Board: Milton Conservation Commission
Date: 2023-11-14
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:45–01:39)
We can open the meeting and let me say welcome to the public and to commission members. This is a November 14th, 2023 meeting of the Milton Conservation Commission. Commission members are appointed by the Select Board to implement the rules and regulations of the Wetlands Protection Act. which is a state law, as well as the Milton Town Bylaw governing the wetlands.
We have two matters of formality that we'd like to put on the record at the beginning. The first one is we invite everyone to speak, but to do so, we ask that you identify yourself for record-keeping purposes. Secondly, as a matter of formality, we introduce ourselves. My name is John Kiernan.
I'm just doing this because I can see people. Arthur, could you introduce yourself? Arthur Doyle, member. Todd Hamilton.
Todd Hamilton, Numba. Wendy.
Speaker 2 (01:39–01:41)
Good evening, my name is Wendy Garpo.
Speaker 1 (01:42–02:53)
Tom Palmer. Tom Palmer, member. All right, did I… Arthur Doyle, where are you?
I lost you. Oh, there you are. You roll call me. Okay, so we have our quorum and as I indicated that Hans van Lingen could not attend and Ingrid Beatty could not attend as well.
We're ready to go and For the public's benefit, I should announce that number five on the agenda will be continued at the request of the applicant until December 12th. That's a notice of intent at 600 Canton Avenue slash 85 Highland Street. With that said, we go to number one on the agenda, which is Richard Wells from the Capital Improvement Planning Committee. He's the chairperson.
Richard Wells, are you present and in attendance? I don't see you. Phillip, are you able to see Richard in the waiting room? Or anybody?
I don't see him, so we will, let me see, I've got another, I've got to scan through more people.
Speaker 2 (02:53–02:54)
I don't see him, John.
Speaker 1 (02:55–05:11)
No, nor do I. All right, so we will, table number one temporarily, because I do expect Mr. Wells to attend. So we'll go right to number two on the agenda, request for certificate of compliance at 339 Hillside Street.
Is the applicant in attendance? I don't see anyone. I know we have received the plans, although the as-built plans are termed as certificate of compliance plans, And we do have a letter from Kevin Grady, PE, which is required. And it says, we hereby certify that we have inspected the project at the above-referenced address, and the work has been completed in substantial compliance with the order of conditions and the approved plans referenced therein.
Any and all deviation from the approved plans as shown on the certificate of compliance plan included here with, please find one copy of the compliance plan and WPA form 8A. Our custom and practice is to have the applicant here and or have our agent, Steve Ives, go out and inspect the property. Looks like we don't have anyone. So my suggestion would be, I don't know that there's any urgency here.
I don't see any problems, but I would prefer that we either have Steve Ives inspect us, and he will be back, I believe, on the 1st of December. So he will be able to do that in time for our December 12th meeting. And or if somebody comes in later in the meeting on behalf of the applicant to request this, we could address it then. But my suggestion is we continue this until December 12th.
Anybody opposed to that? Hearing none, December 12th is the meeting. Number three on the agenda is certificate of compliance at 50 Summer Street. Is the applicant here?
Speaker 3 (05:12–05:13)
Yes, I'm here.
Speaker 1 (05:13–05:15)
Perfect. Thank you. Welcome.
Speaker 3 (05:15–05:16)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (05:18–05:30)
Can you tell us what the project is and what you've done? And in particular, I'll give you a heads up. My question is going to be, how long have the plantings been in place? That is, have they survived over a particular period of time?
Speaker 3 (05:32–05:37)
Yes. So for the project, we… I'm sorry to interrupt.
Speaker 1 (05:37–05:39)
Could you identify yourself, please?
Speaker 3 (05:39–06:18)
Oh, yeah. Sure. My name is Christina Yu. So I'm from 50 Sumner Street in Milton, and we had 22 plantings, 11 evergreen plantings, and stone posts installed, also removal of sprinkler heads and piping on the conservation land, and installation of stone riprap.
Let's see. Yep, so the plantings were installed and the granite markers at the two property corners.
Speaker 1 (06:22–06:38)
Now, I'm going to sound like this is form of a substance, but do you have an engineer or a plan that, by the way, I believe you, but do you have a plan that has been stamped saying that there's substantial compliance?
Speaker 3 (06:38–07:03)
Yes, so I hired Stephen Reed from land planning and he wrote a letter stating that the site seemed to be in good condition and he would recommend issuance of a certificate of compliance upon the commission satisfactory. And Steve Ivis came out to inspect the property and he said that everything looks good.
Speaker 1 (07:03–07:11)
All right, do you know how long the plants have been there? We have a two-year survival standard. Do you know how long they've been up and running?
Speaker 3 (07:12–07:19)
Yeah, so over two years, like two and a half years. All right, any questions from commissioners?
Speaker 4 (07:19–07:27)
No, Mr. Chairman, I'd only add that when I was in that area recently, I took a look at the site and it looks very impressive. Very well done.
Speaker 3 (07:27–07:28)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (07:28–07:52)
All right, good. I know there was an issue and it wasn't really your issue. There was a drainage pipe and there was some concern by the fellow that lived across the street. Not Sumner, but what's the cross street?
In any event, he had some drainage issues and I didn't know if that had improved or abated in any way. Do you know? I think it's actually coming from conservation land, not your land. I'm just curious about that.
Speaker 3 (07:52–07:55)
Yeah, I'm not sure. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (07:56–08:55)
Okay. All right, any other commissioners? If we've got the attestation of compliance and it's been more than two years and Steve Ivis has seen it, I'm comfortable issuing the Certificate of Compliance. Any commissioners have thoughts or questions on that?
Hearing none, is there a motion to issue the Certificate of Compliance? So moved, Mr. Chairman. All right, thank you.
Is there a second? Wendy, thank you very much. Any discussion among commission members? Hearing none, I'll take a roll call vote.
Arthur Doyle? Yes. Wendy Garpo? Yes.
Todd Hamilton? Yes. Tom Palmer? Aye.
I missed it, Tom. What did you say? Aye. Aye, good, okay.
I'm aye too. I vote yes as well. Thank you very much. And Christina, you're all set to go.
Thank you very much for your courtesy and attendance tonight.
Speaker 3 (08:55–08:57)
Of course. Thank you so much. Have a good night.
Speaker 1 (08:58–09:11)
All right. You too. Thanks. Next on the agenda is.
Or Breck Street. This is the request for certificate of compliance. Do we have? Yes.
Speaker 5 (09:12–09:16)
Yes. Good. Good evening. It's Lydia Mason.
Yes.
Speaker 1 (09:17–09:19)
Welcome, Lydia.
Speaker 5 (09:19–09:19)
Hi.
Speaker 6 (09:21–09:22)
Can you tell us?
Speaker 5 (09:22–09:55)
So I have the same. My plantings are 15 plantings in the back of conservation land, and they've been there for like two and a half, almost three years. And Steve Ibis did come out to look at them also. I guess the last time, last year when I requested a certificate, they wanted one more year of growth.
So the last year it was in September that I came in front of the commission. So now we're in November.
Speaker 1 (09:55–10:08)
I recall that. Didn't you have a tree removal issue right back where the garage is? Did that one ever come down? I know there was one that looked somewhat unsafe to your property.
Speaker 5 (10:08–10:27)
Yeah. And that was last year when I submitted everything and that was, um, completed last year. Everything was completed last year. The only thing for one year from September was the commission wanted additional year of the plants to grow on the back.
Speaker 1 (10:28–10:41)
All right. And I know you said Steve has seen it and I agree. We've been out, the commission has been there a number of times. So I agree with everything you're saying.
Do you have a, is there a letter attesting to the compliance with the order of conditions?
Speaker 5 (10:42–10:43)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (10:44–11:00)
All right. Any questions from commission members? Actually, are there any abutters that have a question or a comment? I should ask that always.
Hearing none, is there a motion to issue the Certificate of Compliance at 4 Breck Street?
Speaker 7 (11:04–11:05)
I move we issue.
Speaker 1 (11:06–11:21)
Thanks. Wendy, you went first, so I'll give the motion to you, and Tom, you get the second. Any discussion among commission members? Hearing none, Arthur Doyle, how do you vote?
Yes. Wendy, how do you vote?
Speaker 8 (11:21–11:22)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (11:22–11:49)
Todd, how do you vote? Yes. Tom, how do you vote? Aye.
And I, John Kiernan, vote yes as well. Thank you very much. You've got your certificate of compliance lit here, and thank you for your attendance and your courtesy. Number five on the agenda has been continued until December 12th.
Number six is approval to purchase up to an additional 10 Conservation Commission signs. Arthur Doyle, do you want to address that one?
Speaker 4 (11:49–13:32)
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yes, we previously approved 10 signs that are being installed this year, and we have significant additional sites for signage and a need to have in storage a couple of replacement signs. So using the same budget as was employed last year, we have on the agenda this request for purchasing an additional 10 conservation signs to fill the remaining needs and to have a couple of replacement signs on hand.
The budget for this last year was just under $10,000, $9,650. We had, through our Department of Public Works, a great find in terms of a manufacturer at less than 50% of what other providers were putting on the table. So I would make a motion, Mr. Chairman, if it's in order, have an approval for the purchase of up to an additional 10 Conservation Commission signs, not to exceed $9,990.
$9,950? $9,990. $9,990. Just under $10,000.
All right.
Speaker 1 (13:33–13:42)
Now, are there any cost savings involved in that to the extent that the, is this the same company that provided the first set?
Speaker 4 (13:42–14:17)
I checked with Mr. Berkley on that and it would be if all goes well and the individual signs last year were 9650. bringing it up to $9,650 for the 10 that were previously purchased. He is hoping that with the die set by the manufacturer and so on down the line, that that would offset inflationary costs and things of that nature, and that we might be able to obtain the 10 additional signs for under $10,000.
Speaker 1 (14:18–15:03)
All right. And for the public's benefit and the commission's benefit, this money would come from the revolving fund, which was approved, I don't know, 15 or 20 years ago by the annual town meeting. It's a revolving fund. We're entitled or allowed, I guess, to expend up to $15,000 per year from that fund.
We currently have about $96,000 in the fund. So we have the funds to do it and we have the authorization pursuant to the annual town meeting to expend those funds as long as it's for environmental purposes. And I suggest that it is. And again, for the public's benefit, we have now, how many are in place?
Are all 10 up now?
Speaker 4 (15:03–15:34)
The last report out to the commission had five, and since that time, two have been placed both on either side of Holland Street. So seven are up, and we will have on the agenda before us three more for consideration, which will exhaust the 10 and the initial order. All right. Out of the 10 allocated for this fiscal year are in place.
Speaker 1 (15:35–15:53)
All right. Are there any questions from commissioners? Are there questions from members of the public or comments? Hearing none, as the proponent of the motion, would you like to make the motion, Mr.
Doyle?
Speaker 4 (15:53–16:05)
I did, Mr. Chair. So I will just reiterate. the approval of the purchase of up to an additional 10 conservation signs for a budget not to exceed $9,990.
Speaker 1 (16:06–16:31)
Is there a second for that motion? Second. Thank you, Todd. I saw Todd before I saw you, Tom.
We can give you two seconds. Is there any discussion among commission members? Because we have a motion and a second. Hearing no discussion, we'll take a roll call vote.
Mr. Doyle, how do you vote? Yes. Ms.
Capo, how do you vote?
Speaker 8 (16:32–16:32)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (16:33–17:37)
Mr. Hamilton? Yes. Mr.
Palmer? Aye. And I, John Kiernan, vote yes as well. That's unanimous.
Thank you very much, Mr. Doyle. Welcome, sir. Next on the agenda, and it's appropriate in terms of where this is going, the seventh is determination of applicability, conservation sign, Blue Hills Parkway at Pope's Pond.
And for the public's benefit, please be aware that any alteration within the jurisdiction of the Wetlands Protection Act or the Milton Town Bylaw requires that any applicant, including the Conservation Commission, apply to the commission for approval. And placing the signs in there does actually constitute an alteration of the land. So in an attempt to be in full compliance with the statutory and regulatory rules and regulations, the Conservation Commission is bringing this request for determination of applicability. Can you tell us more about where the sign is going to go, Mr.
Doyle?
Speaker 4 (17:39–18:36)
Yes, Mr. Chairman. In item number seven, the idea would be for a location at Pope's Pond, which would be located along Summer Street and visible along that route as well as possibly from Canton Avenue and at least one, maybe both directions. Everybody has a copy of a map that statistical provided on this site.
There's a hash mark that would indicate the location of the sign. which would be essentially just to the left of the trail going into Pope's Pond off Sumner Street at the intersection of Sumner Street and Canton Avenue.
Speaker 1 (18:38–19:53)
Thank you very much. Are there any questions from commissioners? Are there abutters or members of the public that have a question or a comment? Hearing none and seeing none, is there a motion to approve this negative determination of applicability with usual conditions that, you know, any hole in the ground to not stay open overnight and any equipment not be stored or refueled within our jurisdiction?
With those usual, what we call boilerplate conditions, is there a motion to issue a negative determination of the RDA? Thank you you get the motion time to second the motion. I second the motion any discussion. Hearing none Mister Doyle how do you vote.
Yes. Miscapo how do you vote. Yes. Mister Hamilton.
Yes. Mister Palmer. Aye. And I, John Cannon, vote aye, yes, as well.
That's unanimous. Thank you very much. Mr. Doyle, next on the agenda is number eight, determination of applicability, conservation sign Herrick Drive and School Street.
Can you tell us about that one?
Speaker 4 (19:53–20:23)
That sign would go on town property at the intersection angled in such a way as to address the conservation lands adjacent to one another on both School Street and on Herrick Drive. And a map of that location with a hash mark or a bar for the location of the sign has been provided in each member's packet as well by Philip Driscoll.
Speaker 1 (20:23–21:01)
Any questions or comments from commissioners? Hearing none, are there any comments or questions from members of the public or buddies in particular, but any member of the public? I see no hands raised and I hear no voice. Is there a motion to issue a negative determination of applicability for the conservation site at Herrick Drive and School Street?
Thank you, Wendy. Is there a second? Todd, thank you so much. Did you get to second?
Any discussion? Hearing none, Mr. Doyle, how do you vote? Yes.
Wendy Carpo, how do you vote?
Speaker 9 (21:01–21:02)
Yes, please.
Speaker 1 (21:02–21:28)
Okay, Todd Hamilton? Yes. All right, Tom Palmer? Aye.
Thank you, and I, John Kiernan, I'm a yes, please, too. Thank you very much. Thank you, that's unanimous. Going on to the next agenda item, which is number nine.
This is the determination of applicability at Riverside Avenue.
Speaker 4 (21:29–22:12)
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This proposed sign would be located just off Riverside Avenue on town property. There is, again, a map in each member's folder.
And looking at the map, you will see a gray shaded area. which is town property and a bar or a hash mark at the location of the proposed sign, which would give it angular visibility to all people in that area who use Riverside Drive.
Speaker 1 (22:14–23:06)
And for commission members, the benefit, Arthur and I have actually gone out and walked these areas, and Arthur's wisdom, I think he gets the credit for selecting great locations for public visibility for placing these signs. So I thank you, Arthur, for that. Are there any comments or questions from commissioners? Are there any comments or questions from abutters or members of the public?
Hearing none and seeing no hands raised, is there a motion to issue a negative determination of applicability with our usual conditions for the placement of the sign on Riverside Drive? Thanks, Todd, very much. Is there a second? Wendy, thank you very much.
All right, any discussion? Hearing none, Mr. Doyle, how do you vote? Yes.
Ms. Capo, how do you vote?
Speaker 9 (23:07–23:08)
Yes, please.
Speaker 1 (23:08–23:39)
Mr. Hamilton? Yes. All right.
And Tom Palmer? Aye. And I, John Kiernan, vote yes as well. So that's unanimous.
Thank you very much, Mr. Doyle. Thank you, commission members. I look forward to seeing that.
And people are starting to comment. I mean, I've heard people on the streets saying, hey, I saw the sign in different locales. And I think it's a great idea for public education to know and appreciate where the conservation land is. So I think it's a good project, and Arthur, you get the credit for this.
Speaker 4 (23:40–23:41)
It's teamwork, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 1 (23:42–23:54)
All right. Next on the agenda, number 10, is Notice of Intent, Access Road, Town of Milton, Quarry Hills. The applicant is here, I hope.
Speaker 10 (23:55–23:56)
Oh, Deb Keller.
Speaker 1 (23:56–23:56)
Hi.
Speaker 10 (23:56–24:05)
Thank you. Deb Keller. So I can get started unless you need to read anything prior?
Speaker 1 (24:05–24:07)
We're good. Tell us what's what's going on.
Speaker 10 (24:08–24:26)
All right. Sure. Deb Keller with Merrill engineers representing the I guess the town as the owner as well as the project proponent of USC LLC. So if I could share my screen, I could walk through the plans if that's helpful.
Speaker 11 (24:26–24:28)
It's very helpful. Yes, please.
Speaker 10 (24:29–24:36)
Could I get, I think I need… Yeah, Philip, can you help? I'm trying, hold on.
Speaker 12 (24:37–24:37)
Okay.
Speaker 10 (24:37–24:38)
Okay. I'll start talking.
Speaker 12 (24:39–24:44)
Looks like… Did I do it? You did. Oh, good.
Speaker 10 (24:45–24:48)
No, I think that's somebody else's screen.
Speaker 4 (24:53–24:57)
Wari Hills Access Road is on the right-hand side of the screen.
Speaker 1 (24:59–25:06)
I see all the pictures. I mean, I see our screens, the commission members on the right.
Speaker 2 (25:11–25:16)
Hold on. Yeah, that's Philip's screen. You're sharing your own.
Speaker 4 (25:16–25:31)
Oh, sorry. Philip, on the right-hand side, 1, 2, 3, 4 columns to the left in the center is Quarry Hills Access Road. There's a folder.
Speaker 12 (25:34–25:36)
Say that again. Sorry, Arthur.
Speaker 4 (25:36–25:51)
That's all right. Go to the left of your screen, where it says Quasar Watershed in the middle, and move to the left. The fourth folder in is Quarry Hills Access Road by Label.
Speaker 13 (25:54–25:59)
Hold on.
Speaker 9 (25:59–25:59)
Hold on.
Speaker 12 (26:00–26:03)
I'm new at this, hold on.
Speaker 1 (26:03–26:06)
Yeah, miles ahead of me, Philip.
Speaker 12 (26:07–26:10)
I can't even find the folders I've been talking about.
Speaker 1 (26:14–26:23)
Can I hit new share? Can't you just give Deb permission to share rather than doing it yourself?
Speaker 12 (26:24–26:28)
Yeah, if I could figure out how to do that, sure.
Speaker 10 (26:29–26:53)
Typically, there's a button to the right of the share screen where you can click and allow participants to share their screen. I'm not seeing it on my screen, but that's normally where I find it.
Speaker 8 (27:02–27:14)
Sorry about this.
Speaker 12 (27:21–27:24)
Any other suggestions?
Speaker 4 (27:26–27:28)
Bill, what do you have on your screen?
Speaker 12 (27:29–27:36)
I just have conservation, like the starting screen. Hold on.
Speaker 4 (27:36–27:39)
OK, I have a whole series of folders.
Speaker 12 (27:40–27:40)
OK.
Speaker 4 (27:43–27:53)
On my screen that are yours, it appears. OK. You do not have that, correct?
Speaker 1 (27:53–28:04)
Catherine, I saw your comment. Can you make Deb a co-host? Is that easier than giving her access to share?
Speaker 12 (28:05–28:13)
All right. So hold on. Anybody know how to do that? Sorry.
Speaker 1 (28:15–28:21)
I sure don't. Tom, you were helpful before helping screen sharing. Tom Palmer?
Speaker 7 (28:24–28:28)
I'm sorry. I hardly ever use Zoom, and I'm doing my browser this time.
Speaker 14 (28:29–28:45)
So I think, if you don't mind me just popping in, I think if you hover over the person's name, I'm not sure whose screen you want to share, and there should be three little dots, and you can click on that, and whoever is the host should be doing that, and then it should be able to say, make that person a co-host.
Speaker 12 (28:46–29:23)
All right, hold on. So I'm looking for Deb. All right, hold on. behind the name, sorry.
Oh, here we go, all right, so. May Cow House, here we go. Yes, awesome. All right, we just did that.
Speaker 10 (29:25–30:20)
So I wonder if now it looks like, can you by any chance stop sharing your screen? There should be sort of like a green bar either at the top or the bottom of your screen where it'll say stop sharing. Ah, there we go. Oh, perfect.
Yeah, bummer. I still can't get in to share my screen.
Speaker 12 (30:20–30:27)
Hold on. Come on.
Speaker 1 (30:44–30:54)
Can we go back to Phillip and find Deb's name and hover over it? Okay, I've got it. I know that's worked in the past.
Speaker 12 (30:55–30:56)
Okay. Did I do it?
Speaker 10 (30:57–31:08)
Let's see. I'm going to go back. Yes. All right.
We got there. I'm going to share. Now, hopefully, you see an existing conditions plan?
Speaker 11 (31:08–31:10)
Yes, we do.
Speaker 10 (31:11–36:58)
Okay. Great. Thank you, Phillip. So, again, I'll just start off Deb Keller with Merrill engineers and land surveyors here, representing the town of Milton and USC LLC, just to give a brief history.
So USC LLC filed a 40B project for a 40-unit development on 728 Randolph Ave, which is this parcel here. During that permitting process, worked with the town to obtain access rights, I guess, into the access road so that we could have the project driveway or access to that project be from the access road down to the light rather than increasing the demand for driveway just a few hundred feet down street from that intersection. So that easement to the development was granted by the town and the discussion was obviously had that this portion of the access road would need to be improved up to the limit of the project so that we could maintain access from the access road. And in doing so, we have improved roadway, we added a sidewalk, and drainage so that we could pretreat stormwater runoff.
Currently, everything flows from a high point along in the central portion of this project flows towards the access road and this flows across and into the abutting properties which are owned by the town of Milton. There is some that flows into Randolph and then quite a bit of runoff comes down the access road and into the town properties of which contains a very large wetland resource area. So we have since gone out and flagged that wetland along the property and along the access road where we're proposing our work. We've noted that there is an existing cross culvert coming from a wetland across Randolph Ave, discharges onto the property here.
You can see there's a little head wall right here where the two pipes come in. So that's existing conditions. Here is the proposed work. So the residential development is located on 728 Randolph Ave.
The driveway coming in from the garage and the surface parking. would be up in this location on access road. The access road from the intersection approximately 725 feet or so would be improved. At the entrance, it's the same width of 24 feet and as the existing road comes up, it narrows down, we would maintain the 24 feet all the way up to the driveway.
We are proposing some street trees on what I would say is the north side of the street, full well knowing that the existing properties to the south are fully vegetated. Adding trees might not be helping out there if we're already fully vegetated. going into where we have our impacts. So we have stormwater improvements coming at three points along the roadway to capture the stormwater runoff through deep-hooded catch basins into a pretreatment unit and discharging to the town property adjacent to the wetland.
So the two discharge points up gradient or north near the driveway are outside the 100-foot buffer. The one that is within the 100-foot buffer is at the intersection. Unfortunately, it is the low point on the site and we can't move that or adjust that location. We tried to tie that into the existing headwall.
I can get that a little bit closer. Oops, wrong way. So you can see that. So we are tying our discharge point into where the existing headwall is for the cross culvert so that we maintain that location and not creating a new one.
So it is slightly within the 25 foot setback from the wetlands, but it is in the same location as the existing headwall is currently. I would note that I looked this evening and did not see a DEP file number as of yet. And there is habitat located on the town property. So we have submitted to Natural Heritage and are awaiting any input or response from them as well.
And I'm happy to answer any other questions if I haven't touched upon anything.
Speaker 1 (37:00–37:42)
I have a question, but Tom Palmer, you may know the answer right off the top of your head. And I know that natural heritage has some land that has been at issue in the past, going back to when the town was trying to put up a wind turbine. I think there was one section that was deemed to be sensitive to Indian artifacts. And there was, I forget what the name of it, Tom.
You know the name of the area, don't you, whether it's something quarry? Do you know what I'm talking about?
Speaker 7 (37:42–38:49)
Yeah, you know, there is an archaeological area that's sort of at the other end of the access road. And the habitat of rare species is mapped right up to the existing road. So I think I would agree with the proponent that they need to notify Heritage. On the other hand, it doesn't seem like they're into the habitat in any great amount.
I would note that I've walked up and down that road a lot, and I can't see from the plan where the woods edge is. There's some, I would say the better trees are definitely on the south side of the road. And on the north side, there are places where it looks like the slope is actually just junk pushed up against the road. I think you know what I'm talking about.
There's places where that old stable is, it looks like the slope above the road is basically trash. Is that part of this lot?
Speaker 10 (38:50–39:36)
It is not so this we stopped right where the stables property begins. Yeah, we would we were putting in a small turnaround just so that we made sure that emergency trucks or and if anybody came up here by mistake could turn around and come back out. That was a discussion we had with the fire department. But this would be gated at this location, similarly to where it's gated down at the intersection currently.
We would bring that gate up to this location so that the access road could be still used. I believe gas company has rights to go up there?
Speaker 7 (39:36–39:41)
Yes, they do. They're actually- They go every day. They're just about.
Speaker 10 (39:42–39:54)
Yep. So they'll be wanting to maintain that access. We wanted to make sure that that was still maintained. It's just the gate, instead of being down at the light, will be up here.
Speaker 7 (39:55–40:01)
OK. I would ask, who needs to have a gate there?
Speaker 10 (40:05–40:34)
I can double check our notes, but that was a discussion that we had with The zoning board, as well as the fire department, and I will have to, we've just always, in all our discussions, they said move that gate that we have down here, obviously would have to get moved up to this location so that we can allow the residents at the new development to come and go out of their driveway.
Speaker 7 (40:34–41:11)
So I can, are you- Have you noticed, yeah, I'm just sort of leaving that aside. It's just my own curiosity why there needs to be a gate there. At any rate, where that road comes down from higher up, a lot of water does run down it, and there are places where it freezes. And I wonder if your stormwater system is designed to take the runoff that's coming down the road beside the stuff that's coming off your own lot.
Speaker 10 (41:13–42:14)
Um, yeah, we analyzed it from a high point so that these catch basins, um, obviously we can't, we weren't extending up into, um, farther past. Um, but this would be much better than in actuality, this area right here where you're talking about would be one of those areas that I would suspect freezes. I haven't been out there when it's frozen, but I've seen, you can see sort of where it's breaking out on the side of the road and kind of cutting gully gullies. So we have curbing now and would have appropriate catch basins, and we have a slight high point here.
So these would be the two major catch basins that would be catching the low point, which is what we have naturally here in the road now, and would discharge that out. And then we've just added additional ones to capture the stormwater from the road. not just the expansion of the road, it would be for the road itself.
Speaker 7 (42:15–42:29)
Yeah, I get it. That's appropriate, I think. I would wonder, though, I don't know myself, looking at the plan, how many trees are going to be taken down along this area and on which sides?
Speaker 10 (42:31–43:24)
So I'll double check, but we have a tree line right here. So we're right on the edge of the tree line here. I do believe there's utility poles that come right along the edge of the road. So in reality, we've limited any type of clearing along the road.
It would be just where we have to come in for the three discharge points. Let's see, I had a… That's so this one shows our erosion control lines, you can see where the bump outs would be. Those would be the areas in which we'd have to come into the tree line.
We worked pretty hard to try to improve the grade that we have on the access road without impacting the grading, especially on the south side of the roadway.
Speaker 7 (43:27–43:34)
Thank you. I think I understand the project. I think we ought to do a site visit, of course.
Speaker 1 (43:36–44:03)
Deb, can you tell us, I see what I think of the old stables. Yes, up here. Can you tell us how far away, there's a certified vernal pool just on the other side of that property. I think it was Mr.
Zarella's property. that we actually were involved in a number of years ago. But I don't know what the distance is. I'm sure it's more than 100 feet, but I'd like to know.
Okay.
Speaker 10 (44:03–44:10)
Yeah, I'll have to confirm that for you. I can definitely get that information. I'll track that down for you. And you said it was Zorello?
Speaker 1 (44:10–44:29)
Well, it actually was on the O'Neill property. What's the name of the cul-de-sac road off of Pleasant Street? Is it Kitty Lane? Mary Catherine.
Mary Catherine Lane. Mary, OK. At the end of that road is where the bridge is.
Speaker 9 (44:30–44:30)
Yeah.
Speaker 10 (44:30–44:40)
Yeah, I would say that's well over 200 feet, but I will definitely confirm. I want to confirm that for you. I don't think I have a plan that extends that far for us to measure.
Speaker 1 (44:40–45:13)
All right. Also, if you go, I guess it would be. Is that north? Yeah, that way.
That's where the animal shelter at least was. I don't know where it's going now. We permitted that and we found some isolated wetlands that are relatively close to the road. I don't know how far away those are.
Those may be closer than the Vernal Pool.
Speaker 10 (45:14–45:31)
Yeah, so I can locate those and then get an overall so we can have some general distances from that project. I suspect we're over 100 feet, but I will definitely get that on a plan so we can have that for the record.
Speaker 1 (45:32–45:39)
Good. That would be helpful because my guess is that you are 100 percent correct. It is more than 100 feet, but I'd like to be able to confirm that.
Speaker 7 (45:39–45:46)
Sure. Could you tell us what you're doing with the stormwater on the actual building site?
Speaker 10 (45:47–47:05)
Absolutely. I'm going to zip back here. Let's see if I can find it. What we have done here is we have a large subsurface chamber system that's going underneath the surface parking in the back, which will capture the parking lot, the roof runoff.
It will go into here first with an emergency overflow that we have tied in here. which then ultimately the discharge point would be across the street, which is where the stormwater runoff goes now. And we also have a swale. And in these upper sections, it is a rip rapswell for due to the steepness of the side slope coming down.
There is a large portion of the stable property or adjacent property here that does come on to this property. So we wanted to make sure that we could capture that and direct that appropriately. So we have. Pre-treatment here, we have additional pre-treatment through structures here with the swale and a depression, and it comes across and discharges here.
We've meet the stormwater standards were reviewed with ZBA, and so we've met the peak rate requirements.
Speaker 7 (47:08–47:09)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (47:14–47:27)
Other questions from commissioners? Yeah, do you know that the overall. Dimensions of impervious surface.
Speaker 10 (47:30–47:45)
Um, before. Let's see, do I have that in your check? I can definitely get that for you with regards to the road or just the entire project.
Speaker 1 (47:45–47:52)
No, the entire project. And actually, I was not looking at the road. I was actually looking at the parking area and the building.
Speaker 10 (47:52–48:14)
OK. Sure. So parking and building. I probably have that in the stormwater report, but I did not pull that out for this evening.
So project impervious calcs. I can provide that, definitely.
Speaker 1 (48:17–48:23)
I agree, Tom, we definitely need a site walk, but in the meantime, are there other questions from commissioners?
Speaker 7 (48:24–48:41)
One more about the Randolph Avenue. You say you will tie into the headwall down there where it discharges. What do you mean by tie into? Will you be replacing that headwall?
Will you be drilling into it?
Speaker 10 (48:42–48:57)
No, I apologize. I'm just stating that we're locating our outlet next to that headwall. I didn't want to touch the headwall because it's a separate. That culvert comes from across Randolph Street.
Speaker 7 (48:57–49:07)
Yeah. Yeah, I stood there. I know what that looks like. Yeah.
So this is an area where you don't really have room to do much treatment.
Speaker 10 (49:09–49:09)
Correct.
Speaker 7 (49:10–49:14)
Yeah. You will do some treatment, I guess, right?
Speaker 10 (49:15–49:26)
Yeah, so we have the deep some catch basins and then we will have a storm scepter pretreatment unit which will help us with sediment and oils etc prior to discharge.
Speaker 8 (49:28–49:29)
Okay.
Speaker 10 (49:31–49:46)
That'll give us our water quality treatment. And so with regards to groundwater, we're doing that on the 728 property through the subsurface chamber system, and that compensates for the overall project.
Speaker 1 (49:49–50:07)
Thanks. Other commissioners, questions? We'll definitely do a site walk, but in the interim, how about abutters or members of the public? Questions, comments, suggestions?
Speaker 7 (50:08–50:09)
There's a hand up, I think.
Speaker 11 (50:12–50:31)
Rob C. You're on mute. You're still on mute, I think. Yeah, he's on mute.
You're off now. Good. Go ahead, Rob.
Speaker 9 (50:33–50:33)
No.
Speaker 1 (50:39–50:44)
All right. I can't see any other hands while Rob tries to work with his audio.
Speaker 4 (50:47–50:48)
None visible, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 1 (50:49–50:52)
No, I can't see any with the screen sharing up there.
Speaker 10 (50:53–50:55)
Oh, I will get rid of that.
Speaker 1 (50:56–51:09)
I know, Rob, you put something on the chat, but I don't know what it is.
Speaker 10 (51:09–51:17)
Thank you, Deb.
Speaker 1 (51:20–52:15)
Now I've lost. No, there you are. Still can't hear anything, Rob. All right.
Well, we're going to have another public hearing because the commissioner is going to visit the site and that will be a public hearing. Can everybody check their calendars and see when you're available, starting with this Saturday? I should have dates. That is the 18th.
We got the 18th and the 25th, and then we're to December 2nd. How about the 18th? I'm available. Tom, you're good with it?
Yeah. All right. Arthur, Wendy, Todd?
Speaker 4 (52:15–52:17)
I think I'm going to be good, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 1 (52:18–52:18)
Okay.
Speaker 8 (52:22–52:23)
Yes, I'm available.
Speaker 1 (52:23–53:27)
Yeah, sounds good so far, Todd. I won't be. OK. Tom's good.
Wendy's good. Arthur and I are good. So we'll put it on for Saturday the 18th. And I'll get the word out to Hans and to Ingrid as well.
Because we'll have our quorum. I didn't mean to just go by the fact that you couldn't make it. But I think we ought to move. with deliberate speed on this.
So let's meet Wendy in deference to you. We'll make it 8.30 on Saturday morning, November 18th. Okay. Now, Philip.
The secret code for the gate here, because we need to get that gate open. And only a few people know half the code, and you have to be cleared to get the other half. So can you figure out how to get that gate open? Absolutely.
We've had some problems there before.
Speaker 12 (53:28–53:32)
OK. I won't be there tomorrow, but I'll be there Thursday. I'll take care of it.
Speaker 1 (53:32–53:33)
Perfect. All right.
Speaker 12 (53:34–53:36)
And I'll post the meeting as well on Thursday.
Speaker 1 (53:37–54:21)
That's perfect. That's good. Hey, Rob, did you make it back? Do you have your audio back?
No, it doesn't look it. All right. Well, you can be if you can be there Saturday morning, 830. This is the coming Saturday.
And I know in the past, we've actually parked across the street. I don't think I should do this. But I'll tell people that I parked across the street in the school parking lot, the little kids school there. And sometimes sometimes it's enough from as long as the gate is open that you can park there as well.
All right, so Deb, with your assent, we'll continue this for a public meeting on this coming Saturday, the 18th at 8.30, and we'll meet on site.
Speaker 10 (54:21–54:21)
Okay, thank you.
Speaker 1 (54:22–54:23)
Great, thank you very much, Deb.
Speaker 10 (54:23–54:25)
All right, keep going. Take care.
Speaker 1 (54:25–54:35)
Thank you. Okay, that was number 10. Number 11 is order conditions, Turner's Pond, Milton Parks Department. I saw Kevin there somewhere.
Speaker 15 (54:38–56:57)
John, I think I'll be talking about this. This is Pete Jackson. Perfect. Thank you.
Thank you, Pete. Good evening. We have completed the construction of the Turner's Pond project per the plans and per the order of intent, the order of conditions. But we find with the extreme rains that we had this summer, which made construction difficult, and even after we finished construction, that we're getting overtopping of the path, although it's six inches higher than it previously was.
The amount of drainage that's coming off of Glover School, particularly in the neighborhood of where their play field is, causes the water to back up and overtop the new path. Um, so far the path has held up to it. It hasn't eroded away or anything like that, but, um, for the longterm viability, uh, the park department is, feels that a, um, a trench drain on the inland side of the path to pick up the water, uh, coming off of Glover school and, um, uh, and being directed underneath the path. is the best way to handle the, um, the problem, the continued problems with drainage there.
Um, so what we're proposing is to, um, construct a 12 inches, 12 inch wide by 18 inch trench drain, um, back filled with, uh, with drainage stone. Uh, there will be no increase in the amount of fill, um, within the flood area. because we will not be replacing any more material than that which we removed to construct the drain. So, you know, the total amount of cut and fill is the same.
We have worked with the contractor who built the path and he's given the Park Department a proposal to do this work. Hopefully we could get it done this fall, but if not, it might have to hold over till spring. Are there any questions?
Speaker 1 (56:58–57:02)
So this would be a proposed revision to the existing order of conditions, correct?
Speaker 15 (57:02–57:10)
That's correct. It's the plan and the order of conditions to construct this trench drain, about 250 linear feet of drain.
Speaker 1 (57:11–57:44)
All right, so what I can envision is a determination by the Conservation Commission as to whether or not this is a minor revision or a major revision. If it's a major revision, you'd have to refile an order of conditions. If it's a minor revision, and if we so vote, then we can then take a second vote on whether or not to adopt your proposed trench drain and culvert to get the water out of there. What you just said, Pete, makes perfect sense to me.
Other questions from Conservation Commission members?
Speaker 15 (57:47–58:05)
I might add that this drain is exactly the same thing as when we constructed the path 12 years ago or whatever it was. It's the same kind of drain system we put in for areas that experienced the same thing at that time. So it's not a solution that the commission is unfamiliar with.
Speaker 1 (58:08–58:14)
Right. I remember that. In fact, the first one was, I think, down closer to the parking lot on the central left side, isn't it?
Speaker 15 (58:15–58:32)
Yes. Yes. And that continues to work well. And there's another one on the other side beyond where the beech tree is coming around the high side there.
There's another drain there. And both of them continue to work just fine.
Speaker 1 (58:35–58:47)
Questions from commissioners? But it is members of the public that have a question or comment. Tom?
Speaker 7 (58:47–58:53)
Tom Palmer, did you want to say something? No, I am hoping this happens.
Speaker 1 (58:55–59:26)
Oh, good. All right, then I guess we need to make two motions. The first one is whether or not this is a minor revision, which I believe it is, to the original order of conditions. So as not to require a new order of conditions.
Tom, do you make that motion that this is a minor revision? Yes, I move this is a minor revision. And I'll second. All right, thank you.
Any discussion? Hearing none, Arthur, how do you vote? Yes. And Wendy, how do you vote?
Speaker 8 (59:27–59:27)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (59:27–01:00:07)
Todd? Yes. Tom? Aye.
And I vote yes as well, John Kiernan. So the second motion would be to adopt the revision as described by Pete Jackson and make that a revised order of conditions. And the plan would have to be submitted, and that would be the new approved plan with the addition of this trench drain and culvert. So moved, Mr.
Chairman. Is there a second? Second. Thank you, Todd.
Any discussion? Hearing none, Mr. Doyle, how do you vote? Yes.
Wendy, how do you vote? Yes. Todd?
Speaker 16 (01:00:07–01:00:08)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (01:00:08–01:00:15)
Tom? Aye. And I, John Kiernan, vote aye as well. Thank you.
That's done. Pete, you're all set to go.
Speaker 2 (01:00:15–01:00:21)
Thank you. Mr. Chairman and Phyllis, there are some people in the waiting room who are waiting.
Speaker 12 (01:00:21–01:00:22)
Oh, sorry. Sorry.
Speaker 2 (01:00:23–01:00:25)
Thank you, Phyllis.
Speaker 12 (01:00:27–01:00:30)
Sorry about that.
Speaker 15 (01:00:32–01:00:33)
Thank you, commissioners.
Speaker 1 (01:00:34–01:00:58)
All right. I think we're good. I turned his pond. Thank you, Pete, for your presentation.
Next on the agenda is there actually now we've got two agendas. And one of them has a blank 15 and the other one has a name in the 15, but. Oh, no, we've got to get to 12 first, which I'm sorry. That's 117 Fuller's Lane.
I didn't mean to skip that one. Sorry.
Speaker 17 (01:01:01–01:01:37)
Do we have another? Good evening, Commission. I'm here for 117 Fuller's Lane. Oh, great, Mitch.
Thanks for being here. Yep. What can you tell us? Okay, so my name is Mitch Maslanka.
I'm with Goddard Consulting, wetland scientist, representing the applicant, Patrick Curtin, for a proposed addition project, as well as a deck and proposed pool and patio. I can show my screen, show you guys the revisions that were made, if I was able to share. I'm going to make you a co-host, Mitch. Awesome.
Speaker 1 (01:01:38–01:01:48)
I thought the last time it worked better when you just hovered over his name and allowed him to screen share. I think I'm good actually. I got it.
Speaker 17 (01:01:48–01:01:50)
Oh, good. All right. Perfect.
Speaker 12 (01:01:51–01:01:53)
I think I'm better if I'm a co-host, John. Perfect.
Speaker 17 (01:01:54–01:04:33)
All right. Thanks guys. So, um, last time we had discussed this project, it was on site. Um, commission members were all over and we discussed the proposed, uh, deck in addition.
And, um, can you guys see the screen actually? Yes, we can. It's great though. If you blow it up just like that.
Yep. Okay. So, um, one of the concerns was the, the wetland delineation, um, it. crept into the lawn.
So originally, there were some areas where it was flagged within the lawn. And when the commission was out there, there was some clear signs of soil saturation. So the commission asked for me to adjust the wetland boundary. So I dug test pits and found the extent of hydric soils in the lawn and where the saturated soils came up to.
And I hung new flags. So this faint green line, that's our new wetland boundary. and this darker green line, that's the edge of lawn. So we have edge of lawn, and then we have the wetland boundary extending into the lawn there.
So that pushed our 25-foot no disturb buffer zone closer to the house, which added some site constraints for the proposed project. Initially, we did have a deck already creeping into the 25-foot buffer zone, So it did push the 25 foot buffer zone even closer to the house. So the proposed deck was reconfigured to stay outside of the 25 foot buffer zone. So that was one of the commission's main concerns was making sure that no proposed work or structures were proposed within the 25 foot zone.
the 25-foot buffer zone. So we had the architect look at the plans and discuss with the homeowner Patrick on what they could potentially do to redesign their deck and additions and patio space to stay outside that 25-foot buffer zone and this is what they've come up with. They have a proposed deck shown in the orange here that's been reconfigured so that it's outside the 25-foot buffer zone. Nothing's changed with the garage or the front addition or this addition or the porch.
The patio space didn't need to be shifted back closer to the house. The pool was reconfigured. And so overall, less less disturbance in the buffer zone and no more disturbance within the 25-foot buffer zone. So we believe that had addressed all the commission's concerns.
Let us know if you guys have any follow-up questions.
Speaker 1 (01:04:35–01:04:58)
First of all, thanks to you and to the homeowner because you actually did what we asked you to do. Secondly, I've got a question about the proposed pool. I can't remember if we talked about it, but is that a cartridge filtration system so you're not discharging water? Most new pools are.
Speaker 17 (01:04:58–01:05:05)
I'm going to have to ask if Patrick's on. Patrick, are you on? Do you know what the pool's going to have?
Speaker 18 (01:05:05–01:05:16)
Yeah, we actually haven't gotten to that design level of detail for the pool project at the moment. But whatever would be preferred, we can definitely make sure that we do that.
Speaker 1 (01:05:16–01:06:38)
Yeah, it's pretty easy. The older style pools would backwash, and they didn't empty chlorine or bromide or whatever the chemical component was. And people were kind of dumping it into the wetlands. So we have a very strong preference for the closed systems that operate on cartridges.
And most pools are made that way now anyway. So it's not a cost issue. It's not a design issue. It's pretty easy to accommodate.
But that would be a condition that you're not backwash or discharge cool water that's chlorinated into the wetlands. Absolutely. And for the public's benefit, we've been to the property a couple of times. And although we haven't seen You know, we haven't inspected the new flags.
They look ballpark to where my memory is as to where we thought they would be. Because that was a lawn area that we thought was pretty squishy. And I know that's not the way you define wetlands, I get it. But we appreciate you doing that and appreciate you changing the design of the house as well.
Questions from commissioners? Anybody? I can't see hands raised. I don't hear anything.
Tom, I can see you. I can't see anybody else.
Speaker 4 (01:06:41–01:07:00)
Chairman, I just add a gratification of your comment relative to the adjustments to the plan based upon what the commission requested of the owners. And this looks just very, very responsive to our requests and advice.
Speaker 2 (01:07:03–01:07:03)
Thank you, Mitch.
Speaker 18 (01:07:06–01:07:33)
I just had one quick question. The pool, from my understanding, is going to be a separate building permit application. With respect to the Conservation Commission's potential approval of this design, is there a certain time limit that we'd have to begin construction on the pool for the existing approval to be valid? Or is there a certain time where, after that, we'd have to go back to you guys for another approval?
Speaker 1 (01:07:33–01:08:23)
Well, I thought this was on your order of conditions, but is it just on the plan and not on the… I'm sorry, I said order of conditions, I meant notice of intent. If it's not on the order of intent, you might want to change it. But the answer to your question is yes, it would still be jurisdictional if you put it in.
So if it's not part of the current notice of intent, then you would have to come back. But you could revise this one to add it, because it looks to be properly located. And again, as long as you're not discharging the backflow, we generally approve the pools. The only time we get concerns is if you're on the side of a hill and there's lateral pressure issues, but not on that kind of a hill.
Speaker 17 (01:08:24–01:08:53)
So the pool was included in the notice of intent. And I think, Patrick, just to maybe clarify for you, you'll have three years from the issuance of the order of conditions to complete your project. So that'll give you plenty of time to get the building permit and settle all whatever else matters you need to settle before installing the pool. And if you need more time, you can get an order of conditions extension.
Speaker 1 (01:08:53–01:09:04)
Yeah, Patrick, people do come back to us and ask for extensions, and we generally extend them. But be careful to watch your calendar, because it does expire in three years.
Speaker 16 (01:09:05–01:09:08)
Yep, absolutely. Appreciate it. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (01:09:09–01:10:30)
Any questions from commissioners? I don't see or hear any. How about abutters or members of the public? I don't see any hands and I certainly don't hear anything.
With that said, is there a motion to issue the order of conditions to accept this plan and the provisions? I see the light purple line is the erosion control and that would be pretty serious. I'd like to have a pre-construction meeting so that you sit down with a contractor. With Steve Ivis, not a big deal, but it just gives us an opportunity to make sure the erosion controls are in the right place.
And Patrick, if you want benefit, and Mitch, I know you already know this, we do have standard conditions, and that is you can't store hydraulic equipment, power equipment, within our jurisdiction overnight. and you can't refuel them within our jurisdiction. But I don't think that's gonna be a problem for you, but it just, it wouldn't be for you, it would be for your contractor as to where that storage took place. Any other special conditions that folks have?
I know, Tom, this is an area that you were very interested way out back as to whether or not there was a stream.
Speaker 7 (01:10:30–01:11:20)
Yeah, well, I have to give Mitch credit for, getting back there to look for the back lot line, as Arthur suggested. And I went back there too, and what I was looking for was Cunningham Brook, which does go through there, but there is very little gradient. So there's like no, when we went back, we started to see a flooded area and a deep thicket, but we did not see movement of water or a channel. And we heard a guy on the other side with a whacker.
And we shouted out for him, but he didn't respond. At any rate, that is a formidable, mucky swamp back there. And I guess I had to be a little more ambitious if I wanted to find the channel for a bucket.
Speaker 18 (01:11:20–01:11:29)
You're welcome to come back and try any time you want.
Speaker 1 (01:11:29–01:11:42)
All right. Any other special conditions, folks? Hearing no other additional special conditions, is there a motion to issue the order of conditions?
Speaker 7 (01:11:42–01:11:44)
So moved.
Speaker 1 (01:11:44–01:12:06)
Thank you, Todd. I don't know if you just raised your hand to speak. Tom beat me to that one. OK, so Tom, you get the motion.
Seconds, Todd? Yes. All right, any discussion? Hearing none, we go to the vote.
Arthur Doyle, how do you vote? Yes. Wendy Carpo, how do you vote?
Speaker 8 (01:12:06–01:12:07)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (01:12:07–01:12:09)
Todd Hamilton, how do you vote?
Speaker 8 (01:12:09–01:12:09)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (01:12:09–01:23:22)
Ron Palmer, how do you vote? Aye. John Kiernan, I vote yes as well. So that's unanimous.
Thank you very much, Mitch. Thank you very much, Patrick. No problem. Thank you, commission.
Have a good evening. All right. Thank you very much. Good night.
All right, now next on the agenda is actually the next three. And I should make a comment on this, because this is really one project. So the project itself has to be announced on the agenda under the open meeting law. But we've got the notice of intent, which is 25 Guile Road, Lower Field, and informational 25 Guile Road, Grass for Guile, and Milton Youth Football.
and share, that's really all the same project. And we don't have to give notice on the agenda anyway of the persons that would like to participate. You can participate just as a matter of public rights, which we welcome. But that's essentially one agenda item.
And it relates to the artificial turf field being proposed by the Milton Parks Department. And just to get the public up to speed, we've had a number of meetings and we've had lots of robust discussion. A lot of good questions have been asked. Everybody has been civil and cordial and well-intentioned and well-motivated.
And since our last meeting, commission through me has actually asked for some additional information. And that information that we've asked our consultant for it, And the consultant is Tetra Tech, speaking through Sean Reardon and Ron Myrick as well. And we've also talked to the Parks Department, and that's the applicant and their representative, Chris Huntress. And let me just kind of, I'm probably going to oversimplify this, but let me, tell the public about what our concerns were and what the questions have been related to.
Number one was heat. That is, is the field going to heat up the water, and is that heat component going to impact on Pine Tree Brook, and is that going to impact on the Neponset River, where we all know there are cold water fisheries? and smell thatchers. Temperature is one issue.
We'll get to how that was addressed and how the proposal has changed. The second one was whether or not there is going to be some increase in the PFAS, the forever chemicals. What is the level that's acceptable to the EPA and DEP? Is that changing and has it changed?
And if there is a component of PFAS contamination, then can it be filtered out? And a closely related corollary to that question is, are we gonna get plastic into the wetlands? Little pieces of plastic, different from the chemical contamination, but just pieces of plastic. And what can we do about that?
And then we had some other issues about controlling parking in the area, and these are significant. And by the way, Let me get distracted for a minute because somebody asked me last night whether or not if we keep the parking, the cars from parking at the end of Lower Guile Road, are they going to go to the end of Gulliver Street? So we have to address that too, because we don't want to take the cars that are improperly parked in one area of our jurisdiction and put them into another area of the jurisdiction. But those are the big areas that we've addressed.
And the responses, and I think the responses have been shared, and we've had responses to the responses. The first change, and we've had revised plans, and re-revised plans, with respect to the heat. One of the ways of reducing the heat is to detain the water, to slow it down, to hold it, so it can return to its ambient temperature. So part of that was to, instead of taking the drainage under the field and discharging that into an existing drainage pipe that discharges directly into Pine Tree Brook, we have a new plan that has now been, we have the official formal engineering plans that have been filed with us.
The water is gonna be directed into a very long trench. It goes essentially the length of the field, and then will be discharged through five, I'll call them gateways or outflows, into the wetlands. And that will slow the water down by days or weeks, and certainly will give it a long time to return to ambient temperature. Essentially, it's not gonna go directly into the brook.
And that is in response to the concerns for temperature. Now, we'll have a discussion about that, but that's so far what's happened. With respect to the PFAS, we've had the response from, and we've had discussions about the lack of evidence that there'll be any increase in PFAS, keeping in mind that PFAS are everywhere. But the testing that we have so far, the lab analysis, that any PFAS contamination would be less than, I mean, the principle is that there won't be any, but the testing would be below the anticipated new levels.
Currently, the EPA is at 20 parts per trillion. We anticipate that in January, it will be 4 parts per trillion. But the testing would suggest that it would be below that hazard index level. So that is in response to the concerns about whether or not there will be any PFAS contamination.
with respect to the plastic contamination, the actual tangible pieces of plastic, sometimes called micro-shedding. What happens to that plastic? Where does it go? Well, the temperature control technique of redirecting the water, not putting it into the brook, but putting it into the wetlands, is the proposal.
And for those that think that you shouldn't put anything bad into the wetlands, the wetlands basically they perform, it performs as a filter. and we've got projects all over town designed to improve the quality of water and to take out E. coli, excess phosphorus, excess nitrogen. We've got projects going all over, but that's the purpose of a rain garden.
We have tree filters all over town now, and that's what they're designed to do, to filter out of the water these contaminants. But in this case, we thought further and, you know, some of the concerns voiced by commission members and others was that we don't want plastic in the wetlands. So what can we do about that? So we went back to the applicant and Chris Huntress, I think, can address this tonight and said, look, how do you, you know, if there is, you know, plastic, you know, where's it going to go?
And I know one of the big issues tonight is going to be whether or not this system is a pervious system or an impervious system. But I think there'll be demonstrations tonight that will suggest that this is clearly and demonstrably a pervious system, that the water will drain through. the lower membrane. The shock pad, we've got samples of it.
We asked the applicant to submit samples. We actually have the physical piece of the membrane, and it is most clearly permeable. We've got photographs. Philip actually has the sample itself, but we've got photographs that we're going to share tonight to show that it is pervious, that it is permeable, and the water will go through it.
and then be collected and that water will go into this drain that will go into the wetlands. However, a question came up, what about the surface water? What if there is, now the water should, it's designed to accept all the water on top of the mat or the field. It'll go through and drain down.
But if in fact we had an extraordinary storm and there was water on top and it went to sheet flow, the question then was, well, how do we capture that? to make sure that the plastic pieces don't go into the wetlands. The answer is we put a filter fabric on the brook side of the trench drain. And so the question was, well, will that capture all of it?
And if so, can we go in and inspect it? Because can we see it? And if we can see it, can we find it and can we get it out of there? If every five years we have to go out and scoop it out, can we do that as part of an operations and maintenance plan?
And the answer is yes. But in further support of that, can we find it and remove it? The applicant came back, and Chris Hunters will address that, that there was this kind of a, I'll call it a sump system, where it can be captured from these outflows so that it doesn't get through the filter factor, fabric rather, and it is in a place that is accessible that can be captured and cleaned as part of an operations and maintenance plan. And again, O&M plans are very typical for what we approve and permit.
So those are the big areas that we've addressed, we've tried to address it. You know, the plastic issue, the PFAS contaminant issue, and the temperature issue, and then the parking issue. And I asked for, the commission asked, that there'd be revisions to the plans that have now been submitted to show the split rail fence and any bollards that are necessary to keep traffic away from the brook and the conservation land. And it may be appropriate for the town to consider having some kind of a split rail fence at the end of Gulliver Street as well so that The illegal parkers don't go from the end of Guile Road to the end of Gulliver Street.
The whole purpose of the plan is to encourage people that are using the fields to park at the high school, just two levels up. It's a short walk. So those are the issues that have been kind of circulating and swirling around, and we have accepted all kinds of documentation from everybody. All sides and people on one side and the other side, in the middle and all over the place.
We've got all kinds of data that have come in, and we thank you for that. And so that's just kind of an opening as to where we are, what the existing issues are. And I'd ask Chris Huntress, if you can address the issues that you have addressed since our last meeting.
Speaker 19 (01:23:24–01:23:42)
Mr. Chair, I'd be happy to thank you. Can you hear me okay? Yes, sir.
Perfect. Well, you've summarized well and in quite a bit of detail, so that makes my job easier tonight. But I do have a PowerPoint presentation. If I can share screen, I'll take you through some of the updates on the drawings and details.
Speaker 1 (01:23:44–01:23:46)
Hopefully, we can share screen.
Speaker 19 (01:23:47–01:23:48)
Phil, can you do your best?
Speaker 12 (01:23:49–01:23:50)
I made you a co-host, Chris.
Speaker 19 (01:23:53–01:23:56)
It doesn't seem to work there just yet.
Speaker 13 (01:23:57–01:23:57)
Okay.
Speaker 20 (01:24:05–01:24:22)
There we go.
Speaker 19 (01:24:22–01:33:18)
You got it. Okay. Can everybody see the presentation titled Lower Guildfield with a November 14th date? Yes, Chris, we can.
Perfect. Okay. Well, just to introduce the project team again, Kevin Chrisham, Director of Milton Park and Recreation, is our client. I'm Chris Huntress with Huntress Associates.
And our wetland scientist is Mike Howard. He was not able to join us this evening. And our civil engineer is John Barrows with Marshonda and Associates. And I did see John's name here as well, so I know John's been able to make it in.
The requested plan edits that I'm going to take you through tonight are really threefold. One is that Sherrod said we did extend split rail fence west to the pedestrian bridge at Pine Tree Brook. I'll walk you through where that is on the plan. Second, we revised the drainage design and we did a number of things.
First, we disconnected the stormwater from the Pine Tree Brook outfall pipes. Previously, the system connected to two pipes that went overland down to Pine Tree Brook, so those no longer connect in that way. Second, we added an outfall infiltration trench along the northwest edge of the field that would be just beyond the field. And then third, we added a six-inch trench drain and catch basin sumps, again, along that northwest edge, but this would be in the body of the field itself, right at the edge of where the turf transitions into the chain-link fence.
And then finally, we added one more sheet, L9, with bike path details. Really, the only detail we added was a gate detail, but we kind of compiled. We had details for the bike path on different sheets, so we just compiled them all, put them onto one sheet, being L9, and added the gate detail. So I just wanted to make sure that you're aware of that.
So this is the updated layout and material plan. The field is outlined in the rectangle that you see here. Lower guile comes in from the left-hand side and moves in a westerly direction down to the kind of southwest corner of the field here. So the extension of the fence is the first thing.
We had previously had the fence end right here at the 200-foot riverfront, right at the edge of pavement. At the Conservation Commission's request, we now extended that all the way down to the pedestrian bridge that goes across Pine Tree Brook to prohibit parking within this grassy edge, if you will, this kind of meadow area that's off the edge of the gravel drive. So we've extended that down in that direction. That's really the only major change to this layout plan.
And then the drainage plan. This plan is where we probably did most of our edits. I'll zoom in in just a minute. But what we're going to focus on is this edge along here, this long edge where my cursor is.
Now, this is the northwest edge of the field. And the field tips at 1% with a cross slope from a high point over on this side down to a low point over on the far side here at elevation 38 right along this edge. This is a cross section. This detail 2 is a cross section through that edge.
So what this represents is, I'm going to see if I can zoom in on that just a little bit. This is a concrete turf anchor here. This would be the turf field kind of coming in. And this would be the four-foot chain link fence that you see this pipe coming out of the concrete here.
We've added this six-inch trench drain here, which would run, I've got some pictures of what that would look like as well. And there was three sumps along that entire run. The trench drain will run the entire length of the field. The whole field pitches at 1% towards this trench drain, so any water that would happen to sheet flow would eventually find its way into this trench drain.
The water would then find its way into the bottom of the drain and into these sumps. These sumps have removable basket with a filter fabric liner that would catch any debris or material that happened to get in there. And then this trench drain would empty into the perimeter drains. And I'll take you through that in just a minute.
So this is a blowup of that. And I apologize for the amount of detail in here, but I'll go through it and certainly answer any questions that folks may have. So the field really drains in two halves. There's the upper half of the field here.
Again, the high point is down the bottom of the screen here. And it pitches at 1% across and to the northwest. So this half of the field, if rainwater were to fall in this half of the field, it would migrate through the turf itself, through the resilient shock pad and the filter fabric and down into the stone base and then get either migrate along the top of the stone base or get collected into the panel drains. There would be infiltration that we would expect at that point.
It would then collect into this mid-field collector here, and there's a high point right in the middle. So it would travel this way. If it was over here, it would come in and travel this way, and then down and across the northwest edge through this collector pipe and into an infiltration trench along this edge. And that's going to handle…
I'm sorry, if it fell on this side, it would do the inverse of that and just come over this way and down and around. So this entire… Field becomes subsurface storage and can handle storm events and I'll let john go through what those storm events are. But that's how we encourage infiltration and how we store stormwater during really any of the major events.
What we've done that's different now is we've added, and you can see it here, there's a red line here, a trench drain. It starts right here where my cursor is in the upper right corner and comes all the way across. This is that black graded drain that you saw, comes all the way across. So it would catch everything that happened to go overland or any solids or materials that happened to be in that overland flow would move in this direction, get into the trench drain.
If the storm was large enough, it would eventually overtop these outfall points and go to that outside trench here, an infiltration trench on the outside of the synthetic turf field that is four feet wide and two feet deep with a four-inch perforated pipe connecting five area drains here. One, two, three, four, and five. Again, so stormwater would back up in the field. If the storm event was big enough, it would top into this infiltration trench, and then that infiltration trench would fill uniformly, and it would effectively weep out the top of the riprap stone across the entire way, and you would be able to get access in to clean that trench and those lines through these five area drains that are located along this entire edge.
What does the trench look like? This is some pictures, and I apologize, I don't have an exact photo of what it would look like in our case, but this would be where it's typically used in the transition between a running track and a synthetic turf field, so it's used quite often in this condition. And you would see this black grade, it would be at an even elevation or top of elevation to the turf, and then the whereas this is the red track here, this would be the concrete turf anchor, and then the four-foot chain link fence would be over here. And this is the relative size and scale and depth of that trench drain.
It's about six inches wide, about eight or nine inches deep, and runs uniformly all the way down the field at a constant elevation. The picture in the lower right-hand corner is a picture of the sump. or the inline catch basin, there'd be three of these along this run. And it's this lower section here that's outlined in red that would be the home, if you will, to the filter basket that would sit down as a sump and would collect any solids or debris.
You could quite easily pop this plastic grate across the top and gain access to that basket, lift it out, clean it. change the filter and reinsert it, and this would tie into the overall drainage system. Any questions about the trench drain before I go any further?
Speaker 1 (01:33:19–01:33:26)
Does this change in the mechanism impact on the overall stormwater calculations?
Speaker 19 (01:33:27–01:38:39)
No, this actually, and I'll certainly let John address that as we get into stormwater calculations. But no, this actually helps improve because it's just additional storage for the existing stormwater that's there. The size of the field didn't change, and the amount of rainfall that falls onto it didn't change. So the stormwater calculations didn't change.
We're just directing them slightly differently now. But we did, and that's an excellent segue. John Barros with Marshonda, he reviewed our drainage design and provided a letter at your request, Mr. Chair, that the modifications to the drainage system don't change the analysis that was completed or the calculations that were completed.
So we had done that. Some other things that we had been asked along the way, so I included them on this slide. What were the permeability rates for several of these items? The synthetic turf, which we've identified as the iron turf made by Greenfields.
drains at 13.2 gallons per minute. The shock pad, which we provided a sample of, drains at 12 gallons per minute. And the filter fabric, which this is an image of the filter fabric below, it's a Moraffi 140N. It has a permeability rating of 135 gallons per minute.
It's intended to be an infiltration so you can imagine it's got a high drainage capacity to it, but a very small opening size. It's 0.212 millimeters, so very small. And for water in this storm system to get to the point where it would top back out that infiltration trench, out that riprap, and begin to weep into the wetland, it would have to pass through at least three layers of this Murphy filter fabric. So it would be cleaned three times before it actually was able to exit the site.
And this is sheet nine, I'm sorry, L nine, the bike path construction details. We did add an access gate. So this access gate will be located in two location. Well, there'll be two gates.
One will be at the top of Guile Road that will. limit traffic being able to travel down into Guile Road and certainly you can open it when you need it or if emergency vehicles or maintenance vehicles need to get down, but there will be controlled access at the top of Guile Road. Then a smaller version of the same gate, Mr. Chair, down by the bridge, you would ask that we provide an opening through what is the extension of that split rail fence for maintenance access down in that location, so we included that gate.
in those locations as well. But you can see here, we've just kind of assembled details that were on other plans. We've taken them now and put them all onto this one sheet so they're easier to reference. But we've got the split rail cedar fence.
We've got the gate details, two and three, the bike path paving detail, and then the light fixture detail, pole base and electric conduit raceways for the pedestrian scale lighting that'll be on that path as well. The balance of the presentation, Mr. Chair, is really just a summary of all the plans that we've, the most updated plans that we've submitted. I'll go through them quickly.
This is site prep, tells us how we'll break the site down as we begin construction. This is the layout materials plan that I presented earlier with the extended split rail fence. This is our updated grading and drainage plan. that we just discussed.
Landscape plan, there have been no material changes or edits to the overall landscape plan. Construction details sheet L4, there were no significant changes here with the exception of detail four, which again mirrors the cross-section through the edge of the turf here as well that was shown on L2. L5, which is construction details for the synthetic turf field, mostly being field layout and sports dimensions. L6, again, multipurpose field details for permanent fencing, safety netting, retaining walls and the like, goalposts, a few other things.
L7 is a cross-section through the terrace seating that will be built into the hill along the kind of eastern side, southeastern edge of the site, and some stairway and handrail details. L8, the proposed sports lighting photometric plan and layout locations. And L9, again, the bike path details. A couple of quick images of what we expect the finished product to look like.
This would be in the seating area looking down towards the bike path, and you can see that we've added and extended the split rail fence down this edge as well. Then overall, looking back down and over at the site. With that, Mr. Chair, I can stop here, I can stop sharing screen, or I can leave it up for a little bit if the commission has questions.
Speaker 1 (01:38:40–01:38:49)
Some of the questions might refer you back, so why don't you leave it there temporarily. Thank you very much for that presentation. Commission members, any questions?
Speaker 2 (01:38:54–01:38:56)
I have a question, Mr. Kiernan.
Speaker 1 (01:38:57–01:38:58)
Of course, go ahead.
Speaker 2 (01:38:59–01:39:28)
Mr. Huntress, could you please go into detail about what is necessary as far as an operation and maintenance plan for the town, particularly with respect to the new additions of the drainage trench and the What did you call it? The little catch spaces for the particulates.
Speaker 19 (01:39:28–01:41:07)
The area drain, sure. So as part of our stormwater report, I'll hold up here, which was submitted originally back in, whoops. Sorry. Hitting things while I'm moving along.
There we go. As part of our stormwater report that we submitted back in March, in the back few pages include an operation and maintenance plan, long-term pollution and prevention plan, proposed construction stormwater controls, and that includes in it a lot of things, but there's a summary of maintenance requirements, and I'll just read those quickly for you. Specifically with regard to catch basins, all catch basins, which I would expect this trench drain would be treated similarly, inspected four times a year and cleaned once a year. The turf field from a drainage and maintenance perspective, inspected once a year and cleaned as necessary, it would actually be cleaned more often than that.
but from a drainage and infiltration perspective, it would be checked annually. Trash removal inspected once a month and cleaned as necessary. Roadway and walkway sweeping is once per quarter, so four times a year. Then the plan goes through additional detail and breakdown with regard to inspection maintenance logs and what's required there.
Proposed BMPs and corresponding O&M requirements including, again, the roadway and walk sweeping, trash removal, catch basins, and the synthetic turf field. Does that answer your question?
Speaker 2 (01:41:07–01:41:25)
I guess my question is how much of an incremental increase is there in time and expense that's required of the town to operate and maintain this with the addition of the trench and the additional basins?
Speaker 19 (01:41:25–01:42:08)
Oh, none. It's insignificant. The trench drain will be easily accessible along the edge of the field. There'll be three sumps that can easily be popped.
You can pop the grate with a screwdriver and just get down and pull the the filter base now and clean that, and it's really not an issue. And the rest of the system, we would have had to maintain that drainage system regardless whether it connected directly into the existing pipes or whether it drained the way we have now. So I don't think we've added any real maintenance to the system.
Speaker 2 (01:42:11–01:42:21)
So what would happen in the event that the town is unable to keep up with the operation and maintenance plan?
Speaker 19 (01:42:28–01:44:27)
What would happen? Let me get back to the drainage plan. It's really not that complicated system. This system, everything under the field itself is a closed system, meaning only stormwater can get into there, can get into the subsurface drain system under the body of the turf itself, because it's got to pass through multiple layers of that filter fabric to be able to get down into there.
So you're not going to get contaminants or debris necessarily in the subsurface drain system or in the pipes underneath the turf field. The trench drain itself that runs along this edge I guess could get filled with leaves, it could get filled with debris, or if it did, but you could easily pop that trench drain and clean the entire thing the whole way along. The only area that may require more maintenance would be this infiltration trench on the outside of the field. I'm going to go to the detail, that might be easier to see it.
that would be on the outside of the field here with the perforated pipe. This actually works as a, this whole trench works as an outfall system for the drainage system in a larger storm event. So stormwater would come into this, these area drains, leach into this fill and then seep or back up, if you will, to the point where it would exit out the top of this riprap and then into the wetland system in this way. This is about two feet higher than the, 100-year flood elevation, so the contour's actually, you know, great away from this.
So this would be the only thing that might require any real maintenance over time that may just require you to look at vegetative growth and, you know, leaves or other debris that go on the top of the riprap that may otherwise inhibit that infiltration, but I don't think it's significant. Did I answer your question?
Speaker 2 (01:44:30–01:45:22)
Well, I suppose. In my mind, this seems kind of similar to the gutters on your house, right? And if the gutters on your house are clogged up with leaves, then they're not going to be operating the way that they need to do to keep the water off of your house and prevent ice dams and flooding in your basement and everything else. My concern is that if the town, for whatever reason, or whoever is contracted to maintain these systems is unable to do so, then the problem is that then the pollutants and the particulates are going to end up in the wetland and in the brook.
Speaker 19 (01:45:24–01:46:15)
That's my concern. You know, it's a valid concern. The only way I could see that happen would be complete negligence of the maintenance of the system altogether. And quite frankly, this synthetic turf field requires much fewer hours in maintenance than the natural grass field would have to keep and maintain.
So from an employee hour perspective, from a cost perspective, it's cheaper to maintain this field than it would be to maintain the existing field that you've got out there. I might defer to Kevin Prism. If you're here, Kevin, talk about maybe the manpower and commitment that the town might make to continue to maintain that. Is Kevin with us?
Speaker 21 (01:46:17–01:46:19)
I am here. Hi. Hey, Kevin.
Speaker 1 (01:46:21–01:46:21)
Yeah.
Speaker 21 (01:46:21–01:46:47)
Could you respond to that, Kevin? Yes. If we're going to go through with this project, which I think we are, I mean, I hope we are, obviously the Park Department will make sure that this would never happen, that any negligence would ever happen down there. There's too much money invested from the town that we would ever, ever let this happen.
Speaker 2 (01:46:48–01:47:43)
I understand that that is everyone's intention, certainly, but But my concern is that if these best intentions don't happen, from what I'm understanding, it's not going to cause harm to the field. But I believe that it would cause harm to the wetland in the brook. My worry is that there's not going to be enough opportunity for us to see what's happening in the worst case scenario until it's too late.
Speaker 19 (01:47:45–01:50:01)
You would see it actually quite easily. So the only place that this field could fail would be right here at this trench drain, just because of the way it's designed now. Again, this whole system, the whole turf system that's that's upslope, if you will, of that trench drain, drains vertically through its profile, drains it, I think, the slowest part of the system, drains it 12 inches per hour, which is an incredible amount of drainage. So water is going to make its way into this subgrade, and once it does that, it's in a closed system.
So this system, very seldom, if ever, in doing this for 30 years, have I seen a subbase system, a drainage system under a turf field filled with debris. I have seen stone clog over time or filter fabric clog and have to get repaired at the replacement time, but never have I seen that sub-base not be able to hold water. So where it would fail would be right here in this trench drain. And you would see that along the entirety of its edge.
I'm just going to go to the next screen here. Bear with me a second. And it would be this trench drain that would fill with debris. That's the only way that I can think of how this drainage system might fail or where a failure would be.
It would be that nobody ever cleans this trench drain and it clogs and nobody ever comes in and cleans out these sumps. and it would back up through this system. And again, I don't expect you're going to have overland flow here, but if you did have overland flow, in a condition when this trench was filled, it would talk over this wall and go into this infiltration trench and then again go into the ground through here. And it might help to hear from John Barros.
We can ask John to speak for a little bit about the intensity of the storm events that are captured through this system and when we might expect to see kind of outfall coming into these different pipe systems. John, are you here with us and available?
Speaker 22 (01:50:02–01:53:33)
I'm here, yes. I just want to add one thing about the O&M. It, you know, the O&M requires that logs be filled out and submitted. You know, I would imagine they could, you know, you could require to be submitted to the TPW.
So, you know, it's not something that just would be forgotten about if it's done properly. There should be somebody filling out a form quarterly and sending it back to the appropriate person at town hall. So it's not something that would just be forgotten about, I guess, is what I'm trying to say. As far as the intensities go, we use the Cornell Atlas storm events for the design and the calculations.
Because the field is basically pervious, we're not going to have a tremendous amount of runoff coming off the field. And as we said in the letter, the letter that came out today, the review letter, It doesn't really affect the numbers that we came up with for the report in the stormwater calculations. It's actually an improvement. We didn't get into what the improvement would be from what we came up with in the original calculations.
But you're adding additional stormwater control with crushed stone volume. and some additional capacity. So the addition to that would actually improve on the numbers that we've come up with. Just to give you an idea of what we came up with, and it's in the report, we don't see anything coming off the site in the two-year event.
The post condition in a 10-year event would be slightly reduced, like 0.2 CFS. So again, very little coming off the site. And that's the entire study area too. That's not just the field.
The field would even be less than that. And then the 25-year event, it's knocked down from a 1.3 CFS. outflow to a 0.6 CFS, which is a very, very small amount. And then in a 100-year event, we're knocking it down from what we think is the existing conditions of about three CFS, and we're knocking that down to about 1.1 CFS coming off the site.
So, yeah, those are the numbers we came up with when we did the original design for the site. Again, I don't see any large outflows from the field. It's basically a pervious surface that I don't see a big impact coming from the site.
Speaker 1 (01:53:34–01:54:01)
Hey, John, can I ask you something? I don't want to mess up the screen sharing, but you've mentioned pervious surface a couple of times. And we, the commission, had asked for a sample of the, at least the shark pad component of it. And I know Philip Driscoll's got a copy of it, but is that something you've got?
Or Philip, can you share that? So when you say pervious, I'd like to take a look at what you're talking about.
Speaker 22 (01:54:04–01:54:09)
Yeah, I mean, Chris, you must have something with the cross-section of the materials of the field.
Speaker 1 (01:54:10–01:54:19)
We actually got a sample today. Philip, are you able to put that picture that you shared with us? Let me see.
Speaker 12 (01:54:19–01:54:27)
Hold on. This might take a miracle. Hold on.
Speaker 19 (01:54:28–01:54:29)
I might be able to find it.
Speaker 12 (01:54:31–01:54:33)
It's probably easier for you to find it, Chris.
Speaker 9 (01:54:34–01:54:34)
you.
Speaker 1 (01:55:05–01:55:10)
Tom Palmer, you're pretty good at sharing. Did you get the picture from Philip this afternoon?
Speaker 7 (01:55:12–01:55:15)
Yeah, I did. I can open that email and take a look.
Speaker 1 (01:55:16–01:55:19)
I just found it. You got it, Chris?
Speaker 19 (01:55:19–01:56:12)
I got it. So this is the manufacturer's website. where they talk about it, but this is an image of the pad itself. Each of these sheets is about four feet by eight feet about the size of a piece of plywood.
And it's got this channeled system on the bottom that allows water to move both laterally and horizontally. and or back and forth, if you will. And it's got these penetrations throughout and then each of the seam, there's a separation of about a quarter of an inch around the pads itself. So this pad drains at approximately 12 gallons per minute.
See if they've got. Yeah, they're showing how it works there a little bit.
Speaker 1 (01:56:17–01:56:25)
All right, the photo that Philip had actually shows it up close, and you can see those holes in it where the water drains.
Speaker 22 (01:56:30–01:56:52)
So as far as our calculations, we made the assumption that the water would penetrate through the components of the field into the existing subsurface, which would be, of course, into the gravels below it. and then into the existing subsoils, which would infiltrate.
Speaker 1 (01:56:56–01:57:28)
All right. Thank you very much. Let me let me shift gears a little bit because I know there are some folks that would like to be heard. But Sean Ridden, would you or I mean, I think it was your original suggestion that the water be diverted from the pipe into the wetland area in this trench drain.
Do you or. Ron Myrick, Ron from the hydrological perspective and Sean from the engineering perspective, does this do what you suggested?
Speaker 23 (01:57:30–01:59:02)
Yeah, the proposed trench drain, most importantly, it puts the wetland in the 25-foot no-disturb zone between Pine Tree Brook and the project. So basically, the old solution had a direct connection to the infrastructure, so it would just be sort of like the express lane to Pine Tree Brook, whereas now what we're doing is we're sort of interceding that connection by 200 feet of wetland and 25 feet of vegetated buffer. So huge, huge, huge benefit there. I can't state this enough.
We don't anticipate that that trench drain is going to see any water except for the most extreme events. So it really is a belt and suspenders approach. And hopefully to sort of allay some of Wendy's concerns is This system relies on one key thing, which is gravity. As long as gravity is working, it's going to drain properly.
Unlike your roof, which is impervious, so water runs right off of it, this field is completely pervious, so the water runs straight down through it. You're not accumulating water in any case, so you really don't have to worry about a an apocalyptic scenario where a bunch of water is accumulating and it's not able to get treated the way it needs to. In this case, as long as gravity is still working, that water is going down through the filters that the field provides and it's going to work all the time. Even if there's egregious lack of maintenance, this is something that's going to work all the time.
Speaker 1 (01:59:06–01:59:14)
All right, I don't want to ask an impolitic question, but Ron, your expertise is in the hydrology. Do you agree with that?
Speaker 24 (01:59:16–01:59:36)
My expertise is more on the environmental. I think Sean addressed that. My education goes back to hydrology a little bit more. But I defer to Sean on that discussion.
He's a civil engineer, and that's his thing. But I'm here to answer any questions on the environmental side of my assessment in that area.
Speaker 1 (01:59:36–01:59:45)
All right, well, in that area, does this revision to the plan accomplish an environmental benefit?
Speaker 24 (01:59:45–02:00:04)
I think it provides the benefit. I think the original design with the water flowing down in through the filter fabric, the Murafi fabric, and then going in the subsurface was probably sufficient, but adding this provides some additional protection for what might be liberated due to a heavy rain event.
Speaker 1 (02:00:07–02:00:28)
All right, thank you very much. Commission members, questions, comments? Hearing none, seeing no hands, we can move on. And I know that, Paul, I always pick on you, so sorry for that, but you can go ahead and kind of organize those that have questions or comments from the neighborhood group.
Speaker 25 (02:00:28–02:02:58)
Okay, thank you very much, John. We're gonna have to, Phil, I'm sorry, we're gonna have to do this to you again. We were wondering if you could share with Catherine Simpson. We have a couple of people speaking, and so Catherine is going to sort of oversee the flicking of the tiles, so we have to prevail upon you one more time.
But you know, while we have just a minute at the beginning, I think that for the sake of accuracy, it sounds like, particularly for those people here who are not familiar with a lot of this stuff, it seems like the idea of a pervious or an impervious surface is one that we can just define here. One of the things that is important that we should note is that according to the EPA, and artificial turf is in fact an impervious surface. And I know people have said, well, yeah, but it kind of is pervious. We can see stuff going through it.
So we actually wrote to the EPA today to ask them, and we got hold of Newton Tedder, who is the senior permit writer for the EPA region in New England. And he said that he pointed out, as we pointed out, that according to the EPA, artificial turf and compacted gravel and soil are considered impervious surfaces. Mr. Tedder wrote, there is no provision to rewrite or object to this definition in the MS-4 permit context unless the artificial turf includes the ability for water to infiltrate into the natural soil and is not collected and discharged.
Then the site design of stormwater controls needs to treat the artificial turf as impervious surface. And in point of fact, this whole program, this whole system is set up to do just that, to collect and discharge water. So in point of fact, We can talk about whether or not some of the water will go down or not. But as far as the EPA is concerned, this is an impervious surface.
And I think it's important that we mention that, particularly, as I said, we have people here. You guys are, you know, the Tetra Tech guys are way ahead of me in terms of all this. It's way over my pay grade. And there's a sensitivity to other people who are watching that they don't understand that this is an important distinction.
And it is, in fact, a legal one. So anyway, John, we're going to start off. Catherine Burak is going to start off, and she's going to introduce our speakers. Thank you very much.
Speaker 14 (02:02:59–02:03:04)
And if someone could please make me co-host so I can share my screen. This is Catherine Simpson.
Speaker 12 (02:03:04–02:03:12)
The problem is my iPad died. My computer died, and I can't do it anymore. I don't know what to do.
Speaker 1 (02:03:12–02:03:20)
Do you know if I was ever made a co-host?
Speaker 12 (02:03:21–02:03:30)
I'm not sure. I'm trying to get into my home computer, but I can't get in yet. What do you want now? I'm on my iPad right now.
Speaker 6 (02:03:31–02:03:47)
Hey, Phillip or John, if you want to make me a co-host, I can make others ability to share. I don't know who's talking. I can't, I can't. Sorry, this is Turfett.
I'm the guy with the blue suit.
Speaker 14 (02:03:48–02:03:54)
Or you could just make me a co-host and then… Or Catherine, yeah.
Speaker 1 (02:03:54–02:03:57)
That's the problem. He's not able to make anybody a co-host.
Speaker 14 (02:03:57–02:03:59)
I think anyone who's the host right now can do that.
Speaker 1 (02:04:00–02:04:01)
Philip is.
Speaker 12 (02:04:01–02:04:04)
Right, but my laptop died, unfortunately.
Speaker 14 (02:04:04–02:04:07)
It says Arthur Doyle is also a host.
Speaker 12 (02:04:07–02:04:08)
Oh, all right.
Speaker 1 (02:04:09–02:04:10)
All right, Mr. Doyle.
Speaker 14 (02:04:10–02:04:13)
If you can just hover over my name, there should be three dots.
Speaker 12 (02:04:15–02:04:19)
Perfect. Sorry about this. Can you do that, Arthur?
Speaker 2 (02:04:19–02:04:22)
Arthur, while you're at it, there's some people in the waiting room waiting to get in.
Speaker 1 (02:04:22–02:04:26)
A lot of pressure on you, Arthur.
Speaker 8 (02:04:27–02:04:32)
I know. Sorry to put it on you.
Speaker 14 (02:04:32–02:04:33)
Awesome. It worked. Thank you.
Speaker 12 (02:04:34–02:04:36)
Thank you, Arthur. Thanks.
Speaker 26 (02:04:44–02:07:24)
Hello, my name is Kate Burak and I just have a question before I begin about we didn't get a chance to see any of this new filtration system before tonight. Would we be able to ask questions about What will happen if the infill freezes up? What will happen in the snow? We have a lot of questions.
The example you showed us, Mr. Huntress, was out in the open. It wasn't near a forest. A lot of trees, a lot of debris will be falling on that.
There's a lot of things to think about. We'd like to ask questions later, but we do have a presentation prepared. based on what we knew leading up to tonight. We didn't know this other stuff was happening because it wasn't in the file 48 hours in advance.
I would like to begin by talking about the Milton Wetlands Bylaw. And what it says is that the applicant shall have the burden of proof that the work proposed in the application will not alter the wetland. And we argue that it will. Next slide, please.
So what does alter mean? This is from section seven of the Milton bylaw, dumping, discharging, filling material. Now here we're talking about PIPAs and other toxins, including microplastics that are quite tiny and that will come off the turf. PIPAs are really, really small and cannot be filtered.
The destruction of plant life. Heat island effect is going to be very hot near this field. Heat island effect on nearby plants, trees, and the heated water. changing of water or temperature, biochemical demand, and other physical, biological, and chemical characteristics.
So what we're talking about there is heated water from the turf. We measured 142 degrees on turf on the upstairs field. PFAS in components, as well as those that evolve from precursor chemicals present in turf components. And we'll talk a little more about that later.
and any activity, change, or work which pollutes the stream, not to mention adds more water. It just alters the wetland because it adds more water. This is an impervious surface, adding water. It used to be a grass field.
Next slide, please.
Speaker 2 (02:07:25–02:07:35)
Catherine, excuse me. Sorry to interrupt. Arthur, would you please let the other people into the waiting room, from the waiting room? Okay, thank you.
Speaker 26 (02:07:36–02:14:07)
So I want to talk about what climate scientists refer to as the precautionary principle. That Article 3 of the United Nations Framework for Climate Change establishes that parties should take precautionary measures to anticipate, prevent, or minimize the causes of climate change and mitigate the adverse effects. It's really important that we think about this with this field. This trench is within a foot of a FEMA flood zone, a 100 year FEMA flood zone.
I want everybody to think about that. It is important now to think about both the knowns and the unknowns of this project. So what do we know from other fields in the area? Next slide, please.
So this, before we get started, I want you to show you some slides from Piotelli Little League Field, which is just above the field we're talking about. It is also an artificial turf field to illustrate how easily infill migrates off the field, even without players on it to kick it around, and how easily contaminated water coming off the field might flow between the wetlands and pine tree brook. These are the knowns, what we can observe about the artificial turf field. Next slide, please.
We are looking at existing conditions on a Milton-Pietelli field, and this photo shows how the field behaves during a rainstorm last August. It was August 25th at noon. And you can see there was a very heavy rain that day. And you might remember driving on the Southeast Expressway, there were about four inches of rain on the ground.
Shortly after that, piles of infill came up to the top. And sorry, it's a little bit blurry, but you can see piles of infill like that rising to the top of the field. These black crescents illustrate how the infill moves in the rain and is swept into piles. Keep in mind that Brock is lighter than this particular fill.
Next slide, please. This is the black residue that came off that field. Can you see it at the top? It's little tiny pellets, like almost as if somebody threw it down on the ground, that washed off the field.
This is just outside the fence. This is how stormwater will carry it. Please, next slide. I wanna show you how close this is to the field.
So this is where all of this is from rubber that washed off the field and it washed over If you could go back to the beginning, you can see how close this is to the field. Can you show? It's that close to the field and it washed right over the grass. It didn't stop at the grass.
It won't stop at a filter system. It flowed in a big rainstorm. It flowed. Next one, please.
And the next thing I want to show you is this is the wetland. I'm going to show you. Do you see how the wetland water flows directly from the field right into Pine Tree Brook without stopping? Please play that again.
That's the field at the top of the screen. Do you see that water comes without stopping all the way into the brook? There's no stopping it. That's on a rainy day.
Next slide, please. Next slide, please. This is on a sunny day. We still have the water coming right off those wetlands right into the brook on a sunny day.
So my point is that this stuff will migrate, it will come off, it'll be swept in a big rain, it'll come off and it'll go right into the pine tree brook. Next slide, please. And it happens in more than one place. This is the path that is between the brook and the wetlands.
And there are many of these little, I don't know what they're called, the streams that come off the wetland and right into the brook. They don't stop for anything. Water finds its way. Okay, next slide please.
The wetlands will be altered and the wetlands matter to us because we live in a flood zone. They protect us from flooding. Pine tree brook will be impacted. Okay, and next slide please.
I'd like to introduce you to two presenters, Kyla Bennett, PhD, an environmental scientist and lawyer, former EPA wetlands official who is now Northeast Mid-Atlantic Director and Director of Science Policy of Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility. Her group was the first to discover PFAS in artificial turf in 2019. And then Kristen Mello, MS, an analytic chemist who has reviewed analytical laboratory reports from testing of proposed synthetic turf projects across the region and country, including the one rejected on Martha's Vineyard by the Oak Bluffs Planning Board. She served on MassDEP's PFAS Maximum Contamination Level, MCL, stakeholder group.
And then a final wrap up will come from Paul Makashima of Grass for Guile. So I'd like to introduce you to Kyla now.
Speaker 1 (02:14:08–02:14:11)
Thank you very much, Catherine. Well, well stated.
Speaker 27 (02:14:11–02:21:01)
Thank you. Thank you, Kate, and thank you, Mr. Chairman and Commission, for allowing me to speak tonight. If I could have the first slide, please, and I will be very brief.
First of all, just to remind you, the values of wetlands, and this is pursuant to the Wetlands Protection Act in Massachusetts, flood control, prevention of storm damage, prevention of pollution, and protection of fisheries, groundwater, public or private water supply, and wildlife habitat. These are the things that you are protecting as a conservation commission. This project will alter the wetlands and the brook through temperature changes, introduction of pollution, such as microplastics and PFAS, and also harm fisheries and wildlife. Next slide, please.
what will the stormwater do to the wetlands? And first, I was also unaware of some of the information that Mr. Huntress presented. I would be very interested to know what the pore size is of the proposed filter fabric, because as you are probably aware, The microplastics coming off of artificial turf also become nanoplastics, and some of these are not visible to the human eye.
So to suggest that your DPW can go out there and collect these is a little bit beyond the pale. What will stormwater do to the wetlands? These are quotes from recent scientific peer-reviewed articles, and I have the citations on here later. These are quotes from these brand new articles about PFAS and wetlands and forests.
Once PFAS enter an ecosystem, they integrate into soil, water and air transport cycles due to a lack of both PFAS specific treatment and the high stability of PFAS in nature. In other words, once they go in there, they don't magically disappear. Phyto-uptake does not degrade the contaminant into harmless compounds. Therefore, this method needs to be combined with a PFAS destruction technique, such as incineration of the plant material.
In other words, any plants that do take the PFAS up and filter it out, as you say, those are now contaminated, those are now hazardous waste, and they don't just stay there. They will continuously recycle back into the environment. To date, no studies have assessed PFAS accumulation, transportation, and treatment through constructed wetlands, let alone natural wetlands. You are a guinea pig here.
Next slide, please. Continuing, the temperature of stormwater runoff is of emerging concern. Increase at runoff temperatures are a serious threat to aquatic health. These are, again, quotes from scientific peer-reviewed articles.
Not possible that this water will cool down to ambient temperature before it runs off into the wetlands. The videos that Kate showed indicated that. The storms that we're getting with climate change, which are more dramatic, more water, these rain bombs, the bomb cycles, whatever you want to call them, put a lot of water down in a very short period of time. And there will be sheet runoff off of these fields.
which can reach 180 degrees or higher. If you think this is not going to be a temperature change to the brook, you need to rethink that. Thermally polluted urban runoff can subsequently cause stream temperatures to surpass threshold temperatures, resulting in sublethal and lethal effects to downstream ecosystems. You have a cold water fishery.
This increase in temperature is not going to be good. Dissolved oxygen concentrations are directly related to water temperature. In other words, you're going to lose dissolved oxygen in those streams because of the heat, and that is going to be bad for the entire aquatic ecosystem. Next slide, please.
What about the microplastics? There is limited research on the migration and transformation of microplastics in constructed wetlands. Microplastics can lead to a decrease in plant leaf and root activity, thereby reducing plant nitrogen absorption. and retention.
So remember, you didn't tell us what the pore sizes of this filter fabric, but these microplastics do break down into nanoplastics. And we are talking literally about hundreds of pounds annually coming off these fields. You can't see some of these. You're talking about the wetlands filtering this stuff.
Filter is not destruction. Filter is not a cure. Filter means it gets taken up. It can get bound up in the soil, in the plant roots, in the plants themselves, which can then kill your forest, according to this new article.
Microplastics affects the physiological activities of wetland animals through direct toxicity and indirect impacts. Remember, each little microplastic is a little toxic bomb filled with PFAS and other toxic chemicals that will impact not only your plant life, but your animal life. Next slide, please. The wetlands will not destroy, filter, or remove PFAS.
The current knowledge of PFAS removal in the wetlands is still in its infancy. The ability of microbes in wetlands to mineralize PFAS is limited. The uptake of PFOS by trees would require 48,000 years and 160,000 years respectively, depending on which type of tree you're talking about. And with the fall of forest foliage, PFAS can reach the forest soil.
So if your trees do take up some of this PFAS, in the fall, when those leaves fall down onto the ground, they're gonna get into the soil, get into the wetland, and get into the stream. And if that's not an alteration, I don't know what is. Next slide, please. The absence of evidence is not the same thing as the evidence of absence.
Because there are such limited studies on the fate of microplastics and PFAS in natural forested wetlands, because we do know that the water leaving the field can adversely impact the brook and the fish, We can't just assume that everything is going to be okay. You need to, you can't just say, it's gonna be filtered, DPW can clean these out and everything is gonna be fine, because that's not the way life really works. You need proof in order to prove. The burden, remember, as Kate said in the first slide, the burden is on the applicant to prove that this harm is not going to occur.
It is not your burden to prove that it won't. Next slide, please. I guess that was it. Turning it over to Kristen Mello.
Thank you.
Speaker 12 (02:21:03–02:21:04)
Thank you very much, Kyla.
Speaker 28 (02:21:06–02:31:11)
Thank you, Kyla. Thank you, Chair. So our first slide is actually Kyla in 2019 when they discovered the PFAS in the turf that was bound up in Franklin, Massachusetts. Next slide, please.
That's the Boston Globe. So they took samples, and they had those samples analyzed. And they went down into the wetlands. In the bottom left of this slide, you can see The yellow dot is where the surface water samples were taken.
The green dot is where the rolls were laid and where they took those pictures. And this is the data that came from that sample that was coming straight off that turf. Next slide, please. But it wasn't just Franklin in Connecticut and community group took samples right they couldn't stop the field and the turf field installation so they took a water sample before its installation and they took a water sample after its installation, and these are the numbers they got next slide please.
But the data that we've been talking about, right, is the data from Martha's Vineyard. That's what we keep talking about, where they tested the field turf and they tested the Brock fill and the Brock shock pad. So when these materials were tested with a synthetic precipitation leaching procedure, these are the results that we got. And you will notice that at the bottom, not all of those PFAS are the regulated PFAS-6, but they are all persistent bioaccumulative toxic compounds that are endocrine disruptors everywhere in your food web, right?
So the… And when you analyze the effect of PFAS on aquatic organisms, particularly zebrafish, what you will find is that when a pregnant zebrafish mom is in PFAS water, The eggs that are developing inside of the embryo in that mother fish are denatured by the PFAS. So every exposed pregnant fish exposes three generations and these chemicals accumulate in the environment and recycle just like Dr. Bennett said.
Next slide, please. So the total oxidizable precursor assay was also done in Martha's Vineyard. And the reason they did it is because they could not quantify all the different PFAS precursor compounds, those compounds that when oxidized in the environment or in bodies turn into other PFAS, right, as their terminal endpoints. And so they shoved everything, they oxidized everything they could and measured it again.
What I would like to point out here is that your Brock fill and your Brock pad are more of a concern than your green carpet in this particular instance. But we're not really talking about that so much. Next slide please. But here's the thing, it's not just PFAS, right?
So why am I always talking about PFAS? It wasn't just PFAS they found in these components. There's the bis-2-ethylhexyl phthalate, there's the phenol, dimethylphenol. We don't want any of these compounds going into the wetlands or into the brook.
Next slide, please. So here's the thing about stormwater, and I know you guys have talked about this, but I'm an analytical chemist and we're a little anal, and I'm a little concerned about the fact that an impervious surface is a legal, technical term defined by the EPA as any surface that prevents or significantly impedes the infiltration of water into the underlying soil. If you are diverting this water in a stormwater system, it is impeding the infiltration to the underlying soil. You can't get around that.
You literally cannot get around that. And here's my big problem. The big problem is that one inch of rainfall on an acre of impervious surface produces 27,000 gallons of stormwater. Now, that isn't there when you have plants, there are references everywhere.
And if you have a field that is made of grass, when stormwater falls, some of it gets trapped in between the soil, it gets trapped in the roots, it adheres to the grass, it gets transpired up through the grass, it gets evaporated from the grass later, which has that cooling effect, which is why when you take away the grass and replace it with a plastic tarp, it ends up making a heat island. That is the water that you are adding into the wetlands. And when you add 27,000 gallons per acre per inch, you change the chemistry of the wetlands. And there is no way around that.
Next slide, please. So this is your ordinance. And I highlighted in yellow everything that this project does to the wetlands. Next slide, please.
And so from your own wetlands ordinance, and just full disclosure, in the town where I live, the city of Westfield, I am an elected city councilor and I'm chair of the Natural Resources Committee. And while I never speak for the city of Westfield, that background informs how I look at your ordinance. And when I look at your ordinance, I see it as two questions. Is the subject area significant to the interests protected by the bylaw?
And is there any way you can condition the project in order to protect against alteration of the wetland ecosystem? I absolutely agree that it is significant, as you guys have discussed, but here's the problem. The applicant cannot filter out the PFAS. They cannot filter out the microplastics and the nanoplastics.
They cannot filter out the phenols. You can't mitigate the increased temperature in the surrounding environment and stormwater because you are removing the plant material that uses the water to cool the area. There is no, that water temperature is gonna be higher. The air temperature is going to be higher because you're removing the plants.
You can't get around that. You can't mitigate the increased water volume, right? Because you've got this impervious surface and your extra 27,000 gallons per inch per acre. And so it changes the salinity, the oxygen availability, the erosion, the flooding.
All of it. And here's the worst part to me. Because you already have a field up there, you already have crumb rubber and all the toxins from the crumb rubber and all the toxins from the turf and all the heat already going into those wetlands through your stormwater system, right? So you don't have a model as to how stressed that ecosystem is now.
And you don't know how much further you can stress it before you have collapse. every little bit that you change the pH, the oxygen, the amount of water, the salinity, the amount of other, you know, magnesium, the calcium, the phosphorus, right? Every time you change those concentrations, you're gonna change which species can live there. And you're slowly gonna change that ecosystem and you will not know until it's too late.
And that is my fear. Next slide, please. So I am by training a chemometrician and the patron saint of chemometrics is Yogi Berra. And to paraphrase him, you can see a lot by just looking.
So the next few slides are maps and you're going to see a purpley pink dot. on every map that is to orient you. When I type Guile Road Milton Mass, that is the dot that shows up. And so each of the following slides has that same dot to reference your orientation.
This is a GIS map of the wetlands, the priority and habitat, and the dot. Next slide, please. So this is with your FEMA flood layers added. Next slide.
This is your heat anomalies. you'll notice that all that wetland area and the brook is where it's not so hot. Next slide, please. So this is with the heat anomalies reduced to 50% transparency so you can see underneath it and zoomed way out so that you can see more of Milton.
Next slide, please. So this is heat severity over that first map. If you rip up the grass, that's above that red orange patch underneath the wetlands on the right-hand side. If you rip that up and replace it with plastic, you're gonna move that red closer to that wetlands.
Next slide, please. So this is zoomed out again so that you can see how it affects the rest. That is your little patch of not so hot in Milton, right? That's your little patch of coolness where that water is.
And your last slide, please. And that's where your environmental justice communities are in Milton. Because the decisions you make today affect the temperature there. And temperature and humidity affect pollution levels.
And so it's gonna affect how people can breathe. And I believe that's the last slide. So that's it for me. I'm happy to take any questions.
And of course you can reach me by email or text or phone. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (02:31:12–02:31:18)
Kristen, thank you very much. That was very interesting. Paul, you finishing?
Speaker 9 (02:31:20–02:31:21)
Paul, you're muted.
Speaker 2 (02:31:26–02:31:27)
Paul, you're still muted.
Speaker 25 (02:31:27–02:38:31)
We can't hear you, Paul. John, that's something I'm not often accused of. I think that's true. All right, so let's get to the bottom line.
Here's the bottom line. We're going to go back to the Milton Wetlands Bylaw. The project cannot, quotes, alter the wetlands or harm the brook, which is a cold water fishery. This means the project, again, we've done this over again, but may not degrade water quality, destroy plant life, change water temperature or other physical, biological, or chemical characteristics of the water, or pollute the pine tree brook.
So we also know, according to the law, the burden of proof lies solely with the applicant. It's not ours to conclusively prove that it will. And we say that that standard has not been met. Tonight's presentation make clear that there are significant levels of PFAS and other toxins in the turf components.
There are also substantial amounts of precursor chemicals that will turn into the six regulated PFAS. All this will add to already existing levels of the forever chemicals in the wetlands, brook and surrounding soil, along with some that will come from the atmosphere, as Tetra Tech report tells us. which begs a point we've been wanting to raise. We've noticed there seems to be some confusion about how PFAS bioaccumulation works.
Some seem to think that if the current level in the water or soil is higher than the amount being added, the addition is of no consequence. That's incorrect. The situation is more analogous to a steady leak emptying into a half full tub. It only adds to the total.
And before we leave the topic of PFAS, it's worth noting that as Tetra Tech said last meeting, current rules focus on PFAS being consumed in drinking water, and that's true. But researchers are studying more pathways in the body beyond oral consumption, and those concerns are being enshrined in laws and tested in the courts now, and it's been true increasingly over the past few years. For instance, this year, more than 195 new anti-PFAS bills were introduced in dozens of state legislatures. Some states have already banned PFAS in consumer products like carpets, rugs, fabrics, children's items, and others.
Vermont, Maine, California, Colorado, and Maryland have banned PFAS in cosmetics and in feminine care products. The nation's largest firefighters union is suing to get PFAS out of their turnout here, owing to their outrageously high rate of occupational cancers. There are about eight bills currently in the Massachusetts legislature that would do all of this, as well as ban turf itself. Maine and Vermont have already have turf bans in the books, and California is considering one.
PFAS regulation is being toughened at every level, starting with the US EPA down. Tonight, you've also heard about the microplastics the field will shed as much as hundreds of pounds will find their way into the wetlands in brook, both through the water and carried by the wind. The effects of the microplastics on aquatic life has been well documented, an important consideration, given that the cold water fishing and the aquatic life in the wetlands. In fish, microplastics have been shown to cause structural damage to intestine, liver, gills, and brain while affecting metabolic balance, behavior, and fertility.
And in aquatic invertebrates, microplastics will cause a decline in feeding behavior and fertility. It'll slow larval growth and development. Besides microplastics, though, the field's also going to shed large amounts of the wood infill, much of it which will migrate to the wetlands and brook, and now that presents special problems on its own. The 2021 Martha's Vineyard analysis showed that the wood infill had the highest concentration of PFAS of all the components.
which is, as we'll find, a special problem, because according to the manufacturer's own safety data sheet, Brockfield biodegrades in water and in soil. So rain, snow, wetlands, brook, biodegrades. It also noted on the safety data sheet that any potential health effects of the infill on fish and birds is unknown. That brings us to the risks of heated stormwater to the wetlands and the cold water fishery.
Tonight, you also heard something about how the field will radiate heat up to 46 degrees higher than the ambient air. The plan calls for the system to eventually push the water in the wetlands. And this is a mistake. Because as we said, water goes where it will.
And as we showed in our presentation, it streams so freely between the wetlands and the brook that it's carved channels in the narrow path separating the two. That flow strengthens during rains. That water will carry PFAS and other contaminants along with heated water to the brook, which is the cold water fishery. And consider on days with higher temps, the wetlands and brook will already be warm.
There's proof of that. The Deposit River Watershed Association's Water Temperature Report found that brook near the field averaged above 68 degrees Fahrenheit in May to July. Water must remain year-round at temperatures of no higher than 68 degrees for brook trout and other species to thrive. Many people here don't know that, but there's actually a species of brook trout that is exclusive to Pine Tree Brook.
additional heat and contaminants would add risk. The heated water will also damage wetland life. Sean McCanty, an environmental biologist with the Deposit River Watershed Association, says, quote, using the wetlands as a detention basin for warm water is a bad idea, especially during the early spring when water temperatures are going to be much cooler than the turf runoff, and the amphibians and reptiles that rely on it might be even more sensitive to PFAS and other microplastics that wash off the field. Again, Let's return to the commission's charge.
The project may not degrade water quality, destroy plant life, change water temperature, or other physical, biological, or chemical characteristics of the water, or pollute Pine Tree Brook. This project will do all of this unless the town can find a way to encase the field in a bubble. And that's not the half of it. As part of these deliberations, we haven't had time to consider how the plastic turf is going to kill all the soil beneath it, how the field is going to disrupt wildlife beyond the fish, how the lights above the field will interfere with bird migration, and how the rising heat off the field will also damage trees and other vegetation on the edge of the wetlands.
This is the wrong project for the wrong place. It's an environmentally high risk project in an environmentally sensitive area. And finally, common sense. Let's just ask ourselves, how the hell does it make any sense in a warming world that you tear up 1.3 acres of grass that cools, that exchanges oxygen for CO2 and sequesters carbon to instill a less than carbon neutral foam pad plastic rug that's going to leach toxins, it's going to off gas noxious fumes and literally, literally add heat to the atmosphere and As an added bonus, every 10 years, this thing needs to be replaced.
So the cycle begins again and again, and even more contaminants will be piled on. So what is the town's tolerance for toxins? How long do we wait? Do we wait till the brook is entirely poisoned?
Do we wait till the trees are gone? It's especially troubling because there's a ready alternative, a less expensive, sensibly maintained natural grass that is open, unfenced, and so truly shared by the entire community. Thank you very much, John.
Speaker 1 (02:38:32–02:39:22)
Well, thanks very much. Very articulate. I think you've done a good job organizing and presenting. So thank you.
I do see some hands, and we'll try to get through this. But I will reiterate what I said before. We're going to close the hearing this evening. But because of the reasons I stated, I missed two commissioners.
who will be duty-bound to, but eager to, review the proceedings tonight. And we will continue this matter for a vote next Tuesday at a public meeting, meeting of the Conservation Commission, also by Zoom, beginning at 7.30. It'll be Tuesday, the 21st of November. But let me look at the hands raised.
Kevin? Hold on, John. I have a question. Yes.
Speaker 29 (02:39:22–02:39:39)
When talking about all the heat, We're talking about all the heat that runs off of this. What about all these asphalt roofs and all these houses all over the town that run water into the brooks? I mean, those roofs are hotter than that field's ever going to be.
Speaker 1 (02:39:41–02:39:43)
That's a fair point.
Speaker 29 (02:39:43–02:39:48)
And all the little pieces and particles that run off all the roof shingles on everybody's house.
Speaker 30 (02:39:50–02:39:53)
This hearing's about assessing the field, not roofs in Milton.
Speaker 29 (02:39:54–02:40:01)
It's a point that's got to come up, because that water runs into a brook. Same thing. Oops.
Speaker 1 (02:40:01–02:40:09)
All right. Let's stay focused. It gets to the discussion. Any other?
I didn't mean to cut you off, Todd. No, go ahead, John.
Speaker 31 (02:40:10–02:40:18)
Kevin Chrism? Excuse me, Commissioner. Lower Milton Youth Football and Cheer is on the agenda. So do I get a chance to talk?
Speaker 1 (02:40:18–02:40:21)
Yeah, I know. I was just going to jump in.
Speaker 32 (02:40:21–02:40:25)
Can we have a call to order and maybe have a time limit on speakers?
Speaker 1 (02:40:26–02:40:41)
You'll be silent or we'll cut your microphone off. This is going to be run as a public hearing according to the administrative laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. And you are out of order. Kevin Chrism, you may speak, sir.
Speaker 21 (02:40:42–02:40:51)
Thank you, Chair Canning. Arthur, can you let people in from the waiting room? I'm getting a lot of text and whatnot about people still in the waiting room.
Speaker 1 (02:40:57–02:40:58)
Go ahead, Arthur can do that. And Kevin, go ahead.
Speaker 21 (02:40:59–02:41:01)
That was my request. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (02:41:01–02:41:12)
Thank you. Next, I'm just going as I see this. Tom, is your hand up? I would call the commissioner first.
Tom Palmer, your hand is up.
Speaker 7 (02:41:12–02:41:12)
No.
Speaker 1 (02:41:13–02:41:13)
No.
Speaker 7 (02:41:13–02:41:14)
Sorry.
Speaker 1 (02:41:15–02:41:29)
All right. Kevin, can you take your hand down? C. McCarthy?
I lost C. McCarthy.
Speaker 32 (02:41:31–02:41:32)
I took my hand down.
Speaker 1 (02:41:33–02:41:35)
Oh, OK. Mary Fairbrand.
Speaker 31 (02:41:37–02:41:41)
Yes. Can I please have permission to share my screen?
Speaker 1 (02:41:42–02:42:26)
Yes. Arthur, you may have to do that. Can you make Mary a co-host? Are you good, Mary?
Are you now on?
Speaker 2 (02:42:26–02:42:28)
I'm good now. Yeah. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (02:42:28–02:42:31)
Thank you.
Speaker 31 (02:42:31–02:45:11)
OK. All right. I'd like to start by saying that this is the right project for the right time at the right place. Let me just start by showing you a picture of my screen.
There we go. The Milton community is being held hostage by the Conservation Committee's inaction to vote on the Lower Guile project. The committee continues to delay voting. The requested additional testing has been paid for by the town and completed.
Results have been proved to be within statistical standards of safety as stated by multiple experts. It's even been stated for multiple months now, the same information that drainage will be improved. Conservation Committee has been irresponsible with spending town money. The shopping for answers, behavior, and consistent requests for more information needs to end and is borderline corruption.
The members of this committee were not voted in, but rather appointed by select board to act responsibly for Milton and how to best make improvements for the Milton community. This project has been approved by the town. Funding has been approved by the town. The members of this committee have shown bias by delaying this vote and giving a ton of air time to non-voting members of this community.
To vote in favor of a grass field would further the neglect of lower guile field. There is a sprinkler system that has not been maintained. The ground near each sprinkler head is a hole the size of a grown man's foot that holds water long after a rainfall. This is a safety hazard for our youth athletes that continues to exist and has been neglected for years.
And when you let that field sit with all that water, youth of our town cannot play sports and be active, which leads to significant social, emotional, and mental health issues. There are signs around Turner's Pond that say, give grass a chance, stay on the path. How is the town seriously going to provide the quality and financial maintenance of a grass field that is required by over 600 hours of youth sports? We are not asking for a grassy meadow.
We are asking for an updated, improved, state-of-the-art athletic field with improved common sense drainage system. It is time to make a vote.
Speaker 1 (02:45:15–02:45:17)
How about Tim's phone?
Speaker 33 (02:45:18–02:47:01)
Yeah, thank you. I just wanted to, again, Tim, with I'm a volunteer. I do feel some of the frustration that Mary has just stated. I feel we, you know, we did do all of our due diligence.
We came up with those 10 or 12 questions that need to be answered. We called Tetra Tech back to answer those for us, which they did. And then at the beginning of today's meeting, we had numerous professionals give findings that, you know, really was unequivocal towards, you know, this turf field has almost zero PFAS. And I don't understand why people just keep trying to ask the same question a different way when these professionals that we've hired have answered them several times, actually.
And no one, they just keep asking and asking, hoping to find an answer that benefits their cause, which, you know, I support the will for people to go ahead and do that. But at some point, you're gonna have to accept the answer. You know, who plus two is four? as much as you might want to have five.
So, you know, I guess we'll see everyone next week. But again, we're really hoping to get a vote. It has been months and months and months of families, parents, volunteers that have been waiting for this. So please take the science and the answers that the professionals have given us.
And let's move forward. Thank you all. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (02:47:01–02:47:16)
Bye. Thank you, Tim. Aisha Ifong? I may have mispronounced your name, for which I apologize.
Is it Aisha?
Speaker 9 (02:47:23–02:47:25)
Oh, yes. Hello. Sorry.
Speaker 1 (02:47:26–02:47:26)
OK.
Speaker 9 (02:47:28–02:48:47)
Sorry, I was just I was just joining in from Nantucket. We were dealing with the very same situation with artificial turf And I'd be happy to share information with our school committee or any any information you guys may have We actually were having the same We were looking at the same artificial turf that was proposed at Martha's Vineyard, and we went with the decision not to use it just because of the PFAS and the litigation that's involved with the PFAS leaching into our sole source aquifer. But I'd be more than happy to share that information with you, and I completely understand everyone's desire to have Fields that children can play on I have two young boys in the public school system So I and and you know, I'm just saying this from a liability point of view my my husband is a firefighter and we've been dealing with a lot of these companies and the PFAS situation and it's it's not pretty and I'd be happy to you know, provide more information if needed, but that was my input that I wanted to provide was that I believe One of the companies, Tenkati, that makes the artificial turf is also what was making the gear for the firefighters. And they are now currently being sued for the PFAS in the gear.
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (02:48:48–02:48:52)
Ayesha, thank you very much for calling in. Tracy Stewart.
Speaker 30 (02:48:53–02:50:59)
Good evening, Tracy Stewart from Medway, Massachusetts. I am also a volunteer and advocate in the synthetic turf issue across the state. I just wanted to, jumping off of what Aisha just mentioned regarding Tenkade, there's a group of companies, they're part of the Master Batch Chemical Group, and they are all essentially producing out of the same factories in Dalton, Georgia. So when you talk about Tenkate or you talk about Shaw Sports or any of them, they are all producing materials that contain PFAS in one way or another.
Additionally, I would recommend that you review the Merafi 140N needle punched filtration fabric that Mr. Huntress is recommending because what I'm seeing in their specs is that they contain a UV resistant ASTM D4355. I can tell you that UV filtration chemicals such as UV 328 are on the verge of being banned internationally. So those fabrics, while they're supposed to filter out your microplastics, may be an additional source of PFAS that you are not even aware of.
So those are the two things I would recommend looking into. And I can tell you that every single drain around Medway High School and our conservation land is full of microplastics. Yes, you're looking at Brockville, and we have tire crumb. but this stuff spreads everywhere.
And I would also question what they tell you to treat Brockfill with, not only for mold or moisture, but also for freezing. Mr. Huntress might want to comment on that, but there are a couple of pretty alarming recommendations by the Brockfill company themselves on how to deal with the freezing of Brockfill.
Speaker 1 (02:51:03–02:51:16)
Tracy, thank you very much. We're grateful for you calling in. I don't see – I've got one left, one iPhone, but there's no name other than iPhone.
Speaker 34 (02:51:16–02:52:44)
Oh, sorry, this is Brian Daugherty, a member of the community, a volunteer, Milton Youth Sports. And, you know, I appreciate all of the really active, all the activists that have arrived at the Milton Conservation Committee. It really shows their commitment to fighting turf. and there's been quite a bit of conjecture, things that are about to happen, laws that are going to be passed.
But I do think, and I think Tim made this point, we have to go back towards what we as a town, we as a community want. We have to go back towards what we requested, which was detailed review from the Conservation Committee on 10 key points. We received answered from a open bid, looking for answers to those questions. They were independent, they were objective.
We got those answers back. And now we have a very activated, very politicized base, really pushing an agenda. And I'm very uncomfortable. I think we have to make a decision as a community.
This is a Milton decision. It's not a Medfield decision. It's not an Nantucket decision. It's not, you know, various name your expert.
This is about our community and the need for our children to have a safe place to play. And I think there's an overwhelming majority of people in this community that want their children to have a safe place to play. We need action. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (02:52:46–02:52:57)
Thank you very much. I appreciate it. Milton Perrins. It says Milton Perrins.
Speaker 35 (02:52:57–02:55:44)
Can you hear me? Yes. No, we can. Yes.
All right, commissioner. I just want to thank you very much. I just want to say, um, I've been watching these meetings for I think six, seven months now. And I want to thank you for the thoroughly job that you've done.
I have four daughters and I've learned a lot about the conservation commission over the last seven months. And I've sat through a lot of meetings and watched many projects and, I truly think that you have the goodwill and Milton at heart and you're really trying to do its best and I appreciate your time collecting as much data as you have and I think we've kind of reached a crossroads where we're now debating over something that people are never going to agree upon. And we're fortunate to be close to Boston. And my daughters have been lucky enough to be playing at Jordan Field at Harvard University for the past fall.
And we had a game at MIT. And we had a game at Brooks Field at Northeastern University. And these are some of the greatest learning teaching institutions in the world. And we don't have this opportunity for a lot of kids in Milton.
And my girls are very fortunate that they have the ability to get in a carpool and go down to Weymouth or, you know, go over to Fessenden for their practices. But there's a lot of kids in Milton and youth sports here who don't have the access to these fields. And we have a severe land shortage in town. The fields have been shut down a record number of days this fall because they're wet and unplayable.
And there's a huge equity gap. And I, on behalf of youth soccer, have been fighting to try to get more opportunities for these kids. We've had to expand outside Milton's borders to private .32 health to try to get more playable fields to use. We have a field at Lower Guile that is unsafe and not able to be used.
And we have an exploding youth population that needs a field that can handle heavy, heavy, heavy usage. It's been very interesting to watch the debate. And I think all my questions have been answered. And I think yes PFAS is.
There's going to be a lot of debates for decades to come, but it's everywhere. And at this point, I don't like the negativity in the town going back and forth. I think we have the information, and I think the families in Milton overwhelmingly support this project. So I just want to thank you for your time.
I know this is every night when you see this on the agenda, I know it's tough to get through, but I appreciate the time. I'm looking forward to this being wrapped up and hopefully we'll have a beautiful playing field for all kids in Milton to have access to. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (02:55:44–02:56:19)
Thank you very much, sir. All right, now I may be, I know I'm not looking at all the pages. Let me scroll through. I don't see any other hands that people that have not spoken.
So I think we're done with the debate. As I indicated at the beginning, we're going to continue this matter until Tuesday the 21st for a vote. We'll not take any further discussion. The purpose of it is to allow two other participating commission members that have been involved and will watch the entirety of tonight.
Speaker 36 (02:56:20–02:56:21)
Some of us haven't spoken.
Speaker 1 (02:56:22–02:56:28)
Okay, I didn't see anybody, but Debra, I now see you. I tried to scan everybody, but Debra, go ahead.
Speaker 36 (02:56:30–02:56:36)
Thank you so much. I have about three minutes. Will that be okay?
Speaker 11 (02:56:36–02:56:37)
That will be fine.
Speaker 36 (02:56:42–02:57:37)
Okay, thank you so much. First of all, I want to start out with a fun fact. The chemical company Monsanto invented a product called ChemGrass, C-H-E-M-Grass, ChemGrass, 1964. They renamed it AstroTurf after the Houston Astros installed it in their Astrodome, 1966.
The original name was called ChemGrass, an acknowledgement that the plastic is chemical. Okay, I want to follow up with the document I sent the board yesterday. My apologies for the late submission. It had not been ready to share until after the submission deadline.
Thanks to those of you who took the time to read it. And that means we have not had the time to review the plan presented tonight. Many new questions arise off the top of my head. Did I hear you say you plan to extend pavement into the conservation lands to prevent parking?
You have to approve simple signs.
Speaker 1 (02:57:38–02:57:46)
We didn't say pavement, Debra. We didn't say pavement. That's a fence. That's a split rail fence.
Speaker 36 (02:57:47–02:57:48)
Oh, I thought you said pavement.
Speaker 1 (02:57:49–02:57:49)
No. OK.
Speaker 36 (02:57:50–03:03:54)
I just want to say I feel really badly for the sports program shortage of fields. They're well-meaning parents and coaches. But the sign should not be ignored just because we really need a field. I recently conducted research in my role as professor of public health at Northeastern with the support of the PFAS lab and its director, Dr.
Phil Brown, an internationally recognized expert on PFAS. I presented it today, ironically, at the American Public Health Association Conference in Atlanta, where I'm still sitting in my hotel room. I met several other people who were also organizing to keep plastic turf out of our environment. Most notably, the director of policy and government affairs for the Massachusetts Association of Health Board.
He is happy to speak with the Conservation Commission about the growing number of boards of health across Massachusetts who are concerned about the environmental public health impact of plastic on our wetlands, our drinking water, and our kids. One person I met today said wetlands are not intended to filter out toxic plastic chemicals, especially PFAS. She said nitrates and other organic materials, yes, but not plastic chemicals like this. She couldn't believe the plan was to use wetlands as the filter for toxic chemicals.
It's naive to think you can filter out these chemicals as someone just said. The committee with all due respect, you've come up with your own invented plan. There's no published literature that demonstrates your plan is evidence-based. Because of the experience debating turf, I became very curious to understand how many other cities and towns, especially conservation commissions and boards of health who are doing exactly what we're doing here.
It felt funny that everyone's doing the same thing in their own little town. With the help of other advocates and research assistant, I conducted an inventory of 351 cities and towns. across the state who are debating turf, and especially who are going before public bodies asking for moratoriums and bans. My findings show that many others in your same position They're deciding that plastic turf next to wetlands is too big a risk to take.
Now that you won't be voting until next month, they recommend consulting other conservation commissions who have voted against it and find out why. Here's what I found out. Forty-five cities and towns are debating or have already voted. Seven municipalities have passed moratoriums and bans.
There are 13 conservation commissions across the state who have heard arguments against TURP, some of whom have voted to prevent TURP installation and others who have not voted yet. The Arlington Conservation Commission currently has a moratorium in place. The Conservation Commission in Sherborne also voted against it and issued a press release that said, Impacts to wetlands are a concern of and regulated by the Sherborne Conservation Commission. The commission is concerned about the introduction of hazardous materials that could contaminate wetlands and interconnected groundwater as well as a nearby brook with broader connections.
Because of the risk, a number of our nearby towns has decided against artificial fields or have delayed consideration in order to learn more about the health and environmental impact. One conservation commission member said, We are absolutely confident that the artificial turf won't cause harm. They are obligated to follow the precautionary principle, which Paul said earlier. When it comes to synthetic turf, the most sensible approach may be to follow the precautionary principle of assuming something involving chemicals is hazardous until scientific evidence proves otherwise.
Sharon voted a three-year moratorium. Concord has a moratorium in place. Oak Bluffs, as you heard, is contemplating a ban. They just voted the other day.
I think you said, anyway, I don't know the latest. Nantucket School Committee decided to pause plans for artificial turf for at least a year and on and on. I have a list of 58 towns I could tell you all about. Boards of Health are voting against it.
The Board of Health in Amherst voted against turf four to zero. They said, I quote, a board of health is required by law to protect the public health and environment from damage and pollution. By the way, boards of health should be involved because artificial turf products are unregulated. The CDC Centers for Disease Control and Prevention notes that artificial turf is one of seven sources of lead exposure for you.
Both the Consumer Product Safety Commission and the Environmental Protection Agency have pulled back their previous statements on artificial turf, acknowledging the multiple concerns raised by the scientific and public communities about the product. Another consideration never occurred to me, the laws that protect turf manufacturing companies from releasing the ingredients of their products. Many academic researchers have published studies testing the product, showing chemicals and PFAS, not just the info and all the components. But the turf companies themselves fall under the, quote, confidential business information clause.
This means that the CDC doesn't regulate a product whose ingredients are proprietary and not available to the product, the public. The industry is greenwashing their products, meaning trying to make you think plastic is safe and friendly. Don't be fooled by them because that's their intent. Thank you for your patience.
I know people in the community are impatient to make a decision, and I get that, but environmental contamination cannot be taken back once it happens. Yes, the town needs fields. Yes, it's legitimate, and it's really important. But the solution is to have a town-wide strategic plan to manage all of our grass fields.
This grass field floods because it's constructed improperly. It needs to be constructed properly. So Marble and Springfield, they both have had, for years, organically managed natural grass fields with the help of TURI out of UMass Lowell. And they're detailed reports, and they've done it on a budget, and they've done it successfully.
Speaker 1 (03:03:57–03:03:59)
Deborah, can you wrap up, please?
Speaker 36 (03:03:59–03:04:57)
Yep. I have a couple more sentences, and I'm done. Thank you. So what I'm asking tonight is to, and I know you say you're going to vote next month, but what I'm asking is for you to get in there more and say, oh, wait a second.
Maybe we should consult other conservation commissions. There are dozens and dozens of other communities who are having the exact same conversation, and they're coming out with a different result than you are. And I'm urging you, maybe it's time to bring in the Board of Health. I know next week, not next month.
I know that pro turf folks are going to be impatient and I get that. We do have a crisis in fields. I totally respect that. But this is so critical and I just want to urge you talk to other conservation commissions across the state.
Talk to the Milton Board of Health. It's too consequential to just make this decision in a vacuum. I really appreciate your patience and letting me.
Speaker 1 (03:04:58–03:05:09)
Thank you. Now I see one hand and one hand only. There'll be one more speaker and then we're gonna close debate. I see C-Mac, I don't believe you have spoken.
Speaker 32 (03:05:10–03:06:38)
Oh, hi. I just, this is more of a, I guess, an administrative question. So I understand the vote is next week. I think we've heard a lot of comments.
I think I've heard a lot of, you know, I've been tuning into these meetings. A lot of the same things are being said. And I guess I'd just like to hear from the Conservation Commission, you know, what, is there anything additional at this point from, you know, delaying a vote next week? because I think there's a lot of residents that are very committed clearly on both sides of this conversation and are dedicating their time and participating.
And I think, you know, at this point as a community, we have to come together. And I understand the concerns and the comparison to other towns, but we are not Concord. We are not Lexington. We are not the vineyard.
We are not Nantucket. We just approved a land swap to build a new school. We're part of the MBTA transit community. We're about to increase our zoning for housing.
This is going to bring in a lot of children, a lot of young families. And quite frankly, we do not have the capacity to service all of these incoming families with the direction that the town is going with the field space we have. And I think the sooner we do this, the better. And I think as a community, we have to go to a vote.
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (03:06:39–03:06:59)
Thank you very much. That will conclude debate. This agenda item will be continued until Tuesday, the 21st of November at 7.30 p.m. The link to the Zoom meeting will be on the town website.
That concludes the discussion of this agenda item. Sir?
Speaker 30 (03:07:00–03:07:06)
Chair, sir, sorry, this is Tracy Stewart. I had that question regarding Brockville. Will that be answered?
Speaker 1 (03:07:10–03:07:17)
Well, I'm sorry, you did ask a question and I put most of them down here. Tell me what the question was.
Speaker 30 (03:07:19–03:07:23)
What the recommended treatments are for Brockville when it freezes?
Speaker 1 (03:07:24–03:07:30)
I don't know that. Chris, if you know it, that's great. Go ahead.
Speaker 19 (03:07:31–03:07:49)
I certainly don't know. We wouldn't recommend that you put any treatment on the field whatsoever. If it does freeze, it's not going to freeze any more than a natural grass field would under similar conditions. So no, I don't have anything on that.
Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 (03:07:51–03:08:33)
So we're going to move on to the next agenda item that concludes that discussion tonight. Thank you very much all. Most everybody was wonderful and articulate. We move on now to item 16, which is additional business.
Philip, I think we can take a look at this under additional business, but there is a freedom of information. Act request for minutes that we had not yet approved. And I think they were in the package. Did everybody have a chance to review?
And they go back to 2021.
Speaker 12 (03:08:33–03:08:38)
John, I actually sent them yesterday to the board members.
Speaker 7 (03:08:39–03:08:40)
Yes.
Speaker 12 (03:08:40–03:08:41)
They weren't included in the package.
Speaker 7 (03:08:42–03:08:43)
I looked at them.
Speaker 1 (03:08:45–03:09:08)
I did read them myself. Okay, if we can vote on it tonight, I'm fine. If anybody wants to take the next week, we're going to be meeting next Tuesday. I'm okay with it, but if you haven't looked at them, then I suggest you do.
Does anybody want to vote tonight or wait until Tuesday to vote?
Speaker 2 (03:09:09–03:09:12)
My preference is to wait until Tuesday if we could.
Speaker 1 (03:09:13–03:09:28)
That's fine, that makes sense. But we do have a request for, it's a freedom of information request for those minutes, so we can take care of that on Tuesday. Will you make sure that's on the agenda as well as the vote on this?
Speaker 12 (03:09:28–03:09:29)
Absolutely.
Speaker 1 (03:09:30–03:09:36)
All right, thank you. All right, any other additional business? Arthur, anybody, Ashley?
Speaker 4 (03:09:37–03:09:38)
None, Mr. Chair.
Speaker 1 (03:09:39–03:09:43)
None? I think we're good then. Is there a motion to adjourn?
Speaker 8 (03:09:45–03:09:46)
So moved.
Speaker 1 (03:09:48–03:09:52)
Any second? Thanks, Todd. All in favor? Aye.
Speaker 2 (03:09:53–03:09:53)
Aye. Aye.
Speaker 1 (03:09:53–03:09:56)
Aye. Perfect. Done. Thanks all.
Good night.
Speaker 2 (03:09:57–03:10:02)
Thank you, everyone. Good night. Good night. Thank you, Philip.
Speaker 12 (03:10:03–03:10:04)
See you Saturday.
Speaker 9 (03:10:05–03:10:06)
See you Saturday.