Board: Milton Warrant Committee
Date: 2024-03-11
Transcript
Auto-generated; may contain errors.
Speaker 1 (00:51–00:51)
Thank you.
Speaker 2 (00:53–01:05)
And we're live. Welcome to the War Committee, everyone. Madam Clerk, would you please take our attendance?
Speaker 3 (01:06–01:22)
Yes, we have Dave Humphreys, Tom Caldwell, Lori Connolly, Julie Joyce, Christian Kosiel is on Zoom, Tim Lyons, Julia Maxwell is on Zoom, JJ O'Connor is on Zoom, and Judy Steele will be with us shortly.
Speaker 2 (01:23–01:43)
Thank you. Our first agenda item, Mr. Larry Lauffer, if you please join us. This can be for a presentation, discussion, potential vote on the proposed article with regards to the Historic District Milton Village.
Mr. Lauffer, take it away please.
Speaker 4 (01:43–03:53)
I am Larry Lauffer. I am the Chairman of the Local Historic District Study Committee. I live at 96 Cliff Road here in Milton since 1994. This is my third visit here.
Thank you for bringing me back. What we're here to do is to correct some of the language in the bylaw. Let me bring everybody up to speed. This committee has been studying the need for a local historic district for the town.
This is different than national historic districts and state historic districts. It comes with some regulation, but not much, and it comes with some benefit to the town. In our three year long study of this, we decided after looking at everything in the town that the best place to start would be Milton Village. And so in our proposal to the state, we proposed that and that was accepted.
Once that became accepted as a committee, we had to have public meetings and discussion with the various other committees in town, Warren Commission, the Planning Commission, the Planning Development, Historical Commission, et cetera. In the process of that, we made some adjustments to our proposal. And we are back here in front of the committee to present that proposal with the understanding that this final proposal will have to be ultimately accepted by the select board who identified our group, our committee, three years ago. I think that brings us up to date with what we're actually physically here to do.
We do have a presentation and the proposal are up on the website and I'm available at any point. I'm easy to find. You can call me. You can email me.
Speaker 2 (03:54–03:56)
Thank you. Judy.
Speaker 5 (03:59–04:03)
So if you could outline the changes that you made from December to now.
Speaker 4 (04:04–05:16)
Well, Judy, you were on the emails. You were actually in the meeting. And so the only changes that were made were to the bylaws. And they were the sections that you specifically called out.
Who is going to be on the committee, and how are they going to be chosen? And the way we did that is we followed what the town has been doing. And the only difference we made from when we met with the warrant committee to today is that the Warrant Committee had us including more people who were actually on town committees. And discussion within our committee, who also has a number of people that are on multiple committees, the thought was have someone who doesn't have multiple responsibilities to the town.
and spread it out. So instead of having somebody from preservation, we put another member from, in this case, it'll be Milton Village. If two years, three years from now, we choose another area to have a second historic district, those people can be elected, and then we would have two people from that. Those were the only changes that were made.
Speaker 5 (05:17–05:21)
That's my understanding. May I continue, because I really do have a list, and you're gonna follow.
Speaker 2 (05:22–05:27)
Just in a second. Did you say that there was an actual presentation that you were going to give Mr. Longifer?
Speaker 4 (05:28–05:31)
I do. And I sent it here. Yep.
Speaker 2 (05:31–05:45)
Why don't we do this? Let's let him give his full presentation. And then we'll go to questions after the presentation in case maybe some of the questions that we might have might be answered by the presentation.
Speaker 4 (05:46–06:01)
So. Yeah, that was just a question I was going to ask. So I sent this to you. Did you send it down to them?
Do they have it?
Speaker 2 (06:02–06:05)
Yes, we can pull it up. We can share it.
Speaker 4 (06:05–06:17)
Yes, please. Please. Please. And there's only 12 slides, but it lays out what we did.
Kind of nuts and bolts.
Speaker 5 (06:17–06:23)
Oh, I saw that.
Speaker 4 (06:24–18:14)
So we are the local historic district study committee, and that is different than state historic districts and federal historic districts. We can go on to the next. Okay, so what this is talking about here is how we came about as a local historic district. Please don't kick that.
I just had surgery here. We were chosen in 2021, the select board chose to open up a committee to study the feasibility of this. And there are something like 180 towns within the state. There's a slide later on, on this presentation that shows you.
That is constantly changing. I know that Framingham became one and we're going to become one. So those numbers will go up. The intent of the process is not to lock down like these kinds of committees.
can get lost in trying to maintain some sense of what a town is outside what the lifestyle of a town is. Milton has been around for very, very hundreds and hundreds of years, has a lot of history. We do not need everything to look exactly the same. We need to, as a town, continue to grow.
What we were 200 years ago is not what we are now. It's not going to be what we are 100 years ago. So we approach that with the understanding that Milton does want to continue to grow. We just wanted to make sure that we maintained things about Milton that the town believed had significance.
And that's not every old Building it's not it's there's a criteria more than that and a committee was set up to Determine that made up of town members next slide Okay, so this slide is talking about the difference between a local historic district and a national register district. And those are pretty simple. Liberty Bell is a national historic district, you know, the Bunker Hill. The monument is a National Historic District.
Local historic districts come down and they study what a town decides, not what the state decides. The state has named a variety of, and the federal has named a variety. Milton, we have six or seven federally named historic districts. Milton Hill, the cemetery, railroad district that's in East Milton that physically doesn't exist anymore, but the history of why that was important is historic.
So it wasn't historic for us right now. We're not going to protect the railroad that brought the granite from Quincy over to DuPont to build Boston. That's part of our history. We don't need to protect the cemetery.
We do need, because there is growth going on in Milton Village right now, we do need to make sure that we maintain what the town believes is of importance historically. not to control what materials are used or what paint is being used, but does it conform to Milton historical guidelines. Next slide. Purpose and benefits, there's a whole bunch of, the purpose is to protect what they say is the Milton lifestyle.
Man, you try and define that. You'll find 10 people and we'll have 12 opinions about what that is. But we do understand, like in Suffolk Resolves, how important that building was to the entire history of the United States. Right down here in Milton Village, what happened to the Industrial Revolution when they used these brick buildings down here to fire up the industries for the first time ever in the United States.
These are vitally important things that we need to protect. We're talking about federal versus state. Now, the state, if you are living in town and you have this old home built in 1820, built in 1700, and you really like it, you can, as a private citizen, fill out a form, send it to the state, and you can be registered as an historic district. Traditionally, being in a historic district or an historic town brings real estate value.
So that's a benefit. Being in an historic district brings both a benefit of more value, equity growth in your property, but it also brings the responsibility of maintaining the sense of what the town is. Talking about Milton Village, we have many beautiful buildings that are right there that we'd like to protect. The owners, we've met in our committee with two of the owners, they care very much about protecting and building Milton.
Their concern is regulations and how much another committee that they have to present to may slow down the development of the town. And we assured them that that was not the purpose and that nothing that we do is going to is going to curtail that purpose. That being said, that's not completely accurate because within the proposal there is soft teeth that if you don't If you present a project and there is some concern about the historic nature of it, that the committee can decide that you need to adjust or respond or something. If you don't, then there is going to be some kind of a fine.
how that fine is going to be collected and what that fine is going to be is stated in the proposal, but not with any specificity. After this committee is completed its work, and if the town so designates that we have a local historic district, then there's going to be another committee of the local historic, but they are going to create and codify the laws that be passed through the town. I don't know if I talked enough about the positive thing. I mean, people who have lived in this town, people who have grown up in this town, we all know that this town is maybe not the best, but constantly shows up as one of the best towns in the country.
because of the education, because of the schools. And I know there are better schools, but it's an amalgamation of all of that. And Milton is a special place. It's a big place.
It's diverse. And that is part of its strength. Next slide. Oh, these are the towns.
This is the map I was talking to you about. The green are the towns that us, and I can't see because of that, that Cronin, is that the room? Can we? Can we?
We can't get rid of that? I don't even know if it shows Milton yet, but it should. It does, it's the yellow dot. Oh, the yellow dot, that's us.
Yeah, it's a little far away from me. Well, that yellow means that we are provisionally. We're just waiting for the town to determine. Studies look toward, yeah, this is, we got, we started, we had a bit of difficulty and we started in COVID time.
And as you know, that was a tough time for everybody. We were supposed to have five members. We couldn't keep members because people would come on. This was a lot of work.
And as we know, we all do it as volunteers. And people came on, saw the work, and laughed. Some people came on, thought it wasn't what they wanted to do. So we are now down to five members who have been pretty much since the beginning and dedicated their time and effort.
And so we started with five, supposed to be five. We went to seven. We're at five now. We researched everything.
And if you look at our meeting notes, you will see we talked to every stakeholder that we could, including people from the state and people from other municipalities. So, because once this is done, people on this committee are going to be gone and a hundred years from now, people will be looking at this. Why did they do this? What were they thinking?
What was the reasoning? We wanted to make sure people understood. The next. Oh, these are just pretty pictures of Milton Village itself.
That's the one side. And then I think the next picture is the other side. Yeah, Milton Village. is really unique and it was a surprise to me.
Milton Village wasn't named in state or federal because of its importance, certainly to the Industrial Revolution in particular, but it was one of the first places, of course the Native Americans lived here before anybody else and there was a negotiation between one of the local governors from Boston, from Yeah, from Boston and a landowner, wealthy landowner here in Milton. And that's how Milton Village got started. And then one of our governors, Wainwright, bought a whole bunch of land. And that's when it became a destination place for vacations.
And then he was the first one to actually kind of sliced up, and that's Milton Hill. Very, very significant area in this town, but significant in the fact that he was the first development. And as he left, died, and then left, that land was settled, and there's many, many beautiful homes there. But that was the direct line from the governor to downtown.
And it wasn't the Adams Street, as it was. It was actually High Street, which is a little bit above that, you know, that was the significant area. And it must have been because of horses or some reason.
Speaker 6 (18:14–18:16)
So there wasn't Adam Street at all?
Speaker 4 (18:16–20:32)
Yeah, Adam Street wasn't there all the way through at that time. So High Street, which is this tiny little street, you go down that street and there's so many of these cool, really old, more bungalow-y type buildings, but they've been there forever. So we really did, and I want to stress this. In our committee, like in the next committee, there's an architect, there's an attorney, there's somebody from the historical commission, there's a real estate professional, and then there's town members.
And then all the committees should have We've have this in the proposal should be stated in the proposal that they're there because these are professionals An architect has to be a member of the AIA architect international Real estate person has to be a member of the National Association of Realtors. So there's codes of ethics and we bring that and to the table for the betterment of the town. And we looked at it, not from today, what we want today, but what we want for the town, not just today, but 50 years from now. How can we grow, and that's part of the problem with our most recent election, how can we grow and still maintain our town?
How do we communicate that? We're less evasive, far less evasive. our committee and what we're trying to do. It's a protection and it's an opportunity.
The significance won't be known for years because 200 years from now, sitting maybe in a better town hall at that point, who knows? We'll, hey, there's nothing wrong with our town hall, I'm sorry. Send those letters to Dave Humphreys, care of the, no. I lost my place.
My son said, you know.
Speaker 2 (20:32–20:36)
Okay, so that's the formal brief. Any questions?
Speaker 5 (20:38–20:39)
Seeing as you're looking right at me.
Speaker 2 (20:39–20:42)
I volunteer. We'll go Judy then Tim.
Speaker 5 (20:43–25:57)
I just have a few. Can I make a statement as well as questions or do you prefer statements later? Okay. On the surface.
And it's admirable that we have selected this section of town to preserve some of its visual history. So that being said, I'm sort of a contract language specialist in a way. And so I look at language. It's the basis for everything going forward in any discussion.
What does the language say and how do we proceed? How do we negotiate on that language? How do we adhere to the language? How do we make it work the way the frame is of that language intended it to be?
That being said, Section four was a problem for me, as you well know, language-wise, and I did contact your committee. I went and I listened to your debates and your discussions, and then I, of course, branched out to as many people, all the ones that knew I was coming and didn't close the door, so they had to go through my big spiel. Anyway. What this is, your presentation, which is very good.
I'm not denying that. We've got the history down. If you've driven in that section of town, even once you understand the significance of those buildings. What you say about what is in your vision for the commission that will oversee What goes on in that district for a visual impact means nothing in reality because the language here is going to dictate how we pick those seven people and only four alternates, which was a problem for me.
I did go to the historic commission. I talked to two people there, talked about that. They seemed interested, very interested in changing 4.3 and clearly understood how that could not work into the 7 and 4.1. And what you say, what I say, what anyone here says, that we're not going to tell people not to put up blue shutters or red brick or green grass.
Seven members will dictate via their rules and regulations what happens in that district. They will be appointed by one board in our town. We don't know what their rules are. And each and every person that I have spoken with, and it's been too many and I'm kind of glad this is coming to a head so I'm not running around asking a million questions, has indicated to me that it is of concern because I had an opportunity to, it was a random encounter with someone from another town that has many historic districts, mostly on their main street.
And what happens in their district is Never the same, because the people on that committee change. So you could have people appointed that are really red brick or nothing. You can have nothing but a red brick or a shake roof. And that was big in their historic district.
We have no control over what will happen. to these 40 properties simply because we don't know. And you can't know. I can't know.
Dave can't know. None of us. The Historic Commission can't know. Nobody knows.
Speaker 2 (25:58–26:01)
OK, so Judy, was that the statement that gets us to a question?
Speaker 5 (26:02–27:18)
Well, it does. So here's the thing, and I know you said that you changed it, but you didn't change 4.3, the only thing that changed to my knowledge, and that's why I asked that question so I could zero in, was you changed out and now you have an attorney as one of the seven, and that's the only change I see. Except upping the number of in-district persons, and I'm gonna roll to this. It's my understanding, and I know there was talk that there's one commission for however many districts are formed within a town.
But I'm not sure, and it came to my attention today, that in some towns, they form, as in this case, seven member. committee for each district. Because if you have five districts and only two people from the district, then every district is not represented by in-district people. So the way they solve that problem.
Speaker 2 (27:18–27:22)
Judy, I'd like to bring the rest of the committee into this dialogue. I'm still waiting for it.
Speaker 5 (27:23–27:25)
Well, can they not learn from what I'm saying here?
Speaker 2 (27:25–27:26)
There's so much.
Speaker 4 (27:26–27:27)
I'm waiting for an answer.
Speaker 2 (27:28–27:32)
There's so much going on all at once here. Let's do this. Let's start.
Speaker 5 (27:34–27:37)
And only Barry can answer this.
Speaker 4 (27:40–27:50)
So let me start right away. You said nobody can know. You were elected to this position, correct?
Speaker 5 (27:50–27:51)
No, I was appointed.
Speaker 4 (27:51–29:15)
OK, so these people in this committee will also be appointed. They'll be appointed for a finite period of time. And so you're right that as the people change, so could the policies. You know, we didn't have cars, now we have cars.
We didn't have cell phones, now we have cell phones. So things will change, and they should continue to change. So we wanted to make it flexible. So then another thing you talked about was how there's no specifics.
There's many specifics in here, but we left it general because we did not want to dictate By the way, visually, it's only from the street, from an historic, how you can see it from a public street. So if you're on a corner, you can see two sides of your house. You can do anything in the back that you want as long as town agrees about it. But we didn't want to dictate colors, and that is in fact in our proposal.
Now that doesn't mean, like Judy says, that it can't be changed. The next committee could do that for whatever reason, but I don't think that's, We don't have an area except maybe Indian Village, Indian Springs, where it's kind of very, very similar everywhere.
Speaker 2 (29:16–29:17)
Cliffs?
Speaker 4 (29:17–29:19)
Indian Cliffs?
Speaker 7 (29:19–29:20)
Yeah.
Speaker 4 (29:21–29:26)
So I hope I addressed… And I understand that.
Speaker 5 (29:26–31:24)
And I love that your particular committee wants to have, as this phrase was coined by NASA when they sent the first man into space, a human, a human. and do the most good with the least harm. That was coined by NASA. So I understand that our goal should be to preserve this history.
Doing the most good, that's the most good. But with the least harm to these 40 property owners. If we want to look at it that way, because it's easy to remember that phrase. My interest, I'm on board with historic preservation.
I would have loved to have seen some portion of this old town hall incorporated into this new space that they needed, like the library. Love the library project. Old, but moving forward. I'm all on board with that.
And I'm encouraged that we can do that. My focus, and it goes to perhaps a past thing I did in life, is that I'm always aware that things start out great. And they do. They have a lofty goal.
And it's admirable. But then you get in the weeds later. And it's all who is positioned on these committees. I mean, the person that appointed me had no idea what they were really going to get.
So, well, here you have it. Or any of us, really. You know, they just, you know.
Speaker 4 (31:25–31:27)
That's town governance, though, right?
Speaker 5 (31:27–31:39)
It is town government. And, you know, you answer their questions honestly and to the best of your ability. And if they pick you, well, Year and a half later, you wonder why you applied, maybe.
Speaker 4 (31:40–31:41)
Keep your head down later.
Speaker 5 (31:41–31:56)
Yeah. But I worry about, these are our neighbors. We know that three residents of this town own, between them, eight commercial properties in this district.
Speaker 4 (31:57–31:58)
As well, I know.
Speaker 5 (31:58–31:58)
As you know.
Speaker 4 (31:58–31:59)
I've talked to all of them.
Speaker 5 (31:59–32:00)
We know them. We've talked to them.
Speaker 4 (32:00–32:01)
Yeah.
Speaker 5 (32:02–32:55)
And I worry for them. about their concerns. And I just wanted to perhaps, I guess the impact of my worry about this language went to them, not to those people specifically, but to the 40 that were imposing extra burden of, I'll just call it renovation, regulations, that the rest of us don't have to do. All the rest of us in town.
And it's commercial, and we have so little commercial. We're desperate for commercial. It appears from my listening to various
Speaker 4 (32:57–33:27)
We have always in Milton historically been undisturbed with a commercial group because Milton didn't want it. Milton Village is a place where there are. And the people you're talking about, at least two of them. We know the two that were at the other committee.
These are really, really smart developers. And they love this town. And they're not going anywhere. But just like you said, their concern is another layer of regulation.
Speaker 5 (33:29–33:31)
But that would be for residential as well. Judy, it's Tim's turn.
Speaker 4 (33:31–33:32)
Yeah.
Speaker 5 (33:32–33:32)
Tim, sorry.
Speaker 8 (33:33–33:33)
It's OK.
Speaker 5 (33:34–33:35)
Did I take all your questions away?
Speaker 8 (33:36–33:58)
Nope. I just have a clarification question, well two. Section 5, 5.1 bullet point 2 talks about the Commission has control over changing of colors. Talk up just a little bit.
It says the Commission has the power to basically say what colors you can use.
Speaker 2 (33:58–34:00)
Which number was that, Tim?
Speaker 8 (34:00–34:13)
Section 5, 5.1, bullet point 2. Okay. And then in section 9, 9.1.2, it says you won't do colors. It's contradictory.
It's confusing.
Speaker 4 (34:13–34:17)
Yeah, I would have to look at those specifically.
Speaker 8 (34:18–34:37)
And then it also goes in that same part. It's talking about storm windows and doors, screen windows and doors, and window air conditioners. There's nothing about windows. And windows are huge.
When you talk about historic, you can say it has to be an eight pane over one, an eight over eight.
Speaker 4 (34:37–35:08)
Here's the thing with that, specifically, because we spent a lot of time, we have an architect, a lawyer, a real estate person, those six over six or eight over eight old ones, single pane, horribly inefficient. You cannot dictate to someone that they have to live in a horribly inefficient house. So we had to have a way for them to be able to upgrade those windows to a type.
Speaker 8 (35:08–35:11)
That's my point, and there's nothing saying they can.
Speaker 4 (35:11–35:16)
There is. Where? I don't know specifically.
Speaker 8 (35:16–35:21)
I've read this 10 times, and there's nothing about window types at all.
Speaker 4 (35:21–35:57)
So by the way, when something is left off like that, like there's no color specific, it mentions color, but it doesn't say anything specific. It means that the next group, to Judy's point, can determine what those specifics are during that time for that group. area. And it was specifically made that way.
So it could be determined downstream. When they codify it? Yeah. Okay.
Speaker 8 (35:57–35:59)
Thank you. Appreciate it.
Speaker 4 (36:00–36:05)
But that specific thing with the windows, because I lived in a house with bad windows.
Speaker 8 (36:06–36:16)
I'm a contractor and I've seen it totally throw stuff Yeah. Off. Yeah. Because they got the windows, doors.
Yeah. And some of the colors are just ground stuff to a halt.
Speaker 4 (36:16–36:17)
Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 8 (36:17–36:18)
Yeah. I just don't want to see that happen.
Speaker 4 (36:18–36:19)
You don't see much of that in this town.
Speaker 8 (36:20–36:21)
Hopefully.
Speaker 4 (36:22–36:33)
You just don't. I mean, we're a pretty big town. So, you know, you don't see many. There's a couple.
But. And certainly not in Milton Village.
Speaker 6 (36:35–37:56)
I just, well first I loved the presentation, thank you, and I thought that was really interesting and I didn't know that about High Street, so I love every time I get to learn something new, that was totally new to me. I had a couple of questions and that might be the same that you just answered for Tim, but when we're talking about alteration or to alter, when it says reconstruction, is that after a total loss or is that, like what exactly would reconstruction consist of, removal of exactly of what, to me it's sort of the details that I see that you're not thinking about and then all of a sudden someone's got a $250,000 additional bill that they weren't preparing from because before they bought the house it wasn't the plan. And that changes, and I know that can hit people, and especially some of our older folks who are in some of the older houses. So that was a point that I wanted to make to that.
And a couple of things, Tim, you touched on the windows. Do you want to answer that question before we move on to the next one? Was that a question? No, it was just something that I kind of wanted to talk about, just the devil in the details point of that, and that if it's going to be codified.
I'm assuming your answer to Tim sort of answered that question to me, well, that we're not at that point yet. But I want to make sure that we are, like, before anything is signed on the dotted line, that there's another step that's coming that we'll have the opportunity to really state exactly what that means.
Speaker 4 (37:56–38:07)
I think what's going to happen, my understanding of this, is our committee creates this proposal and the next committee, after this is voted on, creates those specifics.
Speaker 6 (38:08–38:11)
So if this gets approved now, we're approving it with very broad language, is that correct?
Speaker 4 (38:11–38:12)
Yes.
Speaker 6 (38:12–38:13)
Okay. All right.
Speaker 5 (38:13–38:15)
So that wraps it up, huh?
Speaker 2 (38:15–38:49)
Well, so, I mean, that's the point is that right now, the article, when we get back to it, we'll pull up the article, is that we're creating two things right now. It's going to be the commission and the district. So we would be asked, we would give a recommendation to the town meeting to decide commission, district, and then the actual I don't want to use every word except for guidelines. The rules that will be created will come later.
Speaker 6 (38:50–38:59)
And can I just ask you, is this map that you did, so this envelopes the business district, but is this the Verizon building it stops at?
Speaker 4 (39:00–39:05)
No, the Verizon building is up the street. You're on the blaster side.
Speaker 6 (39:05–39:08)
Yep, but right, no I know, right here, like where are we?
Speaker 5 (39:09–39:11)
I have to look.
Speaker 6 (39:11–39:11)
I don't have my glasses.
Speaker 5 (39:12–39:18)
Yeah, okay, so your Verizon, that's how you're going, so your Verizon building is here. Yep, yep.
Speaker 6 (39:18–39:30)
That big, yes, correct. Okay, so that was my thing, so it stops directly at that and then the residential homes afterwards. Do you see that, do you foresee that, this stretching up the hill into the residential?
Speaker 4 (39:30–39:31)
Then you become the Milton Hill.
Speaker 6 (39:31–39:32)
Yeah.
Speaker 4 (39:32–39:33)
and then that would be another district.
Speaker 6 (39:33–39:36)
And that would be a different district, and that would have a different set of… Right.
Speaker 4 (39:37–39:53)
I liked the idea of Milton Hill just because of the history of Milton Hill, but in talking to people in the town and the planning board and the zoning board and all of that, Milton Village was the best place for right now. Okay. Best place to start.
Speaker 6 (39:54–40:00)
I agree. Thank you. That was it for me. Thank you.
Judy.
Speaker 5 (40:01–41:20)
I think I'm encouraged that we've cleared the air about the next. We're giving them permission to create a committee whose job will be to make the rules for how these 40 properties maintain their properties. That's the unknown. We know they're going to pick seven people.
That's all we know. And I think that's my main point is that we can all be very encouraged on the preservation portion of this article. But we also need to be aware that there is an unknown for 40 property owners that are our neighbors. And I just want everyone to, it seems everybody's a quick learn.
Can I ask one more question? I'm sorry.
Speaker 2 (41:22–41:25)
It didn't sound like you were done yet, Judy. Are you done?
Speaker 5 (41:25–41:25)
No.
Speaker 6 (41:26–41:27)
Oh, I'm sorry.
Speaker 5 (41:27–41:28)
No, let Julie go.
Speaker 6 (41:29–41:54)
Julie, go ahead. Julie, go ahead. Just a quick one is when we were talking about things that are viewed by the roadways or the ways, that wouldn't also be viewed through the Neponset River or the highway or anything from the people in the back, like 88 Wharf. I don't know what that view is from Medway Street and from the Ventura Street Park.
So that property would fit in the back of that from the Ponson Riverway, right? Would that fall into this?
Speaker 4 (41:54–42:11)
That's a really interesting question. For instance, one of the questions that we had is, well, there are drones out there now. Can't the historical district get up and drone and see what's going on behind? Not the way the law is written.
Speaker 6 (42:11–42:20)
If it's a motor transportation, or it's an accepted riverway, walkway, highway, any of those… Public throughway is the way it's described.
Speaker 4 (42:21–42:33)
So a public throughway is the way it's commonly known from the front yard, right outside in front. But your point, why not?
Speaker 5 (42:33–42:42)
So her point leads us to 2 Elliot. Is this okay that we discuss?
Speaker 4 (42:42–42:45)
Which one? Is 2 Elliott the bank?
Speaker 5 (42:45–42:47)
No, it's where the gym is.
Speaker 4 (42:48–42:48)
Okay.
Speaker 5 (42:48–42:59)
But if you continue to go over the bridge, over the Neponset, That building backs out to the dam, which is, I mean, you have to stop and watch the water, don't you?
Speaker 9 (43:00–43:02)
It's a really special place.
Speaker 5 (43:03–43:20)
So now that begs, as Julie just pointed out, it begs the question, will this commission consider that a view as well? So we're looking from Elliott, but then we go down to the bridge, which is a major
Speaker 4 (43:21–43:29)
I know the answer to this. This committee will not. But the building department, the planning commission, the zoning commission will look at that.
Speaker 5 (43:30–43:33)
But our committee will not. We're only going to look from Elliott.
Speaker 4 (43:33–43:41)
From the way that this committee is permitted to approach it. From the public throughway. I know.
Speaker 5 (43:42–43:44)
I know. That's a conundrum, isn't it?
Speaker 4 (43:46–43:47)
Welcome to governance.
Speaker 5 (43:48–43:53)
So the public throughway. is going over the bridge as well.
Speaker 4 (43:54–43:55)
Would be Elliot and Adams.
Speaker 5 (43:58–43:58)
Right.
Speaker 4 (43:59–44:01)
So you're standing on that bridge and you can see one side.
Speaker 5 (44:01–44:03)
So now we're going to go over the bridge.
Speaker 4 (44:03–44:04)
Yeah.
Speaker 5 (44:04–44:05)
So here's to Elliot.
Speaker 4 (44:05–44:05)
Yeah.
Speaker 5 (44:05–44:10)
They really have two public way facades, if you will.
Speaker 4 (44:11–44:12)
Elliot and Adams, yes.
Speaker 5 (44:14–44:25)
So you're saying the language in here is only going to incorporate this, even though you've incorporated this highway as well.
Speaker 4 (44:26–44:29)
Right. That's not a highway. That's Central Avenue, right?
Speaker 5 (44:30–44:32)
No, that's Adams Street going over the bridge.
Speaker 4 (44:32–44:37)
Here, can I just get your orientation? OK, I see what you're doing.
Speaker 5 (44:37–44:49)
Yeah. So 2 Elliott actually has a public facade on a public Byway it big only because they were corner.
Speaker 4 (44:49–44:52)
Yeah, that's what I'm selling saying Judy.
Speaker 5 (44:52–45:13)
It's Elliot and Adams I think to Julie's point Will this Commission also determine what's done on Adams? Yeah by the bridge as well as Elliot across from the bank, correct? So it's a two facade building. Yes, that will be under.
Speaker 4 (45:13–45:13)
Yes.
Speaker 5 (45:14–45:14)
Thank you and
Speaker 2 (45:15–45:16)
I have a question.
Speaker 4 (45:16–45:17)
I'm sorry it took me so long.
Speaker 5 (45:17–45:20)
That's OK, because it's confusing, isn't it?
Speaker 2 (45:20–45:27)
Yeah. But you know, Judy's concern is what's going to happen in the future. Yeah. One of the ways that we do things is we have the checks and balances.
Speaker 4 (45:27–45:28)
Yeah.
Speaker 2 (45:28–45:45)
So right now, this proposed bylaws here at the Warren Committee, we're going through it. Right. Who reviews when the committee comes up with their rules that they're going to put into place? Who reviews those?
Speaker 4 (45:45–45:52)
If anyone select board select like board and they'll have to come in front of you as well. Okay with just like I did.
Speaker 5 (45:53–46:10)
Where do you find that that it's got to come before the Warren came in because everywhere I have traveled and I put a lot of miles on this. I have never once heard they have to come through. the process of warrant committee, because our only purpose is to prepare a warrant for town meeting.
Speaker 2 (46:10–46:12)
So the question then is, what's the source for that?
Speaker 4 (46:13–46:28)
My source was talking to Nick and Mike, manager and select board, and Steve O'Donnell, and Meredith Hall. These are all chairmen of committees here in town.
Speaker 2 (46:29–46:32)
Would those rules become part of the bylaw?
Speaker 4 (46:33–46:56)
Yes. Yeah. And they will be chosen again by the select board, but they'll be chosen. Those seven members will be chosen from 14 members.
And then they get chosen seven. And we didn't have enough for alternatives. We never had enough for alternatives. So if we have, I would have loved that.
Speaker 5 (46:57–47:06)
What do you mean you didn't have enough? You could have made seven alternatives. My committee. Six alternatives.
So you had, well, actually, five alternatives. So you had one from each group.
Speaker 4 (47:07–47:11)
No. We had five members, and we went up to seven members.
Speaker 5 (47:11–47:11)
Oh, OK.
Speaker 4 (47:11–47:14)
No, I'm understanding what you're saying now. And we went through 14 members.
Speaker 5 (47:14–47:46)
But to Dave's point, and if you could really clarify this, because this is new news to me. And again, maybe I wasn't looking out the right window when I was putting all those miles on. But I, even in talking to some folks in some other towns, I never once heard that once these rules are made by these appointed people, that it had to go through the process of acceptance.
Speaker 4 (47:48–47:48)
Yeah, of course it would.
Speaker 5 (47:49–47:50)
Not necessarily.
Speaker 4 (47:51–47:56)
That's not the way I understand it. But I haven't done the study that you seem to have done.
Speaker 5 (47:56–48:18)
Well, again, somehow, if everyone knew what road I wanted to travel here, and you'd think someone would have brought that up to me. Well, Judy, there's a checks and balances, and there it is right there. And here it is. Why is it just like at the 11th and a half hour, why wasn't this information put forth before?
Speaker 4 (48:18–48:20)
This is my third meeting here.
Speaker 5 (48:21–48:22)
I know it's your third meeting here.
Speaker 4 (48:22–48:24)
Okay, all right.
Speaker 2 (48:24–48:25)
Badger the witness.
Speaker 5 (48:26–48:28)
No, I wasn't trying to.
Speaker 2 (48:29–48:34)
We need to bring some other people into our dialogue. Jay's had his hand up for a while. Jay?
Speaker 10 (48:39–51:07)
Hello, can you hear me? Can you hear me? Yes. Okay, great.
Hi. So I was looking at the updated bylaws that you presented, the updated text, and I noticed you added quite a few paragraphs to Section 5, which I appreciated. The paragraphs that it appears you added were a lot more specific about what they're looking for, what they're not looking for, when they should prove something, when they should say something's okay, when they should deny it. I very much appreciated that specificity, but I was, I was shocked in that I looked over the rest of the bylaw, and you and I talked in October, and I talked to this whole committee in October, and there were quite a few fundamental problems with the bylaw, just with the wording of the bylaw itself.
And I thought I provided my issues to you in writing. I know I provided them to committee in writing. And all the issues I raised are still here. There are problems and contradictions with the number of members of the committee, who's on the committee, the alternates.
I don't know of any other committee in town that has alternates. So I don't know how this would work. The alternates just raised a whole lot of questions for me. I would, I suggested that be scratched because it seemed to just be causing problems.
There's confusion about, you know, how many members would be on it. There was confusion about how many votes are needed to approve something. There was the numbers and the numbers of days that an appeal takes, the numbers didn't add up. I did the math last October.
I did not repeat the math now because I'm lazy, but they didn't add up and they don't seem to have changed. And the biggest issue that several of us on the committee had last time is that there's no maximum amount of fines. The fines can be up to $500 per day. So if someone is in violation for 100 days, that's $50,000.
I know several of us on the committee in October had a real problem with this, and that's still there. So I'm confused and upset that All the issues that we found in October are still here. So I don't know if you can speak to that.
Speaker 4 (51:09–52:17)
So Jay, in that first meeting, you sent me a long redlined letter. We went through that. We went through with the Warrant Commission the first time. I came back a second time.
I don't think you were at that meeting. I then went ahead and met with Dave and another attorney from your committee. We worked through the language. And then we went back into our committee after talking to the state and other people and everyone of that group was satisfied with the language.
There is some general language in there meant specifically. So you brought up again, who's on this committee? There's seven members on the committee. It's very specifically said who's in that committee.
It's highly unlikely where this town is ever going to find seven people plus four alternatives that this is volunteer work. So if we have seven committee members who are dedicated, that'll be great for the two to three years, whenever they're going to be elected. Have I answered most of what you brought up?
Speaker 10 (52:19–52:27)
No, not at all. Like the makeup of the committee, I'll just start with that. It says the committee will be seven members.
Speaker 2 (52:28–52:32)
Two of them start with the one… Jay, can you give us what number, as we go through?
Speaker 5 (52:32–52:33)
Sure.
Speaker 2 (52:33–52:36)
Can you give us like what's… Sure, 4.1. 4.1.
Speaker 10 (52:43–52:45)
So let's read how many members it says are on the committee.
Speaker 5 (52:47–52:53)
4.2. There we go.
Speaker 2 (52:54–52:59)
4.1. Thank you. 7, 2.
Speaker 4 (52:59–53:03)
That's great if she can share.
Speaker 2 (53:03–53:05)
4, 6.
Speaker 10 (53:12–54:56)
So that was one of the first issues I saw. And then when I opened up the document yesterday, I saw it's still there. It still says seven members. Two have a one-year term, two have a two-year term, and two have a three-year term.
That's not the end of the world, but it's an easy problem to fix, and it wasn't fixed. And then in 4.2, we talk about there being Two property owners from each district. Well, there's only one district. So I don't understand that.
And then in 4.3, the select board may appoint up to four alternate members in a like manner. A like manner like what? I don't know what that means. And do the alternates have to be architects or attorneys or residents of the district or not?
And do the alternates line up with the regular members? Like, do you have a regular architect and an alternate architect? And if the regular architect is gone, they're replaced by the alternate architect? Or is it just whoever the chair decides to call that night?
So that was confusing to me. And also, as I said, I don't know of any other committee in town that has alternates. So I don't know why they're here. Next, 4.7.
4.7 says four members of the commission shall constitute a quorum. Well, how does that work with the alternates? If not everybody shows up, do you call the alternates or do you say it's a quorum?
Speaker 4 (54:58–55:00)
Of course you could use the alternates.
Speaker 10 (55:01–55:08)
Should I keep going or should I? Should I keep going or should I pause there?
Speaker 4 (55:08–55:11)
I think you're making this needlessly complicated.
Speaker 10 (55:11–55:18)
I'm very good at that. The other people in the room will tell you that I excel at that.
Speaker 2 (55:21–55:26)
So it's true. As we look at it, like at 4.1.
Speaker 4 (55:27–55:30)
Could you go to 4.1?
Speaker 11 (55:30–55:32)
Do you want this?
Speaker 2 (55:32–55:39)
I've got a radio. It doesn't add up, Seth. It looks like there's one that's unaccounted for.
Speaker 6 (55:39–55:42)
I think I paged it in print, OK?
Speaker 4 (55:42–56:20)
Great. Yeah, that one that's unaccounted for is that large. Just a minute, let me see this. It's a shame we have that.
Could we get rid of that? Do you want to use my paper? Oh, thank you. So that only gets you the 6 versus 7.
Yeah, that's what was missing there. I only came up with 6 too. I came up with 6. Why would they be able to?
Speaker 6 (56:21–56:26)
I have no idea.
Speaker 11 (56:31–56:33)
I'm going to agree with Jay Hoffman, but I agree with him.
Speaker 6 (56:33–56:37)
No, I agree with Jay Hoffman. I think I caught the alternate thing too.
Speaker 4 (56:45–56:56)
So the like manner, I saw that in context right now, the like manner means the exact same way that they were chosen for the actual board itself.
Speaker 6 (56:56–56:57)
Which number is that?
Speaker 4 (56:57–56:59)
4.3. Thank you.
Speaker 5 (56:59–57:02)
But that interpretive like manner could…
Speaker 4 (57:02–57:10)
It's the same way you were appointed, the same way I was appointed. That's the last time the district committee makes a determination.
Speaker 2 (57:10–57:19)
I think I agree with that. I think it's assumed, when they say it's a like manner, it's assumed that it should be as a like manner by which they originally
Speaker 12 (57:19–57:39)
I understand the alternates I agree with Jay on that the whole alternate number situation there are no other the alternate members there are no other Committees in town that have it.
Speaker 4 (57:39–58:03)
I don't know why we would have it here for this one That was taken from state stated had suggested that because in some of the towns they have alternate members So they would have it would have been you know appointment like for instance say it's two architects or two realtors Get someone else we we can use another realtor, but they would be the alternate Did that make sense?
Speaker 12 (58:05–58:14)
So you have five people that you have found, and then you added an extra realtor and an extra architect.
Speaker 4 (58:14–58:15)
We didn't, but you could.
Speaker 12 (58:15–58:26)
But you could as the… So the alternates are only there to choose from the types of people up here if you don't have seven.
Speaker 4 (58:27–58:30)
And chosen from the select board. The committee does not choose those people.
Speaker 12 (58:30–58:59)
Correct, because it's in a like manner. So those two paragraphs seem to need to be restated a little bit, like I just said. Because that's unclear. I think that is unclear.
And I would go back to just, if you don't have I just don't understand the alternate thing.
Speaker 13 (59:06–59:22)
What's the downside to having alternates?
Speaker 12 (59:23–59:31)
I'm not saying it's just now we don't have any today. Do we need now? We're creating something new.
Speaker 14 (59:31–59:54)
That's all Not to run raises a good point. Yeah, he does. No, I mean the conflict well, then I understand what J and J what Laurie are saying like it's really unique to any board or community in town, but you know I think somebody may not want somebody voting on, you know, just how Ron laid it out. I think it's a good catch, but.
Speaker 12 (59:55–01:00:04)
So to that point, though, the two property owners that are in the district that own property can't vote on anything because they have a conflict of interest.
Speaker 13 (01:00:08–01:00:09)
Potentially.
Speaker 12 (01:00:09–01:00:17)
Wouldn't you think by default? Can we get Ron mic'd? It's really hard to hear Ron on Zoom. Thanks.
Sorry.
Speaker 14 (01:00:21–01:00:23)
Laurie was that does that make sense?
Speaker 12 (01:00:23–01:00:47)
Like I would think any property owner voting on something in the historic district that they live in is a conflict of interest Potentially, I don't know by just by its nature. They're voting on what is going to impact them personally financially Financially, well, yeah, financial personal property. They're gonna either Depending go to certain one.
Speaker 14 (01:00:47–01:00:49)
So the idea would be to remove the person from the district.
Speaker 7 (01:00:50–01:00:50)
I
Speaker 14 (01:00:51–01:00:53)
from the committee. From the committee, I'm sorry.
Speaker 12 (01:00:53–01:01:00)
Yeah, two property owners in the district. If that's why we have alternates for what you're saying with the conflict, which I get.
Speaker 8 (01:01:00–01:01:03)
It does not inherently just cancel out a property owner.
Speaker 4 (01:01:04–01:01:06)
Exactly, that's what I mean. Property owners.
Speaker 12 (01:01:06–01:01:15)
And I agree, I agree, but that's, if that's the rationale on the alternate.
Speaker 2 (01:01:15–01:01:54)
As a general statement, we collectively, individually, don't get to decide what constitutes a conflict of interest. The State Ethics Commission does. It sounds like this is what we're working with here is this is, to some degree, boilerplate that you guys have received from other towns that has been approved by the state body. I would show some deference to that.
Jay's brought up some good points, though, about the numbers not adding up. It's one number.
Speaker 4 (01:01:54–01:01:58)
It's that first number.
Speaker 2 (01:02:00–01:02:07)
Jay, are you still there? I am still here. You had some other concerns?
Speaker 10 (01:02:08–01:03:40)
Yeah, I guess the other things I would say are in Section 7, again, I did this in October. I added up the number of days, and there just wasn't really enough time for everything to get done. I'm too lazy to do the math again, but I had suggestions at the time. And then also 7.6, going back to like the number of people on the committee, 7.6 says you need a majority of members on the committee to issue a certificate.
Well, a few paragraphs ago, we said that you only needed four members for a quorum. So if there are four members in a meeting, it has to be unanimous to issue a certificate. Maybe that's the intent, but it seems unintended. And then, of course, they use the word chairman every time they should use the word chair.
And the final thing is sort of what caused the most discussion when we met last time, which was there's no maximum fine listed. $500 a day for an infinite number of days. And last time something like this came in front of town meeting, which was, I don't know, Tom and I were there, so it's been within the past 10 years. Town meeting rose up and said, no, there cannot be an unlimited fine based on the number of days.
We need a cap on it. And yeah, I believe those are my issues.
Speaker 2 (01:03:42–01:04:00)
OK, thank you, Jay. OK, so the new ones here seem to be revolving around 7-6. concurring vote, a majority, and then this issue of the maximum fine. 11.3.
Speaker 4 (01:04:00–01:04:25)
No, we can't do anything about the maximum fine. The maximum fine information came from the state. So we needed to have something in there as part of this, but we're not determining what that fine, who collects that fine, how that fine is collected, or what the maximum is. Hopefully, we don't have to fine anyone.
But we have to have that in there.
Speaker 10 (01:04:28–01:04:57)
Can I say something? Sure, Jay. Yeah, I mean, you know, one way to view the Warrant Committee is we're asking all the questions that town meeting is going to ask to, you know, to work the answers out now. And I don't see town meetings saying, yeah, it's okay to have unlimited fines.
I don't. So I don't know where that leaves us. But. Okay.
Yeah. Sorry, that sentence didn't have a point. I'll put myself back on mute.
Speaker 2 (01:05:01–01:05:02)
Amanda.
Speaker 15 (01:05:06–01:08:02)
Hello. So I'm going to reiterate what other people said. I think I love the idea of the historic commission. I think a couple of things I have questions about and concerns.
In some of these, I guess my question is when we're talking about that language is coming from the state, but then earlier in the presentation that we're talking about the difference between a state historical, I'm going to get the wording wrong because I don't have it in front of me, but the difference between one that's done by the state and one that's done by the town. So if this is a town commission, And these are town bylaws, then I guess I don't understand why we can't have more flexibility with the language around some of the things that Jay brought up, for example, on the maximum fine. And I appreciate that some of us are more detail-oriented than others, but this is we're asking to recommend language, and I think to Jay's point, where language comes up and we have questions, and it's come up in other places, that if we're not bringing it up now, at what point does it get brought up? Because we're being asked to recommend something, and I think if we have questions around the details about it, then others might as well.
But I guess my bigger question is, it sounds like when we're talking that based on the committee members, and you can correct me if I'm wrong, I guess I want some edification on this, but if we're talking about the committee members, so you have the committee this year that is six members plus alternates, but then the committee changes. And does that then mean that, I guess, where are the, where, at what point are the rules and the regs around, specifics as to what can and can't be done within a historic district. So it seems like it's very much dependent on the makeup of the committee. So this committee might, you know, there is language about color, but this committee might say, no, there's more flexibility around it.
But then the next committee, it sounds like the rules can change depending upon the makeup of the committee. Even sort of that comment about It's the front facing, but then, you know, it doesn't really matter about the back unless the committee has an opinion on it. So I guess I'm just not really clear at what point that gets answered, like sort of where the, you know, does it ebb and flow depending on the makeup of the committee? Does that make sense?
Speaker 4 (01:08:03–01:09:10)
It certainly makes sense to me, the chairman of this, the chairman of this group, not the next group, that the committee, like many warrant committees before this, it's made up of the people who are in the town who have the desire to assist the town. So you want everyone to be inclusive. You're going to try and get the best language in there. To me, I see no difference between quorum and majority.
If you have quorum, you are a majority. That's just the nature of the way it is. But I understand a lawyer wanting exact language to follow through in every exact place. I understand that.
I'm not an attorney. And we're talking about, also again, we got stuck in the conversation about what fines are and what the fines are going to be. We put that in there as general, knowing that the next committee is going to be the specifics on that.
Speaker 2 (01:09:12–01:09:13)
Ron.
Speaker 13 (01:09:14–01:09:56)
I think one thing that could be helpful and maybe make us more comfortable is if the structure are put into writing somewhere. And especially the part where that process where they draft their bylaws gets reviewed by a select board in whatever review process that is. I think you said that Nick and some other folks have told you that's how it goes, but it's not written down anymore. and say the future commission would also be bound by these, whatever it could be, review processes or some language so that they have this.
Speaker 4 (01:09:58–01:10:28)
I absolutely understand your point. When I was appointed and then named the chair, I got zero guidance. Nothing was told. We were just kind of let go and do what you think is right.
And I don't know how you change that with volunteers unless you create forms and everything, which we haven't.
Speaker 6 (01:10:28–01:11:24)
I would just, my question would be, my statement would be to touch on that and also to touch on what Jay said as well about the fines and the penalties. That's really, that's a big deal. I think, so we don't end up in what would be almost a popularity contest and the luck of the draw on who you get to go in front of because you might be having a great day and you don't care what I do and you're not as strict. the next person might end up in front of you and you might have a much different idea and opinion on what's okay.
And if you're trying to price out a project, I think we need really a black and white, yes that's okay, no that is not okay, yes that is okay. And it doesn't matter who you're in front of, what day of the week it is, who's in a good mood, if they like you or not. And that's what I'm afraid would happen is if you had somebody who had any sort of That's what I wouldn't want to see, but I think I like what you've got.
Speaker 4 (01:11:24–01:11:26)
I'm going to answer that. Go ahead.
Speaker 5 (01:11:26–01:11:28)
Oh, no, please answer that.
Speaker 4 (01:11:29–01:11:50)
When you were talking about that, we did a whole meeting on the sign committee. Yeah. You know, what signs can be there and who determines what the right size and all of that. There is physical dimensions and sizes and everything, but then it goes in front of the committee and, oh, well, this has been there for this so many, and I need it, otherwise I can't stay in business kind of stuff.
Speaker 6 (01:11:50–01:11:57)
And that's how you see it, all of a sudden attorneys are involved, there's lawsuits because this guy got it, that guy didn't get it. Right, that would be my fair, just costing the town.
Speaker 4 (01:11:57–01:11:58)
Go ahead, Judy.
Speaker 5 (01:11:59–01:13:47)
To Ron's point and Dave's point as well, this 5.3, it appears that they only have to have a public hearing duly posted at least 14 days, blah, blah, blah, read it, as to the rules. So, the fact that there are town government people verbally explaining, no, this has to go through the whole process, you know, make an article, come to the warrant committee, we send it to town meeting, the Slug Board sends it to us, we send it to town meeting, the town meeting votes, that's a long process. The town meeting doesn't meet more than three times a year, really. So to change a rule seems cumbersome every time someone wants to change a rule or amend a rule.
That rule that we made really not working well. So they say in the comment section of every newspaper in America, cite your source, provide the link. And I think Ron's correct in that, I mean, Nick is great. He's a great go-to if you need a source of information.
I'm there frequently. But cite it. Show me. And Ron's right.
And Dave brought up a good point. And I'm going to concur with both of those that we need to see that in writing. We need to see that as proof. Oh, yeah, this is the process, which could be very lengthy.
A bad rule is in place. They want to fix it.
Speaker 2 (01:13:48–01:13:50)
But I'm looking at what Judy's talking about, 5.2.
Speaker 5 (01:13:51–01:13:55)
Three, I think. Two and three, yes, yes.
Speaker 2 (01:13:55–01:15:13)
The commission may adopt from time to time and from time to time amend reasonable rules. So the commission can adopt rules and regulations not consistent with this bylaw, which we have. in Massachusetts general law, setting forth. I don't see subject to approval by the select board, the Warren Committee on Publishing, as a bylaw.
And then it goes on in 5.3, and it says then, after a public hearing, Dooley posted, they could amend, adopt, amend guidelines that would, for the determination by which they would issue a certificate of, a certificate. Reading this, it seems to me that by adopting this bylaw, we're giving the commission the ability to promulgate these regulations and amend them, the only notice to the town being 14 days conspicuous notice.
Speaker 5 (01:15:13–01:15:14)
So why is everyone saying that?
Speaker 2 (01:15:14–01:15:33)
So then I don't see that this actually says subject to approval of the Select Board of the Warrant Committee and adoption into the bylaws of the town. So if I'm wrong about that, I would like to be made so aware, because I think that's a bit of a difference.
Speaker 4 (01:15:37–01:15:50)
So what you're looking for is the select board to, if this next group, we keep getting stuck in this next group that has nothing to do with me, but I know that we need to have it there.
Speaker 2 (01:15:51–01:16:56)
Yeah, it's like we need, if we're, because that's like the question, like part of the larger conversations that we have is what's the difference between A statute, a guideline, a regulation. You see what I mean? What is binding? What is a suggestion?
You see what I mean? And then a reading of this, of the law, because this is the bylaw. This is going into the bylaw. is that it's conceivable that you could have a commission in town that could promulgate.
The concern or not, again, this is a lot of power. This is a lot of power. and we're concerned about the checks and balances. And my reading of this seems to be that once this commission is set up, that they can make these rules.
It looks like adopt them and amend them as they see fit.
Speaker 4 (01:16:59–01:17:01)
Without the select board.
Speaker 2 (01:17:01–01:17:11)
The way this is written. Right? You know, and if there's like a common practice that's in play, then, you know, like if, right?
Speaker 4 (01:17:11–01:17:13)
A local rule of the town.
Speaker 2 (01:17:13–01:17:36)
And I want to get verification on that. Because that could be simple. These amendments, the commission shall promulgate rules, guidelines, whatever that shall become if approved by town meeting. Yeah, right.
Select that process. Because otherwise, reading this, it's a fire and forget almost.
Speaker 5 (01:17:39–01:18:25)
Right. I concur that clarification. Again, good sources, but we, that's kind of what we do here is the only, well, the real purpose of this committee is to get into the weeds of what's written and what does it mean. We just make a comment at the end of our vote why we came to the conclusion, and things like this could be mentioned in the comment as to, you know, we're trying to find the pathway.
And so we perhaps seem to have a lot of questions, but basically that is the function of this committee.
Speaker 4 (01:18:26–01:18:42)
Well, I think we do have questions here, and I think we have some things that we can correct. Let's keep in mind we're a many, many, many page document. We have a couple of questions. So we're there.
We're very close. We need to tighten up.
Speaker 2 (01:18:42–01:19:03)
Right. It looks like a couple of these issues are just math. Simple math. Just making sure.
OK. Does anyone have any questions for Mr. Laufer before we engage in our discussion? Yes, Judy.
Speaker 5 (01:19:04–01:19:35)
Sorry. So posed that way, would you feel comfortable that Instead of washing this through. we would be, you would be able to, what did you use, tighten up some of these areas and come back to us again?
Speaker 4 (01:19:35–01:20:01)
Yeah. See, I do, I am already set up to meet with some of the other committees and my understanding from Dave right now is I'm going to be talking to the select board. So we, my committee will have another meeting the first Monday of the month. somewhere in this building.
And that's where we'll make the final corrections and then send them. The final, final. The final, final. Final, final, final.
Speaker 2 (01:20:01–01:20:04)
Yes, sir. OK. Thank you.
Speaker 4 (01:20:06–01:20:07)
Can I have a little help?
Speaker 2 (01:20:07–01:20:14)
Yes, please. So do we? Let's have a discussion. We would like to have a discussion.
Does anybody have any thoughts?
Speaker 4 (01:20:14–01:20:18)
Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Laffer.
And your help.
Speaker 5 (01:20:19–01:21:15)
Thank you. I don't know, I'll just throw this out there for our discussion amongst the members. It seems that we would, it seems from listening to the members that we want this document to be the best it can be in clarification. So with that in mind, I would like Would we want to send it back until all of this is a nice, clarified, neat, easy to understand and we don't have as many questions, even though it might be delayed?
until the fall, I don't know. It's a thought.
Speaker 2 (01:21:16–01:22:21)
So it's a good, so I think like what we did the last time was when we said we'll just refer it back. So what we did is true. Tom and I sat down with them. We did have Jay's red line.
We sat down, we met, they went back. And, you know, here we are. And, like, I think Mr. Loeffler said, like, we're getting closer.
I don't think we got to go so far as a vote to send it back. So if we do that now for the annual, for the annual, we're talking about bringing it back, the fall special, whatever, I think we can do it now. I think if we, I think we got good notes. I think a lot of the concerns, I mean, Jay is always very, very helpful with this stuff.
Maybe we can bring Jay in. I think, you know, these are kind of things that we can even do over the phone. I'd want to talk to people at Town Hall about the mechanics of the bylaw. Right?
I think that if we need to put some language in there with regards to subjects of ratification with town meeting, I mean, that's like, I think I just did.
Speaker 13 (01:22:22–01:22:22)
You know what I mean?
Speaker 2 (01:22:22–01:22:25)
Like, this is not just, right?
Speaker 13 (01:22:25–01:22:30)
He seemed amenable to some of those changes, too. But I think he's going through his committee, obviously.
Speaker 2 (01:22:30–01:23:40)
Right. And so like, they're still in a process. So like, if we could, you know, what I saw, you know, I'm going to sort of throw this out. Because we want to not come up with five more things every time we get back.
Because the things that I saw from Jay was the numbers don't add up. 4.1, numbers don't add up. 4.2, it doesn't kind of add up. There was an issue of there's an at-large just floating around out there.
We talked about what is like manner. There's some issue about the alternatives. I think at some point, we're just going to have to make our peace with alternatives, potentially. Max, fine.
Good point. Right? But there are reasons not to have a maximum fine. Like, what if somebody's really messing up?
I can't even think of how you could. But anyway, Ron's point about guardrails, you know, making sure that's in there. Like, what is the overall scheme here? How does this fit into the overall scheme of our town government?
It just seems it's so much power over somebody's life, over their home. I mean, it hits you. Like, when somebody comes up and says, you can't do that on your property,
Speaker 6 (01:23:40–01:23:55)
But there's nothing specific. Everything is so open to interpretation. And my thing is, you shouldn't have a different set of rules than I do. That's not fair to anybody if you happen to the luck of the draw on who you pull, and who likes you, and who doesn't.
That's what I find dangerous.
Speaker 2 (01:23:55–01:24:10)
So whoever comes up with these rules and guidelines and stuff like that, you don't know. You could get somebody who's ideologically out in left field who now wants to promulgate some kind of guidelines. The whole state do it. It's just crazy.
Speaker 8 (01:24:10–01:24:12)
It's tough in Hingham.
Speaker 6 (01:24:12–01:24:36)
I've dealt with a lot in Hingham with the main street, with the pink, like there's, and especially if you try to go to sell something down there, you'll have people like, what do you mean I can't do what? And the windows thing is a big deal. I know he didn't, he was an athlete, it was a big deal. Those windows, the price of those windows starts to double and triple and quadruple.
And then you need special contractors who can install them if there's like, it's, that's a big expensive thing. So yeah.
Speaker 2 (01:24:36–01:25:01)
But that is, like Mr. Laffer says, that is down the road, okay? So what we're doing is we're setting up the overall. So my sense of right now that maybe what might be in order, like a motion to just table this, and then like, I work with people here on the Warrant Committee, you're right, we're not gonna subcommittee, it's not gonna be enough to like, right, we'll get together with them, we'll figure this out, and then I'll bring it back like as soon as we can.
Speaker 6 (01:25:01–01:25:19)
Perfect. And they can't skirt you? I'm sorry. Nobody was mentioned in that language that he had that you just pointed out.
Nobody's going to be able to skirt the Warren committee. What do you mean by… So you had just pointed out the language where it didn't say anything about them having to go in front of the select board or having to go in front of anybody.
Speaker 2 (01:25:20–01:25:27)
And if we table, what's this… All the table means is for purposes of, like, how are we handling this matter before our board.
Speaker 6 (01:25:28–01:25:34)
But are we required to handle it? Are we required to handle it, I think is my question. Like, at what point… Sooner or later.
Speaker 2 (01:25:34–01:26:02)
That's what I'm saying. It's my prerogative of the chair to put things on the agenda. Let us go do our thing. And I will bring it back.
Because if we haven't voted on it, we have to vote on it. Or we have to vote our recommendation to town meeting on what to do. Technically, the old draft of what we did before is still going to the annual, because that was tabled.
Speaker 12 (01:26:03–01:26:04)
OK?
Speaker 2 (01:26:04–01:26:30)
I think that there's time for us to get something here and at the annual. Right? Because I think it's true. It's like, of course, we met with them, was it like an hour?
Like, we were able to meet with them for like an hour the last time. And I think we tightened it up a lot. Obviously, there was work that we left undone.
Speaker 6 (01:26:30–01:26:36)
So you guys already met with them and they came back again with sort of… Yeah, but this is complicated stuff.
Speaker 2 (01:26:36–01:26:39)
I mean, they haven't done it before, we haven't done it before.
Speaker 14 (01:26:40–01:27:25)
I think it was, you know, the great things that Jay brought up, other members, I just think that in our conversations with them, they're bringing it back to the whole committee. You know, so they knew what was, you know, our concerns were. I think they made those adjustments and didn't do others. I think that's just a lack of…
understanding of just the processes in the town. And I know that's what Larry just said, that they were unsure of how this works. But Mr. Chair, I know that the select board needs to approve this language.
And then we vote. So I think it still has to go really back across the hall. And then the order is they approve, and then they send it to us for final comment.
Speaker 5 (01:27:26–01:27:39)
And it's going there tomorrow night? Yeah, it's on their agenda for tomorrow. What's he going to bring? Right.
And I just paused this. I throw it out there.
Speaker 2 (01:27:39–01:27:46)
So I can talk to Nick and give them a heads up.
Speaker 5 (01:27:46–01:27:48)
That they're still at the drawing board.
Speaker 2 (01:27:48–01:28:36)
That we're still. Because what they are going to have, so the select board has to approve the language that goes into the warrant. Let's say that we were just going to approve this tonight. We could have approved subject to the select board, tentatively subject to their approval.
They won't be able to do that. I think that there is enough time. that if we're able to get with Mr. Laufer and his people, make a couple, tighten this up a little bit, we can get that to the select board for their discussion.
They may not, anyway, and then there we go. So I think we're close to close.
Speaker 5 (01:28:38–01:28:50)
So the select board will say on their agenda meeting tomorrow that, It's come to their attention that there might be some language change, so they're not going to address it.
Speaker 2 (01:28:50–01:28:53)
I would imagine that that would be something they would strongly consider doing.
Speaker 12 (01:28:53–01:28:54)
OK, perfect. Thank you.
Speaker 2 (01:28:54–01:28:55)
We never know. They can do whatever.
Speaker 12 (01:28:56–01:28:57)
They can approve it as it is.
Speaker 2 (01:28:57–01:29:13)
They can approve it as it is for reasons that they have. That's fine, right? It's checks and balances. So what I think we'll do is if there was a motion to table, I would table it, and then I would bring it back as soon as I possibly could.
Speaker 11 (01:29:13–01:29:15)
I'll make that motion to table it.
Speaker 2 (01:29:15–01:29:24)
I second. Tim Lyons made the motion to table and Tom seconded it. I think we need to do please.
Speaker 12 (01:29:25–01:29:27)
Jay has his hand up. Jay.
Speaker 10 (01:29:28–01:30:15)
Okay, sorry, just to chime into the discussion. So I mean, as everyone heard tonight, I have issues with the wording. And I think those issues with the wording can be fixed. Yes, without too much difficulty.
But I also echoing what I heard some of my fellow members say, I also have issues with sort of how vague it is. I don't know if that's a deal breaker with me. Okay. Or if it's not.
But I don't want to give anyone, our guest or anyone else, the impression that, yeah, if you take it away, fix the wording, bring it back, I will support it or the Warrant Committee will support it. Because I think once the wording is cleaned up, then I'm going to look at the content. And at this moment, I still have issues with, as other people said, you know, what really specifically is it going to be. I'm just throwing in my two cents.
Speaker 2 (01:30:15–01:30:32)
Yes, Jay. Thank you for that. Reads you loud and clear. Let's start with the wording.
And I'm going to ask, I'm taking your comments here tonight as you volunteering to help us with that. Thank you for your service to our town. I just like causing problems.
Speaker 10 (01:30:32–01:30:33)
I don't like fixing them.
Speaker 5 (01:30:33–01:30:35)
This is your opportunity to salute now.
Speaker 10 (01:30:35–01:30:38)
Hey, you're going to solve problems.
Speaker 2 (01:30:38–01:30:59)
No, that's not my style. J is often our early warning detection system. OK, we can do this by a voice vote. We can do this by the rules state.
We can do this by a voice vote. All in favor of table, say aye. Aye. Aye.
All against, say no.
Speaker 5 (01:30:59–01:31:08)
But you can't hear the Zoom people. The ayes have it. I was about to say aye, but I thought all those people should be included.
Speaker 2 (01:31:10–01:31:45)
The next agenda item that we have, I'll recognize Mr. Callahan and Mr. Jackson. Thank you for your patience this evening with us on the Warrant Committee.
Our presentation is with regards to the… Perfect, perfect, perfect. I want to make sure everybody has it for the Community Preservation Fund. Is everybody got it?
I'm good. You're good? Okay. Thank you.
Speaker 16 (01:31:50–01:31:51)
Take it away.
Speaker 9 (01:31:51–01:31:51)
Thank you.
Speaker 16 (01:31:53–01:32:16)
So I'm Tom Callahan. I first time I've been a town member for 23 years. I've been in town 29 years and live on 16 or no street. But first time appearing in person in front of the war.
Welcome It's exciting exciting Sue in I'm Peter Jackson.
Speaker 17 (01:32:16–01:32:28)
Also, I'm the For the committee. I'm the fiscal liaison between the money people in town hall and our committee. So that's Helped keep everybody on budget
Speaker 16 (01:32:29–01:36:30)
And I am the chair of the committee succeeding Rob LeBache, who got us off to a great start last year, as some of you probably remember this article last year. I just want to mention, before I forget, we have a great committee, Jenny Russell. In addition to Pete and I, Jenny Russell is the vice chair. Joe Duffy, Linda Weld, Ted Carroll, Wendy Garpo, Cheryl Tagayas, and Kathleen O'Donnell round out the nine of us.
A few three at large and six are representatives of different town bodies. I represent the Affordable Housing Trust Cheryl the planning board Wendy the Yeah, Conservation Commission Ted the Parks and Rec and Linda Historic Commission and Joe the Housing Authority so That's the roundup Similar to last year, let me give you just a brief refresher on last year. Some of you will remember this, but last year we funded 11 projects for a total of $1.66 million. This year, we are recommending 14 projects for 1.16 million, so less money this year.
The reason for that is we were working with a little bit less than two years worth of funding in year one because it took us a while to get started up and the town was collecting the CPA surcharge. As you may remember, that passed from voters in November of 2022. It was a town-wide referendum, 62% of voters, over 10,000 voters voted for it, and that's why we are collecting that surcharge, and each year the state matches what we raise locally. And I'll let Pete go into some some of those details But so there's basically two sources of revenue the locally raised revenue, which is a 1% surcharge with some exemptions the first hundred thousand of assessed value is exempt both on commercial and residential properties, but it's essentially a 1% surcharge with those exemptions and So that's the locally raised revenue.
And then the state has a trust fund that matches what towns raise, not dollar for dollar. That match will vary. It's been as low as, I think, almost 11%. In the early, early years of CPA, it was 100%.
It's been in the 20% to 30% range in recent years. And it depends on collections at the Registry of Deeds. That trust fund is funded essentially with $25 and $50 fees at the Registry of Deeds when you refinance or when you get a mort by the house. And that money, as you would imagine, fluctuates based on how many refinancings and how many mortgages are going on in the Commonwealth in a given year.
So that's just a little high-level sort of overview. And I guess we're here to talk about two articles. And I'm going to, and I know Amy Dexter, is on the time accountants on the line two. So I'm going to turn it over to Pete.
I think because in sequence, the first article is the, what I refer to as an organizing article. It's really looking ahead into the next year and doing what we legally are mandated to do from the state. So Pete.
Speaker 17 (01:36:31–01:40:05)
You've gotten copies of a draft budget article. Up until today, we didn't have monies to allocate to it yet because the town hadn't generated estimates of what we would take in in our 1% surcharge. We have numbers now to put to it. And the town has estimated that we'd get $850,000 from the real estate tax surcharge.
The state distribution this year, and they're all estimates at that time, we're using a figure of 17%. Last year, we got 21, a little over 21%. But as we all know, the real estate market's not that great. The county treasurer has told us that it's unlikely that we'll be as high as 20% or something.
So to be conservative, for our budget purposes, we use 17%. And then we also have some investment income because these funds that come into the CPA fund, they're invested and whatever income there is from that investment, that comes back to the committee. So we're anticipating, and again, working with Amy and the others at Town Hall, we're estimating a total budget of $1,050,000 for the committee to use next year. The legislation allows us to set aside 5% for administrative expenses.
The last two years that we've been functional, we haven't used that much. But as a committee, we decided to keep the 5% this year because we never know when we might have to hire a consultant or a lawyer or, you know, some… appraisal expenses or whatever, and any money that's not used out of that administrative expense goes back in to our accounts for the following year, so it's not money that goes away. So we're better off having a little extra in there in case something unexpected comes up.
Then the legislation requires that we set aside 10% for each of the three purposes of the act, historic preservation, community housing, and open space and recreation. So the budget sets aside 10% of our total budget for each of those. And that leaves us an undesignated budget reserve of $682,500. So basically, we will be able to award grants for just under a million dollars based on these estimates.
It is possible that there will be a little money that comes in because We're only partway through the fiscal year, and we don't know really what our tax income is going to be until they close out the books. And even when they close out the books next August, there still might be some lagging real estate taxes. But that's where we are for next year. So the first budget, the first article is really just to establish the budget for the coming fiscal year.
Are there any questions about that?
Speaker 18 (01:40:05–01:40:06)
So FY25.
Speaker 17 (01:40:06–01:40:08)
FY25.
Speaker 6 (01:40:08–01:40:24)
Can I ask a question? Yes. Just because I know the refi market is dead and the interest rates being so high, they're not turning around loans like we were. What happens if we find that we overestimated?
Speaker 16 (01:40:25–01:41:58)
Out of curiosity, it usually doesn't happen. So I happen in my with another hat where I'm chair of the state community preservation Coalition, which is a nonprofit that oversees this lawn has for the last 20 years They work very very closely with DOR the Department of Revenue to make sure that doesn't happen Okay, because they realize People like you on warrant committees all around the state are asking that type of question. People like Pete and I are. like preparing to solicit applications for a certain amount of revenue.
So overestimating is a bad thing in that context because we're getting ready to overcommit. So we are usually pretty conservative and usually they're pretty close also to being right on the point or a couple percentage points lower than what revenues actually come in. But we also the other thing I would say is we have now 24 years of history, okay We've had some bad refinance markets in that 24 years and we've seen what the numbers go down to They never go to zero. They never go to I Have to I don't have the numbers in front of me, but it's basically averaged 26 28 million per year some years way in excess of that but But it never gets really below 20 million a year.
So anyways, that's that's kind of
Speaker 17 (01:41:58–01:43:08)
The other thing I would say, and I think Amy could confirm, she generated these numbers for us, and she was conservative in her estimations also, because the one thing we don't want to do is overcommit. So both the anticipated income from the excise tax, I believe she used 2%. Proposition 2.5 allows us to go up to 2.5 plus new growth. We didn't figure in any new growth because it's not great, but it's a little bit of that.
The state distribution, it's going to be under 20%, but we really don't know. But going down to 17%, again, that's a very conservative number. And the same with the reinvestment, the investment income. If all the money comes in and the taxes it should, that investment income could be more like $70,000.
But Amy was very conservative, so that we wanted, as you guys do, we have to leave ourselves some room. I don't know if Amy.
Speaker 2 (01:43:08–01:43:44)
Thank you for that. It would be a good idea. Amy, can you come on in, please? Sure, I'm here.
Yeah, so can you please give us some confirmation because we're really this is our first budget article in this budget season going into the annual so we're looking at the numbers now and we're anticipating a vote on this Warren article and So you have looked at these numbers, and these are numbers that you're working with? Like, I'm looking at the proposed budget here as a total budget that comes out at $1,050,000. These are the numbers that you've looked at?
Speaker 7 (01:43:46–01:45:30)
Yes. And as Pete mentioned, Lisa Kuhl, who's a member of my staff and I, worked extensively on it last week. We believe the numbers are conservative. the prior year commitments, which is basically what was billed for CPA tax.
And we increased that slightly and then only took about 96% of it because there potentially isn't all collected in a year. And as Pete mentioned also for the state match, we went in with 17%, which is lower than what 20, three match, 24 match was closer to 20%. And then finally, the interest income is probably budgeted at half of what we think it will be in 24, because we don't know what's gonna happen with interest rates going in to next fiscal year. And then to answer the question that one of the members raised about what happens if the estimates do come under, More than likely, it appears right now for 24 that we're going to come in above what we estimated, and that will just automatically fall to undesignated fund balance, which is kind of there as a reserve in case that happens in the future.
If that's not enough, we would raise it the following year. We would have to take it out of the anticipated revenue for the following year.
Speaker 6 (01:45:31–01:45:41)
Is there currently a balance right now of an overage from a previous year, or are you at zero?
Speaker 7 (01:45:42–01:45:53)
At March 7th. As of March 7th, it's about $48,000, and we still have four months of collections on the taxes. So I anticipate it will be more than that.
Speaker 6 (01:45:54–01:45:57)
Thank you. You're welcome.
Speaker 2 (01:45:59–01:46:06)
So this is Amy Dexter. She's the fountainhead of all budgetary knowledge. We're lucky to have her.
Speaker 5 (01:46:08–01:46:29)
Judy. Can I ask a question that may just go to a money question? Can you just explain to me and it doesn't really belong. What the CPD does in the housing department of your, do you mind?
Speaker 16 (01:46:29–01:46:31)
The community housing is essentially affordable housing.
Speaker 9 (01:46:32–01:46:33)
Okay.
Speaker 16 (01:46:33–01:47:06)
So it's housing that's affordable to people making below 100% of the area median income. The towns then have the flexibility to spend that on a variety of uses, building new housing, It could be assistance to renters, assistance to home buyers, but the recipients have to be, and the beneficiaries of that have to be people that make less than the area median income. Median income for the… A follow-up?
Speaker 5 (01:47:06–01:47:15)
Sure. In our town, how do you find that we disperse those funds currently?
Speaker 16 (01:47:15–01:48:58)
So we've only had one year of funding, and we gave the Affordable Housing Trust. So we have decided so far, as a committee, that our best way, because we're not a committee of nine housing experts, our best way to distribute the housing funds is through the Affordable Housing Trust. We have a well-established Affordable Housing Trust in Milton. For many years, they hadn't had, I also serve, I am the representative of that, so I can speak.
For many years we existed but had no money because we had most housing trusts are funded largely through CPA revenue around the state and we didn't have CPA up until a couple of years ago. So now we are we do have CPA and, um, we made a approximately a $500,000 award to the housing trust last year, um, for the purposes of, uh, potential development of affordable housing on town farm. Um, and, um, that is one, um, um, potential vehicle. That obviously hasn't happened yet, but two RFPs have been, or an RFP has been put out there and two responses have been received.
And so, And indeed, those developers, one asked for half a million, and one asked for a million from the Affordable Housing Trust. So the trust is in an enviable position now of having resources to potentially fund a development, whether it's there or other places in town. This year, and we'll get into this.
Speaker 18 (01:48:59–01:49:01)
We'll come back to that this year.
Speaker 16 (01:49:01–01:49:13)
This year, we did something, I think, hopefully that will be good for an existing affordable housing development in town. So I'll get to that, because I don't want to mix last year and this year.
Speaker 5 (01:49:13–01:49:18)
I think I must have missed that last year, like we were on parks.
Speaker 14 (01:49:18–01:49:38)
Yeah, you know what, I was going to ask you a question about the Governor's Stone estate. And I was going to, I guess, while I have you here now at it, and I know there was an allocation of monies last year for the projects you're discussing. from the community. Is there one this year as to the Governor Stoughton?
Speaker 16 (01:49:38–01:49:57)
No. So there is a recommendation. We're going to talk about that in detail when we talk about the second article, which is about this year. There is a recommendation of $400,000 to the Affordable Housing Trust for a different project.
Speaker 14 (01:49:59–01:50:01)
OK. I can defer to.
Speaker 2 (01:50:01–01:50:22)
Why don't we just roll, you want to roll to your presentation with regards to, right? Because then we can get to questions with regards to that, which might answer other questions that we have with regards to the budget article. I don't sense that there's a lot more questions with regards to the budget article.
Speaker 17 (01:50:23–01:50:38)
Just for clarification, we've been talking about this first article as a budget article, because that's established in our Bible. And we've discussed the second one we talked as the funding article. And those are the actual projects we're proposing to fund.
Speaker 16 (01:50:46–01:50:47)
Did you receive the?
Speaker 2 (01:50:49–01:50:57)
You know, I did. Is it? No, Karen, I think I sent it to you from here.
Speaker 16 (01:51:04–01:51:14)
So I can send it to you. What's the best email?
Speaker 8 (01:51:19–01:51:39)
Just while he's doing that, just to update you on last year's projects.
Speaker 17 (01:51:40–01:52:02)
Like Tom indicated, we gave out $1.663 million in projects our first year. Of that, about $745,000 has been spent. So the rest is sitting, waiting for the projects to move further along. But meantime, it's earning us interest, which we always like.
Speaker 9 (01:52:10–01:52:20)
That's all right.
Speaker 16 (01:52:20–01:53:56)
All right, so I'm going to go into the next slide. This is the language of the second article to see if the time will approve projects. The grant funding is recommended by the Community Reservation Committee for fiscal year 24, and it's basically 14 projects for $1.167 million. Next slide.
Here's the list of our recommendations for this year. for the Maytown meetings. Yeah, the Maytown meetings. So we got two community housing proposals this year, one from the Affordable Housing Trust and one from Winter Valley MRE.
And what we did at the eligibility stage, because we have two stages of applications, one we receive initial eligibility application and we kind of Is it eligible for CPA funding? And go through an initial screening, essentially. And at that stage, we encouraged the Affordable Housing Trust and the folks from MRE to talk to each other and to work together for one proposal. And they did.
And they came in for a proposal to fund Portion a small portion of the 36 unit addition at Winter Valley And I don't know if everybody's heard about that but Winter Valley is planning to add 36 apartments to low-income seniors It's a great project Everybody on the committee housing people and non housing people were really excited about this project.
Speaker 6 (01:53:57–01:53:58)
So 65 plus
Speaker 16 (01:53:58–01:54:16)
But what it is? Yeah. I think it's 65 plus. I'm not an expert in the HUD.
It would be the HUD definition of seniors. So it would be a little lower than that. It might be 60 or whatever. 62.
Speaker 2 (01:54:16–01:54:19)
See if we can get it down to 53.
Speaker 16 (01:54:20–01:57:39)
I'm 64, so I guess I got it right. So anyways, that is the recommendation for this year to fund the 36-unit addition. It will also go on our SHI. There's a lot of talk in town over the last many years about how we're under the 10% Goal that the state has set for all communities for the subsidized housing inventory, which is SI GI So these 36 units will go directly towards counting towards that 10% So we'll help us gain make some gains as well The next category is historic preservation, and we funded four projects in that category.
The Milton Cemetery, we actually did a site walk of the cemetery. Lisa Hearn was great, and we're funding a project there to restore some of the historic headstones and deal with some of the trees and the roots that are causing damage to those historic headstones. So that is an exciting project for all of us. They're all exciting.
The Forbes House Museum has came back to us for Year two of the preservation of their carriage house and barn we funded a project We funded the first phase of that project last year and we are I have agreed to Fund second phase. It'll probably be the last phase because we can only for historic preservation deal with exterior and they have to then do the work on the interior, so they will have to seek other funding for the remaining of that project. But that's going to be a great community resource, we feel, for the town. The Milton Art Center Windows Study is a small study, but I think an important step for them in a historic building in East Milton.
And then the Blue Hills Observatory Fence, which is They've done some great work on the observatory and there and the fence is, the wrought iron fence is deteriorated. and really needs some stabilizing to preserve it and also to have it act as a true fence in terms of being a barrier to intruders or what have you. So we have set aside money for that project. Then the bulk of the applications we got were in the Open Space and Recreation category.
This is a very popular category last year and this year. We are funding improvements to the Andrews Park baseball field. We are funding a water station. This was a citizen-led initiative.
His name. East Milton Neighborhood Association guy.
Speaker 12 (01:57:40–01:57:40)
Edamano.
Speaker 16 (01:57:40–02:00:06)
Edamano. Yeah, thank you. Thank you. Came to us with that project.
So it's a water station, water bottle filling. It's the idea is also to be environmentally sensitive and reduce our need on disposable water bottles being used at the park. So that's a, we're funding all of that project actually. Select board has came to us and the town administrator came to us with improvements to the basketball court near the council and aging new fire station.
That's exciting. There's been a lot of talk about. Not having a lot of basketball courts in town, and we've lost some over the last couple decades, as people know, at Kelly Field particularly, so going way back. So this is, and that is definitely a facility that needs improvement because it's in rough shape right now.
Next slide. The another citizen-led initiative, Jeff Stone, came to us with this idea, the feasibility study for a development of a pine tree brook walk, linking essentially the area from, if it, in its full scope would be from the area near Steel and Rye, you know, where the Neponset River walk is in the central lab area all the way out to Yulin Rink and following Pine Tree Brook where we can. So this is really a study to say where do we have ownership, where do we have right of way, where could it be possible. There's already an established walk in the area Uh…
between Thatcher and the parkway, and then on the other side of the parkway through Pope's Pond, but there's not other areas necessarily where you can get that close to the brook. So Jeff has based it on some really exciting trails that they have in Wellesley, and it would be kind of neat if we could see some of that come to fruition here in Milton.
Speaker 2 (02:00:06–02:00:11)
That is interesting. Do we think the town currently has rights of way along?
Speaker 16 (02:00:12–02:00:16)
Not continuously. Not the entire length. It's a three mile length.
Speaker 17 (02:00:16–02:00:29)
Yeah, right. So some places it might have to go on sidewalks around to reconnect again. Or there might be places where we can get it right away. But this is just a study to see where the holes are.
Speaker 16 (02:00:29–02:01:14)
And what the challenges would be to doing something like this. It's exciting. Jeff talked about this in town meeting 15, 20 years ago. And again, now that we have CPA and we have some resources, it's an idea that he could actually get started on potentially.
All right, Kelly Field dugouts, improvements to the Kelly Field dugouts, both on the softball and baseball fields. Conservation Commission came to us with a Neponset estuary study. This is the area off of Copeland Circle. Cortland Circle, rather.
I always call it Copeland, sorry.
Speaker 17 (02:01:14–02:01:16)
Cortland Circle. From Granite Avenue toward Quincy.
Speaker 16 (02:01:16–02:01:21)
Yeah, the marsh area. On the Heritage Hall side of the street.
Speaker 6 (02:01:21–02:01:23)
What's that? On the Heritage Hall side.
Speaker 16 (02:01:23–02:01:23)
No, no, no.
Speaker 6 (02:01:23–02:01:24)
The other side.
Speaker 16 (02:01:24–02:01:29)
No, the other side. Behind the homes going to the river, basically. Towards Quincy. The marshes over there.
Speaker 2 (02:01:29–02:01:32)
The marshes. California Road.
Speaker 5 (02:01:32–02:01:33)
On the highway to the right.
Speaker 16 (02:01:33–02:01:34)
In front of Aaron's house.
Speaker 2 (02:01:34–02:01:35)
In front of the highway on the right.
Speaker 16 (02:01:36–02:01:37)
Barry's sister's house.
Speaker 5 (02:01:37–02:01:38)
Oh, got it.
Speaker 16 (02:01:40–02:03:20)
So this is just a study to kind of, I mean, we don't even know. We actually did a site walk with the Con Con and Arthur Doyle was great about walking us out there and John Kiernan. It's the first time, again, I've been a town resident almost 30 years, the first time I've been out there. It's beautiful, first of all.
It also plays a very important role in protecting those homes right now, that marsh area. They do get flooded, as we know. So some of it is looking at public access. And there's an old rail trail, the Granite Rail, speaking to the previous speaker.
So there is a potential recreational use down the road. But this is just a preliminary study to look at that, but also look at how to protect how to have the marshland help protect the town more. And just Quincy and Arthur was very articulate about how Quincy and Boston have put a lot of money into the Neponset Marsh in terms of studying it and improving it. And Milton really has been behind those two communities.
Account conservation committee compelling argument that we need to to step it up a little bit and do our share to preserve that a very important resource for our town a Quick question on is there gonna be any study to like the PCBs that are potentially in the ground
Speaker 17 (02:03:20–02:03:21)
That's not part of this.
Speaker 16 (02:03:21–02:03:24)
I think that's beyond the scope of this study.
Speaker 17 (02:03:24–02:03:39)
The EPA is going down to Baker Dam. And the select board has asked the EPA to extend their study area down through by the wharf. But out further, no.
Speaker 8 (02:03:39–02:03:41)
Because it all travels in the water.
Speaker 17 (02:03:41–02:04:36)
Yeah, in the sediments primarily, but you know, the further it gets from the sources, it just gets less and less. But this study doesn't look at that at all. That's way beyond our financial capability. One of the things this allows us to do is the Neponserva Watershed Association working with Quincy in Boston.
They're looking at climate change and how that will affect the marsh and sea level rise and all that. And this will give us data and a seat at the table on how they're looking at protecting the marsh into the future. And what's going to happen nearby with sea level rise, because we have homes along Riverside Drive, Riverside Road, that flood quite often now. With sea level rise, what's the future going to be?
Speaker 16 (02:04:38–02:07:00)
So just to finish up, we have the last three are a cluster around Pope's Pond, essentially. We funded last year, as you may remember, a bridge, a second bridge on Pope's Pond to be able to circumnavigate the pond. And these are the first two. Well, the first one is related to the bridge.
And it's a small amount of funding to have a trail extension to go down to the bridge, basically. There's got to be a little bit of path to the bridge in order for the bridge to be accessible. So that's completing that work. And then an accessibility study, similar to what's happened at Turner's, is we have an accessible path around Turner's.
If you've walked Pope's Pond, that is not accessible by any stretch of the imagination. Could it be? This is a study to sort of analyze what it would cost to make Pope's Pond more accessible, or parts of Pope's Pond more accessible. And then finally, the 14th project is Pebberly Park Playground, which would be in the area near Pokes Pond on Sumner Street.
That would be a playground. We funded the initial feasibility study last year, and this is a portion of what some of the costs would be to build that playground. They're going to have to do some more private fundraising in order to complete that, but this hopefully will give them a good start. So $1.167 million.
We've prided ourselves in the first two years of trying to be roughly equal. It never comes out, but $400,000 for community housing, $301,000 for historic preservation, and $466,000 for open space and recreation. That is what we're bringing to town meeting. Judy.
Speaker 5 (02:07:00–02:08:16)
Yes. When you brought up the Bridge of Popes Pond, I had been following the Pope's loop for a while. And coming up in that conversation was when it comes down to the summer end, a house that actually fronts Canton Avenue, backs up to that loop at the, and that people were used, apparently, to just traversing to get to the other side of the pond. Is there anything in your study that will reclaim the narrow strip of land that actually belongs to?
The private owners? No. They own down to here and there's a small little, it's not a whole lot of conservation land that belongs to the pond. But the access to that really like fenced in area by the private homeowner sort of prevents the traverse through on what really is.
Is that going to be part of your study?
Speaker 16 (02:08:17–02:08:19)
Well, we're not studying this anymore.
Speaker 5 (02:08:19–02:08:20)
But I mean, the bridge.
Speaker 16 (02:08:20–02:08:24)
The bridge is funded, and I think you'll see.
Speaker 5 (02:08:24–02:08:27)
We're not going to worry about that bridge.
Speaker 16 (02:08:27–02:08:30)
So they brought our understanding, and Pete, correct me if I'm wrong.
Speaker 17 (02:08:30–02:08:43)
Well, they've got a location for the bridge now, and they're working with the students at Northeastern in the engineering department to actually get the designs and get it built. That, it would be an enforcement issue for the CONCOM.
Speaker 5 (02:08:44–02:08:48)
To identify and enforce. But I wasn't sure if that was part of your project.
Speaker 17 (02:08:48–02:08:59)
Where the bridge crossing, it's not all the way down to Canton Avenue because there is a private parcel in between and the guys put up fences and signs. Correct.
Speaker 5 (02:08:59–02:09:01)
That's, I think, where we're talking about this.
Speaker 16 (02:09:01–02:09:08)
Your venture is going to be closer to the pond than that private person, I think, to avoid some of those issues.
Speaker 5 (02:09:09–02:09:15)
Right. OK. Thank you. And may I ask one more question on another project?
The Peverly Park.
Speaker 16 (02:09:17–02:09:22)
When I joined the Warren… Right, no.
Speaker 5 (02:09:22–02:10:32)
And I was leading into that is when I first joined the Warren Committee, our chair advised us to get out and experience the town through committees. And so I had gone to the very first meeting, the CBC, on the night the Peverley Park moms got together to do this. And it was a great, I was there for two hours, it was a great learning experience. But I come back to the placement of Peveley Park playground because now, as we know, there's the carve-out to the conservation land.
the parks and recs to make the swap, so it'll eventually end up on parks and recs, which is a proper use of park, but conservation land is not. So, to make that even more confusing, where are we at with that? How are you going to do it, knowing that we haven't actually got the stamp on the CONCOMM and the SWAP?
Speaker 17 (02:10:32–02:10:54)
Well, there is a dispute in town whether the land is under the control of the Conservation Commission or the Select Board. And it's been purchased on the recommendation of Conservation, and it was intended to be preserved as open space. And it's been managed and identified as conservation land for 60 years.
Speaker 5 (02:10:55–02:10:59)
Since 63? From 63 to… It didn't get stamped.
Speaker 17 (02:10:59–02:11:27)
Right. So that's, I mean, that's way beyond us, but that may or may not be a legal question. But if the select board wanted to give some of that land to the park department, that would be an Article 97 taking of land. Correct.
So that's not our issue. That's somewhere else. But to all intents and purposes, it's not parkland. It's conservation land.
Speaker 5 (02:11:27–02:11:43)
So to get to putting up little slides and swings, how are you? I hate to get in the weeds of that whole, you know, but how are you gonna erect swings and slides and little sandboxes?
Speaker 16 (02:11:43–02:11:55)
What we have done is we've encouraged the parties, Conservation Commission and the Peverley Playground planners to talk to each other and they are. And that's the best we can do.
Speaker 5 (02:11:55–02:12:01)
But you're allocating the money in the event that there's concurrence on how to move forward.
Speaker 17 (02:12:01–02:12:10)
The CONCOM could allow the Park Department to build on their land, to build a facility like that on CONCOM land.
Speaker 16 (02:12:11–02:12:12)
Not giving up control.
Speaker 17 (02:12:12–02:12:33)
Not giving up control of the land, but like the Park Department mows that now, the concomitants. And so the Conservation Commission could allow the Park Department under a, you know, a memo of agreement or whatever to erect and maintain a playground on that.
Speaker 16 (02:12:34–02:12:42)
Conservation Commission is well aware of this project. We've raised it in our meetings, and we know they're aware, and they've expressed support for this project.
Speaker 5 (02:12:42–02:12:44)
Oh, I thought it was a great idea that night I went.
Speaker 16 (02:12:44–02:12:52)
And so we have not seen anything that raised a stop sign for us to provide the recommended funding.
Speaker 5 (02:12:52–02:12:58)
Right, I was just wondering how that shook out in the analysis, because I know the 97 hasn't actually occurred.
Speaker 17 (02:12:58–02:13:03)
That's not our role. Our role is to review and fund these things if there's other issues.
Speaker 2 (02:13:03–02:13:09)
But you feel comfortable going forward with this allocation, even if things aren't completely settled? Yes.
Speaker 17 (02:13:10–02:13:21)
You feel comfortable? We've still got a couple of years of fundraising and things to do, and they will, you know, the department, the CONCOM, the select board will have to decide that.
Speaker 7 (02:13:21–02:13:21)
Yeah.
Speaker 6 (02:13:22–02:13:29)
I just have a quick question on the Winter Valley development. So there's 36 units, and you said there was just a small portion of it that you were funding, right?
Speaker 16 (02:13:30–02:13:34)
Well, it's like a $20 million project. Yeah, which I know is a huge portion, statistically.
Speaker 6 (02:13:34–02:13:38)
But my question is, have they secured the financing for the remainder of the project?
Speaker 16 (02:13:38–02:13:55)
Is everything stamped? My colleague, Julie Kramer, on the Affordable Housing Trust knows more of the details. But I believe they have gotten the HUD award or destination, yeah. So the project is going forward.
Speaker 6 (02:13:55–02:13:57)
Great. Thank you.
Speaker 2 (02:14:00–02:14:36)
Are there any other questions on, we're kind of discussing both articles at this point, the budget article and the, what should I call it, the granting article, if you will. Are there any other questions? Thank you, gentlemen, for your presentation tonight. Thank you.
Thank you. I'd like to open our table to discussion of both of the articles. Does anybody have anything that they'd like to bring to the table?
Speaker 6 (02:14:40–02:14:47)
Could somebody, if, where exactly is the estuary study for the deposit? I know you said somewhere. I can't picture it.
Speaker 8 (02:14:47–02:14:56)
Grand Ave. You take that right into the neighborhood, you go down like where Barry's sister has a house. It's all that marsh in front of that old street.
Speaker 6 (02:14:56–02:14:58)
Oh, and California Rapids on the other side.
Speaker 2 (02:14:58–02:15:16)
So you're looking at the expressway. You're looking at the expressway, right? It's right there, big hole. You see the bridge.
To the right, there's a march. If you look through the on-ramp to the expressway, there's the march.
Speaker 6 (02:15:16–02:15:19)
Oh, oh, oh, got it. Sorry, I was too far south. I couldn't figure it out.
Speaker 8 (02:15:19–02:15:21)
You're too close to the golf course.
Speaker 6 (02:15:21–02:15:26)
Yeah, got it. Got it, where the garden trust used to own the land before the conservation.
Speaker 2 (02:15:26–02:15:32)
Is that what it was? Yeah, and we had an article last go around about giving that to the Conservation Commission.
Speaker 9 (02:15:32–02:15:33)
Thank you. Thank you.
Speaker 2 (02:15:33–02:15:34)
Thank you.
Speaker 11 (02:15:34–02:15:39)
OK. It's important that the marsh stops the flooding.
Speaker 2 (02:15:39–02:15:39)
Yeah, I keep forgetting.
Speaker 11 (02:15:40–02:15:40)
Better than anything.
Speaker 2 (02:15:41–02:15:43)
I'm always thinking that's George Heston.
Speaker 7 (02:15:43–02:15:43)
That's right.
Speaker 2 (02:15:43–02:15:45)
You want to make a motion?
Speaker 12 (02:15:45–02:15:45)
I do.
Speaker 2 (02:15:46–02:15:49)
What motion would you like to make? I'd like to withdraw.
Speaker 12 (02:15:50–02:15:55)
Oh, did you not want to withdraw? Ask the question. I feel we're close.
Speaker 2 (02:15:55–02:16:03)
I feel we're close. It's going to be like the third motion we would like to hear. Is there a before we get to that one is somebody like to make a motion?
Speaker 8 (02:16:04–02:16:04)
Approve it.
Speaker 2 (02:16:05–02:16:14)
Approve it. OK. Let's start. How about with budget?
I'll make a motion. So a motion with regards to the budget. The article, we don't know what the article number is. Just yet.
Speaker 5 (02:16:15–02:16:25)
Has this come from, been through the select board already? This article? The unnamed article, because they're not numbered yet. We understand that.
Speaker 2 (02:16:26–02:16:26)
Good enough.
Speaker 5 (02:16:26–02:16:28)
Has the select board seen this?
Speaker 2 (02:16:29–02:16:55)
So that's a good point. I don't know. So what we could do is we could make a motion to tentatively approve this subject, too. Because that's one of the reasons why it was important to have Amy Dexter here, get the confirmation from her.
Because she's got the budget there. We have all this.
Speaker 3 (02:16:56–02:16:57)
And then you've said the vast percentage
Speaker 2 (02:16:58–02:16:59)
As presented?
Speaker 3 (02:17:00–02:17:03)
Does that sound right to us? Yes. Sounds right to us.
Speaker 2 (02:17:03–02:17:04)
Let's go with this as presented.
Speaker 3 (02:17:04–02:17:09)
That way, if it changes, you need to read it.
Speaker 2 (02:17:09–02:17:09)
Copy yourself.
Speaker 12 (02:17:10–02:17:16)
Right. See, my motion was the one to make. My motion was the one to make.
Speaker 6 (02:17:17–02:17:19)
I'm back in yours. I don't know. Next time, I'm just going to get out.
Speaker 5 (02:17:20–02:17:22)
So I could make a motion.
Speaker 2 (02:17:22–02:17:24)
OK. June is making a motion.
Speaker 5 (02:17:25–02:17:39)
the two unnumbered articles from CPC involving transfer of funds and allocation of funds. Should I do them separately?
Speaker 2 (02:17:39–02:17:46)
I think we could do together and then we'll do them together and then we'll do a roll call vote.
Speaker 5 (02:17:47–02:18:04)
And the vote will be voted upon as presented and if there are any changes we may have to re-vote.
Speaker 3 (02:18:04–02:18:07)
Sure.
Speaker 2 (02:18:07–02:18:14)
The town vote to recommend. The article's as presented. Thank you for your assistance. Thank you.
Is there a second?
Speaker 8 (02:18:14–02:18:14)
I'll second it.
Speaker 2 (02:18:14–02:18:18)
I'll second it. OK, Tim was first. So.
Speaker 5 (02:18:18–02:18:21)
That was the second time tonight you jumped me.
Speaker 8 (02:18:21–02:18:22)
It's a game.
Speaker 5 (02:18:22–02:18:23)
You wacky one.
Speaker 2 (02:18:23–02:18:28)
So Madam Clerk, could you please conduct a roll call vote? Yes. Thank you.
Speaker 3 (02:18:34–02:18:35)
Tom?
Speaker 14 (02:18:35–02:18:36)
Yes.
Speaker 3 (02:18:38–02:18:41)
Lori? Yes. Jay?
Speaker 10 (02:18:42–02:18:42)
Yes.
Speaker 3 (02:18:46–02:18:46)
Jay?
Speaker 10 (02:18:46–02:18:49)
Jay is a yes. Jay is a yes. Am I off mute?
Speaker 3 (02:18:49–02:19:10)
We'll come back to Jay. Allison? Allison? Julie?
Yes. Kristen? Yes. Yes.
Tim?
Speaker 8 (02:19:10–02:19:10)
Yes.
Speaker 3 (02:19:12–02:19:12)
Julia?
Speaker 12 (02:19:13–02:19:17)
Yes. And Jay was a yes. I could hear him, but it sounded like you all could not.
Speaker 3 (02:19:18–02:19:24)
OK. So I'll put Jay down as a yes. Did we hear Allison?
Speaker 6 (02:19:25–02:19:26)
No.
Speaker 3 (02:19:26–02:19:30)
OK. We did not hear Allison. JJ?
Speaker 18 (02:19:31–02:19:31)
Yes.
Speaker 3 (02:19:33–02:19:44)
Amanda? Yes. Ron? Yes.
Judy? Yes. We'll try Allison one more time. Allison?
Yes. There we are. Dave?
Speaker 2 (02:19:45–02:19:46)
I'll abstain, thank you.
Speaker 3 (02:19:47–02:19:49)
Okay, the motion carries.
Speaker 2 (02:19:49–02:19:58)
Thank you, motion carries. Okay, good job everybody, thank you. So that's the first budgetary vote. Judy?
Speaker 5 (02:19:59–02:20:06)
May I before, and I'll be very brief. On Wednesday, I read the agenda. Do you expect there to be any voting?
Speaker 2 (02:20:10–02:20:10)
No.
Speaker 5 (02:20:11–02:20:19)
I don't think that the agenda for… It didn't provide… I did, but I didn't know if you anticipated that.
Speaker 2 (02:20:19–02:20:40)
The anticipation for Wednesday… Is presentations only. Okay, Nick is going to come present the budget. There's no vote.
We're not going to vote. And then schools comes with school budget. That's traditionally how we go, because schools is such a big part of the budget.
Speaker 9 (02:20:41–02:20:41)
Thank you.
Speaker 2 (02:20:41–02:20:57)
And then we would not vote budget yet, because we still also haven't heard from everybody else. OK? Thank you very much. That's going to be a very big, important meeting.
OK. Is there another motion?
Speaker 12 (02:20:57–02:20:59)
I make a motion to adjourn.
Speaker 2 (02:20:59–02:21:01)
All right, motions to adjourn.
Speaker 6 (02:21:02–02:21:02)
Is there a second?
Speaker 14 (02:21:03–02:21:08)
I second it, Dave.
Speaker 5 (02:21:09–02:21:17)
All in favor? Aye.
Speaker 2 (02:21:17–02:21:19)
All against?
Speaker 5 (02:21:19–02:21:25)
What about the Zoom people? We keep forgetting them. Can they speak as a group?
Speaker 2 (02:21:26–02:21:33)
I'm in favor. Is anyone against? Hearing none, the motion carries. Thank you.
Speaker 1 (02:21:34–02:21:36)
See you Wednesday.