Board: Fire Station Building Committee

Date: 2026-09-22


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:18–02:18)

Okay, folks, I looked around and we had a forum, so I acknowledged the folks who thought of a basis for attending, and we have a few resumes sent to them all. I always like to say that, especially if we thought that the next phase of the last five stations were done, because I certainly think we've done a good work, we'll continue to do so, again, thanks to my wife and me, and I really thank God. Not a good look, you know? I certainly hope that we'll continue to generate resident interest in what we're doing to support the province.

Okay. So, as we traditionally do, after we call for water, we recognize citizens and citizens speak. Do I need a resident's slide to address that slide? No, okay.

Next item on the agenda is the chair update. So many of you here on the committee certainly remember working with Webb Collins. I spent time in a lot of sessions now with Webb's family. He has one son and a daughter, in fact his daughter used to be a member of our select board and she wasn't a member of our select board when they voted to allocate the funds for us to buy the land that we are now building on.

But in any event, I wanted to make sure that I talked to the moderator, and Webb had never officially turned in a resignation. He had indicated to me that he didn't want to step down. But they confirmed his son and daughter were on board with it. In his age, I can't tell you exactly, but I know it's over 90, he felt that he preferred to step down and create an opportunity that we were interested to see if we had

Speaker 2 (02:18–02:34)

some other members of the community that would be interested to know when it's opening. And in fact, we're going to have a second opening with, as you all recall, George Sheldon is about to step down. So we'll have two openings.

Speaker 1 (02:35–02:51)

And I'd like to take a minute now to just recognize. So basically, we have two good, my opinion, two good applicants. And we have two openings, and so I'd like to just spend a minute to recognize you, Arthur. Maybe you can just tell us a couple minutes about the gentleman that you're recommending to take on the job.

Speaker 3 (02:52–03:11)

Yes. His name is David Cornish. He lives in Precinct 10. He and his wife have been residents for a long, long, long, long time.

Believe it or not, he was a schoolteacher at the Dexter School in St. Sebastian's, English teacher. Very articulate, very smart.

Speaker 1 (03:12–03:18)

He went to Milton Academy. He was a year behind me.

Speaker 3 (03:19–04:26)

So you're going to get someone the same age. But the compelling reason is his commitment to the fire department because they saved his wife's life. Believe it or not, she had a major medical event. The ambulance company went to the wrong location.

The fire department went to the right location. The fire department saved his life. So he's indebted. He's committed.

He's a town meeting member. He knows his way around the town. He'd be a great addition. He knows very little about construction.

But process, if you ever needed something written well, he can do that. But more important, he will be part of the committee and look at it from a perspective that I think we may not even have over. an ordinary human being. We all have expertise.

We all have expertise and his insights will be welcome and I hope about that. He's also on the historic history.

Speaker 1 (04:26–04:35)

That's right. Yeah. He's active in the temple. And am I correct that Tom said he lives basically in the Akinson Street by the State of Minnesota?

Speaker 3 (04:35–04:43)

Yeah, he's from Precinct 10. He knows Longroy and they quarreled when He was a town meeting member.

Speaker 1 (04:43–06:06)

He lost by, yes, one vote, but he'll be back. So he's part of the precinct 10 vote. So with that understanding, the second applicant we have, I think many of you know, Rob Lash. Rob is a very active town meeting member.

He has reached out to the volunteers he'd like to join. this committee and again he's in the Appleton Street Planning District and so he's especially interested to see that we get that station done and quote-unquote his words, it's done right. So I think it's terrific. I spoke to our moderator and historically, just to get your perspective, the moderator has to make all the appointments and in fact I voted on behalf of to the top clerk, and then John will be submitting his resignation, I guess, this week.

Tomorrow. Tomorrow. Yes. And then you can, you know, do what you need to do to bring David Gorchuk.

So the moderator was indicated to me, and I had a little history of being a moderator.

Speaker 2 (06:06–06:20)

This is typical dealing with chairs of committees. they have some recommendations in the openings to give that serious consideration. Liz has indicated to me, just let her know, and those will be the appointments that she makes.

Speaker 1 (06:20–09:10)

So, with that, I don't think we have to take a vote per se, but is there anyone on the committee that would have any concerns whatsoever that having those two gentlemen join our committee? Seeing none, terrific. So that was one key administrative duty I wanted to accomplish today. The second one is, with John leaving, we should put in place a new vice chairman.

And the older I get, the more important I realize it is. But in any event, I'd like to recognize, oh boy, you call us relatives. Well, I was one of the individuals who got to serve as vice chairman, obviously. have some experience out of school being a chair.

But our chair, Ryan, kept me in the dark as to who the other candidate was when he told me it was Mark. I said, I willingly and gratefully withdraw, so congratulations, Mark. I'll be supporting you. Terrific.

And I only, not purposely, kept out of the dark. I wanted to check with people. I've had a really busy week. of business.

But anyway, terrific. So Mark, I understand you will be addressing building the rolling? Sure. Well, I can guarantee you'll get the same pay as the treatment.

Yeah, no, I very much look forward to working closely with you. You are an unbelievable chair, and you better keep Good health and I can't get it to the finish line, but I'd be happy to serve it. It's been a number of years I've been on the committee, starting with the headquarters, and I'm excited to finish it off, go 3-3, hopefully win the Red Sox. Go from there, but I appreciate everybody's confidence.

I think it's a great group. Some of you have seconded that? Many have seconded it. All those in favor, just raise your hand.

Against? Yes. Thank you. You're welcome.

I know that we want to focus the time on the applicants tonight. I'll turn it over to Brian Bowers, who, if she wants to make a detour, can move quickly through some of the next items. Yeah, I understand that we have quite a bit of discussion to talk about with that, and so what I'd like to do is to get through our housekeeping business as quickly as possible.

Speaker 2 (09:11–09:21)

If we feel as though the meeting minutes from August 18th and September 8th would be better fit for the next meeting, we can do that. Those are in your packet for approval tonight.

Speaker 1 (09:21–09:42)

I sent them out also yesterday. Let me know. Okay, let's defer those. Based on the agendas, the approval of the better voice hire for month ending August.

Speaker 2 (09:44–09:55)

We're recommending four checks to be cut this month, inclusive of Vertex, And Gene, I don't know if you want to take this, if you want me to explain it first.

Speaker 1 (09:56–10:21)

We're going to get road tax this month. $52,000. Road tax, $132,000. Traffic tax, $135,000.

And the GC, total $801,000. $56,000. $56,000. $986,000.

$401,000.

Speaker 4 (10:33–10:41)

All right, thank you.

Speaker 2 (10:41–10:49)

Any discussion?

Speaker 1 (10:49–10:52)

Do we have any members in the room?

Speaker 2 (10:52–11:09)

So I've promoted anyone that's a member to the panelist there. Rob Labash is on the call. Not officially yet, but that's okay. We have a Virtex team, phone number 617, that may be right.

Speaker 1 (11:09–11:32)

Well, if that's the case, and I think it is, because he sent me a note saying that that's what we do. My attendant chief will require that we vote. So the motions were made in the second. I have to do a roll call.

Brian Walsh? Yes. Joan Shelton? Yes.

Ryan Mulvery?

Speaker 4 (11:35–11:36)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (11:36–11:54)

Thank you. Allen? Yes. LeRoy?

Yes. Philippe? No. Mark Boyle?

Yes. Dean Sullivan? Yes.

Speaker 4 (11:55–11:58)

Dean Maddox?

Speaker 2 (11:59–11:59)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (12:00–12:10)

Paul Cotton? Okay. Next item is recommended purchase orders as well as potential change orders for the project.

Speaker 2 (12:10–12:25)

We'll start with is the potential change orders. These are the random what you'll see proposals here and what our plan is for the next building committee meeting. Our site manager, Aaron, has a pretty extensive FFA.

Speaker 1 (12:29–12:36)

review and it's inclusive of everything that's going to be owner supplied in the building that's not part of the construction contract.

Speaker 2 (12:37–12:56)

But in order to do that, we also need some approvals on some purchase orders to be issued through the town. What we have in front of you tonight is the WB Maison Corp, which is for the furniture or the office furniture, the public furniture, chairs, all of which have been vetted through the chief and the staff.

Speaker 1 (12:56–13:08)

as well as getting soliciting other options for economy to make sure that we can maintain the tight budget that we have. I apologize. It's this one that the header got cut off from WB Mason.

Speaker 2 (13:08–13:12)

It's the one that's stable. That's correct. That's the itemized one that we have here.

Speaker 1 (13:12–13:19)

And this will make up the whole package that we have that we send out that will identify what has been approved for disorder and what is still yet.

Speaker 2 (13:21–14:04)

The reason we're not bringing an entire FFME package is because our budget is tight that we're prioritizing. Real important FFME is part of this, which is your office furniture, your office furniture, kitchen utensils, as well as appliances that need to happen for moving in. And we'll put this inclusive of an entire package What we're asking for WB Mason is the $40,670.59. This is through the state bid list as well.

So the procurement has already been actually done.

Speaker 1 (14:04–14:14)

It's quite helpful. Are you looking for that? No, sorry. We're going to go to the PCOs after.

So these ones are the supplemental ones that are mentioned in that.

Speaker 2 (14:14–14:27)

Yes. I should have just stamped WB Mason on this one because it's not clear. But Brian, just for clarity on that document you're referring to, it's at the end of page four and that's the record page. That's correct.

Speaker 1 (14:27–14:59)

That's inclusive of all of the furniture, all of the mattresses, the bunks. That's correct. That's for WB Mason. That's correct.

Currently right now we have, so we've lumped a lot of things into that FFNA. We have just strictly furniture. We have equipment, radios, security, all of which I believe our total for everything was around $150,000.

Speaker 2 (15:00–16:23)

I will show you where this will come out of our furniture. The next is for Hancock Appliance. This is for all of the appliances that are going in, inclusive of our range, our refrigerator, washer, dishwasher, dryer, the hood. And this is also went through procurement, and Karen did some real good work shopping around, making sure we were getting what we wanted.

And she's also tasked handling this, helping with the selection on this. The invoice or the proposal we're asking for Hancock, and we do recognize as well that this invoice and proposal will need to be amended slightly to make sure that's the time built in and not for a tech staff to be making the purchase so that we can go through them. But this would be an authorization for $18,511 for that. Crazy little question, I don't see a microwave.

So I believe the microwave, what we're doing is lumping that in with some of the small as well as maybe the coffee maker that needs to come with that as well. So these are kind of the ball planks that are going to need coordination with the contractor for installation. So, again, I apologize.

Speaker 1 (16:23–16:50)

It seems like a nitpick, but the coffee maker, is that going to be one that uses those quads? No, I don't think so, no. I'm just saying to know, because in stocking by a patient's ill-being certification, the biggest objection that the current firefighters that occupy that station have is they were so close to dumping bullets that they could easily go over here. So I want to make sure my box is time to go.

I mean, it's on the right side of me.

Speaker 2 (16:50–17:06)

Yep. Thank you. The last single page that we have here. I'm sorry.

Yep. So I was going to ask a question to Cheney or the restaurant for following the path, though. They were alerted at the moment.

Speaker 1 (17:07–17:20)

My question was, had we at the top looked at this, but then I see at the top that we've got to sign off. Yeah, so Karen is, once she vets these out, she's getting the best price that we have when she has the selection ready.

Speaker 2 (17:21–17:27)

She's been having intermittent meetings with Gene and the chief in order to sign off on these to make sure it's what they've selected.

Speaker 1 (17:28–17:39)

With the authorization of these purchase orders, I believe we'll have a final meeting with this before we actually send it to the vendor. to make sure our selections are exactly what you're on paper.

Speaker 2 (17:42–18:25)

Yes, the last page which on the top says NWN is a single page out of a proposal of 30 pages that we, I wanted to just print one because a lot of it was made up of technical stuff that I could provide you in the online packet that you can download. But what this is, if you remember, we took a credit back from our electrical contractor for the networking switch that's going into the building. This is a request from the town IT manager that he would procure it himself. He did receive the credit, I believe about $15,000 from our electrical contractor for that switch.

Speaker 1 (18:26–18:48)

He was able to go out and procure this for $10,329.34. So this will come out of our security butterfly items as well as the fiber connections that you're going to need from the street of our new pole out on Adams Street into the new location line to make sure that our networking is correct.

Speaker 2 (18:49–19:02)

So those are the three purchase orders that we have. Again, I'd like to put this all in one nice clean package that Karen's putting together, but this will get us purchase orders at least to get them initiated and to have them delivered in time for the

Speaker 1 (19:03–20:00)

on both the clients and the IT program. Are we obligated to follow the state procurement law? Yes, so in using the Mass State Bid List or the MHOC, what we can use is the procurement and the competitive bidding has already kind of been done for us on that. That doesn't mean that we can still solicit additional quotes from other vendors.

Some have different manufacturers, some have different, more available than what we can go for. And so in doing so, I know Karen, just what's being put in front of you is a result of several solicitations from different manufacturers and different vendors to see what the best pricing is to make sure that we're getting the brand that we want and the capability that we want as well. So that's where we stand.

Speaker 2 (20:02–20:22)

Ryan, are you looking at all the IT equipment? Yeah, from an IT equipment, that's a unique one where we just took the switch out. And that's because our IT director was, he really was, he wanted a specific model and a specific vendor for what those were that was not carried in.

Speaker 1 (20:22–20:53)

The electrical contractor provided us a change order for upgrading that switch, which was pretty excessive. We said not only do we reject the change order, but we want to credit back what we owned originally and go buy it ourselves. And so that's what the result of that number is. And what number is that third one?

Yeah, that is the $10,329. That's a surprise.

Speaker 2 (20:53–21:06)

Yeah. And I will say, if we just, little revisionist history in order to get this job off the ground. Two years ago, we made some pretty significant cuts when it came to our FF&E and agency budgets.

Speaker 1 (21:06–21:44)

And kudos to Karen and to the Chief and Jean really driving that down to make sure that we're getting as much as we can for as little as we can, but not really sacrificing on quality that much. You'd have some feedback on the mattresses here that weren't very good. So we made some changes with that and the hope is that So Brian, are you looking for a vote to approve those? Yeah, I guess what we're looking for is just authorization to reach out to Town Hall with these proposals here to issue a purchase order for that.

Speaker 2 (21:44–21:56)

And we would execute those purchase orders, release them to the vendor, but then also manage those POs. We would not be paying them until we received the product and now we're satisfied with what was ordered.

Speaker 1 (21:56–22:26)

So, all right, let's move it. I was trying to total the amount, but as long as the three amounts folks got up, $20,670.59, $18,511.10, and $10,329.34. That motion's moved and seconded. Seconded.

Seconded. Seconded. Again, with a remote attendee, we have to do a roll call. Brian?

Brian Walsh? Yes. John Shelby? Yes.

Brian Volpe?

Speaker 4 (22:28–22:28)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (22:30–22:49)

Ellen? Yes. Leroy? Yes.

Mark Boyle? Yes. Dean? Paul?

Yes. Janelle is not present.

Speaker 2 (22:49–22:57)

Okay, next is the larger package of our VCO logs. I'm trying to think of a better way to make this as concise as possible.

Speaker 1 (22:58–23:19)

So we put a cover page on here on what we're recommending for potential change orders here. So this is something that these have been months in the making as well, all of which have been in kind of a potential, then leading up to what we're recommending at this point.

Speaker 2 (23:19–23:49)

We'll run through them. The grand total of these is $27,000. I guess we'll go from an overview. The grant total tonight is for a recommendation of $27,634.18.

And what that does to our construction contingency, through everything that we have approved to date, would leave roughly $160,000 remaining in our construction contingency, which is a good time. So we're tracking some other things that we'll probably be bringing for recommendation, but we're not done

Speaker 1 (23:50–24:01)

arguing and working those prices down. So in your opinion, given where we are in the project, that amount is good? We should be good, yes.

Speaker 2 (24:03–24:34)

If there are any specific questions, I think the one that I'd like to speak to is just the first on this cover page, which is the structural PD calculations. If you remember about three months ago, I brought forward to you that it was just for discussion. We were not approving. There was a disagreement with the structural steel fabricator, and he felt as though that there was additional work that was put on the drawings from the structural engineer.

They provided a change order for over $25,000, which was for the added steel.

Speaker 1 (24:34–24:40)

They felt as though it was not included as part of their delegated design for this project.

Speaker 2 (24:41–25:07)

We had several meetings with a structural engineer who at first held firm with his stance that this was owned by a contractor. Contractor came back with a lot of documentation based on industry standard and what they felt they owned. Subsequent meetings resulted in a potential cost cutting to just under $11,000.

Speaker 1 (25:07–25:09)

So it was less than half is what this was.

Speaker 2 (25:09–25:29)

And the structural engineer felt as if that this would be a good compromise rather than potential litigation on this going any further with it. So we were able to reduce this by more than half. And with the consultants and with the designer and us, we felt as though it's something that we should put forward for recommendation to put this to bed.

Speaker 1 (25:30–25:40)

This is something that's been on our plate for over a year now that we've just been kind of kicking the can down the road. The other changes, all of which are

Speaker 2 (25:40–25:48)

around $5,000 or less are all due to field modifications, additional blocking that was needed.

Speaker 1 (25:49–26:21)

Correct me if I'm wrong, Sean, the gable end blocking, does that have to do with the gable antenna, or is that for? No, this is a clarification for my modification for the gable antenna. The netting wallet is translated up vertically into the gable frame, and we have a disagreement that should be issued by the CCB. They argue that it should come back to item material, which is lower than the original.

Speaker 2 (26:21–26:29)

And I think that goes for a couple of these as well, and SIP modifications as well. Original pricing was a lot higher than what was initially submitted.

Speaker 1 (26:29–27:43)

We agreed on certain type of materials, and this is the resulting of these changes that are there. There's a few things in here that are the result of coordination items that came in late. People didn't technically even change because it was something that was going to be in the vendor for a long time. So basically, you take that, and then you're able to get these seats for it because they're purchasing the rest of the materials.

It just makes sense to buy them all together. So this is the cost that would have been as part of a vendor agreement. So basically, trade-off. Those are the smallest costs that we're covering.

We spend a lot of time, I do personally, setting all these things to make sure I bring them down. I don't see a lot of revision numbers on here. I'm just making sure that it's not in the eyes of prosecutors. I'm just making sure it's back on.

I make a motion to accept this. Okay, motion to accept. Any discussion? Okay, seeing none, again, I move to roll call.

Ryan Wolfrey, yes. John Sheldon? Yes. Ryan Wolfrey?

Speaker 2 (27:44–27:45)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (27:47–28:13)

All right, so we have 80 yeses and one abstain.

Speaker 2 (28:13–28:21)

Thank you, that was, we're getting in the groove on this now, we're getting really quick, that's good. Thank you very much.

Speaker 1 (28:23–28:40)

Moving to Atherton presentation, I will hand it off to Context to provide this. Since we can go over some of the work that the working group had done, also what the task of the cost estimate, we can go through what Context has to provide for a presentation.

Speaker 2 (28:40–28:42)

And then kind of late breaking,

Speaker 1 (28:42–28:54)

Uh, and I did not send it out as part of the packet, but I have taken some of these scenarios and options that were provided by the cost estimate to give kind of a flavor of where we are from our total project budget stance.

Speaker 2 (28:54–29:05)

It's, it's very preliminary, um, and still need some work, but I do want to be able to show my screen and pull that up so that we have an understanding about where we are right now. So, and Brian, sorry to jump in.

Speaker 1 (29:05–29:48)

One more thing with, um, Milk Beast is that we have the final dedication product, Atlantic Cape silage, so we just want to have it. And while I've mentioned this a lot, it's just a bunch of capitals, but those of you in the committee will know that what Paul is saying is on there, and it should be. I mean, people, we justify the cost of the existing station, so it's lethal but not comfortable paying up to that amount for the replacement. Thankfully, it's there for a year.

So this signage you guys have seen multiple times. It's just the latest revision. We only brought a couple physical copies.

Speaker 2 (29:49–29:52)

We made all the changes.

Speaker 1 (29:52–41:02)

The larger change for the plan to pay for it is the removal of the QR code and the wish that in the Middle East scope there were originally two signage that would be placed at that station, found unnecessary on one side, I mean, as far as here, the dedication plaque, it was just some little changes in the wording, and then I believe some people wanted their middle of the short, so we made those changes. I would also just want to talk about, he's built a carriage hall, when you can, drive by and see, you can pull into the school parking lot, to the right of the rectory, go around the back, I think it's coming up sort of really soon. You know, I'm going to be interested, but you may all remember that the community, Week Health's community, they really did not like our original design. It was more of a typical, let's say, brick building.

So I'm anxious to see it get completed and hopefully appreciate it by the community. So we're going to be looking for tonight just a vote to approve Okay, it's been made and seconded. I'm sorry, any discussion? We don't need to deal with that.

I don't think that's a committee either. They just brought it so that context could see what they think. I can talk about it. I'd rather talk about it.

OK. So there it is. Okay, so we reach a point where we want to take a vote. Yeah, I want to go beyond.

I thought we were still voting on the signage. Let's get moving. All right, so we haven't had a motion made and seconded. It's called the signage and roll call.

Brian Walsh? Yes. John Sheldon? Yes.

Brian Mulfrey? Yes. Helen? Yes.

Leroy? Yes. Monarch? Yes.

Gene? Yes. Steve Madden? Yes.

I'm trying to avoid the fact that I do a terrible job. So I start with the first thing, so I'll hit you. Yes, I'm fine with that. So, I want to get into Atherton now.

Yes. So, several months ago, June I think it was, We have been tasked, Context has been tasked to do a couple of things with Atherton. One was to advance a preliminary or redesign of the Atherton station to accommodate the request of the committee, which was back about a year ago, there was discussion in the view of a budget, different scenarios that presented a number of new apparatus space paired with the renovation of the existing station. the original design that we had done had one new apparatus bay plus the renovation of the existing station.

The committee ultimately decided to authorize design funding to put together a project that had three new apparatus bays. We have a A procedure going forward, we're looking at three new apparatus bays and the renovation of the existing building. And so our task was to put together options that explored those three new apparatus bays. During the prior discussions, I think there was a lot of different scenarios, talking about most of them, we're trying to figure out how many bays could actually be stacked next to that original new bay before we ran into Bradley Street, I believe, or Crescent Road and Paddy Street.

So, you know, I discussed the fact that there would be bays that could not be able to exit out in the same manner as the current plan, the current new bay. And then these new bays would be storage for additional auditory and specialty uses of the department. Only one plan to have, which definitely could not be planned to be stored in the older bays, which were not wide enough, not tall enough, not strong enough. In the course of doing this work, the committee formed a subgroup, and Jean and Lloyd were part of that with Chief and Bob, and that subgroup worked on different design iterations to figure out how to make this work.

We looked at the plans, internal configuration, we looked at the site plans, external configuration, and we came up with various options, including whether to exit entirely out to, for the new base, entirely out to Bradley Road, entirely out to Atherton Street, or a combination of both. And ultimately, it was the lower back group and community I think ultimately thought that going in both directions would be the most advanced case. So having arrived at the base, but exiting sort of out the rear, and then being able to split in both directions, depending on traffic situation, where they're sort of at. The direction that you currently see in the packages distributed online and the larger packages in front of you was the last presentation we gave, which is sort of the end of the design phase, which explored three different options.

Two of those options we explored in way more detail, because that was what was originally part of the design effort, which was to integrate the garage into one structure. And so, in so doing, we developed those two different labors, I guess you would say, of how the base would be organized. One of those design options came out of a meeting with the building committee, and it was discussed, you know, what about keeping the original design, but not changing it? And how would you add human-to-robot capability to that?

Well, at the end, we were pretty close to the end of where we needed to do the cost estimate, but we didn't have time to go through the grand design for that. So that rendering that's included in the package has, I think the first option was in there. And the new garage that Eric has attached to the back of the building with no internal coverage. So that's what that…

Correct, yeah. That's not been designed nor is… So that's what that represents. So the real point of where we are today is to determine, from a financial perspective, what makes the most sense.

the cost estimate because we re-estimated the original design. It was the renovation plus that one engine bay addition. The last cost estimate we got was six years ago. While Brian and I did, I think, a good job trying to escalate that for six years, we needed to get a brand new fresh estimate for that.

In addition to that, we estimated adding things to that original design. First was, what if we did detached garage space? So it's completely separate structure, completely duplicated, mechanical systems, envelope, the whole thing. One way of doing that is a pre-engineered building, a metal building, we've all seen them, it looks kind of like, DPW shed or something like that, and then a version of that same type of pre-engineered building, but with a cladding of the building matching up a little bit more with the design from the original after-industry edition.

So lap-siding and types of trims and things like that would make it look nicer, but you're still getting an engineered building with a certain type of structure that's fairly low-cost. In addition to those two options, we also priced out what would be that, what I was talking about before, would be the original design with a two megabyte just added on at the back. No connection from the inside. And then finally, we priced out what's those two different completely redesigned CPOS.

So we actually have six numbers in the package. We did a cost specific, put it in the package. There's six values on that. Matt was a working group last week, discussed the pricing.

And at that time it was fairly preliminary to New York setting, but we had a lot of time before this meeting. So that, I mean, we held a working group, used some numbers that were a little higher than what the department had seen. Subsequent to that meeting, we did get revised estimates and some of those numbers were coming back. What Brian was sharing is that what we really needed to understand the financial picture was the overall project budget.

All we did was the construction costs estimate, and there's other costs that go into it. And some of the expectations around the original budget is that we already are a pinch. The temporary facilities and some of the other conditions have changed a bit. So that sort of looms a bit around what we can actually afford to achieve.

So for today's purposes, the big, I think, question before us is to what level of cost does the committee want to go to to get to the next step? The next step, of course, is to bring this through construction drawings, getting bids, and going to town meeting with bids in spring of next year. That's what our schedule and predicate are on. We have about eight, 10 weeks or so of construction drawings to do between now and the wintertime, essentially, and then going to the bids.

So there's limited time for us to make major changes, I think, but we do need an overall direction. Part of that is the cost component, and the other part of it is sort of the design itself.

Speaker 2 (41:03–41:05)

What are we going to move forward with?

Speaker 1 (41:06–43:34)

Jeff, what's important to me, at least as one member of this point, is we are indeed, as you suggested, with the full support of the tower manager, looking to go to the spring tower meeting to get funded for this project. And so I think it's important to me that we kind of well, the numbers of each option that we would bring to that meeting. Now also, it may get impacted because again, we anticipate and expect, and I plan, to go to the Community Preservation Committee at some point to get some funds. Because in fact, they first went out to the community to get approval to approach the Community Preservation Act, and it failed.

When it went back out to the community, we're making a strong case that look, we have projects like a couple of antique buildings and the fire stations that are gonna get renovated, and this would be a good opportunity to try and sell funds for that. And so, unequivocally, by the way, we did, in fact, when we designed this building, we went a little too late to try to get funds from them, and we were hoping to get some help with the roof, as I recall. But anyway, we clearly, so I think we should always At this point, I'll be working toward what we think the final cost for each option is. And then at some point, once we make the decision on where we're going to go, we'll talk and we'll schedule it as a committee session, what we might want to approach the Community Preservation Committee for the budget.

So I started to see three major components. One is the cost, by far, high priority. The second one is the functionality. We have two basic approaches.

Is it going to be attached? Is it going to be detached? And the third is, and this is in the order of priority, but the third is the design. What's it going to look like?

Are we uncomfortable with what we're moving forward with? And if we're going to change the design substantially, there's probably going to be time for us to go back and do that work, design it. We'll come at some additional costs. The exercise to get to this point was really about getting to the numbers first so that you guys had a chance to understand from an overall perspective how this hitch to the town is going to work in the spring, what number you're going to really be able to bring to that with confidence.

Speaker 5 (43:34–43:45)

Can I ask a question, Jim? This first scheme, you say there's no connection between the bays and the building originally. Can there be?

Speaker 3 (43:46–43:46)

Yeah.

Speaker 5 (43:46–43:47)

Oh, sorry.

Speaker 3 (43:47–43:57)

Yeah. All right. So that shouldn't be a hindrance. It's not a hindrance.

I just wanted to make sure that you have all understood that the cost that we have in front of us were based upon just adding the garage to that.

Speaker 1 (43:57–44:07)

Yeah. And so if we make connections, that's going to increase the cost. Would that be a large increase, or would you even know at this point? I don't think it would be millions.

Speaker 2 (44:07–44:13)

It would be, depending on how far we took it. So one of the big differences between that option

Speaker 1 (44:13–45:07)

was mentioning and the other two design options is that we move the gym to the upstairs and rearrange the program to make it more efficient and effective for the people that live there now that we're putting a garage on the back. The garage essentially makes the gym almost an interior space. You have to go through the gym to get to the garage, which is kind of silly. So if we just say, okay, we're fine with that, we just want to put a drawer in there and put some stairs in there and it works, it's probably a fairly low cost change, there's elevation.

But if we're going to rearrange the program, then that's going to create a positive. I'd like to share a point with the committee and look, especially to our current chief, to see if he shares his perspective. But when we started this project, we were working with the predecessor. And ironically, I recall, with some clear modus operandi, the discussion with him about priority purchases.

Speaker 2 (45:08–45:11)

And, you know, he made the point, look, every time we purchase fire

Speaker 1 (45:12–46:12)

If we're taking one out of immediate service, it makes no sense to try to sell that, because you get a penis part. There isn't a large community that says, hey, I want a black hole, and you can fire it. But conversely, every town wants to have a backup to every engine they depend on. Because like archives, you could go out someday, and it's a problem, and you want to use that backup.

And as he was discussing that to me, and he made a point, which I kind of paid attention to at the time, He said, you know, one of the good things is those older engines, the ones now not in primary service, are in these bays in our stations, and our firefighters walk by and see them all the time. So if a tire is low, they notice. If there's a leak happening, they notice it. So at some point in the discussion, it seems to me we ought to get a price for what the connection should be.

Chief, does that make sense that, in fact, you would want

Speaker 2 (46:12–46:31)

inside visibility to all the bays? Yeah, I mean, it just, it doesn't, right? I mean, it's just an easier work environment. It's, it's front and center, you know, and yes.

So just so everybody knows, we just took possession of an engine probably three months ago.

Speaker 1 (46:31–47:02)

We're taking possession of a new ladder truck probably within a month. Then we'll take possession of another new engine, probably by the time engine two opens up. So then you would look at, say, okay, we're gonna be able to do a ladder or not. Having a spare ladder is the gold in the fire service.

Nobody has a spare ladder. Boston has probably five spare ladders, and they're never in the city because they have to give them out all the time to everybody. Boston is one of the only ones that does have spare ladders.

Speaker 2 (47:03–47:11)

I mean, I get almost weekly emails from other chiefs saying, does anyone have a ladder? Anyone have an engine? So keeping a ladder makes sense.

Speaker 1 (47:11–47:56)

So we'll actually have a spare ladder. And then working with the mechanics, you know, our engine 4 is currently out with broken leaf springs, and it's taking a week to fix that. So if we take a one spare engine and put it in, then we don't have anything else. If it goes mutual aid, you're like, so if engine 1 goes mutual aid, another city, you're bound for a fire.

Now the tile mill is left without it. So that's why the mechanics said, and I agree, and I'm sure Paul can agree, we should have two spare engines. Because when one goes out hard, then we have another one to pull back on. And we've been without a spare engine for several times where we're running the brush truck that you see out there.

We're running that as an engine because we just don't have anything.

Speaker 2 (47:56–47:58)

Nobody has anything.

Speaker 1 (47:58–48:12)

So I don't know if you've read The Brockton Enterprise. Had three engines broke off at the same time. So it happens a lot. You know, Brock Leonard lent them one of the Xpander engines so they could put it in.

So it happens on a regular basis.

Speaker 5 (48:12–48:20)

Because we've heard this cheap a lot. Can we even start talking about the money part? Because I don't think anybody's disputing what you're saying.

Speaker 1 (48:21–48:42)

Yeah, but if I could. The point is that I think it's still this. I want to see it the cheap way. But not if the base containing any of that equipment, the engines, are not connected.

My assumption is they're not going to get viewed as often. Yeah, it's not as easy to check, right? You have an outhouse, like, do you go check?

Speaker 2 (48:43–48:46)

It's just one of those things where it gets out of sight, out of mind.

Speaker 1 (48:47–48:54)

So I just ask the committee to keep that in mind when we consider the non-connective pricing.

Speaker 5 (48:54–49:02)

But to connect those two together, it's very simple. It's not rocket science, Brian, and it's probably not a huge amount of money.

Speaker 1 (49:02–49:09)

So I think we're at $100,000. I think the big issue is that we want to move Jim to the upper pool.

Speaker 5 (49:09–49:12)

Yeah, then just reshuffle the deck.

Speaker 1 (49:12–50:25)

It's not. None of these things are hard. They don't take a substantial amount of time. But I just want to make the only point in saying it was to set the numbers you're going to see.

didn't include that. Okay. That's fine. It's only their estimates anyway.

Okay. So I didn't see the stuff that Brian did in terms of his budgets. So we could look at what you've already seen in the construction costs, but it might be helpful actually to just look at what Brian did because he's out of context in some of the things that seem to have the overall impact. The only other thing I wanted to add here is…

with my motion forward. Thank you, Alan. Thank you, Brian. Thank you, Chief.

This is exactly what my motion goes through, and I'm concerned that we not move away from connected bays and indoor access. Thank you. So my motion is that any final evidence access to those things. So that's a good motion.

May I have a second? What's that? If we have the money. I'm sure we can figure that out.

Speaker 2 (50:25–50:39)

Yeah, that's the point. Well, let's put it this way, Gene. If it turns out we find out that it's so expensive, we can back off of it. But I think it's a good starting motion, especially so Jeff and his team can start

Speaker 1 (50:39–51:02)

Looking at what the best way to do that. In fact, the only reason why we did look at the detached was that the town administrator asked specifically that the committee consider that because it is probably the cheapest of all the options you can look at. Okay. All right.

But we have had, you know, just the final entry procedure here. We had a motion made and seconded that we should take a vote on Brian Walsh's. John Sheldon?

Speaker 6 (51:03–51:03)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (51:03–51:04)

Brian Lopry?

Speaker 4 (51:06–51:06)

Yeah.

Speaker 1 (51:07–52:23)

Helen? Yes. Mark? Yes.

Gene? Yes. Chief? Yes.

Paul Goddard? Yes. Unanimous, okay. Thank you, everyone.

Thank you. Thank you. The only thing I wanted to add on here is, as part of the packet that contact sent out, it was kind of a schedule on where we stand here, and then ultimately we would be receiving VC bids. We've had several meetings with the town administrator about the potential of when spring town meeting is, and whether or not a spec or town meeting would be warranted for something like this.

This schedule in front of you lines up nicely to have a special in the March timeframe, if that is the case, and we're still working with them for that. If things change or other variables come up that we would have to wait until spring town meeting, that may change some of our prequalification that needs to happen, our bidding window that would need to happen. So just so that the committee knows that this is our optimistic pedal down get to our costs as quickly as possible with a potential special town meeting that we're still working with the town administrator on. When you say potential, we have a spring town meeting.

Correct.

Speaker 2 (52:23–52:26)

This will be a special.

Speaker 1 (52:26–52:48)

And this schedule is such that we would have a bid in hand in February, a special town meeting right after that. And that is how we don't get delayed. You'd be ready to do that before the May meeting, okay? All right.

Speaker 6 (52:49–53:09)

Brian, can I just ask about the pre-call? That's a very required and important. That's correct. Time-consuming process.

So you're talking about the week of November 30th, contractor pre-call. So that's when you actually send things out to them. They submit their qualifications to be pre-called.

Speaker 1 (53:10–53:51)

So when we have a committee again, we call them by December 21st. So what we would do is we would, as we get closer and I'll get approvals for this, we would advertise a week prior to make sure that we give ourselves as much time. I think the solicitation is probably going to be two weeks for both. With our estimate being over $10 million, we have to do all the files.

So it's all the files. That's correct. Qualify on some big trades that hit a certain threshold, right? Most of them will.

Okay. All right. So that's a little bit of the full package, the same number of big packages that we got the last time.

Speaker 2 (53:51–54:00)

Right. And I will just say when we get to that, when we establish our pre-qual committee, it's becoming more and more important in today's environment that these pre-qual

Speaker 1 (54:00–54:26)

are done well and we're finding significant, we're finding protests on pre-qualification now at this point which can set a project back. There's been more emphasis on, we'll say, projecting people not qualifying them to now make defensive actions from the contractor. Right?

Speaker 6 (54:26–54:31)

Yeah, I mean, we had to do it for the headquarters. We have to do it for these milkers.

Speaker 1 (54:31–54:34)

We did the, we did the general contract.

Speaker 6 (54:34–54:36)

Correct.

Speaker 3 (54:36–55:02)

Okay. But aren't we tapped out that's going on? We do even have money to pay the architect, you guys. I mean, I voted for the funds, so we are.

Yes. Okay. So all fees are. Yes.

Thank you. It's just that we're going out to bid. With the caveat that we may not have any money in June. And that will be in the midterms, that it's continuing on time meeting approvals.

Okay, that's fine.

Speaker 1 (55:02–55:20)

Just bring that up for members. Do you have a spreadsheet to hand out, Brian? I do not. I just finished my work.

It's not ready for distribution. It will be after this meeting. Okay, we can email it out when you have it. That's the topic.

Speaker 2 (55:20–55:41)

What this is, is trying to put a total project budget based upon those. If you remember my original spreadsheet, which had all of our options spread out amongst what we were going to do, we voted on having the triple new bay, advancing the design, not knowing exactly what that bay is going to be.

Speaker 1 (55:41–56:09)

I left that column in here as column AA, and then I created additional columns, which were the different flavors that were provided as part of the Fogarty estimate on here. So a lot of the soft costs, and I'm going to clean this up to make sure this is clean, will not change. The OPM costs are going to stay stagnant regardless of what the design is going to be. We've carried some estimates for the architects and consultants based upon what their previous amendment was for this.

Speaker 2 (56:10–56:14)

I know we need to give them the important part, which is going to be the construction.

Speaker 1 (56:14–56:19)

But I just want to highlight that we are hearing budgets for temporary operations and facilities.

Speaker 2 (56:19–56:32)

There have been ongoing conversations about where temporary ops would happen during the construction phase. We understand that there may be a need for some temporary structure or tenting for some of the apparatus at that location.

Speaker 1 (56:32–57:02)

So we do have a line out here for $1.5 million. But just for clarification, still Cary College is the location? It's in the discussion. So how I broke these out is in column AA was our original.

I should have printed it out even if it wasn't ready for private time.

Speaker 2 (57:02–57:12)

But for our base construction, this is the estimate that we put together based upon the information that we had from six years ago. We escalated it up to

Speaker 1 (57:13–58:14)

with an added bay, potential alternates, and around $10.1 million in construction. As you can see, what we have for the increase is really on our base construction and what we're seeing. And what I'm going to do is slide to the right of what these total construction budgets are going to be and what they mean. I'm gonna have to zoom out, I apologize.

The first column, AB, is for a detached two-bay structure. which gets us to $11.6 million for construction costs. The next column, AC, is a detached two-bay structure with custom finishes. That increased to $11.8 million.

The next column, which increases up to $13 million, is for the original design with the two-bay garage added on connected to it. So is the $13 million even? just over $13 million for construction, yes.

Speaker 6 (58:15–58:21)

Can you tell us what the number is? And that'd be increasing inflation from the original six-year-old, 10, 13. Plus the base.

Speaker 2 (58:21–58:30)

Plus the brick. Yep. The last two columns, if you can see in the Fogarty estimate, are for design option ones and two.

Speaker 1 (58:30–59:19)

And I know those are the renderings that you had seen at the previous meetings about what those increases are going to be for those types of designs, both of which came with increases upwards of a million dollars on top. on to the existing design. So what we have here is our original budget of construction was $10.1 million, where we stand right now with an added bay of 11.6, and then all of the increases, or we'll call it customizations, of that budget increasing from 11.6 up to about 13.9 for construction. Although at this point, based on the votes I just took, it sounds like we're really dealing with a number that's 50 million.

Correct, that's correct. So can you just be specific, what's the number for option one? I think you're talking about the $13 million. I don't know.

Speaker 5 (59:20–59:21)

I'm just looking at your sheet.

Speaker 1 (59:22–01:00:55)

You've got original garage, you've got option 1 and option 2. Option 1 would be $13.934. So these are construction costs. Do you want to tell us what the construction cost is, Jim?

I know that the construction costs for design option one is 13.1. 13.1? I thought it was 13.9, so that's an old number from… All right, let's stick with the new numbers, but you guys seem to be cushy watching.

I'm just putting up my pictures. Yeah, he has a base number. So I think the issue was is that we got the numbers last Friday and they were working on whittling those numbers down. Those are numbers that Brian has.

Brian doesn't have the new numbers. I'll tell you in one second. Well, I think for the committee's purpose, we ought to think right now, at least for tonight, the worst case for each of these options in terms of cost.

Speaker 2 (01:00:55–01:00:56)

I don't know if you agree.

Speaker 1 (01:00:57–01:01:29)

The worst case in terms of if there's a difference in their estimates. I want to know what the worst estimate is for option one. I have 13,000. 13,000,000, 314,000.

13,000,000, 314,000. Okay, we'll work with your numbers. Okay. And what about option two?

13,000,000, 060,000. And what about, can you just say the original with the garage? 13.2.

Speaker 5 (01:01:30–01:01:34)

I thought you said 13.014. So with the connection.

Speaker 1 (01:01:35–01:01:49)

I have updated numbers that were just handed to me. 13.225. That's with connection? Yes.

I mean, interestingly, there's not a huge difference in cost. That's the impossible.

Speaker 5 (01:01:49–01:01:58)

Yeah. Because it's more square footage. So the square footage for the original plus one, plus the two bays in the back.

Speaker 1 (01:01:58–01:02:01)

The original plus two bays. 12,444,000.

Speaker 5 (01:02:01–01:02:08)

Yeah, I did the math. That's what I got when I did this today. All right, you guys.

Speaker 1 (01:02:08–01:02:38)

I'm not writing anything today. No, we should be doing it with a pencil. The differential is $900,000. The one with two garage vans and non-optional, which is the most expensive.

And if none of the other numbers on your budget have changed, Brian, I think that's really the only difference. So that, I actually know I did this math today. I get your numbers. That's amazing.

I'm afraid that we just, we'll highlight them.

Speaker 2 (01:02:39–01:02:48)

And I think it's important that we got these nice pictures in front of us. I think it's important to kind of keep our discussion around it. It's easier for me as well.

Speaker 1 (01:02:48–01:03:09)

We know what the differences is by these pictures. And perhaps we should, to me, it's not a huge different price. We're talking about, The original was $12 million plus, but of the three options here, almost $13 million flat and $13.3 million.

Speaker 5 (01:03:10–01:03:13)

Between the first one, the original of the garage, it's $12.4 million.

Speaker 1 (01:03:13–01:03:34)

The option one is $13.3 million. That's almost a million dollars difference. Okay. Yeah.

Yeah, almost a million. I'm going to tell you, you say, you will underwork. Yes, I get you. What I think is important, though, is what does that result for a total project budget?

There's a lot of other things that come into this.

Speaker 5 (01:03:34–01:03:49)

But can I ask, Brian, one quick thing? But the project budget, the rest of the project budget is essentially the same for all of the options. Correct. OK, so that doesn't really That number we need to know.

Speaker 1 (01:03:49–01:04:42)

I just want to make sure everybody knows what the total is. Yes, because what you do need to know is there was numbers that were explained in the previous town meeting about what they thought this entire project was going to cost. So these are construction costs. Those are construction costs.

The resulting number at this point and what we're carrying for certain things, and like you said, Ellen, there's no difference in our soft costs. There are differences in the percentage of the contingencies that we're carrying based upon those construction costs. I will move you to this area that I'm highlighting in orange are the three options that you have here currently as it sits now with the numbers that we have. The original design with two bays connected is just over $19 million.

Option one being 19.9, option two being 19.2.

Speaker 5 (01:04:42–01:04:45)

19.9?

Speaker 2 (01:04:46–01:04:46)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (01:04:48–01:05:03)

And then option two, nine, oh, sorry. 19.26. Now what I need to make clear here, this is inclusive of the million dollars that's already been asked for inappropriately. So that would not be asked for again.

Speaker 5 (01:05:03–01:05:12)

Okay, can you just be, I'm a little slow, because I'm hungry. Can you just round that off again? Original with the garage.

Speaker 1 (01:05:12–01:05:47)

19.007. Okay. Option one is 19.963. Option two, 19.262.

Thank you. And since we have these nice pictures, would it be, can someone briefly explain looking at the pictures that Jennings was doing for your office? In case it doesn't jump out at us. I agree.

I've got to go because I haven't been home yet. That's fine.

Speaker 5 (01:05:47–01:06:22)

One quick thing, I think my two cents, I would go with the original with the garage and connect the two because it's the smallest footprint on that site, which is nice for that site, and it's less money. That's my two cents. I think the design is not I don't think the designs are, we have to pick one and then advance it to that more.

Speaker 1 (01:06:23–01:07:38)

Is there a difference in the capacity between? That's what I was going to say, is the programs the same? They're roughly equivalent. The problem, the difference is the gym's on the first floor and there's some extra spaces on the first floor, an option with the new garage bay is added that we improved upon and better things on.

So the gym's upstairs and we make things more efficient. And a lot of that costs come in from the different ways you can do more maintenance. So your original design doesn't have that much equipment in it. The other new designs have a lot more maintenance on them, a lot more clouds on them.

So those are the major differences in terms of cost perspective. There's the maintenance of building plans, in terms of how they function, are very similar between the two design options. The design with the two garage fans doesn't have those plan improvements, doesn't have those efficiency improvements on the layout and the circulation inside. So I think we're going to move forward with that.

I would argue that we should explore looking at making those additional changes, which probably will be added to a little bit of the cost of that garage.

Speaker 5 (01:07:45–01:08:08)

So it could be more design, I know the work group will be in this, but I'm going to invite myself to those as a spectator, if I can't participate, because I'd like to be part of it.

Speaker 1 (01:08:08–01:08:12)

I don't recall we set an absolute limit on the number of amendments.

Speaker 5 (01:08:12–01:08:14)

I would just like to be involved. Sure.

Speaker 1 (01:08:14–01:08:33)

All right, sorry, but I got to go. Thank you. Yeah, thanks guys. I think there are things to be gained by taking the decision of the committee is to go with the design, the original design was too big.

Speaker 2 (01:08:34–01:08:40)

That particular option can keep the aesthetics similar.

Speaker 1 (01:08:40–01:12:28)

I think there's things to be gained by still making the changes to the plans that we made together to design options from the efficiency and effectiveness of moving that program around, particularly since the garage phase now, I think it's sort of obsolete, that old design, how it worked. The other thing I'll say, and I apologize that Helen left, is the same thing I said before, is I think there's something awkward about adding the two garage phases to the back of the Gamble roof. shape of the building from a design perspective, and because of the proportions of it, it is the way it is because it has to house these at-routes, and you can't make it bigger at-routes. It's very awkward, and while we have looked at changing it for a variety of reasons, once you start making the addition the same size effectively as the original building, the purpose of the intent of aesthetically matching it up, Why is it that old one versus the new one?

How much of a mashup are we making? Kind of extrapolating that old design onto the new thing. So that's why the original two designs took a departure. It was really thinking about making an effective split between what's old and what's new.

I'm not advocating that how can we do those other designs that we'll end up back in. Look at how we can make the original design work with these two garage bins. But I think the idea that we would propose is that if people weren't comfortable with those types of materials, the hardy plank siding and the trims and things like that, I think we would still want to make whatever additions we make look distinctly separate from the original historic building. So it's clear what are the newer additions versus the older buildings.

But right now, if we're talking about budget, that's a little bit beyond discussion, we can have that. Because presumably, that eliminates the cost. Well, realistically, starting planks, siding, these trends, that's a generally cheaper construction than the brick and the glass that we've been using. And that's why you see in these costs, it's driving most of the cost of our show.

And so you have a pretty good perspective of what your high and your low average price you might end up paying. So if we make the changes we need to make to the design of the two garage bays out there on the back. It's going to come up a little bit. If we keep the materials the same, it's not going to get to the same cost as those two design alternatives.

We'll change the materials and it'll be in the neighbourhood of those two design alternatives. But I don't think we'll be going, I doubt if I know, we'll be going beyond that $900,000 gap. For me, I'm confused a little bit by the pictures that I was hoping to provide to the patient. So again, we start with original with your eyes and option one, option two.

If I look to the far right, pictures that look foreign to me, I don't know. What am I looking at in option one, the far right pictures? Do you have that page in front of you? Yes.

And so each of these in the column are the same view point for each? No, you were having the far right image on the top. It's the same view point as the middle. It's the same view point as the far right.

Well, it's quite a bit different. I heard what you just said.

Speaker 3 (01:12:28–01:12:38)

But optically, it's hard to surprise. The scale to it is so different from the top. Of course, the architects will pick up on this.

Speaker 1 (01:12:38–01:12:52)

There's a limitation to what the software we're using and how we're using it to get the exact, literal, perfect perspective point. But generally, it's the same. There is some difference. Taylor will tell you all about this.

Speaker 2 (01:12:53–01:13:06)

But we're trying to make it as close as possible. one and option two are about $250,000.

Speaker 1 (01:13:06–01:13:57)

Those two options kind of get together in that you're looking at the original design attached garage and option one and option two, it's kind of two sides of a scale. Because those costs are kind of the same, can be worked through and the materials can be worked through to kind of bring them together. So what is the intent of this discussion? So you heard the discussion about the schedule.

And so I would say that if we don't yet have a consensus on what we want as a design, and where work is going to be needed, two things have to happen. One, we have to add that time into the schedule to accommodate that additional work. And there's going to be some added costs to do that.

Speaker 6 (01:14:00–01:14:24)

So is it up to the working group to sort of cook this up and say, this is what we want to do? Or is it? So now we're into the committee. So I mean, Ellen was pretty clear that the original with the garage was her preference, I believe.

Speaker 1 (01:14:26–01:14:37)

you know, the massing of the rear garages under the original is much less and therefore cost less.

Speaker 6 (01:14:38–01:14:46)

Well, I mean, look at the size of the, and I'd be curious to hear the historic, the historic folks and the Pinewood folks in here.

Speaker 1 (01:14:46–01:15:16)

I think they've had a chance to see, sorry. So it would be great to hear know, their perspective as well. But, you know, I think that if we want to advance, just to give the design team some direction so they can keep them going, that the original with the garage.

Speaker 6 (01:15:16–01:15:22)

Option one is a million dollars more. Because I mean, look at the additional massing and size of the square footage.

Speaker 1 (01:15:22–01:16:37)

No, option one is not a million dollars, the original garage. Well, the original was $19,900. And this, no, $19,900. And this is $19,600.

$19,600. I'm sorry. That's just about a million dollars more. Yeah.

So the other thing to keep in mind for the original design, we had the garage phase and garage phase attitude that the rendering is because of the way aesthetically it's treated. That stair that you're looking at, the vertical dormer thing has white painting on it, and various views looking out of the freeway. Everything including that to the back of the building is all new additions to the outage in the building. It stops for that old stonework stuff.

That's part of what's happening with this visual, trick that's being played. The other new design options change the style so much. It's much more obvious, various changes, and the massing kind of looks differently, whereas even in the old original one, we're still a three-story addition to the back of that original building. Well, I have some basic questions that I feel stupid for asking you, but go on.

I'm looking at option, the top one, original with the garage.

Speaker 2 (01:16:39–01:16:46)

When I look at Atherton Streets, I may have had Both are not big enough to accommodate fire equipment in the future, right?

Speaker 1 (01:16:46–01:17:30)

And as a cellar below it would be a good way. When I'm looking at an original garage, are there in fact three more bays? Yeah, there are. In the back, first of all.

No, one is to the side. Yeah, and two are in the back of the house. In the back of the house. Yeah, and two are in the back of the house.

Yeah, and two are in the back of the house. Yeah, and two are in the back of the house. Yeah, and two are in the back of the house. Yeah, and two are in the back of the house.

Yeah, and two are in the back of the house. Yeah, and two are in the back of the house. Yeah, and two are in the back of the house. Yeah, and two are in the back of the house.

Yeah, and two are in the back of the house. Yeah, and two are in the back of the house. Yeah, and two are in I see it now, spin all the way around, you get to the back. The butt side right here, you have two of these, 14 raised, you got one, two, three, and this is the abdomen.

See at the mid-side, that's the abdomen. You have the front there, but it's in the same space. You got original, original, abdomen. Actually, you can follow this.

Speaker 2 (01:17:31–01:17:41)

And then on the baby, you got original, original, abdomen, original, abdomen. Back, you've got the abdomen.

Speaker 1 (01:17:41–01:18:03)

You have the same vision, and I need to look like you. That's the reason I was looking at these two bays. Are there any other schemes that have two? All of them have three.

Speaker 3 (01:18:03–01:18:23)

Two new bays that roll out onto Blue Willow Avenue. Okay, so everybody has one. Everyone who schemes, it's just a question whether they have two in the back or three in the back. All of them have two in the back.

So we're adding three bays, period, and intersection. All of them have the same period.

Speaker 1 (01:18:23–01:19:42)

But earlier in the meeting, they had stopped it. I understand. I understand. and the approach you were taking was they could go even.

Is that correct? Yeah. I don't think we need to spend time with the site plan, but I just want to make sure everybody's aware that also comes with a cost. Going in both directions requires some retaining walls and some other things to make the grades work.

Is there a cheaper direction that at some point you could share with us? Gravity is probably a little cheaper than Afton, but it really would require you to point the garage beds in that direction. and only exclusively go out in that direction. And I think, you know, there's several hundred thousand dollars worth of propane walls that we could probably attribute to the ability to go in both directions.

And I think it's, you might say it's probably worth it to have that long-term. Well, I don't know. I wanted to suggest that maybe when you said, when it was discussed earlier, on Atkinson Street, there's a child care, little children center. And it seems to me it would make more sense for fire engines to come out the other street and not have to worry about what if it's a change then?

No?

Speaker 6 (01:19:43–01:19:56)

You don't think so, John? We love this. Don't blow it up and start telling us to go out on the Athens street. Well, no, he's saying that the two bays of the back can go out on the Athens street.

Terrific! That's exactly what we're talking about.

Speaker 1 (01:19:57–01:20:23)

And go either way, so the question is, and this is across the boat, so which one? And I'm wondering if we should have some preference because of the little children, et cetera. I'd hate to see us, the fire engines, running out right when this start of day or end of day, or is that something not to worry about? I think that's something that you don't have to worry about.

Okay, the chief said that, I believe.

Speaker 6 (01:20:25–01:20:33)

The original with garage scheme. How historic is the work of the new, of the new work?

Speaker 3 (01:20:33–01:20:36)

Are we going to get cedar shakes on that as well?

Speaker 1 (01:20:36–01:20:57)

We weren't, no. No, when we had presented that and worked with the historic commission on that, that, there was, you know, we're doing a hardy plank. Okay. Okay.

It was actually a nickel gap. We went through all the materials. Okay. I mean, the matching is great.

Speaker 3 (01:20:58–01:21:09)

The image looks wonderful. It just looks like whatever you did on the original building is carried through on the new.

Speaker 1 (01:21:09–01:21:20)

I mean, it's just exceedingly expensive. The material of the original building are going to be different than the original building.

Speaker 2 (01:21:24–01:21:31)

Yeah, okay. But they're intentionally different trees. Right.

Speaker 1 (01:21:31–01:21:36)

That's going to come up. Yeah. So they may have probably already tested it.

Speaker 2 (01:21:36–01:21:40)

It's not there, and it may look like it's not there.

Speaker 1 (01:21:40–01:24:17)

So the driver in the back is very difficult because of the shape of the gambrel, and the fact that it's three stories, and the side of the window tree that's there, so adding any type of a roof with volume, first of all, makes the building very difficult to have windows and things like that, but also, it looks like you just took the big version and stripped it down, and it looks like a bad housing development. So that's how we did it without an actual extruder on it, because we thought, you know, it's from a historic perspective, treatment or parapet style treatment to it than an actual roof volume somehow. Did you guys have anything like looking at it from the ground down? Down in the street side with the multiple doors and on the floor?

Just to break up the box, you can take a flat roof. That's all it's going to be. If, you know, you incorporate steel, you have all these nice… It would require a bigger roof line.

No, I understand that. Yeah, sure. The last one. It's in everybody's preference to get this done sooner rather than later.

We have the interesting and good advantage of two members of Southland Court and a member of our historic commission here. I'd like to hear their thoughts on these documents that you're presenting, if you're okay with providing them.

Speaker 5 (01:24:17–01:25:44)

That's okay. I'm Cheryl Togayes, and I'm a member of the planning board, and I'm an architect by day. And I appreciate the opportunity to speak with you, Brian, and thank you for all your work. Since you asked, and this is the first I'm seeing it at this meeting, but I did look at the prior set of proposals.

And I think the options one and two have similar characteristics to the prior ones, which had concerned me. And the reason they concern me is the amount of volume that was being needed or created because you're connecting these different levels, but you only need a one level program. So you were building so much more roof and so much more volume than you really need. And that then starts to dominate the entire building for a program that I didn't see necessary on the second floor.

the original with the garage in the back I think could use a little more design work to achieve some of the things that I think you folks are talking about programmatically and I think also a little bit architecturally. So I like it better because it downplays that piece in the back architecturally. So it doesn't take away from the original architecture so much. I think the two, option one and two take away because it's just so big.

So that's my

Speaker 1 (01:25:45–01:25:57)

So just for a layman who's not an architect, if I hear you say of the three options, aesthetically or the look, whatever you like option. The top.

Speaker 5 (01:25:59–01:26:16)

And it's because the scale, Brian. It's not that you're adding that much new use on top of the garage, but you look like you are. in what's called option one and option two. And this has to do with the roof line.

Speaker 1 (01:26:17–01:26:20)

I just want to make sure I understand.

Speaker 5 (01:26:20–01:26:38)

And, you know, whether there's further design work on the materials, whether you need two materials back there, I think those are things that you can continue to look at. But I like that approach better from a volumetric and leaving the original fire station a little bit more prominence.

Speaker 1 (01:26:39–01:26:52)

I'm going to ask you to comment. Steve O'Donnell, Historical Commission.

Speaker 3 (01:26:55–01:27:19)

I have decided to show on whatever comes as close to the original plan as possible. How many years ago you gentlemen met with the Historical Commission before any of the stations were begun and the design really favored by the historical commission because of the sensitivity that was given to the original building.

Speaker 1 (01:27:20–01:27:51)

And yes, that extra day on the side, which was pushed back from the front, which again, show sensitivity to the building. The two-car garage is not a thing of beauty for sure, but it is new construction attached to an existing building. And very often, there needs to be a difference to establish that. Now, as Cheryl said, maybe there could be some design elements added there.

Speaker 2 (01:27:51–01:28:00)

But when you look at the front of the building, it highlights the building.

Speaker 3 (01:28:01–01:28:14)

The whole purpose in your going through this struggle with adding is to preserve the building. And if you're going to push out the second floor with a standing scene roof, which, like, really?

Speaker 1 (01:28:14–01:28:16)

This is a 19th century building.

Speaker 3 (01:28:17–01:28:34)

And, you know, option one, the sloped roof to the side looks like a camp out of the 1950s attached to a 19th century building. I would have to personally,

Speaker 1 (01:28:35–01:28:41)

Pretty sure the commission would definitely favor the top row of the original with the garage.

Speaker 7 (01:28:42–01:29:44)

Meredith? I really, I would agree with both. The original design is what we, that I sit on the planning board and the historical commission, and you all have done such a wonderful job, you know, working with our boards and committees. We all unanimously felt like this really modernizes a building, but protects the character of the neighborhood, of the building, and it accomplishes both.

The only comment that I've made, that when you first came to the Historical Commission, is with the ship, the quarter gap, I don't know, not sure, nickel gap siding, that maybe you look at more of the color palette of the stone, and maybe soften it a little bit, maybe a little bit more of grayer, but pulling out from the color of the stone and the shingle style. This, I'm afraid, is going to look like, you know, you're putting something.

Speaker 1 (01:29:44–01:29:46)

That's not for this project. That's for the Golden East project.

Speaker 7 (01:29:47–01:29:58)

That's for the East project. Okay. Because I've seen the original. A darker color palette is all the other.

So we just blend a little bit more.

Speaker 1 (01:29:58–01:30:28)

I think that the, because we put this project on hold so many years ago, Coming back to it, the design team all had a similar feeling. The stone, the colors on the stone there, it's going to be picked up better in the coloring of whatever we're doing. In fact, it came up early on when we showed the committee some brand new renderings of it. I think if they invented more modern design, a lot of the reaction was it was so different color-wise that it was too much of a departure, so I can mention.

Speaker 7 (01:30:29–01:30:47)

That's great. Yeah, thank you. So I think the original, I think it was a great design I have had people approach me with concerns of option one and two, who've watched the meetings and just said, what is the planning board doing about this? And so that's, we just want to be here and just excited to see this get to the finish line.

Speaker 1 (01:30:48–01:31:55)

I think to build on the point you're making, and also what Steve made, is, you know, as I drive around any community, and there are a lot of wealthy communities around that Bill will be happy to compare ourselves to, I don't recall ever seeing another play station with those rock wall, that whole look and the bell tower. Am I missing, are there any out there? I mean, I'm not aware. It just, it has a unique character.

I can't put this out. In that spirit, I move that the committee approve the original. The top row. That's what the title is for.

I second that motion. I can't. Okay, the motion's passed. How about a discussion?

Not a concern. Not a concern at all, just underscoring the fact that we will add time and some costs to work on that, because to the point that we're in, there's zero design that's gone into that one so far, so we do have to put design time into it to get to the point where we're ready to go with the series. So the schedule was to start construction drawings basically next week.

Speaker 3 (01:31:55–01:31:56)

On which?

Speaker 1 (01:31:57–01:32:07)

On 1 or 2? Whatever. We set that schedule before we came up with design. That was based on the town meeting date.

in order to make the town meeting, we wanted to start CDs next week.

Speaker 6 (01:32:07–01:32:13)

So we're gonna have to- Your point about additional, that would be the same case for if we were favoring option one or two.

Speaker 1 (01:32:13–01:32:33)

No, option one and two was planned to go right into CDs. We would take those designs, because for the most part, we already had relatively ready to go designs on the existing building. So we were, we had to spend our time working with the team to get them ready to the point that we couldn't bring those into CDs.

Speaker 6 (01:32:33–01:32:37)

Even though we hadn't approved the final?

Speaker 1 (01:32:37–01:33:51)

Yeah, that was the whole point of this sort of redesign phase, was to get you to the point where you were ready to make a decision and then go right into CDs. Because we had so much work. Well, I guess as long as we could take this to lab, we wouldn't have a lot of time. A normal design process might be eight, nine months.

And we had to do, after 10, the redesign and everything all in a very compressed time. So we were planning on skipping a bunch We have to kind of spend some time redesigning this. I'm going to guess it's at least six weeks to do that. You know, we meet monthly.

So, you know, I don't know how many meetings you want to go with this, but I'm sure it's going to at least be one. Yeah, I would say I think this committee is willing to put in extra meetings. And so those are the only two things. One, we just have some more time for it, and we'll have to think about how it impacts the special town meeting and where that data falls.

And two, we just need a little bit more money to do that. In terms of impacting the special town meeting, if you, Brian, could give me a perspective of when in a perfect world you'd like to see that special town meeting, I'll work with the town administrator to try to push heavy in the Warren Committee so we can

Speaker 2 (01:33:52–01:34:00)

So, they get a call. Yeah, I think Brian that schedule we put together. Is that right? Yeah.

Speaker 1 (01:34:00–01:35:23)

So that puts us at the end of March. Maybe 1st week of April. 6 weeks of continued design work. That would be the final bit.

The final bit. So the point there is if we go that far, I mean, people that are closest to our meeting, a lot of people here are, we might be better off just going to a regular town meeting in May. I mean, that's certainly a good conversation. I don't know what you would say about it, but I think six weeks is probably the shortest amount of time we can things together to get it back to this level.

And the shortest amount of time I want to put the table off so we don't have an impact without meeting cadence. So I think you need to do your best work as quickly as you can with one cutting point. And when you are ready, And the schedule, whatever the schedule is, if we have to go to annual town meeting, if we're talking about late March, then two minutes late to annual town meeting.

Speaker 2 (01:35:23–01:35:27)

I don't want the how to pay to call a special account meeting.

Speaker 1 (01:35:28–01:36:23)

It is extra money if we're only within a number of weeks. Yeah, no, no, no. I get that. So we're, Good discussion.

We're discussing a motion to make, and seconded for the committee to accept the original garage design of the park. Is there any more discussion on that? Because I've got to go to a vote. My only discussion is to thank the representatives of the Planning Board.

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. That was very helpful. And they put in a lot of our voices.

Okay, no other discussions? I'll move to a vote, but we still have remotes, so we have a roll call. Brian, again, this is to accept the original with garage design. Is that you?

And Brian is me. Yes. Good job, Michelle. Yes.

Yeah, Brian, to this place. Brian Moultrie.

Speaker 2 (01:36:24–01:36:26)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (01:36:26–01:36:43)

You? Caroline, I won't mock her, she's not here, but she clearly was in favor of that design. Yes. Yes.

Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

Yes. Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:36:44–01:36:46)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (01:36:48–01:38:37)

Yes. Why, was there anything else that you wanted to talk to us about? No. Yeah, let's do that.

Next standard meeting would be on the 20th. When's our next working group meeting? So I think there's two things going on. We had the working group meeting, but I heard in this meeting that we were going to plan the working group meeting to just be an informal committee meeting.

I have to post the most for our discussion with it, so I think it's fine to keep them as a working group and anyone can actually attend them. Yeah, please consider that invitation. Well, if we get closer, right? Just a little competition.

If we have a forum, if we have a meeting, if we have a book, that could be a good idea. I think so. Laura, you said it's not, but it is public.

Speaker 2 (01:38:37–01:38:45)

It's public, but it's not right. It's not to be rightful. So I think we could accommodate.

Speaker 1 (01:38:45–01:41:17)

So I think it's fine. Okay. So we're talking the 20th of October? I think we're going to want to change the date.

It's the 22nd now, and we might want to meet in… What do you think, Taylor? Two weeks? Do you want to do three weeks?

We can do that for the 13th. My only thing is we may need to hold a remote hybrid meeting after that if the invoices and housekeeping things aren't done for East that we would hold a room meeting at the end of the month. I think we can do that. I mean, you should be invited.

They're saying the 13th. And again, I mean, to me, the priority is doing the best work and now that's the main focus. We'll accommodate remote meetings if we have to approve budgets. Okay.

So we'll plan for the 13th. I will be eating remote into that meeting. Carol will be here in person. Okay.

I'll be there virtually. Oh, okay. Right. I think that's the Tuesday right after Columbus Tech.

It is. You know, it's interesting, though. There's one thing I'd like to check about. We meet on Tuesdays.

I had a sidebar with Chi. The select pool meets on Tuesdays. They're not there. That's the second pool?

I think they're usually the second, right? But every once in a while, we do second floor. I'd like to make sure that we're not possibly putting John, our new representative from the select board, in a position where he cannot attend our meetings, which is what happened tonight, Bob. And so I don't know if that means we just lock him with the dates.

Do it Wednesday. Huh? Do it Wednesday. Well, that's exactly where I'm hoping this conversation will go.

Does anyone have any sense of the guy who's leaving? Right, exactly. We know where he lives still. Actually, we don't.

I generally don't have a complex number of states. Brian Poole? It should be okay.

Speaker 6 (01:41:18–01:41:22)

Which one? It's 13 or 14. Wednesday the 14th.

Speaker 1 (01:41:22–01:42:09)

Okay. In general, it's just that then? Well, there's nothing magical about that particular. Does Thursday work for that week?

No, not for me. No. That's what I'm going to call it. Well, that's the second Tuesday and then we can figure out whether Mr.

Driscoll can make that meeting. Well, I'm fairly certain if the Select Board is meeting, he cannot. That would be the point. I like that.

I'd like to not go a full month. We want to do this after doing stuff, so if we can't do it on the 13th, then how do we propose to do it?

Speaker 2 (01:42:09–01:42:13)

Well, you know what? No. But you can do the 14th.

Speaker 1 (01:42:13–01:43:27)

I have a calendar. Let's do the 13th. I'll speak to John and see if he can tell him where we are. I don't have the materials out in advance.

Yeah. So we'll plan on the 13th, right? Yeah, that's fine. And then for a Friday working, what time does that work for?

What's best for you, Laura? I'm flexible, but the conflict, I was traveling. I just understood. You guys all moved up earlier.

So probably started on the second. Yeah. Sounds like it. I still have a schedule.

And I had a schedule for nine. So I'm good with nine. Still a good nine. I think you published the working group?

Yeah. Oh, I think we accomplished a lot by now. And so I would say the most, which is non-native. So move.

Second? Second. Second. Second.

Brian Poultry.

Speaker 2 (01:43:29–01:43:30)

Yes.

Speaker 1 (01:43:30–01:43:41)

Thank you. There's no one else who voted. No. I haven't announced the rule yet.

We are here and so it's thank.