Board: Climate Action Planning Committee
Date: 2024-03-21
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:49–01:25)
So I will call this, what month are we in, March? March, I think, of the Climate Action Planning Committee meeting to order. It's 6.05 p.m. Welcome, everybody.
It's good to see you again. And our first agenda item for this evening is to approve the minutes from the February meeting. Everybody have a chance to review. I know, Parker, thank you for your updates.
Did anybody else have any changes? I'm all there.
Speaker 2 (01:25–01:26)
Approval, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 3 (01:27–01:27)
Great.
Speaker 1 (01:27–02:13)
It's not good. And we don't need a roll call vote, right? So, all in favor? Aye.
Motion carries. Motion approved. Great. Now, Second topic, and see where we get with this, is we're still in need of a secretary for the meeting.
And Lisa has offered to take notes for this meeting, but is reluctant to take the role permanently. Have any of you moved on that topic?
Speaker 4 (02:15–02:18)
Could we? rotate this job?
Speaker 1 (02:18–02:28)
I don't know. Thinking about me too? I mean, what's that?
Speaker 2 (02:29–02:30)
The idea of rotating?
Speaker 1 (02:30–02:54)
I mean, it works for me. I think we can punt on voting in a secretary until somebody tells us that we have to. required to act, or maybe once the vacancies are filled, it might be easier to resolve those. So you're doing it today?
Speaker 4 (02:54–02:55)
I am.
Speaker 1 (02:55–04:07)
Do I have a volunteer for April? I'll chase you down after the meeting, perhaps. Okay, so we'll leave it at that. Yes, Ma'am.
Oh, wow. You're the best. Thank you. All right, so that does it for item two.
Now the third move public comment up to the beginning because we have a, well, we have two vacancies. on the committee. One appointed by the Select Board is Stacy Tuck Goodman. And our agenda item after this is to discuss and make a vote on a recommendation to the Select Board.
So this is for the vacancy that is appointed by the Select Board. And I think there are three candidates, and two of them are here to give themselves a brief introduction. Why don't we start in the room here.
Speaker 5 (04:07–05:20)
Hi, my name is Kim Johnson, and I've lived in Milton for over 15 years. My husband's a town meeting member, I have a couple of sons in Milton Public Schools, and I've been meaning to get more involved in the town for a while, and I'd especially like to serve on the Climate Action Committee. I graduated from UMass with a degree in economics and a certificate in environmental planning and I interned at Boston City Hall while I was there in the environment department. My current career is specialty foods, like I sell cheese, but I've always been really interested in environmental issues.
My passion is native plant gardening to support biodiversity and I'm a huge advocate for planting gardens that sustain birds, pollinators, and other wildlife in suburban yards. And I looked over everything that you guys had on, like what we've been working on, and it just seems like a lot of work, and I'd love to contribute to it. I'd be happy to commit a good amount of time to help Milton develop and implement the Climate Action Work Plan. I have strong communication and organizational skills, and a lot of interest in learning more and connecting with people who want to protect Milton and its inhabitants from the effects of climate change.
Thank you very much.
Speaker 6 (05:22–05:30)
Thank you and see that.
Speaker 7 (05:31–06:53)
Hi, can you hear can you hear me? Yes. Okay. Great.
Hi, I'm Steve Hopkins. I am a. I guess, 24-year resident of Milton. We moved in in 2000.
We live on Elliot Street right next to the Ponset River. So climate change is certainly something of interest to us. My background is in industrial organizational psychology. I work for the US Department of Transportation Volpe Center, where I am the head of research and technology there.
And at the at the department, I oversee a number of projects, including those with sustainable fuel and land use transit resilience mobility, different types, including. what happens in disasters and coordinating with FEMA, as well as NEPA-related activities. I have a deep interest in this area. I am on the board of the Brookwood Community Farm for Sustainable Agriculture.
And I also support Boston Children's Hospital on their safety committee. And like I said, we've been in town for 24 years. And we're interested in it. And I can give back in some way, either through this committee or supporting it in a less formal world.
Speaker 6 (06:55–07:06)
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (07:07–08:27)
Well, thank you. Thank you all for coming to speak. And we'll move on to item four, which is to review the applicants for the committee seat and vote on a recommendation to the select board. I think you all should have received the three applications that we've received at this point.
Matt Canucci wasn't able to make this meeting time, but we confirmed his interest in serving on the committee to meet yesterday. So I think we have three candidates to discuss, and I just want to preface this discussion with firm agreement with Kim's comment that there's a lot of work to do and build the structure of these public meetings and the way this committee is set up says we have to choose one person to be on the committee. I do hope that we can work with all three of you in some material capacity. And maybe we can flesh that out a little more when we move on to the public engagement discussion later.
So I'm quite hopeful that we'll be working with all three of you in some way. And then I will pass it on.
Speaker 8 (08:27–08:45)
I just have a question. So there are two vacancies. All right. And what are your names?
Kim. And then gentlemen, Don and I, are applying for one. And these other three people are applying for the other?
Speaker 1 (08:45–09:19)
Well, there are two vacancies. One is appointed by the Chamber of Commerce. And we're voting on a recommendation to the Select Board for their final. I suppose it's possible that we could get in touch with the Chamber of Commerce and say, hey, there are these lovely candidates, why don't you apply to them?
Speaker 3 (09:19–09:34)
Is there a defined number of people for the committee? Or is it possible to even consider to expand the size of the committee to 23 people at this point?
Speaker 2 (09:35–09:43)
I think the select board can do that. We have to make a recommendation to the select board and they could act upon it.
Speaker 9 (09:43–09:50)
But wasn't it voted on at town meeting? Was it voted on at town meeting? No, it was just the select board.
Speaker 2 (09:50–09:53)
I believe we had nine members.
Speaker 1 (09:55–10:00)
Right, so there were seven currently out of the two babies. Right.
Speaker 4 (10:01–10:03)
And we also wanted a student.
Speaker 1 (10:03–10:25)
We talked about, yeah, I didn't remember to put that on the agenda, sort of running out of space. No, I think the general, I think the select work, if we wanted to recommend it, it should be large enough to make that recommendation.
Speaker 9 (10:25–10:47)
So I've been in touch, I'm a member of the chamber and I've reached out to the president and they haven't really found anybody. So I kind of was thinking when I heard specialty cheese, could you theoretically be like, like, is it a business or are you associated with the business?
Speaker 5 (10:47–10:51)
Yeah, but the business is in Lynn's mess.
Speaker 9 (10:52–11:36)
That's OK. Yeah. Because there's nobody interested from the chamber. So but if your approach is from like a business fund, maybe I could call them up and ask them.
Yeah. Yeah. So I don't know what the like why the selectmen wanted someone from the chamber, except for I think it probably had to do with I don't know, commercial buildings, you know. So I don't, I'm not really sure.
And they only meet like once a month. So I could reach out and find out.
Speaker 4 (11:38–11:41)
Well, there's plenty of work to do.
Speaker 9 (11:42–11:55)
But I just, I'm pretty sure no one from the chamber wants to be on, and I didn't go to their last meeting, but I just wanted to double check that they didn't have a member who all of a sudden was interested, but I really asked a lot of people.
Speaker 1 (11:56–12:00)
Well, thank you for that. I didn't realize you'd already been working that room.
Speaker 9 (12:00–12:19)
Yeah, so, well, not through the president, but through the other members. So, you know, people I talked to didn't really have an interest, so. Maybe I'll just reach out more directly just to confirm. Because I think they can have an appointee.
Speaker 2 (12:20–12:54)
Mr. Chairman, following up on these comments, the membership says as selected by the chamber. So it would be inappropriate for us to make a recommendation to the chamber for a person who could be a designated. And I would suggest that we might take that course of action.
Speaker 9 (12:57–13:35)
And I don't know if the chamber has to take a vote on it. I could just forward it to the, or you could forward it to the president. And maybe spin your application a little bit to be business. And you know, through the lens of the business, maybe, I don't know.
Or at least talk to the president and find out. But if they haven't appointed anybody, it's a shame. that we're down one person.
Speaker 2 (13:36–13:56)
So if I may, Mr. Chairman, I would move that the Climate Action Planning Committee requests that the Milton Chamber of Congress appoint a designee to represent it in the Climate Action Planning Committee.
Speaker 1 (13:56–13:58)
And one of these candidates.
Speaker 2 (13:58–13:58)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (13:58–15:38)
Yeah. I think that's why we want to get up to our full numbers. Well, do we want to wait until we have a recommendation? I mean, that was difficult because we got to pick somebody and I don't, I really don't want to because all three of these candidates bring great experience.
I appreciate the sort of non-profit leadership experience that Mr. Panucci and Mr. Jhapakam offer as well. I think that's relevant.
We definitely need help on transportation, which I think is a challenging area to tackle. I did have a chance to meet with Dr. Panucci, who's Until recently, he was the director of Friends of the Blue Nails and serves on the board of that and some other non-profits. He brings a passion for conservation and a lot of network in town as somebody who's been active in a large nonprofit that most people in Milton have heard of.
So I think we have three people here that we love to work with. I suppose the recommendation could be, please expand the number of seats and make them both
Speaker 2 (15:39–15:50)
That would be a separate. But right now we have a motion on the table that's consecutive to have the chamber appoint a designee from among the three candidates.
Speaker 1 (15:51–16:00)
Right. And so just leaving it at that. We'd have to have a vote on the motion. Great.
All in favor?
Speaker 6 (16:01–16:04)
Aye. Aye. Passes. Thank you.
Speaker 9 (16:09–16:37)
So then that would allow, so we'd have to talk to the chamber president and probably send them the three. Now, was there four or did Joe not? Mom, do you know? Yeah, I'm sure.
So then maybe the chamber would pick their, they would review and then pick their designee. Is that how it would go?
Speaker 3 (16:39–17:00)
So I would move then to we recommend to the select board that we increase the size of the committee by one more person so that all three of the candidates could be added.
Speaker 2 (17:01–17:15)
Would you be willing to accept a friendly amendment to have that Your recommendation or your motion have added to it the student member as well? Yes.
Speaker 1 (17:17–17:30)
An additional member and a student. I'm not a student member. I'll second. Well, I'm not going to second.
You have a second?
Speaker 6 (17:31–17:31)
I'll second.
Speaker 1 (17:38–17:41)
Who would appoint a student member?
Speaker 2 (17:44–17:51)
We could ask that the student member be… It's a good question.
Speaker 4 (17:51–17:53)
It could be the school committee.
Speaker 3 (17:54–18:01)
Well, we have a recommendation from the science department of the school.
Speaker 2 (18:02–18:35)
What if the student wanted That would exclude anybody from Milton Academy upon who is a resident of the town of Milton. So we want the student to be a resident of the town of Milton. Or maybe we could say certainly in high school and somehow affiliated with an area associated with the Climate Action Planning Committee. I know we have two environmental forces at the high school.
Speaker 3 (18:42–19:50)
I usually hire a high school kid to work in my company, and I usually write a letter every, it happens every three or four years, where I write a letter to the science department and ask for recommendations of students, And then I interviewed them. I usually get four or five all together to interview and then move forward. I've had very good response from the teachers, or the head of the science department at Milton High School, Milton Academy, Fontan Academy. And the last person I hired happened to be from Fontan.
Before that, I had other schools, too. But also, this is a way that can be done and, in my experience, very good response from the teachers and interest on the part of the students.
Speaker 9 (19:51–20:01)
And if it's just a Milton resident, I mean, they could be BC High, Severian, or Slough. Anywhere else?
Speaker 1 (20:01–20:11)
But just mechanically, it's the recommendation of the student, Milton resident, and their designation would review applications and select them.
Speaker 9 (20:13–20:28)
Well, that's what my question was. Usually, I thought the selectmen review the application, since this is their award. That's why I thought it was a little strange that we were reviewing it. I thought that they would just review, and then they appoint.
Speaker 1 (20:28–20:32)
I don't have a strong opinion. I just want it to be correct. Yeah.
Speaker 2 (20:34–20:38)
In the Conservation Commission, the select committee usually expect a recommendation from the commission.
Speaker 6 (20:39–20:39)
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (20:39–20:54)
So I think that's true of some of the other committees as well, when they have vacancies. So moving what John has posited about them, is they're not going to be in a position to automatically pull something out of the air.
Speaker 9 (20:55–20:58)
Just didn't want to make sure we weren't overstepping.
Speaker 1 (20:58–21:09)
So the select board will appoint these ultimately, but we will provide them with a simple decision.
Speaker 3 (21:10–21:32)
And we could also specifically ask for someone that's a junior so that they have it for two years. That's what I usually do. That makes sense. Or even longer.
they go to school locally, or go to college locally.
Speaker 1 (21:33–21:41)
So can we recap the motion? Should I?
Speaker 4 (21:42–22:33)
Yes, please. OK. So we moved that select board at another person, an adult, and a student who's a resident of Milton going into their junior year, we would, I seconded it, we would ask the local science departments, and perhaps, I mean, I'm going to throw this out there. I mean, we could advertise it elsewhere for students who live in Milton but don't go to school here.
So, we would ask for nominees from science departments. We would provide a recommendation to the select board, and the select board would provide, like, accept that nomination.
Speaker 1 (22:38–22:39)
That's been sent to me.
Speaker 4 (22:40–22:42)
Did I catch it all? Yeah.
Speaker 3 (22:42–22:51)
Okay. I'll volunteer to write the letter to the high schools, okay? Because I have all the information already.
Speaker 10 (22:55–23:05)
All right, hold on, hold on.
Speaker 6 (23:05–23:05)
Okay.
Speaker 2 (23:08–23:23)
It doesn't appear we're asking the select board to increase the size of the climate action committee by two positions to be appointed by the select board upon the recommendation of the climate action committee.
Speaker 1 (23:27–23:29)
Is it to a job or anything?
Speaker 2 (23:31–23:34)
No, it's just a job requirement. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (23:34–24:18)
And we currently have three applications. We're asking for an expansion. One adult, we have one vacancy, one additional student that they select from among the three applicants, and we're going to recommend the Chamber of Commerce and Corporate Affairs. So hopefully all three of these applicants can join.
So we're ready to vote? Great. Thank you very much.
Speaker 9 (24:18–24:31)
So that means we can't really, we won't nominate anybody or vote on anybody until we have the information back from the chamber and the select board.
Speaker 10 (24:33–24:33)
I guess so.
Speaker 9 (24:35–24:39)
Because now we only could really nominate or approve one.
Speaker 1 (24:41–24:57)
Right, and the select board would have to take that up anyway. So perhaps they'll deal with it all in one fell swoop when they do take that. So I think there's a follow-up there too. Just to let them know what we need from them.
Speaker 2 (24:57–25:24)
Yeah. Well, I think it would be pretty easy for Maggie to give it to the chair of the chamber of general public here, the names of the three candidates, and ask them upon the recommendation of the committee to and then we can go forward with the others. Does that make sense? Yes.
Speaker 1 (25:26–25:35)
All right, so are we ready to move on to item five, the presentation from Good Energy on the CDA program contract updates?
Speaker 11 (25:37–25:42)
Allison, are you able to share your screen?
Speaker 12 (25:42–25:42)
Let's see.
Speaker 6 (25:53–25:53)
Everyone see this?
Speaker 3 (25:55–25:55)
Yeah, beautiful.
Speaker 12 (25:59–35:05)
Everybody, my name is Allison McNeil. I'm one of the client managers on the Good Energy team. I'm still getting my voice back, so just bear with me. But lovely to join you all tonight.
Thanks for having me. I mainly handle launches and transitions of programs. and Milton's program. This current contract ends in November of 2024.
So we'll be up for renewal for this coming December. So I'll be working closely with the town. Tonight we have a couple of program updates. And then we'll really dive into this renewable energy percentage question.
And just to preface you all as we walk through this, the decision that we'll be talking about tonight is a recommendation for how much additional renewable energy will be included in the default product in this next upcoming renewal. And let's jump in. So this current contract that we're in began in September of 2021. It had a 10% voluntary renewable added into the default.
Just as a reminder, this default product is what most people end in. It's the automatic enrollment product. So anyone who is on Eversource basic service in the town automatically gets opted into this basic product or this Milton Green default product unless they choose to leave the program opt up to the 100% or opt into the basic. Sorry, we skipped something there.
So this is, we really just put this together to celebrate the program a little bit. What you're looking at here, the blue line that kind of goes all crazy is Eversource's residential rate. This changes every six months. And the green rate, that flat line you see, is Milton's program.
So we've had a 10-cent rate stable since fall of 2021, now coming into the winter of 2024. And it has really provided some serious stability for participants. And we're really proud of that. I don't think anybody could have expected what was going to happen, you know, post fall 2021, but we certainly did not expect that.
And we do want to set expectations that this has been a really volatile two years. for gas and electricity prices. And we don't know what will happen, but we likely can't expect something like this. I mean, this has been such a successful program.
So we just want to set expectations that this has been a really, really successful run. We certainly cannot guarantee savings in the future. We don't know what Eversource basic service rate will be. But really, it's been so fantastic.
This is our program participation. You can see we started the graph here all the way on the right side. You can see the access isn't zero, it's 6,000. So we've grown up to over 7,000 enrollments over the past few years.
And enrollments stay really high. They dip typically, you know, as Eversource rates change. That's one of the features we're proud of in the program is that you can leave at any time and come back into the program and people take use of that. But we're currently well above where we started.
And I'm just trying to fly through this so we can get to the renewable energy discussion. But currently, Milton receives, they have NextEra as their electricity supplier. So that's all the basic electricity or what we call the residual mix comes from NextEra. The additional renewables, so that extra 10% in the default product and all the additional renewables in the 100% product that make up that mix come from Green Energy Consumers Alliance.
They source from more local renewable energy projects. And you can see this map here on the screen on the left is all the projects that they're purchasing from. So they really do try to keep it as local as possible to Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and New Hampshire. They also don't include biomass, which is included in the class 1 renewable energy standards.
for the state, and they also provide tax deductible receipts on all voluntary renewables. So for the 100% green folks, that would be all of their electricity, and for the 10% green, that would be 10% of that would be tax deductible. And this will be also an option that we'll see in the upcoming bids. So this is another, you know, Milton can continue with Green Energy Consumers Alliance, or they could just bid with a new supplier.
So, we're looking at here is really just how other communities have used their contract to increase or maintain the amount of additional renewables in their default products. We have some crazy outliers. We have our Brooklines, which are the overachievers who want to have 20 up to 35%. additional renewables, certainly something to take into consideration is when these folks went out to bid, so how much savings they're still allowed to give their residents while increasing the renewable energy in the default product.
But we still have folks, Dedham, Fairhaven, Westford, who have maintained and they're happy with the way the program is. So just to give you an idea of what other folks are doing, And then we could spend a little bit of time just breaking down what the Renewable Energy Standard is for Massachusetts. What you're looking at here is from, you know, a decade 2020 to 2030, the change that's scheduled for the Renewable Energy Standard. All of the colored boxes here, everything that's in color is a part of the Renewable Energy Standard.
And what part it is, is in the legend up top. But the gray is what we call residual mix. That's our base power. That's fossil fuels.
And part of the Renewable Energy Standard goal is to decrease how much fossil fuels are ending up in our electricity. Right now, these green bars here, these 10% are what Milton has in their default product. And as we go forward, as the renewable energy standard increases, and then we add 10% or 15% or 20% on top of that, we get closer and closer to closing that gap and getting fossil fuels out of our mix. You'll see by 2030, you would only need 7% of additional renewables to be completely clean energy, which is exciting.
There is a waste mix in here. It's still burning, but it's considered renewable energy by the state standards. So if we went with green energy consumers lines, this would not be in there, which some folks are excited about. And then finally, and I'll leave some space for questions at the end here if we want to go back to anything.
But we just threw together a slide for you to see what the real impact of adding renewables into your default looks like for people. When we set this program in 2021, we went up to bid, the rec costs were a little bit cheaper than what they are now. So then we were seeing about 37 a rec, now we're seeing about $40 a rec. So to add 10% in for the average user, it would be about $33 extra above the basic cost, above basic service cost.
And as we go up, of course, that increases. And then also you'll see in 2027. what that would mean for closing that gap, getting the fossil fuels out, how close we'd be to totally clean electricity. We threw 2027 in there as a date because we're typically expecting to see two and three year options.
And over the next couple of weeks, we'll be having conversations with the town, but ultimately, we'll probably lean on you all to have a suggestion for them for what additional renewable energy you suggest to have in the default product. So I think that's just about it for me, but I'm happy to go back, walk through anything, or just have you facilitate the conversation.
Speaker 1 (35:06–35:31)
Great. Well, thank you so much for that. I think we'll move into item six, which is the discussion of this and potentially vote on that recommendation. And please stay on so we can ask you questions and maybe keep the slides handy.
I know I have a couple of questions. Would anybody else like to ask questions?
Speaker 3 (35:33–35:49)
Or any comments? Why is the kilowatt per hour cost so high here, or much higher, for example? In Ohio, we pay $0.04 per kilowatt hour.
Speaker 1 (35:52–35:54)
So can we get those prices back up on the screen?
Speaker 12 (35:55–36:00)
Sure. And just to be clear, these are for the additional renewables. This is not
Speaker 1 (36:01–36:37)
Um, oh, sorry, my screen is not 40 cents. I mean, yeah, for anybody who may be. Curious, but yes, it's electricity prices are much higher than other states. So the dollar question.
Alton, do you have any answer to why Massachusetts electricity is more expensive?
Speaker 12 (36:38–37:21)
Great question. Massachusetts is definitely one of the most expensive places to receive electricity in the United States. I think we're second or maybe third to Hawaii and California. However, I will just say in the past two years, pretty much everywhere we've seen prices really be all over the place.
The Russia invading Ukraine has specifically put a strain everywhere, but it wouldn't be, you know, specific to Ohio and Massachusetts. But happy to take that back to my team. We also do have aggregations, Illinois, Ohio as well. So it's a very different market than Massachusetts.
But I am happy to take that back to my team.
Speaker 1 (37:27–38:16)
And just so that we're crystal clear, when I said 0.37 cents per kilowatt hour, those are basis points, right? That's not 37 cents per kilowatt hour we're talking about. It's the price per kilowatt hour that people will be paying on the next contract. What we're looking at is the additional cost per kilowatt hour that would be added, expected to be added if we went with 10, 15, or 20%.
And so this is less, in all of these cases, less than one penny per kilowatt hour for the additional.
Speaker 12 (38:16–38:44)
Yep, that's correct. And just to clarify the top line here where you see 37 cents, this is our current contract. So that's what we bid on in 2021. Currently we're seeing it's more like 40, well, it'd be 0.4 cents per kilowatt hour.
It's not 40 cents. So it's gone up a bit in the past few years, but yes, everything is still less than a cent that would be added to our base rate.
Speaker 1 (38:45–39:29)
And you have in the version of the slide show that you delivered to the select board. I think there was a slide that showed aggregate savings for residents in the first three years and it's approaching $10 million per call. So almost $1,300 per household that was participating. So in light of that, giving a little bit of that back in the extra renewable energy, which is the reason that this program exists so that we can get those clean energy benefits.
It's like giving back a very small portion of the savings, which can't be guaranteed in the future, of course.
Speaker 12 (39:30–39:50)
Right, yep, that's right. And in the graph I showed earlier of just showing Eversource rates really having their way over the past few years, this is the result of that is, you know, right now we're 7 cents below basic service rates right now. And we haven't even come close in the past, you know, two years.
Speaker 9 (39:54–40:15)
So is this both for residential and commercial? Yes, that's right. And what about municipal? Is this what the town is on as well?
I think they have their own municipal contracts. So maybe someone could speak. Yeah, why wouldn't the town be on this too?
Speaker 11 (40:16–40:22)
Yeah, I'm not sure what we're on, but I could find that for sure.
Speaker 9 (40:22–40:24)
Does the town have a bigger savings?
Speaker 11 (40:24–40:34)
I mean, it would be similar to this, but I'm not sure if we're on the basic or if we've elected to go higher or not.
Speaker 1 (40:34–40:51)
So we discussed this briefly with Nick Mojano and he did say that basically do their own power purchase agreements, and I don't believe that they're adding additional renewable energy. That's another topic for another day for this committee, I guess.
Speaker 8 (40:52–41:03)
But who is going to contract with them? When it comes time to renew this in Milton, who signs off?
Speaker 1 (41:03–41:17)
Oh yeah, the select board will ultimately approve the go-to-market strategy, right? Let's say what to bid on and then you'll go ahead. Do you maybe want to speak for a moment about what the bidding process looks like?
Speaker 12 (41:18–42:40)
Sure. Yeah. So over the next couple of weeks, we'll be having a couple of meetings with the town. And the first of which is really to set expectations of if we know going in, if we want to have 10, 15 percent, you know, those are the things we're going to look for.
We'll also talk about term, see what looks good. We probably won't be expecting. I mean, we've had almost over three years of a 10 cent rate. Realistically, we might not be expecting 10 cent rates to come back.
So we'll really be having a conversation around what's the bottom line that we absolutely can't press on if we don't want to. sacrifice any of these additional renewables. And then we'll have an indicative meeting where we'll look at indicative pricing a couple of days before the bid. You know, the market does change pretty rapidly, but typically if there's just a few business days, we'll have a good sense of what it'll be.
And that meeting will probably, you know, get real and talk about realistically, can we accommodate whatever renewables we want to add and what term lengths would work for the town. So those will be happening. I think our bid day may be April 3rd or 2nd or 3rd. So we'll be looking in the next couple of weeks to have this finalized.
Speaker 9 (42:44–43:15)
So going back to the municipal, so I'm kind of a firm believer in that the residents shouldn't be asked to do more than what the town, or we should be doing the same as our municipal. So I'm a little concerned that we're following a different route. But also, have the residents who've opted into this program been asked what their preference is? Because I didn't opt in.
Speaker 12 (43:17–44:06)
Yep, so at the beginning of the program, we send a customer notification letter letting folks know that you're on Eversource basic service and these folks are automatically opted in unless they opt out. And then we typically do once a quarter, a sweep where we send out the same letter to folks who've opened account or have recently come off of third-party supply that they'll be automatically enrolled. But this is an opt-out program, so once you're in, unless you decide to opt out, you're in the program. And with this price change, we, of course, are messaging this.
We want folks to know that the prices is changing for this new contract. But if you're in the program, you're in. So if, when prices change, people don't have to affirmatively opt back in or anything.
Speaker 9 (44:08–44:19)
And so do the customers get a chance or to, weigh in to see if they want to increase it from 10% to 15% or 20%?
Speaker 12 (44:20–44:57)
They don't get an opportunity to Give their feedback on changing the default percentage, but they always have an option to go to our Milton basic, which is the same electricity that ever source offers. It's a little bit cheaper than our default product and it includes no additional renewables and you could change that at any time. We also do when we do this. Upcoming renewal 30 days before folks will get this this letter and have this announcement.
So they'll have 30 days to change to leave the program or go to basic if they want to hang on to those more savings.
Speaker 9 (44:58–45:17)
And I guess maybe it's a question for the select board. Because if they're going to choose to vote. You know, to change the default. And maybe this is a question for them.
What is their outreach going to be to the customers?
Speaker 1 (45:18–47:22)
To me, I think this is a very powerful program for tackling climate change. I think the fairness considerations are addressed by the fact that it's a very low friction process to opt out if paying 0.4 cents per kilowatt hour extra in this case, to save $1,300 over the course of three years for like $33. If that's too much for somebody, and I can certainly understand that there will be people in town who are very price sensitive, who will take that step. But I think the majority, as you can sort of see from the numbers, the majority of residents are not too concerned about this.
They're not really paying attention. It's a small amount of money. that has a big impact on the emissions intensity of our town's use of electricity, 14% of emissions. And I see our role as recommending tactics and strategies to reduce emissions.
I think the select board has to weigh that against all sort of needs and considerations and the politics of it. I think it's our role to make recommendations. This is a very straightforward strategy for reducing emissions. It's one that if anybody feels harmed by it, they can fix it in five minutes on the internet or a phone call.
And the impact on the average household's budget is measured in tens of dollars, not hundreds or thousands. So I had it on my shortlist of key action recommendations to recommend that it be pushed up to 20%. I would certainly like to make that recommendation, but it takes some more discussion personally. There's at least one other perspective.
Speaker 8 (47:22–47:51)
Excuse my ignorance. So I live in Melbourne and Eversource is my source of electricity. I automatically get this. percentage of what they're providing from a renewable resource, all right?
And anyway, if I don't want this, I just say, I don't want to use Eversource, I want to use another provider, all right?
Speaker 1 (47:52–48:26)
So Eversource manages the wires, no matter who your supplier is. So what you're changing is your electricity supplier. Massachusetts has had competitive suppliers for a long time, so you could, like when you get a mail from NextEra, that's a supplier change, or basically, it's still Everstore's managing the wires that come into your home, but the generation charge on your bill moves to a different client.
Speaker 9 (48:27–48:30)
And I think it says on the bill who your supplier is.
Speaker 1 (48:31–49:06)
So, for example, in February 2021, or 2022, sorry, after the invasion of Ukraine, we had just gotten on this, so we were fixed at a price of 10 something cents per kilowatt hour. Every source basic jumped up to 25 cents. Nobody in Milton paid that 25 cents who was opted into this program automatically. If anyone didn't even realize how much money there was.
Because people don't keep an eye on it at all, right?
Speaker 4 (49:07–49:22)
who were in the plan, did not opt out, increased the amount of renewable energy that the town was using over fossil fuels, and they saved a lot of money.
Speaker 1 (49:22–49:50)
And technically the way it works is they use that little bit of extra money to buy renewable energy credits, which are markers of one renewable energy credit per megawatt hour of clean electricity generated on the New England grid. And they're like tradable instruments. So they buy those through an energy supplier, and then there's a renewable energy credit supplier. That's basically the question is how much.
Speaker 4 (49:51–49:54)
That's what my company does, that I work for.
Speaker 9 (49:55–50:38)
Yeah, so my concern is only like we, you guys, we've prepared a you know, a whole public engagement plan for the, so I would think though, increasing from 10% to 20% should also have some type of engagement plan, you know, when you're changing. And again, because I opted out, you know, I'm not comfortable really going from 10 to 20, even though I understand it all. because I just don't know if the average resident would understand that.
Speaker 1 (50:40–51:04)
I think the power of this program is that they don't have to. They only have to understand that if they don't like the extra money they're paying, they can go on miltonca.com and opt out or go down, and there was an outreach process when the program started. Is there going to be another one?
Speaker 12 (51:06–51:28)
Yes, yep, there will be 30 days before we'll have a letter dropping in folks mailbox updating them that you know prices are changing and they have 30 days if they don't want to stay in the program. As well as all the other campaigns that we did at launch that would be social media public meetings, you know anything really to tap the networks that you're concerned about.
Speaker 4 (51:29–51:34)
And this goes before the select board for a vote, right?
Speaker 1 (51:34–51:36)
Yes, I'll make the ultimate decision about which.
Speaker 4 (51:37–51:48)
So citizens who are plugged into the news of the slug for the business of the slug for it, but to have that, right, I mean, that same right of the opportunity to hear this public meeting.
Speaker 1 (51:48–51:56)
I know it's not. Yeah, we're not. I doubt that the entire town is.
Speaker 9 (51:56–52:19)
I'm pretty sure no one's plugged in. I think it takes more than one Slickman's meetings for people to get plugged in. And again, I don't really have an opinion. But I would think that maybe, if you go up to 20% and the people opt out, are you doing more harm by staying in at the 10%?
Speaker 1 (52:19–52:21)
That would be the main question.
Speaker 9 (52:22–52:27)
More people might opt out and then we're not helping the overall situation.
Speaker 1 (52:27–53:08)
I think that's the real question from our perspective. Because if you… certainly took it to an extreme, put it at a thousand percent, which you can do, right? Then most people would opt out.
I suspect with those tiny, I mean, all three options were less than a penny per kilowatt hour. And with the level of price sensitivity that we observed at the first program, I doubt that it would trigger a massive wave of lockouts to increase it.
Speaker 9 (53:09–53:18)
Have you seen, from your perspective, when you go from a 10% to a 20%, have you seen people opting out in certain communities?
Speaker 12 (53:20–54:34)
Typically not. I mean, if they do, we have like four to 10% of folks in both, you know, the 100% and basic for most of these towns. So usually these people were going to make a choice regardless of if they were in the program or not. So mostly we find that people in the default are in the default because, you know, like we're talking about, they don't pay attention and by not paying attention for these past couple of years, they've been saving, you know, now seven cents.
So, typically, it works in their favor. But, and I'll just maybe go back to this slide just in case it helps that 10%, you know, come 2027 is only 15% of fossil fuels left in your mix. So, 10% as the renewable energy standard continues to increase still makes a big hole Of course, 20% is even greater, you'd have 5% left. But it also, at that point, we could really talk about if the 100% product, if we might need to reformulate that, because our default is getting to that point of nearly 100% renewable.
Speaker 9 (54:36–55:09)
To be honest, the only reason why I opted out was because I didn't know enough about it. you know, in any program that is, you're automatically in until you walked out, that kind of makes me nervous. So I'm probably the one you probably want to talk to, to be like, Oh, why, you know? And so, because I did, you know, talk to Nick earlier today about it.
And I said, I just did it because I didn't trust my head, trust issues. with the government. And so I wasn't really trusting.
Speaker 6 (55:09–55:13)
So that's just where I am.
Speaker 9 (55:13–55:33)
And, you know, and I do actually pay attention to my, because my business is, I only have electric, it's electric key. So I'm always paying attention to my bills. So that's the only reason that I chose was I just got nervous.
Speaker 1 (55:34–55:35)
You can still opt back in.
Speaker 9 (55:36–55:42)
I know, yes. I'm open for change. I am open to change.
Speaker 1 (55:43–56:12)
Anybody else have comments? So I'd like to offer a motion that we recommend 20% for the reasons that I mentioned. Okay, should we take a vote? Actually go around, because I feel like this won't be unanimous.
John? Yes.
Speaker 2 (56:12–56:12)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (56:12–56:14)
Okay, good.
Speaker 9 (56:14–56:23)
I'm just going to abstain only because I don't have enough information. I'm not for or against. I just, I'm not comfortable making a decision.
Speaker 1 (56:26–57:02)
Yes. I'll vote yes. And it's a recommendation, I think, in terms of this is a strong strategy for reducing emissions. I think the select board will need to consider more information about cost impact.
I think a big thing that's missing here that they will have visibility into is what's the what kind of prices are we able to get in this market, right? I think it will be a different decision if it's a huge increase than if it's variable.
Speaker 9 (57:02–57:12)
And I would like to know why they're staying at 10%. Why are not our municipal buildings? What's their rationale? So that was the other question I had.
Speaker 1 (57:14–57:22)
We should certainly press them on that. I think it just locks in another contractor. before I asked.
Speaker 9 (57:22–57:29)
So did they discuss this, you know, before they locked into another contract? I'm not sure. Or what their reasoning was?
Speaker 1 (57:31–57:59)
I'm not sure. I'm not familiar with that discussion. Yeah. OK.
Thank you, everyone. That was fun. So let's move on to item seven, which is a discussion and potential vote on the public engagement plan. Did everybody have a chance to review?
Let's see.
Speaker 10 (58:00–58:10)
Keep going for myself. Yes. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (58:16–01:01:18)
So. I'll just give you a little a little overview on what was going through my mind as I rewrote this. You'll recall that we had a sort of draft public engagement plan. It's mostly written by Tracy Dyk-Redmond and I think coming back to it but after about a month and a half of doing more public outreach, first with the sort of expert and stakeholder conversations, and then more recently I've been talking to a lot of people about the Specialized Option Code.
It gave me a more realistic sense of how much effort is required to actually do this. So I tried to simplify and hear some more clarity on what the goals are, and also make a change to the timelines. I think before, we had very tight windows for doing the different kinds of outreach of three months at a time. I feel like all of them are going to need to be ongoing.
sort of forever. Just as I go down the rabbit hole on one, like, just one of these recommendations getting into the details, meeting all the stakeholders, going through the town process, it's just a lot. So I started to think it's not realistic to have done that for everything that's going to be in this plan before we put together a plan. I think at the last meeting around you, you mentioned, before we do, we're out of opportunities in some kind of a draft plan.
So the big changes are, I took out some details in this timeline. I have a draft plan being written by sort of the next month or two. That would be the end of it. We just need to get it down on paper and begin the more or less ongoing process of engaging the community on the specifics to reply and ultimately implement it.
So that's enough of an introduction. Did folks have a chance to read it? Is there any feedback? Any suggestions for modifications?
Any questions?
Speaker 8 (01:01:18–01:02:04)
for our particular piece of this, the conservation piece. I would be more comfortable moving ahead with community engagement activities after we had an agreement among key stakeholder organizations that we've been consulting with, and there are only four of them, so you know, I would propose convening some sort of meeting around our proposal, get everybody's input, a lot of which I had already, and then I'll feel more comfortable moving out with this.
Speaker 1 (01:02:08–01:02:11)
What timeline would you propose?
Speaker 8 (01:02:13–01:02:22)
This is all Ron again, I do apologize to him.
Speaker 9 (01:02:22–01:02:22)
He does it all.
Speaker 8 (01:02:26–01:03:26)
But anyway. Yeah. I could, you know, circulate a new draft of our document and just try to get it all done by email or communications, but I think it would be more, it would be more solid if we had some sort of meeting where the four groups, mainly the community, the town conservation people, the Friends of the Blue Hills, the Ponson River Association, and the DRCs, which is kind of a ladder to this. But the other three have been really enthusiastic and given me good recommendations.
So I think if we had a meeting, it would be a good thing to do before we went out and told everybody else.
Speaker 1 (01:03:28–01:04:15)
Yeah. So just putting that in the framework of what's written down on the page, because I tried to make it general enough that it's like reality could kind of be shoehorned into this. I had expert and stakeholder conversations beginning in January and beyond that, because you're just going to need to keep doing that. Every single item on the plan to the extent that it's at all complicated is going to take a while to work through the details.
I have on your form, technical working groups to provide input and consultation on this topic here. Is that basically what you're doing by convening these?
Speaker 8 (01:04:17–01:05:32)
Yeah, I mean, yeah, it's just, it's a technical working group, but I guess I would just feel better about having this plan be vetted and approved by this group, at least in draft. And then I could go on and actually do the work. But as a first step, again, it would just be good to have approval of the plan, the conservation plan, the climate action plan. That's all I'm saying.
So it's not… I could say we form a technical working group, but if we start sending it out and… before the plan is even committed, we get comments, critiques, support, whatever, from a variety of different people across the town. It kind of, for me, confuses the process.
Speaker 1 (01:05:32–01:07:20)
Right. So another thing, and this was in Tracy's plan, but I tried to clarify it here. There's a broad outreach that's distinguished from public feedback on the draft climate action plan. The broad outreach has different goals.
Goals being two, there are five goals. One is spreading general awareness of science and expected impact of climate change. Necessary private action, common law centers, roadmap, just the sort of general content of our work, right? Second, to gather data on residents' climate beliefs, knowledge of solutions, willingness to make changes, obstacles.
This sort of general information gathering, and that is the focus of broad outreach, which could begin basically now, on this timeline I've got here, where we're thinking about how to get people more engaged in a more general way. And then the public feedback draft action plan gets into the further goals, which is identifying and refining specific action recommendations, right? Primarily working on that with stakeholders and experts now, but eventually we want to give residents an opportunity to engage with that and getting buy-in support for those specific recommendations. Obviously, we can't do that until they
Speaker 8 (01:07:20–01:07:37)
With the first part, you brought engagement. Could you say that that's more awareness-raising than engagement? To me, that would be better terms.
Speaker 1 (01:07:40–01:08:31)
Yes. And also inviting people into the work. And so having these technical working groups I think is invaluable. One of the things I was most pleased about this month was because we had this vacancy and we asked, we discovered, oh, there's actually people in town who want to help.
That's a great feeling. We need to make it clear how people can help. So I think having some kind of working group around each of the topic areas. So you don't necessarily have to serve on the committee to come and help hash out what should be in the conservation plan.
But then, you know, Ron and I, you don't have to do everything.
Speaker 9 (01:08:31–01:09:42)
I'm lost. Ron doing everything. But I was also thinking that there are other, you know, meetings going on. you know, the planning department has a East Milton overlay district public forum next week, I think it's the 25th.
So maybe if somebody wanted to come and just like How about, you know, five minutes because at our last forum for East Milton, it was a pretty big crowd. So maybe you kind of take advantage of maybe an existing forum just to say, hey, this is what's going on. You know, maybe if we had a flyer to hang to hand out or a survey for people to do, maybe people are kind of tired of surveys these days, but And just so people know in town what's going on, because I think I might have mentioned it before, when all of a sudden the bike and pedestrian master plan was being adopted like nobody knew about it.
Speaker 6 (01:09:42–01:09:43)
Yeah.
Speaker 9 (01:09:43–01:10:08)
Until all of a sudden it was drafted. And then neighborhood associations had issues with certain things. And then it was too late. to change.
And that was really disappointing to my neighborhood association, because they kind of had a lot to say about it. So it's just trying to engage people before something is actually written.
Speaker 1 (01:10:09–01:10:56)
Well, I think that I have questions personally about what it means to have a climate action plan, because the work of getting buy-in for the specific elements of the plan That's the implementation that takes years. But I think having, taking the example of the pedestrian plan, having that plan doesn't mean the town is committed to do everything that's in it. It's just we've put together a strategy to get these certain outcomes here with tactics, right? But then to actually change that road to one way requires some additional.
So in a way, the creation of the plan put it under radar so that now we can oppose those specific elements if that's what you want to do, right?
Speaker 9 (01:10:56–01:11:09)
And I think similarly… But people don't like to oppose. That's the problem. People want to be more part of the solution, so it's hard to get up and oppose.
Like, how can you oppose a pedestrian or a bike lane? That's true.
Speaker 1 (01:11:09–01:11:29)
And so framing and using the right words to frame that is going to be really important. Because I think, when I think about getting to a draft climate action plan, it's like, I want to get something specific enough that people can can be drawn out into that discussion, and we can get to the right answer.
Speaker 6 (01:11:29–01:11:35)
Go ahead.
Speaker 3 (01:11:35–01:13:00)
In talking to stakeholders, I found that if you provide them with some of the written stuff that we already have, like if you are looking for information or a position from them, if you give them something that's written, they have more chance to give you feedback and, in fact, give you some good ideas. And if you just try and present it to them, it's too vague. So I've been providing people before I've been meeting with the sections of the draft or the whole draft of what I'm going to talk to them about, and explaining to them clearly that this is the first draft, that I want your feedback, I want your ideas, and that's very helpful to them, I think. Because if you don't do that, you almost get no response.
And so you're not getting as much out of the meetings without having done something or writing. Just my feeling about that. So far, with the experience I've had, it seems to work much better.
Speaker 4 (01:13:01–01:13:29)
Second that, I think you need something to show them and I think having it, you know, just label everything as a draft until it's final. A draft means it's, you know, editable and we're getting your feedback and people have the chance to comment on it that will build support and buy-in. They may not like every aspect of it, but they'll appreciate that they were asked.
Speaker 1 (01:13:30–01:15:32)
One question I have about the framing of the plan. Other plans get finalized at some point. We have our finalized biking-pedestrian plan, we have our finalized master implementation plan. But then the implementation goes on for years and they do change, right?
And I think that'll be the same here. Who's approving the Climate Action Plan? What does it mean when they approve it? Because it's certainly, you know, for example, the specialized building code that's under consideration now, that's something that I put in an initial draft recommendation.
even if we'd approved the Climate Action Plan, that would still have to go through all the processes currently right now in order to happen. So if somebody had approved that plan, what does that even mean? I think it would help us to clarify the scope of what we're trying to do, because I don't think that this committee is going to be able to assess the feasibility or support of everything that's necessary to achieve net zero emissions by 2050. Like I think our assignment is to write down a list of things that if they were done would achieve that goal that are at least, you know, there's some precedent for doing elsewhere.
And then to use that as a starting point for finding out which is loving and crude. Is there unanimous support to some of these things? Or maybe there's absolutely no way in today's political and economic environment that item 7C is going to happen. That's just information for what needs to change so that people will support that.
Speaker 9 (01:15:33–01:16:44)
And that was sort of a question that I had, too, with the whole economic part of it. you know, the selectmen will be putting forth an override, an operational override, that's probably like $10 million in the fall. And so, you know, a lot of these things are aspirational, you know, and I would love to put a moratorium on taking down trees, you know, and but I am a little bit of afraid that we're gonna do a lot of work and there won't be any money to support it. And there's even, like we don't have the money now to do a lot of our maintenance, even keeping up with our roads from my understanding it's like 20 to $30 million to take care of all of our roads.
You know, and then even I heard recently that like the inverter at PolyCon Cunningham hasn't been operational for the past, you know, year to year and a half.
Speaker 6 (01:16:44–01:16:45)
Inverter?
Speaker 9 (01:16:45–01:17:25)
Yeah, so they have been, we've been paying a lot more money. No one's been paying attention to it because the bills go to the school department. not consolidated facilities. And consolidated facilities are the ones who maintain it, and so they didn't know it was- They're installership now.
Yeah, so there was some, and again, this is only I'm hearing recently of this, so I don't have all the information, but it's been going on a problem for a year, and there's no checks or balances. So that was kind of a concern for me.
Speaker 1 (01:17:26–01:18:23)
So I suggest that we If we frame this right, then we can write it faster. I think being explicit, figuring out what's feasible and practical in the near term is the implementation step. So the first draft is what is necessary to reach these emissions reductions. I guarantee you it will not all be possible under the current circumstances.
But then you have that roadmap of like, all right, what on here should we prioritize actually putting in the hours to fix some of these problems and try to get ourselves in a position where we could do some version of that in the real world. But you need that aspirational framework first.
Speaker 4 (01:18:23–01:19:42)
There's a bill in our state government to make Massachusetts the leader in climate tech for the world, not just the country, but the world. Because the Inflation Reduction Act has a tremendous amount of money available for this type of work. And right now, Texas has made it much easier to install solar. Massachusetts has very strict permitting.
So it's hard to cite things. So what could the state legislature do to ease things like that? And the problem, I think, is that you pay a little bit more money for something. And no one wants to pay more money ever.
But the act of not doing something, like think about our hottest summers leading all the way through November. We're going to air condition all our schools, how expensive would that be? And true, it's the town of Milton, reducing our emissions is going to affect the climate, right? We're a drop.
But if everyone does something, it will reduce this climate emergency, which will be very expensive in so many ways.
Speaker 1 (01:19:43–01:20:40)
in terms of change curves, right? So I mean, like electric cars were an oddity until Tesla made them cool, right? And focused on people who could afford them first, but there's a process and now they're becoming more mainstream, right? And similarly, I often hear like, what's the point of tackling this when China isn't or when Georgia isn't.
But Massachusetts pioneered the model for Obamacare and then it was successful here and successful enough that it was adopted nationally. I think that's, I'm proud to live in a state that is leading the way on showing that this can practically be done and not just like Marching and blaming fossil fuel companies, but actually trying to fix it through our energy.
Speaker 4 (01:20:41–01:20:47)
It also supports jobs. There's so many new jobs that are available in this type of work.
Speaker 1 (01:20:47–01:21:19)
That's why we're here. To get to the I think the brass tacks of, like, if we approve this, we'd be saying we're going to write down kind of a more or less complete plan by June-ish, knowing that it's not going to be done. But then just, you know, a starting point that's complete.
Speaker 2 (01:21:19–01:22:04)
It's not a four-hour plan. It's the base. and any strategic plan that's good has built into it the reformulation of the plan for the future. And that would be an important ingredient.
And it might be good to point out somewhere in the plan relative to this discussion related to economics that oftentimes the cost of not doing something in the long term exceeds the cost of doing something. And that's where communities and other entities, businesses, and non-profits, et cetera, really get penalized when their economic sin is a sin of omission rather than one of commission.
Speaker 1 (01:22:04–01:23:14)
Yeah. I mean, just speaking from the personal experience of having, so I put a lot of hours into advocating for the specialized building code since our last meeting. and digging into those kinds of questions in detail, it just took a lot of time. And that's just going to be one of dozens of things that we have on here.
So I no longer feel like it's realistic for us to have done that level of work for every single thing before there's a document, right? Or even before it's approved. a little unclear about what approved would mean. Yeah, well, I would say, well, no, I think it has to be, we've at this point got one that is sort of the centerpiece of our process around climate action plan and we're going to update it every year or whatever it is.
I think there needs to be an ongoing process where You keep working on it and engaging with it to get bits of it done and try to make more of it realistic than it was last year.
Speaker 9 (01:23:14–01:23:17)
Does it have to get approved by town meeting, like the master plan did?
Speaker 2 (01:23:17–01:23:19)
It should go through the site board.
Speaker 9 (01:23:19–01:23:20)
The whole plan itself?
Speaker 1 (01:23:20–01:23:24)
I would charge that consideration by town meeting, but I didn't very much have that back.
Speaker 2 (01:23:24–01:23:34)
Yeah, it would give me an issue to go with the site board, because that's where the charge came from. So we'd have to go back to them, and they would make determination, I think.
Speaker 9 (01:23:34–01:23:36)
If it needs to be town meeting approved.
Speaker 1 (01:23:36–01:24:15)
But at one point, I know town meeting doesn't like to take symbolic votes, right? Because when a while back, there was a kind of rash of town meetings to call for climate emergencies, right? And folks didn't want to do that in Milton because it's It's just a symbolic vote, right? I mean, if you have a climate action plan where the individual items require a town meeting vote in their own right, what does it mean to approve it at a town meeting?
That's the question I have.
Speaker 4 (01:24:16–01:24:18)
I'm keeping an eye on them.
Speaker 1 (01:24:18–01:24:22)
Yeah, I know. I sort of gave up on things I haven't said.
Speaker 9 (01:24:22–01:24:26)
Oh, and the only other comment I have here is- Let me just back up a moment on this.
Speaker 2 (01:24:27–01:25:02)
No item in the line. gets into the warrant, unless it's approved by the select board. So that's why I was saying earlier, from what it is that we adopt, we submit to the select board. The select board would have the responsibility of either coming back to us for clarifications, et cetera, before it might make a presentation to the town meeting.
It's just for consideration. to select what is to define what consideration by the town meeting means.
Speaker 1 (01:25:02–01:25:19)
Yeah, I mean, if I were a town meeting member and you gave me just a copy, like a 30 page document with action items covering every aspect of our economy, and you asked me to approve it, even as into this stuff as I am, I think I'd be overwhelmed.
Speaker 9 (01:25:20–01:26:00)
And even like with the master plan, there are parts of it that are in conflict with each other. So it is kind of challenging sometimes, because two opposing views could be quoting from the master plan. So my other question under your guiding principles, which said messaging should emphasize positive reasons for hope, solutions, and connections to shared values. But then under A, it says abstract language and jargon should be avoided.
So I wasn't sure, like, I think hope and connections to shared values tend to be considered abstract language.
Speaker 1 (01:26:01–01:26:51)
I borrowed that language from an engagement plan. I like solutions, because that's not an… If you provide… Abstract language would be like scientific jargon.
electrification or net zero. There's a lot of marketing research that says that nobody that climate wants knows what that stuff means. But a lot of people, I think 80% of Americans are concerned about climate change. It may not be their top concern, but they are concerned.
And connecting it back to protecting the future for your children is the most effective messaging, not, you know, clean tech jobs, as much as that is.
Speaker 9 (01:26:52–01:28:20)
And so even that's what even, you know, comes before the planning board or applications. And there's one before us now that is taking down 300 trees. So to me, that is, I think that's awful. And As the UN has declared, we are in the decade of restoration.
And the easiest way to prevent climate change is not to remove trees and to pave over open space. And when we talk about different parts of our master plan being in conflict, another plan that's being discussed is taking some land across the street for the library and removing trees and putting in a parking lot. So I'm totally against adding more impervious surfaces in town. And I'm totally in support of keeping our open spaces and our trees.
So I think we, I personally think we need to prioritize our trees and our open spaces. And I know reducing our emissions is a top priority, but we wouldn't have to reduce our emissions if we were more green.
Speaker 1 (01:28:20–01:28:38)
I don't think the carbon budget works out that way. We really do have to reduce emissions and sustain the… But to bring it back to this, it doesn't feel like… Are we ready to vote on this?
No, I don't think it's critical.
Speaker 8 (01:28:39–01:29:14)
If you and others maybe have this idea, and I think you're probably right, that a climate plan with 40 different activities is going to be hard for people to comprehend, understand, and act on, is there value in at this point in time, consolidating, prioritizing where we go ahead, or do we just go ahead on this multi-track system that we're on?
Speaker 4 (01:29:16–01:29:42)
I think it might be interesting to first put out there in the plan, you know, like the draft that we have now, and perhaps some of our survey and outreach. It's like, you know, list your top five that you would support or that you would do to help us focus, you know, and develop a plan that, you know, would be workable.
Speaker 1 (01:29:48–01:31:14)
Yeah, I mean, when I think of getting to a draft plan to start working from, I'm thinking of One example that I come back to a lot is Wayland's plan, which is about 11 pages. And that was done without consulting support, which is, a lot of the plans you read, you know, Maxi or some other professional consulting company was engaged to help them write it. Yeah, five times as many pages last three pictures, so that's hard to do without professional kind of support. And maybe not really necessary, because the longer it is, the fewer people are going to get.
So do you think that we could just knuckle down, get something? I mean, we've all written sort of key action recommendations. I'm just fleshing that out to the next level of detail, stringing together with an introduction. Yes.
framing things like this is operational, we're going to iterate on it, we're giving recommendations for reducing emissions, we're not saying that everything that's planned can be done tomorrow, these kinds of things. So roughly by June,
Speaker 2 (01:31:14–01:31:25)
That might be a good point with that in hand to maybe interim reports of the cycle. Yeah. And have some initial feedback on that.
Speaker 1 (01:31:25–01:31:55)
Mm-hmm. I think we do need to move on. Tracy, we're here. She lives.
I haven't done that in a while, though. Do folks want to vote on this, or that it's too apprenticeship? I don't know. Yeah, I won't buy it.
I appreciate all the work you've done. Yeah.
Speaker 8 (01:31:56–01:32:07)
How does this happen? We have to go through a lot of different things going on here. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (01:32:08–01:32:54)
So I think it's more like a menu of the kinds of things we ought to be doing. And that's one reason why now understanding personally how much time it takes, I've made both broad and, I mean, all the kinds of engagement kind of ongoing for it. Even once we have a plan, I think when we continue, engaging the community to build buy-in and awareness and get closer to actually getting done, you know, costs, funding mechanisms, all those things. We're not going to know all that in the first year.
Speaker 2 (01:32:57–01:33:03)
Okay, so let's move on. So you have a consensus you feel comfortable
Speaker 6 (01:33:05–01:33:06)
I think so.
Speaker 1 (01:33:06–01:33:29)
I don't get it. Gammering you saying no is funny. Yeah. All right.
So next topic, and this actually might help bring some specificity to the discussion we just had. Jack has had some discussions with MATV on producing video content. in the kind of general outreach vein?
Speaker 11 (01:33:29–01:34:29)
They're very interested. They'd like to do a promo video first. I think the idea is to have it like short, shorter, like a three minute video where they do some interviews of the members. So if anyone would like to do that, please let me know.
And I think the question would be for you guys, what would you want to have in that initial um statement um you know in those interviews we can like um just you know write a draft write a script for the interviews um and they'd also like to do at the next meeting some like b-roll footage of the meeting um you guys would be okay with that too um and then yeah so um i think we were talking alex and i were talking with them um i have to follow up on the video for the um specialized ops and stretch code, but they're interested in doing videos like that. So yeah, I think there'll be a very key part in the outreach.
Speaker 1 (01:34:30–01:35:07)
Yeah, I've been really thinking a lot about video content after, you know, as a concerned citizen trying to watch public meetings or public forums. They're often an hour or more. We live in a world where most people consume their information in 30-second to five-minute chunks. As we have specific messages we want to get out, producing short videos that people can consume.
Instagram videos. Yeah.
Speaker 11 (01:35:08–01:35:17)
And they're in the short form. I think we actually made a couple. I don't know if you guys have seen Call the Environment a Minute, and they're very short.
Speaker 1 (01:35:18–01:35:40)
So sorry. Yeah. It's certainly no easy thing to get people to see your content that you put online. And I don't expect that will suddenly become easy after we've done this.
But I think it's a way of getting creative about giving people another way to know what's going on.
Speaker 4 (01:35:42–01:35:45)
Do we need to vote on this?
Speaker 1 (01:35:45–01:35:48)
I don't think so.
Speaker 9 (01:35:48–01:35:58)
I vote you to be the spokesperson for me.
Speaker 11 (01:35:59–01:36:05)
Would anyone want to be interviewed? It doesn't have to be within the next month or so, but… Sure.
Speaker 8 (01:36:05–01:36:07)
Sure. Cool.
Speaker 2 (01:36:07–01:36:40)
This is an excellent vehicle for bringing the existence of this charging and boarding to the public. Most people that talk to me about this don't know that it exists. So it's a very small slice of the town. I don't know that we have a funnel for them to come to.
Speaker 1 (01:36:40–01:37:12)
Yeah, and I think I'd like them to know who's on the committee, the sort of rough topical breakdown, now that we've figured that out. This is who's voting on what. You know, if we agree to this engagement plan, which includes creating working groups in the topical areas, an opportunity for you to engage and say how we're going to be in your working group on extreme heat. Those are the kinds of things we can put in there.
Intro to the video.
Speaker 4 (01:37:14–01:37:29)
As a quick aside, there was a lot of discussion about the board of health meeting that occurred because they were going to talk about the beavers. So we could just say, we're going to talk about the beavers and they had a lot of interest.
Speaker 1 (01:37:30–01:37:41)
Beavers didn't make it into my key action draft. I'm open to conservation. I'm open to learning. Great.
Speaker 8 (01:37:41–01:37:50)
I think that plastering the logo, any place we can put it up, would be a good thing to do.
Speaker 1 (01:37:54–01:38:18)
I also have some, I have a bunch of, there's a library of slides I put together, and I'm putting about four or five on, just over here, or two. At some point, make those available to all of you if you are going to. Somebody has to present about what we're doing somewhere.
Speaker 11 (01:38:19–01:38:32)
So our work with Apex is wrapping up next week. So we will have access to the whole slew of design elements for PowerPoints, flyers, all that good stuff. So that is coming as well.
Speaker 1 (01:38:36–01:38:52)
Any more discussion on this topic? Sorry to make you wait so long. Next is John sharing his TIACHA recommendations to prepare for extreme heatwaves.
Speaker 3 (01:38:52–01:48:38)
Okay. I think a couple of principles we have to remember is, one, the people most affected by heatwaves are the very young, the elderly, the chronically ill, the socially isolated people, and the people without access to air conditioning. I think the second principle we have to keep in mind is heatwaves really have to be considered with situations where there is electricity and situations where there isn't electricity. And the fact that prolonged heatwave places excessive stress on the electrical supply grid, it's possible that the electricity will be out in a major heat wave.
So we have to think about the question of where our facility generators and who has home generators. Because with electricity, we have lots of options for cooling centers. Without, it's a whole nother ballgame. We really have to consider those places that have major generators that will cover their whole facility.
With stakeholders, I've considered the major stakeholders to be practicing physicians, the Milton Council and Milton Hospital, Milton and Council of Aging, and then think about available facilities. So with the physicians, I had a very nice conversation with the Dr. John Barbeckio, who was president of the staff at Milton Hospital in the past. And he's connected me with Mark Hodgman, a cardiologist, and Daniel Driscoll, who deals with the elderly people.
I haven't been able to get together with Richard Fernandez, who's president of Milton Hospital. but I've gotten a lot of information about the hospital through the physicians. The Milton Council of Aging has been disappointing. The response I got back from Christine Stanton was, thank you for the invitation, but I can't commit at this time.
Feel free to keep me posted on the work you're doing, which was kind of a surprising response. But anyway. I think thinking about facilities usable for people without access to air conditioning, with the electrical grid intact, the town hall is air-conditioned, town library has air-conditioned, Council of Aging, as far as government-related facilities, private facilities, Milton Hospital, South Shore Mall, The fruit center marketplace, churches, other shops and restaurants all have air conditioning so that these are places people can go. But without support of the electrical grid, you're relying on places with air conditioning.
And if you think about government, there aren't many. I think Town Hall here probably has a backup generator. I don't know that it does, but I would expect that it does. Private facilities, Milton Hospital certainly has a backup generator that will cover the whole facility.
Curry College, Milton Academy are options, but these are private facilities that aren't necessarily prepared to take in people. The hospital, on the other hand, would be. And so that people would be able to use not only the hospital, but some of the common areas in the hospital, as they really needed to be kicked really from the heat. We really need to think about lifestyle changes to promulgate and implement by individuals in response to heat waves, which includes making use of air conditioning for cooling and having central air conditioning or air conditioning to some extent, in your house.
I think we're at a point where most of the people do, but there are people that don't. Knowing something about acclimation time and how to acclimate, going outside in the morning or evening and not pushing yourself past the comfort. All of these are things that are kind of common sense, but yet can be part of an informational process for this. in terms of really more distinct knowledge for individuals is knowing the signs of heat exhaustion and heat stroke, maintaining understanding what heat-related illness is and knowing and having water available and then thinking about the possibility that there's going to be a counter outage and how to deal with that is certainly important.
And then the emergency community planning preparedness in response to heat waves. I think we need to make sure that there's a lead agency that is involved in this, whether it's fire, ambulance, police, Whatever office it is, it needs to be designated and identified. And they should use and activate and deactivate a specific warning system. Then in terms of information on dissemination of this information, we've kind of talked about it here in regard to the other things in terms of music, community TV, signage, and other things.
And then the hardest problem is figuring out how to implement a response targeting the high-risk populations, especially the people who are essentially removed from regular society. And actually, in talking to Dr. Barovecchio, he suggested the Visiting Nurses Association as a vehicle to deliver much of this information that I've talked about that needs to get out. and especially those people who are not in a position to get it otherwise.
And also another approach would be, for example, the Council on Aging has a newsletter. And to get some of that information into their newsletter would be very good. And also churches and clergy can be helpful in disseminating information. You leave some of this as a plier in church, and I think what it comes down to is assuring the availability of drinking water and electricity are the primary concerns and targets that need to be implemented in terms of protection against extreme heat waves.
So those are the main points that I've thought about in terms of dealing with this. And I think Yeah. We have experience with heatwaves, and heatwaves are going to happen no matter whether climate change is terrible or minor in the future. But this information will be useful and will be usable by people regardless of what the future, because we know from history that we have to deal with these heatwaves every now and then.
So that's where we are on this topic.
Speaker 1 (01:48:39–01:49:53)
Thank you so much. I think this is really important. Because while we've dealt with that historically, e-waves are expected to intensify and get longer. And when you combine that with the rapid transformation of the grid, I think it's natural for people to worry about longer power outages than we've experienced in the past.
uh, growing electricity demand with electrification. So I think, I think it's absolutely necessary to combine a push for electrification with this kind of plan, right? Um, and I've been, um, researching, you know, all electric school buildings or building code, um, for This comes up a lot. People are incorporating plants for heating and warming and cooling centers for vulnerable population as part of their…
plans for new municipal infrastructure and I think we should absolutely make sure that we're doing that here in Walton as well. I don't know if we have any like formal plans for emergency heating and cooling especially in the case of a power outage.
Speaker 9 (01:49:53–01:50:15)
The Board of Health I think is a good resource and You know, my mother has been ill the last few months, and we've had a lot of support from social elder services. So you can add that maybe to your visiting nurses.
Speaker 1 (01:50:21–01:51:01)
And the other thing that pops to mind is the microgrid feasibility study that just wrapped up. When it moves into the stage of seeking funding, I think this is an important reason to put in the profile. Creating a bunch of municipal locations that will have their own on-site electricity generation, the ability to store it. But that doesn't mean that it's currently being designed with enough capacity.
How many people could it shelter?
Speaker 3 (01:51:01–01:52:05)
I think the other thing to realize is that if there's a heat wave in Milton, chances are it's affecting all of eastern Massachusetts. And so it's not going to be necessarily possible to get much help or shelter or cooling areas in adjacent towns. For example, if we have a heat wave and there's a loss of power in Middleton, but not in Brantford. You could go to the South Shore Mall and be very comfortable.
And each time I've recently gone to the South Shore Mall, there's not many people there. But anyway, I think this is the kind of thing that we have to think about in terms of the regional character.
Speaker 1 (01:52:05–01:52:37)
A lot of the all-electric construction that's happening these days still has fossil fuel backup power generation. And that's allowed under the Specialized Building Code without triggering mixed fuel compliance pathways. So I think these fossil, this is the sort of good fossil fuel infrastructure that you only use in emergencies, hopefully almost never.
Speaker 3 (01:52:38–01:53:12)
I think home generators are becoming more popular. In Milton, we don't lose electricity that often if you really need them. In some other towns where there's more trees along the streets and so forth. When I lived in Weston, for example, we lost power at least once a month.
And so it was almost necessary to have a home generator. But here it's not quite so much.
Speaker 9 (01:53:13–01:53:31)
Yeah, we lose power a lot. But we should also plant more trees because trees can reduce the heat island effect by about, what, 10 degrees? For sure. So we need to plant more trees.
That's my motto. Plant more trees.
Speaker 6 (01:53:34–01:53:38)
Any other comments or questions? I see none.
Speaker 11 (01:53:38–01:54:08)
I have one suggestion. Choppy. Sorry. Sort of.
Now it's a little. Chompy. Is there another?
Speaker 13 (01:54:08–01:54:16)
I'm on wired internet, so I might be able to get a recital.
Speaker 7 (01:54:16–01:54:16)
Okay.
Speaker 1 (01:54:17–01:54:40)
Yes, so please send us the comments and email. I do want to be mindful of the time now and try to try to bring us home here. So we have 10 minutes for member updates on activities since last meeting, sir. I know, Arthur, you had a few comments you wanted to make.
Speaker 2 (01:54:40–01:54:57)
I just mentioned that Jack, an intern in the town, and I attended the recycling audit in Avon at the waste management plant, and we'll have a final report or a polling report on that for the next meeting.
Speaker 11 (01:54:58–01:55:21)
12%. It was a 12% contamination rate, which is very good. That's good? That's good.
Well, it's not bad. We didn't get charged extra, which is more towards like the 15, 20% contamination rate of trash in the recycling. So we're doing pretty good.
Speaker 1 (01:55:21–01:55:23)
Anybody else want to give a brief update?
Speaker 4 (01:55:23–01:57:58)
Sure. So people send me things, and I looked at some of them. And one of them was about all electric schools. And so there was some really good information there.
I'm going to have notes, which I'll add to my other public documents. I watched the webinar on how US cities and counties are accelerating the deployment of EV charging infrastructure. And that had some really good information, including there's an opportunity for the town to join the next peer learning cohort. So you get technical assistance provided by the federal government.
And I think that due date to apply is beginning of April. Does this ring any bells with you? No? I'll send it along.
Because maybe, you know, that free technical support sounds good in learning. And then I found, well, you know, I'm looking at transportation, but I'm also representing the school board. And I came across a really cool app for schools to use that allows parents to connect to Carpool. And it has lots of nice features that, you know, you can filter by age and school, and it's only going to show you people who live near you.
So you're not sharing your data with the whole town. And so I shared that with the superintendent, and he was interested in, you know, learning more about it. And with the Glover PTO, which they're going to be like holding up signs at pick up about emissions. And they're thinking about plans for reducing, increasing carpooling, decreasing single occupancy trips or one student, one parent trips going into next year.
So they're going to build a plan for that. So I feel good about those things. And then John and I finally connected after playing quite a bit of email tag, and so we talked about some ways we can coordinate reaching out to stakeholders, if you want to add anything. No, I think that's fine.
Speaker 1 (01:57:58–01:59:07)
And that was all for me. For myself, I think between the planning work that you see here, my other big activity was advocating for the specialized building code. It's been primarily one-on-one outreach with experts and stakeholders. I spoke to Sean O'Rourke on the school building committee to understand potential impacts on the school.
a building project. I've been to the Warren Committee once, and I'll be back to possession again on Monday, where they make their recommendation and did a presentation to the Master Planning Implementation Committee. And for that, I did make some sort of general overview materials about the committee, so I'm happy to share any of that with any of you, if it's useful to you.
Speaker 9 (01:59:07–01:59:11)
The stretch code, does that apply to municipal buildings?
Speaker 1 (01:59:12–01:59:12)
It does.
Speaker 9 (01:59:12–01:59:13)
It does.
Speaker 1 (01:59:13–01:59:27)
So all of the buildings would have to- The stretch code, which we're on, and the specialized code, they both have different requirements, but they cover residential and commercial. And it's for new buildings.
Speaker 9 (01:59:27–01:59:39)
Yeah, yeah, yeah. So that's one of my questions when I was reading this. this report, the Department of Energy Resources.
Speaker 1 (01:59:40–01:59:48)
I'd be happy to discuss that with you in detail offline. It's a deep rabbit hole to go down now.
Speaker 9 (01:59:48–01:59:58)
Oh, yeah. Okay. Because it was just like number eight, it just said both residential and commercial new construction, as well as certain renovations and additions.
Speaker 1 (01:59:58–02:00:02)
That's the stretch code. That's the plan to renovations.
Speaker 9 (02:00:02–02:00:07)
And we're already already on that.
Speaker 1 (02:00:08–02:00:13)
Yeah. OK, I've got pages and pages for you.
Speaker 13 (02:00:13–02:00:14)
Yeah.
Speaker 8 (02:00:14–02:01:32)
It's a. Any other things? I said before, I consulted. With several stakeholder organizations around.
Conservation lands, I got input from, for example, the Mills, the River Valley Association, the DPW, there's a person there who tracks how much of the conservation land Milton actually owns, spoke to other owners, and I got that information. And I'm still trying to connect with the DERC, but I think, as I said before, those four groups have a lot more experience doing this than I do. And I got their input on draft documents, so, I think that's ready, almost to be finalized, and I think if we can pull those four groups together, that would also help with fundraising for the work that is proposed.
Speaker 1 (02:01:34–02:03:59)
Well, thank you all for all the work you're doing. We've scratched the surface here. It's really exciting to hear about it. So, oh look, I have select date for April meeting on here twice.
Somebody's getting tired. So let's, I need to quickly go over these upcoming meetings and then nail down our meeting date for April and then… So, yes, upcoming meetings. So there's a public forum plan for the specialized building code on April 4th.
It'll be at the Council on Aging from 6-7-3. I'm working on that with Josh McGregor. And planning to sort of, it's obviously being publicized generally, but we'll do some targeted outreach to town meeting members as well. And I'm meeting with a group of Folks from the building and development community try to step on the ground, do that as well.
Look for that. And then on May 4th, Sustainable Middletown is hosting a green fair, 10 to 4. I think the time schedule now will be right here on the town green. So keep your eyes out for I think there's a lot of really cool stuff they're planning.
I'm watching the chat channel. There's a lot of cool ideas. Any other events that I didn't mention that people know about? All right.
So April meeting date. Let's crack open our calendars. So I talked about either pushing it forward a Thursday a week or pushing it back a week. I think, Maggie, you told me that neither of those Thursdays works for you.
Speaker 9 (02:03:59–02:04:02)
Yeah, the planning board meets the second and fourth Thursday.
Speaker 1 (02:04:03–02:04:21)
So I'm open to doing it on like a Wednesday of the week before or the week after? Is anybody… So you're leaving on Friday of the week after, is that right?
Speaker 3 (02:04:21–02:04:36)
I'm away the week before, a whole way, and I'm leaving on the 26th, so having it on the 24th would be fine.
Speaker 1 (02:04:37–02:04:54)
Yeah, April 24th works for me. Works for me. Okay, here. Okay, I would do that.
So you shoot for 6 to 7 30 p.m. on Wednesday, April 24th.
Speaker 4 (02:05:05–02:05:06)
It's 2.10.30.
Speaker 1 (02:05:09–02:05:17)
I could tell them this was an overstepped agenda. It felt like a lot of things that needed to be discussed.
Speaker 4 (02:05:17–02:05:18)
Thank you so much.
Speaker 1 (02:05:18–02:05:29)
Hopefully we'll be able to get back to our 90-minute window going forward. So with that, does anybody want to move to adjourn?
Speaker 2 (02:05:30–02:05:31)
Juan, did you have a question?
Speaker 8 (02:05:31–02:05:50)
I had a question, but I hesitate to bring it up. I'll ask it and we can discuss it next time. Do we have like a two, three sentence elevator speech about the Planning Action Committee and what our purpose in life is?
Speaker 1 (02:05:50–02:05:55)
I can show you. Okay.
Speaker 9 (02:05:55–02:05:59)
I'm going to be on their website.
Speaker 1 (02:05:59–02:06:05)
But we have our charge. I don't know if that's that's a lot of words.
Speaker 2 (02:06:07–02:06:11)
Sometimes they are on the website, so I'm going to double check.
Speaker 8 (02:06:12–02:06:13)
Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (02:06:13–02:06:18)
OK, great. I have a motion for that. So all in favor.
Speaker 10 (02:06:18–02:06:20)
Aye. Thank you all so much.