Board: Warrant Committee

Date: 2026-01-29


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:07–00:13)

I will say we're going to start this meeting. It is Thursday, January 29th, 2026. Karen, can you call roll?

Speaker 2 (00:14–00:28)

Yes, we have Jay Fondling, Elaine Craighead, Lorraine Dee, Grace Dougherty, Julia Maxwell, Brian McGuire, Lee Michael McClain, Ronald Sia, and Nicholas Tangney. You have a quorum.

Speaker 1 (00:29–00:42)

Okay, great. Uh, in respect of people's time of this unusual meeting, I will cut right to the chase and attempt to share my screen. Aha. There we go.

Speaker 3 (00:47–00:57)

Hmm. Let's see if that works. Okay. Slideshow please.

Rocking. Okay.

Speaker 1 (00:59–04:53)

No, it's sorry I'm having Windows issues. OK, thank you for coming to this irregular meeting of the Warrant Committee. One question you might have, which I may not have fully explained is why are we having an irregular meeting not on a Monday? Things are moving fast with the budget coming together and I've done some work both with this year's budget and with the coming years.

I've shared the work I've done with some members of the school committee, some members of select board, some members of town meet of sorry. the town admin, but it felt strange because I couldn't share it with all the warrant committee. If I shared my thoughts put together, as far as I know, that would be an open meeting violation if I shared with all the warrant committee. It felt weird sharing with other people and not sharing with my own committee due to open meeting laws.

I wanted to get this in front of you as soon as I could and also in front of the town as a whole. If this is something useful, then the entire town will get to see it right now. So the main purpose of this meeting is just to get the information out. We can certainly discuss it some this meeting, but it also might be a benefit to sort of absorb this, take it in, think about it, turn it over, then we'll come back for our regular meeting on Monday, four-ish days from now.

We'll digest it, we can discuss these topics a bit more, and possibly even take some votes if the Warrant Committee wants to stake its flag in the ground for a couple of these things. Any questions about that? Okay, so what am I going to go over? I'm going to go over how we got here.

These slides are mostly a repeat of what was presented at the January 19th meeting. I'm assuming any members who were not at that meeting have watched it in general. I don't know if I made this clear. I'm assuming that when members miss meetings, they watch them to stay up to date.

Uh, any members of the public that are interested in this, I would recommend you see that meeting that had a more thorough discussion of the, how did we get here question? The short version is that there was a. Around the time of the override, there was a forecast done that assumed all employees town and school would have a 2% pay increase. And that's really not realistic.

So that's how we are where we are. I'll then, after discussing how we got here, I'll discuss the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund, which we'll be talking about quite a bit more tonight. That was just set up last year. I'll be discussing what the policy is for its use, and I'll be suggesting something more rigorous, but still not inflexible.

And then I'll present a couple of forecasts, what I think was the baseline forecast a few weeks ago, and how some changes can be made to get us to a more secure place. I'm gonna go through the first few slides pretty quickly, because as again, those are covered pretty thoroughly at our last meeting. I wanna get them, so to speak, in the record here for anybody looking at it. And I'll post this, Karen, you and I can work to post this on the website on the Warrant Committee page for anyone to look at.

One slide I do wanna pause on, we talked about a good bit last time, is this slide on the operating budget stabilization fund. This is going over how it works. It's a fund to get us through from one override to the next without reducing services in the years when our expenses go up more than our income. So it's a bit of a busy graph.

The green shows the amount that's going into the fund every year. And the yellow is the balance sheet, if you will, how much is in the fund at the end of the year. And you can see that we withdraw more and more and more each year. And so the idea is your expenses are growing faster than your revenue.

You withdraw more each year until you get to the year of override, and then everything resets back to the start. Sorry, taking a drink of water, so we went over that last time.

Speaker 4 (04:53–04:58)

And Jay, that's a town wide fund, right? That's not a school specific fund.

Speaker 1 (04:59–07:54)

Thank you for clarifying. Yes, it's a town wide fund. Yes. And then when I say how did we get here, what is the here?

The here is now, or at least as of a couple of weeks ago, having a $2.5 million shortfall due not entirely but largely to two things. Due to health insurance inflation going up higher than expected. And due to the schools requesting a 5.2% increase when the assumption that was baked in was a 2.5% increase. So we discussed that last week and that it looks like a lot of school districts around the state.

I know nothing about running a school district, but most school districts around the state have about a 5% year to year increase in their costs. I'm going to skip again, skip ahead. This is a new slide. This is talking about state aid.

State aid is a major source of fund for our revenue. This year, we're looking at, of our revenue, about $150M in revenue for the town, $20M of that is from state aid. So that's about 13% of all our revenue is state aid. It's a big deal for our budget.

I got quite a lot of information from the Mass Municipal Association, which is exactly what it sounds like. It's a group of cities and towns around Massachusetts that advocate for city and town issues. They have two documents called A Perfect Storm and Navigating the Storm. You can Google them, which is what I did.

I like the graph in the upper left. The graph in the upper left says that when the Great Recession hit, The blue line happened when the Great Recession hit. The funding to the towns went down and it never came back up to the extent that in the year 2026, the state aid given out to all the towns is just about exactly equal to amount given out in 2008, not adjusted for inflation, just period. It's the same.

If it had been adjusted for inflation, you can look at the gray line that's above the blue line. And you can see they'd be giving out about 50% more state aid than they are now if they had just stuck with the 2008 number and grown it with inflation. Not to oversimplify, but 50% more of the $20 million that we're getting now would be an extra $10 million in Milton's pocket. That would be a big deal.

So, going on, pretty much these 2 documents say state has been too stingy with state aid. They need to give us more. These next 2 graphs, they broke up looking at state aid by rural, suburban and urban. We are, of course, suburban.

You can see on the left hand side, This is the graph of real estate aid. I don't know if that means inflation adjusted probably, but that means that suburban towns have seen negative 1% year over year over year in real estate aid.

Speaker 5 (07:57–08:02)

Jay, is there a reason for that? Do we know?

Speaker 1 (08:02–08:07)

I mean, I think the last graph, so the difference between suburban and urban.

Speaker 5 (08:08–08:15)

Yeah, no, I mean, I know the difference, but is there a reason why suburban is getting less aid? I'll be honest.

Speaker 1 (08:15–15:41)

These aren't very long documents, but I didn't read them. No, no, no, I just didn't know. So whether the reason is like, whether it's something intentional or whether it's sort of a side effect of, oh, by virtue of being urban, they have blah, blah, blah. I don't know is the short answer.

I'm sorry. No, that's fine. But it's the reality, and also Chapter 70 school aid, which the state aid that I'm talking about, the largest part of it is Chapter 70 school aid. Suburban schools have only seen an increase of 0.03% year over year.

So we bemoan that we're dependent on Residential taxes, we say we need more commercial taxes. All these things are true. It would sure be nice if state aid caught up for not us, but for the other 350 cities and towns in the Commonwealth. And that might be something we're advocating to our state reps about, but not something we can change now.

So. Okay, sort of changing topics. Let me look at my script. Yeah, I'm going to switch topics.

All right, so how we got here, we had a 2.5% salary forecast, which is not an accurate representation of our town and the services we provide. So we need an updated forecast. I think it's incumbent on the town, whether that's the town administrator or the warrant committee, or all of us working together to put together a more accurate forecast. And going hand-in-hand with a more accurate forecast is a plan to use the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund.

I've got my trademark here, trademark abbreviation OBSF, because I'm going to type this a lot. So how should we use the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund? I will say, in the forecast last spring, The town administrator forecast revenue forecast expenses and subtracted 1 from the other and said the difference would be made up by the operating budget stabilization fund. That's fine for a forecast to sort of see how things are going to go.

But in the real world, we get to. FY27, FY28, FY29. What does that mean? Take our revenue minus expenses and take everything else out of there.

I think we need something a little more concrete for a plan to say, okay, this is how we think we're going to use it. The current policy, so the select board, so the select board is the body in town that adopts policies for the town. They adopted a policy last spring. They called for what's written down here, prudent withdrawals to support the operating budget so that it has enough to stick around through fiscal year 2030.

I'd like a little something more rigorous. For example, one reason I'd like something more rigorous is when We're also talking about, do we make more contributions to the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund? And if so, what do we do with them? And, well, let me skip to, sorry, let me go to the next slide.

I should stick to my script and not improvise. So what I'm proposing, and as I said on the first slide, I'm not speaking for the Warrant Committee. I'm not speaking for anybody but me. It's just a proposal.

So first of all, set up a baseline schedule. So this fund had an original $2 million in it, plus a plan of 700,000 plus going in every year. Just take that structure and say, with that structure, what's the amount we should be pulling out every year? Get a dollar amount.

And my proposal would be to look at this, look at when we think there's gonna be an override in the future, and pay it out so the withdrawal goes up by the same dollar amount every year. Okay, that's simple math. We can get there. I'll show you that on a subsequent page.

And then if we have an additional contribution, so let's say we contribute a 1M dollars of free cash this year. Uh, to this budget, pay that out and even amounts starting in this year over the remaining years until the override. Again, I've got an example of numbers and coming slides. Sorry about that.

Just a second. So, for example, if we contribute a million dollars for this coming budget, and we think it's going to be 4 more years until there's an override, we take out a quarter million dollars. This year, the same year we put it in and over the next 3 years. And I would also suggest as a asterisk to this pad out over not less than 3 years.

What I mean is if we're in the year 2030, 2029, whatever. and we think there's gonna be an override the following year, I don't love the idea of put in a million dollars and take out a million dollars. That's spending your free cash. I'd like it better if you put in a million dollars and still stuck with that three-year stretch.

You put in a million dollars, you take out a third of a million. Similar example, less so if you're two years out from an override, you know, you can't predict the future that well. I'd rather have us put in a million dollars and spread over the remaining three years rather than two. This, like everything in this presentation, is open to discussion, but I think that's a good idea.

Now, the town administrator spoke to town administrator has an idea sort of like this. Uh, Mr. Laura Walker, who's a member of the budget committee has an idea that's similar to this town administrator suggested on Tuesday that. Instead of pulling out a quarter of a million dollars for four years, you pull out a little bit less in the first year and a little bit more in the second year, rising up to a little bit more in the fourth year.

It grows by 5% every year. That's a good idea. That's also fine. I would not fight that.

That's not what I have here, just because I kept the math simple. That's also a good idea, having it grow a little bit. Assume no interest, that's just like stating my assumptions. I do want to say, if we set up something rigid like this, I'll say rigid, people want flexibility in the budget, and I agree.

I think variation should be allowed, but if there's a variation, the select board, the warrant committee, the whoever should explain to the town, here's the variation, here's why we're doing it, here's our forecast of what it's going to do to future years. I've been talking a lot, let me show you some numbers. Here's an example of, sorry, I'm trying to read my script and look at my slides and it's just too much for my brain. Give me a second.

But this is the baseline. If we're going to have an override in 2030, which is sort of what we were thinking of when we set up that override last year. We're going to have an override of 2030, and we've got the $2.7 million going in the first year, and then $700,000 growing with 200% every year after that. Then my suggestion, remember, was take out an amount so that it grows by the same dollar amount every year.

So we've got $570,000 coming out the first year, double that the second year, Triple that the 3rd year quadruple that 4th year each year the amount we're taking out grows by 570,000.

Speaker 6 (15:41–15:47)

I'm having trouble following your, your narrative on the grid. Can you be a little more specific?

Speaker 1 (15:47–15:58)

Yes, yes, thank you for speaking up. So. The contributions, so the. The, the contributions in the 1st year is 2.7Million.

Speaker 4 (15:59–16:02)

All right, and then we get and that's coming from the state.

Speaker 1 (16:03–16:37)

Nope, nope, good question. The 2.7 million, so when we pass the override, 700,000 out of that nine and a half million is dedicated to going to this fund. And then the extra two, we had extra money in the free cash last year. So we seeded this account, so to speak, with 2 million.

So last year, last May at town meeting, we put in $2 million. And we're also putting in every year, the taxpayers are putting in 700,000 plus growth. So we're okay with the contributions?

Speaker 6 (16:38–16:44)

Yep. So for fiscal year 27, we have $2.7 million balance.

Speaker 1 (16:45–17:28)

Yeah, the balance. Exactly. Yeah. The start of fiscal year 27, we have 2.7 million.

During that year, we're going to add another 720,000. And we're going to take out some amount. Now, what amount? Well, the amount that I had Excel back into for me is 570,000.

The way I got to that number is if you do 570,000 in the first year, okay, at the end of FY27, we've grown a little bit, because we put in 720, took out 570. Okay, it's grown a little bit. The next year, we put in 740 from the taxpayers, and we take out 570,000 plus 570,000. It's growing by 570,000 every year.

Speaker 5 (17:29–17:34)

And Jay, this is going to go to the deficit in the budget, right?

Speaker 3 (17:35–17:35)

Yes.

Speaker 5 (17:36–17:40)

So we'd still be under, if we're under 2 million, we'd still be 1.5 under.

Speaker 1 (17:42–18:20)

Yeah, I'll get to how it affects the FY27 budget later. This is just sort of thinking, you know, what's a good plan for this policy. So FY28, we take out 1.14 million. We end up with 2.4 million.

FY29, again, we take out more than we put in. The amount that we're taking out is growing by the same amount, another $570,000. We end up at $150,000. And then in FY30, start with $150,000, put in $770,000, take out $227,000.

We end up at zero. So that's FY30, which ends in the summer of 2030.

Speaker 6 (18:21–18:25)

Why would we put money in the year that we drain the account to zero?

Speaker 1 (18:26–18:41)

When I say put money in, that's part of the tax base. So when we passed the override, we said every year as part of the override, part of the tax base is $700,000 plus 2.5% going to the stabilization fund.

Speaker 6 (18:41–18:47)

Okay, so that's not coming out of our budget. I understand what you mean. That's part of the tax levy. It's going in there.

All right, gotcha.

Speaker 1 (18:48–19:30)

Correct. So we're putting that in, we're draining it to zero. We see this coming from a few years away. So we've been telling, communicating to the people in town, guys, the summer of 2030, we're gonna be hitting a crisis.

Let's have an override in the spring of 2030. People know this is coming years in advance. So this is what I'm proposing a baseline would be. I'm not saying this would solve all our revenue numbers.

I'm just saying, as far as setting up policy, this is how I see the policy going. If I move to the next slide, I'll show the same example, but if we put free cash in every year, are you okay with this example that I can go to the next one?

Speaker 6 (19:31–19:46)

I'm okay with this example. I'm antsy to get to where you're going with the fiscal year 27 business because we're going to have to talk about a million different scenarios that we could do with this account. So FYI.

Speaker 1 (19:47–19:52)

I hear you. I've only got four scenarios for this account. Uh, this one.

Speaker 6 (19:52–19:54)

Too much for our attention span for right now.

Speaker 1 (19:55–20:49)

This one is the same thing, but we put in a million dollars in free cash every year. So in FY27, we put in a million dollars in free cash and we withdraw a quarter million dollar every year for the next four years. FY28, we put in another million dollars. We withdraw a third of a million dollars for the next three years.

And then what I said earlier, FY29 and FY30, for each of those, we put in a million dollars, and I'd really like to spread it over three years. So we put in a million dollars, pull out a third of a million dollars. So, you know, we're building up more and more money that we can take out for the fund. As Lee-Michael said, even in the last year, we're putting in money from free cash.

We're putting a million, we're only taking 330,000 out of it, but it's sort of for fiscal responsibility rather than taking that free cash and spending on ongoing expenses. We might or might not decide to do that. Yes.

Speaker 5 (20:49–20:59)

Okay, quick question. So we don't have to spend down this whole override budget by 2030, right? We can still have money in this fund.

Speaker 1 (20:59–21:05)

We can, so in this, in this example, we would still, I would think we would call for an override in 2030 and still have a 1Million dollars in there.

Speaker 4 (21:06–21:13)

Okay, that makes sense. And sorry, this, this fund doesn't go away in FY 30.

Speaker 5 (21:13–21:21)

Yeah, that's what I was trying to make sure that's in perpetuity, right? Yes, it continues to okay. That's good. All right.

Speaker 1 (21:23–22:37)

Uh, so the next example I'm going to look at is, people might freak out, but we got to look at options. What if we have an override, not in 2030, but an override in 2029? Here's the same math. If we don't do any more contributions, instead of taking out, what was it?

500 something, $500,000 ish, we get to take out $800,000. Each year and $800,000 more each year, then we run down to 0 in the middle of 2029. We call for another override there. And the next example is putting those 2 together.

This is the example that I think is going to work. For what I'm seeing for our budgets, which I'll be showing a few slides, which is. planning for an override in the spring of 2029, and contributing a million dollars a year from free cash into this account. And then we get out, well, you can compare at the bottom.

The original town administrator's forecast had us pulling out 0.86 in year one. Now we're pulling out 1.15 million. That's $300,000 better. And for each of the three years, we're pulling more money out of this account.

Speaker 5 (22:39–22:49)

So if we move to fiscal year 29 for an override, is the override larger or smaller than if we were to move to 2030?

Speaker 1 (22:53–23:08)

Two answers. One answer is that that's hard to say because it depends on how much we would be slashing our spending and stuff. But the answer is it's probably smaller. The longer you wait, the more you're going to need.

Speaker 5 (23:09–23:13)

So, it's smaller if you do it in FY, 29, that's what you're saying.

Speaker 1 (23:13–23:14)

Smaller if you do it sooner. Yes.

Speaker 5 (23:15–23:18)

Okay. All right.

Speaker 1 (23:18–23:26)

And we might see some numbers later that back that up. So, all right now I'm getting to some.

Speaker 7 (23:27–23:58)

Yes. One challenge with the concept of an override sooner rather than later is, and this might not be for a discussion here, but it's certainly something people should keep in mind is if I understand things correctly, there could be two other overrides that come up before the town over the next couple of years. One probably, and I know it still has to be decided for the fire station at Atherton, and one for the school. And so getting three overrides passed in a relatively short period of time, all potentially for good causes, could be a challenge.

Speaker 1 (24:00–24:30)

You are correct. I might counter that You know, in my imagination, not only is it an override in 2029 or 2030, but it's an override that we telegraphed three years earlier, two years earlier, one year early. We held the taxpayers by the hand and we brought them along saying, here's what's going to come. And as well as, if Atherton is going to be coming along that time, we'll know, especially

Speaker 7 (24:30–25:03)

Yeah, well, no, I agree that building transparency and trust, I think is something that would be tremendously valuable to everybody involved. I'm just saying, as we go through this, I think it's important to be transparent with everybody and not be focused just on this that there are potential other issues that could affect. the tax base of the individual taxpayers. And I think as part of building that transparency and trust, it's important to kind of just make sure that we don't lose track of that possibility or even likelihood.

Speaker 1 (25:04–27:03)

You're right. And that's something we should keep in mind while looking at this budget. We've got three people looking at the Atherton work. One of those three people is a finance professor.

That's not a coincidence. I want them to look at how it's going to affect our budgets and when. You're very right. And if I ever forget that, keep me on top of it.

You're very right. So I'm going to get into a couple of multi-year forecasts. I will say that I tinkered with these forecasts a lot, probably too much, and new information is coming in from the state and the town administration, town administrator weekly, if not more often. The town administrator presented some budget numbers to the select board on Tuesday.

I can promise you my numbers do not match the numbers he showed on Tuesday exactly. Now, I did meet with him earlier this week, and it looks like our numbers are close enough for discussion purposes. So if you want exact numbers, look at his presentation. If you want pretty close numbers that give a high level of where we're going and what we can do, I think this is good for discussion.

So this is, and you know, I know it's hard to read, there's a lot on this page. Now, again, I wanted to get this out there, get it in your mailbox, in your hands, so you can take a good look at it. These are the assumptions I'm using for what I'm calling the baseline forecast. This is…

where I imagine the forecast was a couple weeks ago when we had the $2.5 million shortfall. It's assuming health insurance inflation is 10%. I'm showing it here by 13%, meaning a 13% over 2026. I had to do that to get my numbers to work.

I think that's because we had so many people join in addition to health insurance inflation. I'm saying that the schools are going up by 5.2%. I'm saying the towns are going up by 3.65%. And that's getting us all to a shortfall.

Brian, what's up?

Speaker 8 (27:03–27:06)

Where are you getting 5% on school salary inflation?

Speaker 1 (27:09–27:13)

You're right, because I'm saying 5.2% on the right and 5% on one side.

Speaker 8 (27:13–27:18)

No, I mean, why is it so high? I mean, where did that number come from?

Speaker 2 (27:18–27:18)

OK.

Speaker 1 (27:19–27:35)

What I'm trying to reflect is where we stood a few weeks ago. And where we stood a few weeks ago was the schools had a request that was 5.2% higher than what they got last year. So I'm trying to show, well, in general, the whole budget was 5.2% higher.

Speaker 8 (27:36–27:39)

Are you just doing school salaries?

Speaker 1 (27:40–27:45)

Well, if you see the line for scholaries and line for school general expenses, I've made those both be 5.2%.

Speaker 8 (27:46–27:55)

So you're saying the wages, salaries for the teachers, or mostly teachers, is going up 5.2% each year for the next five years?

Speaker 1 (27:56–28:01)

No, I'm saying that you put those two together, and the school request went up by 5.2%.

Speaker 8 (28:01–28:11)

You have them both going up, if you look at this spreadsheet. And that's excessive, I would think. Well, again, I have two questions on that.

Speaker 1 (28:12–28:29)

OK, if I needed the total to go up 5.2%, That's what I was concerned about, is the total going up 5.2%. I didn't know how else to get there. I could have fiddled with the salary line and the general expense line to be different and get me to the total of 5.2%, but what would be the point?

Speaker 8 (28:31–28:37)

Well, that's the second question. Why are they going up so much? Why is it outpacing inflation?

Speaker 6 (28:37–28:40)

Because it's reality, Brian. It's a contract.

Speaker 8 (28:41–28:49)

It's, they haven't signed a contract. It's negotiated. Are you saying that they've negotiated a 5.2% increase in the contract?

Speaker 1 (28:49–29:15)

This is what we discussed last week, is that, we discussed last week, and I'll switch back to that slide, that I don't know what the ins and outs are of running a school district. But, oh shoot, did I? Oh yeah, here it is. But if we look at 30 of our peers across the state, and we look at their year-over-year increase over five years, They're going up five and a half percent.

So I don't know what it takes to run a school district, but apparently it takes five and a half percent increase year over year.

Speaker 6 (29:15–29:25)

It's more complicated than just negotiating one budget because there are steps and lanes and all sorts of things that are determined by… Elaine, can't you help us here?

Speaker 9 (29:26–30:05)

Yes, I was going to, right before you said steps and lanes, I was going to say the contract include steps and lanes for teachers. So if you have a master's degree with 10 years, there's a level that you hit at a certain point, and it will drive. It's not that all salaries are going up by 5.2%. It's that people are hitting different marks on the steps and lanes, and it's negotiated every three years.

And every school system has steps and lanes. If we didn't have steps and lanes to offer, we wouldn't get the quality teachers that we have in Milton.

Speaker 8 (30:06–30:18)

So you're saying the average salaries for the teachers in Milton is budgeted to go up 5.2% a year for the next three years?

Speaker 1 (30:20–30:22)

Is that a question to me about my model?

Speaker 8 (30:22–30:25)

That's a general comment. That's what you're stating.

Speaker 1 (30:25–30:26)

Who's the you, me?

Speaker 8 (30:27–30:28)

Well, I guess both of you.

Speaker 6 (30:28–30:39)

That average, that mean of 5.4% includes things like insurance, health insurance going up, all these different things that it costs to have employees. Cost of living increases.

Speaker 8 (30:40–30:41)

I think, isn't it?

Speaker 1 (30:42–30:53)

That's a good point. When I got this from Department of elementary secondary education, I think they include health insurance. But when we look at the school budget, it doesn't include health insurance, so it's a slight difference.

Speaker 4 (30:55–30:59)

It also includes cost of living increases that are negotiated, right?

Speaker 9 (31:01–31:10)

Yes, there are annual cost of living increases across the board, and then there are some people who will get more than that because of the steps and lanes.

Speaker 7 (31:10–31:38)

Right. It's also true that the 5.2% that the, I think the 5.2% that the school department is requesting as an increase isn't all for salaries. I get 80% of their total budget is salaries, or I heard 80%, I don't know if that's exactly right, but the 5.2% is a total spend of the budget, I think, right? And so, yeah, a lot of that's probably salaries, but not, it's possible the salaries part is lower and the other expenses are higher, I don't know.

Speaker 6 (31:38–32:00)

In any case, I beg us to not go down this road again. I actually do. Brian, hold on a second. The reality is that we are in the middle of the pack of the whole state of our per-pupil expenditure.

And we haven't really moved much over the years. So we're not out of whack from other towns.

Speaker 8 (32:00–32:02)

Your teacher salaries are actually in the top third.

Speaker 1 (32:04–32:06)

Top third compared to Pittsfield? Compared to what?

Speaker 8 (32:06–32:08)

Compared to the state, the entire state.

Speaker 1 (32:08–32:11)

Well, yeah, the state has a lot in the West.

Speaker 6 (32:11–32:15)

Milton's in the top third compared to the entire state. Right.

Speaker 1 (32:17–32:17)

What are you saying?

Speaker 6 (32:18–32:21)

You want to pay teachers what they earn in Pittsfield? Like, what is your point?

Speaker 8 (32:23–32:34)

The entire state, average, the last numbers we have is actually like 2.5%. And I don't see that it's like, it seems a lot. Like, how many jobs or positions

Speaker 6 (32:36–32:44)

No, first, we need to agree on who our peers are. First, you need to agree on who our peers are. What town are you comparing us to?

Speaker 1 (32:45–32:53)

All right, can I invoke chair privilege here? I don't know. I'd like to focus on- And this isn't even salaries. This is total expenses.

Brian, may I?

Speaker 8 (32:54–32:55)

This isn't even salaries.

Speaker 1 (32:55–33:01)

Brian, may I? I'd like to focus on the big picture of- I'm not sure Brian can hear me.

Speaker 8 (33:02–33:02)

I can hear you.

Speaker 1 (33:02–33:46)

Brian, can you hear me? Yes. I'd like to focus on the big picture of the budget, the big picture. And that's not really the topic for today's discussion.

I want to see what can the budget hold? What can we forecast for the budget? Why are we here? What can we look at as a budget forecast?

I think when we get into details of the school budget, that's fine for the school budget subcommittee to look at, and we'll have the school administration and the school committee come talk to us about that specifically. That's really not why we're here today. I really would urge us to not spend too much time tonight on this, because I think we've got a lot of high-level things to cover.

Speaker 8 (33:50–34:03)

OK. But that 5.2%, there's a lot of noise in that number, is what I'm saying. That's not just salaries. So don't get it—people shouldn't think that that's—all the salaries should be going up 5.2%.

Speaker 1 (34:03–36:50)

I had to make my Excel spreadsheet work somehow. I had to. So where did I end up? School budget going up 5.2%, town department's budgets going up 3.7%, and health insurance going up, I'll say, a lot in the first year.

Again, I had to twiddle some things to make the numbers work. And then I'm looking at free cash. I'm assuming, so we have a free cash policy now, which says our goal is to have free cash of between two and 4% of our budget every year. So even though Amy Dexter says, I can't count on free cash till it appears, and that's true for some purposes, it does keep appearing and our goal is for it to appear.

So I'm assuming we're having about $3 million of free cash every year, and more to the point, putting a million dollars into budget stabilization every year. So, where would that get us again? This is sort of the budget as it existed 2 weeks ago with these assumptions. I got some scary numbers for you.

So. There's a lot on this page. Again, I'm giving it to you so you can look at it. Even though there's a lot, this is my one-page summary.

This is me trying to be brief. I've got the most important revenue line items at the top, but some of them collapsed into miscellaneous. Got the most important expense numbers at the bottom. And what I'm showing you here is the revenue and the expense before we use the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund.

So that stabilization fund that might close some gaps from year to year, that's not being reflected here. And I know there's a lot of numbers on this page, but you can sort of eyeball every year starting in FY27, the expenses are higher than the revenue. OK, so we've got to make those up. So now I'm gonna backtrack on what I said a few minutes ago.

I hope you'll bear with me. I'm showing you an exhibit where instead of that structured operating budget stabilization fund that I showed you a few minutes ago, I'm just gonna pretend just for discussion purposes, what if we use the operating budget stabilization to close the gap every year? I just showed you one where the expenses are higher than revenue every year. What if we just took whatever we need out of there to close the gap?

Well, you'll notice that The withdrawal is pretty high, gets higher. And what do we have at the account at the end of that year? Well, it gets negative in 28, more negative in 29, more negative in 30. This isn't going to work, is what it's showing us.

It says that by the time we got to FY30, we would have a shortfall of a million, almost $12 million every year. And we'd be at negative 20 million. We'd be 20 million behind in funds.

Speaker 7 (36:50–36:57)

Again, Jay, sort of like the 26th and the 27th and the line by line, because I'm not sure I follow that one.

Speaker 1 (36:58–36:58)

Sure.

Speaker 7 (36:58–37:00)

I mean, I get all the red is bad, but.

Speaker 1 (37:01–38:08)

Yep. I had the revenue and the expense. Can y'all see my mouse pointer? You probably can't.

Oh, you can't. Okay. So the revenue, the expense was higher than the revenue every year. And actually this line that I'm calling withdrawal, that's actually our budget shortfall every year.

So I'm saying that's our budget shortfall. So that's what we take out of the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund to cover it. So we've got a shortfall of $3 million in the first year, which fits with what the messaging we've been hearing. We've been hearing from Mr.

Milano. We heard a couple of weeks ago, we're $2.5 million short, and that's including 700,000 coming out of Operating Stabilization Fund. So 3.2 million improved by 700,000 would be 2.5 million. Okay, so I'm in the ballpark of where Mr.

Mona says. We're $3.5 million short in the first year. We're $6 million short in the second year. We're $9 million short in the third year.

And even if we keep putting $1 million of free cash, into this account every year, in addition to 700,000 from the taxpayers, we're burning through it faster than we can.

Speaker 7 (38:09–38:12)

But realistically, in 08, we don't have that money to make up the shortfall.

Speaker 5 (38:12–38:15)

Right. We don't have revenue. That's the issue. We don't have the revenue.

Speaker 7 (38:15–38:24)

So we don't have revenue in 27. You get part of it in 28 because you have some balance at the end of 27, but not even enough to cover what you took out in 27.

Speaker 1 (38:24–38:30)

Exactly. Right. Exactly. So it's not working, is the answer.

Speaker 5 (38:32–38:41)

That's the issue is that it breaks it breaks really in 2028 and we don't have the proper revenue.

Speaker 1 (38:41–39:48)

I don't yeah, so. I've got I've got a better side of the story coming up. I've got a possible good side of the story. Um.

All right, so. we should close this funding gap and we should do it with realistic assumptions. I don't want to reopen the discussion from a few minutes ago, but if an assumption, you know, if a 2.5% increase in school funding is not assumption, is not a realistic assumption, let's see what a realistic assumption is and do a forecast of that. One thing I think we need, and I alluded to this earlier, I think we need a plan for an override in 2029, not 2030.

So in spring of 2029. We'll look at the numbers and see what that looks like. I sincerely believe that if we communicate to the people, here's what's coming, be ready for it up front with them, I think it can work. I also think it's the only option we have.

Speaker 5 (39:49–39:50)

Jay, can I ask a question?

Speaker 1 (39:50–39:51)

Yes. Yes.

Speaker 5 (39:52–40:09)

I mean, I understand the importance of an override and that's sort of a way of getting money, but there have to be other towns that have been in this situation where they found other ways to do this. Do we know any other towns that have been able to kind of overcome this and creating some of the kind of revenue growth outside of tax increases?

Speaker 1 (40:12–40:42)

The short answer is every town is different. To some extent, you could say a lot of towns have more commercial than we do. That helps to some extent, but it doesn't solve everything. If you look at the average tax we pay, among our peers, we're sort of average in the average tax we pay, even though we have less commercial.

So it's not necessarily a cure-all. That is a big picture question. I think it's not one that I'm prepared to tackle.

Speaker 5 (40:42–40:56)

No, I know. I just think that from a town perspective, we need to start thinking about are there any other ways to create revenue in addition to increase because this breaks. It's already broken and then it just continues to break even if you do continue to do overrides.

Speaker 6 (40:57–41:35)

This is a discussion that's been going on for 30 years. As far as I know, there are no other ways for the town to bring in revenue. Every single time some commercial development comes up, It gets voted down by the neighborhood, or the planning board, or whoever. Anyway, the previous chair before me did some sort of financial analysis that showed that we would have to build three legacy places in order to bring in the amount of commercial revenue that we would need to make us on par with the other towns.

We're 97% residentially funded, and there just isn't another way for a municipality to make money.

Speaker 1 (41:36–42:03)

I was going to say, I've heard people say in general, we need more commercial, but I'd like to see some numbers. Build a $5 million grocery store. How much does that move the needle? I don't know.

And also, if we did build three legacy places, we've got more demand for fire. We've got more demand for police. We've got more demand for health inspections. It'd probably be a positive net, but…

So I think it's a good subject of discussion. I don't think I'm prepared to talk about it tonight.

Speaker 8 (42:04–42:55)

I'll give you an alternative on that if you want to hear. Shoot. If you went over three, right now, student population has been flat for eight years in the first preschool And pre-K and first grade are pretty low numbers this year. So the population's pretty flat over the last eight years.

But over that same time, like if you went over 13 years, I'll give you an example, student population's gone up 10%. Teachers have gone up 26%. Expenditures have gone up 78%. And inflation during that time has been 50%.

And a thought could be like maybe trying to save money, because you're outpacing inflation.

Speaker 6 (42:56–42:58)

And I certainly shouldn't be outpacing inflation.

Speaker 8 (42:58–43:02)

I think you should. I'm sorry, what'd you say?

Speaker 6 (43:03–43:07)

It sounds like your idea is significantly decreased funding to the schools, right?

Speaker 8 (43:08–43:11)

It would be to try to control it.

Speaker 6 (43:11–43:21)

Yeah. Okay. Yeah. I agree.

We could lower the funding to the schools by multiple millions of dollars and it would require a ton of layoffs. That's one option. Now we need to talk about a million other options.

Speaker 8 (43:22–43:30)

That's one option. I didn't say layoffs. I said keep it in pace with inflation. Why is that so hard?

Other people do it. Other companies do it.

Speaker 5 (43:30–43:36)

I think that results in the ops for what the school had sent out a couple weeks ago. Doesn't that result in plans?

Speaker 9 (43:36–43:55)

There are things that the schools are mandated by law to include that they don't get fully refunded for, like out-of-district placements and paraprofessionals needed in the classrooms and things like that. So there are things that are out of their control in terms of keeping up with inflation.

Speaker 1 (43:55–44:14)

Yeah, I'll just say, you know, last year, the town administrator put together a forecast that assumed a 2% to 5% increase in schools. And now we're facing laying off 25 teachers. So I'm trying to look at more realistic assumptions, which is a higher increase per year.

Speaker 8 (44:14–44:22)

But why are costs going up? Like, is the headcount going up? Are expenses going up? I mean, everything is 3%.

Why is it going up 5.2%?

Speaker 1 (44:23–44:31)

I think that's a good conversation for another night, a night that's focused on school expenses. I really want to try to get through this.

Speaker 6 (44:32–44:34)

I will make health insurance.

Speaker 10 (44:34–44:38)

We've gone through all these health insurance professionals.

Speaker 6 (44:38–45:17)

Jay, I will make the point that the whole reason why that number is 2.5% last year and every year before then is because people freak out when they see five or higher because they're like, why are we vastly exceeding, you know? And so that number is kept to artificially low, which fucks us in the end. And so we have to get beyond this, Brian. We are not funding the Milton public schools at an unusual rate.

We are middle of the pack. We have analyzed this 20 ways. It's just we are not overspending on the schools. Go and try to figure it out and come back and tell us how we're overspending.

Speaker 1 (45:18–48:50)

I think this is a good discussion to have another night. This is a good discussion to have on a night when we're focused on school funding. So I would ask us to put this aside, please. Of course, the next thing I'm going to say is school funding.

Shame on me 2 things, some changes that I think would help fill the gap and improve our budget forecast 1 plan for an override in 2030 that affects the way we use the operating budget stabilization fund to. And I will probably get some details wrong, and this is going to be a subject of discussion between the town administrator, the school committee, us, possibly the select board. The school budget is funding their circuit. What they have is called a circuit breaker stabilization fund, so their own little stabilization fund.

They're funding that from their ongoing budget. I've heard $700,000. I've heard $900,000. I'm not sure what the number is, but part of their budget is funding their stabilization fund.

A good use of free cash is to fund stabilization funds. We use free cash to fund the various town stabilization funds. A good use of free cash is to fund this school stabilization fund. So if they're spending $900,000 out of their operating budget for the stabilization fund, I'm proposing, and Mr.

Milan is proposing something similar, if not exactly the same thing, half a million dollars from free cash to their circuit breaker stabilization fund instead of them spending out of their own budget. Next bullet point, it goes without saying, I think we should adopt the Operating Budget Stabilization Policy, and that I think not only this year, but every year, the Warrant Committee should present a multi-year forecast, including the assumptions. Last year, should we present it to the town? Town, here's our forecast.

We're assuming pay goes up to an average percentage here. That might've raised some red flags. These assumptions I'm talking about, I'm gonna be making some assumptions that are a little bit more optimistic than what the town makes, for example, and how our expenses grow. I think both are reasonable.

If you're planning for a one-year budget and you wanna make sure to not hit your budget, like let's say, let's say your property and casualty insurance can go up anywhere between two and 7% in a year. And usually it's 5%. It might be prudent to say, I am assuming it's going up 7% because I don't want to break that budget. But whereas I might say, OK, that's fine for one year.

But if we're looking over multiple years and it's an average of 5%, let's use that average. Some years it'll be higher, some years it'll be lower. Now, I will say, and there's a big caveat in the middle of this, is that that conservative assumption is what gives us our free cash. So if I'm saying, I'm assuming we're going to have free cash, and I'm also saying, let's be not quite as conservative in our assumptions, those might come into conflict with each other.

I think that's a good conversation to have with the town administrator, get his view on all this. But that's sort of one of my caveats. Final caveat, of course, is my assumption is not going to be real life. I don't know what real life will be.

I just know it won't be this. But let's see what we can do. So then the next few slides are an updated assumption. All right.

First, let's talk about free cash.

Speaker 7 (48:51–49:17)

Hey, Jay, can we go back for one sec? Sorry. Sure. You talked about the The school stabilization fund, I didn't know that individual.

Departments in town had stabilization funds. I thought the school has trying to fund as I recall from the presentation from the school superintendent a few weeks ago that they were trying to fund the. The special education, I thought that was a stabilization fund.

Speaker 5 (49:17–49:19)

Yeah, they were doing that. Nick. You're right.

Speaker 7 (49:19–50:16)

So is this addition to that? I didn't so they're funding out of their own budget spend estimate, like a stabilization fund and then they would have discretion over how to spend that in future years. So, I don't know, that sort of troubles me. And, you know, again, this could be something to talk about in the future, but it would seem like if they're going to fund a stable, if the town is going to fund stabilization funds to support town expenditures when there are challenges, that that should be a townwide issue or a townwide stabilization fund and not within individual departments.

And so, Rather than put that in the school stabilization fund, maybe that should be a larger contribution to the operating budget stabilization fund that could be spread across the town as appropriate in a given year. Just something that occurred to me as you're going through the numbers, I wanted to get off my chest.

Speaker 1 (50:16–51:59)

I think that is a good conversation. That is a good topic for tonight and or Monday night after people have digested this. I will say that the school has Forgive me if I'm misspeaking. They have several rotating funds, rolling funds, something like that, but this is one of them.

This is the Circuit Breaker Stabilization Fund. Every year they spend a certain amount on special ed, they submit it to the state, and the next year they get the money. And that money goes into this account, and they pull out of this account to do whatever they like. One thing I should say, the school committee wanted me to be very precise in saying, when I'm saying they're contributing to the circuit breaker fund, What they're actually doing is pulling out less.

Now, to me, pulling out less, contributing, works out the same mathematically, but they like speaking precisely. But back to your point, yes, they do have this fund. It is entirely under their control. So they want to build it up so that they can, you know, this is one of the funds that a couple of years ago, when things hit the fan, they reached into this fund and pulled all the money out of it.

Don't cover the problems so the schools are saying, you know, right now, this fund has 0, this, this, the 1,000,000 dollars is in this fund. A couple years ago saved our bacon. Let's build it back up. And I understand that.

So 1 question might be. If we're going to put in $500,000, do we put it in this fund that is entirely under the control of the school committee? Or do we put it in the fund that was established last year called the Special Education Reserve Fund that is under the control of both the school committee and the select board? That's a question.

I don't have the answer to that. I don't. That's a question.

Speaker 7 (51:59–52:04)

But they definitely have the two funds, one for special education and one for general expenditures.

Speaker 1 (52:05–52:17)

I mean, they're both related to special education, but the two funds we're talking about, one is entirely under the purview of the schools. Okay. And one would be under the supervision of the schools and the slot board.

Speaker 7 (52:18–52:22)

Yeah. So I think that's something to explore going forward. But I think you're right.

Speaker 4 (52:23–52:41)

Can you talk in a little more detail about how each is funded versus what you were saying, like just withdrawn from, I think, That is a source of confusion and it could help. People to understand the difference in the 2.

Speaker 1 (52:43–53:03)

I'm not sure I know to the extent I understand your question. I'm not sure if I know the answer. Okay, I guess I would say the 1 that's under the school boards control is funded by the state payments that come in the so called circuit breaker payments. 1 open question is, if this town wants to put money in there, are we even able to I think we have to figure that out.

Speaker 4 (53:03–53:18)

So that's kind of what I mean, like, and you alluded to this earlier, you say, like, put money in, but actually, you mean, take less out because what's in there is reimbursement from the state. from the previous year, correct?

Speaker 9 (53:19–53:34)

Yes, and not a full reimbursement from the state. There's a formula every year, and the amount changes year to year as to what state will refund in Circuit Breaker. And you have to wait to figure out what that is. There's no planning ahead for it.

Speaker 5 (53:36–53:54)

Right, but Jay, you were saying that to put money in from the other override, Fund into this stabilization fund is that what you're saying. From free cash, right from okay from free cash. Okay. So it's in addition, it's really it's money.

That's also going in, not just not taking out.

Speaker 4 (53:54–54:07)

I think it's both so that's kind of my, my question. And so the special ed stabilization fund. Is that funded similarly through the state or is that. Something different.

Speaker 1 (54:07–54:13)

It's something the town would fund if right now it has $0 in it was made last year. It's totally empty.

Speaker 4 (54:15–54:29)

And so can you then re explain in the context that we just talked about of? Drawing down less versus funding with free cash for the circle breaker stabilization.

Speaker 1 (54:32–01:01:39)

Here's what I'll say. I'll say if. the school committee and the warrant committee and the town administrator come to an agreement of concept, I think we could work out the details. I know that doesn't answer your question, but if we all agree in concept, we like this thing, then we'd come to an agreement of maybe we're putting it in their budget.

We're taking free cash, we're putting in their budget, but we're all agreeing this is there so that you can build up your stabilization. Or maybe we would deposit it directly in there. We'd have to work out the accounting details and how money flows once we come to an agreement, which I will tell you right now, we're not at. I know that's not a satisfactory answer to your question, but right now we're not even all agreement of what should be done.

I will say something Elaine said a few minutes ago gets to one point of this account is that how much is going to be reimbursed is not known until later. So that's one reason why they want to build up a cushion. If you're, I mean, every year they're taking in three and a half million and spending three and a half million from this account. So if they're expecting to spend three and a half million from this account, but the state says, no, we were reimbursing at a lower rate this year.

It's only 3 million. That's why they want to have a cushion. And I think that's, I think that's a very good argument. This is a good discussion.

I will come back to this on later slides, so keep your thoughts in mind. Okay. Free cash. We have $4.5 million in free cash this year.

What I'm proposing, which I think is, I think it's really in line with what the town administrator is also proposing, you know, a certain amount of capital non-bonded, again, that's, you know, if we buy a fire truck, we'll go out to Wall Street and we'll finance it, because those cost a heck of a lot of money. If we buy a Ford F-150, we'll pay for it with cash. So capital expenses that we pay for with cash, that comes out of free cash. 1.2 million this year, I'm assuming about a million dollars every year after that.

General stabilization, a little more than half a million dollars this year, a little less than half a million dollars after that. That's what I call Fort Knox. That's what's going to get us through the next recession. Aside from that, pretend it's not there.

Thinking of putting a million dollars in operating budget stabilization fund every year. I'm sorry, I should clarify. I think I'm in agreement with the town administrator on this free cash FY27. Free cash FY28, I cannot speak for anybody but myself.

But think in every year, put a million dollars into operating budget stabilization fund, put a half a million dollars into special ed stabilization of some form or fashion, and then other one-time needs. Things pop up. Committees say, we need $100,000 for this or that. Want to have some free cash for that.

Uh, there's a bit into having a bit set aside for union contracts. That makes my brain hurt. I'd rather not think about that too much. Again, this, you know, hope hopes that we have free cash coming out, coming forward.

We aim to have two to 4% of our budget in free cash every year. We may or may not, but going forward. All right. What do I have next?

Ah, this is where I'm walking through step-by-step. So. Previously, my previous example had an FY27 deficit of about 3.2. Again, that's before using the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund.

So if we were going to use 700,000 of that, we would have had a deficit of 2.5. So before the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund, we were looking at a deficit of 3.2 million. And then through FY29, when all is said and done, we'd be about $4.5 million in the hole. So I made various changes in assumptions.

I mean, me changing an assumption is sort of like me waving a magic wand and making money appear. But we can discuss, are these reasonable assumptions or not? Now, new growth. I discussed this with the town administrator this week.

Again, any errors are mine, not his. He thinks there's a possibility it'll go up. I asked him about $1.4 million. He said, oh, that sounds pretty high.

He'll be talking to the assessors. Pretty much, we have four DBs this year that are being built. We're gonna be taxing them. That's gonna lead to our new growth.

So I'm looking at one and a quarter million dollars in new growth this year, then a million dollars beyond that. So that gives us, well, that gives us a quarter of a million dollars. And over three years, that's a quarter of a million dollars three times, okay? Local receipts.

The town administrator is being very conservative, assuming a 1% annual increase. There are times to be conservative, but I'd rather be sort of middle of the road. Between 2017 to 2022, local receipts went up by about 3 percent. Now, when I say local receipts, I mean the tax on your cars, and I mean meals taxes.

Those are the big ones. Since 2022, we've done even better than this. I'm still a little bit conservative, but I think realistic. That improves our numbers as you can see.

Indirect costs, that's related to healthcare costs. It's costs that are paid for through the water and sewer bills, including some healthcare. I said bump that up a little bit if healthcare is going up. It's a tiny, tiny bit.

Chapter 78, we got the governor's budget just this past week. And we know that Chapter 78, which is the biggest aid, it's related to schools, that went up by two and a half percent. The town administrator is assuming 1% lately, was assuming 1% every year. That's conservative.

In recent years, we've been high above 2%. So what I've got from my assumptions is that it's going up by 2.5% this year, which is a fact. I'm sorry, that's in the governor's budget. We still have to wait for the House and Senate to weigh in.

I'm assuming they're not gonna lower that. So 2.5%, I'm assuming 2.5% ongoing. We could argue if that's too optimistic or not, but it's what we got this year. That improves the situation.

Other state aid. It's been 3% in recent years. Mr. Milano is assuming 2%.

Actually, he got it right in FY27, 2%, according to the governor's budget. It's still been 3% in recent years, so I've got a 3% increase in other state aid. So these are my assumptions regarding revenue. Changing these assumptions gets us about $600,000 in one year, gets us even more in three years going out.

Okay. Any questions about this? This is me setting up a forecast, making changes to the revenue assumptions.

Speaker 10 (01:01:41–01:01:56)

This is something, but does that mean that the deficit drops from $8 million to $1 million? Am I seeing that wrong? Say again? Does that mean that with these less conservative assumptions, the deficit drops from $8 million in 2029 to $1 million in 2029?

Speaker 1 (01:01:57–01:02:18)

Yeah, good question. I've got to say that I changed these numbers multiple times today, which I knew would lead to a problem. Are you saying this 4.51 I suspect doesn't match? What's up here?

Speaker 10 (01:02:20–01:02:21)

I'm sorry.

Speaker 1 (01:02:22–01:02:31)

Yeah, I'm sorry. I was changing these numbers right up till noon today and I knew something would slip through, but this is what I think I'm seeing. Okay.

Speaker 10 (01:02:31–01:02:36)

It's all good news. I'll just accept it.

Speaker 1 (01:02:37–01:02:37)

Thank you.

Speaker 7 (01:02:37–01:02:46)

Sorry, the conservative numbers that the baseline is based is one of the ways in which we're generating the free cash every year though, right? You're correct.

Speaker 1 (01:02:48–01:03:47)

Yeah, you're correct. That's why I said there's a bit of a push and pull of if we assume less conservative numbers, is that going to eat into our free cash? Well, to a certain extent, yes. Less so in that new growth, every year by the time we set the budget, we're going to know what new growth is.

So we're saying right now, two weeks ago, we said it was a million. And then by February 15th, we're going to have a really good number from the assessors to tell us what new growth is going to be. And then even going up through April in town meeting, they might revise that. So that doesn't lead to free cash.

That just, you know, something we don't know in January, but we do know in February, do know in April, do know next year. Same with local receipts. We'll have a much better idea of local receipts in a couple of weeks when we know what we're charging for car taxes this year. and it'll probably be more than a 1% annual increase.

So, yes and no.

Speaker 4 (01:03:48–01:04:07)

Sorry, Julia. So, sorry, this last column here is, like what's this, the 4.51, is that the overall anticipated budget shortfall?

Speaker 1 (01:04:09–01:04:15)

Um, that's over 3 years now, if you're asking, is it different than.

Speaker 4 (01:04:19–01:04:23)

No, I'm just literally asking this is not relative to anything else.

Speaker 1 (01:04:23–01:05:00)

That's through. Yeah. Through 3 years. What's the overall shortfall.

I'm sorry, well, it's the overall shortfall, but it also includes, look at the top, it includes $1 million going to the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund every year. So you might ask yourself, $3 million over three years, wouldn't that be like $9 million negative? Well, keep in mind, we have, wow, yeah, I didn't update every piece of the slide, I apologize. Keep in mind, we have $1 million going to the Operation Budget Stabilization Fund every year.

Speaker 4 (01:05:00–01:05:14)

Is why that 4.5 isn't bigger, but you're saying the 4.5 is. The cumulative over 3 years, not just what would be F. Y. 29.

Speaker 1 (01:05:15–01:07:10)

I'm saying it's a cumulative correct. Okay, thank you. Okay, sorry, I'm 2nd, triple guessing myself while talking and that's never good. So that's the revenue.

The expenses. Health insurance. Again, the baseline expense was 10% in the first year, 7% after that. I'm making a couple of changes here.

One is I'm reducing the first year by 300,000. We spoke about this a little bit at our meeting a week and a half ago. There are, for example, some cafeteria workers in the schools, their salary is entirely paid for out of the cafeteria budget fund, which is another fund that belongs to the schools. Money goes into it, money comes out of it to pay for cafeteria workers.

We're saying, let's pay for their health insurance out of that fund also. Put all those together it's not just cafeteria workers, but there are a lot of them put all those together that safety about 300,000 dollars. Um, and then I. I'm reducing the long term assumption from 7 to 6 and a half percent.

Forecasting long-term health insurance rates is witchcraft. I think six and a half is reasonable. We'll see where it gets us. For any assumption, they could be more conservative or less conservative, but this is what I got.

So those both improve things going forward. General insurance, property and casualty. What if our buildings burn down? This plus Blue Hills Regional, they're small, they're not moving the needle very much, but I'm changing them so that they're closer to the historical average than the very conservative assumptions that were in there.

Now we get to town salaries. Previously, I said three and a half.

Speaker 5 (01:07:10–01:07:19)

Jay, question. On general insurance, so you're saying decrease it, is that realistic? Did they just put 100 percent on general insurance? Or is that real?

Speaker 1 (01:07:19–01:07:20)

I'm sorry.

Speaker 5 (01:07:20–01:07:23)

What number is realistic, the 3.7 or the 8?

Speaker 1 (01:07:24–01:07:44)

I think the 3.7. The 3.7 is our historical average. Some years it goes up 1%, some years it goes up 10%. On average, it's been 3.7%.

So, you know, Mr. Milano and Ms. Dexter, for good reasons, when they're putting the budget together, they want to say, it's going to go up 8% this year, because it might, but it probably won't year after year after year.

Speaker 5 (01:07:44–01:07:45)

Okay. All right.

Speaker 1 (01:07:45–01:10:19)

Makes sense. Same with Blue Hills Regional Schools. For the town salaries, I had put a 3.7 percent in there last time to reflect the budgets that the towns put through, and it was 2.5 percent beyond that. I'm saying 3 percent long-term increase.

Now, on the one hand, you might say, and I think this is a thing to discuss, why are they going to be 3 percent when if I gaze my eyes down the page, schools are going to get 4.5 percent? One answer is because the town administrator put this together last year and he said 2.5%, so I'm increasing it by a little bit. I did have a discussion with the town administrator and he said if we're, you know, he might like to see this higher. He might, you know, in reality, he might like to see town salaries, the total town payroll go up by more like three and a half or four.

I've got three in here for now. So, town expenses. No real change there. School salaries, again, I was saying, if it's 5.2 in the first year and then 2.5 every year after that, I'm changing that to 4.5 percent year-over-year.

That's less than schools asked for this year, but it's more than 2.5 percent. It's in the realm of what's reasonable. All these changes you can see, how do they affect FY27? Well, the FY27 deficit surplus, Before the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund, we've gone from being $3 million and change under to being $400,000 under.

If you made mental notes in the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund, you'll know that means we're looking pretty good. And then how about through FY29? Well, surplus or deficit through FY29. Keep in mind also when I show those examples, I assume we're going to be ending up with A million dollars sitting in our operating budget stabilization fund the day we go to ask for an override.

So what I'd want to see here on the right hand side is about a million dollars. And that's what I am seeing. Uh, if you ask yourself, did I pick assumptions to get me to the right place? Well, you're, you're not too far off, but we can ask, are these reasonable assumptions?

So this has us being good through 2029. Uh, Whoops, I didn't mean to do that. Questions about this? And as I say, there are assumptions.

There could be different assumptions.

Speaker 5 (01:10:19–01:10:38)

So your assumptions, you would have to go back to Mr. Milano and confirm that they would agree with these? Is that, that would be the next step? I mean, I like the approach because it keeps us in less of a deficit.

And as long as it feels reasonable and they feel like that makes sense.

Speaker 1 (01:10:39–01:11:33)

I think the point is reasonable is the key word. I think we want to say to Mr. Milano, to the school administration, to the school committee, to the select board, get their opinion. For example, general insurance, okay, that's tiny, but is this reasonable or not?

Health insurance, they said 7%, I'm saying six and a half. Is that way out of whack or is it not? As school salaries, we want to say to the schools, you asked for 5.2% this year. If we assume four and a half, you know, I definitely want the schools to write in blood on a piece of paper, four and a half percent is reasonable every year.

That doesn't mean some years they won't ask for 4.6, 4.7, whatever. But to say, yes, it's in the ballpark of what's reasonable. If it's not in the ballpark of what's reasonable, we gotta come to a consensus on what's reasonable. So to answer your question.

Speaker 8 (01:11:34–01:11:38)

Do you think it's fair that schools go up four and a half and town goes up three?

Speaker 1 (01:11:40–01:15:50)

No, and that's why when I talked to Mr. Milano, he wanted to see that he, I hope I'm not speaking out of school, but he said he'd like it if the town was more like three and a half or four. I'll be blunt, the numbers didn't work that way, but this is all changing, this is all fluid. So I'd like to see the town salaries be more like three and a half or four.

Absolutely. We'll see if we can make the numbers work that way. Absolutely. I think you're raising a good point.

Yes. Let me go to the next slide while people are digesting that. School budget. We talked about this a bit.

I'm going to bring it up again. Take the first bullet with a grain of salt. I watched their meeting from Wednesday morning. I thought they said they wanted to increase their reserves by 945,000.

It's more likely than not that I misunderstood them, but it's somewhere in the ballpark of 700 plus. So this presentation says, let's use free cash to fund school reserves by 500,000, and let's reduce the school's budget by 900,000. Yes, feel free to faint people listening at home when I say reduce the school's budget by 900,000. I'm assuming that the school's operating budget, instead of putting their operating money into reserves, they reduce that reserve funding by at least 700,000.

And then another two, maybe they'll reduce it by 900,000. Maybe they'll reduce it by 700,000 with 200,000 coming from somewhere else. We can't tell them what to do with their budget. We can only tell them how big it is.

I would like to be clear about 1 thing and just stepping back a 2nd. I've had discussions with members of the school committee. I've watched their meetings. They've watched our meetings.

It's less that we're disagreeing and more that we're sort of speaking a different language and having a hard time communicating. So. We're going to have some meetings next week and hopefully hammer this out. I will say that from listening to their meeting on Wednesday morning, I got the impression that they were thinking they would get half a million dollars for free cash for their reserves, and they would also contribute $700,000 more to their reserves.

Speaking for myself, only as one individual who is 115th of the Warrant Committee, I think this proposal is or, not and. I think it's if they agree not to put $700,000 into their reserve account, then the town will put $500,000 of free cash in there. But it's not if they put $700,000 in there, we will also put half a million dollars in there so they get a 1.2 million in there. That's, as with everything in this presentation, I'm open to being convinced.

My word is not law. But I think it's they fund the reserve with their ongoing account, which is not what I'm suggesting, or they don't, and we fund it with our free cash, but not both. And if they, well, I don't want to assume the worst. Again, I think there's just communication issues, and we'll work those out.

I spit out a lot of words right there. Do you have questions? So not to put too fine a point on it, what I'm proposing is reduce the school's request by $900,000. And almost all of that is coming out of money that they are putting in their savings account.

And therefore, they don't have to lay off teachers, just to be blunt. I'm not promising that. I'm not saying that's what will happen. I don't want the headline in the Milton Times to say, Warrant Committee Chair promises there will be no layoffs.

I'm just saying that's the sort of solution that I'm hoping to work with. I'll skip forward a little bit.

Speaker 7 (01:15:50–01:16:32)

I think that makes sense. I still not entirely clear on the difference between their reserve fund and the special education reserve fund. I thought that the. So I would like to understand the differences between those two reserve funds more carefully.

I think on the superintendent's presentation a few weeks ago, a month ago, the spending plan that they had for the special education reserve fund made a lot of sense, and it would create more, I thought, discipline in their planning purposes going forward. This other reserve fund for the school, I'm not sure I understand. I tend to agree generally with what you outlined here, but I would like to understand that more.

Speaker 1 (01:16:35–01:16:37)

As would I, but good point. Lee-Michael?

Speaker 6 (01:16:42–01:16:55)

What do you forecast the impact to be on the budget next year if the schools reduce their reserve fund contributions by 700 and 900K?

Speaker 1 (01:16:56–01:18:13)

And I think that's one point of disconnect between On the one hand, there's myself and Mr. Milano. On the other hand, there's a school committee. What the school committee has said, and I respect this concern, is they've said, don't quote me on this, but they've said, we want to put aside $700,000 for the next five years, so we build up $3.5 million.

And they've said, if the town bails us out with free cash this year, what are we going to do next year? As we all know, you can't depend on free cash. So if the town bails us out this year, next year, we're going to have to come up with that $700,000. My response to that would be no.

We'll give you a half a million dollars this year. And just like all the other stabilization accounts in town, if we have free cash next year, We'll contribute another half a million dollars next year. If we don't, we won't. And I think that's a disconnect between where I hear the school committee is they're less comfortable with that than I am.

They want to put in $700,000 for five years to get to three and a half million. They're very determined on that. And I'd say, pull that back a little bit. Let us fund it with free cash in the years when we have free cash.

Speaker 6 (01:18:14–01:18:31)

And if we have a year, because we're going to have to pull back on the other, the budget stabilization fund in order to. To meet the gap for this year, so we're going to have to do it on the on the town side and the non town or the school side, whatever we call it.

Speaker 1 (01:18:32–01:18:38)

When you said pullback, you mean expected sooner override, or you mean something different?

Speaker 6 (01:18:38–01:18:53)

I mean, we're not going to be able to contribute as much to a stabilization fund as we were expecting because we have a shortfall that we weren't expecting. We're going to have to come up with money somewhere to close the gap.

Speaker 1 (01:18:54–01:19:20)

Well, I said in our last meeting, we're sort of free cash rich and we're budget poor. So rich being a relative term, we do have enough money to put this year in free cash. We can put a million dollars into the operating budget stabilization account. We can put $600,000 in the general account.

We can put half a million dollars into this. So we are sort of free cash rich. I don't, I'm not, I may not be following you.

Speaker 6 (01:19:21–01:19:47)

I was thinking about the budget stabilization funds that we set up. Okay. You know, my assumption is that we're going to, is that the end story here is that we're going to have to contribute less to it than we were planning to contribute all along. Or that's not the right word because it gets funded by the tax levy.

We're going to have to take out more faster than was previously forecasted is what I'm imagining.

Speaker 1 (01:19:49–01:20:13)

Okay, and I guess I would say we're taking out more faster because we're projecting an override in 2029. So what I'm trying to do is get away from the, oh, we need money this year, let's pull it out of that budget and get to the, we have a structure. And that structure is faster because we're expecting a 2029 override because we're short. So maybe we're saying the same thing.

Speaker 6 (01:20:15–01:20:19)

I was saying the bottom line is that we have to spread the pain around.

Speaker 1 (01:20:20–01:22:40)

Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

I mean, they, what I'm suggesting is not exactly what they want. It is not. And we'll, we'll have discussions on that. I, I, I think at the moment it's more of a communication problem than a, I don't know.

We'll see. But this is, this is my perspective on it. Again, another detailed slide with the forecast, so you can look at all the details when you want. You see, again, at a glance, expenses are still higher than revenue, but this is before the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund.

Once we use the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund, here's the shortfall from the previous slide, and then we have the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund proposed schedule. We've actually got an excess this year, Again, my predictions aren't even good enough to last until the next two months. I'm not saying we're going to have an excess when we go to town meeting in May. If we do, we'll figure out what to do with that.

That's not a problem to worry about. We got a little bit of a shortfall, the 28 and 29. If you add up the excess of 27 and the shortfalls in the next two years, we still end up positive. If this is reality, I'm feeling good about it.

Now, my model is not reality, but it's pointing in a good direction, I think. What's next? Oh, okay. Circling back, I just showed you a positive picture.

Does that mean we don't need to plan for an override in FY29? I've got four examples here. FY30, let's be conservative and say, well, we're going to put a million dollars in this year. Mr.

Mono once said, I think it's a good idea. I think it's going to happen. So let's say we only put in a million dollars this year, or we put in a million dollars every year. Those are the top two.

And you can see, I know we got a bunch of shortfalls. But if we plan for an override in FY29, even if we're only able to put in a $1 million this year, we've still got a shortfall, but it's a whole lot better than we had in those previous two examples. And as I just showed, if we are able to put in a million dollars every year, we come out pretty good.

Speaker 5 (01:22:40–01:22:47)

So when I look- So Jay, the one you have FY30, that's the best scenario here with the million dollar contribution.

Speaker 1 (01:22:49–01:22:50)

When you say best?

Speaker 5 (01:22:51–01:22:54)

The top one? No, the one at the bottom.

Speaker 1 (01:22:55–01:23:02)

Oh, okay. Sorry. I'm sorry. Oh, I- Is that a typo?

You know what? That's a typo. That's a typo. That's a typo.

Good catch. You win the gold star.

Speaker 5 (01:23:03–01:23:06)

Yeah, the bottom one should say- I'm hoping that was right. That's right.

Speaker 1 (01:23:06–01:23:08)

The bottom one should say FY29. Thank you.

Speaker 5 (01:23:09–01:23:13)

The bottom one should say after FY 29?

Speaker 1 (01:23:13–01:23:23)

Yes, because if you look at the columns, the bottom scenario should say FY 29 with $1 million contribution. Not the bottom comment, but the bottom quarter.

Speaker 5 (01:23:23–01:23:28)

Yep. OK. All right. OK.

So I was going to say you could push it out. Didn't. OK. All right.

Speaker 1 (01:23:28–01:29:55)

Yeah. Appreciate the thought. Oh, this is an update to reflect the actual governor's budget. The slide probably isn't appropriate because I actually reflected the governor's budget in previous slides.

So, put that aside. Some red flags. Healthcare inflation, unpredictable. 7%, 6.5%, 10%.

The world does not know. We don't know. We don't know what it'll be this coming year. We don't know what it'll be the next three years.

State aid, also unpredictable. We can hope that the Mass Municipal Association works with our legislators to really, they want, their motto is they want $351 million for 351 communities. It's a catchy slogan. I don't know, it's unpredictable.

I think we were reasonably cautious, but who knows. This gets to something Brian pointed out, that 3% downpay increase may not be prudent. If we don't wanna be laying off librarians and things like that, not hiring, not filling police officer positions, et cetera, maybe that should be higher. And also I was assuming free cash would appear, it may not.

Here's a little takeaway. Again, I'm not trying to spread… What's the opposite of spreading panic? I'm not trying to spread hope.

None of them would be accused of spreading hope. But the short version of how to close this FY27 gap a couple weeks ago is $2.5 million. As we talked about a week and a half ago, the Cunningham Collicott Library work, for reasons unrelated, they're going to be financing that a year later. That's not a long-term savings, but it's a right now savings of $200,000.

We get an extra $200,000 of state aid. Okay, we're $400,000 better already. The health insurance, what I was talking about, about like Lunch workers getting their health insurance paid for by that fund, that's another $300,000. Deciding body on the right-hand side who has to decide this, the school and the town administrators, I think, are the ones who have to decide that.

Then we get to, let's plan for an override in FY29 and plan for how we're going to use the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund. I think the deciding body's the select board. I mean, nobody's going to write an ink. We, we shall have an override in 3 years.

That's not a thing you do, but you plan for it. I think that's the select board with the advice of the. The town budget committee, and I think also with the device of the advice of the committee, I think they'd like to hear what we think about this and. Reducing the school's request by $900,000.

As I said, I think that can be done with minimal pain. But that's, you know, that's not. It's not for me to say for sure and who's going to decide on that. All involved parties, it's best when all involved parties come together and agree on a budget.

And then the last 2. You could say they're me waving my magic wand and saying more money is going to appear, but we actually will learn by the middle of February what's a good estimate for new growth, what's a good estimate for local receipts. I think what we're seeing here is reasonable estimates gets us from a $2 million deficit to a zero deficit. Again, I'm not trying to spread unrealistic hope.

There's a lot of details that need to be hammered out between school committee, the town administrator, us, Just Dexter, the slug board. But at a high level, I at least see a path. This is one possible path to close the gap. So who's going to be doing what?

The school committee will have a meeting on February 4th. That's what, next week? And I would… Propose to them, say yes to accepting $500,000 in stabilization free cash funding in return for reducing your spending on the budget reserve by $700,000 more.

Say yes to that. Might need more discussion, because I believe that's not where they are now. The select board, they're meeting in about a week and a half. Select Board, adopt this policy on Operating Budget Stabilization Fund and plan for an override in three years and use the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund appropriate to that.

That's not gonna be easy. They're elected representatives. They may not make people happy if they're saying, we're gonna get an override one year earlier. That may not make people happy, but my recommendation would be it's the right thing to do.

town administrator and the town assessors before the middle of February, get more information on car taxes. I believe the car tax bills are sent out like right around now. So we have a good idea of what the local receipts are going to be. And the town assessors are going to give us a new growth forecast in the next couple of weeks.

And then action for the warrant committee. One reason I wanted to bring this up tonight is maybe we'll want to take a vote to give some guidance to our fellows in town. We may want to take a vote on Monday to see things like the operating budget stabilization fund policy. Do we think that's a good policy?

Do we want to endorse it? Do we want to endorse, recommend to the select board that they should plan for an override in 2029? We could vote on something like that. It wouldn't be binding, but it would be.

you know, as opposed to 15 of us sitting around and each giving our opinions, it would say the Warrant Committee recommends to the Select Board do this or do that. If we really believe it, it might give the Select Board, you know, give the Select Board something to point to and say, we're gonna plan for an override in 29 and we take the Warrant Committee's recommendation, if that's appropriate. Again, one reason I wanted to get things out tonight is so you can sleep on them and possibly this is a vote we could take on Monday. Is that the last slide?

That's the last slide.

Speaker 6 (01:29:56–01:30:24)

Hey, Jay, you don't need a vote on that, right? And I'm thinking, can't you, as the Warrant Committee Chair, float these ideas with Select Board and School Committee, etc. ? We delay our vote until we're a little bit closer to having the budget numbers be more realistic because you know may as a ways off we don't have to have the, we don't have to have the warrant finalized until April right so.

Speaker 1 (01:30:26–01:31:24)

I guess my response would be, we're not voting on anything that's going to get set in stone in the warrant. What the vote would be, and yes, I can and have and will continue to, as an individual, as the Warrant Committee chair, I sometimes wonder, what can I say as the chair? When am I representing the whole Warrant Committee? you know, a guy who put together a spreadsheet in his basement.

I can and have and will continue to put these ideas forward. It might have a little more heft if it was the Warrant Committee saying it officially, and even if, how many are on us now, 10? Even if there are 10 of us, and let's say five of us are outspoken, we all say we like that, it's a little bit, we don't have to vote on it. It might give a little more heft to it if we do.

I don't know if that answered the question you're asking. I think, yeah, sorry go ahead Julian.

Speaker 4 (01:31:24–01:31:31)

I think even the issue of whether or not it's something we want to vote on, I think would be a good discussion for, you know, maybe Monday after we've had some time.

Speaker 1 (01:31:32–01:31:45)

To digest in another, and maybe this is just a. Oh, I can remember previous warrant committee meetings where we've spent 45 minutes discussing whether or not we should vote. So let's not do that. But go on.

I'm sorry.

Speaker 4 (01:31:45–01:33:14)

No, it's fine. I just, I would be curious to get other people's input on this, but I feel like there's been an emphasis in your presentation on, like, oh, would people be unhappy that we, you know, if we, if we move the override up a year. But I think you somewhat contradicted yourself, whereas you said, like, no, one's going to no one's saying, you know, setting in stone, there will be an override at any time. So, yes, I know that 20, you know, F.

Y. 30 was sort of the year sort of floated. in the conversations last year around the override and how far it might get us. But I don't know, personally, I did not sit there and put override, you know, in my calendar for FY30.

Like, I don't want us to overthink this idea of potentially moving the override up a year when, to your point, it was never a set in stone thing to begin with. Like, we all know things change. We all see it every day in our own personal financial situation. So I just want to caution us a little bit or I guess that's my based on my sort of memories and understanding of what was presented last year.

I was not sitting there being like FY 30 it is and don't you dare come at me a year earlier. So, I don't know if people have a different impression, you know, then, yeah, that that might inform how we think about things and message things. But personally, I, like, 2930, whatever I just, I don't want the schools to have to cut 26 positions or et cetera, et cetera.

Speaker 5 (01:33:16–01:33:35)

Yeah, I just I think I just like knowing when is reasonable to expect something and I think what Jay laid out tonight gives us a good sense of. Okay, so that we're not too far behind 2029 is what it looks like. You know, I think if we can get to that to be able to set expectations, I think that's the best way to go about it.

Speaker 4 (01:33:39–01:33:41)

I see Lee Michael has his hand raised.

Speaker 6 (01:33:43–01:34:59)

I agree with both of those comments. I think we got here because we haven't been great at forecasting and frequently stabilization, I'm sorry, frequently overrides are talked about, you know, the year before they need to be done. People try to start getting people excited and sort of on board with it. I'm all for trying to forecast it out a little bit further so that we can be a little more normalized in how that process works since it really is a regular part of our budgeting.

The comment I made earlier about needing to do a vote on Monday, what I'm struggling with, Jay, is that The select board and everybody else, everybody's already bought into this concept. What you're basically pitching is what town meeting and the voters of Milton already voted on in terms of creating the budget stabilization fund. We agreed some amount of money would go into it and some amount of money would come out of it. I don't think we have enough information right at this point to say what amount needs to come out over the next couple of years.

that's going to come together over the next two months. We already have the framework in place, so why vote to say we agree with the framework?

Speaker 1 (01:35:04–01:37:27)

Two things. One is the You know, remember I sort of said there's a baseline and then there's what happens if we add to it. I think the baseline has been very fuzzy. And when I hear the town administrator say, oh, if we put in a million dollars, we can then just add a quarter million to it every year.

I'm saying add a quarter million to what? So number one is I'd like the baseline to be less fuzzy and more concrete, if you know what I mean by baseline. And the second, yeah, the second one is, The rate that we will pull it out is dependent on how long we think it'll be for an override. Mr.

Milano, I believe, said at the select board 2 days ago. Contribute a 1Million dollars now and pull out a quarter million dollars in the next 4 years. That implies assuming an override is going to be 4 years from now in 2030. So.

We, whoever we is, needs to agree. Is it 2030 or is it 2029? That's going to have a big impact on do we pull out $800,000 this year or do we pull out $1.2 million this year? I don't know if that answered your question, but that's That's going to affect this year's budget and the school committee six days from now will be meeting and talking about their budget and it would be nice for them to know.

Well, I guess they won't know by that point, but it would be nice for them to know. Hey, there's a possibility of an override 1 year sooner and therefore we get, you know, not we, not the schools, but the town gets 400,000 hours more this year or not. And the schools are very concerned about not only F. Y.

27, but F. Y. 28 F. Y.

29 and going forward. And again, if we, whoever the, we is. agrees on an override in 29, I think we're good for next year and the year after. If we don't, I think even if we pull it together for this year, we're going to suffer next year and we're going to suffer more the year after.

That's what I've heard the school say. I've heard the school finance committee say that. If they knew we're aiming for a 29 override instead of a 30 override, they'd be able to sleep a little bit better when it comes to looking at next year and the year after. I have no idea if that answered your question.

Speaker 6 (01:37:29–01:37:44)

It's really a gray area. What we're going to end up doing depends on a lot of variables that have yet to come to fruition, one of which is the school board getting on board with your plan, right?

Speaker 8 (01:37:49–01:37:56)

Brian? Is there a date that the school board is going to have their budget done or closer to being complete?

Speaker 1 (01:37:58–01:38:42)

Here's what I've heard. They want to know where things stand before fall, before February break, mid to late February. They, because they don't know if they're gonna have overrides. They don't know if they're gonna, sorry, what did I say?

They don't know if they're gonna have layoffs. And they want to give people a heads up before fall break if they expect. To have layoffs, or if they say that's a possibility. Yeah, and so they're only there's only going to be 1 school committee budget between now and then and that's 6 days from today.

Um, so your question was, when will they know their budget?

Speaker 8 (01:38:43–01:38:49)

They will be closer to the final answer. So you said February. Yeah.

Speaker 1 (01:38:49–01:39:33)

I don't know if they'll have a final answer. So I guess they'll have something they think is pretty close to final at that point because they'll want to inform people you're on the list for layoffs because we know there are X number of layoffs. And I'm not trying to spread undue hope. That's why I'd like to get heads together as soon as possible to say, I've got my thoughts, town administrator has their thoughts, school committee, finance committee has their thoughts, is it reasonable to say no layoffs, fewer layoffs, what?

Sorry, again, I don't know if I answered your question.

Speaker 8 (01:39:33–01:39:45)

The win is February. I'll go back, I'd just like to see the details on the budget, what's driving it. Expenses, details. I think it's important.

Speaker 1 (01:39:46–01:40:08)

But keep in mind, so We only have a say on what they're spending, on the total amount, not what they're spending it on. So we could tell them, we could shower them with gold, and they still might decide to lay off 100 people. I'm not, again, not trying to cause a panic in the streets, but they decide what to spend it on.

Speaker 8 (01:40:09–01:40:18)

I mean, like headcount. Did they add 50 people last year, and now they want to get rid of 26 this year? I don't really know. I don't know the answers to that.

I'd be curious.

Speaker 1 (01:40:18–01:40:57)

Yeah, I don't know either. I don't know the beginning of the school year. They left a number of positions unfilled. I don't know where that stands right now.

I don't know, but no, there's there's. On one extreme, there's things that aren't our business, and then there's things that are sort of interesting to know, and then there's things that help us set the budget, and there's things that are definitely our business. Somewhere on that continuum is things like, I absolutely think it's relevant to know, did they reduce their headcount at the beginning of the year? Where does that stand now?

What's their headcount? What kind of headcount are they looking at for next year? I think that's a straightforward question and one that's reasonable to ask.

Speaker 4 (01:40:58–01:42:10)

Yeah. I think there are a lot of moving parts here and I think that part of the. Urgency here is like, yes, Lee, Michael, there are. Factors that we will not know about.

Final numbers for a number of months, but the. If there are going to be layoffs in the school, those decisions are being made like. in the near future, so is there an opportunity for this committee to, you know, look at Jay's numbers he presented tonight, do our due diligence, whatever, over the weekend, talk on Monday, and if we think there is a viable path forward here that maybe would give these schools the option to not have to lay off all the people that they may be planning to, I mean, again, I don't know, I don't have any insider information on that, but, you know, that to me is why we can't just wait for the numbers to, the final numbers to come in in the next few months, because then the opportunity for, to potentially avoid things like layoffs is gone.

Speaker 1 (01:42:14–01:43:28)

And one thing we might make a decision on, I said earlier in a slide that, in my opinion, as far as funding that stabilization fund, in my opinion, the choices are they can fund it with, I'll say 700,000 with their operating expenses, or the town can fund it with half a million dollars in free cash. Not both, one or the other. That's my opinion, is that it's one or the other, not both. If the whole warrant committee agrees with me, that might be an easier, decision for them to make because if they're choosing between $700,000 in this account from the operating budget, if they think we get half a million dollars from the town and we could also put in $700,000 from the operating budget, they might think that's a good idea.

They might think that's a fiscally prudent idea. But if they think, well, our choice is take a half a million dollars from the town or lose that half a million dollars and put the money in our savings account, that might lead them towards agreeing with me, us, that they should take the stabilization money from the town and use their operating budget for operations.

Speaker 7 (01:43:28–01:44:24)

Yeah, but this comes back to the question. I think that makes perfect sense. And I think that's a really good choice and just, you know, alternative. But I still am hung up on why an individual department has a stabilization of fund.

I understand why they have revolving funds, you know, because they have to take in income for certain things, and then they have to pay out expenses for certain things. But a stabilization fund at the department level Kind of, I'm not sure I understand that, and I would like to understand how the school department uses that stabilization fund, because I guess a third choice would be to say, well, you shouldn't fund a stabilization fund in the school department at all. Like, how does that make sense? But I would like to maybe understand how they plan to use it or how they do use it, because I think that would help to have greater confidence about how those funds might get allocated.

Speaker 1 (01:44:26–01:44:32)

I do have to apologize. My headphones died and I lost about half of that, but I think I got your- Can I answer?

Speaker 8 (01:44:32–01:44:54)

Yes. I think I know the answer because it was voted on last year for the first time. It was put in there as a safety valve in case they went over budget. My recollection is I think the Warrant Committee has to approve it in total for them to use the stabilization fund.

Jay might probably know.

Speaker 1 (01:44:54–01:45:02)

If we're talking about the new fund we set up last year, it's the school committee and the select board. So the select board would be the check on them for that.

Speaker 8 (01:45:02–01:45:06)

Maybe the town one is. Okay. But they have to vote on it.

Speaker 7 (01:45:08–01:45:15)

So if they get unforeseen expenses in a given year and they go over budget, they use this funds to pay those funds, those bills.

Speaker 8 (01:45:15–01:45:27)

That was the idea. Yeah. Because it kept, well, right, for issues like this, I guess. Yeah, okay.

Or, I don't know, other things.

Speaker 7 (01:45:27–01:45:39)

So if that's how they use it, and that's the purpose, and that's how funds can get spent out of it, then I think that's okay, and I support the way Jay funded the choice that I think makes sense to present.

Speaker 1 (01:45:42–01:46:00)

Yeah, I was being a little vague on, do we give the half a million dollars to their account that they totally control or this new account that is controlled by them with a slot board? I'm purposely being a little vague about what that is. I don't know if that'll be a deal breaker or what. Elaine, did you have something you want to say?

Speaker 9 (01:46:03–01:46:06)

No, the moment has sort of passed. Thanks. Okay.

Speaker 1 (01:46:07–01:46:22)

I think this has been a good discussion. I think we have things to talk about on Monday. It's ten minutes till nine. On Monday, I think we'll be talking about the police budget.

Lorraine, I'll put you on the spot, are we going to be talking about the capital budget on Monday?

Speaker 11 (01:46:25–01:46:45)

Um, you know, I, I can sort of put up what they did for spreadsheets, but they actually said today we didn't take any votes yet. It's not doing that for another week. Um, cause I asked the, to Nick, um, if they were coming to the meeting and he said that it still hasn't, the numbers haven't finalized yet. Okay.

Speaker 1 (01:46:45–01:47:00)

Well, let's chat. I think it would be, would be nice to get an update. Um, uh, yeah. So I appreciate people taking their time out for this.

Irregular meeting, hopefully it was a good use of time. Lee-Michael?

Speaker 6 (01:47:00–01:47:55)

Yeah, just one suggestion for something that we might want to discuss on Monday. We're in a tight situation because the forecast wasn't great, and should somebody's head roll because of that? There's, there's not no one to blame somebody you know some somehow this happened to everybody signed on to whatever spreadsheet was out there and we everybody voted for it but we're going to have to now sell this plan to town meeting. And when we go to them and say.

We need, I kind of think the Warrant Committee is gonna have to come out with a strongly worded statement that says, we shouldn't be in this situation today. We are in it because people made mistakes and those people are either no longer in their positions or somebody shouldn't be in their position anymore. I have a couple of thoughts on that. One of them- We can discuss it on Monday.

I just want to- Okay.

Speaker 1 (01:47:55–01:48:37)

I would go back to what Julia said, which is, To the 1 harm is that there was not a robust discussion of this last year, but 1 benefit is, there's not a robust discussion of this last year. And maybe people aren't thinking that it's going to be an override on 2030 and. You know, a lot can be forgiven if things get worked out. If what I proposed or something close to it smooths everything out.

If there are no layoffs, which I'm not promising, but if there are no layoffs, things get smoothed out, we plan for an override in 2029. I think that could lead to a lot of things being forgiven. Still, I think you're right. Get up.

More committee say, here's what wasn't planned last year. And here's we are communicating this year.

Speaker 6 (01:48:40–01:48:45)

And and we had a giant override last year and came up 2Million dollars short this year. And this is why.

Speaker 1 (01:48:51–01:48:55)

I hear what you're saying. I think. Again, a lot can be forgiven if it works out.

Speaker 6 (01:48:55–01:48:59)

Those people are not going to have the benefit of 20 hours of discussion.

Speaker 12 (01:49:00–01:49:01)

Yeah. OK.

Speaker 6 (01:49:01–01:49:03)

OK? So just something to think about.

Speaker 12 (01:49:03–01:49:04)

OK.

Speaker 1 (01:49:08–01:49:18)

Any other discussion? We will meet again on Monday. Motion to adjourn? Motion to adjourn.

Wave if you want to adjourn. Bye. Good night. Bye.

Speaker 12 (01:49:18–01:49:21)

Good night. Night. Bye.

Speaker 2 (01:49:28–01:49:28)

you