those Do those remain in place? So if there is fill and there is an A horizon, I lump those together.

Speaker 9 (01:08:03–01:08:09)

I got it. But these diagrams represent the existing condition, right? Yes.

Speaker 15 (01:08:09–01:08:23)

So in a natural environment, you'd normally have a three to five inch A horizon. So the fact that we have 20 inches here does imply that there is fill where the test pits were done.

Speaker 16 (01:08:24–01:08:27)

I got it. Yeah, that was my confusion.

Speaker 15 (01:08:27–01:08:52)

And what we do is we're actually going to strip out below the B horizon. Where is it? Yeah, 54 inches. So we're going to do a 54 inch strip out.

That gets us about six inches into the C horizon. That's the layer that we collected the soil sample for. That's what we're doing, designing our park rate off of, essentially.

Speaker 9 (01:08:53–01:09:09)

I'm looking forward to seeing it because I would not have thought this lot had a lot of ledge. If you look up in this direction as you go, I can't have, you do not see a lot of ledge. You see like big meadows and fields. Yeah.

That's surprising how much rock there is here.

Speaker 15 (01:09:10–01:09:11)

Wait until you see this place.

Speaker 1 (01:09:12–01:09:53)

It's this ledge then. George, can I ask you a different question? I'm asking about the leaching field. And now I can't remember if it's the barn or the garage, but there's an apartment there with a bathroom.

And it used to have a leaching field going the other way, I guess, in a northerly direction. And my understanding was that they saw some property, so it's now been halved. So you can't use the bathroom. But if there were a one bedroom or one bathroom facility, is the leaching field large enough to connect to that?

Speaker 15 (01:09:53–01:11:19)

Yes. Well, it would not be able to accommodate a bedroom, but it could function as an accessory structure. So I actually talked to the owner about that. So part of the premise of doing a septic upgrade is you're not increasing the number of bedrooms.

This is listed as a five bedroom house by the town. And that's what we designed for. So and I don't believe zoning allows accessory apartments. So basically all that plumbing has been disconnected.

But what I did talk to the the owner about is if they wanted to have a bathroom or a slop sink or something in here, you could run a line down like this to this septic tank. But as of right now, that is not the plan. We're not planning on doing anything. So the answer to your question, if that was tied in, it would be tied in as an accessory structure to the five-bedroom house.

It would not be like a sixth bedroom. It would be an accessory use. And for that type of, like if you say you had a little workshop out there and you wanted a half bath, You could put in a half bath and tie that in. From a Title V standpoint, that would not constitute a larger leaching field.

It's an accessory used to the five-bedroom house.

Speaker 1 (01:11:23–01:11:27)

What would it require if you wanted to make it a sixth bedroom?

Speaker 15 (01:11:27–01:13:01)

Because we're requesting local upgrade approvals, we're requesting the use of a soil sample that precludes us from adding bedrooms to the system. This is a septic upgrade application, which implies that no increase in design flow. So it would require supplemental engineering, a reserve area, a new application under new construction parameters to the Board of Health. So that's not…

That's not in the cards with this application. Understood. Like I said, the only thing I could the only thing that might make sense seeing we're having that conversation would be, like I said, if at some point, or even during this process that they wanted to put a stub here. So if they did ever want to tie into that someday later, there would be a stub there.

But just so we wouldn't necessarily have to come back to the commission or whatever. But at this point, that is not in the cards. And I did talk to my client about that. If somebody felt strongly about it, you could possibly run a line from the back of this.

Got it. Down to here, because we're elevation 43 and we're elevation 49 here. So you get a six-foot elevation drop between here and there. So you could potentially run a gravity-fed line.

But again, that would be as an accessory activity. It would not be a bedroom. Understood.

Speaker 4 (01:13:02–01:13:05)

All right, thank you. Would that require an updated Board of Health approval?

Speaker 15 (01:13:06–01:14:43)

It would probably fall under, I think it would require a permit from the Board of Health to tie in another line. But it's not like we're applying for a new soil septic system. It would be, I guess it would be similar, like if you were just replacing your distribution box or if you were replacing a line or installing a new line, that would be, a permit would be required, but it would not be like a formal, it wouldn't be like for a whole new septic system application. I think it would be just for a septic component If, you know, and if that, you know, again, if now that we're having the conversation and my client literally mentioned to me, I had everything submitted to Board of Health and Conservation, I go, well, what if I want to tie that barn in?

Like, we should have had this conversation two months ago. But, you know, that, you know, the one thing I am thinking is if they ran a pipe right here, outside of your jurisdiction to this location, they could tie that in later without a permit from the commission. So just food for thought, or if we did do something like that, we could show it on the as-built. But at this point, my client has no plans to tie that in.

We were just kind of brainstorming. After I had already submitted to both Board of Health and Conservation, my client decided to have this conversation with me.

Speaker 1 (01:14:45–01:14:55)

But that's why I asked the question, because I was wondering whether or not the leaching field was enough. I mean, I know how you could connect it, but I just didn't know what was coming, and I know the property was safe.

Speaker 15 (01:14:55–01:15:34)

I don't think they can have two separate dwellings on the same lot. I don't think zoning allows it. I could be wrong, but most towns don't allow two separate dwellings on one lot, which I would think that would be considered a dwelling if you had a bedroom in it. I think there's just some things that had happened there in the past.

I did talk to my customer, Ann, about it and her representative, and they said that all the plumbing is capped off. Understood.

Speaker 1 (01:15:38–01:16:02)

Okay. All right. I think this is a very, very interesting site in terms of the wetlands delineation. So I really think that's why I was concerned with consistency.

And when I brought up, you know, not seeing the previous site, but this one, I think does require or warrant a site visit.

Speaker 3 (01:16:02–01:16:41)

Mr. Chairman, I was out there two weeks ago today. And noted a couple of flags were missing, George. Numbers C5 and C6, just FYI.

You may want to have them put on again. And for the rest of the board as well, there's a huge amount of Japanese knotweed. So you'll have to think about some conditions, George, to allow equipment into the site And make sure that the equipment leaving the site doesn't bring the knotweed with it. OK.

OK. Just FYI.

Speaker 9 (01:16:43–01:17:01)

Something that occurs to me as I look at the plan is that the vernal pool bylaw might be involved. Because the area looking at a plan to the right of the house, I looked at aerials. Yeah, it looked like that could be a vernal pool from the aerial.

Speaker 3 (01:17:01–01:17:04)

Oh, no, there's no doubt. There's no doubt.

Speaker 9 (01:17:04–01:17:22)

Yeah. Well, don't we have a 100-foot no touch? I know that this is already developed, and perhaps they're not proposing to increase the development in that 100 feet, but it certainly worked within that 100 feet if that is a vernal pool.

Speaker 3 (01:17:24–01:17:28)

Yeah, I would imagine it is a vernal pool, Tom.

Speaker 15 (01:17:28–01:18:28)

So I just measured, I'm looking at a different screen. I'm on my AutoCAD. Where are we here? Sorry, I don't know where you are.

I'm trying to get back to the… And from that tank to the potential vernal pool is 145 feet from here to here. So you have the bordering vegetated wetland, but then you have the actual potential vernal pool. So you get 145 feet to the nearest structure.

And I can measure it to the work limit now. Wait a second, we're over here. And then from that potential vernal pool to the closest work limit is 130 feet.

Speaker 9 (01:18:29–01:18:42)

Well, that's outside the bylaw, on the other hand. Yeah, so from the edge of the vernal pool, it was a little bit tricky. So that will be something that I will look at when we go.

Speaker 15 (01:18:43–01:18:51)

Yeah, so from right here to the work limit to this potential vernal pool, flag five is 135 feet.

Speaker 16 (01:18:52–01:18:54)

Gotcha.

Speaker 3 (01:18:54–01:19:20)

Yeah, the flags look pretty good on this site. Like I said, there were a couple missing. There's a very interesting spring box on this site, just off site actually. I think it's the, is it the A series?

It's the one to the south, southmost series there. And there's a couple of old large stumps around the spring box. Have you been out there, George, around that spring box?

Speaker 15 (01:19:21–01:19:39)

Yeah, you know, it's kind of strange. We didn't show it, but, you know, that barn, there's a barn right here. Yes, that's correct. And the wetland is actually behind the barn.

So there's actually a structure. Strange. My survey crew, I don't know why we didn't locate it, but, but I, I, I don't, I don't specifically know what you're talking about.

Speaker 3 (01:19:40–01:20:01)

Okay. It's a rectangular area open to the South and there's water streaming to the South. from that rectangular area. And it's pretty well modified with stone.

So it's just an interesting area to see, historically. That's all.

Speaker 9 (01:20:02–01:20:19)

Yeah. It's interesting that their well exists with the ledge on three sides. They have a drinking water well that seems to be driven into stone. Wow.

You usually don't expect to get water out of a ledge, right? But there it is.

Speaker 1 (01:20:22–01:20:43)

It's curious. All right. Any other questions from commissioners, or can we move this to a site walk? And first question is, is this Saturday doable for members of the commission?

I can do it. What's the date?

Speaker 4 (01:20:43–01:20:47)

25. Memorial Day weekend.

Speaker 5 (01:20:48–01:20:52)

Yeah, I can't do it.

Speaker 1 (01:20:52–01:20:57)

I can't. OK. I'm sorry, who said yes?

Speaker 5 (01:20:59–01:21:00)

I did.

Speaker 1 (01:21:00–01:21:05)

I did too. So that's Tom, Ingrid, Wendy.

Speaker 5 (01:21:06–01:21:08)

No, I can't make it, Jim.

Speaker 1 (01:21:08–01:21:20)

I can't make it. OK, so it's Tom, Wendy, Arthur. It does not look good. OK.

All right. How about the following weekend?

Speaker 7 (01:21:22–01:21:24)

That's the 1st of June?

Speaker 1 (01:21:25–01:21:26)

June 1? Yes.

Speaker 7 (01:21:28–01:21:31)

Yeah, I can do it.

Speaker 1 (01:21:31–01:21:32)

OK. So Hans, can you do it?

Speaker 4 (01:21:33–01:21:43)

I cannot. The following weekend, I will have a hard stop at around 10 o'clock.

Speaker 1 (01:21:45–01:21:52)

We can start at eight. So Tom Palmer, can you do the first? Yes. Ingrid?

Speaker 7 (01:21:54–01:21:59)

Yeah, if we start at eight, I can do it, because I'm going to have a timing issue, too. But that should be fine.

Speaker 1 (01:21:59–01:22:00)

Yes, it should be. Wendy?

Speaker 6 (01:22:04–01:22:05)

Tentatively, yes.

Speaker 1 (01:22:06–01:22:52)

OK. Arthur? Yes. And I can do it, too.

So let's set this up for 8 o'clock on June 1st. Park, the driveway entrance is right next to the Suffolk Resolves House. You just go by that and drive up, and you'll drive right into the driveway. Yeah, and I'll put a cone out.

I'll get there a little early. All right, that's good. That's very helpful. I didn't ask other questions or comments from others or members of the public.

Hearing none, then the assent of the applicant will continue this until June 1st at 8 AM on site. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. All right, you have a good evening.

Thank you. All right. Thank you. Next on the agenda is notice of intent 54 Russellwood.

Speaker 19 (01:22:55–01:22:59)

Hi, this is Lauren Spindler. I'm the resident and owner of 54 Russellwood.

Speaker 20 (01:23:01–01:23:04)

Hi, good evening and welcome. Thanks for your patience.

Speaker 19 (01:23:05–01:23:32)

Yeah. I'm learning a lot about septic systems, but hopefully this will be a simpler discussion. I don't know if I admitted all the people. This is for a small addition to an existing porch and adding a raised deck in our backyard.

I don't know if there are questions, if it's helpful for me to pull up the plans that I submitted.

Speaker 1 (01:23:33–01:23:38)

Yeah, if you could do that, that would be very helpful to us. Does this back up to the brook?

Speaker 19 (01:23:41–01:23:46)

Yes, my backup is back up to the brook, but we're not getting close to that at all. But I can share it.

Speaker 3 (01:23:49–01:23:59)

Lauren, this is Steve Ives, the agent. Did you send a packet to the DEP yet?

Speaker 19 (01:24:01–01:24:31)

So I have not. I know it's on the, can you see this? Can you see the screen by the way? I know it's listed as a notice of intent.

The form I filed was called a determination of applicability because we're just adding sauna tubes for the extension and then a deck and it's not within the 50 foot. That was the form that I was told was applicable.

Speaker 1 (01:24:32–01:24:35)

What's the 50 foot? I don't understand that.

Speaker 19 (01:24:36–01:24:38)

Do you see, can you see the plan?

Speaker 1 (01:24:39–01:24:43)

Yeah, but I, our jurisdiction does not get anything to do with 50 feet.

Speaker 19 (01:24:43–01:24:56)

Well, so it's within 100 feet and the buffer zone, um, for the regulations, there's it's three 10. I can pull up my, um, I can pull up my application.

Speaker 3 (01:24:57–01:25:08)

Uh, you're, you're talking about the state regs, Lauren, not the town regs, just FYI. Okay, no offense.

Speaker 19 (01:25:10–01:25:42)

So yeah, I understand it was in within, and then maybe I have the distinction wrong there. I guess I was looking at filling out the form. I was looking at the state regs. It is within 100 feet.

It's not within 50 feet, but if there's further notification I have to give to the state, I can. And in filling out the form, I didn't see that as a of the determination of a disability form, I didn't see that requirement.

Speaker 3 (01:25:42–01:25:46)

No, there is no requirement for RFD.

Speaker 5 (01:25:47–01:25:49)

Okay.

Speaker 3 (01:25:49–01:25:56)

For the state, that's correct. But you, it was at a notice of intent.

Speaker 2 (01:25:56–01:26:03)

I made a mistake, it's a determination of, it's a typo, my fault, it's my fault.

Speaker 3 (01:26:03–01:26:06)

Okay. Sorry. No issue, no issue.

Speaker 1 (01:26:09–01:26:12)

Are we measuring 200 feet from Pine Tree Brook, or?

Speaker 3 (01:26:13–01:26:15)

No, we haven't gone through that yet.

Speaker 1 (01:26:18–01:26:25)

Well, let's just see what the project is, because I'm thoroughly confused now, because I thought it was, we're talking about Pine Tree Brook.

Speaker 19 (01:26:26–01:26:45)

We are. Pine Tree Brook is in the back. So the edge of my property at the end, there's a defective existing fence that was there when we bought the property. Brook's on the other side of that.

If you can see, again, everyone's looking at the site plan that's on the screen, right?

Speaker 3 (01:26:47–01:26:53)

Yes. Yes. And the brook itself is the gray shaded area to the right-hand side, John.

Speaker 19 (01:26:53–01:26:53)

Yeah.

Speaker 3 (01:26:55–01:26:55)

OK.

Speaker 19 (01:26:56–01:27:10)

And this is obviously my existing house. So the 100, within the middle of the house, this is the 100-foot line. This is all existing. I'm adding 30 inches to the deck.

Speaker 1 (01:27:14–01:27:26)

I'm just stumped as to why this is not a notice of intent. I mean, the jurisdiction line is 200 feet. It's not 100 feet. So the whole thing, everything's in the jurisdiction.

Speaker 3 (01:27:28–01:27:30)

Yes, from the brook. That's correct.

Speaker 4 (01:27:31–01:27:53)

Ms. Swidler, what you might not understand is that the Pine Tree Brook is a different type. It's not just a BBW or a wetland. you're dealing with a riverfront area, which has a wider jurisdictional area.

Okay. So that might be where the confusion is here.

Speaker 19 (01:27:54–01:28:50)

I think the other thing that, and maybe I need to clarify, but so my next door neighbor across the wood, did a very similar project. This is by the commission, I believe in 2021, they added a deck to the back of their porch. And I talked to Philips and we looked at what they had submitted. And so I submitted the same form that they had submitted.

I don't know, I mean, I might have provided information to the plant. And if there's a conflict between the town regs and the state regs, as if the type of project that I was doing, and it being not within the 50 foot, yes, you still need approval by the commission for the regs to fill out given spots. And I know Senator Hickford had done the same exact thing that was approved by the commission a few years ago.

Speaker 1 (01:28:52–01:29:02)

Ms. Whitlick, can I ask you, I don't know if it's your speaker or not, but you're really breaking up. I don't know if the others are having a hard time hearing, but I certainly am. Yes.

Speaker 21 (01:29:02–01:29:05)

Yeah, I'm hungry. I have a problem as well.

Speaker 19 (01:29:06–01:29:08)

Can you hear me any better now?

Speaker 1 (01:29:08–01:29:09)

Yes, much better. Yes.

Speaker 19 (01:29:10–01:29:14)

Okay, I'll talk closer to the computer. Do you need me to repeat that?

Speaker 1 (01:29:14–01:29:15)

If you would, yes, please.

Speaker 19 (01:29:15–01:30:22)

Oh, so, you know, I apologize if there's a longer form that needed to be filled out. When I went on to the commission initially, or to fill up at the DCW to get the information, my next door neighbor at 50 Russellwood had done a very similar project that was approved by the commission in the last year. And so I used the same form and information that they had submitted that was approved. And because it was a project of a certain type for the state regulations, you know, with not crossing over the 50 foot line.

Yes, it was in the jurisdiction of the town. that needs, the regulations that needs to get approval by the commission, but that per the state regs, this was the form to fill out. It was WPA form one request for determination of applicability. And so that's what I submitted.

If there's additional forms I need to submit, I'm happy to do so, but I don't think, you know, project doesn't change. I don't know if there's additional information you need given that it's Pine Tree Brook versus a different stream or water meter.

Speaker 3 (01:30:24–01:30:43)

And for the commission, it looks like there's just sauna tubes hitting the ground, is that correct? That's correct. Yeah. So the impact is not very large, in my opinion.

Speaker 1 (01:30:47–01:31:51)

I don't want to make it sound like we're formal to substance, but I don't know where you're getting your jurisdictional form information from, but it's very definitely within our jurisdiction. Oh, yes. And I don't know what the 50-foot significance is that you're referring to because we just need to see How close you are and if you're changing the impervious surface. Why don't we get get into that because I don't I don't know what you're doing.

And I don't know if it's going to change. the impervious component of your backyard closest to the brook. And I don't know if it's going to require any kind of a drainage. I don't think you're going to have a problem with it.

It doesn't sound like a bad project. So don't misinterpret me. I'm not trying to put form of a substance in it. But I'm just trying to make sure that we know how far away is the brook.

Speaker 21 (01:31:53–01:32:03)

The brook is, like I said, this is the new, and I can talk like this.

Speaker 1 (01:32:03–01:32:05)

We can't hear you again. I'm sorry.

Speaker 22 (01:32:06–01:32:06)

Okay.

Speaker 19 (01:32:06–01:33:01)

So this is the existing condition, right? This is what my property is right now. So here's my existing garage. Here's my existing porch.

This is the brook. I have a marking here for the 50 foot line, the 100 foot line. So what I'm using is adding just this deck here. So again, it doesn't go beyond, you know, it goes a few feet beyond the back of the existing lodge.

So we're over 50 feet from the brook. The exact measurement I can't get, but it's, you know, it's more than 50, less than a hundred from the brook. But the only thing going in the ground are the feet on a tube or the for detention and for the deck. There's no digging, there's no foundation being dug.

Speaker 1 (01:33:01–01:33:05)

What's the surface of the deck? Is it impervious or is it not?

Speaker 22 (01:33:08–01:33:09)

Is the deck impervious?

Speaker 1 (01:33:09–01:33:12)

Yes. What's the deck made of?

Speaker 22 (01:33:13–01:33:15)

It's going to be a composite material.

Speaker 1 (01:33:16–01:33:24)

But are the spaces between, is it like, you know, like a wooden deck that are planks and there are spaces between, like, and when it rains out, where's the water go?

Speaker 19 (01:33:26–01:33:36)

Yeah, I mean, it's, I guess, the standard, when people build a standard, it's off their porch, and then the composite will not be the bag that goes between.

Speaker 1 (01:33:37–01:33:39)

I'm having a real hard time hearing you.

Speaker 19 (01:33:42–01:34:04)

Yeah, it's the, there's nothing there's nothing in that now if we're saying there may be flat in the decking i guess in terms of how it's being built it's better like when you would build composite back your house nothing can you not hear me no

Speaker 4 (01:34:05–01:34:21)

So John, it sounds like it's going to be standard deck. So there's going to be spacing in between each of the deck boards. So it's not a solid. Tom, can you mute your microphone?

There's a lot of background noise. And I think it's affecting everyone else's ability to hear.

Speaker 1 (01:34:30–01:34:34)

Is that better? Yes, it is. Thank you.

Speaker 4 (01:34:34–01:34:58)

So it sounds like this is a fairly standard deck that has space in between. It's not. And correct me if I'm trying to misinterpret what's happening. It sounds like it's a raised deck that has spacing between the board.

So it's not a solid. you know, completely solid surface.

Speaker 19 (01:34:58–01:35:02)

Right, yeah. It's, you know, lengths of wood.

Speaker 4 (01:35:02–01:35:17)

May I ask what is going to be underneath? Aside from the sonotubes, are you going to leave that as grass or what's that? Is it going to have stone or anything like that underneath the deck?

Speaker 19 (01:35:17–01:35:32)

Um, we hadn't discussed plans to put anything. I mean, if there's a recommendation for something that's preferable, but grass, or if for some reason adding stone is better, we'd be amenable to that. Um, we hadn't discussed specifically what would happen underneath the deck.

Speaker 4 (01:35:33–01:35:38)

And what's the height? How high off the ground is the deck?

Speaker 19 (01:35:38–01:35:56)

Um, I don't have that exact figure. I mean, it's probably, it's not, probably quite six feet, but it's probably five something. I mean, I could, I could get that figure and follow up, but it's what the existing height of the porch is. So we're just building off of that.

Speaker 1 (01:36:01–01:36:05)

That's what we need as part of the plan. We need to add those specifics.

Speaker 11 (01:36:06–01:36:15)

I'm trying to think of, unless it has it here. Oh, you probably can't. I don't think

Speaker 19 (01:36:15–01:36:29)

I can share this again. This kind of shows it from the side view, but I don't know if it has the height here that would be.

Speaker 23 (01:36:29–01:36:32)

Oh, sure.

Speaker 19 (01:36:36–01:36:54)

Yeah, that's an image of it, but I'd have to get that. I don't know. I don't know. The way I'm looking at this, I can't tell exactly what that height is off the ground, but it's whatever the existing height of the porch is.

Speaker 1 (01:36:57–01:37:56)

All right, well, one of the things we'd like to do is take a look at it. And again, I know I'm probably sounding like a form of a substance person, but we do need to, if we're gonna approve a plan, we have to know what the plan is. So we need to know, if in fact, I think we're presuming that it's just like a plank kind of deck, like most decks are, and the water would drain between that. But it does make a difference if you're shifting water, particularly towards the brook, how does it get there?

And do you have to slow it down? Do you have to put in some kind of a catch basin? And this is not a huge cost. It's just a design issue.

But we need to know, what is the design? So if you could ask your, I guess you're using an architect? But we need the details of, you know, how high, how wide is it? How long is it?

What's the square footage? You know, how high up off the ground? How many sonotubes? How far apart are they?

Speaker 19 (01:37:56–01:38:24)

Yeah. And I think that, I mean, clearly there's some mistake. I think the sonotube, like the plans that I submitted have the number. If you need to have measurements for how far apart, how high the deck is, The square footage is on here on the plan of 24 by 14.

But I can certainly provide any other additional information that would be helpful.

Speaker 1 (01:38:24–01:39:27)

Or if it's helpful. What you going to do? Why don't you give us a plan as to what you're going to do with the current grade? Are you just going to leave it as grass?

I don't know if the grass would grow. It's going to be shaded. If you're going to leave it dirt, put gravel in there. because we're just concerned with runoff and erosion that close to the brook.

Again, they may sound like complicating factors. It's not a big deal. We just need to know what we're approving. Maybe we could take a look at it.

We won't delay you because I think you've already heard we've got a meeting. It's a public meeting on June 1st, Saturday morning. and we could stop by if it's okay with you and just show us where it's going and then we can eyeball it. It really helps a lot if we actually see it.

And if you could get that data to us and just stay in touch with Philip and get that by the 1st of June, we'll be in a position to vote at that time.

Speaker 19 (01:39:29–01:40:02)

Okay. And again, apologies for my, I'm sure the architect and my contractor can speak more intelligently about it. Um, and in terms of the, what's happening underneath the deck, I don't have a preference for that. So if the commission has that thought about what's better, um, then I'm happy to do whatever's better to be underneath the deck, but, um, maybe that's helpful to when you come out and see it.

I don't, I don't know what would be. the preference.

Speaker 1 (01:40:02–01:40:45)

No, we just want to make sure that the water, right now, when it rains out, the water goes into the ground. As long as you don't put a tile floor underneath it, then the water's not going to go in there. It's the impervious surface. That's where there's no drainage allowed.

The water has to go somewhere. So if it doesn't go into the ground, it's going to head towards the elevation change. It's going to go downhill. It's probably going towards the brook, which is fine unless it starts to erode the surface of your backyard.

So you can put what you want there. We just have to know what it is, because it may change the drainage calculations.

Speaker 19 (01:40:45–01:40:47)

Definitely no plans for tile floor under the deck.

Speaker 24 (01:40:49–01:40:51)

Or mecanum or something.

Speaker 19 (01:40:51–01:41:02)

Yeah. OK. Well, that's all hopeful. And June 1, I guess I would just I would assume that you would be going to that other property first and then you would just be coming over at some point after you finish up there.

Speaker 1 (01:41:04–01:41:22)

Yes. I know. I think some people have hot stops at 10 o'clock. So I, I think we can probably be at your house by nine o'clock.

I don't think an hour, even with travel time. Uh, if we start at eight o'clock, we'll, we'll be able to see what we need to see on Canton Avenue and we'll be there at about nine.

Speaker 22 (01:41:23–01:41:23)

Okay, great.

Speaker 1 (01:41:24–01:41:35)

All right, any other comments, questions from commissioners or about us members of the public? Hearing none, we'll see you on June 1st at about nine o'clock at your house.

Speaker 19 (01:41:35–01:41:36)

Great, thank you.

Speaker 1 (01:41:36–01:41:55)

Okay, perfect. Thank you very much. Next on the agenda is amend order conditions for the drainage infrastructure maintenance and repair at Blue Hills Reservation.

Speaker 25 (01:41:58–01:42:06)

Hi. Can everybody hear and see me okay? I just want to make sure after that mishap that you guys can hear me okay.

Speaker 1 (01:42:07–01:42:08)

We can. You're loud and clear. Thank you. Yes.

Speaker 25 (01:42:09–01:45:23)

Awesome. So good evening. I am Jessica Marino. I'm a senior wetland scientist with AECOM.

here on behalf of the applicant, Department of Conservation and Recreation, DCR, to request an amended order of conditions to include some additional work within Blue Hills Reservation off of Canton Avenue. So originally, you issued an order of conditions in December of 2023 that included drainage infrastructure maintenance and repairs at the site. Since the issuance of the original order of conditions, DCR has designed some additional upgrades that include the creation of a formal and accessible trail, as well as replacement of an existing bridge between the north side of a parking lot and Great Blue Hill Summit Road that crosses an intermittent stream. And I can go ahead and share my screen in a minute.

just so we can all orient ourselves and actually see what we're talking about. But currently, the area contains a narrow and uneven dirt path with a lot of exposed roots and tree roots and a makeshift bridge that was constructed from leftover timber guardrail. So not a great formal bridge by any mean. So obviously, handicap and visitors that cannot maneuver those types of conditions aren't able to use the path and they're forced to actually go out to Canton Ave, which obviously we know is a busy road.

So the new trail that DCR is proposing to construct is going to be six feet wide, made of stabilized stone dust and a water permeable organic binder. And the new bridge they're proposing to create is 28 feet long and 6 feet wide and will include transitions to trail surfaces at each end. The project includes 129 square feet of bank impacts and approximately 9,200 square feet of impacts to the buffer zone. Once the trail and bridge are completed, DCR is planning to replant with approximately 5,400 square feet of native trees and shrubs and appropriate seed mixes to mitigate for all the buffer zone impacts.

Additionally, they are proposing to do some invasive species management to address the significant number of Norway maples that are present. Norway maples are invasive in Massachusetts. And so they're proposing to remove any Norway maples greater than six inches in DBH. And they're proposing to replace those with, I'm sorry?

Speaker 20 (01:45:24–01:45:25)

Ouch.

Speaker 25 (01:45:25–01:46:21)

Yeah. But they're planning to replace those with native tree species. Hopefully one-on-one works out. So I'm happy to answer any questions that you have about the project.

We have some other folks present on the call. Barbara Farina, the project manager from DCR is here. Nate Burgess, the landscape architect from Dodson and Flinker is here. And Doug Blyven, architect from T2 Architects is also here.

So, I will go ahead and share my screen and let me know if you can see everything. If the site plans are coming through okay.

Speaker 1 (01:46:22–01:46:27)

Yes, we can see that. That's good. Awesome. And this is the handicapped accessible area?

Speaker 25 (01:46:27–01:47:23)

Correct. Correct. Yep. Gray underneath are the existing conditions.

So you can see the intermittent stream running underneath the existing wooden bridge. And they have surveyed approximate limits of the used dirt path that's currently being used to traverse to Summit Road. And on our proposed conditions, you'll see a more formalized path that begins at the parking lot with a new van accessible handicap space. It will traverse in kind of a swale, sinuous curve to the new bridge.

They'll construct the new bridge, tie it into both ends of the trail, and then the end of the trail comes out on Summit Road.

Speaker 1 (01:47:27–01:47:51)

You know, I'd be very interested in looking at the specs. I'm sorry to do this, but we've got other areas that we're looking at, handicapped accessible trails, and we're having problems with one of them in terms of stone dust and whatever the binder is that we're using. I'd be very interested in looking at your specs because we're looking for help in some other areas.

Speaker 25 (01:47:54–01:48:06)

So the stone dust paving spec is right here. So it's a three inch depth of crushed stone. with three-inch stabilized stone dust and then native plantings on either side of the trail.

Speaker 26 (01:48:07–01:49:34)

Jessica, I can jump in and speak to the product. Sure. So the material that's the basis of design is a stone dust that has a, and my name's Nate Burgess. I was introduced earlier on the landscape architecture.

And the binder is called OrganicLock. And so it's a permeable binder that is, they advertise it as the double rig infrarometer infiltration rate of 0.85 inches an hour average. Other folk, we've used it on other types of projects and some of the civil engineers that we've worked with have said that it's It can be comparable to loam in terms of that infiltration of that material. Of course, it's on a compacted base that's similar to road base.

And so it's not the same as planting soil by any stretch of the imagination. But it is much more permeable than some of the older forms of stabilized stone dust that may be what you're are being used on other projects because there are impermeable binders that were used commonly with stabilized stone dust in the past.

Speaker 1 (01:49:34–01:49:39)

All right, good. And have you used this particular spec on other sites or at other sites?

Speaker 26 (01:49:40–01:49:40)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (01:49:41–01:49:41)

Okay.

Speaker 26 (01:49:43–01:49:59)

including up at the top of Blue Hill around Elliott Tower. The same, the organic lock material has been put down in front of, as part of some renovations to Elliott Tower at the top of Blue Hill.

Speaker 1 (01:50:00–01:50:53)

All right, thank you. That's really helpful. Now, can you go back, because I, you know, sort of a long-standing joke here, because I'm a fan of trees, and so I want to save all trees, including Norway maples. And the running question for us is, how long do you have to be here before you become a native species?

And I guess it's somewhere in excess of 300 years, because I know that doorway maples have been around a lot. But when you're talking about removing them, how many are you talking about? And if I know you said anything over six inches, but are you taking down trees that have got 12, 18, 24 inches caliper or in diameter? And if so, are you replacing them with what?

I know you said native, but are you talking about replacing a 24-inch tree with a 3-inch sapling?

Speaker 26 (01:50:53–01:51:07)

And Jessica, I'll speak to that too. It's less than six inches within the limit of work. So rather than any tree greater than six inches. So the idea is that.

Speaker 25 (01:51:07–01:51:14)

Oh, I apologize. I misspoke. I misspoke. Yep.

Less than six, I meant. And I said more. I apologize.

Speaker 26 (01:51:14–01:52:01)

OK. So the trees that are in the survey are the circles, filled in circles on the plan. And it captures pretty much all of the trees that are there that are larger than small saplings. And so the trees that we've indicated, there's like two or three trees that are within the shoulders of the renovated trail that will almost certainly have to go.

In order to do the trail improvements that would be larger than 6 inches and then the intent would be for saplings and smaller Norway maples that have that are in the understory. Within the limit of work that those would be removed.

Speaker 1 (01:52:03–01:52:08)

And where is the limit of work? I mean, I know it's designed, but what do you- Yeah, it's that dash line there.

Speaker 25 (01:52:09–01:52:11)

Eight feet off the trail?

Speaker 1 (01:52:11–01:52:12)

Six feet off the trail?

Speaker 25 (01:52:12–01:52:26)

It's a thick black line that's going around the entire site. So probably, yeah, probably based on the scale, probably six to eight feet, I would say.

Speaker 1 (01:52:28–01:52:36)

All right. And the number of trees you're taking out, Ballpark.

Speaker 25 (01:52:36–01:52:37)

Nate, do you have an idea?

Speaker 1 (01:52:37–01:52:40)

I'm not sure.

Speaker 26 (01:52:40–01:53:23)

No, well, the trees that are on the survey, I think it's 3 that if I'm not mistaken, that are. we would be likely removing. And the goal would be to save any that we can. And then beyond that, it would be saplings that aren't on the survey.

So the trees that are less than six inches. And the survey was pretty good. They have some four-inch trees on the survey. So I would assume that what we're really talking about are true saplings that are maybe one inch.

or saplings in that area is what we would be removing.

Speaker 1 (01:53:23–01:53:32)

I don't know the number of those. And are you doing those on a one-to-one basis? I mean, are you then replanting the same number with native species?

Speaker 26 (01:53:32–01:54:37)

of the saplings or of the larger trees? Both. I don't have a number on the smaller saplings that might be in that area. But we do have, you can see the circles on the plan, ARC and NSC are red maple.

And 2 below conservation grade trees, so we're. You know, if we're removing 2 to 3 of the trees that are. Captured on the survey, we've we're replacing with. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 of the smaller conservation grade trees and one larger red maple tree, two to three inch caliper on that's near the trail side museum entrance.

You can see that with the AR there. Yeah.

Speaker 1 (01:54:39–01:55:40)

All right, the reason I'm asking these questions is that we have a performance standard for the town, and we've tried to be consistent about it. We used to say it's a three-to-one. If you take a tree down within our jurisdiction via plan, then you have to replace it on a three-to-one basis. That didn't work very well for the last whatever, 25 years.

So the last maybe eight years we've been shifting over to replace the same circumference or replace the same diameter of those removed. So I'm wondering if, as your plan is proposed, would it fit into our performance standard of, essentially, it's one for one. If you're summing up all of the circumferences of the trees removed, are you replacing it with the same circumference with the new trees coming in? Because that's essentially, although we shift back and forth between diameter and circumference, but nevertheless, it's a one for one replacement.

OK.

Speaker 26 (01:55:40–01:55:47)

And so which one, just for clarification, which one is it that you, circumference or diameter?

Speaker 1 (01:55:48–01:55:50)

It's actually circumference.

Speaker 26 (01:55:50–01:55:51)

Circumference.

Speaker 4 (01:55:52–01:56:10)

So it's more like an inch for inch. So if you're taking out a 3-inch DBH tree or 3-inch diameter tree, essentially you're adding in something that would be equivalent to 3 inches. So whether it's a combination of trees or a single tree of the same size, that would be. That's the intent.

Speaker 1 (01:56:12–01:56:18)

That's true. But you just went from circumference to diameter, which is the same. It doesn't matter which one you use.

Speaker 26 (01:56:19–01:56:56)

Um, I was looking back at the, there are three. Um, there, there are two tenants trees and one, um, six inch tree that are in kind of the most likely to be need to be removed area. And then I do see that there are, um, three additional smaller trees that are called out on the plans currently for removal that are near the trail, um, that are six, six and four. So that would be, um, The math is, mental math is always tricky, but.

Speaker 1 (01:56:56–01:56:58)

I'm at 42 right now.

Speaker 26 (01:56:58–01:58:03)

Okay. So if we had, you know, in terms of 40 inch, 42 inches, those conservation grade trees in the plan are, you know, we'd call them out by height, but they're probably one inch trees. And then the two to three inch, um, caliper maple. So right now that would be under the, uh, that would be less than that, um, replacement standard you were saying.

I think that, um, and Barbara from DCR maybe could chime in on this. I think we, you know, want to make sure that we're, uh, consistent with, um, you know, your, your standard. So I, I imagine there's some flexibility in terms of increasing caliper sizes to, um, uh, potentially meet, your replacement standard and or trying to reduce the number of trees that are being removed by, which maybe there might be one tree or two that would be able to be additionally saved. But maybe Barbara, could you speak to that?

Speaker 27 (01:58:04–01:58:20)

Yeah. Thank you, Nate. Barbara Farina, DCR. As I recall, that is a different policy than I think I've heard from Milton in previous visits with you.

It's certainly something that we can look at.

Speaker 1 (01:58:21–01:58:24)

I've been here 32 years, and it hasn't changed yet.

Speaker 27 (01:58:24–01:58:25)

The one to three?

Speaker 1 (01:58:25–01:58:27)

The three to one did change.

Speaker 27 (01:58:27–01:58:43)

Yeah, that's what I seem to recall. We can certainly look into that. I think if I understand you correctly, it's a cumulative circumference. It's not a six inch tree, directly six inch tree.

It could be two, three inch, or am I understanding that wrong?

Speaker 24 (01:58:43–01:58:44)

Yes, you are correct.

Speaker 27 (01:58:46–01:59:04)

We can certainly take another look at it, take a closer look at which trees might be impacted. I don't know if, In my neighborhood, Norway maples are not a great friend. If we can replace them with something else, that's typically what we do.

Speaker 1 (01:59:04–01:59:06)

And that's what we request.

Speaker 27 (01:59:07–01:59:34)

Right. So we can certainly take a look at either addition of more trees or potentially some of the trees that are maybe skirting the edge of the area. I think another thing that we could potentially look at, Nate, is maybe narrowing the path slightly. I think it's a six foot now.

We could look at making that a little narrower so we have less impact on that site.

Speaker 1 (01:59:36–02:00:28)

Well, the other thing you can do is if there's not room to replace the trees right there, you can place them elsewhere in the area. I mean, there's a lot of DCR land there. And in addition, we have a virtual tree bag. So sometimes if we require that performance standard, if there's not enough room on the site, if it's a private landowner, then they just give us a tree to place elsewhere.

And the town has a trade. Shade Tree Advisory Committee, and the DBW was always looking for trees for street trees. So there are lots of ways, and it's really not an expense issue. I mean, it's not a huge issue, but if the number of trees being replanted don't fit neatly into a good landscape plan, then we'd be delighted to take them and put them elsewhere.

Speaker 27 (02:00:29–02:01:03)

I think that's certainly within our ability to do that and take a closer look at it. The other point I just want to make, or maybe Nate, you can speak to this, is we are removing some pavement in that one corner of the parking lot. There is a catch base in there currently. Nate, you want to speak to that?

We're making a bioretention base in there. So we're removing some pavement in that one low corner, which always had a puddle right where the public would want to use that informal trail.

Speaker 26 (02:01:05–02:03:04)

Yeah, so the corner that's north is to the left on this plan with Canton Avenue on the bottom of the plan. And the northeast corner of the parking lot currently is all asphalt and has a catch basin. And we're taking out a bite out of the parking lot, and that would become a bioretention area that will be planted. And then adjacent to that, you can see the circles on the plan that is currently up close to the parking area, just to the left.

There you are. So those are all shrub. So some witch hazel, and blueberry, and black huckleberry. So those would be on the border of a new bioretention area.

And you can see that where the WM is would be a seed wetlands seed mix within a created bioretention area that would be on the border. where there's currently a catch basin. So that would be one of the benefits of the project is making the current drainage, which goes right into a catch basin and then into the sediment forebay that's within the nearby bordering vegetated wetland, and instead having one more opportunity for water to be infiltrated before it heads off downhill. And I guess the question with that is, with those native plantings and the 3 to 1 ratio, whether there's any, you know, does it extend to, say, witch hazel, which is sort of shrub or tree, depending on how you look at it, or some of those shrubs and ground cover plantings that we are putting in?

Speaker 1 (02:03:05–02:04:08)

Well, when we changed our performance standard from the three-to-one to the sum of either the circumference or the diameter on a one-to-one basis, in the old days on the three-to-one, in that era, we had another performance standard that said you don't have to replace a tree, but you could replace a tree with, I think we had six shrubs for one tree. So we had another ratio. It got a little bit more difficult when we changed about seven or eight years ago to this equalization of circumference or equalization of diameter. But yes, indeed, we do acknowledge and encourage and invite shrubs as a replacement for trees, as well as trees being a replacement for trees.

So you can get, if you're counting trees, you can get credit for the shrubs that you're putting in there in that area. Did that respond to your question or not? Yes, thank you.

Speaker 3 (02:04:09–02:04:34)

And Barbara and Nate, this is Steve Ives, conservation agent. I remember talking with Ali, who was working at DCR, I don't know, maybe three or four years ago, about this very path. And if you keep it six feet wide, then you have room enough for two wheelchairs to pass at the same time. I think that's an important consideration.

Speaker 1 (02:04:35–02:04:45)

Yeah, I agree with that, Steve, wholeheartedly. And I should have said something when you're offering to narrow it. I mean, the key for us is a handicapped access. That's a big deal for us.

Speaker 27 (02:04:45–02:05:50)

That was our intent. This is a public-made cut through, which is a good idea to keep people off Canton Avenue. But we did a site walk with Greg Rudolph of the Adaptive Hiking Group, and he brought this to our attention that when he brings groups of usually young adults up who have mobility challenges, This is a very difficult area, and they end up having to go out at 138. We also did a walkthrough up at Elliott, and that's kind of how, again, brought to our attention that they were taking groups there in wheelchairs and finding it really difficult to get over to the building.

So we're taking that to heart. We've worked on Elliott. We have another section of that Elliott Circle Trail designed for construction. And hopefully we have a larger plan to complete that whole Elliott Circle trail as a universal access path up at the top there.

So this is just a small piece.

Speaker 3 (02:05:51–02:05:55)

Pardon me? Sorry, wonderful to hear it.

Speaker 27 (02:05:55–02:05:56)

We're excited.

Speaker 1 (02:06:00–02:06:07)

That sounds, everything sounds good. Now this is what we've got before us is an amended order of conditions.

Speaker 25 (02:06:09–02:06:10)

That's correct.

Speaker 1 (02:06:10–02:06:15)

When did we do the site work? Was it like two or three years, two years ago?

Speaker 10 (02:06:16–02:06:20)

Yeah, it has to be, John. Close to three years ago, maybe.

Speaker 1 (02:06:22–02:06:37)

Yeah, because we know exactly where this is. And I remember, you know, walking through there and saying this would be, pretty difficult for somebody with mobility challenges. So I'm actually thrilled that you're doing this. This is a good thing.

Speaker 10 (02:06:37–02:06:57)

I was there this past fall with grandchildren, and the condition was worse than it was when we were there, considerably worse in the fall than it was when we were there two to three years ago. So this improvement recommendation is very much needed.

Speaker 1 (02:07:00–02:07:13)

Yeah, this is good. So, what, and I see the, I've got the plan in my hand. But what I'm looking for is the original order of conditions.

Speaker 25 (02:07:14–02:07:16)

I can pull it up. I have it as the.

Speaker 1 (02:07:16–02:07:17)

That we're amending.

Speaker 25 (02:07:18–02:07:31)

Yep. So, it's file number 046-0639. And it looks like it was issued. Let's see.

Speaker 23 (02:07:31–02:07:33)

It was past December, I think.

Speaker 25 (02:07:33–02:07:35)

December 18th of 2023.

Speaker 23 (02:07:36–02:07:45)

Happens to be my birthday, John.

Speaker 25 (02:07:46–02:07:47)

That's the day after my birthday.

Speaker 23 (02:07:48–02:07:50)

Oh, really? Cool.

Speaker 25 (02:07:51–02:07:51)

Yeah.

Speaker 23 (02:07:52–02:07:55)

Happy birthday, Jessica.

Speaker 25 (02:07:55–02:07:56)

Thanks. Almost half birthday.

Speaker 1 (02:07:57–02:08:40)

Yeah. 12, 2023, okay, so I do have that in my hand. So, and we've gone through this tonight, that if these are minor revisions to the order of condition, we need to take two votes, one that they're minor so that we can make the revision, and then the second vote would be whether or not to accept the revision and revise the order of conditions. And it's good to have them as minor revisions because otherwise you'd have to file a new notice of intent.

So I would suggest these are minor revisions, they're good revisions. And in that format, we could keep the same order of conditions and then vote simply to amend it. Does that make sense to you? Yep.

Speaker 25 (02:08:40–02:08:46)

Yeah, and I think that's what we're looking to do rather than to file a new notice of intent.

Speaker 1 (02:08:47–02:08:56)

All right, so there, and I think we can come to an accommodation on our tree replacement policy, our performance standards.

Speaker 25 (02:08:56–02:09:22)

It seems like- Yeah, we can look further into whether the proposed, because we are proposing quite a number of shrubs. So I think with the shrubs and the new native trees that we're proposing, I think we'll be in compliance with that performance standard of the diameter to diameter removal versus replacement, but we can confirm that.

Speaker 1 (02:09:23–02:09:34)

All right, that's good. So, on that basis, is there a motion to… John, I have comments. What's that?

Oh, yeah, I'm sorry, Tom. Go ahead.

Speaker 9 (02:09:35–02:11:15)

Just as far as the placement of the shrubs go, I like the way they're all next to the parking lot, That's a southern exposure. That's where the light will be available. Other areas may be darker. But I have another comment.

I've used this area often for many years. And whenever I go to that parking lot with the intent of going up the road to the summit, I never use this area, and I think hardly anybody does. Where they go is they leave from the east side of the parking lot, where there's a trailhead of the walk-up path, and that cuts off this whole corner and goes up a slope and connects with a summit road. And if people are coming down the summit road, that's the point where they see the parking lot, and they cross through.

And that path is not approved. And it goes over a much more significant grade than this path. And it is badly eroded. And there's a place where water comes out of the ground into it.

At any rate, I would say that this isn't the end of the story as far as figuring out what to do with this connection. Because this trail is great for handicapped access, in part because it's nearly level. But I would say, Few regular users of the parking lot and the Summit Road are going to even know it's there because they all take the Walcott path from the parking lot to the Summit Road.

Speaker 10 (02:11:16–02:11:40)

Tom, Arthur, you confirm what I said about the erosion. And John, I think we go back to the point where we were first here when Judith was with us. So maybe four years, whatever that may be worth. But Tom, I will say that when I was there in the fall, for a good part of a day, this trail was very well used.

Speaker 16 (02:11:41–02:11:43)

Where are people going to and from?

Speaker 10 (02:11:45–02:11:55)

Up above there is a connecting trail. So I can't tell you where they were going to or from, but there was good traffic.

Speaker 9 (02:11:57–02:12:01)

Cool. Yeah, I just, I didn't know that because I never use it myself.

Speaker 1 (02:12:06–02:12:33)

All right. Any other thoughts or comments or questions from commission members or actually members of the public? whether they're abutters or not. Or commission members, thoughts, questions, comments?

Hearing none, is there a motion first, because there need to be two votes, that these revisions to the order of conditions would be minor revisions? I'll move accordingly, Mr. Chairman. Is there a second?

Speaker 4 (02:12:35–02:12:35)

I'll second it.

Speaker 1 (02:12:36–02:12:42)

All right, thanks, Hans. Any discussion? Hearing none, Hans, how do you vote?

Speaker 23 (02:12:44–02:12:45)

I vote yes.

Speaker 1 (02:12:46–02:12:46)

Tom Palmer?

Speaker 9 (02:12:51–02:12:53)

What is the motion again? What is the motion again?

Speaker 1 (02:12:54–02:13:03)

To consider these as minor revisions to the existing order of conditions.

Speaker 16 (02:13:04–02:13:04)

I vote yes.

Speaker 1 (02:13:05–02:13:07)

Thank you. Ingrid?

Speaker 7 (02:13:08–02:13:08)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (02:13:09–02:13:36)

Wendy? Yes. Arthur? Yes.

And I, John Kiernan, vote yes as well. So that's unanimous. Now I'd entertain a motion to approve these revisions to the existing order of conditions. Is there such a motion?

Arthur, can I go back to you? You can, Mr. Chairman. I'll so move.

All right. Is there a second to that motion?

Speaker 4 (02:13:36–02:13:37)

I'll second it as well.

Speaker 1 (02:13:38–02:13:47)

Thank you, Hans. Any discussion? Hearing none, Hans, how do you vote? I vote yes.

Tom Palmer? Yes. Ingrid?

Speaker 7 (02:13:48–02:13:48)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (02:13:49–02:13:49)

Wendy?

Speaker 7 (02:13:51–02:13:52)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (02:13:52–02:14:03)

Arthur? Yes. And I, John Cairn, vote yes as well. So that's unanimous.

So you've got your order of conditions. And thank you very much. It sounds like a great project, and thank you for doing what you do.

Speaker 25 (02:14:05–02:14:06)

Thank you very much. Have a good night.

Speaker 1 (02:14:06–02:14:07)

All right. Thank you all.

Speaker 25 (02:14:07–02:14:08)

Thank you.

Speaker 1 (02:14:13–02:14:41)

Number eight on the agenda is no parking signs at conservation land next to Pine Creek Brook. This is in the area of the lower Gile Road field. I apologize. Deborah, do you want to saying what your idea is.

And it's not a new idea, because you brought it to us before. And I think you've got 100% support. But why don't you tell us what you're looking for? OK.

Speaker 28 (02:14:44–02:16:16)

Thank you so much. I really appreciate it. So a couple of things. One is I was hoping we could do a nice sign, maybe even in the spirit of the ones that you have up, which are really nice, those Wood Conservation Commission signs.

but I realize that might not be doable. So what I was thinking is a sign that, not just a no parking sign, but actually language that also educates, so to say something like, and I have some language, something like, This is conservation land. Cars are not permitted to park here in order to protect the land, the wetlands, and the pine tree brook, and then sign the Milton Conservation Commission. I know at the head of one of your trails, on the parkway, you have a trailhead that goes towards Pope's Pond that's on Blue Hills Parkway, and there is a sign with a lot of information on it.

There are two locations I was hoping for signs. One is next to the bridge, but there's another area where Elm and Gulliver meet, and the neighbors park there for extra parking. It's also like a grassy area. And I do have some pictures as well that I'm hoping, if you don't mind, if I'm allowed to share my screen.

Speaker 20 (02:16:16–02:16:17)

Oh, of course you are.

Speaker 28 (02:16:18–02:16:24)

Yeah? OK, great. Thank you. Do I have screen share powers?

Speaker 1 (02:16:25–02:16:28)

I think you do. If you don't, Steve can, can help. Okay.

Speaker 24 (02:16:29–02:16:32)

You've got it.

Speaker 28 (02:16:32–02:16:42)

Okay. There we go. All right. So, um, can you guys see this?

Speaker 5 (02:16:43–02:16:43)

Okay.

Speaker 28 (02:16:43–02:19:44)

So let me actually, um, right. So this is a view. If you're standing at the edge of the field, this is looking towards the bridge. Can you see the bridge in the background?

It's baseball season, and spring sports are back in the mix. And this is conservation land. All of this is conservation land. And the cars are parking there very frequently, and they leave tread marks, and they leave patches of grass, and it gets muddy.

So this is, let me start over from the beginning, because it's kind of a mix. This is a view of the cars with the bridge in the back. And so directly on the left is Guile Field. And you can see this is also, I know it's paved, but this is also conservation land.

And the cars, there's overflow parking because there's no parking for anyone. And they park on conservation land partly because there's no room, but park anywhere else, and partly because there are no parking sensors. So this is another example, and if you could see on the lower left, do you see how the dirt is mud and there's a tire track on the lower left? So this is an example after it rained.

This is the photo I showed you. This is also a view looking down the end of Guile Road. These are the cars all parked opposite. And you could see that green is the conservation land, and they're parked on it.

This is the path if you're facing the bridge. Again, those are cars parked there, more cars. Okay, so this is the green patch with the bridge behind us. And you can see this is what happens after it rains.

They ruin the grass area. Here's another day that I took a picture and you can see on the ground the grasses, you know, chewed up from the cars. Here's another one, another day. You can see the grass looks a little better because I think it's earlier in the season.

You can see the cars. This is a close-up. It's actually a video, but this is a screenshot of the video. You can see the tire tracks.

This is after a particularly bad parking day a few days later where all the grass is just from the cars. So, I mean, you get the hint. So here's the thing about all of this. This is actually just one area.

And as I said before, there's another area. which is the Gulliver and Elm clearing where the neighbors park as well. So I'll stop sharing my screen.

Speaker 1 (02:19:45–02:21:04)

Yeah, thank you. And for the benefit of the commission that Debra wrote and then spoke to Philip and to me, and I immediately called Chase Berkeley and he said, I know what you're talking about and we'll help. And Deborah, for your knowledge, you know those Conservation Commission signs that you see around town? They're actually, now they may have become cheaper, but I think they're what, Arthur, you know, $1,000 a piece.

That's about right, Mr. Chairman. Yeah, it's a lot more money than I expected. But we asked DPW to see if they could get some signs.

And Chase first said, yes, I can do that. And then he called me back a couple of days later. He said, listen, what about the language? Instead of, say, just no parking.

What about saying, no parking, this is conservation land? So he had, all right, maybe you spoke to him, I don't know, but he had the exact same approach. Now, he didn't have all the language, and I can't give you verbatim what he said, but it was clearly, don't park here because it's conservation land and it needs protection. Um, and I said, that's a great idea.

And, uh, to my knowledge, he's, he's gone ahead and ordered those signs. I don't know where they are in the production. I should have called him today and I apologize. Um, I'll call him tomorrow and I'll send an email to you.

Uh, members.

Speaker 10 (02:21:05–02:21:08)

I'm sorry, Debra, go ahead.

Speaker 28 (02:21:09–02:21:24)

Um, sorry, sir. Um, do you think they're going to be those metal signs or do you think they'll be, um, sort of fitting in with the, with the lands and the trees. Not to be greedy. Not to be greedy.

Speaker 1 (02:21:26–02:21:45)

I suspect they're metal. I don't know that, but I think that may be a cost issue as well. Because the wooden ones or the ones that we had made were pretty expensive. But somebody had a comment or a question.

Speaker 10 (02:21:45–02:23:11)

Yes, it was Alpha, John. Just so that everybody knows, any place where there is one of the green melted conservation signs, you have land that is under the control, care, and responsibility of the Conservation Commission. And that is either by the action of town meeting or by deed, or both. The lands periodically, and the area has to be remediated, and I think most people agree.

Some of that, John, appears to be at Eastman, from the old Gile Road. All those parts of that property are owned by the school department, others by the park department. But when you do the overlay, wetland overlay, it is wetland. So what I would suggest we might consider is marking them as Milton wetlands rather than conservation lands since they're not legally owned by the Conservation Commission and have something to the effect that Milton wetlands, no parking permitted.

Just a thought.

Speaker 1 (02:23:12–02:23:41)

No, and I think it's an appropriate thought, and it's technically correct. We don't own that land, but it is conservation jurisdiction. And to be honest with you, notwithstanding, I agree you made a good point, I think he already ordered it. So I'll have to call Chase tomorrow and find out how far ahead, because I think he used the word conservation land.

But again, I don't have the verbiage in my head.

Speaker 10 (02:23:41–02:23:48)

I'll leave that to your good judgment. I just wanted to make sure everybody was clear about- Right.

Speaker 1 (02:23:48–02:23:53)

We don't own the land. That is correct. That is correct.

Speaker 9 (02:23:53–02:24:31)

Can I ask where the signs would start on the road going down from the high school entrance? Because people park down at the bottom and they park all along the curve going up. It seems if you want to keep cars out of there, You could put a gate there, and it wouldn't matter whether people read the signs or not. There is no gate, and people do drive down.

And I'm just wondering if people will get down to the bottom, see the no parks and signs, and park on the curve going down. So where are the signs going to go?

Speaker 1 (02:24:33–02:26:28)

Yeah, they're going to go at the edge of the grass. And the next question is, well, people are going to park there anyway. So can we call John King and say, can you get the police department to ticket people? So it's going to cost them to violate the no parking signs.

The real answer to your question came up in the permitting process for the Lower Guild Road, the artificial turf field. And as part of the Park Department's plan, there is a fence going in there. And again, we all know that that's under appeal, both in the Superior Court and in the DEP. So I don't know where that plan is going.

But part of the plan is to put a fence in, which would actually practically enforce the no parking ban, because you couldn't get through the fence. Where would that be? It's on the plan that was submitted by the park department. It runs in Deborah's pictures, and the ones that you saw, the green grass to the right where the cars were parked heading into the woods as you look towards the bridge.

It runs all the way down the McAdams side. and would prevent cars from going into where the green grass is. And in addition to that, Hans has made this point several times that there should be some kind of a gate that prevents any kind of vehicle, whether it's a car or a ATV going through that pathway that runs parallel to the brook out towards Blue Hill Parkway. And I think Hans brought that up a number of times.

And I think the Parks Department has agreed, at least in concept, to put that in. But I think that's also part of the full plan. So the fence and the gate that you're talking about is all part and parcel of the plan, which is now held up.

Speaker 9 (02:26:29–02:26:46)

What about if we put aside that plan and ask Where are the signs we're talking about now going on the length of the road between the brook all the way up to the high school entrance road? Will they go all the way up to the high school entrance road, or will they?

Speaker 1 (02:26:46–02:27:12)

I don't believe so. I don't believe so. But I do expect to get a call from Chase, and he's going to say, hey, John, we don't want these signs. So I think that we should have a plan.

I mean, in my mind, I had envisioned that they would go down in the area where Deborah's picture showed the cars parked. But that does not include all the way back up towards the high school.

Speaker 9 (02:27:13–02:27:28)

Yeah, and she had pictures showing people parked all along going back up. Did you, Debra? She did, yes. Yeah.

All right. Well, I guess what you're saying is that we'll put them down at the bottom, but we won't put them on the road going up.

Speaker 1 (02:27:29–02:27:40)

Well, that's what I had in my head, but I never actually, I never expressed that thought. So now it's something for us to talk about. I mean, where should they go?

Speaker 4 (02:27:41–02:28:05)

So may I share my screen for a second? Sure. Let's see if I can do this. Is that the wrong one?

Wrong screen. There we go. So here's the GIS map. So I understand there's…

Can you see my screen?

Speaker 1 (02:28:05–02:28:07)

Yes, we can, Hans.

Speaker 4 (02:28:09–02:28:51)

My suggestion would be this is where the pavement stops. I would maybe suggest having a no parking beyond this point right here. So that would be a sign that would be consistent with the ownership of the conservation, whether it's Gower or not. And this area here, which is conservation, I believe, So this is part of the pine tree brook taking, and this is the area that Deb was indicating, and we have a sign facing outward here that provides more information on not parking in conservation land.

Speaker 10 (02:28:52–02:29:09)

Yeah. Hans, will you have your cursor right now? That's wetlands, but it's not owned by the Milton Conservation Commission. Right.

That's a pine tree watershed easement.

Speaker 4 (02:29:10–02:29:13)

Oh, it is. So it's not. I was confused about that.

Speaker 10 (02:29:13–02:29:15)

And see where the triangle is?

Speaker 4 (02:29:15–02:29:16)

That's right here.

Speaker 10 (02:29:16–02:29:27)

That's owned by the school department. And then in back of the triangle, that's owned by the park department. If you move the cursor down the screen.

Speaker 4 (02:29:28–02:29:30)

Yeah. Town of Minton School.

Speaker 10 (02:29:30–02:29:34)

Yes, right there. So this is owned by the park department.

Speaker 4 (02:29:34–02:29:36)

Park department.

Speaker 1 (02:29:37–02:29:40)

Yeah, that's the town, that's the select board.

Speaker 4 (02:29:40–02:29:55)

This Pine Tree Brook, so this whole path, because there are other signs at the end. Oops, sorry, if I switch to, sorry. There is a sign here at the path.

Speaker 1 (02:29:56–02:30:02)

The hockey stick is ours, is the Conservation Commission. See, you know what I mean by the hockey stick?

Speaker 4 (02:30:02–02:30:03)

Yeah, I understand.

Speaker 1 (02:30:03–02:30:13)

Yeah, you're right. That's the blade and the handle of the hockey stick goes up towards Guile Road along Blue Hill Parkway. That's the Conservation Commission right there.

Speaker 4 (02:30:14–02:30:46)

But there is a sign here that says conservation land, no motorized vehicles, something along that effect. Good. Not to split hairs, but since we've been splitting hairs the whole time. Yeah, so, okay.

But, I mean, to be consistent, I mean, having a sign here that says no parking beyond this point seems like an easy fix.

Speaker 9 (02:30:49–02:30:58)

Could we ask Deb where she thinks the sign should go? Yeah. What do you think, Debbie?

Speaker 28 (02:31:00–02:32:04)

I welcome others and agree with Hans. Those cars are parking facing the woods. And so I would think it should be where they would pull in where the woods are. I am concerned hearing these conversations, and I'm so appreciative that You guys are on board with this.

But I am concerned of multiple signs, because it really is a special place. I walk there every day. And I am also cautious of not having too many metal signs, like one discrete one or one in one spot. So that's also for consideration.

And also to consider that other patch of land. And Hans, when we're done with this, maybe you can go show that other patch when we're done with this to talk about location. But I'm open. I don't know.

I know Kate is on this if you want to chime in as well about location. But I think Hans, I like that idea against the trees.

Speaker 29 (02:32:10–02:32:12)

Kate, did you have a comment? Mr. Eric, you're on mute.

Speaker 17 (02:32:13–02:32:36)

Yeah. Can you move the screen up a little bit? Do you see where that little red box is? at the bottom of the screen.

If you go to the left of that box, you see there's a pond in there? Yeah, that's it. That's all wetlands in there.

Speaker 1 (02:32:36–02:32:39)

Yes, we know. And there are cars parked.

Speaker 17 (02:32:40–02:32:44)

Yeah, and there are cars parked, right? It looks like there are cars parked there in this picture.

Speaker 16 (02:32:46–02:32:48)

Those are cars.

Speaker 17 (02:32:48–02:32:49)

What are they?

Speaker 16 (02:32:49–02:32:50)

Those are cars, yes.

Speaker 17 (02:32:51–02:33:23)

Yeah, so that area actually is very, very close to flagged wetlands in there. The flagged wetlands are not just that pond that you can see, but maybe a foot away from the cars. That area needs to be flagged as well. And Deb has got pictures of that area too.

You can't see it very well. But I would suggest if you're looking for wetland signage, this would be a really relevant place to put it.

Speaker 1 (02:33:23–02:33:27)

I think that's a good point. I agree.

Speaker 10 (02:33:28–02:33:38)

The wetlands overlap map that I saw with Alan had covered that area. regardless of whether or not there are cows back there.

Speaker 9 (02:33:41–02:34:06)

That wetland is actually a detention pond that was built purposely on the upland area to catch runoff from the high school area. But the wetland does extend easterly or to the right of the open water into that grassy area you see. I'm just confirming what Kate was saying, that the well is larger.

Speaker 17 (02:34:07–02:34:11)

Sorry, there's a pipe that runs right under where that red thing is.

Speaker 16 (02:34:12–02:34:12)

Yes, there is.

Speaker 17 (02:34:12–02:34:28)

There's a pipe that runs from Piatelli Field right under the road there. And it lets out right there where those cars are. The pipe, it's a pipe that lets the stormwater off right there.

Speaker 4 (02:34:29–02:34:32)

That pipe's right about here. There's more than one pipe.

Speaker 17 (02:34:33–02:34:50)

Yeah, yeah. But you can see it like it comes under the road. Like there's a circle, like a topping for the rainwater over by, like near, I'm sure Hans knows what I'm talking about. It's over by that red trailer.

Speaker 4 (02:34:50–02:34:52)

Part of the overflow that's associated with this.

Speaker 17 (02:34:53–02:35:00)

Yeah, it comes right out from under that Pietele Field swale there. You can kind of see it.

Speaker 9 (02:35:00–02:35:06)

By the way, that swale is full of baseballs. There's dozens of soggy baseballs in that sweat.

Speaker 28 (02:35:07–02:35:16)

We found 137 baseballs at our Pine Tree Brook cleanup two weeks ago. Oh my god. I have photos if anyone's interested.

Speaker 9 (02:35:17–02:35:20)

Why don't they go and get the baseballs?

Speaker 1 (02:35:21–02:37:11)

I don't know. They just buy new ones, I guess. So let's move this along. We're going to have to wait for Chase to respond with both language, the status of the order for the baking of the signs, and the number of signs.

And then once we get that information, we might have that tomorrow. And then I'll get back to everybody. Deborah, if I use your email, you could probably pass it on, because I know I've got yours. And what we should do is have a meeting.

And Hans, you might want to be able to meet with Chase Berkeley and figure out the best location, which locations, that's plural. But it does depend upon how many sites we have, and work that out, and then report back to us. And we've got a meeting, a public meeting on the 1st. I'm hopeful that we can get this done sooner rather than later.

And we also need to save some signs for the end of Gulliver to put them up there as well. And if the signs aren't appropriate in terms of language, then maybe we can go back and redesign them and work with the cost and see what the town can afford to do. And simultaneously, we're going to have to enlist Chief King to support our quest to have people ticketed. if in fact they ignore the signs.

All right, so that's the plan. So we should have some additional information this week and then maybe have a plan to implement by the 1st of June. And we can put that, Phillip, we can actually put that on the agenda for the site walk. It won't take any time, but it'll at least make it into a public meeting.

All right, is that the end of Gulliver and Elm? It is, yeah.

Speaker 28 (02:37:12–02:37:21)

So that's site walk on June 1st. You're saying that's when the signage would be determined locations? Because I actually won't be able to be there.

Speaker 1 (02:37:23–02:37:29)

No, it doesn't have to be. I just don't want this to get lost. We can wait for your participation.

Speaker 28 (02:37:30–02:38:17)

Or no, just do what I would want to make sure that somebody, that I send somebody who, you know, we've talked about it. That's fine too. Thank you. I really appreciate this.

Can I squeeze in a question about, you had earlier in the meeting, we're asking some of the petitioners early or on the agenda about the type of material people were using. And since we're talking about the wetlands, and feel free to say we'll talk about it another time, what's the material in Donovan? I noticed they put a new material in Donovan field next to the lower guile. Do you know what kind of material?

And do they have to go through Conservation Commission for permission?

Speaker 1 (02:38:18–02:38:27)

Did you help me out with Donovan Field? I'm not sure what the name is. I know where the fields are, but I don't know the name. Is that the lower baseball field?

Baseball field?

Speaker 28 (02:38:27–02:38:31)

Yeah. There's a baseball field all the way in the back next to Guile.

Speaker 1 (02:38:31–02:38:32)

The Little League field, right.

Speaker 28 (02:38:32–02:38:44)

Yeah. They redid that surface. It's not dirt. It's some other kind of poured surface.

Did they go through Conservation Commission, or do you know the type of substance they used?

Speaker 1 (02:38:45–02:39:35)

Because that's right in the wetlands, too. I confess that I didn't know when it went in. We got involved when they tried to put a sign in the wetlands. They wanted to put this scoreboard in the wetlands.

And there was a backhoe sitting there overnight. And somebody called it in. And I went down there. And Arthur, I don't know if somebody else went down there.

Hans, it might have been you. And I said, what are you doing? And they were digging a hole in the wetlands. So that's the first time I realized.

And actually, we did look at some of the field. And the fence along the first baseline is right up against the wetlands. So that one got by us. Or it got by me anyway.

I don't know if anybody else has a different memory. But I don't remember anybody asking to do anything.

Speaker 28 (02:39:35–02:39:37)

No, it was just a couple of months ago it went in.

Speaker 1 (02:39:38–02:40:04)

Oh no, a couple of months ago. No, I'm talking about the baseball field that we actually had it flagged and it was on the fence. The wetland flag was actually tied to the fence. And I said, how'd you get that close?

How'd that happen? But that was the field, but that's been there for decades. But I don't know what happened within the last couple of months.

Speaker 4 (02:40:04–02:40:23)

In the past few months, they replaced the turf on a good portion of the infield. And then I believe they refreshed the stuff within the baselines, the red clay type material. I'll share my screen again.

Speaker 28 (02:40:24–02:40:38)

I have a picture of it. It was resurfaced, not with dirt. It's a different kind of material, like a poured artificial material that went in there?

Speaker 1 (02:40:38–02:40:43)

I don't know.

Speaker 9 (02:40:43–02:40:48)

It's a fair question. It's going to be jurisdiction because of the well that you talked about, John.

Speaker 1 (02:40:48–02:40:54)

Oh, it's definitely jurisdictional. There's no question about that. They tied the flag to the fence. It's pretty clear.

Speaker 28 (02:40:55–02:41:01)

I'll take a minute. I can actually show you the surface, but I don't want to hold up your other agenda items.

Speaker 1 (02:41:04–02:41:10)

Yeah, if you can show it to us, and then maybe we can put this on an agenda for June, because we should get to the bottom of it.

Speaker 28 (02:41:10–02:41:15)

Yeah, I have it right here. It's going to take me a minute.

Speaker 16 (02:41:18–02:41:21)

You've seen it, Hans, huh? Have you walked on it and stuff?

Speaker 28 (02:41:37–02:41:44)

Sorry, hang on. Hans, have you seen the surface? Do you know what I'm talking about?

Speaker 4 (02:41:47–02:41:55)

No, I thought it was just annual maintenance that they do, but I must be wrong.

Speaker 28 (02:41:55–02:42:00)

All right, this is going to take me like 30 more seconds. I'm sorry. If you want to move on, I can show you.

Speaker 29 (02:42:01–02:42:06)

There it is. We should move on, because we've still got a number of issues to get through.

Speaker 28 (02:42:06–02:42:57)

I got it. OK, I'm going to share my screen. I'm so sorry. OK, that's one.

And that brown, that tan stuff in the middle is not dirt. It's a particular kind of surface. And this is the other. And I can, this is, Donovan.

Oh, I realize it's not good quality, but this is not dirt. This is like poured something. The brown stuff? Yeah, that's not dirt.

That's like an artifact. I don't know. Kate, you know what it is? I don't know what it is.

And Park doesn't sometimes realize they have to go through concom. So maybe they didn't realize they had to.

Speaker 4 (02:42:57–02:43:03)

Are you talking about the stuff that's reddish in color? Are you talking about the Green.

Speaker 28 (02:43:03–02:43:07)

Well, the red, red, reddish green is grass.

Speaker 4 (02:43:07–02:43:16)

Yeah. Natural grass and the ground turf that they installed. So I believe the other stuff is like a clay like material.

Speaker 1 (02:43:17–02:43:26)

We don't know what it is, so let's find out. We'll put it on the agenda for the June meeting and in the interim, we'll find out what it is. All right.

Speaker 28 (02:43:27–02:43:28)

Thank you so much.

Speaker 1 (02:43:28–02:44:04)

I really appreciate it. All right, thank you, Debra, very much for your work. Thank you, Debra. Thank you.

Next on the agenda is number nine, request for determination of applicability, MBTA right away, continued hearing. What do we have for the MBTA? Oh, you know what? Is this what we had to…

We had lost our quorum at the end of the walk, so we couldn't take a vote. Alicia, you might be able to get us up to speed. Yes?

Speaker 30 (02:44:04–02:44:42)

Hi there. Yes. Thank you. So Janice Kearney represented the MBTA for that site walkthrough.

She had returned from there with some added corrections to the delineations that you had requested. I believe that's been completed and resubmitted. And then we were thinking that you could vote based on that but I wasn't sure if we had to do anything further for tonight's meeting to confirm that it reflects what your your changes that you had made after that walk through and all has been satisfied.

Speaker 1 (02:44:44–02:45:40)

Right and for those that were not on the site walk and by the end of it there were I guess just three of us left. And when we were still at a quorum, we asked the MBTA to move some of the flags that they had. This is back towards Cedar, Capon Street. It's halfway between Capon Street and and Central Avenue.

So we moved some flags there. And I think everybody was in agreement. So we needed the plans to reflect those agreed upon new locations for the flags. And then after that, some folks went home.

And Tom, you and I were there. And I can't remember who else was there. Steve, I know, was there. So I think there were just the three of us, right?

Steve, Tony, and myself.

Speaker 9 (02:45:40–02:45:57)

That's right. You and Steve stopped before we got to Central Ave from Caden Street. And I went on with the woman you just mentioned and the Wellens guy. And we came to Central Ave, and there you were again, John.

Speaker 1 (02:45:58–02:46:49)

So tell them about the agreement, because rather than flagging that finger that basically sticks out into the ponson, we had sort of an agreement in concept there that the MBTA would designate that as a sensitive area where there would be no spraying. And instead, in exchange for that, we would obviate the need to actually flag it as a wetland. because we'd accomplished the same goal in doing that. So I think that there was a map that was going to come back, and I hadn't seen it, but the map was going to show the changed flag locations closer to Capon Street, and then that finger of land that sticks into the Neponset, and that area is just north of Central Avenue, the Central Avenue bridge that goes over the river.

Speaker 16 (02:46:49–02:46:51)

A little east and north, yeah.

Speaker 1 (02:46:51–02:47:04)

Yeah, OK. But I haven't seen those. I think we've got an agreement in concept yet. But Philip, do you have those plans, the revised plans from the T?

Speaker 30 (02:47:07–02:47:19)

I believe they were submitted. Yes. I don't have them prepared to pull up right now. I'm not sure if Calvin's able to.

Speaker 31 (02:47:19–02:47:21)

Well, they were sent in.

Speaker 1 (02:47:21–02:48:18)

Yeah, I saw that. I don't doubt you at all. It's just we haven't seen it. We don't have them before us.

So really, the cut to the chase. And I know you've been very patient with us. It's been a long evening. but if we don't have them, it would be difficult to vote.

We're going to have another public meeting on June 1st, and this is not a time issue for those on the commission. It would just require a vote, but I think we need to have the plans in hand to see the area that's going to essentially be a no-spray zone, and then the wetlands delineation will be part of those plans. Because I think that those were our issues, correct? And then we were concerned with the spraying.

And I know, Tom Palmer, you brought that up. Yes.

Speaker 9 (02:48:18–02:48:32)

And the people at the visit were very receptive and were fine with adding areas, as you mentioned, to the no-spray zones that are marked along the tracks.

Speaker 1 (02:48:34–02:48:56)

Yeah, so in any event, we're kind of stuck on this. We don't have the plans. The commission members haven't seen it. I think we've got agreement and concept, and hopefully you'll be patient with us and kick this until June 1st.

That's Saturday morning. You don't even have to be there if we have the plans, because we'll be moving around, actually.

Speaker 30 (02:48:56–02:49:08)

So need to resubmit them, and then confirm that you have them, and then you can review them during your June 1st meeting, and then provide a determination from there?

Speaker 1 (02:49:09–02:49:28)

Yes. OK. You are correct. Probably the easiest thing to do is if you resubmit them.

And Calvin, I'm sure they were submitted. But if we don't have them, we don't have them for whatever reason. So if you could do that again electronically, That's the path of least resistance to get this done.

Speaker 30 (02:49:29–02:49:38)

Appreciate that. Yes, we'll confirm and resubmit for the June 1st, and then we'll touch base hoping to receive a determination from there.

Speaker 1 (02:49:39–02:50:04)

Correct. All right. Unless any of the commission members have any other concerns that can be addressed here? I don't see or hear any.

All right. Well, with your gracious consent then, we'll continue this to June 1st. And we look forward to getting. And Philip, as soon as you get the plans, can you just redistribute them to the commission members?

Speaker 2 (02:50:04–02:50:04)

All right.

Speaker 1 (02:50:05–02:50:13)

Thank you. And I apologize. I know you waited a long time this evening for no progress. I appreciate it.

Speaker 30 (02:50:14–02:50:14)

Thank you.

Speaker 1 (02:50:15–02:50:16)

Thank you. All right. Good night.

Speaker 30 (02:50:17–02:50:17)

Good night.

Speaker 1 (02:50:19–02:50:24)

Next on the agenda is 16 Russellwood Road.

Speaker 31 (02:50:28–02:51:41)

Hello, my name's Dave Curtis. I'm the homeowner at 16 Russellwood Road requesting a certificate of compliance. Back in the year 2000, submitted plans to build an addition, an addition built onto the house at 16 Russell Wood Road. It was approved by the town of Milton.

The construction was completed in 2001. But the builder never filed for a certificate of compliance. So that just came to my attention in the last few weeks. So since then, you should all have a copy.

We had a professional land surveyor go out and do an as-built plan. And so we're requesting a Certificate of Compliance approval of one now.

Speaker 1 (02:52:06–02:52:12)

I am trying to remember this, and it was, you said 2000.

Speaker 31 (02:52:13–02:52:18)

Correct.

Speaker 1 (02:52:18–02:52:26)

Do you have, I don't think we have the order of conditions in our packet. Have you looked at it, Steve Ibis?

Speaker 3 (02:52:27–02:52:29)

No, I'm sorry, I have not.

Speaker 1 (02:52:30–02:52:32)

Philip, do you know if we've got it?

Speaker 3 (02:52:43–02:52:54)

People are going to find it.

Speaker 1 (02:52:54–02:53:49)

I'm trying to remember this. And you said it was 2000, right? Correct. Is this one where you shrunk the deck?

Because I know you're close to the 25-foot non-disturbance zone. Is this the one where originally the deck was going to be a little bit longer or wider depending on how you're looking at it. But then you stopped it or you moved it back to stay out of the 25 foot non-disturbance zone? Do you remember that?

Not that I recall. Okay. Because you're outside of it. I'm looking at the as-built plan.

So you did what you're supposed to do. So certificate of compliance, we've got the letter. You know what we can do? We're gonna be at, where is Russellwood?

This is right down off of, wasn't?

Speaker 31 (02:53:50–02:54:00)

Off of Central Ave. Off of Central, I'm sorry, Central Ave. Brooklyn Central or, you know. Yeah, you're right.

Speaker 1 (02:54:04–02:55:13)

And we're gonna be at, We're going to be at 54 on June 1st. Can you get that to us so we have the plan? I don't think it'll be a problem, Steve. And I hope you can spare us the next couple of weeks, because I think we can take care of this in short order, because you've got the…

We just don't have anything to compare it to. I've got your as-built, but we don't have the approved plan. And if we can see them both at the same time, everything looks to be in good order. But I'd ask for your indulgence and let us put this off.

And we can meet you right there, because we're going to be at 54, and you're at 16. Correct. So we can just walk down the streets and say hello to you at about 915 or 930 on June 1st. Is that OK?

Sure. All right. And Philip, can you get this, see if we can piece this together? I know you've got to go back 24 years or so.

Hopefully, we can find it.

Speaker 2 (02:55:14–02:55:20)

All right. I'll have to go to the archives of town hall. I looked before, and I couldn't find it.

Speaker 1 (02:55:21–02:55:34)

Do you know whether or not, what's your fellow's name? I'm sorry, I don't mean to be discourteous, I just don't know his name. Oh, it's Don Rosa? Do you know if he's got it?

Speaker 31 (02:55:36–02:55:41)

I think we might have a copy. Are you looking for the order of conditions? Yes.

Speaker 2 (02:55:43–02:55:44)

We have the original order.

Speaker 1 (02:55:46–02:55:50)

We have a copy here. Do you know how to screen share? Can you do that?

Speaker 31 (02:55:52–02:56:09)

I've got it in paper form. You're like me. I'm challenged, technology challenged.

Speaker 1 (02:56:12–02:56:45)

Well, I'll tell you what. And there won't be any further delay, because if we have the forms with us, we can sign it right there. And otherwise, even if we approved it tonight, you'd have to wait a week before you could get signatures on it. So we're just asking for an extra few days.

So if we can meet you at your house, it'll be about 930 on Saturday, the 1st of June. It looks everything appears to be in order, but we really should see it and have it. And then we can sign it right there.

Speaker 23 (02:56:46–02:56:47)

Okay, great.

Speaker 1 (02:56:47–02:57:12)

Okay. That's good. We don't want to slow you down on this. All right.

Steve, thank you for your courtesy and we'll see you on the 1st. Great. Thank you very much. Thanks.

Next on the agenda is a change to order conditions for 85, 47 Boogal Avenue. That's the ice house. Who is appearing for the Ice House? Do you know, Steve?

Speaker 3 (02:57:13–02:57:20)

I do not. I was talking with… Oh, what the heck is the guy's name?

Speaker 20 (02:57:20–02:57:21)

Charlie Bosworth?

Speaker 3 (02:57:22–02:57:34)

Yes, Charlie. Charlie Bosworth. Back a few weeks ago. And we have a plan, right?

Speaker 16 (02:57:35–02:57:35)

Yes.

Speaker 3 (02:57:38–02:57:38)

It's in the package?

Speaker 23 (02:57:39–02:57:42)

I don't have the package, frankly, here with me.

Speaker 3 (02:57:42–02:58:06)

I don't have a plan. Right. And he wanted to do some modifications to the drainage system in the northeast corner of the site, as I remember.

Speaker 1 (02:58:07–02:58:10)

Northeast corner is closest to the parkway, right?

Speaker 3 (02:58:11–02:58:18)

Yes. I'm sorry, wrong. Make that Northwest corner closest to the pond.

Speaker 10 (02:58:24–02:58:29)

That's where they had a serious issue. Yes, it is.

Speaker 24 (02:58:30–02:58:31)

That's exactly right.

Speaker 10 (02:58:41–02:58:43)

So, this would mitigate that issue.

Speaker 23 (02:58:44–02:58:51)

Right.

Speaker 1 (02:58:51–02:59:48)

Well, I've got the plan in front of me, but without somebody to present it, I'm not exactly sure what the request is. I know we request a change to the order conditions DEP number 046-0595 for the comprehensive 40B permit. Presently known as the Ice House Project, the change is specific to adding one catch basin and minor grade changes to the front parking lot attached to the site grading drawings that depict the changes in red from the original. I think we need an applicant to tell us why it's necessary and why it's a good idea.

It probably is a good idea. But I feel somewhat constrained if we don't have an applicant asking for it.

Speaker 3 (02:59:48–02:59:48)

Agreed.

Speaker 1 (02:59:50–03:00:59)

So why don't we kick it over to the June meeting. And if there's any urgency on this part, we could certainly address it. Again, I know people have time constraints on the first. Hey, Tom, can you mute that?

Tom Palmer? Thanks. If we had to, I suppose if he got material to us, we could try to add it. But I know we might lose a quorum on that.

But I guess that's his risk or our risk. But I just don't see how we can move on changes to a major project unless we have the applicant explaining why the changes are appropriate or warranted. So I suggest we get this until the June meeting. And then, Steve, if you can reach out and just say if it's a time constraint, then we can try to squeeze it in on June the 1st.

Sure. All right. What's our date in June?

Speaker 3 (03:01:01–03:01:05)

The date in June, I believe, is the 11th, and I will just check it right now. June 11th.

Speaker 1 (03:01:07–03:01:23)

All right. So, well, officially we'll put it on for June 11th, then we'll just track it carefully and make sure that if we need to advance it, we will. Okay, next on the agenda is 654 Canton Avenue.

Speaker 3 (03:01:26–03:01:31)

I saw Kristen Ripa here, so she's here. She's still here.

Speaker 18 (03:01:31–03:01:37)

Good evening. Sorry, I'm trying to figure out how to get my camera to come on.

Speaker 24 (03:01:38–03:01:39)

Okay.

Speaker 18 (03:01:39–03:01:40)

I apologize.

Speaker 24 (03:01:41–03:01:42)

You don't have to.

Speaker 18 (03:01:43–03:01:46)

All right. I can see me. Can anybody else see me?

Speaker 23 (03:01:47–03:01:48)

No. Sorry, we cannot.

Speaker 18 (03:01:49–03:01:50)

OK. But you can hear me?

Speaker 5 (03:01:51–03:01:52)

Yes, we can. Yes.

Speaker 18 (03:01:52–03:06:31)

OK. All righty. Well. If it's okay with you, I'll move ahead with just like that presenting if it doesn't bother you that you don't see me.

Kristen Rapa from 654 Canton Ave in Milton. I am asking for a change or an amendment to our order of conditions for an addition that we are adding to our home. I admittedly did not include a new site plan. You should all have the copies of the original.

I know that it was a little difficult to see, so I included panned out version of the plan and then a zoomed in version so you could actually see the house with the measurements and things like that. So please know that those two are together. So the plan that is submitted here already, the request when we submitted this in 2022 was that we were granted originally to add a garage to the property. In 2022, excuse me, 21, we requested that we move the garage up and out of the 100 foot buffer zone, move it up towards the driveway and put in an above ground pool where the garage was allowed for us to go.

And the committee was kind enough to say that's fine. When we submitted the plans, then that's the plans that you have included in your packet this evening. The survey survey or so that is Sorry, that is DeCella and Burke had included this patio or porch that was connecting the garage, the pool, and the existing house. So when I submitted all my paperwork, it didn't occur to me that perhaps I needed a new version of that to give to you.

So my apologies for not getting a new sign planned with this technically accurate architect's plans. So I'm not sure if you've all gone through that packet yet. I have basically to elaborate, there is an existing. Concrete slab.

It's a brick in one section and concrete and another section. And that area is over that area is where we're planning on putting this three season porch. We're planning on using footings and not putting in a foundation and the room. So the the covered area.

If you will, the area that would have a roof over it would be 25 feet 10 inches by 15 feet. The whole floor of the interior of the three-season porch, as well as the front porch and the back porch, would be composite decking. And really, so the only impervious surface, I guess, based off of other hearings that I've been listening to this evening, would be where the roof is over it. And that is actually where there's already driveway or concrete, if you will, So the math actually, I have done a lot of math.

So like my letter of intent, if you will, or the amendment to the order of conditions states that we had, you know, the original order of conditions that was granted to us was for the garage that was 36 by 24, we opted to go smaller on the garage. And then like that, we'd like to add in this three-season porch. So the main change in regards to square footage of impervious surface is 291.45 square feet. Seems like a crazy number, but like that, I can elaborate on how I came up with that.

I'm sorry that I can't screen share. I too am a little bit illiterate when it comes to Zoom and screen sharing, so I apologize there. But I don't know if there's any additional information that you'd like for me to give you at this point.

Speaker 1 (03:06:33–03:08:24)

I'm trying to figure out if these are minor revisions or major revisions. It sounds like a major revision. Now, and again, I try not to be a form of a substance kind of person, but if it's a major revision, you'd have to file a new notice of intent. And when I say that, I have to give you a heads up because I just looked at the old order of conditions and it was signed on June, 16th, 16th of, no, 15th of 2021.

And that means that you have to ask for an extension of that. And you have to ask for an extension before the expiration date, like now. And our next meeting is June 14th. So just make sure you file a motion to extend the order of conditions because If you go beyond the 15th of June, we're not supposed to extend it.

We're supposed to require a new one. But you might require a new one anyway, depending on whether or not these changes seem to be minor revisions or major revisions. And I'm reading your letter, and I'm trying to piece it together. And I know you've done the math here, but I don't I know there's a plan here, but I'm having trouble looking at your plan and matching the plan to what I'm reading here about the size.

The three season porch would be 25 feet by 15 feet. And you're using footings. And that's extending out and over the pool and the patio. That's a question.

Speaker 18 (03:08:24–03:10:32)

Yeah. So this the area would be with a with a three season porch would be would be between the garage and the existing house. And there would be like a front entryway that you'd walk up the stairs and be on a front porch going through. doors into this three season and on the backside then there would be another porch that goes to the pool.

So yes, it is a large area, but it's the 25 by 15 would be the area that is truly impervious. The decking would be all you know, standard decking with a composite and, you know, the slats between so that the, you know, the water does go through it, if you will. So, and again, the area that the three-season porch is going on is already impervious. I guess it's already a driveway, I guess is what I'm trying to say.

The plans aren't, I guess what I want to try to say is I'm looking at, you know, personally, I'm looking at many years of site plans or plot plans that were done for our property and the one that they had produced for us that show the garage with this connecting room, if you will, and proposed, sorry, decking, doesn't actually really show the existing concrete slab that's there. And I'm sorry, it's not really concrete. It's a driveway. I don't know what that is made up of.

Asphalt, I guess, would be the proper terminology. Asphalt and brick patio. So that's what it is already. There's already a deck there.

And we're looking at trying, you know, basically taking the existing deck down and making it bigger to connect the existing house to the garage.

Speaker 1 (03:10:37–03:11:22)

All right. Understood. I'm just, I'm reading your letter and I'm looking at the plan that's been submitted and I'm trying to figure out where everything is going. And I think, I think I've got it.

Um, but again, my gut reaction is it looks like a, like a new project. Um, okay. Tom Palmer has no audio. Tom, can you hear?

Can you hear anything, Tom? No, I guess he can't. He can't be heard, or he cannot hear either. All right, well, keeping that in mind,

Speaker 4 (03:11:23–03:11:29)

John, can we do a site walk on this to see?

Speaker 1 (03:11:29–03:11:34)

I think so, but we're loading up on the first. I don't think we can do it all. We'll lose our quorum on the first.

Speaker 4 (03:11:36–03:11:40)

We have to coach a soccer team.

Speaker 1 (03:11:40–03:11:55)

So we might have to come up with another sidewalk. And we've got to do something before next June, or at least by June 14, because you either have to extend this or file a new one.

Speaker 18 (03:11:55–03:12:09)

Understood. And I'm sorry to ask this technically of you, but do I extend it through the Department of Environmental Protection, or am I doing that through the town? Where would I ask for that extension?

Speaker 1 (03:12:10–03:12:25)

You do it through the town. OK, thank you. It's the same number, but the town commission has the right to issue the extension, as long as the request is made before the expiration. So you've got to do it before the 15th of June.

Speaker 22 (03:12:26–03:12:27)

OK, no problem.

Speaker 1 (03:12:27–03:12:59)

So it absolutely has to be on the agenda for June 4th. So Hans, what do you want to do? I mean, I could do it Saturday the 1st. but I know that you and Ingrid, I think you also have a hot stop at 10.

So do you wanna have a second day to do this? Ted, my gut reaction is it sounds like a major revision, but I wanna hear what other people think. Hans, what do you think?

Speaker 4 (03:13:02–03:13:25)

So looking at the area, I mean, I think I'd like to see what it looks like on site. But yeah, I mean, I could do on that Sunday, I'd be happy to. I don't have to do it, I'm free on the day after.

Speaker 1 (03:13:27–03:13:43)

What about, and I'm willing to do that. Ingrid, what about you? Could you come back the next day? Ingrid, you're on mute too.

Speaker 11 (03:13:48–03:13:55)

Yeah. I think I can make it on Sunday.

Speaker 1 (03:13:56–03:13:58)

Remember, that's Saturday and Sunday.

Speaker 11 (03:13:59–03:13:59)

Right.

Speaker 1 (03:14:01–03:14:10)

Packed agenda. Wendy, while Ingrid's thinking, Wendy, can you do it? I know you can't do it Saturday.

Speaker 6 (03:14:11–03:14:17)

My concern, John, is that I'm supposed to be going out of town that entire weekend.

Speaker 1 (03:14:17–03:14:18)

Weekend, OK.

Speaker 6 (03:14:18–03:14:19)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (03:14:20–03:14:39)

OK, understood. Arthur? I think I can squeeze it in. Good, OK.

So it looks like we can get a quorum. And Tom can't hear us. Let me send a message to Tom.

Speaker 18 (03:14:45–03:16:06)

So I do just want to mention that perhaps when we first started our project, that perhaps I should have done an inquiry or something like that, and we weren't quite ready to start to build. I knew that whatever we were doing needed to be gone through the conservation committee, so I perhaps applied for the order of conditions and that workings uh those workings you know prior to being ready so I just simply want to say that the foundation has started for the garage but the garage is not yet up um so I you know in regards to the site visit um you know like that it is um you know the the the The pool is in, the foundation is in for the garage, and we were originally going to do a prefab garage, and we decided to get a proper builder and contractor to hire to do this project, because we wanted to have it done properly and right. So that's kind of where we stopped. you know, the garage is not built, it's not like we're looking to connect them and have that work, it would be, so we've already been given permission to do the garage and that's why the foundation is in, but we haven't done anything else for this, you know, nothing else has been done, the garage has not been built.

Speaker 4 (03:16:07–03:16:08)

I understand.

Speaker 18 (03:16:08–03:16:09)

Okay.

Speaker 4 (03:16:09–03:16:11)

Do you have full-size plans?

Speaker 18 (03:16:12–03:16:13)

I do, absolutely, yes.

Speaker 4 (03:16:13–03:16:18)

Okay. That'll probably help us while we're there. Okay, absolutely.

Speaker 1 (03:16:18–03:16:35)

I'm trying to get Tom. Can you see it? He's not looking. Yeah, now he is.

All right. Thank you, Kristen.

Speaker 2 (03:16:36–03:16:37)

My pleasure.

Speaker 1 (03:16:37–03:17:04)

So why don't we plan on being those that are willing to attend on Saturday and Sunday? And Steve, what about you? Are you around on Sunday as well? Steve, you're on mute.

You're on mute, Steve. You're still on muting. There you are.

Speaker 3 (03:17:04–03:17:09)

There we go. Yeah, I have duties up in Tewksbury both of those days.

Speaker 1 (03:17:10–03:17:30)

Both days, okay. Yeah. Well, we got one, two, three, four. We've got four people we can do a quorum.

So why don't we do it. Ingrid, you get to choose the time. You're on mute again.

Speaker 4 (03:17:31–03:17:36)

I want to implement a new rule where every time someone talks when they're on mute, they have to plant a tree.

Speaker 18 (03:17:36–03:17:44)

I'm good with 8 AM. Absolutely. No problem.

Speaker 1 (03:17:44–03:17:45)

All right. Good for everybody.

Speaker 18 (03:17:47–03:17:56)

Thank you very much. I appreciate your willingness to come out and make this happen for us. I truly appreciate your time this evening.

Speaker 1 (03:17:56–03:18:01)

OK. All right. Good. Thank you very much, Kristen.

And we'll see you Sunday morning at 8 o'clock.

Speaker 18 (03:18:01–03:18:02)

Sounds good.

Speaker 1 (03:18:02–03:18:05)

Thank you very much. On the second, I guess, the second of June.

Speaker 18 (03:18:05–03:18:08)

Yes, on the second. I'll make sure to have coffee and pastries for everyone.

Speaker 1 (03:18:09–03:18:16)

No, no, we can't do that. We get accused of bribery. Absolutely.

Speaker 18 (03:18:17–03:18:22)

How about a healthy serving of nettles? Something like that sounds better. Thank you very much.

Speaker 1 (03:18:22–03:18:49)

Thank you. All right. Now we're up to 13 potential MCC grant proposals, CPA committee discussion. And I know this has been a long meeting.

So Arthur, why don't you lead off with that and give us your thoughts on it. Just keep in mind that the reasons on the agenda is that by May 31st, where's that noise coming from? Can you tell?

Speaker 6 (03:18:50–03:18:51)

It seems to be Tom.

Speaker 1 (03:18:53–03:19:11)

Yeah, fixing his audio. But the CPA grants, and Wendy, you know this better than all of us, are due by the end of the month. So if we, the Conservation Commission, want to… Ouch.

Tom, he killed us.

Speaker 6 (03:19:11–03:19:15)

Would you mind muting yourself? That noise is really piercing.

Speaker 1 (03:19:15–03:19:26)

Yeah. Tom, wave if you can hear us on the telephone. He's not waving. Looks like he's calling.

Speaker 6 (03:19:26–03:19:33)

Steve, since it's your host, are you able to mute Tom?

Speaker 3 (03:19:36–03:19:38)

I'm not sure. Good question.

Speaker 6 (03:19:39–03:19:40)

You should be able to.

Speaker 9 (03:19:40–03:19:42)

I'm on my phone, I think. Can anybody hear me?

Speaker 1 (03:19:43–03:19:44)

Now we can, Tom.

Speaker 9 (03:19:45–03:20:00)

But you were making a lot of noise. I'm sorry. The audio just cut out. And I was watching your mouse move, but nothing came out.

And I couldn't. read lips and couldn't figure it out. And I still haven't figured it out.

Speaker 1 (03:20:01–03:20:13)

All right. Well, we just agreed we're going to have a second site meeting, one on Saturday at 8 o'clock. But that's going to hot stop at 10. So we're going to carry forward on Sunday morning at 8 o'clock.

Speaker 9 (03:20:15–03:20:17)

That's good for me. That will be the 2nd of June.

Speaker 1 (03:20:19–03:21:44)

Good. All right. Perfect. All right, so now we're up to the CPA grant, CPA requests for grant funding due by May 31st, and we're looking for ideas.

Now, in the past, you know what we've done, the pedestrian bridge, the circumvention of the Pope's Pond, the acquisition of the land and the study to how to preserve the marshland off of Riverside Drive. We did try to get money for a conservation easement in the pursuit of open space on Blue Hill Avenue, but that was turned down, that was rejected by the CPA, the CPA committee. So we're looking for ideas at this point. And keep in mind that there is a Climate Action Planning Committee for which Arthur is our representative.

And they've got some aggressive and energetic folks that are trying to do the same thing, preserve, plan, and they want to. come in with their own proposals, but for some of the money reserved for conservation. So hopefully we can work together and not be in competition. But we need to, and I think we can do that, but we need to have some ideas about what good proposals would be to advance the conservation and open space cause.

Speaker 7 (03:21:44–03:21:46)

What's the amount of money?

Speaker 1 (03:21:47–03:22:15)

We don't know. It's a percentage that we're guaranteed, I guess, 10%. So there are four components and each have, no, there are three components and each have 10% and then we can fight over the other 70%. And they base it on merit and what they think is the appropriate devotion of funds or commitment of funds.

We should have 10% of whatever it is. Now, this year was a million dollars. Last year was a million seven.

Speaker 10 (03:22:15–03:22:21)

And John, fiscal year 25, town meeting approved $1,050,000.

Speaker 1 (03:22:22–03:22:39)

Yeah, but that was, we just approved that. We approved that, that was last year. That's the million that I mentioned. I don't know what money is available for next.

But that's to be expended in fiscal 25.

Speaker 10 (03:22:40–03:22:41)

That's right.

Speaker 1 (03:22:41–03:22:46)

But I don't know that the funds have come in. They've been designated yet, because it's a tax.

Speaker 10 (03:22:46–03:22:51)

It's been that for a couple of years. So let's assume about $1 million.

Speaker 1 (03:22:52–03:22:52)

Yeah.

Speaker 10 (03:22:53–03:22:55)

At least, that's what I was trying to say.

Speaker 1 (03:22:55–03:23:02)

Yeah, the year of the pedestrian bridge, which was 22, was 1.7. Last year was a million.

Speaker 10 (03:23:02–03:23:08)

That's because they had part of the preceding year as well as last year.

Speaker 1 (03:23:08–03:24:00)

Right. So it's around a million, I guess. That's the answer. Okay.

And again, it's recreation, open space, climate preservation, conservation purposes generally. So if there's land to be purchased, land is so expensive, we don't have enough. If they could give us 100,000, 200,000, we're not going to be able to buy a couple of acres of land for that. We could buy conservation restrictions.

And that's been my thought, that we should be pushing in that direction. Because even if we don't own the land, if we can preserve and protect against development, we can keep the open space. So that's my idea to push, but we need to hear from all of you folks as to what you think is good.

Speaker 4 (03:24:01–03:24:40)

And then- I'm not sure if I asked this before, but would potentially asking to do a civil survey, so a survey of property. So for example, the lands that we're taking under conservation restriction, you know, the combined around Pope's Pond, all that stuff, getting a full survey of those lands, including up by Beverly Park. Would that be worthwhile?

Speaker 9 (03:24:42–03:24:48)

Are we taking any land there? I mean, Pope's Pond is already conservation land, correct?

Speaker 1 (03:24:48–03:25:36)

It is, yes. No, we're trying to enhance that, the land that we can preserve, whether we own it or not, or if we're the recipient of the conservation restriction or the conservation easement. That's like when John Cronin was alive. He and I were trying to see if we could put money together to buy the corner of Breedsteel Road and Canton Avenue.

And that lot was sold, and unfortunately, when the fellow sold it, he wasn't willing to split the land, so another person came in and bought it. And I think, Wendy, didn't you say that land was owned by the church right at the corner of Readsdale?

Speaker 6 (03:25:37–03:25:39)

Correct, yes.

Speaker 1 (03:25:39–03:26:23)

John Cronin and I were trying to figure out how to buy that land or buy the conservation restriction on it, just so that somebody wouldn't put a house there. And that goes along the same, preserve the open space. But there are lots of other ideas. And Hans, your idea is good, but so many groups have tried to do that.

The Master Plan Committee tried to do it, or did it. And then when the inventory was done, I guess there were a couple of problems. Nobody knew who had it, and it turned out not to be accurate, because that inventory actually included Pope's Pond on it as being owned by the Conservation Commission. We didn't own it.

Speaker 4 (03:26:23–03:26:30)

But that's why I'm suggesting a survey, including a deed search to try and resolve it.

Speaker 1 (03:26:30–03:26:41)

Arthur, haven't we, you and I talked to Nick Milano about doing that. We're talking about who could do it, how do we get the money for it? Maybe that is something we should be funding for.

Speaker 10 (03:26:43–03:27:07)

Inventorying the conservation lands has been very time consuming. It involves the engineering office, our offices, on the line, there has not been any clear inventory of all conservation lands in the town of Milton.

Speaker 9 (03:27:08–03:28:10)

I recently heard from Meredith Hall, the planning board, that she is working on the open space plan and that Tim Scherzinski of planning had a list of sites that were formerly belonging to the Milton Land Trust. And some had gone to Wildlands Trust, and some went to the Conservation Commission. And she was trying to find out if any of them had been developed. And I said to her that I didn't know myself, but I would hope that the open space plan would have such an inventory of all open space parcels with their managing authorities.

And I guess that's the same thing we're talking about here. I agree. It's a real defect that nobody can open a map and say, these lots in Mildon are X, these lots in Mildon are Y, and so forth, particularly open space lots.

Speaker 1 (03:28:13–03:29:06)

Yeah, and Tom, apropos of what you just said, I talked to Tim maybe a year ago, at least a year ago. And we were talking about, you know, getting that data together. At the time, he was unaware that in 2014, the master plan committee did exactly that. They put together and that was what John Cronin was working on.

And that was his contribution to to inventory that land. And then we had a hard time finding it. But we did. And Kathy Bowen actually was the one that located that inventory and gave it to Tim Zerwinski.

So he's, as town planner, he's pushing for it. So maybe we can get together with you know, the town planner and the open space committee and see if we can get some money to bring in an outside vendor to do it, because we've started and stopped this so many times.

Speaker 9 (03:29:07–03:29:40)

And… Yeah, I think it is a requirement of an open space plan to have such an inventory. And there was one done starting in 1970. That was the first one, which I have a copy of.

And it had a color-coded map of every open space and conservation property in town that they were aware of. And perhaps that has been updated effectively several times. I don't know. I think, Arthur, you're very knowledgeable about this.

Speaker 10 (03:29:43–03:30:06)

We've made a lot of progress in the past couple of years, but we really do not have what other communities possess in terms of a directory and inventory of all open space properties in the town, regardless of whose jurisdiction they fall under. That would be a valuable thing to have for sure.

Speaker 6 (03:30:08–03:31:12)

Well, I know that we have been working on this this inventory. I'm not sure if it's exactly what you guys have in mind, but through this revision of the open space plan, which, like John, you were saying, we've been in the process of revising the last couple of years. My question is, and I wish we had asked him when he was on on the call earlier today, but I'm not sure what the status is of that report. I know that the committee, the last time that we met was last summer, that I recall.

I know that we also had a public meeting in September. of 2023 held at the library in which we were trying to solicit some feedback from the public, from the community members. But I'm not sure what the status has been since then.

Speaker 10 (03:31:15–03:31:34)

John, you and I had a conversation with Tim when he was trying to inventory access to conservation lands, including accessibility by handicapped individuals and people with disabilities? Do you follow that conversation?

Speaker 1 (03:31:35–03:33:54)

I do. And that's the conversation I think I had when I said the Master Plan Committee did such an inventory back in 2014. And Kathy Bowen was able to find it and did send that to him. So I know he's got that one.

And then there have been several attempts since then to update it. But I think Hans might be onto something. It might be if you could write a proposal. Hans, I don't mean to dump it on you, but it's a good idea.

And just, you know what the proposals look like. I've got a bunch of them. You just say, we need some help bringing in a group. And it might be, you know, pay some group $15,000 and sit down and go through the deeds.

One of the most difficult ones is to find the conservation restrictions. And this came up as a result of the land swap with the school building committee that I know was a contentious discussion. Passions were running high and all that. But during that time, somebody said, well, why didn't you guys, meaning the Conservation Commission, re-up the expiration.

The town council told us that after 30 years, the conservation restriction expired because it was not held in perpetuity. And if it doesn't say in perpetuity, then it expires in 30 years. So why didn't you renew it? We didn't renew it because we didn't know we had it.

Or I didn't know we had it. And that led to the question, well, good Lord, there are conservation restrictions all over the town. And the 30 years are going to come and go. And people have been restricting land with easements for years.

Are they all expiring? So one of the plans was, and I'm going back to maybe three years now, can we find somebody to do a search? And Arthur, you and I talked about it, and we talked about getting Kathy Kathleen O'Donnell, because she's very familiar with the way things are recorded in the Registry of Needs. But you'd have to search all of the private residences.

The people that live next door to me have a conservation restriction. I know that because I talked to them about it, but probably nobody else does it.

Speaker 4 (03:33:55–03:34:01)

But at the end of the day, I mean, if it's not filed with the registry or if it's not, if the notification doesn't exist,

Speaker 1 (03:34:02–03:34:18)

Oh, but it is filed with the registry. But you don't know where to look. I mean, you can't type in, give me all your conservation restrictions. It doesn't give it back.

If you look at the property, you can say, oh, look, there's a conservation restriction. But that's a big task.

Speaker 4 (03:34:18–03:34:47)

Yeah. But I think we can start with the inventory that we do have to confirm that the documentation's in line. Right. And so I think that might be a good place to start with a scope.

And I mean, that's either a land surveyor or a law office or something of that effect that can do that sort of comprehensive deed search.

Speaker 1 (03:34:48–03:35:20)

You wouldn't want to hire a, there are, you know, deed runner. Yeah. The law firms hire, if you hire a law firm to do it, you're going to pay a little extra. I would go directly to the, cut out the middleman, go directly to the runner.

And those guys are pretty good. And all the law firms use them. All the advancing firms have their own runners to do that. They just sit at the registry.

And that's why Kathleen O'Donnell is very familiar with how that system works and who the players are. Do you want me to talk to Kathleen?

Speaker 10 (03:35:20–03:35:20)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (03:35:20–03:35:31)

And then work with Hans. And Hans, if you can come up with it, just take a couple of paragraphs for a proposal. And maybe Kathleen could give you an idea of what the cost would be to hire someone.

Speaker 10 (03:35:32–03:35:46)

Or somebody who could do it for reasonable fees, et cetera. So Hans, do you want me to talk to Kathleen and get this to you? Sure. Whatever she has to say, I'll do that tomorrow.

Speaker 9 (03:35:46–03:35:59)

I would just add that Kathleen worked on those land trust parcels and wrote descriptions of them that Meredith shared with me. So she's already doing some of this work, it seems. Yes.

Speaker 4 (03:35:59–03:36:00)

Excellent. That'll be a cost savings.

Speaker 10 (03:36:03–03:36:37)

We also need this to help with encroachment on conservation lands, because there are lands that we own. There are lands with conservation restrictions that are landlocked. The abutting properties have no idea that they are conservation in one form or another. and it's very easy for people to do things that we've seen them do elsewhere in town.

You're right. You know, there are sheds all over the place and gardens and Wildlife is taking a back seat.

Speaker 2 (03:36:37–03:36:39)

Golf greens.

Speaker 10 (03:36:39–03:36:39)

Yep.

Speaker 1 (03:36:40–03:37:21)

Practice putting greens. All right. Can I interrupt this discussion? Because we could actually talk for a very long time on this.

And I know we've got the access road to Milton, and I see Deb Keller waiting hopefully patiently here. Can we table this discussion and then maybe continue it under new business and get to number 14 on the list that's acceptable to everybody? Yes. All right.

Yes. Deb, if you're listening, we're going to go on to the Access Road, Milton Quarry Hills continued hearing. Thanks for your patience. It's getting late.

Speaker 32 (03:37:21–03:42:37)

Oh, I was plugging and chugging while I was listening to you guys so. Good. Happy Deb Keller with Merrill engineers and land surveyors happy to finally be before you again for this project. I can share my screen.

And. Thank you. Um, and I will be try to be as brief as possible, but, uh, not skip over anything. So since we last met, which I think was early, uh, you know, early this year, um, We had a site walk out at the, um, access road.

And, uh, then we started our coordination with natural heritage for the, uh, endangered species on the. town property, identified on the town property just south of the access road. So we have now, yay, I'm so excited. We did receive our determination letter from Natural Heritage this afternoon, which I forwarded I think it was forwarded to the Conservation Office, but I forwarded it again just to make sure that everybody had a copy of it.

We have addressed Natural Heritage's concerns. They have determined that, as designed, we would not be a take. And I will briefly go through the plan. This is the existing conditions plan.

As you can see, this magenta line is the habitat line. So it skirts right along the edge of the existing access driveway and kind of sneaks into some of the shoulder of the drive along this bend here. So what we ended up doing was Move down just 1 more is just tweaking the curve here so that we could shift the access drive. To the North within the right of way, so it's still within the, the.

I'm going to call it right of way for purposes. Defining the roadway and. So that was the shift in the road. The profile stayed the same.

What we did have to do with regards to the drainage, because the habitat was so tight up in this corner, where we had an outlet, an outfall come out up here, tied into the drainage, we weren't allowed to put that outfall within the habitat area. So we tied this, discharge into the next outfall midway down the road and then maintaining the one at the intersection. We also added, I'm gonna zip right to it, a wildlife, I'm gonna zoom into this just a tad. A wildlife barrier, which you can see in this picture, it's a firm sort of plastic barrier that gets installed right on the edge of the habitat and is extended up.

So this is your habitat area. What can I call it? I apologize. I'm not supposed to say the species.

Wildlife. Wildlife. Yeah, that's a good answer. Wildlife stays on this side and can't jump over or get up and over.

But if by any chance the wildlife ends up on the access roadside. This is a gravel ramp. So basically it's just gravel filled up alongside the side of the fence where the wildlife can maneuver and hop back onto the right side of the fence. And this is a further detail on the fencing that would be installed along the habitat limit.

which would be along the southerly side of the access road. And I do know just briefly for clarification, this will be a good one. We are stopping the improvements to the road just past our property line. I think you might have been touching upon that in one of your previous meetings.

So that is where that limit is. further improvements to the roadway, we taper back down to the existing access conditions at that point.

Speaker 1 (03:42:40–03:43:15)

What about the comment that, I don't know if Tim made it or it came up in a discussion with Tim Zerwinski, the town planner, when we were talking about the animal shelter, and Tom Palmer was saying, well, you know, above the yard property line there, the extent of the rehab road, it's going to be the same old dump road, landfill, I'm supposed to call it. Does that water coming down off of that road, is that going to impact your drainage system, your drainage design?

Speaker 32 (03:43:17–03:43:59)

Most of, from what I could tell, looking at the drainage out there, most of that roadway has a cross slope. So it crosses over and runs down sort of the gutter edge, the southerly gutter edge, and would make it into the wetland prior to the improvements. I would suspect that there would be some runoff possibly from this steeper slope on the budding property that would make it in here. But I don't believe that a large amount of the runoff would end up getting into the new catch basin system on the access road.

Speaker 9 (03:44:02–03:45:10)

That seems a little, to me that seems, I'm asking myself, well, where will the water go? Because I know that on the downslope side of the road, there is a deep gully cut into the side of the road by the runoff. And I would say that gully is somewhere near your cursor is, yeah. And not only does water come down, but there is a lot of mineral stuff that comes down too.

It seems to be coming from the quarry hills, a gas line access road. There's something about the drainage up by the road fork, where the road forks, that causes water to collect there and also material to run down from there toward this area. So the road is covered with sand and dirt in places near this gully. And I just don't really understand how that same situation is going to be remedied in any way by what we're talking about here?

Speaker 32 (03:45:12–03:45:20)

I'm not sure that that flow that you're talking about would be remedied. It would still flow into the wetland area.

Speaker 9 (03:45:20–03:45:29)

Well, wouldn't that little wall or berm that's being discussed, wouldn't that interrupt that existing gully?

Speaker 32 (03:45:31–03:46:19)

Well, we're actually going to be north of that gully. because we've pushed the road north. So that gully is over on this side. So this will end up coming, continue to come down the southerly side of the improved roadway and end up into the wetland.

Because we were forced to push the road to the north, because of the habitat limit in this area that allows for that avenue and we wouldn't be blocking that flow. Unfortunately, I'm not 100% sure. Those are improvements that need to happen up gradient of this property.

Speaker 9 (03:46:19–03:47:41)

I understand. Yeah, I get what you're saying. You answered my question by saying that you don't think that water and mineral stuff will continue into the area you've improved. But I would say that by improving and directing it off into the wetland, the existing problem will continue and might even get worse.

I think that's just my impression. One reason for that is at the edge of the road where that gully is cut, There is also, there's already an enormous patch of Japanese knotweed that was, you know, encouraged by all the sedimentation. And directly below that, there's quite a slope. So when the water does get off the road there, it leaves the sediment for the knotweed, and then it cuts deep into the habitat and the same area where you weren't allowed to discharge.

So there is an existing problem. And my question is still, when does that get addressed? I guess we don't have the answer.

Speaker 32 (03:47:42–03:47:56)

Yeah, that's a tough one because, unfortunately, we can't touch it. They won't allow us, natural heritage won't allow us within that habitat unless they consider it a take.

Speaker 9 (03:47:59–03:48:01)

Yeah, that's a constraint.

Speaker 21 (03:48:02–03:48:04)

Yeah, unfortunately.

Speaker 9 (03:48:04–03:48:19)

One more comment. Sure. I don't want to change the subject, but I know that you have a lot of your stormwater system is based on collectors that will be under the parking lot, is that correct? There will be a system of voids under there, right?

Speaker 32 (03:48:20–03:48:22)

Yes.

Speaker 9 (03:48:22–03:48:50)

Yeah, I don't mean to object to the plan, but I just think that it's a little hard to maintain such systems when they're under a parking lot compared to ones that are open to the sky. I would just say that someday will be perhaps need to be maintained or replaced, and that will be a big deal because it's under the parking lot. I wonder if you have a sort of view on that.

Speaker 32 (03:48:52–03:50:18)

Well, I tend to agree it's hard. Out of sight, out of mind is usually the saying I think of. But in these cases, when it's more of a There's an association that will be managing this site. We have a better opportunity to, more confidence anyways, in knowing that the operation and maintenance plan will be followed and the system will be inspected so that hopefully the longevity of that system will be on the longer side than if it was not maintained.

But you're correct. If it does fail, it has to be replaced. And we spell that out all in the operation and maintenance plan so that either the property owner or the maintenance The company that maintains the property will have that documentation. They need to report it and have record keeping of the maintenance.

Actually, all the BMPs that are on the property.

Speaker 9 (03:50:22–03:50:22)

Thank you.

Speaker 32 (03:50:22–03:50:23)

I hope that helps.

Speaker 1 (03:50:25–03:50:59)

Yeah, Deb, can you clarify something for me? You've said a number of times that because of the magenta line that you see on the plan here that shows the extent of the wildlife habitat, that the road had to be moved north. Yeah. As I'm looking at the plan, sometimes that red line is inside what I think is the boundary of the roadway.

Is the roadway going to be moved outside of that red line, that magenta line?

Speaker 32 (03:50:59–03:52:01)

So it is extremely close, especially in this area here. And it was difficult to show on the plans, and I'll zoom in a little bit closer, because we're putting that fence in and erosion control all right up against the magenta line. That's why this kind of looks like a A red purple line, they're all right next to each other. So, as if I, you can see where there's areas where we have a little bit of room between the.

edge of the roadway and the habitat line. So we have a little bit of flexibility here, but we pushed the road over all the way to the property line at this location. And then the other tight location was up at our driveway where you can see that we pushed the road from about where my cursor is now all the way over again, so that we were right on the property line.

Speaker 1 (03:52:02–03:52:07)

Did you narrow the road at all, or does the road maintain its width?

Speaker 32 (03:52:07–03:52:37)

It's maintaining its width. But it is, I would concur, it's an extremely tight line right along that habitat for those two main locations, everywhere else where we have, you know, a little bit more room. And that's just because I had to use whatever line was shown on the GIS mapping is what they required us to use as the limit of the habitat.

Speaker 20 (03:52:39–03:52:47)

OK.

Speaker 1 (03:52:47–03:53:07)

All right. So this is, where are we in the process? This is still the notice of intent. But this is the whole project notice of intent.

Or is it just, is it a separate for the access road?

Speaker 32 (03:53:11–03:53:55)

I guess it's the way, however you want to look at it, the property is not located within the 100 foot buffer, just the access road. But we provided you all of the data so that you can look at the proposed project as well as the improvements to the access road. Gotcha. But I would say, technically, this is for the access road improvements, because now, in actuality, we don't have any other impact within the 100-foot buffer other than the intersection and the first, say, 100 feet of the roadway, which is a 100-foot buffer.

Speaker 1 (03:53:57–03:54:15)

That was really the area of our concern, because I call it the confluence of You know, multiple projects, yeah, because we've got the animal shelter and drainage coming from there down the hill. We've got the 728 meeting at the… Well, wait a minute.

Speaker 9 (03:54:16–03:54:23)

Isn't there a bump in the road that protects the lower end from runoff from the upper end? Isn't there like a high point?

Speaker 32 (03:54:23–03:54:25)

Yeah, yeah, right in here.

Speaker 9 (03:54:25–03:54:41)

Yeah. So the house fall at 28 will only collect water reaching back to there rather than all the way up to the entrance. Is that right? So the cursor is now is at a high point.

Speaker 32 (03:54:42–03:55:06)

OK, so let me I'm going to. Let's see if I can find the profile. Yes. So see, you can see here.

right about where my cursor is here, is this high point in the road? So the catch basins at the intersection do only collect this portion of the access road. Then this pitches back down to the location where these catch basins are?

Speaker 9 (03:55:06–03:55:15)

Yeah, that was my impression. Although I see a deep pipe in between that I don't really get, that deep underground pipe.

Speaker 32 (03:55:15–03:55:23)

This here, that's the sewer main coming up the street and tying into the structure.

Speaker 9 (03:55:26–03:55:37)

All right. Do you get what I'm saying, John? That down at 28, they don't have the burden of the whole access road in the stormwater. Because a lot of it is vented off before it gets there.

Speaker 1 (03:55:38–03:56:03)

I do get that. But our concern was, is there going to be a confluence? Some of the drainage now is going from the project down to, it's going along the old driveway, that is the driveway for the property at 728. Isn't there a drainage directly to a pipe there on Randolph Avenue?

I don't know that.

Speaker 32 (03:56:04–03:56:05)

Do you mean over here, John?

Speaker 1 (03:56:05–03:56:06)

Yes. Yes, correct. Exactly.

Speaker 32 (03:56:07–03:56:44)

None of the new development up here drains in this direction? All of this is addressed with the onsite stormwater and tied into the closed drainage system. And the existing driveway that accesses the abutting property here will be maintained. And then we're vegetating and removing the gravel driveway that comes up to the existing 728 house right now.

So that would get removed.

Speaker 1 (03:56:48–03:56:55)

Is there a pipe going down the existing driveway? Right there, right? Isn't there a pipe going down there to take some of the water off the site?

Speaker 32 (03:56:56–03:56:56)

No.

Speaker 1 (03:56:57–03:57:06)

So it's all going, that is, that which is heading towards Randolph Avenue is going essentially to the lower side of the access road.

Speaker 32 (03:57:07–03:57:07)

Correct.

Speaker 1 (03:57:08–03:57:10)

So this- The south side of the access road.

Speaker 32 (03:57:11–03:57:51)

Yes. Yeah. So this is, there's a water service that comes through here and an overhead, no drainage is within here. So we're allowing the existing driveway, the pavement stops here, and then there's a gravel driveway to the existing home in this location currently.

So that's being removed and revegetated. And then the existing driveway here will be maintained, excuse me, for 718 and 736. Got it.

Speaker 1 (03:57:53–03:58:16)

I know I'm repeating myself, something we discussed previously, but your calculations include the amount of water coming from the 7-Eleven project across the street. Because that's heading into the same, daylight's at the same place, at the intersection of the access road and Randolph Avenue. on the east side.

Speaker 33 (03:58:17–03:58:20)

Across from Randolph Ave, the project across Randolph Ave?

Speaker 1 (03:58:20–03:58:31)

Yeah, that's 711. And it's cut diagonally across the pipe, and it daylights in the same place as the off-pipes.

Speaker 32 (03:58:33–03:59:02)

Yes. So they would be completely separate. So this is the culvert that comes across the intersection here. That would be what 711- Yes, that's correct.

Discharges to, and we're discharging on property outside of the habitat. And you are correct, it's in the same location. Similar, but I'm not tying into that culvert at all, not touching it.

Speaker 1 (03:59:03–03:59:06)

No, I know you're not touching it, but the water is entering up in the same place.

Speaker 32 (03:59:07–03:59:08)

Yes, absolutely, yep.

Speaker 1 (03:59:09–03:59:09)

There's a lot of water.

Speaker 32 (03:59:12–04:00:15)

But the discharge off of here and in this close drainage, it is still relatively the same amount. Oops, I keep going in the wrong direction. Same amount that was flowing to this location before. The only difference is it was getting into probably Randolph Ave drainage.

Rather than being collected and discharged here, it's probably discharges. I obviously don't have drainage on Randolph, but I would imagine it's going to end up in the same. wetland area, the high point is, is, as you can see the dash lines here, this is generally the same high point, uh, existing high point along the roadway. So we're not at least adding to the amount of area that flows down to, to the intersection.

I don't know if that helps.

Speaker 1 (04:00:15–04:00:20)

I know that's your standard. I appreciate that. Yeah.

Speaker 32 (04:00:20–04:00:20)

Okay.

Speaker 11 (04:00:20–04:00:20)

Yep.

Speaker 1 (04:00:21–04:00:26)

All right. Any comments, concerns, questions from commission members?

Speaker 9 (04:00:29–04:00:34)

The stormwater review was done while I was at Board of Appeals, correct?

Speaker 32 (04:00:34–04:00:37)

That is correct, yeah.

Speaker 9 (04:00:37–04:00:40)

Who did that review for the town, do you recall?

Speaker 32 (04:00:42–04:00:43)

Oh, John?

Speaker 29 (04:00:44–04:00:45)

What?

Speaker 10 (04:00:47–04:00:53)

No, he's the ZBA that you're talking about.

Speaker 32 (04:00:53–04:01:05)

It was the zoning board. And I'm going to check right now because I'm not remembering his.

Speaker 1 (04:01:07–04:01:15)

But yeah, I thought you had the peer reviewer for the stormwater discharge. John Lennon, the ZBA, he wrote the opinion.

Speaker 32 (04:01:16–04:01:24)

Yeah, no, it wasn't John, it's Sean. John Reardon. Yes, exactly.

Speaker 9 (04:01:25–04:01:33)

Well, that's sort of the technical review that should happen for a project of this size.

Speaker 32 (04:01:33–04:01:35)

Yes, Tetra Tech.

Speaker 9 (04:01:39–04:01:42)

So I guess it passed muster with Sean.

Speaker 20 (04:01:46–04:01:50)

Yep. All right. Any other thoughts, questions?

Speaker 1 (04:01:54–04:02:21)

Because I think we're at a point of a vote, aren't we? Yes. That would be great for me. I know everybody's tired.

But this is, I mean, our jurisdiction is somewhat limited here. but it seems like the I's have been dotted and the T's have been crossed.

Speaker 9 (04:02:21–04:03:30)

If we were starting at the beginning, I think we would try to make this project address more of the problems on the road than it does. I get that it addresses the increases it's going to create, but there is an existing situation that isn't really integrated effectively. We're just not getting any extra in terms of trying to deal with the problems up the road, which will continue. I get the idea that when this is built, all that stuff coming down the road, instead of going into the proposed catch basins, will go off to the left and down the slope.

Yeah, that would make sense if you're the developer, you don't want to deal with it, but it means that The existing bad situation will simply continue. And I hope it won't be a problem for this road. I guess, Deb, you're convinced that it won't be. So maybe fixing that has to wait for another time.

Speaker 1 (04:03:38–04:03:56)

OK. Any other thought? I mean, Tom, I heard what you said. But it appears that the performance standards have been met, that there's no net increase in water discharge here that is being appropriately slowed down and retained.

Speaker 9 (04:03:59–04:04:43)

We will, yeah, I don't mean to interrupt, but I would say that the discharge that is mapped here that will go towards the habitat, there's a chance, therefore, an erosion problem because it is a slope. So, I think where that outfall is, I don't remember seeing any detail about it, but there might need to be a BMP there to prevent that discharge from eroding the slope. I know that that is a place you can't work because it's inside that magenta line. So, it's sort of a paradox here, isn't it?

Speaker 32 (04:04:43–04:05:21)

It's a tough one because I really would have liked to have, you know, what I originally had in all three locations was, you know, proposing a riprap sediment trap. which would help, one, collect the sediment, would also slow down your flows and minimize the erosion. But unfortunately, in the one area that you have mentioned, which is really the critical one, I've seen it too, they're not allowing us to go into that area at all.

Speaker 9 (04:05:23–04:05:26)

Yeah, I got you. That's just how it's set up.

Speaker 20 (04:05:27–04:05:33)

Yeah. All right. Any other comments, questions from commission members?

Speaker 1 (04:05:36–04:05:40)

Is that no, Wendy?

Speaker 6 (04:05:40–04:05:41)

Oh yeah. No.

Speaker 1 (04:05:43–04:06:45)

All right. All right. Well, um, I think it's time to propose that, uh, if the I's have been dotted and the T's have been crossed and we have to make a decision as to whether or not an order of condition should issue. Um, And you know our regular boilerplate conditions, Deb, I think.

Surge of equipment, refueling of equipment in the jurisdictional areas, things of that nature. And it may be difficult when you're working on the road, but I think there's enough space there to at least have your staging area out of our jurisdiction for overnight and refueling. But other than those special conditions, are there any other suggested conditions by commission members before we have a motion? And hearing none other than the usual, is there then a motion to issue the order of conditions based upon the plans that have been submitted by Merrill Engineering?

Speaker 4 (04:06:46–04:06:46)

I'll make that motion.

Speaker 1 (04:06:46–04:07:17)

So moved. All right. Hans, if you would then Is that Tom who was seconding it or? Yeah, I'll second it.

Okay. All right. Is there any discussion from among commission members? Hearing none, a roll call vote and how do you vote Hans?

Yes. Tom, how do you vote? Yes. Ingrid, how do you vote?

Speaker 22 (04:07:17–04:07:18)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (04:07:19–04:07:19)

Wendy, how do you vote?

Speaker 22 (04:07:20–04:07:21)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (04:07:21–04:07:33)

Arthur, how do you vote? Yes. And I, John Kiernan, vote yes as well. So it's unanimous, Deb.

You're good to go. Great. Thank you very much. I appreciate it.

Thanks for your patience. It's been a long night.

Speaker 32 (04:07:34–04:07:38)

Thank you, Deb. For you guys as well. So I hope you guys can scoot out quickly.

Speaker 1 (04:07:39–04:09:15)

Yes. Hopefully. All right. Thank you.

So now we're new business. And we can return, or we could table the discussion about the CPA grant, but we're out of time. We have to make our applications by the 31st of May. So at least, Hans, with respect to your proposal, if you could come up with that pretty quickly and then circulate it among the commission members so we can all kind of weigh in.

It doesn't have to be complicated. And what I've done for studies, I usually call Chase Berkeley and say, have you done a study like this, like for the circumvention of Hope's Pond, the pond, I called Pete Jackson and said, what did it cost at Turner's Pond? And he gave me some insight. And Chase Berkley gave me some insight.

And these are studies. I'm not talking about the projects themselves. And they're going to be more expensive than you think. And my ballpark would be $40,000.

That's my guess, Hans, but you should talk to Hans. Maybe even Sue Galvin, because I know she's had some study groups that have sent out to vendors. The bylaw committee sent out for a vendor to do an analysis of our 10,000 bylaws or whatever we've had over the last 300 years. So there are people with some information about how much money can be justified.

Speaker 4 (04:09:16–04:09:21)

John, it's basically a title search, right, that we're doing that's for each property?

Speaker 1 (04:09:23–04:09:24)

I think so.

Speaker 18 (04:09:24–04:09:25)

Okay.

Speaker 1 (04:09:27–04:09:36)

Right. All right. Can anybody else come up with ideas? Circulate them.

And my idea is to look for land to buy or conservation restrictions to buy.

Speaker 9 (04:09:37–04:09:38)

But we've got to put it together.

Speaker 1 (04:09:39–04:09:39)

What's that?

Speaker 9 (04:09:39–04:09:47)

Is working on the same questions. Who is? So we would like to avoid duplicating anyone else's work.

Speaker 20 (04:09:50–04:09:51)

Tom, who's doing the same thing?

Speaker 9 (04:09:52–04:10:32)

Open Space Committee, in order to update the master plan necessary for state grants. Yes. Somebody's doing that. Maybe, Wendy, you know something.

I guess you did tell us that there is a committee, and I just know what I know, that Kathleen O'Donnell has been working on parcels. that were formerly belonging to the land trust. So all I'm saying is that, Hans, you might want to call Kathleen O'Donnell and ask her, what parcels do you already know about? I don't know.

It just, it seems that similar work is being pursued.

Speaker 1 (04:10:33–04:10:44)

Correct. And Tim Zerwinski is probably the lead author of all those efforts. So Hans, you probably should start with Tim. Because he absolutely has been doing this.

Speaker 6 (04:10:44–04:11:51)

Yes. Yeah, and I think that Tim will be able to fill us in on where the committee and the consultants have left off, and where the gaps are, and what the next steps really need to be. Because I know that the committee has been working with consultants from Horsley-Whitten Group. But the scope of work was really limited to helping us with making the necessary revisions to this open space plan.

While I know that there have been discussions, very broad brush discussions about where these conservation restrictions are, they really haven't been drilled down to that specific parcel level that we're talking about now.

Speaker 1 (04:11:57–04:12:19)

All right, so Hans, it's in your hands, your capable hands. And anybody else weigh in, please, during the week. So if there is money. And I'm going to look around to see if I can spot some restrictions to buy, or chunks of land to buy, or some kind of a project.

But let's make sure that we communicate with one another, keeping in mind that the 31st is our deadline.

Speaker 10 (04:12:20–04:12:40)

John, just to note. I would just mention. Oh, go ahead, Arthur. I'm just going to mention chunks of land are going to be inordinately expensive.

purchase of the land from St. Agatha's for the East Milton Fire Station. Estimate between $700,000 and $800,000 an acre in Milton.

Speaker 1 (04:12:42–04:12:50)

Oh, I'm well aware of that. That's why I, you know, the glitter went out of my eye. I'm looking for conservation restrictions.

Speaker 10 (04:12:50–04:13:04)

Right. That's why. That we can't afford. That's where I was going to suggest the focus of attention rather than in a proposal suggest both of them.

Speaker 1 (04:13:04–04:13:30)

Oh, absolutely. It's the open space purchase, but it doesn't have to be by fee simple. It can be much cheaper and doable if it's by restriction. And it may be just knocking on landowners' doors and saying, can we buy some of your land via a restriction?

You still own it, but you just can't develop on it. That achieves the goal.

Speaker 9 (04:13:30–04:13:37)

Like that lot on Cunningham Lane. Remember, we talked about a lot on Cunningham Lane earlier tonight? Yes.

Speaker 1 (04:13:39–04:14:04)

Yeah, that's not under conservation restriction, but it was a deal made back when the house was first built in, I don't know, the mid-'90s. And they, it was a, I don't know if it was a teardown or an addition, but we made the deal that we'll permit your house addition, but you have to restrict that land, or you can't build on that land. They said, okay, fine. But it's not an actual conservation restriction.

Speaker 9 (04:14:06–04:14:08)

What sort of agreement is it, would you call it?

Speaker 1 (04:14:09–04:14:52)

It's the same thing. It happens to be the same number, but lot 15 on Herrick Drive, which is right next to where Craig McNaught lives. Yes. We fought over that for years, because we went through several developers that tried to build something there.

And the original Conservation Commission back in the mid-'80s that permitted Herrick Drive made a deal with George Heard, or actually it was Toby Heard, and said, listen, we'll permit these lots, but that lot 15, you cannot develop. And he said, OK. So that was the decision of the Conservation Commission. It was not an easement.

It was a deal. Whatever you want to believe.

Speaker 9 (04:14:52–04:14:56)

It's part of an order of conditions?

Speaker 20 (04:14:56–04:14:59)

Yes. Yes, it was.

Speaker 9 (04:15:00–04:15:09)

That's interesting because that would be appropriate to include in an inventory of protected open space.

Speaker 20 (04:15:09–04:15:11)

Yes, absolutely.

Speaker 1 (04:15:15–04:15:54)

And what the developers were saying, well, okay, we acknowledge that, but you guys have the power and authority to reverse that, to just make a decision that you can grant. I mean, part of it is, most of it is wet, but part of it was upland and they were trying to put a house in there. And- I worked for Craig back then. But we had the authority to do that, I guess, to change our minds.

But the Conservation Commission was not inclined to do that. And we said, no, that was the original deal. We're going to stick with it. And we did that at least twice on that piece of land.

Speaker 10 (04:15:56–04:15:57)

Sean, another issue?

Speaker 1 (04:15:58–04:15:59)

Yeah.

Speaker 10 (04:15:59–04:16:04)

And that is the electronic digitization of all the CONCOM records?

Speaker 1 (04:16:06–04:16:30)

Yes. I don't know where Nick is on that. I know that when you were chair of the Select Board, you were pushing for it, and Nick was intent on finding money in the budget to do that. But I don't know what the status is, because it's not just the Conservation Commission that needs to digitize the records.

It's the whole town.

Speaker 9 (04:16:31–04:16:46)

Other boards are much better at making the records public than we are, though. Like ZBA and Planning Board both have extensive libraries and archives of submitted plans that it would be nice if we had to.

Speaker 10 (04:16:46–04:16:49)

They digitized one?

Speaker 9 (04:16:49–04:17:07)

Yeah, there are links on web pages, usually to PDFs. I think there's quite a bit done that way. And I don't know how they do it or who does it. It's a pretty stark contrast with us, and we don't have anything.

Speaker 1 (04:17:10–04:17:16)

Right. And it's a pain in the neck for us when we try to create a record, an appellate record.

Speaker 3 (04:17:18–04:17:32)

Suggestion that the town of Sharon does a great job with digitization. Maybe somebody should give a call over to planning in Sharon and see how they do it. what their funding is, funding source.

Speaker 9 (04:17:32–04:17:45)

I think the digitization is done because stuff is submitted electronically. What's missing is not digitization, but a public website where the stuff is posted.

Speaker 6 (04:17:46–04:18:37)

Sure. An online archive. I don't, I don't, I don't doubt how important and significant a project like that would be. But unfortunately, I do not think that the CPA is a funding source for it because we're limited to funding projects for conservation that actually acquires land or a recreation project.

in this category. So there really are four categories. It's historic preservation, affordable housing, and then conservation and recreation.

Speaker 23 (04:18:38–04:18:39)

Active recreation, right.

Speaker 6 (04:18:40–04:18:40)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (04:18:42–04:18:47)

Thanks. All right. One other quick thing on that.

Speaker 2 (04:18:47–04:19:08)

Can I just say something? Sorry. I was at a meeting this afternoon about digitalization of the records for the town with Rob Mallett. And the company was talking about it, and I told them we'd be interested in doing it.

They're going to have a demonstration in the coming weeks. So we've started the process of digitalization of records.

Speaker 1 (04:19:09–04:19:17)

That's good news. That's good news. It'll make it a lot easier on you.

Speaker 2 (04:19:17–04:19:32)

Yeah. Good luck to the person doing it. But the guy that's going to do it runs the company. It didn't really seem to bother him.

He just does it. Good luck.

Speaker 1 (04:19:34–04:20:33)

All right, one quick item of new business. On the enforcement order at 24 Wentworth Farm Road, I sent out a request for proposals to the three entities. One was Collins Engineering, two was GZA, and three was Merrill Engineering. The first two declined.

Merrill Engineering agreed to do it, sent in a contract and a proposal. I gave it to, Nick Milano and town council Peter Mello about two weeks ago, 10 days ago, two weeks ago. And I talked to Nick last week and he said, it's only like a $2,100 cost. And keep in mind that the town doesn't pay that, but the town has to guarantee it to sign the contract.

So he said it should not be an issue. So I don't have it yet. I meant to call Nick this morning, but I failed.

Speaker 10 (04:20:34–04:20:36)

He's out this week, John.

Speaker 1 (04:20:36–04:20:59)

Oh, maybe. Well, that's good because I called. I did leave a message for him yesterday, but I missed him. So he's out for the whole week.

All right, well, he said it would move along. It wouldn't require a whole lot of time. So we should be up and running by the June 14th date for that engineering analysis.

Speaker 10 (04:21:00–04:21:03)

We should thank him for moving along with the digitization.

Speaker 1 (04:21:05–04:21:15)

Absolutely. I agree. All right, it's getting late. We don't want to bump into it in the bewitching hour, which is open meeting long.

Steve, can I ask Steve if he

Speaker 9 (04:21:15–04:21:23)

Went to 355 Blue Hills Parkway as he thought he might be able to do where they've been working back to Joe Sloan reported.

Speaker 3 (04:21:24–04:21:48)

Uh, no, you mean, uh, five 33 Blue Hill. Uh, yes. Uh, yes, I did go. I haven't followed up.

Uh, the guy is obviously in jurisdiction. Um, he doesn't see the problem. I'm just making my backyard like everyone else's here. So he needs to be educated as to the rules and regs.

Speaker 9 (04:21:50–04:21:55)

You ought to understand the property line. Can't understand the property line?

Speaker 3 (04:21:56–04:22:05)

Yeah, well, I'm not sure he's over his property line, frankly, but he doesn't understand the rules and regs. And I'll leave it at that for the time being.

Speaker 1 (04:22:07–04:22:11)

Should we write a letter, you know, like the soft deal?

Speaker 3 (04:22:12–04:22:12)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (04:22:13–04:22:17)

Can you do that? Philip, you've got the soft version, right?

Speaker 2 (04:22:18–04:22:20)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (04:22:20–04:22:28)

All right. Can you work with Steve and get a letter out to 533 and just say, please come in and explain why you're cutting in our jurisdiction?

Speaker 2 (04:22:29–04:22:29)

Absolutely.

Speaker 1 (04:22:31–04:22:34)

Thank you, Tom. Thanks. Yeah.

Speaker 3 (04:22:34–04:22:54)

I have a couple other items. Very quickly, one sentence for each. Jeff Stone called me as this meeting was being begun this evening and said that the HOA for Wentworth Farm Road is forming up. Okay, that's a good thing.

Speaker 9 (04:22:55–04:22:56)

I think John mentioned that.

Speaker 3 (04:22:58–04:23:11)

Yes, perhaps. And also work has been done, if you haven't noticed it, on 711 Randolph Ave. Saturday. Yes.

Speaker 10 (04:23:13–04:23:26)

John, I'm willing to serve on the Climate Action Planning Committee for one more year as the representative of the CONCOMM. We need the CONCOMM to reappoint me effective July 1.

Speaker 1 (04:23:27–04:23:41)

All right, I move to appoint Arthur to the Climate Action Planning Committee for another year. Is there a second? I second. All in favor say aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye.

Speaker 6 (04:23:41–04:23:42)

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye.

Speaker 1 (04:23:42–04:23:48)

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Speaker 3 (04:23:48–04:23:51)

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Speaker 18 (04:23:51–04:23:51)

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Speaker 1 (04:23:51–04:23:54)

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Speaker 3 (04:23:54–04:23:54)

Aye.

Speaker 1 (04:23:54–04:23:54)

Aye. Aye.

Speaker 18 (04:23:54–04:23:55)

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Speaker 23 (04:23:55–04:23:57)

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

Aye. Aye.

Speaker 3 (04:23:57–04:23:57)

Aye.

Speaker 1 (04:23:57–04:24:08)

All right, good. Thank you very much. All right, motion to adjourn? I moved.

So moved. Second. I second. All in favor by a claim?

Good.

Speaker 10 (04:24:08–04:24:10)

Yay. Oh, let's wait another minute.

Speaker 1 (04:24:10–04:24:15)

All right, good night, all. Thanks for your patience.

Speaker 12 (04:24:15–04:24:16)

Good night, all. Good night, everybody.