Board: Board Of Appeals

Date: 2026-08-13


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:19–00:21)

Good evening, everyone.

Speaker 2 (00:21–01:08)

We'll call the hearing on the application of the store master funding LLC through their representative Heather Duco of the Gardner School for property at 675 Blue Hill Avenue. They are seeking a special permit to install a commercial ground sign in a residential zone. 6.2 feet from the lot line, whereas the Milton zoning bylaw prohibits commercial signs in residential zones and requires a minimum setback of 15 feet for signs. All this information has been on the website, on our board, and tonight's hearing will be conducted by me as chair with my fellow board members.

Introducing yourselves.

Speaker 3 (01:10–01:12)

Michael Brown. Chris Hart.

Speaker 2 (01:13–02:46)

Thank you. And I see Heather. Thank you for joining us. Thank you.

Where we are with this is that we did have a hearing earlier in the year, June 18th, and there was some discussion about the placement of the sign, whether it needed to be in the position that it was proposed. There were concerns expressed about the fact that we would probably have to be doing a variance and that there were not enough facts to support. The claim of hardship, so we allow the applicant to do a continuation of this hearing and and adjust if possible the placement and the design of the sign. And so, in the information that we've been provided.

That was sort of, you know, as of as of the 16 of June 18th, we did get a letter from the sign review committee that reviewed a revised application. pointing out that the location has been revised to be south of the entrance drive rather than north. It's been reduced in width from 76 inches to 66 inches. Gooseneck lighting has been directed to the sign that remains as set up by the site plan approval process.

Heather, I'm hoping that you could give us an update on what the changes were.

Speaker 4 (02:47–03:00)

Sure, I'm gonna try to share my, well, good evening, everybody. Nice to see you again. I didn't mean to not say hello. I do have the, I'm gonna try to share my screen so I can show you.

Speaker 5 (03:00–03:06)

You'll be able to.

Speaker 4 (03:06–03:44)

Okay. I tried to do this last night and it was an epic failure, so I don't know. I can see it looks great. Okay.

I'm just going to try to get it down a little bit here. And then I'll also show you the revised design. So, the school, they did go back to planning. And we located the science of this area.

So, to the left of the driveway. at the 7.5 setback that planning, that the sign review is allowed to grant.

Speaker 2 (03:47–03:54)

So there's no need then for a variance from us because you're in compliance with the sign raising that. Yeah, correct.

Speaker 4 (03:54–04:25)

Yes. And let me just show you, um, this is the new design. Um, you'll see that it's, it's almost identical to what we showed the board last time. It's just been reduced in width here.

to accommodate the setback. Other than that, it's the same overall height that we showed the board last time, the same design. There's been no changes to the design itself. Just this width has been reduced to accommodate the 7.5 setback.

Okay.

Speaker 2 (04:26–04:33)

And I didn't see that that plan had been submitted. I mean, I didn't find it on our website, this revised plan.

Speaker 4 (04:34–04:50)

So I did not submit it to the board. We submitted a letter to withdraw the variance portion from the board. So the revised design, I did not submit to zoning board.

Speaker 2 (04:51–05:18)

Well, it would be helpful if you could just submit that. I mean, I will accept it, but because I'd like to show the new location. Okay, sure. And that's what we didn't, we didn't get that.

I mean, the assignment plan review committee said that that's what had happened, but I didn't have a plan that showed that. Okay. I can, I can submit both of the drawings too. That's no problem.

That would be great. Yeah. Cause we'd like to reference them in the decision. Oh, sure.

Absolutely. Yep.

Speaker 4 (05:18–05:38)

So the letter that we submitted July 8th, there should be a record of that, that we requested to withdraw the variance portion of the request but we still need the site. We still need the special permit approval to install signage in general in the residential area. Correct.

Speaker 2 (05:42–05:45)

Chris or Michael, do you have any questions for Heather?

Speaker 3 (05:48–05:48)

I do not.

Speaker 2 (05:49–05:57)

Nor do I. Bill, do we see any comments from anyone? Hands raised or?

Speaker 5 (05:58–05:58)

No.

Speaker 2 (05:58–05:59)

Let's see.

Speaker 5 (06:02–06:09)

We do have a hand raised from John Z. John Z, tell us your name and address, please.

Speaker 6 (06:09–06:17)

Yes. John Zikwitz, 245 Atherton Street. I'm the chair of the Sign Review Committee. I just wanted to let you know I'm here if there's any questions.

Speaker 2 (06:18–06:43)

Thank you very much for appearing. I appreciate that. Sure. Um, so I did see, we did see the letter that you folks had submitted and, um, but there was, there was one thing I did note that the letter says that the lighting is supposed to be, what did you say?

Um, one hour before opening, and then it also says one hour after opening.

Speaker 6 (06:44–06:46)

That should be after closing. Sorry.

Speaker 2 (06:46–06:50)

I just want to confirm that that correction was right.

Speaker 6 (06:50–06:52)

Sorry, my typo.

Speaker 2 (06:52–07:16)

No, that's fine. We appreciate your work on this and getting it to a better size and a better design. than we would have had otherwise. Certainly.

So Bill, is there anybody else with a hand raised?

Speaker 5 (07:19–07:21)

No one else.

Speaker 2 (07:21–07:36)

OK. So I think at this point, we could head towards a decision on this. And so I'd be interested in Chris and Michael, what your thoughts are with this revised proposal.

Speaker 3 (07:41–08:03)

So the, I just want to make sure I'm. Understanding the assignment correctly, so the lighting, we're discussing a special permit for the lighting in a residential area. And that includes the new gooseneck lighting in addition to what we heard back in June.

Speaker 2 (08:04–08:57)

No, we're approving just the fact that it's a commercial sign in a residential area. Um, the lighting has been handled by the planning board and the site. The only thing it was, it said we had 2 things before because of the, they needed a variance because it was too close to the front. And and you had pointed out, you know, that this is a mobile location.

It's just something else that we could do because, you know, the standards for variance weren't really addressed. So now they've come back to have made the sign in the opposite side of the road, of the entranceway, and also no longer need our variance for the frontage. So all we are being asked to do is to approve a permit, a sign, a commercial sign in a residential district.

Speaker 3 (08:57–09:02)

I don't have any questions or problems with the proposed projects. Neither do I.

Speaker 2 (09:05–09:19)

Um, so I think we could probably head off to a decision on this. So. Except that we'll have to kill 20 minutes. I don't know, we can stretch it out, Heather.

I don't know. Please not.

Speaker 7 (09:19–09:25)

My dog is itching to get out for a walk, so I need to get out for a walk with the dog.

Speaker 8 (09:25–09:26)

We can take a break.

Speaker 7 (09:26–09:31)

I can go back to the boat and get dinner. She's at the door. I can hear her. She's ready to go.

Speaker 3 (09:31–09:34)

Okay. All right. Let's vote then.

Speaker 2 (09:34–09:35)

Can I have a motion, please?

Speaker 3 (09:36–09:39)

Uh, so moved 2nd motion.

Speaker 2 (09:39–10:15)

Thank you. So, what we are just whatever Michael was about to say, I second it. So we're approving the application by store master funding LLC for a relief from the zoning bylaw provisions to allow a commercial sign in a residential zone. And with the conditions that have been established by the site plan review committee, and the planning board permit that you folks got.

All in favor of that I. And I congratulations Heather. Perfect. Thank you.

Thank you for working with us.

Speaker 4 (10:15–10:29)

Well, thank you for the suggestions too, because sometimes, you know, we get focused on 1 thing and then it just. you know, they just move forward with one idea. So it was very helpful to have the suggestions and I'm glad we could, we could work it all out. Great.

Speaker 2 (10:29–10:31)

Great. And congratulations on the school.

Speaker 4 (10:32–10:34)

Oh, thank you. Thanks. Have a nice rest of the summer.

Speaker 2 (10:35–10:36)

Thank you.

Speaker 4 (10:36–10:37)

Thank you.

Speaker 2 (10:37–11:18)

And then I would take a vote to adjourn the hearing on, um, on this, uh, on the application for store master funding. Yeah. Second. All in favor?

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

So our next hearing is scheduled for 7.30, and that's on Berlin Avenue is the next one. So we can't start that one yet. Does somebody want to volunteer to do the decision for the sign one? I'll do it.

Thanks, Michael.

Speaker 9 (11:19–11:21)

That means I get to do a longer one later. So thanks, Michael.

Speaker 3 (11:22–11:28)

I feel responsible for all the rigmarole on this application anyway.

Speaker 9 (11:28–11:32)

You shouldn't. You and I were, I think, simpaticos on that.

Speaker 3 (11:33–11:53)

Yeah, I think, yeah. Kevin, I don't know if this is an appropriate time to ask this of you, but, you know, as I kind of go through my daily life in town, you know, I come across other people who are lawyers and who I think. Could be a good fit for this board.

Speaker 2 (11:53–11:54)

Yeah.

Speaker 3 (11:54–11:57)

Are we looking for additional members?

Speaker 2 (11:57–12:26)

Well, I mean, I don't think it's a bad idea. Um, you know, um, uh, to have, I'd like to, we had been looking at one or two. Um, and so, um, Liz Dylan is the one who appoints them, but certainly with our, you know, with looking for us to have input. So if you would want to be speaking to somebody or two people or whatever that are interested in serving, that would be great.

Speaker 3 (12:27–12:29)

Yeah, I'll keep my ears open and give us a thought.

Speaker 2 (12:30–14:25)

Yeah, I didn't send along, you know, send along a name and a resume and, you know, I'll forward it off to off to list. We are looking at October 14th for that training session on the new zoning rules for variances that Carolyn Murray is going to be giving to us. But I'm also keeping an eye on the economic development bill, which was supposed to be signed by July 31st and of course wasn't, because there are more changes in that one. Um, uh, including site plan review, um, uh, allowing duplexes as a right, um, allowing housing on religious properties.

And interestingly enough, a requirement that everybody attend training sessions. That would be put together by the executive office of housing and livable communities. So, we'll get around to that and then 2029. yeah, I think I'll be retired by then.

But yeah, but yeah, that was sort of an interesting and for not just for us for the planning board. So that would be an interesting operation, I think. Yeah, interesting. Yeah.

But I mean, I think the biggest thing for us, obviously, is the changes on the bearings. Yeah. And so it would be great to get a good explanation for that. There's a real State Bar Association seminar maybe in a week on the same thing with Susan Murphy, and I can't remember who else.

So I've signed up for that. But I think you have to be a member. And which of course you guys are.

Speaker 3 (14:25–14:33)

I think I was at one point, but definitely not right now.

Speaker 2 (14:33–14:43)

Yeah, no, I didn't think that was the case. So I'll just get whatever materials or whatever they put out and send that along.

Speaker 9 (14:44–14:49)

I feel like the odd man out is a technology lawyer.

Speaker 2 (14:49–14:56)

Yeah, I know. You have to get like a translator to what I'm talking about.

Speaker 9 (14:56–15:00)

What are these? What are these same footprints that you're speaking of?

Speaker 2 (15:00–15:24)

Yeah. Yeah, it is pretty funny. It's cult. It's totally a cult.

I understand that. But. Uh, yeah, so, I mean, as I said, it is, they sort of changes definitely affect the, um, the next 2 applications that we have. So.

Speaker 3 (15:24–15:28)

The changes are in effects that they were immediate.

Speaker 2 (15:28–15:38)

They were in the budget. There's no waiting period for those. So, yeah, so if you guys want to take a break and come back in 15 minutes, whatever.

Speaker 3 (15:39–15:43)

Yeah, I'm going to do that in a bit.

Speaker 1 (15:43–15:44)

All right.

Speaker 2 (15:54–18:00)

Good evening, I'm calling to to order the hearing on application case number 2912. It's the application of Lauren Kenny and Patrick Kenny at 2 Berlin Avenue. Their attorney, Christopher Harrington, has joined us this evening. Their application is dated July 17, 2026, and they're seeking a special permit to build a single story, 15.5 foot by 15 foot right side addition to the existing structure.

The property is located in a residency zoning district. The proposed work would be built 8.3 feet from the rear lot line, whereas our town bylaw Article 4, Section 275-4.1, Subsection B requires 30 feet or 30 percent depth of the lot, which would be 13.5 feet on rear setback. We have received with the application a memo from Chris Harrington, a plot plan of land showing the proposed addition to Berlin Avenue prepared by the Deposit Valley Survey Associates dated April 22nd, 2026. Um, and letters of support from Tracy, Dylan at 1, 0, 1, quantum Marie Griffin at 1, 0, 8, quantum at 1, 10, quantum and Susan and Jim Bertram at 6, Berlin.

And so, uh, we would ask Mr Harrington to, uh, first of all, say, first of all, who's on the hearing for this, um, Kathleen O'Donnell as chair, my co members are introducing themselves. And, uh, thank you for joining us, Mr Harrington.

Speaker 10 (18:01–21:41)

Thank you, Madam chair. Uh, for the record, Christopher Harrington, I'm the attorney representing the homeowner. My law office is at 21 McGrath highway in Quincy. And, uh, this is the first time I've appeared before the Milton board of appeals.

So, uh, thank you for being kind to me and hearing my case tonight. Um, this is a, it's an application for a special permit. It's an existing nonconforming house with an existing nonconforming lot. And, uh, as the, as the chairwoman stated, we are asking to put to build a one-room, one-story addition on the right-hand side of the house.

The back wall of the house will violate the rear yard setback. It should be 13.5 feet, and I think it's 8.6 feet. So we are proposing to do an extension, you know, an extension, you know, beyond the existing building envelope of the house, which, of course, is why we're here for a special permit. In the area where we're building this deck, this addition, there is a deck there.

The rear line of the deck lines up with the location of the rear line of the addition, so the addition isn't any closer to the back lot line than the deck is today. As I said, it's a one-room, one-story addition. It's a relatively small 233 square foot addition. We think the size and scale of this proposal are reasonable and appropriate for the size of the lot and for the existing neighborhood.

In my memorandum, I incorrectly identified the street as West Squanam Street. You'll have to forgive me for that. I grew up in Quincy, and I've always called that street West Squanam Street, and I didn't realize it was just Squanam Street once you passed into Milton. Yeah, so again, As all of you know, West Squanton Street is a very busy road, especially at rush hour.

She's proposing this addition on the right-hand side of the house, which is the side of the house that's away from the street, where it's maybe a little bit quieter and a little less chaotic and a much better location to build a family room. We believe that what she's asking for complies with the Milton bylaw. We believe that desired relief can be granted to her without substantial detriment to the public good and derogating for the purpose and intent of this ordinance. This room, my client is a single mother.

She's the mother of five-year-old twins. She's not on the call with us tonight because she was unable to get someone to watch the kids for her while to get on the Zoom call and 7.30 is their bedtime. That's why she's not here with us right now. She wants to build this room so that she can enjoy her home and have a family room off the kitchen on her first floor, be able to have the kids in that family room and playing while she's in the first floor, cooking meals and taking care of all of her housework.

I know that you have the survey as well as the architectural plans. uh, self evident what's on them. It's just that one room on the right hand side of the house. Um, if you wanted me to go through those plans, I'd be happy to.

I'm not sure that that's necessary.

Speaker 2 (21:42–21:50)

Well, I think you should put the play if you can share the plans. I think that would be good for people that may be watching, you know, may not have gone on the website.

Speaker 10 (21:51–21:51)

Okay.

Speaker 2 (21:52–21:58)

I didn't, I didn't realize if anybody was watching, but I haven't asked that question, but on the assumption that somebody is,

Speaker 10 (21:59–22:07)

I have the plans on my desktop, so if the moderator wants to allow me to share the screen, I can show those plans.

Speaker 5 (22:08–22:10)

You should be able to share.

Speaker 10 (22:26–22:56)

So this is the survey of the property. Uh, right here in the bold area is the room that's proposed 15 and a half feet by 15 feet on the right hand side of the house. And, um, the existing deck that is there now, uh, is also eight, 8.3 feet off the back property line. So that's, that's the line where the deck is now.

And, um, and again, that's, that's the proposal. It's a, it's a relatively modest proposal.

Speaker 2 (22:57–23:02)

You're using the same footprint as the existing deck?

Speaker 10 (23:04–23:50)

Yes. It's not the exact same footprint. The deck that's there now is less than 10 feet on the side property line. That's a little bit closer to the property line on the right-hand side.

We're pulling it back a bit so that it complies with the 10-foot setback on the right-hand side. That's improving that slightly. But the rear setback line of the deck is the same as what's proposed. These are the architectural plans.

You can see on the right-hand side, the deck here, and the room that's proposed on this side.

Speaker 2 (23:52–23:58)

Yeah, we're still on the plan of land that shows the addition. Were you showing a new plan?

Speaker 10 (23:58–24:37)

Sorry. Sorry about that. I was looking at it on my screen. These are the architectural plans.

You can see there's the deck that's there now and the proposed room being added on the side. This plan is the floor plan, which shows the proposed room right here. It's just a relatively small family room on the right-hand side. The red area here is the area where the deck is.

Speaker 9 (24:40–25:29)

Okay. Okay, may I ask a question, Madam Chair? Yes. Yeah.

So that I understand, on the side, on the, I'm thinking about the first plan that you showed, survey that you showed, so the footprint for purposes of the, the addition, the room, is basically being pushed a little bit away from the street, but that's where the proposed driveway expansion is. Is that right? In other words, you're replacing that land with a driveway?

Speaker 10 (25:32–25:35)

No. Okay. This is the proposed room right here.

Speaker 9 (25:36–25:36)

Yeah.

Speaker 10 (25:37–25:48)

and the driveway is in front of this room. Then there's 10 feet to go along the side of the room before the property line on the right-hand side. I see.

Speaker 2 (25:53–26:00)

Yeah, because I think that flat plan shows it as creating a new driveway over there.

Speaker 9 (26:00–26:02)

Yes, this proposed driveway expansion.

Speaker 10 (26:04–26:37)

Yeah, that is the plan that was submitted to the building inspector when the building permit was applied for. That was the one that came back. So that was the plan that I submitted to you. I don't know if that parking space is lawful.

I'm not sure if you're allowed to have a parking space that's within that setback to the side lot line. And if that's the case, then we certainly amend the application and just not have that approved as part of it.

Speaker 2 (26:37–26:44)

Well, I mean, at the moment, the only application, the only thing you're asking for from us is the relief on the rear.

Speaker 10 (26:44–26:45)

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (26:45–26:58)

And so when you submit your plan, whatever to the building inspector, um, you know, I would suggest taking off that existing, you know, the expansion of the driveway.

Speaker 10 (27:00–27:13)

Okay. Yeah, I was, uh, I, I wasn't certain. If that parking space needed relief, it was on the plan, but there wasn't anything mentioned in the denial letter about the parking.

Speaker 2 (27:13–27:21)

Yeah, I mean, well, I think it's, you know, it's, it's, it's already, you've already got a driveway in the front that goes out that far. Right?

Speaker 10 (27:21–27:21)

Yes.

Speaker 2 (27:22–27:44)

Yes. And speaking of somebody in the neighborhood, I'm not located that far away from this property. And thinking about where my driveway is, it's right on the property line. So apparently that's a common practice.

But yeah, I mean, because the only relief that we can give you is what you've asked for, which is on the rear line.

Speaker 10 (27:47–28:03)

Okay, thank you. And these are the elevations, obviously on the lower right-hand corner, what the house will look like when it's done. And on the lower left-hand corner, you can see in red, which is where the deck is now.

Speaker 2 (28:04–28:10)

Yeah. OK. Michael, do you have any questions?

Speaker 3 (28:11–28:17)

So part of this project is to turn a one-story house into a two-story house. Is that right?

Speaker 10 (28:17–28:23)

This house is currently a two-story house. It's a full two-story house today.

Speaker 3 (28:27–28:40)

The only reason I'm asking is I'm looking at the Google Street View and it just appears to be a one-story house. Does it go downhill in the backyard or something?

Speaker 10 (28:42–29:11)

When I was first engaged for this project, the first thing I did was to print off the information from the town of Milton's assessors records. The picture that's on the town of Milton's site still shows a one and a half story cape, which is what the house was, but it's now a full two story home. Everything that's on the elevations is there today, except the room that we're proposing on the right hand side.

Speaker 11 (29:11–29:17)

I must be, Google must have an old photo. That's fine. Thank you. That's the only question I have.

Speaker 2 (29:22–29:30)

Um, Bill, is there anybody with a hand raised. In the audience listening.

Speaker 5 (29:31–29:33)

No, right now.

Speaker 2 (29:33–30:35)

Okay. Um, yeah, you're right. I'm even on Zillow. It's only as a 1 story.

Oh, weird I think they would have caught that by now. Um, so. I'm sort of happy with the idea that you're bringing the building sort of in the deck back away from the side yard. I do note that we have gotten support letters from people on Swanton and also I think importantly from the family that's located right next door on Berlin has sent a letter in support of this application.

And so I'm in line to go ahead and approve this. I'm interested in your thoughts, Chris and Michael.

Speaker 9 (30:37–30:43)

I don't have other questions, and I don't have any. I don't think I have any concerns about the application.

Speaker 3 (30:46–30:46)

Same here.

Speaker 2 (30:49–30:53)

Um, so Mr Harrington, is there anything that you wanted to add?

Speaker 10 (30:54–31:24)

Uh, no, I think you've, you've said everything I was, I was going to mention that, but you beat me to it that the, um, the abutters that the abutters that, uh, have submitted letters in favor of the other direct about us to the property, which is, is great that they're in favor of it. And the other abutters who submitted letters are people who are directly across quantum street. So, The letters of support that my client got are really the closest people and the people who are really most affected by it.

Speaker 2 (31:28–31:58)

I would be inclined to have a motion to see whether we would approve the application for a special permit to allow this deck to be replaced by a single-story 15.5 by 15-foot right-side addition to the house at 2 Berlin Road, and that would be no less than 8.3 feet from the rear lot.

Speaker 11 (31:58–31:59)

So moved.

Speaker 2 (32:00–32:04)

Second. Second. All in favor?

Speaker 11 (32:04–32:06)

Aye.

Speaker 2 (32:07–32:34)

Aye. Aye. So congratulations Mr. Harrington and to your client.

that we've decided that yes, the relief should be granted. I don't think there's any substantial detriment to the neighborhood, and I think it's slightly improved by the fact that you've pulled the deck away from the side yard. I'm appreciative of the support that your client has received from her abutting neighbors. That's always very helpful.

Speaker 10 (32:36–32:37)

Thank you very much.

Speaker 2 (32:39–32:55)

Um, and so, um, we'll be drafting the decision and, um, and, uh, setting it off to the town clerk for approval, as you know, and then you'll have 20 days before you can record it at the registry of deeds. Thank you very much.

Speaker 10 (32:56–32:58)

I appreciate your time. All the members. Thank you.

Speaker 9 (32:59–33:01)

Thank you. I'm sure I'm happy to drop this.

Speaker 2 (33:01–33:02)

Okay.

Speaker 9 (33:02–33:07)

Thank you. I'll do the next one. That's that's why I volunteered.

Speaker 2 (33:07–33:14)

Yeah, yeah. And thank you very much. Mr. Harrington.

And as I said, give your congratulations to your client.

Speaker 10 (33:15–33:17)

Thank you very much. Have a good night. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (33:18–34:05)

Thank you. And so I have a motion to adjourn the hearing on, uh, on, uh, to Berlin road. So moved second. Okay.

So for future reference to Mr. Donnelly, to the rest of us, is that when we are scheduling many hearings on one night, we don't need to allow for the time for that. These people can be delayed. I mean, I've been at sign boards for other towns where they just load them all in like 15 minutes apart.

And so somebody starts later, that's just the way it goes. And then we avoid this now 10 minute wait to the next one.

Speaker 9 (34:06–34:11)

Could we have them all at 7 and just take them in whatever order we want?

Speaker 2 (34:12–34:36)

I don't know. I don't think so. I think they, you know. We do them, we set them 5 minutes, 10 minutes apart, you know, without a problem, but yeah, half an hour is probably a bit generous.

Although, I mean, as I said, you can go on for some time, you know, for hours arguing about something, but not for these. And.

Speaker 5 (34:39–34:40)

Has raised his hand if you're.

Speaker 3 (34:42–34:49)

Um, yeah, that's what I was going to say. If they're all here, we do we have to wait or I guess we do. I think it's open meeting.

Speaker 2 (34:49–35:00)

Yeah, it is. It's cheating to sort of start ahead of time and then finish by 8. did you have something to say?

Speaker 12 (35:01–35:59)

Well, I was obviously I have the 8 o'clock hearing and, uh, as a. Frequent practitioner before this board and the planning board. I can tell you that the planning board schedules their hearings 15 minutes apart. And that's helpful because if one hearing, you know, they generally take more than 15 minutes but As here, you've got a, you've got a gap and, um, I think it'd be helpful to go even 5 minutes apart or 10 minutes apart because you just, you know what the order is and you're ready to go.

And when the next one's up and I think it's more efficient use of everybody's time. Um, I'm not sure you could. Uh, schedule them all for 7 and then figure out which 1 you want to hear unless you post, unless you put out an agenda as to which 1 was going, which order. That's fair.

But I, I do agree that it'd be appropriate to schedule them more closely together.

Speaker 2 (36:00–36:03)

It was such a rare occasion that we really didn't know what to do.

Speaker 12 (36:03–36:18)

So, no, it's, well, it's, it's usual that these, the, that the zoning board has scheduled them at half hour intervals. And I've had occasions where you wait, something ends quickly and you wait a little bit of time.

Speaker 2 (36:22–36:32)

Yeah, I mean, as I said, I think my experience in other towns has been, you know, it's 15 minutes and as I said, people have to wait. So.

Speaker 12 (36:33–36:44)

Anyway, I think the only rule is you have to schedule public hearing for a time certain particular time when they before which they can't start.

Speaker 2 (36:49–38:13)

Anyway, so we are waiting for nine minutes before your next next one. So people could take a break and come back if they want. I'm calling to order the hearing for case number 2913. It's the application of Thomas and Jesse Daugherty at 247 Adams Street.

They're being represented this evening by attorney Nick Corcoran. Their application was dated July 22nd, 2026, and they're seeking a variance to build a 21 by 24 foot single-story detached garage at the front of the property on 247 Adams Street. The property is located in a Residence A zoning district, and the proposed structure would be built 32 feet from the front lot line, whereas our bylaw requires under Article 4, Section 275-10.2, front yards, requires a 40-foot front setback. I see that Mr.

Corcoran has signed on. Presiding the members of this hearing are me as chair and gentlemen introduce yourselves.

Speaker 9 (38:15–38:15)

Sorry.

Speaker 2 (38:22–38:23)

Michael Brown is muted.

Speaker 5 (38:29–38:31)

Apologies, Michael Brown.

Speaker 2 (38:32–39:35)

Thank you. I see that joining us, we have Mr. Daugherty and as I said, Mr. Corcoran representing Mr.

Daugherty. Mr. Corcoran, I just wanted to say that in the application files that we have on the website is the property card issued by the assessors, the plan of the garage, a plan of an addition that was done in January of 2000, a plan of land of number 247 Adams Street and number 58 Churchill's Lane in Milton, Mass., done by Hoyt Land Surveying in March 31, 2021, and an addendum provided by Mr. Corcoran dated July 31, 2026.

A plot plan done by Merrill Engineering dated June 6th, 2026, along with the traditional denial letter issued by the building inspector dated July 15th, 2026. Mr. Corcoran, do you want to explain what's going on?

Speaker 12 (39:36–39:41)

Yes, thank you. If I can share screen, I can show a couple of images and it will be helpful.

Speaker 5 (39:49–39:53)

You should be able to share that.

Speaker 12 (39:53–40:04)

Thank you. Now, I've just got to get to the right. Can you see that?

Speaker 8 (40:06–40:06)

Yes.

Speaker 12 (40:07–43:33)

This is taken from the town's website, the maps online website. 247 Adams Street is a long, fairly narrow, a lot that runs downhill from Adams Street to the rear. There's a mansion-style dwelling located here. Then as you enter the site from the left-hand side, there's a driveway down to the rear to a pool house and a pool.

The thing that's significant about this image and The next one, which is a little more close up, is the dramatic elevation change that exists on this property. The elevation at Adams Street in that top left corner of that site is elevation 120, and it drops down below elevation 60. It's a 60-foot elevation change. The proposed location of the garage is this front right section here, where you can enter the site via a circular driveway and enter into the garage which would face towards the driveway, two cars, single-story, proximate to a single-story accessory garage structure that's directly across the property line next door, although it appears from a dimensional perspective.

that this garage may be compliant with the front yard setback of 40 feet. There's no room to put this garage here any further than 32 feet from Adams Street. We looked at whether you could place it to the rear, but you've got an elevation change of 110 at the elevation of the dwelling, down to 100 below it. And so that's a significant hill to walk up and down.

If you are Mrs. Daugherty or Mr. Daugherty and you have to park your car in a garage, you probably wouldn't use the garage. So I think the only place to locate it is here.

And the idea is that you would, oops, As you can enter the site from Adams Street, the garage would be in this location, two doors facing the driveway. You can see not only the property line, between this property and 241 is a significant amount of foliage that buffers between the two properties. So the notion that there would be much of an impact, I think, is pretty insignificant. And it's pretty clear, when you really look at the elevation issues here, that the topography is such that it makes it physically difficult a practical difficulty to use the new lingo of the variance section.

It would be very practically difficult to locate a garage anywhere other than in this front right corner. And so with that, I'd open it up to questions from the board.

Speaker 2 (43:38–43:47)

Um, I noticed that, um, we didn't did you contact the butter? Do we have support from the butter for this?

Speaker 12 (43:48–43:51)

I don't have letters time. I know you've spoken to neighbors.

Speaker 13 (43:51–44:21)

Yes, I could address that if you want. My nice neighbors, Richard and Jane Howe, they are, as you referred to, that garage there, and immediately, they're at 241. And Richard came over, and you've now just shown the, I'll call it the pieces of wood on the ground, where it would be. And Richard's fine with that.

And that's what I know.

Speaker 2 (44:21–44:26)

Okay. Chris or Michael?

Speaker 3 (44:29–44:30)

I don't have any questions.

Speaker 9 (44:33–44:34)

Madam Chair, you asked mine.

Speaker 13 (44:36–45:21)

Just for clarity, the nice neighbors on the other side, they are maybe, they are further away maybe, and downhill, and it really has no, they wouldn't even see, neither of them, neither Richard, because we share the evergreen rhododendron and tall pines on that side. And on the other side, they're actually quite far away. So they don't see it. And it is 60 feet from the tennis court, then you walk up, there's a swimming pool, And you're walking uphill.

It's wonderful. Don't get me wrong. It gives you exercise.

Speaker 2 (45:22–45:22)

There you go.

Speaker 12 (45:23–45:29)

It's a little cold in winter to park a car and then find your way up and down the hill.

Speaker 2 (45:29–45:30)

Where do you park the cars now?

Speaker 13 (45:31–46:05)

We call that there, that center, that circular, we call that the roundabout. And consequently, if you look at the roundabout, you come in, and you'll see on the… As you first come in, if you turn left immediately, you can… And here it's…

So not right, but turn left on the other side, you can just… set your car there. Now, if someone wants to come in and then drop the newspaper or the, you know, whatever the package is, they can come in on the right side, turn around, go left and go out or something.

Speaker 2 (46:08–47:10)

Oh, okay. Well, you know, until recently, we would have had different standards for variances. And I think of Your council provided a helpful memo about those changes. The practical difficulty is now a consideration, which wasn't one before.

I think you've demonstrated certainly the drop in the elevation and I'm certainly familiar with the property. I think the practical difficulty has been demonstrated. I was curious, I don't know whether anybody knows, how many other garages are on Adams Street in those same locations? I'm thinking that there are other situations along the road that have that same layout where the garage is on the road ahead of the house.

Speaker 12 (47:12–47:23)

I know that at 255, this front area is a garage. I represent them in a different matter before this board. some time ago.

Speaker 13 (47:25–47:43)

Just on the other side of the street, you're not 255, but see on the other side, that's the garage right there. If you go up a little bit further, you'd see. But that one is on the corner, so it's a little different.

Speaker 12 (47:44–48:37)

The other issue is that our zoning is interesting in that a detached garage, has separate setback requirements than an attached garage. Attached garage is deemed to be part of the dwelling, and the dwelling setbacks are what control. In this case, it'd be 30 feet. But in most cases, and certainly in the neighborhood that I lived in on Morton Road, there were lots of small detached garages in the rear of the properties.

They had a long driveway to a small detached garage and they were set back. I think that for valid reasons, the towns established zoning with separate setback for detached garages so that they were further back generally from the street than otherwise.

Speaker 2 (48:42–48:46)

Chris and Michael, do you have any other questions or comments?

Speaker 11 (48:46–48:48)

I don't.

Speaker 2 (48:50–49:56)

Um, so, I mean, we had a situation, you know, we were on 1 recently where we had a garage situation in another part of town where, you know, the, the property configuration, you know, certainly. Propose the proposed garage location was a much better situation than what they currently had. And I certainly think that this property with with this with the elevation drop and the idea that you're going to be walking up a pretty narrow. Driveway in bad weather doesn't make much sense to me.

So, and I, as I said, with the relaxed standards for the variances, I don't think that this is a substantial detriment to the, to the neighborhood. I would suggest for my own comfort that. we would have a condition that the existing landscaping along Adams Street and along the property line with the abutter be maintained to the extent possible. I don't know whether anybody else feels that that condition would be useful or appropriate.

Speaker 9 (49:58–50:02)

I don't have an objection to it. I think it's fine.

Speaker 2 (50:04–50:16)

It sounds like Mr. Dardy and Mr. Horcring, would that be acceptable to just say that you had to maintain that shrubbery along the line, the sideline with your neighbor at 241?

Speaker 13 (50:18–50:49)

This is Tom Dardy. That's fine. If you look at the, well, I just want to be very clear that there's a very old Literally, you talk about Adams Street, there's a really old tree right at the corner when you come in. And that is going to have to, that's going to have, not on this one, there you go.

Oh, that one, yeah. That's been losing big limbs and that's going to have to come down because it's dangerous.

Speaker 2 (50:49–50:51)

Yeah, no, yeah, that's right.

Speaker 13 (50:51–51:05)

But with regard to all the foliage and the evergreen that's there, oh my, wouldn't it? Yes, I'm happy to say that we need to and should, and Richard, I would say too, keep that and be happy with it.

Speaker 2 (51:09–51:37)

I think that's fine with me. I mean, I wasn't really that tree doesn't provide a whole lot of screening anyway. I mean, it's just, you know, it's, uh, but the, I, I think, you know, to have the, you know, the, the protection, you know, from the street a little bit with the existing shrubs or just maintain screening of any, I'm not going to tell you what you have to put there, but, um, I, I, I'd like to sort of maintain that existing screening to the extent possible.

Speaker 12 (51:37–51:48)

Yes. Yeah. I think as long as the condition is to the extent possible, I think that's a reasonable condition.

Speaker 2 (51:48–51:52)

Is there anybody that has a hand raised that wants to speak?

Speaker 5 (51:58–51:59)

No, there are none.

Speaker 2 (52:00–52:08)

Okay. Um, I guess we didn't advertise this enough to have such a ribboning, you know, turnout neighbors didn't show up.

Speaker 13 (52:09–52:20)

Yeah, well, I told Richard and us, but some may be busy.

Speaker 2 (52:20–52:27)

So, um, I would be inclined to somebody want to make a motion on this application.

Speaker 9 (52:29–52:32)

I'll move to accept the application with the condition that you stated.

Speaker 2 (52:32–52:53)

2nd, anybody 2nd. All in favor. Signify by saying, I, I. 3 0.

I'll do this, I'll do this decision. Since it's my turn.

Speaker 12 (52:54–52:59)

Will this be the board's first decision under the new variance standard?

Speaker 2 (52:59–53:04)

Yes, it will. Well, I don't know. Maybe Ginny has done some under hers. I'm not sure.

Speaker 12 (53:04–53:07)

She can't do variances, can she? I don't think so.

Speaker 2 (53:07–53:43)

But yeah. Yes, it would. So I'll have to be really careful. I can't just rubber stamp something that I've done 27 times.

I'm going to have to come up with new language. That's very distressing. But thank you very much. I think the information that you provided was really helpful, certainly to show the existing conditions on the site and the difficulty of putting it anywhere else on a narrow lot with a deep fallback.

Thank you very much, Mr. Daugherty for appearing.

Speaker 13 (53:44–53:45)

Thank you all for all your work.

Speaker 2 (53:46–54:09)

Um, and so, um, I would say congratulations and I'll do a draft, um, probably within the next, uh, obviously within the next two weeks and, um, and, you know, send it off to, um, to your attorney to look at before it's finalized. Um, and, uh, with that, I would take a motion to close the hearing.

Speaker 9 (54:11–54:13)

Second.

Speaker 2 (54:13–54:33)

All in favor. Aye. Aye. And also to adjourn our session this evening.

And with thanks to everybody, including Mr. Daugherty to get this all organized, and to the other members on the board. And I said once again to Mr. Daugherty and Mr.

Forefront.

Speaker 12 (54:34–54:35)

Thank you. Thank you.

Speaker 2 (54:35–54:36)

Thank you.

Speaker 12 (54:36–54:39)

Enjoy the rest of the summer. Thanks, everybody. Take care.

Speaker 2 (54:39–54:40)

Thanks, everyone.

Speaker 12 (54:41–54:42)

All right. Have a good night.

Speaker 2 (54:42–54:42)

Bye.

Speaker 3 (54:42–54:46)

Back to the book. Enjoy.

Speaker 1 (54:46–54:47)

Bye bye. Thanks.