Board: Board Of Appeals
Date: 2026-09-10
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:18–00:44)
All right, it's 7.01 on September 10, 2026. I'm going to call to order the first hearing of the night by the Milton Zoning Board of Appeals. My name is Jeffrey Moe, and I'll be acting as chair. With me tonight, members of the board, Michael Brown and Nick Gray.
The first hearing we have is upon the application of Zachary and Alexa. Is it Alexa?
Speaker 2 (00:45–00:46)
Alexa, yes.
Speaker 1 (00:46–00:48)
Alexa, roll you.
Speaker 2 (00:49–00:49)
Ruel.
Speaker 1 (00:50–06:06)
Upon the application of Zachary and Alexa Ruel at 39 Frothingham Street, dated July 29, 2026, seeking a special permit to build a two-story addition with a 5 foot by 26 foot breezeway and a 13 foot by 26 foot single car garage with habitable space above it to the left side of the existing structure. The property is in a residence C zoning district, whereas the proposed addition would be built 4.9 feet from the left side lot line and 21.5 feet from the rear lot line under the Milton bylaw. Section 27.41 that requires 10 foot side setbacks and 30 foot rear setbacks. The permit request was therefore denied and will require a special permit from the board of appeals to proceed.
All is set forth in the application and plans on file with the board. I see the applicant is with us, represented by Attorney Marion McKettrick, familiar to the board. Welcome. Before we begin the proceeding and offer the applicants a A moment to present a case, let me, let me just let everybody know what we have in the file.
We've got the applicant application to which I referred earlier data July. 27, 2026 submitted by attorney on behalf of the applicants. Substantially consistent with what I just read in terms of the relief that the applicants are seeking a form of a special permit on the section 275. 4.1B with respect to side setbacks and rear setbacks.
We have the letter of denial written by the Town of Milton Inspection Services Department to the applicant. Uh, that that's dated July 14. we have a letter from Mrs. McKettrick laying out the details of the application.
I'm sure she'll get into it in her application as well in her presentation as well as a standard. For decision, I'll note that the decision is dated. I mean, the letter is dated July 22nd. It might, it may be helpful.
Um, Mr. McKettrick, just to pause it is just to make note of the fact that the legislature has made changes to the special permit application. I mean, special need for special permit. I assume they don't apply here since since we are in front since we are here for a special permit, but we.
We do take notice for the record that the board is well aware the legislature has made changes to when a special permit is needed. I'm going to assume. Because this hearing has been called that those that circumstance doesn't apply a little bit of a detail here, because it could be that this application came in before the law was passed, et cetera, but we're very well aware of that and. Okay, may not apply very much to today this hearing, but to the others that we seek a variance tonight, I just want to note for the record.
It's a. As the attorneys know, it's a rare event that the legislature changing anything in. Chapter 48, but that's what's happened. Um.
I've got a, uh, several attachments to Mrs. McKendrick's letter, including a plot plan. Some some, uh, some plans, uh, of the residents. Prepared by Rockwood design in several sheets.
With the elevations nicely done, thank you very much for that. There's some information on the title. Your, your, your acquisition deed and the like, which, which, which often get in the property card from the town. So, I think the applicant and Mrs.
McKendrick for all of that. I'll also note that you've got 2 letters, 3 letters. I'm sorry. It's a form letter, I'll read it.
I've reviewed the plans for renovations at 30 Frothingham Street with our neighbors, Alexa and Zachary. I understand that zoning relief from the Board of Appeals will be required in order to construct a 2 story addition at the left side of their home. I have no objection. We have objections to the Board of Appeals granted the relief.
This is from The people who are at 20 lantern lane, the letter, the name is indecipherable. It would be good to enter that into the record. I assume there are the abundance to the rear. Same letter is from the property owners or at least people who live at 48 Frottingham and the same letter for 41 Frottingham.
We'll have questions and perhaps in the application, you can let us know who these people are, where they live with respect to your property, et cetera, which is standard practice. Oh, we have another one. That'd be four letters. We have the same letter.
The same letter from the Ryan's. Michael and Emily Ryan at 54, frothing him, so there's 4 letters of support that you've provided us with. Thank you very much. Let me with that introduction, I'll ask Mr.
McKendrick a state. Welcome to the board of appeals. How can we help you this evening?
Speaker 3 (06:06–12:52)
Thank you very much. I'm Mary McKettrick and I represent the applicants for this application. Since we just went over the letters from butters and those across the street, I just want to make sure that the board is aware because these have all been sent to you that there are letters in support of this application from 41, 48, 55 and 54 Frothingham. That's four letters.
Another one from 20 Lantern Lane. And although we don't have a letter from 37 Frothingham street, I checked again with the applicants today. They've spoken twice with these neighbors, including today, and they also have no objection to the granting of the relief requested. So, just wanted to say, there is 1 more that I believe you didn't list in any case.
I'd like what's sorry. Okay. Okay. I'd like to explain the application, point out a couple of details that maybe aren't obvious in the notice.
They're not critical, but I think they're somewhat important. So the applicants own a 5,880 square foot pre-existing non-conforming lot. That means the lot was recorded or described in a deed before 1938 when we adopted our zoning bylaw. and it's in a residency district.
Situated on the lot presently is a residential house. constructed in 1915 and located at a non-conforming nine foot right side setback where 10 foot is required. That's legal, but non-conforming. The rear setback is conforming at 29.3 feet.
The engineer provided measurements for us on his plans, showing us what 30% of the mean depth of the lot was. It's 25.2 feet here, so the required setback is 25.2 feet. rather than 30 feet. That's an exception that the bylaw provides.
And the front setback also is conforming. It's 24.6 feet. And the required front setback, however, is only 16.8 feet, which is 20 percent of the mean depth of the lot. There's a garage located at the left rear corner of the lot, which is at non-conforming setbacks.
It's about five feet from the left side lot line, less than one foot from the rear lot line. That garage is to be removed as part of this plan. So the proposal is to demolish the garage, add on to the house on the left side, where there's currently one end of the driveway, place a one-car garage and a mudroom on the first floor, and a master bedroom and bathroom on the second floor. The addition is set back a significant distance from the front of the house.
And certainly from the front lot line, it's 36.8 feet back to the front of the addition. It does extend closer than the existing house to the rear lot line and to the left side lot line. So there are actually two nonconformities in this proposal. I don't know if that was totally clear in the ad.
and even in the denial letter, but there are. The addition will replace a small existing porch. In the front of the addition, there'll be a covered porch and stairs. For one exit at the rear of the addition, next to the existing house, there'll be a garage access and a mudroom to enter the house.
So the non-conformities are intensified in two ways in this application. The addition is at 4.9 feet, rather than the required 10 feet from the left side lot line. And we'll be set back a nonconforming 21.5 feet from the rear lot line, rather than the required 25.2 feet. The old garage was nonconforming to the rear and to the side.
So that's going to be removed. So the new addition is nonconforming. The old garage was nonconforming. That's going to be removed.
But you have these new nonconformities. While the new addition, with the new addition, the lot and the house still meet lot coverage and gross square footage limitations for a single family home on a lot in a residency district. But I think it's important to point out that because there will be no accessory structures, it would be possible for applicants to have proposed a larger footprint and a larger gross square footage, which they are not doing, and purposefully, in order to propose a change that fits in with the neighborhood and will look good with this house. But they could have proposed something larger.
Well, they would still have the setback issues to deal with. So with this addition, there'll be a providing expanded living space. They have a growing family, two children, two adults. On the second floor, there'll be four bedrooms as there are now, but the new master bedroom over the garage will have its own bathroom.
There will be a hallway and a centrally located laundry room close to all the bedrooms. The family will now be able to park in a suitably designed garage for their vehicle. They can exit from their car directly into the house through the mudroom this will be much more convenient for the family. So the neighbors on all sides have stated that they support the relief that's being requested here.
In particular, I want to point out that the closest neighbor at 41 Frothingham Street, this is on the left side, they have reviewed these plans and they have no objection to approving the requested zoning relief. While the side of the house facing these neighbors will be closer, and the rear yard on the left side will be shorter going back. There will now be an unbroken rear yard space with removal of the old garage. And the addition will actually block the view of activities directly adjacent to the back of the house, so they'll be shielded from the direct view on the left side.
This is an attractive design. There's a peaked roof and a dormer window on the second floor over the garage, and the finishes will match those of the existing house. While the house is going to be modernized and enlarged, the home will still fit in with the surrounding neighborhood. This proposal improves the use of the lot by combining the garage with the house and removing an existing non-conforming garage, which opens up the rear part of the backyard.
And because the design of the addition will shield part of the rear yard from view on the left side, So, for these reasons, and because the neighboring property owners on all sides have no objection to granting the requested relief, we are respectfully requesting that you approve the request and if. If the chair would like to let the applicant speak, I don't know if there's anything they might want to add to that description. You're welcome to show.
Speaker 2 (12:54–13:29)
Marion, you know, she did a great job explaining all of the plans. So we thank you for your consideration. Um, I did want to mention as well. We do have a couple neighbors on the call, including 41 Frothingham directly next door where the addition would be going and directly across the street at 50 Frothingham.
So they're both, um, attending the call today in support as well. But just on a personal level, we've lived in this house for nine years already. We've grown a community within the neighborhood and just needed more spaces. Our family has grown over the years since we've moved in.
Speaker 1 (13:31–14:11)
Thank you. I'm going to ask my colleagues if they've got questions, but before I do that, I just have one 1 question for you. Council in terms of the relief that you're seeking, and I know you stated that you thought that it might not have been a clear in the ad, but is it is it not the case that. And I think you did say it's in the nature of a special permit, right?
A rare. That there's a rare issue real outline issue and a side line issue. Correct? And it's an exacerbation of the nonconformity is that, but, but is it inconsistent with what what was stated in the ad?
Speaker 3 (14:12–15:01)
No, I just felt that. Honestly, the denial letters tend to be very general. So I'm trying to provide a lot more clarification of what's being asked for both. I did try to do that in the application, but then when I prepare for these hearings, I go back over it again.
And yet again, I feel as if I want to make it even clearer. So I just want to make sure the board understands there are those two intensifications. then the standard that's been imposed on the applicants by the building commissioner is that they need a special permit that's consistent with the app. As far as the changing law goes, no, I haven't even thoroughly reviewed its implications, but I don't believe it changes what we need to ask for right now because of the timing of this application.
Speaker 1 (15:01–15:17)
Okay, all right, I've got a couple other questions, but I wonder if I'll let my colleagues, thank you for that. I'll let my colleagues, Mr. Gray, do you have any questions of the applicant? No, I'm fine.
Thank you. Mr. Brown?
Speaker 4 (15:17–15:19)
I don't have any questions at this time. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (15:20–15:33)
Let me ask you, on 41 Frothingham, it's signed by Andy and Brittany Faudos. Faudos? Did they just buy the house?
Speaker 2 (15:33–15:33)
Excuse me?
Speaker 1 (15:34–15:35)
Did they just buy the house?
Speaker 2 (15:35–15:38)
They moved in almost four years ago now.
Speaker 1 (15:40–15:50)
The plot plan, not the plot plan, but Bob Hannigan's plan indicates that the owner is, it's now a formally, the Downs and Jolf?
Speaker 5 (15:50–15:52)
Yeah, they were the previous owners.
Speaker 1 (15:54–16:14)
I don't care who used to own it. I don't even, I'm not suggesting that the plan is wrong, because it's been noted as now formally, but I just want to confirm that the people who signed the letter from 41 brother him. I knew you said Alexa that they're on the call, which is great. And we'll, we'll be happy to hear from them.
They do own the property.
Speaker 2 (16:15–16:17)
Correct property.
Speaker 1 (16:17–16:39)
Okay. All right. And let me ask you when you. When you do the improvements, is the facade going to look the same as what you currently have?
By all outward appearances, is it gonna look like one seamless home? Just give me an idea of what that's like. Go ahead, I'm sorry.
Speaker 2 (16:39–16:48)
Yeah, we're planning to use the same paneling continuing on the new portion of the house, so it will all be cohesive.
Speaker 1 (16:48–17:05)
Repaint the entire home? Yes. And so that when you finish, not to put words in your mouth, but when you finish, notwithstanding the fact that the building will be larger and one building will be removed, it will look like there was not really any renovations. It was just one home.
Speaker 2 (17:06–17:10)
Correct. Yes. It's all very inclusive and goes with the style of the original home.
Speaker 1 (17:11–17:15)
Okay. And what is your schedule for conducting the improvements?
Speaker 2 (17:17–17:29)
Um, we would like to aim to start this fall. If we can get everything approved and moving in time before the ground freezes. Um, that's, that's the plan. Um, otherwise we'll wait until the spring, but hoping to start.
Speaker 1 (17:30–17:33)
And how long does it take? How long will it take to build?
Speaker 2 (17:34–17:38)
The contractor quoted about eight to 10 months, eight to 10 months.
Speaker 1 (17:39–17:41)
And will the building be vacant while it's being renovated?
Speaker 2 (17:41–17:45)
Uh, we will be living in the construction.
Speaker 1 (17:45–17:50)
Okay. Um, I don't, I'm sorry.
Speaker 2 (17:50–17:57)
Oh, I was just gonna say there's minimal to existing living space. A minimal of the existing living space will be touched.
Speaker 1 (17:57–18:18)
Yeah. Okay, I don't, I don't have any further questions unless the applicants got something to add. I'd like to ask if, does the applicant have anything to add? All right.
So, continuing with the testimony, let me ask if there's anybody in the audience who wishes to be heard in favor of the application.
Speaker 6 (18:18–18:27)
2C1, allowing them to check, please state your name and address.
Speaker 7 (18:31–18:38)
Uh, hi, my name is Andy produce at, uh, 41 brought in here, direct neighbors and we fully support the project.
Speaker 1 (18:39–18:44)
Thank you. Is that it? Mr produce?
Speaker 7 (18:45–18:59)
Yeah, we, um, we've been here for years. I know you had questioned, uh, about the property ownership. We've been here since, uh, 2022. And, um, we think this is a great addition to the neighborhood.
Speaker 1 (18:59–19:04)
Terrific, thank you very much. Is there anybody else Bill?
Speaker 6 (19:05–19:12)
Okay, Chris Watson. Please state your name and address for the record, Mr. Watson.
Speaker 8 (19:14–19:42)
Hi, yes, my name is Chris Watson. I'm at 50 Farthingham Street, which is directly across from Zach and Alexa. And we support the project. We've moved in approximately the same time as them in 2017.
And we have, I think this will be a great addition to the street as well.
Speaker 1 (19:43–19:53)
Great. Thank you very much, Mr. Wass. Was it Wasson?
It's Wason. Wason. Wason. Thank you, Mr.
Wason. Anybody else, Bill?
Speaker 6 (19:55–19:55)
No other hands.
Speaker 1 (19:56–20:02)
Is there anybody you'd like to be heard in opposition to the application or ask questions of the application?
Speaker 6 (20:05–20:07)
I see no hands. Okay.
Speaker 1 (20:08–20:32)
Let me ask my colleagues if they've got any further questions of the applicant, and if not, we'll bring the evidentiary portion of the hearing to a close. No questions, no questions, no further questions for me. Uh, let me close the evidentiary portion of the hearing and. In accordance with the open meeting law, the Milton board of appeals will debate the merits of the application.
As Mr. Leonard was fond of saying right here and now.
Speaker 5 (20:33–20:44)
He used to say that you knew I was going to say that right? Well, I, it sounded very familiar now that you, you recalled it to my. Fading memory, Mr. Mullen, so I appreciate the.
Speaker 1 (20:44–20:58)
The reference you can't sit in his parents with him for 25 years and not. Correct. I just can't do it. Mr.
Mr. Mr. Gray. Uh, let's say you.
I think, um.
Speaker 5 (20:59–22:01)
The addition looks very much like additions of this type I've seen all over town. Recognizing that Frothingham Street, the houses are packed in, housing prices are super expensive, it's not easy to move anywhere. There's obviously a need. When you want to expand your property, you love living here, you want to do it.
I think it's a lovely, nicely designed addition. The scale is, you know, when looking at the street is not out of proportion to other additions that are in that neighborhood. And given the fact that all of the abutting neighbors are, you know, have submitted or indicated their assent to the project. I think it's, I'm in favor of granting the application per special permit.
Thank you. Mr. Brown.
Speaker 4 (22:01–22:06)
I'm also in favor of granting the application for all the reasons that Mr. Gray just said. I have nothing to add.
Speaker 1 (22:07–22:56)
Right. I agree with my colleagues. This is a well presented application. I applaud the applicants on moving it on advancing it forward.
It'd be a tasteful addition to a very nice neighborhood in character with the neighborhood, very consistent with the standard that's been established in the, in the, in the, in the Milton bylaw and in the commonwealth's law. And I. I'd be proud to support the application for a special permit for all those reasons. So, let me, let me, let me ask my colleagues to indicate that they're in favor for the record.
Say, aye. Aye. So, you have a unanimous vote of the Milton Board of Appeals on your application for a special permit for the reasons stated in this hearing. Congratulations.
Speaker 3 (22:57–22:58)
Thank you so much.
Speaker 1 (22:58–22:59)
You're welcome.
Speaker 3 (22:59–23:04)
Do you want me to draft a something with that?
Speaker 1 (23:04–24:16)
That'd be terrific. I think I think the current chair is moving us in that direction and welcomes that. And if you want to, you can just get it to me. I'm happy to take it from there.
Marion and share it with with the board that will. Zach and Alexa, that'll speed you up a little bit. It's the reason why I asked you what your schedule is. The process is, well, it takes some time to prepare a decision.
Sometimes it takes longer than others, depending upon our own personal workloads. But Mrs. McKettrick drafting 1, we'll speed that along. We'll take a look at that.
And once it gets signed and filed with bill at the town hall, there'll be a 20 day appeal period following that. You can, you can go to the special services and obtain your building permit and you want to take steps to record, record the special permit in the Norfolk registry of deeds to confirm the benefit of the benefits of the special permit. Thank you. You're welcome.
Good luck with your project. It sounds challenging and exciting for you.
Speaker 2 (24:16–24:18)
Yes, it's exciting. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (24:19–24:33)
You're welcome. Thank you, everybody. Is there any other business for the board on the Frothingham Road hearing? Hearing none, we'll stand in recess pending the 7.30 hearing this evening.
Speaker 9 (24:34–24:46)
Thank you very much. 730. Okay.
Speaker 1 (24:47–29:01)
All right. So, members of the board, are you prepared? You ready? Applicant, are you prepared?
Yep. Okay. Can you pronounce your name for me? Your back, your last name?
Darren Mimna. Mimna. Mimna. Mimna.
Mimna. Okay. Okay, this is a board of appeals is calling to order our 2nd hearing of the evening. It's a 730 hearing upon the application of Darren minima.
A 53 Lawrence road dated July 30, 2026, seeking a special permit. To build a 7 foot by 21.2 foot 2nd story addition. at the premises at 53 Lawrence Road. The property is in a residence C zoning district.
The proposed addition would be built 6.9 feet from the right side lot line and the Milton zoning bylaw article four, section 275.41B requires 10 foot side setbacks. The permit request was denied and will require a special permit from the zoning board of appeals to proceed. All is set forth in the file. As is the board custom, I'll just take a minute to introduce what's in the file and I'll ask the applicant to make a presentation.
We've got the advertisement that appeared in the requisite newspaper. We've got the application of Mr. Mimna, dated, well, undated actually. He's from 53 Lawrence Road.
He states he's building a closet. We should get some more detail on what's actually being built, but But we've got a letter dated July 20 from Michael white CBO building commissioner to which I referred to earlier denying the application. For the reasons stated, uh, failure to comply with the. Requirements is going by Lauren advising Mr.
they could seek a special permit from the zoning board of appeals, which. Uh, is what led Mr to the hearing today? We've got a plot plan prepared by James McGrath PLS. That plot plan is dated July 27 to 2006.
we've got an addition plan prepared by Michael Antonio Antonio Antonio. Antonino, the addition plan, a couple of sheets of that. We've got building plans. It is a walk-in closet indicated on the building plans, but by T-Design LLC in several sheets, proposed walk-in closet, second floor construction, several sheets.
Then we've got letters of support. The letters are all the same and they're brief. I'll just read the text. We've discussed our plans for the 18 foot 6 inch by 7 foot addition to the above to our existing footprint of our home at 53 Lawrence Road with our neighbors.
We understand that zoning relief from the Board of Appeals is required. We have no objection. This is the 1st letter is signed by, would that be Garvey at 9 Clark Road? Yeah, yeah, yeah, and Diana Downey at 59 Lawrence road.
Judy and Robert Casey at 43 Barton's lane. These are all the same letter. And Susan Grimes at 7 o'clock road. And then and then lastly.
Tom and Don Flynn at 15 o'clock road. Mr. Miniman, are you going to want to represent to the board where these people live with respect to your property and whether or not they're the abutters? And you can state that when I yield the floor.
And lastly, it's way long at 43 Lawrence Road. Lastly, we've got an updated plot plan that came in after the original plot plan. from James McGrath, that's the substance of the file. And now I'd like to ask Mr.
Minma to welcome him to the Board of Appeals and ask him how we could help him this evening. Mr. Minma.
Speaker 10 (29:02–29:32)
Thank you. Yes, basically a closet we're building. It's on the same footprint of the house. It's pretty small.
It's just off the primary bedroom. And yeah, we have the support of all the neighbors behind us, the left. The right neighbor, there's a new house there, it's vacant, but the next door neighbor, two doors down, he's supporting it. So pretty much all around us are supporting it, front and back.
Speaker 1 (29:35–29:50)
Let me ask you, so this is at the second floor. Yeah, and it's within the existing footprint of the building, but whereabouts in the building will the improvements be? Just give us an idea. So where we, it's at the rear of the property?
Speaker 10 (29:51–29:59)
On the right hand side. On the right? Yeah, there's a bumper on the right hand side at the minute, and it'd be just going over the top of that in the same footprint.
Speaker 1 (30:00–30:07)
Yeah. And on the right hand side, as you're looking at the house,
Speaker 10 (30:07–30:08)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (30:08–30:43)
Yeah. And what's on the 1st floor? 1st floor is a bathroom and a laundry. Underneath where the walk-in closet's going to be.
And the walk-in closet will be accessible from the master bedroom. That's the idea. And when you finish with this, so you're exacerbating the non-conformity on the side, hence the need for the special permit according to the building inspector or building commissioner. And when you finish with the improvements, you'll paint the whole house, you'll shingle it the same way?
Speaker 10 (30:43–30:52)
Yeah, it's all shingled at the minute, so when it's shingled, then I'll probably repaint the whole house, you know? So it's going to look the same in the front, and yeah, it's going to look all the same.
Speaker 1 (30:53–30:54)
And are you doing the work yourself?
Speaker 10 (30:56–31:01)
Yes, I'll be doing some of the work myself. I'll be getting framers, and I'll be contracting it myself.
Speaker 1 (31:01–31:07)
And will your plan be to perform the work this year? What is your schedule?
Speaker 10 (31:08–31:11)
Yeah, as soon as as soon as I get a permit, I'll get it will start right away.
Speaker 1 (31:12–31:18)
Yeah. And how long will it take to build? Probably like a month, I think.
Speaker 10 (31:18–31:19)
Six weeks.
Speaker 1 (31:20–31:29)
Okay, all right. And you spoke to all your neighbors and you've got their support, with the exception of the vacant building.
Speaker 10 (31:30–31:42)
Yeah, the next door house actually knocked their house down, so it's pretty much a new construction house. So nobody's living there at the moment. This is the house on the left?
Speaker 1 (31:42–31:57)
The right house on the right. Yeah, the right. I'm sorry. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 4 (31:57–32:08)
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3 (32:08–32:08)
Yeah.
Speaker 10 (32:09–32:12)
No, it's a little bit more. There's a bit of a cantilever, like a foot.
Speaker 4 (32:14–32:16)
Okay. Do you know how much more?
Speaker 10 (32:16–32:19)
It's around about a foot or so.
Speaker 4 (32:22–32:23)
Okay. Thank you. No other questions.
Speaker 1 (32:25–32:25)
Yeah. Mr. Gray.
Speaker 4 (32:26–32:27)
No, no questions. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (32:29–32:56)
Okay, let me ask Bill, can you see, can the audience see whether or not there's anybody in the audience who would wish to be spoken in support of the application? There are no hands. And is there anybody in the, I'm sorry. Is there anybody in the audience who wishes to be heard in opposition to the application?
Speaker 6 (32:57–32:59)
I see no hands for that call either.
Speaker 1 (32:59–33:09)
Okay. All right, Mr. Minmud, is there anything you'd like to ask the board, add to your presentation at this time?
Speaker 10 (33:11–33:19)
Not really. It's pretty straightforward. It's really just a closet for extra closet space, you know? Yeah.
That's all.
Speaker 1 (33:19–33:36)
Okay. All right. Any other board members, any questions, any further questions? No, I'm going to close the evidentiary portion of the hearing and in accordance with the open meeting law, we can debate the merits of the application.
Right here and now, Mr. Brown.
Speaker 4 (33:38–33:55)
I am generally in favor of the applications. I think it's very small in addition. I think it's going to keep with the nature of the house and the surrounding neighborhood. I don't really see any issues with it.
Speaker 1 (33:56–33:58)
Yeah. Thank you. Mr. Gray.
Speaker 5 (33:59–34:35)
I feel very much the same way. I'm in favor of supporting the application. First of all, I can recall having an application for a special permit for a closet, but it makes good sense. The addition itself is basically just stacking on top of the existing first floor bump out, I believe the phrase is.
So I'm in favor of it. I think it will definitely help out the family, the neighbors are in support, and I can certainly see the desire and need for it.
Speaker 1 (34:36–35:44)
Yeah, I agree. I think it's it's well done. It's a deserving. And merits our support consistent with the standard for a special permit in the bylaw.
So I'm prepared to support it all in favor of issuing to. Mr. Minma, a special permit for the purpose of constructing a closet consistent with the. Application indicate support by saying hi.
Hi. All right, so audit the board has granted you a special permit. Mr. consistent with your application.
We'll, we'll, we'll write up a written decision and consistent with this hearing. We'll file that with bill bill. We'll get in touch with you. Uh, provide you with a copy of that.
There's a 20 day appeal period for that. And you'll want to record the special permit at the registry in denim. And that's it, unless you've got questions of the board, we congratulate you on your receipt of the special permit and wish you the best of luck.
Speaker 10 (35:44–35:45)
Thank you very much. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (35:45–36:14)
You're welcome. Thanks. Nick or Michael, one of you want to drop? You're welcome, Darren.
Good luck to you. I'm sorry. Do you want 1 of you want to draft this? Michael was volunteered now Michael is volunteered.
So, uh. A bill will take note and will bug Michael for the hearing at the appropriate intervals, consistent with his customary and usual practice.
Speaker 10 (36:15–36:16)
But thank you.
Speaker 1 (36:16–36:34)
You're welcome. All right. Good luck. Unless there's additional work matter before the board with respect to the application that 53 Lawrence road, the board will stand in recess until eight o'clock, at which point we'll hear the variance request for 350 Blue Hill Avenue.
Speaker 10 (36:36–36:38)
Thank you guys. Okay.
Speaker 1 (36:39–37:02)
Good night. Okay. Thank you folks. I'll be right.
I'll be right with you. Just give me a bit. Said he'll be a few minutes. He asked us to begin acceptable to the applicant.
Speaker 11 (37:08–37:09)
Yes, OK.
Speaker 1 (37:11–37:29)
So, it's 8 o'clock on on September 10. my name is Jeffrey Mullin. I'll be acting as Board of Appeals Chairman tonight. With me are Michael Brown and Nicholas Gray, members of the board.
Tonight's hearing is upon the application of Stanley Jenius.
Speaker 11 (37:30–37:30)
Genius.
Speaker 1 (37:31–41:03)
Genius. Yes. Isn't that convenient? Yes, you're like, I'm Jeffrey genius genius.
This is Nick genius genius or members of the genius family. Yeah. Mr genius is seeking a variance at 350 Blue Hill Avenue. filed an application dated August 5 to build a new 40 foot by 38 foot dwelling with a 10 foot by 35 foot rear deck.
The property is located in a residency zoning district. The proposed dwelling would include a basement that would be considered a story and a main structure that would be three stories, making the entire structure four full stories in violation of Milton by-law. Section 275-9.1 height regulations, which allows only 2.5 story residential structures. The permit request is denied.
In addition, the proposed rear deck would be set back 20 feet from the rear lot line, whereas 30 feet rear setbacks are required as per the Milton zoning bylaw. A variance from the Board of Appeals is required to proceed unless set forth in the application. In the file for everybody listening is the application submitted by Mr. Corcoran on behalf of Mr.
Genius. with respect to 350 Blue Hill Avenue for the construction of a single family dwelling. The application has several attachments explaining the application, the relief sought, a detailed discussion of the application. It also includes the letter to Mr.
Genius from the town of Milton, inspectional services consistent with what I just said. There's a plot plan prepared by Deposit Valley Survey Association, laying out the stakes, as well as some design drawings in several sheets from Borough Engineering, and some renderings of what the building will look like, the design development building for the single-family dwelling that's been proposed on the site. Bear with me, bear with me. That's in several sheets as well.
Those design drawings have been prepared by Rosa Design. And then finally, Mr. Corpin indicated, submitted an addendum to the application that he indicated to Bill that it was done owing to the fact that the legislature has changed the variance standard Uh, can recently in the in the Massachusetts budget that large effective and that means that relaxes the standard and and no longer requires that the board. Make a finding of hardship that I'm sure that Mr.
Corcoran will will get into. Um, uh, that's the extent of the that that that's the middle was was made on. July 31, 2026, so that's dated July 31, 2026. That's the extent of the application.
I see that Mr. Genius is with us and Mr. Corcoran is here as well. Welcome to the Board of Appeals, Mr.
Corcoran. How can we help you this evening?
Speaker 12 (41:03–45:54)
Thank you and I apologize for the delay at the fire station. Just jumped out of a separate meeting with the planning board. So, I would wonder if you could promote Eileen Rosa. I believe I've done so.
You've done so. Okay. Thank you, Jeff, members of the board. For the record, Ned Corcoran, I'm here on behalf of Stanley Genius, who's the property owner at 350 Blue Hill Avenue.
350 Blue Hill Avenue is a small 6,000 square foot site that fronts on Blue Hill Avenue. It's part of an old subdivision that is actually comprised of three lots, 2,000 square foot lots that were reassembled some time ago. Mr. Genius has purchased the property and submitted a building application for which there are three elements of relief.
As Mr. Mullin started to explain, the standards are now relaxed with respect to the variant standard. Practical difficulty is now the buzzword, um, and I had a recent matter before this board with three- constituted with three others where, um, Kathleen O'Donnell actually drafted the first decision based on the new standard. Um, there are three elements of this application, two dealing with height, and the third that deals with the setback for a deck.
The 1st issue with respect to the basement is that the 1st floor elevation was established at 4.3 feet. There's a provision that says that if the 1st floor elevation is at 4 feet or greater, then the basement is counted as a story. Which is the case, then this is a 4 story building, not a 3 story building, but there is also a provision in that section under height that allows the board to issue a special permit to allow the use of some fill to bring the. to measure the 1st floor elevation based on the finished grade as opposed to existing grade.
In that case, we bring the site, the 1st floor elevation to 1.2 feet. If the board would grant that special permit, that would eliminate the need for variance with respect to the finding on the basement. The 2nd significant component of this is that the 3rd floor, is that the building has a flat roof. In a moment, I'm going to ask Eileen Rosa to sort of walk through her design intent and how she envisioned this dwelling for this site and in this neighborhood.
But I used to live on Morton Road, My next door neighbor is a historic federal, three stories, three full stories, flat roof. You can't build that today under Milton zoning because we're only allowed two and a half stories and a half story is counted, defined as half story within an area within a sloped roof. where if you come up from the floor to a point that is four feet where it intersects the slopes of the roof, if you count the square footage within that area, that area is more than two-thirds of the area of the total floor below it, then it is counted as a story. If it's less than two-thirds of the area, it's not a story.
In this case, we have a flat roof with a vertical pitch, and the area is actually less than half of the area of the floor below. But because it's not a sloped roof, it's a flat roof, it's strictly prohibited under our bylaw. I think the calculation is actually that we're at 49% of the area of the second floor rather than two thirds. And I think if this were a slope roof, the bulk of the mass of the full area of the slope roof would be significantly greater than the area that is there for the second floor.
the flat roof. The third issue deals with setback from a deck. Deck is outdoor living area. We think it's an important part of the overall dwelling.
But with that, let me turn it to Eileen to walk through her design intent, the vision of the building, how it fits into the site, why she chose the design that she did, and I think you'll find that helpful.
Speaker 13 (45:56–46:52)
Thank you, Ned, and good evening, Mr. Chairman, members of the board. My name is Eileen Rosa. I am the residential designer for this project with Rosa Design and Construction.
I have actually a personal connection with this project as I am a neighbor. I live at 286 Blue Hill Ave, basically down the street, a couple of houses, 600, 700 feet away from the subject property. I'm not sure if I'm able to share my screen if you allow me to, otherwise I'll just continue. Please, please.
Okay. Thank you. Okay. I see the access here.
Just bear with me for a second. And if you can confirm you can see my screen.
Speaker 14 (46:52–46:54)
Yeah.
Speaker 13 (46:55–54:03)
Okay, thank you. It's basically the same set of drawings submitted, just to go over the plants as we speak here. So yeah, so as I said, I'm a neighbor as well, and speaking both as a designer and as someone who lives in the immediate neighborhood, I am excited about the opportunity to see a thoughtfully designed new home constructed at this location. I'm going to be walking through this plant as I speak.
We're going to see some renderings that you have on files, and we're just sharing some additional renderings for your reference at the end. We believe this project will bring a fresh, attractive, and modern architectural presence to the Blue Hill Avenue. It will complement the investment, improvements, and development already taking place along this area and contribute positively to the surrounding neighborhood. The proposal is for a new six-bedroom single-family dwelling with a total gross floor area of approximately 3,732 square feet.
The design uses clean contemporary lines, fiber cement panels, composite siding, stone veneer, generous windows, architectural accents, and carefully arranged balconies, and terraces. Although the home has a modern appearance, its scale, placement, massing, and materials have been thoughtfully considered in relation to the property and the surrounding residential neighborhood. The exterior materials have been selected for their quality, durability, appearance, and long-term performance. Safety and code compliance are also important parts of this design.
The finished lower level, and I'm going to scroll down to the floor plans now. Bear with me a second. So here it is. On your left, here's the finished lower level.
It is approximately 165 square feet. It contains two bedrooms, a bathroom, a family room, laundry facilities, and mechanical room. The first floor, which is the main space here, it's approximately 1,193 square feet. It contains the principal living spaces, including the living room, dining room, kitchen, pantry, powder room, and access to the rear deck.
Going to the next page, on our left here, we have the second floor, which is approximately, let me make a zoom here, maybe it's helpful. It's approximately 1,121 square feet. It contains the main bedroom at the rear, which is a suite with a master bathroom. We also have an additional bedroom.
and a bathroom, a laundry facility, and the central circulation area right in the middle. Now, right here, we have the upper enclosed floor. This one is approximately 553 square feet. It contains two bedrooms at the rear of the space with one bathroom.
This one is together with substantial open porch and balconies areas, throughout the front and the left side, rear left side of this space. As mentioned, the second floor contains approximately about 1,121 square feet, while this enclosed upper level contains approximately 553 square feet. The enclosed upper level is therefore approximately 49% of the floor area immediately below it. The remainder of that level is not enclosed floor area.
It consists of basically a primary of one open porch and balcony space, as previously mentioned, and it's intended to provide outdoor living. in these areas at the front, natural light and fresh air. Because the enclosed upper level floor area is less than half of the floor immediately below, the design intent is for this level to function and be recognized as a half story rather than a complete third story. The upper level has also been intentionally set back and divided into smaller components This reduces its visibility mass and prevents it from reading as a complete third floor when viewed from the Blue Hill Avenue and neighborhood properties.
This is something visible, especially the front view here. Here's the upper floor where we can see that that third, upper floor was recessed from the main facade. Also to note that, as you can see here on the site plan, the building was strategically located further back than the minimum requirement. This dash line is the 20 feet setback requirement, so we're further back from there.
It's intentionally located. Overall, the relief being requested is focused and limited. As you can see, we're showing a reasonable open space. Basically, both the residential designer and the nearby residents.
I believe Blue Hill Avenue, it will replace an undeveloped condition with a thoughtfully designed home, improve the residential streetscape, and bring a clean, fresh, and high-quality appearance to the neighborhood. We are encouraged by the improvements and new investment taking place along the Blue Hill Avenue, and we believe this project can contribute to that progress and add lasting value to the area. I appreciate your time and I will remain here around just in case you have any questions about the plans. That's all I have for now and I'll hand over the presentation to Attorney Nett.
Speaker 1 (54:03–54:05)
Thank you, Mr. Corcoran.
Speaker 12 (54:05–54:09)
Thanks, Eileen. With that, Jeff, I would put it to the board for questions.
Speaker 1 (54:10–54:15)
Let me ask if the members of the board have questions. Mr. Brown.
Speaker 4 (54:18–54:31)
Um, so I think I know the answer to this, but the outdoor portions of the third floor are not being counted it for the square footage. Is that correct?
Speaker 12 (54:34–54:43)
That's correct. The total, the area of square footage that is at their floor is about 550 square feet.
Speaker 4 (54:43–54:58)
Okay. And do, does the request for the variance with regard to the top floor, um, is that contingent on the granting of a special permit for the, um, adding a fill for the treatment of the basement as floor?
Speaker 12 (55:01–55:52)
Well, we'd either need, uh, a variance from the, um, the standard for the, The 1st floor elevation at 4.3 feet for the basement not to be counted as a floor. But I think the more appropriate way to approach it is a special permit. The board does have the authority to grant special permits under the height provision to allow 1st floor elevation to be considered at the finished grade rather than the existing grade. It is a.
relatively small delta, a couple of feet, but it is still a delta that changes the equation from 4.3 feet to 1.2 feet, so three foot difference really. And there's plenty of excavation coming from the building itself to create that finished elevation.
Speaker 4 (55:53–56:02)
Can you tell me more about the adding of 3 feet of fill? I mean, would that be across the entire lot? And how would that interact with the surrounding properties?
Speaker 12 (56:03–56:52)
I think that if you scroll down, Eileen, I think that on 1 of the sheets, there's some. There is a. Yeah, you can see how the grade is brought up around the building, but then gradually slopes away. So it's not a dramatic, it's not gonna entirely change the entire slope of the property, but it will change the grade and it will be, you know, The site slopes gradually from front to back.
It will level the site really in the middle. Change a little bit about the way it slopes to the rear.
Speaker 4 (56:56–57:09)
I think I still have questions about that. I mean, I. Is the is the fill going to like, is the 3 foot fill going to be level across the property or is it going to be sloped near the house?
Speaker 12 (57:09–57:35)
You can see. I'm sorry you can see the. the new grades that would be there. So you'd see 110, 109, down to 108 towards the back, 107.
So it would be a gradual, looks like a two-to-one, probably two-to-one slope. A one-to-two slope.
Speaker 4 (57:38–57:42)
I don't think I have any more questions at this time.
Speaker 5 (57:43–59:10)
Mr. Gray. What I'm stumbling on at the moment, gentlemen and Ms. Rosa, is the treatment of the top floor being treated as a half story.
What's tripping me up is while the square footage If you measure the square footage based on what's enclosed, are you telling me, Mr. Corcoran, that it counts as within the meaning of the half story if you treat the third floor enclosed space as a certain percentage of what's below? What I'm stumbling with is although there's open portions on the upper decks of this top story, It has walls, it has mass. It doesn't look like a half story to me, which fits under a gable, right?
So it really does look like a three-floor building visually. So can you help me with understand what what the rule is and what I'm looking at versus why this isn't a three-story building.
Speaker 12 (59:10–01:00:14)
I guess that's a question for Rosa. As I understood the intent of design when we filed this is that there were decks at the roof of the second floor level so that there would be an enclosed third floor. that was half the square footage of the area of the floor below it. I see what you're suggesting.
I don't know whether that from this image, that brown area on the left is open and covered, but therefore, is it You know, how much area, I guess, Eileen, is sort of covered. Because that would define whether it's a third floor or a second floor. Or a full floor or a half story.
Speaker 13 (01:00:15–01:00:39)
Just to add to what Ned just mentioned, basically, two and a half stories, basically, 49 percent or less of the habitable square footage of the area below, which is what we are proposing. I know you mentioned specifically this porch at the front.
Speaker 5 (01:00:39–01:00:42)
That's really tripping me up.
Speaker 13 (01:00:42–01:01:09)
Right. But however, it's basically a covered porch. And that's what probably looks like, especially from the southwest view, it might look, which is the main image here. Yeah.
It might look because of this wall, but we're definitely open for any suggestions or recommendations.
Speaker 5 (01:01:10–01:02:03)
Yeah. I mean, I'm curious what my fellow board members think of that particular issue. It seems to me, I mean, it's like we're trying to get around or meet the definition of a half story while getting the benefit of semi-enclosed space with a wall and a roof. I mean, like that upper left-hand corner of that building doesn't put a window in it and it's enclosed, take the window out and it's not counting as part of the square footage for purposes of determining whether it's a full story or a half.
You see what I'm saying? That visually, it doesn't look like a two and a half story building. It looks like a full on three-story building that is higher. Let me ask you this.
How much higher is this building than the neighboring houses?
Speaker 13 (01:02:04–01:02:34)
The houses around are two-story with, seems like with crawlspace attic. So I would say they are, this one is about, it doesn't exceed the maximum requirement, but I would say the houses next to it, they are in the 25 feet or so to this one. So this one is about nine feet higher than the others, roughly.
Speaker 5 (01:02:35–01:02:52)
Okay, so the other question I have concerns or parking. We've got 6 bedrooms. I don't see a garage, which is, you know, which is fine. But where are the cars for this property?
Going to park and how many are required? How many spaces are required? And how many spaces do we have?
Speaker 13 (01:02:53–01:03:16)
Yeah, so the requirement for. Uh, the residential see, uh, it's a 1 per unit and we're proposing for parking spaces and these are located at the front of the property. With, um, basically pavers throughout the front where we're going to have 2 on the left and 2 on the right side.
Speaker 11 (01:03:17–01:03:20)
As well as charging stations to.
Speaker 5 (01:03:20–01:03:42)
Okay, I don't I don't really care about that. Um. Mr. Corcoran, can you explain what the, just for my, because I haven't had a huge amount of time yet to study the changes to 40A and the standard for, can you just give me, say again, what the current standard or the soon to be standard for approving of variances?
Speaker 12 (01:03:44–01:06:05)
Sure. It's really that the, It changes the definition from a straight hardship associated with the ground to a practical difficulty that renders a hardship. The intent is to make it easier to permit, particularly residential properties in properties that otherwise can be difficult. To get there, so we're saying that the, the size of a lot 6,000 square feet, you know, that's a small lot, even in a residency.
That's that's that's small when it when the minimum lot size for new lots and residency is 7500 square feet. So it's a relatively small. The house needs to fit reasonably on the site. Uh, and so the, the size of the house, uh, there's a practical difficulty about doing a sort of a more standard 2 and a half story.
Building, as it were, um, with a slope roof, and I think, you know, this. The bylaw, as we have it, looks back to a different day. Town was, as you know, was zoned after it was built, and the zoning has a certain standard to it that doesn't necessarily reflect all building styles, and it doesn't reflect, in many cases, the historic building patterns that appear around town. But the standard is relaxed from strict variant standard, strict hardship associated with the shape of the lot, the makeup of the soil conditions, and the size of the lot, and the topography.
There is a sloping topography. It's not significant. I can't say that the sloping topography itself creates a significant practical difficulty, but I think the combination of things does. And I think that At the end of the day, the new approach under the state law is to favor innovative approaches to developing new housing in communities.
Speaker 5 (01:06:05–01:06:52)
What's the practical difficulty here with a 3,700 square foot house on a 6,000 square foot lot? What's the difficulty that requires the house to be larger such that it requires the third or two and a half, whatever, you know what I'm saying? How does that relate to the land in, in, in a way that requires it to be 3,700 square feet of living space? We're asking for height.
So like, what, what's the, how did, how does the small lot mean that we have to have a taller house? I'm not sure I can answer that.
Speaker 12 (01:06:52–01:07:53)
I understand that. I'm struggling to answer that question quite honestly. I think it's a reasonably scaled house on a small lot. The issue on the height really was going after this notion that if this were a gabled roof, you could have a bigger roof, you'd have a bigger third floor under the town's definition.
Then you would with a, um, with, with, with, uh, with, with a flat roof. Um, I, I separately get the, get the issue whether a covered deck. should be properly considered here or whether the deck alternative should be uncovered such that you really only have covered space that's the 550 square feet. That to me is a design question that goes to the heart of really what's the definition of a third floor.
Speaker 5 (01:07:54–01:07:57)
All right. Thanks. I don't have any further questions at this time.
Speaker 1 (01:07:58–01:10:21)
Thanks. I have questions, but I wonder if we should hear from the people in the audience. I'm concerned about the size of this building and the size of the lot and whether or not we've established the underlying predicate that a 6,000 square foot lot in a residency meets the standard in the bylaw. It's you've got a chart on page one of your design drawings.
Maybe you could just turn to that if you don't mind Eileen. Um, and we may need some supplemental information. Maybe it's not maybe it's a, it's the sheet that is entitled 350 Blue Hill Avenue in the. In the top, it's it's a dash.
Yeah, yeah, there you go. Could you just pull that up that zoning dimensional regulations chart piece there in the middle? Yeah. You don't mind a little bit more.
Yeah. So, you know, you've really. number of issues here that I don't see all of them being addressed in the application lot minimum. I know the application indicates that 6,000 square feet are permitted under certain circumstances and 60 feet under certain circumstances.
I'm not sure it's been established that that's the case and maybe it has. So I've got questions along the lines. I'm also interested in understanding Why the front lawn front yard isn't it just looks like a parking lot to me and it looks like way more than 1 car. So, I don't I don't I've got questions on that, but I'm interested in hearing from the.
uh, whether or not there's anybody here who would like to be heard just owing to the time, if that's okay. And then maybe we'll come back to the questions and maybe others have questions. So I'd like to proceed on that basis, but I just want the applicant to know that I myself have questions and members of the board may have additional questions. So Bill, let me ask, is there anybody in the audience who would like to be heard in support of the application?
Not seeing any hands raised. Okay. Is there anybody in the audience like to be heard in opposition to the application or who has questions on the application?
Speaker 6 (01:10:21–01:10:22)
No hands raised that way either.
Speaker 1 (01:10:23–01:10:42)
Okay, so let's go back to the, let's go back to the questions I had about. Lot size and frontage, I mean, which I do think I think are consistent with Mr. Gray's. I mean, the building's massive.
You just have to acknowledge this big building and you're asking for, but I don't think we've established that the lots big enough and I'm wondering why it is.
Speaker 12 (01:10:42–01:11:32)
I think the lot is it's the lot. No, I know the lots a lot, but in a residency, you need 7500 well, not in a you, you need under zoning 657500 square feet, but under state law, you can have a minimum lot size of 6000 square feet. And these are all the lots around in this neighborhood of 6,000 square feet. They're all part of an old subdivision that was created so that they're all 6,000 square feet to the rear, 6,000 square feet to the right, 6,000 square feet to the left.
All of these lots were, you know, Developed prior to the 7500 square foot minimum standard, but state law does provide for a minimum lot size of 6000 square feet.
Speaker 1 (01:11:33–01:11:50)
If the, if the, if the lot was improved. It's a valid lot for the purposes for which it's being used. You're saying because the lot was created before the adoption of the zoning, it's a valid lot and it can be modified for an improvement like this?
Speaker 12 (01:11:50–01:12:00)
I would say otherwise, there would be a substantial hardship associated with the purchase of that lot.
Speaker 1 (01:12:00–01:12:03)
Okay. The same with the frontage?
Speaker 12 (01:12:03–01:12:11)
All of the lots are the same size. And all the lots are improved though. Understood.
Speaker 14 (01:12:11–01:12:14)
Yeah.
Speaker 12 (01:12:15–01:12:27)
They are. I mean, some are double lots. You can see one behind it. But some are smaller, some are larger.
That neighborhood is Residence B across the street. There are larger lots across the street.
Speaker 1 (01:12:28–01:12:49)
Yeah, yeah. on lots established on February 10, 2020. I just, I'm struggling with the, and it could be me, just I'm looking at the definition of residency and I just don't, I don't know. Let's talk about the front yard.
Is there a lot coverage issue here?
Speaker 12 (01:12:49–01:13:05)
No, there's no lot coverage issue that I'm aware of. There's a building coverage max, we're at 30 percent. Then there's a gross floor area max, but there is no separate lot coverage.
Speaker 1 (01:13:06–01:13:24)
Is the front yard going to be used as a parking lot? Can you just go to the site plan and show us how you've laid that out? Does that not show four parking spaces, at least four parking spaces, maybe six?
Speaker 12 (01:13:25–01:13:41)
Certainly shows the attendance to show for. Yeah, the zoning zoning table she provided provides for 4.
Speaker 1 (01:13:42–01:13:45)
Did you talk to your neighbors about this improvement?
Speaker 11 (01:13:46–01:14:14)
Yes, I have I've talked to the 1 to the left and to the right of me about it and. Mr. Daniel, he loved the proposal. He signed off on removal of the tree and the one to the right of me as well.
So they kind of excited to see something like this coming in. And he was living there for over 30 years, Mr. Daniel Alfonso.
Speaker 12 (01:14:14–01:14:44)
Mr. Genius has had a sign on the property saying coming soon with a rendering that is as shown with a link to act to, I don't know, this is newfangled for me, but you can click on it and he's gotten 47 or 48 clicks. No specific commentary that we've seen, but a lot of clicks.
Speaker 11 (01:14:44–01:14:46)
Yeah, a lot of clips, a lot of interests.
Speaker 1 (01:14:46–01:16:26)
Here's what we're struggling with. The building's very large. The lot is very small. There's a parking lot in the front lawn.
I feel like this is a very aggressive application. I know the testimony. I know the application says it's modest. Frankly, with due respect, I don't think it's modest.
To Mr. Gray's questions, I think we need more information on this third floor. I have to say, I agree. It looks like a third floor to me, and I'm not 100% sure I understand it.
I'm not sure the board is prepared to vote on this. If that is a hardship as well, I'm sorry. But I feel like we need more information given the aggressive proposal we have in front of us. This is very atypical to what the board ordinarily would see on such a small lot.
Now, if it's got universal support, that's fine. But that doesn't mean that we can't have questions about the density that we're looking at. And there's also an indication that there might be an ADU coming. So I don't know.
I don't quite know. I have more questions than answers now. And I'd like to recommend that we kick this for a couple of weeks to give us a chance to take a deeper dive. I'm interested in a lot size.
I'd like to get to the bottom of Mr. Gray's questions if we can. I'd like to put that out there. I mean, maybe initially see whether or not the board would support that, unless the board wants to proceed.
And of course, I'm interested in what the applicant has to say about the building, about that proposal. So first, board members, thoughts on that?
Speaker 5 (01:16:28–01:16:49)
No, I used to live for 10 years, not a few blocks away. So I'm really I'm familiar with this. Sure. That neighborhood I'm familiar with the condition of the houses on Blue Hill Avenue in general.
And, and, and I agree with with, I think what Mr. Gina said, I mean, if this area is due for. Some some assistance, right?
Speaker 3 (01:16:49–01:16:50)
Yeah.
Speaker 5 (01:16:50–01:17:38)
And I like the fact that someone was wanting to invest in and build an updated dwelling. I think more information about. The because we're being asked for a variance right on the height. Correct and and so.
If we say we were even in favor of doing that, I would want to make sure that the decision that we write has enough evidence in it to withstand an appeal. I don't feel like getting reversed by the Superior Court, and the applicant certainly doesn't feel like wasting time with a further proceeding. To your point, I'd be happy to have more information about the questions I asked earlier, assuming I can actually reformulate.
Speaker 1 (01:17:38–01:17:45)
I think we understood the purpose of the questions and the thrust of it. Mr. Brown.
Speaker 4 (01:17:45–01:18:22)
Yeah, I feel the same way. I have extreme reservations about the size of this building and the height. I mean, it's going to be a three-story building, really almost three and a half, especially if you're one of the neighbors on the sides or, in particular, in the back of this house. I don't understand what the practical difficulty is.
Not being able to build whatever you want is not a practical difficulty. And I just don't see how anyway, I have a lot of questions and it sounds like we're going to hopefully get some answers. So, I'm in favor of continuing this.
Speaker 1 (01:18:22–01:18:51)
All right. I appreciate that from the board members. Let me hear from the applicant on on the board's proposal to, uh. To, uh, to, uh, to, uh.
What's the word I want to continue. To continue this hearing to a later date, at which point I offer the applicant an opportunity to supplement the record and to hear from the, to respond to the questions that the board has raised. What does the applicant say?
Speaker 12 (01:18:51–01:18:59)
I would recommend to the applicant that we take the opportunity to provide that extra time as requested by the board. Agreed.
Speaker 1 (01:19:00–01:20:17)
Okay, so let's do that. I don't think we have to poll everybody. I think the sense of the room is, you know, obviously you've put a lot of time into this. This is a very expensive and well designed building.
It happens to be very large. We want to make sure we get it right. We want to make sure before we debate the merits of the application that we've got all the facts. You've heard the nature of our concerns.
It has mostly to do with size. The board has traditionally not talked a lot about About aesthetics, but it looks like a parking lot in the front yard. I don't know. That doesn't like, I don't love that.
I just be honest with you and I feel better if there's actually like 1 parking space, frankly, but it looks like. There's going to be cars on that all the time if it feels like for such a tasteful home. I don't know. That's a lot.
Maybe that's not for me to say, and maybe there's not a zoning provision that I can rely on, but I just wanted to put that out there. I'll look at it myself and I know the building inspector didn't comment on it. So fair enough. A fair point by Mr.
Corcoran. Let me ask Bill if he's got a proposed date that we can meet. Is the board meeting every Thursday or every other Thursday these days?
Speaker 6 (01:20:17–01:20:40)
We have three on October 8th already with another group of the ZBA. So October 8th, I don't know if you want to try to- What about the 24th of September? 24th of September is open.
Speaker 1 (01:20:41–01:20:44)
Mr. Corcoran, Mr. Genius, Eileen?
Speaker 4 (01:20:44–01:20:48)
I'm not available on the 24th. Okay.
Speaker 15 (01:20:48–01:20:51)
Can we do 23rd? No, I can't do the 23rd.
Speaker 5 (01:20:52–01:20:59)
I'm on vacation the 23rd through the 1st of October. Not that I couldn't sign in, but I'd prefer not to, if you know what I mean.
Speaker 12 (01:21:01–01:21:11)
You know where the chair is now? What's that? You know where the chair is tonight. She's sailing somewhere.
She's on a cruise between Iceland and Greenland.
Speaker 1 (01:21:11–01:21:13)
Good for her. A place to be.
Speaker 12 (01:21:14–01:21:14)
Yeah.
Speaker 1 (01:21:17–01:21:19)
Go ahead. I'm sorry.
Speaker 12 (01:21:19–01:21:22)
Every night's as good or bad as another night, so whatever works.
Speaker 1 (01:21:26–01:21:29)
Do you want to October 15th? Is that too late?
Speaker 12 (01:21:30–01:21:46)
How about Tuesday the 29th? Oh, no. Nick's away. I am away.
First is no good. 15th is fine with me, but Stanley, I don't know if that's too far out for you.
Speaker 11 (01:21:47–01:21:54)
Yeah. I mean, if that's the only available date, I mean, I mean, I have to take it. Take what we get.
Speaker 9 (01:21:57–01:21:58)
Sorry, what was the date again?
Speaker 11 (01:21:59–01:22:03)
We've got the 7th. Yeah, if we get the 7th, that'd be great.
Speaker 9 (01:22:04–01:22:05)
October 7th?
Speaker 4 (01:22:06–01:22:15)
I can do that. I can't do the 7th, I'm traveling in New York for work. 6th. 6th is good.
A week is bad for me.
Speaker 12 (01:22:16–01:22:24)
Okay. 15th looks like it's going to be our best bet. Yeah. All right.
Speaker 1 (01:22:24–01:22:28)
I could also do the 14th. So can I.
Speaker 12 (01:22:30–01:22:33)
So, can I, I can do it for you.
Speaker 4 (01:22:34–01:22:41)
We can't we have a. The board of appeals has that meeting about the zoning changes. It's a job.
Speaker 1 (01:22:42–01:22:43)
Let's do the 14th.
Speaker 6 (01:22:44–01:22:49)
No, the 14th is the seminar on the new zoning.
Speaker 1 (01:22:51–01:22:53)
Then the 15th, I'm sorry.
Speaker 11 (01:22:53–01:22:56)
Yeah, 15th. All right.
Speaker 1 (01:22:57–01:24:18)
Let me just make it clear. You've heard the questions we have. I think each of us are curious enough about this application. We're going to do a little bit of research.
It could be that the applicant gets questions. If you get questions, they will come through Bill. And I'll say to the board members, you can do that on your own and submit them to Bill and Bill will get them to Mr Corcoran who'll discuss them with the designer. Ms Rosa and Mr genius.
That's point 1.2 is you've got the nature of the comments that we've got. You can I'll invite you to supplement the record. And maybe that record should also include information on the modification of the variant standard, which may very well come into play in our deliberations. And at least this is, you know, I've been on this board a long time, and this is the 1st time I've.
I've had the variant standard apply, so this will be new for me and then and then the last is. Well, maybe that's all maybe that's all maybe that's all I need to say, but we'll invite you to supplement the record as as necessary. And. To the extent that the board has questions, I just ask you to get those back to us a couple of days in advance of 15.
so we can have a chance to take a look at it. Okay. That's okay. Sure.
Okay. Is there any other question? Are there any other questions from the applicant for the board at this time?
Speaker 12 (01:24:19–01:24:23)
Is there a time certain for. You want to say 7?
Speaker 5 (01:24:24–01:24:28)
7 PM is fine, whatever whatever works for you guys.
Speaker 1 (01:24:28–01:24:37)
It's going to require that the matter pan Charlie be running on time for me to get here for 7. No one can guarantee that, Mr. Mullen.
Speaker 12 (01:24:37–01:24:39)
You used to have power over that.
Speaker 1 (01:24:39–01:24:58)
That was a long time ago. That was a long time ago. You and me both. Let's say 7 o'clock for the convenience of the parties.
Unless there's further questions, the board will- We do have a question raised.
Speaker 6 (01:25:01–01:25:13)
Bill? We do have a hand raised by a Robert Rotecki. I don't know if we can entertain that. Sure.
Mr. Rotecki, please state your name and address for the record.
Speaker 16 (01:25:17–01:26:09)
My name is Robert Rotecki. I live at 97 Manhattan Avenue, Milton. I'm an attorney and I represent Robert Sacco who lives at who is an abutter, the rear of the property, who wanted to attend this hearing and to voice his objection to the petition. But we just, he thought it was an in-person hearing.
I'm so sorry, I'm trying to get the video on here. I use Zoom frequently, but I'm getting a very different So I apologize that I haven't been able to come up with a video yet. Anyway, so we're not back.
Speaker 1 (01:26:09–01:26:12)
Did you have an opportunity to hear any of the hearing?
Speaker 16 (01:26:12–01:27:07)
Well, I know that we only caught about the last 5 minutes or so, but I understand that the hearings being continued to October 15th at 7 PM. I will tell you candidly, Mr. Chairman, that I and Mr. Sacco were unaware that the hearings were only.
Remote, he went to the town hall tonight and banged on the doors. Another of Butter, and what was the other of Butter's name? Mr. Goff.
Mr. Goff, where does he live? It was that he was appearing in objection to the petition. Okay.
So they were unaware of it. So I understand that your hearing is being continued to October 57 PM. And I will ask, or Mr. Sacco and I will submit a written objection to the board.
Speaker 1 (01:27:09–01:28:08)
I'd appreciate that, Mr. Rotecki. Let me also, Bill, or Mr. Rotecki, if you could reach out to Bill and make sure that you have communication, he'll make sure that you get where the record is and the board's website so that you have the benefit of that information.
I'll tell you today, tonight's hearing, we had several questions. We had some testimony. Ms. Rosa, the designer, went through the design plans and we're happy to, at the subsequent hearing, we can do a bit of a review of what we went through.
I'll ask the applicant to do that for your benefit and your client's benefit. But I think you'll find that there's a fair bit of material on the website and Bill can Bill can help you help you with that, but I think it would be good for you to, you know, not make a formal appearance, but at least to. Make your presence known and that that it's terrific that you had an opportunity to weigh in.
Speaker 16 (01:28:08–01:28:17)
And I thank you so much and I apologize once again for my. Technical in the expertise that without I'm not trying to hide my video.
Speaker 1 (01:28:18–01:28:52)
By no means, that's okay. No, no, there was no, no, nothing inferred from that. So. I was about to say that unless there's additional business before the board, we're going to adjourn for the evening for the purpose of reconvening this hearing at 7 o'clock on Thursday, October 15th.
Uh, by zoom and, uh, and, uh, Bill will make sure you get all the appropriate information and you can share that with Mr. Sacco.
Speaker 16 (01:28:53–01:28:56)
And I will, and I'll make sure that he's present for that. Okay.
Speaker 1 (01:28:56–01:29:05)
Great. Okay. Thank you so much. Okay.
Any other business before the board? All right. We'll stand adjourned for the evening.
Speaker 9 (01:29:05–01:29:06)
Good. Good night now.