Board: Board of Selectmen September 23rd, 2014 Pt 2

Date: Unknown


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:00–00:01)

All right, well, thank you, Bill.

Speaker 2 (00:01–00:05)

Well, thank you for your time. I appreciate it, all right? Thanks, Bill. All right, have a good night.

Good night.

Speaker 1 (00:07–00:10)

We are now on to a meeting with our town treasurer, Jim McAuliffe.

Speaker 3 (00:14–00:25)

Hey, Jim. This is Richard Rogers from Abbey Financial. He does all our investments. Hi, Richard.

Hi, all the trust funds.

Speaker 4 (00:25–00:27)

Thanks for joining us.

Speaker 3 (00:28–02:38)

Okay, we're having a, I would say a, well, it's a bit of a problem. The legalist investments that we use in our investment policy, it has gone over the years from 37 stocks down to 22 stocks. All the stocks are in a few fields. Most of them are drug companies and banks.

So our investment options are limited. And we want to keep equities, about 30% in equities in all our trust funds. investor in bonds, CDs, and what have you. And a few towns, well, I know the Mass Treasury Association trying to pass a prudent investor role.

And it gets brought up every year. It sits in committee. It never gets thrown. So a lot of towns are taking it upon themselves now to go out and do a home rule petition for the prudent investor role.

And a lot of them are going to the prudent investor role, but then they're tailing it back to just the standard pause 100. So it gives you 100 options instead of 22. Most of the stocks on the legal list are in the standard pause 100. So we want to move in that direction.

I spoke to John Flynn today. He had a couple different opinions on how the town of Peabody did it. There's a few other towns out there that are going through it right now. So I told him before we voted on anything, I'd sit down with John and Rich and work out a way that would suit the town's bylaws.

Because every town's bylaws are different. So we don't want to vote on that tonight. But it's just something that I just want to bring out, bring up, and see if we can move forward on it. Because right now, I mean, when the economy's bad, Those two stocks, it's a flight to safety, and they perform okay.

When things get good, people jump out of those stocks, and then our equities will not perform as well. So we want to get away from just the 22 stocks and get it up to 100 stocks. I know the library's looking for more options. The cemetery, when you sit down with their trustees, they're looking for more options to invest in.

And 22 stocks just is not doing it right now.

Speaker 5 (02:38–02:40)

You're not diversified either.

Speaker 3 (02:40–02:46)

Yeah, it's not diversified. For safety's sake, you better offer more options and spread out the funds.

Speaker 1 (02:48–02:53)

And Jim, just for the benefit of people who might be watching, these are just trust funds we're talking about? Just trust funds.

Speaker 3 (02:53–02:55)

General funds, you don't invest in stocks.

Speaker 1 (02:55–02:59)

And so could you give just an example? Is it the scholarship funds?

Speaker 3 (02:59–03:12)

It's scholarship funds, stabilization funds, OPEB, cemetery funds, the library funds. Any trust fund is under the legalist at the moment in our investment policy.

Speaker 1 (03:12–03:15)

But the cemeteries at the perpetual care fund that you'd be talking about? Yeah.

Speaker 6 (03:15–03:22)

OPEB are actually under Chapter 32, so you can use the prudent investor rule to manage OPEB funds. Right. Okay.

Speaker 2 (03:22–03:27)

How much are we talking about, Jim, right now? What's the total? About $9 million?

Speaker 6 (03:27–03:30)

$9 million or so between the cemetery and the trust funds.

Speaker 2 (03:31–03:32)

Is it making money?

Speaker 3 (03:33–03:44)

Yeah, we've been making money recently. And actually, I mean, every year we do pretty well. He is part of the reason we are a AAA rated community.

Speaker 2 (03:44–03:54)

But if you're allowed to invest in the S&P 500, the 100 best stocks, do you think you'll make more money?

Speaker 3 (03:54–04:06)

It's a better chance of not losing money by sticking with the 22 stocks we have. So you just want to diversify. And that way, it's going like this instead of this and this.

Speaker 6 (04:07–05:06)

But 22 stocks are on the legal list. They're all consumer staples. Last three and a half, four years, they've done extremely well. Most of them are trading at levels that you know, on a historical level are 2.5, 3 times their normal, like price to earnings, price to sales, things like that.

And now, you know, there are people hanging out with them because of 2.5, 3.5, 4% dividend yields. As rates tend to rise, you know, when they, maybe June next year they start to raise the federal funds rate, you know, people are going to start to look for competing investments against the Kelloggs and things like that and the Procter & Gambles. So the S&P 100, the largest company, is able to broadly diversify our portfolio into many sectors that aren't on the legal list, the 22 stocks. I've modified the legal list many times over the last 22 years.

I was one of the main people that would modify it every year. Then they kind of changed the rules, and the state kind of doesn't have too much of an interest in even modifying it anymore. And I'm actually unable to even modify it going forward.

Speaker 5 (05:07–05:25)

So this really isn't, per se, the prudent investor. I mean, because the prudent investor in Section 203 is a methodology of investing. It's a wide open, for the most part, but a methodology. We're not saying we're going to adopt a methodology other than We're going to just broaden.

the investment of fees, the investment of fees.

Speaker 6 (05:25–06:00)

All the same stipulations that govern us under the Chapter 44, Section 54 Mass General Laws. That's why you want to crawl doing this, because you want to have all the restrictions and stipulations of the unadmitted trust funds from the Mass Legalist, pretty much. Right. General Legalist.

All we're doing is this, modifying the prudent investor rule all the way back to only allowing the S&P 100 stocks. Right. Which is adding, actually, the 17 of the stocks on the legal list or on the S&P 100. So we're really adding not exactly 87 stocks.

Speaker 2 (06:03–06:16)

And again, as the amateur investor here on stocks, not real estate, how do we move forward? What are you looking for here? And what are the terms we're allowed to do this?

Speaker 3 (06:17–06:22)

Right now, Clark could go strictly put investor. Peabody.

Speaker 6 (06:23–07:21)

Peabody, we just went through the process. The city council voted 100% to do it. The mayor took it on. And they said this makes sense to diversify funds.

It was common sense. And so the council has voted it. Then what we did is a home rule petition, or they did a home rule petition. And it's actually up at the state house in the municipal committee.

Brookline did this in 2003. Full prudent investor rule. I've spoken to the treasurer many times. He went with a full prudent investor rule.

The State House did vote on it. They approved it. So I find it would be difficult for them to not allow the city of Peabody, Stoneham, Leominster, Amherst, Greenfield, all the municipalities we manage money for. No, Peabody's the first one.

I live in Milton, grew up in Milton. So this is, I think, five, 10 years from now. So five, 10 years from now, I think we'll have a lot more money if we have the ability to diversify these funds.

Speaker 5 (07:21–07:33)

You're right. I mean, the broader the base of your investment portfolio, you at least are going to flatten out those highs and lows, if nothing else.

Speaker 2 (07:34–07:36)

So is there a home rule petition we're looking for here?

Speaker 3 (07:37–07:56)

Yes. Yeah. And I talked to Representative Timilty, and he's on board with it. And I talked to John Flynn, and I want to sit down with John and craft the right way to do this.

He had some ideas. different from the way Peabody did it. So I just want to sit down with Richard and John to see the best way to go about it.

Speaker 1 (07:58–08:02)

Jim, this requires a vote of the board in addition to your approval of it.

Speaker 3 (08:02–08:19)

Yeah, it's well, John thought it could be just a vote of the Board of Selectmen and then go to Home Rule Petition. Or it could be Selectmen, Tom Eating, Home Rule Petition. So that's one of the things we're looking at right now, which is the best way to go about it.

Speaker 1 (08:19–08:23)

But it sounds like it's a joint decision between the treasurer and the selectmen. Oh, yes.

Speaker 5 (08:23–08:31)

Yeah. We amended our investment policy a couple of years ago, didn't we?

Speaker 3 (08:31–08:32)

Or adopted a new one?

Speaker 5 (08:32–08:33)

We adopted an investment policy, yeah.

Speaker 3 (08:35–08:39)

OK. Yeah, you just be changing just the legalist to standard clause 100. OK.

Speaker 1 (08:42–08:45)

Anything else you'd like to add or discuss?

Speaker 3 (08:46–08:48)

Well, that's all on this subject.

Speaker 2 (08:49–08:58)

Well, I think this is, I mean, it shows you how good our treasurer is in thinking outside the box here, making more money for different departments and prudent investing. So well done.

Speaker 3 (08:59–08:59)

Scholarship funds.

Speaker 2 (08:59–09:02)

Well done to our advisor here as well.

Speaker 3 (09:02–09:16)

And he has some skin in the game because he's a child in the middle school system. So if he does well in the investment policy, who knows? So we'll just wait for an update from John Flynn? Yeah.

I'm going to sit with John and Rich and see the best way to approach it. OK.

Speaker 1 (09:17–09:20)

OK, so we'll do some further work on this and take it up at a later date.

Speaker 3 (09:21–09:21)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (09:21–09:22)

OK. Good. OK.

Speaker 3 (09:22–09:25)

All right. Then do we have something to talk about?

Speaker 1 (09:25–09:28)

We do. Jim, I don't know if you want. We need Richard for this one or not.

Speaker 3 (09:28–09:29)

You're free to follow up.

Speaker 1 (09:29–09:31)

All right, Richard. Thank you, Richard. Thank you.

Speaker 3 (09:32–09:33)

You're welcome.

Speaker 1 (09:34–10:52)

So Jim, we also put on the agenda, as you know, just a policy discussion regarding tax title properties. We're going through the process right now with the planning board of trying to adopt a housing production plan. And one of the things that we're looking at is town-owned properties that might become available at some point for affordable housing potentially and tax title property is one of those areas that we've had a little bit of discussion about and those are probably, maybe you can explain the process of how that works, but before you do that, the idea is that if the town's able to acquire some of those properties, we'd like to see if And maybe we need to talk with the planning board about this and get them to weigh in too and take a vote. The idea would be to have those properties considered for affordable housing.

Not all of them may be appropriate. But it may be that if you take a property by tax title, your interest obviously isn't collecting the overdue taxes. But the board of selectmen and the planning board are trying to focus on affordable housing. And perhaps those are properties that might become available either through the affordable housing trust once we have it capitalized and up and running or through a private developer to purchase that property that you've acquired and use it for affordable housing so that we serve two goals of collecting the tax revenue and also making some more property available for affordable housing.

Speaker 3 (10:53–12:10)

I spoke to Mary Bosquette. She's a treasurer over at Halston. They have a pretty thorough document on this. And what happens in Halston, they do get the first right, these different funding agencies for affordable housing.

And what they'll do is they'll pay off the tax title, the amount of the tax title, then they get the property. So instead of auctioning it off, say if there's $50,000 on the property at the time of foreclosure, they'll give the town $50,000, then they take the project off from that point on. Some other towns have different funding mechanisms. They'll use some of the proceeds on an auction and fund affordable housing through that.

So if you have a property with a $50,000 tax title, you foreclose on it, you auction off, make $300,000. A portion of that, or $250,000, could go right into an affordable housing trust. Other towns do it based on different mechanisms if filing could be five dollars more on demand that goes right into an affordable housing. So I mean, every town has some different mechanism to fund it and also to sell off these properties.

Speaker 2 (12:11–12:15)

But you could make the decision based on the individual property, each property.

Speaker 3 (12:15–12:16)

Oh, definitely.

Speaker 2 (12:16–12:17)

I mean, you wouldn't adopt just a bylaw.

Speaker 3 (12:18–12:25)

No, I mean, you could make a policy that the Affordable Housing Trust

Speaker 1 (12:25–13:17)

just uh… take a look at it as a product worthwhile before you put up for auction yeah i think it all depends on how we were the policy i did talk with one of town council's colleagues does some tax title work in other communities and gave me some of the same information that you've gotten jim from people you've been consulting so because you know you're a you're an elected official we're elected officials but we've got independent boards and the appointed board obviously they're all elected we all have different little areas of jurisdiction that were overseeing, we'd have to agree upon a policy with the treasurer that would serve your goal. Yeah, we're all on the same team, but your objective is to collect the tax revenue, and we're focused on affordable housing. So how do we kind of come up with a policy that melds it together and serves your purpose and serves our purpose?

And it's just a matter of putting a written policy in place if we're both agreeable to it.

Speaker 3 (13:18–13:32)

One of the treasurers I talked to said, oh, they always take the prime properties. You know, the Affordable Housing Trust. She says, oh, the ones I can get good dolls for at auction, they always take them on me and stick me with the junk.

Speaker 2 (13:34–13:42)

What happens with a property that you take back and you sell it and you make, we'd say, $300,000? What happens to that money?

Speaker 3 (13:43–14:14)

Does it go to the general fund? What happens, if I take a property, we took the property up on Meeting House Lane, and at the time they owed $350,000 in back taxes. So we got it, we held an auction, we sold it for $455,000. So the $350,000 goes and pays off the back taxes and tax title.

The other $105,000 goes right to the general fund, so that's free cash. So anything you get above and beyond, we'll add it to the free cash figure. So sometimes you might not want to give away a nice piece of property. You want to make some money.

Speaker 1 (14:16–14:38)

And I think the policy probably would be to consider each property acquired through tax title in recognizing that they might not all be appropriate for it. It might depend on the location and the size of the property, how much square footage there is, whether a developer is interested, whether the trust has the resources. So there's a lot of different factors. But I think the goal would be to try to just consider all of them.

Speaker 3 (14:38–15:06)

Yeah. And this time, a lot of the properties, once you put it in foreclosure, it puts them on notice. And they'll either go out and try to sell the property, they'll refinance, they'll settle. Right, so it doesn't happen all the time.

It doesn't happen that often. Maybe once every two, three years, we'll get a piece of property where the person just won't do anything about it. And fortunately, we have two right now in the pipeline in the next few months that may be put out to auction.

Speaker 5 (15:07–15:30)

Maybe we should pursue and see what more other towns do. For example, Wellesley Needham. I know Nantucket, for a fact, has a program similar to tax title property goes not to the Affordable Housing Trust, but they have a separate nonprofit down there. Basically, it's first crack at anything that comes available.

Speaker 1 (15:30–15:55)

Yeah, it sounds like there's a lot of different alternatives. But the idea, at least what we need to explore, was your willingness to enter into this sort of a policy and have this kind of a discussion. That's no problem. So maybe we should, I mean, Jim's got his counsel who does tax title properties, maybe you could settle with with Jim's attorney and with town council and see what kind of other policies we can come up with as examples.

Speaker 5 (15:55–15:57)

Yeah, see what other communities are doing.

Speaker 3 (15:57–16:13)

And the man we use is Jim Coppola out of Marblehead. And I always wondered, how did Kim Insorgia get an attorney from Marblehead to do a tax title? They went out to treasurer school. He's the man that teaches all the classes.

But he handles probably half the municipalities. So he's very good.

Speaker 1 (16:14–16:23)

OK, so we've got some interest in doing it, and we should just do some due diligence and some research and come back with a draft of a policy at a later meeting.

Speaker 3 (16:23–16:27)

I do have a copy of the Halston policy downstairs. It's a good read.

Speaker 1 (16:28–16:34)

Yeah, good. Maybe we could start taking a look at that. All right. Thanks, Jim.

OK. Thank you, Jim.

Speaker 3 (16:35–16:36)

Thanks.

Speaker 1 (16:38–17:20)

Okay, the next item, we had two items for Zero Central Avenue. One is a, we're going to combine them together. We have a demolition bid extension. We have our demolition agreement that we entered into with Carrick Realty back in May at the date of September 30th, which is a week from today, to do the demolition.

And we have not yet, we have a pending bid that we have not yet accepted. We did ask for an extension, which we received, but we have not acted on that bid yet. So the idea would be to extend the period of time in which the demolition is required. From September 30th to, we have a draft amendment that would provide an extension until November 30th.

Speaker 5 (17:22–17:40)

I'll move to approve a first amendment to the agreement between the Town of Milton and Carrick Realty Trust. so that the concurrent demolition of the Town Home Building at 0 Central Ave and the Carrick Building at 131 Elliott Street shall be completed by November 30th, 2014.

Speaker 2 (17:41–17:41)

Second.

Speaker 1 (17:42–17:43)

Any discussion?

Speaker 2 (17:45–17:54)

Will, in your opinion, Katie, when and if Town Meeting approves the eminent domain, will we have that in our possession by November 30th?

Speaker 1 (17:56–18:10)

Will we have the 1,200 square foot parcel in our possession? Yeah. That's the goal, that it's a relatively short period of time that's required after the eminent domain article is voted at town meeting, assuming that we get a positive vote on that.

Speaker 2 (18:11–18:15)

Because it's important that these buildings come down, if they are to come down, before the winter.

Speaker 5 (18:16–18:17)

Yes, absolutely.

Speaker 1 (18:18–18:54)

Yes, and as we've said at prior meetings, we're in discussions with the principal of Carrick Realty. And we both were at a hearing before the Conservation Commission last week. So it's a complicated project, and there's a lot that still needs to happen. And we do have a town meeting article coming up that we need to deal with.

So if no other discussion, then all in favor. Aye. Unanimous. OK, the next item on our agenda is to, relates to the town meeting warrant for the fall town meeting.

To open and close the special town meeting warrant.

Speaker 2 (18:55–18:57)

Can I ask, Katie, are we done with number 13?

Speaker 1 (18:58–18:59)

Yes, unless you had something else.

Speaker 2 (18:59–19:01)

No, I had nothing, but I. OK.

Speaker 1 (19:03–20:21)

So just by way of background, the town meeting warrant has, I believe, 19 articles, and we have a We have a copy that I think has just been given to us tonight. I don't know. So does this one have the report of the committee in it, the comments? The draft we had seen didn't have the, oh, it looks like they've been added to this version.

So we have now a complete copy of the warrant. One of the articles was for an appropriation for trees that we had submitted at the request of Senator Joyce when he was in here giving a presentation over the summer. He asked that we submit that article and talked about some reimbursement that's available from the state. The Warrant Committee had a lot of questions about that article, and they felt that they had made appropriations in May, which is the time that the annual budget is usually voted, and that there really wasn't a funding source available to them.

We discussed some possible options for funding, but the Town Administrator and I talked with the DPW Director, Joe Lynch, and because there are some cost savings from the solid waste contract, now that we have a new contractor, Mr. Lynch was agreeable to diverting some of the cost savings to pay for trees.

Speaker 5 (20:21–20:24)

That's a good move.

Speaker 1 (20:24–22:15)

Yes. So the article would no longer be needed and we could, I talked with Ted Hayes about withdrawing this article for the trees since we're able to do it within the budget as voted at the Maytown meeting. The Swift Hathouse articles are ones that we submitted a few weeks ago. They're currently articles 18 and 19.

And one of them relates to the land that would involve a transfer of land from the park commissioners to the board of selectmen. The second article would be an authorization for us to acquire the Swift Hath building as a gift. We've said it at some prior meetings, there's a lot of interest in trying to see what we can do to preserve the Swift Hathouse, but there's also a lot of open questions. And I think probably as Tom and I have a good understanding from our days on the Warren Committee, we never want to be in a position where we're submitting an article to the Warren Committee that's not really ready to go and isn't really ripe.

They've made no recommendation at this time because they know that we still have a lot of due diligence and work on our end to do to resolve some issues and figure out some questions. But I think the idea from the feeling among some people have talked to me about this and I think just in talking with the town administrator and the planning director and others is that the articles are probably more appropriate for the May 2015 town meeting. That they're really not fully ripe yet because we have so many open issues and questions to be answered that town meeting has enough on its plate with all the other zoning articles and the some of which will generate some discussion and take some time at town meetings, so it's probably best to not take town meetings time and the Warren Committee's time on two articles when we still have a number of open questions.

Speaker 2 (22:15–22:19)

Can you give me an example of the open questions, Katie, if you can think of any?

Speaker 1 (22:19–24:24)

Well, whether the land is parkland or not, what the historical use of that property has been, I've talked with Mike Roberts a few times since we had the site walk, including this afternoon, to let him know what our current thoughts were on the two articles. And he would like to know what the town's position is sooner rather than later. But he also understands that what his plans are for his property, the gift of the red house impacts what he can do with his property. And the two parcels are not really tied together.

They relate to each other. So he's got some ideas that he would like to pursue for development of his property where the Red House currently sits. And we did have a meeting with him a while back, and we asked that he sit down and talk with the town planner about some ideas for that parcel. And what can be done at that parcel really relates to what he might be able to do in terms of a gift of the Red House.

So those are some of the open issues. What the purpose of the Red House would be if it's moved to town land is another issue. There's just a lot of moving pieces. for lack of a better term here.

So the recommendation that I was going to present to the board is that we withdraw Articles 18 and 19. Again, just to emphasize for viewers, not because there's a lack of any interest in this, but because they can be in a better position to go forward at the May town meeting. We might want to consider appointing a committee to work on some of these issues, possibly comprised of a member of this board, member of the park commissioners, the Historical Commission, possibly some residents who have had a real interest in preserving this property. But it's important to note that we wouldn't be withdrawing them because we don't want to go forward.

We wouldn't be withdrawing them because there's any lack of interest. To the contrary, there is a lot of interest. It's just a matter of, are the articles ripe for town meeting at this time?

Speaker 2 (24:25–24:30)

But have we determined who does own the land, where the building would be transferred onto?

Speaker 1 (24:31–24:43)

Well, Town Council and the Town Planner are still looking into that question. We think it's Parkland. That's the premise that we're operating on. The Town Planner is doing a lot of historical research.

He's just stepped out of the room.

Speaker 5 (24:44–25:18)

I think that becomes the bigger issue, is the history of that land. Is it in fact the Olmstead Park? Yes. obviously not wanting to damage anything there if that's in fact what that land is.

So yeah, I think we do need research to make sure that and making the appropriate move if we do decide that's where we should move it.

Speaker 1 (25:19–26:39)

And the research is going on. It's just taking a while. It's leading in some different directions. And then there is still the question of what the house would be used for.

And we probably need to get a better handle on that before we ask town meeting to allow us to take the property. Several years ago, there was an article to take the Milton Women's Club. I wound up being recused on that because it's not far from where I live, but the Warren Committee at the time, I was at that time the chair of the Warren Committee. Tom was the one who had to take that one over.

There were a lot of questions that came out of the Warren Committee as to the condition of the building. Do we have the resources to maintain it? So we have all those same questions with the Red House. And there may be grant opportunities.

There may be other preservation monies available. We have to explore a lot of that. But we really need to be in a position where we can tell town meeting, we've done all this research. We have answers to a lot of the questions.

And we think we're in a position. to go forward with these. And right now, there's just a number of open questions that it seems that we really shouldn't present these to town meeting in October. We should do more work on it and then and hold them off for a little longer.

We're not that far away from January, believe it or not, and that's the early January is the deadline for submitting articles for May. So that would give the Warrant Committee more time to look at these, gives us time to finish up some loose ends.

Speaker 5 (26:40–26:52)

And that being said, you know, and And I think we have reasonable assurance that the building won't be torn down in that interim. And I don't think it will be either.

Speaker 1 (26:52–26:55)

Yes. No. And Mike Roberts understands where we're coming from.

Speaker 5 (26:55–27:12)

But that was a concern, that the way in Milton, there is no historic preservation, per se. There's no historic district that you can't All we have is a cooling off period of nine months.

Speaker 1 (27:13–27:14)

I think so, yes. Nine month moratorium.

Speaker 5 (27:15–27:30)

Right. And then it can be taken down. So this building has gone beyond that nine month period. Personally, and I think we're basically on agreement that we want to save that building, that it's worth saving, it should be saved.

So I think that's our goal.

Speaker 1 (27:30–27:47)

So long as we can come up with a plan for it that we can either raise some money or come up with the means to make it become self-sufficient and pay for itself for maintenance costs going forward. Assuming we can do that, Tom, yes.

Speaker 5 (27:48–28:04)

Yeah. I mean, you're going to get some people that at all costs it should be saved. I'm not sure. I'm close to that.

I'm getting tired of just losing historic properties. We've lost so many.

Speaker 1 (28:05–28:38)

We have. So we're making the effort on this one. And that's why we submitted the articles a few weeks ago, because we knew that the owner of the building has the ability to demolish the building, I think might even already have a demolition permit for it. But based on further discussions with him, he understands what the town's issues are, what the timing here is, and that it probably is better not to submit an article to town meeting for the fall.

That's really not ready to go yet. So he understands where we're coming from. He's made a generous offer of the building to the town, and I think he's willing to work with us on this.

Speaker 2 (28:39–29:47)

I mean, under normal circumstances, I wouldn't support this, you know, pulling this off the table, because as a developer myself, you know, this guy is ready to go. He has a demolition permit in his hand, and he can tear it down tomorrow. And by delaying it, what we don't want is another Henry's building, where there's confrontation between the town and the developer. And we end up getting nothing.

And he's not going to tear it down until he gets his permits, obviously, to put up a new building. That's what I'm trying to avoid by having this go forward now. If we leave it till May, I can almost guarantee it'll be April by the time we do any homework on this again. I would hope not.

And then it's going to get delayed again. So I would make the recommendation that we move forward with this and just put the effort into it over the next few weeks to get this in front of town meeting, get it approved, and move on. Time is money in this business. And elected officials like ourselves, we have a habit of holding everything up.

And I'm just not in agreement with it.

Speaker 5 (29:50–29:54)

I think the practical problem we have right now is I don't know if we'll get it through town meeting.

Speaker 1 (29:54–31:06)

I think at best, town meeting would send it back to us for further study. But what it could generate is a lot of discussion at town meeting when we already have 16 articles that are going to take probably at least two nights, maybe more, to go through. It might lead to all kinds of other avenues being explored. You just don't know what's going to happen if you go to town meeting without a real Without answers to all the questions that might come up and without a plan for what are we going to do if we move it.

There are some people who have voiced concern about moving it to the location on Wharf Street and Adams and question whether that's really the appropriate site because of some of those issues Tom raised, the Olmstead issue, the historical parcel. Other people have suggested different locations for it. So there are enough questions that I think it will generate some debate if it goes forward. But the likely result is it will be sent back to us for further study.

And we can continue doing that. I don't think we're going to be in a position where we find that it's months without doing anything, and then suddenly it's April and we're working on it. Bill Clark and town council are working on the historical issues. And I know Bill has consulted some local historians and others.

Speaker 2 (31:06–32:01)

He's putting in a pretty good amount of time just everything else that's pending and I think we'll have some answers I think that's I mean what you're saying makes sense, but you'll take the the no man's land. We'd call it between Jerry Connolly's building and the town on portion You know we've owned that building since the mid 90s, and it's only a couple of months ago. We found out about this no man's land We've had all these years to find out who owned it, and all of a sudden it's down to the wire. I just don't want this to happen again with the Swift house, in particular because the real estate market is driven by trends.

And right now we're on an upward trend, and this developer does not want to miss the upward trend. If he feels that there's only a year or two left, and it's going to take him over a year to get permits, He may just take it down and we lose another historical building just like Tom said. We don't want to do that.

Speaker 1 (32:01–33:21)

Well, I think right now that it's a unique parcel, and there are some zoning issues. It's zoned commercially, even though there's a two-family house on the property. So there are some zoning issues that would apply to his property. And one suggestion I thought about making was appointing a committee.

Because right now, we don't really have a group of people working on this. We have some interested citizens. We have the Historical Commission that wants to save it. We have the Park Commissioners who are willing to work with us.

We've had we've had a meeting with some other committee chairs with the town administrator with with mr. Roberts, but we don't have a Dedicated committee working on this and that would be one option to appoint a committee that can really focus its time over the next few months on coming up with a plan to address What we do with the Swift hat building and work on the answers to some of these questions I understand where you're coming from, Dennis. You don't want to lose an opportunity and take the risk of having the building torn down. I think the owner is understanding of the town's position, probably was disappointed that we're pulling the articles initially, but understands that it's best not to submit an article to town meeting that really has a lot of loose ends.

That was the conversation that I had with him this afternoon, and he was understanding of where we were coming from.

Speaker 5 (33:22–34:31)

I support, I do support pulling the articles because I don't think they're ready right now, but I don't support appointing another committee. I think if we finally do decide to take it and move it, I think just go, The best way to figure out what the best use for the building is, is to get proposals. We go through these and they just become political nightmares when you start appointing committees. We saw what happened on the Granite Ave thing.

I think if you just went out and got proposals, then you'd get a lot of good ideas, a lot better ideas than three or four people in a room trying to figure out what to do with it. Let the business community, let the people out there that have interest in it figure out what the highest and best use is, and then evaluate them.

Speaker 1 (34:32–35:22)

Well, they'd address that question, but the question about is Wharf and Adams Street the right location, the Master Plan Committee is already kind of weighing in a little bit on that, might have some more discussions Monday night. I think they, the Master Plan, the initial draft of the Master Plan had a suggestion that it be used as a tourism or information office and that probably isn't financially feasible and I think Well, you would know better. You're on the master plan committee. I think that might be getting another look at the master plan by the consultants.

Right. But there's issues more than just what can you use the building for. There's also the site. The site.

Right. Absolutely. Yeah. So my thinking was a committee, especially with a park commissioner on it, since they have, currently, we think the land is theirs.

And the historical commission and some residents who were interested and motivated to save the building.

Speaker 5 (35:22–35:24)

To determine is the site appropriate.

Speaker 1 (35:24–36:36)

Yeah, that and maybe some other issues. I mean, we could put on a future agenda a discussion of a committee and what a charge might be. Right now, the only thing that's before us is opening and closing the warrant and considering removing articles. But that's something we can add for the next meeting agenda if we want to take it up then and give some thought to it in the meantime and pull some thoughts together and then have a discussion about a committee.

Number one, whether we want to appoint a committee or not. And number two, if so, what the charge would be. Other than that, the Warren Committee has made recommendations on a number of articles. I went to their meeting where they met with the Chair of the Planning Board and the Town Planner.

Some of these articles are, there's a public hearing scheduled for Thursday evening, so there's no recommendation at this time on a number of the articles, including the signed articles. and some of the townhouse development article and some of the other zoning articles. But we do have positive recommendations from the Warren Committee on the water and sewer enterprise funds article, on the capital committee article, on the easements, on the eminent domain.

Speaker 2 (36:37–36:40)

Yeah, they're all fine.

Speaker 1 (36:40–37:06)

So it's really just the trees and the two Swift Hat articles. that in talking with the chair of the Warren committee, that there was a possibility that we may remove three articles. I think he was in favor of that. So that's a question for the board.

Do we want to remove one, two, or three articles?

Speaker 4 (37:08–37:11)

Well, let's get the motion out there first.

Speaker 1 (37:11–37:15)

Do we want to remove the tree article? It sounds like we might have some agreement on that.

Speaker 5 (37:16–37:23)

Yeah, I'm in favor of that. That's going to get done anyway, so sure.

Speaker 2 (37:23–37:25)

I'm in favor of the tree, yeah.

Speaker 1 (37:25–37:37)

We have a draft motion, which would be to open and close the warrant to remove three articles. But we need a sense of where the board's at on the other two. Or if anyone would like to make a proposed motion.

Speaker 2 (37:38–37:41)

We can just make the motion and take a vote on it.

Speaker 4 (37:41–37:42)

Okay.

Speaker 5 (37:44–38:01)

Do either of you want to read the motion? Yeah, I'll move to open the October special time meeting warrant to delete Article 5, tree removal, Article 18, swept hat house, and Article 19, transfer of park property to Board of Selectmen, and to close and approve the warrant.

Speaker 2 (38:04–38:16)

Let's second it for discussion. My vote will be a yes on Article 5 removal, and then I'll abstain from Article 18 and 19. You can vote on it.

Speaker 5 (38:17–38:25)

I don't think you can. I'll vote no on it. I mean, you can propose an amendment to the motion.

Speaker 2 (38:25–38:26)

We make it two motions.

Speaker 1 (38:27–38:30)

Yeah, why don't you, do you want to propose a friendly amendment to just consider Article 5?

Speaker 5 (38:30–38:31)

By itself?

Speaker 1 (38:31–38:59)

By itself, and then to delete from that motion that Tom made the reference to Articles 18 and 19. You accept it as a friendly amendment? I accept it as a friendly amendment. Okay, so the motion that's before us is to remove, to open the October Special Time Meeting Warrant to delete or remove Article 5 and to close and approve the warrant.

Why don't we just say to make a further friendly amendment to reopen the October Special Time Meeting Warrant to remove Article 5.

Speaker 5 (38:59–39:01)

And keep it open for now, yes.

Speaker 1 (39:03–39:12)

So you're accepting that friendly amendment? Yes, I am. OK. So that's the motion that's before us.

Then any discussion on that, just to remove Article 5? Then all in favor? Aye. Aye.

So that's unanimous.

Speaker 5 (39:13–39:29)

And now I will make a motion to, it's already open, just to remove Article 18, Swift Hathouse, and Article 19, transfer of park property to Board of Selectmen, and to close and approve the warrant.

Speaker 1 (39:29–40:12)

I'll second it. Any discussion on this? I have a question for the Town Administrator. If we approve the warrant, we just got the copy tonight that has the report in it and the comments, and obviously those are the Warrant Committee's comments and reports, so we wouldn't have any discussion or comments on those.

The only issue would be the numbering of the articles, which we've already done. But two points. One is we may want to move the eminent domain article up to be the first article so that it's taken on the first night so that we can handle that one early and then, if necessary, sign any paperwork that night, assuming Tom Eaton approves that article.

Speaker 5 (40:12–40:13)

I agree.

Speaker 1 (40:13–40:59)

And then the other thing that Bill Clark, who stepped out of the room, had mentioned to us at a previous meeting is that there are some, I think he said, people from Europe and Asia who are planning specialists who, at the request of MIT or one of the planning schools, are coming to town meeting to observe and listen to the discussion. And so the question might be, do we want to renumber some of these articles? Can we do that if we've already approved the warrant? Can we renumber it later so that we can work with Bill to put whatever zoning articles are appropriate for that group of people to hear together?

I know that the moderator could take them out of order and just ask for a vote at the town meeting to take them out of order, but I just happened to think of that late this afternoon that we might want to renumber some of these for that purpose.

Speaker 5 (40:59–41:05)

Isn't everything else pretty much a, I mean, obviously the Article 1 is not.

Speaker 1 (41:05–41:15)

1, 2, and 3 are accounting. 1, 2, 3 are not, yeah. Actually, 4. 4 is the library appointments to the capital committee.

5 is the landfill access road.

Speaker 5 (41:16–41:21)

Yeah, so it's not to get out, and then the zoning are all together, but they're in the middle right now.

Speaker 1 (41:21–41:49)

Yeah, and I guess the question for Bill is, the room is reserved for what, Monday and Tuesday? Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday, the 27th and 28th and the 30th of October. So we should probably find out what night the planning specialists are coming. Bill may not have that information now.

If he doesn't, we probably leave it to the moderator to figure out at the beginning of the meeting. But I guess the big question is.

Speaker 5 (41:49–41:51)

At least they're all together at this point.

Speaker 1 (41:52–41:59)

Yeah, right now we have the eminent domain article as 16. So it would be the last article. Move that up to number 1. So we could renumber it to move it up to number 1.

Speaker 5 (41:59–42:00)

1, right.

Speaker 7 (42:01–42:02)

The order of articles.

Speaker 5 (42:02–42:16)

And then if you had to just take articles 2 and 3 and just have the moderator move them back if you wanted to move the zoning articles up.

Speaker 1 (42:16–42:38)

OK, so it sounds like we want to move eminent domain up to the article number 1. And then do we want to then just renumber the rest of them so that the capital items is number two, the water sewer fund is number three, four, we just renumber them? Yeah. And then we'll figure out the zoning and have the moderator get a motion to reorder them?

Speaker 5 (42:39–42:40)

I'm fine with that.

Speaker 1 (42:40–42:44)

OK. So then with that question, any other discussion?

Speaker 5 (42:45–42:52)

Well, now we just have, well, so we're on the SWIFT hat and the Article 18 and 19, basically, right?

Speaker 1 (42:52–43:02)

Yes, and approving the warrant. And approving the warrant.

Speaker 5 (43:02–43:20)

What would happen if you were to leave Article 18 in to accept the gift? would take Article 19 out to not transfer the land yet. Then you'd be accepting the gift. You have no place to put it.

Yeah. But at least we'd be accepting the gift.

Speaker 1 (43:20–43:21)

Yeah.

Speaker 5 (43:21–43:22)

Assuming the town meeting approved it.

Speaker 1 (43:23–43:26)

Although, wouldn't that raise the same number of questions that? Probably.

Speaker 5 (43:26–43:55)

Probably. But then, worst case, it comes back to a study committee, or it comes back to the Board of Selma for further study. Well, I guess, well, two things could happen. Either three, it either gets approved, And we don't get it as a gift until he's ready, until Mike Roberts is ready to give it to us anyways.

Which I think is going to be going to take a while because he needs either a special permit or a zoning variance to build where he's at.

Speaker 1 (43:56–44:05)

Yeah, and keep in mind that the article, the way it's written is to Doesn't it identify a specific location?

Speaker 5 (44:05–44:09)

It doesn't for the purpose of moving to that location.

Speaker 1 (44:10–44:25)

Provided that said authorization is contingent upon the donor at no expense to the town transporting the building from said property and installing it on the town-owned property located at the east side of Wharf Street. So it has the current location which we think is Parkland.

Speaker 5 (44:26–44:33)

Yeah, and regardless of whose land it is, I think the bigger deal is the history of the site.

Speaker 1 (44:33–44:35)

And what's the plan for it? Is it appropriate? Yeah.

Speaker 5 (44:35–44:38)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (44:38–44:39)

Good suggestion.

Speaker 5 (44:42–44:45)

That's all I have to say.

Speaker 1 (44:45–44:59)

All right, then if no further discussion, then all in favor? Aye. Aye. And opposed?

No. OK, 2 to 1. All right, thank you. We now have some boards and committee appointments.

Speaker 2 (45:01–45:23)

I move to approve the appointment of Amy Dexter, Tom Hurley, Leroy Walker, Kevin Sorge, Michael Hale, Ed Duffy, Chris Huban, and William Ritchie to the Capital Improvement Planning Committee to serve through August 2015. Second.

Speaker 1 (45:23–45:25)

Discussion? All in favor.

Speaker 5 (45:25–45:25)

Aye.

Speaker 1 (45:25–45:25)

Aye.

Speaker 5 (45:27–45:37)

I move to appoint Stephen O'Donnell, Brian Chaney, and Dudley Lane to the Historic Commission to serve through September 2015. Second.

Speaker 1 (45:37–45:39)

Any discussion? All in favor? Aye.

Speaker 7 (45:41–45:57)

Administrators report yes madam chair let the board and the public know that the Norfolk County Register of Deeds William O'Connell O'Donnell will be holding office hours at Town Hall on Wednesday October 15th from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. 12 p.m.

Speaker 1 (45:58–46:09)

12 noon in the blue conference room okay looks like we know what next is a one-day liquor license for the Milton Arts Center

Speaker 2 (46:10–46:21)

I move to approve a one-day liquor license for the Milton Arts Center for a fundraising event that will take place October 5th, 2014 from 7 to 10 p.m. at 334 Edge Hill Road.

Speaker 1 (46:21–48:52)

Second. Discussion? All in favor? Aye.

That one is unanimous. On to the chair's report, three quick things. One is just, again, congratulations to two retired firefighters, Deputy Chief John Foley and Firefighter Joe Garrity, all of us. The three members of the board and the town administrator attended a very nice ceremony recognizing the retirement of the two firefighters a couple weeks ago.

It was well attended and some very well deserved recognition for two people who have served the fire department very well over the years. Congratulations to John and to Joe. We had, right before the start of tonight's meeting, we had a flag dedication ceremony in honor of former State Representative M. Joseph Manning.

It was the occasion of his 90th birthday and we dedicated a new flag in his honor at the town gazebo. Eddie Duffy, who's a member of the planning board, put the ceremony together and it was very, very well attended. I think half the fire department was there. Chief Wells' wife, Lieutenant Pauline Wells, sang the National Anthem and a happy birthday to Joe Manning.

There were a lot of former town administrators, former, Jeff Damley, the former appraiser, former park commissioners, current park commissioners, board of assessors members, and just a lot of, Representative Walter Timothy, Representative Galvin, and several of them. Walter Timothy's colleagues from the Joe Manning's former colleagues from the State House came and attended including Speaker Finneran. So it was a very nice ceremony and congratulations to Joe Manning on his 90th birthday. And thank you to Paula Rizzi for always putting together very nice proclamations and letters for us to read on behalf of the board.

And lastly, I just wanted to mention the board has received letters from a group known as the Friends of the Yulin Rink. That raises questions about the town's contract with Curry College relating to the management of the skating rink. We are looking into issues that the letter raised. The initial contract between the town and the college was signed in 2010 before any member of the current board was elected and before the town administrator took office.

So we have some due diligence to do, and we're looking into the issues. Once we have more complete information, we will address the issues at a future meeting. Next item is, does anyone else have a report to make, anything to add?

Speaker 2 (48:52–48:54)

The report, Madame Chairperson? No.

Speaker 1 (48:55–49:01)

Citizen speak response. We didn't have a citizen speak tonight, but any previous?

Speaker 5 (49:01–49:44)

Well, not a citizen speak, but the Council on Aging report, I think, I think we have to look at those numbers a little more carefully, and I have no reason to believe they're not true, that if we're not keeping pace, then, you know, we're not the war committee, but to certainly support the Council on Aging, and I think we all do support the Council on Aging, but if we're in fact not keeping pace with other communities and not funding it properly to look into trying to find a way to right a wrong.

Speaker 1 (49:46–51:18)

Yeah, it's a small department, and it's always been one of the smallest budgets in town. But it serves an important constituency and a growing constituency. So going into the next agenda item, which is future agenda items, we should probably put a discussion of the FY16 budget on the agenda fairly soon, along with a five-year financial report that I know everyone's working very hard on. Not necessarily the next meeting, but one of the October meetings.

I think we should have a discussion about the budget and we have had other Boards raise the question of an override an operating override in the spring so we should probably begin the discussion of how the budget is shaping up and At that time consider the council on aging issues and some other issues Anything else for either citizen speak response or future agenda items I? OK, then if not, we have an executive session scheduled, but we also have a meeting of the Governor Stoughton trustees. So we will recess the board of selectmen meeting, assuming that's OK with the board, and convene a meeting of the trustees. And we will return to the board meeting after we have a brief meeting of the Governor Stoughton trustees.

So I'll convene a meeting of the trustees of the Governor Stoughton Fund. We have a request from Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital Milton and I'm going to be recused on this one so I will step outside and you can let me know when you've acted on it.

Speaker 5 (51:19–51:31)

So this is a motion to approve a grant to Beth Israel Deacon's Hospital to provide free medical care and support. Do we have the amount of this grant? Or the amount that we're given in future?

Speaker 7 (51:31–51:33)

In the past, you've given $5,000. OK.

Speaker 5 (51:34–51:38)

And what are we given now? It will be up to our recommendation.

Speaker 2 (51:40–51:42)

I think they're asking for 10, aren't they?

Speaker 7 (51:42–51:45)

They've asked for ten, but in the past you've given five thousand.

Speaker 5 (51:45–51:47)

Okay. How much is left in the fund?

Speaker 7 (51:51–51:53)

I don't know the balance right now.

Speaker 2 (51:53–51:57)

Give an approximation. Is it a couple of hundred? It's more than that, I think. Yeah.

Speaker 5 (51:58–51:59)

But under four, I think.

Speaker 7 (51:59–52:01)

It is under four. It's like mid twos.

Speaker 5 (52:03–52:04)

Mid twos or mid threes?

Speaker 7 (52:04–52:05)

Yeah, no, I think it's on mid twos.

Speaker 2 (52:06–52:06)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (52:07–52:07)

Okay.

Speaker 2 (52:09–52:15)

So I read somewhere they're asking for 10, but we've given 5. Do you want to stay with the 5, Tom?

Speaker 5 (52:15–52:21)

I think, yeah, I mean, given that we want to, you know, there isn't.

Speaker 7 (52:24–52:33)

They always ask for the 10. You give 5, because you also give $5,000 donation to Partners Health Care. To what? The Partners Health Care.

Speaker 1 (52:34–52:34)

OK.

Speaker 5 (52:35–52:42)

Okay, so you want to move to?

Speaker 2 (52:43–52:53)

Move to approve a grant of $5,000 to the Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital Milton to provide free medical care and support for Milton's poor and disadvantaged.

Speaker 5 (52:53–53:01)

I'll second. All in favor? Aye. Okay, unanimous?

Speaker 7 (53:02–53:03)

I'll second.

Speaker 1 (53:11–53:16)

Okay, so we have a motion to adjourn the Trustees of the Governor's Stoughton Fund meeting.

Speaker 5 (53:16–53:17)

So moved.

Speaker 1 (53:18–54:04)

Second. All in favor? Aye. Okay, we're back in session for the Board of Selectmen's meeting and I will move that we, we have two combined motions here, I will move that we enter executive session to consider the purchase, exchange, lease, or value of real property, 0 Central Avenue, and to discuss the discipline or dismissal of or complaints or charges brought against a public officer, employee, staff member or individual, believing that having these conversations in open session would have a compromising effect on the bargaining position of the body, and to return to open session to adjourn.

Second. All in favor? Mr. Cohen?

Yes. Mr. Hurley? Yes.

And myself? Yes. Thank you. We are in executive session.