Board: Planning Board
Date: 2026-05-28
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:21–00:36)
Good evening, and welcome to the 21st meeting for the Milton Planning Board of fiscal year 2026. At this time, I would like to now call the meeting to order and begin by introducing the members of the board and our staff. If you'd like to begin.
Speaker 2 (00:37–00:38)
Hal Munger, member.
Speaker 1 (00:39–00:55)
Cheryl Tagaia, secretary. And Meredith Hall, serving as chair. This evening, unfortunately, Sean is out of the country. Maggie is not feeling well, so she will not be here this evening.
But we do have with us our staff. Avanti?
Speaker 3 (00:56–00:58)
Yeah, Avanti Grady, Assistant Planning Director.
Speaker 1 (00:59–01:43)
Liz Manning, Planning Director. Great, thank you. Now moving on to, we'll begin by our first administrative items. We have two sets of meeting minutes that we had deferred from our previous meeting, but unfortunately, You were here in March, which were March 12th and the 26th.
And we don't have a quorum here to vote on those. So I'm going to defer those meeting minutes from March, or have a motion to defer the minutes. If you wish to agree the 12th and the 26th, that we move the voting of those to our next meeting. Do you want to make the motion?
Speaker 2 (01:43–01:45)
Second. Can I second it? Yes. OK, second.
All in favor. Aye.
Speaker 1 (01:47–02:08)
Great. And then the future meeting dates, we have currently scheduled our regularly scheduled meeting for June 11th and June 23rd would be the next meeting dates. And we can now go to staff update. Avanti and Liz?
Speaker 3 (02:08–03:31)
Yeah. I can start. Yeah, I'll just provide a brief update on the open space plan. We had our pop-up event on May 16th.
which was successful. We had 35 participants for that. So yeah, that was great. That was a collaboration with MAPC in terms of language access.
So we had poster boards translated into Haitian Creole, Chinese, and Spanish. So it was great to get that perspective from that part of town. They provide various interesting pieces of feedback. such as like several clients feeling that the Northwest section lacks adequate outdoor recreational facilities.
Some felt that there wasn't much programming for teenagers in Milton in general. Some expressed that they had to get into their car to get to the closest open space and rec facility. Some expressed having more materials translated on the town's website and also having multigenerational activities to do at sites. So several participants shared those thoughts.
So yeah, it was just nice to hear back from the community and to have that just be something that we can integrate into this plan moving forward.
Speaker 2 (03:33–03:36)
Will you share that with the board that documents you're reading from?
Speaker 3 (03:36–03:43)
Yeah, yep. And yeah, looking to get this posted on the project website too, but I will share it with the board.
Speaker 1 (03:43–08:20)
That's great. Yeah, thanks, Avanti. I mean, a lot, a lot of hard work went into getting those materials translated on such a, such a, you know, an expedited basis and a lot of follow up and so excellent work. And I was really impressed when I saw the amount of feedback that they, that Craig was able to receive in such a short period of time.
So it was a very worthwhile event. Okay, so I've got four items here, shared supporting housing office, currently working with the folks at Accenture, following up on the 936 Brush Hill Road project, 703 Randolph Ave and 440 Grandin Ave. Those would be sort of like the three projects that are closest to occupancy. So, perfectly, you know, perfectly honest, still kind of working through exactly what the types of supportive activities they're gonna be providing for us moving forward.
I put together a pretty detailed spreadsheet last week for them, kind of like with my expectations of how they were gonna support the town in monitoring these projects and following up and what have you. Haven't connected yet with our consultant there. But happy to share that with you folks if you want, if you want to sort of see what I'm thinking in terms of support. Not 100% certain what our budget is for that.
So my support needs might exceed what people are thinking in terms of budget. But we'll figure that piece out as we move forward. But there's just so many projects in play. And they're all in different stages of development.
And they're all different types of models. And so there's just a lot there. So housing production plan, I think, I know Cheryl's been in the loop on this one because we're going to have a kickoff meeting next week, June 3rd. That advisory committee has been, is in place.
It consists of Winston Daly and Megan Nolan on the select board and two members of the Affordable Housing Trust. I'm going to get their names wrong. I should have written them down. Lauren Lizio and Eric Hopkinson.
Thank you. Thank you, Cheryl. And obviously, Cheryl and Sean. So that meeting will take place next Wednesday.
And then we will be discussing scope and budget, scope and schedule, and introductory types of topics next Wednesday. So Sean will not be back. I don't know. Yes.
I didn't, yeah, I knew that. I felt like it was… She's on a pretty tight schedule. I was really balancing.
I know, we want to get this done, so yeah. Right, you know, so that was a balancing act with that one. Well, Cheryl can fill in. Yeah, yeah, fill Sean in.
Yeah, I think so. And this initial meeting is sort of laying the groundwork for what the process is going to look like. And so I think we can get him caught up without too much trouble. Third item is the letter that you have in your folder, which is on the agenda as well.
for the library parking form that was held back in March and the board's comments on that. And I also printed out a copy when we come to that agenda item. Maggie had submitted something today asking for additional language in that letter. So I think we're going to defer that just for anyone watching.
Oh, okay. Because we don't have Maggie sick today. Okay. Sean's not here and Cheryl, you know, is on that task force.
So she was going to recuse herself. So I think it's better just to defer it. Got it. OK.
Sounds good. And so my final item was just a sort of an update for everybody that Carolyn Murray from KP Law will be at our next meeting June 11 to discuss the recodification process and potential zoning articles for fall town meeting. And I don't have an exact date, but my understanding is the end of June is the target for submitting articles.
Speaker 4 (08:22–08:22)
End of June.
Speaker 1 (08:23–08:29)
End of July. I thought it was July 7.
Speaker 5 (08:29–08:30)
All right.
Speaker 1 (08:30–10:33)
Well, I will circle back on that. I will circle back on that. Week of July 7. OK.
All right. Maybe I was building in an extra week for myself. Yeah, probably. So just to kind of frame that, because obviously we'll need to be conducting audit hearings and et cetera.
So just having that date in mind, just for everyone's sake. And I know you'll probably talk to Carol in advance, but it might be nice if she has an idea of the articles that we're looking to get in. Obviously, the MBTA, just getting up that language would be very straightforward, but maybe looking at, I know how you've offered to look at what some of the other towns are doing for short-term rentals, Airbnb's, and maybe she has some that she could come or send us an advance meeting that we could review. I know different towns are going through different experiences with Airbnbs in short term.
Middletown, Middleton, Rhode Island, somebody just told me, just repealed their Airbnb law. And anyone who has them is grandfathered, but they have been having issues, so they've now repealed. So it's Rhode Island, it's not Massachusetts, but it's an example of some towns You know, it didn't get implemented the proper way and they didn't have regulations. So, Carolyn may have been hearing about those, you know, some communities in the area that she could maybe provide some things to you.
Yeah, my goal was to have, I know there was a lot of discussion at the last meeting about different zoning topics. So my goal was to have that sort of rolled up to Carolyn. Yeah.
Speaker 6 (10:34–10:48)
And sharing with her as well the research that she did on the various towns, which we uploaded already to the folder for our next meeting. So that's there if anybody wants to take a look at it, it's available.
Speaker 1 (10:49–10:58)
But yeah, that was the intent. The intent was sort of like a combination of the recodification process itself. I received that contract today so that,
Speaker 6 (10:58–11:09)
funding is encumbered, so we're, you know, we've zeroed out our planning studies budget for fiscal 26, so that money's encumbered.
Speaker 1 (11:10–14:09)
And so, yeah, so the intent was to have sort of like half was that piece, and reviewing that piece with everybody, and sort of what's in that contract, how it's going to work, and then the other piece was to talk about what can happen, like what makes sense for all. Can you also ask her to look at the pre-existing non-conforming businesses? Some have, exist under variance and some exist under special permit through the Zoning Board of Appeal. And my understanding is anytime they want to change some aspect of their operation, they have to go back.
to that body, so they all go to the ZBA now. They come to the planning board if site plan review is triggered, but otherwise they don't come to us. And a lot of businesses fall into that category. So I know I had asked you for a list which you provided and Ellen Bishop is working on mapping for those.
But just to understand, first of all, how the process works now, So, if we're going to try and make it better, we need to see where the problems are, right? But we saw it firsthand with Milton Marketplace and the restaurant, because there was a lot of confusion about their permits. And then we also experienced it firsthand with 440 Granite Ave, when they had to go to the ZBA and they had to come to us. and then which do they go to first.
DBA wants to hear from planning board, planning board wants to know what the variances are going to get granted. And so how can we make that process better? So we need to really understand the process well. And since it doesn't come to us, maybe Michael White also should be consulted because the applications first go to him, I believe, and then he decides where they go.
Now doesn't the new site plan, doesn't the new site plan bylaw say if you need to go to the zoning board you don't have to come to the planning board for the site plan? No. The issue is the businesses always have to go to the ZBA. That's a discretionary process.
None of those are as a right for the businesses. And it makes it more risky for a business. So I think what we're trying to make, we talked about trying to make it a little bit more business user-friendly, the town approvals more user-friendly, I think. First, we need to start with sort of almost like an audit of how things work now, where the problems are, how to fix it.
Yes. Because they're tricky because they're also most often, you know, in residential.
Speaker 7 (14:10–14:12)
Yeah, they are. Because residential is everywhere.
Speaker 1 (14:12–14:26)
It's everywhere. So it's, yeah, so it's tricky on how you do that. And we saw that with 10 Bassett Street, too. Neighbors do want to be involved in that process.
So how do you find that balance?
Speaker 2 (14:29–14:39)
I had a couple questions before we move on to public comment. The next meeting, the 23rd, the normal date would be the 25th. Is that the 23rd where we're going to meet with the select board?
Speaker 1 (14:39–15:07)
Oh, I'm sorry. It's the 23rd and the 25th. We're meeting that week. Apologies.
I had that. Oh, that's right. That needs to be posted. Yes, we're going to post that.
So that's the meeting where we're going to attend and join the select board on the 23rd. I think because of the tight timeline, I don't want to cancel our meeting on the 24th. So I apologize if we're meeting twice that week. But I think it'll be a brief meeting with the sub-board, you know, our time with the sub-board, and then we'll have our regular schedule on the 25th.
Speaker 2 (15:07–15:27)
So thank you. Thank you. And then the shared supportive housing office, from my own perspective, knowledge and maybe the people that are joining it haven't been part of it before. Is that where the process where the Milton is sharing resources with other towns in the area to work?
Can you explain that a little bit more?
Speaker 1 (15:28–16:11)
Absolutely. So my understanding is this sort of was birthed out of like the TRIC group with MAPC's TRIC sub-region. And I think there are 86 communities still participating in this sort of combined contract with Accenture. Accenture is actually the new firm, the original firm was the Anser advisory, which I think was a smaller firm, more local smaller firm, but they were acquired by Accenture in the last year.
So, exactly, to help smaller communities expand their bandwidth in terms of monitoring affordable housing,
Speaker 6 (16:11–16:17)
you know, staying abreast of, you know, the requirements and regulations with comprehensive permits.
Speaker 1 (16:18–16:35)
Something that just went out recently are the annual recertifications for the home ownership units, right? So just those types of tasks. And they're helping us right now, you know, as a specific example, helping us work with the folks at 440 Grand Ave to get their, you know,
Speaker 6 (16:35–16:44)
the documentation together for their state approvals for their affordable units to ensure that they will be accounted on the subsidized housing inventory.
Speaker 1 (16:45–16:59)
I know enough to figure some of that stuff out and probably do an okay job at it, but it's time-consuming and it's really an area of expertise so I'm like super grateful to have them available.
Speaker 2 (16:59–17:07)
Great. So it frees you up to do other things that you that they have more knowledge of to be able to do. Exactly. Yeah.
Great. Yeah. So.
Speaker 7 (17:07–17:08)
Okay. Yeah.
Speaker 2 (17:09–17:16)
Thank you. And then one last thing we touched on the housing production plan and the committee meeting with that. Any update on the master plan committee?
Speaker 1 (17:18–17:34)
So I think we're waiting. I know that there was an email I was cc'd on to Liz to see if she's made her appointments. I mean, I don't know if she's done that yet. Did she respond to you?
She hasn't responded to me. We have to wait for Liz. I can't read my card.
Speaker 6 (17:34–17:34)
We don't.
Speaker 1 (17:34–17:50)
And at some point, I think we just should. I just thought we might want to round out with, you know, see who's been selected, you know, who's available. I haven't seen any of the applications yet, so I don't know who's on. Do you have those?
Have you received those applications?
Speaker 7 (17:50–17:51)
I have.
Speaker 1 (17:51–18:50)
I have. Yeah. Lynn's been copying. Lynn from the Select Board's office has been copying me on applications as they come in.
And so, yeah. I mean, I think the last time I checked, I want to say there might have been six or seven applicants still available after the Select Board had made their picks. Yeah. I think we can certainly go ahead.
I mean, I think there's a lot of things that we can do, but I don't think there's a lot Hopefully they've filled out their applications with the qualifications so we can not have everyone be an architect or everyone be a real estate person. Not everyone, a real estate, I should say a realtor or whatever it is. Or a realtor. Yeah, it could be whatever, lawyers.
Speaker 3 (18:51–18:57)
But there's certain things that you hope that will be balanced out.
Speaker 1 (18:58–20:57)
Yeah, so I think we can definitely, Sean will be back on the 28th. But there's a meeting on the 25th, so we can tentatively plan on that meeting. But it sounds like there's plenty of people, so. So that's good.
And anything else? Or anything else to do? No, thank you. So I did have one other thing.
We talked about a few different things, short-term, long-term, as setting priorities for the new year. I would like to come back to that. We talked about some of the shorter term things, but I do think we shouldn't let too much time pass without thinking about the spring because it'll be upon us before we know it too. So can we get that back on the agenda as well?
Yeah. And actually, Liz, I think, had a conversation with Nick on having some sort of matrix so that we can have it just sort of, you know, what these are, you know, short-term, long-term, sort of have a ranking of what we've discussed, and sort of have things that we can check off. You know, once we've accomplished those, you know, what's moving down on the list of priorities and long-term. I just thought it would be helpful for the meeting on the 23rd with the select board.
Yes. It might, it just may be helpful for you folks in general, but, and then, you know, areas of, you know, areas of convergence. Because I think I saw, I think he's got something like that and we chatted about it. And his recommendation was, you know, it's really nice too, because sometimes you can just sort of check things off and sort of get a sense of, okay, you know, doing 10 things and now four of them are done.
And yeah, three more things got added, but you know, progress is being made. I think it's helpful to have that tangible. Exactly. Tangible.
So, so I will work, I will work on that. That's kind of like, it's a lot of these things are sort of interconnected because
Speaker 8 (20:58–21:08)
Like, you know, clearly a lot of these conversations are going to be happening with the Housing Professional Board, right? And we're going to be having conversations with KPIs.
Speaker 1 (21:08–23:28)
So I think that's actually important, too, if we note in that matrix where there's already work being done. I can think of some things, I think maybe economic development, and then we're going to talk about scope of work, because previously it did not include decreases in nonconforming, which I think is an issue. But, you know, certainly the open space plan, the housing production plan. I also think if you could put the summary together of where we've already committed our dollars or financial resources and what we have left so that that'll factor into what we can realistically accomplish.
Especially if we want to go deep with the repopulation, you know, depending on how deep we're going to go with that. Well and whether there's any other source of funds to assist with that because it's, you know, it'll help the building department, for example. It'll help the planning department. So can some funds come from other sources besides planning board funds, which is really for studies and for zoning initiatives, but it's a pretty big portion of the budget, our budget, so.
I think that'll be helpful. Because I think a lot of the subcourt members are new, new members, the new ones. So I think it will be a great meeting just to, I know Lisa said, I get asked all the time, like, what is the plan we're working on? And so this way they can have a reference.
Okay, this is a focus right now. This is what our staff is working on right now. And so I think it would be a great conversation. All right.
So, just, all right. So step up, that's everything, Liz? You're all good? Okay, great.
So now we can move to item number three, which is our public comment. If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to speak or online, you can raise your hand and we'll be happy to have you join us. Yes. Yes, welcome.
Yes, you can come right up. We're fully mic'd in this room, so you don't need to.
Speaker 8 (23:28–29:10)
I know, you don't have to hold up a microphone. It's nice. Hi, my name is Jessica McDaniel, and I'm here tonight on behalf of Connect Milton. I'm one of the eight members of the steering committee here in town, and some of my fellow committee members are here in the audience as well.
We're here because at the April 23rd meeting of this board, incorrect statements were made about us, specifically the nature of our activities and our funding sources. Unfortunately, some of that misinformation has since filtered into the community. So we wanted to introduce ourselves to clear up any confusion for members of the board, for town staff, and for our residents. So before I address the specific points of clarification, I'd like to tell you a little bit about our organization and what we do.
We founded Connect Milton in 2023 to help connect community members to each other, to local resources and to civic opportunities, and in turn, build a more inclusive and engaged community. While the members of our committee come from different backgrounds, some of us grew up here. I'm Glover, class of 85, while others moved here as adults. We have shared experiences.
of not knowing how something works or wanting to become more engaged in the community and not knowing where to start. So some examples of how we are working toward that goal. We host a robust set of FAQs on our website, addressing a wide range of topics that residents frequently ask. Everything from what precinct am I in and where do I vote to whether Milton allows chickens and sports signups information and information on early education opportunities in the public schools.
We crowdsource these questions and answers from connecting with Milton residents at community events. We also post voting and election information on our website. For the last two town elections, we created a comprehensive listing of all townwide candidates web pages, as well as an overview of how town government works and what these positions do. We send out a regular newsletter highlighting local community events, upcoming elections, and our own events, such as Community Cornhole, an event we started this past February to get neighbors out of their houses and engage with others, even in the dead of winter.
We've organized three informational events around civic engagement, including Town Government 101, Town Finance 101, and Town Committee 101. These sessions are open to everyone and involve town staff as well as elected officials. They've been recorded by Milton Access TV and videos are available on our website. And finally, for the past few years, we've been delivering welcome bags to new residents of Milton.
These welcome bags, which I forgot to pronounce, contain information about the town and small promotional items or coupons and gift cards from local business sponsors. We invite current Milton residents to help us deliver the bags to new residents and invite new residents to a new-to-Milton social to help foster some initial connections in their new home. To date, we've welcomed 616 new households to Milton, and we hope that that will be just a start in ensuring residents feel better connected and invited to engage in their community. Regarding our funding forces, We are all volunteers, but our activities incur costs.
Because establishing oneself as an independent nonprofit is not only complicated, but costly, we chose to find a fiscal sponsor. A fiscal sponsor is an established 501c3 nonprofit organization that extends its legal and tax-exempt status to smaller, unincorporated projects and provides administrative and financial management support. It's a common mechanism for small grassroots efforts like ours to manage donations. Social Good, a nonprofit based in California, is our fiscal sponsor.
All of this is explained on our website in detail. To be very clear, Social Good does not fund us. In fact, they charge us a percentage of our revenue for the administrative and financial support that they provide. We are funded entirely by donations and the sponsorship fees that local businesses pay to include their items in our welcome packs.
And regarding the statement that Connect Milton has a political focus, all of our activities, information, and events, including those focused on civic engagement, are freely open to anyone who lives in Milton. We do not endorse political candidates. nor do we screen or poll residents for their political affiliation or political beliefs. As an organization that promotes civic engagement, it shouldn't be surprising that many of us are also members of either elected or appointed bodies in town, because we already recognize the importance of civic engagement and can speak to that experience.
As an organization, however, we are nonpartisan. and we are confident that our activities, events, and the information we share with the community support that claim. Thank you for your time and for the opportunities. We hope this clears up any misconceptions about our organization, and we hope that we can find opportunities to work together in the future.
Thank you.
Speaker 1 (29:10–29:36)
We appreciate your coming. that Shawn and Megan get to have. There's three items that go into our wall of bets. Absolutely.
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for your work. We signed up for your newsletter.
Oh, good.
Speaker 3 (29:36–29:37)
So good. During our talk?
Speaker 1 (29:38–29:50)
I'm really quiet. I did the cost benefit. It ran out of my head. Yeah.
Thank you. Anyone else here for CitizenSafe or online?
Speaker 6 (29:51–34:54)
Good evening. Good evening. Deborah Felton is your team meeting member. I'm here because I listened to the last meeting where you spoke about Airbnb's.
And I was encouraged that you are hopeful that we won't put together any regulation for Airbnb, that we will not, knowing that the town won't take the stand, we'll just warn them to go away, because they're not going to go away. I think, and you know, it's just an estimate, kind of putting in different addresses and looking around, not only Airbnb, but also the RVO, vacation rental plan owners, that we probably have about At least 30 Airbnbs. But the town really doesn't know that. There are a lot of towns now that are regulating Airbnbs.
Belmont, Lexington, Somerville, Salem, Gloucester, Great Barrington, of course the Cape of the Islands, Boston, Cambridge, Brookline, Greenfield. And they all address it differently. But there are, so there are choices that the police would make. I think this is important for the town to adopt our own rules, licensing, zoning, occupancy permits, occupancy caps, and safety.
And a lot of towns use the building department, the fire department, and the health department for inspections. And of course, we can charge a local your local tax. So there is, I'm sure, a small amount of revenue. But more importantly, it's really to protect the neighborhoods.
And so what's happening is that this housing is going to short-term rentals when it could be housing for people who want to live in Milton. And there are definitely safety concerns. In my neighborhood, there's fire fits. in one of the Airbnbs.
I thought my house was burning down. I'm not sure what they were burning that night, but it really… It was off-putting, to say the least. So I would really encourage anyone to look at this.
Also, I was in contact and have permission to use John Cohane's name. He's a precinct town meeting member, Precinct 7. He lives on Antwerp. And I know in their neighborhood, they're very concerned about any Airbnb that seems to be a party house.
There's no regulation. So that's a little research that I've done. If the planners want, I can send you what I have. And just on Rhode Island, on Middleton, The reason they have rescinded their law is because there are so many Airbnbs that they don't want anymore.
So if one pops up, then it hasn't been grandfathered in and it will be shut down. Wow. You've heard about that too. Huh?
I said you've heard about that. Yes, I did. So, you know, many cities and towns are regulating them and I'm sure there will be more now that it's so popular. So thank you very much.
And just since I did watch your entire May 14th meeting, I really encourage you to try to work with the developer on the food mark. I know you had mentioned that at the last meeting. that there was a developer who was looking and then went away and we haven't heard from them. But we've been putting up with that neighborhood.
That's been in disrepair like that for way, way too long. I hope we can be a little proactive in that. And as to the condo conversion, I think we really do need to lower the acreage requirement so that because who knows what's going to come up for sale. And it certainly, along Route 138, that big mansion could have been condos if there wasn't that increase.
And there are certainly other lovely homes in town that may sell at some point. And I'd rather see a condo conversion than any other house. So thank you for your work.
Speaker 7 (34:56–34:56)
Thanks.
Speaker 1 (34:58–34:59)
OK, anyone else?
Speaker 5 (35:00–35:01)
Anyone online?
Speaker 1 (35:01–35:28)
Are we seeing? I'm not seeing any. Let me just double check. I didn't see any the last time I looked.
No hands. Two attendees with no hands. OK, so thank you all for coming to me and speaking. We can now move to our site plan review for an ADU located at 1210A Randolph Avenue.
Welcome.
Speaker 4 (35:31–36:49)
Good evening, Madam Chair and members of the board. My name is Jim Chen. I'm the architect at JCPT Architect located in Quincy. So tonight we're seeking approval for site plan review for this project at 1210 Randolph Ave.
1210 Randolph Ave is a conforming lot, which is in residential B zoning district. There's 20,000 square feet in conformance. And the current structure there is a single family, meets all the zoning setbacks. And the owner here tonight, non-chat, we want to propose a detached ADU, a single story detached ADU at the back of the lot.
So the primary structure in the front, single family, will remain untouched. The original structure is about 2,900 square feet itself. The reason for this proposal is to have their grandparents live separately, independently, as a family.
Speaker 9 (36:50–37:40)
So originally I started the project last year. Both my grandparents were doing well. My grandfather actually passed away a couple of weeks ago. Now it's even more important because my grandma is alone.
So we're taking turns. And originally it was supposed to be like a happy thing. Bring them here. As they get older, we can take shifts.
So it made a lot of sense. My parents aged too. And it just made a lot of sense. People can sleep, right?
So then we can take turns. And it doesn't get in the way. So, you know, that's basically the kind of motivation that I felt. My HELOC's approved, so I'm ready to go wherever I need to go.
Speaker 1 (37:40–37:41)
That's good.
Speaker 4 (37:41–38:35)
That's great. Since we're talking about the site plan, let me know if you want a different, if you want a different, just let me know. So some of the improvement that we're going to make on the, on the site is that in the front, there's currently a three-car parking. It's only one foot set back by a neighbor.
So we're gonna push it back in compliance at minimum three feet. And then we're gonna post a five feet walkway to the back of the house where that sort of general patio currently sits and connect that from that patio connected to the new ED. The ADU is 896 square feet. I think it might be a typo in the memo.
I said it's 876.
Speaker 1 (38:36–38:41)
Yeah, I was coming up with a different measurement, but either way, it's within the requirements.
Speaker 4 (38:41–40:25)
Yeah, it's still within the requirement. And we meet all the setback requirements for the new ADU. Currently, it's 10 feet. Easement, drainage easement, I think it's certainly the back of it, the property in the back.
But we're not touching any of that. They sent it back 18.4 feet away from that property line. And then another 31 feet from the back. So we're well within the zoning setbacks.
And then with the proposed walkway, we planned some privacy planting, we probably added some LED's along the path, added some lightings to improve the site. And in terms of utilities, we're not connecting directly onto Randolph app, so we're not doing any kind of street opening. We're connecting back into the existing structure. The engineering department did review that incoming water and the sewer need to be tempted by the co-compliance.
So we will do that. And all the utilities such as water, sewer, and electrical are coming underground into the ADU. So a little bit about the ADU. ADU is in line with the existing structure.
The original structure is a raised ranch. So this is a single story ranch. I think the architectural language is very in line with it.
Speaker 1 (40:25–40:29)
Would you like me to pull up the elevations? Yes, please. Does that give you?
Speaker 7 (40:34–40:34)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (40:37–40:38)
That's the house, right?
Speaker 4 (40:38–40:41)
This is the original, the primary house.
Speaker 1 (40:41–40:42)
Yeah.
Speaker 4 (40:43–41:05)
And that's the four elevations of the ADU. Slightly raised up. It doesn't have a basement. It has a crawl space and additional storage at the attic space.
I'm open up for any questions.
Speaker 1 (41:07–41:22)
Cheryl or Hal, do you want to go first? Can we have Liz run through her memo? Because I think this is our first one under our new bylaw. I think the process that we established would be nice if people can see it.
Speaker 5 (41:22–41:23)
That was great.
Speaker 1 (41:23–44:34)
I just want to thank Liz for doing that. So thank you. I think it's for the presentation and for your package. And then Liz, if you could run through your review.
Absolutely. Thank you. Okay, so I included this memo, I believe you folks were copied on it as well, from the board, a three-page memo, and gave a list, a detailed list of all the plans that we're considering here this evening, so all of the dates and the last revised dates and what have you. So we reviewed this under the zoning for accessory dwelling units, and the application was received on April 28th, There's a requirement to have you folks in front of the board know less than 30 days.
Today was day 30. So we were doing our best on that one. I wanted to go back and see what day you guys actually It was probably early April or early in March. So we're going to strive to be faster.
But once we get this process down, I think that can happen. So a little bit of the delay was sort of in terms of the plans and the level of, you know, engineering required on these plans, you know, some of the requirements for grading and drainage and et cetera. So I had a conversation with the building commissioner about that. He was confident that he had the information he needed to make the zoning determinations about the ADU and that, that the detail that was provided was sufficient.
So I, so, you know, that's how we, that's how we're proceeding. And so, you know, and that's just a, just a note here that our, our site plan approval is, is limited and that the building commissioner, you know, issues the alternate firm. So, so that's, so that's that first, that first section of the memo. So, and the background is stuff we've already discussed, you know, in terms of the, the it's in the residence B zone, Discussion about the drainage easement is important.
The town engineer's memo dated May 19th outlines the limitations of the drainage easement in terms of what can happen in the easement, you know, specifically no tree plantings. This description of the ADU itself, as was already mentioned, the crawl space, the unfinished attic space for storage, the ingress and egress, Um, so I think, um, you know, I guess, I guess if I had to sort of summarize, I probably would just like a little bit more information. I guess I had three things, you know, that, that I kind of wanted a little bit more information on. One was, um, the, the getting in and out of that parking area, it looks like it's going to be really tight to sort of like make that swing to be able to kind of drive straight out onto Randolph Ave.
I just drive by my class.
Speaker 9 (44:35–44:52)
In the morning, you're just more about sleeping in, but one minute later, it's easier to come out. I just go on the grass. But most of the time, I come home first. I rotate my car ahead, so it's already aimed to exit.
Speaker 7 (44:52–44:54)
So you're backing in.
Speaker 9 (44:54–45:04)
It's your own house, so you come out the door, and you just live with it. Usually, my idea gets vetoed. I don't have much say.
Speaker 1 (45:06–45:17)
So that, especially with the addition of the third space, that just might be something to consider, that you might need a little bit more elbow room in that driveway area.
Speaker 4 (45:18–45:21)
I think they're currently parking three spaces there.
Speaker 9 (45:21–45:26)
Yeah, we can actually park four. But four, you have to be organized. But three, you don't have to really.
Speaker 1 (45:27–45:46)
It works. Yeah, OK, good. That was, OK, good. Good stuff.
And then in terms of any sort of like excavation, have you, do you have any sense on that, you know, as you're, as you're excavating for the foundation, do you have any sense on sort of, you know, kind of the quantity or the process or?
Speaker 4 (45:46–45:53)
Yeah. So we, we, contact dates say, and there's no utility beyond that. We're excavating.
Speaker 3 (45:54–45:54)
Okay.
Speaker 4 (45:56–46:00)
There might be minor ledge. Okay. Where we dig in.
Speaker 1 (46:00–46:01)
Okay.
Speaker 4 (46:02–46:04)
we would only find out when we start digging.
Speaker 1 (46:04–46:06)
When you get going, and that would probably be drilled.
Speaker 4 (46:07–46:16)
Yes, but I mean, if the ledge is big enough, we could just support onto the ledge, drill into it, and put the foundation on top.
Speaker 1 (46:16–46:18)
Okay, okay.
Speaker 4 (46:18–46:19)
So we won't need any plastic.
Speaker 1 (46:20–46:53)
Okay, okay. So, all right, so that was a question on that. We discussed the lighting, so just want to make sure that it's not spilling onto neighbor's properties, that it's down lit, that it meets the dark sky standards. And also, too, the best practice for erosion control because of that drainage easement.
So I'd ideally like to see the catch basin and the manholes for the drain.
Speaker 4 (47:02–47:08)
we're going to have to surround it entirely. That area. OK.
Speaker 1 (47:08–47:44)
Erosion control. Perfect. Perfect. So that's pretty much it for me.
That wasn't already covered in the applicant's presentation. So Liz, did you speak to Michael about those three, Michael White, building commissioner, about those three comments? Because I'm wondering how those get. incorporated, is that something, since he grants the permit, does he make that a condition of the permit that those be addressed?
Speaker 3 (47:44–47:45)
Required?
Speaker 1 (47:46–48:38)
My sense is that this will be a decision that you folks will endorse maybe at your next meeting. I'm suggesting that it gets recorded, I don't know that there's really a better way to ensure that this requirement that it's one ADU per property can be enforced if these decisions are not reported. We can definitely, I'm putting that out there for the boards to think about. And if you want me to kind of get some additional That would be a typical requirement on a site plan approval would be to record the decision.
This is sort of a what? Mini-site plan approval.
Speaker 5 (48:38–48:40)
Yeah. So it's a little bit of different.
Speaker 1 (48:40–48:41)
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (48:41–48:43)
Is that where you guys sign? Yeah. OK.
Speaker 1 (48:44–50:18)
Well, getting recorded means it's in the registry. OK. OK. So if somebody wanted to look up down the road, they don't have to look in the building officials database on a property to see if it had an ADU, it would be an official record that's recorded.
So are you suggesting, then, that the items that you noted you would like to have addressed between now and our next meeting, so that those are incorporated into site plan approval? I don't. If the board would like to see a different layout for the parking area, then that might be something that needs to be addressed. I actually, for the fact that he's not expanding in private service, I appreciate that.
And if he can make it work, which it sounds like he's doing right now easily, that was one of my questions is that I was hoping Because a lot of times, sometimes, you know, people do have extra, you know, apartment or space and they end up paving over their whole front yards, you know, and that's, it's much better for you to have trees and grass, you know, and more of a buffer too. Yeah. So I, I wouldn't see that, but you know, and it does sound like you're, that you would be doing some protection for the,
Speaker 4 (50:19–50:22)
Correct. And then that's one of the requirements by the building department.
Speaker 1 (50:22–52:30)
By the building department. So that's something that I don't think, I guess, we necessarily need to do. But if there's other things that come up. Yeah.
I think that that's, I mean, that would probably be the only item that I've flagged that would result in a change in any type of a change And then again, my recommendation that there be a site plan decision reported against the property. So, yeah, I'll go ahead. You know, this site is obviously perfectly adequate to accommodated ADU without impacts to adjacent properties, which is one of the reasons the bylaw was basically proposed by the planning board and approved is that we were concerned about, you know, situations that might not be as suitable for it and how to best not prohibit people from doing that, proposing them and doing them, but finding a way that doesn't have adverse impacts. So you really don't have I mean, it's set back from the property lines, 31 feet from the rear, 35 and a half from one side and almost 18 and a half from the other side.
I mean, those are very generous setbacks, generally speaking, and that it's positioned to you know, face the yard. So it's kind of like a shared yard, but then it does have some private open space, I think is it the benefit that it has, you know, the walkway from the parking and the walkway from the existing patio, you know, it's for the purpose that you're, you're speaking of, you know, that intergenerational outdoor relationship is there too. So I think, Liz, thank you for your thorough review. And in my review of this, I think I don't have concerns with anything that's proposed.
Speaker 2 (52:31–53:10)
Yeah, I got that the review, the memo that you put together was great. And then also the director, I mean, the engineering memo was great. And the little table which showed what's allowed and what they're, so that's the plan going forward. That's awesome.
I said two things. One about the easement. I see in the engineering report, there's a comment about not allowing plantings on the easement. I do see, though, in the permit set that you're providing some opportunities to screen.
How do we rectify those two conflicting statements or ideas?
Speaker 1 (53:12–53:23)
Yeah, I think I'd probably turn that to you folks, because I think you received the engineer's memo, and this plan predates that memo. So what do you do?
Speaker 2 (53:24–53:34)
And just to follow up on that, is that a… defined requirements, or is that just a preference from the engineering department?
Speaker 1 (53:35–53:45)
It looks like there's a kind of a warning that if you plant them and they need to come in the future, they can take them out without being able to put them back. Okay. So it's kind of a risk assessment.
Speaker 9 (53:46–54:05)
Our neighbor is Vietnamese and they have similar use cases. So they literally just went around the back. For us, it's not a big deal if it's not screened. If you guys prefer the uprootings, we'll plant them.
I think they're fine.
Speaker 2 (54:05–54:09)
I just wanted to point out that as long as you're comfortable in knowing that it could be ripped out.
Speaker 9 (54:09–54:12)
So those things are up for negotiation.
Speaker 2 (54:12–54:14)
Okay. I like them.
Speaker 9 (54:15–54:16)
I do too. I like them.
Speaker 2 (54:16–54:17)
If you want them, I just wanted to highlight that.
Speaker 9 (54:17–54:23)
It's not going to break my heart or something if someone needs access to figure it out. Sure.
Speaker 2 (54:23–54:23)
Okay.
Speaker 9 (54:23–54:25)
But it'll take like a few years.
Speaker 2 (54:25–54:34)
Yeah. And I think the same thing goes for the pavers, the pathway, right? Just knowing that it could be removed if… Right.
Speaker 9 (54:34–55:17)
Okay. When we bought the house like six years ago, we already know because we're going to ask, what is this? Can you see the plan? And it tells you this is the easement.
And it's cooler there in the summer, so my kid literally lies on top of me. Oh, it's cooler. It's cooler because near the cover, it's like a string. It's got the lattice, right?
Oh, interesting. So you can see the cold air coming through. Oh, interesting. So he likes to lie down.
In the beginning, I was a little nervous, because you're thinking, like, my kid's going to fall in. But after a while, you're like, you know, you step on it, and you're like, OK. So we're aware that easement exists.
Speaker 2 (55:18–55:33)
Gotcha. Okay. And then I just have one more question. I don't know if it's within our purview.
I don't think it has any bearing on my opinion of this, but have you guys considered or are you providing separate meters for the service going there?
Speaker 9 (55:33–55:37)
We prefer to have separate meters if possible.
Speaker 4 (55:37–55:53)
I'm just asking because- I'm not sure if the DBW would allow a separate meter for a single property. Okay. That's really up to them. Okay.
I think if they allow it, they'll be happy to have a separate meter.
Speaker 2 (55:53–56:00)
I'm just thinking, I believe when you guys were discussing at some point standalone structures That was a discussion point, and I don't remember how it ended up.
Speaker 9 (56:01–56:17)
I'm just thinking for their sake, in the future.
Speaker 4 (56:17–56:33)
I mean, either way, I'm paying the bill, so I guess it makes a difference. Sure. I mean, I think it does make it slightly different if you want a separate meter. It needs to tie onto the street on that.
Yeah. Whereas right now, you just tie it into your original.
Speaker 1 (56:34–56:59)
Whatever you guys think makes sense, because you're experts. Yeah, we weren't allowed to regulate that short in our article. So because we discussed that we want, because we didn't want to encourage people that to put a whole new waterline and a whole new, you know, whatever, gas line, you know, we wanted them to be able to connect. And the state required, the state said that you can't.
Speaker 2 (56:59–57:12)
You can't require it. You can't require it. But they could on their own. They can do it, but they can't require it.
So just something to think about. If this is a situation now, you don't know what the situation will be in the future, just try to think about it.
Speaker 1 (57:12–57:25)
Be smart. So the only question I had is, in the back here, is there no vegetation? Is it just lawn area? It's all lawn.
It's all lawn right now.
Speaker 2 (57:27–57:36)
No, no trees. It looks like the property on the other side has some trees kind of along your back edge. Yeah, there's a pretty tall evergreen.
Speaker 1 (57:36–57:41)
Good, because that would be something that it sounds like you have a great relationship with your neighbors, but you might want to ask.
Speaker 9 (57:41–57:47)
Just the ones to the left and right of me. because the one behind me went over too far with the chat. There's a block by the trees.
Speaker 1 (57:47–57:59)
So I don't know how they feel, like if they would want a tree to sort of block the house. The house is very attractive, but I didn't know if they would like to see some extra plantings around the new structure.
Speaker 4 (57:59–58:05)
And then if you see on Google Maps, there's a lot of planting, actually, on the lower part of the house. I don't think you can see it from the person behind you.
Speaker 1 (58:05–58:57)
There are larger trees. So there is a buffer for them, because that was one of the things that we were And again, you have really nice setbacks. And for your own grandmother's privacy, if she wanted to have some trees, you might want to consider planting something back there. But I think your building is very attractive.
And I think it fits nicely onto the site. I'm just going to pick up on something I see in your memo, Liz, is the radon. Yes. And you said there might be ledge or rock there.
when this file was passed at town meeting that was a request of a town meeting member to include an encouragement of data on testing and incorporation of mitigation if necessary. So I did see that and just want to highlight that for you.
Speaker 4 (58:58–59:15)
Part of it is because, well, the type of construction this is, it's not on a slab. So it's a cross face, which has ventilation, cross ventilation inside. So even if there's radon, it'll be vented outside.
Speaker 1 (59:15–01:00:20)
Yeah. I put the system in my house, but I have little kids, so. Yeah, because we do have a lot of ledging, though, to be fair. But yeah, that's great.
Liz, you thought that we couldn't take care of this tonight? Well, you would definitely vote tonight. But then I will put a decision document together for you and then bring it back for you at your next meeting. Yeah, because I don't think there's anything else that we would need to request and wait for.
I agree. So I would entertain a motion to approve the site plan approval. So I just want to get the address for the accessory dwelling unit at 1210 Randolph Avenue and 1210A Randolph Avenue. I think that's it.
We don't have to make it subject to anything, correct? Liz? No, I didn't. Yep, you guys discussed my comments.
And yep, as long as everyone's comfortable, then I think we're good.
Speaker 2 (01:00:22–01:00:22)
OK. I'll second that.
Speaker 1 (01:00:23–01:00:32)
Second. All in favor? Hi. Congratulations.
Thank you. First one. First one.
Speaker 5 (01:00:32–01:00:33)
It's very well done.
Speaker 1 (01:00:33–01:00:34)
You did a very nice job.
Speaker 4 (01:00:35–01:00:37)
This is the first one. Yeah.
Speaker 1 (01:00:37–01:00:43)
Very first. Yeah. It's great. Thank you very much.
It's a very new bylaw. You're welcome.
Speaker 4 (01:00:43–01:00:44)
Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 (01:00:44–01:00:47)
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Speaker 7 (01:00:47–01:00:49)
Good luck.
Speaker 1 (01:00:51–01:01:26)
That's great. And so the only other item we had on our agenda, we're actually going to defer because we don't have, we're missing, we wouldn't have a quorum tonight to be able to vote. Because Cheryl is going to recuse herself on number five. So.
I'm just going to not recuse, but abstain from the vote. Abstain, yeah. So we can put that on for. Before we adjourn, Meredith, can we get you and Liz, again, Liz said on June 11, Carolyn, what's Carolyn's last name?
Speaker 7 (01:01:26–01:01:26)
Murray.
Speaker 1 (01:01:27–01:07:15)
Murray. I don't know if it's going to be there. But what else will be on that agenda? So, well, obviously, recodification.
And what we're trying to get to for the fall is the timeline for recodification, I should say, the layout. Because she might not even think it's reasonable for fall. I don't know. Oh, the ADU rules and regulations.
So she reviewed a subsequent set. And so that shouldn't be a big deal. We're already handing them out. So they seem like they're working.
So I think hopefully that will be a deal. Little tweaks to that. We'll have to take a vote on those. And then she may be able to comment on short term.
I had asked whether it's OK. possible in Massachusetts to prohibit, because Sean had asked about that last time. And I thought we need to be able to answer that question, because if we're to bring something to me, I think that's definitely something people are going to ask about. And so I wanted to get an answer from town council about that, if possible.
And then, because I think legally, We can prohibit anything that's less than 30 days. And that's what we ran into. I think it's a little bit. Because I've heard that we can't.
So I don't know. I don't know the answer. And I don't either. And I just feel like some people might want to prohibit.
Some people might want to regulate. Right. I think a lot of people probably don't realize that there's 30 plus or minus, and that they are causing some problems for some neighbors, and there's no mechanism for enforcing the issues. So I do think if she could advise us about that, that would be helpful.
Absolutely. And then did we hear, just again, because of the cleanup on the MBTA communities, did we hear back from HLC that they accepted the? I heard, I got a, I got a, we're very busy. I got a, I got a form response.
We're very busy with the towns that still need to be brought into compliance and we're working through things as essentially working through things as fast as we can. So that was sort of a non-answer answer. Um, and so I took that as no. They haven't even reviewed it yet, but I'll dig a little harder than that.
I still haven't connected with Adam Pletz from MAPC, the folks that did the study. They may have a direct line to get it. Yeah, it would be abstract. Absolutely.
Yeah, yeah. I emailed him, he called me. And then I called him back, and we missed him, and missed him, and missed him. So my sense is this is probably something he wants to discuss with me.
You know what I mean? So anyway, I'll connect with him. Because my feeling is, without that, then an applicant could say, you're only allowed to do 10% because you don't have your approval yet on the 15%. And we all really wanted to see the 15%.
Everybody wanted to see it. So I think we should have it. Yeah, and it's an easy, I think it's an easy. Yeah, because it's just removing some of that sort of caveat language that was put in there.
Okay, so that's what you anticipate for June 11th? Yes, so we can get that and get those focused for fall. And then on the June 23rd with the select board, I just wanted to kind of be able to think ahead a little bit on this agenda. That's going to be the scope of the economic development study and maybe where funding's coming from for that.
with the select, but that's the focus of our discussion, or with other items too? I bumped into Winston today just briefly, and we're going to try to connect before, because Nick had suggested just having sort of an agenda of what we want to discuss. And when I spoke to Winston, he was more of, we just want to hear what the planning board's working on, or the things that we could work together on, and how can communication be Because one of the things I was thinking about during the last few months, and right now I know the school building committee is looking at LaBarre for a school. But if that doesn't end up going forward as a school, the property's going to go on the market in the fall.
I just have the property's own single family. It's assessed at over $13 million. Is there going to be somebody who buys it just to build three single families, which is what you can build on there with the current zoning? So I don't know if they've been thinking about it, but it is something to talk to them about perhaps.
So I think I did watch their meeting last week, and they are looking at it either for a school, and they're sort of going in a parallel path looking at the school, or would they want to acquire it? for looking at other purposes to sort of control what will happen on that site.
Speaker 5 (01:07:15–01:07:18)
I think it's preliminary to leave zoning there.
Speaker 1 (01:07:19–01:09:57)
But we should be in communication. I just think we ought to be in communication about it because if we should maybe make a recommendation. I was going to ask if this board would like to discuss. I think we should think about if we could do a quick planning around it.
Other communities, when they have a school closure, like a college or something like that, they do a planning effort that leads to something that can be an RFP. So if the town buys it, and they don't need it for a school, they can write an RFP, and they can do the zoning that coincides with what's in the RFP. If the town wants to keep it, it's a lot of money. You've got to go to town meeting, or you're going to have to get an override.
So there's a lot of things to think about. And we may be a part of what needs to happen in terms of zoning. So I just think it's, when we're talking about collaboration, I'm not suggesting that I have a particular recommendation. But I do think we should be in conversation with the select board.
I agree. And I think we should be definitely proactive on it. Because too many lost opportunities. Yeah.
Yeah. The obvious opportunity, I did watch the school committee meeting when John Galen, and I don't wanna, it's not on our agenda, but was speaking on the leadership team, was very excited about it. And I look at ways, and this is part of our conversation with the select board is, how do we bring our town together on things that have been divided issues? And I think the Lamb's Woods land swap was, for the school, I think there were people who were really torn that really, wanted to keep that conservation land, but they also wanted to support a school.
What could be better than a win-win is if the school could, the overflow could be housed sooner rather than waiting and do it at a far less expense to the town and preserve the open space and I just think that would just really be unifying for us to come around supporting. That's my personal opinion, but they're doing their due diligence and they brought an architect in, whether it will work or not, but I think it could be sort of a flagship, just a really incredible site as a sort of an entryway into the Milton public school system to have pre-K and kindergarten come together from all over town. I think it can be exciting. But that is not our work.
I think that's really a school committee.
Speaker 5 (01:09:57–01:09:59)
It's a school committee issue.
Speaker 1 (01:09:59–01:15:04)
But it is land use. And I think we should be having that conversation. And I know the schools are working hard. And it's being discussed whether we would have control of that.
And yeah. Because I don't know if it's going to happen with the housing production plan, but previously we had to identify sites that could have the potential for housing. And if this, like I said, they're doing their due diligence and it's their decision about recommending this for school, so I'm not making any judgments about whether it's good for school or not. But it might be something that gets suggested in the housing production plan.
as an opportunity place, because there aren't that many places as we know. But this is where having a discussion about these things and- Between boards, yeah. Between boards and early is beneficial. I think on the 11th, maybe we put this as an agenda item to discuss things that we would like to share.
I mean, obviously, it was great that we had our last meeting. And we were able to go through our goals, prioritize so we could talk about the things that we're working on. I think Liz has said she would be able to come on the 23rd because I think it's also, I don't think residents realize how much our staff is doing in the building department and overseeing what is in the pipeline currently and all the 40E projects that have to be monitored. We have the memory care project, which is going to be happening coming on soon.
I think it's sort of a time right now where we can sort of stay on top of the projects that we already have approved and that are in the works. But it's also a time that the planning board can really do some housekeeping things that we've needed to clean up. I mean, our recodification, how long has that been? If we can tackle those things, while simultaneously the staff is able to work on the oversight and the building department with all of their applications.
I think it's good for us to have some goals for looking at future projects, but this may be a great time for us to do housekeeping as well and clean up a lot of the, and do some of the zoning articles that we've been talking about for a long time. I don't disagree with that, but I do think we have to be mindful that changes are going to continue to come, like a lot by closing. And you remember when the Carberry property, as it was known, was going on the market, there was a lot of concern what would happen with that land, a lot of acreage. And, you know, it was the developer who bought that worked with the town to develop zoning, right?
But not every developer is going to do that. And so that outcome could be a lot different. No, I hear you. Yeah.
We just have to be prepared. And I think residents should hear that we're thinking about things and we're aware of things and ready to act. Absolutely. But I absolutely agree about the housekeeping and addressing things that have been on the radar for a while.
They have to get back running, especially during the MBTA, which took so much of our time. Because we had COVID hit, then MBTA, then ADU. And it's all good. We're in a good place now.
But with the 40B, with 840Bs coming on all at once, it's been And I think, never mind CPC and other things that we're staffing. Well, the codification should really help the building department. And I think getting established procedures and processes should help both planning and building. So that I think like having However, however much time it took you to do this first one on the 80s I'm sure the second one will be faster.
And as applicants, we get kind of like a one pager, or whatever, you know how we talked about making it pretty clear for someone who's getting ready to do an application, they shouldn't have to come in and necessarily meet with you to figure it out. They should be able to get it from the website and then come in with what they think is fairly complete. So there's a lot of interest and work at the state level on ADUs to help homeowners understand the process. MHP, Mass Housing Partnership, is working with HLC I'm having consultants who do that, so.
And then the other thing, just on the June 11th, is the non-conforming businesses.
Speaker 7 (01:15:04–01:15:04)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (01:15:04–01:15:59)
And I don't know if that's something Carolyn could, she could advise us on how to address. Yeah, I was going to ask if you wanted me to sort of, she's going to be talking about the recodification sort of overall, but do you want me to focus her more on like the short-term rentals? Like, kind of in the short term? Like, as far as if we get that to a fall, if we could get that something to happen, that would be great.
It sounds like you want to have a conversation. Ideally, do you want to have a more in-depth conversation on the 11th? Because that sort of like, that tees it up even further? Is there potential for an article for the fall?
I don't know. I'm just asking. Well, I guess I'm, did you get any sense from her about the timeline for the codification? Because the codification, if there was any chance for it in the fall, I wouldn't want to detract from that.
Speaker 2 (01:16:00–01:16:03)
Would you rather do codification before short term?
Speaker 1 (01:16:04–01:16:38)
Well, I'm just thinking it's been four years that we've been asking for the funding. I mean, I feel like she sort of, the way it's laid out is it's spread out over, It's spread out over three meetings, potentially spread out over three meetings, right? So I guess it depends on, you know, what's the first batch, right? It changes.
So, right? What's the first, you know, it's not going to be sort of a full repeal and replace.
Speaker 7 (01:16:38–01:16:38)
No.
Speaker 1 (01:16:38–01:18:48)
What's the first batch? Is the first batch the use table and the dimensional table and a bunch of housekeeping things? Is that the first batch and the second batch is substantive changes like short-term rentals is the third? I don't know.
Do you see, you know what I mean? Like I just don't know because I feel like some of that conversation has to happen. Has she started the audit yet? So I think that we've literally got the contract today.
I saw the contract today. So and she's coming on the 11th. So that to me would probably be the down to codification will be done by default, like I said before. So if we can at least get a realistic timeline from her, and even if it's options of if you would do it this way, we can get it done in this timeline.
If you do it that way, a different timeline. You were at the meeting where she had given us the scope. Did you see her? I did watch the work.
And we approved funding for phase one and phase two. And then I think we were going to assess the needs for phase three, as I recall. So the question is, can she get phase one done? So what I would suggest is maybe on the short-term rental, Al, you've done some work it sounds like that we haven't seen yet.
I've reviewed a few bylaws myself. It occurred to me that we can look at things like, Does the homeowner have to be on site for rental? Is it for all the time that they're on site? I mean, just what are the criteria?
Because it's not writing it. It's like, what do we want to control? And if you read through several examples, they're all pretty consistent. They're all consistent in some of the things.
So I think if we just could do that kind of work, On the 11th, because Carol will need that guidance from us. What is it that we're hearing from residents, that is, we don't want the parties we don't want the commercial rentals we don't want at us being rented out we don't want. affordable units being used for this.
Speaker 2 (01:18:48–01:19:29)
We want some way for the town to regulate it and to be able to enforce it. I mean, so you looked at a few, by no means am I an expert, but I'll play one tonight. It seemed like they were all very consistent. They were all three or four pages.
They were similar language. Half of it was definitions. It seems like it could be something that could be achieved for the fall. And we could, I know I've heard you guys say this before, you could always come back and tweak it if it's not working out the way we intended it in terms of individual language within there.
But to get that on the fall town meeting would be a great, I think, response to comments like this and comments from community members.
Speaker 1 (01:19:29–01:19:47)
Yeah, so it seems doable to me. It seems. Yeah, so in terms of whether she could prioritize, I guess those, if she can address both of those. Like if we gave her the, we need to agree on those things.
Speaker 6 (01:19:47–01:19:48)
The framework.
Speaker 1 (01:19:48–01:20:04)
The framework, yeah. And we're not going to have a chance to talk about it until the same meeting she's coming to, right? So I guess the question is then, the 25th, would we be able to say here is draft?
Speaker 2 (01:20:05–01:20:28)
But if she came with a model bylaw that says this is the Whomever produces this, but broad outline. This is what a majority of communities in the area, similar to Milton, are doing. Here you go. We could review that over those two weeks and then come back on the 25th to be able to have maybe specific responses.
Yeah, I agree.
Speaker 1 (01:20:28–01:21:44)
That sounds good. That sounds great. And then we're not going to get non-conforming businesses, I don't think, for the fall. But if she could talk to us about what she's learned by trying to look at the variances and the special permits, just so we can kind of understand what we should be doing, then we can start to get a realistic framework.
If she says, well, you should zone it for business, then we have to talk about that. I don't know if that's the solution or not, but it might be part of it. In some cases, it might be that. In other cases, it might be something else.
Because one of the things we talked about in East Milton Square was we did an overlay, but we didn't change the underlying zoning. And the underlying zoning has a lot of things that are business uses for decades that are in residential. So that's something to talk about. The parking requirements we know are a challenge.
So that's something to talk about. So those are going to be a little different than the ones that are kind of off on Randolph Ave or something else, right? So what's recommended for a fix for, let's say, East Milton Square is definitely going to be different than other places.
Speaker 7 (01:21:46–01:21:47)
Right. Makes sense.
Speaker 1 (01:21:50–01:22:06)
Yeah. All right. So that is, unless there's anything else, Liz, I forgot one little thing, which is actually good news. The fellow.
Speaker 3 (01:22:06–01:22:23)
Oh, yes. The kelp fellow. Someone has been chosen for that. So yeah, they'll be- For the administrator position?
Oh, no, this is in relation to- Climate, what's a kelp?
Speaker 1 (01:22:23–01:22:32)
C-E-L-P-T. you know, climate leader training, energy leader training, maybe something along the lines of that.
Speaker 3 (01:22:32–01:23:00)
But I know Kai, the municipal energy manager will be supervising a fellow, but they'll be kind of working with us remotely three hours a week in the planning department. So, yeah, definitely interested, you know, to get grant funding for the climate action plan that they can provide. additional support on that. But yeah, just provide support to our department.
Speaker 5 (01:23:00–01:23:01)
Yeah.
Speaker 3 (01:23:01–01:23:04)
So that would be great. Yeah. Use all the support we can get.
Speaker 1 (01:23:04–01:23:05)
Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker 3 (01:23:05–01:23:06)
Yes.
Speaker 1 (01:23:06–01:23:16)
I forgot. I meant to put that in the report. I forgot. So that's good news.
That's good news. So something on that front. Energy and environment portfolio.
Speaker 7 (01:23:16–01:23:20)
Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 1 (01:23:20–01:23:27)
All right. So I would entertain a motion to adjourn. So moved.
Speaker 2 (01:23:27–01:23:28)
Second. Second.
Speaker 1 (01:23:28–01:23:29)
All in favor.
Speaker 7 (01:23:29–01:23:32)
Aye. Aye. Thank you.