Board: Board of Appeals October 21st 2014 Part 1
Date: Unknown
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:05–01:30)
on file with the board for a variance from the terms of section 6b 3 of chapter 10 the general bylaws of the town so as to build a 6 foot by 35 foot point 5 foot by 1 story porch addition to the front of the existing single-family residence located at 86 Warren Avenue in Milton, which is located in a residential C district. The addition is set back 13.8 feet from the front property line rather than the 20 feet required under Section 6B.3. All of that is set forth in the application that was submitted to the board on September 11th. I have in front of me a copy of the application, a copy of a letter to Mr.
McCormick from Mr. Prondack indicating that he had denied the proposal to construct the addition. the porch, a plot plan of the property on Warren Avenue, a list of the abutters, a list of the abutters to the property, along with an abutters report and several other addresses. That I believe is the extent of the file that we have in front of us today.
I see that the applicants are here along with their attorney. Welcome to the Board of Appeals. How can we help? Thank you very much.
You're welcome.
Speaker 2 (01:30–04:32)
I'm Attorney Bob Sheffield. I'm pleased to represent Tom and Michelle McCormick. They are in the process of enlarging their house. So far, they have gone up.
In order to have a porch, they need a variance from the 20-foot setback. Unfortunately, when this house was constructed 104 years ago, we didn't have a 20-foot setback, so that at that time, The house was built in 1910. And this was the home that Michelle grew up in. And they purchased it from her father.
And now they are enlarging it so as to be able to serve their family needs. And in order to have any front porch at all, It is necessary to get a variance from the 20-foot lot line. I mean the front setback. They have spoken to all the neighbors regarding this and all the neighbors are supportive.
and are very happy to see the portion of the new addition which is already up and hopeful that McComas will be able to have a front porch. I have the plans here if you need to look at them in detail. a double lot, making the frontage 120 feet, rather than the 60 feet, which is normal and standard in the area. They were required in the construction, when they went in and put in a second floor, they were required to keep it from protruding closer to here to cover the original building because of the side lot setback, and they were prohibited from putting in any porch at the time of that construction.
without the delay that would be necessary to go to the Board of Appeals and get the approval for the full plan, which hopefully will be approved tonight, which is just the porch.
Speaker 1 (04:32–04:42)
Okay. Is that it? Yes, sir. Anything you want to add to that excellent presentation?
No. Questions from the members of the Board?
Speaker 2 (04:44–04:51)
I don't have any questions, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 1 (04:54–05:09)
So I have a question. So this plot plan that you submitted shows a small walkout set of stairs. Are those stairs protruding from this front?
Speaker 3 (05:09–05:25)
Those stairs were, in fact, out approximately four feet. At the time there wasn't a measurement taken. However, they were, again, about four feet from the existing foundation, which is still in place. So the foundation hasn't moved.
Speaker 1 (05:25–05:27)
So this is an existing rendering?
Speaker 3 (05:27–05:31)
That is existing, yes, that's correct.
Speaker 1 (05:31–05:48)
So right now you have, your building is 19.8 feet from the front property line and it has a small set of stairs. And you're going to change that with a more like a country kind of porch? Yeah.
Speaker 4 (05:48–05:59)
Well, it's to hide the 4-inch variance, the 4-inch back. So we had to set the second floor 4 inches back. So the second floor is 4 inches back from the front of the house.
Speaker 2 (05:59–06:02)
In order that you have the front set back from the second floor.
Speaker 1 (06:02–06:09)
So that's why you have to hide it. So what you said was the addition's already been done.
Speaker 2 (06:09–06:11)
Yes, it has.
Speaker 1 (06:11–06:12)
And when was that done?
Speaker 2 (06:12–06:15)
Oh, it's been done this summer and it's continuing.
Speaker 1 (06:15–06:23)
But it doesn't look good because it has a foreign setback, a reverse setback. It's the opposite of what you might ordinarily see, the overhang is on the second floor.
Speaker 3 (06:23–06:27)
The reason for that was just that you expedite the building process. Well, we could do it in good weather.
Speaker 1 (06:27–06:44)
Okay, so now you want to cover that over with this porch, which is universally going to extend into the, well, it's going to exacerbate the current nonconformity.
Speaker 3 (06:45–06:46)
By about a foot and a half.
Speaker 1 (06:46–06:58)
By about four inches. Right, right now it's four inches and now it'll be a little bit more. But this doesn't show. That's correct.
So can we have these? Did you bring these for us?
Speaker 3 (06:58–07:00)
I brought those, yeah. You brought these.
Speaker 1 (07:00–07:06)
These are only set? No, I have not. This is my point.
Speaker 2 (07:06–07:08)
Oh, you can have it.
Speaker 1 (07:08–07:18)
It would be helpful for the board to have what's actually being built in the file. And the only plan that's in the file is this. But this is really showing the current condition. That's correct.
Speaker 2 (07:19–07:19)
OK.
Speaker 3 (07:21–07:36)
And I have a, I have kind of an overlay that kind of gives a downward look on I think the second page there which will show where the stairs would be existing and where they would be if this were to go through.
Speaker 1 (07:37–07:39)
Yeah, but the stairs are going to be gone.
Speaker 3 (07:40–07:46)
The stairs will be gone. Are they there now? Right now we just have temporary stairs leading from the door. I see.
Speaker 4 (07:46–07:48)
We're still under construction.
Speaker 1 (07:48–07:58)
Yeah, and the setback from the edge of the porch to the property is, it actually doesn't show here, but you know, look, maybe it's 16 feet, something like that?
Speaker 2 (07:58–07:59)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (08:01–08:07)
Okay. And you're representing to us that it's going to look like this when it's done?
Speaker 5 (08:07–08:08)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (08:09–08:14)
And will the shingles be consistent with the roof shingles? They will, yep.
Speaker 3 (08:14–08:28)
It's actually going to be a hip roof, so the shingles wall. What are you going to do, put a new roof on the building too? Only a new roof on the, a new roof that's already on the addition. The building?
The porch itself would have a matching hip roof.
Speaker 1 (08:28–08:29)
Oh, you call that a hip roof?
Speaker 3 (08:30–08:31)
Yeah.
Speaker 6 (08:31–08:32)
I call that a hip roof.
Speaker 1 (08:32–08:42)
That's what I do, yeah. Two hip roofs, huh? I suppose, I suppose it's a hip roof. It's just a roof.
Yeah, it's a roof. Yeah, okay.
Speaker 4 (08:43–08:45)
Do you want to see a picture of it before and after?
Speaker 1 (08:45–08:47)
I think it would be nice. Yeah, that would be great if you have it.
Speaker 3 (08:48–08:49)
He does.
Speaker 1 (08:51–08:57)
It might help. And what will the stairs be made out of?
Speaker 3 (08:58–09:07)
Stairs will be exact PVC trim with Trex composite decking.
Speaker 1 (09:07–09:12)
And what will the lattice be made out of?
Speaker 3 (09:12–09:18)
Lattice will be one by three PVC vertical trim as well. White? White.
Speaker 1 (09:19–09:26)
And will the whole house appear to be all uniform as if the addition was never really done?
Speaker 2 (09:26–09:30)
Yes, it will appear as one uniform house.
Speaker 1 (09:30–09:32)
And when would this work be done?
Speaker 3 (09:32–09:44)
We would hope to have the holes dug before the ground freezes up. So we'd really like to expedite it. So we'd probably, I would say all goes well. We could have it done mid-November.
Speaker 1 (09:45–09:46)
Are you the contractor?
Speaker 3 (09:46–09:48)
I am not, no. I'm the homeowner.
Speaker 1 (09:48–09:49)
I know that.
Speaker 3 (09:50–09:53)
No, no, no, no. Sometimes I feel like the contractor, but no.
Speaker 1 (09:53–09:57)
I'm only the homeowner. Like the hip hoop going and the feet.
Speaker 3 (09:57–10:08)
Yeah, I know. I've learned some of the terminology. He watches this old house a lot. Too much, matter of fact.
OK. So I can show you a picture of.
Speaker 7 (10:08–10:10)
Good question. I get a better picture.
Speaker 3 (10:10–10:27)
This is probably the closest I have I don't have anything with the siding on yet. So that's what the house looks like now? That's what the house looks like now. Well, you can imagine with a roof and siding, but that's how it looks now as far as the structure, the overall idea.
Speaker 2 (10:28–10:29)
We could send a picture of that to Mary.
Speaker 3 (10:29–10:36)
Possibly. I can possibly find something a little… I think that's okay. I think the board has a…
Okay. Gives you an idea. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (10:37–10:52)
I think it would be helpful to have a photo in the file. Let me ask you, Nick, do you have any other questions? And Steve, do you have any questions? I don't.
Can I ask if anyone in the audience has any… would like to testify in opposition to this application?
Speaker 8 (10:52–10:58)
We're here for it. We're here for it. I'll get to you.
Speaker 1 (11:02–11:16)
We have a process and we're going to follow it. Now it's your turn. Can I ask if anybody is here that would like to support the application? Yes, would you like to be recognized?
Speaker 9 (11:18–11:31)
Welcome. And I support it. I've been here before.
Speaker 1 (11:31–11:36)
Terrific. Thank you very much. Is anybody else like to support the application? Yes.
Speaker 8 (11:37–11:45)
Ditto. Except I live in 94. There's a house. 94 Warren Avenue?
94 Warren Avenue. And your name is? Helen Lucy.
Speaker 1 (11:46–11:47)
Helen. Welcome.
Speaker 5 (11:48–11:49)
Thank you.
Speaker 8 (11:49–11:51)
I worked at Town Hall for a while.
Speaker 1 (11:52–11:52)
How did you like it?
Speaker 8 (11:53–11:58)
I loved it. But then they decided to get rid of the switchboard.
Speaker 1 (11:59–12:03)
Let's just say the Board of Appeals had nothing to do with that.
Speaker 8 (12:03–12:10)
I even offered to John Cronin if I could pay him to keep my job.
Speaker 1 (12:10–12:20)
I think that's illegal actually. I think we're going to strike that from the record Helen. Just note that Mr. Cronin denied that request.
Speaker 8 (12:20–12:29)
He's still alive you know. Those were the old days.
Speaker 1 (12:29–12:31)
Back to the application.
Speaker 8 (12:31–12:32)
Back to the application.
Speaker 1 (12:32–12:34)
What do you think of it?
Speaker 8 (12:35–13:04)
The house is absolutely beautiful, but this is going to make it so, I don't know how to explain it, warmer, homey, and put a little bit of conflict here. This is just, these kids have worked so hard to have this happen. the whole neighborhood, that everyone couldn't be here, but the whole neighborhood in school that might help him talk to anybody who was negative about it.
Speaker 2 (13:04–13:26)
Thank you very much, appreciate your testimony. I'd just like to add that the moving the house back the six feet or so would pose an unbearable and unreasonable problem and it would create an undue hardship.
Speaker 1 (13:27–13:38)
Thank you. Did you speak to the neighbors on both sides of the property? I have, yep. And what is it that they said about the application?
Speaker 3 (13:39–13:42)
They are entirely for it, no problems whatsoever.
Speaker 4 (13:43–13:47)
They both couldn't have been here, but they would have if they could have.
Speaker 1 (13:48–13:53)
Does anybody else in the audience want to offer any comments or testimony on the application?
Speaker 2 (13:53–13:55)
Do you want to play on the point?
Speaker 1 (13:58–14:20)
Okay, thank you. Questions from the members of the board? Okay, we're going to close the evidence portion of the hearing and begin the deliberations. The open meeting law requires that we do so in public, and as Mr.
Leonard is fond of saying, we're going to do that right here and now. Mr. Lundbaum, do you have anything you'd like to say about this application?
Speaker 7 (14:20–14:42)
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Very well presented, very tasteful design. It obviously has merit for a growing family.
We've granted this type of relief in the past, and it makes our job easy when you get that support from your rebutters and your neighbors. So in the overall, I would tend to vote in favor of the application.
Speaker 6 (14:43–15:07)
I would also intend to vote in favor of the application for the reasons Steve stated. I think it looks great. I looked at a house on Warren Avenue once to buy, and this one looks really great. So I think it will be an improvement.
Certainly if it will cover up the four-inch retreat, I don't even know what else to call it, of the second floor, that might be a good reason.
Speaker 1 (15:07–15:30)
I agree with my colleagues. I think it's well presented and a tasteful addition and something that's well within the range of what this board would typically grant with the kind of support that you have. So I'll ask for a vote. All in favor of granting this variance upon the application of Michelle and Thomas McCormick?
Aye. Oh, yes. OK, so you have your variance. Congratulations.
Thank you. Thank you very much.
Speaker 5 (15:30–15:31)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (15:31–15:47)
You're welcome. It'll take us a few weeks to get this in order, and there's a short appeal period. And then Mrs. Fitzgerald will help you with the procedure to record it at the Registry of Deeds, et cetera.
So good luck with your property.
Speaker 2 (15:48–15:54)
Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 (15:56–15:59)
Thank you. Thanks a lot. Bob, good to see you.
Speaker 2 (15:59–16:00)
Thank you, good to see you.
Speaker 4 (16:00–16:07)
Thank you so much. You want to give him back to him? Nice to meet you.
Speaker 6 (16:07–16:08)
Who wants this?
Speaker 4 (16:08–16:10)
He wants to be a lawyer.
Speaker 6 (16:10–16:12)
Either way, I'll do it.
Speaker 5 (16:17–16:19)
Okay.
Speaker 9 (16:19–16:21)
Thank you very much, gentlemen.
Speaker 1 (16:21–16:22)
Okay, it's good talking to you.
Speaker 9 (16:22–16:31)
Thank you. I swear to God you did right. I'll have you known that this room is named after one of our good friends, Carol.
Speaker 1 (16:31–16:33)
Oh, Carol, yeah. Yeah, that's nice.
Speaker 9 (16:33–16:34)
For a long time.
Speaker 10 (16:34–16:35)
Yeah, that's nice.
Speaker 9 (16:35–16:40)
And my aunt. Josephine McAteer was the town accountant for 49 years.
Speaker 10 (16:40–16:40)
Wow.
Speaker 9 (16:43–16:48)
I'm just in the process. My cousin tied up her estate. She left me her house in Milton.
Speaker 5 (16:49–16:49)
Oh, wow.
Speaker 9 (16:49–17:00)
He caught the death tax. I never knew there was such a thing. She had property in Maine and everything. So I'm just in the process of selling it to my next door neighbor.
Speaker 1 (17:00–17:01)
Good luck with that.
Speaker 9 (17:02–17:06)
I don't think she wants to do any changes. There's no room.
Speaker 7 (17:07–17:18)
Okay.
Speaker 1 (17:23–17:48)
Is the applicant prepared for the 7.30 hearing? You got the slack on going tonight, huh?
Speaker 3 (17:48–17:49)
Busy night.
Speaker 1 (17:50–18:01)
Are you taping us? Yes. Oh, you are? I am.
Oh, boy. You're not live now. That little show is going to be on television now? You know what?
They're going to love it.
Speaker 6 (18:01–18:04)
They're absolutely going to love it. It's going to be good.
Speaker 1 (18:07–23:37)
Spice it up. Oh, boy. I wish I knew that. OK.
You ready? All right. We are going to call to order the 730 hearing 1126 to 1146 Randolph Avenue. This is a continuation of a hearing.
that I believe originally began on June 12 was continued to July 23rd, included a site visit at some point, the date for which I don't have in front of me, but then was continued to September 10 and has been further continued to October 21. And so in the intervening period of time between September 10 October 21, today, the Board of Appeals published an amended and restated special permit from the terms of the Zoning By-law. For the purposes of permitting the applicant time to take a look at what the Board was considering based upon the testimony that we've heard at the preceding four hearings and the site visit, as well as the input that we've gotten from written testimony from various town members, town citizens. So tonight's hearing, we would like to hear from the applicant On that, a draft amended and restated special permit.
So that's the main purpose of this meeting. I will also say that since then, we received a memo from Mr. Prondack, the building commissioner, making comments and observations about the draft permit, to which I haven't replied out of respect for the open meeting law, but we want to talk about that as well. In addition, we received a communication from Mrs.
Martinelli in a butter about a couple of comments on the application which we'll address tonight and a question as to whether or not this application was related to the land court's decision in the Coulter case from 2012. and some limitations that were set forth in the Coulter case. I want to address the Coulter case up front, and I might invite my fellow board members, both of whom are attorneys, practicing attorneys in Massachusetts, to comment. But I think the Coulter case is different than this case for the following reason, or for the reasons I'll articulate.
Let me just say first that the Coulter case was about was largely about the validity of a special permit or a series of special permits that were issued over a long period of time and ultimately was decided on the basis of the validity of a landscaping business on the property. It's distinguished from the, and Mass General Law Chapter 48, Section 9 requires or permits that bylaws and ordinances may provide for specific type of uses which shall only be permitted in specific districts upon the issuance of a special permit. Our bylaw permits special permits to be issued as an accessory use. Let me say this.
In the district, an accessory use is allowed on the same lot In customary incident two, use is permitted by special permit and not detrimental to the residential neighborhood. This hearing, we've had a lot of testimony over the conditions of the neighborhood and the history of this use, like in the Coulter case of dates from the 1960s. But I do think it is distinguished because, for a couple of reasons. One is the special permit has been superseded, the current special permit has been superseded, or superseded some of the prior special permits.
Secondly, the types of uses in the Coulter decision are different than the ones in the Sanatellis decision. And thirdly, we're specifically prohibiting a commercial landscaping business from operating on the premises, which is a large part of what the Coulter decision was about. I think the facts and circumstances of each individual case need to be, I would say, rest on their own bottom or be considered individually, and that's what the board does. I will say that there is some language in the Coulter decision that is helpful to the board and instructive to the board and which the board will be mindful in considering these decisions.
But I don't think that it, and I'd like my board members to comment if they'd like, I don't think it establishes a precedent or provides us with any particular guidance on what to do in this instance because the facts are different. Indeed, they're very different. But I'd like maybe Steve or Nick to And I know they both read the case and I appreciate it being brought to our attention. Steve?
Speaker 7 (23:37–24:30)
No, I agree with all your comments, Jeff. I wasn't based on the memo that was sent over from Mrs. Martinelli. I wasn't quite sure or I was just wasn't quite clear as to what she was suggesting so I took the time to read Coulter.
And I sort of came to the same decision that Coulter was an express determination A landscaping business would not be allowed, and we've specifically done the same thing here. Potentially have laid out language to that effect. And as you said, based on differing facts and circumstances, I don't think that there's anything in Coulter that specifically binds us here. Other than that, I agree forthrightly with everything you've said.
Speaker 6 (24:30–24:50)
Thanks. I don't think I have anything to add beyond saying I agree with both of your comments just now. I think that we are specifically excluding a commercial landscaping business, and that's as a use on this special permit on this property, and I think it's distinguishable on that basis. Okay, thank you.
Speaker 1 (24:50–25:05)
Can I ask Mrs. Fitzgerald, if other than the comments that we got from Mrs. Martinelli today, the comment we got from Mr. Prondack on September 24th, whether or not there's been any other comments submitted to the board?
Speaker 8 (25:05–25:05)
What Jason submitted.
Speaker 1 (25:06–25:13)
I haven't seen that. This is mine.
Speaker 8 (25:13–25:13)
Is this it?
Speaker 1 (25:13–25:15)
No.
Speaker 8 (25:15–25:17)
There was something I put in the beginning of it.
Speaker 1 (25:18–26:23)
Mr. Sanitalis, you want to come to the table? OK, so let me just, yeah, we have seen this. Mr.
Sanitalis has issued a given a note to Mrs. Fitzgerald which lays out the mulch delivery schedule that we asked for and includes a reduced copy of the plan that I think everybody has seen. So let me Let me continue the hearing by welcoming Mr. Sanotelis and his attorney to the board and asking if he has any comments that he wants to share with the board based upon what we've given you.
I see that Mr. Prondek has joined us. Mr. Prondek, do you want to join us at the table?
Certainly. Thank you. Jason?
Speaker 2 (26:24–26:25)
Good evening.
Speaker 1 (26:25–26:26)
Good evening.
Speaker 11 (26:29–26:54)
We're going to take them one at a time, I think. There are a number of items that we would like at least a brief discussion on, Mr. Chairman, and for what it's worth, I was very much involved with Tom Coulter in the early stages, and that clearly was about a landscaping business and is quite distinct from this. It's probably too early to say whether the case will offer precedent in the future, but for now, there's really, it's apples and oranges.
There's no comparison.
Speaker 1 (26:54–26:54)
Thank you.
Speaker 11 (26:56–27:20)
And what we'd like to do as we proceed is discuss individual, by the way, we're very appreciative of the board's efforts. There's a whole lot of time, a whole lot of effort, even more praiseworthy when we consider that you guys are volunteers. It was a nice piece of work and we appreciate it. There's a couple of points that we'd like some clarity on, possibly some minimal relief on, but we can discuss those in whatever order you choose.
Speaker 1 (27:20–27:41)
Let's go right in order. If you wouldn't mind, I've got a memo from Mr. Prondack that when you raise an issue, perhaps we could also discuss what Mr. Prondack has raised and we can deal with the efficient carrying out of the people's business that way.
Mr. Barron.
Speaker 11 (27:41–28:39)
Yeah, on Mr. Prondack's letter, and I have a copy of it here. OK, great. On number one, we have no issue with the restrictions on refrigerator trucks.
With one minor exception, it's possible to store a refrigerator truck during that Thanksgiving week. It only involves a total of two to three days, the Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday of Thanksgiving. And it's possible to store it off site overnight so as to not bother anybody with the fact that it continues to refrigerate and make some minimal noise, I suppose. The only problem is, during those two or three days, during the day, during the working day, it would be difficult, if not impossible, to have it off-site, because it, you know, as I say, this is not a night issue, but during the day, you can't be going across town or even across the street for turkeys, and that's what it's all about.
So that's only a minor issue with number one. As to the other items of Mr. Pruindex, we had no issue at all.
Speaker 1 (28:42–28:43)
on the whole memo?
Speaker 11 (28:43–28:44)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (28:44–29:16)
OK. So I think the way we'll do this is we'll take your testimony. We will ask you questions, and then the board will deliberate, OK? Sure, sure.
But I don't want this to be a, this is not so much of a negotiation as much as I want to just, as we're the deliberating body. So let me ask you, so you're suggesting with respect to Mr. Prondack's addition or concern about the refrigerator trucks, that refrigerator trucks be permitted during Thanksgiving.
Speaker 11 (29:17–29:32)
Right, during the three days of Thanksgiving week, on the premises… Three days of those. Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, leading up to Thanksgiving. Yeah.
Just during the business day. I know that trucks… What is that? Business hours.
Business hours.
Speaker 12 (29:32–29:36)
What is that? What are those? Eight to seven. 8 a.m.
to 7 p.m.
Speaker 1 (29:39–29:41)
Okay. Proceed.
Speaker 11 (29:43–29:45)
Well, that was our point on that.
Speaker 13 (29:45–29:53)
If we could get a concession that during those hours… Do you have a comment about that?
Speaker 12 (29:55–29:56)
We would put it across the street.
Speaker 13 (29:57–30:01)
Down in the back?
Speaker 1 (30:05–30:18)
I don't know that we're going to get into the details of what's going on at Newcomb Farms, right? Because we've commented before that this isn't about Newcomb Farms, unless you want it to be, because you're the one who asked us to have this hearing.
Speaker 13 (30:18–30:25)
The refrigerator truck, when it is on site at Eagle Farms, parked right up against Randolph Avenue. In the past, Jason?
Speaker 12 (30:26–30:26)
That's not true.
Speaker 13 (30:27–30:29)
Well, let's point on the site.
Speaker 12 (30:29–30:30)
On Randolph Avenue?
Speaker 13 (30:31–30:52)
Yeah. Yes. And so it's on the site, and then to take that across the street to Newcomb Farms and park it right on against the sidewalk at Newcomb Farms is essentially not, you're going to hear those concussions regardless. That's my point.
Speaker 11 (30:52–31:01)
But as long as he has the option, he's already suggested it would be on the back of the property, Joe, not the front. Obviously, that's no guarantees long term.
Speaker 12 (31:03–31:34)
We're talking a small box truck from Ryder that has a small reefer in there that kicks on when the temperatures are warm. It doesn't stay on continuously. The noise is minimal. During the day, It shouldn't be much of an issue.
We can, at night, we can move it across the street. You know, behind a building is fine.
Speaker 13 (31:34–32:00)
I think a solution may be to just simply say, if you were inclined to agree with that, that maybe a certain distance from the Eagle Found property, maybe three and a half feet, or something like that would suffice. That way we're not talking about another specific topic.
Speaker 1 (32:00–32:03)
Yeah. No, it's a good idea. OK.
Speaker 10 (32:07–32:07)
Mr. Barry.
Speaker 11 (32:08–32:14)
As to Mr. Prondack's letter, we have no issue with any of his other points. We're satisfied with it.
Speaker 10 (32:14–32:20)
OK. Terrific. Thank you. You're going to stick around, right?
I'm going to stick around. OK. You're done with this lecture?
Speaker 13 (32:21–32:22)
For tonight, yes.
Speaker 10 (32:22–32:27)
Excellent. They come first. Mr. Barry.
Speaker 11 (32:28–32:52)
Well, back to the now, as to the board's recommendations. Yes. As we reviewed them, we had no problems with one and two at all, and a little bit of concern on three courts being somewhat of a severe limitation, but as long as he has the capacity to store across the street, and we can't project the future on that, but for now he does, we really don't have a problem with number three either.
Speaker 1 (32:52–33:21)
Let me say something on that. One of the things that I know Mrs. Martinelli has raised this in her comments is trying to draw bright lines between what is large and small. And I'll admit that three is, it's not too small, not too large.
And my thought on that would be that if that doesn't work, you have the ability to come back to the board and we can talk about it further.
Speaker 11 (33:21–33:46)
It could become an issue because typically in a season he'll do 15 or 16 chords, not 3 chords, and it generally gets delivered at once. So as long as he has off-site storage, he's in good shape. Should he not, we'd have to deal with it in the future. Fair enough.
If we turn that page over for 4, 5, and 6, there were no issues. We're in agreement.
Speaker 10 (33:55–33:55)
Okay.
Speaker 11 (33:57–34:11)
I was a little confused in reading 7 and 8, one which seems to prohibit the use of heavy equipment, and then in 8, recognize the use of heavy equipment. And maybe, I think Jason had less trouble with it than I did. Maybe he can explain where we are on that.
Speaker 1 (34:11–34:25)
Here's what I think it says. It says that you can't move stock. Right. But that doesn't mean that you can't use heavy machinery.
Okay. That's the difference between 7 and 8. Now that's something that's been in your special permit since 2003.
Speaker 12 (34:26–34:30)
That pertains to the property at 1146 Randolph Avenue?
Speaker 1 (34:31–34:37)
Yeah. Why do you ask that?
Speaker 12 (34:42–35:01)
I ask that because sometimes we do move stock on 1126 Randolph Avenue with a small loader. If a person may get 12 shrubs, I may bring the loader. near the greenhouse and put the 12 shrubs into a bucket and then bring it down into their car.
Speaker 5 (35:01–35:01)
Oh.
Speaker 1 (35:05–35:10)
When I read this, you know… No, I'm trying to not draw these kinds of distinctions any longer.
Speaker 12 (35:11–35:14)
I would assume that it was for the 1146 Randolph Avenue.
Speaker 1 (35:14–35:18)
So what you're saying is in your retail operation, you move stock with a heavy machine.
Speaker 12 (35:20–35:23)
Heavy machine being either a forklift or… Understock. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (35:23–35:33)
As defined here. Yeah. That's something we'll have to talk about. OK.
1126, you do that?
Speaker 12 (35:34–35:34)
Correct.
Speaker 11 (35:39–35:54)
We had the most discussion at our end on number 10, where we see a limitation of 125 cubic yards of mulch. And I think 125 cubic yards of mulch was a limitation in an earlier permit.
Speaker 1 (35:54–35:57)
It was. Mr. Lumbaum's been talking about it for three hearings.
Speaker 11 (35:57–36:41)
And then there was relief from it. And I think the reason there was relief on a later, but more, but past hearing was that the 2,525 wasn't a practical number. The trucks bring in 70 to 80 cubic yards. It would be impossible to get them to bring in a lesser number, at least financially complicated to get any lesser number.
So if two truckloads already exceeds the 125, we have no problem with the two truckloads, but you're already probably dealing with 140 cubic yards, and you've got some potential problem there. They won't deliver. As a matter of fact, Coon and Jason, they simply won't deliver partial loads. You have to, he has to take the loads.
Speaker 1 (36:42–37:26)
What is the capacity of the bins that you've got on your drawing? That's really the issue, isn't it? It wasn't on there. I'm sorry.
It wasn't on there. There was testimony before from the, I've forgotten his name, right directly behind you. Jack Happener. Jack wanted the mulch to not go higher than the top of the bin.
So what we're trying to do is match the top of the bin with the capacity. And I just don't know how many yards you can fit in there.
Speaker 12 (37:29–37:49)
You know that, Jason? I would say we could fit keeping it at the level, I mean, that I don't know if, you know, without keeping it to the level of the rear barrier, if you will, you could fit 100 yards in there.
Speaker 1 (37:51–37:54)
How many do you want? How many are you suggesting that needs to be in 10?
Speaker 12 (37:55–38:05)
Realistically, if we have three types of mulch and the average is 70 yards because it's 60 to 80, the realistic number would be 210.
Speaker 11 (38:05–38:15)
When they relieved that limitation in the past, there was no sprinkler system, I like to add, and that will make a whole lot of difference here.
Speaker 1 (38:15–38:18)
But what's the capacity? How many can fit?
Speaker 7 (38:19–38:26)
How high would 210 go? Is it going to spill over? I mean, that's really a concern, I think.
Speaker 12 (38:26–38:42)
Right. It won't spill over. It would probably be 12 feet high, the pile. I think when you guys did the site visit, it was about 10 feet, 12 feet high.
Speaker 7 (38:43–38:48)
And the bins go to? Six feet. At the back end?
Speaker 12 (38:48–39:01)
At the back. Two bins go four feet, and one bin goes six feet. And it was only because I needed some of the cinder blocks to use elsewhere that we took those off the back.
Speaker 11 (39:02–39:05)
Is that a possibility, adding cinder blocks and raising the?
Speaker 12 (39:06–39:17)
We could, and we suggested it. Mr. Pondyke put it in his memo not allowing that.
Speaker 7 (39:22–39:33)
But where you're proposing to add in the 13 green giant arborvitaes and then additional fencing beyond the arborvitaes.
Speaker 12 (39:33–39:34)
There's definitely room for it.
Speaker 7 (39:35–39:49)
And I know that that's elevated, so between the arborvitae and the fencing, you know, the mulch, the height of the mulch is going to exceed the bins, but it's not going to exceed the arborvitae and the fencing.
Speaker 1 (39:52–40:12)
So you're suggesting that 10 instead of 125 should be 210? Yes. During April, May, and June. Then you have July.
You see how this works, right?
Speaker 12 (40:13–40:14)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (40:14–40:42)
This is based on the testimony that your peak seasons were the spring, and you have a declining need. And Mr. Martinelli has said that the spring is the worst, most deliveries in the spring, and that if the capacity is lower, then the situation is better is what we've heard. So are the other capacities work for you?
Speaker 11 (40:43–40:52)
The only problem with the other capacities, the 50 and the 10, is that he's concerned what if I have left over from the earlier period. And then what do I do with it?
Speaker 1 (40:59–41:02)
Yeah, okay. Do we have a suggestion for that?
Speaker 11 (41:04–41:18)
We certainly don't mind. He does a great deal with the town as it is, and that might be a practical solution to some extent. But once he reaches his end of his busy season, if he has left over more than the new capacity allows, it's, you know.
Speaker 1 (41:19–41:25)
Okay. Are those the extent of the comments on 10?
Speaker 11 (41:26–41:58)
I think that was it, Jason, right? That was it. A number, if we can, if we can go on to number 11, we discussed last time that moving the piles of moss 20 feet would block access to the barn. And I think the board was sympathetic to needing that access.
So the 20 feet might not be a workable number, no probably a necessary number given the amount of screenage we now have with fencing and arborvitaes, et cetera.
Speaker 1 (41:59–42:07)
What is the setback, would you suggest? Is there any setback? I think 20 also came from Jack.
Speaker 12 (42:09–42:17)
Right now, there's about seven to eight feet from the property line to the tip of the bin, and then the mulch starts.
Speaker 1 (42:18–42:23)
And you're saying because you've put the arborvitae in, the setback need not be so extensive.
Speaker 12 (42:24–42:51)
Right. I think with the fencing and the arborvitaes and the irrigation, plus there's 48 and a half feet from the rear of, from the fence or the giant screening to the existing arborvitaes. You know, that would help. That 49 feet also helps.
Where's the 49 feet?
Speaker 6 (42:51–42:56)
On 1146? I don't know, I'm lost.
Speaker 1 (42:56–43:04)
Right behind the proposed 13. Oh, oh, oh. Yeah, but that's not your property.
Speaker 12 (43:04–43:04)
It's not.
Speaker 1 (43:05–43:09)
You're just suggesting that that's a buffer because his property is back.
Speaker 11 (43:09–43:40)
This is where he puts his grass. Yeah, it's a garden spot. Composting, yes. Composting.
The reference to eight feet, I guess that's actually not in number 10. He has no problem with the eight foot fence. We've not argued it. We're just concerned a little bit about the aesthetics of it.
Eight foot on a stockade is somewhat higher than you usually see in a residential area. And we're wondering if the homeowner even wants eight feet.
Speaker 1 (43:42–43:48)
So you said six, right? Six is what you've already put in.
Speaker 12 (43:49–44:01)
Six is there, that was existing. When we did the plan, it was suggested as eight. We made a mistake, there should have been six because it was already existing.
Speaker 1 (44:05–44:06)
But you've corrected that?
Speaker 12 (44:06–44:08)
We have, yes.
Speaker 5 (44:08–44:08)
Okay.
Speaker 11 (44:10–44:41)
That eight-foot reference actually goes over to item 15 on the proposal. We had no issues with 12, 13, or 14, and we've just discussed the issue that we had with number 15. Article 16 and 17, obviously 17 continues to be a little bit tough for Jason, who felt after all we've gone through, if he could get longer than a four-year extension here, he was hoping to ask for a 10-year permit.
Speaker 1 (44:41–44:42)
Right. Go ahead.
Speaker 12 (44:44–45:19)
The reason I'm asking is if something was wrong within the 10 years as it was in 2014, a phone call to the building commissioner could rectify that and bring me back in front of the board. So I just thought, you know, since we went through this, I believe we're six years into the 10-year permit, just suggested maybe if we could start 2014 for 10 years further. Okay. Only suggestion.
Speaker 1 (45:20–45:58)
Understood. Can we back up a second on paragraph 16? Ms. Martinelli has asked the board what small quantities are.
I wondered whether you had a suggestion or Mr. Prondack might have a suggestion. The idea was that small quantities of landscaping materials were not part of the commercial operation because they were furthering the local business. used by local businesses, which is what we heard at this hearing.
But I don't know what small quantities are. We saw the small quantities, and they did appear to be small. But, you know, I don't know.
Speaker 13 (46:00–46:47)
One gauge that comes back that you're using is things that are not still in the whole quantity. You know, small. You know, if If Jason had a pallet of 30 or 40 bags or 30, 40, 25-pound bags of fertilizer to be sold at a retail level, that would be a typical small quantity in my mind. But if he had 250-pound cases of fertilizer for sale at a retail level, then I don't know.
It is judgmental.
Speaker 1 (46:47–47:13)
It can be hard to… Well, it's your judgment. I understood. Okay.
Which is why you're still here. Why we didn't let you leave. Why we're here to begin with. I understand.
All right. Is your feedback to the board on this, does that conclude your… It does. Okay.
Can I ask if there's anyone in the audience who wants to comment on what they've heard? Mr. Minor.
Speaker 14 (47:13–47:48)
It seems, you know, this whole thing was driven by the mulch. And 200 yards doesn't really address any kind of relief. I think we were dealing with those right around World War I. And it's a huge quantity.
200 yards of mulch is a lot. And it'll get back to square one. This is why it all started. The deliveries and the dust and the noise and the trucks.
I don't see any relief coming with that number. It's a pretty big number.
Speaker 6 (47:48–48:13)
What about the water? The sprinkling of it should knock down the dust. And the larger quantities should… Let me finish.
If the sprinkling would knock down the dust, and the larger quantities would reduce the number of deliveries, is that right? So would there be fewer trucks making deliveries if we were able to store more on site? I mean, you're asking, I'm trying to come up with something.
Speaker 14 (48:13–48:55)
Yeah, it's the material going out. The deliveries are going to come, and the majority of the dust comes from the deliveries. It's the trucks that are pushing it out, these trailers, they call them walking on the floor. The stuff keeps pushing up the back end as it does.
This is where the cloud of most of the stuff comes. I mean, some does come from the loading of it. And of course, it'd be reduced with the sprinklers. The quantity of the trucks going out, that's what it is.
The machine is running and loading. That's what kind of drove this whole power concerns. Besides that and the fire risks and all that, none of that's going to change with 200 gallons.
Speaker 6 (48:56–49:21)
Whether he stores 60 cubic feet or 210, if his sales stay the same, then the loading is the same. Is that right? I mean, I'm just trying to get down to the bottom. I want to make sure that whatever we do is going to make a difference.
But if he stores smaller quantities, but the sales continue to be at the same level, then the loading is still going to be the same amount of loading, isn't it?
Speaker 14 (49:21–49:40)
Well, you were restricted in the amount So it wouldn't be the same. I mean, if you can only get so many deliveries a week, at a certain amount, it'll reduce and give us some relief. If it's back up there, then… It's got two a week.
Yeah. It's only two a week.
Speaker 11 (49:40–49:42)
And we have no issue with that.
Speaker 6 (49:45–50:10)
Jason, I have never seen these things deliver. I can imagine what they're like. But if Mr. Martinelli is saying there's dust that occurs on the delivery as the machine is pushing the mulch out the back, sometimes the construction sites, I know that they hose down stuff.
We can turn the irrigation on. Would it be possible, well, either that or somebody with us, to spray it as it's coming out? Absolutely. To keep the dust down?
I mean, if that's?
Speaker 12 (50:11–50:11)
Absolutely.
Speaker 6 (50:13–50:14)
You have the capability probably to do that?
Speaker 5 (50:15–50:15)
Yes.
Speaker 6 (50:16–50:19)
I don't know if that would help, but I'm just trying to figure something out here.
Speaker 11 (50:20–50:23)
We're not going to know until it happens, and you certainly would be.
Speaker 7 (50:23–50:43)
Yeah. Do you have a situation where your landscaping vehicles and the business involved in that comes across the street to load up the mulch and off to your home deliveries and so forth? Is that a typical situation?
Speaker 12 (50:46–50:47)
when we deliver mulch to homeowners?
Speaker 7 (50:48–51:21)
Well, no, yeah, but also as part of your, you know, we have a specific provision in here barring any commercial landscaping operation. Do we, and maybe we just didn't address this, but do we have, do you take your landscaping trucks that are generally across the street at the Pepsi, back them in, load them with mulch, and off you go to your commercial landscape. Once in a while, yes.
Speaker 14 (51:22–51:28)
It doesn't really matter to me where the trucks are going.
Speaker 7 (51:28–51:44)
It's just the sheer volume of them. You're making the point that it's not so much, correct me if I'm wrong, not so much the delivery of the truck, the trailer load's full of the trucks, but it's then the customers coming in and chasing landscaping.
Speaker 14 (51:45–54:36)
Oh yeah, collectively all of it is going off. Collectively, it's all. It's the deliveries, it's the loading, and it's the volume. Like I said, the last few months, it's perfect.
The whole place changes, but for those three months, it's very intense, it's very aggressive, and it's tough. That's what drove this whole meeting. I mean, it's simple math for the size of the bins, because we're dealing with cubic. as it is, but 210 yards of mulch is a lot of mulch.
Like you say, going back in the permits, it started out as bagged mulch, and then it turned into a little bit more, then it's 120, and then it's out of sight, and it's just, it's tough. And I think that's a pretty high number. of the question too. I didn't see the site plan.
Is there a copy shown on And I do think that maybe not the bin on the left would have to come out as far, but it will give some relief. I think there can be a setback off the property. The two bins that are on the right-hand side, it's just a driveway in front. But you know, we're just looking for some relief.
And I mean, all of those, I thought the thing was drafted well. You know, there were some good ideas there. I thought the limits were reasonable. Maybe if that works, we'll see how this goes.
If he comes back and says, hey, you know, the operation is going better, maybe we could up it by 100 gallons. I think we should at least get a chance to get some relief from this and see how it goes. It's pretty reasonable. We're not saying, you know, ideally there'd be no mold.
I mean, that would be great. Have it off-site somewhere. We never, you know, just asked him to explore when our site was there. I never heard anything come back that he didn't want to explore.
There weren't any options. It was always staying here. So we never heard about potential of moving it all off-site, but to just, I mean, how much are we really reducing if we're going to 200 yards?
Speaker 5 (54:36–54:36)
I mean, what was it?
Speaker 14 (54:36–54:39)
300 yards? 400 yards?
Speaker 11 (54:39–54:51)
It's not a matter of reduction. It's a matter of the spray, the irrigation system, the willingness to spray as it comes in, and I think in all likelihood that's going to give substantial relief.
Speaker 13 (54:55–56:30)
Well, I do think that the limit on the vouch, I guess I would have to agree with Mr. Martinelli. You know, I do believe a large part of the complaint and the nuisance here is that watering doesn't do any good to alleviate the loader, the backup people, the slamming of the trailer. I do agree that it is an intense use in life.
Alright, let me…
Speaker 1 (56:31–01:02:12)
take stock of where we are. Is there anybody else who wants to comment on the application testimony that we heard today? Okay, I hear none. Let me read into the record what Mr.
Prondack has asked for. So if people are familiar with the three or four page special permit to which we will attach our findings which will Largely mirror what has been found by this board before in terms of the general overall character of this area and the number of similarly situated Properties and the traffic on Randolph Avenue, etc. There's the project has made a comment that restricting, asking for refrigerating. Oh, OK.
So we're going to close the testimony, and we're going to do it right here. And I'd like to open up the dialogue for people to add, and now we'll have a discussion. That's OK. So Mr.
Prondek has asked on number one that no refrigerated trucks be brought onto the property with a proviso that, and the applicant has stated that the trucks should be committed to be brought on the property Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday from 8 to 7 p.m. Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday of Thanksgiving week. from 8 to 7 p.m. and that thereafter they'd be located a distance of more than 300 feet from the property.
Does that sound like a reasonable addition to this? Is that accurate, Mr. Prondek? I believe so, yes.
Okay. Let me remind people, the reason that we're here is that Mr. Prondek has asked for an interpretation of the 2008 special permit and that this is not a the NOVO review and a reapplication of the conditions of the special permit really is intended to clarify remove, eliminate, repeal, or invalidate provisions of this permit, and perhaps the permit at all. I think that's important to just say.
And I'm gonna raise that again at another point. On number seven, so we've heard from the applicant. On number seven, Mr. Prodek has asked, and the applicant has also asked for a change in this provision.
The applicant has asked that the portion that stock may be moved by Bobcat or Heavy Machinery by Heavy Machinery at 1126, which is the main property. And Mr. Pranik has asked that you permit the loading and offloading of trucks by forklift or Bobcat. because it will be difficult to offload larger trees and shrubs by hand.
I'm assuming that the applicant is fine with that, and I think that's a good point that the commissioner has raised. So I find that to be reasonable. Yes. Okay.
Number nine, Mr. Pronik has asked that the deliveries, which are limited to two deliveries of mulch during any week, I had written Sunday through Saturday. Mr. Pronik has asked for that to be Monday through Saturday so that there will be no Sunday deliveries.
that no single delivery in excess of 80 yards of mulch may be made. We've also changed the deliveries of trucks to not before 10.30 or after 4.00. It used to be 9.00. And I changed it to 10.30 with the traffic on Randolph Avenue during the commuting hours, which nobody knows I care about.
11. does already specify that the concrete barriers may not be made any higher. Mr. Prodig has asked for that.
Mr. Prodig has also asked on 13, it says that the applicant shall not use chainsaws on the premises after 9. Mr. Prodig has asked that we limit that to 8 a.m.
to 5 p.m. except during the Christmas tree season where 9 p.m. can be permitted, which would permit you to use chainsaws after 5 during the Christmas season. Then lastly Mr..
Pranic has asked that the town of note we had a provision the town of Milton's representatives have the right to enter the property During any of Eagle found regular business hours for the purpose of determining compliance with the special permit I think you would ask for that before I am III think each of these conditions is reasonable and Suggest that we add them to the draft of this document Do you have any comments on that? No, I think that's fine. So I think where that leaves us is that there are a couple of issues. The first is on the fencing, whether it be 6 feet or 8 feet.
I had 8 feet in because that's what we heard. My own sense is I'd rather have a uniform fence than a non-uniform fence, but I'm also not a member of the fence police department. I wonder if the building commissioner has a preference. My own view is given the extent of the additional buffers that have been added, frankly not at the request of the board necessarily, but I do think Assisted with this application.
I think the six feet would be okay, but I'd like to hear from you I actually do prefer the 8-foot fence.
Speaker 13 (01:02:12–01:02:25)
You prefer it? Even on a stock 8-foot fence alone, that in itself would add some sound barrier. a fence specifically designed for sound attenuation that you feel is appropriate.
Speaker 1 (01:02:25–01:02:40)
Well, it does say that, I'm sorry, that portions of the perimeter fencing along the, it says certain portions of the perimeter fencing as shown on the site plan shall have sound attenuating provisions.
Speaker 13 (01:02:40–01:03:27)
If you look at, there's a lot of fencing that you see along A stock A-type fencing, whether it be vinyl or wood, you see it a lot along Bloomfield Avenue and along Randolph Avenue. And the difference between six foot and two foot is, from an aesthetics point of view, is not all that different. And I think the people that live on those main roads, they tend to go with the eight foot fences on Canton Avenue as well. And you were talking about separating the used property from the residential property.
Eight foot does give a little bit of extra protection.
Speaker 11 (01:03:27–01:03:34)
Do we know if the homeowner even wants eight feet there? That's the privacy that we'd be protecting, and I haven't heard that.
Speaker 1 (01:03:38–01:03:43)
Members of the board. We didn't hear it either, but at least I
Speaker 6 (01:03:44–01:04:20)
You can go either way, but I think Mr. Pondak's convincing me that eight feet, given, this would be on the sideline between the corner of the lot where the mulch is. Given the obvious testimony about the problem the mulch has created, I think the extra two feet I think would be helpful. I was wondering if it would look weird having an eight foot fence, but if it's not, if in your experience it's all right, I mean, I could support eight.
Speaker 12 (01:04:22–01:04:29)
We have no problem doing eight. I just thought because of the elevation. Yeah, I know. It will look.
Speaker 6 (01:04:29–01:04:34)
It's six feet now, right? Six feet. Because I did notice when I was whizzing by at five.
Speaker 12 (01:04:35–01:04:42)
And it pops out at the six feet. Yeah. And we'll be more than willing to put eight feet. I just am concerned aesthetically.
Speaker 1 (01:04:42–01:05:09)
So let me just clarify where this fence is. The fence is going to be located. The material lot line is shown on this drawing. Are you also putting, do you also have fence along each boundary of the premises that abuts a residential property?
It shows existing fencing, but is that existing stock fencing?
Speaker 12 (01:05:09–01:05:11)
That is existing stock fencing, six feet.
Speaker 1 (01:05:14–01:05:25)
So what are we saying here? saying that you have to maintain the fencing as existing. You have to install an eight-foot fence where the mulch is. Is that what we're saying?
Speaker 12 (01:05:26–01:05:36)
I think we're saying that coming off the six-foot fence, we're going to eight-foot. Correct.
Speaker 1 (01:05:37–01:05:41)
Mr. Proctor, are you following that? I just want to be clear about my discipline.
Speaker 13 (01:05:45–01:05:48)
Yeah, I think, I think, I believe that's appropriate.
Speaker 1 (01:05:48–01:05:53)
Eight along the, eight along the, where the mulch is.
Speaker 7 (01:05:53–01:06:04)
And then six along the Martinelli part line, I believe. Is that right?
Speaker 13 (01:06:04–01:06:13)
Correct. Yeah, so if you've got the eight foot here, that, you know, there's no, it eliminates the need to make that eight foot.
Speaker 7 (01:06:15–01:06:19)
existing six here.
Speaker 13 (01:06:19–01:06:22)
But this fence would be doing most of the work of screening.
Speaker 1 (01:06:23–01:06:41)
Right. Is there a, is there a, is there a wooden fence along the entire perimeter of the property where it amounts to residential, residential neighborhood now, except in the back? The back of 1146?
Speaker 12 (01:06:41–01:06:47)
Yes, there is. Except the rear of 1146, that's correct.
Speaker 1 (01:06:47–01:06:57)
But you're going to install a fence there? Yes. Which Mr. Prodak has suggested be six feet.
Correct. So if it said that you would either install or maintain a