Board: Budget Coordination Committee
Date: 2025-10-17
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:20–01:19)
Good morning, everyone. I will call to order the October 17 meeting of the Milton Budget Coordination Committee. I see we have Maggie and Nathan on the screen. Good morning.
So we have a pretty packed agenda today. And we are going to try to time box some of these items Good morning, Winston. We're going to time box some of these items so we can get through them. So, and I know we want to kick it off with the financial forecast, so Nick in the Town staff will take 25 minutes.
We're trying something here, so bear with us. But Nick and the staff will try to take around like 25 to 30 minutes to walk us through the five-year forecast.
Speaker 2 (01:21–04:40)
All right. Good morning. Thank you. So I had provided both a broader workbook that has with some notes in it that provide more context overall.
Just to introduce kind of what the assumptions are, I'm actually going to show some of the overview as a way to introduce it. And first I'll just, we already talked about kind of how our fiscal 25 ended at a previous meeting. We had discussed that again with the finance committee, the school committee this week, but the one new update we wanted to provide is that free cash was certified last week at $4.5 million. So because of the positive year end results, at 4.58 million.
The first appropriation out of that is scheduled to take place at the special town meeting on Monday, the 27th, which is a $60,000 appropriation to fund the special election on November 4th. Hopefully that'll be cheaper than that, but that is the money we're setting aside for that. So I just wanted to provide that quick update. In terms of the financial forecast on the revenue side, the way it's been set up is as follows property tax increases we assume we would to under Proposition 2.5, which is a 2.5% increase on the overall tax levy.
For new growth right now, the last three years we've been well over a million dollars in new growth. We have plugged that for the succeeding five years. This is a place where we might have to re-evaluate that depending on how some of the macroeconomic stuff affects Milton and Massachusetts going forward. For fiscal year 26, our new growth estimate was a million dollars.
We are going to be well over that. The Department of Revenue has already reviewed our new growth numbers. The Board of Assessors will be discussing them on Monday. So we'll have, once it's official, we'll have well over where we were last year in new growth, which was about 1.29 last year, and we've exceeded that this year.
For state aid, the way last year, this year, sorry, fiscal. Yeah, sorry. It's a little bit tricky. So we budget going into the town meeting.
The new growth is set when we set the tax rate in the fall for the current fiscal year. So last year's new growth I'm referring to as for fiscal 25 was about 1.29 million this year for fiscal 26 will be in excess of that. and the assessors. Fiscal 26, we're only three months into fiscal 26.
New growth lags. New growth is the prior year's growth is captured on this year's taxes. How could I get that wrong? So we capture any and all projects up until June 30th.
Speaker 3 (04:41–04:47)
So the FY25 new growth is what happened in FY24. Correct. OK.
Speaker 2 (04:47–04:48)
Thank you.
Speaker 3 (04:48–04:49)
You're welcome.
Speaker 2 (04:49–05:48)
So all of the growth that's happening now will feed into fiscal 27. State aid, the way we budgeted that, again, trying to be conservative here, on Chapter 70 education aid, we treated it at $132,000 increase a year, which is $30 in additional aid per student out of approximately 4,400 students. It's just a conservative placeholder that we plugged in. We will reevaluate that for fiscal 27 Unrestricted general government aid, that is another state aid account we've plugged in for the forecast at 2% increase per year.
That's been below where it has been lately. That translates to about $82,000. Obviously, with potential impacts to the state budget, this is something we'll have to watch for 27 and beyond, but that's how we've approached it for the forecast. Our local receipts, which is, you know, we talked a little bit more.
Speaker 3 (05:48–05:55)
I'm sorry, does one of those have a minimum like it can't go below 30 per people or something, or am I making that up?
Speaker 2 (05:56–08:03)
The way, Chapter 70 is generally the state will hold all districts harmless and you won't ever have less than you had the year before, but it doesn't have to go up every year. Okay. And then dire economic straits, that might be different, but that is generally the case. Okay, sorry to interrupt.
Is this in the materials that you sent? Correct. Okay. And there's more details and there's like a one page revenue financial forecast summary chart that has a little bit more notes and covers this.
This is just like an easier way to present it, I think. For local receipts, so that's motor vehicle excise, building permit fees, interest income, everything that we collect locally. We've plugged that trash fees are in that. We've plugged just a 1% income.
So again, overall, I would view the revenue forecasting as pretty conservative. Maybe some tweaks in terms of how we treat new growth, and then we'll have to monitor where state aid will be. The forecast also doesn't assume any use of free cash in any year going forward. For fiscal 27 specifically, this gets us to about $4.2 million.
revenue from 26 to 27. And that tracks kind of roughly in each year succeeding. So that's on the revenue side. The one thing I didn't flag in here is just how the operating budget stabilization fund would interact into the forecast.
The workbook I've shared talks about that and shows that in more detail, but that's a separate revenue source that we haven't, I didn't spell out specifically here. but the baseline is ultimately at the end of the day, most of our revenue accounts are pretty consistent year over year. And I don't wanna say they're easy to forecast, but they're generally pretty, we just keep it pretty low in terms of where that money is coming from.
Speaker 4 (08:03–08:31)
Stay on that for a second, just a few questions. So the 2.9% increase in revenue is 2.5% from property taxes and the other 400 basis points Chapter 70 and unrestricted UGDAs in the approved budget for this year? Those figures from? For this year approved state budget.
Speaker 2 (08:32–08:58)
Yeah, those I think. That's January, right? Yeah, so that was set in the state budget. I think the per pupil aid was about $135 per student.
So in fiscal 26, it was much higher than that. And then for unrestricted general government aid, I think it was like 1.7% in the prior year. It was like 5%. So does that answer your question?
Speaker 4 (08:58–09:05)
Not exactly. OK. So the $132,000 increase, was that in the budget that the governor signed?
Speaker 2 (09:05–09:38)
Oh, and that is just a forecast, because they have not released any information yet. So this is just looking at 27, what we've baked an increase in. And we view it as a pretty conservative forecast. where the governor released her fiscal 27 budget, and that's when we'll have the first take on what will that actually look like.
Okay, got it. And then we won't know the final final till… Hopefully, June, July, August. Depending on when they do their work.
Speaker 1 (09:44–09:47)
Yeah, it's tough to make these assumptions this year.
Speaker 5 (09:48–10:08)
Do you think we underestimate? Well, it seems like on some, if you look at the estimate for 26, we underestimate some of the revenues based on history. I wonder if we should be a little bit more, not so conservative.
Speaker 2 (10:10–11:17)
It's a delicate balance. I don't disagree. I think one thing that we've tried to do is In the wake of the COVID slowdown, cities and towns across the state drastically cut some of the revenue forecasts, and we're very slow to bring them back up. That is one thing we've done, is try to reset our forecasts so that they're conservative, but a bit more accurate.
But again, looking at where the high revenue came in, really the only, the two that we can adjust is And on the local receipts here, some of the higher accounts, and a lot of this truly is one-time stuff. Building permits, for example, we had three or four 40Bs all permitted last year with a substantial building permit payments. We're not going to have that again in 28. We're not going to have it in 29 necessarily.
Interest income, we've really increased that forecast, but we're
Speaker 5 (11:20–11:22)
Yeah, there's like a million less than correct.
Speaker 2 (11:23–12:08)
However, there have been there was one year in fiscal 19 I think the interest income was $50,000. So like, there is, there can be wide variations. And if we increase these too much. And we're starting to pay recurring operations based on higher revenue they can't support those increased budgets.
So it's, it's a good question. It's, I think a lot, penalties and interest again, the treasurer has, or the collector wearing a collector hat has been trying to close out some longstanding issues. So we're, we're seeing more tax liens redeemed, penalties and interest being paid. So that's not necessarily going to recur.
Speaker 5 (12:09–12:29)
Well, that one stood out to me and because it's like a million dollar difference. And I know, and I know it will be less next year than this year. I completely believe that, but I don't think, as much less. And maybe the other one that I looked at, and it's not a lot, but it's something, but the recycling fees, trash and stuff.
Speaker 2 (12:29–12:54)
Trash fees, we'll look at that. Fiscal 25 was the first year of the new increase, so we weren't quite sure how that would actually play out. If we increase the fee, do people change their behaviors a little bit? So it's one we'll keep an eye on now that the $4 in terms of the revenue side you wanted to add beyond that.
Speaker 6 (12:55–13:12)
No, I agree with being cautious about increasing our projections related to a couple of these line items. I mean, I think the one that stood out to you was the penalties and interest. Is that what you're talking about here?
Speaker 7 (13:12–13:15)
Um, the trash and the cycling fees.
Speaker 6 (13:15–14:25)
Yeah, but before that you said, oh, I, um, the tax investment income investment income. So that is really dependent upon, um, changes in market value. Yeah. You know, um, I do my best to, to kind of capitalize on, on rates, um, and using our cash as best as possible to the town's, um, benefit, but you know, the, if the interest rates dip, kind of…
Exactly. And I don't think it's… And to Nick's point, I just don't think that to the extent that we start using that money, depending on that money to pay recurring operational expenses with an offset in the budget, that it would be prudent how to manage like that moving forward. I think we can talk about whether 400 this year, 400,000, is the right number moving forward and how to increase that and how to project, but it's a bit of a moving target, as you can imagine, when you're budgeting, we have no idea about.
Speaker 5 (14:25–14:31)
It just seems like a big dip. I think it will go down, but it just seems like a big one.
Speaker 4 (14:31–14:48)
Yeah. You're also raising up. budgeting philosophy question, which is, as we estimate, I think we always want to be surprised to the upside, not to the downside. I think we all agree on that.
Speaker 1 (14:50–14:55)
Especially in a volatile environment that we're in right now. Right. Gee, he's got his hand raised.
Speaker 3 (14:56–15:39)
Yeah, that gets to something I was going to ask. And if it's too far off topic for now, we can table it. But we've had free cash, which is a positive surprise of multiple millions of dollars in the past several years. And in the free cash policy, it's proposed that we aim for a free cash of, what, 2% to 4%.
So that's aiming for a good surprise of 2% to 4% every year. That's what we want. That's what we want. But I guess that's question is, are we aiming to have a positive surprise of two to 4% every year.
If so, and we want to be underestimating our revenues. But let's decide, is that what we want or is that not what we want?
Speaker 5 (15:40–15:56)
Who decides that? I think we should always be conservative. But I think if we can be as accurate as possible, we should try to show, everything you do, if you can tighten it and get it better, it's better for the town budget. Less surprises.
You should try to do that.
Speaker 8 (15:57–16:46)
I just want to point out that 4.6, Sounds like a ton of money, but as a percentage of our overall budget, it really isn't that big. And if you swing one, it's great to swing the positive way, but there are communities that swing the negative way. And I just would caution, I'm a big fan of being conservative because I would hate for us to be faced with something like that. Because a lot more goes into the calculation than revenues and excess of budget and expenditures less than appropriation.
There's other things that fall into that calculation that could swing it to a lower number. So I just think the superintendent has something to say.
Speaker 9 (16:46–17:23)
I totally support all this dialogue by saying, you'll know if we're being too conservative that after a period of fiscal years goes by and your free cash is so high, to conservative, which would be a good news story. But then that's when you could start to moderate a little bit. But until that time, if we're hitting the key points of a certain structure, then it seems to be a good practice to be conservative, positive balance, so we can look back on what to do and how we can allocate those resources. 2% of your budget or 1% can go south real quick.
So I appreciate the conservative viewpoint and structure to this budget, for sure.
Speaker 10 (17:27–18:13)
I agree with everyone said but I think for us to really adjust these up. We need a longer track record. We were here for two, three years, maybe four, so then we can move it but right now, I don't think it's a good enough reason to say the reason for the budget is that we did this last year, because we are still in to use yours. after the pandemic and changes in interest rates, and sort of settling where we're gonna settle economically, nationally, before we can even think we're gonna hit this number again, and even consistently.
So we may just be in a space where for the next two to three years, it's best if we're surprised a little bit with the budget.
Speaker 8 (18:13–18:36)
And also, like, if you look at the five-year forecast, we go into a deficit pretty quickly. And if we remain conservative in our revenue estimates that will, and they can say we're conservative and they come in higher, that's only going to help us in the out years. So.
Speaker 2 (18:46–23:25)
On the expense side, just to outline how we've mapped out the forecast and what is baked in. So this is showing 27, but this carries forward for each year in the forecast itself. Salaries for all departments are projected to increase 2.5% a year. General expenses, 3% a year.
Health insurance, 7%, and I'll come back to that. General insurance is our liability insurance. That's a little bit higher at 8%. state assessments across the board at 2%.
Debt services in accordance with our debt schedule, which we're just refreshing now. So I'm a little vague there, but you can look into how right now for the debt service schedule, it's expected to increase by half a million in 27, another half a million in 28 before stabilizing a bit. So that's already leaked into the forecast. For OPEB and retirement, they pretty much go hand in hand.
We have a policy that says that $2.5 million a year, increasing 2.5% is reserved and set aside for our long-term liabilities, whether that's OPEB or retirement. If retirement system needs additional funding over its normal costs, that $2.5 million is there for the retirement system. If it doesn't, that money is there for OPEB. Currently on the funding schedule, the Milton retirement system for the next two years is the funding schedules, it's normal cost for expected future benefits of current employees, plus a million dollars over above that to keep building up a reserve.
The OPEB appropriation therefore is $1.5 million for the next two years, because it's the two and a half million set aside for it, minus the 1 million additional going to built in retirement, if that makes sense. And that's already baked into the forecast over the next several years. And it assumes that trend will continue I carved out utilities specifically, although it's budgeted within general expenses, just to speak a little bit more about where that is heading right now with a lot of national attention on utility costs. We've extended our supply contract for electricity for an additional three years.
Right now we're paying 13.7 cents a kilowatt hour under the new contract that will extend from December kilowatt hour. So despite what has been a lot of news and attention paid on electricity costs for our supply, we're locked in long term, and we'll see a decrease in savings, a decrease in costs. However, that's only a portion of the bill. Eversource's costs for distribution are expected to also increase.
So on the one hand, we're seeing some savings. On the other hand, if not slightly increase. And then gas supply, our gas contract is up next year, next November. Right now, based on the market, our plan is to not extend that contract just because the pricing is not favorable at this time.
However, the forecast for next winter is that costs should remain somewhat flat. Although, again, the supply is only half the bill, delivery charges are expected to grow 5% to 7%. That's a little bit more detail on utilities, but I just wanted to flag that as an item of interest. On health insurance, I've talked about this both with the Select Board Finance Committee as well as with the School Committee.
We're seeing a lot of pressure on the health insurance front. Our premium increase last year was 14%. The Mass Municipal Association held a forum a couple of weeks ago. where the overall takeaway in the room was last year's premium increases are what you should expect this year.
So while our forecasts have planned a 7% per year increase, which is well above what our recent history has been, the market fluctuations are significant enough that fiscal 27 will be tough on health insurance. There are things that the town can do to premium increase. None of those measures have been taken or really planned yet at all. But I just wanted to flag the health insurance piece is kind of the biggest cost pressure we're seeing for fiscal 27 at this time, and that would extend into future years depending on when and if this trend finally slows down.
Speaker 1 (23:27–23:59)
At what point, right, like I know, again, there's a lot of volatility in this, we're definitely beyond our 25 minutes. At what point, so the assumption is 7%, we saw 14%, we're probably gonna see something around that again this year, maybe more. At what point would, does the forecast And I know that's probably what you're trying to figure out right now.
Speaker 2 (23:59–24:25)
Yeah, I think that's I So it's been helpful MMA event we had the managers meeting for Norfolk County Wednesday, and we went around budget. So I think we're about ready to up that forecast.
Speaker 1 (24:25–24:28)
Have you seen this? Like when's the last time we've seen this?
Speaker 2 (24:29–24:44)
I think the last run up in health care costs like this was prior to the health reform measures that were taking place back in like 2010, 2011. Since then, it's not been, it's been high, but it's not been like outlier years like this.
Speaker 4 (24:49–26:41)
One is different than we talked about with Bremen News. history before you make a conservative increase in revenue. The opposite is true for expenses, where you have real life experience last year and you read the room, so to speak. So health insurers are losing money.
Blue Cross Blue Shield and Point 32 have both reported hundreds of thousands of losses. And the likelihood is, so what does that mean? That means they're going to raise premiums. And if we had 12% increase last year, is that right?
14. Oh, 14. Then I don't know how we could come away with an estimate that says our costs are going to be 7%. I don't know how we could even justify that.
This is an area where I think we should certainly increase that. And similarly on utilities. Eversource's proposed fee increases are so high that the governor's trying to see if she can figure out a way to rein those in. So even if, as you say, we see some savings, the distribution charges, I don't come away with the conclusion that the outcome will be flat.
I come away with the conclusion that the electricity costs are going to see probably three, four, 5% increase there. So again, I would suggest we take a look at that.
Speaker 2 (26:42–28:14)
I just want to, I should have introduced this a little bit differently in terms of the overarching piece. So I just, I should clarify in terms of what the forecast today is set up to show. So the way we structured this forecast with these numbers on the expense side is we went first to the revenue and we said, what are our revenue forecasts? Plus, what is our assumption if we use down the operating budget stabilization fund over the next four years.
If we do that, what can we afford. And that's what this slide is showing so If health insurance is not 7% and it's 14%, that means all of these other numbers need to go down. So that is how the forecast is set up. The forecast is not set up first from an expense saying what our anticipated expenses and what is our deficit going to be.
We set it up on the flip side saying if our revenues are X, what does our expense need to be? So that is the structure today and I think there's probably worth saying is that the right approach but that is the way it's set up today I just wanted to, I should have introduced that at the outset just to. So, what we're saying is your salaries needs to be Apple, at or below 200% general expenses need to be at or below another way to approach it would be like, what are anticipated costs and what does that mean for a gap? But I, so I agree with your point.
It was just the reason we had flipped it around a little bit different.
Speaker 4 (28:15–28:28)
And if the assumption is that we're over a four year period, we're using 25% of our reserve each year, then I would argue that's not a balanced budget. That's what you're doing deficit spending.
Speaker 2 (28:29–28:46)
And that we don't disagree, but that was the kind of intentionality behind the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund is we're going to do this to support the budget over the next four to five years when we discuss with the Select Board of the Warren Committee in town meeting.
Speaker 4 (28:46–29:03)
We should talk more about that. I thought that, particularly because it requires, I think, a 2 3rds vote of Select Board and school committees, right? Or is it a majority vote? Different fund.
Oh, OK, I thought we were talking about the operating budget stabilization.
Speaker 2 (29:03–29:05)
That requires a two-thirds vote of the town meeting.
Speaker 4 (29:05–29:07)
Oh, OK.
Speaker 2 (29:07–29:16)
The SPED reserve one, that's the vote of the school committee and select board. OK. And that has $0 in it today. The operating budget stabilization fund is $2.7 million in it.
Speaker 4 (29:17–29:25)
Same point, that if we're spending 25% of that each year, then we don't have a balanced budget.
Speaker 3 (29:25–29:58)
That may be a different topic for a different day. I disagree, because I think that's the entire point of that budget. It's to get us through what we've done in the past is we've had an override, and then we've cut expenses and laid off people and closed the library for four years. And then when we can't cut anymore, we have another override.
And the point of this is we have that cushion, we spend a little bit in the first year, a little more in the second year, a lot in the fourth year, and then we have an override without cutting services every year. Probably a conversation for a different day, but I think that's the whole point.
Speaker 2 (29:58–30:17)
It is. And I'll just note of that, $700,000 is recurring. So there is an element of that that is recurring every year. So at the very least, $700,000 plus 2.5% is trickling back in.
And that would be kind of the baseline of truly recurring money from that.
Speaker 3 (30:18–30:24)
So if in year one, we put $700,000 into that fund and take out less than $700,000, that makes it a little bit easier.
Speaker 9 (30:25–31:03)
I think I like that tool. I think it's a great tool for the town to have. And I think it makes it very transparent that if you're operating as X and you're continuing to use this operating stabilization, there is some worry there that you're, but that's what the tool's for. And I think it's a really nice way to be able to fluctuate the support you need to give to the operating budget each year with a reoccurring funding mechanism within it.
It just shows everything right on the front so you can look at it and really assess what we're being able to do with the operating body in general, about the tool or with the tool. So it's a nice idea. I think it's helpful.
Speaker 5 (31:06–31:28)
Can I just talk about health back to that again? I don't actually think it's probably wrong to be seven or 8% next year, but the increase that we had, I know we were like 7% and then it bumped up 14%, but wasn't that, well, I think it was mostly due to headcount and you can't really look at health insurance without looking at the headcount. This changes, how many people are on it?
Speaker 2 (31:28–32:28)
That it was a component of why our health insurance budget went up last year, but the health insurance budget year over year, increase year over year, of which the premium was a 14% increase. So the other reason that cost jump was because headcount was higher, and we had experienced a much higher enrollment in the lead up through 2324 and into 25. Right now, our budget assumes stable headcount. So that is, it's assuming a stable headcount, assuming not a lot of departments, if any, would be adding any new FTEs.
And the changes would be if people who are already employees are shifting onto the plan or off the plan. So right now, this is assuming a 7% budget increase overall. We're not expecting much of a significant change on enrollment, but it's something we need to keep an eye on. I agree.
Speaker 11 (32:28–33:27)
Can I have a question? Sorry. Hey, Maggie. One, I'm wondering who decides on the policy change for the health insurance on the all the employees, like, who decides what the contribution from the employee side will be.
And then that's 1 comment. The other comment is, I think I'd be a little bit. more conservative and not depend on an override every four years. I don't think that's sustainable for long-time residents in the town, especially commercial properties.
Our commercial properties go up at a faster rate than residential property. I wouldn't assume that an override will happen every four years. Thanks.
Speaker 2 (33:29–34:26)
On the health insurance piece, the premium increases set by the town on a year by year basis, the share in which the town can town right now pays 76% of the plan costs the employees. that. Plan design is also a subject of collective bargaining, but there's legislation that was approved in 2011 that allows a town or city to make plan design changes through a form of negotiations, but allows the town to make those changes So on plan design, the town has a little bit of control over that in terms of the share of the premium costs that is set only can be changed on the collective bargaining. And then the premium increases is a yearly amount set by the town.
Speaker 11 (34:27–34:33)
And then how often do you go to collective bargaining? How often can you go back and negotiate that?
Speaker 2 (34:35–34:49)
On the premium split, we could always ask. I don't think the other parties would be necessarily that interested in having more costs shifted to them, but there wouldn't be anything prohibiting the town from trying to negotiate over it.
Speaker 5 (34:50–35:01)
Who decides? Milton Pays, they work 20 hours a week, right? Who decides that? Is that part of collective bargaining or is that?
If somebody works 20 hours a week, they get health insurance. That's a state law. That's a state law?
Speaker 2 (35:01–35:17)
Yeah, for any employer. For a town or any employer? For any employer. If once you're triple over the 20, is it whether 19 and a half or 20 hours a week?
I don't think so. I think it's 30. No, it's more than half time. More than half time, you're eligible for health insurance.
Really?
Speaker 1 (35:17–35:18)
Yeah. We're at 810.
Speaker 2 (35:21–35:22)
Yeah. That's the forecast, so.
Speaker 1 (35:23–35:45)
OK. I didn't realize that. I'm good. Okay, this is helpful.
I don't know if we have any other questions or follow-up coming from this, but I think that was a helpful background on how that model's put together.
Speaker 9 (35:45–35:55)
I want to thank Nick and Amy came in and provided this update in our finance subcommittee this week, so thank you very much for doing so. It was really helpful as well, so thank you.
Speaker 1 (35:59–36:19)
All right, so I don't know what we have next on the agenda. We have 20 minutes left. I know there was the, Amy, were you guys going to do budget to actual for FY26?
Speaker 2 (36:19–36:22)
Any questions, we're happy to take them.
Speaker 8 (36:22–36:23)
We provided the report.
Speaker 1 (36:23–36:25)
It's somewhat early in the year.
Speaker 8 (36:25–36:33)
I don't see anything that's concerning at this point. Okay, sounds good.
Speaker 2 (36:33–37:27)
The only point I'll make and just because it was tied to the health insurance is that we're below our budget enrollment for health insurance today in terms of overall headcount. The challenge that we're seeing and we'll have to watch throughout the year as well as into next year is that at open enrollment from June to July, we had a substantial increase in change over from individual plans to family plans. So those are $15,000 more expensive for larger number of employees on our family plans than we had anticipated. We budget a reserve within the budget for these kinds of changes year over year, but headcount has been steady and on target.
The plan enrollment is slightly different than had been anticipated. And since it's such a large budget item we're just talking about, I just wanted to flag that 426 in terms of something we're watching throughout the year.
Speaker 10 (37:30–37:34)
or is it due to spouses changing plans?
Speaker 2 (37:35–37:41)
We have young employees, we have a young workforce, and I think you're seeing families growing.
Speaker 9 (37:42–37:53)
We're seeing a lot of maturity, over the last couple years and projecting into next year.
Speaker 1 (37:55–38:04)
just skipping around a little bit. Nick, did you feel like you had covered the FY27 budget? I know we had like some time on that.
Speaker 2 (38:04–38:13)
Yeah, that's kind of where things stand. We have departmental requests are due back at the end of the month and where that process is well underway at this point.
Speaker 1 (38:15–38:22)
Okay. So we also had policies on the agenda.
Speaker 4 (38:27–38:37)
that we've been working on. My thought was we were going to distribute drafts to committee members.
Speaker 2 (38:38–38:48)
Yes, and they were in the meeting materials folder I set up and sent around Wednesday evening. So they're there. Folks can take a look at any questions, let us know.
Speaker 4 (38:48–39:07)
Right, so that's great. So anyone who has comments should send them Megan Winston and myself. Megan Winston and you, okay.
Speaker 1 (39:07–39:29)
But so to your point, and I took a look at the deck that you had for last week. So the policies are taking a look at some of the various reserve accounts. Nick, I don't know if you want to speak to it a little bit, just as a high level for folks to take a peek at.
Speaker 2 (39:30–40:39)
Some of the key points were referenced earlier but they set targets for the General Stabilization Fund, the Capital Stabilization Fund, set slightly more guardrails on the use of free cash, speak to how the Operating Budget Stabilization Fund can be withdrawn over the next several years. And then capital planning and debt management set like targets as to what our overall investment in capital should be. So they all kind of tied together. And Jay reached out this week as well with Trying to come up I think more specific rules around the use of free cash show.
So, a lot of towns also have a free cash policy I had kind of baked it within the reserves policy but a free cash policy would say, rather than just say it shouldn't be be used. So, it's another way to approach it that would be complementary potentially to the rest of the reserves policies. So, that's kind of on a high level as to what they set out as targets.
Speaker 1 (40:44–40:48)
Hey, Nathan.
Speaker 12 (40:49–41:13)
Hey, everyone. Nick, just a clarifying question on the policies. It wasn't clear to me, are these I'm seeing these three policies. Are these brand new or are they revisions of existing policies or are they sort of like new versions of something else that existed previously?
I just wasn't sure what the history was on these.
Speaker 2 (41:14–42:01)
They are new. Yeah, they track. So the policies track with kind of what has been our general attempts, but never really kind of written down anywhere specifically. The policy framework themselves and the templates that you see, those are the Department of Revenue's policies that they use when they go into a city or town and help write a policy packet.
So we've stolen, or I should say we've plagiarized from the Department of Revenue their format, their phrasings, and then the kind of the town by town decisions are the goals. the more specific policy parameters, but the overall framework comes from the Department of Government.
Speaker 4 (42:02–42:24)
And I should say that initially I thought we needed work groups on the policies, but when I learned about all the research that Nick had done in preparation, I decided that's no longer necessary. So if anyone has comments, as I said, I'll send them back to Nick and CC, myself, Winston, and Megan, but no need for a work
Speaker 1 (42:29–43:28)
This is good stuff, right? I mean, I'm excited. I'm excited that we're taking steps to advance this because it's a pretty important and standard practice that I know the city of Boston has many reserve accounts and such that are maintained. going back to the forecast conversation and the use of free cash and the need to be conservative in the revenue forecasts.
I mean, having a more disciplined approach to building up reserves is gonna help further insulate the town from any shocks, so.
Speaker 10 (43:40–43:56)
of also pointing in the right direction. Just for clarity on where we are and feedback on this, myself, Megan, Amy, Joanne, Joanna, we've already looked at these and had our input in, so to the rest of the group now, take a look and come back with feedback.
Speaker 3 (43:58–44:47)
I'm just high level. I think I've got a meeting with Mr. Milano about this next week, but I think at a high level, I'd like to see more structure and more direction. As you said, if we all disappear tomorrow, I would like to see more structure and more direction in these.
Now people say, you shouldn't have too much structure. You shouldn't have a policy that says you shall spend this and you shall fund that. Totally agree. But a little bit more structured.
Somebody reading it could sort of anticipate, oh, here's how much we have. Here's how much will be spent. Yeah, I get it. At the moment, it seems that a lot is left up to every year budget.
Say, oh, what do we need? I'd like to see it more on the structure side. And that's something that may take a year for us to come up with. It's not going to happen in two weeks.
But that's where I'd like us to work.
Speaker 4 (44:49–44:50)
And I think that's worth the discussion.
Speaker 1 (44:51–45:28)
And I also think that's part of the reason that you want to have many eyes on this, right? Because no single one of us is going to have all the answers or anticipate all the possible needs or outcomes associated with it. So everybody paying attention to this right now is very important. And thank you to our town staff for putting it together and encouraging us to do it.
Sorry. Oh, Nathan.
Speaker 12 (45:29–46:56)
Sorry. Thank you. 1 more just process question. or maybe two things.
I think just, I heard Winston make a comment about who's reviewed this. Are we clear as a, so it sounds like you're seeking input from this group on these policies. And then are we clear on what then happens next and how these policies get finalized? Who does that?
I just want to make sure we all have the same expectations there. And then, I, I haven't read the policies. I probably agree with Jay that I'm sure we'll find ways to bring more specificity and structure. I hope it doesn't take us a year to finalize these policies.
I think that would be unfortunate. But I do think we should. It would probably be worth also, and again, I haven't read the policy, so this might not make any sense once I read it, but I think whatever we are attempting to do in the policies, it would be useful to probably model that out with historical data and see, okay, if we had applied these policies over the last X years, what would have happened? That would probably give us a little bit of a reality check on on how applicable they are to our actual situation.
Speaker 3 (46:59–47:23)
Can I real quick? Maybe I was being a pessimist when I said a year, but what I was really thinking is, it's best to have a policy before you set your annual budget. Otherwise your policy is sort of, you're making it fit the budget you set up. And I think there's about a 0% chance we'll get these policies set before we make the next year's budget.
So I'm hoping that we get these policies set up before we make the following year's budget.
Speaker 1 (47:23–47:24)
FY28. Yeah.
Speaker 2 (47:24–47:56)
And in terms of who would, be a signatory to the policy, just to pick up that piece. Right now, they're proposed to be approved by the Select Board and Warrant Committee. It could be just the Select Board. It could be Select Board, Warrant Committee, and School Committee.
The more buy-in across the boards and committees, and getting to a consensus across all three, I think, would be the best outcome. But I think that's a question for other committees.
Speaker 1 (47:57–47:59)
But the minimum is the Select Board has to sign off on.
Speaker 4 (48:06–48:40)
So with regard to approval, the select board approves the policies for the town. Other parts of the town might endorse the policies. They might have reviewed the policies. They might have commented on the policies.
But except for those policies that apply directly to the schools, where the school committee has statutory authority to approve policies, the select board approves the policies for the town. Our committee doesn't. School committee doesn't. Select Board does.
Speaker 2 (48:42–48:46)
I agree. It would be great to have all three say we agree and we will abide by.
Speaker 4 (48:46–48:51)
I guess my point was my point. I just want to be clear about the use of the word approval.
Speaker 10 (48:52–49:40)
And I think also we're talking about different steps in these policies. This first piece that we're asking for comments on is really frameworks, definitions, what we intend for each fund to have in terms of percentages. And I think Jay's point about usage, how we utilize free cash, where we do go forward is a longer conversation, and those may become amendments and additions to these policies. But I think there are steps that we can put in place once we have feedback and agreement, and then there are other pieces that we can add on.
as we try to refine and get even more sharp and technical in how we use each fund, especially as we're talking about, you know, we've created funds over the last year or two that we intend to spend down and that's something we need to have intentions on and how we review them the next few years. So I don't think it'll take a year for us to put this first piece in, but maybe a longer time for some of these amendments and the intentionalities.
Speaker 4 (49:44–49:45)
Oops.
Speaker 13 (49:46–49:48)
You want to talk about work groups?
Speaker 4 (49:48–51:11)
Just briefly. So I said that my thinking on work groups had evolved. So I don't think we need work group policies for the reasons previously stated. I do think we need a work group for the financial projection, financial forecast.
So my thought would be anyone who's interested communication that says when the work group will meet. But the idea would be to actually continue the discussion we started here, drill down a little bit more, test some of the assumptions, make sure we've got all the assumptions there that we should have. So just kind of a continuation of the discussion we had today, but a little more of a drill down so that ultimately we come away with, as I've said a couple of times, financial forecast that is publicly accessible and that helps us educate the general public about what we're doing, why we're doing it. And hopefully my dream would be that they would be so bought in that when we propose an override, majority of the people say, yes, we get it.
We knew about it and we're all on board.
Speaker 1 (51:13–51:36)
So the planner in me really loves the idea, I'd be interested to get people's thoughts on this, of running the forecast through three plausible future scenarios. Like if the group, I don't know if the work group would want to do this, but if there were.
Speaker 4 (51:36–51:39)
Do you want to come to the work group?
Speaker 1 (51:39–52:01)
I might. But I also don't want to derail what the group is working on. For me, I think it's very interesting to contemplate three potential scenarios with the most likely risk factors integrated. Come do the work.
OK, great.
Speaker 4 (52:01–52:02)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (52:02–52:04)
Thanks. Sorry. You got me excited, Leroy.
Speaker 4 (52:04–52:06)
That's a great idea.
Speaker 1 (52:06–52:11)
But that might be something to help contextualize and illustrate for folks. Absolutely.
Speaker 11 (52:11–52:11)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (52:13–52:19)
OK, sounds like we're going to keep having fun. I'm going to throw my name in the hat.
Speaker 4 (52:19–52:24)
My name in the hat for the ring. Next meetings?
Speaker 9 (52:25–52:32)
Oh, I think we have a meeting in two weeks, right? Oh, yeah. OK, good.
Speaker 1 (52:32–52:34)
This was the catch up meeting.
Speaker 9 (52:34–52:38)
It's two weeks from today. It's Halloween morning.
Speaker 1 (52:38–52:42)
Halloween. Sorry.
Speaker 13 (52:42–52:44)
Halloween themed budget meeting.
Speaker 4 (52:44–52:57)
It's not a holiday or anything, guys. It's just, you know, the kids dress up. That's all it is. It's a Friday this year.
It might be more than just that. Halloween morning. I didn't know that was a business.
Speaker 1 (52:57–53:02)
It's not November 1st morning, so it should be fine. Agreed.
Speaker 10 (53:02–53:09)
Yeah. It's Halloween morning. You'll be out candy shopping and grabbing candy. I know.
It's like a lot of pressure.
Speaker 4 (53:09–53:11)
You're going to have your levels up.
Speaker 8 (53:11–53:13)
This is out of touch, I guess.
Speaker 4 (53:13–53:15)
It might be a costume parade at school day. True.
Speaker 1 (53:22–53:33)
Okay, well, I think this was a great discussion and I think we have our next steps and I hope everyone has a great weekend. Do we have a motion to?
Speaker 10 (53:33–53:35)
Motion to adjourn.
Speaker 1 (53:36–53:42)
All in favor? Aye. Aye. You guys have it.
All right, thanks everyone.
Speaker 11 (53:42–53:42)
Thanks.