Board: Climate Action Planning Committee

Date: 2024-09-19


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:50–00:53)

I'll call the meeting to order.

Speaker 2 (00:53–00:54)

And it's great to see everybody.

Speaker 3 (00:56–01:32)

So we'll begin the meeting with public comment. Is there anybody from the public who wishes to comment? We're being run. We can move on to our second item of business.

Vote to approve the August 15th meeting minutes. Did anybody have any feedback or corrections to offer? Everybody get a chance to take a look at them.

Speaker 4 (01:35–01:37)

Just say, great job by Lisa.

Speaker 5 (01:38–01:39)

I didn't do them.

Speaker 4 (01:39–01:40)

You didn't?

Speaker 5 (01:40–01:42)

Jack did them.

Speaker 4 (01:42–01:47)

Jack. Good editing. It was good editing. Whoever did, did a great job then.

Jack, thank you.

Speaker 3 (01:49–02:13)

I'll entertain motions to approve. Motion to approve. Is there a second? Ron seconds it.

Let's start on Zoom. Maggie, how do you vote? Yes. Mr.

Panucci? Yes. Reagan?

Speaker 6 (02:14–02:15)

Yes.

Speaker 3 (02:15–02:27)

Kim? Oh, Kim, you're not going to remember this, so sorry about that. Arthur? Yes.

Mr. Johnson? Yes. There's no rhyme or reason to whether he's incorrect or not.

Ron?

Speaker 7 (02:28–02:29)

Yes.

Speaker 3 (02:29–02:30)

Eric?

Speaker 7 (02:30–02:34)

Yes.

Speaker 3 (02:34–02:34)

Lisa?

Speaker 5 (02:35–02:36)

Yes.

Speaker 3 (02:36–02:58)

Alex? Yes. Did I miss anybody? No.

Okay, the motion passes. It's like a feeling of success. We've done some goodness. And actually, before we move on to item four, did anybody offer to be the minutes taker for this meeting?

Speaker 5 (02:59–03:10)

Well, I'll do it this meeting, but I would entertain nominations for next meeting.

Speaker 7 (03:11–03:19)

Volunteer. Whoever clicks their hands last.

Speaker 3 (03:23–05:09)

So the two main things I wanted to spend the bulk of our time together today on are items four and five. Four is to to spend some time discussing how our working groups are going to work together, what processes you want to use, and what kind of roles you want to work towards. I tried to stir the pot a little bit this month and get folks focused on something sort of narrow and tangible that made sense to me, but I do want it to be a discussion. I didn't really think through in advance how this would work.

with half of us on Zoom and half of us here. I think it'd be tough to have like four discussions about working group plans. And so that's item four. And item five is to just go over the state goals that folks researched and put on the air table.

So I'm happy to do these in ear order. And I'm just wondering, People would prefer to start with the goals and we're working on that or people prefer to start with talking about working with processes. Can I see a quick show of hands for going in the order it's written with working group first or second? And who would prefer to start with topic five?

OK, so I guess we'll keep it in order.

Speaker 5 (05:11–05:13)

This is the load I need to record.

Speaker 3 (05:13–06:06)

No, I'm just saying, no. So how to make this productive? Well, first of all, actually, can I join the Zoom? I want to know the one thing I wanted to do.

I'd like to show the rosters that I have got based on your email responses and just do a quick check with all of you that the right names in the right places. So we know who's on which. I'll take sort of a last call. I think the buildings working group is suffering from overuse.

Speaker 7 (06:11–06:22)

Am I able to share? Should be. Make it possible for you to share. Thank you.

Thank you, co-host.

Speaker 1 (06:22–06:36)

Does that work?

Speaker 3 (06:43–08:29)

Okay. And the primary focus on the emissions and mitigations working groups. So on transportation, I heard from Lisa Troy, Carl Johnson, and Eric Miller, interested in working on that. Is that correct?

How are you so interested? Again, I've on, I don't know, Everyone should be in. Every group should be in. As many as you can stand.

I can't. I feel like I'll maybe put more of my time into mitigation because there's less people working on it. I would say that the emissions mitigation is the priority that the select board gave us. I definitely think it's important for us to be talking about adaptation as well.

But the town has a hazard mitigation plan in place. We're a little further ahead on some of those topics. Great. So for buildings, it's just me.

Can I convince anybody to work with me on this? You don't have to answer right now. Great. Fusion of emissions, nobody.

Did I miss somebody? Okay. And the Waste Management Working Group. I have Arthur, Jack, and Kim Johnson.

And there's quite a few folks from Sustainable Milton who are engaged with that as well. So I think we're okay there.

Speaker 4 (08:31–08:50)

Alex? Yes. The Working Group, We'll be meeting next Monday, and it will also consist of Lauren Barofsky and Christina, known as Kiki Litherhook.

Speaker 3 (08:52–08:52)

Wonderful.

Speaker 7 (09:01–09:02)

Wonderful.

Speaker 3 (09:14–10:12)

No, they're informal, they're not subcommittees, they're critically not subcommittees. They're just groups of residents and you can engage and you should engage anybody in town or outside of town who has appropriate expertise to help. Right now I'm just focused on making sure that there are names on this roster. I think at some point I'll want to flesh this out to a more complete roster of everybody who's participating.

There's quite a few folks in the conservation working group who are not part of this committee, who I don't have on this list. It's not limited to committee members, and there's nothing saying that you can't help out on one of these topics just because you're not on my roster. But I do want some people to put their names on it so I know who I can.

Speaker 7 (10:13–10:26)

pursue progress. You have to brush off a part of the state. Great. Just so I'm clear, what's the work of the fugitive?

Speaker 3 (10:29–11:38)

So fugitive emissions is on this list because it's more emissions than it's in the top four. It's primarily the athletes. Right. to come up with some response to that, to address gas leaks and refrigerant leaks.

Yeah, so Tracy Teich-Redman was taking this on before she had to step down, and there is a one-pager that she put together with some suggestions. So natural land conservation, which sequestered 6% of Milton's emissions annually. So it's an important component of net zero. Arthur also.

Can I put your name on this, Arthur?

Speaker 4 (11:39–11:40)

If you'd like, sure.

Speaker 7 (11:42–11:44)

There we go. OK.

Speaker 3 (11:44–12:09)

So for heat waves, I have Anna Morgan, Bersamian, and Kyle Johnson. Nobody on intense storms and wind damage. Flooding is myself and Arthur, although we haven't done much since we put our name on this a year ago. But does that sound right to you, Arthur?

Speaker 8 (12:09–12:10)

Alex.

Speaker 4 (12:11–12:47)

A lot of that's going to, in some areas, in particular, the Nepenthe River, involve the Nepenthe Watershed River Association, to which Milton has a representative. And we might contact that person to see if they would join this working group. They have tremendous resources at NEPRA detailing flood maps. waterway that we want to take advantage of.

So I just tossed that out. We can talk offline about it, but I wanted to put it in your mind at this time.

Speaker 3 (12:48–13:14)

Great. Energy security and grid resilience, myself, Wildfire, Matt Panucci, and Fiona Jevin. The crowd, Harold Johnson, Matt Panucci, and Fiona Jevin. All sound right?

And Raydon, you have an idea of which working groups or groups you'd like to participate in?

Speaker 6 (13:16–13:26)

Yeah, I think I emailed you a little while ago. I would be totally fine working. I thought the drought and then the fugitive emissions were really cool.

Speaker 3 (13:26–13:28)

Did you say drought and fugitive emissions?

Speaker 6 (13:30–13:31)

Yeah, that would be amazing.

Speaker 3 (13:32–13:32)

Okay.

Speaker 7 (13:37–13:38)

Where's drought?

Speaker 9 (13:41–14:14)

Okay, no, or for for drought to separate for drought and for wildfire. So, Fiona and I've kind of kicked off of. a couple of calls. And so for Johnson and for Reagan, let me just add you to those Zooms, and hopefully they work.

It's just framework discussion, research that we're trying to get kicked off, who kind of owns what. So I'll just add you to those invites, and hopefully it works scheduling-wise.

Speaker 4 (14:18–14:21)

Great. I'll ask a question if I may.

Speaker 3 (14:22–14:23)

Yes.

Speaker 4 (14:23–14:33)

Going back to flooding. Yeah. We want to consider titling that as flooding and stormwater.

Speaker 3 (14:41–14:46)

Sure. Okay. Stormwater does cause flooding.

Speaker 4 (14:47–15:42)

As do riverways and oceans. Just so that nobody doesn't think that we're not going to be taking a look at stormwater management systems, drainage systems, the impact of impervious and impervious coverings in the town of Milton, and a whole host of other things. This is becoming a rather pronounced topic. The annual meeting of the Massachusetts Association of Conservation Commissions next month has about five program sessions on stormwater, indicating the increasing concern from communities because those topics for the curriculum are based upon what

Speaker 3 (15:54–15:56)

Ryan, did you also have a question?

Speaker 2 (15:56–16:37)

Yeah. There need to have so many different groups say that, two reasons. One, looking towards the presentation of the plan, that it might be, to some people, confusing or overwhelming. And secondly, If the focus is on mitigation, some of the groups, we don't know that much about technical makeup of all the topics, but some of them seem to be more adaptation.

Speaker 3 (16:37–18:19)

Yeah, the right-hand side is adaptation, left-hand side is mitigation here. And I agree with you, our priority should be mitigation particularly is at least four of the working groups on the left should be our focus. That's why I put them explicitly on the agenda. I think there's a lot more to figure out in terms of aligning on goals and deliverables and timelines for the adaptation areas.

The thing that's in our charge is coming up with a plan for reducing found wild greenhouse gas emissions in alignment with Massachusetts net zero goals. And that's, I mean, really 80% of it, more than 80% of it is transportation and building. So I do think, Your point is well taken. There's a lot of topics here.

I do think to be complete, we all need to address them. But sequence and prioritization is important as well. So I'll circle back and say, anybody wants to help me with this? It's 42% of the emissions.

And probably if you cut out fast food traffic, it's the number one.

Speaker 2 (18:21–18:28)

Who caved?

Speaker 9 (18:28–18:38)

I couldn't see. Congratulations. You got there a millisecond before me. I felt the pressure.

So well done.

Speaker 7 (18:39–18:42)

I could see his icy glare.

Speaker 3 (18:42–21:05)

Yeah, that's worth a drink. It's a fun topic, actually. So yeah, we'll see how this goes. Maybe what we will need to do is sort of tee up a conversation that you guys can get together outside of this meeting and have about how are we going to work together?

What are we going to do first? What I'd like to get to is we're not going to be able to just declare this is how much we're going to get done this month. the work is new to all of us and it's pretty complicated. But I do think it is important to kind of set up a rhythm where we make some kind of claim about what we're going to do over the next month, something verifiable, and then try to hold ourselves accountable to it, which is not the same thing as like, If you can't get it done, you're a bad person.

There's a lot more momentum in trying to set a target for what you're going to do month to month and following up on whether it happens, even if it falls short. That's fine. It's just really the process of being transparent with each other and trying to set up some cadence where people know what to expect and when they're going to be meeting. So if we could, I don't know, at least align on when do the working groups want to meet with each other?

Do you want to meet in person, online, synchronously, asynchronously? And I know there was some confusion this week about whether I wanted a response from everybody or just from the leader. I'd be fine either way. But I don't think it was clear who the leaders are.

Sure. So let's get a little more clarity on that. So how long that was.

Speaker 5 (21:06–22:06)

Eric and I met at the library, Alex came and I thought that was nice to really dive in. So I think I would propose for transportation having two maybe hour, hour and a half meetings between our meetings to get work done. And the library is a nice place to meet. And so we can align on what times work best.

And if it's hard to attend in person, we could do, yeah, someone could join us remotely. So I guess, can Even Eric, do you have times that would work? Evening or weekend?

Speaker 7 (22:08–22:13)

I do, yeah. These initials were throwing me.

Speaker 3 (22:13–22:26)

Yeah, I'm sorry. I was trying to make it all clear.

Speaker 7 (22:26–22:28)

Okay.

Speaker 10 (22:41–22:50)

I would say, too, I could set up a Zoom town hall if you need that, too. Or you could just get a room here, as well.

Speaker 7 (22:50–22:58)

So. I think if people need Zoom, Sustainable Melting can help with that, too.

Speaker 5 (22:58–23:26)

Yeah. I've worked Zoom. OK. So I'll send out an email, and we'll align on but we'll try to make it a cadence so maybe you know like the week after we meet and then a break and then the week before the next.

Speaker 7 (23:28–23:32)

Maybe Thursday's even if we already have a day kind of blocked in our heads.

Speaker 5 (23:35–23:42)

Thursdays are my busiest day, but. We can negotiate. We can have four busy Thursdays.

Speaker 3 (23:42–24:22)

I really like the idea of looking at meeting off cycle. Especially if people are participating in more than one, it might be difficult for everybody to be at all of them. So some mix of having it on the calendar so that people can can come and have the opportunity to kind of put their heads together, but also agreeing what the focus is for the month. So people want to do it asynchronously and kind of check in.

Speaker 7 (24:22–24:32)

Yeah. Or maybe they are more talented.

Speaker 5 (24:39–24:43)

I know it can be really hard to find.

Speaker 3 (24:43–24:47)

So I think my feeling is it's going to be hard to really narrow it down.

Speaker 8 (24:47–24:47)

Yeah.

Speaker 3 (24:49–25:34)

If we were all together and said, let's just go in the corner. Yeah. You will follow up with the transportation to narrow it down. Let me know where you land with that.

Similarly with buildings. Since it's just me and Eric at the moment, I might be able to glom on to whatever you do. So, Arthur, you have a solid waste working group meeting set up for Monday. Are you planning on a regular cadence for that?

Speaker 4 (25:35–26:02)

That's the plan to work out with the committee on Monday. So I would say tentatively yes, and we're looking at 90 minute meetings. We'll have an agenda for that. Jack has arranged for it to be held at the town hall.

Speaker 3 (26:12–26:39)

And so, Ron, I think you had some thoughts for the conservation group, not just about the meeting cadence, but you, and I only shared it right before the meeting, but you have put together a pretty comprehensive working plan with the conservation group. So do you want to take some time to Shouldn't talk about that.

Speaker 2 (26:40–31:13)

Let me let's go over here. We've met over the summer a couple of times in person and and then through email and we've come up with three goals. The goals reflect the interests of the members of the working group who represent different conservation land interests around Milton. So it includes Friends of the Blue Hills, and the Ponson River Watershed Association, the Shade Tree Advisory committee and the conservation commission that we get to meet with.

That's probably the missing link right now in this plan. But as of now, we've identified three goals or two-year goals. One is reducing the impact of climate change on private property, the Bucks, the Blue Hills, and the Ponson River Valley. The second one is increasing the amount of day trees in Milton.

And the third one is improving the quality and mitigation effectiveness of the tree stock in the Blue Hills. And for each of those goals, our working group has identified a strategy and a series of activities to achieve the goals. And for each of the goals, I'm going to get mixed up in my usage of the term goals. For each of the working group goals, we have linked them to the goals for the state as identified in the State Forest Action Plan of 2020.

And we lifted those goals. Those goals are non-quantifiable goals. Maybe I'll hold off on getting into the goals discussion until we come to that part of of the meeting. But so the three working group goals are linked to those.

And yeah, so I mean, I would say we're almost done with this phase of our work. All of the committee members have had an opportunity to review this It would be great if the broader Climate Change, Climate Planning Action Committee could also review it and give us some feedback. There are of course some big questions, which I think are going to reemerge for each of the working groups. The biggest question is, Now that we have our goals and we have our approach and our strategy and activities, how is this going to happen?

Where is the funding and the resources going to come from to make what I think is a fairly realistic and relatively small scale and affordable set of conservation land working group goals How can we make that happen?

Speaker 3 (31:13–32:02)

We're recognizing that we sent this out. After the normal, so normally when we're bringing materials to the committee and we want to have a, we're expecting people to have read it and be prepared to discuss it in detail. Those should be distributed by the Friday before so people have a chance to do it over the weekend. I was saying, not expecting that people would be ready with detailed feedback now.

Let's plan on looking over this and having some feedback and suggestions for the next meeting.

Speaker 7 (32:04–32:17)

What is the proper forum to do that? probably to the support of this group.

Speaker 3 (32:19–33:05)

We're somewhat constrained by open meeting loss. Not really clear in my own mind where the line is between providing some feedback offline and conferring. I would handle that by making a copy of it and putting my comments in that and sharing it one-to-one maybe with the document owner, in this case, Brian. So that way, it's just between you and him.

That's not a quorum conferring. You're free to discuss it offline.

Speaker 7 (33:07–33:23)

And just as a follow-up question, it's OK for us to reach out feedback about the canopy. Yes. Yeah.

Speaker 3 (33:25–33:28)

Just to, can I have the screen share back?

Speaker 2 (33:29–33:38)

A lot of this came from those groups.

Speaker 3 (33:40–37:19)

That's true, but the sort of general question, should we be reaching out to relevant people to get their Absolutely. I think that's really going to be the majority of the work that we do. But the focus I'd like us to have in the near term is, I think we did a fair amount of that last year. I think engaging stakeholders is hard if you're not yet there.

Everybody's concerned about climate, but not many people know what climate actually looks like. Even, I think, for all of us, it's still very complicated. What are the stakes goals that we have to achieve? So I'll just put up a zoom.

refresher, our high-level Gantt chart. So we did, throughout last year, expert and stakeholder engagement, we put together a one-pager sort of top action recommendations in each section. We talked to folks about them. At the pace we were going, we talked to a bunch of folks at town hall who now no longer work here.

So I think we should get to a place where we have a fairly complete listing of the goals and strategies that we want to work towards. Maybe not all the way down, breaking it down to actions, because we may want to prioritize first before we start planning the interim action. I think when I say a complete draft plan, it should be working backwards from the goals, the emissions outcomes, to make sure that we're proposing outcomes that would actually meet the charge. And they're going to feel totally impossible.

And then the question then will be, what strategies can we employ to move in that direction? You'll probably have a goal that 90% of vehicles will be meeting this time. 2015, something like that. Obviously you can't go out and just start forcing people to buy 1,000 a year.

Where do you begin? And I think once we've got the goals and we've got strategies for how we'll begin, it'll become clearer who would be involved in executing on those strategies. And then another question I have, a total question mark for me, is the second start and approved common action plan. Presumably that's by a select board and or county input.

Speaker 7 (37:19–37:23)

I'm not quite sure what that process will look like.

Speaker 3 (37:27–37:46)

Question kind of related to this in terms of what's the thought process for managing redundancies and overlap. Because I can see a lot of them, like I already know of tree canopy and shade trees are part of some of the other working group plans that are being worked on.

Speaker 7 (37:46–37:55)

So is there thinking about how to oversee that people aren't doing the same research or having the same conversations more than necessary?

Speaker 3 (37:56–38:59)

That's one reason that I just kind of in desperation over exactly what you're talking about while set up that air table with the forms. I know it probably felt like a lot of digital overhead, but the problem I've been having is over the summer, I was trying to draft out just the building section of the Climate Action Plan and just finding almost everything I looked at belonged in several categories. And so it feels a lot easier to me to put it in a database and tag it to both categories. And then, so I think if we have a central repository of the sort of strategies, actions, and goals that we're considering, we can all look there and you put something in that turns out to be a duplicate, like, well, we can review it periodically and go, hey, these are duplicates.

Speaker 5 (39:01–39:08)

Is that what you meant? Or did you mean that other parts of town government would have done it?

Speaker 3 (39:08–39:11)

No, no. We aren't supposed to figure that out.

Speaker 5 (39:12–39:14)

But there is a shade treatment.

Speaker 8 (39:14–39:14)

Right.

Speaker 5 (39:14–39:15)

They're planning.

Speaker 7 (39:16–39:35)

Yeah, I don't know. I wonder if it makes sense to have someone who's in charge of checking on, I guess that's what our overall meetings would be for, but like checking what everyone's drafting on a regular basis to check for redundancies.

Speaker 3 (39:36–39:59)

Now I'm definitely doing some of that. It gets a little overwhelming. I'm trying to get it all collected in one place. Because the problem, one problem we had last year was we produced a lot of documents, and then like multiple drafts of documents on the same topic.

It's just a little hard to know what's in there. I think it's going to be hard regardless.

Speaker 11 (40:02–40:59)

I have a question, it's Maggie. So I know last year when we started, you had us look at multiple towns, different climate action plans, and there were different parts of each town, you know, that I kind of like different parts of. I'm wondering if there's You know, did you have a town that you thought was, you know, a really top notch plan? Because the state goals are the same state goals, no matter what town we are in.

You know, our approach might be different because our lands are different and our buildings are different and our cut through traffic is different. But I'm wondering, is there one climate action plan in particular that you really like and you are striving for Milton to adopt?

Speaker 3 (41:04–42:49)

There's no one plan that I feel like, oh, I'll just cut and paste. I think there are several plans that I like aspects of. One issue is that the state's goals have evolved a lot in the last few years. The climate law committing Massachusetts to net zero was passed in 2021.

And then, of course, it takes agencies a year, two years, three years to promulgate the plans that were mandated by the law. Those have come out in 2022, 2023. And a lot of the better plans from towns that are really on top of this are much older than that. So some of their goals are way more aggressive than the state's goal, which I just don't.

I mean, I think things are hard enough. So I couldn't take them without modification. So like Acton is an example of a town that is similar in size to Milton and has been very forward leaning on climate action planning. So I think there is a good resource.

And then some of the larger cities have good plans that were very, very thoughtfully done in a more recent, like Somerville. I think is a good resource. I just found, I didn't even have that one until a couple weeks ago, but I really like it. But it's Somerville, so they have a sustainability staff of 11, so their plan is going to be a little more ambitious.

Speaker 11 (42:50–43:36)

That's what I was sort of wondering, because there are bigger communities with staff, you know, do we really necessarily have to reinvent the wheel? And if you have, you know, you've been doing this a long time, you've been on sustainable Milton forever. So, you know, you're, you know, you're, you've been sort of, you know, dreaming of this, I would assume. And so, you know, I don't want to then come in and, you know, do something a little bit different that might be, you know, different than what you're envisioning.

So it'd be nice to have kind of a template of things that you're sort of, you know, thinking.

Speaker 3 (43:37–44:27)

So I'd say I do envision this process as one of like reading others, other town plans and the state's plans and like drawing from those to create our own plan. And none of us here is qualified to invent climate solutions from old cloth. They're all based in science. They're all based in emerging technologies.

They're all based in research that's been done at the federal and state and nonprofit level. I mean, there's so much information out there. And I think the challenge that I've felt, and I feel like we've all been experiencing, is there's just so much information that organizing it into something coherent that's also appropriate for Melton has been much harder than I thought it would be.

Speaker 11 (44:27–45:07)

Has done an excellent job kind of laying it out simply, you know, one, two, three, you know, and then so that's, is this kind of how you're envisioning each category to do it. So, you know, we are creating one plan and the plan should be cohesive. So it would be nice to know what kind of just template, you know, you talk about the goals, do you want the goals listed, you know, and then right next to it as a strategy, like, is there an actual template you want us to kind of follow?

Speaker 3 (45:09–48:51)

Yeah, I'd love to get there. But let me show you what I do have in mind. And this was kind of lying behind my ask for this month. Definitely a common theme across all the climate action plans that I've seen is that they're organized into goals, strategies, and actions.

I think depending on which climate action plan you look at, they're not always really sort of consistent about what they mean by these things. But the goal is an outcome. It's not how you're going to get there or who's going to do it. It's the physical, verifiable outcome in the world that will directly cause emissions to be reduced.

And that's where we're collecting this model. X many cars are electrified per household vehicle miles traveled is reduced by 2030 by this much. Just to clarify, what are you trying to do? And then usually linked to each goal are strategies.

How are we going to approach that? And that can be qualitative. So I think we may have a goal that every household in Melton would have access to charging infrastructure that would make it possible for them to own. But it would probably be unwise to say, well, therefore, Massachusetts plans to install 7,000, so let's do 50.

I think Melton is a highly residential town where lots of people have driveways. So the need for EV infrastructure may be different in Milton than the rest of Massachusetts. The strategy might be to begin with a study where there are people who want EVs but can't get them to charge. The point is that the strategies are probably where the need is.

of the thinking is in terms of what kind of outreach programs do we need? What partners do we work with? And where are they deliverable? Are we getting bylaws passed?

Are we doing an outreach program? And then I think once we have like a So it's very clear vision in terms of goals and strategies. Breaking it down to the action level, who's going to do what by when, is more like a prioritization thing where that's where we get serious about, OK, with the resources we actually have, what do we do next? Like planning out detailed actions for things you don't even have the resources to do today is maybe a waste of time.

This is how I'm thinking about it. This slide deck is linked from the Google Doc version of the agenda that I sent out. We went over it in May as well, but most of you were there, so I thought we'd revisit it. Any questions or input on this?

Speaker 2 (48:55–51:20)

We can segue into that. So I just thought a bit about this and I hope we've gone back and forth a little bit. The state goals in some areas are not quantifying. And I know that you lean heavily and I support you in having quantifiable goals.

Where they are quantifiable, they're statewide. And just in terms of thinking through what that means to tiny book of Lovett and Milton, and they were just a little sliver of that. And in order to put energy into figuring out how we contribute to the state goals itself, I think is a fairly heavy duty process. So in this, in our conservation land, working group, we gave credence to the state goals, both quantifiable and not quantifiable, but we put priority on outcomes.

I mean, this is lingo, but our plan is categorized in terms of three goals. right now. And for each goal, there are two-year outcomes, which most of them probably don't deal with the amount of CO2 that we have mitigated as a result of our work. But the outcomes do relate to the concrete progress steps that can verify whether this goal within the context of Milton, not necessarily the whole state, can be reached.

Speaker 3 (51:23–53:00)

Yeah, I mean, I think conservation is a bit of a special beast that straddles adaptation and mitigation. The state's goals for natural land conservation basically come down to increasing permanent conservation land and minimizing losses of forest land overall. And I know that's something that many of you on the conservation working group are concerned about, maintaining our green space in Milton. So I think that that's going to be a good fit and eventually you want to have something to monitor.

Are we maintaining our tree canopy in Dalton? And there's a goal to increase conservation land statewide from 27% of currently to 30% by 2030 and 40% by 2050. We already are above 30% of Milton landmass, so I think it's kind of a judgment call of what the target would be in Milton. But I just think that's the thought process that should be included in this on some level.

But also, there are all these things that are more in the adaptation realm, like it needs to be healthy land. And that's so much harder to quantify. I don't, you know, all of this stuff is important.

Speaker 2 (53:00–53:28)

The sequestration goal for the state is 25% below the 1990 level by 2030. That's what you sent to me, and it seems like a reasonable goal, but I just don't know to actually measure that goal in the small activities that we're doing I don't know how practical.

Speaker 3 (53:30–53:32)

Matt, you wanted to say something?

Speaker 9 (53:32–53:57)

Yeah, just a question. Ron's mentioned two years is the time horizon on this goal. And it's absolutely possible that I missed the two-year window for these goals. Is that for all of the working groups, or is this something that I just that Ron is comfortable with and he's working in kind of a tighter window as opposed to 2025, 2030, and 2050.

Speaker 2 (53:57–54:47)

Yeah, I know that those come from this working group and from the goal of trying to put something together that is concrete and kind of measurable within a short window frame of time. which I think would appeal to any members of the supply board or whoever is doing this, as opposed to going out further time-wise to 2030 or 2050. So I don't think anybody else is doing this yet, and we're kind of the first to propose it. Other people don't think it's

Speaker 9 (54:48–55:46)

I mean, I could understand it. Again, it's not right or wrong. I could understand it if there's a lot of kind of infrastructure to build. That's the wrong word.

Let's say a lot of research to do, a lot of relationship building to do. In other words, you need a couple of years to really get set up and develop a baseline, at which point then you can start to set quantifiable targets, you know, for 2030 as an example. So I think that would make more sense in kind of in kind of a setup mode, if you see what I mean. And again, I've read the plan, Ron, but you'll know it better than I.

Is that kind of the thought process here in terms of that tighter window? Is there just so much work to do to kind of get set up and get active here that we really can't dream about, you know, conserving land, you know, a target of Axe and Milton by 2030, because we have so much setup work to do. And so that's really the focus for the next 24 months.

Speaker 2 (55:47–55:51)

Right, that's the rationale that we use.

Speaker 3 (55:51–56:04)

I would just pick a plan that says, like, this impossible thing over here is where we're trying to go, and we don't know how to get there. This is where we're starting. I'd rather have a plan that just admits that, rather than kind of leaving out.

Speaker 9 (56:04–56:26)

Yeah, I just think that's important. At least it's important for me. Maybe other folks caught that as kind of an acceptable way to approach this. But helpful for me to think about that is, you know, a step towards something obviously much, much larger, which is going to have to fall in line with the state targets.

So, thanks for that.

Speaker 3 (56:27–56:29)

Yeah. Lisa, you were going to say something?

Speaker 5 (56:29–56:46)

Yeah. So, I just had a request that when people show documents, if you could after, who's ever taking the minutes, if you can email the links so that I can include the link in the notes. The ones I've shown are already in the agenda.

Speaker 3 (56:47–56:50)

And I will add, Ron, was there another one?

Speaker 11 (56:52–58:53)

Yeah, so just to follow up on that two year. So I haven't spoken to Ron directly about this, but personally from a conservation perspective and land acquisition perspective, Milton is under a lot of pressure for development. And we just, town meeting, just surprisingly to me, Voted to take land out of conservation and tear down, you know. Trees to build a new school and I don't want to argue if we need a new school or not.

My daughter's a teacher. I understand all the needs. But from a land acquisition standpoint, just drive around town. Like, you know, I've been in town 50 years and, you know, just recently I was taking one of my guys to go see a job and he's been working for me for 20 and he's like, oh my God, look at all this construction in Milton, look at all these trees that are being taken down.

There's a lot going on, you know, just go down Randolph Ave, you know, memory care, 300 trees coming down. So to me, I do feel like there's pressure to come up with some type of, strategy to conserve our green spaces, open spaces, somehow come up with money to buy more space. My understanding is even the CPC was a little bit surprised that nobody even put in a a proposal to buy some land, you know, we should be working with property owners to, you know, to come up with a plan. So it's a very aggressive timeline and I understand that, but I do think it's really important.

So I do applaud Ron's, you know, aggressive, if some people call it aggressive, but I approve his timeline.

Speaker 3 (58:57–01:00:40)

Yes, it's probably a good time to start segueing into the goals and take a look at the, let's see, take a look at what we put into the air table. I'll just relate it back to, you asked about a template. And so I'll describe the process I have in my mind because I think Doing it all in a Word document is really hard because it's going to be such a big document right away. And finding stuff in it becomes challenging.

And then if you have like, hey, we're working on this strategy. Doesn't that kind of apply to buildings and electricity and also transportation? Oh, let me cross-reference 30 pages farther in the document. Oh, yeah.

I'm a data person, and so I think in terms of spreadsheets and databases. And I just have this powerful desire for a database of goals, a database of strategies, a database of actions where I can just, if a strategy relates to two goals, I can just lend it to both of them. When I want to see all the strategies that relate to a goal, I just run a query, and I see them. And you don't have to decide.

The thing I kept bumping up against was, well, do I put this under buildings, or do I put it under transportation, or any mobile questions like that. So I just started by setting up.

Speaker 1 (01:00:40–01:00:49)

Let me share that again.

Speaker 3 (01:00:55–01:01:12)

There's all this Zoom stuff on my screen. I can't see the tabs or anything.

Speaker 8 (01:01:12–01:01:31)

Apologies. I need to drop to join a different meeting, but I'm looking forward to the meeting on Monday with the- The rest will be up on YouTube. Okay. That's great.

Well, thank you. Everyone have a good night.

Speaker 3 (01:01:56–01:05:18)

So you guys found a lot of goals. That's awesome. Part of what I was doing was testing whether I could impose some restrictions. But ideally, the goals that we put in our climate action plan would relate to some existing stakeholder.

I think we quickly ran into cases where there were very reasonable goals that we ought to be working towards that don't have any corresponding state goal. Like under heat waves, we're having trouble finding any coherent state goals for heat wave readiness. It doesn't mean we shouldn't have them. Sure, we'll find some at some point.

So I think the exact structure, I'm happy to change. But basically, I started with goals at the town level, at the state level. And what I envisioned was having this place where you can submit things into this table here, explicitly link them together. And then I add a strategies table and an actions table so that As you think of things, or you find things that you're reading and other towns climate action plans that you think sounds like a good idea for Milton, you can just put it in there and not worry too much about is this a good idea, or have I put it exactly the right way, or has anybody else added this?

Just ask. Everything will be in here, and we can, within the working groups, or when we're merging everything together. Later on, we can refine and duplicate. If we realize later that a strategy links to two different goals, or three different goals, we can just add those ones later.

And then generate a document from that at the end, rather than trying to edit an 80-page Word document by committee. All right. So we're actually talking about the goal. I haven't really thought about how to track unintended consequences or secondary impacts of things.

I wanted to just get to a place where if we're planning to do something, we can relate it to a strategy that we know relates to reducing emissions.

Speaker 7 (01:05:18–01:05:26)

Right, but we're not going to go down to a very particular action, so we're not going to think about a particular outcome or output on that.

Speaker 3 (01:05:26–01:06:19)

So there are goals in here from the states roadmap to We have 28% of all commercial and municipal buildings implementing energy efficiency requisites by 2020. And they've quantified how much emissions reduction, they've modeled how much emissions reduction to get to that. Probably the first thing we do to move in that direction is gonna be some kind of outreach program. It'd be impossible to quantify, I mean, it'll be difficult to quantify it.

It's possible to do it in advance. If we measure success, we might be able to put back something. The adoption curve is going to be an estimate. Getting fixated on, well, we better do an equal amount every year.

Speaker 5 (01:06:19–01:06:44)

In the interest of time, how about each group takes one or two goals from the state one and maybe discuss how they think that could flow into a town hall, and then maybe even less a strategy.

Speaker 3 (01:06:45–01:07:09)

Yeah. Or even just sharing with the group one or two that surprised you, new information for you. I didn't expect that people would have figured out how we began moving in this direction for tonight. But, yeah, how about transportation?

Let's go 1st and talk about 1 or 2 of them.

Speaker 5 (01:07:10–01:08:41)

So, I'm looking at row 36. It's kind of general increase alternatives to personal vehicle use. It's the short distance transportation alternatives. And then if you look at the descript, if you click on that, the description is.

a 15% reduction in passenger vehicle emissions by 2050. I was a little surprised. I thought that was kind of small. But I guess if that's what the state is saying, then maybe it's more achievable than I thought.

So if the town plan was to reduce passenger vehicle emissions by 15%, then some strategies would be to look at, you know, reinforcing bike infrastructure, you know, electric vehicles, how people commute to work, promoting carpooling, promoting, you know, I also represent the school committee, so I'm big on getting, you know, carpooling and buses, maybe electric buses, you know, incentivizing less, you know, one adult and, you know, one family driving and maybe multiple families coordinating. So those would be some strategies.

Speaker 3 (01:08:41–01:09:26)

Yeah, related to it is this other one, number 30. There's a goal to reduce light-duty vehicle miles traveled per household. The state's plan modeling anticipates total vehicle miles traveled to increase. But that's still within the pathway.

As long as the conversion to EVs is happening at the pace they're anticipating, the goal is really to limit the growth of vehicle miles traveled under a ceiling and achieving that through.

Speaker 5 (01:09:29–01:09:39)

But they're acknowledging vehicle miles traveled will increase, but there'll still be a reduction in emissions.

Speaker 3 (01:09:39–01:09:43)

An individual household will first of all be driving

Speaker 5 (01:09:44–01:10:06)

I'm comparing the two. So you can have the individual household vehicle miles decrease, but also overall you want the emissions from passenger vehicles to decrease, even though total vehicle miles has increased.

Speaker 3 (01:10:06–01:10:30)

I'm a little confused. I think it's 15% less than would have been if people grow the same amount that they drive now with population growth and all that, because there's a goal further up here to reduce GHG emissions from transportation by 86%. So I think that's the gross reduction by 2050.

Speaker 5 (01:10:33–01:11:02)

But that's all transportation, right? All transportation. The other one is, see, it's like, yeah, because you have different grades of, you know, you have a lot of units in here. You have to wrap your brain around what they mean.

Anyway, so here, just one, how to define one, you know, one goal, one strategy, it does get very complex. All right, I'll pass to the next person.

Speaker 11 (01:11:03–01:12:14)

Oh, I have a question. Are our goals, like especially for buildings and transportation, you know, I'm a firm believer that you lead by example. Now, is it easier or should we look at for if we are trying to reduce, you know, short-term travel or carpooling, does it start with like our terminal fees? You know, Jack might not like this suggestion, but instead of Jack hopping into his DPW truck to go, somewhere when he hop on a bike.

Like, are these the policies that are internal at Town Hall? You know, and is Town Hall putting together, you know, they're reducing, I know they have solar panels on like Cunningham, but as I said last year, it was broken. And no one knew it was broken for like a year, and I believe it's still broken. So I just, you know, if the town is going to create a plan, for us residents to follow, then I think that they need to follow it as well.

So is that where we start?

Speaker 3 (01:12:14–01:12:25)

I think it's a strategy-level discussion. Okay. I can't imagine that we wouldn't address the municipal front of this though.

Speaker 5 (01:12:25–01:13:32)

The example I gave was targeted at, what was it? It was passenger vehicles. So, you know, one aspect of that is, you know, households, but another aspect is the municipal fleet. And, you know, I definitely have thoughts about what the goals for the municipal fleet would be, but that's a much smaller slice compared to, you know, the number of households, but it does set a good example.

So I think Part of what we do is to look at what levers do we have. We have more levers to have the town government be a good role model. We have less levers to get individuals in a capitalistic country to adopt certain measures. But we can create incentives to do that.

So that's kind of my thought. on in the way I'm approaching these goals.

Speaker 3 (01:13:34–01:13:39)

So in the interest of time, I'll just quickly do a couple for building. What do you want to do next?

Speaker 2 (01:13:39–01:13:46)

Is it possible to build into your vision more near-term outcomes?

Speaker 3 (01:13:48–01:14:42)

Well, I will shortly after this meeting, I'll add a strategies table and actions table. And people can start putting stuff in there. Near-term outcomes. I guess outcomes, you can put that on the goals table and the target date on that.

I only put 2030 and 2050 goals because that's what the state is defining on this table, but you can put any date you like in there. So yeah, so the other goals table is the ones that we want to propose for Meltzer, and my only ask there is to make it like a measurable outcome. So I think there, not to call you out, even though you put some things in there, like let's investigate such and such. I see that as a strategy.

So when I create the strategy table,

Speaker 7 (01:14:43–01:15:04)

And when you put things in this sheet, should we put everything that's in the state with specifics of where we won't do something because it's either not enough. So we have addressed everything that's in the state plan. So if something doesn't pertain to us, we aren't going to do anything about it. But we can explicitly state we're not going to.

Speaker 3 (01:15:04–01:15:21)

I mean, I think if we don't put any strategies against something, it would be clear that we're not doing anything about it. There's also a component of strategy, which is deciding what you're not going to do about it. And to the extent that we're making some tough decisions to not do something, probably worth recording that.

Speaker 2 (01:15:23–01:15:27)

Might be good to just have a lexicon of our terminology.

Speaker 3 (01:15:28–01:18:08)

Yeah, I'm trying. I have actually written a short summary of this in the draft Climate Action Plan that I put over the summer. I think it's accessible to you guys. In that first overview slide deck, I linked to it.

It's in Sustainable Milton's SharePoint drive, because I can't work with it online. Doesn't let me deal with it. I'll send that out afterwards. So quickly, knowing we're a little short on time here, Building goals is a sub-goal to reduce emissions from residential heating and cooling by 95% by 2050 versus 92% for commercial and industrial heating and cooling.

So they're differentiating by sector a little bit. going down into the sort of priority action plan, the chief levers they are looking at to achieve that emissions reduction goal are home energy efficiency. So there's goals around 24% of single family homes having an energy efficiency retrofit by 2030, 63% of existing homes having one by 2050. And this is just like, better windows, better inflation, not the heating and cooling equipment.

There's a separate goal for 20% of housing units electrify with high performance air source heat pumps by 2030. That's a ridiculously ambitious goal. That's kind of what the model says is necessary to be honest. But also 4.5% doing it with geothermal heat pumps.

So there's a couple of different technologies that they're focused on. And likewise, similar goals for commercial and municipal. So that's what I'll focus on for building. And Arthur, I did put in the few that you told me about.

For waste, do you want to speak to those quickly?

Speaker 4 (01:18:11–01:21:20)

This is the state goal for a 30% reduction, as stated here, 2030, and a 90% reduction in solids waste by 2050. No question that the latter is extraordinarily ambitious. But much of this is driven, as Jack may attest, by the fact that we are losing landfills. So maybe in one or two years, there will only be one open.

And then, of course, there's the difficulty of shipping to states that will have landfills open and what the costs of that entail, and then the extent to which their landfills are going to gradually close as well. Then we'll be breaking down. a number of topics. You have food waste going into composting, what goals might be there.

You indicated that when we were having a conversation recently, Alex, at 10%. And in a couple of the plans that I'll be working on with Kim and company on Monday night will be seeing what it is that they're setting up for this particular activity. And you were indicating, as some others have, that Sustainable Milton is very interested in moving the needle on food waste diversion in the town of Milton. Right now, I believe we only have about 300 participating households, Jack, could that be it?

And the desire to increase that significantly. We also have to look in this total context at communications and the extent that and people understand the availability of alternative resources and actions that can be taken, as well as looking at what it is that town can afford. The topic of affordability in Milton is a very important one. And I hope that part of the work that our committee will be doing is moving away from the way in which much planning has been done and more toward not how we solve today's problem for today, but how we anticipate tomorrow's problems and needs and resolve those on a very timely basis.

Some of the plans in other communities for waste management go back to 2019. It's true for the city of Boston, it's true for the city of Cambridge. The town of Brookline in Norfolk County, a cousin of Milton, had his plan in 2021. So we have some good models to look at, but we have a lot of catching up to do on a short string.

Speaker 3 (01:21:22–01:22:00)

Yeah, and just an example, you're asking about shorter term goals. You know, to Samuel Milton, working on a goal of getting to 600 Black Earth subscribers in the next year or so. And that will be something that we could drop into the goals table, put a one or two year target date on it and be working on that now. And it obviously links back to this.

It's hard to see how we get from 600 to 90%. reduction of waste disposal. That's a crazy number.

Speaker 11 (01:22:01–01:22:06)

And just as a question, does Black Earth use electric trucks to go and do it?

Speaker 3 (01:22:08–01:22:12)

These things are all unrelated. They do not.

Speaker 11 (01:22:13–01:22:16)

They should get greenhouse gases. Are they contributing?

Speaker 3 (01:22:17–01:22:19)

Between now and 2050, I bet they'll switch.

Speaker 11 (01:22:21–01:22:21)

That's good.

Speaker 4 (01:22:22–01:23:44)

Wow. To Maggie's point, if I may for just a moment, that's recognized very broadly by communities and one of the things that is being looked at until there might be alternative fuel means for heavy equipment. such as trash trucks, as we call them, is introducing measures whereby trash reductions might be reduced from once a week to once every two weeks. by setting up programs, educational programs, and methodologies that reduce the amount of trash that's consumed by or yielded by individual households.

We also have to be looking in this community now at something that we didn't have to look at before, and that is large scale buildings, the 40 Bs, now these two of which are going to have 90 or more units in them. And how we manage and prepare for that today rather than wait until four or five years from now when they're all on stream and say, oh, Milton has a problem. We have to get away from that culture and get to the problem solving and anticipation type of orientation.

Speaker 3 (01:23:46–01:23:59)

I'm looking at the time, and we have one more agenda topic. And I apologize, Matt, for squeezing you. We talked a little bit about conservation goals. Are you comfortable with moving on to topic six?

Speaker 9 (01:24:00–01:30:53)

Yeah, sure. Thanks. So I talked a little bit about a new development in town, proposed development by the Gardner School. Let me give you a little background here.

So it is a seven-acre lot on Blue Hills Avenue. The sale is pending to the Gardner School, which is a for-profit private pre-K, not to be confused with Goddard Schools, which is another pre-K private school in town. So this is the Gardner School. The current land has no utilities, no roads.

No cutaway to Blue Hill Avenue is heavily forested and is quite sloped. Um, and from what I understand from folks that have been to the site and, and, and people that are close to this issue is it's going to be a massive undertaking to develop land. Clear, clear, cutting trees, bulldozing, et cetera. Um, and expected that there'll be significant, uh, habitat destruction and potential for stormwater runoff.

There was another potential buyer in town for this land who's a resident whose bid was unsuccessful. Her property abuts the seven-acre parcel. She offered what she thought to be fair market value and proposed to put the land into a conservation trust. So that's the background.

Seven Acres, Gardner School, big undertaking, a lot of trees getting cut down, another buyer in town that tried to buy it at a fair offer. Again, the detail of that is not really what's at issue here. But it was not approved. So why do I bring this to Milton's Climate Action Planning Committee?

Number one is, and Maggie, you brought this up earlier, is we should be thinking about keeping our natural habitat. And in fact, this could represent a setback in our own goals, right? So, as Alec has already said, is that the state goals are to increase permanent conservation lands to at least 28% by 2025, at least 30% by 2030, and at least 40% by 2050. And so at a high level, again, as Alex said, and Alex, I'm going to use your math since I trust it, is that although we're above the average right now, estimated about 33% of conserved land to the state's target of 27%, If we wanted to increase in line from percentage basis with the state goals, we need to be conserving around 104 acres of new conservation land by 2025, over 300 acres by 2030, and over 1300 acres by 2050, right?

So if the state has got a target of X and we're already overdeveloped, to X. The state's not counting on us to reduce. It's expecting us to increase at the same level on a percentage basis. Otherwise, their math falls apart, right?

And they would expect that in all the towns as they're looking at conservation land across the Commonwealth. So we actually need to be conserving more space on a percentage basis just to keep up with our spare share, if you see what I mean in terms of the the state goal. So number one is a setback for our own goals within Milton from a conservation standpoint. The second is from a coordination standpoint.

Again, I'm new to the committee. I'm new to town politics in a way. And so how do we better coordinate amongst the various town communities is really the question. We've got CPAC here in Milton.

We're striving to meet our own clean energy goals vis-a-vis the state targets. A conservation committee, I talked to Tom Palmer and John Kiernan, who visited the site. And John, last year, Maggie, you spoke about CPC applications for purchase of land. They actually proposed helping this resident buy the land.

So they did submit an application to CPC. but that application was not approved. Open space and rec planning, I reached out to somebody that I know on that committee. It's not really an active committee.

I'm sure there's a reason why. But they would also potentially have a seat at the table. And then of course, the planning committee has got an important seat at the table here. And while I've not had a chance to talk to anybody on planning as I'm just trying to get up to speed here, I understand that it's on the agenda for next week's planning committee meeting.

And so number one, again, I see it as a setback to our own goals. Anytime we're selling land to a developer when a resident was happy to buy it, And most likely is going to not maintain the integrity of the land. They're going to build a school. And you can look up the site plans and what they intend to do there.

And it seems to me that it's very unlikely that it will be a small building with a small parking lot and a whole lot of trees. At least that's not what the current site schematic looks like. While I'm not ready to move to the third point, which is about what can be done or even concessions yet, right? If the sale does progress, you know, what can we negotiate to maintain the integrity of that land?

So that's it. You know, really, it's as much a discussion about how to coordinate with the other committees as it is, you know, essentially giving you an update on a piece of land. But I think it's important that we're at least all aware that it's potentially a setback to our own goals, and that through at least the resources in town that I've been able to track down, we tried, we weren't successful, and I worry about the next one. And that's what I've got.

Speaker 11 (01:30:53–01:33:05)

interesting you brought that up because I talked to the town administrator today and I've been struggling with this and I've been frustrated. I've been on the planning board for only two years, but this is my biggest thing. And one of the things I asked him was like, for instance, the conservation commission, and Arthur could speak on this, has a tree fund. And I just asked Nick today, I said, is there any way that we can take some of that money you know, because we as a town have a line item in our budget for trees every year and, you know, can we take possibly some of the money from the conservation tree fund and can we use that in a, you know, in a more broad um application and can we use that to acquire some land you know and we need to set up and I talked to him I said we need to set up like an open space acquisition fund and how do we get that audit and I said that to him I said we the town has not done outreach for property owners And probably now, as I said to him, the people I talk to are a little bit nervous about leaving land to the town, just because of the whole lands, woods debacle.

And how do we get and convince people to work with the town and come up with some type of plan? And it doesn't have to be large, Shrack seven acres is a big enough area, but some people have small blocks. And sometimes it's the smaller lots in neighborhoods where there's not a lot of tree canopy and there's heat islands everywhere that really are important. And you look at Amor Road, it was one acre on the corner of Amor Road and the developer bought it for 500,000.

Why couldn't the town come up with $500,000?

Speaker 9 (01:33:07–01:34:06)

Maybe just one more before somebody jumps in. This resident who I know quite well has been working on this. I heard about it probably three years ago for the first time. In terms of exhausting all resources, this is one where, you know, every phone call, every year, every, you know, process that could be followed.

She did. It just didn't, yeah, either there's not enough, Maggie, like you said, maybe funds need to be repurposed or she missed something and she's not, doesn't seem that kind of person that would have kind of exhausted all kind of talent, talent options here. So, yeah, maybe something can be fixed in the future, but at least for, or seven acres, it's a big piece of property. Again, it's not approved yet, but let's just say it's not trending in the right direction, having exhausted all means within.

Speaker 3 (01:34:06–01:35:23)

Over time, I really have to leave in the next few minutes here, so I'm going to. Well, it's out of details. I'll just say, I think it would be premature for this committee to try to get involved in this particular outcome as a committee. I mean, everybody's free to work the processes they know about.

I think it's a great case in point of the kind of thing that's gonna come up between now and 2050. And I agree with you, Maggie, you need to develop a strategy for how you approach these situations in general, build capacity to acquire and protect land. And I think having a slightly longer term focus now will be helpful rather than kind of chasing, trying to change an outcome as the Climate Action Committee that's happening right now before we built that capacity, rather than viewing it as potentially an opportunity to learn what didn't work, what could we have done differently, and how can we turn that into a playbook for when these situations come up in the future. No.

Arthur, you want to make a comment?

Speaker 4 (01:35:23–01:37:03)

I'll be very brief. Thank you, Alex. I think what this conversation is pointing to is systemic problems to resolve. Matt pointed out about the need for coordination, articulation, and collaboration among different committees.

We have an Open Space and Recreation Plan Committee that hasn't updated its plan since 2006. Some of its wording is contradictory. You can't tell whether it's focused only on public lands or public and private lands. Other communities have, as Maggie was referring, I believe, to acquisition funds in reserve.

I am affiliated with another town in the Commonwealth where I spend a lot of time. 85 acres of land went up on the market in that community last month, the town moved and acquired it because it had planned and positioned itself to be able to do so. It was anticipating the future. We can't, again, as I said earlier, wait for the present to solve a problem that can only be resolved by future planning.

We also have to take a look at conservation restrictions. And there's no reason why we can't advertise and market to the members of the community their ability and the tax benefits of putting conservation restrictions on private property that they and their heirs will retain. There are plenty of mousetraps to follow in working down this road. We just have to do it.

Identify, plan, and execute. End of speech.

Speaker 3 (01:37:04–01:37:38)

Thank you. So I'm late for an appointment across the green here. So I will entertain a motion to adjourn. Second.

Any nos? All yes. Yes. Adjourned.

Adjourned. Excellent. You can just pretend I did a roll call. Thank you, everybody.

It's really great to see you. And let's keep these passionate discussions going in the working groups.

Speaker 1 (01:37:38–01:37:40)

All right. Thanks, everyone.