Board: Climate Action Planning Committee

Date: 2026-06-18


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:19–00:57)

All right, I will call this session of the Climate Action Planning Committee to order. Welcome, everyone. Thank you for joining. We have a lot of people here in person today.

It's kind of fun. I put public comment on the agenda as the second item, just in case. Uh-oh, Al can't hear the meeting. Matt, can you hear the meeting?

Yeah, everything's fine on my side. Okay. Maggie, can you hear the meeting?

Speaker 2 (00:57–01:07)

Yes, I can. Thank you. So, maybe it's on your side if you click on the air.

Speaker 3 (01:07–01:13)

Oh, you can't hear you. Sorry.

Speaker 1 (01:20–02:00)

I'll just continue taking care of the administrative stuff. I'll give him a second. So seeing nobody online for public comment, I'll move on to approval of the May meeting minutes. Anybody have any corrections or comments on the May meeting minutes?

Can we have a motion to adopt? from Marsha in a few seconds. All in favor? Aye.

All opposed? All abstaining?

Speaker 2 (02:00–02:03)

I'll abstain because I wasn't there. Thank you.

Speaker 1 (02:06–02:31)

Great. So that's five. Does that pass? I don't know.

It's a majority of the quorum. Majority of the quorum. Thank you for your Robert's Rules of the Way of Knowledge. One of these days, I've been caring for two plus years.

It'll get there. Okay.

Speaker 3 (02:35–02:47)

So, Kale, can you hear us?

Speaker 2 (02:48–03:13)

Maybe you can point him towards the arrow next to the audio symbol. That's where, that's often the, the people are all, yeah, next to him.

Speaker 4 (03:13–03:25)

My way to tell him also, he could, he could leave and try to dial back in sometimes. Sometimes it works.

Speaker 1 (03:25–03:39)

Okay. All right. So, um, the next item on the agenda is the energy manager's update. We have Pamela, the municipal energy manager here to give the energy manager's update.

Speaker 2 (03:40–03:51)

Yep. The energy manager will start off by introducing the, and I will give the official title only once, the Clean Energy Legacy Transition Fellow.

Speaker 5 (03:51–03:52)

Nice.

Speaker 2 (03:52–04:03)

Now on Clean Energy Fellow, Eric Lechine, who joined us last week. Eric, do you want to introduce yourself?

Speaker 3 (04:04–04:30)

Yes, my name is Eric Lechine. Finance major at the Masshole, just started last week from Western Massachusetts. I have a little bit of background in construction, landscaping. I've worked on the Net Zero Housing Project in New Hampshire.

So it's kind of sparked my interest in like energy saving and clean energy. Yeah. I'm excited to learn more about everything. See how municipalities work.

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (04:30–06:43)

Awesome. Eric has run his own manscaping business and this program that he's a fellow through the Clean Energy Transition, Clean Energy Legacy Transition Program is a state funded program to help young graduates interested in clean energy enter a career in that field. And he will be with us for six months until beginning of December, 20 hours weekly, 10 with Randolph, where I also work, 10 with Milton, one in-person day in each town. Jay's the in-person day in Milton.

And mainly, he'll be working with us on communications projects. His first big project is to look at the town websites of Randolph and Milton, look at the energy and climate pages, look what other towns do, identify improvements. Other communication projects that I'm thinking of are social media campaigns, or if not a campaign, at least developing content stuff for the town newsletter, and also maybe, hopefully, help jumpstart regular, maybe monthly, energy savings office hours at a public place here in Milton, whether that's the Council on Aging, the Senior Housing Development, Winter Valley, or the library, I'm not sure yet, We're starting that in Randolph next week. So hopefully some lessons can be applied from there to here.

And I should also say that part of it, part of this work will maybe be with the planning department, depending on their needs on the Climate Action Plan. And also, if you have any ideas, wishes, that's also definitely something worth considering.

Speaker 4 (06:45–06:59)

whether you'd be able to help if we want to have a meeting with the public on, let's say, transportation and part of the Climate Action Plan, get some feedback or put out some information.

Speaker 2 (07:01–07:20)

So because the Climate Action Plan is more in the planning department portfolio, they would be the better persons to speak with. But I think that would be a great way to use Eric's skills. Yeah.

Speaker 4 (07:20–07:47)

At this week's meeting of the Waste Management Committee within CAPC, it's one of the working groups that student development committees are working with. We discussed the advantages of social media campaigns and maybe we can piggyback on the experience that you have with what you've developed for energy. so that we maximize the resource that we have in there.

Speaker 3 (07:47–07:54)

Definitely. It's a very big platform now, and it's definitely, I think, a task to definitely use it, utilize it more.

Speaker 1 (07:54–08:07)

It's obviously the right channels, but… Sandra's done a very good job, sort of, putting more content out on the DPW Facebook page. And also in today's times.

Speaker 4 (08:07–08:11)

Oh, I haven't had a chance to read it yet.

Speaker 1 (08:13–08:48)

I'm very excited about the idea of energy affordability office hours. Very, very excited. Sustainable Milton has talked about, so I'd be excited to partner with you. It's a little daunting, the idea of like as a volunteer, well, I'll chef and I'll help people with energy affordability.

So just a little bit of like formal support or lining up resources, I think would be good. We can do more if we work together, right? I'd love to drop by the Randolph one and see what's going on.

Speaker 2 (08:49–10:42)

The first office hours, well, I should say that National Grid, unlike Eversource, has a range of positions called customer advocates and their main responsibility is to go to these public places, sit together with lower income persons, especially, but not only, to help them get on the low-income utility rate or electricity rate, and help connect them with other resources. And next week, what we're doing in Randolph is to bring the National Grid Customer Advocate together with our MassSave Community First Partner. Representative Community First Partnership is something where towns collaborate with nonprofits who do outreach to to reach communities like immigrants or low-income households. So we will have the utility side, the Mass Save side.

The utility person has expertise in explaining utility bills, which in itself is a very daunting and also fruitful endeavor. And so I sent Eric a one-hour webinar from the Massachusetts Attorney General's office just about utility bills, because that's, I think, one of the most effective ways and easiest ways Eric can help right away to help explain utility bills. Yeah. And then I would envision something similar for third party suppliers.

I don't know if I've told you about that term. That's something you'll have to look out for that. I'm sure there are plenty of residents who are overpaying for their electricity because of third-party suppliers.

Speaker 1 (10:42–11:11)

We have a community electricity aggregation program that offers a very competitive fixed price. Folks who are not already in contract with a third-party supplier were automatically opted into. almost six years ago now. But that's definitely something to watch out for in Milton, people are overpaying relative to the town sponsored program.

Speaker 4 (11:12–11:20)

Yeah. And do you envision these office hours to be like later in the evening after people get off work or during the day or?

Speaker 2 (11:21–12:09)

That is something we will have to determine as we move forward. There are different, it will depend on the venue, We're not at that point yet. In Randolph, for example, we agreed on Wednesdays between 10 a.m. and 2 p.m.

at the intergenerational community center. However, at this intergenerational community center, the seniors fought hard to have seniors only hours from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. So there will be no young parents who will benefit from this first office hours.

So now we're thinking about doing it at a different time, different place, it's in flux.

Speaker 1 (12:13–12:35)

One thing, just an idea that passed through my mind was it could be something we could partner with faith communities in Melton to do, if you sort of co-sponsored one with the synagogue, the Catholic church, be not a congregational church or parish.

Speaker 2 (12:35–12:58)

I mean, ideally, I really think it would be good to have something that reaches the biggest number of people on a regular basis, because really the regularity will draw people and be a resource for people. And then over time, depending on resources, we can expand and raise attention.

Speaker 1 (12:58–13:14)

Yeah. And if we can train volunteers to do it, then we can do it more often. And I think today's era of overstepped calendars and being able to repeat an event is important.

Speaker 6 (13:14–13:14)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (13:14–13:16)

And I will say one more thing to this.

Speaker 2 (13:16–17:24)

I think that so many of these, too much in my opinion, or very much of Massachusetts efforts on the climate side, even on the energy efficiency side, has focused on Homeowners, Mass Save, since its founding, has mostly benefited homeowners, which tends to benefit middle-class, higher-income households. But really, the energy crisis is affecting lower-income households, tenants. And these office hours are really the first step towards reaching the lower 50% of the income scale on this energy question. Do you have any other updates?

So that's for the CLT, the Clean Energy Fellow side. Very exciting update. Yep. The second thing is the Climate Leader Community status update.

Thanks to, again, thanks to the advocacy efforts of the Climate Action Planning Committee and maybe Stainville, Milton, and many others, we are very close to submitting the application. We, as the Town of Dalton, submitting the application by June 30th to be a climate leader community, one step up from the green community status. The select board approved both the municipal decarbonization roadmap and the zero emissions first vehicle policy. Zero emissions vehicle first, not the, yeah, zero emissions vehicle first policy.

The school superintendent needs to sign off both of those letters or both of those items. And then I will gather the documents, hopefully early next week, to upload them on the platform of the Department of Energy Resources, the state-led Department of Energy Resources, and we will submit it. And then we should, based on my current state of knowledge, we should be in a good position to obtain climate meter community certification, which ideally next year will provide us with funding for technical design, and then actually money for implementing the projects resulting from the technical design. And which projects we will select, it'll be up to a million dollars.

which sounds like a lot, but really isn't that much, still a good chunk. And which projects to select, we will be in a better position to decide that based on, and this is my next point, the comprehensive building assessments, these free in-depth studies of big buildings, outlining pathways towards electrification. And we already got this CBA, this comprehensive building assessment for the biggest building of the town of Milton, the high school. We got different cost scenarios for HVAC electrification, ground source heat pump, air source heat pump, all in the range of $20 million to $50 million, excluding incentives, federal tax incentives, and not taking not taking into account the cost of replacing the fossil fuel heating system.

And I actually don't have, I don't have any numbers right now off the top of my head how much it would cost to replace oilers because some of these school equipment heating systems are coming to the end of their life. And I don't know how much it will cost to fully replace them. It will probably also be very, very high.

Speaker 1 (17:24–17:30)

So they didn't give a baseline scenario where you replace They have existing equipment, but the same kind of equipment?

Speaker 2 (17:30–19:37)

In the comprehensive building assessment of the high school, they did. OK. But that would have been a good thing to do there. So we are in the process of getting these CBAs for all other four school buildings in Milton.

And we're also looking, we're starting to look at the MSBA accelerated repair program, which Out of all state funding sources, the MSBA maybe has the biggest funding power for school upgrades, and it will always require a matching contribution from the municipality, which is why it's a bigger commitment question. I think 20 or 25 years ago, the town of Milton did a really great job at Harnessing MSBA funding and ended up only paying 20% of the total project costs, which for a high income town like Milton was a great deal. Maybe unlikely, maybe not to be expected for this next round, but it'll be worth looking into. Another item I have is that we're moving.

We're hopefully moving forward soon with EV charging stations here at the Town Hall. And the Council on Aging EV charging stations is pending. We'll hold off on that until the next year when Eversource publishes its new incentives because it looks like the electrical infrastructure upgrades are going to be more expensive than we thought, than we initially thought. So we're going to wait until next year to see how the Council on Aging will be charging.

Stations can be financed. I'm sorry I rushed through all that, but do you have any questions so far?

Speaker 1 (19:47–20:01)

It's a lot of progress. I guess I'm curious what the status of the solar projects that were, the ground was laid for town meeting.

Speaker 2 (20:01–21:53)

Oh, right. So town meeting approved the possibility of solar power purchasing agreements at the fire headquarters, the library, and I believe another project. The animal shelter. The animal shelter.

So at the fire headquarters, which we've built solar ready, we still need to confirm details, but it seemed, and I'm new to much of the, many of the technical details. If a roof is, it has a slope that is greater than 5%, then additional attachment is required, additional fastening. is required. And apparently the fire recorder's roof is exactly at 5%, which means that the engineers looking, the structural engineers looking at how easy it would be to put solar panels on there are determining what the extra costs of that might be.

It's not ideal, I will say, because it was built as a solar-ready roof. So we're trying to get more information from Solect, the solar company, on the extra costs that might be involved. Those would be costs for Milton or would they be costs for Solect that they sort of bundle into the pass? So the electricity rate that they initially gave us at 6% per kilowatt hour is fantastic, it will probably not be as good following their new analysis.

Speaker 4 (21:53–21:56)

So the determinate slope is 5% or above?

Speaker 2 (21:56–22:07)

Yeah, anything above 5% doesn't make it impossible, but it makes it less economical.

Speaker 4 (22:07–22:09)

What if we're at 5%?

Speaker 2 (22:09–22:12)

The roof, apparently, is at Exactly 5%.

Speaker 4 (22:12–22:20)

So what was here is above 5%. Right. So there's a gray area here.

Speaker 2 (22:20–22:22)

Right. Which is why further discussions are needed.

Speaker 4 (22:23–22:29)

Okay. Makes sense. Has there been any conversation about solar for the East Milton fire station?

Speaker 2 (22:30–22:56)

No, I'm not involved in those discussions. I haven't, at least I haven't been to date. Yeah. On the animal shelter, I submitted a grant application for technical assistance to develop design specifications for solar panels and a battery storage system at the animal shelter.

Let's see if we get that money.

Speaker 4 (22:56–23:17)

But to go back to what Arthur just said about the eastbound fire station, I guess I had the assumption that any new building the town was constructing would be, you know, some, level of need or have the ability to be solar or heat pumps are thought through.

Speaker 2 (23:17–24:12)

Yeah, so I guess technically even the fire headquarters is solar ready. They have, I'm blanking on the word right now, they have an extra section for cables to run through. Yeah, forgetting the name. So In terms of the electrical infrastructure, it is solar ready.

But the roof slope isn't made. It's a question at the end of the day of costs. If the town had a million dollars, it could easily put the solar panels on there, fasten them properly, and it would be fine. But because we're dependent on this solar PPA from a private developer, they will have to look also at their margins.

Speaker 1 (24:14–24:44)

So in the case of a PPA, these are not costs to the town directly, it's cost to the solar developer who's going to build and own the panels. And they had originally offered a six cents a kilowatt hour, which is sort of sized for them to amortize their costs and make a profit. And if they have to make a larger capital investment, at least six, it might be I don't know. What do we pay for electricity?

Speaker 2 (24:44–24:59)

Depending on the building, because each building has different, buildings are different electricity classes, but between 22 and 28 cents, I believe.

Speaker 1 (24:59–25:16)

So, I mean, I think the headline should be, even if it's more than six, it will be a lot less than 22. Periodically, yeah. So probably a cost saving, unless the costs are astronomical.

Speaker 4 (25:17–25:35)

Yeah. Just to be clear, so there's nothing, when they were architecting the new fire station, there was no requirement for them to do a cost differentiation analysis, how they're going to heat the building or electrify the building. Was that the case?

Speaker 3 (25:36–25:37)

Sorry, can you repeat your question?

Speaker 4 (25:38–26:01)

When they were working with the architect, Was there any requirement that the town or the architect would have to provide an analysis saying, you know, the construction cost would be X more if we did this greening, you know, putting greener energy or heat pumps in it. But over time, you would recover that versus, you know, a larger method of upfront cost.

Speaker 2 (26:02–26:12)

I'm not sure on that. So the planning for that happened long before I started. The only thing I know is that it was built as a solar-ready fire headquarters.

Speaker 1 (26:13–26:15)

Are you talking about East Milton? East Milton.

Speaker 2 (26:15–26:16)

Oh, East Milton.

Speaker 1 (26:16–26:30)

It's the same fire station building committee, though, right? So probably their architecture planning was… Their building now is probably that big for it.

Speaker 4 (26:30–26:40)

It was pretty steep. It's steep? Yeah. And maybe Brian Walsh is the chair of the Power Station Program Committee.

Speaker 1 (26:40–27:38)

I think we should connect with them. But just at a policy level, Milton has adopted the specialized opt-in building code, which has provisions that encourage solar, but it doesn't require it. It does require electric service that's sort of adequate with support of electric heating. So you don't have to start out with heat pumps, but you have to be sort of heat pump ready.

Probably I would say solar ready as well. That might be a technical term that I'm abusing, but I think if we want to know sort of what preparation was done for this, we should connect with the fire station building committee. Do you know Ron Walsh? Ron Walsh, I recommend he pass the top shift.

I can work with him.

Speaker 2 (27:42–27:44)

That's it from my side.

Speaker 1 (27:46–28:02)

Thank you. It's always a pleasure to get these big substantive updates when somebody is actually doing this for a living and stuff happens. Any other comments or questions?

Speaker 5 (28:02–28:06)

I just want to appreciate you for getting us to this stage. It's excellent.

Speaker 2 (28:07–28:31)

Thank you. That's exciting. Yes. But I also, again, I want to make clear that the legwork for the climate leader community status was mostly done by engaged citizens, stuff like the opt-in specialized billing code.

I'm sure there was lots of work and many emotions went into that discussion.

Speaker 1 (28:31–32:46)

I was happy not to. It's been a team effort to be sure. And that's exciting to get to this point. Look forward to hearing that the superintendent has signed on.

That's the last step to access the resources to do the work. Well, the next item on the agenda is committee membership and reappointments for the 2026-2027 term. So I just want to share who's leaving. So Ron Israel, Kyle Johnson, and Matt Panucci have all elected to not serve next term.

I think you saw in the chat that Matt is moving out of town. And we will have one new member, Stevie Caldwell, from the school committee. She's been appointed by the school committee to serve with us. And was going to try to make it this evening, but had other things on the calendar.

So look forward to working with her very much. The rest of you have all agreed to serve another year, and I'm very, very grateful for that. And all of your intentions have been forwarded to the select board, and I expect they proactively reached out and gave me a deadline, so I'm expecting that'll get brought up in a select board agenda before the end of the month, those three appointments. And I'll let you know when that's done.

So there, I think we'll have a quorum. Anna and Hale are both willing to move up from associate memberships to voting members, but we still have a lot of vacancies. So my intention is to continue recruiting new folks to fill those vacancies over the course of the summer. We've had quite a few vacancies for a while now though, so we really can't fill those seats by the fall.

They may ask the select board to amend the charge again to make it a little easier to meet quorum and get work done. The Chamber of Commerce position hasn't been filled ever. We have the high school students seat, which I would really love to see filled. And I've done the first and second thing to try to fill it with.

I think if we all kind of reached out to the networks of the young people in our lives, maybe we would have a chance to fill in that. The environmental science courses. That's where I started, yeah. And that's how we got Reagan.

I reached out to the teacher of the climate crisis class at the high school, and she had a name on the tip of her tongue, and Reagan joined us. I'll say, I think municipal committee work is, is slow and at times frustrating, even for grownups. So turning it into something that makes sense for a high school student, and where they can sort of understand what their contribution is and what they're going to get done over the course of the year would help.

Speaker 4 (32:47–33:26)

Two of the files that I might be able to help you with this is to see whether or not Fontbonne has an environmental science course. know that Milton Academy has an advanced environmental science course. And I was thinking if there's a Milton resident at either one of those schools, they would seem to be qualified on par with a Milton resident at both of those schools. And what if there were a Milton student in Environmental Science or Curriculum course at Cary College.

Speaker 1 (33:31–33:37)

They could be appointed as a resident, I think. They couldn't take the high school students.

Speaker 2 (33:40–33:41)

Correct.

Speaker 4 (33:43–34:07)

There was a poster by Cary College at the Massachusetts Association of Conservation Commissions. So we could possibly get down that track and see what's going on. If you're looking for someone at large, who's actually doing work in this area.

Speaker 1 (34:08–35:49)

I think I'm not sure how, like, how the seats will get assigned, but Ron, was the select board designee, and Matt and Kyle are the residents with relevant expertise seats. I think our committee, partner committee designations have all been filled for us. Planning department representative, conservation commission, school committee, because the select board just needs to choose their designee. And then the town administrator has an appointment as well.

So, I mean, I think one of the ideas is town administrator could appoint a staff member even whose work we've impinged upon if we chose to. I think there are a lot of options, and I intend to use the quieter summer months to try to build out our team. Any other comments or questions on this topic? The high school has an environmental club.

It does, yeah. So they have a recycling club, but I was in the high school for my daughter's flute lesson last week and saw a new a new club.

Speaker 5 (35:50–36:04)

It's the picture of it, but I. Yeah, I started following like an environmental club on Instagram or whatever, just so I could kind of get a feel for who these were. I mean, of course, it's the end of the school year, but and I have a couple of kids at the high school.

Speaker 7 (36:05–36:11)

Eco-friendly club. Are you interested in making Melton a cleaner, more eco-friendly community?

Speaker 5 (36:11–36:12)

There we go. These are our people.

Speaker 1 (36:15–36:47)

So, yeah, they they started May 21st. Yeah. So I would absolutely welcome help from all of you getting the word out. I did write a medium and a short blurb and I distributed it to the Milton Interfaith Clergy Association.

Just thinking of all the newsletters that are out there, the library, schools.

Speaker 4 (36:47–37:03)

This might be a great role for you because I have a son in high school too. I'm dad. You know the social media, you know the lingo, and so you might be able to relate a little bit more too.

Speaker 3 (37:04–37:13)

I was just thinking you'd probably want to make it appeal to a high schooler more because a guy came told him like I'll come sit down with meeting at 630 p.m. and probably, like, no, no chance.

Speaker 1 (37:13–37:17)

Yeah. You know, if we can make this more attractive to a high school student, it'd be good for us, too.

Speaker 6 (37:19–37:20)

It's a little dry.

Speaker 4 (37:21–37:25)

Meet their service requirement at high school. Yeah, that's the average.

Speaker 3 (37:26–37:43)

Yeah. I'm sure a lot of high schoolers would be open to doing a lot of social media stuff if you can make it appeal to them in a certain way. If you tell them you're going to make a social media post for the town, I'm sure somebody would be interested in that. I am.

Yeah, I would assume trying to make it more appealing.

Speaker 1 (37:44–39:04)

Sustainable Milton had a high schooler volunteering with us to do graphic design last year, and that was great. You can define a clear task with an outcome you can feel good about. And we've had that in working towards the climate leader communities, and you know, knock on wood, we may get there any minute. And I think we need to zero in on some strategic goals for next year.

I mean, I think we're waiting to see if we get the EEA planning grant and if that comes through, I think that we'll spend relatively more time on the kind of public meetings and finalizing the draft plan and taking it through an approval process, the kind of completing the work of the charge. consulting support to do that properly. I remain very interested in supporting residents in their clean energy journey. That has to include affordability now, right?

So I think what you're starting to work on, I think is exactly the kind of thing I'd like to spend that on.

Speaker 2 (39:05–40:09)

I'm not sure if you'd sent me this, but I asked Eric to look into this initiative that came from Montgomery County, Maryland, which has been doing lots of cool stuff, but it's a nonprofit called, remind me. Solar United Neighbors. Yeah, it's a nonprofit called Solar United Neighbors that partnered with this company called I Choose R, and they've been pioneering group purchasing programs for solar and heat pumps. The basic idea is that a bunch of residents, maybe coordinated or organized through an organization, come together, then they can get better, more advantageous pricing for solar panels, for heat pumps.

And it's something that was a discussion that started among my energy manager colleagues. And I asked Eric to look into that a bit more. And I guess I can share the memo.

Speaker 3 (40:10–41:32)

Yeah, I did just hear you say it. So, yeah, I think there's more to add to this stuff. But yeah, it was basically saying with the group purchasing program, that's almost a 10 to 20% price cut because of the just incentive to the contractor that involved purchasing all the equipment and stuff like that. They also just, they have a group of clients so they can reduce the price that way.

They use a reverse auction program that it looks for the lowest bid instead of the highest bid. which there's good and bad to that. If you're not vetting the contractors enough, then you might just be getting a guy just tossed in the lowest jungle, just not doing the best work. Other issues then are whether they're local companies or out-of-state companies.

Some out-of-state companies might not care, might not be the best customer service people to this area because they're not living in it. So yeah, that was just something to think. But it's a pretty straightforward process to just have a meeting with solely United Neighbors. But the town, there's not much the town has to do.

So United Neighbors reaches out and communicates all the information and material to the residents. You guys, the town just basically has to sign off on it, allow them to use the town logo, I think is what they said. It's all in the document. So I can send that to you guys.

Speaker 4 (41:33–41:36)

where they get their funding?

Speaker 3 (41:38–41:59)

Same question. Something you can look into. Because it is a non-profit, so it's, I think they get a little bit of each, like, purchase, like every time someone signs up for it, I think they get a little bit percentage of what they're paying contract, you know what I'm saying? And that's, I would fund with that.

Speaker 1 (41:59–43:06)

I'll definitely hand it to you, man. It's in the Google summary. Solar United Neighbors is funded by a diverse mix of philanthropic foundations, government agencies, individual donors, and earned income firms on the ground. Does not receive funding from or affiliated with solar installation companies.

Were any of you in Milton for the Solarize Milton program? I think it was 2015, 2017. Oh, that already happened? I didn't even know that.

There was one. I wonder how it's different. Is that really kind of a group purchasing strategy? It's a sensible thing to do because I learned recently that the soft costs of sales and just sitting at dining room tables with five or six families in order to sell one system is 20 to 30% of the cost of an active system in Massachusetts.

So if you can cut out those soft costs, then people have better jobs.

Speaker 3 (43:06–43:19)

Exactly. I think those same contractors are still getting like $300 or $500 per job when they did the buyback program themselves. So it may sound small, but it definitely adds up over time.

Speaker 1 (43:19–43:32)

Great. So the next item on the agenda is working group updates. It's kind of a grab bag. Who's got updates?

Speaker 4 (43:32–46:18)

We can do a little bit on the working group on waste management. Yes. Because we met earlier this week and discussed a number of topics, which is planning for a community engagement program, probably sometime in the fall, bypassing summer vacations and allowing time for adequate planning and involvement. work that has begun on a local audit, community audit.

Recycling was very successful. Going to Cassie, she had a lot of conversations, both positive and negative, and plans involving for including other people in the process in the future, such as students doing public service a community service initiative in the public schools. How did the other work? It's random sampling throughout the community of the move-ins when they're on the sidewalk, primarily to see whether or not people have plastic bag recyclables and put them in there.

That's the major offense and driver of increased costs. I was reading this week that the city of Quincy, between 2022 and 2024, reduced their contaminate. This is called contamination. It involves a lot of things, too.

Like, people were deciding to put regular trash in an air hole. But yeah, it's recycling. They reduced theirs from something over 10.8% down to 6.5%. I wonder how they did that.

That's what I'd like to do a little bit of homework on. And this, of course, affects the cost that's borne by the immigrants and residents. Because the higher the contamination rate, particularly one that's 15% or above on a sampling basis, then the rates have to go up because the carrier has to absorb the cost associated with separation of materials and then offloading them into the appropriate. Remind me the name of our hauler.

It's waste management. The plant that we use is an Avon, which is also the same plant that Kate Abercrombie uses.

Speaker 1 (46:19–46:25)

What is Sunrise Scavenging? Is that the solid waste? Yeah, the solid waste I think. Yes.

Speaker 2 (46:27–46:31)

And so it's single-use plastic bags that are the biggest offenders?

Speaker 4 (46:31–46:37)

Yes, that's the biggest. Like grocery bags or like garbage bags? Plastic.

Speaker 8 (46:37–47:26)

Yeah. Anything that can get tangled up. I watched, so Canton is having this problem, way too much contamination. And they had sort of what we were talking about having like a community engagement meeting.

Only a few people were there, but I watched a video of it and they had someone from the, facility and Avon just talk all about the challenges that they have with. But besides plastic bags, which gum up the machines, the other big problem is batteries, batteries, batteries can start fires. And he said that they all like he said, lose sleep, or the idea of somebody putting like a, let's say a lawnmower battery or some like big battery in there. Think it would chargeable lithium.

Speaker 1 (47:26–47:30)

I'm that kind of thing, but not not alkaline batteries that say they go trash, right?

Speaker 8 (47:30–47:48)

Yeah. I mean, yeah, it sounded like it was bigger batteries that could like their facility. The facility had an incident like this a few years ago, and it got shut down for like a week or more just because that the alkaline battery shouldn't go in.

Speaker 4 (47:48–48:04)

And now there are two facilities in Milton. It shouldn't go in the trash. It should not. It should actually be put into facilities that accommodate them.

Even the ones that are labeled, this goes in the trash?

Speaker 1 (48:05–48:18)

If it's labeled that way, then that's it. No, I know the button batteries don't. There's a whole bunch of batteries that don't go in the trash. Exactly.

Now there's a depository. Yeah.

Speaker 4 (48:19–48:34)

Yeah. And there's been a discussion about the possibility of seeing whether a depository can be placed at the end of two fire stations after the switch doors gets undergone.

Speaker 1 (48:37–48:51)

What was the name of that vendor? The offender? No, a vendor. Oh, God.

Which vendor? No, for the specialized collection in the office here.

Speaker 4 (48:51–49:30)

Tam does it. Oh, okay. Tam collects them. Who they vend it to.

Right. I've talked to them about that. We're at 15% or so. Tam?

Tam is just below 15%. Yeah, that sounds about right. That's pretty high. Yeah, it is.

When I went on an audit two years ago with Cassie's predecessor, we were about 12%. And the audit prior to that was at 10%. It works. So we need a good communication program.

Speaker 1 (49:30–49:56)

Yeah, and I think holding a sort of traditional public meeting when we want them to know about trash, but I don't think anybody wakes up and says, you know what I want to do today? Go learn about what to put in which bin. I need to go where people are with really bite-sized information and lots of repetition.

Speaker 4 (49:56–50:14)

And it has to be ongoing, continuous and repetitive. You have to build out a calendar, a cycle, if you will. Because new people come into town, we have lots of new people in town. It shows the cost of the tax.

Do we know what the incremental cost is?

Speaker 1 (50:14–50:37)

We've asked for that information. We haven't done that yet. That would help a lot. Yes.

We could sort of boil it down to, like, this is going to cost you $6. I mean, I'm sure inflation also played a role, but we didn't see our trash tickers go up by a dollar. Right.

Speaker 2 (50:38–51:14)

different legislative level, but I can see that. Unfortunately, in this new state environmental bond bill, the Senate version, which was going to provide funding for environmental bonds, but also included other environmental regulations, including the statewide single plastic use ban, did not make it into the House version. So the Massachusetts State House wanted to remove the single plastic, single plastic use. Yeah.

Speaker 4 (51:14–51:24)

Is that the bill that was voted on today? It was yesterday. I think by noon today, they voted afternoon.

Speaker 2 (51:24–51:41)

And I know that, Madam Chief, it says voted by noon. Environmentally minded states in this country, they've been working on it hard for a long time on those single plastic, single use plastics. But again, it didn't make it into the law. It says that.

Speaker 4 (51:41–51:42)

But it's a town by town.

Speaker 2 (51:43–51:59)

It's a town by town, but this would have been a state by town. I lived in Rwanda for three and a half years. And in Rwanda, when you arrive at the airport, they check suitcases of all those tourists from the United States and they remove single-use plastic bags in.

Speaker 1 (52:00–54:44)

Wow. Is there a nationwide ban there? Yeah. When they do something, they're rigorous.

Thank you for the update. Anything from transportation? Nope. It's sort of a blend.

I mean, so as you guys know, I've worked with this committee. I'm on the board of Sustainable Milton. I attend the United Congregational Church next door. And it's been an exciting month for the green team, United Congregational Church.

We had a congregational vote a couple of weeks ago to do a big solar installation and also make a congregational commitment to replace fossil fuels by 2015. What I'm most excited about is a commitment to actually do the planning work or what that would entail over the next 12 months, which is more tangible. So that was a lot of work that a lot of folks assisted. So it was really nice to see a community effort like that take shape.

That's removing the radiators or the boiler? We're at a stage where We really need the inventory. What is the equipment? We know we have natural gas equipment, so where is it?

What kind of ductwork do we have? How's the installation done? And just collecting that information is work, so getting a clear vote of support lets the staff know who they should spend time with. So I'll spend that as a building emissions flipping group update.

What's that? Yeah, I mean, it definitely is a collective action problem and you just need to go with the decisions you're being made and try to steer them, give people a reason to consider. Any other updates? Ron isn't here to do conservation.

Speaker 5 (54:45–54:51)

What will happen with the conservation sub-working group without Matt?

Speaker 1 (54:51–55:41)

That's a good question. I know Ron would like to see somebody carry on with that. I think there are some really nice proposals. And the challenge is assembling a team of folks who can either raise money to pay somebody to do the work or find volunteers with the right skill set to support some of the work.

We heard you had some town meetings planned, some town engagement activities. He was definitely thinking about it. So I would encourage anybody who's interested in helping them move forward to reach out to Ron. Yeah.

See, see what the next steps might be.

Speaker 4 (55:43–55:46)

And there might be some of the new ranks would be adjusted.

Speaker 6 (55:48–55:48)

Okay.

Speaker 4 (55:54–56:28)

So that, um, that will just follow up on the mention of funding. Um, that would be a potential topic for the Community Preservation Committee funding sources. The cycle was the 27 that closed last month. So that would give a window of opportunity for better people to collaborate on getting ready for a proposal for next month.

Speaker 1 (56:28–57:07)

I think that was, so one of the organizations that Ron had connected with was the Ponds of the River Watershed Association. It was. Sean McKenzie from NEPRA had also recommended CPC as a potential funding. And the Conservation Commission was aligned with that thing.

Right. But as we all know, it's definitely, somebody's got to do a fair amount of legwork to go on. And it's a competitive process. Yes.

But that would, I think, be the path forward for that subject.

Speaker 4 (57:07–57:14)

Are they involved with the taking down the dams on the La Paz, or is that just the state EPA?

Speaker 1 (57:15–57:34)

Well, the NEPRA, I think, is involved in advocacy for that. I think it's their position that it should be removed. How about the funding? Would it still approve or something?

The EPA funding is for cleanup. It's a super fun site, and they're dredging the bottom to remove nasty chemicals, PFAS.

Speaker 4 (57:34–58:23)

They have to get that cleanup done before they can even move back because all the contaminants are behind the thing. So not just that thing, but Elzaker, two dams, both of them, and the Tilleston-Hollingsworth Dam is very dangerous because it's in disrepair, it's eroded. So getting the re-contaminants out from Upper Brook down to that dam is short order, it's imperative. And once that's done, then they can remove the dam I was trying to cream up on the network would take a lead role in the dam removal.

Advocating for it or doing it? Advocating for it. They didn't have the resources themselves to do something like that. It's an enormous task.

Speaker 1 (58:24–58:25)

I can imagine.

Speaker 4 (58:25–59:09)

The Toronto Watershed Association and the communities in that area have and built, the results have been phenomenally positive. It's short order. We've seen weapons restored for 48 months. Wow, back to pristine condition.

It's amazing what happens. And the bigger danger problem is compounded by the fact that we have two centuries of silt coming down in the Bossa Nova, stored behind that dam with contaminants also. And that raises the level of Water. That's true.

Speaker 1 (59:09–59:21)

Yeah. So with the dam removed, with the water level, it wouldn't impact any of the buildings around in the ponds that are down there, would it? I think it still has to be.

Speaker 5 (59:21–59:29)

I've heard that the people who live there don't really want the dam removed, just because it's part of the whole scene. They don't really want it to change.

Speaker 4 (59:29–59:41)

And there are different approaches they can be taking. That would be a major study. but then you'd have the shad coming back up the river and they'd go fishing. Yeah.

Speaker 2 (59:42–59:45)

And is this at Lower Mills or where is this? Baker's at Lower Mills.

Speaker 4 (59:45–59:54)

That's where Baker Dam is, but the first dam is up towards the Mattapian area.

Speaker 1 (59:55–01:00:13)

I mean, it sounds like a public advocacy effort is a little premature with all the work that precedes it, but when they get to that point, I think having a rendering of what it would look like And they would probably go a long way towards making people comfortable, assuming that it wouldn't look terrible.

Speaker 4 (01:00:14–01:00:32)

And they do have their community engagement groups from Hyde Park, Manaphan, Milton, Boston. So it's just as you say, we've decided to buy as part of Boston and Kittleton.

Speaker 1 (01:00:32–01:03:49)

Great. Okay, well, the last item on the agenda is just an acknowledgement of the outgoing members. I'm sorry that they're not here to hear it, but send them the minutes. As I said before, Ron Israel and Matt Benucci and Kyle Johnson are not planning to serve on the committee next year.

Ron has been serving on the committee for three terms. He was one of the one of the founding members when we got started in 2023 and has done a ton of work to envision conservation projects that would make the valuable natural lands around Milton more resilient to climate change and building connections with relevant organizations in the area. I do hope that, as you said, some of that will continue to move forward. I think they can move forward with or without a toehold in this committee.

So a lot of thanks to Ron for all his hard work. Matt also, I think, was a major partner in that effort and reaching out to our our firefighters in Milton to work on the wildfire component of our draft climate action plan. So thanks to Matt for that. And I think Kyle was a contributor in the transportation work.

And even just the time it takes to clear at 90 minutes in the calendar once we show up for a super incredibly exciting committee meeting on a regular basis. I just really admire folks who are willing to serve the community in that way. Not splashy, but meaningful. So I want to offer my thanks to all the outgoing members and And my welcome to Stevie Caldwell, and hopefully over the coming months, we'll have some more memories to welcome as well.

And thanks to you for continuing. I'm obsessed at this point, I can't stop. Well, great. With that, unless there are other comments or questions, I'll entertain a motion to adjourn.

I move that we adjourn. All right, Kim moves that we adjourn. Any seconds? I'll second.

Okay, all in favor? Aye. All opposed? Unanimous.

Thank you everybody for making time to be here tonight and we'll see you soon.