Board: Special Town Meeting Info Forum
Date: 2026-10-14
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:19–11:31)
Okay, good evening, everyone. I'd like to welcome you all to tonight's sort of town meeting info event happening before town meeting next week. This is primarily to focus on Article 6 with a bit of discussion around Article 7. The thought being that as important as this acquisition of Labor Day could be, that we should have as many info sessions as we can, not only with town meeting members, but the community.
Unfortunately, time has only allowed us to have one but we thank you all for being online and in person. So the way this will go for this evening. My name is Winston Daly I'm chair of the select board, I will be giving a small presentation on article six and a bit on article seven. Then our Warren Committee Chair, Jay Funling, will also give a presentation on those articles.
There may be some overlapping information, but it's better to have more information and a couple of different perspectives, after which we will then take questions for any of the town meeting members and folks online. Here with me as well is Nick Milano, Town Administrator. Liz Dillon, our moderator, and John Phelan, our superintendent, for all questions to be asked tonight. So with that, we'll begin.
Mr. Milano, if you could bring up my presentation. Okay, so this is the presentation I'll be giving at town meetings, so we'll pretend that we are there, and so we'll start here. So Labouret Acquisition.
Why are we asking to buy 303 Adams Street and what is the benefit and what will we build there? Article 6 will be to buy and purchase Labouret for the price of $11,750,000. It will authorize us at the Milton Select Board to build it and use it for general municipal purposes. And Article 7 is $1.2 million for a study of a pre-K and kindergarten that may possibly be built there as a part of the school.
building project. Again, what we are discussing tonight is a vote for Article 6, is a vote to buy the land. It is not necessarily a vote to build a school. All right, what are the steps before us tonight?
One, town meeting. A two-thirds majority vote will authorize the acquisition and borrowing of Labouret. Second, there will be a ballot and debt exclusion, and registered voters will vote for that on December 15th of 2026. What is 303 Adams Street?
The land is 4.77 acres, approximately 54,000 square feet across three connected structures. The historic mansion is building A, about 10,000 square feet, three floors in an attic, building B, a former office and administrative space, and building C, a classroom space of roughly 725 square feet. What does it lack? There's no cafeteria, no gymnasium, limited bathrooms, and nothing in the classroom wing.
The current zoning of the property is residence A, single family, plus uses protected under state law. The appraised and highest use from one of our appraisers is of a school or other institutional use. Why has the town pursued this property? 4.77 acres.
Knowing the difficulties we've had in milting the round land, we know that this kind of opportunity does not show itself often. Two, control. Owning it means the town decides what gets built there. It is completely up to the town and its residents what happens with Labarré if we execute this purchase.
Third, something I'm sure all of you have heard about, the schools and the school issues. Currently, we have 2,244 students at our elementary schools in buildings that we say fit about 1,900. That's an overflow of roughly 300 students. You all know we may have, that we have a current school building project at Guile Road for a 7-8 kindergarten.
The estimated cost difference between that project at Guile Road and the project at Labouret is about $33 million. Now there's been no decision made yet. Tonight only funds the land and the study. It does not fund what gets built at Labouret.
How did we arrive at the bid price of $11,750,000? Our initial bid was $10.9 million. That came from our appraisal in the summer. Through conversations with Labouret, where we had asked for the ability to make any matching offer for any bids that were above the town, they came back to us and said that the price that they would sell to Milton would be $11.75 million.
After discussion with the town administrator and the select board, we felt that this was a good price for the town. It was below our previous appraisal of $13.6 million, and so we moved forward. The appraisal was made by a certified appraiser over 40 years of experience, valued the property at about $200 per square foot, with a range of about $187 to $224. That's about $10 to $12.2 million.
The appraisal then only considered uses allowed under current zoning. It did not value a Chapter 40B multifamily development. So the private market price may be a bit higher than what we have here. Why are we recommending reviewing a school use first?
I think simply it's already a school. The site is zoned for institutional use. The appraiser identified school use as its highest and best use, and the classroom wing already exists today. Milton has been working on the school overcrowding for over a decade now, and a very large school project is already in our pipeline.
This land was not available when our project began, and so we think it is a natural question to ask, can LabArray solve some of the issues? What would we have done if LabArray was available when we began our school building project? And can this existing infrastructure deliver a beneficial outcome for less money and quicker? The biggest question deserves to go first.
I say this because the school potential project will be the largest capital project in the history of the town of Milton. We think we deserve to leave no stone unturned as we try to understand which project is the best and what sites will best suit our students and our budget going forward. Why are we only doing a school first and not saying what what can go the lab array no matter what. Because we believe that running every option at once would only would not serve the town.
It would only serve for us to have confusion if multiple groups were looking at lab array and saying. Well, what can we build here no matter what? We don't think that would be the right message and the right outcome to bring before town meeting. The reason that we believe that we can execute a assessment of a school at Labouret really is because of the work that's already been done.
We are working on the bones and the existing infrastructure of the school building committee and the work that's been done over the last eight years. But this is more about sequencing. It's not a decision. It is to look at Lab Array for a school first.
And if the answer is no from the town, if it's no from our existing boards, then we move forward with a different development process. One possible option, I'm sure many of you have heard about, is the pre-K and kindergarten. I wanted to go through those options. The pre-K and kindergarten option was brought to us in the summer.
It was after a conversation between the select board, the school committee, and the superintendent to say how could this be used. Now, to be clear, this was done very quickly. We were able to get this assessment, I think, in maybe two or three weeks. So this is very early, it is rough, but these are the numbers that came back to us.
A pre-K, all pre-K and K kindergarten students would move to one building that would free up classroom space in the elementary schools. Early literacy and foundational learning delivered consistently on one campus with one staff. Currently our pre-K and kindergarten staff do move from building to building and this would eliminate that and I think we can all imagine that that would certainly serve our early learners much better than the system that we have now. The administrative spaces that are currently at the high school would move to Laboret, to the mansion space, and that would also free up space at the high school.
This again is only a preliminary option, not our final decision. The sale has moved very fast, and so we have not been able to explore every single facet, but we owe every consideration to the town. The design options that were returned by the architects in the summer were option one, a minor addition of 17 classrooms, but that would not meet our current pre-K and K kindergarten. Option two, a two-level addition with 26 classrooms, which meets the requested program.
And option three, the three-level addition, which gives us 33 classrooms and a lot of room for growth within our pre-K and K kindergarten program. Where does this leave us in the MSBA project? I won't assume that everyone understands what the MSBA is. That's the Massachusetts School Building Association.
Milton was accepted into the MSBA in the fall of 2024. The MSBA has assessed that Milton is in need of a new school because of our capacity issues, and they have offered a 40% rebate on the school that we would build. So where does that leave us in the project? Understanding that folks have asked the question, if we explore a lab array, does that leave state funds on the table?
Does that kick us out of the project? And how does that move forward? We will not be leaving or leaving the state grant or turning down any state money as of tonight. Milton is in the MSBA pipeline for the study of a K-5 or 7-8 project at any site within Milton.
We entered eligibility December 2024, if I said, and feasibility in February of 2026. And we are currently in the designer selection for a project architect. If purchased, Lab Array will be included in that study of K through five and seven through eight. What Milton needs to ask for is to be added into the MSBA project, the pre-K and kindergarten structures.
Article 6, again, is only the land acquisition. Buying 303 Adams Street does not hurt our standing with the MSBA, and it is not our intention at the select board or any of the boards to impact the MSBA process. We want this to go as smoothly and positively as possible. Article 7, however, funds the information that the town may need.
If pre-K and K is not allowed to be added by the MSBA, it allows the town to have a thought out, well designed program and cost estimate for what we would do if we moved forward with a pre-K and K operation. But we would not want to move forward if this negatively impacted our standing with the MSBA.
Speaker 2 (11:31–11:33)
What if this is not a school, if we
Speaker 1 (11:33–16:50)
Go to town meeting or we go to the folks in the town with our ballot, and it is not accepted. What happens next. First, the town has full control of the zoning, which means Milton does get to decide if we decide to purchase the land. Milton decides what happens next.
We then would enter a community redevelopment process. That means that the school is not the answer. The select board and planning board start to work through a full redevelopment. For any who've watched the select board meetings, I will say this.
Member Obersheimer has been very adamant about helping to create a charge in the committee that would help to look at the redevelopment of Labouret if a school is not the choice going forward. But that would be a longer term and a sort of a deeper process for that redevelopment. Sale or lease always remains a possibility. If we have ownership, we can decide what happens next.
And the historic mansion, this is the only way that we get to retain the mansion that was, I think, built in 1850. What happens if we do not buy it? So if Milton does not move forward with purchasing Labouret, what can happen there? It can be bought by private market.
Folks at Labouret and Curry, we go back to the private market. What can happen? Single family homes. It is zoned for potentially building three to four homes, frontage limits it to about three unless a road is built, unless assumes there's full demolition, including the mansion.
Annual tax revenue, altogether we estimate to be $100,000 to $133,000 on the high end. It could be a Chapter 40 B development, something that I think the town has now become all too familiar with. That would be about 850,000 at an estimated 150 units at the 40 B. For comparison, I believe the 40 B we have on Canton Ave is 116 units.
I think that's the largest one we have in town, Mr. Molano. So it would be larger than any 40 B we currently have zoned in Mill. It is also available for protected uses, meaning religious, educational, childcare, agricultural, solar, and that is zero dollars in tax revenue if it is educational or religious.
The path forward. It would be a town meeting vote to put this forward on the ballot. It would then go to the town wide ballot on December 15 for a vote from all registered voters. Article 7 funds our study and evaluation if the MSBA does not allow us back into the process.
We would then decide, I think we have our drop dead date for decision. through discussions with the school building committee and the school committee would be about June or July of 2027 to decide if we're moving forward with Laboray as a school or something else. So we have about six months in 2027 to make that decision. Once that decision is made, if it is a school, we return to town meeting with a vote, not only for the budget of the school, but to move forward.
If it's not decided to be a school, then we go on a new path. meaning we have a completely new redevelopment team that is built and that committee will have its charge to decide what will get built at Labarré. What are the things that we do not know yet? The construction costs are preliminary.
They were only produced in the study which I said we got over a couple of weeks in the summer and Article 7 exists to replace that study with real numbers if we are not re-entered into the MSBA program. We have not yet determined whether a Labor-A-School project would fully address the middle school. That has come up often. It addresses elementary capacity.
The middle school question is still open. Those are questions to be asked and answered. We do not yet know whether the MSBA would allow pre-K or kindergarten into the study at Labor-A, but we have met twice with the MSBA to discuss this further. Our last meeting with the MSBA was yesterday.
The group that met with the MSBA will still need time to debrief, and that may also impact how we move forward with Article 7, but that is not, excuse me, being a little under the weather, I'm apologizing. But that decision may also impact Article 7, and we will be meeting this week to debrief our last meeting with the MSBA, and if we will be petitioning to reenter the MSBA process for the pre-K and kindergarten option. No alternative use has yet been developed in detail because the sale timeline did not allow for it. We only became aware of Lab Array in May of last year and I think you all kind of understand that this is moving very quickly and that is why we want to have as much information as possible out in the public and as many questions answered before we move forward.
So what we are asking is for, in Article 6, to buy the land, fund the study of the land for the school, and then we decide our path forward. Milton has been working on school capacity for over a decade. The project gives us an alternative, and it also gives us options, whether we use it or not. This is an item that we did not have before, and I certainly hope that everyone in the town would look at the purchase of Labouret as a great asset for the community, no matter what step we take forward.
And that is all. So if you just hold your questions to Mr. Funley.
Speaker 3 (16:51–16:54)
Thank you, Mr. Daly. Did you say a minute ago that you're coming down with a cold?
Speaker 1 (16:54–16:57)
Is that what you said? Yeah, a little bit.
Speaker 3 (16:57–16:58)
I'm right here with you.
Speaker 1 (16:59–17:01)
Not available. Oh, man. A little bit.
Speaker 3 (17:01–18:19)
Sharing air. Okay, thank you. My name is Jay Funley. I'm the chair of the Warrant Committee.
The Warrant Committee has recommended that the town meeting take affirmative action on articles six and seven. I have a presentation to share tonight. My name is Jay Fundling, chair of the Warrant Committee. I will be sharing a presentation tonight.
It is very similar to a presentation that was shared at the Warrant Committee approximately a month ago. I think it does a good job of summarizing the Warrant Committee's thoughts in recommending positive vote on articles six and seven. The presentation as I have it put together has a lot of overlap with what Mr. Daley shared.
Between now and Monday, I'm sure we'll coordinate to make them flow a little more seamlessly together. But for now, I'll just sort of, well, where we overlap, I still might give a different view on the facts if we're discussing them. Come out article six and seven, which we know, moving on. I just talk about the price we're paying, what happens if we don't purchase it, what happens if we do purchase it, and some challenges.
Speaker 2 (18:22–18:22)
Oh, whoops.
Speaker 3 (18:24–18:34)
You haven't missed much on the presentation. Did I say I'm sharing my screen? Oh, hold on. I have to click the share button.
That always tricks me up.
Speaker 2 (18:40–18:42)
Great. Okay.
Speaker 3 (18:44–31:23)
So, you know, setting the stage, it's unusual for us to have the opportunity to purchase a parcel of land like this. One of several options is that it might be a room for a new school, and if we purchase it, we can consider what the best use for Milton is. What the first question that the warrant committee had was is the price for paying a fair price and I won't reiterate too much of what mr. Daly already said but we got the information from them the price was negotiated between the select board and the seller and then we got the information we got to see the appraisal we got to see Well, we got to see the appraisal that went into it.
And as Mr. Daly said, the appraisal said $10.9 million, but that that number was arrived at by looking at sort of the midpoint of a range, which could go from almost 10 to a little over 12. And that specifically the appraiser did state that the highest and best use of this property is a school or some other institutional use that would make use of the buildings that are already on the property with one caveat. And the appraisal did not consider what would be the value of this property if a 40B is built there.
The appraiser looked at it and asked himself, what is it zoned for? It's zoned for single-family use or, like we said, some of the non-profit institutional use, like a school or religious place. The appraiser, because of that, did not look at multifamily housing on there, although we all know a 40B can just ignore our zoning and build there. So that was not considered when they said what the most valuable use of the property would be.
Moving on a little bit, again, what Mr. Daley already said was that we saw that the final price they agreed to was about 8% than what the town's appraisal was, but still within the range of what the appraiser gave, and that, as Mr. Daley said, it was less than what the town had it for in its books. Now, of course, this was a non-profit, so when the town had 13.6 million on the tax rolls, They weren't paying any taxes.
I don't know if anybody was fighting over it, but at least it gave us a ballpark to let us know we're in the right area. So now the question in front of us with Article 6 is a yes or no question. Do we purchase the property? Do we not purchase the property?
So let's look at what if we don't purchase the property. If we don't, its uses are limited. It can be single family homes. It can be a protected use like religious or educational or 40B.
Again, you've seen some of this, but just a different perspective. Here's what the property looks like. It could be divided easily into three lots. It would hold three houses.
Or you could build a little street in there, a little cul-de-sac, and make it into four houses. And that would, you know, four houses at about $2.5 million per house would generate $133 in taxes per year. And I focused on this because one of the questions we had the Warrant Committee coming up was, well, what if we don't buy it? What if we turn it into a moneymaker for the town?
It's currently not being taxed. What if we turn it into taxable property? That was one of the questions. Well, if we just let houses be built there, about $133,000 per town.
per year that's with a big ballpark you know don't i'm not i'm not saying it'll be exactly 103 000 just saying that's about what it would be Now, what if we turned it into a 40B? For comparison, I looked at the Ice House property. The Ice House property is about an acre and it's worth about $15 million. So I said, okay, this is 4.7 acres.
Just multiply that number by 4.7. I'm not a real estate developer. I'm sure building 40Bs is more complicated than that. But again, ballpark.
That would be a $72 million property on that land at the residential tax rate. I'd bring in about $850,000. So again, if we're wondering what could it bring in if we just let the free market take its hand, that's what it would be, an extra ballpark $850,000 into the town's pocket. So these are the possibilities.
It could be houses. If we don't buy it, it could be houses. It could be a 4DB. It could be a school or a church.
OK, so what if we do purchase it? And this is where it gets a little tricky in the discussion of this article. Myself, I think I can speak for the moderator, we all feel like we have an article in front of us. The article doesn't say, what are we going to do with this property?
The article says, do we buy it or not? So to some extent, we want to restrict our consideration to that question, do we buy it or not? But if you're considering buying a property, you should at least discuss what you'll do with it. Even if that's not a final decision, it's a little bit silly to say, should we buy this property or not, and not have a conversation about what we could do with it.
So yada, yada, yada. As you heard, there's been discussions about building a pre-K school on this site. Now. Warrant committee, very interested in dollars and cents.
What's the financial opportunity of building at LaBarre versus building at the Gile Road site? The Gile Road site, the best numbers we have are the $181 million project. We'd receive $51 million from the state, net cost of $130 million to build the building. For LaBarre, if we want to build that, we would acquire the land for 11.75 million right now.
The construction estimate we have is $85 million. There's a big asterisk on that. This was a quick and high-level estimate done over the summer. But despite that, it's the best estimate we have, $85 million to build out a full K pre-K program.
I'm assuming in this slide that we would get no MSBA funding from it. We might, but I'll just go with this assumption for now. So the total cost, capital cost of building the building, $96.75 million. I've got some notes on here about administration cost.
The administration cost of a new middle school would probably be higher. You'd need to hire a principal. Administration cost of the pre-K, we already have people who run the pre-K. We're thinking that administration cost would be lower.
This is all qualitative, not quantitative. So we're talking about an upfront cost of $96 million versus $130 million. What does that mean to us? Well, let's turn that into financing.
We don't pay $130 million out of our pocket. Today, we borrow it and finance it. So if we're financing the Gow Road site at $130 million, making some reasonable assumptions, that would cost the town about $7.5 million per year. There are about 10,000 residences in town.
I like round numbers, so chop a couple digits off that. That would cost the average house $750 per year. LaBarre, $96.75 million. If we finance that, it'd cost us about $5.6 million per year.
The average taxpayer would pay $560 per year. The difference between those two, the less expensive option, the LaBarre option, would cost the town $1.9 million less per year to finance it. Let's pull that all together with some of the other things we were talking about. We were taught, so if, if one option is, and I'm not saying this is certainly what would happen, just throwing it out as a hypothetical.
If we walk away from Guile and build LaBarre, and if the cost is $34 million less to build LaBarre, that would save the town, you know, relatively speaking, $1.9 million per year. Compare that to if we had a 40B built there. Well, 40B would build, bring in $850,000 per year. What if we, people at Warren Committee ask, what if we had a commercial development there?
Well, we can't just do that tomorrow, because it's not zoned for commercial development. Let's say we waved a magic wand and somehow made it a commercial development right now. That would be a very rough estimate, a little bit less, probably in the ballpark of the 40B. So either one of those options brings in less money to the town than the savings if we do the library option versus guile.
um so this is just uh yeah this is repeating what what i said before and again the warrant committee is looking at money we're not saying this is the better option we are saying this is probably a cheaper option so you know give us another data point to work with uh so did it sorry i'm getting up to speed on these uh and i'll just i'll ignore what's on this slide my my perspective and i think the perspective of the warrant committee is purchasing this land gives us the option of building the k pre-k school on there may give us the option of building some different sort of school asset on there may give us the option of doing some different use whether it's town owned or town sold for that property If we don't buy this property, all those options are unavailable to us. So the building the pre-K there, I don't know if that's the best choice. But I know we're never going to learn if it's the best choice if we don't buy the land. This is repeating what Mr.
Taylor already said. And then I'll say a bit about Article 7. I'll say a little bit more about that this is if article 6 passes what article 7 does is it gives I'll say allocates because it may or may not be spent allocates 1.2 million to study do a detailed study of a school at the LaBarre site. Now, why would we want to do this?
The reason, and what we discussed at the Warrant Committee was, right now we have a Gow Road site that has been studied for years. We spent quite a bit of money to get a detailed drawing and cost estimate of the possible Gow Road site. We have not done that for the LaBarre site. So in order to, at some point, if I'm looking at my crystal ball, if we do purchase this land, at some point the town will have the question, do we want to go for building a school at Guile?
Do we want to go for building a school at Laboree? In order to compare apples to apples, we really should have a detailed comparison of the two of those. So this is to allocate funds to have a detailed examination of the laboratory site so that if we buy the land, we can really make an informed decision, apples to apples, and not have a fully fleshed out option at one site and a really quick and dirty option at the other site. And the Warrant Committee felt especially okay approving this because we looked at what the School Building Committee has done with funds up until now.
School Building Committee was formed at the end of the previous decade. They spent almost no money for the first three, four, five years of their existence. And then once things really started moving at the Gow Road site, they did spend money to get that full examination done. And since then they spent very little.
School building committee has been very frugal with their funds. I do not expect them to change that right now. If we allocate the money to do a detailed study at Gow Road, I do not expect they will spend the money unless it is prudent and under the blessing of the school building and school committee. That's it.
And I had an appendix about how I made up the numbers about commercial costs made up. Yes, that's correct word. So, you know, it comes back to, we don't know what the final and best use of this property is, but we do know if the town doesn't buy it, which is the question before us, we're never going to learn what the best use of the property is.
Speaker 1 (31:27–31:29)
Nick, are you handling the questions online?
Speaker 4 (31:30–31:44)
Yes, so the folks on Zoom, if you do have a question, you can raise your hand and we'll give you opportunities for questions. And then, obviously, for folks in the room, if you could come up to the table here to speak.
Speaker 5 (31:44–31:56)
Not everyone all at once.
Speaker 3 (31:57–31:58)
We've got a hand on mine.
Speaker 1 (32:00–32:07)
So we need to do a name, precinct, name, address. Sure.
Speaker 6 (32:07–32:21)
Megan Walsh, 107 Church Street. Yeah, bring it a little closer. Precinct 7. I'm just curious as to the 85 million dollar estimate, how you came up with that dollar figure.
Speaker 1 (32:21–32:43)
So that was given to us by the designer, that entire estimate and design is on the school building website, I believe. So if you, we don't have it with us unless Mr. Milano can pull it up, but it's on the school building committee website and that was given to us in the summer and it had the three options that I listed, the different costs and what would go into the bill.
Speaker 4 (32:43–33:09)
So yes, the cost estimate was done by PM&C, which is a cost estimator used for a lot of public projects. Their report is available on the town website on the school building committee page, and their numbers are based on the very preliminary conceptual plans that were done by the DLR group, which is the architect that worked for the school building committee to do that kind of test fit study. So that number came from a cost estimator.
Speaker 6 (33:10–33:12)
So will that be available for town meeting?
Speaker 4 (33:12–33:14)
Yeah, it's already available on the town website currently.
Speaker 6 (33:15–33:29)
And just another question for Superintendent Phelan. How many classrooms or office spaces do we currently have in the central office space within the high school?
Speaker 7 (33:29–34:23)
We have a suite in the superintendent's office with four offices in a conference room. We have a special education central office team that takes one space but it has four individuals in one small space. We have a business office that has one large space but it has five, one, two, five individuals that work in that one space. We have then single small offices that we put into our band practice rooms, which are very small spaces, and we occupy four of those.
And currently, the consolidated facilities director, interim director, has some space there as well. We also have a file room in the basement of the first floor of the school across from the cafeteria. And we have some facilities workshop space within the custodial space by the vocational rooms.
Speaker 6 (34:23–34:35)
So have we designated how many, how much square footage and how many classrooms could be allocated if we moved central office out of the high school?
Speaker 7 (34:35–35:08)
We haven't gone through that exercise yet, but the original design of the high school did not have central office occupying space. So originally, for example, the superintendent space, the assistant superintendent, the HR director. and the conference room was supposed to be for the guidance department, which is adjacent currently. So that would probably turn into potentially guidance space for students.
The other spaces were classrooms, small classrooms for not full classrooms, but half classrooms. And the other one would be giving the space back to band in the music department.
Speaker 8 (35:12–35:14)
All right. Thank you.
Speaker 3 (35:17–36:08)
I will, if I can share my screen briefly, I want to show where we can find this information on the town website. There might be another place for it, but I just googled Milton School Building Committee. Am I sharing my screen? And I got here, and I scrolled down, and I found evaluation of Laboree College.
At first, I clicked on the pre-K Laboree College study estimate. That was a very confusing document. But then I clicked on the group presentation of the school building committee and found this, which talks about three options and their costs. So I will stop sharing my screen.
That's the $85 million, you're saying? Yes. No, it's very small, but the 85 million is there. We have two people online.
Speaker 1 (36:08–36:17)
If we could hold it in person, I'm going to go to one person online and then we'll come back in person. You can still sit there. Ms. Felton, can you hear us?
Speaker 9 (36:19–36:20)
Yes. Can you hear me?
Speaker 1 (36:20–36:20)
Yes.
Speaker 9 (36:22–39:18)
Great. I have a few questions and comments. I'll start with Jay, since Jay, you were the last one to make your presentation. I'm curious because I did watch some Warren Committee meetings, and I did watch one meeting when there was a vote on these articles, and it seemed like a number of the Warren Committee members have abstained from that vote.
And so I am curious about the number of people on the Warrant Committee who actually approved the articles. That's one question. There was also a presentation, you mentioned that apples to apples. That's the thing that is very unclear to me in terms of the square footage of Guile compared to LaBarre, and are you really going to get the exact same square footage and classroom space?
Also, it was mentioned, you mentioned, you know, if it's not a school, then 40B. Well, you know, that property could be rezoned, and it's my understanding that other authors There were contingencies to get that property rezoned. And we've seen that happen before in town with the memory care unit. So there are other possibilities.
And I think mentioning just the possibility of a 40B does scare people. So I think that's all my comments. for now. I am curious about the middle school because I know there was a film made in 2021 where the middle school, it was said that there was overcrowding and now there isn't overcrowding.
So I am curious how that relates to special ed and are more kids in the middle school being placed in out-of-district placements because we do not have the room in the middle school to accommodate the different learning styles of kids who are sent for out-of-placement. And if we built Guile Road as a middle school, would that give us the opportunity to bring back those kids, which would certainly save us a lot of money. So as you can see, I have been thinking about this for a while and, you know, very curious about some of the answers to my questions. Thank you.
Speaker 3 (39:20–42:06)
Mr. Davey, I'd like to take a stab at these questions. Okay, so your first question, Ms. Felton, was about what were the votes of the Warrant Committee.
My view as Warrant Committee Chair is that the Warrant Committee as a body makes a decision and then proceeds with that decision. In the past, we've seen committees, be them the Warrant Committee or be them other committees, saying on some articles, we had a unanimous vote on this, and other articles, we don't say we have a unanimous vote. Or maybe a committee will say, well, the majority thought this, but the minority also thought that. I don't like proceeding that way.
The committee as a whole decided to support this, and so that's where we're going. Now, your specific question, what were the votes, I don't know off the top of my head. I encourage you to watch the videos. The minutes for that meeting have not been approved yet.
That's not secret how the vote went, but my view is we're the Warrant Committee. We made a decision. I'm presenting the decision of the Committee as a whole, not a minority report. So I hope you can understand that.
The next question was about apples to apples, and you're very right. When I said apples to apples, I meant a thorough examination of one or a thorough examination of another. You are right. One project would be larger than the other.
One project would be presumably more expensive than the other. So do you want the larger, more expensive one, or do you want the smaller, less expensive one? That I'm not sure of. So you're absolutely right that when I said apples to apples, they're not going to provide exactly the same service.
And that's something the town will have to think about. Your third question was about could it be rezoned for something else? Memory care, commercial, Trader Joe's, I don't know. And this is where I would go back to the question in front of town meeting at this time is on Article 6, do we purchase it or do we not purchase it?
If we do not purchase it, then the buyer can do whatever they want at that point. It is not zoned for commercial right now. It is not zoned for memory care right now. It is not zoned for whatever else you might want right now.
So if someone else purchased it, I don't know what they would do, but they would I would think they might work under the current zoning. If we, as a town, think it would be great to rezone this for another purpose, then owning it, changing the zoning, and moving forward with that purpose. may be the way to go. I don't know if you want to address that last point in particular or any of the points.
Speaker 1 (42:06–43:46)
Yeah, I will join on a few of those. First, Ms. Felton, your question on the zoning. We are not aware and we weren't a part of the other side of the cellar of any potential buyers either wanting to purchase or not purchasing based on zoning.
We share the zoning as it is because that's what a buyer would need to deal with if they did buy the property. We then included 40B because the 40B development is a development that does not need to worry about zoning. It does not matter what it is zoned for. So those were the reasons why that was included.
It's not to scare anyone, although it may somehow feel that way. But that's what would happen. If anything else, they would need to go to the Planning Board, Board of Appeals for a change of zoning. On the apples to apples, one thing I will say is, and we've already gotten there, is that it is very easy to immediately go to school versus school because of the project that we have in front of us.
I don't think that is our intent to say that it is a school at Labouret or a school at Guile. What we're saying is this asset has come online, and these are the reasons that we would buy it, these are the things that we may do with it, and all of this information, we are seeking to get all of it together to put in front of the town and the boards that have been elected to make the decision. Saying that we're going to buy Labouret does not necessarily mean that everyone prefers that we buy Labouret, saying that we don't buy doesn't mean everyone wants to go with Guile, it is to give the town as many as much knowledge, options and flexibility for what we're going to do moving forward. Mr.
Molano, anything you want to speak to?
Speaker 7 (43:49–44:31)
I just want to address the questions related to the enrollment at the Pierce Middle School. There are currently 983 students enrolled at the Pierce Middle School. That building can hold more students than that and has in the past. There is no correlation or connection to special education in our enrollment.
and our need or our not need for a new building at Pierce. We have successfully brought back many, several students back into the district over the last several years to have our students take part in programming within the district instead of traveling out of the district. But again, that is not a factor in this building purchase, nor in the consideration for the library plan versus the Guy Rowe plan. It's just not a, it's not an issue.
Speaker 2 (44:36–44:37)
Can you still hear me?
Speaker 9 (44:37–44:47)
Yeah. Okay. I just want, I want to thank you all for your responses and I look forward to hearing more. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (44:48–44:50)
We'll go in person. Who are you, sir?
Speaker 10 (44:51–45:33)
I am John Cohane, town meeting member from Precinct 7. My question is basically on the December date for, and let me back up a second, because I know we've been at this for a long time, and I totally understand it. But I'm just asking, that seems very aggressive. It's two months between now and then, and we have to do this study.
Are there any outside influences on that date or is it just purely we got to keep moving? And I understand if we really got to keep moving, but is there something else that affects that like MSBA or something there's some.
Speaker 1 (45:33–45:36)
Well, the date is for the ballot vote to purchase.
Speaker 10 (45:36–45:42)
It's not for moving forward over school. But this is to approve the funds to build it.
Speaker 1 (45:42–45:46)
No, to approve the funds to buy Labor Day.
Speaker 10 (45:46–45:52)
No, I'm talking about you also mentioned, though, in December, we're going to have to have a debt exclusion vote.
Speaker 1 (45:52–45:56)
Yes, that's to buy the property. Just to buy the property? Just to buy the property.
Speaker 10 (45:56–45:57)
I thought it was to fund the school.
Speaker 1 (45:58–46:03)
That's just to buy the property. My mistake. The only thing that will be on the ballot is the 11-7 to buy the property.
Speaker 10 (46:03–46:05)
We're just going to fund that money into Senate?
Speaker 1 (46:05–46:05)
That's it.
Speaker 10 (46:05–46:06)
All right. Thank you. Ms.
Speaker 2 (46:12–46:21)
Hovland, can you hear us? Yes, I can.
Speaker 11 (46:21–46:22)
Can you hear me?
Speaker 1 (46:22–46:22)
Yes.
Speaker 11 (46:23–48:04)
All right. Thank you. Christine Hodlin, town meeting member from Precinct 3, 112 Maple Street. I appreciate you having this forum because I have not been in town able to keep myself up to date on everything.
So thank you for that. I just have a couple of questions, and they could be something that you've already covered. But I guess one question I have is, why are you limiting the use to municipal only? if we, the town, own the property, couldn't we, if we decided we didn't need Laboret, decide to get commercial there, whether we had to rezone or not is kind of a different question, but we'd have to then change the use to something other than municipal with the town meeting vote, or would we have to do that anyway?
And I guess my second question is, you know, I think, Jay, for the discrepancy or the changes, I guess, in the prices, whether we go with Guile or with LaBarre, but I feel that they're somewhat unequal because my understanding is the only conversation I've heard along with LaBarre as a kindergarten pre-K And I'm not sure how that kind of a school would address the overcrowding, which is what the Guile project had a lot more things other than just, I think, use for, you know, for removing pre-K and kindergarten to eliminate overcrowding in many more of the schools, which I thought was the middle school and the high school. But maybe those things have all changed and I'm just not up to date. So if you could maybe help me with that, any one of you, thank you.
Speaker 4 (48:08–49:07)
Chris just so the language in the so Chris is referring to is that in the language of the article in the language of the article as well as the recommendation there is it says that the property shall be acquired for general municipal purposes including but not limited to school purposes so Whenever the town acquires property it does need to provide a general category for what will be used general municipal purposes gives it broad latitude to be used for really anything in any purpose that might include leasing it out. It might include. you know, a town use, and then including but not limited to school purposes also provides that opportunity to be used for a school. So that's more just general kind of legal language to provide the authority to use it for any number of purposes, which could include selling it, it could include leasing it, it could include a school, it could include something else.
So it's very broad catch-all language. It's not limiting, it's actually more broad than it would be limiting.
Speaker 7 (49:09–51:02)
Good evening Chris, John Phelan, Interim Superintendent. The overcrowding priority for us to remedy is at the elementary school where we have all four of our elementary schools at capacity or above capacity. The 7-8 model for Guile Road did a nice job of adjusting the grade configuration. So fifth grade would leave every elementary school.
And then the current peer site would host grades five and six in plenty of room in the middle school where it currently has three grades. And that would give the room and the space for the elementaries to sustain the K to five plus preschool in the high school, again, would be able to provide, get space by the central office leaving and going to the middle school as well. The pre-KK program basically does the same thing except remedy the middle school. So what it would do was it would take the pre-K classes at the Cunningham and the Tucker and it would take all the kindergartens out of every elementary and move them over to that one site.
That would free up all the space at each of the elementary schools where currently the biggest log jam is of students and classroom space that's needed. The high school would still be remedied because the offices of central office would move out of the high school instead of going to the middle school, which is the Guile Road option to remedy the high school. And we'd go to the LaBarre site with the middle school not having any remedy to relief any pressure there at the moment. So this is very clearly been stated in the past that This option does not make every remedy available like it does with the 7th and 8th grade program at Guile Road, but it does take care of the majority of the enrollment issues that we have or space issues we have at this time.
Speaker 11 (51:06–51:08)
Okay. Thank you. I don't have any other questions.
Speaker 1 (51:11–51:11)
Thank you. Ms. Walsh.
Speaker 6 (51:13–51:34)
Maggie Walsh, Town Meeting Precinct 7. Just for clarification, what are the purposes of having the special election in December as opposed to waiting in April? Because I know everyone gets all crazy about the money that we have to spend for a special election.
Speaker 1 (51:34–52:01)
So, that was part of our discussion with Curry College and Labouret. Initially, we thought about getting it on to the state ballot in the November and it would have been too difficult. Also, it would have been at the end of a very long ballot. So, the best date was December to have it closed in time for the funds to be sent to Curry because they have a deadline because that money is actually going to go roll into their program because they're going to continue the Labouret program.
Speaker 6 (52:02–52:03)
So, it's required for year end?
Speaker 1 (52:04–52:09)
I'm not sure on their books, but in our discussion with them, December was what worked for their timeline.
Speaker 6 (52:13–52:15)
Okay. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (52:17–52:21)
Is there anyone else in person? Hold on.
Speaker 10 (52:21–52:22)
John Cohan.
Speaker 1 (52:22–52:29)
Hold on, we got one online. Oh, sorry. Ms. Christensen, can you hear us?
Speaker 12 (52:30–52:31)
I can hear you, yes.
Speaker 1 (52:31–52:32)
Yep, you can go ahead.
Speaker 12 (52:33–52:39)
I have two questions. My first one is- Who are you? Pardon me?
Speaker 1 (52:39–52:39)
Who are you?
Speaker 12 (52:41–55:14)
Oh, I'm Cindy Christensen. I live at 59 Colomer Street, and I'm a town meeting member for Precinct 7. And I have two questions for you tonight. One is how much has the school building committee spent to date?
And then my second question, There's some lead into that. For about two years now, Megan Walsh and I have been trying to get people to listen to us. After our research, we show that the information provided to MSBA and to the land swap was incorrect by about eight classrooms as far as elementary school capacity. We've asked for that to be corrected and we're two years past the time that we brought it to the attention of town government and still nothing has been done.
So our concern started with the 2019 presentation by some firm that suggested we needed 25 more elementary school classrooms. That's based on having 83, 85 as-built classrooms when there's actually 95 as-built classrooms. That doesn't count all those music and other classrooms. There's now three computer rooms that are being used as classrooms.
So that boosts it up to 98. And then there's been two classrooms added to Cunningham. So we have 100. elementary school classrooms.
In 2019, when we were advised we needed a new school, elementary school with 25 new classrooms, there were 2,395 pre-K to fifth graders. Today, there are 2,221, a reduction of 174. So my question is, has anyone, I know we're all talking about building a new school and now it's, will it be at Labouret or will it be at Guild? But I'm asking, has anyone checked to see, do we actually need a new school or do we just need a few more classrooms?
Speaker 1 (55:17–55:22)
Mr. Malani, you want to take the school building committee spend and Superintendent Phelan?
Speaker 4 (55:23–55:26)
Give me a minute.
Speaker 7 (55:26–56:47)
All right. Superintendent Phelan, you first. Good evening, Cindy. John Phelan, interim superintendent of schools.
As someone who's only been in the district for the last 14 months and spent one day a week in every single school for the last 14 months, I could say that we definitely need more space at our elementary schools. I think our middle school could use space generally and the high school could use more space because they are the school that is getting more students each year, intermittently each year. The elementary classrooms that you're referring to in the count, I could not speak to directly, and I know that we did meet over the summer and have this conversation. So I can't speak to the count of full classrooms per se, but I can say what's driving this need for space is not only just general classrooms, but it's also how we are engaging in programming students revolving around the different needs that we have today related to students getting intervention, math intervention, reading intervention, support for special needs students, preschool, EL students that we serve, all of which are part of our school community that we wanna make sure that we can effectively service on a daily basis.
So I don't have a count for you, but I can say that the elementary school space is sorely needed at this point in time.
Speaker 1 (56:53–57:14)
And Ms. Christensen on the school building committee spend, I think our estimate right now is about a half million dollars. We will, we can go more in depth to get the exact number, but that's about the estimate that we have. Does that answer your questions?
Speaker 12 (57:18–57:25)
I don't, okay, I've got the mic, I guess. Yeah, I'll have more, I'm sure. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (57:25–57:28)
Okay, thank you.
Speaker 10 (57:29–57:53)
John Cohen, town meeting member, precinct 7. On question 7, I A couple of questions I have is I don't see anything listed in there for construction costs. I see architectural engineering and project management services for the design of the addition, but how are we getting construction costs? Is that part of that?
Speaker 1 (57:53–57:56)
That would be part of the entire study.
Speaker 10 (57:57–58:07)
It's just not clear in the question. It doesn't say construction costs. And unless project management services means that?
Speaker 4 (58:08–58:48)
No, Article 7 is just to study and design a building. And then if that is the preferred choice, that would come back to town meeting. there would be a subsequent town meeting vote and article with the total project budget amount at a future town meeting, not this town meeting. That Article 7 would only cover design, cost estimating, project management services up until a schematic design level, at which point another warrant article would be required to come back to a future town meeting with a total project budget of $100 million to construct, followed by a debt exclusion vote.
Speaker 10 (58:48–58:51)
So there'd be a second article that would be to develop the costs.
Speaker 4 (58:51–58:52)
Correct.
Speaker 10 (58:52–59:02)
Okay. Okay. And then the other question then I have, and again, in the interest of speed, because we've been at this forever, is there a deadline for this design phase?
Speaker 4 (59:03–01:00:15)
So in the MSBA program, we're already working under. It's a very regimented schedule with a number of deliverables that are required on certain deadlines to stay on track. And if the MSBA program were to adhere to that schedule, which is our intention, The schedule that we have right now assumes that we will be submitting to the MSBA around this time next year what's called the preferred schematic report. That preferred schematic report will outline all of the options that were studied, identify what the town has decide its preferred option with a cost estimate and ask the MSBA to approve that design for further design work prior to coming back to town meeting.
So it's a very long-winded way of saying about this time next year is when school committees, select board, and others will have to say, this is the option we want to go with, request MSBA approval to proceed. And then another year after that, we would expect to be coming to the town meeting and to the voters saying, This is a $100 million project at this site. We're asking for your approval for that. So fall of 2028 for a vote on the total project budget of a school project.
Speaker 10 (01:00:15–01:00:21)
Thanks. And that answers my question earlier about their outside forces driving the schedule in their hours.
Speaker 4 (01:00:22–01:00:23)
Sorry. Yes.
Speaker 10 (01:00:23–01:00:23)
Thank you.
Speaker 3 (01:00:25–01:00:55)
Can I circle back to a previous question? Ms. Felton's question about the votes. I hope I was not too dismissive of that question.
I have my feelings, but how your town committee votes is public knowledge. So, Ms. Felton, I just sent an email to the Warrant Committee clerk, copying you, I hope. You should have an email from me in your inbox, asking the Warrant Committee clerk to tell you how that vote went.
Sorry if I was too dismissive earlier.
Speaker 1 (01:00:59–01:01:02)
Miss Varela, can you hear us?
Speaker 13 (01:01:02–01:01:02)
Can you hear me?
Speaker 1 (01:01:03–01:01:03)
Yes.
Speaker 13 (01:01:04–01:01:14)
OK. Hi, everyone. Thanks, first off, for having this meeting. As other people said, it's really good that you're having it for the questions.
I have a couple of questions.
Speaker 1 (01:01:14–01:01:16)
Can you just introduce yourself?
Speaker 13 (01:01:16–01:03:58)
Oh, I'm sorry. Sheila Varela, 70 Lyman Road, town meeting member, precinct A. I guess what I wanted to ask, you know, with the conversation and the two presentations that both Winston and Jay have given, because of the speed that this needs to happen, that, you know, if town meeting says they approve the $11 million and change to go out to a debt consolidated, you know, override vote in December, just so that the town can purchase it and we can own it. But then there's all the other steps that need to happen.
Will MSBA also consider the pre-K model for reimbursement? They may, they may not. And if they don't, and if they don't and we still, and then we still, the town still thinks that the early education center is the best thing for Labouret, I know you've mentioned that it doesn't mean that we're not still moving forward with the MSBA middle school on Guile, but would the town really consider having both? Number one, because if that's the case, then you'd still need another debt consolidated override to pay on down the road.
to pay for the middle school, even though we're getting a reimbursement, we'll get some sort of reimbursement from the state on that. Will it, do you think, or is the feeling, I mean, it might be too early, but it is either going to be either or, or are you still thinking it could be both? You could still have the early ed center and still have the middle school, or because of the alleviation at the element, the four elementaries, because you're taking away all the pre-K and K, and it will be 1-5. I mean, Superintendent Feldman, you had said, and it will leave the high school, but the middle school, even though it's not overcrowded now, like it's still sort of, if you don't build the new school, leaves them hanging for the future.
So I guess my question to Winston and to Jay are, I mean, do you feel it will be one or the other? I mean, because if we, you're asking the town for this $11 million change, debt consolidated, override now to pay for it, and then it's sort of, it's a lot of money kind of back to back, just as someone who's been an override queen in the past understanding the ask, so if you could speak to that, please.
Speaker 1 (01:03:58–01:04:18)
It's a good question, and I will say, never say never, but I do not believe it is our intention to build two schools. If a school choice is made, whether it is Laboratory or it is Guile, I believe all of the bodies that have been in discussion and agreed it will be one or the other. Superintendent Phelan, do you agree with that?
Speaker 7 (01:04:18–01:04:54)
I feel, first of all, I'm very thankful and grateful to the school building committee and the town for moving forward with the Guile Road site program and model. And that is not going to be in jeopardy at all during this process, so I'm thankful for that. This is an either or, in my opinion. I think we're asking a lot of the taxpayers to move into a situation where they're gonna be okaying either 130 million for the seven and eight school with the preschool attached and or the library site at roughly 100 million.
And I do not believe we need the space for both at this moment in time. And I think it would be prudent to do only one of the two.
Speaker 3 (01:04:57–01:05:23)
Yeah, and I'll just say something that I heard a few minutes ago from my colleague, Mr. Daly. I had previously said that I thought we would have to decide La Barre or Galle site. Mr.
Daly, at a certain point tonight, said it's not going to be one school project versus another. I don't know if we're saying the same thing in two different ways, or if we have two different opinions, which is fine.
Speaker 1 (01:05:23–01:05:57)
I think we're, maybe we should just clarify our communication in that. What I'm saying is not one or the other, is that what's before town meeting, and it's really hard to not conflate the two, but the first piece for us to discuss is, are we buying Labarré? Does the town agree that Laboray is something that the town should own as an asset? And then there's the next step.
And the next step that the select board and the school committee have agreed on is to include it in looking at for the school building project.
Speaker 7 (01:05:58–01:06:56)
I would just like to concur because that seems to be a point of some confusion. First of all, you know, as a taxpayer, myself and a resident, I think buying the asset is a very, you know, it's an excellent step for the town to take advantage of that. And these two projects should be looked at as options together and not in competition with each other. This is just adding another option.
to explore, and by not exploring it, we would have some residents say, why didn't you do that? Why wouldn't you explore that? That seemed like it might have been a good option or less expensive or better for our early childhood students. This just allows the town to have that conversation in front of the whole community, answer every question we can as we go through the process.
and then town meeting and the voters will decide which they prefer moving forward. So this is really about having everybody part of this conversation and exploring the facts that we can bring to them if the both articles pass. So I don't see this as a competition. I see it as just another good option for the town to explore.
Speaker 1 (01:06:56–01:07:35)
And so when I say, Jay, that it's not a competition between the two, is I don't want folks to connect their yes or no to buying the property to which school do they prefer or if they want a school. And I know it's really hard to disconnect that, but I think it's important that we say that. Purchasing Lab Array is not a checkmark or an X for your ideas on the school. It is saying that you think Do you think that the town should own Labouret, and then we are taking this, if that is a yes, and is a yes across the town, then we are taking steps to present what we think should happen next, and the town will also have a vote on that.
Speaker 3 (01:07:36–01:07:43)
I agree entirely. I'm glad we clarified that. We've got another hand up.
Speaker 1 (01:07:44–01:07:45)
Anyone in person?
Speaker 14 (01:07:49–01:12:08)
Joe Curran, Precinct 7. So, I appreciate everything that the Warrant Committee has done, and in watching the presentation, I'll call it, I would prefer to focus on the details of what the purchase is, and although I understand we want to have what I'll call totem pole hearsay about What would happen if the town didn't buy it? I don't think that's really part of this conversation, because the town is either going to buy the property or not. And again, in watching the presentation, it almost seems like we want to do almost the reverse of the state land for homes.
proposal that the governor is doing where they're taking excess land and selling it off and developing homes. And what I'm hearing from this presentation is maybe the town is going to buy the land and then develop it as homes. So we are going to somehow buy the land, then somehow sell it back to someone else to do some other use with it. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me.
and I would rather think that the presentation should focus on the purchase of the property and What the town I don't want to say what the town's gonna do with it to what you're saying We're either gonna build a school or we're gonna do something else I don't know what that something else could be it could be another dog shelter as far as I know but but I think that that's what the presentation should focus on and a lot of these town meetings we go to, everyone talks about how they're too long, the presentations take forever, people talk, and I think that we should focus on the facts and take out the stuff that's not a fact to this particular project, which is what somebody else is going to do to it, I don't think is part of what we're kind of focusing on. And then one of the other things, and I'm sure I'm wrong about this, but in all of these school presentations that I've attended over the last few years, it's been my understanding that the new school on Guile Road that we've been talking about, the staff is existing. We weren't going to need to add staff. That was one of the selling points of the school is that we have the people in town now.
And when we built the school, we wouldn't need any new personnel because we would have existing personnel transferred there. So maybe the superintendent can talk a little bit about that. I think it's a fabulous idea to move the school department out of wherever they are now. And for those of us who have been in town a long time, I think the school department sadly has moved more times than I can count.
The first time being actually on land that was now part of the cemetery, right? And that's where I remember it from a long time ago. And in talking to my neighbors, some of them are concerned about actually the density of placing another school on the Guile Road property. and that it's already hard enough to get in and out of the property, and to add another school to it is only going to make it that much more complicated for them, especially people with young kids who are more apt to be dropping their kids off and wanting to drive and then drive to work.
A lot of my neighbors actually drop their kids off and then drive over to Fairmont and go downtown for the day. So I don't know if anybody has reached out or thought about that particularly. And then when we get into the… The building costs, and again, I'm very confused.
I think what I heard Mr. Milano describe is that whatever school option we go forward with, we're going to have an ECC sometime next spring. And then the following year, we're going to have a TPC, which would be the total project cost. And I don't think for the whatever options we have now, we've ever seen a total project cost.
I think we've only seen the ECCs developed by our consultants. And I think it's important to understand that that estimated construction cost is going to be some value, but that the total project cost potentially will be more as the new or current superintendent develop what the resources are around FF&E and other school items that aren't part of the construction cost.
Speaker 7 (01:12:11–01:13:57)
So, hello, how are you, Joe? John Phelan, interim superintendent. The operation costs will, having done this in my previous district where we did build a seven through 12 school and had to move staff from a middle school setting up to that new setting, did result in some operational costs. So there will be some operational costs in either program.
Not a lot, but some. There seems to be, and we will do a better job digging into this as we progress and if we do purchase the building and we are moving forward around what those actual operating costs will be. But to a comment earlier, the preschool in the K is more self-sustaining right now. They have their own program.
They have their own director, they have their own support services in place, and all of those folks would travel and be more of a separate unit. They could actually be kind of pulled away and put into a space without much operation cost. We don't offer world language or pre-KK. There's certain other services that we don't provide in the same level as we would in 7th and 8th grade.
So it would be a little different from an operational cost system, but we will provide the town that kind of detail because people should know what and if there'll be more expense on either program or either site. So we will provide that. But there will be, I don't know what was said in 2023, but I can tell you that having experience in this just three years ago, there will be some, not a lot, but there will be some. You might need to add a nurse.
You might need to add some administrative support. There are certain positions that can't travel from one building to the next in time to make sure they can address the needs. So we'll evaluate that and we'll provide that information when we go farther down the pathway.
Speaker 4 (01:13:59–01:14:04)
I can address a couple of other things that you mentioned.
Speaker 3 (01:14:04–01:15:50)
One, you asked about, are we discussing buying this land to then sell it to create housing? I believe that probably Mr. Daly's presentation and I both discussed in the universe of things that could possibly happen after we buy this land, one option is we could sell it. That's certainly not plan A.
I don't think it's plan B or plan C. So when you asked, are we planning to buy this to then sell it to have a lot of housing go there, that's, I don't think, on the list of considerations. You asked, Why are we looking at what'll happen to it if we don't buy it? I'm looking at, you know, the article in front of us says, do we buy it or not?
I thought it was prudent to look at both. If we buy it, what happens? If we don't buy it, what happens? It's zoned a certain way right now.
So there's a sort of narrow path of things that could happen under current zoning if we don't buy it. And I thought it was prudent to address that. And why I thought it was prudent to address that also gets to my point of, Are the presentations too long? Is it off topic?
I am 100% guilty of having presentations that are too long, but that's intentional, and I'll tell you why. Because if I don't cover something that I think town meeting members are likely to get up and ask, such as, what will be built here if we don't buy it? then town meeting goes even longer. So my view is if I'm talking for an extra five minutes, and if that can prevent 30 minutes worth of questions and discussing from town meeting, that's a good investment of time.
So yes, I'm putting a little bit extra into not only this presentation, but all the other articles too, in hopes that I'll answer questions and we'll get through things quickly. I'm not going to get it perfect, but that's my goal.
Speaker 4 (01:15:52–01:16:41)
And just on the construction cost question total project budget question so that the $85 million number that has been used in relation to a potential project that library is assuming $65 million construction costs and an additional 20. about a 30% adder for soft costs. So that $85 million is treated as obviously a very early kind of rough estimate, but it is meant to incorporate the soft costs, architectural fees, the project management expenses, and likewise for the middle school project, which had a construction cost number, but also an adder, again, a 30% adder for those potential soft costs, which we'll have a better idea of down the road, but we have been trying to incorporate that now To be clear, we are thinking in those total project budget terms, not just in the construction cost term.
Speaker 14 (01:16:46–01:17:00)
Okay. I guess I would hope that maybe some of the accessory uses for a property that if it doesn't get owned by us get I don't know, reduced a little bit in the conversation. I just thought it was a little off topic, that's all.
Speaker 3 (01:17:00–01:17:09)
Thank you for that feedback. Thank you. We do have another hand online, Ms. Bradley?
Yeah, we do. I'm not calling on her, because I'm not running the meeting. Just informing you.
Speaker 1 (01:17:11–01:17:12)
Ms. Bradley, can you hear us?
Speaker 8 (01:17:13–01:17:14)
I can hear you. Can you guys hear me?
Speaker 1 (01:17:15–01:17:15)
Yes.
Speaker 8 (01:17:16–01:18:18)
Hi, Erin Bradley, town meeting member, precinct 4A. 28 Lincoln Street here in our lovely Milton, Massachusetts. I am just wanting to say a couple things real quick. One, I'm strongly in favor of us purchasing LaBarre.
I think it's a good investment for the town. I think that it will allow us to have control over what ends up going there. I can't tell you how many people have complained about 40Bs, myself included, and how they've ended up and are ruining our town. So I think that if the town has the control over LaBarre, we can then move on to whatever the next step is.
I just wanted to clarify though, if the town chose to, we could technically have a pre, if the town chose, we could do a preschool, center, K, community center at LaBarre, and then we could also still do the school building, right? There's nothing in this that says we can't do both if we wanted to, correct?
Speaker 1 (01:18:21–01:18:25)
Technically, we could present that option to the town, yes.
Speaker 8 (01:18:25–01:20:33)
Okay, I'm just making sure that that is like, I'm not saying I want to do that either, but I think that I think what we're looking at this too narrowly almost where we need to make sure that we are doing what's right for our town one we need a better community center for the folks over here on the west side of town as some people call it. I think you know we really do need more of a meeting space. I love the library but it gets booked up very quickly and we really don't have other spaces that community groups can can utilize. So I just want us to think about that and think about that in terms of using it and putting something in with a school.
Because schools are only used for part of the year. They're not used for the full year. So we want to make sure that whatever we are putting into the town actually is usable all 12 months of the year and the community gets something out of it. I just don't want us to lose the thread of maybe two centers might be what we need.
I don't know. I'm just saying maybe it is. But the bottom line on this article is that if we don't buy it, And somebody else buys a developer buys it and puts in a giant 40 B. I can only tell you all the people from precinct 7 precinct 6 who's going to be apoplectic that another 40 B is going into that area.
So I just really need everybody to think about that as we start taking the votes next week. The other piece that I heard a minute ago about the timing of our town meetings Yep, they go long But I trust in our madam moderator to make sure that she is setting the pace for what needs to happen That's not a warrant committee job. That's not a select board job That is on her to set the pace and to set the the cadence for what's about to happen for our meeting So I just want everybody to stay in their lanes as well because we do have folks that are in charge that can shepherd the meeting along a little bit quicker if we all just respect her wishes during our meeting. So those are my little points for tonight.
Thank you for having this and I can't wait to see everybody next week.
Speaker 1 (01:20:35–01:20:35)
Thank you.
Speaker 3 (01:20:38–01:20:51)
This may be a bit off topic, but it seems to follow up on what Ms. Bradley just said. If anyone has amendments to present, today's, what's today, Wednesday? Would you like to address that, Madam Moderator?
Speaker 15 (01:20:51–01:21:25)
Sure, it's Wednesday. Thank you. So, you can see, Liz Dillon, town moderator. You can see that I've requested that people submit any amendments by 3 p.m.
on Thursday, which is tomorrow, October 15th. In addition, if you are not a town meeting member and would like to speak at town meeting, you're supposed to request that in advance. And if you have any presentations that you would like to provide, I've already heard from some people, which I appreciate, but please let me know again by tomorrow at 3 p.m. Thank you.
Speaker 6 (01:21:30–01:21:32)
Megan Walsh, town meeting member.
Speaker 1 (01:21:32–01:21:33)
Get a little closer to it.
Speaker 6 (01:21:33–01:21:33)
367.
Speaker 1 (01:21:33–01:21:35)
What? Pull a little closer to you.
Speaker 6 (01:21:36–01:22:47)
Usually I don't have a problem with speaking too loud. Just as we go back and talking about the Cunningham addition, there's been very little publicity over what has taken place there. The additions, like the impact for the overall elementary schools for both Collicott and Cunningham, and having both of my children graduate from the amazing Cunningham Elementary School. I'm confused as to with we have four.
It's stated three additional classrooms, but it's publicized as four, and six office spaces, and then the updated library. So can you give us an understanding of the overall impact of that, and if the community is going to be provided some insight as to what took place, the impact of the overall elementary schools, both Colley-Cunningham that were very much in need of additional space.
Speaker 7 (01:22:48–01:23:57)
Sure, there was construction during the summer of 2025 to take the library that was in place and make it into the four classrooms in office space as you described. The work in the summer of 26 this past summer is when they took the attic of the Cunningham School and made it into the library. So both floors are now currently done and occupied by our students. The classroom space is being used by the Cunningham School.
I believe the fourth grade is up there. I was in there the other day in a classroom during a science lesson. It was unbelievable. And the office space is used both for offices for the adults, but also for small breakout space for students in those classrooms for reading support and intervention, math support and intervention, etc.
Both schools are accessing the full library as they had in the past. And the space is beautiful, well utilized. We are having the facilities subcommittee meeting there tomorrow if people want to go to that sub meeting in the library to see the space. And if there's a need to have an open house of sorts, we could do that.
But I know that Principal Redden had taken parents through that during the Cunningham open house this past month.
Speaker 6 (01:23:57–01:24:01)
So what has been the overall impact for the schools?
Speaker 7 (01:24:01–01:24:42)
So we have, for example, teachers not sharing spaces. We have two teachers in an office and working with students in small groups instead of, say, three or four. We have our preschool director sharing an office with only one person instead of two people. And we have some more breakout space for our preschool that's been in need of some breakout space for the types of students that they're working with at the age of three, four, So it's been helpful.
It certainly doesn't cure the overall elementary picture because we still have some continued crowding at the Cunningham and at the Collicott, at the Glover. The Tucker is in a little better shape, but it's fully utilized. It's not overcrowded at the moment.
Speaker 6 (01:24:42–01:29:36)
I just think it's very interesting and something that as a community we need to take into account because that was something that we've addressed for seven years and they kept telling us, nope, that space cannot be utilized. And it was pushed forward and now we have 10 additional spaces available. And I think that as a community, we really need to push forward with the other opportunities that may exist in our existing public schools, that there are spaces that could be, you know, Redone or Spaces that in the past I mean before they were saying that we couldn't use that space because the ladders couldn't reach that the level and that was a old rule and So now we have this beautiful space. I've walked through it.
It's gorgeous. It's I can't even believe it sat there for so long and And at one time, it was a cafeteria. So, you know, when we really delve into it, and I understand the overcrowding. I have two children.
They're now in high school. I've been addressing this since my kids were in kindergarten. But we really need to look at opportunities. I think Laboree is a fantastic opportunity for us to especially We've now seen the most the highest enrollments in the high school, which is fantastic It's built in high schools phenomenal and To you know move the central office out of the high school and utilize that space I think is very important for our high school students, especially as we addressing, you know science labs we need updated facilities there, but I really think that we haven't taken into account additional opportunities that exist.
And if we could have Labor Day and move our pre-K, because we saw a lot of additional issues that resulted from moving our pre-K into the Caldecott-Cunningham environment and Tucker, which didn't exist before. And to me, that seemed kind of crazy as we're talking about space issues. We now, in the elementary school, we moved our pre-K into the elementary school. It seemed to be counterproductive.
But I'm totally for LaBarre, but I Previous caller miss Bradley. I don't like the idea of entertaining both. I think that is Complete nonsense. So if we can you utilize that space for central office pre KK I'm all for that.
But I think we need to be very transparent as to what the the true goal is and I I'm not confident that you know we have one one specific goal in place and that kind of the previous caller gave me a little angst. So I think we need to be very transparent and have conversations about available space issues. What's readily available and if we do purchase Laboret. What will be utilized for the schools.
So I'll just play moderator tonight and just keep our town meeting rules about responding to other members It just brought up It's it's definitely an issue if that's brought up by Other town meeting members as a town meeting member if somebody brings it up. I think that's something that is very concerning to all town meeting members and if we're going to vote on something We need transparency on what the direction is. And I understand it's difficult because we have time constraints. That's why I asked why we would have to vote in December as opposed to giving an extended time frame.
But. We have opportunities which was proven in Cunningham and that was something that was resisted for a long time and we made it happen. It's awesome. I encourage everyone and I hope that the town would provide some opportunities for people to view it.
and provide some information as to what was done, the impact to the community, the impact to the schools, we've heard nothing. And that's concerning and very disheartening. Thank you.
Speaker 7 (01:29:37–01:29:56)
Only want to say Megan that we will, I hear your feedback related to celebrating the Cunningham library being done over and then with the square footage in the classroom space that we gained. I believe that was brought up at a school community meeting last year, but it certainly wasn't something that was probably well broadcasted across the community. So we can provide that data.
Speaker 2 (01:30:03–01:30:04)
Ms. Rowland, can you hear us?
Speaker 16 (01:30:06–01:30:07)
Yes, I can.
Speaker 1 (01:30:07–01:30:07)
Go ahead.
Speaker 16 (01:30:09–01:30:11)
I guess in listening.
Speaker 1 (01:30:12–01:30:13)
Can you introduce yourself first, please?
Speaker 16 (01:30:13–01:31:23)
Oh, sure. Sorry. Janet Ferron, town meeting member, Precinct 271 Central Ave. From my understanding, you know, we've heard a lot of the school, this one, that one, the other thing.
I feel like the focus of the meeting that I'm hearing is that it's specifically regarding the Laborate property. And do we think the town should buy it or the town should not buy it? And what I'm hearing is there's provisions for studies to determine best use. So it just seems like we're getting ahead of ourselves in terms of needing to fully establish all the parameters of the school and the needs and that You know where we're more focused right now on the specific lab array and that we have the studies coming up That's it yeah, thank you, it's sort of what I said early on which is I
Speaker 3 (01:31:24–01:31:39)
Yes, on the one hand, we're focused only on this one question. Do we buy the property or not? On the other hand, if you're buying a property, it's silly to buy it without discussing what you're going to use it for. So good luck to Madam Moderator deciding what's in scope and what's not at the town meeting.
Speaker 1 (01:31:42–01:31:58)
And I think that's also part of the reason we wanted to have this meeting before, was this is such a potentially big acquisition that we need to have more opportunities to get folks to talk, not all in three nights at town meeting, so.
Speaker 2 (01:32:03–01:32:12)
Ms. Christensen, can you hear us? Hi, Cindy Christensen, Precinct 7.
Speaker 12 (01:32:12–01:34:53)
town meeting member, 59 Colomar Street. One of the previous speakers said we need more information, more transparency, a look at what we have, what we don't have. I agree with that. But you know what I want?
I want honesty. And I'm really upset that the town government sent an application to MSBA claiming that our as-built elementary school capacity was 1,900 students based on 87 as-built classrooms. The reason this bothers me is that there were 95 as-built classrooms, which would have, of course, boost up that number 1,900 that we keep seeing as the capacity for the elementary schools. Now I learned tonight that there's actually four new elementary school classrooms in the Cunningham Collicott area.
So we've got those four. We've got three computer rooms. So we're up to, if we add the 95 as-built classrooms and seven more that we've gained in the last few years, we have 102 classrooms for elementary school. As I said last time, our current enrollment pre-K to fifth grade, 2,221.
That's about less than 22 per classroom that we have. We also have the projections from MSBA. And for the next five years, they project less than 2,200 in our elementary schools. So I just, I want some truthful numbers, some factual numbers.
I think that we've been misled with misinformation that we just can't seem to address. So I really am bothered by this. I believe that we've been misled with misinformation and given the amount of effort that some of us have given to trying to make this point, I believe it's gone to a strategy to just delay our concerns, deflect them to somebody else, to just not address them, and to trudge forward with the misinformation, because they know that with misinformation, they can convince town meeting members and voters. That's all.
Speaker 1 (01:34:56–01:36:07)
Ms. Christensen, I cannot speak to the numbers that were sent, I don't think many of us can, that were sent years ago. What I will say is we are still in the process with MSBA and over the next 8 to 12 months we will be receiving all the information. The state will be here studying, going into our schools, looking at the potential.
not only at LaBarre if we do purchase, but also at Guile, and then all of that information will be made public. So that information will be available to those in the town. I understand you've been in contact with the School Building Committee, and I believe you are being, you are having meetings with them as well. So you are not going unheard, but I will say that the state would not have assessed us or provided us with the funding.
if they did not think that we had an overcrowding issue, as well as we will be receiving the state's assessment before we go into build and design, and that will be coming online in the next year or so. So, thank you. I understand your concerns, and I know you've been working at this a long time, but you are not going unheard, but thank you.
Speaker 2 (01:36:07–01:36:11)
If there's anyone else in person, there's no one online.
Speaker 1 (01:36:17–01:36:26)
Okay, I don't have to get a motion to adjourn or anything. I think we will close and I will see you all at town meeting next week. Thank you all.