Board: Climate Action Planning Committee

Date: 2025-10-16


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:23–00:24)

Good evening, everyone.

Speaker 2 (00:25–01:01)

I would like to call the October meeting of the Climate Action Planning Committee to order. It is 6.06 p.m. on October 16th, and I'd just like to say all this stuff out loud so that my AI tools can spread everything for me with less effort. I'd also like to do a quick roll call of The committee members present.

So I'm Chair Alex Sasha, I'm present. Ron is present.

Speaker 3 (01:02–01:10)

Also in the room, we have Kai Miller, Energy Manager of Milton and not a committee member.

Speaker 2 (01:11–01:16)

And then on Zoom, you can declare yourselves.

Speaker 4 (01:18–01:19)

Steve Popkin, committee member.

Speaker 5 (01:22–01:24)

Isle Johnson, committee member.

Speaker 6 (01:29–01:37)

Maggie Oakfield, committee member. Anna Morgan-Barsamian, non-voting member.

Speaker 2 (01:37–03:15)

OK, and Kim Johnson is present, but can't get her audio to work at the moment. Wonderful. Good to see you all. I'm tempted to cross the room to press that okay button.

I can't stare at that for an hour and a half. All right. So a quick housekeeping item. The first item on the agenda is to vote to approve our meeting minutes from the September 11th meeting.

And a point of order, I don't know Maggie, I know you tend to abstain for approving minutes when you were not present, but we have a bear quorum here. Does anybody know if we can approve meeting minutes if Maggie abstains? I have no idea.

Speaker 4 (03:20–03:28)

Why wouldn't you be able to? Because you could have a number of people abstain and still have a quorum for running the meeting.

Speaker 2 (03:28–04:26)

You need a majority to vote yes for something to go through. I'm not going to worry about it. Let's approve the minutes, and then I will find out offline when I'm much more intelligent. if the vote was valid, and if we have to redo it some other time, we can redo it some other time.

So did anybody, did everybody have a chance to review the minutes? And are there any corrections or additions? Okay, so seeing no discussion, I want to entertain a motion to approve the minutes. I move that we approve the minutes.

Okay, Ron Israel has moved to approve the minutes. Do I have a second? Second. Kyle Johnson seconds.

Roll call vote. So Steve Popkin.

Speaker 4 (04:27–04:27)

Approve.

Speaker 2 (04:30–04:30)

Maggie.

Speaker 6 (04:31–04:31)

Aye.

Speaker 2 (04:33–04:37)

Kim. Approve. Kyle.

Speaker 1 (04:38–04:39)

Approve.

Speaker 2 (04:40–05:05)

Alex approves. So we probably approve. Wonderful. Okay, now we can, a little more relaxed.

We have mostly discussion items on the agenda this evening. And next up is an update from our energy manager, Tyne. You take the floor.

Speaker 3 (05:06–08:25)

So as you know, Milton is green community, and I'm in the process of completing the annual report for the Green Community Program, which is one part of being compliant with the Green Community Program, which is a requirement to, at some point, apply for climate leader certification. Yeah, it's interesting digging through the town's utility accounts. and you learn about different stuff. And then separately, we're also working on submitting so-called expressions of interest forms, which are not grant applications, but a step before that for several projects to get funding from the state And the project I'm working on right now for an EOI, expression of interest, is a solar and battery storage project.

It's probably going to be at a school, but that's not certain yet. At Collicott Cunningham, it's the current contender. Yeah. We, Alex and I spoke about Sustainable Milton submitting a separate EOI for an improvement and public engagement process around the Climate Action Plan.

What is being a green community? So being a green community It consists of five criteria being compliant with five criteria. And it's a program from the late 2000s. So Milton has been a green community for over a decade now.

Milton actually is one of the few communities in all of Massachusetts that have received over $1 million cumulatively in green community funds, which is why Milton is now eligible to only smaller grants. but the five criteria are having submitted an energy reduction plan, plan to reduce your energy by 20%, having a fuel efficient vehicle policy in place, having designated a zone or having created zoning regulations allowing for renewable energy facilities, and making sure that the permitting process for that takes less than a year. Those are four criteria. And the fifth criteria, I can't think of off the top of my head.

Speaker 2 (08:26–08:34)

Is it the adopting this specialized building code or the stretch code? I'm sorry.

Speaker 3 (08:34–08:41)

That wasn't… That is part of it, yes. The specialized stretch code is the fifth one. Correct.

Speaker 2 (08:41–08:50)

So the stretch code was the community's requirement, and the specialized opt-in building code, which we did last year, is finally your community's requirement.

Speaker 7 (08:50–08:55)

And just out of curiosity, what are we using the million dollars for?

Speaker 3 (08:59–09:47)

Bill Ritchie. I had the pleasure of meeting Bill Ritchie recently. He was the de facto energy person at Milton for a long time, and he gave me this very helpful list of all the projects. I can't say for certain because I only glanced.

I didn't take a good look at the document yet, but from what I read skimming the document, it was using the money for stuff like HVAC. um, heating, ventilation, air conditioning improvements in various buildings, weatherization improvements in various buildings. Um, those are the ones I remember from glancing at the documents.

Speaker 2 (09:48–10:25)

Yeah, I happened to cross the list. Oh, I know. But, uh, actually, we're fine with the place. I thought it said it was, um, I guess this is the second floor, right?

Yeah. I found a list of past grants. Today, I was looking for something else, and now I can't find it again, but I can probably find and share it with you. Kai's characterization was accurate qualitatively.

Speaker 3 (10:26–10:32)

Any questions from the in-person or virtual audience on this? Any more questions?

Speaker 2 (10:34–10:56)

I was curious, I know that the facilities department is planning to look into the sort of remaining lifespan and replacement timelines and cost options for the school HVAC systems this year. Is that something that has entered your backlog or been discussed at all?

Speaker 3 (10:57–10:57)

Not yet.

Speaker 2 (10:58–10:58)

Okay.

Speaker 3 (11:00–11:15)

Do you have a regular meeting with the facilities director Um, not, not a regular one yet, but I've met him three times now. Yeah. So we, we have been meeting Tom, Tom McCarthy.

Speaker 5 (11:18–11:38)

Just a quick question, if the expression of interest slash grant application for the solar and battery, is that part of the proposal that's been discussed previously about an emergency power for the town through that system or through for government buildings as like a shelter, emergency shelter usage?

Speaker 3 (11:40–12:21)

That's a possibility, but that's not a certainty yet. I should say that I've been with the town for only a bit over a month now, and I understand that the official designation as an emergency shelter carries, I think, a lot of weight. So yeah, it would enhance the grant application, but I'm not sure. I haven't read in too much about what different emergency shelters there are in place already and whether whether the school would be the best place for that.

Speaker 2 (12:22–12:33)

What department has looked at this issue of emergency shelters in the past? I didn't know that there was an official designation, so that's nice to learn.

Speaker 3 (12:33–13:07)

Yeah. So six years ago, Milton went through something called the Municipal Vulnerability Preparedness Process. the MVP process. And one location I remember reading in the MVP plan that was a Red Cross certified or designated emergency plan was the Brooks Fieldhouse, which I tried finding in Google Maps and I could not find it.

Speaker 2 (13:09–13:17)

I think that's the high school, like the gym part of the high school. Well, we're basically nine votes.

Speaker 3 (13:19–13:24)

Is that OK? Is it called the Brooks Field House?

Speaker 2 (13:24–13:28)

I think so. I think now Maggie's saying no. I don't know.

Speaker 6 (13:29–13:35)

The field is the football field. And then the actual gym is called the Copeland Field House.

Speaker 3 (13:36–14:42)

That's right. Yeah. I think this MVP document, the MVP plan, which is publicly accessible. If you type in MVP, Municipal Vulnerability Preparedness Plan, you'll probably find it pretty easily.

It was done in a workshop style. And so I think much of it was based on what people said. So the precision in that document is not as high as in a different document, which has lots of overlap with the MVP plan. And that other document, which is also five to six years old, is called the Hazard Mitigation Plan for Milton, which you can also find.

Yeah. But it's only in the MVP plan, I believe, that I saw that the Brooks Fieldhouse was viewed as the best emergency shelter. But I should say, I did not confirm this information with my colleagues. We're all learning here.

Speaker 8 (14:43–14:55)

Alec was asking about the expected lifespan of HVAC systems in the school. Have you looked at that for the town hall?

Speaker 3 (14:57–16:14)

No, but I should say that Eversource, as our electric utility, they offer a free study from what I understand called the Portfolio Prioritization Plan. And that's something I have in my to-do list to move forward. And once I submit to Eversource a spreadsheet with all the buildings, they can determine next steps and find a vendor to take a look at all the buildings of Milton and Um. Review assess the quality of the building envelope and energy efficiency generally.

And then. Provide recommendations on which buildings to prioritize. For upgrades, and it is not an in depth study of each building. It would be more of a bird's eye view of the building better answer in a couple of months, maybe half a year once we have that completed.

Speaker 2 (16:14–16:33)

That sounds like it would have a lot of overlap with the building decarbonization roadmap study. I'm not saying it would be identical, but just redundant in parts at least.

Speaker 8 (16:33–16:56)

Could be, yeah. Mentioning Eversource. Eversource put a district geothermal system in Framingham as a pilot. And it'd be nice if we were able to interest them in doing the same thing in Milton.

Yeah.

Speaker 3 (16:57–17:47)

Yeah. I'm a big fan of geothermal. I'm not sure what the current thinking is among utilities. on geothermal.

I know that National Grid, they had big plans for a pilot project in Lawrence-Hurt Lowell. And there was some, they, after lots of studying, they realized it wasn't feasible at the cost they were aiming for. And so now they're doing it, now National Grid is doing it at Franklin Field in collaboration with Boston Housing Authority. Those are the only two Um, network to thermal.

Bigger projects. I know of in Massachusetts going on right now. Correct.

Speaker 2 (17:51–21:55)

Any more comments or questions for time. Great. Well, thank you. Kind of good to have you here.

Please feel free to chime in with the rest of the discussion. Um, some of which we're gonna circle back to the eco one-stop grant opportunities after this next topic. So next agenda item is to discuss the upcoming article four voting special town meeting. So let me share my screen here.

So for those joining us for the first time, or if you want to watch the recordings of our last few meetings, over the last few months, this committee has been developing this article to bring to the town meeting that starts October 27th that will establish Climate goals in Milton aligned with the state's legally binding greenhouse gas emission reduction targets. Sorry, I'm trying to, that's not gonna work. Okay, so now the article's finalized, it's been added to the warrant. And the WAR Committee voted to recommend that the town meeting approve the article.

In our last meetings, we've removed some of the extra language that provided context from the body of the article itself, and that's been added back in, at least in part. in the Board Committee's report recommending adoption of the article. And what I wanted to use this time with you all for is to discuss what, if anything, that we should be doing between now and town meeting to set this article up for success. Any support or concerns that you've heard in the community regarding this?

I can tell you that I have worked with Sustainable Milton to develop a webpage with some more detailed context on where this article came from and our rationale for bringing it forward and why we think it's fit for the town. I have a one-page flyer that put together with help from a really talented graphic designer, a burgeoning graphic designer of high school that I've been distributing on social media and in person. And I have a date to speak to community team at Fuller Village Friday of next week. It's probably probably other things I or we could be doing, but that's my update.

Any comments?

Speaker 7 (21:59–22:01)

You make a presentation at the town meeting?

Speaker 2 (22:02–22:44)

Yes, my expectation is that the chair of the committee that sponsored this article. I will go speak for 10 minutes to make the case for it. And I also plan to have that flyer available on the table as timely members enter. So it's got a QR code so they can get from the flyer to the web page and ask for information.

And I've reached out to the moderator about distributing those materials in advance by email, possibly. I have not heard back yet. Which would be to town meeting members, I assume. To town meeting members, yeah.

Speaker 7 (22:45–22:47)

Is it a majority vote in the town meeting?

Speaker 2 (22:48–23:31)

Yeah, it passes by a majority vote of town meeting members. And it's a non-binding advisory resolution. So I think it expresses the will of the town. It leaves town staff and leaders sort of full flexibility to figure out how to work towards the goals.

And it does satisfy a requirement for, we have a few remaining requirements for climate leader community certification. It would satisfy one of them. I'm getting the flyer up on the screen here.

Speaker 4 (23:33–24:01)

Alex, are you aware of any particular sentiment among the town meeting members, or have you reached out to anyone that have greater influence in how those votes go?

Speaker 2 (24:02–25:41)

We worked with the Warren Committee on this one to try to really make this one pretty palatable. I think the experience, my experience doing this last year with the building code, there were much clearer arguments against that needed to be, that we anticipated and needed to have a response to. I think because we position this as non-binding and because it therefore has no sort of concrete cost implications that are locked in just by passing this article. And it moves us towards eligibility for significant new resources for the town.

It passed the work committee with almost complete support, a couple of abstentions and one vote against, but there was no negative, there were no points against that were brought up in that discussion, nor by urting my attempts to engage the town on social media or in person. So on the one hand, I feel like This is on a good path, and I'm anticipating it to pass easily. On the other hand, I'm kind of a risk-averse pessimist, and I'm worried about being surprised by something I hadn't anticipated.

Speaker 8 (25:41–25:47)

Have you taken this article to the select board since the initial discussion with them about an article?

Speaker 2 (25:47–26:10)

I mean, both times we voted on it, it went back to the Select Board for them to put it on the warrant. There was no material that was national that would feed that. So basically, you get the support of the Select Board and the Warrant Committee. The Select Board encouraged us to bring this article forward, and then they put it on the warrant.

We can't put an article on the warrant ourselves.

Speaker 6 (26:14–28:00)

So if I don't, can I speak? My only concern about the article, and it's a major concern, I think it's gonna pass town meeting, but I don't know if it was brought up anywhere, but town meeting cannot compel another board to do something. So back like in 2022, you may recall when there was an article before town meeting about Algerian Corner, Um, they wanted, uh, there was a citizen's petition that wanted, um, to compel the select board to do something in town council ruled, you know, and said that for like the, for over a hundred years, um, there's been a law that a legislative body cannot compel the executive branch to act. Um, And it came up more recently when somebody put forth to town meeting to compel the planning board to pass MBTA zoning.

And town council got up and said the same thing, that one body cannot compel an elected body to do something. So that's the only, I don't know if this article has any teeth to it. It's just sort of an article that I think it will pass, even though there's nothing that they, it doesn't really hold any value in my face.

Speaker 2 (28:01–31:08)

So let me respond to that in two, two parts. So this, this came up in the work committee discussion to what extent can Can an article like this compel or direct a elected board to do anything? And basically came to the same conclusion that you just mentioned. And so one of the rewordings was to ditch the word direct throughout and we used the word authorize.

So yes, it is not my name, as I said before. I would, and I know that I've heard many times that in Milton there's kind of a norm against passing symbolic resolutions at town meeting. Certainly nothing legal says you can't do that and many other communities past non-binding resolutions over the last five years, declaring a climate emergency or adopting climate goals. So there's plenty of precedent for this.

And I think to say it has no value is I think a little too strong because strategic clarity and expression of the approval of residents through their elected town meeting representatives does matter to town leaders and town staff who, just from my experience working with town staff over the last few years, there's a lot of things that are within their discretion day-to-day. But I think an appropriate caution about using that discretion to do something that they would consider controversial. So I think having a clear expression of support from town meeting will clarify those sort of discretionary decisions or town staff, but anything that is sort of financially material enough that it would need to come to town meeting still needs to come to town meeting. So we're not pre-committed to the big future investments, which I think would make this a much harder discussion and not where I wanted to start us off.

Does that make sense?

Speaker 6 (31:13–31:33)

Yeah, I mean, I think select board probably already has the right, has a right to do these things. So I don't think they necessarily need town meeting support, but where you're coming from for it, but I think they already have the right to do it. Yeah.

Speaker 2 (31:35–32:43)

I think that's true. So very, very tangibly passing this, I think, just validates the hard work this committee's been doing. The town still wants it. I personally want to know that.

And it does check a box towards qualifying for climate leader communities. One of the eligibility criteria is to make a municipal decarbonization commitment to eliminate onsite fossil fuel used by 2015, which sounds stronger than this to me, but the agency that validates whether a town has met these eligibility criteria is the Department of Energy Resources, DOER. So I've been in touch with our liaison there who verified that this article language will satisfy that. that requirement.

Speaker 8 (32:48–33:50)

Well, I know just getting, I guess, to the point of what is the value of this article? I think very simply stated, it simply aligns the town with the state's legislative goals regarding climate change. I can imagine maybe a town meeting member who's, no, doesn't believe in climate change or is reluctant to commit any resources towards climate change. My question, the 30% reduction target by 2030, and if someone was to ask, well, how would you measure that?

And is that achievable for the town? That might be a hard question to answer.

Speaker 2 (33:51–34:37)

That's a question that came up at the Warren Committee as well. So yeah, the town's, the state goal is a 50% reduction for 1990 levels, but we are doing 30. That's a 50%. And emissions have come down from 1990 levels already.

So I think it was something like 38%. We have to estimate these things for Milton because we have a greenhouse gas inventory from 2017 and 2022. So using 2017 as a baseline year and assuming that Milton's emission reductions sort of track the states between 1990 and 2017, you get something like a 38% reduction.

Speaker 8 (34:37–34:41)

But this would only apply to the town's emissions, right?

Speaker 2 (34:41–35:31)

Versus the whole, I mean, the municipal emissions versus the- So backing up to that, it's in the article language that we'll measure progress with the greenhouse gas inventory no less than once every five years. So we have a 2017 inventory, a 2022 inventory. we would probably follow with a 2027 inventory from Chippen's Pass. And Greenhouse Gas Inventory, let me stop sharing while I pull up the draft presentation I'm working on here.

And what things on that computer.

Speaker 4 (35:46–35:47)

Okay.

Speaker 8 (36:06–36:42)

I can see one point of confusion. The climate leadership community designation applies only to the municipal buildings facilities, correct? Also vehicle. And vehicles, yeah.

Yeah, it's a municipal. Whereas this article, I guess, would apply to the whole town? Am I reading that correctly? The goals apply to town-wide emissions.

Speaker 2 (36:47–36:55)

who can touch the end of the hearts. Let me get that. What am I calling Zoom here?

Speaker 4 (37:01–37:01)

Okay.

Speaker 2 (37:12–39:27)

So in 27, The 2017 and 2022 inventories were completed by the consultants that we were working with when we first formed in 2023. That was funded by a community compact grant of $50,000. And that wasn't the entire scope of the grant, but within that grant, they did greenhouse gas inventories for two years. is a standardized process.

So the greenhouse gas protocol is the accepted standard for accounting for emissions based on data sources like utility bills, fuel purchase records, et cetera. So it's a data gathering exercise that gets fed into standardized spreadsheet and analysis tools to produce overall greenhouse gas emissions numbers to measure tons of carbon dioxide equivalent, which is a way of, you know, there are many greenhouse gases, but some are more potent than others. And we calculate all those different gas emissions and then sort of normalize them, the impact of carbon dioxide. So the future greenhouse gas inventories could either be done, we could get another consultant then who has experience doing greenhouse gas inventories or the I personally used to work for a carbon accounting startup, so I have some familiarity with the greenhouse gas protocol, and I bet we could hack one together internally in a resource-constrained situation.

Speaker 7 (39:27–39:41)

There was a global emissions study that was resolved at least today that said the emissions globally.

Speaker 2 (39:42–43:18)

Right, so there are national greenhouse gas inventory standards that were developed by the IPCC. And the greenhouse gas protocols was developed from those national inventories standards, but with the sort of reframed for companies and municipalities and some other kinds of entities. So that they're related to the include a lot of the standardized techniques for estimating emissions that were developed at the IP system. So you said, people will wonder like, is 2030 realistic?

Yes. I think that's a non sequitur, but we certainly need to be prepared to answer that question. Why is it a non sequitur? So even, and this, I'll tell the story, in my presentation, but the nature of Massachusetts legally binding emission reduction goals is that it directs state agencies to do things like make plans and monitor progress.

And if, and in my opinion, when they missed the 2030 target to hold themselves accountable and make plans to address the deficiency. And so basically there's no fines. Nobody's going to jail when Massachusetts doesn't hit that 20% target. And I wouldn't be surprised if at some point they get adjusted to make them achievable again.

And so the wording of our article is to adopt goals aligned with the state's goals. My expectation is that if the state's goals change, then so will middle sense. I would love to see the world hit these goals on time. I'm increasingly pessimistic about it personally.

But I think that nonetheless, the value of having goals is significant. My corporate life, I remember working on a sort of big, hairy project that my team leaders were calling the October Challenge. We started the project in June, and we were going to get something done by October. And we did.

We got it done by October of the following year. And everybody was, you know, chortling that we did it. We finished the October Challenge by October. Nobody said which October.

And so it has value as a motivation. If we just said, we'd like to do this, but we're not gonna make any commitments as to when, then things just sort of drag along as a nice to have forever. If you put a deadline on it, even if you end up having to move that deadline back, I think it motivates progress much more effectively. And that's, That's why I think symbolic resolutions, even if they don't have sort of concrete feet, there's still a lot better than doing nothing.

My answer there.

Speaker 6 (43:18–44:23)

Well, I focus on, you know, because this article, you know, you know, Take me for an example. I would, as a town meeting member, be like, oh, well, it doesn't really matter which way I vote on this. But it actually does, to your point, because it does check boxes that lead us to further down the road. So even though it could be symbolic, and I think you need to reassure people and convince people that it's more than just symbolic, even though the select board as of today could do all this because they have the right to do it.

We need it for X, Y, and Z reasons. You need to convince me why it's important when legislatively it's not really important. Do you understand what I'm saying?

Speaker 8 (44:23–44:53)

Yeah, Alex, I, you know, instead of saying it's a non sequitur, I think I would state it as an aspirational goal for the state, and also for the town, but not a hard commitment that will get there. You know, just to try to dispel people's anxiety that would suddenly trigger all types of, you know, expensive expenditures that No, we might not be able to afford as a community.

Speaker 2 (44:56–46:39)

Yeah, I don't understand where the, I mean, Maggie, you're far from the only person I've heard this from, this idea that if something's symbolic, it's pointless. We spend a lot of time as a culture fretting over symbolic actions. And I think they do influence behavior, which is ultimately what we're trying to do here. So I think it makes a huge difference.

If a strong majority of town meeting rejected this article, I don't know, would that impact how you did your job? Yeah, that's a leading question for you. Well, I'd be terribly discouraged. It wouldn't make a difference, right?

So and I think likewise, if a strong majority of town meeting approves this, it's the message I would receive is yes, people do think that doing something about climate change is important. It's not. a blank check to spend bajillions of dollars without any kind of review, but we still need our existing processes for working through trade-offs and making wise investments as a talent. But strategically, this is an aspirational goal that there's majority support for.

Speaker 6 (46:42–47:34)

I mean, I think it's gonna pass town meeting, don't get me wrong. I think it's gonna pass, but it's not town meeting I'm worried about, it's more the general public that I would be worried about. I talked to a lot of people and everyone got the warrant last week. And that's they're saying, well, what is this all about?

If the select board already has the authority to do away, what's the point of why do we even need an article? You know, it's just another. You know, a lot of people don't like a lot of government. You know, but that's why I think it's important to say why it's needed.

It's to check a box, it'll allow us to apply for grants, you know, even though we don't have to do it, there's reasons to do it.

Speaker 2 (47:35–48:16)

Yeah, and that is the argument. Yeah. And the big picture, I hope that we'll be back at town meeting and electing boards with other sort of specific actionable recommendations on a regular basis over the coming years, but rather than trying to bundle it all together and shove it down the town's collective throats all at once, I think take things one easily understandable piece at a time and hopefully raise awareness that this is happening.

Speaker 8 (48:19–48:27)

It's also an opportunity to educate the town as to what the state's goal to do.

Speaker 2 (48:27–55:24)

Maggie, the fact that you're having these conversations with folks is in itself an opportunity, right? I think it gets us on the topics of discussion agenda, and we've got to take advantage of that. It is very, very challenging. I've been trying to do this for several years now.

How do you spread the word that something's being worked on that might impact people's lives and spread it widely enough so that people don't feel blindsided when it finally comes up for a vote or a decision has been made? I think we've structured this so that it's sort of another ping on people's radar that, oh, this kind of stuff is happening, and if I'm worried about it, I should pay attention, without it being something that I think might upset a lot of people. All right, it's 655, so I think, Unless there are objections, I would like to move us on to the next agenda item, which is the eco one-stop grant opportunities. So I sent an email out about this and Kai mentioned it in his report at the beginning.

So what this basically is, is that in the past, the Executive Office of Environmental Affairs had a number of distinct grant programs that all had their own distinct and uncoordinated application processes. So it's a bit mystifying for folks like us who don't do this for a living, to know that these grants exist, and to prepare to pull together a strong application. At the right time, we've missed tons of application deadlines. And now that we're, as a town, eligible for these again, The upcoming grant cycles, I think these applications will be due in January.

So these are for potential disbursement and project starts in spring of 2026. But what they're offering with this one-stop process is a unified intake process where we could submit expressions of interest aren't full grant applications, but they get you to sit down and sort of think through what is the project that you'd like to get funding for, you have in mind. And then staff at EEA will review those and schedule meetings with the applicants to advise them on which grant program is the best fit for the concept. what recommendations they would have about strengthening the application and so on, to sort of give you a sort of preview round, so that when it comes time to actually apply, you don't waste your energy doing something that doesn't have a good chance or, you know, with the benefit of some input and feedback before we would actually put it in the grant application.

There's a limit of four. um, expressions of interest per entity. Uh, that's just a function of EEA's bandwidth to, uh, to respond to all of these. Uh, and so I think because there were easily four, um, concepts that the town wanted to move forward with, um, and I also for a long time have felt that this, this committee needs some professional consulting support, um, to, I think, strengthen our recommendations, certainly.

I mean, I think there are areas where we have gaps in our expertise as a volunteer group, and certainly gaps in our bandwidth to continually refine the Climate Action Plan. But for me, the most important thing is robust stakeholder engagement and public engagement. I think we've certainly made efforts to engage the public on the development of the plan that I would not feel comfortable sort of trying to declare the draft we have today done with the amount of public engagement that we've done. And what I've observed in other towns that have worked with consultants to develop their climate action plan is that a big thing that consultants do is run like a robust public engagement process, hosting several public meetings, providing help with social media outreach, stuff like that.

And also engaging stakeholders and town staff in a more structured way than we've been able to so far. So I would love to get grant funding to support that because the town has already met its quota of four expressions of interest. I was planning on submitting that from Sustainable Milton because 501c3s are also eligible to submit expressions of interest. I'm not sure whether Sustainable Milton could actually submit the grant application, but there's no limit on the number of grant applications, so it needs to come from the town later on, I think, but we can still do that.

And Ron, did you want to? share anything? You were thinking about submitting one as well? Yeah, is there room to do that?

Sustainable Houston might be able to submit another one.

Speaker 7 (55:26–56:32)

Well, I just volunteered to submit one for the work that the conservation subgroup has been doing, including basically would be for R&D support to conduct a study of the impact of the tree stock in the Blue Hills on climate and the impact of the Nepotisip River Valley, Nepotisip River Valley's valley on how climate affects property along the banks of the Nepotisip River. Yeah, I was thinking of fashioning a proposal around those things. I haven't talked to Maggie yet about this, my co-leader on conservation group, but that's my thought, but I need to hear if we should go ahead.

Speaker 2 (56:36–57:11)

So I don't think I have bandwidth to help with it, but if you can pull something together, for me to look at before the deadline is October 28th. Correct. Next Tuesday. No, the Tuesday after next.

Yeah. It's a pretty short application. It's, I mean, like six or seven sort of substantive questions about the project. Many of them are limited to 150 words or less.

So really like big picture.

Speaker 7 (57:13–57:13)

Okay.

Speaker 2 (57:15–58:09)

And I think this EEA cooling corridors program includes, has been used for things like tree planting. Is there an evaluation criteria? So I mean, I think part of the idea of this is you don't really have to know if it's a good fit for one of these programs. You can submit the idea and then they'll tell you.

And if it's not a fit for any of these, That's the most efficient way to find out, I think, rather than you personally trying to read the criteria for these eight or nine grant programs. Yeah, my feeling is it's okay to make mistakes. Sorry. Who was that?

Speaker 6 (58:10–58:30)

That was just sorry. So I'm glad you pointed out that cooling corridors program. So has the town applied for that? Cause that seems to me in line with their tree planting, the shade tree committee.

Do you know why for that?

Speaker 7 (58:32–59:03)

I don't know. I've been in touch with the shady tree committee and they are I don't know if they've applied for that, but I do know they're in some kind of in-depth discussion with the town about getting increased allocation of funding for shade trees. And they feel pretty confident about that. But I don't know about that specific application.

I can ask them.

Speaker 6 (59:04–59:54)

Because if the town doesn't want to pursue law, if I heard you correctly, Alex, a nonprofit could. And I'm wondering if you recall for the Milton's 350th anniversary, there was a big push to fund the town with trees. And I think they raised quite a lot of money for it. So I'm wondering if the town has exceeded their four, Uh, the limit of four applications would like the Milton 350th or the Milton Garden Club.

Would they ever want to put in an application for this? If the town's not that particular.

Speaker 2 (59:56–01:00:48)

Yeah, I think that's the legwork that somebody has to do. I can't offer to do it, but I can offer the potential for a sustainable Milton to sponsor at least an expression of interest, right? So the expression of interest is a fairly casual expression of interest. And the applications will be more involved and will come later in January, I believe.

And the limit only applies to the expression of interest. So there's no, I guess, Once we get feedback on the expression of interest, we'll know more about what constraints apply to a full application. But I think we should absolutely look into that and more shape choices align with our mission here.

Speaker 8 (01:00:51–01:01:10)

Alex, I had asked you whether a sustainable militant might be interested in submitting not an application or request for feedback on a shared public-private geothermal field.

Speaker 2 (01:01:10–01:02:20)

I think I gave you the same answer I gave Ron, which is I don't have the bandwidth to write out the answers for the EOI form, but if you want to do that, look at it with you and run it by the Sustainable Loans Board. What do you think? I mean, do you think it's appropriate? I mean, why?

What I like about this expression of interest process is I feel like it's okay to submit something that ends up not being a good fit for any of these grant programs. they're trying to make it easier for people to access these grants by offering to give them feedback on their idea. And if their feedback is your idea is never going to fly with any of these, then we know that.

Speaker 3 (01:02:21–01:03:11)

I can speak a bit more to that because I looked at the potential for energy relevant projects more in depth. And I think out of all the listed grant projects, the MVP project, grant project, or MVP action grant, has the most overlap with energy resilience stuff. And what they say is that any expression of interest around an energy resilience project couldn't restrict itself only to a feasibility study, but it would have to aim for a feasibility study plus the actual implementation. So an alternative for a study might be the EEA planning assistance grant.

Speaker 2 (01:03:11–01:03:26)

Yeah, and those are the two grant programs that I've seen towns use traditionally to get climate action plan consultancy as well.

Speaker 8 (01:03:27–01:03:33)

Kyle, you're basically saying that this particular program is probably not a very good fit for that.

Speaker 3 (01:03:34–01:03:43)

If you wanted to see if it's worth it, I would look more into the EEA planning assistance grant category. Oh, well, yeah.

Speaker 2 (01:03:43–01:06:06)

Versus the one that's up on the screen. The nice thing is we don't have to decide up front which program we're applying to. We just say, this is what we'd like to advise us. And then we'll get some advice between to November 1st and December 31st.

Great. Okay, so any more comments or questions on that? Next topic is just a discussion of the decarbonization roadmap planning process. There may not be much to discuss here based on your update.

I guess the last time we talked about it, the decarbonization roadmap plan is one of the two additional eligible other requirements for climate leader communities. My discussion with town staff suggested that it is a planning only process. It requires you to kind of make an inventory of your fossil fuel dependent equipment in town, a fleet and facilities and to map out what a roadmap to net zero, but zero fossil fuel use by 2050 would entail. It doesn't require you to actually do any of those projects.

It's also a well-defined sort of data gathering and analysis process overseen by the Department of Energy Resources, which provides technical assistance grants specifically for this. You don't have to be a climate leader community to get these. I don't think even money changes hand. You apply for the grant and then they pair you with a consulting firm that kind of walks you through that.

And the deadline to apply for that support is in November, November 28, I believe. Right. And I think the intention is to apply for that. Yep.

So I guess that's, that's the update. Any discussion?

Speaker 8 (01:06:09–01:06:20)

So that would be basically creating an inventory of all town facilities and vehicle use and consumption of fossil fuels.

Speaker 2 (01:06:20–01:06:51)

Yeah. And it aligns with one of the sort of near term recommendations in the building section of our draft plan. I think we worded it differently, and I may update that wording to emphasize the alignment with this. We were recommending also doing some capital planning for it, but I do think costs and estimates are part of the decarbonization environmental process.

Speaker 8 (01:06:51–01:07:02)

I'm not sure. What kind of help do you need in that process? Is there any way that committee members could be able to assist you right now?

Speaker 3 (01:07:02–01:07:20)

So far, I haven't been able to think much about the municipal decarbonization roadmap application process because I've been focusing on getting data for the green communities reporting. So I appreciate the question, but I can't answer that yet.

Speaker 2 (01:07:20–01:07:37)

Feel free to reach out to us. as soon as anything comes up. Thank you. All right.

Next item on the agenda is working group updates. Are there any? Anybody want to say anything at all?

Speaker 7 (01:07:38–01:08:36)

Well, I've spoken to members of our working committee, and rather than a meeting, each of them is going to refine their proposals and focus on fleshing out the two-year action plans that we developed and this proposal that you just spoke about. And then we should be ready to do something. And one of the questions I had was, at some point when we get past this state grant program, will we get back into looking at the two-direction plans in the climate action plan and begin to implement them? Is there some thought of doing that, or just let it be?

Speaker 2 (01:08:40–01:09:04)

So I'll say for my part, I've always been most personally interested in the buildings and energy pieces of the country. And I'm prioritizing my personal bandwidth for this kind of work to move that forward, and best way I know now. And that's what we all have to deal with.

Speaker 7 (01:09:05–01:09:50)

Yeah, yeah. But I'm saying, within the whole committee, I think we're divided working. Each of us is working on one of the four, was it four goals of the Climate Action Plan? And each of those sub-components, I remember, has a two-year action plan.

So I do remember that you're focused on buildings, and I've been working on conservation, someone else is doing transportation, and they all have these action plans that we put together. So at some point, I'm assuming we'll get back to working on those.

Speaker 2 (01:09:53–01:10:58)

Right. I guess what I'm looking for from the committee is when I send out the draft agendas and say, this is a draft agenda, please get that to me with your suggestions and additions, like put stuff on the agenda. I think we've gotten to a point where there's a bunch of stuff in there, and then it's a matter of rolling up our sleeves and trying to push things forward. and seeing where we're making progress and where we're not, and letting that feedback guide where we focus our energy after that.

I do worry, I'm taking up a lot of oxygen by filling the agenda with the things I'm focused on. It doesn't have to be that way, but in the absence of assertive input from all of you, the agenda's gonna look like we're not needing that.

Speaker 7 (01:10:58–01:12:07)

Yeah, no, I think what we're working on now is really important, and we need to work through it, and it would be great to get this leadership grant. All I'm saying is that it would be interesting to learn from the other people once we get past that, and maybe it's gonna take us another six months just focused on this. It just seems that six months ago, we developed these plans. They each had action steps that we wanted to take.

And so my question is, do we want to, as a committee, maybe this is too premature to ask. Maybe I should wait a couple more months. I would be interesting to ask each of the people working on the different components, what their plans are or if they have any interest in moving forward on implementing the action plans.

Speaker 2 (01:12:09–01:13:12)

Yeah, so when I put working group updates on the agenda, that's what I'm looking at. And yeah, I think I would urge all of you to sort of pick your pet action items from the Climate Action Plan and think about what you can do to get the ball rolling. It's kind of challenging to get balls rolling in local government and in the world in general. Yeah, yeah.

Some of you just got to try. Yeah. And I definitely focus on accessing resources, because I think grants have a way of focusing energy and making today's easier. Everyone likes free running.

Speaker 8 (01:13:12–01:13:35)

This may be an unfair question to you, but if you were to think broadly about the needs of the town. Is there any particular project or goal that you would like to see as a quick win in the climate area or not?

Speaker 3 (01:13:38–01:14:41)

I think whether, I mean, depending on what the portfolio prioritization plan or the municipal decarbonization roadmap, produce, whatever is on the top of that list. And I would expect that the school buildings, because they are by far the biggest energy consumers, would be at the top of that priority. So identifying projects that are cost effective to implement and at the same time deliver results quickly, that would be my priority. Lighting is…

In Milton, I don't think it's as big of a problem. But in Randolph, the second community where we're colliding is a big one because the utility incentives are expiring next year. So lots of these questions are also shaped by what are the deadlines for expiring utility incentives, state grant deadlines.

Speaker 8 (01:14:42–01:14:52)

One concern I have that I think is fairly immediate is the new fire station, and what's being done to make that a green building?

Speaker 3 (01:14:55–01:15:13)

We're looking into PPAs, solar PPAs. Power purchase agreements. Yes, thank you. Power purchase agreements, yeah.

That's one of the projects we have on our to-do list in the coming weeks.

Speaker 2 (01:15:13–01:15:27)

I think you, last time I spoke to you, the expressions of interest, you mentioned submitting one for solar for the fire station. Did that, and that's changed to the repairs to the Colorado County solar?

Speaker 3 (01:15:28–01:16:14)

Yeah, the reason we're not aiming for the fire headquarters anymore is that the Eco One Stop grant program speaks about energy resilience in the form of not only solar, but solar and storage. And because the fire headquarters already has a backup generator, a new backup generator, it wouldn't make sense to install a new battery there for emergency storage, which is why we're looking into the Collicutt-Cunningham school. Although we're also, I'm still waiting to hear back if that already has a backup generator that is maybe old and needs replacing.

Speaker 2 (01:16:14–01:16:22)

Yeah. I will say there's a great big diesel generator by the door where I pick up my kids from after school.

Speaker 3 (01:16:23–01:16:26)

And does it look old?

Speaker 2 (01:16:27–01:16:35)

Yeah. I don't know how, it doesn't look old to me, but I don't know. Neither does the HVAC on the roof and I'm not sure that those are old.

Speaker 8 (01:16:38–01:18:01)

Now in terms of how to finance solar, based on information from a number of years ago, my belief was that PPAs were the least attractive because basically you're renting out your roof in return for discounted energy. I think that would be a lease. Least attractive. No, no, a lease.

No, the second method would be a lease um you know where you actually or a loan program where you finance for the loan and and are you know offsetting the interest cost through energy savings and the most attractive is when you actually own you know if you own the panels and you know take appreciation you know so anyway you know just um you know the challenge for the town is that putting out cash is difficult, but if there's a way that they can actually finance the borrowing, I think that would be a better financial option for the town than actually doing a PPA.

Speaker 3 (01:18:03–01:18:42)

I think a year ago or one and a half years ago, the possibility of ownership have been much more straightforward because of the 30 percent. Yeah, because of the 30 percent. Now, that's been one of my big questions in the past four weeks, especially with the upcoming deadlines on all the IRA funding opportunities. And my conclusion is that it's not doable for us.

The timelines are too tight.

Speaker 8 (01:18:45–01:19:00)

Have you been working with any firms that have run scenarios for you, using both debt and PPA scenarios?

Speaker 3 (01:19:00–01:19:16)

Yeah, I got a proposal today that I need to still read through thoroughly from Kathy Doyle from Fireflower. Okay. But I haven't had time to take a better look at it.

Speaker 8 (01:19:16–01:19:23)

Is that her proposal for putting solar on the former landfill?

Speaker 3 (01:19:24–01:19:32)

No, it would be police headquarters, the new animal shelter, and the library.

Speaker 7 (01:19:32–01:20:38)

I have another quick question. Yes, please. So for the next meeting, maybe an agenda item, instead of asking kind of generally the working groups, maybe we could ask each one member from each of the working groups. I think it will be me or Maggie for conservation and new buildings, and Arthur does waste.

And I think Stephen does transfer, I don't know. Yeah, if each of us could do, could come and just share a new and noteworthy development affecting the town in each of those areas. I think that would be, you know, if we could begin to do that on a regular basis under these four categories, which cost to the organization of our Climate Action Plan, that might be good.

Speaker 2 (01:20:39–01:21:05)

It would be good, yes. So I will be reminded of that recommendation when I throw the minutes together, and I will, next month when I send out the draft agenda, I will put that on. And that's sort of what we were doing before we got wrapped up with the article and all the references there. Yes, Maggie?

Speaker 6 (01:21:05–01:21:38)

So that was just, I was going to say, uh, follow up with, with Ron that, you know, if you look at the charge of the climate action planning committee, our charge is really to come up with a plan. And, um, you know, we're supposed to reach out to the public and experts and stakeholders. So, um, you know, Not that finding grants is not important, but is that really in our charge to do so?

Speaker 7 (01:21:38–01:21:45)

To get a grant for planning?

Speaker 6 (01:21:47–01:22:22)

Yeah, is that in our charge as a committee? And again, I'm not saying we shouldn't do it or we shouldn't be advocating, but I was just saying, to your point, when are we going to get back to talking about the act because isn't what the charge of this committee is, is coming up with a climate plan. And so, you know, is it under our charge to come up with grants and apply to grants?

Speaker 7 (01:22:23–01:23:15)

Well, I think Alex has brought this, at least the climate leadership grant application to our attention, and I think it deserved a couple of meetings to focus on and try to nail it. These other applications are also interesting, but the climate leadership one seems to be a linchpin, and it's been worthwhile, at least from my point of view, taking a couple of meetings to develop a process to pursue it. But I think as we're kind of getting towards the end of that, I think it would be worthwhile to get back into the mini-gridding of our planning in some way. And we can do both, I think, with the structure we need.

Speaker 2 (01:23:16–01:24:29)

Well, that's why the expression of interest I'm personally working on is for a grant to support our core charge. Getting to a complete and finalized climate action plan that's been vetted through robust public engagement. That is very explicit in our charge that we need to consult with everybody who ought to be consulted with. I think that in the absence of consulting support, that has proved very, very difficult.

And the climate action plans that I have reviewed that were developed in partnership with consultants and much more robust public engagement. And then just from talking to people who've been through those processes, that's really the value that a good consulting firm will bring. They'll run a structured public engagement process, which I think we've struggled to do. And the other ideas on the table, those are…

Those sound good to me.

Speaker 7 (01:24:29–01:24:36)

OK, yeah. Yeah, I'm in agreement. It would be nice if we begin to mix in.

Speaker 2 (01:24:36–01:24:56)

We've got to get back to it. That's a regular focus on the plan and refining it and engaging the public. And I hope to, at the very earliest, that consulting support would be coming midway through 2026. So we're going to have to get back to it on our own before then.

Speaker 8 (01:24:57–01:25:09)

So to what extent is this committee also charged or not charged with being responsible for implementing some of the actions within the plan?

Speaker 7 (01:25:14–01:25:48)

Well, that's what we're talking about. In the plan, for each of these four subgroups, there are two-year action plans. And when we developed them, to the best of my memory, we agreed that that would become the focus of the work of these four committees, at least for a two-year period. We didn't want to go beyond that because that would seem to me beyond what was reasonable to expect of us.

Speaker 2 (01:25:49–01:26:31)

I do think that when we get to the end, at some point, somehow, we should get to a iteration of the plan that we want to serve. So this is the plan. I think it would be crazy to say this is the plan and will never change if there are no provisions for updating it or implementing it. I think at that stage, it would make sense to go back to the select board and ask for a new charge that clarified this committee or successor committee's role in supporting implementation.

But I don't think it's particularly constraining.

Speaker 7 (01:26:31–01:26:53)

Yeah, I agree. And if we do this new and noteworthy segment of our meeting, people can, during that time, maybe make suggestions for modifying their component of the plan. Just a thought.

Speaker 2 (01:26:57–01:29:06)

All right, folks, I have a 730 conflict that I'm trying to get myself to. So there are no objections. I'll move on to the last agenda item. And just to be quick, just a reminder, we have several open seats on the committee still.

I think the ones that occupy most of my attention Maggie, I'm glad that you're back with us. So that addresses the planning board seat. We have a representative of the school committee and a seat for a high school student. And that is a resident of Milton.

They don't have to be a student of Milton High. I would love to fill those seats. I think that because the schools are the sort of largest emitters among municipal facilities and just an important demographic in our town. It would be great to fill those seats.

I have been in touch with the science department at Milton High School in the last week to sort of remind them that this opportunity is out there. And I'm in discussion with the teacher who teaches the climate crisis class, it's 10 students. You know, our high school students are very busy. So I think it might take some creativity to sort of come up with a framing of it that would make sense for a busy high school student to devote some time to.

Also, if any of you in your network know your folks your staff members at the schools or folks who are particularly engaged with the schools who might be a good fit for this committee, feel free to, I mean, I strongly encourage you to reach out to them directly or let me know about them, but you can definitely reach out to them directly. Alex? Yeah.

Speaker 4 (01:29:08–01:29:19)

Does For a high school student, does volunteering on this or being part of this committee account for, can they collect volunteer credits? They have to collect so many a year, I think.

Speaker 2 (01:29:20–01:29:59)

Yeah, so it's complicated. The high school asked me that same question. I always assumed that, obviously, yes. But I don't know if there's any formal process for giving students' community service hours, certainly I'd be happy to sign something.

I think it seems obvious to me that attending a local government meeting to represent the school council's community service. But then again, I'm just not familiar with any formal requirements that exist. If any of you know who knows that, that would be very helpful.

Speaker 7 (01:30:02–01:30:04)

Last year's student was Greg.

Speaker 2 (01:30:05–01:30:32)

Is she graduated? She graduated. So yes, lost to us for now. OK, any final comments?

Hearing none, I will entertain a motion to adjourn for the evening. I move that we adjourn. Brown is moved to adjourn. Any second?

Speaker 4 (01:30:33–01:30:34)

Second.

Speaker 2 (01:30:35–01:30:45)

Thank you, Steve. Okay, all in favor, say aye. Aye. Aye.

All opposed? Seeing none opposed, this meeting is adjourned.