Board: Town Meeting

Date: 1994-03-12


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:17–00:47)

Meeting will come to order.

Speaker 2 (00:51–01:02)

This meeting will be opened with an invocation by the Reverend Mark Harris, the pastor of the First Parish Unitarian Universalist Parish in town. Reverend Harris?

Speaker 3 (01:06–01:13)

All stand.

Speaker 4 (01:13–03:45)

Let there be peace in our hearts as we join together in an attitude of prayer. O great and gracious Spirit, God of love and life, in whom we live and move and have our being, we invoke thy blessings on this assembly, on this honorable tradition of democracy at work. We invoke the blessings of mission, that the deliberations of this assembly be infused with a sense of purpose so that we would strive for the greater good for this town above our own selfish motives. We invoke the blessing of respect that a sense of the dignity and worth of every human person be manifest here.

We invoke the blessing of wisdom that the decisions of this body be just and sound. We invoke the blessing of humility that each of us in all our efforts be reminded of our own limitations and thus strive to listen better, to learn more, to grow in understanding. And may this community and its citizens never cease from striving to build a world more just, to forge a prosperity more widely shared, to attain a society more equal and more free. And so may we carry out our duties and responsibilities as citizens with dignity and with honor and respect for all.

and live in peace and harmony together. Amen.

Speaker 2 (03:48–10:49)

Having been advised by the town clerk that more than a majority of the town meeting members are in attendance, I hereby declare that a quorum is present for the transaction of business. Before proceeding with the business of the meeting, however, there's certain preliminary matters to be taken up. First, permission has been granted, has been requested for certain members and personnel of the school committee, planning board, board of health, and other boards and committees who are not town meeting members to sit on the floor with other members of the respective boards and committees upon the understanding, of course, that they will not vote. Hearing no objection from the body, such permission will be and hereby is accorded.

Permission has also been granted by the moderator to Curry College radio station to broadcast and to Milton Cablevision to televise these proceedings. Additionally, permission has been granted by the moderator to the town clerk to tape record all or a portion of these proceedings. Thirdly, I will now review briefly, particularly for the benefit of any new town meeting members, some of the rules for the conduct of the meeting. First, Any person who is employed as an attorney by another person interested in any matter under discussion shall disclose the fact of his or her employment before speaking thereon.

Secondly, town meeting members are required to check in and to be seated in the lower part of the auditorium. Citizens and others who are not town meeting members are required to be seated in the upper part of the auditorium beyond the point demarcated for town meeting members. Any town meeting member wishing to speak with reference to any article will first go to the nearest microphone and upon being recognized by the moderator will identify himself or herself by giving his or her name and precinct. By tradition, any, and by the bylaws by the way, any other voter of the town who may desire to address the town meeting may do so, however, that person must obtain in advance permission from the town moderator.

No such voter has requested permission from the moderator, and that's where it stands now. Nonetheless, permission is sometimes granted during the course of a meeting, so keeping in mind that permission must be granted, if you wish to speak, you're going to have to see me. Motions. By tradition and again, consistent with the bylaws, complex or substantive motions traditionally are put in writing.

Now this is not an attempt by the moderator to make things more difficult. They are simply a matter for the moderator and the town clerk, when these proceedings are over, to have a record of exactly what the motion was. Short motions I will in fact simply recognize, okay? Now, In that regard, if you have not submitted a motion in advance, as some of you have indicated that you will do, to me, I will nonetheless, if there comes the time where you believe it's appropriate to make a motion, I will give you time to put it in writing.

But nonetheless, if it's complex or substantive, it will be required to be put in writing. Now, I am told by the chairman of the Warrant Committee that the budget articles as recommended by the Warrant Committee to this town meeting, are not only at the maximum, and actually the last time I talked to the chairman they were over the maximum, but I suspect he's moved it down closer to the maximum, tax levy limitation permitted by the state pursuant to Proposition 2.5. While I will entertain motions to amend budget articles upward, the town's total appropriation may not exceed the Proposition 2.5 levy limit. Thus, to avoid chaos and the necessity for additional meetings, to balance the town's appropriation with the levy limit on the amount of revenue that the town may raise by property tax, your moderator both urges and expects that any member offering an upward amendment to a budget article will also specify an offsetting decrease in some other line item, or specify what additional source of revenue is expected to be available.

In addition, I will recognize motions that will make increased funding conditional on an override vote, which is another legitimate way of proceeding. With reference to each article on the warrant, the recommendation of the Warrant Committee shall ordinarily be considered to have been presented in the form of a motion by the chairman, which has been seconded by the secretary or other member of the Warrant Committee who is a town meeting member. Unless I otherwise expressly state at the time, then, the question to be voted upon under each article will usually be on whether or not to accept the Warrant Committee's recommendation. In the event the Warrant Committee recommends a no vote on an article, the question will be presented as a vote on a motion made and seconded to approve the article.

That is, members will vote yes if they favor the article and no if they oppose the article as recommended by the Warrant Committee. When it is announced that the meeting will proceed to vote, debate will be closed and the question will be put to the town meeting. Upon a question being put to the town meeting, the moderator will first determine by voice vote the sense of the meeting. If the moderator is unable to decide by the sound of the voices or if his announcement of the vote is doubted by seven town meeting members standing in their places, the moderator shall then proceed to have a standing vote on the question.

I would point out here also, as an aside, that there are certain articles which I will announce as we are going along that require a two-thirds vote. If a two-thirds vote is required, and unless it's unanimous, I will have to have a standing vote. If the vote is further doubted by 25 town meeting members standing in their places, then there will be a roll call of the meeting with the town clerk calling the name of each town meeting member in alphabetical order, and each town meeting member, upon his or her name being called, shall rise in his or her place and answer yes or no. No vote shall be reconsidered at the same meeting except upon a motion made within one hour of the adoption of such vote, unless by two-thirds vote, provided that the time which elapses during any adjournment of the meeting shall be excluded in computing the hour since the adoption of the vote.

With these brief and obviously uncomplicated rules established, we will now proceed with the business of the meeting. Article one to choose such town offices as are not required to be chosen by Bell these are Now we'll entertain a motion that James a Braxton and Robert O'Meara be voted upon as measures of lumber there's such a motion Is there a second? It's been moved and seconded to appoint James A. Braxton and Robert O'Meara measurer of lumber.

Is there any debate?

Speaker 5 (10:51–10:52)

Ah.

Speaker 2 (10:54–11:05)

Good point. Mr. Muller, before we go to article one, you kindly swear in these time meeting members' votes.

Speaker 6 (11:05–11:40)

Please stand, raise your right hand, and repeat after me. I solemnly swear to uphold the bylaws of the town of Milton, the general laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and to uphold the Constitution of the United States of America. So help me God. Thank you, James.

Thank you for that reminder.

Speaker 2 (11:42–13:24)

Is there any debate on the motion to appoint James a Braxton Robert O'Meara measure of lumber seeing none all those in favor of those appointments say aye those opposed it's unanimous and they are appointed article to to hear and act upon the report of the town accountant in the town offices and committees we are required to to accept the report of the town treasurer as it appears in the annual report of the town 1993. I will entertain a motion to accept the report of the town accountant as it appears in the annual report. Is there such a motion? Is there a second?

It's been moved and seconded to accept the report of the town accountant as it appears in the 1993 annual report. Is there a debate? All those in favor of accepting the town accountant's report say aye. Those opposed.

It's unanimously accepted. I would point out that inadvertently the treasurer's report for the library was omitted and for those of you who wish to have a copy of the treasurer's report extra copies are in the table outside. At this time there's one other report we Those who have revolving accounts pursuant to section 53E and a half are required to report to the town how those revolving accounts have been used. And at this time, I will recognize either Mr.

Sheehan or Mr. Desmond to make that report from the school committee.

Speaker 7 (13:24–13:24)

Thank you.

Speaker 8 (13:29–14:41)

Thank you, Mr. Moderator. This report is a status report of the revolving account established by Article 20 of the 1993 Annual Town Meeting. Number one, this report is forwarded to the Board of Selectmen to comply with the subject of Town Meeting Articles, MGL Chapter 44, Section 53, E and a half.

The revolving account was established to authorize the school committee to utilize fees received from rental of school facilities for the maintenance and repair of school facilities. As of January 30th, 1994, the amount of $4,000 has been received and deposited in the school revolving account $29- 250-338 school facility rentals. No expenditures have been made. The funds are intended to be spent on the necessary electrical repair work at Milton High School Auditorium.

Thank you.

Speaker 2 (14:43–15:09)

Thank you. I'll entertain a motion to accept the report of the public school department on the status of revolving account established in article 20 of the 1993 annual town meeting. Is there such a motion? Is there a second?

It's been moved and seconded to accept that report. Is there any debate? Seeing none, all those in favor of accepting the report say aye. Those opposed?

The report is unanimously accepted. At this time the moderator will recognize select person Kathy Dunphy

Speaker 9 (15:11–17:33)

Thank you, Mr. Moderator. The Board of Selectmen asks you to join us in honoring two outstanding employees who have retired from the town during the last year, and I don't see them present today. I hope they're watching the town meeting on cable.

Lawrence W. DeSalle, Jr. served the town for 27 years, 23 years as Director of Public Works. In addition to maintaining and improving Milton streets, sidewalks, drainage systems, and water and sewer systems, Mr.

DeSalle excelled in the ever more complex area of landfill management. He was a prime mover of the town's successful curbside recycling program. As budgets became tighter and government mandates more difficult, Mr. DeSalle guided Milton into the future and always with a smile.

Larry DeSalle's fellow employees and many friends honored him upon his retirement last fall, but we take this opportunity to say again our sincere thanks and best wishes for many great years ahead. At the end of January, Joseph G. Graziani Jr. retired after 40 years of service to the people of Milton.

As town meeting member for 39 years, park commissioner, treasurer and collector, town accountant, veterans agent, and chairman of the Board of Retirement, Mr. Graziani has directly served the people of Milton. The Retirement Board's Article 9 to establish a retirement system funding schedule is an example of Mr. Graziani's efforts in behalf of the town employees and the taxpayers.

The Board of Selectmen hope that all of you have read Mr. Graziani's letter of thanks to the citizens of Milton in yesterday's Milton record transcript. It is another example of his dedication and his love for the town. Joe Graziani chose not to have a big retirement party, and it would have been a big retirement party.

Today, the town of Milton has an opportunity to say thank you, Joe, and best wishes for many more productive years.

Speaker 2 (17:42–21:56)

Thank you very much. Article 3. See if the town will vote to authorize the town treasurer, with the approval of the Board of Selectmen, to borrow money from time to time, in anticipation of the revenue of the fiscal year beginning July 1, 1994, in accordance with the provisions of General Laws, Chapter 44, Section 4, and to issue a note or notes therefore payable within one year, and to renew any note or notes as may be given for a period of less than one year, in accordance with the provisions of General Laws, Chapter 44, Section 17. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town treasurer, with the approval of the Board of Selectmen, be and hereby is authorized to borrow money from time to time in anticipation of the revenue of the fiscal year beginning July 1, 1994, in accordance with the provisions of General Laws, Chapter 44, Section 4, and to issue a note or notes, therefore, payable within one year, and to renew any note or notes as may be given for a period of less than one year in accordance with the provisions of General Laws, Chapter 44, Section 17.

Is there any discussion? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed?

The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is unanimously carried and Article 3 is adopted. Article 4. See if the town will vote to authorize the collector of taxes to use all means of collecting taxes which a town treasurer when appointed collector may use. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote yes.

Is there any debate? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed.

The article is carried unanimously. Article 5. To see if the Town will vote to authorize the Town Treasurer to enter into compensating balance agreements during the fiscal year beginning July 1, 1994 in accordance with the provisions of General Laws Chapter 44, Section 53F and to act on anything relating thereto. Recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the Town vote yes.

Is there any debate? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed?

The article is adopted unanimously, Article 6. To see if the town will vote to authorize the selectmen to employ counsel to represent the town at hearings before committees of the general court, the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote yes. Is there any debate? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warren Committee say aye.

Aye. Those opposed? The article is adopted unanimously. Article 7.

To see if the town will vote to authorize the moderator to appoint a committee of five citizens to consider such proceedings of the legislature and state boards and commissions as may affect the interest of the town and confer as they may think expedient with the selectmen in regard to the employment of counsel to represent the town in any such proceedings. The members of such committee to hold office until the final adjournment of the next annual town meeting and until the appointment of any succeeding committee authorized at such meeting. The recommendation of the Warren committee is that the town vote yes. Is there any debate?

All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warren Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed. The article is adopted unanimously.

Article 8, to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate to the board of selectmen for the purpose of conducting a municipal audit for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1994, and further to see if the town will vote to authorize the committee appointed pursuant to Article 14 of the 1978 annual March town meeting, the town audit committee, to make recommendations to the selectmen relative to the employment of a certified public accountant for the foregoing purpose and to act on anything relating thereto. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote to appropriate the sum of $30,500 for the purpose set forth in this article. Is there any debate? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye.

Aye. Those opposed? The article is adopted unanimously with respect to Article 9. It is to see if the town will vote to accept the provisions of Chapter 32, Section 22d of the Massachusetts General Laws, which requires the town to establish a retirement system.

funding schedule designed to reduce the unfunded liability of the town to zero as of June 30, 2028, and which would remove the requirement of a maximum salary upon which a retirement allowance may be based for employees who went to the service of the town after January 1, 1979, and to otherwise act thereon. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is the town vote yes, but the moderator now recognizes the chairman of the Warrant Committee, Mr. Philip Murphy, to explain that recommendation.

Speaker 10 (21:59–26:02)

Thank you, Mr. Moderator. What a great way to start a day to get up and try to explain the actual calculations that went into the funding of the retirement system. I'm being facetious.

I have no intention whatsoever of doing that, nor could I. Let me just comment. I think the current comment in the article is fairly self-explanatory. Let me highlight two points.

There are two principal issues in this article. Number one, it would allow the town to finally adopt a funding schedule to amortize the unfunded liability in the contributory pension system. That would be amortized through the year 2028 and then we would be on a currently funded or normal cost basis I guess going forward. The second thing that it does, and this is a very important issue for many of our employees, is it lifts the $30,000 salary cap that is applied to the defined benefit pension plan.

In layman's terms, and I'm a layman, What that means is in your final pay calculation for retirement, you look at the final pay of the employee, but for certain employees who are hired after, I believe it's January 1, 1979, although not for the teachers, but for other employees, they are capped. The final salary that goes into that calculation is capped at $30,000. So as we go forward in time, we have more and more employees who are hired after January 1st, 1979. We also have, through inflationary pressures, we have more people whose final salary will exceed the $30,000.

So it will do the two things. The acceptance of this article would remove that cap and would put us on a funding schedule to amortize the unfunded liability, something that many town officials have wanted to do for many years. In prior years, the disparity between the current way we fund our contributory retirement system on a so-called pay-as-you-go basis, the disparity between that and adopting the funding schedule and lifting the salary cap was very dramatic. It was an added cost of somewhere in the $400,000 range some years, at least $250,000-$400,000.

And in these Proposition 2.5 budgets, we simply couldn't do it, despite the merits of the argument. This year the stars are all aligned and I think you have to give credit to the retirement board who has excellent performance of the investment account and this year that we could adopt a funding schedule and lift the cap the appropriation the following article I guess in Article 10 that's recommended is actually $7,000 less than the pay-as-you-go appropriation that the state pension board would require us to make. So it's actually less expensive this year to do this. The other benefit that we derive from adopting this is that as we go forward on a funding schedule with periodic reviews every three years or so we will have a fairly smooth ride.

The funding schedule will have an increase of somewhere I think in the range of a hundred thousand dollars for next year. It'll be a fairly predictable climb so we won't go lurching around as we might have done under the existing system. So for a number of reasons principally principally probably the fairness issue for our employees who by the way will have to pay an additional 2% for the salary over 30,000 so they will be contributing more to this plan for a number of reasons the Warrant Committee very strongly supports this and recommends a yes vote.

Speaker 2 (26:02–26:07)

Any town meeting member wish to be heard on article 9?

Speaker 1 (26:11–26:47)

Peter Mullen, Precinct 3. I support the purpose of this amendment, of this article, but I had a question. I know we've considered this before and we did not adopt it previously because of funding limitation. I'm wondering whether there are any town employees who have retired in the interim since the last time we considered this and who were subject to the $30,000 cap and whether there's any authority to include them now that we have the money into this new system, which would not have the $30,000 cap.

Speaker 2 (26:48–26:54)

That's a good question. Mr. Murphy, can you answer that question?

Speaker 10 (26:54–27:09)

I'm going to try. I believe there are a few disability retirees since then. My understanding is that this is retroactive and would apply to the employees who have retired. And there are only two, right?

Does that answer your question?

Speaker 1 (27:09–27:11)

And they would be covered? They would be covered.

Speaker 10 (27:11–27:12)

Thank you.

Speaker 2 (27:13–31:34)

Anyone else wish to be heard on Article 9? If not, all those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed?

Article 9 is adopted, and the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is adopted unanimously. Article 10. To see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994, and for the several categories classified as employee benefits and to act on anything related thereto. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town appropriate the amount shown below in the following tabulation under the heading recommended.

And that comes to a grand total, I won't read all the subtotals, of $5,231,305. And that included in this appropriation for employee benefits are the sums of $14,469 representing expenses attributable to the sewer enterprise. and $184,045 for expenses attributable to the water enterprise which are to be included in Schedule A local receipts not allocated of the tax recapitulation as sewer and water estimated receipts. The sum of $39,836 but no more shall be used for salaries and wages.

Does anyone wish to be heard on Article 10? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Those opposed. Article 10 and the recommendation of the Warrant Committee are unanimously passed.

Article 11. To see if the town will vote to amend chapter 13 of the general bylaws known as the Personnel Administration Bylaw as follows. And those recommendations appear on pages 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, and the top of 20 in the warrant. And I'm not going to read those, but the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote.

to amend chapter 13 of the general bylaws, known as the personnel administration bylaw, by striking out the sections position identification by grade, department, and municipal division, and position classification schedule of rates, and inserting in place thereof the sections position identification by grade, department, and municipal division, and position classification schedule of rates exactly as set forth in the warrant, and that no appropriation be made. Any town meeting member wish to be heard on Article 11? If not, all those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye.

Those opposed? Recommendation of the Warrant Committee under Article 11 is unanimously adopted. Article 12. To see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994 for the operation of the town departments classified as general government and to act on anything relating thereto.

Recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the Town appropriate the amounts shown in the following tabulation under the heading Recommendation, and I will read the totals. Under Accountants, 126,518. Election and Registration, total 31,457. Holiday Celebration, 1,178.

Law Budget, 83,200. Town Office and Library Buildings, 229,992. Annual Report, 6,143. Selectman $196,207, veteran benefits $15,775 for a grand total of $1,068,514.

Board of Assessors total $147,663, town clerk total $126,312, treasurer collector Total $199,801, and that included in this appropriation for general government are the sums of $99,029 representing expenses attributable to the sewer enterprise and a $27,931 for expenses attributable to the water enterprise, which are to be included in Schedule A local receipts not allocated of the tax recapitulation as sewer and water estimated receipts. Does anyone wish to be heard on Article 12? If not, all those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, say aye. Aye.

Those opposed? It is unanimously Article 12, and the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is unanimously adopted. Article 13 is to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994, for the operation, maintenance, and improvement of public works, and to act on anything relating thereto. I understand that the Warrant Committee has an amendment, and I recognize Chairman of the Warrant Committee, Mr.

Murphy.

Speaker 10 (31:37–37:50)

OK follow along carefully. There are several changes in the numbers and so forth. But first of all under the broad heading of solid waste management I'd ask you to simply strike the word contract in the second and third lines of the collection of refuse where it says collection of refuse contract. If you would strike the word contract and where it says curb curbside recycling contract strike the word contract.

That change is because those items inadvertently have been termed just for the contract, but they include other things such as stickers and so forth. So the contract with the pickup company is not the entire amount that's in those articles, in those lines. Let me now go to the line item changes starting with the fiscal 95 recommendation the solid waste management account again the collection of refuse because of bids that have come in recently that changes to 3 3 5 0 0 0 3 3 5 0 0 0. The next line item the curbside recycling that is 1 7 6 0 0 0 and by our calculations that changes the subtotal solid waste, which is right below the line, to $881,150.

It then changes the total tax levy amount, the next line down, to $1,829,565. Moving then down to the water operation, the MWRA water assessment changes from eight thirty four seven fifty two to nine zero three four five zero changing the subtotal for water enterprise to one comma six seven one three five four then down to the sewer the M.W.R.A. sewer assessment that changes to two comma nine six five zero zero three Again the 3 2 0 9 3 3 1 changes to 2 9 6 5 0 0 3. And then the subtotal now becomes for the sewer enterprise becomes three million two hundred and thirty eight thousand seven hundred and thirty seven.

Moving on to the next page. My fingers are killing me from the calculator last night. Total water and sewer enterprise changes from the $5 million figure to $4,910,091. $4,910,091.

And then the total for the Department of Public Works changes to $6,739,656. Again 6 million 7 3 9 6 5 6. That almost concludes the amendments in the second paragraph that follows the numbers in the 1 2 3 4th and 5th line. It talks about how much money comes from the tax levy and then to be raised from local receipts and that number of 1 million 4 5 3 1 3 0.

by my calculation changes to 1,000,00521,828. 1,000,00521,828 in both places fourth and fifth lines and then down to the next paragraph again the fourth and fifth lines the number 3,000,00280,720 changes to 3,000,000,036,392. again three million zero three six three nine two and that is that is now the recommendation of the Warrant Committee. Let me just let me let me quickly speak to some of the changes the Again, in the solid waste program, these are the result of favorable contracts secured by the DPW.

One area that I think will be exciting for the town is, not sure I should say exciting, but I think it was a favorable development for the town, is in the collection of refuse. The new bids include the ability to place large items such as refrigerators and couches and so forth out there is a charge for that and I believe the selectmen are reviewing a charge for the homeowners you know put sticker on it and have that picked up but it would be definitely a convenience in the MWRA adjustments the adjustments we're talking about what we're voting you should understand that These are based on preliminary estimates from the MWRA. Later we'll be talking about moving the town meeting back in time. I guess this would not be affected by that, but we have changing numbers throughout the process.

The original numbers that appeared in the warrant were the best estimate we had at the time the warrant went to press. Since that time, the MWRA has come out with some revised preliminary estimates or revised estimates. These are now the best numbers that we have today. Everybody should understand that after the legislature finishes its process, for example, you'll notice that the MWRA sewer assessment comes down substantially.

That's based on the governor's proposal to have some rate relief in his budget that would affect the rates and drive them down. If, of course, something happens in the legislative process, some of that money gets diverted to another sewer district or whatever, then that number would change. And, of course, the selectmen, when they set the rates sometime in July, or perhaps I guess July typically, will have to make an adjustment there.

Speaker 2 (37:51–38:00)

So I guess that's all I'd like to say. Thank you, Mr. Murphy. The moderator at this time will recognize Public Works Director Billy G.

Taylor.

Speaker 11 (38:03–44:11)

Thank you, Mr. Moderator. I'm pleased to be here today to address a couple areas of critical need that we're going to be talking about more in the future for Public Works. And I prepared a very short slide presentation.

And I could use a little bit of assistance Reveal the screen, take down the lights. The slides that you'll be looking at, except for the photographs, there is a handout that that was available before the meeting and will be available on the table outside afterwards if you'd like to take home copies of this. I'm going to try to interest you this afternoon in two areas that you'll be hearing more about. street resurfacing and equipment replacement.

The department made requests that would significantly increase the amount of money that's devoted to these areas in this budget. However, however sympathetic the Warrant Committee was, they couldn't find money to significantly increase the amount of money spent in these areas. The two areas that are that have been critically underfunded for at least the past 10 years are street maintenance and equipment replacement. What what this is going to cause is that you're going to see huge future costs for the town by deferring road maintenance.

You're going to have bills in the future that are four or five times higher than what you would have spent if you'd had a decent ongoing maintenance program and in not replacing equipment, we forego productivity improvements and drive up dramatically the cost of maintenance. An ongoing road maintenance program from non-arterial streets would have cost the town about $2.5 million over the past 10 years. Instead, the town spent $355,000. The slightly over $2 million not spent means that the cost has now skyrocketed to well over $4 million.

And that figure will continue to climb due to underfunding. The next slide, please. This slide just graphically illustrates how far short the town's expenditures have fallen over the past 10 years. Assuming the roads were in good condition in 1985, an average of $250,000 should have been spent over this time.

But you can see we didn't come anywhere close. The next slide, please. And just quickly run through these. These are what some of your roads look like due to the fact that this program's been unfunded.

This graph illustrates how a pavement's quality declines over time. If we spend a dollar at the right point in a pavement's life, Before it starts down that very steep curve of deterioration, we can avoid the necessity of spending $4 to $5 only a couple years later. Unfortunately, many of our streets are past the point where low-cost routine maintenance will be effective any longer. Next slide, please.

The second area that's been critically underfunded is equipment replacement. We've calculated the cost to replace equipment in the department that's outlived its useful life, and that replacement value is over $2 million. The value of the good equipment that we have is $1.5 million. An annual program to replace equipment on an ongoing basis would have cost us $270,000.

Unfortunately, the town has never spent at a level even half of that in even one of the last 10 years. And the next slide please will illustrate that. Equipment and if we could see the next couple of slides equipment such as the department's 1968 sidewalk tractor is in dire need of replacement. If this particular tractor fails during the course of a snowstorm the sidewalks are not plowed.

And I think most of you realize Schools cannot open because a good portion of our students walk to school. This is what that piece of equipment looks like. Next, please. This is my final slide.

This just illustrates that 71% of our equipment has outlived its useful life.

Speaker 5 (44:14–44:15)

Thank you.

Speaker 2 (44:27–44:36)

Thank you very much, Mr. Taylor. Does any town meeting member wish to be heard on Article 13? Mr.

Mullen.

Speaker 1 (44:38–44:58)

Peter Mullen, Precinct 3. I think I read recently that the town was appealing the assessment from the MWRA with regard to water and sewer charges. And I wonder if somebody can confirm whether that's true and can explain to us what the issue is and what the likely consequences would be if we prevail.

Speaker 2 (45:00–45:05)

Is there an appeal and is Kathy Dunphy a select person to answer that?

Speaker 9 (45:07–45:39)

On Thursday, the Board of Selectmen signed a letter to begin a formal appeal process of the MWRA water assessment. We feel that it's based on estimates. We know that part of it is an increase in the MWRA base rate. 7% of the 21% is just an increase of their rate to all cities and towns.

But we're appealing the assessment that they have given to Milton it is a preliminary assessment and the appeals process has been initiated.

Speaker 1 (45:41–45:52)

Is there any estimate as to what the fiscal impact would be if we prevailed and what the time period might be?

Speaker 9 (45:52–46:08)

It would, if we are successful in our appeal, it would affect the water rates. It would not affect the tax levy. But it would, we would expect, allow us to keep the water rate as low as possible based on other circumstances.

Speaker 12 (46:09–46:10)

Thank you.

Speaker 2 (46:11–49:26)

Any other town meeting member wish to be heard on Article 13? If not, I'll move the question, which is the adoption of the recommendation of the Warren Committee as set forth in the warrant but as amended by Mr. Murphy. All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye.

Aye. Those opposed? Article 13, the recommendation of the Warrant Committee there under is adopted unanimously. Article 14 requires a two-thirds vote and the article is to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate from maintaining, repairing, improving, and constructing ways under the provisions of General Laws, Chapter 90, said some or any portion thereof to be used in conjunction with any money which may be allotted by the state for this purpose to determine how said appropriation shall be raised, whether by borrowing or otherwise, and to act on anything relating thereto.

The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the sum of $292,361 be appropriated for the purposes set forth in this article that to meet said appropriation, the treasurer be authorized to issue, with the approval of the Board of Selectmen, bonds or secured notes in the amount of $292,000, that the sum of $361 be raised in the tax levy, that the town vote to accept grants under the provisions of Chapter 33, Acts of 1991, in the amount of $292,361, the said reimbursements from the state 100% to be restored upon the receipt to the town treasury. Does any member wish to be heard on Article 14? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye.

Those opposed to Article 14, the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is adopted unanimously. Article 15. To see if the town will vote to revise the appropriations under Article 13 of the March 1993 annual town meeting by decreasing the MWRA sewer assessment by $658,922 and by increasing the MWRA water assessment by $9,614. So the revised recommendation would be MWRA sewer assessment $2,802,909, MWRA water assessment $747,316 and to act on anything relating there too.

and the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote yes and that the sum of $9,614 be transferred from the water surplus to be added to the appropriation of $737,702 for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1993 for the MWRA water assessment made under Article 13 of the March 1993 annual town meeting. Is there any debate on this article? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Those opposed?

The recommendation of the Warrant Committee under Article 15 is carried unanimously. Article 16. To see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate transfer from available funds or otherwise provide to supplement the appropriation for the Public Works General Account for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1993, under Article 13 of the March 1993 Annual Town Meeting, and to act on anything relating thereto, the moderator recognizes the Chairman of the Warrant Committee, Mr. Murphy.

Speaker 10 (49:27–50:03)

Thank you Mr. Moderator. We have a revised recommendation on this article. It is recommended that the sum of fifty three thousand dollars be appropriated to supplement the appropriation for the public works general account.

for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1993, under Article 13 of the March 1993 annual town meeting, and that to meet said appropriation, the sum of $53,000 be transferred from the overlay reserve.

Speaker 2 (50:10–50:34)

The recommendation of the Warrant Committee under Article 16 is to approve an appropriation of $53,000 for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1993, under Article 13 of the March 1993 Annual Town Meeting, and to meet said appropriation, the sum of $53,000 be transferred from the overlay surplus. Is there any debate?

Speaker 10 (50:35–54:56)

You may speak to it, Mr. Moore. Just by way of explanation, I don't think much explanation is necessary in terms of the amount of snowfall this year. Unlike last year, we're not engaged in a blizzard.

But the snow problem is is that budget has been overexpended I think by some two hundred thousand dollars plus the Department of Public Works has reviewed their account account to see what work they can do to shift some of their projects and so forth. I think the net figure Mr. Taylor is about one hundred sixty six thousand dollars that they would need to make up this deficit in snow removal costs this week. We received a copy of a letter that the assessor sent to the board of selectmen reporting that there is an additional ninety seven thousand dollars of overlay reserve due because of favorable experience in a tax abatement cases.

These are for prior the overlay account for prior years. One might say why doesn't the full 97 go in here. Let me let me back up a little bit. When we were putting this budget together, we met with all of the financial officials throughout the town.

We went through the estimates of revenue. As you might imagine, there are several areas that are subject to change. When we finally came down to balancing the budget within the Proposition 2.5 limits, We review the various accounts and again in recognizing that in discussing with the assessors and other officials that there might be some changes in some of the revenue accounts exactly like we have seen. We had overestimated to some degree our the revenue.

That figure was about one hundred and ten thousand dollars. in balancing the budget. It was a calculated risk. It turned out to be fairly conservative in light of the developments.

We now have $97,000 of additional money from the overlay reserve account. In addition, because of the override, there's a slight impact on this year's tax rate. That has to do with the debt service for the planning for the high school science edition. That figure is roughly $55,000.

And the net effect of all of that is that We have some fifty three thousand we feel it can now be moved from that account into the snow removal account. The balance of that must we would we are going to later recommend will be put in to help fund the reduce the amount that comes from the tax levy to fund the reserve fund. Again that will bring us back into balance given this over projection of revenue or optimistic projection of revenue at the time that the warrant went to print. One comment about the snow account.

As I mentioned, $166,000 underfunded in that area. $53,000 certainly won't make up the difference. There is, however, a state bill that's, I think, two-thirds of the way there. I think it's gone through the governor proposal.

I think the House voted the other day to appropriate some $15 million for cities and towns for emergency snow aid. It's very problematic. You don't know exactly how that would be calculated, what the distribution of Milton would be. Officials at the Mass Municipal Association have reviewed last year's funding formulas and speculate that it might be somewhere in the range of $40,000 to Milton.

There's a you know again you're rolling the dice you don't know that's only two thirds of the way through the legislative process so we don't know what the money will be like. We hope that if it comes out it will come out in such a form that it can be applied to this 94 snow account. There's a problem in terms of timing. It's fairly technical.

And then the balance we would hope to meet from this year's reserve fund account. And just to keep in mind later on in our discussions of the reserve fund and how much we set aside. That's the account that we set aside at the hundred and eighty two hundred thousand dollar range. And we need that for just such a you know for these just these occasions.

So I guess that's my way of explanation.

Speaker 2 (54:56–54:58)

Thank you. Thank you Mr. Murphy. Yes sir.

Speaker 13 (54:59–55:09)

David Pickering now 367. It looks to me like Article 16 is the snow removal but doesn't say anything about snow. So the money would go into general fund, I presume. Shouldn't you add Tiago, so it says snow?

Speaker 10 (55:10–55:22)

It's a program budget. There isn't an individual line item for snow removal. If you go back and look at the prior, what was it, Article 13.

Speaker 2 (55:22–55:27)

So, and I think… It goes under Public Works General.

Speaker 10 (55:27–55:30)

Public Works General, that general program part of the budget.

Speaker 13 (55:31–55:34)

So the money's appropriate, it doesn't necessarily have to go to snow removal then?

Speaker 2 (55:34–56:20)

The state of affairs, at least the moderator understands, is these funds have already been expended on snow removal and a careful projection of the available funds remaining in the budget approved last year would mean that you'd have to furlough a significant number of the portion of the employees in DPW unless there were some extraordinary effort made to replenish, well not replenish, but to add to the budget to account for the amount that was spent in excessive budget for snow removal.

Speaker 13 (56:20–56:29)

Thank you. One more question while we're talking about snow from Mr. Taylor. How many private ways do you have in the town?

Does the DPW plow these private ways at no cost to the people?

Speaker 2 (56:29–56:31)

I'm sorry, I didn't quite get the question.

Speaker 13 (56:31–56:34)

I wonder how many private ways are plowed by the DPW in this town?

Speaker 2 (56:35–56:44)

How many private ways are plowed by the DPW? Yes, sir. And at what cost? Mr.

Cronin, can you answer that question?

Speaker 12 (56:44–57:02)

In 1935 or thereabouts, the voters of the town of Milton accepted a general law, an optional law, requiring the town to plow the private ways. Ms. Agostino.

Speaker 14 (57:03–57:38)

Diane Agostino, Precinct 8. I have a question for the Law Committee. I was under the impression that If the budget for snow removal, that there was a law in the Commonwealth of Mass, if the budget for snow removal was equal to or greater than the previous year's budget, there was some allowance that this snow removal deficit that may result could be picked up in the future years. And I'm only raising this question to see if something else comes up on town meeting floor today, if we don't have that option for the 53,000 from the overlay to be spent elsewhere.

Speaker 2 (57:39–57:55)

I understand your question is whether or not there is an option to defer the extra amount by which the budget has been exceeded for snow removal into some future year. Can you answer that, Mr. Murphy?

Speaker 10 (57:55–58:33)

Well, you are correct. There is a provision that allows you to do exactly that. And the precondition is exactly as you stated. You must have a line item appropriation equal to or exceeding your prior year's line item appropriation.

Similar to the answer to the last question, the DPW budget is a program budget. So there is no line item appropriation. And it's my understanding that the town officials, town accountant, have queried the Department of Revenue probably the Bureau of Local Accounts Bureau of Accounts to see whether under those circumstances you could avail yourself of that provision and simply put it on the next year's tax rate. And the answer is that we cannot.

Speaker 2 (58:37–58:38)

Yes sir.

Speaker 15 (58:39–59:22)

Mr. Moderator. Bernard Lynch precinct 10. I live on Brook Road down from Aquinas Business School Aquinas Academy.

We were two days, two and a half days, without water. And they had to come out and dig up the water pipes, which have all been fractured because of the excessive, quote, truck use. We have trucks using that place morning, noon, and night. And there's a certain amount of fatigue there, and hydraulics, I guess, given the fact that there's a brook running under Brook Road.

And I wonder if the Public Works Department Has given any further thought to that? Or someone?

Speaker 2 (59:22–59:25)

Any further thought to precisely what, Mr. Lynch?

Speaker 15 (59:25–59:28)

To correcting rather than patching up the problem.

Speaker 16 (59:29–59:30)

Correcting the problem?

Speaker 15 (59:30–59:41)

Well, the problem would be, too, a truck supposed to be of the size that they encumber using Brook Road. There was a time that they couldn't use it.

Speaker 2 (59:45–59:47)

All right. So your question is.

Speaker 15 (59:48–59:51)

Well it might be best that Mr. Taylor.

Speaker 2 (59:51–59:55)

Mr. Taylor if he understands the question to respond.

Speaker 15 (59:55–59:59)

It's a serious problem. The water there you couldn't drink it for over two days.

Speaker 2 (01:00:02–01:00:08)

Mr. Taylor we have a question for DPW relating to the problem on Brook Road where a town meeting.

Speaker 15 (01:00:08–01:00:10)

Excessive truck traffic.

Speaker 2 (01:00:10–01:00:17)

Mr. Lynch. Can you rephrase your question for Mr. Taylor Mr.

Lynch. Repeat it, please.

Speaker 15 (01:00:19–01:01:00)

Mr. Taylor, we had broken water mains on Brook Road, down near Aquinas Academy, going towards St. Agatha's Church. There's a brook under the road there.

The heavy tracks, the constant use of tracks and the vibration, it caused fatigue among the pipes. The roads cracked. There were huge crevices in them. and all of the people along there were without water, but the main thing is that this appears to be the potential for a health hazard and other accidents of cars that are spinning along there and have been knocking over the horses that were there.

Speaker 2 (01:01:02–01:01:28)

Okay, let me see if I understand the question, Mr. Lynch. The question is whether or not the DPW has any plans or suggested solution to solve the problem of pipes broken being broken on Brook Road apparently due to an excess amount of traffic by heavy trucks. OK.

Is that something you can answer Mr. Taylor.

Speaker 11 (01:01:28–01:02:14)

Well I'll try. I think the question of the truck traffic Mr. Lynch is is a fairly complicated one. I mean if you're going to divert traffic from one route you're going to put truck traffic on another.

And I think that's a question that the traffic commission would like to take up and look at. I think probably, though, the water main breaks that we've experienced this winter, and there's been quite a number, are mostly due to the severe weather. Frost got a number of feet in the ground, three or four feet in the ground, and I think the age of the system and the severe weather caused most of the breaks. Does that answer your inquiry, Mr.

Lynch?

Speaker 15 (01:02:14–01:02:26)

Yes, it does. I would just like to say that this is not a criticism against the Public Works Department. It's something called age, and I'm totally familiar with that.

Speaker 2 (01:02:26–01:04:09)

Thank you, Mr. Lynch. And does anyone else wish to speak to Article 16 and the amended recommendation of the Warrant Committee, which is to appropriate the sum of $53,000, essentially. I'm paraphrasing.

And to meet that appropriation, $53,000 will be taken from the overlay surplus, not from the overlay reserve. All those in favor of the amended recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed?

This is Article 16, the amended recommendation of the Warrant Committee. is adopted unanimously. Article 17 is to see if the town, without assessment of betterments and without making an appropriation, will vote to accept the following street as a town way as laid out by the selectmen. And that's Gerald Road from previously accepted section southerly to the end and to act on anything relating thereto.

The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote yes. Is there any debate? Are those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee? Say aye.

Those opposed? Article 17 is adopted unanimously. Article 18, because it involves a bond issue, requires a two thirds vote. However, Article 18, which is to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for capital items, said some to be raised by a bond issue.

And to act on anything relating there to, despite the lengthy list, the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that no appropriation be made. Is there any debate? All right, first I recognize Mr. Murphy to explain the position of the Warrant Committee.

Speaker 10 (01:04:09–01:05:40)

Well, I just want to comment very briefly. The Warrant Committee wanted this article in the Warrant this year just to highlight the problem that we're facing year after year in trying to balance budgets within Proposition 2 and 1 1⁄2. Really, I think there are items here that just go to reinforce what Mr. Taylor said about the DPW, the roads.

We see the same conditions in the school buildings. We see it in town office buildings. We have computer systems that are either non-existent or out of date. Many of these capital costs that we put off are exactly as Mr.

Taylor described it's not a question of you can pay me now or pay me later you can really it's a question of you can pay me now or pay me four or five dollars later on and I should mention just just to clarify that this is far from a complete list we made a particular effort in the budget process this year to secure information from everybody about what needs were going on met I've heard from some departments, for example, the library, there are a lot of library needs that aren't reflected in this list. We'd hope that there'd be more emphasis and more consideration about long-term planning in the capital areas because of just the concerns that Mr. Taylor represented. But again, given the constraints of Proposition 2 1⁄2, at this time, we didn't feel that appropriation was, that we could sustain one.

Yes, sir.

Speaker 17 (01:05:41–01:06:33)

Jeff Wilkinson, Precinct 11. There was a headline in the transcript yesterday, I think, that said the buck stops here. And we're really passing the buck on this issue. It's not the first time that we've heard this statement.

And I appreciate it. I'm sure I'm not alone in appreciating that the Warrant Committee took the trouble to give us this list. I have a question for Mr. Murphy or for a representative from the selectmen.

If you would look in a crystal ball or share with us some of your deliberations, how are we going to address this over time? Are we hoping that state aid to cities and towns rises? Are we looking for new commercial tax revenues? Are we looking for an apropos time for an override to address some of these capital needs?

When will the buck stop here?

Speaker 10 (01:06:34–01:10:47)

Mr. Murphy is recognized. Thank you for that question. Jeff that's a that's a tough one.

You know in the last couple of months I guess we've been going around delivering the pessimistic news and maybe maybe I'm pessimistic maybe I'm just conservative in taking a long term view. I think we do need to look at the long term. The area which concerns me Jeff and others is that is state aid. If you look in the if you look in the mid 80s Milton received in many years I think 86 a million dollars of additional state aid in that year alone to try to grow the budget.

This year we are counting we are hoping and I think it's a fairly good projection that we will get $82,000 of additional school money and that's based on a formula it's $25 per pupil. And we're also hoping that the governor's proposal to distribute additional lottery money, which is general state aid, of I think $130,000. We have projected that in the budget. But combined, on a net basis, you're talking about $200,000, not a million like you had in some years during the mid-'80s.

My long-term view is somewhat pessimistic in a general sense on state aid. insofar as the state has made a tremendous extraordinary commitment to the education reform bill and I support those efforts those are to distribute money throughout the Commonwealth so every community can come up to a certain foundation level and that's good news for the Commonwealth but for the for the town of Milton unfortunately it's bad news that because of our above average per capita income, we will get this minimum aid, or the $25 per pupil. So just by way of example, this year when Milton gets $80,000, a neighboring community of Weymouth will get a million dollars extra. So the substantial help is going to those other communities.

And what's troubling, I guess, what I've heard from the Mass. Municipal Association, their presentations on this subject, is that it looks like state aid will come out less and less in an unrestricted area, but maybe directed to specific targets, like, you know, education was first on the list, maybe the next thing will be, you know, increasing community policing grants and so forth. And so I don't want to get up on the soapbox and say we need a big effort, but I certainly think that people who are involved in local government do have to make sure that the state does continue to fund their specific areas of state aid, like the Quinn Bill. I was also discussing with the now former chairman of the school committee the fact that the state has not come through on a provision to fund state wards who are educated in Milton.

Because of our proximity to Boston, we have quite a few state wards here. And I think the reimbursement would be in the level of $200,000 to $250,000 if we could secure that. But the state has, although that's part of the education reform bill, It has the magic word subject to appropriation. The state is not appropriate that money.

So in all of those areas I guess we need to need to try to grow the revenues on a short term basis. I guess the only optimistic news I would say is that in talking to the town treasurer early this year he reported with the improving economy real estate and also his fine efforts to increase collections through tax title and so forth that that tax collections are up. They appear to be going up. They're already very high anyway on a percentage basis.

And perhaps as that money builds back into the budget, that shows up in subsequent years as free cash. And, you know, one fiscal school thought is to take that money once it develops in the ensuing year and through a special town meeting or whatnot, appropriate perhaps for capital items or other items. But, you know, we do need to look at the long term. I think there are some ominous signs out there, but I hope that's probably a lot longer answer than you expected.

Thank you, Mr. Murphy. Yes, sir.

Speaker 18 (01:10:47–01:11:16)

Perhaps the town can buy some mass millions tickets and be a little lucky. Michael Kraft Precinct 5. This is a question. Looking on the list I'd say that a number of these items appear to be purchases if it was new equipment and I wonder to what extent used equipment of moderately good value could be substituted for new or equipment leases could be used instead.

Speaker 2 (01:11:16–01:11:41)

I mean, obviously, the answer to that question is that those things could be done. But does anyone wish to address that further? The question is whether or not, instead of new equipment, you could purchase used equipment or leased equipment. I mean, obviously, you can.

Does anyone have anything further on that? Is the answer any more precise than what I just gave, Mr. Murphy?

Speaker 10 (01:11:42–01:12:18)

No, I think a former chair of the Warrant Committee just answered that question very well. You know, I think efforts are made in that direction. Obviously, you'll notice later in the article, later in the warrant, there's an article dealing with the replacement equipment. It's the other side of your, it's not your question precisely.

I mean, we obviously turn over equipment and try to recoup some money in that fashion. I'd be lying if I said I was an expert on equipment leasing. I have looked at it briefly in the past. It's fairly complicated under municipal finance and so forth.

But I believe the department heads and the town managers are looking at all those options.

Speaker 2 (01:12:20–01:15:30)

Any further discussion on this article? If not, all those in favor of the warrant committee's recommendation that no appropriation be made, say aye. Aye. Those opposed?

The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is adopted unanimously. Article 19, and this requires, because it involves unpaid bills, a four-fifths vote. It is to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994 for the several categories classified as public safety and for unpaid bills of the fire and police for prior years, and to act on anything relating thereto. and the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town appropriate the amounts shown in the following tabulation under the heading recommended.

And I will read the totals for building 69,437, fire total 2,331,927, Milton Emergency Management Agency 5,535, plumbing and gas $17,088, Police, $3,356,139. Street lighting, $402,500. Traffic lighting, $23,715. wire $140,615 for a grand total of $6,346,956.

And to meet said appropriation for leash law enforcement, the sum of $1,718 shall be transferred from the dog licenses surcharge account received pursuant to Chapter 187 of the Acts of 1981. And at the balance of $6,345,238, be raised in the tax levy of the fiscal year. Is there any debate on Article 19? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye.

Aye. Those opposed? It is unanimously adopted. Article 20.

To see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the purpose of funding cost items not in the fire department budget for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994 for the collective bargaining agreement between the town and the fire bargaining unit and to act on anything relating there too. Recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the sum of $68,027 be appropriated for the purpose set forth in this article with said sum to be raised from the tax levy. Is there any debate on Article 20? All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye.

Aye. Those opposed? Recommendation of the Warrant Committee is unanimously adopted. Article 21.

to see if the town will vote pursuant to chapter 44, section 53E 1 half of the Massachusetts general laws to establish a revolving fund to utilize the fees received by the fire department for the purchase of equipment, supplies, and materials, to authorize the fire chief to expend money from such revolving fund, to determine a limit on the total amount which may be expended from such fund in the fiscal year beginning July 1, 1994, and to act on anything relating there to. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is the town vote no. The moderator recognizes our Fire Chief, Mr. Don Affanado.

Speaker 19 (01:15:47–01:17:16)

Don Affanado, Precinct 6. The reason for submitting this This ought to go over the past three years with the installation of new bylaws and town bylaws and state statutes. We have been taking in more money into our budget than we ever had before. Expenditures made out of our budget have gone into the general fund and and have left our budget short.

The reason I submitted this amount is because of the money that has been taken in. If we need emergency funds or new equipment or to replace equipment during the year, if I don't have the money in my budget, I have to look for a reserve fund transfer from the law committee. I felt in submitting this, we could avoid this and use the money that is sent to the, that's brought in for the fire department to, at least part of it, to stay in the fire department. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (01:17:16–01:17:17)

Thank you, Chief Affenado.

Speaker 10 (01:17:18–01:19:53)

Mr. Murphy. Let me just amplify a little bit on our comments. in the warrant.

I think essentially our no recommendation is simply that this doesn't fit the profile of what we consider to be a good revolving fund. You've got to remember that revolving funds are relatively new under these new state statutes. Excuse me. They have been revolving funds for school lunch programs and athletic programs, et cetera, under different statutes.

But this year, I think because of the new revolving funds, primarily in the park department area, There were a number of requests for revolving funds when we first started the budget process. I'd say there were four or five others that were withdrawn. This year the town council held a forum in town and kind of explained how revolving funds work and what the requirements were and after most folks went to that many many of the participants in that discussion subsequently withdrew their revolving funds. The concern here I guess is that is taking revenue and diverting it directly to a department and not reducing the expenses that go along with that.

I said that this doesn't fit our profile I guess I Let me tell you what you know our profile of a good revolving funders and I think that's the park department recreation program in that area. The park department took the revenues for its existing camps and sports camps and so forth and use that to fund those things. All of the expenses that previously were on the budget then came off. So that became a self-supporting unit aside from the budget that gave them flexibility.

But even more important than that it gave them a sort of entrepreneurial spirit or the ability to then take and expand their program during the course of the year without coming to town meeting. And they've been tremendously successful in that area. I think people who have read or observed or participated in the ID program targeted the middle school kids knows how successful that has been. And I think in part that was fostered by our adoption of a revolving fund in that area.

There's probably nobody on the Warrant Committee that's more supportive of the concept of revolving funds, but I think we have to be very careful about where we use them and what the trade-offs are. So the Warrant Committee recommends a no vote on this.

Speaker 2 (01:19:55–01:20:09)

Anyone else wish to be heard on Article 21? If you're voting for the article, you will vote aye. If you are voting with the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, you will vote no. All those in favor of adoption of the article, say aye.

Aye. Those opposed, say no.

Speaker 7 (01:20:10–01:20:10)

No.

Speaker 2 (01:20:10–01:21:12)

The article is defeated. Well, we have gotten to Article 22. I assume by the continued conversation that you'd rather not have me interfere with your conversation. Is that it?

Article 22. Article 22 is to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the purpose of implementing the recommendations of the committee appointed by the moderator to study the fire protection of the town pursuant to the vote of the March 1993 annual town meeting under Article 16 and to act on anything relating thereto. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that no appropriation be made at this time I will recognize Mr. Charles Winchester, who was appointed by me to be the chairman of the Fire Protection Study Committee.

Mr. Winchester.

Speaker 20 (01:21:25–01:21:35)

Thank you, Mr. Moderator. The Fire Department Study Committee was appointed

Speaker 2 (01:21:36–01:21:59)

Last summer by the moderator pursuant to article 16 First of all people will stop talking and give mr. Winchester the courtesy of listening to him that would help And mr. Winchester, I guess if you talk as close to that microphone as possible that will help also Can you hear me?

Speaker 20 (01:22:00–01:34:43)

All right As I started to say, the committee was appointed last summer by the moderator pursuant to Article 16 of last year's annual meeting. The charge to the committee under the article was very broad, namely to study the fire protection of the town. That's certainly subject to almost anybody's interpretation. The committee met a number of times and we decided that our mission was to report to the town the condition of the fire department as we find it and to report to the town our recommendations as to what we believe the town should do to have a proper operating fire department.

We were not charged with the issue of, I might say happily, with locating funding for our recommendations, but we were not ignorant of the fact that these are difficult, have been difficult times, and probably will continue to be difficult times, as has been explained here by Mr. Taylor and by the chairman of the Warrant Committee, in view of the strictures of Proposition Two and a Half. First of all as is quoted in the comment of the Warrant Committee we found which should be no surprise to anyone in the town that the town is not a high risk fire hazard community. It's largely residential.

Most of the residences are well spaced from one another. The So that you know we don't have a large industrial or commercial areas in the town. We do have some particular fire hazards that deserve attention. We have a hospital in town.

Happily to my knowledge at least we haven't had any problems there but it's one of those things that you have to know about. We have dormitories at Curry College and Milton Academy where When you have young people in close quarters you have always concerns about life safety. We have several elderly housing projects in town which did not exist 30 years ago. We have a proliferation of licensed daycare centers in many homes throughout the town.

And of course we have schools and small commercial areas. One thing consistent in this town with national trends is that the number of fires which have had to be addressed by the fire department has declined dramatically in the last 15 or 20 years. This is part of a national trend and apparently is accounted for by early detection through smoke detectors, other technological things of that nature. and by upgraded building codes and vigorous code enforcement.

This is all to the good, obviously. Having said that, we then examined the fire department as it exists and looked at the adequacy of staffing, equipment, and the like. Equipment issues incidentally the ones that we were concerned about have already been addressed in the article just approved for public safety. There were two concerns that we had.

One was so-called turnout gear. This is the equipment worn by the firefighters at the scene. There is much more modern turnout gear. available today which offers firefighters significantly enhanced protection in a fire.

And incidentally the conditions that can be encountered in fire are incredible in terms of temperatures in terms of explosive atmospheres and the like. And our firefighters deserve the best in terms of personal protection. And the budget that was just approved goes a long way toward addressing that issue. The other issue that we were concerned about as far as personal equipment goes was the air packs worn by firefighters.

The first element of that is to acquire a compressor that will allow high pressure air packs to be used. And I believe that was in the budget. Thereafter air packs will be bought hopefully on a year to year basis. So I think those two issues were addressed.

Which brings us then to the amount of equipment that we are using, its location in the town, and the staffing. The fire department today is operating with three pieces of equipment. Two years ago it was operating with four, and ten years ago it was operating with five. A few years ago I've forgotten exactly when the ladder truck in East Milton was discontinued.

And a year, year and a half ago the Atherton Street station was closed. And that gets us down to three pieces of equipment. One pumper located in East Milton at the East Milton station. The other pumper and the ladder truck located at the central station behind Town Hall.

The manning of these pieces of equipment is based on a minimum 10 man manning per shift which includes a deputy. The actual firefighters on the trucks themselves it means nine men per shift minimum. It can be more because we actually have larger staff than that on the payroll if they're all healthy and if they're not on vacation. But that puts as a minimum two men on the ladder truck four men on the pumper behind the in the in the central station and three men in the east Milton station.

We regarded that as barely minimum. largely because of the idea that there would be three men on the pumper in East Milton. It takes one man to run the equipment and one man should always stay outside if you're at a house fire. So it really gives you two men on a hose line which is very difficult if you're moving a hose through a building, nearly impossible.

So one of our recommendations was that the minimum manning be upgraded to 11 from 10. The other major recommendations of the committee were that engine 4 which is the engine formerly at Atherton Street be reinstated. And that's that's an expensive recommendation because while we feel that it could be operated by as few as three men if there were four or five men from the central station working with it when there is a fire. Nevertheless each position that you create in the fire department because there are four shifts requires four men.

So if you if you want to add it strictly and apply and put on three positions to cover the engine for that would mean hiring a total of 12 men which is an extremely expensive proposition. Nevertheless it was our belief and is our is the committee's belief that to properly protect the town. There should be two. There should be the pumper in East Milton the pumper from Atherton Street and one in Central Station or three pumpers plus the ladder truck.

Now that you should understand that a first response to a fire call requires two pumpers and the ladder truck usually. I mean you bring it along. In this town you don't have too much aerial work to be done but you may need to ventilate a roof so you need a ladder to get up there. So The reason we feel that the number amount of equipment is deficient is because you don't have in this town any second response capability.

If there is a fire if there is a fire all your all your equipment goes to it. If any of that equipment is out on some other job or disabled for any reason you're going to have to wait for mutual aid to kick in. which would be called when the first engine arrives at the scene and knows that there's nothing else available. That was sort of interesting that two weeks ago or so after the January 30th on Belvoir Road there was a fire and one of the engines the one that's being replaced actually collapsed because of the rear springs giving way and was unable to respond.

The other engines had to take care of the fire. Now that was an oddball situation and I doubt would be repeated again but you don't know when a piece of equipment may be unavailable for any reason answering medical calls tied up on the expressway extracting someone from an accident. Our feeling was that there should be a second response capability. so that you can put three engines at the fire and have one left over to do something if called upon or to answer a second alarm if called upon.

The question of the Athens street station is sort of a difficult one. Our primary recommendation was to as I say reinstate engine for whether to reopen Atherton Street is a separate question. But the fact is that to run the Atherton Street station itself costs about five six seven thousand dollars something on that order of magnitude. The building exists and basically what you have to do is heat it and run some electricity there.

So if you're going to have the four engines it seemed to us wise to put that engine up there because of fire hazards in that area and proximity to them. Secondly another concern of ours is that the East Milton engine if if that's the only if we didn't have the Atherton Street station open and if the East Milton engine has to answer a fire call up in the other part of town it's a long way from East Milton. So those were our principal recommendations. And I think everybody has received a copy of the report.

If anybody has any questions I'd be happy to answer them.

Speaker 2 (01:34:43–01:34:47)

Thank you Mr. Winchester. Moderator recognizes Chief Don Affanado.

Speaker 20 (01:34:50–01:35:17)

Mr. Moderator, if I may just say one further word. You may, Mr. Winchester.

The committee did not expend any of the money appropriated and expects to be discharged at the conclusion of this article. So we will be happy to return the $2,000.

Speaker 19 (01:35:25–01:45:22)

Chief Afanato. Thank you Mr. Moderator. I'm Don Afanato again from Precinct 6.

For the past 32 years I've been a firefighter in this town and for the past year I've had the privilege of being your chief. As Charlie stated, Article 16 of the 1993 town meeting was voted to establish a study committee to study the fire department due to the amount of reductions made over the past four or five years. The moderator appointed five citizens, with Shelly as chairman and Selectman Shields and myself as ex-officio members. The committee spent long hours deliberating over the facts, figures, and comparisons, and also took part in practical demonstrations.

We also reviewed the fire department study committee report done in 1960. At that time, there were about 6,700 dwelling houses in the town, and the department was responding to around 1,000 ones a year. Back then, that committee recommended 19 men on duty per shift. There was now over 8,200 homes in town, and we are responding to over 2,000 ones a year.

We now have 12 men assigned per ship barring absence for injury, sickness or vacations. It has been said that the committee didn't put sufficient emphasis on the real world financial constraints of the town. I refer you to the conclusion of the report which states that the committee was in fact very cognizant of the financial constraints of the town. and that the unanimous recommendations were made for minimal, not optimum staffing and equipment.

We feel that lives and property in this town, the protection of lives and property in this town is as real world as you can get. US technology has improved over the past 30 years, as codons and rodents requiring smoke detectors and sprinkler installations. Smoke detectors have saved lives, but they do nothing to extinguish fires. It takes men and equipment arriving in a timely manner.

Of all the elderly housing complexes in town, Ankerty House, Miller Avenue, Pine Tree Brook, and Winter Valley, Building 5 at Winter Valley is the only building out of all these elderly housing complexes that is sprinkled. Curry College has 33 buildings on their campus. 11 of these buildings are dormitories. None of these buildings have sprinklers, nor do any of our public school buildings or any of the churches around town.

No, there's no guarantee that fires won't result in personal injury and property damage, but odds on this are greatly reduced when there's a firehouse nearby, not three or four miles away. to tell the residents on the westerly side of town that their fire protection is a calculated risk is ludicrous. With the continued new home growth and the future development of the fuller property, Engine 4 is essential in this area of Milton. The residents are paying for fire protection and they deserve the same level of protection as the other areas of town.

In regard to the mutual aid coverage, We work under a plan that was devised in 1980, 81. This plan involves the Metro Fire District, which includes the 34 cities and towns around Boston. Each chief, back at that time, each chief and board of selectmen or mayor of these respective communities signed this mutual aid agreement. Mutual aid is designed to assist neighboring communities when they have a fire too large to handle with their existing resources.

It is not intended to supplement another town's fire protection. Under the present mutual aid agreement, this apparatus would respond, the first response, in other words, to Milton is Boston Engine 18, which is housed in Peabody Square near Ashmore Station. That's 2.7 miles away. If the apparatus from the rebuild station, which is right over the line, responded to the alarms on the westerly side of town, of our town, we would be obligated to respond to alarms in the rebuild section, further reducing the town of Milton's fire protection.

The mutual aid concept is not designed to function in this manner. The 1992 fire report from the state fire marshal's office, the Massachusetts Department of Public Safety, 1993 report has not been issued yet, states that structure fires in the Commonwealth were up 5.2% and civilian fire deaths were up 9% over the previous year. 40% of these victims were under six or over 65. 83% of the civilian fire deaths occurred in private homes.

In the past year, we had 19 dwelling fires in Milton. This may seem like a minor statistic, but the families involved in these losses, it's a very real and unforgettable experience. Our fire prevention education, inspections, and code enforcement have always been in effect and will continue to be an ongoing part of our duties. In reference to the comment in the article, that suggests we should consider reducing our medical and service runs.

Fire suppression is still our primary function. Over the past decade, the role of fire departments has expanded considerably. Firefighters now, by law, are trained first responders for medical emergencies. We are also responsible for hazardous materials situations and a wide variety of other incidents.

Present-day fire departments are more service-oriented than they ever were before. In 1991, the town turned their ambulance service over to the Fallon Ambulance Service. Like many of our neighboring communities, the fire department responds along with the ambulance. In 90% of our medical calls, our fire apparatus arrives ahead of the ambulance.

These two winners can be extremely critical in cardiac and other life threatening situations. In the front of the 1990 warrant, the Warrant Committee report stated, and I quote, in the fire department, we recommend a budget that continues less than full service by latitude in East Milton. We do not recommend the funding requested for two vacant positions. However, We believe that there should be discussion and vote by the citizens before we would recommend funding cutbacks that would completely eliminate LATITUDE, or close or cut back the Blue Hills Fire Station.

These further cutbacks could total six men at $150,000." Unquote. Well, since then, LATITUDE is out of service. The eight men are gone, and Engine 4 is closed. And I can't recall any discussion or vote by the citizens of this town on these cutbacks.

I think the brief history of the Athens Street Fire Station that was published in this past week's transcript seems to say it all. A hundred years ago, the town realized they needed permanent fire protection in this westerly section of town. With the influx of so many new homes, the growing Covey College campus, In the future development of the fuller property, fire protection in this area is more critical than ever. In 1987, considerable monies were spent refurbishing the Engine 4 station.

Renovations were done to bring the building up to code, and a new heating system installed to make it more cost effective. Power and heat are presently kept on due to existing apparatus still there. And there will be no new equipment needed to reopen this station. And if I recommend I think we'll submit an amendment to the recommendation and article 22 recommend that the town vote to appropriate the sum of three hundred and fifty thousand dollars for the purpose set forth in this article including the reopening of the Athens Street fire station and restoring and the rest and the restoring of a firefighter positions to the fire department contingent upon the passage of a prop two and a half override referendum question for those purposes by the voters of the town of Milton.

To provide adequate protection for the entire town of Milton, we urge your support for this amendment.

Speaker 2 (01:45:22–01:45:24)

Thank you, Chief Avenato.

Speaker 19 (01:45:24–01:45:36)

Before I step down, excuse me, I just want to personally thank the study committee for their diligence and sincerity and the tasks they were called upon to accomplish. Thank you.

Speaker 3 (01:45:46–01:46:33)

Thanks, man. All right, this motion is being accepted by the moderator.

Speaker 2 (01:46:34–01:49:58)

Now, for future reference, however, for those of you who, and perhaps we're going to be facing this problem at future town meetings more and more, given what Mr. Taylor said and what the Warren Committee's put in in the way of capital expenditures that are not being met. And this I have no control over. There is a section of the bylaws of the town that will not allow me to entertain motions for expenditures in excess of $500 unless I can conclude that the town meeting members have been fairly put on notice that those expenditures are to be made.

Now, I am accepting this motion on the theory that the Warrant Committee's comments relating to the report of a committee, namely, and this tracks the bylaws where there's been a report of a committee, indicating the need for certain expenditures. And the Warrant Committee gave fair notice to the town that those recommendations would cost at least $500,000. So I am willing to accept this motion which asks for approval of some $350,000 in that it is within that $500,000 figure mentioned in the warrant. Now again, I point this out not to create hurdles to our process, only to remind you that I am bound by the written rules in our charter and bylaws.

And so this should be kept in mind when someone submits an article to see what sum of money the town will appropriate. If the Warrant Committee is going to say no and no sum appears, I am in the future not going to have any choice but to then when someone comes along and says well I want to spend 100,000 under this article to rule you out of order. This one is not out of order. Now let me also explain what the procedure will be that we have this motion pending.

I need a second to this motion. The motion has been seconded. All right. So it's been moved and second seconded that We recommend that the town vote to appropriate the sum of $350,000 for the purposes set forth in this article, including the reopening of the Atherton Street Fire Station and the restoring of eight firefighter positions to the fire department, contingent upon the passage of a Proposition 2 1⁄2 override referendum question for those purposes by the voters of the town of Milton.

Now, I am taking this as a motion on the article. It is not a motion to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, in which case I'd have to have two votes, one to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, and another vote as to whether you accept it. If, in fact, this motion is not further amended and goes down favorably, then that will be an appropriation under the article. I'm going to have one vote.

Now, as a matter of procedure, we will now have debate. And I will recognize those who wish to speak to the adoption or if your position is not to adopt the motion. And the first person that the moderator recognizes is Representative Joseph Manning.

Speaker 21 (01:50:10–01:58:15)

Oh, he's good. Thank you, Mr. Moderator. I'm Joe Manning from Precinct 7.

And at the outset, I would like to express my sincere appreciation and congratulations to the committee, Mr. Moderator, that you appointed, and its chairman, Mr. Winchester, for the in-depth study of this very, very serious problem that faces our community. I'm impressed with our fire chief, Don Affanado, who just presented to you his genuine concerns as our fire chief, as he carries out from day to day his responsibilities as the leader of a fire department to protect the lives and property of our citizens.

Last year I appeared before you asking for your support of Article 16 of the 1993 Warrant that the Board of Selectmen join with me in filing to call for study of the fire protection of the town of Milton. This measure received the support of the Board of Selectmen, our Warrant Committee, and this membership voted their unanimous approval. Our moderator appointed a committee of five citizens. A thorough study was made and the report was filed with our Board of Selectmen in December of last year.

Permit me to share with you some of the committee's findings that I found very revealing. And I quote. The recent history of the Milton Fire Department is one of significant decline in terms of size and staffing. Staffing levels are dangerously low.

Response times are down on the west side of town and equipment is outdated, although we have addressed that somewhat in the previous article. We regard the present manning situation to be very deficient. The present minimum staffing is inadequate in light of the duties of the firefighters at the scene of a fire. Undermanning is a potential threat to life and property as well as to the firefighters' safety.

We believe that Engine 4 should be restored to service and restored to the Athens street station. That was a quote of the study report. In fact Milton was without fire protection. Two instances in the last 48 hours within this town on Thursday afternoon.

And on Friday, two incidents of dwelling fires that left this town without fire protection for short periods of time before we had mutual aid come in and cover. The lack of fire protection has been an issue of paramount concern to the citizens of the western section of Milton. It is not something new. to come before this meeting.

Close to a century ago, the same concerns and fears were exhibited by the residents of that time as a result of a tragic fire death in that locale. The Atherton Street Station was built as a result of this sad tragedy that occurred on February 23, 1901, a house fire at the Salt and Stall Estate on Milton Street resulted in the death of a three-year-old child. Much grief spread throughout our town, which resulted in petitions to the Board of Selectmen to do something about the lack of fire protection in the western section of Milton. The Board of Selectmen and the town meeting.

This body. Took immediate action and funds were voted at the March town meeting. One month later. To build a fire station on Bloor Avenue and Atherton Street.

That was 93 years ago. And now 91 years later. The engine for a fire station is closed. For the past two years residents of this area involved have expressed their deep concerns.

A member of this town meeting has conducted a one man crusade focusing attention on the serious lack of fire protection. offered to the western section of our town. A district that is vastly different today in both development and population than it was when Mr. and Mrs.

William Oxton conveyed to the town of Milton one acre of land at Athens Street for the consideration of one dollar. Now some 93 years later we find ourselves faced with the same conditions that we were faced with. They were then as the appropriating body. We are being asked today to approve a warrant calling for expenditures of over 41 million dollars.

to operate our town government for the next 12 months, an increase of some $900,000 over the present year's spending level. Article 22, now before us, filed by the Board of Selectmen, calling for an appropriation of funds for the purpose of implementing The recommendations of the study committee is recommended by our warrant committee that no action be taken as this town meeting is the appropriating a part of this town. Let us listen to the debate that will follow I'm sure and then establish our priorities. as we are the appropriating authority and then hopefully restore peace of mind to those citizens who feel so neglected by their town.

Speaker 2 (01:58:25–01:58:33)

Thank you, Representative Manning. The moderator recognizes the chairman of the Warrant Committee, Mr. Murphy, for the Warrant Committee's position with respect to the motion.

Speaker 10 (01:58:34–02:01:11)

The Warrant Committee has been polled and recommends a no vote on the motion. Let me be brief. I think there will be a lot of debate on this. This is a very difficult issue.

I think the words are spoken so far have been very sincere. I think the I'd echo the words that were said about the work of the fire study committee. They produced an excellent report. The price was right.

There really was a very good and thoughtful study. I've read it four or five six times as recently as last night. I think they've done an excellent job. I think we also have to recognize and thank the firefighters for doing doing an exceptional job continuing to do an exceptional job under these tough financial times.

And I'd also like to thank people who throughout the course of this debate through the newspapers and so forth have kept the debate to the to the issues. I think we've heard that so far today and I expect that we will continue to hear that. I think everybody should be commended for doing that. The difficulty I think that we have with this proposal to one degree the amended or this new I guess this is now the motion on the floor.

Part of the trouble with this is I guess that to some degree you would say well we as town meeting are off the hook. We don't have to weigh the merits of this or the priorities within the overall town budget. Let's just pass it on to the voters. Let's let them decide.

The Warrant Committee doesn't feel that that's the appropriate, the appropriate course of action. Remember that we have just had an override election. We have not yet gone to the latter part of the year when we might find that there is additional money. But even besides that, beside all of that, even if there were additional money, the Warrant Committee has been through couple of months of very extensive discussions reviewing all the budgets reviewing the capital needs and so forth.

Some of the things we talked about earlier tonight earlier today. I guess the question is if there were that additional money is this where you would put it. Let's say for example there were one hundred and fifty or three hundred and fifty thousand dollars right now. Would you put it in this area.

Speaker 7 (02:01:12–02:01:12)

I

Speaker 10 (02:01:13–02:07:10)

Remember that the override that's being contemplated here is a permanent override. This would add on a permanent basis $350,000 to the operating budget. And it would grow. As I understand the proposal today, it's to hire four, excuse me, eight new firefighters.

They would come in at step one. As they advance through their four steps, their salaries would obviously increase. In addition, reopening Athens Street, as I understand it, will soon require a replacement engine. I gather the engine four is fairly old and would have to be replaced soon.

Remember that the part of the debt service that we did in, I think it was 1992, town meeting, was to purchase a fire truck, which I gather was delivered just this week. I think the cost was somewhere about $150,000 or so. So we'd have to do a capital item. I guess we are talking primarily as a from a financial point of view and we can be pardoned for doing that.

We spent a lot of time going through the budgets and do try to try to keep financial concerns in the forefront of our deliberations. But as I said I think the people have spoken today have already spoken clearly about their concern. But as Mr. Winchester mentioned We look at the statistics and we see that there really is a success story, both nationally, statewide, nationally and locally.

And that over the last several years, over the last decade, the number of residential fire incidents has declined from, I believe it was 88 in 1984, to now 20 in this last year, excuse me, in 1992. It's a very dramatic decline. And as Mr. Winchester correctly pointed out, this is attributable to some very discreet planning and something that the fire department has has participated in and should be credited for the fire prevention efforts through installation of smoke detectors, better building codes, etc.

I think it's a success story. It's something that we ought to be proud of. The firefighters ought to be proud of it. They certainly play a large role in educating us in that area.

On the other hand, we have to face up the fact that this is an area where we're talking about measuring risk. And it's very difficult, I guess, because if the unforeseen or unwanted event occurs, then no amount of protection against that risk is adequate. No amount. Think of the way you manage risk in your own lives.

In the insurance area, and I think some have made the analogy to the fire department, a well-manned fire department being like an insurance policy, will be there to protect you. Well, everybody manages risk in their day-to-day lives. They have to purchase life insurance, health insurance, property insurance, and so forth. When I bring in the financial considerations, I'm simply bringing in the same type of considerations that each of you make.

I think each of you make the same kind of considerations. While you'd love to have more life insurance, while you'd love to have more protection in all of your insurance policies, you somehow manage that and you cut down on the cost. You look at your ability to pay and you cut down the cost by increasing deductibles or reducing the limits. And so I think that's what we're being asked to do here.

I think the taxpayers have demanded that. I've been out talking to various groups throughout town. We continually hear the suggestion that we need to evaluate our services. We need to reduce them.

We have to respond to declining service needs. The fire chief mentioned, I agree with him, the medical runs is certainly an area that has increased in the non-traditional fire response role, has increased their service needs. But there again, We believe there's an effort undergoing to try to refine that response protocols established to determine when and what response and what measure they will respond. And we think that that number could that number of runs can be reduced as well.

So. One last thought when we now talk about to some degree again we're off the hook within the constraints of proposition two and a half to the extent that this is now contingent upon an override. There's one member of the Warren committee said to me the other day. Consider if we had a study committee appointed for each of the other departments.

Suppose we had a park department study committee. school department study committee a library study committee I guess we actually do a facility study committee wouldn't we see that the same kind of decline is happening in every area of services we simply have to we simply have to adjust so now when you go on the other side of the two and a half ledger and you want to go out to the people for an override in this sense where would where would your priorities be You know, would we do the technology for the schools? Would we do the building, the pavement management or the equipment replacement? There are several needs, several millions of dollars of needs out there in addition to this particular need.

And so I think the Warren Committee is saying that even if there were additional money right now within this budget, we would not have voted to recommend that. Even if you go to an override, we think that that is not a wise move at this time. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (02:07:16–02:07:18)

Anyone else wish to be heard on the motion?

Speaker 22 (02:07:20–02:07:38)

Fran? I would like to ask Mr. Murphy a question. Was the vote of the Warrant Committee unanimous, and if not, what was the breakdown?

And secondly, I'd kind of like to know and refresh my memory, what is the cost to the town of even going to putting an override vote before the public?

Speaker 2 (02:07:40–02:08:01)

All right. Fran, Mr. Beek has two questions, whether the vote of the Warren Committee was unanimous. And secondly, what the cost is to have an override vote, which I understand under these conditions has to be conducted within 45 days of this meeting if it passes.

Mr. Murphy is recognized if he can answer those questions.

Speaker 10 (02:08:01–02:08:13)

Yes, I certainly answer the first question. The vote was 10 to 4. And I understand from town officials that the cost of the election would be somewhere between $16,000 and $18,000.

Speaker 5 (02:08:14–02:08:15)

OK.

Speaker 10 (02:08:15–02:08:16)

Yes, sir.

Speaker 23 (02:08:16–02:08:49)

Ned Rogerson, Precinct 3. Two questions. One is, what would be the average cost to the average homeowner in tax per year? I think that helps put it on a level we can understand perhaps a little bit better.

And second of all, is it only the selectmen that can put a proposition 2 and 1 half override on the ballot? In other words, does town meeting have the right here to actually force a two and a half override. I'm just unclear on that. If it is the Selectman then we have to have the Selectman's position on this.

Speaker 2 (02:08:50–02:09:09)

Okay there are now two questions perhaps addressed to the Selectman unless Mr. Murphy. The first question is what the $350,000 annual operating cost would translate into in a per household amount? And I assume if we know the number of households, we could divide that into $350,000.

Speaker 10 (02:09:09–02:09:19)

I guess we have a rough calculation of $38, somewhere in that range, on the average taxpayer, the $196,600 residential tax base.

Speaker 2 (02:09:20–02:09:26)

If your average assessment is $196,000, it would be an approximate increase of $38,000. The second question is?

Speaker 5 (02:09:26–02:09:31)

$38. $38. Excuse me. Getting loopy.

Speaker 2 (02:09:33–02:10:03)

$38 per household. The second question is whether or not there's a choice as to whether or not this goes to the voters, and that choice is exercisable by the Board of Selectmen. And I don't know the answer to the question, so I'd ask either the Selectmen or the town council the answer to that question. Moderator recognizes Mr.

John Flynn, town council.

Speaker 24 (02:10:03–02:10:22)

Mr. Moderator, Decision whether to put an override question on the ballot is in the Board of Selectmen and town meeting or any other town board or officer has no such authority. All right so be it.

Speaker 25 (02:10:22–02:11:45)

Barbara Hearn precinct 8 and a park commissioner. I'm just concerned that in article 18 we passed up on one point nine million dollars in capital improvements. And I think as a park commissioner, I'd be negligent if I didn't stand up and say, if there's a yes vote on this article, then I want to reconsider article 18 and go through my budget. Because I have $213,000 worth of improvements that I've asked for for the past three years.

And while I realize that the fire department and all they do is a tremendously important aspect of the town, think we just we ripped through 1.9 million dollars and we went well there's no money let's go on to the next article I just don't think that's fair number one and number two I think we'd be negligent the Board of Park Commissioners has talked if we didn't move to reconvene read look at article 18 if if the decision is to put this to the voters if we're going to ask for $350,000 Why don't we just make it an even $500? Because it's going to cost us X amount of money to issue the bonds. It's going to cost us X amount of money to hold the election. So why are we just asking for $350,000 when we just passed up on $1.9 million?

Thank you.

Speaker 3 (02:11:47–02:11:52)

On this side of the hall, yes sir?

Speaker 13 (02:11:52–02:12:05)

John Fasano, Precinct 4. Point of information. While we're at this microphone, we'll be will we be allowed to address the article or simply the amendment to the article Okay, I thought I made that clear.

Speaker 2 (02:12:05–02:12:21)

I consider this motion to be a substitute motion For the recommendation of the Warren Committee and that action on this motion is definitive action under the article So in other words, we can always you want something different you would be Behoove you to move to amend the

Speaker 13 (02:12:21–02:12:40)

What is a before the town meeting that's what that's why I'm asking for the point of information Can we speak to the article originally printed or just to mr. Appenado's? Amendment to that article which which asks for an override Can we only speak to the override or can we speak to the original?

Speaker 2 (02:12:40–02:13:18)

No, let me repeat the motion is not just to have an override the motion is Which I am construing is definitive action under the article is in fact to appropriate the sum of three hundred and fifty thousand dollars Under the article the article only asked what some this Town meeting will appropriate for those purposes and the motion is to appropriate three hundred and fifty thousand for those purposes Subject and contingent upon the passage of a proposition two and a half override So in other words, I can't speak to the article you certainly can I

Speaker 13 (02:13:18–02:13:57)

If I may 22 is comments. I have a couple of things underlined here that the I Suppose it's the recommendation of the comments of the Warrant Committee If mr. Murphy could answer me the question In line, I believe it's seven What major advances in fire control have reduced the risk of loss of life and property in the town of Milton? It's your comment.

I'd like to know what exactly were the major advances.

Speaker 2 (02:14:01–02:14:02)

Is that it, or do you have other questions?

Speaker 13 (02:14:02–02:14:03)

I have other questions.

Speaker 2 (02:14:03–02:14:13)

Well, you have to give them all to me. As you know from prior meetings, I don't allow cross-examinations. I allow debate, but not cross-examinations. So give me all your questions, and I'll try to get them all answered.

Speaker 13 (02:14:14–02:17:17)

Fine. That's right. It also states in the federal level blah blah blah down the line and it says residential smoke detectors the availability of sprinkler systems for elderly housing and dormitories. The availability not the existence the availability.

On the second the last line fireproof materials. Let me tell you right now the NFPA would have you up before them on that statement. There is no such thing as a fireproof material. fire resistant, not fireproof.

In addition, does the Warrant Committee expect the City of Boston, their taxpayers, to subsidize the Town of Milton's taxpayers for their lack of support for their fire department? And additionally on that, there are going to be cuts to the Boston Fire Department because they're streamlining their department. Engine 48, or 49 rather, is one slated for a cut. Disenfranchising the western part of the town, of which I'm right on the border of, is absurd.

If you expect a third alarm response to get to Eileen Road, or Silverbrook Road in a timely manner from Ashmore Station, or get there, period, in a bad time of day, you're sadly mistaken. And for any of the residents that live in that area, in the Brush Hill Road area, which, by the way, when you say there was a low risk here, you're talking about, of this low risk town, the highest risk area in the town. You've got the highest taxpayers in town on Injun 4's running card. You've got five churches on their running card, five schools on their running card, two nursing homes on their running card.

When you talk about sprinkler buildings up at Tom Flatley's place, you have to remember that somebody has to feed that standpipe, and that's us. Now if you're going to put an engine out of service to feed that sprinkler system and you have to wait for somebody to come from East Milton or from PBD Square, I hope my mother, I'm glad, unfortunately she's dead, but I'm glad that I don't know anybody who has any family in that building. Nor do I have a student in Curry College who lives in those dormitories that have the availability of sprinklers but they're not existing. And we wouldn't have enough body bags in the whole metro region if we had a fire in the Jean-Doc building up there.

Now I hope you people have to understand there is a serious safety consideration here for the firefighters involved. Not just the residents of this town or the residents of Curry College. We're taking a risk every time we go out the door and you're asking us to take a bigger risk by asking us to respond with a piece From each Milton to try and get there in time to save the guys in the first responding piece And I think it's absurd, but I like those answers to my question if possible.

Speaker 2 (02:17:17–02:17:53)

Mr. Murphy Thank you very much There are I believe two questions addressed to the Warren committee one is with respect to the comment of What major advances in fire control did the Warren committee have in mind when they made reference to that in the first paragraph of the comment. And the second question was whether or not we truly believed it was appropriate that through mutual aid Boston should subsidize Milton's budget. And the moderator recognizes Mr.

Murphy to address those two questions.

Speaker 10 (02:17:54–02:19:47)

I thought I'd talk about the advances briefly, but what we're talking about is the success stories with smoke detectors. Recently, we added a bedroom and installed a hardwired system. I think that might be part of the building code now that you have to do that. Of course, building codes that you have to place plugs, you know, so many plugs so you're not overloading circuits and so forth.

And you also alluded, and thank you for bringing up the sprinkler systems and so forth, and I think you're right about what's available and what's actually in place and obviously that's a concern. I think the fire study report I don't think the fire study report did actually talk about perhaps amending bylaws to require some additional sprinkler ring and so forth in those buildings. That's that's sort of a trade off I guess in my mind between private finance control of risk as opposed to the taxpayer control of risk. The second second question I thought was more of a rhetorical one but I'll I'll try to answer I guess was was do we expect the city of Boston to pay to somehow help out on that side of town.

My understanding is that there are some direct responses from Quincy on the other side of town. Would we hope that there could be some additional dialogue or discussion of the of the mutual aid in that area. Obviously you know I this is news to me that there are a couple of mutual aid requests honored in the last couple of days but in the in the recent past I guess we have not had if you look in the town report there was zero mutual aid delivered to Milton as far as I as I read as opposed to us sending mutual aid elsewhere so so right now at least the most recent report we're sending out 16 runs and they're they're sending zero in in the last year so I hope that addresses the question.

Speaker 2 (02:19:52–02:19:56)

Thank you, Mr. Murphy. Any other town meeting members, please identify who you are and what precinct you represent.

Speaker 26 (02:19:57–02:20:13)

Kevin Donahue, Precinct 11. Has there been any discussion with Curry College or any of the nonprofits for a fee in lieu of taxes that might help to subsidize this program where there would be a direct benefit to those institutions?

Speaker 2 (02:20:13–02:20:15)

OK, do you have any other questions?

Speaker 27 (02:20:16–02:20:16)

No.

Speaker 2 (02:20:16–02:20:30)

The question is whether or not any of the town officials have discussed payments in lieu of taxes with some of the nonprofit organizations, such as Curry College. And who can answer that? Mr. Cronin is recognized.

Speaker 12 (02:20:32–02:21:53)

There have been discussions with Curry and with Milton Academy for payments or donations in lieu of taxes. Curry has not responded. except for the fire-related safety sled for rescuing on ice and water conditions that they donated to the fire department earlier this winter. Milton Academy donates, or has picked up the cost of all the street lighting on Center Street between Voethus Lane and Randolph Avenue, and they've also picked up the cost of their traffic supervisor that they have there.

And they've recently turned several houses. I'm sorry. Milton Academy pays for, has picked up the street lighting cost recently, on Center Street, between Voza's Lane and Dudley Lane on Center Street. And they have picked up the cost of the traffic supervisor that's there for the benefit of their students.

And they've taken some houses that they own and have sold them. and put them back under the tax levy. And they're maintaining a few other houses that they've acquired in recent times, keeping those on the tax levy. So that's their effort.

Thank you, Mr. Cronin.

Speaker 28 (02:21:54–02:23:02)

Robert Mason, precinct 8. I'd like to know what guarantees, if there's an override, that that money will go. We were to the fight about it. We were promised a lot of 2 would be put back in when we fought for the override.

The override one, ladder two was never put back in. Don't shake your head, Joe. You came right to our meeting and told us that. Don't shake your head.

My second question to the Warrant Committee is, you know, I'm not a statistic. Neither of these people are their families, OK? You take and speak of statistics. We don't speak of statistics at the firehouse.

We speak of people, okay? The people we represent. All we're trying to do is do our job. That's all we want to do, people.

We want to do our job. All they're thinking of is statistics. We go on too many medicals. What is too many medicals?

When you call for help, we show up. Now you want to cut it down. Oh, we got to streamline it. You know, I just don't understand this.

I've been on the job 23 years now. All the guys I know want to do their job. And all they're interested in, bottom line, cut down the runs. Don't let them get too many runs.

Don't make it look too good. That's all I got to say.

Speaker 2 (02:23:03–02:23:48)

OK, I believe the answer to your question is contained within the scope of the present motion. The only guarantee you have is what is stated in the motion, which I will read again. It's that the town vote to appropriate the sum of $350,000 for the purposes set forth in the article, including the reopening of the Athens Street Fire Station and the restoring of eight firefighter positions to the fire department, contingent upon, et cetera. So your only guarantee is the including part that specifies that $350,000 will be used to reopen the Athens Street Station.

and to employ eight additional firefighters. Does anyone else wish to be heard? Yes, sir.

Speaker 27 (02:23:48–02:24:53)

Bruce Pearson, Precinct 4. Just a quick comment and then a question. Representative Manning, we were just talking about this back when a three-year-old girl died. And we've heard from the WANC committee about insurance policies.

Well, I think it's a good insurance policy. And I will call it an insurance policy. Because a lot of us, I don't have any children, But if I did have children, there was a lot of elderly that has been spoken about before. I think it's an essential part to have this coverage.

And I commend the study committee. It was an outstanding job. And I think you have to take that into consideration before we start taking everything else. We talk about roads and everything else.

There won't be enough people if we don't keep the public safety together. My question to Phil, I guess to you, to the moderator, if this is adopted, And then we have park commissioners and other people coming back with this be standing on its own many. We have a menu that on the override with this be on its own menu.

Speaker 2 (02:24:57–02:25:50)

All right. Do you have any further questions. That's it. OK.

All right. Then you can be seated. The I can answer one of the questions which is you are by passing this motion you do not get a smorgasbord on the override. You only get overrides that are specifically sent to an override for a vote.

That, of course, does not preclude, as indicated by a member of one of the park commissioners, that they might think about asking for something else. I mean, there is an infinite amount of, not an infinite amount, there are obviously several millions of dollars worth of needed expenditures, or arguably needed expenditures, that could be sent to the voters. This motion only asks that one such expense, namely the expense of $350,000, be sent to the voters.

Speaker 23 (02:25:51–02:26:19)

Yes, Ned Rogerson, Precinct 3 again. One comment, obviously we're getting down into the two and a half shove again, which is everybody needs money. But the question I have specifically, and this would I guess be to the selectmen, is as the override, if we as town meeting members vote for this contingent upon an override, and only the selectmen can approve an override, I think it would be good to know how the selectmen feel about this article. I think it would be good to know up front.

Speaker 2 (02:26:23–02:26:43)

That was not, I assure you, from any reluctance of the selectmen to indicate what their position is. They have been prepared to do that for quite a while, and I was simply trying to recognize more town meeting members. However, perhaps this is the appropriate time, so the moderator recognizes a select person, Kathy Dunphy.

Speaker 9 (02:26:44–02:34:52)

Thank you Mr. Moderator. The Board of Selectmen wish to remind the town meeting that the taxpayers have already approved a proposition two and a half override this year last week. That override was a debt exclusion override not a permanent tax increase and came with two million dollars in state funds.

The Board of Selectmen strongly support the Warrant Committee recommendation for a no vote. We do not support an override for this purpose. We are listening to the debate. I would like to make a few comments at this time.

The Board of Selectmen also express our thanks to the Fire Study Committee. Today we will hear from other committees who have worked hard to identify and present the needs for school technology and modern library facilities in this time of limited financial resources. But the Fire Study Committee has had a particularly difficult assignment, and they have done it well. We would also like to convey the thanks of the town to the members of the Milton Fire Department.

We should never forget that these firefighters are ready to risk their lives to save our lives and our property. They chose this career in order to serve the public. But since they made their career choice, changes in fire protection have occurred, largely driven by limited revenues, but also because of major technological developments. The laws requiring smoke detectors and stricter building codes that we've heard referred to were passed at the urging of fire professionals.

The celebration of the 200th year of the Milton Fire Service gave us a better understanding of all the changes that have occurred over those 200 years. Major changes are still occurring not only in Milton but in every city and town and change makes us anxious. The goal of the Milton Fire Department is still the protection of property and lives, but the means by which this goal is most effectively accomplished has changed. Protection of property is important to all of us, but the real issue before us today is the protection of lives.

The real issue on the back of our minds is the risk of loss of life in a fire. To be honest, we are all afraid that if we do not vote to open the Atherton Street Station, a life will be lost and we will be responsible. But will reopening Atherton Street Station eliminate this risk? No.

I went on a tour of Curry College with Deputy Foley. We toured the dormitory at the main building. Although there are fire doors and numerous smoke detector alarms, that building is a worry. A fire at Providence College resulted in deaths in spite of all the manpower and equipment resources of a city which has very high manning levels needed to fight fires in industrial buildings, gasoline and oil tanker docks and storage areas, and in densely concentrated old wooden two- and three-family houses.

The fire department manning and equipment in the city of Providence was not enough. There will always be a risk. Reopening Avenue Street is not the solution. Rigorous inspections to be sure that those fire doors are kept shut, flammable materials are removed, and that smoke detectors are working, frequent fire drills, and an effort to have a sprinkler fire suppression system installed are far more effective.

The Avenue Street station was closed June 1st 1992 because there were insufficient funds in the fire budget to pay overtime costs to keep it manned until the end of the year. As the new fiscal year passed it was also evident that would not be enough money in the budget to reopen the station. During that time since June 1992 Milton firefighters have provided good coverage even while assisting the Advanced Life Support Ambulance Service. In 1992, the New England Journal of Medicine published an article that deals directly with our concerns.

The study looked at fatal and non-fatal residential fires in non-urban areas. For each fire, fire officials were interviewed about the dwelling, the fire, the people involved, and the fire response system. Analysis of the fire response system considered the time of the alarm and the time of the response, whether the firefighters were volunteers or paid, and whether a 911 system was available. This study is particularly useful because there is no prejudice for union issues of manning and overtime, nor is there any consideration of municipal budgets and competing needs, just an examination of what works and what doesn't work to save lives.

It is clear that smoking is a major cause of fatal fires. Smoking and alcohol use are a lethal combination. that must be addressed by education, not after a fire begins. Risks are greater for persons with mental or physical disabilities.

Risks that have led to our stringent fire codes for elderly housing, nursing homes, and hospitals. Not surprisingly, fatal fires are more likely to occur during sleeping hours. The most significant factor in preventing loss of life is the presence of a working smoke detector. which alerts residents and enables them to escape.

This study has concluded that the variables associated with a fire response system appear unrelated to the risk of a fatality in a fire. And yet it seems that response time should make some difference, if only to reduce property damage. But Appenham Street Station has been closed for almost two years. And the metro fire system has not changed its procedures still maintaining a system that would provide backup to the western part of town from Ashmont and Grove Hall while firefighters sit in the rebuild station.

Is metro fire acknowledging that response time doesn't matter. Are they influenced by a militant state union or are they just slow to change. The chief has said the last plan was developed in 1981. We can never eliminate the risk to life and property.

Our police department could have multiple major accidents or crimes occur at the same time, but we cannot man the department 24 hours a day for that exceptional circumstance. Neighboring police departments and the state police would respond just as we would go to the aid of surrounding towns. Similarly, the Milton Hospital Emergency Room can have a contingency plan for an accident involving many persons with severe injuries, but cannot, on a daily basis, be prepared for every disaster. At such times, they will rely on other hospitals.

Our fire department should have a solid contingency plan. For almost two years, the fire department has provided an appropriate level of firefighting response while also assisting the Fallon Advanced Life Support Ambulance Service and making the inspections, which are increasingly the most effective means of reducing risk of loss of life. We cannot afford the cost of increased manning of our fire department with so many other competing needs. The Board of Selectmen ask you to join us in supporting the Warrant Committee's recommendation that no appropriation be made under this article.

Speaker 11 (02:34:53–02:34:59)

Thank you for that clarification.

Speaker 29 (02:34:59–02:35:49)

Ian Palmer, Precinct 7. I live four blocks from the East Milton Firehouse and I feel very safe. And I was grateful not too long ago when the fire and police responded to a medical emergency at my house and they were there before the ambulance. But those couple of minutes were very anxious ones for the family.

I was grateful that the fire department was there ready to break down the door to get my mother off the floor if necessary. I have great compassion for those people on the west side of town who are afraid they might have to suffer many moments of anxiety waiting for someone to come to their aid in case of a fire. I urge strongly a yes vote on this recommendation.

Speaker 16 (02:35:49–02:35:50)

Thank you. Yes sir.

Speaker 30 (02:35:51–02:36:17)

Michael McGuire, Precinct 4. There's been a lot of talk about improved equipment in relation to saving of lives. Two and a half years ago, I was a resident assistant at Boston University. They were under city law to impose a sprinkler system in all of their dormitories.

Why is there no such law in Milton for the dormitories of the colleges here if the alternative is not to open a police station?

Speaker 2 (02:36:20–02:37:04)

It isn't quite on the motion, but I think it's relevant. And the question is, why has Milton not adopted some type of a bylaw or something that would make it the law that places such as Curry College have sprinklers? Now, that's an interesting question. And does anybody want to address that?

OK. I think it's something that has been addressed. And it certainly was addressed. I believe that it was in the study committee itself recommended that perhaps there should be those changes, and I'm sure that they're under consideration because those are worthwhile suggestions.

Speaker 13 (02:37:06–02:37:12)

Mr. Mullen. Oh, I'm sorry.

Speaker 2 (02:37:13–02:37:19)

Next, and then you, Mr. Mullen.

Speaker 19 (02:37:19–02:38:37)

Just in regard to the previous gentleman's question on the sprinklers at Curry College, the question did come up many times in committee while we were sitting and so I looked into it extensively. Sprinkler codes come under the state building code. Fire departments only accept them when they're put in through acceptance tests. The way the building code is now, and from what I understand, the mass state building code is about cast and stone.

There's no way to improve it or take away from it. It's the way it is. And right now, the way it stands, Covey College and buildings similar to it are grandfathered in to the existing conditions they have now. The only acceptance, sprinkler acceptance, that we've passed in this town is if you put an addition on or build another building that's in excess of 7,500 square feet, sprinklers must be added.

Now even if this building, this 7,500 square foot addition is put on a building that doesn't have sprinklers, it doesn't

Speaker 1 (02:38:38–02:39:31)

Demand that the sprinklers be put in this the existing building only in the new addition Thank You chief F and Adam mister Whether to appropriate three hundred and fifty thousand dollars contingent on a proposition two and a half override Because I think there might be a lot of reasons to vote no not to do that not because of the merits of fire protection in the town but the mechanism of doing this and And therefore, Mr. Moderator, I'm going to move at this time to amend the chief's motion to make the chief's motion an amendment to the Warrant Committee's recommendation so that we can have an up or down vote on the chief's amendment. And then if that doesn't carry, I believe the article will still be before the town meeting. And there's the possibility of considering other action under the article.

Speaker 2 (02:39:35–02:39:58)

All right. if I understand you are moving to amend the present motion so that it reads that it's a motion to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee that the town vote etc. That is correct. And that is on your theory Mr.

Mullen that therefore I will have to have two votes which I was trying to avoid.

Speaker 17 (02:39:59–02:39:59)

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (02:40:01–02:40:53)

And that motion has been seconded. Okay, is there further discussion? I will go to that motion now. I think that's pretty clear.

All those in… Mr. Munchester, you wish to be heard on the motion? Okay, the…

All right. The motion is to amend the motion that is before the town meeting by adding the words… to amend the recommendation of the Warren Committee that the town vote to appropriate the sum of $350,000. So this would be coming up as a motion to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee.

Once that is done, then I would take a vote as to whether or not the amended recommendation of the Warrant Committee would be passed. I don't see, Mr. Mullin, that gains us anything, but… Yes, it would still be contingent.

Speaker 1 (02:40:55–02:41:23)

As I understand them the amendment that I'm proposing mr. Moderator It would be I would be proposing an amendment to amend the chiefs Motion If my amendment carries, the chief's motion would then be to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee to appropriate $350,000 instead of the no appropriation which the Warrant Committee has recommended.

Speaker 2 (02:41:23–02:41:28)

Then we will have an amended recommendation of the Warrant Committee which would have to be voted on.

Speaker 1 (02:41:28–02:41:39)

First, we'd have to have a vote on the amendment as to whether or not to make it. That is correct. And if that were to carry, we'd then have a recommendation before the town meeting to appropriate $350,000.

Speaker 2 (02:41:39–02:41:44)

That is correct. And if it goes down, you will have a recommendation of the Warrant Committee that there be no appropriation.

Speaker 1 (02:41:44–02:41:50)

That's right. And then we'd have to have a second vote as to whether or not to adopt the no appropriation recommendation. That is correct.

Speaker 2 (02:41:50–02:43:09)

And there are two people that understand what we're doing, you and me. Does anybody? And so that we may enlarge that number, let me see if I can explain it to the 200-odd people that are here. What Mr.

Mullen suggests is that rather than have the motion of the chief be simply a motion that is definitive under the article and a substitution, that we simply take it as a motion to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee. So if it is voted down, we will still have the recommendation of the Warrant Committee to be voted on. Now, it doesn't bother me if we do it that way, and if Chief Affanato has no objections, I mean, we can consider that to be an amendment to his motion. All we're going to have is two votes.

Is that satisfactory to Chief Affanato? Wait a minute. It's satisfactory to Chief Affanato. All right.

So we will take, we'll take it that the Chief is now moving to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee. That'll give us two votes. So there will be two votes, Mr. Mullen.

Okay?

Speaker 1 (02:43:10–02:45:06)

Speaking to the amendment, to the merits of the Chief's amendment. Okay. I think everybody has to be concerned about fire protection. I think that's a basic function of local government.

I think everybody here is concerned in good faith that Adequate fire protection is being provided and that it's being provided on an equal basis around the town It's very difficult for somebody who hasn't been deeply involved in this issue to have a sense of whether those two factors are present I would ask that we have some explanation as to the two incidents which Representative Manning referred to as to what they were because I think that will help people assess what is the risk. I think there's been several references to response times and whether they're adequate or inadequate. It seems to me one critical issue is whether there is a disparity in response time. Just looking at the geography of the town, it would seem like there's a high likelihood that there's a substantial disparity in response times between the western and the eastern side of town.

I think also, I as a town meeting member not located on the western side of town, I would like to hear from some people who are located on that side of town whether they believe that there is inadequate fire protection on that side of town or not. I don't particularly support the idea of appropriating these funds contingent upon a proposition two and a half override. If we need additional firemen and if we need that fire station, I think we should appropriate it here and now, not contingent on an override. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (02:45:07–02:45:34)

Thank you, Mr. Mullen. I will not insist on direct answers to those questions. report by Mr.

Manning as I understood it was simply indicating that there were a couple of instances when we had to rely on mutual aid and so until that mutual aid comes you are in fact without fire protection and I would think that I don't know of any study that's actually been done but I would point out that if you're on the west side and you're farther away from a fire station necessarily the response time has to be longer.

Speaker 1 (02:45:34–02:46:06)

Mr. Monterrey I would ask that Mr. Monterey, I would ask that we get the details of what those two incidents were. I want to know, did it take a half an hour?

Did it take two minutes? What were the circumstances? I don't think we can judge this thing unless we know what these circumstances are. And I'd like to have somebody involved in the fire department tell me whether it takes two or three minutes longer to get to a house on the western side than on the eastern side.

Speaker 2 (02:46:06–02:46:24)

OK, I understand, Mr. Mullen, what you'd like to know. And if someone wishes to volunteer that, he may do so, such as the chief. Are you familiar with these instances?

And it is a fair question for Mr. Mullen. And if you have any more details, let's present it to the town meeting now.

Speaker 19 (02:46:31–02:48:20)

So let's see. Thursday afternoon, we had a kitchen fire on Ridgewood Road. Naturally, the two engines in the ladder truck that's in town respond. The deputy on duty put in a call for a second alarm, which brings Boston, engine 18, to Milton headquarters.

On the third alarm, Boston Apparatus would respond to the fire and Quincy would come to headquarters. That's the way the system works and down and down and down and down the line. I haven't reviewed the fire report yet for either of these two fires thoroughly. We are still waiting for response from the state fire marshal's office to come out to complete make a thorough investigation especially of this this one yesterday afternoon nobody was home and there's a serious electrical problem and they had got a good head start in the house and if it didn't burn through to the outside where a neighbor happened to discover it and call us it would have been much more serious I understand that yesterday's At yesterday's fire, there was some delay in Engine 18 getting there for one reason or another, whether it was a communication problem, or whether they were out at another run, or traffic was a problem, or what.

I'm not privy to that yet, but I'm going to make an investigation Monday morning on this. Thank you, Chief.

Speaker 2 (02:48:20–02:48:54)

Now, there are, and I'm going to continue the debate, but I would simply like to point out that we have been debating this issue now for an hour and a half, in case somebody didn't notice that. And so there is a point at which comments become repetitious. And I'd like you to keep that in mind so that as the debate goes forward, if you'd make your points succinctly, we can hopefully reach a point where we'll close debate and we will move on the motion to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee. So we'll go over here first.

Speaker 31 (02:48:54–02:49:21)

Mr. Moderator, I'm Bob Califf from Precinct 2. I'd like a clarification of this motion. And specifically I'm asking, is the figure $350,000 a part of this motion?

And if it is, are we now for the first time allowing a motion to appropriate money without officially designating where that money is coming from? No.

Speaker 2 (02:49:22–02:49:46)

The motion before this town meeting is a motion to amend the recommendation of the Warren committee that you appropriate $350,000 and you do so by going to the voters on a proposition two and a half override. So the sponsors of this motion, namely the chief, the fire chief, has obviously designated where he hopes to get the money. He hopes to get the money from the tax levy through a proposition two and a half override. Any other questions?

Speaker 13 (02:49:46–02:49:56)

And of course that would be conditioned upon the… Point of order. Point of order. That's not the motion on the floor.

The motion on the floor is Mr. Mullen's motion, which is an amendment to the amendments.

Speaker 2 (02:49:56–02:49:56)

No.

Speaker 13 (02:49:57–02:49:59)

Yes, there is. He made an amendment to Mr. Rafferty's amendment. Now, hold on.

Speaker 2 (02:50:00–02:50:45)

Whoa. I'll accept a motion for clarification, all right? Okay, and I'll even get a point of order, but we're going to do this in an orderly way. When Mr.

Mullen raised the question, I then asked the chief whether or not he was voluntarily amend his motion. So we have one motion and the motion is to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee. This means that if that motion goes down we will have to have a second vote on the then unamended recommendation of the Warrant Committee which is to vote no appropriation. Now I presume that Mr.

Mullen did that because he is contemplating having a further amendment. Now I don't know but that would give him the opportunity to do so. OK. Now I will get to you as soon as this town meeting member Mr.

Kaler finishes his comments.

Speaker 31 (02:50:46–02:51:16)

Are we then in this motion for the first time putting a motion to appropriate money by and using an override and thereby for the first time this town meeting is instructing the Board of Selectmen to vote for an override where the whether an override is put to the voters or not rests solely with the Board of Selectmen.

Speaker 2 (02:51:17–02:51:37)

The prerogative to calling a proposition a two-and-a-half override is with the Selectmen. Right. And the answer to your first question is whether this is the first time that there's been such a vote. I'm just not sure.

I'm not sure whether it makes any difference whether it's the first time or the second time. But it probably is the first time.

Speaker 31 (02:51:37–02:51:46)

I think the vote is out of order to instruct the Selectmen to do something when we don't have the power to instruct them to do this. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (02:51:47–02:52:03)

You have the power to pass this and I suspect that if you do so that will then have to lead to a judgment by the Board of Selectmen whether to honor the recommendation of this town meeting. I would be astounded if they didn't. Diane Augustino. I'm sorry, this side next.

We'll keep it even.

Speaker 7 (02:52:04–02:53:37)

Just to moderate it, Kathleen Otien, a Town Meeting Member, Precinct 7. I share the same concerns as Mr. Kaler, and that is that we're tying an increase in appropriation of $350,000 to a Proposition 2.5 contingency that I think is well beyond the scope of the responsibility of this Town Meeting. It's my recollection in the past that when Town Meeting appropriated sums of money that exceeded the Proposition 2.5 levy limit, we were advised by the Warrant Committee that by voting to support certain recommendations or certain levels of funding it was tying the town to an excess of the levy limit which would in turn default to the Board of Selectmen but I can't remember in the years that we've dealt with Proposition Two and a Half that we have instructed the Selectmen to with specifically earmarked monies on an article by article basis.

My concern really is that this would open up a can of worms for every future article that if there was a sum of money not recommended by the board of select not recommended by the warrant committee that a certain group supported that an amendment would be put forth subject to a proposition two and a half levy limit override contingency and I believe that we really at town meeting level relying on the recommendation of the Warrant Committee and if we vote to exceed the levy limit it's then incumbent on the Board of Selectmen to put a question before the voters. I see that this is a question that on the face of it the $350,000 is a completely separate issue from a contingency on a two and a half override

Speaker 2 (02:53:37–02:54:16)

vote okay you raise a fair question uh uh which can be viewed in two parts i would suggest one whether or not it's a good judgment to do this however i will assure you and i will ask the uh town council, to correct me if I'm wrong, but there is a special state statute which does allow the appropriation of funds by town meetings contingent on a proposition two and a half override. So your point in seconding Mr. Kaler's point, which is whether or not such a motion is out of order, it is not out of order as a matter of what the town meeting is allowed to do by state statute.

Speaker 7 (02:54:17–02:54:23)

Now, if I'm wrong, Mr. Moderator, that there's a state statute that allows town meeting to appropriate funds contingent on an override.

Speaker 2 (02:54:23–02:54:29)

Yes. And I would recognize Mr. Flynn. So in case I am wrong, I can suitably turn red.

Speaker 24 (02:54:33–02:54:49)

Mr. Moderator, you are correct. Massachusetts law allows town meeting to appropriate money from the tax levy from available funds or from borrowing Conditioned upon a passage of a referendum question of proposition two and a half referendum override question.

Speaker 2 (02:54:49–02:54:52)

Thank you Town meeting member Augustina.

Speaker 14 (02:54:53–03:00:20)

I just like to address two issues one fire protection to funding As you heard earlier and excuse me for addressing this to your back. I know I don't like anything in my back either but There are two issues there was a fire on Ridgewood Road it was in the evening and it was only a few houses away from my house and At the fire were two engines and one ladder. The ladder did go up because they did think they had to go through the roof. The fire was in the wall.

It was very upsetting for my family and my neighbors. It was very upsetting for several reasons. Over the last few months, I heard the discussion about mutual aid. And although I don't have my library of Milton information here, I do have a few.

And in 1981, we received mutual aid 16 times. In 84, we received it 10 times. And if we looked over the last 10 years, I think maybe 1993's annual report might be a little blip that we didn't receive any. As I stood on the street watching my neighbor's house and watching the firefighters that arrived, the entire fire department of Milton, the two engines and the ladder, as many people surmise or believe that there were two trucks manned in East Milton and that the trucks sitting in Atherton can't be manned, that's not true.

There was two engines and the ladder. And as I stood there, up the street came engine 18 and 6. out of Ashland Station, contrary to any indication that it would come from Reidville. Our mutual aid contract, although it was written in 81, for whatever reason, that's where they came from.

And I don't think it was my position in the downpour to ask Engine 18 and 6, since they, in fact, were not necessary. I don't think it was my job, but I did ask them how long it took to get to Ridgewood Road, which is not that far out of town. I mean it's up for and off out across from Austin golf course. They were on route to the main station which it has.

The chief explained that the procedure they would go to the main station. They did not go to the main station because they were notified on route to come direct to Ridgewood. It took them. He calculated eight minutes.

During that time, the firemen did, and the deputy who was there, point out to me that Chief McCurtain from Boston had just this week come to Milton to talk to an official in the town regarding mutual aid. And today I asked Chief Apponato what occurred. He told me he wasn't at that meeting, which raised other questions in my mind. When I look at the charts and graphs that have been handed out today by the fire department, I see a large discrepancy in the way we provide fire protection to our town versus the other towns.

Wellesley, which has a similar population, has 57 personnel. It's on the first chart that was handed out. Milton has 49. Those include the chiefs.

26,000 residents. When we all put our head on the pillow at night, we're very equal people, aren't we? Square area, Wellesley only has 10 square miles, Milton 13.2. When I look across to a town that might be equal to Milton in personnel, I see Winchester with number of personnel at 44, but their residents are only 20,000, and their square miles is 6.3, half the size of the town of Milton.

When we look at fire protection, a key issue certainly is the square area that has to be covered. And I certainly commend the Fire Study Committee for all their time and effort that they put into this. I further would like to point out, on the second chart, the personnel graphs. Milton has the least amount of personnel for the most square area.

We saw also under fire protection concerns, the fire study, I believe the report was submitted December 1st. And I know the selectmen can submit bylaws right up until the warrant goes to press. I do feel it was remiss that the bylaw having sprinklers put into certain buildings should have been looked at and be included in this warrant, not next year's warrant. It's our obligation as town meeting members to discuss these issues.

It's the liability of the town right now, also, because we have been fully appraised of some of the concerns. If you look at the fire budget for the last few years, the chief signature is not on it. It's typed in. When we go down to the funding question, I'd like to ask the moderator, since there seems to be an awful lot of confusion on the amount and the override.

We've heard discussed here today an overlay surplus of $97,000 with $53,000 going to another article. We heard Mr. Winchester mention $2,000 from the FIRE study. We also know fully well that the Reserve Fund is never really used until towards the end of the year.

If we look today at how much money is sitting in the reserve fund this March, we may see that we are well over $100,000. And next March, we could always add more money into that, the same way we went and added money into the snow item. So on the issue of funding, I hope it'll be made clear what the other options are to the town, and that this debate is not cut off regarding our fire protection. Thank you.

Speaker 16 (03:00:22–03:00:22)

Over here.

Speaker 13 (03:00:25–03:00:51)

Mr. Moderator, this is your name and your name and precinct for John Fasano precinct. Okay, you're ready to be a lot of confusion in this room right now over what we are What exactly is the motion on the floor if mr. Muller could give me a clarification Did he amend?

the amendment, or did he not amend the amendment? And if so, then we should only be speaking to the amendment to the amendment.

Speaker 2 (03:00:52–03:02:23)

Right. And I've been trying to monitor that. And you're right, it's somewhat. Oh, no.

All right. Let me see if I can make it clear to you and everyone else. Mr. Mullen proposed to have a motion to amend the motion on the floor.

That motion was not necessary because Chief Affanato agreed that his motion could be changed to conform to what Mr. Mullen wanted. That saved us about 15 minutes I figure because it doesn't make any difference. All right.

All it means and I want everybody to understand is that we're going to have at least at least two votes. We're going to have a vote on the motion to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee and that motion is Put my glasses on. To appropriate the sum of $350,000 for the purposes set forth in this article, including the reopening of the Athens Street Fire Station and the restoring of eight firefighter positions to the fire department contingent upon the passage of a Proposition 2.5 override referendum question. For those purposes, by the voters of the town of Milton.

Now, let's be absolutely clear. If this is not passed, I will then go to a second vote to whether or not you're going to adopt the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, which is that no appropriation be made. That's very simple. There's going to be a vote on this motion, and there's going to be a vote on the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, unless there's some other amendment.

Speaker 13 (03:02:23–03:02:31)

Well, as far as I'm concerned, it's still very confusing.

Speaker 2 (03:02:31–03:02:33)

No, I know, but he wanted a motion to amend it.

Speaker 13 (03:02:33–03:02:36)

Now, if I may speak to the amendment to the amendment.

Speaker 2 (03:02:36–03:02:40)

No, there's not an amendment to the amendment pending. I don't know how many times we're going to have to make this clear.

Speaker 13 (03:02:41–03:02:52)

Well, Mr. Moderator, a parliamentary procedure, if Mr. Rafferato made a motion on the floor, right, the only amendment that could be made is an amendment to his article.

Speaker 2 (03:02:52–03:02:53)

Yes.

Speaker 13 (03:02:53–03:03:48)

Technically you are right except why are we considering any other motion when there is a motion on the floor? I'm sorry to be so adamant about this, but there was a motion on the floor Parliamentary procedure requires you to consider only that motion if there is an amendment to that motion Then only that amendment can be spoken to we have been discussing everything but the amendment to the amendment here That's why I need these people to have some understanding as to what they're voting on, okay? If they have to make a decision on Mr. Mullen's vote, then that effectively kills any chance of an override going before the people, because then they will accept the Warrant Committee's motion, comments, not to accept any appropriation.

That's what that's what I'm getting from these motions that have been from that motion to mr. Mullen made it effectively kills any chance of an override All right.

Speaker 2 (03:03:48–03:03:53)

I appreciate your views and parliamentary procedure. Okay Well, all right now hang on.

Speaker 13 (03:03:53–03:03:56)

No, you cannot move the question until I'm through speaking.

Speaker 2 (03:03:56–03:04:03)

I'm sorry, sir I'm on the floor and you are recognized by me and I wish for you to finish your remarks.

Speaker 7 (03:04:03–03:04:03)

I

Speaker 13 (03:04:05–03:04:15)

I don't think the people in this room understand what's going to transpire if they vote yes on Mr. Mullen's article, motion. I don't think they understand what's going to happen.

Speaker 2 (03:04:15–03:04:30)

I will make that clear as soon as you finish. All right? Let me tell you exactly what we're doing. And we're doing it by consent of Chief Fafanato, who has somewhat changed the scope of his motion.

All right? Here's what we are going to do. And we're going to do it. OK?

Sooner or later.

Speaker 13 (03:04:32–03:04:48)

There is one motion. Mr. Moderator, if Mr. Affanado has changed his motion, I have yet to see him at the microphone to change it.

He's the maker of the motion, then he has to get to the microphone and make that statement to this seated body. You can't make that statement for him. It's his motion.

Speaker 2 (03:04:52–03:06:05)

Have you finished your remarks? Because the next time you stand up, you're going to have to be recognized by me and not interrupting me. All right, now. How this happened was when Mr.

Mullen was moving to amend the motion, I asked the chief by looking at him and asking him whether by consent he would change his motion. He did not have to get up. He said to me, because he's sitting right there, yes, that would be fine. OK?

So we have one motion on the floor, and that is a motion to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee. all right now if you vote yes for that the most the recommendation of the Warren committee will be amended and we'll have a second vote as to whether you want to adopt it okay if you vote no okay we will still have the recommendation of the Warren committee which is to have no appropriation which we will have a vote on that is what mr. Mullen was trying to achieve he has managed to achieve it now that is not difficult to understand Now the motion before us is a motion to recommend, is to change the recommendation of the Warrant Committee. And we are pretty much running out of points to be made.

So I'm going to recognize these two and then, and then Selectman here and Mr. Gordon. Okay. Four more.

One.

Speaker 32 (03:06:06–03:06:07)

Yes. Here Mr. Moran.

Speaker 2 (03:06:08–03:06:09)

Hang on. Yes.

Speaker 32 (03:06:09–03:06:12)

After my remarks I'd like the Town Council to make a statement.

Speaker 2 (03:06:12–03:06:12)

All right.

Speaker 17 (03:06:13–03:06:13)

You're recognizing me?

Speaker 2 (03:06:14–03:06:14)

Yes sir.

Speaker 17 (03:06:14–03:09:42)

Jeff Wilkinson from precinct 11. And I'm rising to address the question that Mr. Mullen put, asking for feedback from people on the west side of town. I live on the west side of town.

I live six doors from Hyde Park. I pass by the Reedville Boston fire department station twice a day. And I confess that I'm a little bit confused about to what extent my family's safety is jeopardized right now. We were concerned with the closing of the Atherton Street Station and we'd like to see it open and my neighbors, constituents, would like to see it reopened.

My own concerns were heightened by the Fire Study Commission's report. And it was particularly compelling because Selectman Shields was on it, as well as the fire chief. and other citizens of the town. So I was confused, but also interested and moved by Selectman Shields' letter in the transcript, which was introduced as not a minority report, but had that effect and that appearance to me.

I was also interested to receive a letter on Thursday from the Selectman, urging my support for their position. And I understand talking with people in the audience today that not everybody received that letter. And I'm a little confused about that. I don't understand who got it and who didn't and why some of us got it and some of us didn't.

I was very moved by Selectman Dunphy's comments. And I have always been impressed by her in her position as chair of the Warrant Committee. I was often impressed and often moved by her statements. And so her eloquence and the power of her testimony confuses me further.

And so I rise with a question. And I'm feeling some anger about it. Because I think there's another issue here. And my question is whether there's another issue here.

It seems to me that there may be some question, or there is some question about to what extent my family's safety and my neighbor's safety is at stake, at jeopardy. And my question is, does this involve a tug of war between the selectmen and the town administration and the firefighters union? Selectman Dunphy mentioned a militant state union. Selectman Shields signed a report that said my safety, my children's safety, my neighbor's safety is jeopardized.

And I would like to know how much power politics is influencing the debate. I've also heard a number of people in the audience say when the selectmen or when the Warrant Committee, when the administration wants to find money, they can find money. $350,000 is a lot of money. I've worked on town finances.

I am equally concerned with Catherine Otina's questions about the larger implications here. But right now I'm just trying to figure out where is the truth and to what extent are politics influencing the debate about the safety.

Speaker 2 (03:09:46–03:10:15)

I don't know whether that's a rhetorical question or not as to whether or not. All right. So town meeting member Wilkerson would like someone to address the question as I understood it whether or not there is a political I guess difference of opinion between the firefighters union and the selectmen with respect to the merits of funding this article. And Mr.

Winchester would like to be recognized and is recognized.

Speaker 16 (03:10:20–03:10:21)

Thank you for the recognition.

Speaker 20 (03:10:24–03:11:31)

Just to address that question briefly. We had a committee fundamentally of non politicians. I suppose you might consider me a politician in a sense of a town meeting member and I've been a former politician on a townwide basis in the town. I can assure you that my views as expressed in the committee report were not the result of any political considerations on my part nor do I believe the votes of the members of the committee were in any way politically inspired.

I think they were the sincere convictions of the people who signed the report. I think there was an underlying concern about the cost of the recommendations being made and whether The cost of insurance is too high. So you know I just answer that. I don't think politic politics played any significant part in the recommendations being made.

Mr. Moderator may I address a couple of other points.

Speaker 2 (03:11:31–03:11:31)

You certainly may.

Speaker 20 (03:11:31–03:13:24)

Thank you. I just like to address a couple of other points that I've been making notes on as the debate has continued on for some time now. And I'll be very brief. But one thing I noted was somebody being a couple of people being concerned about instructing the selectmen to call an override referendum.

I don't think that's what this motion calls for. What this motion says is that there's an appropriation being made subject to an override. It's up to the selectmen however whether they call one. I would hope that if the town meeting thought that something should be appropriated.

The select number would honor that request but I would view it as more as a request than a direction. Another point that was made by one of the park commissioners I just think it's pertinent to note that we're not talking here about a capital expenditure we're talking about operating budgets. I think that just basically I think I'll just conclude by saying that You know what we're what we're confronting here for the fire department is very similar what Mr. Murphy referred to a few moments ago.

The situation of a reflection really of what's happening on a town wide basis. Department after department after department is being hammered away on the budget level and things are getting neglected that shouldn't be neglected. At some point Somebody has to have the courage to go to the voters and say we need to do more.

Speaker 18 (03:13:24–03:15:26)

Thank you. Thank you Mr. Moderator. Michael Kraft Precinct 5.

I'd like to make just a few points and then at the end I have a question. I bought my home on Canton Avenue with the comfort of having the Atherton station two blocks away from my house. and a year and a half, or less than a year later, that station was closed, much to my dismay. My kitchen is approximately 20 feet away from Canton Avenue, and I will tell you, for those people who live on the eastern side of town, it is a rare night that I don't see the fire trucks go past my home, both directions, with probably a good half hour between trips.

suggesting to me that there is a significant amount of time that not only is the West not protected, but the East is also suffering from the lack of fire protection. I also want to tell you that with respect to the speed of traversing the town, even under the best of circumstances, it cannot be fast. About a week and a half ago, my wife and I were driving directly behind the ladder truck as it returned to its station. going past the area near Milton Academy.

And I'm not kidding you, when I saw the rear of that truck bounce at least a foot in the air several times to the point where it had to slow to a crawl because the roads were in such terrible condition. That truck could not proceed any faster than five miles an hour safely through the town. And I don't know how it would be possible for that truck, in an emergency situation, with traffic on the road, which is a very heavily traveled road, to make it from one end of town to the other and still be able to be effective in putting out fires. Now, I have a question now, which is, if we vote in favor of the amendment which has been proposed, Would this still go to the board of selectmen for their discretion as to whether or not an override vote would be heard?

Speaker 2 (03:15:26–03:15:43)

All right. Let me give the definitive answer. And the answer to that question is yes. It's been asked and answered three times.

Does anybody not understand that it goes to the board of selectmen, and the board of selectmen gets to decide whether it goes to the voters? Now, that's not mysterious.

Speaker 18 (03:15:43–03:15:58)

Then in that event, I would ask that the chief amend the motion once more. to strike from the language the issue of the override and leave it to a vote of town meeting whether or not the money is appropriated. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (03:15:58–03:16:13)

All right, I'm not going to entertain that because that can be done after the vote on this motion and that will unduly delay. That was the point that Mr. Mullen was trying to make. There are going to be three more people.

This lady, Mr. Gordon, and Mr. Shields, and possibly town council. So that might be four.

Yes, ma'am.

Speaker 33 (03:16:14–03:16:45)

Corinda Shillingford from Precinct 5. We have been the beneficiaries of the Atherton Street fire station with a quick response. But what I was wondering was if the fire chief could answer, given the level of smoke detectors in houses and at the time that most alarms are called in, what is the difference in the response rate now and how critical is this in most general calls that you get?

Speaker 2 (03:16:47–03:16:54)

The question, if I understand it is, is there a difference in response time to the west part of town as opposed to the east part of town? Is that your question?

Speaker 33 (03:16:55–03:17:13)

Is there a difference in response time to the western part of time from what it was when the Atherton Street Firehouse was open, but more critically, Is that difference critical? In other words, when most alarms are called in now, is there enough of a leeway?

Speaker 2 (03:17:13–03:17:45)

Those are fair questions. It seems to be self-evident that there has to be a difference. But I think that's a fair question, which is, is there a difference in response time with the Atherton street station closed? And is that considered by anyone to be a critical difference?

Now, Chief Affanato, can you address that? It seems to me that goes to the heart of the matter, and I thank you for that question. That's the best question I've had in an hour and a half.

Speaker 19 (03:17:45–03:18:34)

If I understand the first question, very definitely there'll be a delay in response. From Headquarters Station to the Curry College area is a little over two miles. to the Silverbrook area. It's a little over four miles and most of that ride to the Silverbrook road area is uphill once you get beyond the dam at Hunkerty Road.

And these response time varies naturally according to if there's school buses on the road, weather conditions, nighttime, etc. etc. It's very hard to pinpoint you know make it a definite time because of conditions but it's it's there's no question about it so it's a definite lagging in response.

Speaker 2 (03:18:34–03:18:53)

The question is whether or not in your judgment without having Athens open that the response time poses a critical the difference in response times is critical to the safety of people who live in the western part of the town.

Speaker 19 (03:18:54–03:19:22)

Here again, it's a distinct possibility, especially in a medical emergency or even in a fire. Sometimes you get away from that. We still are firefighters, and in our business, seconds count. And the longer you take to get there, sometimes make the difference whether you can fight a fire from the inside or you fight it from the outside.

All right, thank you, Chief.

Speaker 34 (03:19:22–03:20:12)

Mr. Moderator, I can give you exact. It's Paul Mason Precinct 8 times the lady asked. Fine.

From headquarters in a sunny weekday, dry road condition, it takes the engine driving at absolute top speed 7 minutes and 35 seconds to make it to the MDC police station. From headquarters, the time we leave the door. Not the time we take the call, get our equipment on, and leave. From when we're leaving the door.

Because I've timed it with a stopwatch. My lieutenant said if I ever drive like that again, he'll kill me. That's absolute the fastest time you could go. Actually endangering people.

Seven minutes, 35 seconds.

Speaker 2 (03:20:12–03:20:14)

How long would it take to get there from the Athens Street?

Speaker 34 (03:20:14–03:20:48)

I have not time that but I have time. I have time to Curry College. Okay from Athens Street It is considerably shorter. I mean you come you come from from the center of town to MDC or up, you know up through the As compared to it's got to be a mile or so shorter, but I have timed Curry College from engine 4 to Curry College and and then from Engine 1 to Curry College, and the time difference is four minutes.

Speaker 2 (03:20:48–03:20:58)

All right, thank you. All right, I'm recognizing three more, Mr. Selectman Shields, Mr. Gordon, and Mr.

Flynn. Selectman Shields is recognized.

Speaker 32 (03:20:58–03:26:59)

Thank you, Mr. Moderator. My name is John Michael Shields. I'm a town meeting member from Precinct 2 and a member of your Board of Selectman, and I was also a member of the Fire Study Committee.

As some of you may know, I signed both the report of the Fire Study Committee and also authored a report to the Board of Selectmen which recommended not opening the Atherton Street Station. The reasons for both of these actions, while confusing to some, are quite simple to make. The Study Committee's charge from the town meeting last year was to study the Fire Department and evaluate its needs and make recommendations. I believe that the Study Committee performed this task and that's why I signed it.

Indeed, I believe that if we commissioned a study for other departments, the results in each instance would be recommendations for more. If we commissioned a study to study the park department, the recommendation would be for more. For the libraries, the recommendation would be for more. But my role as a selectman is quite different from a study committee member.

As a selectman, I must evaluate the needs of all of the town's departments under our jurisdiction. And be aware of what is happening in other departments outside of the Selectman's control. It is a poor Selectman who is an advocate for just one area of our municipal government, given the limitations of funding. In a perfect world, we would be able to afford a fire station on one end of every block and a police station on the other.

But this is not a perfect world. So elected officials and professional managers have to evaluate the circumstances and changes in certain areas and act accordingly. Some of the things we evaluated were these. In the back of the fire study report, you will find tables.

The workload of the fire department is broken down into 13 categories. In nine of the 13, there has been a dramatic reduction in incidents requiring fire department response. For example, Residential fires have decreased by 80 percent. Brush fires have decreased by 58 percent.

Public assistance calls have decreased by 49 percent. Auxiliary alarms have decreased by 93 percent. Pumping assistance by 88 percent. Wires arcing have decreased by 53 percent.

And vehicular alarms have decreased by 52 percent. In mutual aid, was at the same level in 1992 as it was in 1984. The town, as it says in the fire study report, is not a high fire risk community. But where, ladies and gentlemen, are we as a community at risk with regard to public safety?

If we have to prioritize spending in public safety, what is the best use of those funds? I would maintain that we can make a direct correlation that with more policemen on duty and in the streets, there is less risk to our citizens. But no matter how many firemen we have on duty, they cannot prevent fires. Tougher building codes, sprinklers, home fire extinguishers, and smoke detectors now help prevent fires and save lives.

In other words, fire service, as we have always known it, is changing. It is a little like the dentist who preaches the benefits of fluoride for 25 years and discovers that he doesn't have a lot of cavities to fill anymore. Change is hard to recognize, especially if you are very close to it and have been trained a certain way. 15 months ago, your board of selectmen worked hard to try to keep the station open.

We would open it when we had a full contingent and close it for vacations and sick time. But our enemy was the overtime account. And it still is. But if we vote to fund this station, we must recognize that it is a long-term commitment of funds.

That over a 10-year period of time, with the present value of money, we're talking about millions of dollars. And you have to ask that if fires and fire incidents are down, could those millions of dollars be better spent elsewhere? We live in a community in which surrounding communities have higher crime rates, and that must be our primary focus with regard to public safety. Prevention of crime, the money you spend elsewhere, affects this because it all comes from the same limited pie.

The budgets of some of our smaller departments, like Youth Department and Council on Aging combined, do not add up to this expenditure. Yet they could be affected by this vote, and I don't think we want that. I know I don't. People will then say, what is the answer?

I believe that the answer is to vote no on this particular amendment and then the article. We must remember that the Atherton Street Station was built 100 years ago, and it was built for horses and not for mobile fire equipment. I believe that if Curry College does not have a sprinkler system, then that's the fault of Curry College. It is not the job of the town of Milton to be providing extra protection because they don't have sprinklers.

In the course of the FIRE study, we did go into this at quite a bit of length. One of our members, Bob Bonneran, had done the retrofit of sprinklers for Boston University. It is not a heavy expenditure of funds for Curry to get sprinklers into these dormitories, and we would urge that that happen. Mrs.

Agostino asked a little while ago, why hasn't the town passed a bylaw to require this? I don't believe the town can pass a bylaw to require something like that. It has to be done at the state level. Thank you very much.

Speaker 7 (03:27:02–03:27:03)

Mr. Gordon is recognized.

Speaker 2 (03:27:06–03:27:15)

This will be the last speaker and then we're going to go to a vote. Mr. McDermott's suggestion that we move the question. Mr.

Gordon you were recognized.

Speaker 35 (03:27:16–03:31:59)

Thank you Mr. Moderator. Town meeting members. The Fire Study Committee should be commended for bringing to our attention several significant issues indicative of the gradual erosion of fire protection service in this town over the past decade.

However, The specific issue before us today can and should be confined to the necessity for a third fire station to cover the western section of town, namely the Atherton Street Firehouse. In order to help clarify this issue, I think it is important to examine how Milton stacks up against other towns of similar characteristics. At this point, I'm going to differ in my analysis of the statistics from Mrs. Agostino, which is nothing unusual.

On the specific point of numbers and locations of firehouses in suburban towns, I chose what seemed to me to be the three most important criteria against which to measure Milton. One, the area to be covered per firehouse. Two, the population. in relation to the number of firehouses, and three, one that's been discussed a lot today, the distance to the furthest significant residential or commercial structures.

I included in my study eight other towns which are either close by or against which we are often compared because of similar demographics, size, and per capita income. The towns I looked at were Canton, Dedham, Lexington, Needham, Norwood, Sharon, Wellesley, and Weston, the last being the highest per capita income town in the state. Of these towns, two have only one station, and all the rest, including Milton, presently have two. On every one of the above criteria that I mentioned the three criteria Milton ranks in the top half of the comparison.

We are third out of nine on the basis of area. We are third best measuring distance to the furthest buildings and we are fourth when ranked in fire houses per thousand population. Four of the eight communities compared to Milton have per capita incomes greater than Milton. So what does all of this tell us?

My conclusion is that all communities have had to balance response time against affordability and other community priorities. With our present two fire stations, we still rate favorably on this criterion against towns with fine public safety reputations. Could a life be saved someday if Atherton Street were reopened? Undoubtedly, yes.

However, I think at this point an analogy is in order. As a selectman, I pioneered the introduction of an advanced life support ambulance service in this town. The statistics have shown that many lives have been saved as a result, which would have been lost otherwise. many many lives I can tell you that without a doubt however if we could position advanced life supports the ambulances in more than one location that a definitely quantifiable number of lives would be saved because of shorter response time we presently have the ALS ambulance positioned in one location at the hospital.

However this would be financially and pragmatically unfeasible and thus cannot and should not be considered. Similarly we must vote no on this article because it is not feasible financially or pragmatically. If anybody is interested in the specific numbers that I have in the study that I conducted, most of which was done with MAPC data. I have them available.

I thank you for your patience. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (03:32:03–03:32:52)

I am moving the question. And before the floor, so that everyone understands, is a motion to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee. And that motion is to amend it in the following way, that the town vote to appropriate the sum of $350,000 for the purposes set forth in this article, including the reopening of the Atherton Street fire station and the restoring of eight firefighter positions to the fire department, contingent upon the passage of a Proposition 2.5 override referendum question for those purposes by the voters of the town of Milton. If you vote yes, you're voting to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee If you're voting no, you're voting not to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee.

All those in favor of amending the recommendation of the Warrant Committee as I have explained it, say aye.

Speaker 7 (03:32:53–03:32:53)

Aye.

Speaker 2 (03:32:54–03:33:06)

Those opposed? No. The motion is not carried. We now have the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, which is that no appropriation be made.

Does anyone wish to speak to the recommendation of the Warrant Committee? Mr. Mullen.

Speaker 1 (03:33:07–03:33:35)

Mr. Moderator, I propose an amendment to the recommendation of the Warrant Committee to appropriate the sum of $2,000 to be used for the purpose of continuing the committee and for the committee to report back to the town meeting at the next annual town meeting as to any other recommendations they have, such as changes in the town bylaws or any other recommendations they might have to improve fire safety in the town.

Speaker 2 (03:33:35–03:33:42)

OK, except it'd be nice to have something in writing, Mr. Mullen, so that we have a. Exactly how do you want to do it?

Speaker 1 (03:33:44–03:33:49)

To appropriate the sum of $2,000 for the purpose of continuing.

Speaker 2 (03:33:53–03:35:15)

All right, the sum is already there. All right, this raises the fire study committee has asked to be discharged. And I gather what you're saying is But they don't have to be discharged. Or the moderator could appoint a new one.

Or the moderator could appoint a new one. So you wish to attach to the recommendation of the Warren Committee that a fire study committee be continued to report at the next, to report similarly as the prior one did, I assume. That's, let me explain how that works. And then I'm going to ask town council whether we're going over the deep end here.

If you are trying, Mr. Mullen, to have a fire study committee that is analogous to or similar to the one we had, that would be a fire study committee appointed by me, which would be required to report to the board of selectmen no later than the first Thursday in December of this year with respect to their findings on fire safety needs. Now, the reason it's set up that way is that is the time at or about which slackmen have to decide what articles to put in the warrant. Now, I'd be happy to entertain that as a motion if you so choose.

Speaker 1 (03:35:16–03:35:39)

That was my purpose, Mr. Moderator. In the materials that have been presented today, there's a number of other recommendations. There's recommendations about changes in the fire department's equipment, the backpacks, the outer gear.

There's recommendations, or at least I've heard discussion about possibly selling the Atherton Street property to provide additional funds.

Speaker 2 (03:35:39–03:37:36)

there is at least consideration as to whether the… I understand why you're doing it. The only problem we have, Peter, right now is a procedural one, which is that we get straight exactly what the motion is you want this body to consider. And where it gets complicated is the last Fire Study Committee article, Article 16, I mean, had some, you know, rather express specifications as to who would be on the committee.

So you want a continuation of of the same committee to be appointed or reappointed by the moderator? I'm asking you. I believe that's correct, yes. All right.

Let's see if I can get a fair motion here, which is to recommend that no appropriation be made but that the fire study committee be extended to make a further report to the Board of Selectmen by, John, first Thursday of December? First Thursday of December. I think that would achieve your purposes. All right, there was a motion on the floor to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee as follows, that no appropriation be made, but that the Fire Study Committee be extended for be extended to furnish the fire study committee be extended to furnish a report to the Board of Selectmen by the first Thursday of December.

Is there a second to the motion? Second. All right, it's been moved and seconded. Is there debate on the motion?

Yes, sir.

Speaker 36 (03:37:36–03:38:34)

Malcolm Larson, Precinct 11. I support the motion and I would also like to amend it to be more specific to cover the two features. One, I read recently that the town of Braintree recently purchased a parcel of land in order to build a brand new fire station. I think that should be a definite long-term consideration.

It seems like we're being very short-sighted, especially when we're talking about actually selling firehouse property. And secondly, I think it also should be considered by this committee on whether we should close other firehouses and rotate opening. It's done in Quincy where they rotate closing between North Quincy and Wollaston. I think if there is a disparity in fire coverage in Milton, it would be worth considering closing Engine 2 in East Milton Square and rotating the closures with Engine 4 in the Western sector.

Speaker 2 (03:38:37–03:38:40)

All right, you have pitched that in the form of a motion.

Speaker 36 (03:38:40–03:38:53)

I'm sure that if this motion passes, that the Fire Study Committee would be happy to… I'm sure they'd be happy to, but such a long-term planning just is non-existent.

Speaker 2 (03:38:54–03:39:14)

You want three mandatory subjects. Let me see if I got them right. Hang on. Let me reiterate them.

Whether a new fire station should be constructed, whether… There should be a rotation of the apparatus between the East Milton and the Atherton firehouse?

Speaker 36 (03:39:15–03:39:27)

Yes. It seems like it's without doubt the western part sector of Milton is the one that's shortchanged in this arrangement. I think it's at least worth considering.

Speaker 2 (03:39:27–03:39:34)

Look, you have to give me the motion, see, in case people are wondering why I wanted them in writing, OK?

Speaker 36 (03:39:34–03:40:17)

So you tell me what you want in the way of a motion now, okay The motion is to specifically request that the fire study committee entertain the possibility of Building a new firehouse in a better location building a new firehouse anything which could more evenly distribute the the uh the fire coverage in Milton and number two to consider closing other firehouses on a rotating basis so that uh engine four in the western sector would not consistently be shortchanged in their fire coverage all right let me see if i can keep this as simple as possible your motion is to amend the present motion uh

Speaker 2 (03:40:18–03:40:29)

so that the Fire Study Committee would be required to report on whether a new firehouse should be built and whether there should be the closing of other firehouses on a rotating basis. Is that correct?

Speaker 36 (03:40:29–03:41:02)

Yes, and I would just like to make one other point of information regarding Mr. Gordon's comparisons with other towns by counting the firehouses. A firehouse is not a firehouse. If you drive to Norwood and drive by the Norwood Fire Department, you will see that the entire town of Norwood, yes, it is covered by one firehouse.

But I believe there's four or five pieces of apparatus that respond out of that relatively new fire station. So just to count a firehouse is like counting a schoolhouse without paying any attention to how many students are inside.

Speaker 2 (03:41:04–03:41:54)

Is there a second to the motion to amend the motion? Is there a second? All right, now I would ask Mr. Mullins, save me 10 minutes, if you wish to…

All right. Now hang on. All right, I'm going to move this along after you're here, but let's so everybody knows. The motion is that no appropriation be made, but that the Fire Study Committee be extended to furnish a report to the Board of Selectmen by the first Thursday of December, and in that report to include a recommendation relating to one, whether a new fire station should be built, and two, whether other fire houses should be closed on a rotating basis.

All right, now that's the motion. Anybody want to be heard on that motion? Yes, sir.

Speaker 16 (03:41:55–03:42:21)

Yes, Mr. Moderator. Walter White, Precinct 2. I'm not trying to be a wise guy.

I know you're trying to digest this entire motion. But perhaps the best way to go about it might be if the fire study amendment passes, maybe you could just appoint the last speaker to the fire study committee and ask him now to withdraw his motion. And again, not trying to be disrespectful, but I think that might accomplish the role.

Speaker 2 (03:42:21–03:42:30)

That's the deputy chief of the fire department. Okay. Anybody else? All right.

Mr. McKettrick, Selectman McKettrick. On the motion.

Speaker 37 (03:42:31–03:43:14)

Mr. Moderator, on the motion, the board of Selectman would ask that there be a no vote on the motion. and that the town meeting decide to discharge the fire study committee. We feel that the matter has received a full treatment over the last few months by the committee.

We've had an extended debate today. The Board of Selectmen, upon discharge of the study committee, would certainly consult with Deputy Chief Larson, Chief Affanato, other interested members of the town meeting to determine whether there is any need for changes in the bylaws or any other disposition of the forces of the fire department. But we feel that under the circumstances, that is the way to proceed rather than continuing the study committee procedure. Thank you, Mr.

Moderator.

Speaker 2 (03:43:14–03:43:19)

The moderator recognizes the chairman of the Warrant Committee, Mr. Murphy, for the position of the Warrant Committee on the pending motion.

Speaker 10 (03:43:20–03:43:20)

The Warrant Committee recommends a no vote.

Speaker 2 (03:43:22–03:43:55)

All right, I'm moving the question. The motion is? to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee so that it now reads that no appropriation be made but that the Fire Study Committee be extended to furnish a report to the Board of Selectmen by the first Thursday of December and in that report to include a recommendation relating to whether a new firehouse should be built and two, whether or not other firehouses should be closed in a rotating basis. All right, now if you vote aye, you're voting to amend the recommendation of the Warrant Committee.

If you're voting no, you're voting against it. All those in favor of the amendment, say aye.

Speaker 7 (03:43:56–03:43:56)

Aye.

Speaker 2 (03:43:57–03:43:58)

Those opposed?

Speaker 7 (03:43:58–03:43:59)

No.

Speaker 5 (03:44:00–03:44:05)

The noes have it.

Speaker 2 (03:44:05–03:44:19)

Okay, now we have before us the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, which is that no appropriation be made. Is there further discussion? All those in favor of the Warrant Committee recommendation that no appropriation be made under Article 22, say aye.

Speaker 7 (03:44:20–03:44:20)

Aye.

Speaker 2 (03:44:21–03:44:33)

Those opposed? No. The ayes have it. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee that no appropriation be made has been adopted.

OK. Now, I want to take a five-minute break.

Speaker 20 (03:44:33–03:44:37)

Mr. Moderator, before you break, I'd like to move to discussion.

Speaker 2 (03:44:37–03:44:41)

I will accept a motion from Mr. Winchester that the Fire Study Committee be discharged.

Speaker 27 (03:44:41–03:44:42)

Yes.

Speaker 2 (03:44:42–03:47:15)

Is there a second to that motion? All right, any debate? No. All those in favor of discharging the Fire Study Committee say aye.

Aye. Those opposed? No. Your committee has been discharged, Mr.

Winchester. Fine. Then we are on Article 24. Please take your seats.

Article 24 is to see what sum of money the town will vote. 23, excuse me. See what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994, for the operation of the several boards and committees classified as boards and special committees and to act on anything relating thereto. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town appropriate the amount shown in the following tabulation under the heading recommended, and I will read the totals for the Board of Appeals, 19,877.

Conservation Commission, 4,200. Council on Aging $62,224, Historical Commission $1,500, Personnel Board $21,199, Planning Board $2,254, Warrant Committee $4,542, Wages and salaries and general expenses seven five sixty and a total of twelve one oh two youth department sixty five thousand five twenty one for a grand total of a hundred and eighty eight thousand eight seventy seven Is there any debate all those in favor of the recommendation of the Warren Committee say aye Those opposed the ayes have it. It's unanimous in article 23 the recommendation the Warren Committee there under has been adopted article 24 is to see what sum of money is the town will vote to appropriate for the support of schools for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994, and to act on anything relating thereto. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town appropriate the amounts shown in the following tabulation under the heading Recommended.

And that comes to a total appropriation as set forth in pages 35 and 36 of $15,644,113. And to meet said appropriation, the sum of $567 shall be transferred from the adjustment account for special education for 1993, and shall be applied as required by law to the cost of programs provided under General Laws Chapter 71B, and the balance of $15,643,546 be raised in the tax levy for the fiscal year. And the moderator recognizes the chairman of the school committee, Mr. Frank Desmond.

Speaker 8 (03:47:15–03:55:14)

I'll try and be very brief. First, on a very good note, I would, on behalf of the school committee, like to thank all the voters for their support last week on the debt exclusion override for our science wing that will be built finally. We'd like to also give a special thanks to Dr. Anne Coughlin for her work over many years.

It's nice, very nice to have something good to say and to have going for our school department. We'd also like to thank the Board of Selectmen, the Warren Committee, and a special thanks to the students of Milton High School who helped us drop literature throughout the town. We had over 40 students from Milton High School who probably will not have the opportunity of using the science wing, but did get involved because they knew what was needed in their own high school and we wish to thank them also. At this time I'd like to give just a brief overview of some of the workings of the school committee and a brief rundown on the budget that has been recommended.

We have had a budget analysis conducted by an independent consultant consultants who have been associated with an international internationally known consultant firm of Bain & Company. They have compared Milton spending for the schools to that of four other towns. The towns are Braintree, Brookline, Needham and Newton. A more detailed report will be given in the upcoming school committee meetings and I'm sure After today you all want to watch the school committee meetings to see the detailed reports on the Bain study.

But we do have a brief rundown that I would like to share with you town meeting members. Number one is despite an increasingly diverse student population on a total per pupil basis Milton spends 25 percent less than the average school system study. Milton spending is lower in almost all major spending categories. One striking difference can be seen in the lack of spending in teacher training and updating of curriculum.

Despite what you might think in special education Milton spends 23 percent less than the other districts studied. Milton has the lowest per pupil expenditure of any of these districts. The differences range from close to $300 per pupil in the lowest, which is Braintree, to almost $2,000 per pupil in the highest, which is Newton. If Milton were to fund at a rate compatible to Braintree, we would have approximately $1 million more in our school budget.

If Milton were to fund at a rate compatible to Newton, which we'd like to do, we would have approximately $6,800,000 more in our school budget. These additional funds would allow Milton to meet its major needs in areas of technology, maintenance and repair of buildings, teacher training, and curriculum development. In the area of teacher training, Milton spent the least of any town studied Milton spends $4 per pupil in teacher training as compared to Needham, which spends $19 in this area. In special education, Milton spent the least of any of these towns studied.

Milton spent $6,428 per student as compared to Newton, which spends $10,787 per student. Since 1987, Milton has been decreasing its spending per pupil. Adjusting adjusted for inflation in 1987 Milton was spending four thousand eight hundred and fifty eight dollars per student using the 1987 dollars Milton is presently spending four thousand three hundred and ninety nine dollars per student. During the last 15 years Milton has liked to compare itself to 40 other towns in the Commonwealth.

Milton's per-pupil spending was in the upper half of these towns through 1987. After 1987, Milton has dropped to the bottom 25 percent of these towns. The only communities today that follow Milton are Randolph, Stoughton, Sharon, and Weymouth. The state has determined the minimum a town must spend on education.

The minimum is now becoming the maximum Milton is going to spend. Milton's Warren Committee is recommending the funding at a bare minimum permitted by the state. Superintendent Dr. Mary Grasser O'Neill developed a level of service budget supplemented with some additional monies to begin to move in the right direction.

The level of service The level service budget requested was $15,752,113. This was really a somewhat less than level service budget because it did not include any provisions for the projected increase in students. The school committee exercising fiscal restraint in these difficult times requested only an additional $375,000 which would allow us to start to address some of our most pressing needs. This brought the total school committee request to $16,127,113 for fiscal year 95.

However, the Warren committee has supported a budget appropriation of only $15,644,113. This amount provides the schools with less than a level service budget. The Warren Committee's recommended budget leaves the Milton Public Schools with major unmet needs in the areas of technology, maintenance and repair of buildings, teacher training and curriculum development. In addition, for the second year in a row, there has been no funds included for collective bargaining agreements.

And that's just a brief look at our conditions of the school department. You've heard from several departments today and what kind of conditions the roads are in kind of conditions our fire department is in. We want to let the town meeting also know that we're working very hard with what we have. We would like more.

We are going with the Warren committee's recommendation and at this time I would like to introduce Dr. Mary Grasser O'Neill for further remarks.

Speaker 2 (03:55:15–03:55:23)

Dr. Mary Grasser O'Neill is recognized. Thank you.

Speaker 38 (03:55:23–04:04:03)

Thank you Chairman Desmond. This is my first town meeting and when I was asking school committee members what it is I should say they directed me to give a state of the school's address They told me to talk about our plans for the system. They told me to be informative, to be funny, and to be inspiring. And then they told me to do it in five minutes.

But I talked to Bill Taylor coming in here today, and he said that John Cronin had told him that he had to do the same thing, only he was given 90 seconds. So I guess we're doing better in the schools than in the DPW. At any rate, I had known the Milton Public Schools as an outsider prior to September of 93. I thought the Milton Public Schools were very good.

Now from the inside, I know for a fact that the system is indeed very good. I was hired, however, and a condition of my hiring was to bring some change and some improvement into the Milton Public Schools. When any organization is looking to change, it really needs to look and to study what made it great in the first place and then make a determination if what made it great originally is something that's strong and right and fitting for the future. So to assess our strength and to assess our readiness for the future, we decided to ask people what they thought about the Milton Public Schools.

We asked them through a survey and from December and during December and January and February, we surveyed parents in the district and heard from hundreds and hundreds of you. We surveyed every teacher in the system and we surveyed students at the middle school, the high school, and all of our fourth graders. The surveys really are a reflection of my experience in education that tells me it's best to be straightforward, to bring issues forward for open discussion and thought, and at the same time to get an input and an assessment of what's really important. And we have had an incredible, a truly incredible response with lots of creative ideas just flowing into our office.

Based on the survey and the budget analysis, we are really going to need to work together to find a way to get back up to being competitive with our schools. I was hired as the superintendent based on four core values, or four driving beliefs that have kind of been important to me throughout my career. The survey is organized to discover where Milton stands with these core values, and really to make the values come alive throughout the Milton Public Schools. The survey results have made me see both strengths and challenges meeting the core values.

The first core value is high academic achievement for all, and we have heard really poignant stories from the respondents about how important it is to challenge each and every child to reach his or her highest potential. We really need to know more about how to do this, and the developing technologies and the report from the Technology Committee gives us a really exciting opportunity to meet every single child's needs. The second is respect for human differences, and the changing student population offers Milton an incredible opportunity. Parents and teachers, and we know this for a fact now from the survey, are really committed to school improvement in the Milton Public Schools.

And we were surprised to see across the board, I didn't know what parents were like, and we asked a lot of questions, but we were delighted to see the wonderful opportunity we have. You know how much of a child's success in school is based on the education level of parents. And across the board, for all of our racial and ethnic groups, for all of the parents in Milton, we find that about 75% of them have higher education, which gives us You know, a true opportunity, and over and over what was repeated through the surveys is that folks see the diversity we have in our town as a real strength. And we were told that people are looking to us, the Milton Public School System, to make this all come together.

And we're looking forward to that challenge. Thirdly, third core value, excellence in the classroom. The faculty in the Milton Public Schools is a real mix, a mix of wonderful experience and exuberant youth. We have a lot of new teachers in the system and a lot of wonderful, experienced teachers.

However, we have systematically under-invested in their growth and in their professional development and in their training. Virtually every single teacher surveyed wanted us to invest in those areas, despite the fact that there hasn't been a real commitment to this in the past. The fourth core value that we're checking out in our survey is one of collaborative relationships. And we're hearing good things about this.

We're hearing you say that you feel welcome in our schools and that's very important to us. You want to take part in the life of the schools and we want that too. We've received some major gifts just over these few short months. GTE has given us hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of furniture.

You notice no one came forward today looking for furniture, despite all the tight budgets that we have here, because we've been able to share a little bit with the other town departments. We got a donation of a computer lab from Arthur D. Little. Fallon Ambulance, in something unprecedented in town, gave four scholarships, as well as four guaranteed full-time or part-time jobs to Milton High School students, and in addition is providing free training for us.

Bain & Company has been a terrific support in the development of our surveys and helping us with the analysis and helping us to understand and synthesize the results and come up with a very strong plan for the future. Aquinas College has given us free training. The Milton Performing Arts gave us these wonderful curtains that you see how much more attractive it looks in here than last time you may have been here. Also, we're looking to start, in a major and a public way, some way to stimulate private investment within the Milton Public Schools.

Particularly, we are pleased with the development of the technology plan and last Saturday's override to fund the new science building at Milton High School. We are grateful to the voters, the citizens, the students of Milton, especially to Chairman Ann Coughlin, who got such well-deserved recognition a few minutes ago. But also, we're very grateful for the united and the unanimous support of all of the elected bodies in town, the school committee, the selectmen, and the warrant committee. We are truly appreciative.

School Committee Chairman Frank Desmond has described this year's bare bones and less than level service school budget. We look forward to presenting details of our independent budget analysis at a future school committee meeting. But as I've had a chance to look at the survey data, I find that we are in a remarkably unique position. And we're in this position for several reasons.

First, we have particularly strong teacher commitment. Second, we have a top quality teaching staff. Thirdly, we have enormous parent and community support. Fourthly, we have a richly diverse and wonderful student population.

In addition, we have the opportunity to contribute more to education than we have in the past. We have a very high confidence level in the Milton Public Schools. Most respondents to our survey, this is parents, teachers, and students describe the Milton Public Schools as excellent. Recently, passing the override showed the public's confidence and commitment to the children of the Milton Public Schools.

These facts give me real confidence. We need to keep this level of commitment and drive, and we can do great things together. I ask for your support, each and every one of you, so that we can expand into the 21st century with new vigor and grasp this opportunity that we have at our fingertips to be a pioneer in leading schools into the year 2000. Thank you very very much.

Speaker 2 (04:04:03–04:06:52)

Thank you very much Dr. O'Neill. For the purists among you who have added all of the sub numbers and found that they do not add up to $15,644,113. The problem is in a typographical error under regular education where the sum $12,308,681 should be increased by $5 to $12,308,686.

Any further debate? No. All those in favor of the Warrant Committee's recommendation say aye. Aye.

Those opposed? Article, as recommended by the Warrant Committee, is adopted. Article 25 is to see if the town will vote pursuant to Chapter 44, Section 53E and a half of the Massachusetts General Laws to authorize the school committee to expend a sum of money not to exceed $40,000 for the purpose of maintenance and repair of school facilities from the revolving fund established by vote of the March 1993 Annual Town Meeting under Article 19 for fees received from the rental of school facilities and to act on anything relating there to the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote yes. Is there any debate?

All those in favor of the Warrant Committee recommendation say aye. Aye. Those opposed? It's unanimous.

Article 26. See if the town will vote pursuant to chapter 44 section 53E and a half of the Massachusetts General Laws to establish a revolving fund to utilize fees received for the preschool program for regular education students in the Milton Public Schools for the purpose of operation of said program, to authorize the school department to expend money from such revolving fund in the fiscal year beginning July 1, 1994, and to act on anything relating thereto. And the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote to establish a revolving fund pursuant to Mass General Law Chapter 44 Section 53E and a half to authorize the school committee to utilize the fees received from the preschool program for regular education students in the Milton Public Schools for the purpose of operation of said program and to determine a limit of $60,000 as the amount which can be expended from this fund in the fiscal year beginning July 1, 1994. Is there any debate?

All those in favor of the Warrant Committee's recommendation say aye. Aye. Those opposed? It's unanimously adopted under Article 26 of the Recommendation of the Warrant Committee.

Article 27. To see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate to purchase and install computer hardware and other data processing equipment for educational purposes, and to purchase computer software incident thereto, and for other expenses incidental and related thereto, to determine whether this appropriation shall be raised by borrowing or otherwise, and to act on anything relating thereto. It's recommended that the sum of $45,000 be appropriated for the purposes set forth in this article. Is there any debate?

Mr. Walsh.

Speaker 39 (04:06:54–04:15:30)

Thank you. Mr. Moderator and fellow town meeting members, I'm Brian Walsh, a town meeting member from the very voter active Precinct 8, and a proud member of the Milton School Committee. In the interest of time, I intend to be clear, be brief, and then be seated.

I am speaking to you as a representative of the school committee in the Technology Advisory Committee, a subcommittee of the school committee formed a few years back. I will not be taking you through an explanation of the very detailed plan that was the basis of this request. And I hope many of you are aware of it. It's probably 40 more pages, a very, very detailed plan.

But I do intend to gain your support with a fair explanation. The $45,000 article in front of you, as stated in the comments section of the warrant, is a significantly smaller request than the original $691,000 submitted. This is in recognition of a few key points. First, funds are limited, and the science facility is our priority this year.

Second, as a body, we are just now beginning to understand the pervasive nature of technology in our society and the subsequent requirement of our schools. It's the second point that I want to focus my remarks upon today. I'd like to talk a bit about the current state. Now, we've all heard an awful lot about the Information Highway over the past year, and it's been the subject of many network news programs.

We see it in the magazine articles and in the newspaper. We hear it discussed at business meetings and on the trains, etc. Well, please, if you will, visualize with me this Information Highway coming by Milton. Now picture 3,400 cars representing the students of the Milton Public Schools.

Now I'm sad to say that the vast majority of those are sitting stuck in the breakdown lane. Now through the efforts of the PTO and school budget, the Technology Advisory Committee and others, we've been able to push a few of those cars out into the travel lane, but even those are having trouble keeping up with traffic. Now the high-speed lane I have to tell you there's nobody in the town of Milton from the Milton Public Schools that's really prepared to get jumped into that high-speed lane for now. So, in fact, if we don't do something soon, we might as well let them close the Milton oil ramp to this highway because our kids just can't use it.

And that's really the state of the technology in the Milton Public Schools. Now, is this situation hopeless? No. This $45,000 is one of the early and critical steps towards our technology journey.

But what is the current state specifically in Milton Schools? I hope you will all receive the handout today on your way in. I'd like to tell you what color it was, but it was copied on several colors, so I can't. But it's a one-page article.

Many of you should have. It summarizes where we are in terms of technology that we currently have in the schools. I'll give you a minute to get that out. I see a sea of color.

It summarizes where we are in terms of technology that we currently have in the schools and where we stand in relation to the kinds of communities that we like to compare ourselves to. Now very quickly on what I call the front page, you'll see a graph that indicates the per pupil expenditure that we in the Milton Public Schools are doing in terms of technology against the per-pupil expenditure that the same kinds of communities are doing. And to say that the difference is dramatic is understatement. Now if you'll turn the page over, this is a good graph and a snapshot of where we are in terms of the amount of technology that we have in the schools.

Technology is a funny word. Computers is even a vague term. You know, we certainly don't want to get bogged down in terms of megabytes and megahertz and chip speeds and all that kind of thing. But what the Technology Advisory Committee has been able to do is to really frame this in a way that I think most of us can understand.

If you realize that the computers that are six years old or older are really old technology that has little effective use, then this chart tells you that the majority of the technology we do have is too old. And so when you have a few minutes I'd like you to look at that. But I think it gives you a good state of the current situation. Now let me address the need.

If we were going to do as well as everyone else in terms of this kinds of community, would we be doing enough? In an era where our state is concerned on the issue of school reform, the Boston Sunday Globe had a feature article about six to eight weeks ago which discussed a survey that they had done. Perhaps many of you saw it. They asked college students what did they feel they were most inadequately prepared for as they handled their college work.

The number one answer was computer training. Now keep in mind they're talking to college students all around the state so presumably mostly to students that do a lot more funding than we do. Now, they found that not only were they unprepared in understanding how to use the computer in specific topic areas, but they were also poorly prepared to deal with the college assumption that they would be able to effectively use the computer labs to produce their reports and other homework assignments. And what about the rest of society?

We have known for some time now that most administrative and white-collar jobs regularly use computers as part of their daily routine. But what about now? You know, when the UPS truck delivers a package to our door, the driver uses a computer to keep track and has a sign on a computer tablet instead of a paper. I'm sure some of you have had that happen to you.

When we have our cars get a tune-up, the mechanics must understand and use a computer to do the job. When we use a catalog to phone, order a product, the person on the other end quickly handles the order using a computer. Even when we drop off our dry cleaning in East Milton, By simply providing our phone number, the employee generates a receipt with our name and the audit details using a computer. They are everywhere, and today's student must understand them.

If we don't include technology training in our schools, we are not preparing our kids for the real world. Readiness. If you support this article today, you ought to know whether the schools are ready to use them. For the past several years, the Technology Advisory Committee has been working on three things, acting as the coordinators and maintenance contractors on the existing technology, holding together what we have with tape and bailing wire, running fundraisers to help provide some teacher training and technology opportunities such as KidsNet, and continuing to maintain a detailed plan to assist our administration in implementing technology system-wide.

When the school committee asked me last fall to be the liaison to this group, I was immediately impressed with the participants, along with representatives from our PTOs and other parents, who were key members from our school's administrative staff. Our assistant superintendent for curriculum, an assistant principal from the high school, an elementary school principal, our high school science department head, and our K-6 math coordinator are all regular participants on the technology advisory committee. While giving up significant amounts of their free time, these individuals have been preparing themselves to integrate technology into our schools. Our system is ready to get this job done.

In closing, although I could go on, I'll honor my opening pledge and close. I would like to leave you with this analogy. If you had to, you could build a house with a hammer and chisel as your tools. You could also build a house using electric band saws and miter saws and a lathe.

When finished, which house do you think would be a better product? Well, our product should be a well-prepared student. Please join us in supporting this article and help us give our students the right tools they sorely need. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (04:15:30–04:16:55)

Thank you, Mr. Walsh. All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, say aye. Aye.

Those opposed? The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is carried unanimously. Article 28, to see if the town will vote to establish a high school science facilities building committee. for the purpose of constructing, remodeling, and furnishing high school science laboratories at the high school authorized by vote of the March 1992 annual town meeting.

under Article 15, and do act on anything relating thereto. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town moderator be authorized to appoint a high school facilities building committee to consist of five citizens. Which committee shall be authorized to advertise and secure bids for construction, remodeling, and furnishing of science laboratories at Milton High School, to award a contract or contracts for said purpose, and to supervise such work all in the name of and on behalf of the town of Milton. said committee shall submit a progress report to the Board of Selectmen and the School Committee no later than December 1 of each year is the debate.

All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Those opposed? Recommendation of the Warrant Committee under Article 28 is carried unanimously. Article 29, to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the support of the Blue Hills Regional Vocational School for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994, to act on anything relating thereto.

The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the sum of $322,735 be appropriated for the purposes set forth in this article as their debate. Yes, sir.

Speaker 40 (04:17:00–04:18:28)

My name is Phil Kleiman. I'm a town meeting member from Precinct 11 and your representative to the Blue Hills School Committee. As noted in the printed comments of the Warrant Committee, it is now the Commonwealth of Massachusetts who determines the minimum funding levels for the public schools. The Blue Hills Regional School District has endeavored to meet that objective.

Also, I'd like you to note that as indicated in the Warrant Committee's report, the buy-in costs in their eighth year. That's a 10-year program in two years that $30,548 will no longer be included in the Blue Hills regional request. Milton's assessment is based upon its proportional share of the Blue Hills operating budget as a function of the number of students from Milton who are enrolled in grades 9 through 12. In addition to the students who are enrolled in 9-12, a number of Milton residents are taking advantage of such things as the postgraduate programs, the extensive number of evening school programs, and also the community service programs such as the restaurant, bakery, hairdressing and skin care services, and our Olympic swimming pool.

On behalf of the Blue Hills District School Committee and the school administration, I want to thank the Milton Town meeting for its support over the past years, and hope that you will act favorably upon this article. Thank you very much.

Speaker 2 (04:18:32–04:19:45)

Thank you, Mr. Kleinman. All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, say aye. Aye.

Those opposed? The recommendation of the Warrant Committee under Article 29 is carried unanimously. Article 30, to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for health and sanitation for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994. and to act on anything relating thereto.

Recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town appropriate the amounts shown in the following tabulation under the heading recommended. And those are. Board of Health salaries and wages seventy four thousand five twenty four general expenses three eight three one five hundred for new equipment extermination contractual services a thousand one five eight animal inspection six hundred for a total of eighty thousand six thirteen is there any debate. All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye.

Aye. Those opposed. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee under Article 30 is carried unanimously. Article 31 see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the public library for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994.

Are there amendments to this, Mr. Murphy? And before I read the recommendation, there are going to be changes to the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, and the moderator recognizes Mr. Murphy for that purpose.

Speaker 10 (04:19:47–04:22:16)

Yes the Warrant Committee voted to change its recommendation in the following manner and under new equipment to add change the zero to four thousand dollars and of the book line item twenty six excuse me twenty six thousand eight seventy six for a total of five hundred and twenty seven thousand three thirty three. This is the amount that would be, the total appropriation would be the amount that would be necessary to meet the state standards to keep the libraries certified and make them grant eligible and keep them as part of the library networks, etc. We had a meeting this morning with the chair of the board of library trustees who convinced us that she had discussed with the governor's staff, etc., and various state officials, state board of library commissioners, and that the 100% standard that we were operating under, that is now part of the governor's proposed budget, would in fact be changed and the administration did not intend to go back to the 100% standard, but would return to the 102.5% standard. And so, We would we would rather do that now rather than later.

You should know from reading the comment that the Warren Committee has always been committed to meet the municipal appropriation requirement. Twelve thousand dollars brings back at a minimum twenty six thousand dollars in grant money. So it's fiscally responsible to do that in order to fund this. We will later propose that we amend the reserve fund article.

I think that's 51 and reduce that by twelve thousand dollars. At the time we deliberated this article and we reduced the $12,000 down to the 100 percent standard we had made a commitment that we would come back in later in the year if necessary and even in the event that there were no special town meeting in the fall we would make a reserve fund transfer. So for us this became a question of timing. Let's do it now rather than later.

and prepare the libraries for the grant eligibility. In addition, I might point out that one of the other very significant, beyond the mere $26,000 grant, the library is now studying its facility needs. There are multi-million dollars of library grant, building grant money that will be coming down the line, according to Mrs. Jeffries, quite a bit sooner than had been anticipated, perhaps as early as fiscal 95.

And so we would not want to do anything that would jeopardize the grant eligibility of the library.

Speaker 2 (04:22:19–04:23:05)

Thank you. So the amended recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town appropriate the amounts shown in the following tabulation under the headings recommended and the changed figures are under new equipment add instead of zero four thousand and under books instead of eighteen eight seventy six make a twenty six thousand eight seventy six for a total recommended appropriation for fiscal year ninety five of $527,333. The department is hereby authorized to sell or exchange all equipment to furnish additional funds for new services. The chairperson of the library trustees is Marjorie Jeffries, and I assume, Mrs.

Jeffries, you do not wish to be recognized in light of this? I would like to be recognized. You would like to be recognized, so you are therefore recognized.

Speaker 7 (04:23:14–04:23:20)

All right, all right.

Speaker 41 (04:23:21–04:30:17)

I hardly know where to begin because I'm so pleased about what has happened with the Warrant Committee. I think that it is really, really important that we look at the library as an institution in this town, which is one of the three or four legs that the town stands on. Schools, and we can go through a litany of what is necessary for the town, but the library is certainly one of them. And as Mr.

Murphy has said over and over again, as everybody has been saying, what we are looking at has been declining funds that have been available for maintenance. You can look at the walls in our building, which the outside walls are leaking, so the plaster is going to pieces. Deferred maintenance, which is going to cost more in the end. Everybody's saying this.

We're saying this. capital budget items have been set aside and just for your information in the litany of capital budget items on in article 18 the library's capital budget item has been neglected to be put in and that would be something like The oil tank outside, which holds oil, needs to be replaced. It would cost about $25,000 to replace it now. If we wait and we have an oil leak, and you know these things happen, it may cost four times as much.

Now, there's nothing we can do about it. I'm just putting this in front of you. At this time, there's nothing we can do about it. We are also in a minimum budgeting mode which we all of the town departments are in and as Frank has said with the school department we are at the lowest of comparison towns in the amount of appropriation.

You can look on page 137 of the town report if you want to see this spelled out. Be glad that I've decided we have decided not to have a whole bunch of slides and a whole bunch of figures. Book prices Here's something for you to contemplate with some amusement. In 1967, an adult fiction cost, the average price of adult hardcover fiction was $4.81.

It is now $20.34. Nonfiction prices in 1967 were $9.62, and now they are $52.40. So we are very, very happy to get the $8,000 back again in our book budget. But I would like to say that the library is doing its part to try to help the town all it can.

In 1990, the book budget was $69,000 plus. In 1991, because of the budget crunch, the book budget was cut to $15,000 plus. And the library had to make up the balance of those funds because, like the town appropriation, the book budget is mandated as part of the certification process. In 1995, as you see, the town appropriation is $18,000, and yet we need to have $74,000.

So the library will have to find these funds. We will find these funds. We have a double whammy this year because the Article 25 Space Library Needs Study Committee is asking for $10,000, but the recommendation is against any money, so the trustees will have to find this $10,000. we are going to uh we are entertaining the idea of selling off some some become be very careful that i say some of the art in order to raise some of this money this is a one-time thing we can't resell the art every year not that art so we're doing it very very carefully you'll hear more about it i'm sure the ten thousand twelve thousand dollars that you just heard about being restored to the library budget can buy books and computers, but the real importance of this money is that it is necessary to meet the state requirement for the town appropriation for the library in order to be certified.

Why is certification so important? The history of this certification, this whole formula, which is so many hurdles that you have to jump through, was started by the State Board of Library Commissioners, who are the state authority in charge of local libraries. in order to make sure that local libraries got the kind of funding they needed when the crunches were on. We all know schools need money, we all know police and fire and so on need money.

Libraries also should not get left out, and they haven't been, mostly, I would suggest, because it has been mandated for certification. So that's nice, it's nice to be certified, but what it really means There is an incentive, a carrot, to this appropriation that the towns must do, and the carrot is called an incentive grant. And we have been getting an incentive grant for the past few years. And thanks to the former chairman, Paul Buchanan, this incentive grant now goes straight to the library instead of coming to the town, which means, of course, that the library gets a little more money, which is nice.

And we have earned it because we have jumped through all those hoops. And after all, we have to remember that the town is not divided into a lot of different garments. The town is really one garment. And whether you put this money into the library budget or whether you put this money into a town budget or a school budget, it is all part of the same garment.

So that whether it goes into this pocket or that pocket, it goes to the town. So don't worry. You are getting this money as well. It doesn't matter whether it goes to this budget or that budget.

What is really important now and what the Warren Committee has recognized is that we are embarked on a building program. We started this last year. In fact, a year and a half ago, when the trustees voted that we needed to enlarge our space. And for anybody who has gone to the library, I think this speaks for itself.

And I won't go into that, because you'll hear enough about that at another time. But in order to be eligible for a major state grant, we had to have the certification. And as, what's your name? Mr.

Murphy pointed out.

Speaker 2 (04:30:18–04:30:19)

Mr. Murphy.

Speaker 41 (04:30:20–04:30:32)

I have been known not to recognize all my best friends. Please don't take offense.

Speaker 2 (04:30:32–04:30:34)

I have the same problem, so don't worry about it.

Speaker 41 (04:30:34–04:32:14)

It's a name problem. As he and his committee have recognized, this… I doubt I'll ever live to stand. But as you, as they have recognized, we are eligible if we, we will be eligible because we will be certified when we've gone through all these hurdles, and the major one was the appropriation, to be eligible for two to three million dollars.

So although you are painfully extracting 12,000, the amount that will be gained is major. This is exciting times for the library. I foresee that we will be having big steps coming to our library. I foresee a board that is going to work together.

They already have committed themselves to many different aspects in the last meeting. I see that people in this town who really feel strongly that the library is an important institution are going to help. We are going to ask for help every which way. And as Mrs.

O'Neill has pointed out, see I remembered her name. She has been welcoming parents into the classroom. This is a wonderful thing. We welcome everybody into the library.

We welcome everybody to help us in every way and we will need a lot of help.

Speaker 16 (04:32:14–04:32:16)

Thank you. Thank you very much.

Speaker 2 (04:32:21–04:32:57)

Any further discussion on the amended recommendation of the Warrant Committee? All those in favor of the amended recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed?

The recommendation of the Warrant Committee under Article 31 is carried unanimously. Article 32 is to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate to hire a consultant to prepare preliminary drawings and a site plan for construction and or renovation of the Milton Public Library. and to act on anything relating thereto. And the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that no appropriation be made.

The moderator recognizes Ann Coghlan.

Speaker 42 (04:33:04–04:35:11)

I promise to be very brief. The Library Building Study Committee was established under Article 25 of the 1993 town meeting. The committee appointed by the moderator consists of myself as chairman with members Paul Buchanan, Marjorie Jeffries, Joseph Santos Suoso and Russell Tremaine. We fully understand why no money was appropriated for our purposes last year and we also understand the reason that none is being recommended in the current warrant.

The committee has been working since its appointment last summer. And it is in the process of hiring a consultant using a grant from the library trustees. We expect to do the following. Use the consultant to verify our needs and present partial preliminary plans by September.

Secondly, we expect to return to the town if there is a special town meeting in the fall of this year. to seek money for schematic drawings in order to be able to apply for the state money that has already been discussed. The committee has identified six very important needs relative to the main library building, and they are as follows. There is a severe need for space for services, materials, and seating.

There is a need for a physical layout that is efficient not only to deliver services but also for such matters as security and efficiency of staffing. For those of you who have been to the library lately there is a severe need for proper heating air conditioning and ventilation. A need for a structure that is fully handicapped accessible a need for infrastructure to provide for emerging technologies, and lastly, for adequate parking. Thank you very much.

Speaker 2 (04:35:16–04:35:46)

For further discussion. All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed.

Recommendation. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee that no appropriation be made is carried. Article 33. to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the maintenance and improvement of the cemetery for the year beginning July 1, 1994, and to act on anything relating thereto.

Do you have an amendment to the recommendation? Moderator recognizes Mr. Murphy for the purposes of amending the Warrant Committee's recommendation. Thank you for recognizing me.

Speaker 10 (04:35:49–04:36:29)

Sorry. Sorry. Sorry, Mayor. Believe me, I look forward to the days when fewer people recognize me, which will be very shortly.

Yes, we have amended our recommendation consistent with a vote of the cemetery trustees as to how they would like to distribute their money. They would like to change the line item for salaries and wages to $315,093. and then reduce the general expense line item to $71,921 which still remains, and the total remains exactly the same.

Speaker 2 (04:36:30–04:40:57)

Thank you. So the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the total be in accordance with what Mr. Murphy just suggested, $315,093 for salary and wages, $71,921 for general expenses for a total budget of $387,014. and that to meet said appropriation, the sum of $194,564 be raised from the tax levy of the fiscal year, and that the balance of the appropriation be transferred from available funds as follows.

Proceeds from the sale of burial rights, $68,000. Income from cemetery perpetual care fund, $124,450. And the department is hereby authorized to sell or exchange all equipment to furnish additional funds for new equipment. Is there any further discussion?

All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, say aye. Those opposed? The recommendation of the Warrant Committee as amended is adopted unanimously under Article 33. Article 34 is to see if the town will vote to accept the following gifts to the Milton Cemetery for the planting of flowers and placing of decorations and the beautification of the Milton Cemetery as specified by the donor.

I will not read them. They appear on page 44 of your warrant. Recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote yes. Is there any discussion or debate?

All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed? The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is unanimously adopted under Article 34.

Article 35, and this requires a two-thirds vote, is to see if the town pursuant to Chapter 530 of the Acts of 1990 will authorize the trustees of the Milton Cemetery to borrow a sum of money from the Perpetual Care Fund for the purposes of cemetery development as set forth below at a rate of interest of five percent per annum. The term of such borrowing shall not exceed 10 years. The principal and interest shall be paid from the sale of burial rights in such manner as the trustees of the Milton Cemetery shall determine with the approval of the Board of Selectmen. A, to borrow a sum of money not to exceed $240,000 to complete the second and final phase of the new cemetery development project.

Said money shall be used for surveying, permitting, permitting road construction, installation of drainage structures and utility services, earthwork, finish grading, and landscaping. B, to borrow a sum of money not to exceed $47,000 for the construction of a pre-engineered steel building to replace the existing wood storage building. Said building is deemed necessary by the Board of Trustees of the Milton Cemetery to support the maintenance of 10 newly developed acres and to act on anything relating there to. Now, the recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote to appropriate the sum of $287,000 for the purposes of this article, and to meet said appropriation, the town vote, in accordance with Chapter 530 of the Acts of 1990, to authorize the trustees of the Milton Cemetery to borrow the sum of $287,000 from the Cemetery Perpetual Care Fund.

at a rate of interest of 5% per annum, for a term not to exceed 10 years, with the principle and interest of such borrowing to be paid from the sale of burial rights in a manner determined by the trustees of the Milton Cemetery subject to the approval of voter selection, provided, however, that in no case may any portion of such payment be affected by appropriation from the tax levy, is their discussion. All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee say aye. Aye. Those opposed?

It's unanimously adopted under Article 35, the recommendation of the Warrant Committee. Article 36 is to see what sum of money the town will vote to appropriate for the 12-month period beginning July 1, 1994, for the operation of parks and recreation, and to see if the town will vote to authorize the continued use of the Park and Recreation Revolving Fund, pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 18 of the general bylaws of the town, and to act on anything relating thereto. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town appropriate the amount shown in the following tabulation under the heading recommended. And that total for parks and recreation is $181,114, as specified on page 46 of the warrant.

And that the town vote to authorize the continued use of the park and recreation revolving fund pursuant to the provisions of chapter 18 of the general bylaws of the town. Is there discussion or debate? All those in favor of the record? You're recognized.

Mr. Herndon.

Speaker 5 (04:40:59–04:41:05)

Thank you.

Speaker 25 (04:41:06–04:44:44)

Barbara Hearn, Precinct 8. I've been asked by the other park commissioners just to give you a brief overview of our revolving fund, even though we're not required to under Chapter 44, Section 53D. You've heard a lot of talk of how successful it's been. We implemented our revolving fund in November of 1992, or this body did, I should say.

I've been asked to explain how this revolving fund has really affected the Parks Department. Over the course of the past five years, our department's been cut by just about one-third. I don't think any other department in this town can say that. Yet, we're offering more and more programs, it seems like, every day.

Since its inception, this revolving fund has really been a model for other cities and towns. And in fact, it's been the subject of two separate Boston Globe articles. The Park Department has had a tremendous amount of phone calls on us from communities all over the state. How are you doing this?

You know, what's the success behind it? Just to give you an idea of some of the programs we've implemented. When I was elected in 1981, not one of the parks was open in the summertime. Years ago, when I was a kid, there used to be counselors that would sit and play with the kids and take them on field trips and whatnot.

As a direct result of the revolving fund, We can now charge a small user fee and hire kids to work each of the parks. And I'm proud to say, and I'm sure Brian Joyce and Dan Malloy are proud to say, that every single park is now open now because as a direct result of this revolving fund. Other things we've done. We run all of our summer camps, which generate about $40,000.

And when I say generate $40,000, I mean $40,000 goes through this revolving fund. What we're doing is we're not asking for an initial appropriation from the town. We're really going to our users, the users of our programs, and saying, give us a small fee. We'll turn around and calculate how much we need to actually run this program.

The other thing we've done is we've sponsored all of our band concerts. through private donations and run through the revolving fund. Brian Joyce has done a tremendous job at that. And I think you've probably read about our ID program.

We've got 900 kids in the 6th, 7th, and 8th grade who came out of the woodworks when we decided to implement this ID program. Issue a photo ID card, charge them a $5 fee, Take him on field trips, open up the NBC rink, have volleyball, play ping pong, give him something to do, a place to go for a modest fee. This is done as a direct result of this revolving fund. I know one criticism has been that it's really unfair to charge a user's fee.

It's really a tax. Well, I think the three commissioners are very sensitive to that fact, and we've been very adamant that if a parent feels that he or she cannot afford to send their child to a park department program, let us know. Because all three of us have said consistently that no one will be excluded if they can't afford it. No one.

Now, this is a success story. We've heard today the gloomy financial times and everything else. This is a success story, one that all three of the park commissioners are very proud of, one that everybody in this room should be proud of because people in this room voted for it. As a result of that, the children have had a tremendous amount of programs to participate in.

And our recreation department is really becoming a model for other cities and towns. I hope that you vote again to approve it.

Speaker 2 (04:44:52–04:46:15)

So further discussion. All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee under Article 36, say aye. Aye. Those opposed.

Recommendation of the Warrant Committee is adopted unanimously under Article 36. Article 37, to see if the town will vote pursuant to Chapter 44, Section 53E and 1 half of the Massachusetts General Laws to establish a revolving fund to utilize fees received from the use of town parks and recreational facilities for the purpose of maintenance and repair of town parks and recreational facilities to authorize the park commissioners to expend money from such revolving fund, to determine a limit on the total amount which may be expended from such revolving fund in the fiscal year beginning July 1, 1994, and to act on anything relating thereto. The recommendation of the Warrant Committee is that the town vote to establish a revolving fund pursuant to Mass General Law Chapter 44, Section 53E and 1 half to authorize the Board of Park Commissioners to use the fees received from the rental of Park Department facilities for the maintenance and repair of Park Department facilities and to limit expenditures in the fiscal year beginning July 1, 1994 to $5,000. Is there any discussion?

All those in favor of the recommendation of the Warrant Committee, say aye. Aye. Those opposed? Recommendation of the Warrant Committee is unanimously adopted under Article 37.

Cathy Dunphy is recognized.

Speaker 9 (04:46:18–04:46:24)

Mr. Moderator I move that we adjourn the town meeting until Monday evening at 7 30 p.m.

Speaker 2 (04:46:25–04:46:40)

Is there a second? All those in favor of adjourning these meetings at 7 30 Monday here say aye Those opposed the ayes have it. This meeting is now adjourned till Monday at 7 30. Thank you all very much