Board: Planning Board

Date: 2025-06-26


Transcript

Auto-generated; may contain errors.

Speaker 1 (00:22–00:59)

Good evening and welcome to the 51st meeting of the fiscal year 2025 of the Milton Planning Board. I would like to now call the meeting to order and begin by introducing the members here this evening and our staff. This evening, we do not have Sean Fahey or Jim Davis, so it'll be the three of us here in person. If you'd like to introduce yourself, Cheryl.

Yes, Cheryl Tagaya, Secretary. Meg Yieldfield, Member. And Meredith Hall, serving as chair. And on Zoom tonight, we have our staff.

We have Cheyenne. Cheyenne Frazier, assistant director of PLANET. Great. And Julia?

Speaker 2 (01:00–01:01)

Julia Getman, clerk.

Speaker 1 (01:02–01:44)

Great. Thank you. We can begin with the administrative items. Cheryl had said over one set of minutes, but we're going to defer those until our July 10th meeting.

So everyone has a chance to just review those. And then we'll probably have another set as well to approve on July 10th. Which brings us to the next meeting dates. July 10th is a regular scheduled meeting.

And then we will have a following regular scheduled meeting on the 24th of July. So we can keep those dates in mind. And then Cheyenne, any staff update that you might have?

Speaker 3 (01:44–01:59)

No big updates, just to note the July 24th meeting is going to be a joint meeting or joint public hearing with the tree warden. We're going to have about two scenic road applications coming up for that. So that's what we have on the agenda for that day.

Speaker 1 (02:00–02:01)

Okay, that's great.

Speaker 4 (02:03–03:45)

Can I just say something? So I've been receiving some emails and comments about when I joined via Zoom. And a few months ago, I did reach out to the Assistant Town Administrator, because a lot of times, I mean, I'm at work when I joined my Zoom, and so I do have my work. I'm on my work computer.

So a couple months ago, Nick Connors gave me some information and then Nick Milano just followed up with it again yesterday. So I just wanted to let people know that that there is not any rule prohibiting the practice of having any particular display name and that the open meeting log guide on remote participation only lists two minimum requirements. And one of the requirements is that a member of a public body who participates remotely In all persons present at the meeting location must be clearly audible to each other and to that all votes taken during a meeting in which a member participates remotely must be by roll call vote so other than that there's no. any requirements to have any particular name displayed as well as there's no particular requirements to have your camera on either.

So just some information for the public.

Speaker 1 (03:45–04:30)

All right, thank you. So yes, so then we can move now then to citizen speak. If there's anyone here in the public, which we don't have anybody tonight, or on Zoom, you can raise your hands and let us know that you would, if there's something you would like to say. No hands on Zoom.

Okay, great. So then we can now move to item four of our agenda, discussion of the budget and vote. And Cheyenne, if you want to just introduce this with our budget that's remainder and options for us.

Speaker 3 (04:31–05:12)

Sure. So about a couple weeks ago, Nick and I had a meeting about where the planning board budget stood. And we have about, it's between $19,000 and $24,000. We still have to pay one more bill for UTL.

We'll have a final estimate. But we're throwing out some ideas of what that remaining balance could be used for since fiscal year does end Monday. So we reached out to a couple people and got quotes, and I'll put that up on the screen, but so far the quote that we have that's the leading one is for the economic feasibility study, and that's gonna be through MAPC, and that'll fit right into our budget.

Speaker 1 (05:13–05:23)

Great. So Cheyenne, would we encumber all, just the total amount of funds for that project, in case it slightly goes over? Yeah.

Speaker 3 (05:23–05:27)

Yeah. Okay.

Speaker 1 (05:27–05:37)

Okay. And is that something we'll obviously vote on it tonight. Does that have to be submitted or sent in? I would think tomorrow morning.

Speaker 3 (05:39–05:48)

Yeah. So Nick didn't say specifically when, but we do need to have a vote on it so we can't go forward. So probably send that in by tomorrow, Monday the latest.

Speaker 1 (05:49–06:27)

Great. So I think that we would, I know doing an economic feasibility study is something we are required to do to get, to raise our percentage to the 15%, which was in the drafting article six language. Nick also felt like there may be an opportunity to actually increase that even a little bit higher with that study. And we'd have to go back to town meeting and amend that.

If it does increase above 15%, but that's certainly something I think our board has always said was important that we do. So, I would entertain a motion.

Speaker 2 (06:27–07:29)

Yeah, I just, I found the scope of. work to be comprehensive and I think it'll be very helpful not just for this zoning. I was thinking it could be beneficial for the Milton Village when we were speaking about talking about potential other zoning articles to work on. It made me think it's been five years since we passed that and we've had no applications come in.

And so I was wondering whether Cheyenne and Nick could speak to MAPC to see if this study, and this could be added later, if it's necessary to get this out the door tomorrow. But look at Milton Village zoning as well. I mean, it looks like they might be looking at that anyway from reading the scope. But it would be interesting to see if they felt as if there was any economic reason in that zoning that we weren't seeing any applications.

Speaker 4 (07:31–08:37)

So I kind of was wondering something similar because this specifically says for 3A, so I was wondering if that could be more than just 3A, you know, our you know, we are the board that's responsible for zoning. And as we all know, this, the citizens petition, the MBTA article was put forward by the citizens petition, but we are responsible for zoning. So I was wondering if we could expand it because under the narrative section, It did just talk about a preferred policy option, so I was wondering if that could be elsewhere too. I wasn't thinking specifically down in the village, but…

I mean, it could easily be East Milton Square because, you know, we could wait to see whether five years and nothing comes in.

Speaker 2 (08:38–09:06)

But while they're doing the work, while they're looking at everything, it makes sense. I don't wanna hold this up, but if there's enough time to think about an amendment, or if it's embedded in here somehow, then it would be, I think, very valuable to us to get, sort of pull that information out, just as you said, Maggie, not so specific to 3A. Because they're looking at the town anyway, from what I understand from their data gathering.

Speaker 1 (09:06–09:23)

So I think that would be a good follow-up. Yeah, I think that would be a very good follow-up question. I think perhaps the reason why they address the 3A is because it's a requirement of 3A to do this. So I think at this time, I agree with both of you, but maybe at this time, the way it reads would be appropriate.

Speaker 2 (09:23–10:24)

Yeah, the way it reads, I would make a motion, but I would like to ask Cheyenne to speak to Nick and see if they can speak to MAPC about even having an amendment to this. that could come in our next fiscal year budget, you know, which starts July 1st. While they're doing all this data gathering, it seems like it would be a small add rather than coming back and doing it separately as a separate contract. So does that make, does that agree with that, Maggie?

Yeah, yeah. All right, so I'll make a motion to approve the use of the remaining planning board funds up to the $20,000 for the proposed scope of work and cost for a 3A technical assistance for the town of Milton for the economic feasibility analysis per the MAPC proposal. And encumbering all funds. Okay, encumbering all funds, all remaining fiscal year funds?

Speaker 1 (10:24–10:48)

All fiscal year funds, yeah, is really what we need to vote on. Second. Okay, all in favor? Aye.

Great. Perfect. Thank you. And then anything else?

Cheyenne, is there anything else you wanted to add to any of the, any budget conversation? That was primarily.

Speaker 2 (10:48–12:43)

We have the next fiscal year starting and we have $50,000 and I think we're going to talk about some potential zoning but I was recalling, and I was thinking maybe if Cheyenne doesn't have it at her fingertips that she could get it for us, the codification that we've talked about for some time. There's at least the level of codification to address the comments that the consultant had put fourth, and some of it had to do with just bringing it current with state law, correcting some inconsistencies, and I personally think putting tables in so it's easier to use. We've had turnover at the building department and in the planning department, and our zoning bylaw is not It's not the way many are written, and it's not easy to review. And I think it takes more time from staff, and it takes more time for us and applicants.

And we even have seen where there's been mistakes in waivers, et cetera, because the bylaw is just so out of date. So, Cheyenne, you don't happen to have the figure. I know Tim had It's that there's a range for this and there's consultants who would, the same consultant could do it that did the original or the initial codification. And the other question I have about the codification is what about the maintenance of it?

So now we've passed zoning articles. Is there funding in some other budget to put that into the e-code system? The online system?

Speaker 3 (12:44–12:52)

I can't tell if those both work for me, but I can, again, write up an email about the figures and the maintenance for that.

Speaker 1 (12:52–13:34)

And I actually had a conversation with Sue Galvin today along this line, and Kathleen also, on this, and that it is really important. And we've done the big piece of it by having it now electronic that you can access. But really, part of the conversation was, There's a lot of consultants that write zoning, but really we should have an attorney looking at it. So I think we could put this on the agenda on codification on what our approach is with who we would have to do it.

And then you're right, we would want to have a maintenance system because it hasn't really been

Speaker 2 (13:34–14:22)

Well, I want to make sure that the articles that just passed are going to be put into the e-system, the e-code system, because the problem we had, as you know, for a long time was people would get the PDF version of the Zoning By-law, and then they'd have to go to Sue Galvin to get all the amendments that were made since that was last updated, and that was years. And I'd hate for us to have the e-system be in the same place. I'm wondering, we did have a meeting where Sue Galvin participated, And I'm thinking, and also Kathleen is the chair of the ZBA, and if the building official wants to come as well, because I really do think there's a, all of these folks interface with the zoning, not just us, right? And I think there is a lot of cleanup work that needs to be done.

Speaker 4 (14:22–14:49)

So there isn't some type of, the program does not allow for just to input new zoning for it, to somehow get absorbed, like our IT department couldn't somehow scan and put it into the… I don't know if we should invite Sue Galvin, I think, to ask her about that process now that it is electronic, how that is… And if we need to set aside budget for that, it would be good to know now.

Speaker 2 (14:49–14:52)

as we plan for this fiscal year.

Speaker 1 (14:53–16:27)

I talked to Nick and Cheyenne about that we would want to have some funding and on budget too. One of the things that I had mentioned is there is now, in Judy Barrett's office, somebody who actually came from the Massachusetts Historical Commission and has been hired to work in Judy Barrett's planning department One of the things that I was thinking, because we have the local historic district committee, and I think it's the planning board we could help facilitate this moving forward, is to have somebody with that experience from Mass Historical who would be able to consult with the town to explain it. I think the committee, because this is so new, there's a lot of questions that came out. I know different boards were weighing in.

But maybe having some funding, having somebody with a background who could actually help to move that local historic district, moving forward to town meeting and being able to help explain it to town meeting. It is something very new. Most towns have it. And I think it would be a very good tool for planning and protection of our historic assets.

So I think possibly we had talked about doing that. And her name is Jennifer, and I'm just forgetting her last name from Mass Historical, but she just recently… What is it again? Jordan.

Jordan. Jordan?

Speaker 3 (16:27–16:30)

No, Doherty. D-O-H-E-R-T-Y.

Speaker 1 (16:30–16:58)

Jennifer Doherty. Yes. Yes. Yes.

So she's very talented. I mean, I know she's very highly respected. And I don't know what it, like if it was a minimal, you know, a small amount, it might be worth having just outside help to facilitate this moving towards an article that would be, that town meeting would understand. support.

And she has experience with all the different towns. So I think that also would be helpful.

Speaker 2 (16:59–17:15)

Because that committee doesn't have funding, you're saying? That committee, right. They were a study committee. So you're suggesting that the planning board engage with them, but it would be in support of that committee's work?

Speaker 1 (17:15–17:47)

It would be the planning department. It would come from the planning department's funding. So I think we don't really have to I wouldn't want to get really too in the weeds with it, because I think this committee was set up to do that work. But I think that they may need help, and it might make sense.

The way sometimes we've funded an MPIC project, for example, or some other things that that money may go towards. And it could be MPIC funding too, because that's part of the work that you all have been doing too.

Speaker 4 (17:48–18:50)

We can talk, I'm just putting it out there as a possibility. I think it's a good idea just from way back when the committee was first started. They came to our neighborhood, Hillside Neighborhood Association meeting. And our neighborhood has a lot of historic houses, and my neighbors are really concerned about it.

But all the questions that they were asking a committee member at that time, just like you said, it was so new that the committee member couldn't really answer the questions that the Neighborhood Association had. And it was a little bit unfortunate because then the neighborhood sort of, you know, was a little bit turned off from having it, but mostly because we didn't have the questions answered. And I think it might be helpful to have somebody who is more knowledgeable to come and talk to neighborhood associations.

Speaker 1 (18:50–19:06)

And I don't even know if they have been doing that type of work because she's new in Judy Barrett's department. But I think that's part of the reason why she was hired was to look at tools in planning for historic preservation. So I think it's worth trying and having a conversation.

Speaker 2 (19:06–19:10)

Are you jointly having a conversation with her?

Speaker 3 (19:11–19:31)

I had emailed her yesterday and she got back to me. And it's just like a little thing. She just had to make a call to the Ethics Commission. She noted that while she was working at Mass Historical Commission, she was involved with our work with Milton Village district proposal.

So before we fully engage with her, she would have to check if she can even do that.

Speaker 1 (19:34–19:51)

Okay. I didn't know she was involved with our… Milton Village. Okay.

Okay, great, so that was just another thought, but we should be thinking about things that we would want to maybe be able to look at.

Speaker 2 (19:52–21:08)

So one thing I want to mention too is, the Master Plan Implementation Committee as a $30,000 allocation. And I asked Nick to include that in the contingent budget because the committee, as you know, is getting ready to make its report. And in the report, we're going to recommend some targeted updates. And so we wanted to have funds available for that targeted, for those targeted updates.

So the last time the master plan was done, a committee was established by the planning board. It was chaired by Emily Ennis. Remember Emily from the planning board in those days? I was on the committee before being a member of the planning board.

I think there were like 14 people, so it was a pretty big committee, you know, pretty extensive. I don't think that we need that large a committee to update it, but I just want to put that out there for something to be thinking about in this coming fiscal year. The final report will go out you know, in time for the fall town meeting. We're still working on it.

So we owe an update to the planning board and to the select board.

Speaker 1 (21:09–21:12)

Yeah, if you wanted us to put aside a meeting for you all to present.

Speaker 2 (21:12–21:16)

Yeah, probably at the, I'm thinking September because it's just.

Speaker 1 (21:16–21:22)

And maybe we do a joint, I don't know if it will be a joint planning board and It's look forward to hear the presentation or if we if you rather.

Speaker 2 (21:23–21:36)

Yeah, it might be separately, but we can see if that works, you know, if they would want to do that. So just put just putting that on the radar screen for this coming year fiscal year.

Speaker 1 (21:37–24:52)

Right. Good. Thank you, Cheyenne, for following up on that. Just giving that information, that would be great to have.

So because those were things on the list that I was thinking of as well. So the next item on our agenda was just to talk about because we've dedicated so much time to the MBTA. zoning that we now have time to actually look at some of the things that we've I know that have been on our list, codification being one of them, recodification. But we also I know the cut and fill you all have mentioned the landscape and updating to the maybe the landscape zoning and And certainly I had also mentioned that I had talked to Tim Zwinski and he provided me what he had written up in 2015.

And I can circulate that to the board members to take a look at that because he had really gone through and put a thoughtful um, update to the, to the signage language that just, he left to go to Boston and nothing ever happened with it. So, but we have it from 2015 and I, I think it was very good. I, in looking at it, one of the things that it addresses, um, is billboards. We all know that there was the big petition and, um, where there was a billboard possibly going to go into two at two granite and I think that was something that there was tremendous opposition to.

This way, you don't have to fight it with a petition. It's already in the zoning language. The other thing, we're starting to see a lot of things that had not ever been allowed before, but now because they're not in our zoning, it's difficult to defend saying no. Neon signs being one of them, and then also even internally lit signs.

Um, such as the Santander, which I know East Milton residents really dislike, um, and find it to be a really offensive, um, and not, not, um, contributing to the aesthetics of the town. There's also, you're starting to see little neon lights, placards going up on different restaurants. whether it says open or different little things going up, but, and also the new gas station, the gas station on Bryant Street, they just applied and went for a new electronics digital sign. the way the other one, that was also very controversial.

So these are things that other towns have that you can just say no, because there's another way to do lighting. When I go to Santander and other towns, they have cute, the gooseneck lights and a wooden sign, and it can be done differently. And I think that's sort of our goal and sort of the look that we're wanting our town to have. So that would be one, but I would be open to you all your thoughts to what you would like to look at.

Speaker 2 (24:54–27:17)

I think we have to be realistic, too, about how much we're going to be able to get done. And, you know, with Cheyenne leaving and Tim's position open. But I do think it's worth having a list and kind of thinking about how it could be done, whether committee, whether board members can do it or whether We would seek some kind of ad hoc committee. We haven't taken advantage of that in some time, but I know the first involvement I had in Milton was serving on a committee through the planning board.

It was a study committee for Temple Shalom. And so they had looked for volunteers with certain kinds of skill sets. So that's something we could think about as a way to help advance some of the ideas. I did have a couple of things that I wanted to add, and that was, I mentioned during the ADU discussion about how we should look at our setbacks for accessory structures.

And then also with MBTA community thinking about our FAR and our open space that doesn't exist. in our single family for sure, but we should look at whether there's any other parts of the zoning bylaw where we would want to add FAR and open space requirements. So those I think are not big lifts. And then another one that had been on my radar screen when thinking about the 40Bs, two of the 40Bs where there's historic homes and historic properties.

They weren't of a size that meets the condo conversion bylaw, which is five acre minimum. So those were like less than five acres. And I wonder if it would have been more if it would have been attractive if they could have gone in under the condo conversion. So I think we should look at reducing that minimum lot size from five acres down to something less.

So I don't think that's a big lift either. I think there's some work that had started on that. I think we had asked Alan Bishop to generate a list of properties that had historic homes on properties that were less than five acres. And I think we might have that list or that information somewhere in the planning department or in the GIS department.

Speaker 4 (27:17–27:21)

Just to clarify, do we have currently

Speaker 2 (27:21–27:57)

any we do have a condo conversion bylaw yeah but on five acres or more so it's on more but none like none by special permit or variance there's none existing i just i'm trying to visually yeah i don't i don't recall if it's special permit it's probably a special permit um because i don't think that's an as of right currently because we didn't have any as of right multi-family so it's i'm sure the current is a special permit, but I think the Burr Estate maybe may have been.

Speaker 4 (27:57–27:59)

That has a lot of acreage.

Speaker 2 (27:59–28:03)

Right. But if you think about like the 582 Blue Hill Ave, I forget the name of that.

Speaker 4 (28:04–28:05)

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (28:05–28:33)

If you think about that, that would have been a perfect example if you could have had, if that could have been converted instead of what's happening with the 40B, right? I just remember thinking, like, we should be thinking about ways, we're still thinking about MBTA committees, but we're still susceptible to 40 Bs, and what are developers going to look for? It kind of depends, what's the best economic opportunity? So.

Speaker 4 (28:35–28:48)

Yeah, so I'm not necessarily saying I don't agree with it, but just in my head, I'm a visual person, I was just trying to think, where in town do we already have some that's not Burr? Because I always go to Burr.

Speaker 2 (28:48–29:15)

I don't know which ones, but I was thinking we could ask Alan to pull that. He's already done it, I think. It's just that it's been a long time, and I honestly would have to see if I have it in my record someplace. And I'm not saying that that's something that we absolutely should do, but it's something I feel we should look at.

again, kind of giving an alternative to the 40 B that that which I don't want to forget, because I did.

Speaker 1 (29:16–29:40)

That was part of my conversation, too, with Cheyenne and Nick is the housing production plan is something that we want to fund. Are we is that coming from our funding? So that would come from our funding, too. And I don't want to interrupt you and what you're saying.

I just wanted to put a placeholder. That's good, too. Yeah, because we did. I think Cheyenne, you were reaching out to the woman who did the last two updates to the housing production plan.

And I think she still is. during the work?

Speaker 3 (29:41–30:08)

Yeah, so she was interested. Nick was talking to her and I was talking to some other people because I sent in like a question to the planner and lister and we'd gotten a couple quotes, which is why we couldn't do it in this budget because they were coming in around like $30,000-$40,000 higher and we only had about $20,000. So we're looking into the woman who did the past ones and her budget on that.

Speaker 1 (30:09–30:20)

She was a lot less expensive than that, because I served on that committee. And she's already done the work. So it's really just updating the work that she's already done. So that's why I was interested.

Speaker 2 (30:22–30:24)

Yeah, that's it.

Speaker 1 (30:24–30:30)

Yeah. Yeah. I was just looking at that. She is still doing it and interested in Katie Conlon had mentioned that that we should we should.

Speaker 2 (30:30–30:42)

She was I was I worked on that committee with Katie and Melinda Collins. And Karen was very nice to work with. Yeah. And good.

And got the work done in.

Speaker 5 (30:42–30:47)

Sorry. What was the name of the person who did that work?

Speaker 3 (30:47–30:47)

Karen Sonnenborg.

Speaker 5 (30:48–30:49)

OK, thank you.

Speaker 1 (30:50–31:04)

So yeah, so we're following up on that as well. And that would be something that obviously is really important, especially if it allows us to be in safe harbor, depending. Right. OK.

OK, so please continue.

Speaker 2 (31:05–32:11)

Oh. The last thing I had was our rules and regs. And that doesn't require zoning, obviously. So but remember, like our roadway section, it's a very wide roadway.

It requires sidewalks on both sides. If we go back, we had this list of variances. I think I forgot now who put it together. It may have been one of Lauren Messier when she was here.

But how many variances like or waivers we had granted on things in our permitting? And it's not very up to date with respect to low impact kind of like whether we use rain gardens or other things. It's not just piped and storage kind of of stormwater. We would want to work with the engineering department on aspects of that, I think.

But those components of it, I mean, the rules and rights have been updated a little bit, but those components of it haven't been updated probably for decades. And they really are out of date.

Speaker 1 (32:11–32:25)

And especially since we've just done the site plan, our new site plan review approval process, some of those things we did put in rank, you know, certain things that we would be asking for, especially sustainability.

Speaker 2 (32:26–33:12)

Right. But if that's under MBTA, but if we had that consistent throughout, like there was… Marina had come to us at one point or maybe her predecessor and said that just to be compliant with I think it was EPA or DEP requirements that there were some things that we needed to do in our rules and regs and probably in our zoning and it's just Maybe when Josh was here, too. It's just there's been no follow up, again, with some of the changeover.

So that was something else I thought would be important for us to try and put some time into. Yeah, I think that's great. And that's it for me. Yep.

Speaker 4 (33:12–33:56)

They all sound good. I mean, basically, I was sort of focused on the FAR. I think that's a really important one. And the open space.

light of everybody's property is getting smaller and coming off COVID, even though it's been five years, we've all learned the importance of open space and distance from each other. So I think that's important. And just having trees, you know, being on the Climate Action Committee, just you know, the importance of trees and helping reduce the heat island effect.

Speaker 2 (33:56–35:39)

So I think that's… So Maggie on the trees, you know, Boston has been revising their requirements in a number of different places, but the places I'm more familiar with on projects. So if an applicant's coming forth with a project, they have to document, as we do the existing trees, but also the caliper of trees, I think starting at six inches and higher, and then total them, and then that whatever their replacement is, if there's a difference, if it's less, then there has to be a contribution to trees to another part of the city to make up the difference so that there's no net loss in tree canopy. So I think if you wanted to look at their policies, I can send you some links because I've been copied on some of those recently.

And one of the other things I think you and I spoke about before but I forgot to list was lighting in terms of, and I don't know if that would be a zoning bylaw or in our rules and regs, but it seems like we continually have to like each application kind of go through the same thing. Like if there's a standard that we want them to use, if a standard pole height we want to use, kind of design character that is preferred, particularly like on the street tree, I mean a street light, we should update that too. And that's another probably maybe some DPW input too.

Speaker 4 (35:39–36:09)

Yeah, so are there departments that can take the lead on some of these things, not just us starting fresh? Can we ask the DPW or ask the engineering to look into what other towns are doing and create a sample bylaw and then you know, have it come from the department itself. So then they're invested in it as well.

Speaker 2 (36:09–37:07)

So one thing that when Denny was on the board and she and I worked with Tim, Josh or Tim and I think Marina on, no, Joe Prondack actually on, a bit on cut and fill when she was on the, we were working on the tree one. So it's like a little ad hoc committee. So maybe these, which required DPW, and I'm hoping that we will get fully staffed so that we can get staff support for it too. And maybe we're just gonna have to prioritize, but I think it's good to put the list together and see which ones are, take sort of low-hanging fruit, as it's called, in the master plan, you know, take those, and those that are going to take more work and more collaboration, you know, they may not get started right away.

Speaker 4 (37:07–37:32)

Because if the staff is involved in the department that gets the phone call, you know, then they they they're well versed in it. And because it's helped create the bylaw and they see it every day, you know, they can say, oh, this might work. This doesn't work or I've seen it work better here. So just having some buy in from the department could be helpful.

Speaker 2 (37:33–38:02)

Well, and having again, having things like in a Like if the DPW and the planning department both take ownership of certain things that are like stormwater goals, then if questions do come up, it should be easier to answer for the applicants before they get to us, right? In their pre-meeting.

Speaker 1 (38:02–38:26)

Right, it just streamlines it, yeah. Well, I think that's a good list. And we can, you know, start to be thinking about that and and what grant money will be coming in. You know, I know Nick is, you know, pursuing some things, I think.

Do we have a are we putting any grant requests together for the housing production? Plan, or is that.

Speaker 3 (38:29–38:37)

Maybe. Yeah, apply for one. But that's what I thought. It's going to do it out of the budget.

Speaker 1 (38:37–38:52)

OK. Yeah, especially if we can get that cost reduced. That seems like that would be something we have to do soon in the feasibility study, obviously. But this is a good list.

So if there's anything else that people think of, we can add.

Speaker 2 (38:52–39:20)

I'd like to get clarity sooner rather than later on the maintenance and the updates on the e-code and also on the codification, just It sounds like between that and the housing production plan, I mean, one of those things, if you're looking at those, could take up most of our budget, which would be, I'd like to make sure that we could get codification. We've been talking about it for many years now. I mean, we finally did get the codification, which is great, but it's important to maintain it.

Speaker 4 (39:21–39:37)

So none of that would come from just not the planning board budget, not shouldn't come from, I would hope so. But you know, from either the building department or overall, general government, I feel like this is general government.

Speaker 1 (39:39–39:43)

Because the general bylaws also have to be done.

Speaker 2 (39:44–40:24)

Yeah, so I think maybe Sue Galvin and Nick Milano. I mean, they could be asked about which budget it should sit in. I agree with you, just an update to what's been passed or taking an update in the e-code from articles that we passed shouldn't be a planning board budget item. But when we did the codification, some of the funds came from the clerk's office budget.

So maybe some of this could be split, which would be helpful. But that might have been for the general bylaws, actually.

Speaker 4 (40:26–40:27)

We'll have that.

Speaker 2 (40:27–40:28)

Yeah, I think that's a conversation.

Speaker 4 (40:28–40:32)

So would it actually come from the planning board budget or the planning department?

Speaker 2 (40:32–40:42)

They don't have a large budget, you see. Yeah, I would think it shouldn't come from ours because ours is really intended to do planning.

Speaker 4 (40:43–40:46)

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (40:46–40:58)

But I think the time that we did the codification before we offered it to the clerk because we were so interested in getting it done also, that it wasn't going to happen otherwise.

Speaker 4 (40:59–42:41)

So one thing I sort of was thinking of if we're still, you know, in the process of reviewing applications for the town planner position, would we ever expand our search to include possibly an attorney? So we know that, you know, Cheyenne went to, attended law school, and zoning is all legal, just like you had said. Would it be helpful to have somebody with a background in law to help write a lot of this zoning language. So I know that, you know, it's been said that it's been challenging to to get someone with planning purposes, I mean, planning experience, but Milton is pretty much built out as we've all noticed through this whole MBTA process.

Would it be helpful to have an attorney on staff in the planning department to help write all this language? We just talked about how many, one, two, three, four, five, six, 70, 10, 10 possible updates to our zoning and our budget is limited. And if we had somebody on staff who can write language, what a savings that would be. You know, we wouldn't have to be going out.

So I don't know if we could. Yeah, if we could expand our search a little bit.

Speaker 2 (42:41–44:25)

I guess what I think of like what the support that's provided to the board for applications is, you know, look, it's not necessarily so much the legal aspect of it, but the planning aspect of it, right? So if you think about like the kinds of applications we may get under the MBTA communities, it's more on the planning side, like how you're taking the standards that we put in and submission requirements and all of that. I'd rather have like a design professional. really looking at all of that more than, because it would be an attorney would be looking at it for, you know, does it meet that?

And we would be looking at it, you know, we would want somebody like looking at it saying, well, the board's, you know, been consistent about thinking about these things as being important, which are a little bit more subjective in some ways. I realize we have to be very objective in the MBTA communities, but we still have special permits. that could come in under other parts of the zoning code where I think it's, one thing I'll say too, is the ZBA is entirely attorneys. Kathleen as the chair is interested in working more with the planning board, right?

And so I think taking advantage of their expertise could maybe be something that's available to us now that we didn't have available to us before.

Speaker 3 (44:27–44:34)

So I have a question. Oh, yeah. Are we taking comments from people in the audience? Because Kathleen has her hand raised.

Speaker 2 (44:35–44:37)

I'm talking about her. She raises her hand.

Speaker 4 (44:38–47:03)

Yes. So my only concern. So I agree maybe. maybe our assistant planner could have some architectural backgrounds for design help.

So maybe being a little bit more expansive in that description too, because I agree with you that a lot of it does come, a project can look better if it's designed appropriately. And it would get more acceptance in a neighborhood if it fits in architecturally and stylistically wise within each neighborhood. So I understand that point. My only question though about working with the ZBA And again, I don't really have the answer and maybe I'm off base, but is it appropriate?

I sort of view the ZBA as sort of the, you know, they're the judges, sort of, and they make decisions on projects or plans or properties And is it appropriate for them to sort of be in or have a say in what is being written legally? And then they're then adjudicating on it later. So it's sort of like a separation. Historically, it's been separate.

Yeah, so it's a separation of powers kind of thing. And maybe, you know, with all that's been going on, I'm a little bit more sensitive to that. So Again, maybe that's just a question for down the line that if the ZBA is going to be making decisions, they're supposed to be viewing each project individually on the merits of that project. And can they view it that way if they have a hand in writing it?

So it's like the legislature versus the courts.

Speaker 2 (47:04–47:15)

Yeah, I don't know if that's the way the ZBA is. I know that's some people's view of the ZBA, but I would be interested to hear what Kathleen has to say, since she has her hand raised.

Speaker 1 (47:15–47:39)

Yeah, yes, because I viewed Kathleen Cumming as an individual and an attorney, but not representing the ZBA. When she came in, we were working on the ADU and the site plan. Yeah, and she was very helpful. Very helpful, yes.

But it wasn't as the… Anyway, Kathleen, welcome, and you can please feel free to comment.

Speaker 5 (47:39–50:04)

Thanks. I just wanted to say that while I tell other people, Meredith doesn't know this, but we were interviewing potential town councils this afternoon. And that was one of the questions that we asked the town council candidates was the services that they would provide to the planning board and to the CBA. And it's sort of a change in in philosophy of the use of town council.

But one of the firms, interestingly, said that they prefer to do the drafting of zoning articles themselves. They're not very happy about having a consultant do it and then have to back and fix it up, which was, I said, funny. Because, I mean, consultants would be saying, God, the last thing you want to have is lawyers for the game. And with some justification.

So I do think that going forward is the potential to be sort of looking for more assistance underneath the town council services, not as an extra job, to have the town council be more helpful in drafting zoning, at least taking a look at it earlier than they normally do, than they have in the past. And going to Maggie's point about the fact that the ZBA is a judicial sort of situation, my friend, a friend in Cohasset, as chair of the zoning board, did a reconfiguration of all the zoning bylaws in Cohasset. And he didn't, he's not a lawyer, but he didn't see any reason why the CBA couldn't have a word to say, or not a lot of words, about how the zoning code looked. And so I don't think that, I don't think that our participation in it is sort of looking to see what what zoning might be proposed, and actually coming to you guys and saying, you know, we think we're running into this trouble all the time about this one particular thing.

And looking back to you folks to say, you know, is there something you can do about this? You know, we keep getting variance requests for this random thing that should be fixed. And so I think there should be more sort of back and forth between the two boards than there has been in the past.

Speaker 1 (50:05–50:22)

Thank you. And a couple of the firms also have addressed the recodification and have gone through the entire zoning bylaws and cleaned it up. So there are some firms that do have that experience doing the town's codification.

Speaker 2 (50:22–51:40)

So while we're speaking, I did think of another one that I had worked on one with Brian first when he was on the board, which is the pre-existing nonconforming uses. So that would be like our 7-Elevens that. And there's, I think, a few other businesses in other locations that were business before they were the zoning was enacted. And we've lost business uses in other parts.

When the business use ends, it reverts then to the underlying zoning, which was the single family that was overlaid over everything. And one thing I think you'll remember from the Ice House days was that people still today say there's not enough amenities on the west side of Milton. And there used to be some, but then they've been lost. Oh, the other one I'll say, I guess, is Franny's Corner, which is, you know, the equipment and gas station, you know, being converted into a little market, a little.

Speaker 1 (51:42–51:45)

Right. But I don't know if it's so.

Speaker 2 (51:45–52:42)

So that's just another one of those. So if you think about it, it's the same kind of thing that we have run into where some of these exist by special permit. And then if they want to change things, they have to go to the ZBA. And some of it might be triggered to come to us.

And it's, again, one of those things that we said should be cleaned up, should be easier. Many people in town think we should be They want businesses here. They want to be able to stay in Milton for certain things. But we heard from some that it's not easy.

And part of it is the permitting. So the preexisting nonconforming. And Kathleen, that's probably another one where the ZBA should weigh in too because that one falls under the ZBA's jurisdiction probably more than the planning board because of the zoning. That's true.

Speaker 4 (52:43–53:54)

Yeah. So my recollection, though, with them, that's when I sort of started paying attention. I think that was back in like 2014 with the preexisting nonconforming business uses was I thought it was a great idea, but I thought if I remember correctly, it was expanding. So it kind of, I think, stalled a little bit because they were they were looking at other neighborhoods, so it became a bigger thing to wrestle with instead of just really focusing on the existing businesses as they were.

I mean, because that's when that was sort of a problem that I had with part of the conversation that was going on, that it was, I felt that it was, it was more looking for expansion than actually preserving and helping the businesses that were there currently to maybe loosen up some of their restrictions. So I agree, I would support looking at some pre-existing non-conforming businesses.

Speaker 2 (53:55–55:30)

But I also think about whether we should think look at neighborhood business as an allowed use in certain places. And that's going to take some public outreach and some work. But people have been asking for it, or at least have been interested in it. When it starts to look at how that might work, we'll see.

But there's, I mean, it's a component of not having to get in your car to go get a quart of milk or something like that. There's the idea that was also, I think, floated at one time is where you can have the idea, I think, what that pre-existing nonconforming was, it was to allow mixed use. So it's kind of that idea where you can have housing above and have the business on the ground floor. It's just another way to expand the type of housing.

That was before ADU and before MBTA. So whether that would still be the same approach, I guess. But the pre-existing nonconforming and neighborhood business should really be looked at together, because that's what those are. Those are pretty much neighborhood businesses.

It's a lot to bite off, so we should Yeah, get this list together. Is that something that Cheyenne or Julia can help with, at least getting this list together based on the meeting?

Speaker 1 (55:31–55:35)

Yeah, and circulate that to the other members who aren't here. That would be great for all of us.

Speaker 5 (55:36–55:45)

We have a list left over from a couple of years ago that's still on our bulletin board.

Speaker 1 (55:46–55:52)

Good, I think these have risen to the top. I'm sure some of these are on it. Yeah, I think a lot of these are probably on it.

Speaker 4 (55:53–56:01)

Oh, and the other one was, what about Airbnbs? Where does that come in to play?

Speaker 1 (56:02–56:34)

I think we should have a bylaw on that. And I don't know what other towns have. That's a good question because it's, they're not, there is something in the building code which says that it should not be less than 30 days, rented for less than 30 days. I don't know exactly where that is.

In the zoning code or the building code? I think it's in the, I have to double check that. Cheyenne, do you know, because I know that that question has recently come up with, in East Milton Square.

Speaker 3 (56:37–56:39)

Regarding the Airbnbs?

Speaker 1 (56:39–56:39)

Yes.

Speaker 3 (56:41–56:59)

I haven't seen it, but I know when I go to our website under zoning code, we do have a little bit under, I think it was just short-term rentals. I think we pulled a PDF way back when we were talking about ADUs, but I don't know if it's specifically in the book.

Speaker 1 (56:59–57:38)

I think Nick was following up with that, because there was some neighbor complaints in East Milton regarding an Airbnb. So Nick might have more information on that, and that actually would be a good one to have. The other one I just thought of also that Tim had been talking about, if you recall, the 5G. Remember when all the 5G technology was going on and having some design standards for those 5G?

And I believe he circulated a sample bylaw on that. So that's something that would be easy, low-hanging fruit. And I didn't want to forget about that.

Speaker 2 (57:40–58:05)

So when you put the, when you revised the list, Julia or Cheyenne, based on what we discussed here, like the ones that involve collaboration with other departments, can you like note that? And then the ones that we've identified as being a little low-hanging fruit, kind of note that so we can begin to prioritize them.

Speaker 1 (58:09–58:51)

And also, thank you. Sorry, Julia, did you have a question? Oh, OK. You were responding.

OK. So the other thing that we were thinking about this and being realistic is we have an October 27 Falltown meeting that's been announced. So Cheyenne, would you be able to get what our deadlines would be if we did want to do any zoning, because I It may be because this recent meeting was on the 16th that we're getting closer to that deadline for fall town meeting now. And we were so focused on getting everything ready for that.

Speaker 3 (58:52–58:54)

Yeah, I'll get those deadlines.

Speaker 1 (58:54–58:57)

Yeah, if you could just give us the dates. We have a month, so. Maybe two.

Speaker 2 (58:57–59:06)

Yeah. Let's probably have two. OK. Because if you think this goes to print, I think at least a month before.

So that's the end of September.

Speaker 4 (59:06–59:08)

We can do a placeholder, can't we?

Speaker 2 (59:11–59:33)

I think we should at our next meeting, we should decide which we think we can achieve. Yeah. And basically. It would be two meetings in July, two meetings in August and one in September.

Four to five meetings to to submit something. Right.

Speaker 4 (59:33–59:37)

And we'd have to hold public hearing. on each of the one.

Speaker 2 (59:38–59:44)

But like we held the public hearing for the last ones right before. Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 4 (59:47–59:57)

And I don't think most of the things on the list would be. Too controversial, except for maybe Airbnb.

Speaker 2 (59:57–01:00:52)

So I would say if if could we get the condo conversion information that was pulled a couple of years ago? I'm sure if you ask Alan Bishop, he has it somewhere and recirculate that before our next meeting. So that would be like which properties have there was a year if a property had a home built before a particular year, and I don't remember which year it was. And it's on.

Five, less than five acres. And I don't think, I don't know, we may have set a lower limit, and I don't know what lower limit we may have set, but if that doesn't ring a bell to him, let me know and I'll start to see if I can find information. Yeah, because I do recall. Does that sound familiar to you?

Speaker 1 (01:00:52–01:01:01)

Were you on the board when we did that? Yeah, I think it was. Okay. Because if we talk about four acre, I think we had different thresholds that we were looking at, like how many properties?

Speaker 4 (01:01:01–01:01:14)

Was it the number of units, number of houses in town? But how many? So if you had five acres, what were the number of units per five acres? First, we were just identifying how many properties.

Speaker 2 (01:01:14–01:01:17)

So you didn't even go that far. Yeah. Yeah, it wasn't.

Speaker 1 (01:01:17–01:01:17)

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (01:01:18–01:01:24)

And that's why I thought if we have information, we can get a little head start on just reviewing what we have.

Speaker 1 (01:01:25–01:01:25)

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (01:01:25–01:02:03)

on that. I do think on FAR and open space, we have an, you know, we can, I can represent the information that I did previously. That would be great. When we look, when I was saying this is what analysis I had done.

Of course, it was targeted in the areas that were for MBTA communities, but a lot of that's our Residence C and some Residence A. So we can, that would be good to look at that. Yeah, we can use that to start with. And I doubt a codification could get done that fast.

Speaker 1 (01:02:03–01:02:04)

Yeah.

Speaker 2 (01:02:04–01:02:39)

Given a consultant, you have to get a board or attorney. Yeah, I don't see that happening. I see that one maybe being for the spring, if we could do it. I would love to have that.

That would be great. Yeah, I think that's going to take at least six months to. Yeah. But if we can get a target of spring of 2026 for that.

I would agree. Do we agree that we should try for FAR, open space, and setbacks for October? I think so. Okay.

And signs. Condo conversions.

Speaker 1 (01:02:39–01:02:40)

Because Tim's already done some.

Speaker 2 (01:02:40–01:02:57)

Yeah, the article's ready. I mean, we'll send it. Signs and 5G, you say we should… 5G was also…

I don't know anything about that one. It was something that the select board had asked us, actually, when Katie Conlon was on it to look at.

Speaker 1 (01:02:59–01:03:01)

But they were recommending towns pass it.

Speaker 2 (01:03:03–01:03:33)

And then I think something with the landscape business was out of out of wasn't consistent with state. And Marion McKettrick had done a memo about that. So, you know, if we want to ask Marion about that again, if it's already kind of pretty much ready, Maybe that's one. Because really, we want- Do you want to put Airbnbs on the October agenda?

Speaker 4 (01:03:34–01:03:36)

We might be having some extra meetings.

Speaker 2 (01:03:37–01:03:41)

Airbnb, it depends how much is- I think we'd have to find out.

Speaker 1 (01:03:41–01:03:57)

Yeah, we'd have to research to see, Shane, if you have any time to look at any other towns who have Airbnb Yeah. Regulations, I should say. Yeah. Or bylaws.

Speaker 2 (01:04:01–01:04:22)

And then, Cheyenne, could you check the listserv with your colleague, other planning colleagues, to see if any of them have what they've done about preexisting nonconforming kind of neighborhood business, if they have any examples we can look at? Or it doesn't have to be preexisting, just neighborhood business. Yeah.

Speaker 1 (01:04:30–01:04:36)

OK. I think those would be some good places to start.

Speaker 2 (01:04:36–01:05:36)

Mm-hmm. Cut and fill, Sean said he would work on with me. I had started working on that with Joe Prandack. And the reason it would involve Joe Prandack is we already have a cut and fill.

But I don't know, like if you go out Canton Ave right before you get to the end where it cuts over to the right, that property on the left that has multiple layers of fencing and so forth, that was a huge amount of fill. And I remember asking him, did that get a permit? And he said no. And I said, how was that?

And he said, well, it's a judgment. So we, you know, cut and fill has become something I think that we we think is pretty important. So I don't know if it needs to wait until we have a new building commissioner, but. I can talk to Sean and see if you'd be interested.

And maybe that's for spring also. Since we ticked off a bunch that we could probably get done in the four or five meetings. I'm not sure that's one.

Speaker 4 (01:05:40–01:05:46)

Because within that is the tree bylaw. It's a very big bylaw.

Speaker 2 (01:05:46–01:06:46)

We were linking them before, but then we ended up going more just with tree with a little bit of cut and fill, but not a true. like what I would like to see for cut and fill. And part of it, I think, when that subdivision off of Pleasant, I forget the name of the street now, there's five homes there. That was going to have so much cut.

and somebody retaining walls. And yet there was nothing in the subdivision rules and regs that gave us anything to say you couldn't do it or that you needed to do less of it. And that was like, OK, it works on paper to subdivide this property this way, but it required every tree to be removed and big cut next to the neighbors, both sides. And that's different.

Well, so it's a little more complicated than just a standalone cut and fill, I think.

Speaker 1 (01:06:48–01:06:49)

That's going to take, I think, a little more time.

Speaker 2 (01:06:49–01:07:53)

I think so, too. So maybe spring for that. And I don't know if you remember Franklin, they have something called a development guidebook or something like that where they really have encouraged development that's more sensitive to the existing topography. You know, we've looked at a number of things, whether it be the memory care or the daycares, where there's just a building type that the applicant is used to building, and they just plop it on a site instead of designing something that would fit the site.

And that's why we end up with so much cut and fill. So if there's any way we can get something in our rules and regs, it could be beneficial.

Speaker 1 (01:07:55–01:08:25)

All right, so I think this is a good list. I think this is a good, you know, starting point. We can compare this to the list that Julia has in the office from previous, but I think this is a lot of overlap. I think these are, and these I think would, I would say are priorities that have come up recently, so.

Great. So I think that's it unless anybody has anything else, so. If not, Cheyenne, did you have anything else that you needed to add or would like to add?

Speaker 3 (01:08:26–01:08:28)

No, that was all great.

Speaker 1 (01:08:28–01:08:41)

We'll get working on that tomorrow. Perfect. Okay, great. So then I would entertain a motion to adjourn.

So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye.

Good night, all. Thanks.