Board: School Building Committee

Date: 2023-12-18


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:41–02:13)

I'll call the meeting to order. So, what is it, December 18th, School Building Committee for the Town of Melbourne. We just do a typical roll call, so I'll just call you out. Scott Tereshek, present.

Mike Zulis, here. Yeah, and trying to work here. Also, this is like we're joining our OPMs, Sean Burke, and Seamus, I gotta get your last name. Seamus O'Connor.

O'Connor. Got it. Not a word from this one. That's right.

And Mark Lauren. Thanks. Sorry about that, sir. And also the facilities director for the town, Mr.

Chris Hayden. So that kind of kicks us off. On the agenda, we reserve the first 15 minutes of every meeting to have a citizen speak. So at this point in the meeting, we ask if you are here to speak.

Can you say your name and your address? And let me get your comments to three minutes. So leave it with that. We'll start with anybody in the room if you're here for CitizenSpeak.

Timothy, how are you?

Speaker 2 (02:13–02:28)

Okay, where would you have me on? Right here? Right here is fine, right? Yes, sir.

Thank you all very much. Good evening. I hope everybody's doing well. Belated Happy Hanukkah and Merry Christmas to everybody.

Speaker 3 (02:28–07:41)

I just wanted to touch base. After the November 13th meeting in my travels, of course, I had my own meetings that night. I had a couple of constituents call in who all mentioned certain things to me, the November 13th meeting, so I just thought it'd be helpful. I jumped in with you tonight and briefly, of course, I know you have a lot of serious things to take up, but a couple of things that I think will go smoothly going forward.

It was said at the last meeting on the rough draft that I received on October 5th on a Thursday night. It was concluded on August 6th, 8th, 6th. I actually received it on Thursday night, the 5th, and right away, of course, I dutifully the next day forwarded it to Senate Council. They came back, of course, with the red lines and suggestions, in which case we forwarded right away to the committee.

It was said, and I just want to clear this up, that we can only take up these articles of legislation, these home rule petitions, in December and July. And actually, that's incorrect. We can take this up at any time during the calendar year. Any time at all.

It was also said that various subcommittees, of course, the bill would have to traverse subcommittees to get to the cert process. So for those reasons, we couldn't get it done in December. We actually don't have subcommittees in the legislative process. We have joint committees.

Now, there is a 15-step process. On October 17th, I directed my chief of staff to send a memo to Senator Administrator Milano, which he did, which I have copies of, which I'll leave here for the record. It outlines essentially what is a 15-step legislative process between both the House and the Senate. We can take up any type of legislation at any time during the calendar year.

does not matter as to what the month is. There is no month dedicated to any one month or any one topic. Also, it was also said that pretty much it's now between town council and myself, and obviously I look forward to working with each and every one of you. Until I receive a certified copy, we have yet to receive a certified copy, legislatively, legally, and officially, our hands are tied.

When I say our hands, I refer to the legislative delegation, Representative Driscoll, Representative Fulker-Oakley, and myself. As soon as we receive a certified copy of myself, right away, what we'll do is we'll forward it to the Senate Council, if it happens to be myself. Only myself, as a member of the Senate, can interact with Senate Council. And obviously, I'm more than happy for any constituent from my district to bring the talent to Senate Council to bear on any issue and any challenge and any question.

At which point, what's called a late-file. You know, we embark upon two-year sessions, and I know you're all aware of that. In January of our year, in this case 2023, we were sworn in on the first Wednesday after the first Monday, and believe it or not, that's how it's written in the Constitution. In February, we have a call bill filing.

If a bill is filed after that, it's a late file. And the first step, of course, is myself or any member of the noble delegation files the legislation. We have to get concurrence from the House Rules Committee and its chair and the Senate Rules Committee and its chair. I don't expect that will be a problem.

At which point, the Senate Clerk, the House Clerk, and the Senate President's Office and the Speaker's Office will direct it to a joint standing committee. And of course, I sent that email out, directed my chief of staff to one October 17th. And as I mentioned earlier, I'll leave that here for the record, several copies of it. It's been down seven months since May 8th, and I know you're all well aware of that.

It's highly unusual for a Home Rule petition not to have made its way to the legislature after seven months. So I know there's some outstanding issues. I presume that they're out, given that I haven't received them yet. And I've also been told, and what I've listened to, I've reviewed the tapes, that July is, you know, next July.

You wouldn't hope it would be done by then. In order for it to be done by July, I need that whole room petition certified. A certified copy or representative Driscoll or representative Fluker Oakley, but time is definitely the essence if we're looking at July as what the target is. So if there are any issues you'd like to talk to me or inform me about, please feel free to do so now or at a later time.

But seven months is definitely a long lapse of time in between an actual vote in town meeting and have it still not have made its way to the legislature. And of course, we see the rough draft, and I was more than happy to bring that to Senate Council and bring their talents to bear. But rough draft doesn't do anything for us in terms of the official process and our legal abilities to bring it forward. And Senate Council will not stop working on anything until they see a certified copy.

At my request, they're more than happy to advise and counsel, consult, but there will be no actual earnest work. Once we receive it, though, Senate Council and the various committees that this bill will traverse its way through, we will also engage EOA and various relevant state agencies. The legislature, of course, has its own process as well. So I just figured it would be helpful to jump in here today and pass along a few bits of information.

I appreciate it, Larry, for a few things. And obviously, I'm more than happy to answer any questions.

Speaker 1 (07:42–08:00)

Yeah, just information for you. The components of the bill of rule, as we understand it, that has to accompany the special legislation, namely the appraisals and the alternative analysis will be done probably by next week. Okay. So after that, we should have basically the components.

Speaker 3 (08:02–09:43)

And as I said, once we receive a certified copy, it can be filed at any time. It's not confined to any time period on the ballot. So any weekday. And this session will last until January of 2025.

We meet by constitution minimum every 72 hours. And obviously there are a lot of committee hearings and sessions in between. So whenever it's ready to go, please forward it to myself or Representative Driscoll or Representative Fluker-Oakley. And if it happens to be myself, I will file it.

And of course, I will invite my partners in the House of Reps to sign on as co-sponsors. And we'll, of course, inform the town and all relevant parties when there is a hearing. Every bill receives a hearing. And that's about it for tonight.

I know I'm interrupting what you have on your busy agenda, but I thank you all for the time. I just want to let you all know that this can be taken up at any time. It's not confined to any one month. But we do need a certified copy.

That's important for us to be able to start the process. It is a process, and I often say it's much like baseball. It's not an exact science. But it is a process that takes, in many cases, several months.

I've seen home rule petitions take about a year. And most home rule petitions do make it across the goal line and get to the governor. Not all, but obviously as a member of the legislative delegation, it's my job to shepherd any and all home rule petitions. But I thought it was very important that you folks are aware of that.

And you folks very kindly volunteer your time for our aware of it. But I thank you all very, very much. I hope you have a great Christmas.

Speaker 4 (09:44–10:24)

Just in terms of timing, my understanding is Town Council has been putting this forward and they were waiting for feedback from EOEA. They have that. My understanding is that it's ready to go. They were going to be in touch with your office.

So that could be imminent because they did get feedback from EOEA. They didn't make some revisions based on what you suggested. So the last I heard was that they're ready to go. So hopefully, hopefully, you know, as I said, the town council has kind of taken this and hopefully they'll be

Speaker 1 (10:24–11:16)

I was standing by we call the town council to go over this or it actually landed today. So, the draft legislation. I received the red lines from Senate Council myself. Oh yourself.

I apologize. Okay. And then also from EA. So we took the combination of those consolidated it down and have that kind of finalized.

In addition to that, as I mentioned, the appraisals that we do as part of the DEA's requirements and also the alternative analysis, which I drafted. Essentially, we're voting on the alternative analysis tonight. And then the appraisals, there were some minor comments, so we're asking them to wrap up by next week. Okay.

Speaker 3 (11:16–12:04)

In terms of timelines when it comes to the legislature, there are no guaranteed timelines. There are a few members of the State Senate right now who have Article 97s. that are, you know, they're chomping at the bit and they're working diligently to secure their passage. But as I said, it's in exact science.

So the process does take many months. And obviously, for the certified copy, the sooner would be the optimal situation. But I also know your folks are working hard, and I thank you for the opportunity. I will leave those copies behind that I sent by my direction.

My chief of staff said to Town Administrator Milano on October 17th, which outlines the process. And I thank you all for your time, and I hope everybody has a great Christmas and a happy new year.

Speaker 2 (12:04–12:08)

And thank you all very much for your time.

Speaker 1 (12:08–13:16)

Thank you. Okay, next, I don't see any other public here. So anybody online that has for citizen speaking. No one has their hand up.

I see any. On to agenda item number three, which is approval of our previous minutes. I don't believe those got Issued so we'll have to table that to our next meeting. Thank you all.

Welcome. So agenda item number four for old business and for a essentially the timeline. Um, so Sean, I'll turn it over to you if you kind of want to walk through what you've got already. Uh, so for, because we don't have a projecting TV tonight, if you log into the zoom, you'll be able to see it.

Let me share this so people can see it.

Speaker 5 (13:29–14:05)

All right. As part of the timeline is just the educational grant update for the district. Just a reminder that we did send out some draft process and just something that the school committee should be aware that exists. The architect that is going to help you through this process, but trying to figure out who's going to be involved in that process and drafting the ed plan and try to Provide around what is going to be expected them would be his hand.

So John 3 again. Yes.

Speaker 6 (14:06–14:30)

Just on that point, appreciate the documents that have been shared. They've been passed over to the superintendent, and we've been reviewing them, and the superintendent has been working with his internal team to identify folks to be a part of those reviews and begin the process based upon some of the draft plans you've shared, Sean. So thank you for that. That's great.

Speaker 5 (14:30–16:16)

If you have a team already developed, it'll just save a lot of time. RFS was available on December 5th. We did a survey on the 13th. deadline is set for the 20th.

Sometimes extended if you have a really good answer, you're welcome to but as far as the 20th is the cost in restrictions answered by the 29th. So we received a few questions. There's a couple We're going to talk about tonight and that other than that. It's pretty sure people understand the project and we're just working on getting there.

Is on the 12th, we expect them all to receive. So we get these, we're going to get the RFPs from the people proposing on the project on the 12th. And we have a meeting, our first meeting set on the 15th, which is the 12th of Friday. The 15th is the following Monday to try and go through and set up a shortlist.

And Sean and I talked earlier, whether or not that's too quick, and it may be too quick, but I think it might make sense to have that meeting anyway. Even if we spend a lot of time sitting together and reviewing those, If you come on Friday and then you say it's going to be a week from Monday. I'm all week long, would you come up with a Monday meeting so we can have a meeting time and certainly have another meeting but. There could be questions, there could be trying to get people to understand what they're supposed to be looking at and make sure everyone's on the same page.

I think there's a lot of value in having that meeting.

Speaker 1 (16:16–16:22)

So just to be clear, that meeting is for the subcommittee that's making the shortlist selection, not the entire school.

Speaker 5 (16:23–18:27)

It's going to be set up because you're going to pick a subcommittee of the school committee and members of the school district that are going to make the shortlist determination. So that would be a meeting for them and the full committee would not need to be in that one. We have it set for January 29th. If the timeline works, the time to interview is the week of the 29th.

So usually we look for 3. Some people do 4 or 5. It tends to get a little bit long if you get 5 people for the job. So we do think that 3 is probably better.

It's a good number. Try to hop in on those 3 top firms that you really want to interview. notice of intent and try to get contract negotiations done and get someone to contract and get going with the project. So just to repeat, we have 52 current plan holders, 52 people have requested.

Out of that, 36 are core architectural firms, 14 are specialty firms like Geotech or NEP or Landscape. We have one firm that's a data analytics. They pull every RFP and they have, you know, they send out this RFPs that are listed. And then one GCCM firm has pulled it.

A lot of them are heavy into the MSBA school in Massachusetts. It's names that we would hope to see and that we'd expect to see. So it's a good list and there's a lot of people interested in the project, which I think is great. We had 12 design firms, which is also the town administrator that is there.

We're there for about a half an hour. Do you want to be very similar to that? Not to see what we are looking at the trees, but just going through the process, going through the, just trying to lay out what the job is. Will here attended that?

And Nick was there as well.

Speaker 7 (18:28–18:28)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (18:33–18:49)

Yeah, we'll talk more about the process, you know, for the short list later on. But, you know, essentially for the timeline that Sean laid out, just seeing if anybody has comments or questions or anything like that.

Speaker 5 (18:49–19:07)

There's a link for a file share with the RFS. The drawings are on there. We issued addenda one, which is everybody who signed in at the conference hall, that's available. And all the firms know who else was there.

We provided that whole sign-in list.

Speaker 1 (19:07–19:16)

So the sign-in list, what it did is, if I understand you guys correctly, whoever pulled the RFS off, you created the list from that. And then whoever showed up physically signed.

Speaker 5 (19:16–19:34)

Signed in addition to that, but yeah, so that was that we sent out will include anyone who's pulled the drawings. Plus anyone who showed up at the walk there in the same firms, which just might have been a different person. So they signed in separately. Yeah.

Yeah. Got it. Any other questions?

Speaker 8 (19:35–19:39)

Just the. January 15th is Martin Luther King Day.

Speaker 5 (19:40–21:23)

My husband's birthday. I would find a time if that doesn't work for the subcommittee. I don't even know, can you have a subcommittee meeting on a public holiday? No.

So I would find time with that subcommittee. And around that day. So, design first know that it'll be a couple of the Tuesday or Wednesday people are available to have some communication with that group. Right.

procedure of how we go through designer selection. We know there's a matrix that we'll send out. We have a listing of what's important to different people on the committee and try to list everything that we can think of. The design selection, the town has voted and approved to have some sort of, it has a couple items of criteria, but on top of that it says, and then any criteria that the selection committee feels that it's important, put that on there as well.

You know, it's experience, active projects, 149 experience, the whole kind of laundry list of stuff that you'd see, which we would present to that committee, but other items that group would like to include as well. Everyone have a sheet that you design a selection. You can typically rank by numbers because the MSP doesn't allow that, but we can certainly do it here because it's not MSP. of the road and then just advantageous and then try to add up how many wins the most and see if there's any consensus there.

And then conversation from there.

Speaker 1 (21:23–22:04)

Yeah, so I think, you know, Chris, for you, I'm not sure if you're going in place of Peter Burroughs or not, but it's the list I got from Shelley was Peter Burroughs, John Redden, Bernadette Butler, and Heather. Apologize, I don't have my answer. But based on that, I know there's a lot of questions of, you know, what's the process, how we do it. So we'll talk about a little bit tonight, but what we'll do is, you know, when we talk about a gender item, we're talking about architectural selection services.

We'll dive into a little bit more and then finalize it. That's cool.

Speaker 5 (22:04–22:28)

So that's a basic timeline that we should talk to them, define what that subcommittee is, and make sure we have communication. And maybe before the interviews come in, it would make sense to have a meeting, even if it's a Zoom and online, just to understand what they're going to get prior to the package coming out. Because if there's any changes you want to make once you receive them, that's it. There's no opportunity to change the rules.

Speaker 1 (22:28–22:42)

Yeah, and we'll talk, we voted on the formation of that committee of what power be comprised, I think, two meetings ago. So we can just review that when we get to it. But in regards to the timeline or anything else, any comments, questions?

Speaker 5 (22:44–23:31)

timeline that we're looking at and it's just based on what our standard of feasibility study for an MSP project would be eight to nine months. So you could probably get your your feasibility done in July and then schematic design portion of that you can get done probably in October. And the question is how does that tie out against town meeting in the November election because I believe there was I think a desire to maybe entail the election for the overall override vote. So understanding when the work needs to be put in place, the timing to approve the ballot, the question, things like that.

What is the timing of that and how do we make sure we incorporate that correctly with the design, with the designers there?

Speaker 1 (23:33–24:29)

Yeah, so that one typically, correct me if I go wrong on anything here, Mike, but for, if we're doing a special town meeting, typically for the warrant to migrate its way through the warrant committee and stuff like that, we probably want an article a couple months ahead, right, to have that there. So what I think the need or the ask is going to be at that time is, you know, The article I think will, the text of the article we work on, I think the hardest number is going to be what that number is going to be, the hardest thing is going to be what that number is going to be of the article we all know would be for the construction of the school. What the number needs to be, I think, is one of the things we need to start working on once we onboard an architect. You know, when would they feel comfortable or you guys feel comfortable with their progress to start putting numbers to it?

Speaker 5 (24:30–26:03)

It sometimes depends for school projects. It depends on the way the project is laid out. Sometimes we'll do it after a feasibility study and people feel very comfortable. And sometimes it's after a schematic design.

And it just depends how much contingency you want to put in there and how many unknowns you have at that point. Working with the designers and making sure that they're comfortable with it as well, because we do not want to go and if we're not confident that the amount of money that you're requesting is the appropriate for the project and going back is not, we don't want to do that. We want to be right. We want to have an appropriate budget for the project that we're trying to do.

And I think by the end of this summer, we probably have a good number, and then we'll just have to get the comfort level of, is it good enough to go forward, or do we hold off? Those are the things we're going to have to think about as we go through this process and as we start negotiating the contracts with the architects, is the budget for them is above 50% of the full feasibility in schematic design, not to be a little better than that. So we have to figure out how their process lays out and whether or not sometime in between now and that next phase, you want to get some more money to kind of have them go beyond the feasibility into schematic design. The notion is how far do you want to go down that road before you have the article, before you have the land, right?

Before that's approved. So it's a decision the committee is going to talk to the architect about, but if you're comfortable moving forward, that's great. If you don't get the land, then you're moving into the next phase and spending the money to design some land that isn't going to be the desire of the committee.

Speaker 1 (26:03–26:04)

So it's something you have to think about.

Speaker 7 (26:04–26:05)

Yep.

Speaker 1 (26:05–26:28)

And the 50% number you were quoting there for funding is feasibility and schematic. All the numbers that we've put forward up to this point for additional funding is only for feasibility, not for the schematic design. Okay. And the schematic design takes us to roughly what percentage?

Like if you're talking design deliverables or something like that, probably 30%.

Speaker 5 (26:28–26:39)

You'll have a pretty good layout of the building, maybe rooms and things like that, but then you start getting into the details of finishes and how windows work and things like that. You know, you can score footage, you'll have layout, you'll have adjacencies.

Speaker 1 (26:40–26:48)

You know, it'll be a decent project, but you can't build a package. Not just for myself, but putting the number on it.

Speaker 5 (26:50–27:28)

Because you have basically one location and you have an idea of what you want to do, and obviously we need to talk to the design team and make sure we're receiving everything. Instead of that, typically you look at a bunch of different projects, add renos and things like that. And if that's off the table, then it could probably go a little bit further in the feasibility and the schematic design of the player. And then it's just a matter of budget because they're going to put, if you want to go faster, they're going to put tons more hours into it and get you there.

And they can certainly do that because they don't have to do all the studying of different plots and different options because you've already done that. 5 years of research and study that you've done as this committee and that's the spot right here.

Speaker 1 (27:29–27:39)

You want to talk about that on the lens? Well, you better. All right. Any other comments, questions?

Is that the new schedule that you just showed?

Speaker 5 (27:39–28:06)

Is that what you outlined to the architectural reviewers? Looking at the RFP, there are, there's probably more time in there than there is here. So we're going to, we'll do an addendum to them just to take a portion that is a pretty large portion of time to review all the different options they have and then tell them this is the one we want to go with. I think that goes away and then it becomes an option that looks more like this.

Okay.

Speaker 9 (28:07–28:41)

If we are able to advance to a higher. level of design by that October timeframe, the language for the article has already been submitted at that time. But we will, as my understanding, correct, that we'll still have an opportunity to amend that language as we were able to take that design and understand the dollars behind it more, because we'll be able to, you know, remove some doubt that's baked into the contingency dollars, but probably insert funds as we further understand the scope at that point.

Speaker 1 (28:41–30:39)

Yeah, so you're talking about, you know, so essentially the money that we have appropriated right now takes us a little bit past the feasibility study and into schematic design. I think that's a safe way to say it. I guess, I guess in an ideal scenario, we would be able to secure some additional funding to advance the design beyond that ahead of the time. So to do that, you're basically asking, to may dollars so may dollars yeah i mean the intent was to just make the ask to get us to the fall that's essentially what we're doing with the funding article the next on the agenda um supplemental funding in may it's kind of the you know the will of this committee um you know i think we need to look at it And as we onboard an architect, really figure out what they can do with the funding that we have allocated for them and see where it gets us.

And if that gets us to a point that we think. we'll have a hard enough number that we can put dollars to it to go for the full funding in the fall. I think that's two meetings ago, kind of where we're heading as a committee. That's the type of work I want all of us to start over the next couple of months, really dive into and start thinking about.

So the question is, if the question is, could we ask for more money in May? Yes. No, we'd have to put an article together probably February to figure out what that number should be and then present it. And I'm just going through the typical timeline for your May now meeting.

You have to get an article. It has to migrate through the committees, basically with a select board and then through the Warren Committee. And then we'd have to get ready for May for a presentation and ask and ask that we just did. So.

Not true.

Speaker 5 (30:41–31:25)

But, yes, I think the point of once it gets on board. Figure out what their schedule is and their phase ends, whether or not it makes sense, the ground running and they, you know, with a certain amount, we just come out of design before. the time that's going to be better. It's going to be a better estimate.

It's going to give you more, um, like assurity that the money you're asking for is the correct amount of money. And so it may make sense to do that, but I think in February, that's maybe one of the first conversations you have is about what day and let's backtrack from that November election to make sure that, um, we can support a number and actually say that the Warren article that you put forward is a valid number. Yeah.

Speaker 7 (31:28–31:47)

Any other questions regarding both situations we're probably drafting an article without a number in it, or. be there till the end of February with the architect.

Speaker 9 (31:47–31:55)

You know, they're brought on board in early February. It'll take us that long for them to figure out what we already know and what they don't have to do.

Speaker 1 (31:55–32:08)

And now we can shorten timelines and adjust the costs. So we might have to draft and submit and plug numbers as we go. It's probably a placeholder. Right.

Same thing might happen with November.

Speaker 7 (32:11–32:14)

Which I think that happens all the time, right?

Speaker 4 (32:15–32:33)

Yeah, I think so. I think there are times when you have an idea about direction and you try to get the process moving and get things through the warrant committee and make sure you have the number finalized before they do the final deal, I think that matters.

Speaker 1 (32:36–33:54)

I think it would be difficult to go in front of the warrant committee without a number just, you know, leaving it blank. So, you know, the quicker and, you know, we're going to be going. I think everyone realizes, you know, we move in pretty fast, you know, over the next months, getting our tech on board, getting them up to speed. Like you said, here's everything that's already been done.

Let them digest that and get in, you know, get into the project and get going. Anything else on timeline? kind of blends in to our next agenda item for old business item 4B, the funding article. So just an update.

We were able to secure a vote at the town meeting last week, I believe it was. for approval of our funding articles for $400,000. So we've got the additional funding request that has been approved. So that's good news.

It aligns with onboarding the architect for the funding that we've advertised. So outside of the previous conversations we already had regarding funding, any other questions or comments? hearing them, all right?

Speaker 9 (33:54–35:00)

I think we're going to surprise you. I think that 400K is going to get us a little further than we think, just because of the previous work that's been done. And I'm not saying we're going to stick to these, but technically we have some schematic design plans done, not very refined yet, not been brought very far, but we have a preliminary site plan, we have a preliminary building layout. Even if we don't go with the architect that did those, there's no reason we can't say, hey, this is what we're thinking.

And then once they give us some good reason why we shouldn't go in that direction, that should give us a leg up on getting this thing going. Hopefully. I think you're right, we're going to have to ask for someone to get some money. We're going to have to ask for a whole lot.

And I actually think once the architect's on board, we're going to have a better idea of what that number is, obviously, which I didn't see it mentioned. But, you know, when we get an architect on board, we're going to know what they expect to be paid for preliminary fiscal ad design all the way through, you know, all phases of the design and construction.

Speaker 1 (35:00–35:42)

So hopefully that'll help navigate that a little bit as well. And part of it in the RFS, when we issued the RFS, we also advertised what the dollar amount would be too. And I mean, so with the OPM, there was no advertisement of a dollar amount. It was basically, we'd have a negotiation after.

There was a discussion a couple of meetings ago coming to what that number was. and agreeing to that so that way the architects knowing who's bidding on it here's the budget we're asking you to do and here's what we're asking you to do for that budget so um you know I'm looking forward to, you know, having the interviews with the architects to kind of see what that number, how much, you know, they can get done and get them on board.

Speaker 5 (35:44–35:51)

Is that something that you want to send out to all the firms now, or is it something you'd rather hold and give it to them once they're on board?

Speaker 9 (35:51–36:04)

I think I'd wait until we get to the free, right. I'd wait until it was free. And I think, yeah, I think that I think it's worth sharing, you know, let them know what they think.

Speaker 5 (36:05–36:09)

And this is just a question I think you're probably best suited to answer.

Speaker 1 (36:10–36:19)

You're comfortable with that, knowing that one of those three, in all likelihood, may be the same group that generated those preliminaries?

Speaker 9 (36:21–36:53)

I actually think that's advantageous. That's a nice gentleman will tell you that's not unusual, especially working with a town that's done repeat work with architects, that that's sometimes that's the situation, you know, I work for a school firm, we would tend to get repeat work and even though we had to go through the whole process. We were already kind of going through that process ahead of time. People were doing the feasibility study.

So it's really not too unusual for that to happen in public work. In private work, it could be very unusual.

Speaker 5 (36:53–37:21)

You don't want to share anything. It's the public nature of this work, and it was made for the public funds. So that information is available if they push for it, if they watch even some of the meetings at a certain point. and packaging it up and sending it to them.

And I think you're right. Maybe you pick them to talk to and then provide them the information prior to their interviews so they can see what you're getting at and tell their interviews around.

Speaker 1 (37:22–37:52)

Yeah, that's going to be part of it. As you were talking about, Scott, is just getting them up to speed. The five years of work that we've done, how this is the one site that works for everything. And, you know, someone might be on an MSBA process where they want to do site evaluation.

They want to run around and look at the town to see if there's other stuff out there. And I'd like to focus them on, you know, this is the site we want to do. There's also incentive for the outside firms to kind of outdo the firm they know provided this work.

Speaker 9 (37:52–38:14)

Show them up, either be financially or, you know, we can do this better. This is how we can do this better. So it's nice to have a little competition. And that's the way it's supposed to be, and that's…

We're the only state in 50 states that does it this way, right? Mike, am I wrong? I didn't know. Yeah, other states just don't do it that way.

Speaker 4 (38:14–38:16)

Oh, I didn't know.

Speaker 9 (38:16–38:31)

It's unique to Massachusetts. They might do it that way in other states, but in some states, we're the only state that does it that way. Mike, thank you for not letting anybody leave last Monday night.

Speaker 1 (38:32–39:17)

It was a little surprising. So there was, for those of you who weren't familiar, a town meeting on the second night. So the town meeting was a Monday night. They couldn't do it the following night, so it was a week later on a Monday.

After some articles were heard, there was a motion to dissolve the meeting, which means basically they're not hearing any more articles. The closing meeting, it goes out. Mike was kind enough to make a friendly amendment to that to get a committee funding article on there. So about 10 o'clock, I had to run down to the podium, jump up, give the presentation.

And, you know, after that, the meeting dissolved. So it was interesting. Well, I was, I was a selector. I was a selector.

I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector.

Speaker 4 (39:17–39:45)

I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector.

I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector.

I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector.

I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector.

I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector. I was a selector.

I was a selector. I was a Yeah. Anything else on funding articles there.

Speaker 1 (39:46–42:14)

All right, all right, item, business item 4C, for, and just double checking, Sean, is there any other school building committee members in the attendees? Just Aqua or Selena. If you can promote him to analyst, just so he can speak. Joe Modern.

Thank you for the promotion. Any comments on the previous agenda items that you weren't able to speak to because you weren't a panelist? Nothing that adds value. Thank you.

All right. No problem. Thank you. All right, so item 4C.

And again, I'm doing a hand agenda on here because my computer died. Yeah, if you could just pull it up just so I can see. Sorry. I have talking about the land swap.

So it's very impressive. Yeah, I did it all from memory. So for the land swap right now, Perfect, yeah, possible vote too. Alternative analysis I sent out to everybody earlier today.

That alternative analysis was sent out beginning of September and basically got comments back, got yours, Scott. went through incorporated all those and added the appendices that were missing from the other executive summary or summary up front and stuff like that. So essentially for that, for the land swap, as Timothy mentioned earlier, there's certain components that have to accompany the special legislation. Alternative analysis is one of them.

Appraisals is the other one. So with the alternative analysis, our committee basically has to review it and come to a decision or vote to approve it. And then once we vote to approve it, you know, we'll have it approved. I'm not sure if the select board would need to approve it if they do.

If it wouldn't hurt. No, it wouldn't hurt. So, you know, just focusing on not the appraisals right now, but the alternative analysis, just see if anybody had any additional comments or edits they saw fit for it.

Speaker 2 (42:22–42:23)

Can you repeat that question? Yeah.

Speaker 1 (42:24–42:43)

So for the alternative analysis that was sent out earlier today, yeah, that was, you know, similar to the one that was sent out before, just with the updates to it and the appendices, basically just seeing if anybody has any comments or questions in addition to that. So basically something I may have missed or something.

Speaker 8 (42:44–42:53)

I would just ask that it be spellchecked. I think in the conclusion, there's an error. So just to thoroughly did the whole document.

Speaker 7 (42:53–43:05)

Yeah. But in regards to content or anything like that? No, I thought it was great. Okay.

Any other?

Speaker 1 (43:05–43:16)

So in the absence of that, it's basically just needs a motion to get approved.

Speaker 4 (43:17–43:26)

So I'll make a motion to approve the alternative analysis and to recommend the select board approval as well. I'll second. I'll second that motion.

Speaker 1 (43:28–43:34)

All right. Scott, you get to it, Mark. Actually, I'll give it to him.

Speaker 10 (43:34–43:34)

Sorry.

Speaker 1 (43:37–44:03)

Good point. Now that it's been moved and seconded, just see if there's, again, any other commentary or discussion before we head to a vote. Seeing none. All right, so we'll do a roll call vote just based on attendees.

Scott Teresheim? Yes. Mike Zulis? Yes.

Tim Lombard? Yes. Carrie Hurley?

Speaker 8 (44:03–44:03)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (44:04–47:05)

Glenn Hawthorne? Yes. Mark Lorien? You're on mute, Mark, maybe.

Yes. Thank you. Aqualung? Yes.

And Toronto Ward? Yes. And Dr. Miranda is not online, right?

Just making sure. All right. The other portion that came with that is we got the appraisals, which is the other component of that, and I sent that out late today. Everybody said I didn't.

We can dive into that at another meeting. We kind of had time to look through it. The short of it is the financial analysis of the land that we're taking out as composed of the land we're putting back in shows the valuation of that is higher. The valuation of what we're putting in is higher, yes.

Correct. They've worked on that for the past couple of months and we just got it last week, so I apologize for not sending it last week and sending it today, but that's not something we have to vote on or anything. And I wouldn't have asked for a vote on the alternative analysis, but we saw that probably a couple of months ago. It was just kind of minor edits and clean up stuff that we were doing on there, along with spellcheck I'll do before I said this.

So that's just announcing that for everybody just for consumption purposes to take a look at that. And so when the figure is higher. Any other questions in regards to the requirements for the land swap or anything that, you know, Senator Timothy talked about earlier? Any concerns with the basils?

It sounds like it was a good result as far as our, you know, to support our signal. There's a couple of nuances that they had in there for some of the items that they considered percentages of a lot buildable, and they had percentages in there that were not as high as I thought, that we looked at that we think are more buildable, but not by much. And if anything, it would just swing it more in the positive direction. But even with the conservative numbers they gave, the valuations of parcels that are landlocked on the Randolph Ave, those upper parcels that we put in there, those had a low valuation dollar wise for it.

So, you know, it kind of worked out for what I was thinking, or at least the way when the cost analysis came up in town meeting last year, when we're doing the analysis on there, just taking some of the parcels that are up there, their valuation is lower.

Speaker 7 (47:06–47:06)

Anything else?

Speaker 1 (47:09–47:58)

All right. Item 4E, a discussion update from MSBA, so I'm sure You guys all saw the announcement last week from MSVA that Milton was not selected for invitation to their program. So, you know, with that, we'll have to make a decision over the next couple of months. We'll have to, if we want to participate in it, I think it would be safe to submit again to rehash out the statement of interest.

you know, bring it back around and resubmit it next year just so we're in the program again, just to, you know, try it one more time. But I honestly leave that open for discussion.

Speaker 9 (47:59–48:31)

It might sound silly. We stopped the process like we're talking about. We can still go and apply. Again, in the MSBA program, correct?

Yes. Okay. That was the next question. And as we've discussed before, even if we got MSBA funded now, they may make us repeat work we've already done.

Correct. Sean, have you worked on a project where they had to start over again in that same manner? I have not.

Speaker 5 (48:33–48:55)

I know there have been some schools that have built it. They've asked for funding, and they somehow got some funding from it afterwards. But I think if you've heard a good argumentation written to you or not, you have to go through their process. You have to start with it.

So if you did get into it, I think you could certainly make a case that says, here's all the work we've done, here's where we're at. We'd like for you to continue the rest of the project. But there's no guarantees that they would even consider it.

Speaker 1 (48:55–49:24)

Yeah, a lot of the work that we're doing up to this point is kind of following the MSBA modules. So if we got accepted, they couldn't say, yeah, check all these boxes and you're ahead of the game. We have a really good head start going forward. For example, one of the first things they actually do is form a school building committee.

already there. And I mean, alternative analysis, so not the alternative analysis, but you know, some of the stuff we've already done would definitely help, you know, move us along quicker.

Speaker 5 (49:25–49:43)

And all of our budgeting and all of our cost information, the same way the MSBA runs it. So if there is a chance, you know, everything will align with their own systems and we'll run our own 3011s, we'll run all the kind of documentation they run as well. So we'll have that handy.

Speaker 1 (49:44–49:47)

Any other questions regarding MSBA?

Speaker 10 (49:51–50:15)

I had a question and raised my hand and I'm sure you didn't see it in the previous section. I just wanted to be clear. Do we have anything outstanding with regards to getting the land swap approved by by the government committee that needs to do the approval. Do we have anything that we've not prepared yet?

Speaker 1 (50:17–52:12)

We had Senator Timothy in earlier for public comment. So the special legislation that we need to file has been drafted and we've been working with town council on that. The portions that have to accompany that special legislation are essentially the appraisals that I sent out earlier today and then the alternative analysis that we just voted in. So once we have all that stuff, I think the commentary on the appraisals that the town administrator had were minor, and we should have those by the end of next week.

So essentially by the end of the year, I think we should have all the required documentation to submit. So I think that answers your question. Once we submit it, as Senator Timothy pointed out, there's a process by which it would go through approve it. Thank you.

Item 4F, Discussion Update Architectural Services for Gow Road. So this is kind of, you know, I think we touched on it a little bit at the beginning of the meeting when we were talking about timeline and stuff like that. And I appreciate Chris, I appreciate you coming tonight too. You know, we'll probably have to follow up one on this too, just to go through.

So the formation of the subcommittee, what we were trying to do at the meeting, again, I think it was two meetings ago, was have the other four members that didn't participate in the OPM subcommittee participate in this. The only volunteer that got volunteered was Mr. Hoffman when Mrs. Zulus couldn't do it.

Speaker 7 (52:13–52:13)

I appreciate that.

Speaker 1 (52:13–53:32)

Yep, yep. Perfect. So we had the four members of that and we left four members of school committee. And let me just pull up.

There we go. So it's Middle School Principal Bill Fish, Preschool Coordinator Bernadette Butler, Cunningham principal, John Redden, and then superintendent, Dr. Peter Burrus, but Chris, you might, you might have usual on the tram. That might be a possibility.

Yeah, that's fine. We welcome it. You know what I mean? So, out of, you know, the eight people from School Building Committee, four from this district, they'll make up that subcommittee.

So, I'll put an email together. Sean, so that will open up the door for communication with that group. So I think we'll probably good to kind of have a kickoff meeting with them just to some of them haven't done this before. Yeah.

And just to, you know, walk through the designer selection process and stuff like that.

Speaker 5 (53:33–53:46)

We can set up our kind of our score sheet with everybody's with the intention to be able to put it all up and then we'll have it ready to go before we receive any any of these submissions from the design team.

Speaker 1 (53:47–55:40)

Yes. And I think the key thing is just making them aware of that weekend. the 12th, 13th, 14th, you know, where we're getting these on Friday. Ideally, we'd like you to start reviewing them over the weekend and then have a meeting probably after that 16th or 17th, something like that.

Any other questions, comments, anybody? All right. The only thing we have under new business is for the designer services for the RFS. We had to put an advertisement in the Milton Times.

So we had an invoice that comes in for $260. So I think at some point we're going to have to formalize the process for approving invoices. and stuff like that, you know, especially we'll be getting some from PMA once we get an architect on board. So, no, no, we want to talk with Nick and figure out from the town what's the proper process for all that.

But for this one, I kind of, it's in line for previous invoices that we got for things. So I would entertain a motion to approve it. And then once we get that, we can be done with that agenda item. Any discussion?

Good deal. I paid more than that to advertise my permission to get a front porch put on my head. So we'll make note of that when we make our presentation at our meeting for funding. All right.

So perfect. So we'll do another roll call vote and start with Scott Jericho. Yes. Yes.

Speaker 8 (55:41–55:41)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (55:43–56:51)

Yes. Yes. All right. Item 6A for future meeting dates.

I'd love that to be determined mainly because with the timeline that we're working on for onboarding the architect, I think that's going to drive some of it right now. The thing is, I don't see a need to meet at any time between now and the end of the year. So I'm not sure, even with the subcommittee, I think the next meeting would probably be with the subcommittee meeting at some time that second week of January. And then, you know, the interviews we're having at the end of January.

So I'll leave it open for people. I don't see much need to meet between now and the beginning of January. And Marcus's hand up. Oh, yeah.

Speaker 6 (56:51–57:29)

Go ahead. Yeah, I agree with that. Sean, I think the only thing I was going to just jump in and advocate is just that we put something in the calendar, even if it's just a standing meeting every other week, as we kind of, you know, established back in August. And if we need to because we don't have anything to talk about, I think everybody would appreciate, I know I would appreciate the time back certainly, but just holding it on the calendar is really helpful for planning purposes.

I think that makes sense to me.

Speaker 10 (57:31–57:56)

I'm not sure if when you discuss about meeting if it covers a subcommittee entirely or if that will be discussed separately and how that would happen would you be sending meeting invites just a coordination part of that meeting? You can touch on that, I would appreciate it.

Speaker 1 (57:57–58:35)

The meetings for the subcommittee would be coordinated separately because it wouldn't require the entire school building committee. And there's not a quorum at that meeting of the school building committee because there's only four members. So that one, Sean will be coordinating that with the, you know, call it subcommittee. But the overall school building committee, essentially, I think the point Mark was making is You know, do we want to just go on like every two weeks?

I know previously we're doing every three weeks. I just open it to anybody's suggestions or anything like that.

Speaker 7 (58:38–58:44)

It's kind of hard to hard to predict for January and February with the RFP going out.

Speaker 1 (58:45–59:19)

I think we'll crash a lot. Yeah, I'm thinking of putting a hold on my calendar on the 22nd and just seeing what happens. Yeah, because if we aim for the 22nd, I mean, we could do it too. I'm just trying to think of how other committees meet.

So the Conservation Commission, I think, meets once a month. And I think it's like the third Tuesday of that month or something. So, you know, for us, if we wanted to just say we want to meet once a month and additionally as needed, that lends itself to what Mark was talking about. But

Speaker 6 (59:23–01:00:12)

Go ahead, Mark. I would assume we might need, once we get the architect on board, that we might need some, a few meetings, you know, in the early February timeframe to get them fully launched and fully on board and, you know, have whatever discussions they need to be able to kind of hit the ground running. Does that sound right to you? Because I worry once a month actually isn't going to be right if we schedule something on January 22nd, which again, to me, sounds like a good timeline for the next meeting.

But then once we have the architect on, waiting another month before the next meeting feels like a long time. Other people's thoughts on that?

Speaker 1 (01:00:13–01:01:15)

My take on it, and that's kind of why I want to discuss it with everybody is at some point when we do get the architect on board that, you know, having after we get through the static friction of getting the process moving with them, you know, holding a more scheduled meeting. But up to that point, I think we have to be agile with our scheduling, even though it might not be perfect for everybody. But, you know, aiming for, you know, the week of the 22nd, or January, just have a meeting to prep for the interviews the following week, kind of see what's come out of that. Would be helpful.

And then following that, you know, the contract date is the first week of February. So maybe that following week after that, have that with the architect and the OPM, you know, with us at the table. So we want to kind of aim for those two dates right now, which would be the That sounds good.

Speaker 4 (01:01:17–01:01:24)

Those are the numbers? Those are the numbers, yeah. Is the 12th, is that a school vacation? That's the week after.

Speaker 7 (01:01:25–01:01:28)

Yeah, it's the week after. Okay.

Speaker 1 (01:01:28–01:01:48)

Yeah, 19th is President's Day, so the 12th will be the week before. Okay, I got it. Any comments on line to see if anybody had their hand raised?

Speaker 8 (01:01:49–01:01:53)

Is there any check-in required for what needs to be submitted to Senator Timothy?

Speaker 1 (01:01:56–01:02:34)

No. So with our approval of the alternative analysis, that was the only thing this committee had to do. The town with the appraisals and our alternative analysis, the town Council is actually filing that with the Senate. OK, so I just want to acknowledge.

I mean, for us, our timeline, the old one that I had had land swap, OPM onboarding and an architect onboarding. So that was the third component.

Speaker 7 (01:02:34–01:02:36)

Where would be a good place?

Speaker 5 (01:02:40–01:02:57)

I'll put that on our file show site if that's all right. If you still have access to that, I'll email the link to the committee after this and it'll be there. It'll be dated tonight's meeting and then all the information that we presented for tonight's meeting will be in that folder. Perfect.

Speaker 1 (01:02:58–01:03:46)

Thank you. I think meetings were good. Item seven, this is adjournment. I'll entertain a motion to adjourn.

So, want to hang out? Sure. All right. So, we'll call a vote.

Scott Tereshev? Yes. Mike Zillow? Yes.

Tim Lombard? Yes. Carrie Hurley? Yes.

Glenn Hoffman? Yes. Mark Lorraine? Thank you all.

Speaker 7 (01:03:48–01:03:49)

Have a good night.